26.05.16

1

2016 AhrweilerEA  European  Academy,  Germany

Agent-­‐based Simulation  forScience,  Technology  and Innovation  Policy

Prof. Dr. Petra Ahrweiler

EA European Academy of Technology and Innovation AssessmentBad Neuenahr-Ahrweiler, Germany

2016 AhrweilerEA  European  Academy,  Germany2

The  Framework  Programmesof  the  European   Commission

Funding  policies  for  STI• 1983:ESPRIT  programme• 1984:  First  Framework  Programme (1984-­‐1987)• 1987:  “European  Single  Act”

• science   becomes  a  Community   responsibility• 1987:  Second  Framework  Programme (1987-­‐1991)• 1990:  Third  Framework  Programme(1990-­‐1994)• 1994:  Fourth  Framework  Programme(1994-­‐1998)• 1998:  Fifth  Framework  Programme(1998-­‐2002)• 2000:  European  Research  Area• 2002:  Sixth  Framework  Programme (2002-­‐2006)• 2007:  Seventh  Framework  Programme (2007-­‐2013)• 2014:  Horizon  2020

!"#$%#&"

!

!$&" '()*+,-+).'/.0)12+34/'536+789/:+)7348#

9$43#(),$"1'.*"#%

!$&" '()*+,-+).'/.0)12+34/'536+789/:+)7348#

!$&" '()*+,-+).'/.0)12+34/'536+789/:+)7348 !$&" '()*+,-+).'/.0)12+34/'536+789/:+)7348

51T+),4D/H(+/2+),16/!$&EK!$!$9/H(+/.0)12+34/Q177,GG,14/*,--/G2+46/3P10H/WL$XM3P10H/W;X/1R/*(,5(/*,--/D1/H1/BQC

!"#$%#&"

=

!$&" '()*+,-+).'/.0)12+34/'536+789/:+)7348

;0/,48 -0*#//,$" 203 %7#?.30@#($1A0--,)),0$

B03,C0$ DEDEF1 9-@(4%1!))#))-#$%1($*1?G&!$%#1?:(/.(%,0$1021%7# ?.30@#($1 9A613#)#(347 /($*)4(@#

YG,4D/Z+H*1)I/'43-8G,G/H1/714,H1)/346/H)35I/.RR+5HG/)+G0-H,4D/R)17/Q(34D+G/,4/@1-,58/B4H+)T+4H,14/346/B4GH)07+4HG/J?['AC/!$&$\$$!%M

?:(/.(%,0$1H$,%

!$&" '()*+,-+).'/.0)12+34/'536+789/:+)7348

!$&" '()*+,-+).'/.0)12+34/'536+789/:+)7348

9-@(4%1())#))-#$% 02 +6912.$*,$" @0/,4,#) .),$" +I!GH3463)6 2)15+60)+ 1R .T3-03H,14/Y4,H

" ](,5( 4+H*1)I GH)05H0)+G (3T+P++4 2)1605+6 P8 F@L/J51723)+6H1 F@"M^/

" ](,5( 4+H*1)I GH)05H0)+2)1605+6 *(3H 10H20H^

" ](1/3)+ H(+ 5+4H)3- 35H1)G J(0PGM/,4/H(+ .A'^

" U1* 3P10H H(+ 4+* 7+7P+)GH3H+G^

" U1* 3P10H H(+ ?[.G^" U1* 6+4G+\51(+G,T+ ,G H(+

4+H*1)I^" U1* 3P10H 4+* +4H),+G^" .H5#

!"#$%#&"

E

!$&" '()*+,-+).'/.0)12+34/'536+789/:+)7348

J(%(1.)#*1 ,$1+I!

!$&" '()*+,-+).'/.0)12+34/'536+789/:+)7348

J(%(1.)#*1 ,$1+I!

!$&".'/.0)12+34/'536+789/:+)7348

F@L/,4/BQC@)1T,6+6 P8 _:/BZF?`

!"#$%#&"

%

!$&" '()*+,-+).'/.0)12+34/'536+789/:+)7348

9)).#) =,%7 +I!

" X8/H(+/+46/1R/F@L9/3/5+)H3,4/ *,))(%,)2(4%,0$ *,H(/ H(+/0G+6/7+H(161-1D8/ R1)/+T3-03H,14/20)21G+G P+537+/1PT,10G/*,H(/_:/BZF?`

" ?Z'/14-8/532H0)+6/H(+/GH)05H0)3-/ 3G2+5HG/1R/H(+/)+G+3)5(/-346G532+#/'5H1)G9/ 2)15+GG+G/346/530G+G/2)1605,4D/ H(+G+/GH)05H0)+G9/ *+)+/,4T,G,P-+/P+H*++4/R)1V+4/G432G(1HG/1R/H*1/4+H*1)I/GH3H+G/R1--1*,4D/ 0214/+35(/1H(+)#/

" @1-,5873I+)G/P+537+/514T,45+6/H(3H/,H/*10-6/P+/0G+R0-/H1/I41*/3P10H/H(+G+/2)15+60)3-/ 3G2+5HG/H1/R,46/322)12),3H+/ 12H,14G/ 346/355+GG/21,4HG/R1)/,4H+)T+4H,14G/ 346/5(34D+G#

" F0)H(+)71)+9/ ?Z'/a0GH/3--1*G/H1/+T3-03H+/H(+/GH)05H0)+G/ 2)1605+6/ P8/5+)H3,4/ R046,4D/21-,5,+G/ N+S/21GHOb/+SK34H+/+T3-03H,14/,G/14-8/21GG,P-+/,4/H(+/T+)8/-,7,H+6/*38G/1R/GH3H,GH,53-/ 716+--,4D

" C(+/R0H0)+/ ,G/41H/ 366)+GG+6/2)12+)-8c

"

!$&" '()*+,-+).'/.0)12+34/'536+789/:+)7348

YG,4D +72,),53- 346 3)H,R,5,3- 63H3>@1-,58 ,7235H G,70-3H,14

" N;0/,481,-@(4%1),-./(%,0$#/'4/,721)H34H/D13-/1R/+T3-03H,14/)+G+3)5(/,G/H1/73I+/+T3-03H,14G/)+-+T34H/H1/21-,58/12H,14G/R1)/,4H+)T+4H,14/ ,4/AC_/346/,441T3H,14#/.T3-03H,14G/70GH/)+-3H+/1PG+)T+6/23)37+H+)G/346/,7235HG/H1/H(+/5(3)35H+),GH,5G/1R/H(+/,4H+)T+4H,14#/ BH/70GH/P+/21GG,P-+/H1/6+605+/*(3H/510-6/346/G(10-6/P+/5(34D+6/,4/H(+/,4H+)T+4H,14/ H1/,72)1T+/,7235HG#/'551)6,4D-89/705(/71)+/0G+/G(10-6/P+/736+/1R/+SK34H+/4+H*1)I/343-8G,G/%01),-./(%# H(+/,7235HG/1R/,4H+)T+4H,14/21-,58/5(34D+G#O/

J.0)12+34/Q177,GG,14/ ]1)IG(12/A+21)H/ NYG,4D/Z+H*1)I/'43-8G,G/H1/'GG+GG/?8GH+7,5/B7235HG/1R/A+G+3)5(O9/ [3)5(/!$$;>/&<M#

!"#$%#&"

"

!$&" '()*+,-+).'/.0)12+34/'536+789/:+)7348

?:(/.(%,:#1K.#)%,0$)1 2031B03,C0$1DEDE

&# ](3H/,R/H(+)+/3)+/41/5(34D+G^/

!# ](3H/,R/H(+)+/3)+/5(34D+G/H1/H(+/H(+73H,5/ 3)+3G^/

=# ](3H/,R/H(+)+/3)+/5(34D+G/H1/H(+/,4GH)07+4HG/ 1R/R046,4D^

E# ](3H/,R/H(+)+/3)+/,4H+)T+4H,14G/5145+)4,4D/ H(+/G512+/1)/10H)+35(/ 1R/R046,4D^

%# ](3H/,R/H(+)+/3)+/,4H+)T+4H,14G/5145+)4,4D/ H(+/23)H,5,23H,14/ 1R/5+)H3,4/35H1)G/,4/H(+/4+H*1)I/J+#D#/?[.GM^

!$&" '()*+,-+).'/.0)12+34/'536+789/:+)7348

(HH2>\\5)+GG#G15#G0))+8#35#0I\?dBZ\

+L9I1;/(%203-

!"#$%#&"

L

!$&" '()*+,-+).'/.0)12+34/'536+789/:+)7348

$%&'()*+,- .$/0&1!2234!2256.+-7)(8&9):+;<=&>)?+(@A@,+=&A@: BCD&,);;AE)(A-F)@ @+-7)(8<

24

Empirical and simulated network

Empirical Green: research institute Purple: uni Red: industry Blue: public bodies Yellow: SMEs

Simulated Blue: RI Red: industry Green: SME

'5H03--8 ?dBZ/,G 3P10H ,441T3H,14 21-,589P0H/3-G1/322-,53H,14G R1) ,460GH)8 21-,58346 R1) G5,+45+ 346 )+G+3)5( 21-,58

!$&" '()*+,-+).'/.0)12+34/'536+789/:+)7348GH

INFSO-SKIN flow diagram

Q3-,P)3H+6 P8 +72,),53- 63H3 1R &&<=/.YKR046+6 )+G+3)5( 2)1a+5HG9/=L<=/R046+6 1)D34,G3H,14GJ04,T+)G,H,+G 346 )+G+3)5( ,4GH,H0H,14G JA.?/3D+4HGM9/)+G+3)5( 6+23)H7+4HG 1R P,D R,)7GJ-3)D+/6,T+)G,R,+6 R,)7G e_F/3D+4HGM/346 ?[.G/J?[./3D+4HGM9/346 &&!EE/2)1a+5H 23)H,5,23H,14GP+H*++4 !$$L/346 !$&=

!"#$%#&"

<

!$&" '()*+,-+).'/.0)12+34/'536+789/:+)7348

9I<+M&+L9I13#@30*.4,$"%7# #-@,3,4(/ *(%('()# (3%,2,4,(//8

!$&" '()*+,-+).'/.0)12+34/'536+789/:+)7348 !$&" '()*+,-+).'/.0)12+34/'536+789/:+)7348

N03>2/0=12031B03,C0$1DEDE1#G&($%#1#:(/.(%,0$

@1-,58 +S2+),7+4HG ,4/G,-,51

!"#$%#&"

;

!$&" '()*+,-+).'/.0)12+34/'536+789/:+)7348

?G(-@/#F1;0/,48 O(4>"30.$*1 203 P.#)%,0$ D

" C+5(41-1D8/20G(>/f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

" ?H3I+(1-6+)G/1R/_:/BZF?`/3GI+6>/](3H/,R/H(+)+/*10-6/ P+/5(34D+G/,4/H(+73H,5/ 3)+3G/1R/R046,4D^/U1*/*10-6/H(+/50))+4H/ )+G+3)5(/ -346G532+/,4/BQC/1R/H(+/.A'/*10-6/)+35H/H1/H(,G^/

" ](3H/,R/71)+\-+GG\1H(+)/ H(+73H,5/ 3)+3G/*10-6/P+/R046+6/H(34/H(+/+,D(H/5(1G+4/H(+73H,5/ 3)+3G/,4/F@L^

!$&" '()*+,-+).'/.0)12+34/'536+789/:+)7348&<

!$&".'/.0)12+34/'536+789/:+)7348&<

X3G+-,4+

[1)+/H(+7+G

F+*+)/H(+7+G

d41*

-+6D

+/R-1

*

C,7+

A+G0-HG/R1)/](3HK,R/*+/)+605+\+SH+46/H(+/407P+)/1R/R046+6/H(+7+G^

?G(-@/# 3#)./% 203 P.#)%,0$ D

gK'S,G>/I41*-+6D+ R-1*G P+H*++4 3D+4HGb/hK'S,G>/H,7+/-,4+ 1R R046,4D ,4GH)07+4Hb/)+6 -,4+ i/X3G+-,4+/?5+43),19/D)++4 -,4+ i/71)+ H(+7+G9/P-0+ -,4+ i/ -+GG H(+7+G

!"#$%#&"

&$

!$&" '()*+,-+).'/.0)12+34/'536+789/:+)7348

+.3@3,)#) ,$13#)./%) 203 P.#)%,0$ D

" ?,70-3H,14/+S2+),7+4HG *+)+ G0)2),G,4D 346 5104H+)K,4H0,H,T+/R1)H(+ _:/BZF?`/GH3I+(1-6+)G#/

" C(+/+S2+5H3H,14 (36 P++4 H(3H 2),1),H,G3H,14 1R )+G+3)5( R046,4DJ-+GG H(+7+G9/G37+/714+8M/*10-6 (3T+ )+G0-H+6 ,4/705( 71)+6)3GH,5 5(34D+G 5145+)4,4D H(+ I41*-+6D+ P3G+ 346 1H(+) 10H20H23)37+H+)G#

" B4/514H)3GH9/H(+ G,70-3H,14 G(1*+6 3/)+73)I3P-+ )+G,-,+45+ 1R H(+)+G+3)5( -346G532+ 346 ,GH/I41*-+6D+ P3G+#/

" C(+/5145-0G,14 6)3*4 *3G/H(3H 2),1),H,G3H,14 1R )+G+3)5( ,G P3G,53--83/21-,H,53- 6,G50GG,14 346 6+G5,G,14 ,R ,H GH38G *,H(,4 3/5+)H3,4 )+3-7j 3/51)),61)9/*(,5( 510-6 P+ 2)+5,G+-8 -153H+6 ,4/H(+ G,70-3H,14#/

!$&" '()*+,-+).'/.0)12+34/'536+789/:+)7348

?G(-@/#F1;0/,48 O(4>"30.$*1 203 P.#)%,0$ Q

" 'HH+72H H1 ,4H+D)3H+ ,441T3H,T+/)+G+3)5(K,4H+4G,T+/?[.G/,4/.YKR046+6 )+G+3)5(>/fC()10D(/H(+,) R-+S,P,-,H8 346 3D,-,H89/?[.G/2-38 3/2,T1H3- )1-+ ,4/6+T+-12,4D 41T+- 2)1605HG 346G+)T,5+G#/`0HGH346,4D/346/R3GH/D)1*,4D/?[.G/(3T+/H(+/21H+4H,3-/H1/H)34GR1)7/H(+/GH)05H0)+/1R/.0)12+kG/+514178/P8/D)1*,4D/,4H1/H171))1*kG/70-H,43H,143-/517234,+G/Jc#M/3-H(10D(/23)H,50-3)/3HH+4H,14/(3G/P++4/23,6/H1/,45)+3G,4D/?[./,4T1-T+7+4H/ H()10D(10H/F@L9/?[.G/3)+/GH,--/R,46,4D/,H/5(3--+4D,4D/H1/23)H,5,23H+O J:)++4/@32+)/14/3/Q17714/?H)3H+D,5/F)37+*1)I/ R1)/.Y/A+G+3)5(/346/B441T3H,14/F046,4D>/'43-8G,G/1R/20P-,5/514G0-H3H,14/!$&&9/?#/&$M#

" C(+/+T3-03H,14 04,H 1R _:/BZF?`/3-)+368 (36 ,GG0+6 3/R+* H+46+) GH06,+G H1 R,46/10H/3P10HH(+ )+3G14G R1) H(+ f21-,58 R3,-0)+N/*(8 .Y/R046,4D *3G/41H/3G 3HH)35H,T+ 3G +S2+5H+6 R1)?[.G9/346 *(8 H(+ 7+3G0)+G H3I+4 (36 41H/P++4 3G G055+GGR0- 3G +S2+5H+6#/

" F0)H(+)71)+9/3/6,G50GG,14 GH3)H+6 3714D H(+ GH3I+(1-6+)G9/*(+H(+) H(+ 21-,58 +RR1)HG 34651GH-8 ,45+4H,T+ GH)05H0)+G H1 6)3* ?[.G/,4H1 .Y/)+G+3)5( *10-6 P+ )+3--8 *1)H(*(,-+ 346238 1RR/H(+ *38 +S2+5H+6 348*38#

!"#$%#&"

&&

!$&" '()*+,-+).'/.0)12+34/'536+789/:+)7348

9$%#3#)%,$" 3#)./%) 203 P.#)%,0$ Q

" ]10-6 H(+ +RR+5HG 14/H(+ .A'/,46++6 P+ 3G 21G,H,T+/3G +S2+5H+6 ,R H(+)+ *3G/71)+?[./23)H,5,23H,14^/ C(+)+ *+)+ 5+)H3,4 610PHG j 3/53G+ R1) H(+ G,70-3H,14 *,H(BZF?`K?dBZ#

" C(+/)+-3H+6 G,70-3H,14 +S2+),7+4HG GH3)H+6 *,H( 514G,6+)3P-8 71)+ )+G+3)5(K,4H+4G,T+/346 (,D(-8KG2+5,3-,G+6 ?[.G/,4/H(+ GH3)H,4D 2120-3H,14 H(34 510-6 P+G++4 ,4/H(+ +72,),53- 6,GH),P0H,14

" C(+/G,70-3H,14 G(1*+6 H(3H H(+G+ f366,H,143-N/ ?[.G/1T+)K2)121)H,143--823)H,5,23H+6 ,4/2)121G3-G 3469/+G2+5,3--89/ ,4/G055+GGR0- 2)1a+5H 514G1)H,3#/F0)H(+)71)+9/ H(+8 (36 21G,H,T+/+RR+5HG 14/I41*-+6D+ 346 4+H*1)I 23)37+H+)G#/

" C(,G/)+G0-H G0221)H+6 H(+ ?[./21-,58 36T153H+G ,4/H(+ GH3I+(1-6+) D)102 *(1)+2)+G+4H+6 H(+ :)++4/@32+)/21G,H,149/ 346 3)D0+6 3D3,4GH H(+ 5),H,5G 1R H(+G+21-,5,+G *,H(,4 H(+ D)102#

!$&" '()*+,-+).'/.0)12+34/'536+789/:+)7348

!*:($%("#102 (3%,2,4,(/ *(%(

" ?,70-3H,14/)+G0-HG 534 ,4R1)7 GH3I+(1-6+) 6,G50GG,14G 3P10H -,I+-8 R0H0)+ +RR+5HG 1R 21-,585(34D+G

" ?17+ 1R H(+G+ +RR+5HG 3)+ G02),G,4D 346 5104H+)K,4H0,H,T+#/Z+*/I41*-+6D+ ,G D+4+)3H+6 R1)H(+ GH3I+(1-6+)G#/Q172-+S 514H+SHG 3)+ 736+ 3T3,-3P-+ 346 355+GG,P-+ T,3/+S2+),7+4H3H,14#/?,70-3H,14G 534 (+-2 346 2)35H,5+ (1* H1 6+3-/*,H( H(+7#/

" '/R0)H(+) D3,4 R1) GH3I+(1-6+)G 3)+ H(+ ,4G,D(HG 14/G1K53--+6 +72,),53- f04K1PG+)T3P-+GN9/*(,5( 3)+ 736+ 355+GG,P-+ 346 1PG+)T3P-+/*,H(,4 H(+ G,70-3H,14#

" ?0221)H,4D H(+ D+4+)3H,14 1R 4+* I41*-+6D+ 346 R3G5,-,H3H,4D I41*-+6D+ R-1*G P+H*++4 35H1)GJ-+3)4,4D9/6,RR0G,14M/ 3)+ 5+4H)3- 21-,58 H3)D+HG 1R )+G+3)5( 346 ,441T3H,14 21-,58 )+-3H+6 H1,721)H34H 1T+)3-- 1Pa+5H,T+G JfG5,+4H,R,5 +S5+--+45+/1R .0)12+34/)+G+3)5(9/51(+G,14 ,4/3/(,D(Kl03-,H8/.0)12+34/)+G+3)5( -346G532+9/(,D(/-+3)4,4D 346 ,441T3H,14 53235,H8 1R .0)12+34/)+G+3)5( 1)D34,G3H,14G +H5#M#/

" ?,70-3H,14G +43P-+G 1PG+)T3H,14 1R I41*-+6D+ D3,4G 346 I41*-+6D+ R-1*G9/346 G(1*G H(+G055+GG 1) R3,-0)+ 1R 21-,58 7+3G0)+G H3)D+HH,4D 3H/H(+7#

!"#$%#&"

&!

!$&" '()*+,-+).'/.0)12+34/'536+789/:+)7348

@0P-,53H,14 2+)7,GG,14 !/8+3)G3RH+)/2)+G+4H3H,14 346 322)1T3- 1R H(+ F,43-/A+21)H/1R H(+ GH068P8 H(+ .0)12+34/Q3P,4+H

!$&" '()*+,-+).'/.0)12+34/'536+789/:+)7348

.Y9/F@L/!$&=K!$&"/:1T+)4345+/1R/A.G214G,P-+ ,441T'C,14

A.33#$% ?!13#)#(347 @30R#4%) .),$" %7# -#%70*0/0"8

?,70-3H,4D H(+ +RR+5HG 1R 5,T,- G15,+H8 1)D34,G3H,14G JQ?`GM/14.YKR046+6 )+G+3)5(9/+G2+5,3--8 *,H( 3/T,+* 14/AAB/2)171H,14 346 -+3)4,4D

:+)734/[,4,GH)8/1R/.6053H,14/346/A+G+3)5(!$&%K!$&</?43P-,4D/9441T3H,14/P8/+,70-3H,14/J.B?M

?,70-3H,4D H(+ +RR+5HG 1R ,441T3H,14 21-,5,+G R1) 20P-,5)+G+3)5( 1)D34,G3H,14G J[3S/@-345I9/F)304(1R+)9/e+,P4,V9/U+-7(1-HVM/14/H(+,) ,4GH,H0H+G 346 14/H(+ :+)734/)+G+3)5(346 ,441T3H,14 G8GH+7 3G 3/*(1-+

!"#$%#&"

&=

!$&" '()*+,-+).'/.0)12+34/'536+789/:+)7348

CU'Zd/g`Ym

@-+3G+ T,G,H 0G 3H//(HH2>\\***#+3K3*#1)D