chapter seven
Post on 23-Feb-2016
32 Views
Preview:
DESCRIPTION
TRANSCRIPT
CHAPTER SEVENTRIALS AND TRIAL PROCEDURES
Trials command public attention Spectacular crimes Notorious parties Sympathetic victims
Visible representative of the criminal justice process
Few cases make it to trial
Introduction
Arrest
Police Lockup
Bail Set
Initial Appearance
Preliminary Hearing
Grand Jury
Arraignment
Pretrial Motions
Pretrial Procedures
Seizure or forcible restraint
Taking or keeping a person by legal authority in response to a criminal charge
Arrest with a warrant Felony and misdemeanor arrests
Arrest without a warrant Felony arrests if committed in the officer’s presence, or upon probable
cause Misdemeanor arrests if offense is committed in the officer’s presence,
or if allowed by the state for other specific offenses
Arrest
Short-term detention
Processing
Book suspect into jail
Investigations
Custodial interrogations
Suspect Placed in Police Lockup
Process of securing release prior to next court appearance
8th Amendment prohibits excessive bail
Bail set by judge or magistrate
Preventive detention Presents a significant flight risk Presents a significant public safety threat Bail Reform Act of 1984 Issues with preventive detention
Methods of posting bail Unsecured bond Cash deposit Property bonds Bail bondsman Percentage deposit
Bail
Processing of felonies and serious misdemeanors
Judge considers existence of probable cause for arrest
Charges are reviewed
Attorney representation addressed
Takes place 24-48 hours after arrest
Initial Appearance
Felony and misdemeanor cases
Right may be waived by defendant
Defendant informed of charges
Discussion of right to counsel
Discussion of bail reduction
State begins presentation of evidence to show probable cause
Preliminary Hearing
Guaranteed by 5th Amendment (federal felonies)
Private aspect Hearings are closed Defendant, media, and public cannot attend Members are sworn to lifelong secrecy
Size variation
Prosecuting attorney advises grand jury
Unanimous decisions are not needed
May issue true bill or no true bill
Grand Jury
Judge may address counsel and bail
Defendant is informed of charges
Defendant informed of Due Process Rights
Defendant enters a plea Guilty Not guilty Nolo contendere Guilty but mentally ill Not guilty by reason of insanity Alford plea
Arraignment
Advantages Eliminates uncertainty of trial Lesser sentence Removes time and stress of trial
Issues Places prosecutor in a position of power Defendant is at the mercy of prosecutor and defense attorney Judge plays a minor role
Factors driving plea bargaining Caseload Allows all parties to get something they want
Plea Bargaining
Work History
Education
Family
Prior Criminal History
Makes a recommendation of incarceration or probation
Presentence Investigation Report
Dismissal of charges
Severance of Charges
Change of Venue
Suppression of Evidence
Discovery
Continuance
Many others
Pretrial Motions
Right to jury trial is guaranteed by the 6th Amendment
The defendant may waive this right
In a bench trial, the judge determines the outcome
Most felonies are resolved through jury trials
Jury and Bench Trials
Small lists are assembled from the master list
Venire goes through jury selection
Potential jurors are questioned (voir dire)
Biased jurors are eliminated Unlimited strikes for cause Limited number of peremptory challenges
Art or science of jury selection
Case may be won or lost in jury selection
Jury Selection
Prosecuting attorney goes first
Each side gives an overview of their case
Explain the theory of the case
Opening Arguments
Prosecution calls witnesses first
Initial questioning (direct examination) done by the side calling the witness
Opposing side then questions the witness (cross-examination)
Attorneys may continue questioning until both sides have concluded
Types of witnesses Eyewitnesses (lay witnesses) Expert Witnesses
Witness Examination
The court “must decide whether the proposed expert testimony meets the requirements of relevance and reliability.”
Party seeking to admit the evidence “must show that the expert’s underlying reasoning or methodology, and its application to the facts, are scientifically valid.”
Factors for scientific validity (Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals)
Whether the theory can be or has been tested Whether the theory has been subjected to peer review or publication, the theory’s known or
potential rate of error, and whether there are standards that control its operation The degree to which the relevant scientific community has accepted the theory
Use of Scientific Analysis
Defense gives closing arguments first
Addresses inconsistencies or flaws in the opposition’s case
Judge reads instructions (charge) to the jury Explanation of the state’s obligation Guilt beyond a reasonable doubt Instructions about witness testimony Special instructions
Closing Arguments and Jury Instructions
Determination about sequestering the jury
Jury elects a foreperson
Preliminary vote
Address and discuss evidence
Final vote
Judge announces the verdict
Jurors may be polled
Judge sets sentencing date and orders pre-sentence investigation report
Jury Deliberations and Verdict
Theories of sentencing Retribution Deterrence Incapacitation Rehabilitation Restorative Justice
Performed by jury in capital cases, judge in other cases
Judge determines concurrent or consecutive sentences
Judge may suspend some sentences
Sentencing
Misdemeanors Appeal to courts of general trial jurisdiction De novo (new) trial
Felonies Appeal to courts of intermediate appeals or courts of last resort
Right of appeal limited to court examination of trial record for error
Few cases are appealed
Appeals are based upon errors of law
Appeals
top related