lecture 5: protein structure prediction methods. chen yu zong tel: 6874-6877 email:...

Lecture 5: Protein Structure Prediction Lecture 5: Protein Structure Prediction MethodsMethods. Chen Yu Zong. Chen Yu Zong

Tel: 6874-6877Tel: 6874-6877Email: Email: csccyz@nus.edu.sgcsccyz@nus.edu.sghttp://xin.cz3.nus.edu.sghttp://xin.cz3.nus.edu.sg

Room 07-24, level 7, SOC1Room 07-24, level 7, SOC1National University of SingaporeNational University of Singapore

22

Protein Structural OrganizationProtein Structural Organization

Proteins are made from just 20 kinds of amino acids

33

Protein Protein Structural Structural OrganizationOrganization

Protein has four levels of structuralorganization

44

Protein Folding: Protein Folding: Sequence-Structure-Function RelationshipSequence-Structure-Function Relationship

55

Protein Folding: Protein Folding: Sequence-Structure-Function RelationshipSequence-Structure-Function Relationship

66

Measuring Structural Similarity:Measuring Structural Similarity:The use of RMSDThe use of RMSD

77

Measuring Structural Similarity:Measuring Structural Similarity:

88

Measuring Structural Similarity:Measuring Structural Similarity:

99

Measuring Structural Similarity:Measuring Structural Similarity:

1010

Protein Structure Prediction:Protein Structure Prediction:

1111

Protein Structure Prediction:Protein Structure Prediction:

1212

Protein Secondary Structure Prediction:Protein Secondary Structure Prediction:• Secondary structure forms early in protein folding process.

• Identification of secondary structural elements makes the topology of protein structure more obvious—so that similar ones can be identified in a topology database such as TOPS.

• Prediction of the positions and lengths of secondary structure elements can be used as a prelude to "docking" these secondary structural elements against each other

• Useful guide in the construction or refinement of primary structure alignments, and to the correct correspondence between parts of two proteins' respective tertiary structures.

• Useful for making some kind of intelligent guess about the higher order structure of your protein

1313

Protein Secondary Structure Prediction:Protein Secondary Structure Prediction:Traditional methods: CF, GOR – Accuracy 60%

Recent improvements: Neural network, homologous sequences – Accuracy > 70%

References:

• "Prediction of the secondary structure of proteins from their amino acid sequence", P. Y. Chou, G. D. Fasman, 1978, Adv. Enzymolog. Relat. Areas Mol. Biol., 47, 45-147.

• "GOR method for predicting secondary structure from amino acid sequence", J. Garnier, J.-F. Gibrat, B. Robson, 1996, Methods Enzymol., 266, 540-553.

• "Analysis of the accuracy and implications simple methods for predicting the secondary structure of globular proteins", J. Garnier, D. J. Osguthorpe, B. Robson, 1978, J. Mol. Biol., 120, 45-147.

• "Improvements in protein secondary structure prediction by an enhanced neural network", Kneller, 1990, J. Mol. Biol., 214, 171-182

1414

Protein Secondary Structure Prediction:Protein Secondary Structure Prediction:Software:

• Zvelebil, M.J.J.M., Barton, G.J., Taylor, W.R. & Sternberg, M.J.E. (1987). Prediction of Protein Secondary Structure and Active Sites Using the Alignment of Homologous Sequences Journal of Molecular Biology, 195, 957-961. (ZPRED)

• Rost, B. & Sander, C. (1993), Prediction of protein secondary structure at better than 70 % Accuracy, Journal of Molecular Biology, 232, 584-599. PHD)

• Salamov A.A. & Solovyev V.V. (1995), Prediction of protein secondary strurcture by combining nearest-neighbor algorithms and multiply sequence alignments. Journal of Molecular Biology, 247,1 (NNSSP)

• Geourjon, C. & Deleage, G. (1994), SOPM : a self optimized prediction method for protein secondary structure prediction. Protein Engineering, 7, 157-16. (SOPMA)

• Solovyev V.V. & Salamov A.A. (1994) Predicting alpha-helix and beta-strand segments of globular proteins. (1994) Computer Applications in the Biosciences,10,661-669. (SSP)

• Wako, H. & Blundell, T. L. (1994), Use of amino-acid environment-dependent substitution tables and conformational propensities in structure prediction from aligned sequences of homologous proteins. 2. Secondary Structures, Journal of Molecular Biology, 238, 693-708.

• Mehta, P., Heringa, J. & Argos, P. (1995), A simple and fast approach to prediction of protein secondary structure from multiple aligned sequences with accuracy above 70 %. Protein Science, 4, 2517-2525. (SSPRED)

• King, R.D. & Sternberg, M.J.E. (1996) Identification and application of the concepts important for accurate and reliable protein secondary structure prediction. Protein Sci,5, 2298-2310. (DSC).

1515

Protein Secondary Structure Prediction:Protein Secondary Structure Prediction:Types of amino acids

Hydrophobic

Hydrophilic, Neutral

Hydrophilic, Acidic

Hydrophilic, Basic

1616

Protein Secondary Structure Prediction:Protein Secondary Structure Prediction:

Types of Secondary Structures:

Alpha helix and Beta- sheet

1717

Protein Secondary Structure Prediction:Protein Secondary Structure Prediction:

Secondary Structures: Favored Peptide Conformation

1818

Protein Secondary Structure Prediction:Protein Secondary Structure Prediction:Secondary Structures:

Computation of structural propensity of a residue

• Data derived from proteins of known structure is used to calculate 'propensities' for each amino acid type for adopting helix, sheet or turn

1919

Protein Secondary Structure Prediction:Protein Secondary Structure Prediction:Secondary Structures:

Computation of structural propensity of a residue

Three states: alpha helix, beta sheet, turn

2020

Protein Secondary Structure Prediction:Protein Secondary Structure Prediction:

Structural propensity of

amino acids

Each residue is assigned to

one of the three classes:

• Forming residues – favor a structure

• Indifferent residues

• Breaking residues – stop the extension of a structure

2121

Protein Secondary Structure Prediction:Protein Secondary Structure Prediction:

Position specific turn parameters

2222

Protein Secondary Structure Prediction:Protein Secondary Structure Prediction:

Chou and Fasman procedure• Find helical initiation regions

• Extend helices until they reach tetrapeptide breakers

• Find beta initiation regions

• Extend until they reach tetrapeptide breakers

• Find turns

• Resolve conflicts between alpha and beta

Somewhat subjective … often have overlaps. Chou and Fasman suggest using additional information:

• alpha-beta pattern, i.e. does this look like an b-a-b structure ???

• end probabilities – Chou and Fasman in later papers also tabulated the preferences for the residues to occur at the amino and carboxyl terminal ends of a and b structures.

These can be used to resolve overlaps

Chou and Fasman did not provide an explicit algorithm for this conflict resolution, relying on their expert

judgment. This meant that each person’s prediction could be different. Most people are not experts.

"Prediction of the secondary structure of proteins from their amino acid sequence",

P. Y. Chou, G. D. Fasman, 1978, Adv. Enzymolog. Relat. Areas Mol. Biol., 47, 45-147.

2323

Protein Secondary Structure Prediction:Protein Secondary Structure Prediction:

2424

Homology Modeling:Homology Modeling:

2525

Homology Modeling:Homology Modeling:

Reference:• Sanchez R, Sali A. Advances in comparative protein-

structure modelling. Curr Opin Struct Biol. 1997 Apr;7(2):206-14.

• Krieger E, Nabuurs SB, Vriend G. Homology modeling. Methods Biochem Anal. 2003;44:509-23

• Rodriguez R, Chinea G, Lopez N, Pons T, Vriend G. Homology modeling, model and software evaluation: three related resources. Bioinformatics. 1998;14(6):523-8

• Alexandrov NN, Luethy R. Alignment algorithm for homology modeling and threading. Protein Sci. 1998 Feb;7(2):254-8

2626

Homology Modeling:Homology Modeling:

Basic Idea:• Similar sequence=> Similar structure• Structure is conserved more than

sequence• Structure of new protein derived using

existing protein structures as templates.• Changes are compensated for locally.

2727

Homology Modeling:Homology Modeling:

Twilight Zone: below 25% sequence homology

2828

Homology Modeling:Homology Modeling:

• Similar sequence=> Similar structure

2929

Homology Modeling:Homology Modeling:Step One:

• Align sequence of your protein (unknown) with that of candidate template proteins (known)

3030

Homology Modeling:Homology Modeling:

Step Two: • Select template proteins based on sequence

similarity and minimize their X-ray structures• The whole sequence can be matched by one

or more templates

3131

Homology Modeling:Homology Modeling:

Step Three: • Combine the main chain of the template proteins

and fill-in gap sections to generate a complete main chain model of your protein

• Gaps are filled-in by using short sequences from a sequence linker library, the selected short

3232

Homology Modeling:Homology Modeling:

Step Three: • Combine the main chain of the template proteins and fill-in gap

sections to generate a complete main chain model of your protein• Gaps are filled-in by using short sequences from a sequence linker

library, the selected short sequences need to be exchangeable to the section of your original protein.

3333

Homology Modeling:Homology Modeling:

• Step Four: Adding side chains to the main-chain model based on the sequence of your protein: – Mutate and add

3434

Homology Modeling:Homology Modeling:

Step Five: • Minimization and MD of the

homology model of your protein

bondednon ijij

ji

ij

ij

ij

ijrra

bondH

bondS

rra

rotationbond

n

eqbendinganglebond

eqrstretchbondatoms

r

qq

r

B

r

AVeV

VeVn

v

krrkm

pH

][])1([

])1([)]cos(1[

2

)(2

1)(

2

1

2

61202)(

0

02)(

0

222

'0

'0

3535

Homology Modeling:Homology Modeling:

• Swiss-Model - an automated homology modeling server developed at Glaxo Welcome Experimental Research in Geneva.  http://www.expasy.ch/swissmod/ 

• Closely linked to Swiss-PdbViewer, a tool for viewing and manipulating protein structures and models. 

• Likely take 24 hours to get results returned!  

3636

Homology Modeling:Homology Modeling:

How Swiss-model works?

• 1)  Search for suitable templates• 2)  Check sequence identity with target• 3)  Create ProModII jobs• 4)  Generate models with ProModII• 5)  Energy minimization with Gromos96 

• First approach mode (regular)• First approach mode (with user-defined template)• Optimize mode 

3737

Homology Modeling:Homology Modeling:

How Swiss-model works?

Program  Database  Action

BLASTP2   ExNRL-3D   Find homologous sequences

of  proteins with known structure.  

SIM    --  Select all templates with sequence

identities above 25%. 

-- -- Generate ProModII input files

ProModII   ExPDB   Generate all models  

Gromos96  --    Energy minimization of all models  

3838

Threading Methods:Threading Methods:

• Similar proteins at the sequence level may have very different secondary structures. On the other hand, proteins very different at the sequence level may have similar structures. Why? Because the protein function is determined by its functional sites, which reside in the cores not the loops.

• Therefore, researchers propose the inverse protein folding problem, namely, fitting a known structure to a sequence.

• The problem of aligning a protein sequence to a given structural model is known as protein threading.

• Given a protein whose structure is known, we derive a structural model by replacing amino acids by place-holders, each is associated with some basic properties such as an alpha-helix or beta-strand or loop of the original amino acids.

3939

Threading Methods:Threading Methods:

References and software:• Lemer C., Rooman, M. J. & Wodak, S. J. (1996), Protein Structure

Prediction By Threading Methods: Evaluation Of Current Techniques, PROTEINS: Structure, Function and Genetics, 23, 337-355.

• Bryant, S. H. & Lawrence, C. E. (1993), An empirical energy function for threading a protein sequence through the folding motif, PROTEINS: Structure, Function and Genetics, 16, 92-112.

• Alexandrov NN, Luethy R. Alignment algorithm for homology modeling and threading. Protein Sci. 1998 Feb;7(2):254-8

• Jones, D.T., Taylor, W.R & Thornton, J.M (1992), A new approach to protein fold recognition, Nature,358, 86-89. (THREADER).

4040

Threading Methods:Threading Methods:

• Threading methods take the amino acid sequence of an uncharacterized protein structure, rapidly compute models based on a large set of existing 3D structures. 

• The algorithm then evaluates these models to determine how well the unknown amino acid “fits” each template structure. 

• All the threading models in the second to most recent CASP competition produced accurate models in less than half of the cases. 

• However, threading is more successful than homology modeling when attempting to detect remote homologies that can’t be detected by standard sequence alignment. 

4141

Threading Methods:Threading Methods:

Protein Threading Model • Input:

– A protein sequence A with n amino acids

– A structural model with m core segments Ci: • (1) Each core segment Ci has length ci. • (2) Core segments Ci and Cj are connected by loop Li, which has length

between li-min and li-max. • (3) The local structural environment for each amino acid position, such as

chemical properties and spatial constraints.

– A score function to evaluate a given threading.

• Output: – T = {t1, t2, ..., tm} of integers, where ti is the amino acid position in A that

occupies the first position in core segment Ci.

4242

Threading Methods:Threading Methods:

Protein Threading Model • An algorithm: Branch and bound • Spatial constraints:

1 + SUM (cj + lj-min) <= ti <= n + 1 - SUM (cj + lj-min)

j < i j >= i

ti + ci + li-min <= ti+1 <= ti + ci + li-max

• A score function (second order, considering pairwise interaction): f(T) = SUM g1(i,ti) + SUM g2(i,j,ti,tj)

i j > i

• Algorithm testing: self-threading and using structural analogs.

4343

Ab initio Methods:Ab initio Methods:

• ab initio means from the beginning. 

• Ab-initio algorithms attempt to predict structure based on sequence information alone (i.e., no emperical structural info is considered). 

• Although many researchers are working in this vein, it is a science in progress – sometimes marginally successful, but very unreliable. 

• Methods: MD and Simplified models

bondednon ijij

ji

ij

ij

ij

ijrra

bondH

bondS

rra

rotationbond

n

eqbendinganglebond

eqrstretchbondatoms

r

qq

r

B

r

AVeV

VeVn

v

krrkm

pH

][])1([

])1([)]cos(1[

2

)(2

1)(

2

1

2

61202)(

0

02)(

0

222

'0

'0

4444

Ab initio Methods:Ab initio Methods:References:

• Hardin C, Pogorelov TV, Luthey-Schulten Z. Ab initio protein structure prediction. Curr Opin Struct Biol. 2002 Apr;12(2):176-81. Review.

• Srinivasan R, Rose GD. Ab initio prediction of protein structure using LINUS. Proteins. 2002 Jun 1;47(4):489-95.

• Bonneau R, Strauss CE, Rohl CA, Chivian D, Bradley P, Malmstrom L, Robertson T, Baker D. De novo prediction of three-dimensional structures for major protein families.

• J Mol Biol. 2002 Sep 6;322(1):65-78.

• Bystroff C, Shao Y. Fully automated ab initio protein structure prediction using I-SITES, HMMSTR and ROSETTA. Bioinformatics. 2002 Jul;18 Suppl 1:S54-61

bondednon ijij

ji

ij

ij

ij

ijrra

bondH

bondS

rra

rotationbond

n

eqbendinganglebond

eqrstretchbondatoms

r

qq

r

B

r

AVeV

VeVn

v

krrkm

pH

][])1([

])1([)]cos(1[

2

)(2

1)(

2

1

2

61202)(

0

02)(

0

222

'0

'0

4545

Ab initio Methods:Ab initio Methods:

LINUS as an example: Local Independently Nucleated Units of Structure

• 50 amino acids are folded at a time, in an overlapping fashion: 1-50, 26-75, ...

• Based on the idea that actual proteins fold by forming local secondary structure first.

• Side chains are simplified. Only 3 interactions are used:

– 1 repulsive: steric

– 2 attractive: H-bonds and hydrophobic

– Then the calculation of all possibilities for the search of the lowest free energy

bondednon ijij

ji

ij

ij

ij

ijrra

bondH

bondS

rra

rotationbond

n

eqbendinganglebond

eqrstretchbondatoms

r

qq

r

B

r

AVeV

VeVn

v

krrkm

pH

][])1([

])1([)]cos(1[

2

)(2

1)(

2

1

2

61202)(

0

02)(

0

222

'0

'0