akim rahman, a079 687 751 (bia dec. 6, 2011)

8/13/2019 Akim Rahman, A079 687 751 (BIA Dec. 6, 2011)

1/14

RAHMAN, AKIM4428 TRLE DRVEHILLARD, OH 43026-0000

Name: RAHMAN AKM

US. Dpn

Executive Oce r Immiaion Review

Board of Immgraton AppalsOc of h lk

5107 Lesburg Pike. Site 2000Fas Clcl. Vin 204

S/CE Oice of Chief Counsel CE1240 E. 9th S Room 585Cleveland O 44199

A079687751

Dae of hs notice 12/6/2011

Encosed is a copy of the Boad's decision and ode in the above-erenced case.

nclosue

Panel Members:Guendesbege, John

Sinceely,

Donna CaChief Clek

Cite as: Akim Rahman, A079 687 751 (BIA Dec. 6, 2011)


2/14

us Dn of .Executive Oce Imaion Reiw

Fas Church, rginia

Fe A079 687 751 Ceveand OH

In re AM RAHMAN

I OVAL POCEEDINGS

APPE

ON BEALF OF SPONDET Pr se

O BEAL OF DS Kris K SerAsssan Ce Cnse

APPLICATIO enan prceedngs

Dcison of the Board o Imigraion Appeals

Dae

D -120

Te respnden a nave and cizen Bangades appeas m e Immgran dgesdecsin daed arc 29 201 wic rdered m remved m e Unied Saes Te pariesave prvided argmens n appea Te appeal wi be dismssed in p and e recrd remanded

We review mmian dges ndings c r cear er b we revew qesns awdscren and jdgmen and all er sses appeas de nv 8 CF 003(d)(3)() (ii)

e recrd sws a n Apr 15 2003 e Deparmen Hmeand Secr (DS)persna served e respnden w a ce Appear (T A) wc alleged a e was adied e ned Saes n l 6 999 as a nnimmigran sden aend Oi Sae Univers anda e dd n aend a scl m ne 2002 g Apri 5 2003 and carged a e wasremvable nder secn 237(a)()(C)(i) e Immgrain and anali Ac8 USC 227(a)()(C)(i) (nnmmian viaed cndins sas) (Ex ) Onvember 28 2005 an Immgrain Jdge graned a jn min adminisraivel cseprceedings allw e ned Saes Ciensp and Immgran Servces (USCIS) epprn adjdcae a pending rm I40 Pen r Aen Wrer On April 26 200 ecase was recalendared prsan a DS mn a indicaed a e USCIS dened e

respndens I40 n anar 23 2007 Tereaer e DHS wdrew e ca alleganm e A and ldged a sbse allegain a e respnden aled mainan e cndiins is suden sas (x 3; r a 5458) e respnden rg cnsel dened e allegainsand e carge r a 3940 55) He ed a mn ermnae prceedngs e Immgrandge nd a e respnden was remvable as carged dened e min ermnae anddeeined a e respnden was n eligble r rele m remva ( a 59)

1 e recrd sws a e respnden was represened b cnse dung e Ocber 7 200cnesed earing Cnse sbseqenl ed a min widraw wic e Immigrain dge

graned n anar 25 201Cite as: Akim Rahman, A079 687 751 (BIA Dec. 6, 2011)


3/14

A079 687 751

Upon de nvo review, we agree with the mmigration udge's eterination that te responentis removable charged. A nonmmiant in the nited States who has been accorde anonmiant cassication that authorizes empoyment or who has been peitted to engage empoyment may engage in only such employment as has been authoze. 8 C.F.R. 214.(e ). nyunauthorzed emloyent by a ommigrat constitutes a ie to aintin status Id n F-1

student is generaly admitted r the dration of satus. 8 C.F.R 242((5)(i) Dration of satusis dened as the time durng which an F studet is pursuing a l course of sudy at an educatioainstitution appoved by e Service r attenance by reign students or engaging auhorzepractica raining owing copletion of studies Id. See als 8 CR 214.2(( 0) For astuent with post-cometion optiona practical training (OPT), te uation of status is ened ashe perod beginning when the students aplication r OPT was properly e and penngaprova, including the auhorized perod of postcompetion P, and ending 60 days aer he PTauthorzation exires. 8 C.F.R 242(()(ii)(D). A student must apy to the USCIS rauthorization r tepory empoyment r OPT. 8 C.F.R. 2142(()(ii)(A), (( )(i). See8 C.F.R. 274a12(c)(3) (whe a F1 studet visa hoder must apply r empoymentauthorzation). A sudent may not begin OP unti he date indicated on his or her empoyentauthoriation docuent. 8 CR 2142()()(ii)(), (( )(i)().

hs cae, he respondent had employment authorition r OPT r the eros omFebr 25, 1998, through Febary 25, 1999; May 14, 1999, trough Aprl 30, 2000; and Juy 30,2001, rough Jne 1, 2002 (Exh. 2 r at 6470). He did not receive any other eploymentauthotion cs (r at 7778, 85). he respondent testied that he graduated om Ohio Sateniversiy in Deceber 2000 (r at 64) From sometme aer auation until July 30, 2001, hewas working l time r the State of Ohio (7576, 79, 82-84). e also had time employmentwith he Sate of Ohio aer June , 2002 (Tr at 70) Notwithstaning the respondent's belief to teconary, either a pening epoymentbased visa petition nor an apication r ajusment of

status conrs work authoition r puposes of maintaiing the conditions of student visa status(r. at 7778, 83, 85, 103-104, 50-5) See 8 CF.R. 274a.2(c)(9) (an alien who has e aappication r adustment of staus ust appy r epoyment auoration) Absentcoesponding eoyent authozation docments, we are not persuae that the reference in theJuy 29, 2005, letter om the USCS to termination of epoyment authoration requeste orgranted psuant to 8 C.F.R 274a2(c)(9) ay be reasonably constue to mean that herespondent had epoyment authozation o the SCIS up to the date of that leter Moreover,e respondent testie that he never applied r eploymet auorization in connection with hisappication r adjustent of status (Tr at 77-78, 85) hus, we agree with e Imigration Judgehat the respondet admied to engagig in eloyent not authorized by the USCS and hat suchunautorized employent constiutes a ilure to maintain satus See 8 C.FR 1240(c)

(removabili may be estabished by amission of the responent). Tere is no ocumentatio ome designated school ocial to sppor a cotrary concusion. ccorngy, we aee with teImatio uge tat he respodet is rmovable a charge

he respodent makes a umber of due process argets i his brief on apeal, wich we ndare whout mert he decisio to iitiate removal proceedings against he responent in 2003 isa ater witin the soe discretion of the DHS See section 242(g) of te ct, 8 U.SC 1242(g).Simily, the aeged denial of the ght to conse at the specia regsation inteview with the DS,whch ed to he issuance of the NA, or enil of access to es nder DHS contol is beyon the

2Cite as: Akim Rahman, A079 687 751 (BIA Dec. 6, 2011)


4/14

A079 687 75

sce u sdctn See Matter ofHeandez-Puente, 20 I&N Dec. 335 339 (BI 991). heesnden admted, hugh cnsel, he DSs allegatn he esndens aenage n the N(T. a 39). See Mater of Velasquez, 19 I&N Dec. 377, 382 (B 1986). The ecd des ntsup the esndens cntenn n apea ha he addna allegan dged by he DHS wasneve seved n hm cunsel (Exh 3; . at 5455). We hewse nd n deec n the chagng

dcuments (Exhs. , 3). 8 CFR 239. 00330. We ae n esuaded tha he I213, Recd Deable/nadmssbe en (Exh. 1), was nt seved n the espnden cunse sthewse subect supessn. See Matter of Barcenas, 19 I& Dec. 609 (BI 1988). Inaddtn, the ecd shws ha espnden hugh cunse, and he DHS ny aeed tadmnsave csue ceedngs n 2005. See atter of Velasquez, supra The DSsl 200 mn ecaenda ceedngs ndcaes tha was seved by ma n the esndent,and the ecd des nt ndcae that he psed such acn. The esndents assens d ntesuade us cnclude hat the DS nennay deayed e esndens mmatnpceedngs.

thugh we agee that the espndent s emvabe as chaged, we nd tha emand s equedwth esect he ee whch the espndent s entaly egbe. he Immgan udgedeened that the esnden was n elgbe adustment status because hee was napved I-40 and any pendng I140 was edcated n he same bases as vsa pettns thahad been evusly dened (. a 8). Dung ceedngs, he esnden submed va eces evdence demnsae hat he had led seveal vsa petns n hs wn beha. See 8 C.F R. 204.5(h), () u evew he ecd eects ha the esndent led at east ee vsapetns n anua 27, 999 (ece numbe LI990825065); May 7, 2004 (ece numbeIN0415751079); and May 24, 2006 (ecep numbe SRC0618551154) (nt Mtn dmnsatve Csue daed Nvembe 25, 2005, ab ; Resndens mtn daed vembe29 200). Accdng he USCIS nne database, each these tee vsa etns s cuently

endng. hee s n ndcatn that any hese vsa petns has been dened n a na decsnby the SCIS (.. at 8).2 nde he ccumsances, we nd ha s aate the Immgatnudge ascean me ecsey he status he espndents vsa petns and deemne whahe ceedngs ae waanted wh espec he esndens ena adustment satus.See Matter of Rajah, 25 &N Dec 127 (BI 2009) (enumeatng a numbe cs t evauaewhen cnsdeng whehe hee s gd cause cnnue pceedngs awat he adudcan a pendng emymenbased vsa pettn).

he Immgan udge as deened ha the espndent was nt egbe vlunaydepaue because he dd nt pesen a cen passp (.. at 9). u evew he ecd des neveal any dscussn dung he na heang cnceng he espndens pass puses

2 he ecd ndcates ha a Fm -40 (ecept numbe SRC067455307) s led theesndents name bu s n asscated wh any alen numbe cnnected t the esnden (xh. 6,Reques vdence dated cbe 2 2006). The USCIS nne database shws hat a denance hs vsa etn was maed n Decembe 15, 2006. s unclea whehe the denal hs vsa en was the bass he DSs 200 mtn ecaenda the esndent'semva ceedngs bee the mmgan udge.

3



5/14

A079 687 71

vluntay depare3 With the tice f Appeal the espndent prvided a cpy f his renewedpasspQt whih was valid until Mach 3 201. On remad if the respndent still seeks vluntaydepartue the Immiatin Judge shud make a specic inqui as t his eigibili.

Finay we nte tat the respndent asks n appeal that we gant him Uited Sttes citizenship.

A pesn may acquie United States citizenship by birth r naturaliatin. e natuaitinapplicatin pcess is unde the sle uisdictin f te DS neithe the Bad n the ImmiatinJudge has any authty in such a matter See Matter of AcostaHidalgo, 24 & Dec. 03BIA 2007). any event we nte that the recd des nt indicate that the respndent can satisis buden f prve tat he has been awlly admitted t the United States r pemanent residencea preequisite t natuaitin. See sectin 318 f the Act 8 US.C. 129.

In cncusin we aee with the Imiatin Judge that the espndent is remvabe as charged.wever a remand is equied t evalate the respndents eligibility r relief m remval.Accrdngly the llwing rdes wil be entered.

OER: he respndent's appeal f the Immigatin Judges decisin nding him remvableas charged is dsmissed.

FRER OER he ecrd is emanded t the Immigratin Judge r futher prceedingscnsistent with the reging pinin and r the enty f a new decisin.

hee is a discussin duing the Octbe 200 heaing abut the espndents passprt elatedt ceicatin f his schl enllment (r at 994 9 99)

4



6/14

US PATT F JUSTCXCV FFC F AT VW

AT CT80 WST SPR AV ST 3-00

CVA H 43r

, f-;"> C

i (.j' \

r;_ -

n Th : ))))

ir:

Akm AHA n movl Pocn'

Rspondnt.Dockt: Clvand Non-Dtaind (CL)

Fl umb A079 687 75 Motion to rmnat o Dsmiss Pocdings

CHAG Sction 237(a)I )(C)i) o th Immgation and Nationaity Act

BHAF F TH SPT BHAF F TH HSo se Amy Scan Assstant i Couns

Oc o t Ci ounslUS Immgation & Customs Encmnt124 E 9th Strt Suit 519vand Oho 4499

AU A RDR

HSTY F CAS

Rspondnt is a nat and ctn o angadh who ast ntd th Unitd Stats on Jy 6999 hs pocdngs bgan hn th Dpamnt o Homland Scity (HS") d aNotc to Appa (NTA" th th Court n un 12 23 havng srvd th N A on thRspondnt on Ap 15 23 S hbt h A cargs that th spondnt srmoabl und mmraon and Naona Act NA) 2a) 1 (C{i)e maintainor compy t conditons o nonmmgant tatus) Id An -26 w d w t


7/14

h Courts orr om anuary 26 20 contans a tald summary of th hstoy of thsprocdings. I summa th spont appar at svra mastr canar harigs 2004 200 nlu wth a pror attoy n Jauary 200 Padings wr ot tak at ayof ths prior harng as cotinuacs wr grantd ithr to allow spont to nd counsor to allow tim r ajuicaton o Rspots -0 O Novmbr 28 200 th Cotgrat a joint motio to amiistraty clos sponts rmova procdigs submittd byRponts w attoy a cousl r DHS to alow tim r SIS to ajuicat th I0 h spondts cas rmaid aminstrativly clos t a motio to rcanar wasl by HS i April 20 J to th dia of spondts 40 nxt harg was hon Augst 2 200 At that haing pags wr takn and th spodt throgh consl,dnd agatio 4 as w as th ryg charg of rmovabiity spondnt asst h hasmaintad hs onimmigrant studnt stats sinc his last ty in uly I 999 Following thatharg o Sptmbr 23 200 HS sbmittd th -26 d at xhbit 3 Th 26 ists aaditioa agation howvr at th Octobr 7 200 harig HS mov to sta hav thallgatio b a sbstitt agatio 4 spodnt contiu to ny th algation as amnd

At th contst rmovabilty haig hl on Octobr 7 200 HS cad th spodt as awtss an h tstid udr oath rgarig both his dcatioa an work histo sic lastntrg th Uit Stats spondt's tstimoy s summaizd blow ollowing thathaing spondts attoy withrw om hs cas ad h has bn apparng i cot pro ssic that tim

Folowing th Octobr 7 200 haring th spodnt d thr motios whch wr aarss a id in an ordr issd by this Co o aay 26 20 Aothr mastrcada haig was h on Fbuay 8 20I spodnt broght to that haig a 9 i rspos to th Cot ordr of anuay 26 20 h apicatio had not yt bn dwith SCIS ad id ot ncud suppotig docmnts vidcing prima ci igibility rristatmt of hs stdt visa h cas was contiud to ach 22 20 r th spondtto brg vic that h is prima ci ligb r ristatmt of his studt visa

Foowig th bary 8 20 haing th ot rcvd addtiona lgs icldig a Motioto inat by th Rspodnt o Fbary 6 20 and a otion to Tminat and rantlif o arch 0 20 O arch 7 20I HS d proposd xhbts and th o March8 HS ld thir oppostio to th sponts motion to tmiat At a mastr calndaharing o arch 22 20 th spondt l a addm to hs otio to Tattitl Moto r Anaysis as wll as a aitional oton to rant i Th Cot

diat at th March22 20

harig that th rcor ws closdAt th March 22 20I harig th sponnt also tstid that h was unabl to obta anytp o lttr om Oho Stat ivrst rgarg h mata tt tatuRspt as a h has a br that OS would ot su a nw 20 bcaus owa not cssary h Cou closd th rcor a dicatd a writt ordr wol b issd toadrs rmovabiit and th pdg mto

rdr 79 687 75 Pg 2


8/14

V

The owg oumens we make a eee no evdence

xhibit

xhibi 2

xhibi 3

xhibi

xhibit 5

xhibi 6

xhibi 7

espoes NT ae Ap 5 23

ubmisso om esponen eceve by he Cou o Ocobe 2010 goupehb cosisng o 6 pages

-261 e by H eceve by he ou o epembe 23 21

ubmsso om espoe eceve by he Cou o uy 16 2

ubmssio om espoe, Moon o a a eef wih suppotigocumes eceive by he Cot o Febay 8 2011

ubmssion om espoe Moon o Temae wh suppog ocumes,eceve by he Cou o ebuay 16 211.

ubmssio om H eceved by he Cou o Mach 211

A he Ocobe 21 coesed emovabiy eang he esponde ese as he soe

wess espoen was epeseed by couse a his heag He ese ha he s eeedhe Uied aes i epembe 99 wh a F1 an a -20 o ae he Uivesy ofMesoa e esed ha s mos ece e was o uy 6, 999 h a F pusua oa 2 o ae Oho ae Uvesiy espoen esie ha he has eceive 2s omhee eies Uivesy of Mesoa Ohio ae Uivesiy a Coumbus ae CommuyCoege

espoe esie ha whe he epoe o H hs EEs egsao i 2003 he waswog Ohio ae Uvesy pusua o hs opoa pacca ang O ad he waso aeg schoo a ha me He ese ha he showe he H ocas his dipomacang ha he ha gauae om Oho ae Unvesy esponde he esed ha he

ha a -2 om Coumbus ae Commuy oegeespoe esed ha he ecev OP Decembe 2 and ha 20 was he he srcivd emoyme authorzaton. e esd tha he appld hs PT a empoymeauhozao bee he gauae n Decembe 2 espoe ese ha he eceivedmpoymen auhoao hee mes Copes o a hee empoymen auhoao cads aecuded he eco a oup hib 2 A e appea o have bee issue pusuan o OT

rr A079 687 75

1G IA i

Pag

M.f @ mMw Q : I;,.x= . . . M . ..j k CQ i;


9/14

sas and Responden esed o he same Responden tesed ha his last period of OTbegan on Jly 00 Responden acknowledged ha the last employment athorzato cardexpired on Jne 00. Respondn esed ha aer ha card expred, he was aendngombs Sae ommn oll nd orkn ll me r he sae o Ohio e esied hewas dong hs becase he had a pendng 40 and 485 Responden esed that he wasang compter scence corses r hs empoyer and was enrolled in n associate degreeprogram n comper science He esed he as no mantaning a corse load of hors ormore bt as receng crei r research he as dong a Oho tae nersty

Respondent tesed ha om ecember 000 to Jy 3 00 he was workng me r hesae of Oho and sad he had O sas Respondent sted hat he began taking classes agan Jne 00 Responden then esied ha he was hred becase of he Hd e receied iDecember 000 e esied hat he had preosly been working on a project as a stden hathe had compeed withn a few months of nishing his hesis e tesied hat he was paid rhs work by blic Ulies ommsson of Ohio. Noing ha he had no empoyment

athozaion card r the perod of Apr 000 o Jly 00 Responden was asked whatdocments he had hat athorzed him o ork drng ha ime Responden estied tha hisemploymen based case was pendng He esied tha he did not receie empoymenahoraion prsant o hs 485

Respondent tested hat he maintaned hors o corse creds om ecember 000 o Jly00 de o he research projec he was workng on Responden tested hat he is centlyagain a stdent at Ohio tate Uniersity seeking hs masters n pblc heah and sbmiededence o ha eec. ee rop Exhib

Responden presened wo I0s issed by Oho tae Unersy with the more rece one dated

March 00 tha ndicated Respondents expeced gradaon date was Je 0 004 eeGrop Exhibt Respondent also sbmied eidence tha he is crrently erolled in anohergradate program a Oho ate nersty eece Sepember 00

AAYSS

movbili

HS has he bden o esabsh ha he Responden s remoable as chared by clear andconincng eidence INA 40(c)3 (A. An -3 Record o eporable Alen was aachedo he Responden's NTA. ee hib H also sbmitted docmens showg the

Respondent is not n he SV Sysem hoeer apparenly hs name oes no appear o be nhe ssem See Exhbt 7 HS called he Responden as a wness a he contestedremoably hearng.

he sse bee he Co s wheher he Responden has mananed his sden isa sas sncehs ast enry n y 999 nder he regans a sden who ransrs to a dieren schooltho permsson or has commed ny oher oaon of hs stden sa sch as

Ordr 79 7 75 g


10/14

unauthorized empoyment has ie to maintain status an the Court must therere nd such arespondnt remoabe r iing to compy with his isa. Matter of Yazdani, 17 l& Dec 626BA 8) The ou has n authorit to einstat a studnt isa or othrwise rgie een atchnica ation f a stunt a ttu I h Rpondnt ttmon rsed seera aeasof conces r the Cou in regard to ioations of his status including whether he propertransferred to Coumbus State Community oege; whether he engaged in unauthorizemploment and whether he has contnued to mantain hs status since his time at ColumbusStat ommunity oege

At the contestd remoabty hearing th Respondent testd to attendng sera derentcoges and unersites to pursue seera erent degrees. he Respondent clame he wasssued an 20 to attend Coumbus State ommunit Collge and properl transed to thatschool espondent has now submitted to the out a cop of hs -20 om oumbusCommunit College indcatng his antcipated date of completion of studes was June 10, 2004S xhibt 6 This -20 oes indicate that Responnt propr trasrd to Coumbus StateColege ahough it s not clea whther he thn proper transed back to Oho Statenrst o has otherwse mantaned his -1 stuent isa status at OSU Respondent hasrepeated submitted eence that he is sti enroed at OSU hower noment n schoolalone oes not mean espondent has maintned compance with the student sa since 1999

Responnt testied that hs last empoymnt authoriation card expired on June 1 2002 Seealso Group xhbt 2 Respondent ther acknowedged n his testimon that he did not haemploment authoriation to work between April 0 2000 to Ju 30 2001 Respondenttestied that he worke r the state of Ohio om sometime in 2000 untl md 200 He fuhertested that at the tme he repote to HS n complance wth the NSRS pogram he wasworking a not attending school and this would hae occued n April 2003 While he testiedthat he beg his work wth the state of Ohio and ublc Utites Commission as a studentworkng on a resech project he tested that the work contnued after he nished hs thesis andhe was ater pad b the Pubc Utiities Commssion n regard to his work between Aprl 2000ad Jul 200 espondent teste that he beleed he was authorzed to do this work becausehe has an 1 40 d 485 pendng. Responent tested that he neer rceied emplomentauthoriation through hs -485 He fuher testied that the onl thee empomentauthorzaton cards that he receed were pursuant to OP copes of whch re include nGroup Exhibt 2 The cads reect a the Respondent testied to a gap n the emplomentauthoiation om Api 2000 to Juy 2001 The cards ther reect and the espondenttestied that the ast one expred in June 2002 howeer he tested he was workng in Apri2003 when encountered b CE Respondent testi again at subsequent heaings that hebeliee h could work ue to his penng 85 howeer he has also acowedged that hener appie r or receed mpoymnt authoization base on that pending 485ccording the empoment the Respondent ngage in betwn Apr 2000 and July 200 aswe as his empyent aer June I 202 wa unauhred emplymen Theere, the Cuns that the Responent engaged in unauhore empoment which is a ioaton of stuentsa status 8 F.R 242 Accoingy th out nds that the Rspondent ha eto maintain or comp wth the contons of his studnt isa and therere nds that algaton

Ordr A79 7 75 Page 5


11/14

4, a amndd n the 1 61 ha been tabhed by ca and convncn evdence. At th methe ou nd the Repondent mvabe a chaed unde A 37a)(1 due o hu to antan o comply wth the ondton o h nonmmant va

A ha bn epaned to the Repondent he h ha epeaedly ubmtted document hown

cuent enoment n OSU thee much moe to compance wth the equement o a udenva than enoment n chool and the Reponden ha no ubmted anythn om heDenated School Ocal DSO at OSU veyn he condeed to be n vald -1 atuA dcued beow the Repondent ha ed eva moton n th cae and n h moton hemae eeence to havn peented t out wh a ette om a DSO eadn h contnuedenollment a OSU See hbt 6 The documen ncluded n Exhb 6 ae ned by aaduate ude commttee cha and a coee ecetay The DSO dened n the eulatonand we he Reponden ha ubmtd evdence o contnun enolmen none o h cuendocument have been ued by the DSO o by any ndvdua authozed to adde whehe theRepondent cunl mantann h 1 tudn va au. See 8 .. 2143)1 denon o SO

ndcated above due to the Rponden tetmony eadn h peod o unautoedempoyment th out nd ha S ha met t buden o poo and utann the chae oemovablt. The out contne to have ueton about whehe the eponden haothewe mananed atu connuay nce 1 999 hoeve wh the cuen ecod heou not n a poon to adde no doe t need to detemne whthe any othe volatonhave occued

Motons to rmnt nd Grnt l

Snce the ou lat ode daed Januay 26 211 the Reponden a ed appoxmately veaddonal moon ll o he moton ae eenaly eqen ete tha he ou enaethee poceedn o an he Repondent ele.

Repondent has aetd n eveal o h moton hat the emoval poceedn weempovdenty beun. He has aued ha he wa tl n vald uden au a e mepoceedn bean n June 23. e has alteatvely aued ha he hould no hae beenplaced n poceedn becaue he had a pndn -14 and 48 a he te he wa placed npoceedn Havn pendn 14 doe no con any ype o laul tau ha potecomeone om emoval pocedn n ead to whethe he epondent ha been popeyplaced n emova poceedn, once DHS chooe to ntate pocedn aant an alen the oe o the mmaton cout o dtemne whehe tha alen emovable a chaed

atte o azdan upa at 63. In th cae the ou ha no uled tha he Reponden emovabe as chaed. ccodnly th u mut ode the Reponden emoed unle heetabhe ebt a m of ele. he te ou und tha the Repondentvolaton o tudent va tatu occud po to the uance o the otce to Appea

Ordr A79 7 75 Pg


12/14

Respondent aso cites Maer of GNC- r the proposition that his proceedings should be

ermiaed I& Dec 66 BI 998 I Maer of GNC- he Board hods ha heImmigration Judge is not required to terminate proceedings upon motion by OHS but mustisad adjudicae moios o ermiae o heir meris accordig o h reguaios Id ciig 8 CFR 9 The Cour has horoughy reviewed al of he Respodes moios ad

memorada he Cou wi address some of he specic issues raised by he Respode beohowever e if o addressd beow he Cour has reviwd ad osidered a of heRspodes argumes ad ds here is o basis o ermiae proceedigs

I regard o he Respodes ogoig cocer abou he deay i his case his issue ashoroughy addressed i he Cours prior order he Cour udersads ha he Respode owishes he had ped o he aegaios ad charges agais him back i 004 he he rsappeared bere a immigraio judge oever, as oed i he Cou's prior order heRespodes prior hearigs were coiued a his reques or he reques of his prior aoeysurher as discussed above, he Cour ds ha he Respode had aready vioaed hecodiios of his sude visa by 00 so whie his case may have bee resoved a a earier

dae if peadigs had be doe earier he oucome oud o have chaged herere heRespode as i o way prejudiced as he as esseiay aowed a addiioa 5 or 6 years oremai i he ied Saes ad o coiue o pursue oher aveues of reief such as headjudicaio of his 1-1 40 Fooig he deia of a eas e of his I1 40s OS properysough recaedarg of he Respodes case

I his February 6 moio o ermiae, Respode ses h some cosiuioa ad regulaoyvioaio argumes r why his proceedigs shoud be ermiaed Respode previousy,hrough couse ackowledged proper service of he NA herby makig ay alegaio of areguaoy vioaio i he issuace of he T moo or uimey Fuher, oe of he decs ihe N appear o have prejudiced he Respode i anyay Fiay, his Cour is o he

proper rum o address ay aegaios of cosiuioa vioaios uess hey are egregiousCosiuioa vioaios ha may jusify suppressio of evidece I his case, he Respode,hrough couse, previousy ackoedged proper service of he ad ped o he aegaioso asseio as made a ha ime ha he evidece submied by S such as he - assubec o suppressio herere he Cou ds he Respode cao o argue rsuppressio of evidece See Maer of V lasqu z 1 9 I& N Dec 77, 8 B 986arespode is boud by aoeys peadigs ad admissios abse a shoig of egregiouscircumsaces A he coesed removabiliy hearig, o objecios ere raised o he 1 ad he Respode vouariy esied a he coesed removabiiy hearig hich as heeidece preseed by S i suppo of he aegaios agais him.

The Respod her assers ha DHS is abusig is poer ad aig i acios agaishim however he Cour does o see ha hese aegaios are accurae or reeva i hesepceedis his arh 2 oo o emia the epod reuess aoased o a aegaio ha HS has vioad dera civi righs aws his is o he properrum r such a aegaio ad is o a bass r his Cou o emiae rmova proceedigs

Order A79 7 75 Pae 7


13/14

he Cou ds h s o bss o m hs pocegs l ccogl heespod's oos o T. 8 .R 9.

Rspode ld Moos o G R hs m cle hs o ebu 8 01 ch 01 boh of hese moos h Respode dces h he old lke he

Cou o g hm elef so he c sv h d Ss cludg he el gove Ihe moe ce moo espode lso sss hm ssues bsed o h pedgeclosu of hs house I hs moos he Respo pps o be sseg h ue o hssks, eghy esdece he ed Ss d oh cos h ou shou smpy g hmsome m of elef o udgs ol hve h uhoy o cosde ms h edelge o hem b he Aoe Gel h Immo Noy c ofW , 5 I&N Dc. 45 46 (BIA 009); se lso 8 C. 003(b The Cou s ouhozed o smply lef o Respod The spode hs h bue of poof oesbsh gbl some of ll sus o dse o o 8 C FR. 408(d

As dscsse s Ju 6, 01 o he Cou hs ege lehy quy seehes o ee hehe e Respode s egble m of ele The ou hseeed h he spode oes o hve fmy bse mo opos hs ed s o eb cello o mo o Pee se (EO4)s he does o he qulfyg s ued ue NA 40A(b)( I ) Whe heespoe hs pusue mmgo opos hough he g of vous - l40s s e ofexody bly, o -40 hs bee ppo hs me The Rspode s o lge l sus l -140 hs bee ppoe The Respoe s sseg h bse o heoe ssem oe of hs -140s s s pe hoe h oes o d h see hve beepeosly dee d hs 40 s sml o bs o o ees e hch soy e o sml pecee of dduls I hs moos h espoe hs coeo ss h he hs o ecee pope e of hs -140 hoeve he o oes o he

jusco o ee -140 A hs po s hee s o evce h spoe h ped -140 h s pm ce ppovble h Cou s he s o bss o ga hcoucs hs cse o llo djco of dol l 40s

The o h pevously suggese o he Rspod h he cos g o he hs ses esad A e me hs ssue ll ose Rspo s epesee by coseho oul he bee be o l evu d deme f c espoe s be osek esem Sc espod s g po s h Cou e hm do me opusue s opo De o he ou o d h he Respoe gd uuhozedempoyme he c he spoe hs cd m e hogh he lg of hs 40s -485 he ou dos o blev h s lk o scc sekg eseme

uh, he espoe hs o sbmd docmes om he DSO Oho Sees suppo of ees sm Accodg, s os o ppe hespod prma c egbe r reaeme o hs d i' sd on reordTee e o o he Rspde uhe oces t hsos.

rde A79 7 5 Page

% Dh! v


14/14

.

he heag hd o ugus 00 Respo aed he ha o fea of beg peseuef e o Bagash he a h me o s eags he Respod dd o possess opese a val passpo ha ou ao hm o gad voua dpaue ee Cou s ha a hs po he Rspo has o sashed egl a of elefo a sas h e Sas

s dsussed aboe he Co ds ha has m s de of poof i sashgalegao 4 as ae e 6 b a a ovg vee e Co he sha pope ameded he allegaos as he ae aloed o do so a a me gpoeedgs e 8 CR 00330 ad 8 CR 40(e) he allegaos a he bass a ae osse h he soe ag o moval led agas e Rspoe de 37a)({C)) e Cou he s ha h Respoe s movale as hagede o hs admsso ha h egag ahoz empome s he Co he sha Respod has o sabse gb a m o ee he Co as o ho o oe he Respoe moved o Bagaesh

RDES

ogl i s b ode ha:

. Respoe's oos o mae a Ga a Relf ae DENIED.

2. aual aegao #4 as saed o h 61 s SUSTANED as has be esalshe ba a ovg evdee

3 he Respoe s RMVABLE as agd ue 37a)( l )C))

4 Respoe is oed emove o aglaesh asd o h sole hage o he

lso ommgao Jdge

APPAL IGHSRspoe s b me ha he has e gh o appea h Cos eso o h oa

of mmgao ppas o o so he ms l o EO6 h 30 aea as hhould April 28, 0 f he m pod xps a o appeaP Jed ad eved e oad ofmmgao ppeas h so of hs ou becm s aBoard ofmmgraon ppas ms he o on o that h o sode s a op of h Rspods appea ghs ad sructios R. 0033800339 400a3 rder A079 687 751 Pge 9

.<

akim rahman, a079 687 751 (bia dec. 6, 2011)

Documents