article review - siyasah syariah
Post on 03-Apr-2018
212 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/28/2019 Article Review - Siyasah Syariah
1/8
Siyasah Shariyah or the Policies of Islamic Government
By Mohamad Hashim Kamali
Introduction
This article was written by Mohamad Hashim Kamali.The author aims to
delineate the arbitrary and legitimate uses of power in Islamic law. He
worked on the hypothesis that an adequate understanding of siyasah al-
shar'iyah would show that it is incompatible with the arbitrary and abusive
exercise of power in any form. Furthermore unlike the impression that
many have maintained, siyasah al-shar'iyah does not object to the
regulation and control of discretionary power through the medium of
statutory legislation.
The author states that SS is aboard doctrine of Islamic law which
authorizes the ruler to determine the manner in which the Shariah should
be administered. Thats means the ruler may accordingly take
discretionary measures, enact rules and initiates policies as he deems are
in the interest of good government, provided that no substantive principle
of the Shariah is violated thereby. The discretionary powers are
particularly extensive in the field of criminal law. The author also
suggested that SS, as such defies effective control and it is open to abuse,
which would ultimately undermine the ideals of justice under the rule of
law.
This article showed that the author divided this article into eight parts.
Every part discussed on different issues and topics which will be described
hereunder.
Part I
In this part, the author have discussed the different usages of SS. In the
usage of ulama SS means Shariah-oriented policy, or government in
accordance with the Shariah. But in usage of fuqaha SS implies decisions
-
7/28/2019 Article Review - Siyasah Syariah
2/8
and policy measures taken by the ulu al amr on matters which is no
specific ruling could be found in the Shariah.
According al Wahhab Khallaf, SS is tantamount to acting on maslahah, or
public interest which the Lawgiver has neither upheld nor overruled. It
means SS denotes administrations of public affairs with the aim of
realizing the interests of, and preventing harm to the community in
harmony with the general principles of Shariah even it disagrees with the
particular ruling of the mujtahidun with the only restriction that SS must
not contravene the shariah itself.
The jurist of later ages (almutaakhkhirun) however have used the term SS
in a more restricted sense, that is the administration of penalties meted
out by rulers and judges in order to combat criminality and evil. But to
confine siyasah to the administration of penalties is not totally justified,
for siyasah has much wider scope as it can equally apply in other areas of
government.
In my observation, Muslim jurists differ in their definition of SS following
their differences in the nature and area in which SS could be applied.
Some of them view it only applies in hudud, qisas and tazir cases, while
the other of the opinion that it covers all fact of life and some others hold
that it refers to the action and decision made by the ruler in administering
matters of peoples life and interest. From the above definitions it is clear
that the fuqaha of all mazhab had unanimously agree on the concept of
SS even though they named and applied it differently.
Part II
In this part, the author states about the legal authority of SS which can be
found in surah al-Nisa : 58. Obedience to the ulu al amr is a duty of the
Muslims, but the ulu al amr themselves must obedient to God and His
Messenger.
The author also mention about the suitability of Islamic law and its siasah
to the interest of people. Siasah in its widest sense has five purposes: theSiasah in its widest sense has five purposes: the
-
7/28/2019 Article Review - Siyasah Syariah
3/8
protection of faith, life, intellect, lineage and property. The protection ofprotection of faith, life, intellect, lineage and property. The protection of
these values constitutes the ultimate objective of the Shariah itself.these values constitutes the ultimate objective of the Shariah itself.
Based on SS, the ulu al-amr must have powers to uphold and protect theBased on SS, the ulu al-amr must have powers to uphold and protect the
values and objectives of the Shariah and be able to order punishment forvalues and objectives of the Shariah and be able to order punishment for
conduct that violates the sanctity of these values. Some jurists haveconduct that violates the sanctity of these values. Some jurists have
added to these five values a sixth, namely the elimination of corruption.added to these five values a sixth, namely the elimination of corruption.
Part III
In this part, the author discusses about the types of SS. Ibn Qayyim
divides siasah into two types: unjust siasah (siasah zalimah) which the
Shariah forbids, and just siasah (siasah adilah), which seeks to serve the
cause of justice. The Prophet has occasionally ordered flogging or doubled
the amount of compensation in mitigated cases of theft, and gave orders
to smash the container in which wine was found.
Ibn Qayyim maintains that whoever sets free the accused, after his
taking an oath (as to his innocence), stating that there should be no
punishment without the testimony of just witness, even though he has a
reputation for corruption and robberies, verily acts contrary to SS.
A just siasah requires that the judge does not set dangerous criminals free
merely due to an insufficient of evidence, but should detain them until the
truth emerges. It would be patently tyrannical, on the other hand, to
exercise the same degree of severity on every accused person, especially
first-time offenders who have no criminal record.
Part IV
In this part, the author discussed about ciri-ciri/requirement yang perlu
ada pada mereka yang boleh dilantik sebagai pemimpin atau ulu al amr.
According Ibn Taimiyah, the requirement of a just siyasah, with regard to
the selection and appointment of officials have been laid down in surah al-
Nisa :58. It is a trust that is fulfilled only when the selection is based on
ability and competence. It is also the fact that refers to amanat in theplural indicates that all forms of trusts, the responsibility of public office,
-
7/28/2019 Article Review - Siyasah Syariah
4/8
abiding by ones promises and contracts, responsibility to give a sincere
counsel, and ones duties towards others are all within the gambit of
amanat.
The Quran also singles out two qualities namely strength and loyalty.
Firstly, strength in every wilayah (delegation of power) is to be sought in
the best of its relevant qualities. Secondly, loyalty which is refers to fear
of Allah, refusal to neglect His commands for a small price, and lack of
fear of men.
The detailed terms of this trust are spelled out in the Shariah with special
emphasis on justice, consultation in public affairs, fulfilment of rights and
obligations, and protection of the five values of life, faith, intellect, lineage
and property. The head of the state, according to the Islamic theory of
government is only one among the entire community of equals and he
rules by virtue of the trust that the community has reposed in him.
No candidate for a public office must be given priority over others merely
because he has requested it or because he is eager to obtain it. On the
contrary, self-canvassing is prohibited in Islam. The prophet is reported to
have discouraged one of his companions, Abd Rahman b Samurah who
made such a request. But at present, anyone possessing local influence,
enjoying well-deserved and unsolicited esteem would have a genuine
chance of success. The hadith above also constitute temporary legislation,
which was appropriate at the time but which may not be suitable under
modern conditions. It would be unfair to the general public to confine the
range of selection only to those whom the authorities happen to know. It
is thus concluded that the open method of seeking voluntary applications
from potential candidates is more suitable to modern conditions.
Government is a trust in Islam and the state exercises its powers in the
capacity of a trustee, of God and the community, in order to protect the
faith and regulate the affairs of the community. God Most High has
designated man as His vicegerent (khalifah) and entrusted him with theamanah to rule according to His will as is expounded in the Shariah.
-
7/28/2019 Article Review - Siyasah Syariah
5/8
The Quran and Sunnah do not provide specific procedures as to how the
leader should be deposed nor have the Muslim jurists and political
commentators reached a consensus over a workable procedure fordeposing the head of state. But a formula may be approved and specified
by the community itself, through consultation, and in conformity with the
nature ofamanah and considerations of public interest (maslahah).
Part V
In this part, the author discussed about hadd penalties which he states
that Islam simultaneously warns the Muslims against showing eagerness
in the enforcement of hudud. The prophet also has urged the judge to
drop the hadd penalties if there are any doubts in hudud cases and
replace the punishment into tazir. It means tazir is applicable to
violations for which the Shariah has not specified a punishment, or that a
punishment has been assigned but the conditions for its enforcement
remain unfulfilled.
The author also mention that there is no minimum for tazir and it may
consist of any measure that inflicts suffering, be it a verbal reprimand or
measures that entail social degradation, financial loss, imprisonment etc.
But the ulama have differed the maximum limits of tazir. There are two
views; firstly tazir must not reach the lowest penalty in the range of
hudud. Secondly, in ascertaining the maximum limit of tazir, one must
refer to the type of offense in the hudud categories. For example, tazir for
theft of unprotected property must not reach the hadd for theft even if it
exceeds another had. But some jurist said that tazir may amount to the
death penalty.
In my opinion, semua hukuman yang selain hudud dan qisas adalah
dibawah kategori tazir and there is no minimum and maximum of tazir
punishment. Contohnya semua hukuman di bawah Akta kesalahan
jenayah syariah di Malaysia adalah dibawah kategori tazir.
-
7/28/2019 Article Review - Siyasah Syariah
6/8
The type and severity of punishment of tazir are to be determined with
reference to the nature of the offense, the pain it has inflicted on the
victim, and its implications for the community.
In this part, the author also mentions that most of the references to
punishment and just retaliation in the Quran are accompanied by an
allusion to the virtues of tolerance and forgiveness. It also is a better ways
to educate its people, promote moral virtues, and reform the wrongdoer.
According Ibn Qayyim and Mahmud Shaltut, the Quran lays on the virtues
of sincere repentance (tawbah) in granting pardon to offenders and the
most significant element in the prospects of educating and reforming the
offender.
In my opinion, for several cases only. Untuk kes yang melibatkan jenayah
x boleh pakai tolerance and forgiveness.
Part VI
In this part, the author mention about the important of Siyasah Syariyyah,
the spirit and misconception about Ijtihad. The purpose of Siyasah
Syariyah is to opening the doors of mercy and beneficence to the people,
and selecting from the diversity of schools and interpretations advanced
by the ulama that which is beneficial to relieve people from severity and
hardship.
Legislation in Islamic countries must reflect the true spirit of ijtihad which
is essentially aims at constructing new legal rules from the existing
principles through the exercise of independent reasoning often involving a
reinterpretation of the original sources. The Ijtihad also permitted only
when no definite ruling can be found in the original sources on a particular
problem.
-
7/28/2019 Article Review - Siyasah Syariah
7/8
There are commonly recurrent misconceptions about Ijtihad as follows:-
1. Closure of the gate of Ijtihad. Even if it is accepted as a historical fact, it
was conceptually erroneous and totally anomalous to the original
teachings of Islam.
2. A certain finality which is ascribed to the Fatwa and Ijtihad of the
Muftahidun of the past which is ignores the rule that Fatwa and Ijtihad are
changeable with the change of circumstances.
3. Ijtihad is reflected in the contention that modern legislation in Islamic
countries, even if enacted in consideration of public interest, is anomalous
and disagreeable with ijtihad.
According to al Tamawis views, Ijtihad by individuals in the manner
practiced by the fuqaha of the past is no longer suitable to modern
conditions. For example,
The author juga telah mengaitkan SS dan sadd al-dharai iaitu nikah tahlil.
Selain itu, kita juga boleh mengaitkan penggunaan SS dengan Islamic
jurisprudence yang lain seperti maslahah, istihsan dan sebagainya.
Contoh :....
According to Khallaf and Taj, SS is changeable in accordance with
changing circumstances and accommodate the needs of social change
with the syariah.
PART VII
Siyasah shariyah is an instrument of the trust that Allah (SWT) has placed
on the shoulders of the community and their leaders. In the field of policy-
making, the Shariah provides general guidelines for a just policy and
leaves the day-to-day formulation and implementation of such a policy to
the discretion of the ulu al amr.
-
7/28/2019 Article Review - Siyasah Syariah
8/8
The word Amanah....
According to Mahmud al Aqqad who discusses what the classical
commentators have to say and then concludes that amanah in this verse
refers to the heavy burden of responsibility (taklif) man has undertaken.
Man is capable of bearing the trust, but he must at all times discipline his
inclination toward injustice.
Ibn Taymiyah comments that both the ruler and the ruled have both been
enjoined in this ayah to pay their dues to one another. The citizens must
not expect from the government more than what they deserve, nor must
they withhold any payment to which the government may be entitled. For
example,
Conclusion
top related