american express strategy and policy
DESCRIPTION
TRANSCRIPT
Exploring a Renewed Strategy for 2010 and Beyond
GSB Consulting Group proudly presents:
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group
Prepared for
The Board of Directors Policy and Strategy Review Committee
1
GSB Consulting Group• Andrew Whyte
• Chad Abougoush
• Curtis M. Goodman
• Dennis Laird
• Jason Campbell
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group 2
Where (#) exists in presentation, see accompanying ‘Reference Document’ for relevant sources12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group 3
Presentation Index 1. Executive Summary2. Operating Environment
• American Economy• Company Mission, Business Approach• Credit Services Market-Share • Top Global Issuers of Credit Cards• Environmental Conclusions
3. Strategic Position• Competitive Analysis• Closed Loop vs. Multi-Issuer Model• Industry Orientations• Partnerships and Enhanced Business Services• Strategic Alliances• Technological Innovator
4. Financial Position• Metric Performance• Business Risks • Cash Position• Bank-Holding Company
5. Current Issues & Opportunities• Management Changes• Governance Relationships• Industry Practices • Impending Government Regulations
6. Moving Forward• Short Term Strategy Options• Long Term Strategy Options• Final Recommendations
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group 4
Definitions• Charge card
– A card that charges no interest, but that requires you to pay your bill in full each month.– Usually: higher limits, corporate, high net-worth individuals
• Example: American Express, Discover
• Credit Card– A credit card is a card whose holder has been granted a revolving credit line. The card enables the holder to make
purchases and/or cash advances up to a pre-arranged limit– Continuous balance that is charged interest
• Example: Visa, MasterCard
• Delinquency:– Nonpayment of a debt when due
• Revolver– A profitable client - someone who does not pay off their account balance each month
• Deadbeat– The least profitable client – someone who always pays off balance in full each month
• Interchange Fee– A fee paid by the acquiring bank/merchant bank to the issuing bank. The fee compensates the issuer for the time after
settlement with the acquiring bank/merchant bank and before it recoups the settlement value from the cardholder.
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group 5
• Forward-swaps:– A swap agreement created through the synthesis of two swaps differing in duration for the purpose
of fulfilling the specific time-frame needs of an investor. – Also referred to as a "forward start swap," "delayed start swap," and a "deferred start swap."
• Interest rate swaps:– Is a derivative in which one party exchanges a stream of interest payments for another party's
stream of cash flows. – Used by hedgers to manage their fixed or floating assets and liabilities.
• Securitization:– The process through which an issuer creates a financial instrument by combining other financial
assets and then marketing different tiers of the repackaged instruments to investors. The process can encompass any type of financial asset and promotes liquidity in the marketplace.
• TTM :– Represents “trailing twelve months” of data
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group
Definitions
6
# Findings Implications Implementation Importance Timeline
1
Current state of American economy is worrisome. Unemployment at very high levels; consumer spending is down over last year. In addition both public and private debt loads are continuously growing and reaching unsustainable levels. Current economic decline increases risk of credit defaults, especially among lower socio-economic status. Also has a direct negative impact on AMEX’s profitability.
Dramatic cuts to government spending trend is required to rein-in public debt loads and budget deficit.Personal spending is expected to continually decrease as consumers are forced to save more to lower household debt levels.
Maintain current course: •target high net worth clients, •increase cash position, Avoid clients of lower socio-economic status to avoid loan defaults.
American economic growth will not parallel historic levels, especially compared to developing nations (China, India).Japan is perfect case study of similar situation – still have not rebounded from 1990 levels, sustained low-level of economic growth
Expected to stay in recessionary state for next year.
2
American Express comprises 20% of credit service market in the USA. AMEX utilizes a spend-centric model, charging 2.56% on total transaction value. The American market is oversaturated and mature with little growth potential. American Express does 70% of its total credit services business in the USA which represents an over-reliance on one single market.
Profits are directly correlated to the health of the American economy (as indicated by spending).
AMEX should increase global presence to benefit from new market growth opportunities.AMEX should also maintain current American market presence and expand where possible.
Current business model cannot be maintained while still expecting continual growth.
Expansion should be continuous since benefits will be manifested in the long-term (10 years)
3
AMEX utilizes a closed-loop business model. AMEX card members spend 2-4 times more per transaction than with competitors cards; this suggests that AMEX has great control over who their customers are. AMEX target market is high net-worth individuals and corporate accounts. Revenues (49%) are derived from a 2.56% charge of total card transaction value. Under this model profits are directly correlated to the health of the economy and amount of consumer spending.
Although the AMEX business model offers greater profitability than competitors, the current business model cannot be maintained while still expecting continual growth.
AMEX should maintain the current single-issuer, spend-centric business model for the domestic American market. Because it allow for more control over business and the past positive revenue effect.Currently AMEX is expanding to incorporate the multi-issuer model to accommodate growth in foreign markets. This is necessary to gain new market-share.
The single-issuer model allows complete control in transaction value chain. Countries, like China, require local partnerships as a means of gaining access to their markets. Adopting the multi-issuer model makes expansion strategies feasible. Adopting the multi-issuer model will provide long-term future growth-prospects in key developing markets
To expand into multi-issuer model should be done incrementally and based on local market conditions Expansion should be continuous since benefits will be manifested in the long-term (10 years)
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group 7
# Findings Implication Implementation Importance Timeline
4
Partnerships and enhanced business relationships have been instrumental in securing access across many industries that in turn expand AMEX’s reach to their target market.
Secures new markets and access to target clients. Provides benefits for business clients thereby improving customer relationships
Actively seek new strategic and exclusive partnerships (Like COSTCO)
Increases brand awareness and recognition.Establishes stable revenue sources
Continually seek new partnerships
5
AMEX credit services business-segment faces serious issues:•21% decline in fee revenues and a rise in net write-offs, •Interest rate risk exposure as a result of floating interest rates on debt.
If Interest rates begin to rise: A doubling of the corporate debt rate from their 4% to 8% could cost $3.6 billion more annually and effectively wipe-out the $2.6 billion in operating profit generated at current interest levels. This is realistic due to potential debt downgrades and the Federal Reserve potentially raising rates within the next eight yearsIf write-offs continue to rise: A 50% rise in write-off percentages would create an additional $2 billion loss for American Express. Based on current write-off trends which have doubled in the last two years, this potential rise is realistic and such an outlook is considered optimistic
AMEX must stop using interest rate swaps. Instead to reduce risk exposure allow for fixed interest rates on debt rather than floating rates.
Currently IF rating agencies downgrade debt or IF interest rates rise, then AMEX would be very impacted negatively and the company’s ability to finance operations would be in question. Stopping interest rate swaps is crucial to stabilize future profits of the company while reducing overall risk exposure.
Immediate and continuous.
6
In 2008 AMEX was granted Bank-Holding Status. This is a major strategic advantage and will provide added financial security - providing access to sources of government financing outside of securitization (including TARP and TALF).
Bank holding status opens up additional sources of capitalProvides enhanced financial security
Already implemented Strengthens the balance sheet by providing access to treasury funds and the ability to take deposits.
Now and always
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group 8
# Findings Implication Implementation Importance Timeline
7
AMEX has always been the industry leader in technological innovation. Future success in the credit-services industry will continue to be based on differentiation and maintaining a technological competitive advantage
Continue funding research and development.Being the industry leader gives competitive edge and increased brand recognition brand
Increase funding for AMEX Labs.
Retains existing customers, and provides incentive to attract new customersTechnological innovation should be based onFraud reductionIncreasing convenience Maximizing profitabilityProvides “first-mover advantage”
Continuously be THE industry leader;
8
The President’s departure marks a critical loss of human capital. May result in transfer of strategic knowledge to competitors which will undermine AMEX’s competitive advantages. Selection of next president must be carefully decided and should factor in the individual’s objective within the company.
Loss of strategic human capital to potential competitorsPromote within companyBe aware of potential company security breaches
No choice, already in motion.
Difficult to replace such a key human resource and the business connections he offers
Suitable replacement must be found by January 2010.
9
Government regulations present the biggest challenge to the future profitability of the industry. Changes to usury laws will have an impact on the bottom line. If government sets interest ceilings then revenue will be limited, especially as interest rates increase.
Regulations are intended to protect consumers; possible restrictions on interest rate limit of cards will result in a loss of net income
AMEX should boost funding for:Lobby-groups to influence key government officialsConsumer credit awareness campaign
American government regulation poses single greatest threat to profitability and longevity of credit services industry
Ongoing, monitor progress closely.
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group 9
Overview of the American EconomyPopulation 304,059,724
GDP $13,122,000,000,000
Per Capita $43,155
2009 National Debt $12,075,130,000,000
Budget Deficit $1,275,000,000,000
Median Household Income $50,740
Average Credit Card Debt $9,797.38
# of Credit Cards per Eligible Person 3.04
Unemployment Rate 10%
Small Business Loans in Moderate Delinquency Rate 4.4%
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group
See Reference #2
Executive Summary
Strategic Position
Current Issues & Opportunities
Moving Forward
10
Executive Summary
Strategic Position
Current Issues & Opportunities
Moving Forward
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group 11
Executive Summary
Strategic Position
Current Issues & Opportunities
Moving Forward
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group 12
© GSB Consulting Group
Executive Summary
Strategic Position
Current Issues & Opportunities
Moving Forward
12/8/2009 13
American Economy Conclusions
• Dramatic cuts to government spending trend is required to rein-in public debt loads and budget deficit.• Personal spending is expected to continually decrease as consumers are forced to save more to lower
household debt levels.• American economic growth will not parallel historic levels, especially compared to developing nations (China,
India). Japan is perfect case study of similar situation – still have not rebounded from 1990 levels, sustained low-level of economic growth.
Implementation:• Maintain current course:
– target high net worth clients, – increase cash position,
• Avoid clients of lower socio-economic status to avoid loan defaults.
Timeline:Expected to stay in recessionary state for at least one year.
Current state of American economy is worrisome. Unemployment at very high levels; consumer spending is down over last year. In addition both public and private debt loads are continuously growing and reaching unsustainable levels. Current economic decline increases risk of credit defaults, especially among lower socio-economic status. Also has a direct negative impact on AMEX’s profitability.
Executive Summary
Strategic Position
Current Issues & Opportunities
Moving Forward
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group 14
The mission is to be the world’s most respected service brand.
AMEX is a world leader in global payment systems network and travel company with a focus on six main businesses:1. Charge and Credit Cards2. Travel Services3. Financial Planning4. Investment Products5. Insurance6. International Banking
AMEX Mission and Business Approach
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group
(3 & 4)
Executive Summary
Strategic Position
Current Issues & Opportunities
Moving Forward
15
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group
Publicly traded on the NYSE: AXP2008 Approx. 1 Year Growth
Sales $31,920,000,000 1.1%Net Income $2,699,000,000 (32.7%)# of Employees 66,000Primary Target Market Corporate cards & high net-worth individualsMain operating region United States (approx. 70% of total business)Fortune 500 Rank #74JD Power & Associates 1st in Overall Customer Satisfaction (2008)Interbrand Ranking 14th most valuable brand worldwide (2006)
See Reference #1
Executive Summary
Strategic Position
Current Issues & Opportunities
Moving Forward
Overview of American Express
16
Credit Services Market-share
Credit Services Industry is an oligopoly where Visa and MasterCard dominate the USA credit services market – holding 75% market-share.
(Each company utilizes different card-issuer models, will be discussed further in Strategic Position) 12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group
(5)
Executive Summary
Strategic Position
Current Issues & Opportunities
Moving Forward
17
Top Global Issuers of Credit Cards
American banks dominate global credit services industry. Top three issuing banks are American and have close to $976 billion in total credit volume.
Translates to: 23% of global industry, 58% of American market 12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group
(4)
Executive Summary
Strategic Position
Current Issues & Opportunities
Moving Forward
18
Operating Environment Conclusions
Implication:• Credit service industry is an oligopoly that is
saturated which presents difficult growth conditions further amplified by current economy.
Three American banks account for 23% of the global credit services industry and 58% of total American market. These banks operate primarily under the banners: Visa and MasterCard. American Express only comprises 20% of credit service market in the USA. The American market is oversaturated and mature with little growth potential. American Express does 70% of its total credit services business in the USA which represents an over-reliance on one single market.
Executive Summary
Strategic Position
Current Issues & Opportunities
Moving Forward
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group 19
Competitive Analysis
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group
49% of AMEX revenue is derived from a 2.56% charge on total transaction value; average card member spends 2-4 times more per transaction than on competitors cards
(12)
Executive Summary
Strategic Position
Current Issues & Opportunities
Moving Forward
Executive Summary
Strategic Position
Current Issues & Opportunities
Moving Forward
Executive Summary
Current Issues & Opportunities
Moving Forward
20
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group
(3)
Executive Summary
Operating Environment
Current Issues & Opportunities
Moving Forward
AMEX mainly utilizes the closed-looped model • Beneficial because:
• allows ownership and control of the entire value chain • AMEX charges 2.56%
• Provides 4-8 times more merchant fee-based revenues than competitors (Visa or MasterCard)
• provides great flexibility:– Issues and services own cards– Control entire pricing and fee structures – Does not rely on merchant acquirers or
financial institutions as intermediaries
• Disadvantageous because:• Reduced potential customer pools• Greater risk exposure• Requires independent merchant
infrastructure• Not accepted universally
Closed-looped Model
21
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group
(3)
Executive Summary
Operating Environment
Current Issues & Opportunities
Moving Forward
Visa and MasterCard utilize the multi-issuer model.
• Beneficial because:• Diversifies risk exposure • Allows for penetration of foreign
markets through local partnerships and alliances
• Disadvantageous because:• Increased exposure results in
dependency on partnerships and intermediaries
• Reduces profit potential• Visa only makes $0.15 per $100
transaction
Multi-issuer Model
22
Business Model Conclusion
Implication:• Although the AMEX business model offers greater profitability than competitors, the current business model cannot be maintained while
still expecting continual growth.
Implementation:• AMEX should maintain the current single-issuer, spend-centric business model for the domestic American market. – Because it allow for more control over business and the past positive revenue effect• Currently AMEX is expanding to incorporate the multi-issuer model to accommodate growth in foreign markets. – This is necessary to gain market-share.
Importance:• The single-issuer model allows complete control in transaction value chain • Countries, like China, require local partnerships as a means of gaining access to their markets. Adopting the multi-issuer model makes
expansion strategies feasible. Adopting the multi-issuer model will provide long-term future growth-prospects in key developing markets
Timeline:• To expand into multi-issuer model should be done incrementally and based on local market conditions• Expansion should be continuous since benefits will be manifested in the long-term (10 years)
AMEX utilizes a closed-loop business model. AMEX card members spend 2-4 times more per transaction than with competitors cards; this suggests that AMEX has great control over who their customers are. AMEX target market is high net-worth individuals and corporate accounts. Revenues (49%) are derived from a 2.56% charge of total card transaction value. Under this model profits are directly correlated to the health of the economy and amount of consumer spending.
Executive Summary
Operating Environment
Current Issues & Opportunities
Moving Forward
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group 23
AMEX seeks to create strategic business alliances across numerous industries, with a key focus on:
TYPE # of Relationships or Example
Business-2-Business 925,000 +E-commerce and Mail-Order Revolution Money
Government California
HealthcareMajor Retailers COSTCO
Restaurants McDonald’s
Travel Delta Airlines
Entertainment TicketMaster
Industry Orientations & Partnerships
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group
(8)
Executive Summary
Operating Environment
Current Issues & Opportunities
Moving Forward
24
Enhanced Business ServicesAMEX offers numerous solutions for different industries:
1. Assistance to improve business efficiency– Industry trend analysis– ‘Best practices’ approach – comparison with other competitors
2. Online merchant services– Cash flow management– Expense management– Faster dispute resolution
3. Revenue enhancement opportunities– Placement on specialized feature websites – which provides extended network reach– Special offerings for businesses
» Statement-based coupons» Targeted advertisements
4. Reward and recognition programs for employees– Improves productivity and retention
5. Recently added consulting division – Will analyze spending trends from 127countries, 90 million cards
AMEX provides a variety of benefits for the business consumers in which they serve – these are intended to increase efficiencies and profitability
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group
(9)
Executive Summary
Operating Environment
Current Issues & Opportunities
Moving Forward
25
Partnerships & Alliances Conclusion
• Secures new markets and access to target clients. • Provides benefits for business clients thereby improving customer relationships
Implementation:• Actively seek new strategic and exclusive partnerships
– Like COSTCO
Importance:• Increases brand awareness and recognition.• Establishes stable revenue sources
Timeline:• Continually seek new partnerships
Partnerships and enhanced business relationships have been instrumental in securing access across many industries that in turn expand AMEX’s reach to their target market.
Executive Summary
Operating Environment
Current Issues & Opportunities
Moving Forward
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group 26
Innovator in Technology• Originally the credit service industry was entirely paper-based
– Paper-trail limited industry profitability – Reduced speed of transactions
• Technological advances were required to meet need of:– Credit card fraud– Identity theft– Fast and convenient account management– Data collection to analyze customer spending and risk
• AMEX was the industry leader, technological advances enhanced consumer experience while improving the overall profitability. AMEX was the first to introduce:– Plastic card– ‘Superphone’ authorization process– Magnetic strip on card– Premium card
• Buyer’s Assurance and rewards programs– Express-Net - online management tools to track spending– Embedded Chip and PIN – Photograph on card
• Technology in credit services industry are strongly and positively correlated to profitability and risk reduction
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group
Executive Summary
Operating Environment
Current Issues & Opportunities
Moving Forward
27
Continuous Technological Advancement 1. American Express Labs
– Mobile-phone applications – merges loyalty programs with your account– Widget development – virtual travel agents – Integration with social networking sites
• Leverages geographic information from your social network to provide travel information and deals
2. Efficiency and Service– Card holder can set personal alerts– American Express will notify customer with email or text message alerts if there has been
suspected fraudulent activity
3. Fraud Protection– American Express was first issuer of the Smart Card in 1999
• Smart card provides enhanced online security, loyalty applications, and secure point-of-sale payments for their customers• The smart card also offers no annual fee, a low fixed interest rate, and a fee free rewards program• Receive input that is processed on embedded integrated circuits, which in turn the card provides an output
4. Customers Tracking– AMEX to use RFID readers called "consumer trackers" designed to closely watch people’s movement in
stores. Potential problems associated with collecting and transmitting time and location information regarding the path traversed by consumer within the merchant's facility.
(29, 30)12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group
Executive Summary
Operating Environment
Current Issues & Opportunities
Moving Forward
28
Techno-domination Conclusions
Implication:– Continue funding research and development.– Being the industry leader gives competitive edge and increased brand
recognition brand Importance:
– Retains existing customers, and provides incentive to attract new customers– Technological innovation should be based on
• Fraud reduction• Increasing convenience • Maximizing profitability
Timeline:– Continuously be THE industry leader; provides “first-mover advantage”
AMEX has always been the industry leader in technological innovation. Future success in the credit-services industry will continue to be based on differentiation and maintaining a technological competitive advantage. Therefore, should increase funding for AMEX Labs.
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group 29
Executive Summary
Operating Environment
Current Issues & Opportunities
Moving Forward
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group(18)
Executive Summary
Operating Environment
Strategic Position
Current Issues & Opportunities
Moving Forward
3Q’09 3Q’08 % Increase (Dec) FX Adj.
Billed Business ($B) $156.6 175.5 (11%) (9%)
Total Cards in Force (MM) 88.4 92.1 (4%)
Avg. Basic Card member Spending $2,898 $3049 (5%) (3%)
Card member Loans ($B)- Owned $31.5 $45.7 (31%) (30%)- Managed $60.7 $75.5 (20%) (19%)
WW Travel Sales ($B) $4.4 $6.2 (29%) (27%)
Metric Performance
30
All metric indicators suggest a depression in the credit services business segment of American Express. This is most likely due to overall economic recession.
• Recently, net write-offs have more than doubled. This requires higher loss reserves and hurts the overall financial position of the company– In 2007 write-offs were 4%, now up to 9% in Q3’09– Loans are written off after 180-days of delinquency – AMEX Response: early this year AMEX provide $400 to high risk clients to close accounts
• Average spending on cards has been declining– Between 2008 and Q3’09 there has been a 21% decrease in fee revenues
• Return on assets steadily declining through 2009– Q3’08 ROA = 2.8%– Q3’09 ROA = 1.4%
• As ROA decreases AMEX becomes less appealing to potential investors who seek consistent growth from the company
• Return on equity (TTM) is 10.7% – Compared to five year average of 26%
• ROE can be very high, but is subject to significant volatility due to leverage nature of the company
Overall financials of the company is trending towards being negative with higher net write-offs, declining revenue, and lowered return on assets and equity.
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group
Business Risks
(19, 20, 21)
Executive Summary
Operating Environment
Strategic Position
Current Issues & Opportunities
Moving Forward
31
Cash Risks • Potential cash outflow as a result of securitization is $10 billion
• Derivatives have switched long-term debt from fixed to floating interest rates – Has been beneficial in the
past but in today's economic environment could be a massive liability
• $54 billion in long term debt coming to maturity over the next 8 years– In current environment with
higher interest rate potential this could significantly increase the cost of capital and interest expense incurred by the company
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group
(25, 26)
Executive Summary
Operating Environment
Strategic Position
Current Issues & Opportunities
Moving Forward
32
• AMEX has various foreign exchange derivatives to hedge currency exposure for near term (around one year)– Could require additional cash to maintain positions but most are forward-
swaps so no outlay required till maturity
• Interest rate swaps:– Allowed hedging of short term cash flows, approximately $2.4 billion, from
floating to fixed rate debt– Interest rate swaps have also allowed AMEX to convert over $15.1 billion in
long term debt from fixed to floating rates. AMEX continues to use these swaps as debts get rolled over:• Has allowed AMEX to historically have 20% lower interest expense on debt• Floating rate increases risk associated with interest rate exposure and financial risk to
the company if interest rates begin to rise significantly
These contracts do not create any potentially immediate large demand for cash, however the interest rate swaps do create future risk exposure due to significant interest rate fluctuations.
Derivatives risks
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group(24)
Executive Summary
Operating Environment
Strategic Position
Current Issues & Opportunities
Moving Forward
33
Credit Agency Entity rated Short-term ratings
Long-term ratings Outlook
DBRS All rated entities R-1 (middle) A(high) Negative
Fitch All rated entities F1 A+ Negative
Moody’s •TRS & other subsidiaries•AMEX
Prime-1Prime-2
A2A3
StableNegative
S&P All rated entities A-2 BBB+ Negative
“Downgrades to the companies debt or its main subsidiaries could result in higher interest rates on unsecured debt and asset securitization also higher fees related to
borrowing and reduce the borrowing capacity of the firm.”
Most rating agency’s outlook suggests a downgrade is likely.
AMEX relies heavily on both debt and securitization to maintain its business. If rating agencies downgrade AMEX it would be very negative to the companies ability to finance operations.
Debt-related risks
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group(27)
Executive Summary
Operating Environment
Strategic Position
Current Issues & Opportunities
Moving Forward
34
Risky Business Conclusions
Implications:• If Interest rates begin to rise:
– A doubling of the corporate debt rate from their 4% to 8% could cost $3.6 billion more annually and effectively wipe-out the $2.6 billion in operating profit generated at current interest levels
– This is realistic due to potential debt downgrades and the Federal Reserve potentially raising rates within the next eight years
• If write-offs continue to rise:– A 50% rise in write-off percentages would create an additional $2 billion loss for American Express– Based on current write-off trends which have doubled in the last two years, this potential rise is realistic and such an
outlook is considered optimisticImportance:• Currently IF rating agencies downgrade debt or IF interest rates rise, then AMEX would be very impacted
negatively and the company’s ability to finance operations would be in question.• Stopping interest rate swaps is crucial to stabilize future profits of the company while reducing overall risk
exposure.Timing:• Immediate and continuous.
AMEX credit services business-segment faces serious issues:•21% decline in fee revenues and a rise in net write-offs,•Interest rate risk exposure as a result of floating interest rates on debt.These issues must be addressed immediately – AMEX must stop using interest rate swaps. Instead to reduce risk exposure allow for fixed interest rates on debt rather than floating rates.
Executive Summary
Operating Environment
Strategic Position
Current Issues & Opportunities
Moving Forward
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group 35
• October ‘09 billed business = $58 billion• Since 2007, the cash position has increased approximately 131%
to $20.5 billion in 3Q2008. – Raised $6 billion in Certified Deposit Program and $7 billion in FDIC
insured savings programs– Strategically necessary to help withstand the financial crisis in 2008
• As of September 30, 2009 AMEX has US$18.65 billion in cash and equivalents up from $15.9 billion a year prior. – Cash decrease due to buy-back of $3.39 billion in government preferred
shares in summer 2009
• Bank-holding company status is largely responsible for improvements in overall cash position.
Cash Position
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group(22 & 23)
Executive Summary
Operating Environment
Strategic Position
Current Issues & Opportunities
Moving Forward
36
Bank-Holding Company
Implications:• Bank holding status opens up additional sources of capital• Provides enhanced financial securityImportance:• Strengthens the balance sheet by providing access to treasury
funds and the ability to take depositsTiming:• Now and always
In 2008 AMEX was granted Bank-Holding Status. This is a major strategic advantage and will provide added financial security - providing access to sources of government financing outside of securitization (including TARP and TALF).
Executive Summary
Operating Environment
Strategic Position
Current Issues & Opportunities
Moving Forward
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group 37
Management Changes
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group
(16)
Executive Summary
Operating Environment
Strategic Position
Moving Forward
• Alfred Kelly Jr. is leaving the company in the beginning of 2010.
• His departure is a result of the inability to move up the corporate ladder into the position of CEO.
• Loss of the top president represents a significant loss of strategic human capital.
• In the past, AMEX senior management have been carefully selective of high performing individuals. Traditionally they have been promoted from within the company to maintain take full advantage of the already developed human capital.
Since 1987 he has led key business groups including:
• Consumer Card Services Group• OPEN from American Express• Consumer Travel• Global Travelers Cheques • Prepaid Services• Establishment Services, North
America• U.S. Customer Service,• Global Risk Management• Interactive Services Worldwide 38
Governance Relationships
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group(16)
Executive Summary
Operating Environment
Strategic Position
Moving Forward
39
Human Resources Conclusions
Implication:• Loss of strategic human capital to potential competitors• Promote within company• Be aware of potential company security breaches
Importance:• Difficult to replace such a key human resource and the business
connections he offers
Timeline:• Suitable replacement must be found by January 2010.
The President’s departure marks a critical loss of human capital. May result in transfer of strategic knowledge to competitors which will undermine AMEX’s competitive advantages. Selection of next president must be carefully decided and should factor in the individual’s objective within the company.
Executive Summary
Operating Environment
Strategic Position
Moving Forward
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group 40
Industry Practices• Certain industry practices exist through legal loopholes – has
increased profitability, however these are under threat from pending government regulation.– Contractual agreement can change with 15 days notice– Usury Laws:
• Creates maximum interest rate that is allowed to be charged, however, varies by State.• In Marquette vs. First Omaha Service Corp., the Supreme Court ruled that a national bank
could charge the highest interest rate allowed in their home state to customers living anywhere in the United States, including states with restrictive interest caps.
• Usury friendly states like Delaware have become credit services havens where .
– Universal Default:• Most credit agreements state if you are late for a payment on any credit card or credit line,
with any other company, you will be treated as delinquent for other cards. • Includes mortgage, car loan, bouncing a cheque, going over credit limit or even inquiring about
another card or loan.
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group
(8)
Executive Summary
Operating Environment
Strategic Position
Moving Forward
41
American Regulation • H.R. 627: Credit Card Accountability Responsibility and
Disclosure Act of 2009. • Requires 45 day notice for rates increases to allow consumers to shop
for better deals• Cannot apply payments automatically to lower interest debt • Elimination of “fee Harvesting” cards and fees cannot be charged to
credit card
• S.235: Credit Card Holders Bill of Right Act • Companies cannot increase rates due to behaviours unrelated to
company credit lines (threatens universal default clause)• Eliminate fees for paying off balance• Cannot Issue cards to anyone under 21 unless can show how they can
pay it off or passed financial literacy test.
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group
(9)
Executive Summary
Operating Environment
Strategic Position
Moving Forward
42
Impending Government Regulation
Implications:• Regulations are intended to protect consumers; possible restrictions on
interest rate limit of cards will result in a loss of net income• AMEX should boost funding for:
• Lobby-groups to influence key government officials• Consumer credit awareness campaign
Importance:• American government regulation poses single greatest threat to profitability
and longevity of credit services industry
Timeline:• Ongoing, monitor progress closely
Government regulations present the biggest challenge to the future profitability of the industry. Changes to usury laws will have an impact on the bottom line. If government sets interest ceilings then revenue will be limited, especially as interest rates increase.
Executive Summary
Operating Environment
Strategic Position
Moving Forward
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group 43
Short Term Strategy Options
Executive Summary
Operating Environment
Strategic Position
Financial Position
Current Issues & Opportunities
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group 44
Long Term Strategy Options
Executive Summary
Operating Environment
Strategic Position
Financial Position
Current Issues & Opportunities
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group 45
Summary of FindingsExecutive Summary
Operating Environment
Strategic Position
Financial Position
Current Issues & Opportunities
Three American banks account for 23% of the global credit services industry and 58% of total American market. These banks operate primarily under the banners: Visa and MasterCard. American Express only comprises 20% of credit service market in the USA. The American market is oversaturated and mature with little growth potential. American Express does 70% of its total credit services business in the USA which represents an over-reliance on one single market.
AMEX utilizes a closed-loop business model. AMEX card members spend 2-4 times more per transaction than with competitors cards; this suggests that AMEX has great control over who their customers are. AMEX target market is high net-worth individuals and corporate accounts. Revenues (49%) are derived from a 2.56% charge of total card transaction value. Under this model profits are directly correlated to the health of the economy and amount of consumer spending.
Current state of American economy is worrisome. Unemployment at very high levels; consumer spending is down over last year. In addition both public and private debt loads are continuously growing and reaching unsustainable levels. Current economic decline increases risk of credit defaults, especially among lower socio-economic status. Also has a direct negative impact on AMEX’s profitability.
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group 46
Summary of Findings
Executive Summary
Operating Environment
Strategic Position
Financial Position
Current Issues & Opportunities
Partnerships and enhanced business relationships have been instrumental in securing access across many industries that in turn expand AMEX’s reach to their target market.AMEX has always been the industry leader in technological innovation. Future success in the credit-services industry will continue to be based on differentiation and maintaining a technological competitive advantage. Therefore, should increase funding for AMEX Labs.
AMEX credit services business-segment faces serious issues:•21% decline in fee revenues and a rise in net write-offs,•Interest rate risk exposure as a result of floating interest rates on debt.These issues must be addressed immediately – AMEX must stop using interest rate swaps. Instead to reduce risk exposure allow for fixed interest rates on debt rather than floating rates.
In 2008 AMEX was granted Bank-Holding Status. This is a major strategic advantage and will provide added financial security - providing access to sources of government financing outside of securitization (including TARP and TALF).12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group 47
Summary of Findings
Executive Summary
Operating Environment
Strategic Position
Financial Position
Current Issues & Opportunities
The President’s departure marks a critical loss of human capital. May result in transfer of strategic knowledge to competitors which will undermine AMEX’s competitive advantages. Selection of next president must be carefully decided and should factor in the individual’s objective within the company.
Government regulations present the biggest challenge to the future profitability of the industry. Changes to usury laws will have an impact on the bottom line. If government sets interest ceilings then revenue will be limited, especially as interest rates increase.
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group 48
Short Term Strategy Options:Anticipate government regulations,Financial restructuring of debt,Technological innovation.
Long Term Strategy Options:Revitalize key market focus, Seek mergers and acquisitions, Enhance bank-holding status.
Questions or Comments?
12/8/2009 © GSB Consulting Group 49