allogeneic hematopoetic stem cell transplant...dreger, 2014 cll is the enemy –not the allo sct...
TRANSCRIPT
Allogeneic Hematopoetic Stem cell transplant
A key role to play in management of high risk CLL
Why does allogeneic HSCT have an important place in CLL therapy? • Strong graft vs leukemia effect
– Immune anti-CLL impact• It can overcome adverse prognosis• It can restore normal immune function• It is the only curative therapy for CLL• Cure possible even with:
– Transformation, post HSCT progression• Patients can have normal quality of life
– Much improved from that experienced with active CLL
Graft vs Leukemia
Graft vs leukemia effect
• Higher chance of CR / OS with gvhd• Auto HSCT has no impact in CLL• CLL response to:
– Withdrawal of immune suppression– Onset of gvhd– Donor lymphocyte infusion
Toze, BMT Nov 2005
• TCD Allo SCT• DLI• Real time q PCR of CLL
specific IgH rearrangement
Gribben, Blood Aug 05
Valkova, Hematol Oncol 2010
Valkova, Hematol Oncol 2010
Survival post adverse prognosis
403020100
Overall survival from date of diagnosis (y)
1.0
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
Cum
Sur
viva
lTreatment, n=585
No treatment,n=411
P < 0.001
Huang, Toze 2014
2520151050
Time from 1st to 2nd treatment (y)
1.0
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
One
Min
us C
um S
urvi
val
Median 1.9 (range 0.1 - 21.5)
• 2012– First line – 89/246 (36%)– Second line – 48/246 (20%)– Third line – 42/246 (17%)– Fourth line – 28/246 (11%)– Fifth line – 18/246 (7%)– Sixth line – 10/246 (4%)– Seventh line – 5/246 (2%)– Eighth line – 2/246 (0.8%)– Subsequent lines (Ninth) – 4 (2)/246 (1.6%, 0.8%)
44% 3rd line or higher…..
Multiple therapies given over a patient’s lifetime
Survival of CLL Patients by Line of Therapy
1441209672482400
20
40
60
80
100
Time (Months)
Overall survival (%
)
Total Died Subgroup609 129 Initial Dx327 167 1st Rx794 548 1st fludarabine salvage233 158 fludarabine refractory
Fludarabine failed
Alkylating agents failed
MDACC data, M Keating.
Prognosis – FISH and other
Poor prognosis• Short duration of response to therapy• Inadequate response to therapy• High-risk markers
– FISH• 17p,11q, clonal evolution
– B symptoms– Bulky disease– Advanced stage– CD38 +– IgVH unmutated status– High B2 microglobulin
17p deletion …..
• Dreger et al; Blood, 7 October 2010
FISH FISH
Donor Donor
Dreger et al; Blood, 7 October 2010
Allo HSCT can cure CLL!!!
Swic, Toze 2014
Swic, Toze 2014
Building better transplants
• Improved safety• Risk lower if well prepared• Choice of regimen intensity
– Non-myeloablative– Reduced intensity– Full intensity
Improved survival with less intense conditioning
Swic, Toze 2014
Excellent survival with reduced intensity and post SCT CR
Swic, Toze 2014
Comorbidity
Improved survival with low comorbidity index
Does SCT improve survival?
Lines of evidence
• Donor / no donor comparison– Herth / Dreger, Heidelberg
• Decision analysis– Kharfan-Dabaja, Beirut
• Population based comparison– Swic / Toze, Vancouver
2 yr OS 88% SCTVs 38% no SCTMortality halved by SCT
“It is intriguing that the survival of the donor group was at no time inferior to that of the no-donor group, implying that the superior disease control provided by allografting is never counteracted by the NRM risk associated with alloSCT.”
“This notion is further substantiated by the fact that mortality due to CLL progression before intended transplant was higher than transplant-related mortality in this high-risk selection.”
Dreger, 2014
CLL is the enemy –not the allo SCT
Decision analysis
BC Population-based data:OS of patients treated with SCT vs non-SCT tx
403020100
Overall Survival (y)
1.0
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
Cum
Sur
viva
l
SCT, n=103
Treated, no SCT,n=494
P = 0.033
Swic, Toze 2014
Conclusion…..
• SCT wins when compared to non-transplant therapy
Quality of life• CLL
– “CLL has a profound impact on QoL at all disease stages” Shanafelt
– QoL best in PFS state– Worst with advanced disease, progression
• Allo HSCT is a PFS state that reverses advanced CLL
• Allo HSCT– Gvhd impacts QoL but absence of malignancy
NB
• SCT restores immune function• Clinical experience – Excellent QoL for
most post SCT• Novel agents - promising• Potential concerns remain
Will novel agents be a panacea for all patients?
• No – Some will develop resistance
• Stilgenbauer data– Long term impact of drugs
• Effect on CLL – escape from response• Other long term effects
Patient Characteristics with Acquired SNVs
Stilgenbauer, S. IWCLL 2013.
Study Age,years Gender # of Prior
Treatments Cytogenetics IbrutinibTreatment
Durationon
Ibrutinib
Best Response Mutation
PCYC‐04753 59 Female 5 17p‐, +12 560 mg qd 621 days PR C481S BTK
PCYC‐1102 75 Male 2 17p‐, complexkaryotype 420 mg qd 673 days PR R665W PLCg2
PCYC‐1108 59 Female 3 11q‐ BR x 6 cycles420 mg qd 388 days CR C481S BTK
PCYC‐1109 51 Male 2 complex karyotype
Ofatumumab x24 weeks 420 mg qd
674 days CR C481S BTK
PCYC‐1102 69 Male 9 17p‐, complex karyotype 840 mg qd 868 days PR C481S BTK
Single Nucleotide Variations (SNVs) Acquired at Time of Ibrutinib Resistance
Stilgenbauer, S. IWCLL 2013.
Patient ID Gene Position
Before Treatment
After Treatment
DNA and RNA Nucleotide Change
Amino Acid Change
Mutant Allele Frequency (DNA)
Mutant Transcript Frequency (RNA)
B00‐00G BTK chrX:100611165 Not present T1441A C481S 63% 85%
CEO‐AOE BTK chrX:100611164 Not present G1442C C481S 32% 93%
BAG‐AAB PLCγ2 chr16:81946260 Not present C1993T R665W 65% 47%
B00‐C0F BTK chrX:100611164 Not present G1442C C481S ND ND
BAG‐A0B BTK chrX:100611164 Not present G1442C C481S ND ND
Deep sequencing of sequential specimens obtained at baseline and at relapse after durable remission
Dreger, 2013
High-risk patients
• Inadequate response to standard therapy– Short response duration– Need for retreatment with short treatment-free
interval• High risk of death from infection, CLL• Risk of transformation• Risk of aquistion of high-risk FISH, CE
What can allo HSCT do in CLL?
1. Cure 50-60% of patients2. Produce CR in >70% of patients3. Eliminate high-risk FISH abnormalities4. Restore normal immune function including
normal immunoglobulin levels5. Result in ability for patients with progressive
disease post-transplant to respond to therapy (? Immune ‘reset’)
6. Allow patients to live a normal life free of CLL
CLL is the enemy –not the allo SCT