ambrogio lorenzetti – allegory of the effects of good ... · ambrogio lorenzetti –allegory of...

37
How do you feed a city? Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338

Upload: others

Post on 03-Aug-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

How do you feed a city?

Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338

Page 2: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

Urban Paradox

Shanghai, China Mato Grosso, Brazil

Page 3: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

Society Nature

‘Political animals’

Page 4: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

Oikonomia

Agora Polis

Page 5: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

City 2.0

Rome, 300 AD

Page 6: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

Ancient food miles

Page 7: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

16th Century London

Grain

Meat

Fish

Page 8: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

Visibility

London – Smithfield Market, 1830

Page 9: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

Goodbye Geography

Liverpool to Manchester Railway, 1831

Page 10: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

Urban Sprawl

Growth of London 1840-1929

Page 11: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

Transformation

The American ‘Great West’

Page 12: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

‘Cheap’ meatChicago Union Stockyards, 1880

Page 13: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

Dust BowlOklahoma, 1935

Page 14: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

Organic

Eve Balfour The Living Soil, 1943

Albert Howard: An Agricultural Testament, 1940

Page 15: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

Industrial paradigm

PesticidesFertilisers (Haber-Bosch)Justus Liebig

Monoculture

Page 16: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

Externalities1/3 harvest 55 % decline

1/3 lost or degraded 70% in farming

10 cals for 1

30% food-related

50% wasted2 billion 50% of lakes

Page 17: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

McGlobe

Page 18: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

Back to the city-state?

Thomas More, Utopia, 1516

Ebenezer Howard, Garden Cities of To-Morrow, 1902

PlatoRepublic, 380 BCE

Page 19: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

‘Progress’

Page 20: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

Techno-Fix?

Haber Bosch Lab Meat?

GM

GM

Page 21: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

Ultimate life hack?

Page 22: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

Polarised vision

Page 23: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

Scale

X 2000 to feed London?

Page 24: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

End game?

Wall-E, Pixar, 2008

Page 25: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

Utopia = ‘Good place’ or ‘No place’from Greek eu, good + topos

or ou, no + topos

Page 26: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

Sitopia = ‘Food place’from Greek sitos, food + topos, place

Page 27: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

Food flow

Page 28: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

A Good Life?

?

Fast Slow

Page 29: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

Valuing food

Havana, 2010London, 1940 Detroit, 2015

Page 30: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

Power Lines

160 million consumers

110 buying desks

3 million farmers

Jan-Willem GrievinkEuropean Food Study

Page 31: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

Working with nature

Permaculture

Forest Garden

Nature-led dietOrganic

Page 32: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

Food Planning

Urban Design Lab – NYC Regional Foodshed MVRDV – Almere Oosterwold

Patrick Geddes, Cities in Evolution, 1915 Bohn and Viljoen – CPULs

Page 33: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

Co-producing

Park Slope Food Coop, BrooklynCSA: Angelic Organics, Chicago

Food Share, Toronto Growing Communities, Hackney

Page 34: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

Food space

Patchwork farmsLocal infrastructure

Urban growing

Food hubs

Governance Farmers’ markets

Page 35: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

Small things

Page 36: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

Seeing through food

Page 37: Ambrogio Lorenzetti – Allegory of the Effects of Good ... · Ambrogio Lorenzetti –Allegory of the Effects of Good Government, Siena 1338. Urban Paradox Shanghai, China Mato Grosso,

www.hungrycitybook.co.uk