liquid journals. overview. how social computing and liquid knowledge will shape and navigate...

Liquid Journalshow social computing and liquid knowledge will shape and navigate information waters

What’s a LJ?

The opportunity we miss today

• It’s not easy to find scientific knowledge• Even more difficult than we think

• Growing number of contribs, search does not scale in quality

• Inefficient dissemination process• Dubious filtering and quality assessment• Narrowness

Key intuition 1 – evolving network of multifacet objects

Data

Key intuition 2 – It’s subjective!

Key intuition 3 – editing power of the community

Key intuition 4 – readers create knowledge

Key intuition 5 - Diversity

Scientific Resources for Liquid Journals

Scientific Resource Space

• Set of connected and annotated scientific resources • S=<SR, E, PR, R, A>• SR=<ID, URI, CT, CF, A>• R=<Esrc, ETarget, RType, END, A>• A=<SR or R, E, text>

Relationship types (examples)

• Temporal (e.g., next_version)• Structural (e.g., performed_on, reporting_on)• Representation (e.g., alternative_repr_of)• Authorship (contributed, edited,…)

Journal Model

Definition

• Collection of links to resources• Selected by editors (Possibly based on defined

procedures)• Offered by a publisher• May change continuously and may have issues

(snapshots)

Creating knowledge selfishly…

Approach: agile and socially-driven IT

Entity Relationship

Resource next_version

Person Alternative representation

Annotation

Journal

Agency ……

Creating and Filling a Journal

Manual selection

Subscriptions

Liquid journal on peer review

Liquid journal on mashups

Settings Universal Resource Space Management SystemMarcos, Fabio, MaurizioThis paper presents a tool and a model that allows…

Authors

Communities

FabioJuan Alejandro

Computer SciencePhysicsBiology

TagsPeer-reviewScientific publ

Sources

Time

SpringerArxiv

FiltersReadings»

Peer review, scientific publications,

Liquid journal on mashups

15

Adaptive Lifecycle Management Journal on Lifecycle Management

Labels

mashups

data integration

[1]

[1]

Rethinking peer reviewJoeExploring new ideasPeer review, scientific publications,

Liquid journal on peer review

13

Adaptive Lifecycle Management

Journal on Lifecycle Management

Journal on Data Integration Alejandro

You can drop things on the dock for putting stuff in the Cooking area or sharing them with your contacts

You define the quick links by dropping journals and users here

No intrusive and without distracting effects

Subscriptions

Liquid journal on peer review

Liquid journal on mashups

Settings

FiltersReadings»

Labels

mashups

data integration

[1]

[1]

Journal on Lifecycle Management

Journal on Data Integration Alejandro

Peer review, and overviewPeter, Pablo, Pedro

New frontiers in ScienceErnesto, Juan, …

Liquidpub research on evaluation metricsJoe, Matteo, Fabio,…

Evaluation of reviewers‘ behaviorJuan, Alejandro, Carlos

Authors

Communities

FabioJuan Alejandro

Computer SciencePhysicsBiology

TagsPeer-reviewScientific publ

Sources

Time

SpringerArxiv

»

Automated selection

• Keyword based (basic and adv, eg source,…)• Relation-based and annotation-based• Reputation (see next)• Diversity

• (partner with ERC search computing)

• Why better than what we have today?

Consuming, creating, and “measuring” knowledgeEmpowering readers

Not just reading…

• Navigating• Sharing• Linking and annotating (selfishly)

• => measuring reputation based on sharing and inclusion in journal

• => specific reputation measures based on annotations• Implications: better metrics, community filtering, better

search and navigation

What all this means….

• Search and management of info overload• Knowledge extraction from readers/editors• Fair assessment• Efficient dissemination• Publish what I want, when I want, how I want, then deliver

it through the information pipes• Make evolution explicit• Reuse implicit review that people do anyways when

selecting content for their own purposes