akat ir 'andyas ukiiidarepo.komazawa-u.ac.jp/opac/repository/all/30239/rkz041_4... ·...
TRANSCRIPT
1REALLOCATIONOFLAI0tR:JPROCESSINNOVATIONSAND
R UNIONPROMOTESTHECASEINWHICHALABOt
AkaT
Ab
J
t tsrac
ir
re
hta
her
o
u
her
fferi
r
korer
rogrel iogcalecuc
l
e
iinhtc
d tnusry
-
i
d-an
fispec
hsearc
ci .Whns htmo lp ssoccusw et ea
ma gd nofw sd s&m t
meu
sitvaoroce
ic
f k hworerswe
i honwit
np ssi ninno
h decond ter hficons
dteid Wtnusry.nln
nt ec erll noio
itvao
toca
hi We
ea
fl nt sp nno no ei nalei ssi ni yo h e mi
h
roce
d terions
d tnusry.
her
paperw,
eac
hwe
in
is
ff teren
baour
h
i
I
d
o
toetprom
ionh ll tereaocatt taesiliac
lyias
sitvaorocehw ekorersfw np ssi ninno
nitvaorocehatsulinaysihTkorers. sa ss sttp ssi nigge nno
sl ilogcaprogreltecfopey mo ssi
d i S dtnusres prea,
fwer no
tecorssuc, teworiotfn
m b
ds ha oma ndn ki sesi na
ioll teaoca
i iunonze
nu
ht
less-
RODUCTIVITYTp
"daiIkiu'anlera dY 町as
af k h kipeoworerw oworsnil tcuarytapar
hgh f iepresenceoaunoni ton,tva mi
l ilogcaprogre
ioll teaoca
l ltgenera ec,
hd terions
d Itnusry n.eac
i Wspaper,
inff teren
h
i
I
d
nt ec er no
hi mo ssh innuenceT terenBidasa
ssiizeproce nnolif k teroworersu
i lcuatar
f lony
korer.
iitvh d teprouctproveim
Ap rt
yo
h tersecors.to
ioll teaocahitesClulr ,ter
ionsnhi fennuenceou
ion
nit
fitcaa
b fecauseo
LClssi Nu 2,21J,24J,6J;bm er
IJI.INTRODICTON
EJ
acnd tnusr
yto
ac
klei
i
l
ne hi yadone hw
forminssdloehesecausihT sisb et em sa
321
dloes.ataitcedpre dby sndrdm
tns.roveiitvd tprouc yi memp
駒揮大学経済学論集 第 41巻 第 4号
llntel u yi sa sw hh hp y Wigr ndw
h l lSecnooge.
iitv
ne
ns hc
ig
dnl
itkorer
toi
j tusdtoa
d itnusresw
d itnusre
h k idteseworersarerane
h i ktereexsworersan
lnon,onh d trouc
di 仇b hoda wtmn
I
i b tsurvveecause
h towever, ,
ucⅠ
h h tesorIty n.logwtmolechenetto
owever,d dHere.ionsnc
).h tape7C,9 r6
d luaiivdnfi
korerfow
dneritvaofproceittnaoleihed tericons mp me no ssi nunno
te
itrc
rols
asydner
9
he
har
luenc
tages,
a
fn
wt
eg,..
la
st np rl se cw re( Bl d1mi nc
iizn
i
Ho nt ni ya ne gw ymayaop molqua
fale
averll no ymayh easmir i eu mme
i
i fonone
lroe
cono
he
hi dt tenrouc
lonspa
f k Tworers.
owe
i tnnuence
ower
htauVe
io
iuno
lweverg,
toca
i lunonsaso
ea
hta
h
i
t
he
tew
h ipasze
ii honslteahlysea)
iona,
2loa
d i ite eunonza,
Acmo hi ndVi e( na er pb eenAg na nt 001 dto
dtmi ng ndi dtlhcaca
lgu,
lec
e
iaseb-lliks
lldeifks
ttueid i d bt tnusresproucesus
ivewbt texh d dtesanarTy. ookh lecnoog
bira
a
iliqu
nd
dleaOrSCteItwo mO nd
ion.d i it tes eunonza
tyilqua
peyfersoeachenu
toixs
iiitesav ,
r
t tnac
ee tb hs ge
ndt m b ht
rocessherb haourw e
vic
itooca
h
ea
icase
httaeiliac
nw hhoi
sterll nofl nt eisp
i ftsoenunemp metnloy
leveiitvd trouchbtoservma nma scmo etep y l soarnageri honw e,t
korers.
ifnor
w
inloointaepar gandp
mheT.itylnequa ye
ro
lpoye
iitrranniitvh d terproucit
da
yo gp mo
agtewii honslteahllayseJ9991 )a d te r p b een w e ine
?ncreaseyiiitvi d il d tonsoessocaproucitd h dtasesunerw acon,
gtobirrnlb Rfaour e.f
iitvd tproucheteror yo
e,
t
h feret,intepa
ioh ll tereaocattgessug
gtos ra ga ornd
no he
mheTences.idaged ieucn
ncreas
nr gw 飴r ye
ei
f i iounons
hdt nita nea
lroe
hsowe
nuhtefIrges. mb
inlooBts ofi mp
S tpresen.h lb itaaaourunot nl
hbiruiliqu ms
derW ispaper econs,
ioitdtacon
I
hd Wgoos.
n血i 血e
nf
lb iaourunonsoff fteecoheT
Ac u (mo
hnesw
k i tworersncreases,
dlte,
i tsnves
i
h
lr
Itn.
h fe
ic
lg
lpoy
e
nh heunem me smo
concem
dtee
ingt m' me
mi he
ee
biruiliqu m eme
fihsSncreases uc.
Wsepapers e,t
it
ftso
i lnequa
lresu
yi ha ts
he
itssumponheat
ioll teaocad tnusrynlnitovaoirm ni yo ?Rno ei ft txenohltoon
tnaloy
depen
foehssa'hid tenusrytonb ltuasoitrmovaon
nd sn yontee
re mp me ndt
nah f i Wepresenceoaunon.tsonyaswe,lgolechenef k h toworersw ouse
processi
wtmo lla h e
ionh tepropor
421
i
t
)da
hgninmioh fepresenceoaui ton,
ion.
R(T iIera,UOB
tzamo liteswageequaproh ieunont
NOFLAOIT
ssi tnnovaizeproce
f k hworersw en
lik torersub ferownum
OCALLAENSAND ROITOC SINOVANSERP
b feroum
tk dorerexpensoneu
・ktowor
♂E.ac
h terornoh htoosew e
hw ni
t.
fio
lrf
tropor
a
k teworersa
hT
l feveso
t
iitv
qua
lrm
-
d trouc
las
or
1is
ht,
pey
lrm
tra
kworer
kor
h l iltecnoogcaprogress
-a
hw
)
htce
t
t
a,
h tou
k equaworersa
korersa
少 1-
kworer
a
is
wi ep yl H-ndL
re l;A ndB oe ypll
ndw rema da nd nofH-yp mA
t nd( 4 soft Lw katf B. ep no
so ow atf (
mi
nIII, ed eb kc ndu odsst om a eormo es
iasesntt
t
lppdlea
us
ur
ase
V d lweeveo,
rlenc
iotec
h
Its.
hemo
idl ervsa me e
ndrd 飴c nS nI nda yine po mo oc
iscuw
iuno'
tte
dte
io
a
i
pro
S tec
tsa
l
'
dlIe n.hb ieascht moII ktwesec,iontec
henteelsd tnusry.hal ni ti rtftei Weaod etsp nap mihoareseniunobaourichw
V wep deirov
ikpewo ssrerty- 少
he
-
hau
l
A
fpe-
A,
ty
B.s smet tt
fB m Sis1
nlnfferilrkorerw sa mSd yindf so
ttoat
i fonotpropor
H,L;he ln
H
iontec
nSIs.fllasoowdze
l doyeneirektearbaousint rma ndh suhel mp
su rw hp yisi .InSdncrease
ng ma
iitvd troucich
ks.r
dne
re
ion
i
itdcon
ldconcu
=idnexe,
ta
lre
isir
wde
t-
ions
iotpropor
wec rt yp ffmS dbot so yi
nofA ef ta hyp ms ndt no
gP ssi
d terwo
ei htec yo
roce
ii dbconswe yp y -
fiitvd trouc
f k idesoworernexe,
hic
t
hnw ep
nno
ashd terC ions
fll loown
l・pei h tsoreryhftno
-k iorersspewty- 1
loyehtk itew mp me
htatAty.inoudt ssume
ioh teproport
hte
lrfence,i Hve.d trouc mS
ingsexpab isusne'kworerhek trers, ssi nd
pety-
ioh teproporT.om
iitcpae
l loyn
tar
eis
iesp
mp gWO
irm
.THEMODEL
1 Thwo dth fekrerane.
ⅠⅠ
II
rh lbeaour
irm
i tes
h
lp
e
kworersup
ntef
ma
i ltscreelnalbaoura,
nofL
fo ndcnO yd yc
airfpety- msre
ion.tva
no
ni
ioll treaoca
i ispapersorgahT
io
izelma
h teproporthat
k iworerssnor
dtan
acaitirhT
a
efm w hv nc
nda
hk Wworers.
fkorer)t-1♂a,)t nd( 少 w soBpetyf H
521
hfm a hresownirk iorerneacfeow
駒津大学経済学論集 第 41巻 第 4号
ype ka mB m b htyp
ABLE1T
fersoeachenuT.lrftor
T
Lw
el.lTba
t
in
ond depenh f tereore,
siitvtc yi
rocess
ll ioown
drprou
toesno
ighet,
i t tsconsana
lrfta
¢)
mA nhhe gp
ndd
F horeac
ks
hw,
tht
f ktaoworer
(.
H ow
Weassume a Y>y>1. at
)
h t teoupuor
lrmf
irm
り
jheachり f k ipeoworerneacb ferohenum
FirmA (t) Fim β (1-
wokrerH (4) f¢ (1
wokrerL(1-♂ ∫(1-♂) -i)♂(1
)ttiitv-drouc (1-yf
itouny.izel
f kworer
isnor
kor
iitv
nno Mo H w sf kworer
Ldhe tprouc yo
h f kt teoupuoworer
ireover,
L Tdtmyp mat,lrf
ion.
feo
dBt tgenerae ecause.
tva
hte
i
t
igi heveshac hpet yw Hkorerh ltaonposSup
inghtmacO f hl2eoeac.,iiTbavh d teprouc
Y;th
in
is,irfk torsaH hw, ow mAkorerfow
B Ly;ndt
i k d tngworerprouc, hssownt
korer
iiv
h ftaow
T
ais,
htcma yi
ABLE2T
Fim βFirmA
YwokrerH
h hrougievei hsac
i
korers
sawage
fwioll teaocahkt trerances,ircuSU dner
k l tworersvounar
血e eCwoms L er1 no〟1
dt
ndf
tyi isun
amkrerde.P iero
ha
Iitongwk
li
eriissoj
ycng
n dnmaa dmo lWo se
bos.jlng
ccLteuI.
I
2 Des o
i
ingi knueworoc tonf idoperohb i ieegnnngt
)daNOFLBOUR(T iIera,AOITAOCLLAERNSANDOIT
.山tup
OC SDNOVAJSERP
ma goinhtchierto
i tpencursacos.try
idpero,tfh b iie egtta m ngohe
fet eoyp
d tenoesi lveya,k trsrespec,korerw wo ndr
hel te,
o
cco gt
ittraege
At wo wo
ttesmef rtoq ttef ndmoeo Wo sp es st
uc
ursu
t
mi Awo mOma omo oa
b
ew oo omoea yt n fdandp
it :opons
krer
iescrwlge ssi sd es hawo
ln
n.
on
f
v
lr
xpre
k h trersave
i tscosca
tves
h
n
a
a
o
2,
irm
h
hiu
krerw
vttps
o,
ffshi .erpayo
irm
h
a
tze
korerw
t :msances
in
h
ix
dr
h
icrcu
a
a
T
skrer '
hshrougthi t teroupudteiivk doreraw hNa
Olrffptyttabo he eo m tj
)
)2(
(1
)3()LB,C-ALw,,( +wWL, +〟 x1A+ ma-
1 )4(i
heh teotf
)HB,C+W-HAw ,,(
1 )A,C+WH-HBw ,,(WHB+ ma+〟 1 x,-BH,V
htenob ituscrpeconi trsatge,'krerswa hef nds ds sd et
:fllsootteir na ws
LA,
lsvaue'krer
C+W
ewL Ca,kreriresichw, hh wo n b
)5(α-
B-,,L
We
Sliovng
lr.lricons
xlA.
d fer
5
tx,
b llarganng.
lebpro
Ne we Af ndmS m a
mf A
maWL
(
w+〟1 max(+BWL ,-
1 + max+〟1
hed t tenoes wo
h fen orexa,Traollgannbsar'korerhewd ttenoe gpwe Sa. m p
eors .T ollemo efhvesh
1w芸, AX(Y-wH,A)
heichirff minw ht
1
WHA,HA-,V
V
V B
LA,
L ,
hhichw
Vi t tsconex,
h te
h
h
i t tscounrae.
I
d tenoe
krera
h det
nt
stewo
wo ndt ypeo
imfor
W
ll iowngcわh fedtsilye) :ge 'skorerhew♭tri fonsitdon wa
721
駒揮大学経済学論集 第 41巻 第 4号
wH,A -aY )
)
6
7
(
(
)8(=a
isltt t toaoupu,lrff btersewik dworers eenfm S
kworersa
dTze.ixreiitvd taverageproucl dt t toaoupuan
re
ya mami he
)9(
verageffec
h
o
dne
oe
ze
kworer
ix
Jpe
-e
y
t
a
iitvd trouc
kworerswor
lrft
verag
or
-peyan
ence
korersw-pey
sd snta ta
.H ,a ep y ismamidu rtef
・a llt Hw ka mA;llt
dt L ka
A;yp L
inglloow
B;lmftak kworerswor
WI
W W BL,
/ll.
=AL,
l leves.hi t terouputtoi lonatagesareproporw'korersencew,H
tyiivd tyerageprouc3A.ⅠⅠ
=ay
-peyfak Iorers.-eftoionh ll teaoca yp Hw llt H
A;
1tanorkworersw ka yfm.
lmft
Y+(11¢)
L-enoftyp
irmft
d trouc
S丘 ma mo
-
ll :ows
eep yoyp Ht
)
f
he
isa
mariyd m i dbyt
iitv
t,mp at mA nt
ne
t tupu
ir
tee
f
u
ht
l
ixm
l doye
Because
ipr
lttoa
e
Qma 少r-
ioll tocahtt,tonra
tyiiv
lttnusoacos
B
d tprouc
yc s ea
mi t.
i :onsit tsua
-e・a llt Hyp
orkorersw-pey・a llt H w ka
ltt t tsoaoupuierof iareneaclehenwlb i t ttaoursconsan,f hp di
821
tiliitsuhdetfI yo
)daiINOFLAB R( ,T ieraUOOITAALOCLERSINOⅥt NSAmOIrNSECORP
NCHMARKCASES
rs.
ions
eed
it
exc
baou
ii dtcencon
nofl roccu
ht tages a
s
we,
e
i lcu
ar
tar
,
i Inon.
d tenoe
avirtoichas
i itzao
de
l-equaage
ions
hewd ter
Wtx,
icons
Ne ec hec nw hb hf eau np art ei msh r
nr nt
B( dby面) esta
korersfagesowhewi tscase,h
ehai tvetncen
k iorersrecevew
havea
a,llw
B n i ocng
hets
henboswje
tyiivhi d terprouc
ha
bb tosecauseje
B cng
eincashed terions
B
ydtseeiencCl: yi m血e db
irver
nr ec
iouninl ndt nw ha nl ne yfm .P S treen
ionw,
S
ttepresena
iunoichh ieoneP S treenaSo
ffurarenecell) yassa nds
lrmfta
irmfta
haoinc ocng
ty
i tveten
p.Wo ek frerso
haven
na mnyfiagesizewlqua
he yl leves.iitvi d trproucttoi lonatarepropor
eH
irmf
ioi fonsoumtgura五ouscon
Bone,heunbyt ni
ioll teaocahhet, nterfimr
.l ilogcaprogress
katworhw o
・onheutl foeo ni 2I
Ihint lscaseony,
f keorworerhaofrohepayotfiis,htaT ff mjbcng H
a(10)nd(
ntoe
ioitzalageequah b feasenceowInt
yptk forersow
he
ase
r
ou-
i ltonnun
noh f iereore,
cos
T
tofc gtOWOkatt
nt ni ,he nc
id:eifs
III.B
oc riderva
E
hn
ions
ic
T
hw
Wo y Lpetk frersobos.j
dze.ixbtageo eforaveragew mami
ioumh ieresnotenWh
ni tssaioitOdn
Ⅲ .1 No iumom
m ena
he gC
ni
ln
hesa
flloow
its
t
ltecft texeno
lrto
tossan
i ions.ⅡI
nc d也e mo
2 Un nb hrmS
ioil tsocad
-C+αy >αγ ⇔α(Y-y)>C
y丘rm
lrm
92
hos
1
a,d tenoe
:sllowわf
A( dbyw)ndt eatfltfrma
駒揮大学経済学論集
sosha,
tssaioit
ndtec ti
ni
s・ecause excLbosb t eedje
ld:eifsOdnhfll leoowntf面+ di gCh f lb i llC. tereoreaoursreaocae,T
dlesar
baou
tahreasonswhet
nofl
ysnd dmo
第 4巻 第 4号
Y+(1-♂))
1
wo satf A enoi etocng
ha
ha
atfmB egn&mjbcngoo
ivtncen
iaht,
hav
lr
lrmkrer
kworersFor
irideroI.l ilogcaprogresslecBotifene mtmo np 1,fmB
読-α(
面-α(Qy+(1-4))
¢
in
rin
korer
lloow
ilveyw,
h
t
T
eAirBrwage oighitabbtosje oo na he mfmA.ltma L
B. ef ougf
mtspresenoinoichashd terionsionw,tsecis ec ec nw ni dyin丘ei hau
ioll teaocanf herort
W-W>C
ioitdon
tns.provemiicenc
o
ffte
u-no
btonsosr
hempredwiht nit
ythani uc yI metu
a
lp
co
im
omaghitabboha
ierve
ca
ha
h
ic
I
hw
ca
fir
nt
hd
n cng
mA n cngej stoo n tew eB
fiissonhTase.nc eo
諭- -W-
t
hw ere
01 hec>¢> ,For
ZVI.PARTIALUNIONI
sasmallb
lrmkorerw,f iperob i iegnnnttAfageowoheuff toers nina 面. he go d2 nfHi
fm
;bosjhiertehcang
bbto u,jhanges〝C エd ;toesno
:d dereiconsmsre
bto
attpae
1. ndLhHa
2.
eisW
α¢(Y-y)
ATION
risstrong,
β,
B
面 .
;toesnobbto u,jhanges上C 〝d 3.
bos.jehcaLnorHhertine4. ng
031
)daNOFL OUR(Tihera,BAOITAOCLLAERNSANDOITOC SINNOVASERP
ber
n
n
In
krers
r
krer
np m 3 eu nw ecngsb etea nofw
h
korers
lqua
-
T
tor
io
y
ag
ll toca
pe
flm B,th o b yp L o
-
las
f
e
io
t,h
s
hht
hgeca
ltanum
k erer
1
面・-
ln
T
a
tropor
ag
(
h
ecaus
h♂(
t,
i
e
a
me
ha
♂(lt
)
korer
hepayo
w
t
ag
-
ino
-t e
1
ln
krer
tes
fero
ins
1
)
becaus,
,
oe
tem
kttae orers
L kitllo 訂wa yp wong ng w
te
H H siwo srma wo
mB Lndt ftstng ep no wo
L mB1np eo yw ew ee sa.t
Hayos
I
Thes e.
hca
s
I a
L mB ei oα.eo ywo ew ept
i
m 2becaus,
dcorresponngtowo nT
hca
lr
beco
tpae
f
ABLE3T Ho
llledf
)61()
H::上 α面,
h ltteoanumTs1-♂.
-peyep noftiotroporhT.♂)t
ws.lloわi fagesas
inghtacmheacf
b fo ehtani tonsitdcon eedt ul
rsinfm B iir
.I snt sebe ecau,iscah
iwu nwnoheneT.
lrfi tsa
l3e .ba
rke
at(1-
y・諾
irfi tsa
hsownittsraegesare'krers
♂)t-
α〔号諾
d terieconsbirumili Won,ieequt he
¢)+(11
♂-1
)+
wokrerH ss,ttraeg tyaflrm B D htonocan
ge, H :面一,L :-C+面一,
Change
H:--CC++aaYL..
H :-C+ Ya上: αe
wokrerL ttssraeg, tyaflrm Change
D htonocang
i bssuschtIn
hsV.I I Na
ft -ypeo
(11¢
'korershewtsrabirumiliquSheteitt traegesS ob Nahe
駒滞大学経済学論集 第 41巻 第 4号
iltoaes
e1(H:ng;L ng
3ses,
i
oll gc
hT
a
H: αY>面
t
L: a>a
ho
′
0>L Cfollmt gt wstec o sv.ait,
ssump ,hi nn
+
+
htoca
hca
C
C
(H: L:;ca ng on ng
-
:hca
-
scaseca
d
ehtoca
e
e
t
hca
h
hus
hca
d
Fro
i Ton.
Fro
lown
t
2se
3se
asc
f
a
ca (H:on ng;L:ng
mt ri
hetr,ooccui tscasehF tor.birumiliqu
htenr inlteaiotdoni
.birumiliqusNahehebteto
)12(
.birumiliqu
li rises.tnequanowigi ya
a(Yll-)C ¢< =Xlα(-)γ1
sheits)e Nahe
.birumiliqu
h fte, oll
Naheshe
llde.
its
if
)e
α+C Y>面
.ieslgtoLimp c>0
-H:
L:a> +C- a
eedtob ulfeionsnitdon
inlteaiotdconhe i nr
sheits)e Nahe
C-+αY
inlteaioti
Fro
h decon
mt
T nr
′
>′
C
面
-
H:
L: +面 >α
gtoH
nequanh flleoot, wigi lity
231
inlteaiotdconhe i nr gtoH
i)daR(T iIera,UOBNOFLAOITAALOCLERNSANDOITOC SDJNOV
mt
ASERP
Fro
)42(= x2
eitrsw,F
)52(
)82(
)92(
biruiliequheit tcerze m.
.birumiliqu
)y)t(-I-Yt
sheits)e Nahe
¢> =X3 ・
+(llt)tc )1-y(a
mt
mt
troper
htnocaca (H :on ng;L: ngdoehtoca
i feso
d
Fro
Fro
4se
.VI 2 P X
C-H :面> +αY
)1-Y(a-C
haic
i2x ,For
i fesotproper
l l fnavaueso
soi tneaeL dlteuse me x,wh hcra
xI ft
C-L:α> +面′
gtoH,
L,
¢> xl.
¢> a(-It+c
gto上,nr inlteaiotdconhe i
inlteaioth deconi nr
inglteaioth deconi nr to
¢<x 3・
:0-h iteemfid teni yt
331
駒津大学経済学論集 第 41巻 第 4号
α(x t=.
x2l=t1
4t-11・F rX3,f -
y
(( ) ) i 0: tsses o, ,
l2
Cro
C-)1-)03(X=
α(γ-1)
-1:fJ
,hus
I
T x2
)23(x 3 1=.1 -
α (γ-1)
las
:fJ-1
h Xus,
I
T 3 oc
)33(E11-x3l=
rosses(1,1)・
fi
n
d ten
s
ieS decon w, yc
ig
Forh l fesopesotionsonitdon x・ x2:
sgs-in (34)
)13(1-
((a(Y ・-1)-C)(Ca(y-Y)))
431
TIONSANDREAL OCATONOFLABOUR( ,T ieraILROCESSmlNOVAP
3:XFor
)daiI
sgsin-s(igna(y-1)-ci
at∈[ ,♂∈[01,]01, h fereor]T.we re
ma Sf
head ter
わa
icons
idrzebesum
f
iescan
a
h teseproper
he
te,
iidvdst ree a .I
s.llow
n1.iotP iropos
-1>C Y y ss) >a( - )if a(YI hen
・aa
ldeifsta ,t
re
x2
tssaa(yll>ci) d tesiivhenldte,ifs X3d he
lopeshes1i,ecause
he
)a,
ich
11,
ieasitexsar
( ndb Y>y> ft es
nw ht
Becausex2 a 3ndX Cross
herehei tve,tipos nt dsconbiruiliequ mi heseioneit dbyt
ines.
a
l
re
an)w,11,
0-.t
( ecr,ig
ioi tsques
c
h
W
ter
h ihi hesh x2
nbyi
ross
ihc
dtocae
ein
hnw
to
i
i
ha
i hons
ve
h lterea
0r
i itgantnves
X3?Ginttb hl sc
gt pi
s l
2.itonP iropos
wans
-1/ s s)2 iIf c>a(Y henideifsta , t x3 x2
)53(
fIbaove ・
531
駒揮大学経済学論集 第 41巻 第 4号
x3・baoveil dtsocae2xhenldte,ifsa(Yll)/2>ci tssa
ihch
nindepenesa eed goren dd
.htem
ashlndeions,we c ro y t e ie c n wlePXeam
i btpseweeni honsh ltereat
l(H :
2i 1gures,,
uc
iFnhesown
i tsnos
ionsarttua
om hl
feotrt
e
ine,ih
d htonoca
itsooh tecos
(a
B tecause.birumiliqu
H : ng;Lgh heyp
tnodo:
fno
kworer
,as¢
sbeco)ehtnocado
lrmkorerolbtalfro efrw nfH i
L: ng me
hantarger
ioh teproporW.birumiliqu h ent
lrmfro
However
kyworeritaneh beoneoto
B.
db H mf
bleoheareaT wX
lfebtalii ftssnopro or
・igurFinii hsssownhT・ el
iscase
h ieses
o dmo e u g a
Y 1 1>(Yll)/2>Y>y h- - - nty. ,
eedy. y.
I
T4
d3We
n
d toesnoexc
lsnttnsrae
.
In
T
an
ss w tts lg
nd
hrap
on
evera
l lf teveocosa,
hahoitoniropos
ireah teeni i iilTtscasesrva.h re
hilsowa,agew ndt
ashNetsme he
lai iagessil iaunonwthiieni tncreases, mirt
;htnocange
mo
3 N me mples
l ilogcaprogre
ilrcaexau
ltec
V.I
lblseow.hd iteeatliexpan
>a(yl1)
h ieunonk il tworerssow,
C>atshNe asme he
Y()h bcange eco
doH:baaovexl(
bos.jk hworercanges
beco)ehtoca
bu
d
lr
e
-e
hca
t
ng;L:on ng
yp H
Li mA,nf ti spti
ssa hendt
aeY,sischt
T-1).
ephesT
A:aseC
>
CaseB:
a(Y-1) C
Y
631
heate,h fere
S
T
het
A・ or re
Nahe .birumiliqu
i)daNOFL OUR(T iIera,BAOITA
・nd Where3x ,a?2xlx
ALOCLERNSAmOITNOVANISS
・T pb ween
-
teii honsh lterea1・igF
OCERP
e
hs
son
la
heuag
h
t,ino
i fscase ora,
eco
ihfr
hI.
e
tever,
hca
hk i toworerssa,
r
korer
e2 nt rg
;L: ng)b mesteNaH w
eumBnwniH ei
1.02.-C05.,
02.
1i0 古gu.2T0 4../)1- i6.0ii hsssownh nF
41 a., -15y,. -Y
Y(
ehaod(a,are¢a ma H ‥ ontcngndas llt
-petyf
Fo
ioteproporlaBecausea.birumiliequ
iism
rg no
A. rwirmkorertt tracagw ea sw Ltof
)1(y-aseCa C: >C>a
駒津大学経済学論集 第 41巻 第 4号
ndX3,Wherea,2・igF
fyoitlih bbeproattenoeD,
ndd
ium
a,
sp
ftilih bbeproattenoe yo
hayotxpece
e
h
xe
ha
iilt
o
bbroa
jf
fareao
4.0
hT
ttsraegin
-y),
mi de
gthe yo bcng a
oasq. ep y tatt
hee dp ffistes
ff fersromii dgureifsh3Tre.briliqu
1TherelationshipbetweenXl?x2
Y-1.5,y-1.4,a-0.5,C
18.i0guinF
8.01.=
6.ii h0sssownhT
h itereexssant
2.0
Caseα(D:1/ YY-)2>C>α(
hta
hc
igureF 2int
ooskworer
korerw
H
L
eam
ngs
h ttesraeg bhsencoy
dio
ht tw aever
)63(
)daiINOFL OUR( ,T ieraBAOITAOCLLAERNSANDOITSINNOVASEORP
αY一面 -C q= -l -
W -W
)73(
boveh
ugScaeing
Stea
・Almo h仇e ionsitdcon
hieriehhositcoexswbosj itht ew ormanint
olli fsas
hant ts
s.ow
leiBstaioitnaoht,
t tneres
mbec
iissanihT.birumiliqu
ywihr dtow Lkoreregartitlh bbeproaill tary,
面 P=
αTT''-
′ C-α-
nthea aofmi
血e Nahe
xe
S
mi
i ionss
re
is
I
tequa
de ubimriliqu
5y.forit toacunk dorers
mantesme
maye yma on mlnw nywhlixpa
ah
ish
i
b Tos.
re
j
ehaocnghkorersww,
931
C
駒津大学経済学論集 第 41巻 第 4号
・T pb eenXl
- . - .
tew
4a,1
ii hons
5y,1
h lterea
Y
3・igF ndX3,Wherea,x2
1.・0-05C.,
)
-
0.己
heecoehtocad
占;e.
korer
0hca
ilsoww,
4.0
h tecosB tecause.birumilh iasequ
Case
N
a a(H : ng
L:on ng)b mestH
(YE:- irtnhy)>C.Tee eare 1 _
ninwageflltasouoheu2t,
fttac,he
b H i idos encenpero. ,
ha
jhcanges
korworer
lfebta
kh woreus,
li ftsnopro
toss.
It.itny
nc T Ltocng
80
ioil tsocak i dworerncurs in;bosje
i)daR(TiIera,UOBNOFLAOITACOLLAENS DRNAOITAV
nttporaiismt
SNNOSEORP
ase.iuno- nc
e,h ferei idTnonze.ltpar
lbaour.fo
yu or
ionh ll tereaocatt taesiliac
i lonaith dtera
f
korer
nnuench
u
iresence
irv
ecaus
ls
flowerer
lias
iotnnova
d i S dtnusres prea,
i ht t tsonra unonsaveasron,
lyproce,
d itnusres
roce
e
tewor
her
h f i iereoreunons,
Btrsecors.
d i Ct tnusres onsequen.
ich
iot
t
ilTa.
k tesac
id tnusr
t tpoen
fnor
i iunons
a
s
har
yinw ht sp ssi nma od twei ya eo sw
nnwi mayl
si ma ndn ki se yb eo ei eona ft
nohe yc gp nt
mo ki ssi
dt
tk ies
hesa
he Si l ntor Hkworer
ites
f
4me me ng meterra
tporaiismhtaxts
-
lgure
i honw en,
fset
i ttasu
b taou
texre
l teraeaiot
r
fn
i
itr
ht.n
roce
syrr
prove
iase
owe
dne
ino
CONCLUDINGRE
hatgesug
ixercs
prea
liys
h
l iogca
hroug
V.
Ou
ltec
M
rb dp ssistturana ss
ht fu ciro me or nc cceeoee np ra ma n a
ls ndeda T simo me ccu noso
t
0,ろ>¢
ihchwienhera1t, ng
ionitzalqua
i donefhas-dl
hit
li Aa n.ttoen
o
-
h
4
haC .H erngee eedst tintenxcahtence,>)1-
wagitnnovaon, ee
htecorssuc,i iunonze- ds
hw ene,
hepara1t,
nc ・A tteo eetxremtiposphaseiuno-
nd tnusri ionnaitzab f lrsecauseowageequa ni yi
sd tnusrti si ntei yinC sg h
nf
hwetreaerrease
ioil i itaunonza
ltt toaoupu
tpar
d tnusryai hnsucitnnovaon ni ma
VIiontec
tk iorerswi trvesouwici honw,tva hd hp
iency.C
essiotnnovahtaprocettgessliysssug ssi ninl
ng
st
a(
eii)imo yi gin卓, hwenincreasnilltnoonca
Y
s
i
ha
iesifs
hca
tsa
Becaus
a
lweanayseihcb i haourunonsw, dinS
miencCl:B yI
・conomyheoveratniicencffieveaverageehaco yi lle
ionol terafpeoaitsy
t
h
hl
T
itsecorsw
cce ccu
h a
heb Itosn.
W
jng
ti henn t o
rocesnherichw ht ei ssiop nno
isahT na
0<♂<
RKS
141
C
1
駒津大学経済学論集 第 41巻 第 4号
hJeapanesetfgo
1)het
s
hen
toeno
-
2
to
t;()t mi rihed na
,i Y 1 c wsα(-)
keilourwtau
Japanese
h desecon
hohe Mift
T). ho dl
ilnng
ld hlfegeep
lleare,
w
hameet Of Ws maco
kcdl oano he
ing.
ktei
t
lrwou
SttaP tanICtparl
ul
ld tege
foitnsry
azawKofo ma
ioniti dsconhh ten
i dandbla
iib :ssecausehT (
'
ll tueueengff d iere varyn,agesff ierencesnwi
r
i lionsexpa
tngo
le
Vl taua
co
Mo mey(
nt o gq hu hehed dt
mpme
ir
ittsraegc
ff ierencesidlde, nfms
mmeet
We dl oanow
in
kckte
tauurr
ilwou.tyi invers
rogram
t dT y(MEXT
oano hP
h lecnoogSis cencean,Sture por,i Clon u,d tuca
kc
E
t
t
Ky oS tyi invers
8.00
Uyo
2y,
ang
U i invers
to
tyi inversUamazawoK
ies.titporunopbojsit tenerpreenb daca'irm f̀n t modlea,hisiis,lltaT
G) a.3002( ri
ity.d
1
iiagergfttconexow
)> C.
faoourconce
eno
a
)l-
htahesoL Wtaer. ,
t 0;u , hed minad ( t
t-1 wt x2 re mw
dahe2 6
yU
00tttaspresene
CitksaaOt
hef hoit trsaui ton,itdd
rciRc eseafi
† A r1 nohi
miss na
spaperwtf
ioitoca
i ierverso
fmNatensro
Ac
ea
Econo
comm
n
nthi Ina
he
eours.
t
spaperar
ftporoilasupC
ierrors
i lnuf Aidf Sitorcen-in-G tran
dtranlSe,bas
Vi ha yin仙e ttsraeg
fy orexa,sehamo gs yh eenu db mpttraeg
usesuc
in
)50
dlle
02(ltoane
suc
Y >1-
lS he rcReseaS ilpecatftporoupiaCi lnuhfeld tegew
-
nincreasnilltnooncar of x smo g i2 i y i
isI.birumiliequ nh mo
heniguouswsunatig hi yi mb a(Ylequaisnftonh iesT
heti dtnoyoanhSiko
ichicase
dxelluaysessuc)1991
nw h2y
hami
dteiivdd toesno he
iitsshi ton,l l ltecacua he
mitnao
hwen1
deno
α(y-)> O
ide.ifsi t tsnosa
ages.fowtyitnar
i4 Bysmp
5
2
3
241
i)daNOFLBO R(TiIera,UAOITAOCLLAERNSANDOITNOVANISSE
ERENCES
OCRP
itve
lca
lte
i lton ec,
t
nE cR ,8i
i iteunonza
conom
D'e ( mi).100
imerca
2
y:na maa
ievew p.9 p,
iclbu
2.381997p.p,
age
9.
idt ternusr
7-36
n
1p.6p,0i 1conomcs,
di yw
flCS ionerene ererC sonPR h tocese-C iarnege, '
RE
Ch nu mp m e nd liiagenequawtnaloyneianges').9991(.
F
l Dgu,
9,conomyitcailo lE ,1 pp.
Acmo
dsmee ,TeA
Acmo hi ntAg Vi
eadine
h
loa
Blnc
'
L.
2dG Vi e(
denceiv
ltoan
o
o
L.
n
P.,.
an
hcang
P.
l Dgu,
ibla ,d
e
e
a
G iar
llInc, .ice-P treni L d Ha:cs onon,
everancetnloyhT̀).50 eemp m ete飴 c sofs0
E iJ lconomcourna, ,'iesitd 115iiagerg
ni isperso
wime
E iqu
hw
). gbiruil' m waed na19
t
91(.
tnspay
JDry,.
hdlewit
Macroeconom).7991(.h d0ar,
i iarganni :nons
lourna o
ixpanso
Europea,'baor
eore nofu ab gmo
sl nJ fP
・lnaofoultuarerQ, yJ fE'
nandG
4.61922p.5p,i 5cy,Plo
tyilqua
in
Mo me
lechT' ed).3002
tngo
dJ(tran,.S
8.7-9521
yanheort
.
hteerogeneou
二1740一3
ilasf terentid
341