guide to journal writing
Post on 01-Sep-2015
46 Views
Preview:
DESCRIPTION
TRANSCRIPT
-
Dr. TJS Anand 1
Preparing Research Manuscripts for
Impact Factor Journal
Dr. T. Joseph Sahaya Anand
Department of Engineering Materials
Faculty of Manufacturing Engineering
Universiti Teknikal Malaysia Melaka
Email: anand@utem.edu.my
Tel.: + 60 6 331 6489
016 412 7232
For
FTMKs Colloquium & Seminar 19 March 2014
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
mailto:anand@utem.edu.myhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/ -
Table of Contents Introduction
Part I: Publication & Peer Review
Deciding to Publish
Submitting Your Paper
Part II: Writing a Scientific Manuscript
The Scientific Manuscript
The Abstract
The Introduction
The Methods & Materials Section
The Results Section
The Discussion Section
Figures, Tables, Equations, and References
2 Dr. TJS Anand
-
Research Manuscript - Introduction
There is no way to get experience except
through experience.
3 Dr. TJS Anand
Publication & Peer Review
What to publish?
abstract vs. full report
Choosing your forum
Which type of journal is best for you?
What audience are you targeting?
Research the journal
Publication guidelines
Article style
-
4 Dr. TJS Anand
Research Manuscript - Introduction
-
Research Manuscript - Introduction
5 Dr. TJS Anand
Publication in Science Global View
Approximately 40,000 journals published
regularly
20,000 of them are ISI or Scopus indexed
Total number of papers published annually
exceeds 2.5 million
Google Scholar has almost to taken over the
world bibliometry.
Over 70% are never cited by any one
-
Research Manuscript - Introduction
6 Dr. TJS Anand
Publication in Science Global View
Articles published (1665-2012)= 54 million
Free and paid abstracts available Scopus, ISI Web of
Knowledge (WoK), PubMed Central, and Google
Scholar
PubMed Central holds over 2.5 million articles, has a
collection of over 21 million citations
SciVerse Scopus holds over 47 million records, it
includes 21,000 peer-reviewed journals (including
1,850 open access journals), 700 trade publications,
and 450 book series.
-
Research Manuscript - Introduction
7 Dr. TJS Anand
Publication vs. Researcher
1. I love to do research
2. I have no choice
3. I hate to do research
-
Research Manuscript - Introduction
8 Dr. TJS Anand
Publication
How information is communicated among
scholars and to potential users
Research is not complete until it is published
Provides accountability, which is the basis of
trust
From one author to many
-
Research Manuscript - Introduction
9 Dr. TJS Anand
Publication - Deciding Whether (or When) to Publish
Some factors to consider: quality of the work,
extent of the work, interest to others
Suggestions:
Seek guidance in this regard from others in
your field who are more experienced in
publishing journal articles - Supervisor.
Present your work orally first. Doing so can
help in deciding whether the work is
publishable and in shaping the paper.
-
Building the Writing Habit
The same time.
The same place.
Carry a notebook
Get rid of rid of negative thoughts.
Sit alone in silence.
Ideas, not grammar, for the first draft. Rewrite.
Dr. TJS Anand 10
-
Key to Writing Skills
The path to writing well is to read excellent
writers and write.and writeand write.
Free write your thoughts. Dont worry about
structure initially.
Use the best paper in your field as a template
and try to convert your free write-up into a
format.
Keep writing concise, dynamic and simple in
construction.
Convey enthusiasm in your writing so it attract
the audience.
Dr. TJS Anand 11
-
Look at your references these will help you
narrow your choices.
Review recent publications in each candidate
journal. Find out the hot topics, the accepted
types of articles, etc.
Ask yourself the following questions:
Is the journal peer-reviewed?
Who is this journals audience?
What is the average time to print?
What is the journals Impact Factor?
Decide on one journal. DO NOT submit to multiple
journals.
Select the best journal for submission
Dr. TJS Anand 12
-
Research Manuscript - Introduction
13 Dr. TJS Anand
Identifying a Target Journal
Decide early (before drafting the paper).
Do not write the paper and then look for a
journal. (Why?)
Look for journals that have published work
similar to yours.
Consider journals that have published work
you cite.
-
Research Manuscript - Introduction
14 Dr. TJS Anand
Some Factors to Consider
Audience Researchers, Educators
Prestige Relevant in the field
Access Open Access
Impact Journal value
Publication time
Quality of reproduction
Likelihood of acceptance
-
Research Manuscript - Introduction
15 Dr. TJS Anand
What makes a good research paper?
Good writing
Publication in good journals
Great science when written poorly can be a good
paper or alternatively, average science when
written well can be a good paper.
On the other hand, great science when written
well can be an excellent paper and average
science when written poorly can be the readily
rejected paper.
-
Publishing in High Impact Journals-Its
the idea which matters
Dr. TJS Anand 16
-
Research Manuscript - Introduction
17 Dr. TJS Anand
Excuses for not publishing.
Fear of judgement / rejection.
I cant write.
I dont know where to start.
Need for perfection.
I dont have enough time.
Lack of Confidence
Fear of public scrutiny
Unsure whether have the skill
Caution work has a use by date.
-
Research Manuscript - Introduction
18 Dr. TJS Anand
The Seven Deadly Sins
1. Data manipulation, falsification
2. Duplicate manuscripts
3. Redundant publication
4. Plagiarism
5. Author conflicts of interest
6. Animal use concerns
7. Humans use concerns
-
19 Dr. TJS Anand
-
Research Manuscript - Introduction
20
Creativity
Open mind
Curiosity
Patience
Persistence
Positive Attitude
Discipline and focus
Dr. TJS Anand
-
21 Dr. TJS Anand
Research Manuscript - Introduction
What constitutes good Research?
Novel new and not resembling something formerly
known or used (can be novel but not important)
Mechanistic testing a hypothesis - determining the
fundamental processes involved in or responsible for
an action, reaction, or other natural phenomenon
Descriptive describes how are things are but does
not test how things work hypotheses are not
tested.
-
22 Dr. TJS Anand
Research Manuscript - Introduction
What constitutes good journal?
Who do I want to reach?
Less important than it used to be
Which journals have previously published work in
this area
Review your citations
Maybe too much work in this area?
Which journals have a style or message that is
consistent with yours?
Impact factors
-
23 Dr. TJS Anand
Research Manuscript - Introduction
What constitutes good journal?
Impact factor
average number of times published papers
are cited up to two years after publication.
Citation Index
average number of times published papers
are cited up to two years after publication.
-
24 Dr. TJS Anand
Research Manuscript - Introduction
Impact factor
A measure of the frequency with which the "average
article" in a journal has been cited in a particular year
or period. The annual JCR impact factor is a ratio
between citations and recent citable items published.
Thus, the impact factor of a journal is calculated by
dividing the number of current year citations to the
source items published in that journal during the
previous two years.
Impact Factor = no. of citations
total no. articles
calculated over the last 2 years
-
25
Dr. TJS Anand
Research Manuscript - Introduction
Impact factor
Calculation for journal impact factor.
A= total cites in 2012
B= 2012 cites to articles published in 2010-11 (subset of A)
C= number of articles published in 2010-11
D= B/C = 2012 impact factor
The impact factor eliminates some of the bias of such
counts which favor large journals over small ones, or
frequently issued journals over less frequently issued
ones, and of older journals over newer ones.
-
26
Dr. TJS Anand
Research Manuscript - Introduction
2012 Impact Factors are available at various sites;
newer impact factors are copyright-protected
Drawbacks of impact factors:
Review articles are cited more than original
research
Number of citations does not measure quality,
just exposure
The nature of results in different research areas
yield different amounts of publications at
different paces. Generally, medical journals
have higher impact factors than mathematical
journals.
-
27
Dr. TJS Anand
Research Manuscript - Introduction
Rank Abbreviated Journal Title IF (2012)
1 ANNU REV IMMUNOL 52.431
2 CA-CANCER J CLIN 44.515
4 NAT REV CANCER 36.557
5 PHYSIOL REV 33.918
6 NAT REV MOL CELL BIO 33.170
7 REV MOD PHYS 32.771
9 NATURE 32.182
10 SCIENCE 31.853
13 CELL 28.389
14 NAT IMMUNOL 27.586
15 JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC 24.831
http://www.nature.com/nrm/index.htmlhttp://www.nature.com/nature/index.htmlhttp://www.sciencemag.org/http://www.cell.com/http://www.nature.com/ni/index.html -
28 Dr. TJS Anand
Research Manuscript
Reasons of Rejection
So what factor - fails to communicate a sense of
purpose and how it extends the boundaries of
knowledge
Material is inappropriate for the journal
Work is fundamentally flawed
Work is unintelligible
-
Reasons for major revision or rejection of journal papers
29
Dr. TJS Anand
4%
9%
7%
8%
13%
2%
16%
7% 7%
English Errors
27%
Faulty methodology
Inadequate references
Poor quality supporting figures
Outside the scope of journal
Not enough contribution to field
Authors did not follow manuscript instructions
Poor writing style and use of English
Title not representative of study
Subject of little novel interest or not generally
applicable
Poorly written discussion
-
Manuscript - Get rejected
When rejected, try again
Even Nobel Laureates get rejection letters.
You may need to play ping pong with the
paper. Submit the paper to another journal
within one month.
You do not have to revise a paper every time it
is rejected. But if a paper is rejected 4 times,
there is a serious flaw in the paper. Find and fix
the problem.
Why? The same referee might get it again.
Dr. TJS Anand 30
-
www.weirdscience.ca
What is Peer Review Process?
Exciting the reviewers
mind is far more
important then
exciting the readers
mind.
It is likely that no one
will ever read your
paper more thoroughly
than the reviewer.
Suggest referees that
appreciate your work
(political)
31 Dr. TJS Anand
-
Research Manuscript
32 Dr. TJS Anand
A scientific paper tells a story!!
We need a problem or something to
catch the readers attention
We need a plot / results
We need resolution of the problem at the
end of the story.
-
Research Manuscript
33 Dr. TJS Anand
Attributes of the best papers
Resolve a controversy
Separate Results and Discussion sections
Discussion with sub-headings as questions
Introduction builds to central questions
All roads lead to central question
Hypotheses / research questions crystal
clear and results flow from these questions
-
Research Manuscript
34 Dr. TJS Anand
Paper Structure and relative level of writing difficulty
Title (difficult)
Abstract (difficult)
Introduction (Most difficult)
Study Area or Background (easy)
Methods (easy)
Results (easy - just the facts)
Discussion (Second-most difficult)
Conclusions (easy)
-
Research Manuscript Structure
35 Dr. TJS Anand
* Abstract
* Introduction
* Body of Article / Methodology
* Results
* Discussion and Conclusions
* Acknowledgements
* References
* Figures and Tables
-
36 Dr. TJS Anand
Research Manuscript Structure
Abstract
Summary of Manuscript (200-300 Words)
Problem investigated
Purpose of Research
Methods
Results
Conclusion
Common Mistake : Prepare abstract at the beginning
of the manuscript writing
-
37 Dr. TJS Anand
Research Manuscript Structure
Abstract - Common Mistakes
Prepare abstract at the beginning of the
manuscript writing.
Too much background or methods information
Figures or images
References to other literature, figures or images
Abbreviations or acronyms
-
38 Dr. TJS Anand
Research Manuscript Structure
Introduction Explains the problem
* Broad information on topic
Previous research
* Narrower background information
Need for study
* Focus of paper
Hypothesis
* Summary of problem (selling point)
* Overall 300-500 words
-
The introduction should also contain a section
describing why this work was done and its
importance.
This is often omitted because the authors assume
that it must be inherently obvious.
Some readers may understand the implied
importance, but many will not.
These statements may also catch the attention
of those who focus more on applications and
potential rather than techniques.
Introduction in the research manuscript is also
includes literature review in any technical report.
Dr. TJS Anand 39
Research Manuscript Structure
-
40 Dr. TJS Anand
Research Manuscript Structure
Introduction as an inverted pyramid
Status Quo
Whats wrong with the
status quo
Why this is a problem
How you intend to fix it
Specific Objectives
# of references
increases
Very general
References
Very specific
references
-
41 Dr. TJS Anand
Research Manuscript Structure
Introduction - Common Mistakes
# Too much or not enough information
# Unclear purpose
# Lists
# Confusing structure
# First-Person anecdotes
-
Methodology
42 Dr. TJS Anand
Research Manuscript Structure
Provides instruction on exactly how to repeat experiment
* Subjects / Field of study
* Sample preparation techniques
* Sample origins
* Field site description
* Data collection protocol
* Data analysis techniques
* Any computer programs used
* Description of equipment and its use
-
The descriptions of the experiment must be
clear enough so that they can be readily
replicated.
This is much better if it is done without going
through several other references to get the
gist.
Research Manuscript Structure
43 Dr. TJS Anand
-
Material and Methods
Write the methods section first because it is the
easiest to write.
Start writing when experiments still in progress
Sufficient information must be provided for
reproducibility
Animal, human, protections details
Measurements/ instruments
Statistical analysis
Data collection
Descriptive subheadings general experimental
methods, animals, spectral data, etc
44 Dr. TJS Anand
-
http://www.nature.com/scitable/ebooks/english-communication-for-scientists-14053993/writing-
scientific-papers-14239285
You are not expected to do it..
45 Dr. TJS Anand
-
46
Too little information
Information from Introduction
Results/ sources of error reported
Explaining experimental difficulties
Dr. TJS Anand
Methodology - Common Mistakes
Research Manuscript Structure
-
47 Dr. TJS Anand
* Objective presentation of experiment results
Summary of data
* NOT a Discussion!
Results - Common Mistakes
Research Manuscript Structure
Results
* Raw data
* Redundancy
* Discussion and interpretation of data
* No figures or tables
* Methods/materials reported
-
48 Dr. TJS Anand
Research Manuscript Structure
Discussion Presents the WHY and HOW story
* Interpret results
Did the study confirm/deny the hypothesis?
If not, did the results provide an alternative
hypothesis? What interpretation can be made?
Do results agree with other research? Sources of
error/anomalous data?
Implications of study for field
Suggestions for improvement and future research?
* Relate to previous research
-
49 Dr. TJS Anand
Discussion - Common Mistakes
Research Manuscript Structure
* Combined with Results
* New results discussed
* Broad statements
* Incorrectly discussing inconclusive results
* Ambiguous data sources
* Missing information
-
50 Dr. TJS Anand
Research Manuscript Structure
Figures and Tables
Tables
Presents lists of numbers/ text in columns
Figures
Visual representation of results or illustration
of concepts/methods (graphs, images,
diagrams, etc.)
Captions
Must be stand-alone
-
The selection of illustrations, tables, and graphs
are not just to present the data and apparatus
described.
Too many or too few illustrations can greatly
weaken a paper.
On one hand, too few leave details as
ambiguous. On the other, too many can be
redundant, distracting, and divert the attention
of the reader to the main points.
51 Dr. TJS Anand
Research Manuscript Structure
Figures and Tables
-
52 Dr. TJS Anand
Research Manuscript Structure
Guidelines for Figures and Tables
High resolution
Neat, legible labels
Simple
Clearly formatted
Indicate error
Detailed captions
-
One area that many authors overlook or give only
minor attention to is the acknowledgements.
Although the people and organizations included
there do not affect the readability of the
manuscript, many authors have made grievous
errors of omission in their acknowledgements.
Leaving out someone who has aided through key
ideas, review of the manuscript, etc. etc. can lead
to injured feelings.
Subsequent assistance may not be so readily
forthcoming.
Research Manuscript Structure
Acknowledgements
53 Dr. TJS Anand
-
54 Dr. TJS Anand
Research Manuscript Structure
References
Check specific referencing style of journal
Should reference:
Peer-reviewed journal articles, abstracts, books
Should not reference:
Non-peer-reviewed works, textbooks, personal
communications
Common Mistakes
Format, Format, Format
(Figures & Tables, Equations, and References)
Redundant Information
Text, Figures, Tables, and Captions
Type of Reference
-
Examples of offensive citation:
"The deficiency of Smith's approach is..."
"The problems with Smiths paper are"
A serious weakness with Smiths argument,
however, is that ......
The key problem with Smiths explanation
is that ......
It seems that Smiths understanding of the
X framework is questionable.
55 Dr. TJS Anand
-
A better citation would be:
Smiths model was effective in X
problem, however in Y
The X benefit of Smiths approach
are not applicable to Y
56 Dr. TJS Anand
-
57 Dr. TJS Anand
A bit on Writing Style - Language
Research Manuscript Structure
Write in the active tense instead of passive tense:
We collected samples of blah... instead of
Samples of blah were collected...
Avoid all jargon if at all possible. Never assume
the reader knows any jargon.
Write in simple sentences
Subject and verb up-front in all sentences
You can use personal pronouns: We sampled
-
Scientific Language - Tenses
Present tense for known facts and hypotheses:
The average life of a honey bee is 6 weeks
Past tense for experiments you have conducted:
All the honey bees were maintained in an
environment with a consistent temperature of 23
degrees centigrade
Past tense when you describe the results of an
experiment:
The average life span of bees in our contained
environment was 8 weeks
58 Dr. TJS Anand
-
Research Manuscript - Summary
59
Preparation Style Usage or Words
Dr. TJS Anand
Examine vs. Analyze
Activity to gain knowledge vs. Describing
the analysis of that knowledge
Blooms Taxonomy
Knowledge
Comprehension
Application
Analysis
Synthesis
Evaluation
-
Research Manuscript - Summary
60
Preparation Style Usage or Words - Blooms Taxonomy
Dr. TJS Anand
Knowledge - Recitation of fact
Found, identified, labeled
Comprehension: State a problem or interpret fact
Discuss, predict, compare
Application: Apply old information to solve new problems
Solve, show, examine, classify
Analysis: Used to explain patterns or meaning
Analyze, investigate, compare, contrast
Synthesis: Making predictions or discussing possibilities
Predict, plan, devise, propose
Evaluation: Drawing conclusions, making recommendations
Justify, verify, argue, recommend, determine
-
61 Dr. TJS Anand
Research Manuscript - Summary
Words and expressions to avoid
Jargon Preferred use
a considerable amount of much
on account of because
a number of several
In a number of cases some
Has the capacity to can
It is clear that clearly
It is apparent that apparently
Employ use
Fabricate make
Source : Day, RA. How to write and publish a scientific paper, 5th edition, Oryx Press, 1998.
-
62 Dr. TJS Anand
Research Manuscript
Ethical Publishing
Material must be obtained ethically and must
be accurate
Experiments or trials involving human subjects or
animals must have been approved by the
relevant research ethics committees
Material should be unbiased, uncensored,
complete, factual and verifiable
Relevant funding and any conflict of interest
must be disclosed
-
63 Dr. TJS Anand
Research Manuscript
Ethical Publishing - Authorship
Authorship requires a significant contribution to
at least one aspect of the work
(concept, data collection, data analysis,
literature review, writing)
Ethical Publishing Things unacceptable
Duplication of previously published material (this
includes web publication of previous print publication,
Web and print publication covered by the same
copyright is now frequent and is OK )
Simultaneous submission to more than one journal
Plagiarism
-
64 Dr. TJS Anand
Resources / Bibliography
Day, RA. How to write and publish a scientific paper, 5th edition, Oryx Press, 1998.
Ravi Lochanan P. Research Methodology 3rd Edition, Margham Publications, 2009.
Uma Sekaran and Roger Bougie Research Methods for Business 5th Edition, Wiley,
2010.
Salkind NJ. Exploring Research 7th Edition, Pearson, 2009.
Fischer BA, Zigmond MJ. Components of a research article. survival@pitt.edu
Marshal GS. Writing a peer reviewed article.
http://dor.umc.edu/ARCHIVES/GMarshallPublishingarticle.ppt
Hall, JE. Writing research papers (and getting them published)
http://dor.umc.edu/ARCHIVES/GMarshallPublishingarticle.ppt
Benos, D., Reich, M. Peer review and publication in APS journals.http://www.the-
aps.org/careers/careers1/EBSymposia/Benos2003.ppt
mailto:survival@pitt.edumailto:survival@pitt.edumailto:survival@pitt.eduhttp://dor.umc.edu/ARCHIVES/GMarshallPublishingarticle.ppthttp://dor.umc.edu/ARCHIVES/GMarshallPublishingarticle.ppthttp://dor.umc.edu/ARCHIVES/GMarshallPublishingarticle.ppthttp://dor.umc.edu/ARCHIVES/GMarshallPublishingarticle.ppthttp://dor.umc.edu/ARCHIVES/GMarshallPublishingarticle.ppthttp://dor.umc.edu/ARCHIVES/GMarshallPublishingarticle.ppthttp://dor.umc.edu/ARCHIVES/GMarshallPublishingarticle.ppthttp://dor.umc.edu/ARCHIVES/GMarshallPublishingarticle.ppthttp://dor.umc.edu/ARCHIVES/GMarshallPublishingarticle.ppthttp://dor.umc.edu/ARCHIVES/GMarshallPublishingarticle.ppthttp://dor.umc.edu/ARCHIVES/GMarshallPublishingarticle.ppthttp://dor.umc.edu/ARCHIVES/GMarshallPublishingarticle.ppthttp://dor.umc.edu/ARCHIVES/GMarshallPublishingarticle.ppthttp://dor.umc.edu/ARCHIVES/GMarshallPublishingarticle.ppthttp://dor.umc.edu/ARCHIVES/GMarshallPublishingarticle.ppthttp://dor.umc.edu/ARCHIVES/GMarshallPublishingarticle.ppthttp://dor.umc.edu/ARCHIVES/GMarshallPublishingarticle.ppthttp://dor.umc.edu/ARCHIVES/GMarshallPublishingarticle.ppt -
Take Home Message
Sacrifice other interests
Researchers gave up hobbies, games and
time with friends to become high impact
researchers. Most mentioned that they still
had time for family, but less TV, computer
games, and sports.
When you play, play hard; when you work,
work hard, don't play at all.
Theodore Roosevelt
65
Dr. TJS Anand
http://www.quotationspage.com/quote/2864.htmlhttp://www.quotationspage.com/quote/2864.htmlhttp://www.quotationspage.com/quote/2864.htmlhttp://www.quotationspage.com/quote/2864.htmlhttp://www.quotationspage.com/quote/2864.htmlhttp://www.quotationspage.com/quote/2864.htmlhttp://www.quotationspage.com/quote/2864.htmlhttp://www.quotationspage.com/quote/2864.htmlhttp://www.quotationspage.com/quote/2864.htmlhttp://www.quotationspage.com/quote/2864.htmlhttp://www.quotationspage.com/quote/2864.htmlhttp://www.quotationspage.com/quote/2864.htmlhttp://www.quotationspage.com/quote/2864.htmlhttp://www.quotationspage.com/quote/2864.htmlhttp://www.quotationspage.com/quote/2864.htmlhttp://www.quotationspage.com/quote/2864.htmlhttp://www.quotationspage.com/quote/2864.htmlhttp://www.quotationspage.com/quote/2864.htmlhttp://www.quotationspage.com/quote/2864.htmlhttp://www.quotationspage.com/quote/2864.htmlhttp://www.quotationspage.com/quote/2864.htmlhttp://www.quotationspage.com/quote/2864.htmlhttp://www.quotationspage.com/quote/2864.htmlhttp://www.quotationspage.com/quote/2864.htmlhttp://www.quotationspage.com/quote/2864.htmlhttp://www.quotationspage.com/quote/2864.htmlhttp://www.quotationspage.com/quote/2864.htmlhttp://www.quotationspage.com/quote/2864.htmlhttp://www.quotationspage.com/quote/2864.html -
66
Dr. TJS Anand
All the best!
-
67
Dr. TJS Anand
-
Thanking you !
Comments & Suggestions
68
Dr. TJS Anand
top related