almost total replacement of fish meal by plant...
TRANSCRIPT
Almost total replacement of fish meal by plant
protein sources in the diet of a marine teleost,
the European seabass, Dicentrarchus labrax
S.J. Kaushika,*, D. Covesb, G. Duttob, D. Blanca
aFish Nutrition Research Laboratory, Unite Mixte INRA-IFREMER, Unite d’Hydrobiolgie,
64310 St-Pee-sur-Nivelle, FrancebMediterranean Finfish Research Laboratory, Station Experimentale d’Aquaculture IFREMER,
34250 Palavas-les-Flots, France
Received 1 April 2003; received in revised form 28 May 2003; accepted 28 May 2003
Abstract
Five practical diets in which the supply of protein from fish meal was decreased gradually from
100% to about 2% and replaced by plant protein sources were formulated. European seabass
weighing about 190 g were fed these diets for 12 weeks at a water temperature of 22 jC. Feed was
dispensed using automatic self-feeders and voluntary feed intake (VFI) was closely monitored. We
did not find any significant difference among diets in the apparent digestibility coefficients (ADC) of
dry matter (80–82%), protein (94–96%), energy (88–92%) or phosphorus (49–58%). Replacement
of fish meal by plant protein ingredients did not influence VFI. All groups had very good growth
rates (DGI above 1.3%/day) and there were no significant differences in growth rate, feed efficiency
or in daily nitrogen gains among groups. There was, however, a slight increase in fat deposition in
fish fed diets with plant protein sources. Ammonia nitrogen and soluble phosphorus excretion rates
were measured. Nitrogen and phosphorus balance studies indicated that fish meal replacement by
plant ingredients led to a slight increase in nitrogen losses (from 83 to 103 g N/kg weight gain) but
led to a significant reduction in total phosphorus losses (from 13 to 5 g P/kg weight gain). These
results combined with the remarkable acceptability of diets containing high levels of plant protein
ingredients with identical growth performances of European seabass show clearly that dietary fish
meal levels can be considerably reduced without any adverse consequence in terms of somatic
growth or nitrogen utilisation.
D 2004 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords: European sea bass; Fish meal replacement; Plant proteins; Growth; Nutrient utilisation
0044-8486/$ - see front matter D 2004 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/S0044-8486(03)00422-8
* Corresponding author. Tel.: +33-5-59-51-59-51; fax: +33-5-59-54-51-52.
E-mail address: [email protected] (S.J. Kaushik).
www.elsevier.com/locate/aqua-online
Aquaculture 230 (2004) 391–404
1. Introduction
Given the global needs for fish oil and fish meal for aquaculture (FAO, 2002), there is
an increasing demand for more insight on the potential of alternative protein sources in
aquafeeds (New and Wijkstrom, 2002). Under intensive farming conditions, in species
such as the rainbow trout, development of fish meal free diets has met with some success
(Kaushik et al., 1995; Watanabe et al., 1998). When working with marine species, the
latter authors, however, observed a number of adverse effects in yellowtail fed non-fish
meal diets (Watanabe et al., 1999). This interest for the substitution of fish meal by more
sustainable and renewable protein sources applies also for the culture of marine teleosts of
interest to the Mediterranean area (Alexis, 1997; Alexis and Nengas, 2001). Although
studies were initiated as far back as the late 1970s on the replacement of fish meal by other
protein sources in the diets of European seabass (Alliot et al., 1979), only limited
knowledge is available today on the nutritional value and the physiological consequences
of plant protein use in this species (Dias et al., 1997; da Silva and Oliva-Teles, 1998; Dias,
1999). The aim of this study was to evaluate the possibility of replacing a great portion of
fish meal in the diet of European seabass using practical ingredients readily available to the
aquafeed industry and to detect possible effects on carcass quality, body composition,
excretion and plasma metabolites.
2. Materials and methods
2.1. Diets
Five diets were formulated to contain different levels of fish meal incorporation,
ranging from 520 to 50 g kg� 1 (Table 1). They were formulated so as to meet the nutrient
requirements of European seabass (Kaushik, 2001) as well as to be least costly, using the
solver macro of Microsoft’s Excel software. The diets with fish meal replacement above
50% (diets FM25, FM 12 and FM5) were supplemented with L-lysine and dicalcium
phosphate. In the absence of specific data on vitamin, mineral and trace element require-
ments of European seabass, requirement data for other species were applied (NRC, 1993;
Kaushik et al., 1998). All diets contained yttrium oxide as an inert marker for determining
apparent digestibility coefficients (ADC). Extruded diets were manufactured by an
industrial fish feed manufacturer (Le Gouessant, 29 Lamballe, France) using a twin-screw
extruder (Buhler).
2.2. Rearing facilities
The trial was conducted at the experimental facilities of IFREMER (34 Palavas les
Flots, France). The rearing system consisted of 15 individual tanks supplied with sand
filtered (15 Am) and UV-treated seawater (salinity 31–38x) in a flow-through system
(flow rate: 1 m3 h� 1 in each tank). Water temperature was maintained constant (21.8F 0.1
jC) using titanium heat exchangers and oxygenated to maintain oxygen concentrations
above 80% saturation. Each tank was covered and individually equipped with a lamp (75W)
S.J. Kaushik et al. / Aquaculture 230 (2004) 391–404392
about 70 cm above the surface of the water with a photoperiod of 16 h of light (0600 to 2200
h) and 8 h of darkness with twilights of 30 min each at dawn and dusk (Fig. 1). An
electronic demand feeding and monitoring system developed by Boujard et al. (1992) was
attached to each individual tank. Some adaptations were made as described by Coves et al.
(1998) in order to prevent any unintentional triggering of the feeders by fish. This system
allows for distribution of feed per demand as well as to closely monitor demands and
rewards and to store data directly in a computer.
2.3. Digestibility and growth trial
European seabass juveniles (Dicentrarchus labrax), obtained from a commercial farm
(Extramer, France), were acclimated to the experimental conditions before the beginning
of the trial. Fish were sorted and 15 homogenous groups (coefficient of variation of
body weight < 12%) of 50 fish each were randomly allotted to each tank. The five diets
Table 1
Ingredient and chemical composition of the practical diets (g/kg)
FM52 FM40 FM25 FM12 FM5
Fish meal LT 94 (CP, 70%) 520.0 400.0 250.0 125.0 50.0
Corn gluten meal 80.0 205.8 209.6 200.0
Wheat gluten 50.0 166.0 237.8
Extruded wheat 195.4 67.9 19.6
Soybean meal (CP 48%) 94.7 150.0 150.0 140.1 131.5
Rapeseed meal (primor 00) 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0
L-Lysine 0.65 6.5 10.0
CaHPO4�2H2O (18%P) 6.7 22.5 32.8
Fish oil (Scandinavian) 158.9 171.2 186.3 199.4 206.9
Binder 10.0 10.0 10.0 10.0 10.0
Yttrium oxide 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0
Mineral premixa 10.0 10.0 10.0 10.0 10.0
Vitamin premixb 10.0 10.0 10.0 10.0 10.0
Dry matter (DM), g/kg 902.8 896.9 895.5 894.2 889.8
Crude protein, g/kg DM 450.5 483.1 503.7 468.8 506.6
Crude fat, g/kg DM 216.2 217.1 199.6 227.6 183.0
Phosphorus, g/kg DM 11.6 12.5 9.3 7.2 5.7
Gross energy, MJ/kg DM 24.2 24.3 24.1 24.8 24.4
Theoretical cost (o/ton)c 651 610 604 633 649
Both mixtures were manufactured by Unite de preparation des aliments experimentaux (UPAE), INRA, Jouy-
en-Josas, France, according to the recommendations of NRC (1993).a Mineral mixture (g or mg/kg diet): calcium carbonate (40% Ca), 2.15 g; magnesium oxide (60% Mg), 1.24
g; ferric citrate, 0.2 g; potassium iodide (75% I), 0.4 mg; zinc sulphate (36% Zn), 0.4 g; copper sulphate (25%
Cu), 0.3 g; manganese sulphate (33% Mn), 0.3 g; dibasic calcium phosphate (20% Ca, 18%P), 5 g; cobalt
sulphate, 2 mg; sodium selenite (30% Se), 3 mg; KCl, 0.9 g; NaCl, 0.4 g.b Vitamin mixture (IU or mg/kg diet): DL-a tocopherol acetate, 60 IU; sodium menadione bisulphate, 5 mg;
retinyl acetate, 15,000 IU; DL-cholecalciferol, 3000 IU; thiamin, 15 mg; riboflavin, 30 mg; pyridoxine, 15 mg;
B12, 0.05 mg; nicotinic acid, 175 mg; folic acid, 500 mg; inositol, 1000 mg; biotin, 2.5 mg; calcium panthotenate,
50 mg; choline chloride, 2000 mg.c As per ingredient prices in June 2000.
S.J. Kaushik et al. / Aquaculture 230 (2004) 391–404 393
were randomly allotted to triplicate tanks and self feeders were filled with the respective
diets each day and the feed intake (quantity dispensed minus eventual refusals)
monitored daily.
At the beginning of the growth trial, a representative sample of six fish was withdrawn
and kept frozen (� 20 jC). Growth trial was conducted for 12 weeks (Sept–Dec 2000),
and every third weeks fish in each tank were bulk-weighed. At the end of the growth study
and after an overnight fast, six fish from each tank were sampled and frozen. Fifteen fish
per treatment were anesthetised (ethylene glycol monophenyl-ether 1:2500). They were
individually weighed and total length measured; blood was collected from the caudal vein
with a heparinised syringe. Plasma was recovered after centrifugation and stored at
� 20jC for total cholesterol and triacylglycerol analysis.
Fish were ground and moisture content was determined (110 jC, 24 h) and
subsequently freeze-dried before further analyses. For digestibility measurements, fecal
matter was collected in a modified version of the decantation chamber described by Cho
and Slinger (1979) and directly fitted to the circular rearing tanks (Fig. 1). Almost at the
end of the growth trial, faeces were collected over five consecutive days and frozen.
ADC of the dietary nutrients and energy were calculated according to Maynard et al.
(1979):
ADC ð%Þ ¼ 100� 1� dietary Y2O level
faecal Y2O level� faecal nutrient or energy level
dietary nutrient or energy level
� �
In order to quantify soluble nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) losses, outlet water
from the same rearing tanks was automatically sampled using a peristaltic pump over
three consecutive 24-h cycles and collected daily into bottles containing a small
Fig. 1. Diagram of a tank with photoperiod control, attached demand feeder and fecal trap used for rearing
European seabass.
S.J. Kaushik et al. / Aquaculture 230 (2004) 391–404394
amount of chloroform following procedures used by Kaushik (1980) and Dosdat et al.
(1996).
2.4. Analyses
Fecal samples were freeze dried before analyses of dry matter, nitrogen, energy,
phosphorus and yttrium oxide. Diets, freeze-dried feces and whole body samples were
analysed for dry matter (DM, 110 jC, 24 h), ash (550 jC, 18 h) crude protein (Kjeldahl
nitrogen� 6.25) and lipids (dichloromethane extraction by Soxlhet method) were
performed following AOAC (1984) procedures. Gross energy was determined by
calorimetry (IKA Adiabatic Calorimeter C4000A). Yttrium concentrations were deter-
mined in diet and fecal samples by atomic absorption spectrophotometry using a nitrous
oxide-acetylene flame, after acid digestion (2% nitric acid and 2 g l� 1 KCl). Concen-
trations of ammonia-N and urea-N were analysed by the indophenol blue (Treguer and
Le Corre, 1975) and diacetylmonoxime methods (Aminot and Kerouel, 1982), respec-
tively, using an autoanalyser. Soluble P (PO4) in the water was determined by the
ammonium molybdate method (Treguer and Le Corre, 1975). Based on diet and
comparative carcass analysis, daily N, fat and P gains and retention (as % intake) were
calculated. Concentrations of plasma triacylglycerols and cholesterol were determined
spectrophotometrically using commercial enzymatic kits (BioMerieux and Boehringer
Mannheim).
2.5. Statistical analysis
Data were analysed using ANOVA using the GLM procedure of SAS (1993). The
means were subsequently compared using Duncan’s multiple range test (significance level
P < 0.05). Data presented are meansF standard deviations with superscript letters indi-
cating differences between groups.
3. Results
3.1. Apparent digestibility
ADC of dry matter ranged between 80% and 82%, that of protein between 94% and
96% and that of energy between 88% and 92%, little affected by dietary fish meal
Table 2
Apparent digestibility coefficients (ADC, %) of the different experimental diets
FM52 FM40 FM25 FM12 FM5
Dry matter 82.4F 1.2 78.9F 1.2 80.3F 0.8 80.3F 1.4 79.7F 0.3
Protein 94.9F 0.4 94.2F 0.8 95.5F 0.6 96.1F 0.3 96.1F 0.3
Energy 91.6F 0.6 88.8F 0.8 89.4F 0.6 89.4F 0.5 88.5F 0.5
Phosphorus 49.2F 0.1 55.3F 0.3 54.5F 3.9 57.9F 4.3 52.3F 1.5
Values are meansF SD. Absence of superscript indicates no significant difference between treatments.
S.J. Kaushik et al. / Aquaculture 230 (2004) 391–404 395
replacement levels (Table 2). Availability of phosphorus was lower in all diets (49% to
58%) but given the variability, there was no significant difference among diets.
3.2. Growth performance and nutrient utilisation
At the end of the 12 weeks of the growth trial, all groups of European seabass had
reached mean individual body weights ranging from 313 to 333 g (Table 3) with no
significant differences among groups. Analysis of length–weight relationships did not
show any differences either between groups described by a common relation of
y = 0.027X 2.808 with an R2 of 0.682, where X and Y represent total length (cm) and body
weight (g), respectively. Over the 12-week period of the growth trial, the daily mean
voluntary feed intake (VFI) was slightly higher in fish fed FM40 (10 g/kg/day) than in the
other groups (9.1 to 9.4 g/kg/day) which did not differ among themselves. The values of
daily growth index (DGI) were high for seabass of this size, grown at 22 jC, reflecting the
good rearing conditions and physico-chemical quality of water, with no significant
differences among treatments (Table 3). While there was no difference between groups
in feed efficiency (FE =wet weight gain/dry feed intake), the protein efficiency ratios
(PER=wet weight gain/crude protein intake) varied and the lowest value was observed in
seabass fed diet FM5. Whole body protein or phosphorus contents did not vary among
groups but body fat content increased with increasing level of fish meal replacement
(Table 4).
3.3. Nitrogen and phosphorus losses
Measurements of total ammonia-N rates showed that ammonia-N excretion rates were
lower in FM52-fed fish than in all other groups (Table 5), reflecting possible amino acid
imbalance or more probably an excess supply in the latter groups, which, however, did not
affect N-gains differently. Urea N excretion rates differed between treatments ranging
between 35 and 50 mg urea-N/kg BW/day. The relative proportion of urea-N to
ammonia + urea N decreased with decreasing levels of dietary fish meal levels. Daily P
Table 3
Growth performance and nutrient utilisation in European seabass (initial body weight: 190F 2 g) fed diets with
graded levels of fish meal replacement over 12 weeks at 22 jC
Diet FM52 FM40 FM25 FM12 FM5
Final body weight, g 330.8F 12.9 333.2F 10.9 317.2F 12.0 327.3F 8.9 313.9F 11.6
Final total length, cm 28.9F 0.9 28.1F1.2 27.9F 0.8 28.0F 0.9 28.7F 1.0
Voluntary feed intake, g/kg BW/day 9.25F 0.09b 10.02F 0.20a 9.17F 0.52b 9.42F 0.40b 9.07F 0.08b
Daily growth index (DGI)1 1.36F 0.11ab 1.48F 0.12a 1.34F 0.09ab 1.38F 0.09ab 1.25F 0.07b
Feed efficiency (FE)2 0.68F 0.04 0.68F 0.04 0.69F 0.01 0.68F 0.01 0.65F 0.02
Protein efficiency ratio (PER)3 1.51F 0.09a 1.41F 0.07ab 1.36F 0.02bc 1.46F 0.03ab 1.28F 0.05c
Values are meanF SD. Within a row, means with different superscript letters differ significantly (P < 0.05).
Absence of superscript indicates no significant difference between treatments.1 DGI: (FBW1/3� IBW1/3)/84 days)� 100.2 FE, Weight gain/dry feed intake.3 PER, Wet weight gain/crude protein intake.
S.J. Kaushik et al. / Aquaculture 230 (2004) 391–404396
Table 5
Daily mean NH4–N and PO4–P excretion rates in European seabass fed the different diets
Dietary Treatment FM52 FM40 FM25 FM12 FM5
Ammonia-N excretion,
mg N/kg/d
187.7F 25.5 280.6F 18.6 258.8F 18.4 288.6F 18.1 312.8F 50.9
Urea N-excretion,
mg N/kg/d
37.1F 5.1 49.7F 2.8 40.1F 6.2 38.6F 1.4 34.5F 5.1
Urea N/[Ammonia +
Urea N, %
16.5F 0.8 15.1F1.2 13.4F 1.0 11.8F 0.3 9.9F 0.4
[Ammonia + urea]�N
excreted as % of
digestible N intake
44.2F 0.7b 48.0F 1.8b 52.7F 3.1b 45.7F 3.1b 53.3F 2.3a
PO4–P excreted,
mg P/kg/d
23.1F 6.6 29.4F 4.6 11.6F 0.9 4.4F 1.5 � 2.6F 0.9
PO4–P excretion as %
of available P intake
41.8F 6.7a 40.3F 5.4a 23.6F 4.8b 6.6F 2.1c 0
Values are meanF SD. Within a row, means with different superscript letters differ significantly (P < 0.05).
Absence of superscript indicates no significant difference between treatments.
Table 4
Whole body composition, nutrient retention and gain in European seabass (IBW: 190F 2 g) fed diets with graded
levels of fish meal replacement over 12 weeks at 22 jC
Diet FM52 FM40 FM25 FM12 FM5
HSI1, % 2.1F 0.4 2.1F 0.5 2.2F 0.5 2.3F 0.6 2.5F 0.6
VSI2, % 11.0F 1.6 11.2F 1.5 11.3F 2.3 11.9F 3.7 10.7F 1.5
GSI3, % 0.52F 0.36 0.72F 0.39 1.41F 0.50 1.05F 0.65 1.01F 0.75
Final body composition4
Moisture, % 62.3F 1.9ab 60.5F 0.4b 60.2F 0.5b 60.8F 0.1ab 59.6F 0.2b
Protein, % 16.1F 0.8 16.4F 0.1 16.4F 0.8 16.6F 0.3 15.9F 0.5
Fat, % 18.4F 1.0c 19.8F 0.3b 19.9F 0.5b 20.0F 0.2b 21.8F 1.0a
Phosphorus, % 0.6F 0.05 0.6F 0.3 0.6F 0.1 0.6F 0.03 0.6F 0.1
Ash, % 3.1F 0.3 3.3F 0.6 3.6F 0.7 2.7F 0.2 2.7F 0.7
Energy, kJ/g 10.8F 0.7c 11.5F 0.2ab 11.6F 0.3ab 11.4F 0.2bc 12.1F 0.2a
Retention, % of intake
Dry matter 26.8F 4.4 29.7F 0.9 30.6F 0.6 29.4F 0.5 30.1F1.2
Protein 22.3F 4.3 22.1F1.6 21.0F 3.0 23.2F 0.6 17.9F 2.2
Energy 34.2F 6.0b 38.2F 1.2ab 39.5F 1.5ab 36.8F 0.8ab 40.9F 1.6a
Phosphorus 23.1F 7.0c 25.8F 3.5bc 36.1F11.9abc 46.5F 7.8a 44.2F 16.0ab
Daily nutrient gain (mg or g/kg/d)
Nitrogen (mg) 148.9F 30.1 171.3F 15.7 155.2F 25.3 163.5F 7.2 132.0F 17.0
Fat (g) 1.5F 0.2b 1.8F 0.1ab 1.7F 0.1ab 1.8F 0.1ab 1.9F 0.2a
Phosphorus (mg) 25.1F 7.8 32.7F 4.8 31.3F 11.2 32.0F 6.5 23.1F 8.5
Values are meanF SD. Within a row, means with different superscript letters differ significantly (P < 0.05).
Absence of superscript indicates no significant difference between treatments.1 HSI = hepato-somatic index, 100�weight of the liver/whole body weight.2 VSI = viscero-somatic index, 100�weight of digestive tract/whole body weight.3 GSI = gonado-somatic index, 100�weight of gonads/whole body weight.4 Initial body composition was: moisture 63.6, protein 17.1, fats 14.7, phosphorus 0.78, ash 4.7, and energy 9.9.
S.J. Kaushik et al. / Aquaculture 230 (2004) 391–404 397
gain did not differ among groups, P retention values increased with increasing levels of
plant protein incorporation. Based on data on VFI, digestibility and on measured soluble
nutrient losses, combined with comparative carcass analysis, total nitrogen and phoshorus
fluxes were calculated and reported in Figs. 2 and 3.
Fig. 2. Nitrogen budget in European seabass (mg N/kg BW/day) based on digestibility, ammonia + urea N
excretion and comparative carcass analyses. The fraction corresponding to ‘‘Other N’’ represents that not
accounted for by measurements of fecal and metabolic losses.
Fig. 3. Phosphorus budget in European seabass (mg P/kg BW/day) based on digestibility, total soluble PO4
excretion and comparative carcass analyses.
S.J. Kaushik et al. / Aquaculture 230 (2004) 391–404398
3.4. Other metabolic consequences
Very few fish (less than 3%) were found to be mature and the gonadosomatic index
varied between 0.5% and 1.4% with no differences between sexes. We did not find any
differences between groups in the liver to body weight ratio (HSI) or in the viscero-
somatic index (VSI; Table 4). Concentrations of plasma triacylglycerols ranged between
100 and 400 mg/dl (Fig. 4) with much variability among treatments. Plasma cholesterol
levels decreased with increasing levels of fish meal replacement, the lowest level being
found in fish fed diet FM5 (Fig. 5).
Fig. 4. Concentrations of plasma triacylglycerols in European seabass fed the different diets. Values are
meanF SD. Means with different superscript letters differ significantly ( P< 0.05).
Fig. 5. Plasma cholesterol concentrations in European seabass fed the different diets. Values are meanF SD.
Means with different superscript letters differ significantly ( P< 0.05).
S.J. Kaushik et al. / Aquaculture 230 (2004) 391–404 399
4. Discussion
Some earlier studies with rainbow trout as well as European seabass have suggested
that the major problem connected with poor growth of fish fed fish meal-free, plant-
protein-based diets is caused by poor feed intake (Gomes et al., 1995; Dias, 1999). In
European seabass fed diets containing very high levels of single protein sources such as
soy protein concentrate or corn gluten meal, there was a decrease in VFI, which was
improved by supplementation with an attractant mix (Dias et al., 1997). But other data
indicate that when the same protein sources replaced about 60% of fish meal, adequately
supplemented with limiting amino acids such as lysine or methionine, there was no need
for an attractant mix such as squid extract (Tibaldi et al., 1999). It is thus of interest to note
that the diets used here and made commercially did not lead to any reduction in voluntary
feed intake.
The growth rates observed here were higher than those reported earlier by Dias (1999)
for seabass grown at 18 jC and even higher than those reported by Ballestrazzi et al.
(1994) for fish reared at similar temperature levels. Earlier data have shown that partial
replacement of fish meal by plant protein sources (Tibaldi et al., 1999; Tulli et al., 1999) or
single cell proteins (Oliva-Teles and Goncalves, 2001) is feasible in European seabass.
Dias (1999) observed that inclusion of corn gluten meal or soy protein concentrates as the
sole protein source led to significant growth reduction. This is the first ever demonstration
of an almost total replacement of fish meal and soybean meal by a mixture of other plant
protein sources in European seabass. Diets were formulated to be least costly and it is
apparent that considerable reduction in fish meal levels can be achieved without
comprising fish performance under similar economic terms.
We observed, however, a significant increase in fat content with increasing levels of
fish meal replacement. This consequently resulted in a similar increase in whole body
energy content. The high fat and energy retention values in this group clearly suggest that
there was increased lipogenesis with increasing levels of fish meal replacement, without
any effect on nitrogen utilisation. Indeed, daily N gains or N retention expressed as a
percentage of unit N intake did not vary among groups. The HSI values of above 2 as
found here are common in European seabass (Ballestrazzi et al., 1998; Dias, 1999), where
hepatic fat deposition indeed is very high (Dias, 1999). There is evidence that replacement
of fish meal by plant protein sources such as corn gluten meal or soy protein concentrates
affects hepatic lipogenic enzyme activities variably in seabass (Dias, 1999): while the
activity of malic enzyme decreased, that of fatty acid synthetase increased significantly
with high levels of corn gluten meal in the diet.
The data on the relative proportion of urea-N to ammonia + urea N which decreased
with decreasing levels of dietary fish meal levels have to be treated with caution, since the
daily excretion rates measured here in well growing fish were relatively lower than what
has been found earlier (Dosdat et al., 1996). Expressed per unit digestible N intake,
measured (ammonia + urea) N excretion rates ranged between 43% and 53%, higher than
values reported earlier by Robaina et al. (1999), but close to other data (Ballestrazzi et al.,
1994). Reactive phosphorus losses decreased with increasing levels of fish meal replace-
ment, with practically no measurable soluble phosphorus in the effluents in fish fed diet
FM5. The sensitivity of the analytical method, albeit low, was not sufficient to detect
S.J. Kaushik et al. / Aquaculture 230 (2004) 391–404400
differences between inlet and outlet water. Indeed, measurements of low levels of soluble
P in fish farm effluent water is difficult due to the low concentrations generally found.
Data of Ballestrazzi et al. (1994) also provide evidence that seabass fed diets containing
corn gluten meal had lower reactive phosphate concentration in the effluent water than in
those fed herring meal based diets. It is clear from Fig. 2 that while fecal N losses are
relatively small and that daily N gains are similar among groups (Tables 4 and 6),
metabolic N losses are high. We also observed that measurement of ammonia-N + urea N
as measured here does not, at least in our case, reflect total metabolic losses, confirming
earlier suggestions that in fish, N balance measurement based on comparative carcass
analysis is more reliable than measurement of excretory rates (Cho and Kaushik, 1990).
Earlier data have shown that phosphorus availability was reduced in European seabass
fed soy protein concentrates (Dias, 1999). Given that the raw materials used here did not
contain detectable levels of phytic acid, addition of phytase, known to improve phytic P
availability even in European seabass (Oliva-Teles et al., 1998), was not found necessary.
Although daily P gain did not differ among groups, P retention values increased with
increasing levels of plant protein incorporation, reflecting that the inorganic phosphorus
supplementation was efficient. The data on phosphorus budget (Fig. 3) show that quite a
significant portion of soluble P was not accounted for by measured soluble PO4 in
effluents from fish tanks. It is, however, interesting to note that total P losses were reduced
in fish fed plant-protein-rich diets (Table 6).
The decrease in plasma cholesterol levels in fish fed diets with plant proteins (Fig. 5)
has already been reported in rainbow trout (Kaushik et al., 1995) and in European seabass
fed different plant protein sources (Dias, 1999; Tulli et al., 1999) in replacement of fish
meal. In terrestrial animals, plant products are generally considered to have a hypocho-
lesteromic effect (de Schrijver, 1990), mainly due to the relatively high levels of
estrogeno-mimetic isoflavones (Setchell and Cassidy, 1999). Given that the diets used
here contained small amounts of soy bean meal, it appears that the hypocholesterolemic
effects seen in such studies have more to do with the withdrawal of fish meal rather than
with a direct effect of plant proteins. Besides, measurements of phytoestrogens in several
plant products do show that there was considerable variability in the flavonoid contents of
soybean products and that other plant products used here contain very low or no genistein
Table 6
Nitrogen and phosphorus budget per unit body weight gain in European seabass fed the different diets
Dietary treatment FM52 FM40 FM25 FM12 FM5
Nitrogen, g N/kg BW gain
Intake 106.3F 6.3 113.3F 5.8 117.4F 1.5 109.9F 2.2 125.2F 4.8
Gain 23.6F 3.3 25.0F 0.6 24.6F 3.2 25.4F 1.0 22.4F 2.0
Losses 82.8F 9.3 88.3F 6.3 92.8F 4.7 84.4F 1.4 102.8F 6.3
Phosphorus, g P/kg BW gain
Intake 17.1F1.0 18.3F 0.9 13.5F 0.2 10.5F 0.2 8.8F 0.3
Gain 3.9F 1.2 4.7F 0.6 4.9F 1.6 4.9F 0.7 3.9F 1.4
Losses 13.2F 1.7 13.6F 1.2 8.7F 1.7 5.7F 0.9 4.9F 1.5
Values are meanF SD. Absence of superscript indicates no significant difference between treatments.
S.J. Kaushik et al. / Aquaculture 230 (2004) 391–404 401
or daidzein (Bennetau-Pelissero et al., in press). In an earlier study with rainbow trout
(Kaushik et al., 1995), we also observed that casein had a stronger hypocholesterolemic
effect than soy by-products. From a comparative perspective, it will be of interest to gather
more insight on the specific effects of plant proteins on lipid and cholesterol synthesis and
metabolism, in as much as these factors might affect, among others, flesh quality.
5. Conclusions
Data obtained here show that development of diets based mainly on commonly
available practical ingredients of plant origin with very low levels of fish meal
incorporation and appropriate supplementation of essential amino acids does not affect
growth or nitrogen utilisation in European seabass. The low levels of phosphorus in these
diets can be easily supplemented with inorganic phosphorus to maintain body phosphorus
status while having a significant reduction in phosphorus discharges.
Acknowledgements
We express our thanks to Le Gouessant Aquaculture, 29 Lamballe, France, for the
manufacture of extruded diets used in this study. Recognition is given to all the technical
staff of Ifremer, Palavas and Inra, St-Pee sur Nivelle for their assistance in conducting
growth trials, samplings and chemical analyses. Special thanks are due to A. Charrier,
(IFREMER) for her help in excretion measurements and to C. Vachot (INRA) for analysis
of plasma metabolites. This study is a part of the Eureka project A! 1960: Aqua-Maki 2.
References
Alexis, M.N., 1997. Fish meal and fish oil replacers in Mediterranean marine fish diets. In: Tacon, A., Basurco,
B. (Eds.), International Cent. for Advanced Mediterranean Agronomic Studies, CIHEAM, Zaragoza (Spain).
Cah. Options Mediterr., vol. 22, pp. 183–204.
Alexis, M.N., Nengas, I., 2001. Current State of Knowledge Concerning the Use of Soy Products in Diets for
Feeding Sea Bass and Seabream. Needs for Future Research Publ. American Soybean Assn., Brussels,
Belgium. No. 5, 32 pp.
Alliot, E., Pastoureaud, A., Pelaez-Hudlet, J., Metailler, R., 1979. Utilisation des farines vegetales et des levures
cultivees sur les alcanes pour l’alimentation du bar (Dicentrarchus labrax L.). In: Tiews, K., Halver, J.E.
(Eds.), Finfish Nutrition and Fishfeed Technology, vol. 2. Heenemann, Berlin, pp. 229–238.
Aminot, A., Kerouel, R., 1982. Dosage automatique de l’uree dans l’eau de mer: une methode tres sensible a la
diacetylmonoxyme. Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 39, 174–183.
AOAC (Association of Official Analytical Chemists), 1984. Official Methods of Analysis, 12th ed. Association
of Official Analytical Chemists, Washington, DC. 1141 pp.
Ballestrazzi, R., Lanari, D., D’Agaro, E., Mion, A., 1994. The effect of dietary protein level and source on
growth, body composition, total ammonia and reactive phosphate excretion of growing sea bass (Dicen-
trarchus labrax). Aquaculture 127, 197–206.
Ballestrazzi, R., Lanari, D., D’Agaro, E., 1998. Performance, nutrient retention efficiency, total ammonia and
reactive phosphorus excretion of growing European sea-bass (Dicentrarchus labrax, L.) as affected by diet
processing and feeding level. Aquaculture 161, 55–65.
S.J. Kaushik et al. / Aquaculture 230 (2004) 391–404402
Bennetau-Pelissero, C., Lamothe, V., Shinkaruk-Poix, S., Kaushik, S.J., 2003. Screening estrogenic activity of
plant and food extracts using in vitro trout hepatocyte cultures. Phytochem. Anal. (In press).
Boujard, T., Dugy, X., Genner, D., Gosset, C., Grig, G., 1992. Description of a modular, low cost, eater meter for
the study of feeding behavior and food-preferences in fish. Physiol. Behav. 52, 1101–1106.
Cho, C.Y., Kaushik, S.J., 1990. Nutritional energetics in fish: energy and protein utilization in rainbow trout
(Salmo gairdneri). World Rev. Nutr. Diet. 61, 132–172.
Cho, C.Y., Slinger, S.J., 1979. Apparent digestibility measurement in feedstuffs for rainbow trout. In:
Tiews, K., Halver, J.E. (Eds.), Finfish Nutrition and Fishfeed Technology, vol. 2. Heenemann, Berlin,
pp. 239–247.
Coves, D., Gasset, E., Lemarie, G., Dutto, G., 1998. A simple way of avoiding feed wastage in European seabass,
Dicentrarchus labrax, under self-feeding conditions. Aquat. Living Resour. 11, 395–401.
da Silva, J.G., Oliva-Teles, A., 1998. Apparent digestibility coefficients of feedstuffs in seabass (Dicentrarchus
labrax) juveniles. Aquat. Living Resour. 11, 187–191.
de Schrijver, R., 1990. Cholesterol metabolism in mature and immature rats fed animal or plant protein. J. Nutr.
120, 1624–1632.
Dias, J., 1999. Lipid deposition in rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) and European seabass (Dicentrarchus
labrax L.): nutritional regulation of hepatic lipogenesis. Dr thesis, Univ. Porto (Portugal) and Univ. Bordeaux
I (France). 190 pp.
Dias, J., Gomes, E.F., Kaushik, S.J., 1997. Improvement of feed intake trough supplementation with an attractant
mix in European seabass fed plant-protein rich diets. Aquat. Living Resour. 10, 385–389.
Dosdat, A., Servais, F., Metailler, R., Huelvan, C., Desbruyeres, E., 1996. Comparison of nitrogenous losses in
five teleost fish species. Aquaculture 141, 107–127.
FAO, 2002. The State of World Fisheries and Aquaculture. FAO Fisheries Department, Rome. 159 pp.
Gomes, E.F., Rema, P., Kaushik, S.J., 1995. Replacement of fish meal by plant proteins in the diet of rainbow
trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss): digestibility and growth performance. Aquaculture 130, 177–186.
Kaushik, S.J., 1980. Influence of nutritional status on the daily patterns of nitrogen excretion in the carp
(Cyprinus carpio L.) and the rainbow trout (Salmo gairdneri R.). Rep. Nutr. Dev. 20, 1751–1765.
Kaushik, S.J., 2001. European seabass. In: Webster, C.D., Lim, C.E. (Eds.), Nutrient Requirements and Feeding
of Aquaculture Fish. CABI Publ., United Kingdom, pp. 28–39.
Kaushik, S.J., Cravedi, J.P., Lalles, J.P., Sumpter, J., Fauconneau, B., Laroche, M., 1995. Partial or total replace-
ment of fish meal by soya protein on growth, protein utilization, potential estrogenic or antigenic effects,
cholesterolemia and flesh quality in rainbow trout. Aquaculture 133, 257–274.
Kaushik, S.J., Gouillou-Coustans, M.F., Cho, C.Y., 1998. Application of the recommendation on vitamin require-
ments of finfish by NRC (1993) to salmonids and sea bass using practical and purified diets. Aquaculture 161,
463–474.
Maynard, L.A., Loosli, J.K., Hintz, H.F., Warner, R.G., 1979. Animal Nutrition, 7th ed. McGraw-Hill, New York.
602 pp.
New, M.B., Wijkstrom, U.N., 2002. Use of fish meal and fish oil in aquafeeds: further thoughts on the fish meal
trap. FAO Fish. Circ. 975. Rome, 61 pp.
NRC (National Research, Council), 1993. Nutrient Requirements of Fish. National Academy Press, Washington,
DC, USA. 114 pp.
Oliva-Teles, A., Goncalves, P., 2001. Partial replacement of fish meal by brewers yeast (Saccaromyces cerevisae)
in diets for sea bass (Dicentrarchus labrax) juveniles. Aquaculture 202, 269–278.
Oliva-Teles, A., Pereira, J.P., Gounveia, A., Gomes, E., 1998. Utilisation of diets supplemented with microbial
phytase by seabass (Dicentrachus labrax) juveniles. Aquat. Living Resour. 11, 255–259.
Robaina, L., Corraze, G., Aguirre, P., Blanc, D., Melcion, J.P., Kaushik, S., 1999. Digestibility, postprandial
ammonia excretion and selected plasma metabolites in European sea bass (Dicentrarchus labrax) fed pelleted
or extruded diets with or without wheat gluten. Aquaculture 179, 45–56.
SAS, 1993. SAS/STAT User’s Guide. Version 7, 4th ed. SAS Institute, Cary, NC.
Setchell, K.D.R., Cassidy, A., 1999. Dietary isoflavones: biological effects and relevance to human health. J. Nutr.
129, 758S–767S.
Tibaldi, E., Tulli, F., Amerio, M., 1999. Feed intake and growth responses of sea bass (D. labrax) fed different
plant-protein sources are not affected by supplementation with a feeding stimulant. In: Piva, G., Bertoni, G.,
S.J. Kaushik et al. / Aquaculture 230 (2004) 391–404 403
Satoh, S., Bani, P., Calamari, L. (Eds.), Recent Progress in Animal Production Science: I. Proc. A.S.P.A. XIII
Congress, Piacenza, Italy, 21–24 June 1999. Assn. Sci. Anim. Production, Italy, pp. 752–754.
Treguer, P., Le Corre, P., 1975. Manuel d’analyse des sels nutritifs dans l’eau de mer (Utilisation de l’autoana-
lyseur Technicon), 2nd ed. Laboratoire d’Oceanographie Chimique, Universite de Bretagne Occidentale,
France. 110 pp.
Tulli, F., Tibaldi, E., Comin, A., 1999. Dietary protein sources differently affect plasma lipid levels and body fat
deposition in juvenile sea bass. In: Piva, G., Bertoni, G., Masoero, F., Bani, P., Calamari, L. (Eds.), Recent
Progress in Animal Production Science: I. Proc. A.S.P.A. XIII Congress, Piacenza, Italy, 21–24 June 1999.
Assn. Sci. Anim. Production, Italy, pp. 782–784.
Watanabe, T., Verakunpiriya, V., Watanabe, K., Viswanath, K., Satoh, S., 1998. Feeding of rainbow trout with
non-fish meal diets. Fish. Sci. 63, 258–266.
Watanabe, T., Aoki, H., Shimamoto, K., Hadzuma, M., Maita, M., Yamagata, Y., Viswanath, K., Satoh, S., 1999.
A trial to culture yellowtail with non-fish meal diets. Fish. Sci. 64, 505–512.
S.J. Kaushik et al. / Aquaculture 230 (2004) 391–404404