crm-mpl1 the western sahara in the light of the international law : fifteen basic statements on the...

CRM-MPL 1

The Western Sahara in the light of the International law :

Fifteen basic statements on the conflict of Western Sahara

Carlos Ruiz Miguel, Universidad de Santiago de Compostela, EspañaMoisés Ponce de León Iglesias, Université Rennes 2 – Haute Bretagne, France

CRM-MPL 2

Fifteen basic statements on the conflict of Western Sahara

CRM-MPL 3

« Any legal analysis of the question of Western Sahara should take into account

several basic, objective, statements that are the key of any approach to the conflict

according to the International Law »

Fifteen basic statements on the conflict of Western Sahara

CRM-MPL 4

Fifteen basic statements on the conflict of Western Sahara

« Any approach differing from these statements could be clearly qualified as illegal according to the Law of the United Nations  »

CRM-MPL 5http://www.un.org/depts/Cartographic/map/profile/afrique.pdfOctober 2011

CRM-MPL 6

http://www.un.org/depts/Cartographic/map/dpko/minurso.pdf

CRM-MPL 7

1884. Spain signs a Treaty of protectorate with certain Sahrawi tribes and begins its occupation of the territory

1965. The General Assembly of the UNO asks Spain to withdraw from Spanish Sahara, in the international context of the decolonization, and asserts the right to self-determination for the Sahrawi people

1973. Creation of the Frente Popular de Liberación de Saguía el Hamra y Río de Oro (Front Polisario)

Small historical reminder

CRM-MPL 8

Small historical reminder

1974. Spain announces its intention to withdraw and begin to organize a referendum of self-determination. Hassan II persuades the General Assembly to ask an advisory opinion of the International Court of Justice about how to proceed with the decolonisation of the Territory

1975. Advisory opinion of the International Court of Justice reaffirming the application of resolution 1514 of the UN-GA in the decolonization of Western Sahara and the application of the principle of self-determination for the populations of the territory. (October 16th)

CRM-MPL 9

1975. Green March launches the occupation of the Western Sahara by Morocco (November 6th)

1976.(February 26th) Withdrawal from Spain. Morocco and Mauritanian try to conquer the Territory

1976 Spain, Morocco and Mauritania sign the so-called “Madrid Agreements” where quality of Spain as “administering power” of the Western Sahara is illegally tansfered to an interim (as much until Feb 28th 1976) to a tripartite administration (Spain-Morocco-Mauritania)

1976. (February 27th). Creation of Sahrawi Arab Democratic Republic ( RASD) by the Front Polisario

1978-1979. Cease fire and peace treaty with Mauritania. Annexation by Morocco of the territory occupied by Mauritania

Small historical reminder

CRM-MPL 10

1981 - 1987. Construction by the Moroccan army of  walls of 2700 km long which divide the Sahrawi territory

1984. OUA ( Organization of African Unity ) admits the SADR within as its 51st member

1991. Under the auspices of the OAU and the UNO, signature by the two parties (Morocco and Polisario Front) of the “Settlement Plan”, wich establishes a cease-fire and the holding of a referendum of self-determination in 1992. The Settlement Plan is approved by the Security Council (resolutions 658 & 690). Creation of the Misssion of the United Nations for the Referendum in the Western Sahara (MINURSO in the Spanish acronym)

1992. Boycott of the referendum by Morocco

Small historical reminder

CRM-MPL 11

1The Western Sahara is a

« non-self governing territory »

and a

« colonial country »

A/RES/2072_1965A/RES/2625_1970…A/RES/66/86_2012

Fifteen basic statements on the conflict of Western Sahara

CRM-MPL 12A/RES/2072_1965

1

CRM-MPL 13A/RES/2072_1965

1

CRM-MPL 14RES/2072_1965

1

CRM-MPL 15A/RES/2625_1970

1

CRM-MPL 16A/RES/2625_1970

1

CRM-MPL 17A/RES/66/86_2012

1

CRM-MPL 18

2The conflict of Sahara Occidental is a

« question of decolonization »

A/RES/2072_1965A/RES/2229_1966A/RES/3458-A_1975A/RES/33-31_1978A/RES/34-37_1979A/RES/35-19_1980A/RES/39-40_1984A/RES/45-21_1990A/RES/64/101_2010A/RES/65/112_2011A/RES/66/86_2012

Fifteen basic statements on the conflict of Western Sahara

CRM-MPL 19

2

A/RES/2072_1965

CRM-MPL 20A/RES/2229_1966

2

CRM-MPL 21

2

A/RES/35-19_1980

CRM-MPL 22

2

A/RES/35/19_1980

CRM-MPL 23

2

A/RES/35/19_1980

CRM-MPL 24

2

A/RES/45-21_1990

CRM-MPL 25A/RES/65-112_2011

2

CRM-MPL 26A/RES/66/86_2012

2

CRM-MPL 27

3The United Nations recognizes

internationally the existence of the

« people of Western Sahara »

A/RES/2072_1965A/RES/2229_1966A/RES/3458-A_1975A/RES/3458-B_1975A/RES/33/31_1978A/RES/34/37_1979A/RES/35/19_1980A/RES/64/101_2010 A/RES/65/112_2011S/RES/1920_2010

Fifteen basic statements on the conflict of Western Sahara

CRM-MPL 28

3

A/RES/2229_1966

CRM-MPL 29

3

A/RES/3458_1975

CRM-MPL 30

3

A/RES/66/86_2012

CRM-MPL 31

3

S/RES/2044_2012

CRM-MPL 32

4The ‘people of Western Sahara’

is composed by the

« indigenous people of the Territory »

A/RES/2229_1966A/RES/3458-A_1975A/RES/3458-B_1975S/2000/131, para. 6

Fifteen basic statements on the conflict of Western Sahara

CRM-MPL 33

4

CRM-MPL 34

4

A/RES/3458_A/1975

CRM-MPL 35

4

S/2000/131

CRM-MPL 36

4

S/2000/131

CRM-MPL 37

4

S/2000/131

CRM-MPL 38

5The ‘people of the Western Sahara’ 

has a « right to self-determination »

A/RES/2229_1966A/RES/3458-A_1975A/RES/3458-B_1975A/RES/33-31_1978A/RES/34-37_1979A/RES/35-19_1980A/RES/64/101_2010 A/RES/65/112_2011S/RES/1871_2009S/RES/1920_2010

Fifteen basic statements on the conflict of Western Sahara

CRM-MPL 39

A/RES/2229_1966

5

CRM-MPL 40A/RES/65/112_2011

5

CRM-MPL 41A/RES/3458-A_1975

5

CRM-MPL 42S/RES/1871/2009

5

CRM-MPL 43S/RES/1920/2010

5

CRM-MPL 44

6The ‘right of self-determination’ of the

‘people of Western Sahara ’ is

« inalienable »

A/RES/2229_1966A/RES/64/101_2010 A/RES/65/112_2011A/RES/66/86_2012

Fifteen basic statements on the conflict of Western Sahara

CRM-MPL 45A/RES/2229_1966

6

CRM-MPL 46A/RES/66/86_2012

2

CRM-MPL 47

7The ‘inalienable right of self-determination’ of the ‘people of Western Sahara’ should be

exercised by a « referendum »

A/RES/2229_1966A/RES/3458-A_1975A/RES/3458-B_1975A/RES/33-31_1978A/RES/34-37_1979A/RES/35-19_1980A/RES/38-40_1983A/RES/65/112_2011S/RES/621_1988S/RES/658_1990S/RES/1871_2009S/RES/1920_2010S/RES/2044/2012

Fifteen basic statements on the conflict of Western Sahara

CRM-MPL 48A/RES/2229_1966

7

CRM-MPL 49A/RES/3458-A_1975

7

CRM-MPL 50A/RES/38-40_1983

7

CRM-MPL 51S/RES/658/1990

7

CRM-MPL 52S/RES/690/1991

7

CRM-MPL 53S/RES/2044/2012

7

CRM-MPL 54S/RES/1920/2010

7

CRM-MPL 55S/RES/2044/2012

7

CRM-MPL 56

8The referendum of self-determination should be

« free, democratic and impartial » « without any administrative or

military contraints  »

A/RES/2229_1966A/RES/38-40_1983

Fifteen basic statements on the conflict of Western Sahara

CRM-MPL 57S/RES/2229/1966

8

CRM-MPL 58A/RES/38-40/1983

8

CRM-MPL 59

9The ’people of Western Sahara’ has a

« right to independence » Because never existed

« any tie of territorial sovereignity » Between Morocco and the Western Sahara

A/RES/2229_1966CIJ 1975A/RES/38-40_1983

Fifteen basic statements on the conflict of Western Sahara

CRM-MPL 60A/RES/3292/1974

9

CRM-MPL 61A/RES/3292/1974

9

CRM-MPL 62

9

http://www.icj-cij.org/docket/files/61/6195.pdf

CRM-MPL 63

9

ICJ Western Sahara, 1975

CRM-MPL 64

9

ICJ Western Sahara, 1975, para. 105

ICJ Western Sahara, 1975, para. 105

CRM-MPL 65

9 ICJ Western Sahara, 1975, para. 105

CRM-MPL 66

9

ICJ Western Sahara, 1975, para. 162

http://www.icj-cij.org/docket/files/61/6195.pdf

CRM-MPL 67

9

ICJ Western Sahara, 1975, para. 162

http://www.icj-cij.org/docket/files/61/6195.pdf

CRM-MPL 68

10

Spain is the

« administering power » of the Western Sahara

A/RES/2072_1965A/RES/3458-A_1975A/RES/3458-B_1975A/66/65_2011A/67/71_2012S/2002/161, para. 6

Fifteen basic statements on the conflict of Western Sahara

CRM-MPL 69

10

S/2002/161

CRM-MPL 70

10

A/67/71

CRM-MPL 71

10

A/67/71

CRM-MPL 72

10

A/67/71

but… a State neither loses its status of administering power,

nor is  released from the fulfilmente of its obligations

by simply opposing to it de facto…

CRM-MPL 73

11

The presence of Morocco in the major part of Western Sahara is an

« occupation»

S/RES/380_1975A/RES/34-37_1979A/RES/35-19_1980

Fifteen basic statements on the conflict of Western Sahara

CRM-MPL 74

11

S/RES/380_1975

CRM-MPL 75

11

A/RES/34-37_1979

CRM-MPL 76

11

A/RES/35-19_1980

CRM-MPL 77

11

A/RES/35-19_1980

CRM-MPL 78

12

The Frente Polisario is the

« representative of the people of Western Sahara »

A/RES/33-31_1978A/RES/34-37_1979A/RES/35-19_1980

Fifteen basic statements on the conflict of Western Sahara

CRM-MPL 79

12

A/RES/33-31_1978

CRM-MPL 80

12

A/RES/34-37_1979

CRM-MPL 81

12

A/RES/34-37_1979

CRM-MPL 82

12

A/RES/35-19_1980

CRM-MPL 83

12

A/RES/35-19_1980

CRM-MPL 84

13

The Frente Polisario and Morocco are the two

« parties to the conflict »

A/RES/38-40_1983A/RES/39-40_1984A/RES/45-21_1990S/RES/1495_2003A/RES/64/101_2010A/RES/65/112_2011

Fifteen basic statements on the conflict of Western Sahara

CRM-MPL 85

13

A/RES/38-40_1983

CRM-MPL 86

13

A/RES/39-40_1984

CRM-MPL 87

13

A/RES/45-21_1990

CRM-MPL 88

14

The ‘people of Western Sahara’ has

« legitimacy » ‘to fight on behalf of the right to self-determination

and independence of the people of Western Sahara’

A/RES/2625_1970A/RES/34-37_1979A/RES/35-19_1980

Fifteen basic statements on the conflict of Western Sahara

CRM-MPL 89

14

A/RES/34-37_1979

CRM-MPL 90

14

A/RES/2625_1970

CRM-MPL 91

15

There is a

« responsability of the United Nations »

in the decolonization of the Western Sahara

A/RES/2229_1966A/RES/2983_1972A/RES/3162_1973A/RES3458-A_1975A/RES/64/101_2010A/RES/65/112_2011

Fifteen basic statements on the conflict of Western Sahara

CRM-MPL 92

15

A/RES/2229_1966

CRM-MPL 93

15

A/RES/2983_1972

CRM-MPL 94

15

A/RES/3162_1973

CRM-MPL 95

15

A/RES/3458-A_1975

CRM-MPL 96

15

A/RES/65/112_2011

CRM-MPL 97

…for, any proposed solution needs to be firmly grounded in international law

in order to achieve just and fair, legitimate and sustainable outcomes.

Karin Arts et Pedro Pinto Leite

(in International Law and the question of Western Sahara, Éd. IPJET, 2007 Le droit international et la question du Sahara occidental, Éd. IPJET, 2009)

CRM-MPL 98

The history of the conflict is downright discouraging to anyone who believes

in the rule of law.

CRM-MPL 99

Despite dozens of UN Security Council resolutions since 1975, all reaffirming the right of the people of Western Sahara to self-determination, and the fact

that the UN’s Fourth Committee treats Western Sahara as a Moroccan colony, Morocco continues to put itself above the law and remains firmly in place,

and in charge, in

Western Sahara, Africa’s last colony.

CRM-MPL 100

It is what lawyers call res ipsa loquitur (the thing speaks for itself),

which means that in certain crystal clear situations a simple recitation of the facts, without need of further

proof, is sufficient to presume guilt.

CRM-MPL 101

We are all Saharawis now

Aujourd’hui, nous sommes tous des Sahraouis

Hoy todos somos saharauis

Frank Rudy Ambassadeur des États Unis

CRM-MPL 102

Occupied but not conquered

Ocupados pero no conquistados

Occupés mais non conquis

CRM-MPL 103Hmad Hammad

CRM-MPL 104

SOURCES- ‘The rigth to self-determination and the natural resources of the Western Sahara’ (inedit), Carlos Ruiz Miguel

- ‘International law and the question of Western Sahara, Éd. IPJET, 2007, Karin Arts et Pedro Pinto LeiteIPJET (International Platform of Jurist for East Timor)

- http://www.un.org/depts/Cartographic/map/profile/afrique.pdf- http://www.un.org/depts/Cartographic/map/dpko/minurso.pdf-http://un.org A/RES et S/RES -http://arso.org

Carlos Ruiz Miguel and Moisés Ponce de León Iglesias

The Western Sahara Symposium, Ljubljana, Slovenia, Mai 2012