1 a roadmap to carbon neutrality & solutions for the acupcc webinar october 30, 2008

1

A Roadmap to Carbon Neutrality & Solutions for the ACUPCC

WebinarOctober 30, 2008

Today’s Speakers

• Ms. Bridgette Anderson, Associate Dean of Administration, Dutchess Community College

• Mr. Evan Evans, Senior Vice President of Consulting, Econergy

• Ms. Margaret McIntire, Higher Education Account Executive, Johnson Controls, Inc.

Today’s Agenda

• Brief overview of each organization

• Overview of ACUPCC

• Johnson Controls and Econergy’s solutions for carbon neutrality

• Dutchess Community College, an early adopter of energy efficiency and committed to carbon neutrality

• GHG inventory results for Dutchess Community College

• Q & A

About Us

Congratulations!

• FOR JOINING YOUR PEERS IN THE FIGHT AGAINST GLOBAL WARMING

• FOR COMMITTING TO AN AGGRESSIVE GOAL TO ELIMINATE GREENHOUSE GAS (GHG) EMISSIONS AT YOUR UNIVERSITY

• FOR TAKING AN EARLY LEADERSHIP POSITION IN ADDRESSING CLIMATE CHANGE

The ACUPCC Commitment & Timeline

WITHIN 2 MONTHS WITHIN 1 YEAR WITHIN 2 YEARS ONGOING

ESTABLISH INSTITUTIONAL STRUCTURE

SELECT 2 OF 7 ACTIONS

INITIATE THE 2 SELECTED ACTIONS

COMPLETE GHG INVENTORY UPDATE GHG INVENTORY EVERY YEAR

DEVELOP CLIMATE ACTION PLAN & SET TARGET DATE TO REACH CARBON NEUTRALITY EXECUTE THE PLAN

MAKE PROGRESS PUBLICLY AVAILABLE

WHAT’S REALLY NEEDED?• Have you developed a campus-wide carbon

footprint? Are you satisfied with it?

• Inventory of current GHG Emissions & forecast into the future

• An Inventory Management Plan (IMP) and tools that allow for updating, tracking and auditing

HOW CAN JOHNSON CONTROLS &ECONERGY HELP?

• Econergy has developed GHG inventories for ~100 major corporations, institutions, and governments worldwide

• Econergy selected by US EPA to provide GHG inventory support for prestigious US EPA Climate Leaders program

• Johnson Controls engaged Econergy to develop its own global GHG inventory

A Roadmap to Carbon Neutrality: First Steps

• Establish GHG Inventory• Establish GHG Inventory

• Develop Climate Action Plan• Set Target Date for Neutrality

• Execute a Climate Action Plan• Initiate 2 of 7 Actions

• Provide ongoing GHG updates and tracking

A Roadmap to Carbon Neutrality: Creating a Strategy

WHAT’S REALLY NEEDED?• Capability to identify, analyze and prioritize

emission mitigation strategies Prioritization based on GHG reduction

potential, technical feasibility and cost

• Expertise to translate strategies into an integrated Climate Action Plan comprising a least-cost set of execution steps

• Our “wedge” approach offers a uniquely prioritized path to carbon neutrality

• The wedges are customized to your situation

• We bring 14 years of experience as a pioneer of the carbon management specialty

HOW CAN JOHNSON CONTROLS & ECONERGY HELP?

• Establish GHG Inventory • Develop Climate Action Plan• Set Target Date for Neutrality

• Develop Climate Action Plan• Set Target Date for Neutrality

• Provide ongoing GHG updates and tracking

• Execute Climate Action Plan• Initiate 2 of 7 Actions

A Roadmap to Carbon Neutrality: Putting it Together

WHAT’S REALLY NEEDED?• Capability to turn a customized strategy into programmatic actions in an integrated way

• Ability to access funding and other resources to make the plan a reality

• Specialized experience to select the most cost-efficient and effective 2 actions to implement immediately

• Ability to develop a comprehensive public relations and communications program aimed at the university community and beyond

HOW CAN JOHNSON CONTROLS & ECONERGY HELP? • Over 9 million tons of carbon emissions avoided through energy efficiency programs

• Over $4 Billion of total energy savings guarantees

• Comprehensive Climate Action Plans designed for dozens of clients

• On target to generate one billion gross kWh/year of renewable energy across the globe by 2009

• Programs and tools designed and tested over time that engage the broader academic community in energy efficiency and carbon management initiatives

• Establish GHG Inventory• Develop Climate Action Plan• Set Target Date for Neutrality

• Execute Climate Action Plan

• Initiate 2 of 7 Actions

• Execute Climate Action Plan

• Initiate 2 of 7 Actions

• Provide ongoing GHG updates and tracking

Includes:

• Carbon Footprint• Inventory

Management Plan• Preliminary Carbon

Mitigation Strategy (Wedge 1.0)

• Energy Efficiency Opportunity Assessment

• Recommendationof 2 of 7 ACUPCC early-action steps

An Approach to Working Together

Includes:

• Measure and manage energy and GHG data continuously

• Updating GHG inventory annually

• Updating Climate Action Plan

• Providing ongoing performance assurance services on energy efficiency projects

• Establish GHG Inventory• Develop Climate Action Plan• Set Target Date for Neutrality

• Execute Climate Action Plan• Initiate 2 of 7 Actions

Includes:

• Detailed Carbon Mitigation Strategy (Wedge 2.0; builds on Wedge 1.0)

• Comprehensive Climate Action Plan (Based on Wedge 2.0)

• Target date for climate neutrality

• Energy ProgramProject Development Agreement(authorizing detailed engineering, capex requirements, and conditional approval to execute)

Carbon Action & Energy Efficiency Program Planning

Preliminary Carbon Neutrality Assessment

Includes:

• Finalize Climate Action Plan

• Support in initiating 2 of 7 early-action steps

• Implementing approved energy efficiency program

• Implementing other approved carbon mitigation strategies (e.g. renewable energy technologies, others)

Carbon ProgramExecution

Ongoing Carbon Management Services

• Provide ongoing GHG updates and tracking

John

son

Cont

rols

& E

cone

rgy

Serv

ices

• Public Relations & Communications Planning and Execution

Dutchess Community College…Early Adopter of Energy Efficiency

BACKGROUND• Located in Poughkeepsie, NY

• An ACUPCC signatory

• Recognized as a leader in energy efficiency and sustainability

• Recipient of EPA 2003 Leadership in Energy Award by Secretary of Energy

• Completed two highly successful performance contracts which improved infrastructure and reduced energy use

Dutchess Community College…Early Adopter of Energy Efficiency

Performance Contract Phase 1• Implemented campus wide energy management

• Replaced chillers

• Reduced campus summer peak electric load by 50%

• Exceeded guaranteed energy savings by 26% in year 1

Performance Contract Phase 2• Implemented geothermal renewable energy system for heating and cooling

• Yields 37% savings compared to a conventional system

Dutchess Community College…Continuing Investment in Energy Efficiency

Current Performance Contract - Phase 3• Lighting upgrade for 6 buildings, estimated annual savings of $38,000

• Building envelope improvements for 9 buildings, estimated annual savings of $18,000

• Boiler improvements in 4 buildings, estimated annual savings of $26,500

• Water conservation measures in 5 buildings, estimated annual savings of $5,700

• Energy efficient window film in 6 buildings, estimated annual savings of $19,500

• Building controls improvements in 5 buildings, estimated annual savings of $17,500

• Lab hood retrofit in 1 building, estimated annual savings of $51,600

• Glycol loop heat recovery in 1 building, estimated annual savings of $31,000

• Campus wide computer power management, estimated annual savings of $14,500

• Other improvements with estimated annual savings of $23,300

Dutchess Community College…Continuing Investment in Energy Efficiency

Current Performance Contract - Phase 3 Financial Snapshot

• Project cost of $3,170,000

• Avg. annual energy savings of $276,600

• Simple payback of 11 years

• Annual O&M savings of $29,500

• Finance term of 15 years

• Net positive cash flow after installation is paid for of $164,500

Current Performance Contract - Phase 3 NYSERDA Grants

• New Energy Smart Loan Fund (PON 941) – estimated $175,000

• Technical Study (PON 1045) – estimated $20,000

• Commercial and Industrial Performance Program (PON 984) – estimated $25,000

Dutchess Community College…On the Road to Carbon Neutrality

ACUPCC Greenhouse Gas (GHG) Inventory Not Including Commuting

• Direct

• Stationary combustion

• Mobile combustion

• Process emissions

• Indirect

• Purchased electricity

• Scope 3

• Business travel

• Commuting

Dutchess Community College…On the Road to Carbon Neutrality

Comparing GHG Footprints With and Without Commuting

Dutchess Community College…On the Road to Carbon Neutrality

Building Energy Use vs. Emissions

Dutchess Community College…On the Road to Carbon Neutrality

Investments in Energy Efficiency Reducing Emissions

Dutchess Community College…On the Road to Carbon Neutrality

Business-As-Usual

Dutchess Community College…On the Road to Carbon Neutrality

Hypothetical Carbon Mitigation Strategies

Thank You for Attending!

QUESTIONS?

Contact Information• Ms. Bridgette Anderson, Associate Dean of Administration, Dutchess Community College –

banderso@sunydutchess.edu

• Mr. Evan Evans, Senior Vice President of Consulting, Econergy – evans@econergy.com

• Ms. Margaret McIntire, Higher Education Account Executive, Johnson Controls, Inc. – margaret.e.mcintire@jci.com