implementation of projects 25 july 2013 lt col (retd) l shri harsha project management consultant...

IMPLEMENTATION OF PROJECTS

25 July 2013

Lt Col (Retd) L Shri HarshaProject Management Consultant & Technical Arbitrator

AGENDA

• Preparing TOR and RFPs• Evaluating feasibility reports, DPRs,

procurement documents and contracts• Bidding processes, Evaluation and award of

contracts• Monitor and Manage Projects

2

Project Management Context

• Initiation - TORs & RFPs• Planning - Evaluating feasibility reports,

DPRs, procurement documents

and contracts• Execution - Evaluation & award of contracts,

contract management• Monitoring &- Contract Management

controlling • Closing - Contract Management

3

Project Initiation

“Define the problem before you pursue a solution”

- John Williams4

• Variety of activities ranging from engaging consultants, service providers, project partners, financers etc.

• Defines boundaries of the relationship for mutual support for a particular objective.

• Establish check points and methodology for reviews progress

• Requires approval of competent authorities• Subject to change based on economical, functional

and technical requirements by mutual consent

Terms of Reference

5

• Context of the proposal• Objectives desired to be achieved• Scope of work• Expected Output/deliverables • Duration of engagement• Financial aspects• Qualifications and experiences• Method of submission of proposals

Contents of Terms of Reference

6

• Request for Information• Decided on course of action• Soliciting information from various sources on same

subject• No legal binding• Leads to request for quotations

Preliminary Documents

7

• Request for Proposals• Intend to do something, but not sure of what to do or

how to do• Evaluate different approaches with same criteria • Finalize approach and methodology first• No legal binding with any proposer • Approved proposal then offered to multiple vendors

for pricing through RFQs

Preliminary Documents

8

• Request for Quotations• Clear course of action and intentions to act.• Not legally binding till contract signed• No changes in scope of work permitted• Evaluation based on capabilities to complete work

and best price offer

Preliminary Documents

9

Project Initiation and Planning Documents

• Terms of Reference• Feasibility Reports• Preliminary or Concept Project Report • Detailed Project Report• Procurement Documents or Tenders• Contracts

10

Evaluation of Project Documents

• Relevance to environment and working conditions• Functional Viability• Technical Viability• Financial Viability• Institutional Capabilities

11

Hallmark of Good Contracts

• Simple and Understandable• Precise and clear• Fair and Practical• Meet Technical and Commercial requirements• Foresee eventualities• Dispute settlement mechanisms

12

Project Monitoring and Controlling

“If you don’t know where you are, a map is of no help.”

- Watts Humphrey

13

Monitor & Manage Projects

User Requirements

Change Management

Contract Management

Breach Management

Dispute Resolution

Relations Management

Time Management

Professional Responsibilities and

Ethical Issues

Stake holder Management

14

Cost Management

Contract Management

• Begins even before the contract is drafted• On going process and a distinct end is not

identifiable• Ensured by constant visits and interactions• Long term relations built on trust and

reliability

15

Contract Administration

• Begins after the contract is signed• Ensures that the provisions of the contract are

adhered to by all parties• Roles by various SMEs defined and generally

in phases• Concludes with the closing of all litigations

and contract documents

16

Process Overlaps

Planning

Planning

M onitoring &

C ontrolling

Monitoring &

Controlling

Executing

Executing

C losing

Closing

Initiating

Initiating

Contract Management

Contract Administration

17

Responsibility

• Project Manager and his team

• Contract Manager

• The PMO

18

Role of a Contract Manager

• Creation and Maintenance of Contract documents• Ensure compliance of statutory requirements• Review performance and progress• Customer Relationship management• Rebate management• Monitoring and regulating invoicing and payment• Interpretation of contractual conditions• Change management• Dispute resolution and escalation• Sub Contract management• Brand Ambassador

19

Essential Skills

• Technical knowledge• Legal knowledge• Negotiation skills• Proactive Approach • Decision making• Analytical thinking• People skills

20

Advantages

• Better understanding of the project from the inception

• Ensures better and realistic planning• Realistic risk analysis and its mitigation• Clear assignments of responsibilities• Holistic problem identification and resolution • Establishes contractual milestones and tracking• Effective Cost tracking and controls• Facilitates contract audits• Minimizes contractual litigations• Enhances relationships amongst stakeholders 21

Weaknesses in Contract Management

• More time spent in Contract award than administration

• Unclear roles and responsibilities• Poorly defined Statement of work• Inadequate supervision and monitoring• Delays in contract closures and audits• Lack of diligence in closing contracts• Improper handling of breaches• Weakness in dealing with closeout issues

22

• Try to get Agreement signed in standard format.

• Where Customer’s format is insisted upon, ensure that this is made known upfront.

• Minute proceedings of all meetings and distribute copies.

• Consider cost, time, risks involved in proposing/ reviewing change requests

• Use breach and default notices as enforcement tools.

• Maintain a Master File

Do’s of Contract Management

23

• Get responses in writing from contractors.• Get contractor to address customer’s RFP

requirements, not just their standard products on their terms.

• Get contractor to agree to service levels and fix time lines.

• Ensure that contractor is part of unit/ final acceptance testing.

• Obtain and review clause by clause compliance to customer : tender/legal terms, flow downs, acceptance testing, language, governing laws.

• Have NDA and Teaming Agreements in place with contractors.

Do’s of Contract Management

24

• Assume that a Contract Form once used is valid for all occasions.

• Commence work without a Contract in place (LOIs, POs)

• Agree for changes / additional Work without written approval and outside Change Control Procedure.

• Take over what is clearly a contractor’s responsibility.

• Forget to have a Close-out Procedure, including recording of Lessons Learned.

• Neglect to use meeting minutes/graphs to record progress and issues.

Don'ts of Contract Management

25

• Neglect to follow paper trail audits. • Agree to contractors working on their own terms.• Agree to payment terms not tied to users

acceptance / payment.• Agree to pay travel costs (ie cost of business).• Use different currency, laws and language.

Don'ts of Contract Management

26

• Understand the functional and technical requirements before finalizing specifications

• Market study to compare and evaluate products• Purchase specifications should be broad based on

functional and technical requirements• Assess capability of supplier/vendor• Link delivery schedules to payment conditions• Impact of changes in tax policies and currency rates• Conditions and warranties• Liquidated damages and penalties • Transit risks and losses• INCO Terms and HSN Classification of goods• Risk Purchase conditions

Procurement of Goods and Services

27

• For capabilities not available in house.• Ensure availability of manpower as promised

during the tendering stage.• Clear boundaries of responsibilities including

dependency on in house resources.• Deliverables linked to time lines and penalties.• Define liquidated damages on account of

consultants non performance impacting other works

• Risk and cost arrangements.• Performance evaluation mechanism.

Peculiarities of Consultancy Services

28

• Clause 2.4 – Employer’s financial arrangements• Clause 8.7 – Delay damages• Clause 14.2 – Advance payments• Clause 14.8 – Delayed payments• Clause 15.2 – Termination by employer• Clause 15.5 – Termination for convenience• Clause 201. – Contractor’s claims• Clause 20.2 – Appointment of Dispute Board• Appendix – General conditions of Dispute Board

Agreement

FIDIC Conditions

29

30

THANK YOU

31