aiaa sci-tech 2014 1st sonic boom prediction workshop · aiaa sci-tech 2014 sonic boom prediction...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 1st Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop · AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop Test Case 2 • NASA 69deg Delta Wing (WB) – CAD geometry based on limited](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022051912/6002b2f9460b817f8350acc7/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
1 Copyright 2014 Lockheed Martin
OVERVIEW
John Morgenstern
January 11, 2014
AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 1st Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop
![Page 2: AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 1st Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop · AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop Test Case 2 • NASA 69deg Delta Wing (WB) – CAD geometry based on limited](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022051912/6002b2f9460b817f8350acc7/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
2 Copyright 2014 Lockheed Martin
AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop
Objective • The objective of the First Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop is to
assess the state of the art for predicting signatures suitable for sonic boom propagation. – Prediction resolution sufficiently far for propagation – Off track prediction resolution – Prediction resolution versus test data Assessing the state of the art and identifying areas requiring additional research and further development.
![Page 3: AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 1st Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop · AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop Test Case 2 • NASA 69deg Delta Wing (WB) – CAD geometry based on limited](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022051912/6002b2f9460b817f8350acc7/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
3 Copyright 2014 Lockheed Martin
AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop
Test Case 1 • SEEB-ALR “Flat-Top” Signature (B)
– Axi-symmetric geometry re-created “as-built” from average of inspection measurements around it
SEEB-ALR Model
17.68 in
∅ 1.4 in ∅ 0.747 in
29.25 in 3.85 in
![Page 4: AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 1st Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop · AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop Test Case 2 • NASA 69deg Delta Wing (WB) – CAD geometry based on limited](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022051912/6002b2f9460b817f8350acc7/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
4 Copyright 2014 Lockheed Martin
AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop
Test Case 2 • NASA 69deg Delta Wing (WB)
– CAD geometry based on limited definition in report – Un-cambered x-y plane symmetry, 5% thick diamond airfoil – Parabolic nose definition r = 0.540 - 0.011 (x - 7.01)2
(r = 0 @ x = 0.0035)
![Page 5: AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 1st Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop · AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop Test Case 2 • NASA 69deg Delta Wing (WB) – CAD geometry based on limited](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022051912/6002b2f9460b817f8350acc7/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
5 Copyright 2014 Lockheed Martin
AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop
Test Case 3 • NASA N+2 LM 1021-01 Configuration
(WBNV) – Propagation Refinement – Off Track Refinement – Aeq/Lift Signature Level Matching – Viscosity effect on Nacelles Internal
Flow, External Flow and Vehicle Lift
Potential Problem due to model scale viscous effects
Blade
Sting
Viscous CFD Predictions Indicate the Potential for an Interaction Between the Blade Mount and the
Centerline Nacelle.
Attached lower surface flow with shock wave interactions on wing and tail from nacelles
REFS: AIAA2012-3215 (Measurement Procedure) -3216 (Measurement Challenges) -3217 (Model Design)
![Page 6: AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 1st Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop · AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop Test Case 2 • NASA 69deg Delta Wing (WB) – CAD geometry based on limited](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022051912/6002b2f9460b817f8350acc7/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
6 Copyright 2014 Lockheed Martin
AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop
Prediction Comparisons
![Page 7: AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 1st Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop · AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop Test Case 2 • NASA 69deg Delta Wing (WB) – CAD geometry based on limited](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022051912/6002b2f9460b817f8350acc7/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
7 Copyright 2014 Lockheed Martin
AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop
Prediction Methodologies • Key to Prediction Methodology, A # # #
– Designation – solver, grid: • A011 – Cart3D, Cartesian grid 57M • B110 – CFD++, hybrid 24M • C100 – USM3D(sst, laminar), provided (hybrid) 14M • C110 – USM3D(SArn375), Pointwise/MCAP (hybrid) • D000 – Eugenie, provided (hybrid) 14M • H011 – Cart3D/Ovrflow, Cartesian/structured hybrid 39M+35M • P100 – FUN3D/CFL3D, provided (hybrid) 2M(nodes)+3M(cells) • R110 – FUN3D, VGRID unstructured 164M
– 1st #: 1 – Viscous BL, 0 – Inviscid – 2nd #: 1 – New grid, 0 – Provided grid – 3rd #: 1 – Solution adapted grid, 0 – Fixed grid (swept)
![Page 8: AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 1st Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop · AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop Test Case 2 • NASA 69deg Delta Wing (WB) – CAD geometry based on limited](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022051912/6002b2f9460b817f8350acc7/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
8 Copyright 2014 Lockheed Martin
AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop
Boundary Layer Induced Sonic Boom Level Variation • Two Solution Groupings: BL and No BL (Boundary Layer)
Viscous
Inviscid
Boundary Layer Required to Match Measurements (at Wind Tunnel Reynolds Number)
![Page 9: AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 1st Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop · AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop Test Case 2 • NASA 69deg Delta Wing (WB) – CAD geometry based on limited](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022051912/6002b2f9460b817f8350acc7/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
9 Copyright 2014 Lockheed Martin
AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop
Turbulent vs. Laminar Sonic Boom Level Variation (Tunnel Re#)
Flow Through Nacelle Exhaust
Wind Tunnel Model Boundary Layer has a Mix of Laminar and Turbulent Flow (not Significant at Full Scale)
![Page 10: AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 1st Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop · AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop Test Case 2 • NASA 69deg Delta Wing (WB) – CAD geometry based on limited](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022051912/6002b2f9460b817f8350acc7/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
10 Copyright 2014 Lockheed Martin
AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop
Matching Test Under Track Test LM4, Sig75c, R=31.8”, 0 roll
Remember: model bouncing and tunnel flow variations cause rounding of tunnel measurements—Actual DP/P would be sharper
(Data has not been interpolated to match CL of CFD yet)
![Page 11: AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 1st Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop · AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop Test Case 2 • NASA 69deg Delta Wing (WB) – CAD geometry based on limited](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022051912/6002b2f9460b817f8350acc7/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
11 Copyright 2014 Lockheed Martin
AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop
Matching Test Off Track Test LM4, R=31.8”
10 roll (Sig86)
40 roll (Sig80)
20 roll (Sig85) 30 roll (Sig84)
50 roll (Sig82) 60 roll (Sig83)
![Page 12: AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 1st Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop · AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop Test Case 2 • NASA 69deg Delta Wing (WB) – CAD geometry based on limited](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022051912/6002b2f9460b817f8350acc7/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
12 Copyright 2014 Lockheed Martin
AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop
Propagation Resolution • To 100.7 inches: A011, C110, H011, P100
A011 C110
H011 P100
DP/
P * s
qrt [
R /
10(b
/2)]
Tau = (X-Beta*R)/L
![Page 13: AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 1st Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop · AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop Test Case 2 • NASA 69deg Delta Wing (WB) – CAD geometry based on limited](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022051912/6002b2f9460b817f8350acc7/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
13 Copyright 2014 Lockheed Martin
AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop
Propagation Resolution • Less than 100.7 inches: B110, D000
B110 D000
DP/
P * s
qrt [
R /
10(b
/2)]
Tau = (X-Beta*R)/L Tau = (X-Beta*R)/L
![Page 14: AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 1st Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop · AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop Test Case 2 • NASA 69deg Delta Wing (WB) – CAD geometry based on limited](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022051912/6002b2f9460b817f8350acc7/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
14 Copyright 2014 Lockheed Martin
AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop
Off Track Resolution • To 60 degrees Roll Angle: B110 and H011
B110 H011
![Page 15: AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 1st Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop · AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop Test Case 2 • NASA 69deg Delta Wing (WB) – CAD geometry based on limited](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022051912/6002b2f9460b817f8350acc7/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
15 Copyright 2014 Lockheed Martin
AIAA SCI-TECH 2014 Sonic Boom Prediction Workshop
Off Track Resolution • Less Sharp Off Track than Under Track: A011, C110, D000, P100
(though may still be sharper than B110) A011 C110
D000 P100