australia live cattle export ban

Photo by Carla Wiese-Smith

Australia’s Live Cattle Export Ban

By Victoria Frobish

htt

p:/

/ww

w.z

imb

io.c

om

/pic

ture

s/U

2kt

dET5

kyP/

Au

stra

lia+

Su

spen

ds+

Live+

Catt

le+

Exp

ort

s+In

don

esi

a/

bKo3

8Fd

ld_F

Video Clip

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wQuj3X5iRyw&feature=related

Objectives

1. Background

2. The Issue

3. The Controversy

4. Stakeholders

5. Views of Stakeholders

6. Current Solutions

7. Future Issues

Background

Background

•Activist Groups• Animals Australia• Royal Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (RSPCA)

•Meat and Livestock Australia (MLA)

•Abattoirs = Slaughter Houses

Background

•Australia exported about 800,000 cattle to Indonesia in 2009 at it’s peak

•Exports • Livestock• Cattle – Sheep - Goats

• Breading• Horses – Dear - Pigs

Issue Background

•Largest cattle export to Indonesia

•Indonesia is highly dependent on Australia’s cattle

•Australia is foot and mouth disease free

The Issue

The Issue

•Animals Australia Investigation Documentary aired in May on ABC Four Corner• Mistreatment animals

• Inhumane slaughtering• No stunning

The Issue

•One week after airing live cattle exports to Indonesia were banned

•Cattle were left in limbo

•Two months later theban was lifted to all but 11 abattoirs in Indonesia

The Controversy

Supporters of the ban

•Issue was known for a long time

Opponents of the ban

•Government reacted too quickly

•Animals Australia had video for 30 days before releasing it

The Controversy

Stakeholders

Stakeholders

•Animals

•Australian farmers

•Cattle companies and agencies

•Indonesian Abattoir employees

•Indonesian consumers

•Australian transportation

•Other types of Australian farmers including grain producers

Supporters of the ban

•Animal Cruelty

•No rules or regulations

•Government reacts to public pressure

•Create and enforce rules and regulations• Stunning

•Ban live exports, build domestic market

Supporters of the ban

Problems

Solutions

Opponents of the ban

•Animal cruelty

•No reports of the problem

•Government acted too quickly

•Risk retaliation from Indonesia Government

•Educate how to slaughter humanely

•Tracking system

Opponents of the ban

Problems

Solutions

Current Solutions

Current Solutions

•Rules and regulations

•Educating abroad

•Tracking devices

•Compensation for farmers

Future Issues

Future Issues

•Australian farmers fear ban of live cattle exports in the near future

•Animal welfare groups hopes stunning becomes mandatory in Indonesia

•Could affect Australia’s relationships with other countries