agr 2010 winter survey report
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
1/53
The AGR Graduate
Recruitment Survey 2010Winter Review
Produced for AGR by
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
2/53
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
3/53
The AGR GraduateRecruitment Survey 2010
Winter Review
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
4/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
Association of Graduate Recruiters
The Innovation Centre
Warwick Technology Park
Gallows Hill
Warwick CV34 6UW
Survey produced for AGR by
CFE
Phoenix Yard
Upper Brown Street
Leicester LE1 5TE
For more information please contact Hayley Lamb on 0116 229 3300 [email protected]
Website: www.cfe.org.uk
All information contained in this report is believed to be correct and unbiased, but the publisher does not accept
responsibility for any loss arising from decisions made upon this information.
CFE and the Association of Graduate Recruiters
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in
any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying or otherwise, without prior permission of the
publisher.
mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected] -
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
5/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
1
ContentsForeword ................................................................................................................................... 2
Executive Summary ................................................................................................................... 3
Introduction .............................................................................................................................. 6
Methodology .................................................................................................................................................................. 6
Participation ................................................................................................................................................................... 7
Graduate vacancies and salaries .............................................................................................. 12
Graduate vacancies in 2009 and 2010 ......................................................... .............................................................. ... 12
Changes in vacancies by business sector ................................................................ ...................................................... 14
Vacancies in 2009 by business sector ............................................................................................................. .............. 18
Vacancies in 2009 by region ......................................................................................................................................... 19
Vacancies in 2009 by career area ................................................................................................................................. 19
Achievement of 2009 recruitment targets ...................................... ............................................................... .............. 21
Diversity of graduate recruits in 2009 .......................................................................................................................... 22
Challenges in filling anticipated 2010 vacancies ............................................................... ............................................ 25
Graduate salaries in 2009 and 2010 ............................................................................................................................. 27
Graduate salaries in 2009 by business sector ........................................................ ....................................................... 29
Graduate salaries in 2009 by region ............................................................................................................................. 29
Graduate salaries in 2009 by career area ..................................................................................................................... 31
Expected salary changes in 2010 by business sector ........................................................ ............................................ 32
Lump sum payments to graduates in 2010 .................................................................................................................. 33
Education premiums and other remuneration for graduates in 2010 ............................. ............................................ 34
Graduate recruitment marketing ............................................................................................. 37
Total marketing spend in 2009 and 2010 .................................................................................... ................................. 37
Graduate recruitment marketing activities in 2009 ................................... ............................................................... ... 38
Spend on key activities in 2009 and 2010 .................................................................................................................... 39
Marketing spend per vacancy ........................................................... ................................................................. ........... 39
Targeting universities in 2009 and 2010 ................................................................ ....................................................... 40
Hot topics in graduate recruitment .......................................................................................... 44
School-leaver entry programmes ............................... ................................................................. ................................. 44
Recruiting for UK vacancies overseas ............................................................................... ............................................ 45
Advice to graduates in difficult times .................................................................... ....................................................... 46
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
6/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
2
ForewordI begin by welcoming our new research partner, CFE, who have stepped up to the plate admirably and
produced a very readable and fascinating report. I must also pay tribute to the previous research team at
Trendence for the professional way in which they dealt with the handover.
While I am expressing my gratitude, I want to issue a big thank you to all the organisations who took the
trouble to complete the survey questionnaire. Without your efforts the Review would be a meaningless
exercise. The more members who contribute, the more meaningful the findings become. These are busy
times for graduate recruiters and we do appreciate your support in ensuring that the AGR Graduate
Recruitment Survey continues to be the largest and most respected survey of its kind. It is our intention to
build up the participation rate and if your organisation did not manage to complete the survey this time,
prepare yourselves for the next survey, which is to be revised following a consultation exercise with AGR
members, before it goes live in May 2010.
Much has happened to the UK economy in the past 12 months and this has clearly had an impact on the
graduate recruitment market but in what ways and to what extent? The Summer 2009 Graduate
Recruitment Survey predicted significant cutbacks in recruitment activity. Were these predictions met?
For the first time since we have undertaken the survey, graduate salaries were predicted to stagnate rather
than rise. Was this actually the case? And what has been the impact of the recession on marketingactivities and spend?
To find out the answers to these and other intriguing trends in the sector, read on!
Carl Gilleard
Chief Executive
AGR
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
7/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
3
Executive SummaryGraduate recruits, vacancies and salaries
The 8.9% decrease in graduate vacancies experienced during the 2008/09 recruitment season is far less
dramatic than the 24.9% fall that was predicted in the Summer 2009 Review. While AGR employers
anticipate a further 1.6% decrease in graduate vacancies during 2010, this does suggest that the fall in
vacancies may have started to level out.
The 2009 graduate vacancy market was dominated by accountancy/professional services, oil companies
and investment bank/fund managers who together offered nearly half of 2009s graduate vacancies. Oil
companies are expecting to significantly increase the number of graduates they recruit in 2010, while
employers in the public sector are among those predicting a decrease in vacancies. More than half of
graduates continue to be recruited in London and the South East although notable increases were reported
in Scotland, the North West and Europe during 2009.
The AGR employers predicting an increase in vacancies during 2010 attributed this to either an anticipated
or actual growth in business. In most cases, employers predicting a decrease in vacancies reported that this
was either a direct or indirect consequence of the economic climate.
The vast majority of AGR employers did not face difficulties filling their 2009 graduate vacancies and over
nine-tenths felt they met their 2009 recruitment objectives. However, AGR employers expecting to recruit
graduates during 2010 predict they are likely to experience high dropout rates as candidates apply to a
large number of organisations simultaneously.
In 2009, almost half (48.1%) of graduate starting salaries ranged from 22,001 to 26,000, with only one in
ten (11.9%) exceeding 36,001. For the second successive year, it is predicted that there will be no change
to the average starting salary offered by AGR employers. Mirroring the Winter 2009 Review, the median
starting salary for graduates recruited in 2010 is anticipated to be 25,000.
Investment bank/fund managers and law firms again topped the salary charts in 2009. While most sectors
predict there will be no change to graduate starting salaries during 2010, construction or consultancy and
transport or logistics both anticipate increasing salaries by more than 6%. No sectors are expected to
experience a dramatic decrease in salaries during the year. The proportion of organisations offering lump
sum payments to attract graduates is expected to fall by 6.3 percentage points to 26.6% in 2010.
There has been an 11.7 percentage point increase in the number of employers intending to offer a financial
premium for qualifications above an undergraduate degree. Pension schemes and training for professional
qualifications remain the most common non monetary benefits offered by AGR employers to graduates.
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
8/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
4
Graduate recruitment marketing
AGR employers median spend on graduate recruitment marketing activities in 2009 was 20,000.Although significantly less than the 80,000 predicted in the Winter 2009 Review, the median marketing
spend is not expected to drop further in 2010. AGR members plan to use a mixture of marketing
techniques for their 2010 recruitment campaign. More than nine-tenths will use brochures and/or the
company website followed by on campus activities and advertising. Just under three-quarters plan to use
online promotion techniques. Compared to 2009, AGR employers plan to allocate bigger median budgets
on their recruitment websites and smaller median budgets on recruitment brochures for their 2010
campaign. Median budgets for online promotions, advertising and on-campus activities are expected to
remain unchanged during 2010.
Hot topics in graduate recruitment
The proportion of AGR employers offering a school-leaver entry programme for 16 to 18 year olds has
declined by 3.4 percentage points since 2008 and now stands at 26.3%.
2009 saw a further fall in the number of AGR employers looking overseas to fill their UK graduate vacancies.
Despite this, many AGR employers still look abroad to ensure they recruit the most talented graduates
available and to reap the benefits of an international workforce.
As the UK emerges from the longest recession since records began, many graduates are still struggling to
find a job. In these difficult times, the advice from AGR employers to graduates is to attend interviews well
prepared. Conducting research into prospective employers and their sector is crucial, as is gaining
interview practice. To graduates considering postponing their job search to improve their employability,
AGR employers stress the importance of accepting temporary employment, undertaking skills training or
accepting unpaid work. In the current climate, graduates must do everything they can to get ahead of the
competition.
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
9/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
5
Introduction
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
10/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
6
IntroductionWelcome to the AGR Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review. The AGR Graduate Recruitment
Survey is the definitive study of AGR employer members and their recruitment practices, providing up to
the minute insights into conditions and trends in the graduate recruitment market alongside benchmarking
of key market indicators such as vacancy and salary levels.
As the leading survey of graduate recruitment practices, spanning the longest continuous series of
recruitment seasons, the Survey is the primary source of information on graduate recruitment levels,
methods and practices amongst AGR members an invaluable tool for assessing and optimising graduate
recruitment activities.
The Graduate Recruitment Survey is conducted twice a year. Undertaken on behalf of AGR by CFE, the
Winter Review provides an assessment of the latest graduate vacancy levels and salary information while
also examining AGR employers predictions for the near future. It describes the ways in which employers
marketed their graduate opportunities during the 2009 recruitment season and provides insight into their
recruitment marketing plans for 2010. The content of the Winter Review is largely unchanged from
previous years, although work will shortly be undertaken to develop the content of both the Summer and
Winter surveys to ensure they continue to meet the needs of AGR members. CFE will be consulting with a
sub-group of AGR members as part of this process. It is envisaged that the format of the Winter andSummer Review reports will change following this consultation; in the meantime, we have included some
additional commentary in the Policy Insight and Comparative Data boxes to position the findings in a wider
context.
The Summer Review, to be published in July 2010, will further investigate recruitment practices and
graduate recruitment management.
Methodology
An online survey was developed and hosted on the CFE website. AGR employer members were invited toparticipate in the survey by an email which included the link to the survey and a personalised password.
The survey contained a combination of different types of questions; some of these were mandatory in
order to ensure a high in-variable response rate for key questions. Respondents were automatically routed
through the survey on the basis of their response to previous questions.
The survey was open for a period of four weeks between November and December 2009. The results were
analysed using statistical software and are presented using tables and a variety of charts and graphs. In
addition to frequencies and averages for the overall sample, data is also reported by business sector, region
and career area where the size of the base is sufficiently large to permit robust analysis. The number of
organisations that responded to each question is presented for each table and chart as the base; that is, the
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
11/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
7
total number of valid responses on which the figures or percentages are calculated. This changes for each
question to reflect the routing not all respondents were asked the same questions.
Participation
361 AGR employers were invited to participate in the survey; responses were received from 214 of these
which represents a 59% response rate. Collectively, responding organisations recruited 19,247 graduates in
2009. Submissions were received from a cross-section of AGR members in terms of business sector, size of
organisation and the career area and region graduates are recruited to. The findings of the Graduate
Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review can, therefore, be regarded as representative of AGR employer
membership.
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
12/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
8
The following AGR members took part in the survey
AAccenture
Accenture (Technology Solutions)
Addleshaw Goddard
AECOM Ltd
AIESEC (UK) Ltd
Airbus
AkzoNobel
ALDAR Properties PJSC
Allen & Overy LLP
American ExpressAmey
Aon Ltd
Arcadia Group Plc
Argos
Army Recruiting Group Headquarters
Arriva Plc
ASDA Stores
Ashurst LLP
Atkins
Atos Origin
Audit Commission
AXA GroupAXA Investment Managers
BBAE Systems
Baillie Gifford
Baker & McKenzie
Bakkavor Ltd
Balfour Beatty
BAM Construction Ltd
Bank of America Corporation and Merrill Lynch & Co.
Bank of EnglandBarclays Bank Plc
Barclays Capital
Barclays Wealth
Barratt Developments Plc
BDO LLP
Bechtel Limited
Bircham Dyson Bell
Bloomberg
Bond Pearce LLP
Boots Plc
Bovis Lend Lease Limited
BP International Ltd
Brathay Hall Trust
Brodies LLP
BT
BUPA
CCabinet Office
Cadbury Plc
Cancer Research UK
CapGemini UK Plc
Capital One
Carillion Construction Limited
Centrica
CFE
CHP Consulting
Citigroup
Clifford Chance LLP
CMS Cameron McKenna LLP
COA Solutions Ltd
Corus Group Plc
Credit Suisse
Cummins Ltd
DDanone
Davis Langdon LLP
Deloitte
Department for Work and Pensions
Detica
DHL International Ltd
Diageo Plc
Dixon Wilson
DLA Piper UK LLP
Doosan Babcock Energy Ltd
DSG International PlcDTZ
Dunnhumby Ltd
EE.ON UK
EC Harris
Edmund Nuttall Ltd
Enterprise
Enterprise Rent-A-Car
Ernst & Young
European Personnel Selection Office
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
13/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
9
Eversheds LLP
FFactSet Europe Ltd
Fidelity Investments
Filtrona Plc
Financial Services Authority
Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer
Fujitsu Services
GGardiner & Theobald LLP
GCHQ Government Communications HeadquartersGlaxoSmithKline
Government Economic Service
Graduate Recruitment Bureau
Grant Thornton UK LLP
HHammonds LLP
HAT Group of Accountants
Hewitt Associates
Hiscox
HM Prison Service
HM Revenue & Customs
HSBC
Hymans Robertson
IIBM UK Ltd
IMI Plc
Imperial College London
Infosys Technologies Ltd
JJ Sainsbury Plc
J.P.Morgan
Jaguar and Land Rover
John Lewis Partnership
Johnson Matthey Plc
Jones Day
KKerry Foods Ltd
Kirkland + Ellis International LLP
KPMG LLP
LLinklaters LLP
Lloyds of London
Lloyd's Register
Lockheed Martin
Logica
L'Oreal
Lovells LLP
London School of Economics and Political Science
MMacfarlanes LLP
Majestic Wine Warehouses Ltd
Marks & Spencer Plc
Mayer Brown International LLP
MBDA UK
McDonalds Restaurants Ltd
McKinsey & Company
Mercer HR Consulting
Microsoft Corporation
Mills & Reeve LLP
Millward Brown
Moore Stephens LLP
Morgan Stanley & Co International Plc
Motability Operations
Mott MacDonald Ltd
Mouchel
Mountbatten Institute
NNabarro LLP
National Express UK Limited
National Grid
National Nuclear Laboratory
Nationwide Building Society
Nestle UK Ltd
Network Rail
NG Bailey
NHS Institute for Innovation and Improvement
Nomura International
Northern Foods Plc
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
14/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
10
OOlswang LLP
Osborne Clarke
Ove Arup International Ltd
PPilkington Group Ltd
Pinsent Masons LLP
PriceWaterhouseCoopers
Procter & Gamble UK
QQinetiQ
RRaleigh International
RBC Capital Markets
Reed Smith Richard Butler LLP
Research in Motion UK Ltd
Reynolds Porter Chamberlain LLP
RM
Rolls-Royce Plc
Royal & SunAlliance Insurance Group Plc
Royal Bank of Scotland Group
Royal Mail
RWE npower
SSantander UK Plc
Scott Wilson Holdings Ltd
Scottish Water
ScottishPower
Sellafield Ltd
Shell International Ltd
Siemens Plc
Simmons & Simmons
Skanska UK
Sky
Standard Bank
Standard Life Plc
Stephenson Harwood
SunGard
Swiss Reinsurance Company
TTAC Europe
Tate & Lyle
Taylor Wessing LLP
Technip UK Ltd
Tesco Stores Ltd
Thales Group Ltd
The Co-operative Group
The National Audit Office
TLT Solicitors LLP
Towers Perrin
Transport for London
Trayport Ltd
UUBS
UK Intellectual Property Office
Unilever UK
United Biscuits
United Utilities
University for Lloyds TSB
VVT Group Services Ltd
WW M Morrisons
Waitrose Ltd
Watson, Farley & Williams LLP
Westinghouse Rail System Ltd
Whitbread Plc
Wolseley Plc
WRC Plc
ZZurich Employment Services Ltd
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
15/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
11
Chapter 1
Graduate vacancies and
salaries
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
16/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
12
Graduate vacancies and salariesThis chapter provides a comparative analysis of the actual vacancy and salary levels experienced by AGR
employers in 2009 and predicted levels for the 2010 recruitment season.
Please note: the predicted changes in vacancy and salary levels between 2009 and 2010 are based on the
responses of employers who provided data in the Winter Survey for both 2009 and 2010. Those
organisations that provided data for only 2009 or 2010 were discounted to ensure consistency with the
method used in previous surveys, although their responses are included in all other analyses.
Graduate vacancies in 2009 and 2010
The decrease in vacancies observed in 2009 (8.9%) appears set to continue with a 1.6% drop expected for
the 2010 recruitment season based on AGR employer predictions. The last decrease in vacancies observed
in 2002 which stood at 6.5% - was similarly followed by a further small drop of 3.4% in 2003 so this is
consistent with previous trends. However, the decrease expected for 2010 is relatively slight and suggests
that the fall in vacancies may have started to level out. Moreover, with the final year-end figure for 2009
captured in this survey indicating an actual 8.9% decrease in vacancies, the decline in vacancies turned out
to be less dramatic than feared in the Summer 2009 Review when a 24.9% fall was anticipated (Figure 1.1).
Figure 1.1:
Graduate vacancy changes at AGR employers 2000 - 2010 (predicted)
Percentage increase or decrease on previous year (varying bases)
-1.6%
-8.9%
0.6%
12.7%
5.2%
5.1%
15.5%
-3.4%
-6.5%
14.6%
14.7%
-15% -10% -5% 0% 5% 10% 15% 20%
2010 (predicted)
2009
2008
2007
2006
2005
2004
2003
2002
2001
2000
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
17/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
13
Further evidence of the more positive outlook for 2010 is apparent in Figure 1.2. Overall, 51.5% of
responding organisations predict to have more vacancies in 2010 than 2009; the comparable figure for the
Winter 2009 Review, which compared the 2008 and 2009 recruitment seasons, was significantly less at
34.5%. This suggests that the significant slowdown in graduate recruitment experienced last year was
primarily as a result of the recession and does not look set to continue. Although the increase is small, with
one-quarter (25.8%) of AGR employers indicating that they will be offering between one to ten more
vacancies in 2010, it represents good news for the graduates set to leave university in 2010 together with
those who graduated in 2009 but have yet to find their first job. The percentage of organisations reporting
a decrease in the number of vacancies has similarly dropped from 46.0% in the Winter 2009 Review to
31.0%. The majority of this decrease can be seen amongst the category one to ten fewer graduates
(16.8%).
Figure 1.2:
Changes in vacancy levels 2009 to 2010 (predicted) Base = 195
4.2%
1.6%
8.4%
16.8%
17.4%
25.8%
14.2%
2.6%
8.9%
0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30%
51-200 fewer
26-50 fewer
11-25 fewer
1-10 fewer
Same as 2009
1-10 more
11-25 more
26-50 more
> 50 more
Comparative Data:Percentage change in vacancies
The Office for National Statistics Vacancy Survey provides estimates of the number of vacancies for
which employers are actively seeking recruits from outside their organisation across the UK. This
indicates that the decrease observed in 2009 amongst AGR employers was significantly less than that
experienced across all occupations. Based on a three month rolling average for the period June to
August 2009, a 29.0% decrease was observed when compared to the same period in 2008 for all job
vacancies. Comparing the findings of the Office for National Statistics Vacancy Survey and the AGR
Winter 2010 Review, we therefore see that graduate recruitment amongst AGR employers has not
been as adversely affected by the recession and provides further cause for optimism in 2010.
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
18/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
14
Analysis of the number of vacancies offered by AGR employers in 2009 and predicted levels for 2010
(Figure 1.3) encouragingly indicates a small decrease in the number of organisations reporting no new
vacancies (3.6% compared to 5.1%). Although still above the equivalent figure of 2.9% for 2008, as
reported in the Winter 2009 Review, some initial signs of levelling out of graduate vacancies are apparent
in 2010. Increases can also be seen in the percentage of AGR employers predicting between 26-50, 101-
250 and 251-500 vacancies (Figure 1.3).
Figure 1.3:
Number of graduate vacancies offered by AGR employers in 2009 and 2010 (predicted) Base = 195
Changes in vacancies by business sector
Figure 1.4 provides the expected percentage change in vacancies from 2009 to 2010 by sector. In stark
contrast to the Winter 2009 Review, the majority of the bars are to the right of the vertical axis illustrating
an anticipated increase in the number of vacancies. Those sectors reporting an increase in 2010 include the
traditionally largest graduate recruiters: banking or financial services (24.5%), investment banks and fund
managers (16.2%) and accountancy or professional service firm (0.4%), although in the case of the latter
this is only marginal. This contributes to a more optimistic picture for graduate recruitment given the
percentage of total vacancies typically offered by these operating sectors. However, the largest predicted
increase between 2009 and 2010 is for oil companies (49.7%) and consulting or business service firms
(47.2%) where there are almost half as many more vacancies in 2010 as in the previous year.
However, a small number of sectors are predicting significant decreases in the number of vacancies offeredin 2010, most notably third sector (49.2%) and transport or logistics (13.5%) organisations.
0.0%
5.1%
37.2%
19.9%
11.2%
5.6%
12.2%
3.6%
4.6%
2.1%
3.6%
34.9%
22.6%
8.2%
4.6%
14.9%
5.1%
4.1%
0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40% 45% 50%
Don't Know
No new vacancies
1-25
26-50
51-75
76-100
101-250
251-500
More than 500
2010 (predicted)
2009
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
19/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
15
Please note: oil and utility companies and third sector organisations have not featured previously as
standalone operating sectors. In earlier Graduate Recruitment Surveys, they were included in the all other
sector category as there were too few organisations to provide robust sector levels. However, due to the
large number of vacancies offered by all other sectors if grouped in this way, which stands at almost one-
quarter (23.1%) of all vacancies in 2009 according to the final year-end figures, the above sectors in this
Winter Review are presented in their own right. This is designed to provide more useful intelligence to AGR
members about the sectors accounting for the largest number of vacancies in 2009. It should be noted that
the number of organisations that responded to the survey from these sectors is small and the results
should, therefore, be used with some caution. This is applicable to all the sector breakdowns provided in
the Winter 2010 Review, including salary levels. The other category includes only those sectors not clearly
belonging to a sector listed in the questionnaire and chemical or pharmaceutical companies.
Figure 1.4:Expected percentage change in vacancies from 2009 to 2010 by sector Base = 195
-17.9%
-49.2%
-13.5%
-8.9%
-7.5%
0.4%
5.3%
7.4%
10.3%
11.8%
16.2%
20.5%
22.8%
24.5%
30.9%
32.0%
47.2%
49.7%
-60% -40% -20% 0% 20% 40% 60%
Other
Third sector
Transport or logistics company
Insurance company
Public sector
Accountancy or professional services firm
Energy, water or utility company
Law firm
Engineering or industrial company
FMCG company
Investment bank or fund managers
IT hardware or software company
Motor manufacturer
Banking or financial services
Retail
Construction company or consultancy
Consulting or business services firm
Oil company
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
20/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
16
With a much more positive picture apparent for the 2010 recruitment season, what are the reasons behind
this? AGR employers were asked how important several factors are in their predictions to recruit more or
less graduates on a scale of one to six, where one is not important at all and six is very important. The
mean score is provided in order to compare the importance ascribed to these factors.
Figure 1.5 indicates that, amongst those employers who expect an increase in vacancies between 2009 and
2010, anticipated (4.32) and actual (4.25) growth in business were rated more highly than any other factor
cited. This is in contrast to the Winter 2009 Review which indicated that the increase was primarily as a
consequence of an increased strategic focus on graduates within organisations; anticipated growth in
business in particular was of much less significance. With a mean score of 3.93, increased focus on
graduates continues to be of importance in 2010 although it no longer remains the primary driver. Higher
recent turnover of staff (2.55) and an increase in the number of applicants (2.48) were deemed by AGR
employers as significantly less important in accounting for the increase in vacancies.
Policy Insight: Government support for key sectors
The Government is now taking a more active role in promoting the development of key sectors that it
believes hold the key to economic growth and future prosperity. This increased activism was first
signalled last year in the paper Building Britains FutureNew Industry, New Jobs and has meant that
funding (including that provided to universities to place graduate interns with employers) is already
being prioritised to support key sectors such as advanced manufacturing, life sciences and digital and
creative industries. Related to this, plans were outlined in the Governments recent higher education
framework, Higher Ambitions, to help deliver the higher level skills needed for these sectors to
develop. This included enhanced support for STEM subjects degrees in the sciences, technology,
engineering and mathematics. The 10,000 additional student places announced by the Government
in 2009 were restricted to STEM subjects.
Comparative Data: Percentage change in vacancies by sector
The Office for National Statistics Vacancy Survey offers intelligence on the percentage change in
vacancies by sector. However, as the business sectors used in the Graduate Recruitment Survey are
reflective of AGRs membership rather than standard classifications, comparisons with the national
picture are less robust. CFE will be undertaking some work to align AGR sectors with the Standard
Industrial Classification (SIC) 2003, which is used in all major government surveys to categorise
establishments by the type of economic activity in which they are engaged. The AGR sectors will also
remain to ensure data is of value to members.
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
21/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
17
Figure 1.5:
Relative importance of various reasons for expected increase in vacancies from 2009 to 2010Mean ratings on a scale from 1 (not important at all) to 6 (very important)
Figure 1.6 indicates that the impact of the economic climate is once again significant in explaining the
decrease in graduate vacancies. Indeed, with a mean score of 4.51, direct result of the economic climate is
deemed more important than any other factor cited. At 3.47, indirect result of the economic climate is also
rated relatively highly and is consistent with the findings of the Winter 2009 Review. More positively for
the increasing number of young people entering higher education, lower strategic focus on graduate
recruitment was deemed of relatively low importance (2.39) and, therefore, reaffirms organisationscommitment to the employment of graduates.
Figure 1.6:
Relative importance of various reasons for expected decrease in vacancies from 2009 to 2010
Mean ratings on a scale from 1 (not important at all) to 6 (very important).
2.48
2.55
3.93
4.25
4.32
Increase in the number of applicants (b=82)
Higher recent turnover of staff (b=80)
More focus on graduate recruitment (b=81)
Actual growth in business (b=79)
Anticipated growth in business (b=80)
2.39
2.77
3.47
4.51
Lower focus of graduate recruitment (b=31)
Improved retention rates (b=30)
Indirect result of the current economic climate (b=32)
Direct result of the current economic climate (b=35)
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
22/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
18
Vacancies in 2009 by business sector
In terms of the percentage of total vacancies, the graduate vacancy market in 2009 was dominated byaccountancy and professional services (18.2%), oil companies (15.1%) and investment bank or fund
managers (14.9%). Whilst the ascendency of accountancy and professional services was evident in the
Summer Review where it topped the table at 24.4% - banking or financial services have dropped to fifth
place in the table and law firms to sixth. In the case of banking and financial services, this represents a
decrease of 5.7 percentage points and is indicative of the global credit crunch and banking crisis (Table 1.7).
The increase in vacancies recorded by oil companies is unprecedented; in the Summer 2009 Review they
were included in the other category and now feature as the second highest recruiter of graduates
amongst AGR members at 15.1%. The gains made by investment banks and fund managers are similarly
significant. In the Summer Review, investment banks stood seventh in the table at 5.5%.
Table 1.7: Vacancies at AGR employers by sector 2009
% of total vacancies
Accountancy or professional services firm 18.2%
Oil company 15.1%
Investment bank or fund managers 14.9%
Public sector 10.0%
Banking or financial services 7.9%
Law firm 6.5%
Retail 5.6%
Engineering or industrial company 5.2%
Consulting or business services firm 3.3%
IT / Telecommunications companies 2.7%
Construction company or consultancy 2.3%
Third sector 2.0%
Transport or logistics company 1.7%
FMCG company 1.5%
Energy, water or utility company 1.0%
Motor manufacturer 0.3%
Insurance company 0.3%
Other 1.6%
Based on the responses of 195 participants (Base count of vacancies = 19,247)
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
23/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
19
Vacancies in 2009 by region
At 42.8%, over two-fifths of 2009s total vacancies were in London. This represents a decrease whencompared to the Summer Review where it stood at 49.0% and a narrowing of the gap between London
and the South East (11.0%) by 6.5 percentage points. However, collectively London and South East account
for over half (53.8%) of all vacancies in 2009 and thus reiterates the dominance of the South. Notable
increases can be seen in the North West, Scotland and Europe, whilst decreases are evident in relation to
the South West, Wales, East Anglia, the North East and Yorkshire (Table 1.8).
Table 1.8: Vacancies at AGR employers by region in 2009
% of total vacancies
London 42.8%
South East 11.0%
The Midlands 9.3%
North West 8.3%
Scotland 6.5%
South West 6.2%
Wales 2.5%
Northern Ireland 1.4%
East Anglia 1.3%
North East 1.2%
Yorkshire 1.1%
Offshore British Islands 0.3%
Europe 6.4%
Rest of the world 0.6%
Ireland 0.4%
Asia 0.3%
USA 0.2%
Based on the responses of 195 participants (Base count of vacancies = 13,867*)
*Due to the fact that some respondents did not know the exact number of
graduates they recruited within each region.
Vacancies in 2009 by career area
Whilst there were once again more vacancies in accountancy than any other career area (14.8%), there has
been a marked decrease when compared to the Summer Review where it stood at 24.7%. At 14.0%,
general management has maintained its ground whilst legal work has dropped to third in the table (8.5%).
This is indicative of the resurgence of general management due to the popularity of rotational schemes.
Indeed, analysis of past AGR Graduate Recruitment Surveys indicates that general management has been
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
24/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
20
falling in popularity over the past decade. Encouragingly, the percentage of vacancies in investment
banking is higher than reported in the Summer Review 9.6% compared to 7.8% - possibly signalling some
recovery following the turbulence in the banking and financial services sector (Table 1.9).
Table 1.9: Vacancies at AGR employers by career area in 2009
% of total vacancies
Accountancy 14.8%
General management 14.0%
Investment banking 9.6%
Legal work 8.5%
IT 7.6%
Consulting 6.7%
Financial management 4.8%
Retail management 3.6%
Civil engineering 3.0%
Electrical / electronic engineering 2.9%
Mechanical engineering 2.6%
Human resources 2.5%
Sales 2.5%
Marketing 2.2%
Research and development 1.8%
Manufacturing engineering 1.6%
Logistics 1.6%
Purchasing 1.2%
Science 1.2%
Actuarial work 1.1%
Other 6.2%
Based on the responses of 195 participants (Base count of vacancies = 13,448*)
*Due to the fact that some respondents did not know the exact number of
graduates they recruited within each career area.
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
25/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
21
Achievement of 2009 recruitment targets
The vast majority (80.5%) of AGR employers filled their graduate vacancies in 2009. Although marginallylower than the predicted rate reported in the last Summer Review where nine-tenths indicated that they
anticipate to fill their vacancies this nevertheless confirms that the economic downturn has almost
eliminated recruitment shortfall (Figure 1.10). Engineering or industrial companies have the strongest
representation in the small group of participants who experienced a recruitment shortfall (17.6%). They
are followed by accountancy or professional services, law and banking or financial services companies,
which are equally represented. Moreover, analysis of recruitment shortfall by size of organisation indicates
no discernible differences with both larger (defined as 2,500 employees or more) and smaller (up to 2,499
employees) organisations filling the majority of their vacancies.
Figure 1.10:Proportion of AGR employers with a recruitment shortfall in 2009 - Base = 185.
Analysis of the extent of shortfall in 2009 (Figure 1.11) indicates that for the majority (55.9%) it was
relatively small at between one and five per cent of vacancies. Encouragingly, only a small minority of AGR
employers stated that they experienced a shortfall of between 26 to 50 per cent of vacancies at 2.9%;
however, over a quarter (26.5%) had experienced a shortfall of between 11 and 25 per cent.
Figure 1.11:Extent of shortfall of graduate recruits in 2009 - Base = 34
Yes80.5%
Don'tknow1.1%
No18.4%
55.9%
14.7%
26.5%
2.9%
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
1 to 5 %of vacancies
6 to 10 %of vacancies
11 to 25 %of vacancies
26 to 50 %of vacancies
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
26/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
22
All respondents were also asked about the extent to which their organisation met its graduate recruitment
objectives in 2009. Interestingly, over nine-tenths (94.6%) answered yes in response to this thus, indicating
that respondents perceived their organisations to have achieved their aims despite a shortfall in the
number of graduates recruited. Indeed, nearly four-fifths (79.4%) of those who indicated that they had a
shortfall stated that they had achieved their objectives for 2009. This suggests that target numbers of
vacancies are just that targetsrather than bottom line must have recruits.
Diversity of graduate recruits in 2009
The majority of respondents monitor recruitment by both gender (74.6%) and ethnicity (54.5%) which isconsistent with the findings of the Winter 2009 Review. This amounts to an increase of 5.2 percentage
points in the proportion of AGR employers monitoring recruitment by gender. Disability is monitored by
45.1% of respondents and age by just over one-third (29.1%). Within the past year, the percentage of
respondents monitoring recruitment by age has dropped by 6.6 percentage points to 29.1%. This is of
particular interest as arguably a small increase may be expected following the introduction of the
Employment Equality (Age) Regulations in 2006, which made it illegal to discriminate against employees,
jobseekers or trainees on the grounds of age. Indeed, whilst previous Graduate Recruitment Surveys have
indicated that age is receiving increasing awareness from AGR employers, this increase has not been
sustained in 2009.
Gender
Just under three-quarters (72%) of respondents who monitor recruitment by gender stated that they know
the number of male and female graduates recruited. For these respondents, the total number of males
recruited in 2009 was 5,185 in comparison to 2,867 females. On average, each responding organisation
recruited 45 males and 25 females.
Table 1.12 provides data on the gender split across sectors. This indicates that males formed the majority
of all graduates recruited to AGR employers in 2009 in all sectors with the exception of law firms. No
difference was observed in the case of FMCG, where a 50/50 split was apparent. Males were significantly
over-represented in a small number of operating sectors, including investment bank or fund managers,
engineering or industrial companies, construction companies or consultancy, and transport or logistics,
where they comprised over three-quarters of graduate recruits. This is consistent with the findings of
previous AGR Graduate Recruitment Surveys.
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
27/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
23
Table 1.12: Gender split across sectors
Male FemaleTransport or logistics company 83.3% 16.7%
Investment bank or fund managers 81.3% 18.7%
Engineering or industrial company 76.7% 23.3%
Construction company or consultancy 76.6% 23.4%
Energy, water or utility company 75.9% 24.1%
Oil company 73.3% 26.7%
Public sector 72.7% 27.3%
IT / Telecommunications companies 66.4% 33.6%
Consulting or business services firm 65.4% 34.6%
Retail 61.3% 38.7%
Accountancy or professional services firm 59.6% 40.4%
Banking or financial services 57.9% 42.1%
Insurance company 55.6% 44.4%
FMCG company 50.0% 50.0%
Law firm 45.0% 55.0%
Other 58.4% 41.6%
Based on the responses of 115 participants
Age
Figure 1.13 indicates that almost four-fifths (78.6%) of graduates recruited in 2009 whose age is known by
the responding organisation are aged 24 years or below. This represents a slight decrease of three
percentage points when compared to the Winter 2009 Review. Whilst the figure reported for 25-34 year
olds is broadly consistent (16.6% in 2009 compared to 16.8% in 2008), the percentage of graduates aged 35
years and over has more than doubled between 2008 and 2009 from 1.6% to 4.9%. This represents an
increase of 3.3 percentage points.
In absolute numbers (derived from 62 responding organisations) 2,373 recruits were 24 years old or less,
500 recruits were aged 25-34 years and 147 recruits were 35 years old and over.
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
28/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
24
Figure 1.13:Percentage of graduates recruited by age
Based on the responses of 62 participants (Base count of vacancies = 3020)
Ethnicity
Over half (54%) of respondents who monitor recruitment by ethnicity stated that they know the number of
graduates recruited from a minority ethnic background. For these respondents, the total number of black
and ethnic minority graduates recruited was 1,344, which is equivalent to an average of 21 graduates per
responding organisation.
Ethnic minority graduates accounted for up to 10% of all graduates recruited in 2009 in two-fifths (42.6%)
of responding organisations. At 22.2%, the next largest category was 11% to 20% (22.2%) followed by 31%
or more (20.4%). The average percentage of ethnic minority graduates recruited was 17.4%.
Figure 1.14:
Percentage of graduate recruits from ethnic minorities Base = 54
24 or less78.6%
25 to 34years old
16.6%
35 orolder4.9%
42.6%
22.2%
14.8%
20.4%
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
30%
35%
40%
45%
50%
Up to 10% 11% to 20% 21% to 30% 31% or more
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
29/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
25
Figure 1.15 indicates that almost one-third of ethnic minority graduates recruited in 2009 were Indian
(31.2%). This represents an increase of 7.8 percentage points when compared to the figure for 2008
reported in the Winter 2009 Review. At 15.7%, the next largest category is Chinese (15.7%) followed by
Pakistani (11.2%).
Figure 1.15:
Breakdown of ethnic minority graduates recruited Base = 54
Disability
56% of respondents who monitor recruitment by disability, as defined by the responding organisation,
stated that they know the number of graduates recruited with either a physical or mental impairment.
Amongst these, the total number of disabled graduates recruited was 149. On average, each responding
organisation recruited 3 graduates with a disability and 66 graduates without a disability.
Challenges in filling anticipated 2010 vacancies
AGR employers expecting to recruit graduates in 2010 responded to a sequence of questions about the
challenges they anticipate to face in filling their vacancies on a scale of one to six, where one is definitely
will face and six is definitely will not face.
Candidate dropout because graduates are applying to a large number of organisations (3.34) and
graduates perceptions of the industry sector (3.34) are the two main challenges that AGR employers
anticipate that they are most likely to face. Whilst graduates perceptions has been a relatively consistent
challenge in recent years, candidate dropout represents a new challenge and is reflective of the economic
downturn which has seen unprecedented levels of youth unemployment. The recession is not only
affecting those traditionally at risk of unemployment, such as the low skilled, but also those with higher
1.7%
5.2%
6.5%
8.3%
10.7%
9.6%
11.2%
15.7%
31.2%
0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35%
Black other
Black Caribbean
Bangladeshi
Black African
Other Asian
Mixed
Pakistani
Chinese
Indian
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
30/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
26
level qualifications including recent graduates. Indeed, data published indicates that, in the quarter
September to December, one in six unemployed 18-24 year olds hold a degree; this is up from one in five
three years ago (Source: The Guardian, 6th January 2010). In this context, graduates are applying to a large
number of organisations to increase the likelihood of success rather than identifying a more limited
number to approach. Interestingly, both candidate dropout and graduates perceptions relate to the
quality of applicants rather than internal issues relating to AGR employers. Dropout is an unfortunate yet
understandable side effect of the tightening jobs market for employers.
Late changes in the businesses requirements (3.27) is only marginally below that of candidate dropout and
graduates perceptions and therefore also poses a significant challenge. In an uncertain economic climate,
delayed decisions or late changes may adversely affect their ability to meet their targets for 2010.
Figure 1.16:
Relative likelihood to face different challenges in filling expected graduate vacancies in 2010
Base = 199; Mean ratings on a scale from 1 (definitely will not face this challenge) to 6 (definitely will face this
challenge)
1.87
2.39
2.41
2.42
2.6
2.83
2.96
3.27
3.34
3.34
Offering a competitive graduate training and development programme
Candidates dropout because selection and assessment process is slow
Offering a competitive starting salary
Not enough applicants with the right qualifications
Shortage of applicants in specific geographical areas
Limited resources to market graduate vacancies properly
Not enough applicants with the right skills
Late changes in the businesses' requirements
Graduates' perceptions of the industry sector
Candidates dropout because graduates are applying to a large numberof organisations
Policy Insight: Government support for employability skills
The Government has outlined plans to ask all universities to produce a statement on how they
promote student employability, setting out what they are doing to prepare their students for the
labour market, and how they plan to make information about the employment outcomes of their
provision available to prospective students. Universities will be expected to demonstrate how they
prepare their students for the world of work and support the development of generic employability
skills such as team working, business awareness and communication.
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
31/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
27
Graduate salaries in 2009 and 2010
For the second consecutive year, it is predicted that there will be no change in the median starting salary ofgraduates working for AGR employers in 2010. For the first time in the history of the Graduate Recruitment
Survey, the Winter 2009 Review predicted stagnation in salary levels; both the Summer 2009 and Winter
2010 Reviews confirmed this to be true with the average graduate employed by an AGR employer earning
25,000 in 2009. Although the 2010 figures are predictions, this trend looks set to continue in the
prevailing economic climate with the class of both 2009 and 2010 the first cohorts to pay top-up fees for
higher education provision in England and Wales feeling the full impact of the downturn (Figure 1.17).
Figure 1.17:
Changes in median graduate starting salaries at AGR employers 2000 - 2010 (predicted)
Percentage increase or decrease on previous year (varying bases)
0.0%
0.0%
1.8%
2.4%
2.0%
7.1%
3.4%
4.1%
2.6%
2.7%
5.7%
0% 1% 2% 3% 4% 5% 6% 7% 8%
2010 (predicted)
2009
2008
2007
2006
2005
2004
2003
2002
2001
2000
Comparative Data: Median salary for adults with a degree or equivalent qualification
The Labour Force Survey, which interviews some 53,000 UK households each quarter, is one of the
most drawn upon sources of information on the labour market. It asks questions about all aspects of
the labour market, including salary level. The latest publicly available data indicates that, in the
quarter July to September 2009, the median salary for adults with a degree or equivalent level
qualification was 30,004. This amounts to a difference of 17% when compared to the median salary
offered by AGR employers. However, it must be remembered that the figure reported in the Labour
Force Survey is the average salary for all degree qualified adults in the UK and not a starting salary. In
this context, the starting salary offered by AGR employers is, therefore, competitive.
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
32/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
28
Figure 1.18 indicates that one-quarter (25.0%) of responding AGR employers expect to offer a starting
salary of between 24,001 to 26,000 in 2010, with a fairly even distribution between 22,001 to 24,000
(20.1%) and 26,001to 31,000 (20.7%). Just under two-thirds of survey respondents are represented in
these bandings.
Figure 1.18:
Graduate starting salaries at AGR employers in 2009 and 2010 (predicted)
Base = 184
0.0%
2.7%
5.9%
25.4%
22.7%
22.2%
8.6%
11.9%
3.9%
4.9%
4.9%
20.1%
25.0%
20.7%
7.6%
13.0%
0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30%
Don't know
Less than 19,000
19,001 to 22,000
22,001 to 24,000
24,001 to 26,000
26,001 to 31,000
31,001 to 36,000
36,001 or more
2010 (predicted)
2009
Policy Insight: The importance of a good salary
A good salary is more important than ever to recent graduates - the class of 2009 is the first to have
paid up to 3,225 in top-up fees for each year of study and the financial cost of obtaining a degree is
only likely to increase in the future. The Government recently launched an independent review of
student fees led by Lord Browne, the former head of BP, and it is widely expected that the review will
recommend that the current cap on tuition fees should be lifted. Projections in a report published by
Universities UK in 2009 indicated that even a modest increase in fees to 5,000 could lead to
graduates owing an average of 26,000.
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
33/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
29
Graduate salaries in 2009 by business sector
Investment bank or fund managers top the salary chart in 2009 with a median starting salary of 38,250an increase of 3,250 when compared to 2008. Law firms have dropped from first to second place in figure
1.19, which is in part accounted for by the drop in salary offered by this sector, from 37,000 in 2008 to
35,000 in 2009. Oil companies for the first time appear in the chart in third place. Not unsurprisingly,
third sector organisations offer the lowest median started salary in 2009 at 19,000 followed by the public
sector and retail (both offering starting salaries of 23,000).
Figure 1.19:
Median graduate starting salaries at AGR employers in 2009 by sector
Base = 184
Graduate salaries in 2009 by region
Unsurprisingly, London continued to top the median starting salary table in 2009, although the decrease
observed in recent years has continued from 28,375 in 2007, 28,000 in 2008 and 27,750 in 2009. The
South East has maintained its position in second; however, the Midlands has over-taken the South West for
third place thus suggesting a narrowing of the gap between the South and elsewhere. Interestingly, East
Anglia which offered a median starting salary in 2008 of 23,250 has dropped from fourth to last of all
of the regions in the UK (Table 1.20). This may reflect changes to the sectors recruiting in this area since
the Winter 2009 Review; in 2008, accountancy was the main sector whereas in 2009 it was retail.
25,000
19,000
23,000
23,000
23,000
23,500
23,500
25,000
25,000
25,500
25,500
26,000
27,000
27,750
28,500
33,500
35,000
38,250
Other
Third sector
Public sector
Retail
Construction company or consultancy
Engineering or industrial company
Transport or logistics company
Energy, water or utility company
Accountancy or professional services firm
FMCG company
Insurance company
Motor manufacturer
IT / Telecommunications companies
Consulting or business services firm
Banking or financial services
Oil company
Law firm
Investment bank or fund managers
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
34/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
30
Table 1.20: 2009 starting graduate salaries by geographical area
Median salary Upper Quartile Lower Quartile
London (Base= 136) 27,750 33,500 24,500
South East (Base= 78) 24,500 27,000 23,000
Midlands (Base= 75) 24,000 26,000 23,000
South West (Base= 71) 24,000 26,500 23,000
North West (Base= 74) 23,750 25,000 23,000
Scotland (Base= 65) 23,500 26,000 22,250
Yorkshire (Base= 57) 23,500 25,000 22,750
Wales (Base= 34) 23,250 25,000 20,500
Northern Ireland (Base= 25) 23,000 25,000 20,750
North East (Base= 45) 23,000 25,500 22,500
East Anglia (Base= 30) 23,000 25,000 23,000
USA (Base= 2) 34,750 36,000 33,500
Europe (Base= 20) 28,500 37,750 22,500
Asia (Base= 5) 28,500 37,250 24,750
Ireland (Base= 8) 25,000 27,750 23,000
Offshore British Islands (Base= 4) 25,000 27,750 20,500
Rest of the world (Base= 5) 26,750 37,250 22,000
Comparative Data: Median salary for adults with a degree or equivalent qualification by
region
Data from the Labour Force Survey similarly confirms the dominance of the South in terms of salary
level. Analysis of data on the median salary for adults qualified to degree level or equivalent in the
UK by Government Office Region for the quarter July to September 2009 indicates that London tops
the table at 34,008. It is followed by the South East (33,592), East of England (32,578) and West
Midlands (30,004). The North East and North West regions offer the lowest median salary at
27,976 and 27,248 respectively. The regions used in the Graduate Recruitment Survey differ
marginally from the classification of Government Office Region used in major national datasets;
development work will be undertaken to align these sectors to facilitate analysis in the future.
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
35/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
31
Graduate salaries in 2009 by career area
Table 1.21 indicates that investment banking continued to offer the highest median starting salary whencompared to all other career areas offered by AGR employers in 2009. This is consistent with the Winter
2009 Review, although it should be noted that legal work which previously shared first place with
investment banking has dropped to second in the chart with a difference of 3,250 between these
functions. This is reflective of the decrease in median starting salaries in the legal sector, from 37,000 in
2008 to 35,000 in 2009. Consulting, actuarial work and IT have maintained their positions in third, fourth
and fifth place, with small increases in salary observed for all career areas apart from IT, where a decrease
of 500 is apparent. However, the most notable difference is in relation to accountancy, which was
previously in sixth place with a median starting salary of 25,000, now sits in fifth from the bottom of the
table in seventeenth place. Although only a relatively modest decrease of 500 in the median starting
salary of graduates entering this function is apparent when compared to 2008, other career areas
including sales, science, purchasing, electrical engineering, mechanical engineering, and research and
development have increased their salaries and overtaken accountancy in the table.
Table 1.21: 2009 starting graduate salaries by career area
Median salary Upper Quartile Lower Quartile
Investment banking (Base= 16) 38,250 41,500 32,250
Legal work (Base= 34) 35,000 37,250 26,250
Consulting (Base= 24) 28,250 32,250 25,250
Actuarial work (Base= 15) 28,000 30,000 25,000
IT (Base= 63) 26,000 28,500 23,750
Sales (Base= 31) 26,000 27,250 23,000
Science (Base= 14) 25,500 27,500 25,000
Financial management (Base= 48) 25,000 28,500 23,500
Electrical / electronic engineering (Base= 35) 25,000 26,750 23,000
Human resources (Base= 43) 25,000 27,000 23,000
Marketing (Base= 41) 25,000 26,750 23,000
Research and development (Base= 21) 25,000 27,500 24,000
Manufacturing engineering (Base= 21) 25,000 26,500 23,000
Purchasing (Base= 22) 25,000 26,250 23,500
Logistics (Base= 20) 25,000 27,000 23,000
Mechanical engineering (Base= 38) 24,750 26,000 23,000
Accountancy (Base= 45) 24,500 26,000 23,000
General management (Base= 48) 24,500 27,000 23,000
Civil engineering (Base= 22) 24,250 25,250 23,000
Retail management (Base= 14) 23,750 26,750 23,000
Other (Base= 37) 24,000 27,000 23,000
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
36/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
32
Expected salary changes in 2010 by business sector
Table 1.22 is reflective of the predicted stagnation in the overall median starting salary of graduatesrecruited during the 2010 season, with eight sectors reporting no change in the salary level offered to
graduates. Of these, this is the second consecutive year for which there is no change for investment bank
or fund managers. The banking or financial services and accountancy or professional services sectors
experienced a decrease between 2008 and 2009 and is, therefore, indicative of the levelling off of their
salary levels. The anticipated stagnation in public sector salaries is in part accounted for by the squeeze on
public sector salaries and pensions as the Government attempt to scale back the 178 billion deficit. The
Pre-Budget Report issued in December 2009 indicates that this is set to continue with a two year cap of 1%
on all public sector pay settlements from 2011. At 8.7%, the largest increase can be seen in construction,
which is the only sector to increase its salary for a second consecutive year. Transport and logistics,
consulting or business services firms and law reported no change between 2008 and 2009.
Table 1.22: Predicted salary change from 2009 to 2010 (predicted) by sector
Construction company or consultancy +8.7%
Transport or logistics company +6.4%
IT / Telecommunications companies +5.6%
Consulting or business services firm +2.7%
Law firm +2.5%
Energy, water or utility company no change
Banking or financial services no change
Accountancy or professional services firm no change
Public sector no change
Investment bank or fund managers no change
Retail no change
Oil company no change
Third sector no change
FMCG company -2.0%
Insurance company -2.0%
Engineering or industrial company -2.1%
Base= 179*
*Participants who recruited in a specific sector in 2009 but are not planning to recruit in that
sector in 2010 were not taken into account for the calculation of salary changes. As a result,
some sectors do not appear in the above table.
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
37/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
33
Lump sum payments to graduates in 2010
Figure 1.23 indicates that just over one-quarter (26.6%) of responding organisations intend to attract andreward successful candidates in 2010 with a lump sum payment. Not unexpected in the current economic
climate, this amounts to a decrease of 6.3 percentage points since the Winter 2009 Review. It follows that
there has been a significant increase in the percentage answering no in response to this question (64.5%
compared to 55.1% in the Winter Review which amounts to 9.4 percentage points).
Figure 1.23:
Proportion of employers expecting to pay lump sums to graduate recruits Base = 203
At 33.3%, the largest category is lump sums between the value of 1001 and 2,000. Just under one-
quarter (24.1%) of responding organisations pay between 2,001 and 3,000 whilst one-fifth (22.2%) pay
4,001 and above (Figure 1.24). The median lump sum expected to be offered by AGR employers in 2010 is
2,500, which represents an increase in this figure for the first time since 2008 of 500.
Figure 1.24:
Predicted lump-sum payments for 2010 Base = 54
No64.5%
Don't Know8.9%
Yes26.6%
3.7%
9.3%
33.3%
24.1%
7.4%
22.2%
0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40%
Don't Know
Less that 1,000
1,001 to 2,000
2,001 to 3,000
3,001 to 4,000
4,001 or more
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
38/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
34
Lump sums are paid when graduates start work in the vast majority of organisations (79.6%); only a small
minority (11.1%) make a payment when the offer is made. At 46.3%, payment is in addition to salary in
almost half of responding organisations.
Figure 1.25:
Facts about lump-sums paid - Base = 54
Education premiums and other remuneration for graduates in 2010
Just under one-third (29.7%) of responding organisations intend to offer a financial premium for
qualifications above an undergraduate degree in 2010. This represents an increase of 11.7 percentagepoints when compared to the Winter 2009 Review and thus suggests that competition for talent continues
despite the economic crisis. Figure 1.26 indicates that more organisations offer a financial premium for
PhD degrees (12.3%) than for a postgraduate degree (9.9%), such as an MA or MSc. Relevant work
experience attracts a financial premium in only a small minority of responding organisations (5.9%). PhD
degrees attract the highest median financial premium at 3,000 followed by postgraduate degrees (1,125)
and relevant work experience (1,000).
Please note: the above percentages have been calculated on the total number of respondents to this
question rather than those who offer educational premiums only, as in the Winter 2009 Review. These
figures are, therefore, not directly comparable with previous Graduate Recruitment Surveys and should be
used indicatively.
3.7%
7.4%
11.1%
46.3%
79.6%
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80%
Payment is an advance of salary
Payment is repayable loan
Paid when offer is made
Payment is in addition to salary
Paid when graduate starts work
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
39/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
35
Figure 1.26:
Qualifications for which premiums are paid - Base = 203
Pension schemes (96.1%) and training for professional qualifications (84.7%) continue to be offered by thevast majority of responding organisations in 2010 and maintain their position as the popular non-monetary
benefits. Private healthcare (65.0%), free or subsidised sports and leisure facilitates (60.1%) and study
leave and sponsorship (59.6%) remain in third, fourth and fifth position in the table when compared to the
Winter 2009 Review with almost no discernible difference in the percentages reported. Whilst the
relocation package continues to fall in popularity (30.0% compared to 33.9%), it is travel where the largest
decrease is apparent; it has dropped by 8.3 percentage points from 40.3% in 2009 to 32.0% in 2010 (Figure
1.27).
Figure 1.27: Benefits offered - Base = 203
4.9%
5.9%
9.9%
12.3%
70.4%
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80%
Other qualifications
Relevant work experience
Postgraduate degrees
PhD degree
We do not pay premiums
0.5%
0.5%
6.9%
29.6%
30.0%
32.0%
59.6%
60.1%
65.0%
84.7%
96.1%
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
Don't Know
We will not offer any benefit
Company car
Share options/schemes
Relocation package
Travel
Study leave or sponsorship
Free or subsidised sports or leisure facilities
Private healthcare
Training for professional qualifications
Pension Scheme
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
40/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
36
Chapter 2
Graduate recruitment
marketing
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
41/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
37
Graduate recruitment marketingIn this section we turn the spotlight on AGR members graduate recruitment marketing practices, and in
particular the size of recruitment marketing budgets and the proportionate spend on different marketing
activities and approaches.
Employers were asked to specify their actual spend in 2009 and their predicted spend in 2010 on key
marketing activities. These activities were: employers own graduate recruitment brochures and websites;
graduate recruitment advertising; online graduate recruitment promotions; and employer presence at
graduate careers fairs and on-campus presentations. The survey also asked employers to indicate how
their spending was distributed within each of these areas.
Total marketing spend in 2009 and 2010
The final year-end data for total marketing spend per organisation indicates that the predictions made by
AGR employers for 2009 were extremely optimistic. Estimated at 80,000, the actual figure was some
60,000 less at 20,000. This suggests that the full impact of the recession was not felt until after AGR
employers set their budgets for the 2009 recruitment season and, as the economic climate worsened, they
were forced to downgrade their total marketing budget. More positively for 2010, no further decrease is
expected with median total marketing spend remaining steady at 20,000.
Figure 2.1 indicates an increase in predicted marketing spend in 2010 across all bandings with the
exception of 30,001 to 40,000 and 40,001 or more. Whilst a decrease of only 1.1 percentage points is
apparent in relation to the former, the equivalent figure for 40,001 or more is considerable at 10.1. The
increase observed across the remaining categories is marginal, with no difference observed in relation to
10,001 to 20,000; the notable exclusion is the category 20,001 to 30,000 which has increased by 9.1
percentage points.
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
42/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
38
Figure 2.1:
Median total spending on graduate recruitment marketing in 2009 and 2010 (predicted) Base = 188
Graduate recruitment marketing activities in 2009
The traditional mainstays of graduate recruitment marketing activity continue to feature in AGR members
recruitment plans for 2010. As Figure 2.2 shows over nine-tenths (92.8%) of respondents to the survey
plan to utilise brochures and/or company websites, with 89.7% of recruiters planning to use on-campus
activities such as attendance at careers fairs, presentations or promotions. Interestingly, although still an
important method of marketing, the percentage of recruiters saying they will use paper-based advertising
has fallen from 95.1% in the Winter 2009 Review to 86.7%. This may be an indication of planned cutbacks
in advertising during the recession.
Figure 2.2:
Graduate recruitment marketing activities planned for 2010 - Base = 195
9.0%
4.3%
6.4%
8.5%
37.2%
4.8%
29.8%
9.6%
5.3%
6.9%
8.5%
46.3%
3.7%
19.7%
0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40% 45% 50%
No Budget
Up to 4,000
4,001 to 10,000
10,001 to 20,000
20,001 to 30,000
30,001 to 40,000
40,001 or more
2010 (predicted)
2009
72.8%
86.7%
89.7%
92.8%
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%
Online promotion
Advertising
Career fairs/campus presentations or promotion
Brochure/company website
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
43/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
39
Spend on key activities in 2009 and 2010
Figure 2.3 indicates an interesting finding: that there is no difference in the predicted median spend ofresponding AGR employers in both 2009 and 2010 on online promotions, careers fairs and paper-based
advertisements. This is particularly surprising given the increasing popularity of online methods, including
social media. Expenditure on careers fairs and paper-based advertisements in 2009 was less than that
predicted in the Winter 2009 Review (by 5,000 and 6,000 respectively), presumably as a consequence of
the economic climate, with the figures reported predicted to remain static in 2010. An increase in spend on
recruitment websites is predicted, with a decrease expected for recruitment brochures.
Figure 2.3:
Median spend 2009 and 2010 (predicted) on key activities Varying Bases
Marketing spend per vacancy
Marketing spend per vacancy has been calculated by dividing the total marketing budget available to AGRemployers in 2009 and 2010 by the number of vacancies.
At 800, the median marketing spend per vacancy in 2009 was significantly below the figure of 2,533
predicted in the Winter 2009 Review. Moreover, this is predicted to decrease further still during the 2010
recruitment season to a meager 540. This is reflective of the slowdown in graduate vacancies and salaries
which had not impacted upon graduate recruitment marketing until the 2010 season.
It follows that, in contrast to the Winter 2009 Review, a small decrease in median marketing spend per
vacancy is apparent across all bandings (Figure 2.4) with the exception of up to 1,000, which has increased
by 7.2 percentage points from 47.2% to 54.4%. Smaller proportions of AGR employers are, therefore,
3,750
5,000
15,000
15,000
15,000
2,000
7,000
15,000
15,000
15,000
Recruitement brochure (Base= 139)
Recruitment website (Base= 125)
Paper Based ads (Base= 127)
Careers fairs/ campus promotions (Base= 135)
Online promotions (Base= 95)
2010 (predicted)
2009
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
44/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
40
expected to be spending in the highest brackets in 2010 which is reflective of the overall decrease in
marketing spend per vacancy. Moreover, an increase of 2.5 percentage points is apparent in relation to the
percentage of organisations with a null budget per vacancy which is predicted to increase from 5.6% in
2009 to 8.1% in 2010.
Figure 2.4:
Median marketing spend per vacancy in 2009 and 2010 (predicted) Base = 161
Targeting universities in 2009 and 2010
When asked if they had targeted UK universities for campus events or local advertising, the vast majority of
AGR recruiters (82.2%) said they had done so. This proportion is forecast to remain largely unchanged into
2010 (82.6%) (Figure 2.5).
Figure 2.5:Whether targeted and whether will target UK universities - Base = 213
5.6%
47.2%
21.7%
11.2%
10.6%
3.7%
8.1%
54.4%
20.0%
8.1%
7.5%
1.9%
-10% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60%
Null budget per vacancy
Up to 1,000
1,001 to 2,500
2,501 to 4,500
4,501 to 10,000
10,001 to 20,0002010 (predicted)
2009
0.5%
17.4%
82.2%
4.2%
13.1%
82.6%
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%
Don't Know
No
Yes
2010 (predicted)
2009
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
45/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
41
Further analysis of those 175 employers who targeted UK Universities for campus events and local
advertising shows that 42.9% of employers targeted between 1 and 10 universities, with a further 33.7%
targeting between 11 and 20 universities and 22.9% targeting over 20 universities. As Figure 2.6 shows, the
forecasted picture is one of an increase in the proportion of employers targeting the mid range figure of 11-
20 universities with a resultant reduction in the numbers seeking to target 10 or less and 20 or more.
Figure 2.6:
Number of UK Universities targeted for campus events in 2009 and 2010 (predicted)Base (2009) = 175; Base (2010) = 176
Personal contact with university careers advisers is the most utilised form of communication with
universities with 65.7% of AGR members saying they adopted this approach. A further 41.7% of members
said they had made personal visits to academics on campus.
The broader approach of the use of open days for careers advisers and academics were less popular
methods of communication with universities in 2009 with 34.9% and 13.7% of recruiters adopting these
approaches respectively. However, significantly more recruiters are planning to use open days in 2010 with
43.2% of recruiters saying that they plan to run open days with careers advisers and 22.7% mentioning that
they plan to run open days with academics. This growth is in part attributed to AGR-led sector focus groups.
In 2009, four sectors (retail, banking or financial services, engineering and FMCG) ran events
targeted specifically at careers advisers; in 2010, the number of sectors running similar events is expected
to increase to six.
37.5% 38.6%
19.9%
4.0%
42.9%
33.7%
22.9%
0.6%
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
30%
35%
40%
45%
50%
1 to 10 11 to 20 more than 20 Don't know
2010 (predicted)
2009
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
46/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
42
Figure 2.7:Communication methods used to contact universities in 2009 and 2010 (predicted)
Base (2009) = 175; Base (2010) = 176
5.1%
13.7%
34.9%
41.7%
65.7%
11.9%
22.7%
43.2%
47.7%
67.0%
-10% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70%
Don't Know
Open days' for academics
Open days' for careers advisors
Personal visits to academics on campus
Personal visits to careers advisors on campus
2010 (predicted)
2009
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
47/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
43
Chapter 3
Hot topics in graduate
recruitment
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
48/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
44
Hot topics in graduaterecruitmentThis final chapter of the Winter Review addresses a series of current hot topics in graduate recruitment.
The chapter begins with our annual look at the prevalence of school-leaver entry programmes among AGR
employers, as well as examining the proportions of members who actively recruit for UK vacancies abroad
and their reasons for doing so.
School-leaver entry programmesThe proportion of AGR employers who offer a school-leaver entry programme for 16 to 18 year olds has
declined from 29.7% in the Winter 2009 Review to just over 26.3%. An entry programme for school-leaversis under consideration at 12.6% of those organisations who currently do not operate one (see Figure 3.1).
This is an increase from the 10.6% of employers who reported they were considering implementing an
entry programme for school-leavers in the last Winter Review.
Policy Insight: The demand for university places is outstripping supply
In January 2010, the Higher Education Statistics Agency revealed that than 1.14m students started
undergraduate or postgraduate courses in 2008/09 a jump of 7% on the previous year. In the face
of this unprecedented demand, it is estimated that as many as 200,000 individuals could miss out on
a place at university. Cuts in the higher education budget have also meant that universities face fines
if they recruit more students than planned, despite the slow progress being made towards the
Governments target of 50% of 18-30 year olds achieving a higher level qualification. In Skills for
Growth, the Governments national skills strategy published in 2009, this target was increased to 75%
and expanded to include young people completing an advanced apprenticeship or equivalent
technician level course.
-
8/3/2019 AGR 2010 Winter Survey Report
49/53
Graduate Recruitment Survey 2010 Winter Review
45
Recruiting for UK vacancies overseas
The number of AGR members looking overseas to fill UK graduate vacancies continues to steadily fall. One-
fifth (22.8%) of survey respondents reported this as being part of their recruitment policy in Winter 2009
Review, while this year (as shown in Figure 3.3) the figure has fallen again to 18.4%. This may be a
reflection of the tightening graduate jobs market, resulting in more home-grown talent applications and
less need to look overseas. Of the AGR employers who plan to recruit overseas, 25.6% are from the
investment bank or fund manager sector, with a further 17.9% from engineering or industrial companies
and 12.8% from the banking or financial services sector. All of these expect an increase in vacancies in
2010.
Just under one-third (30.8%) of those respondents who actively market UK vacancies abroad limit this
activity to Europe, down from 36.0% in last years Winter Review (see Figure 3.4).
No70.9%
Don'tknow2.8%
Yes26.3%
Figure 3.1:
Proportions of employers operating a school-leaver
entry programme (16-18 years)Base = 213
Figure 3.2:
Proportion of employers not yet operating but
considering a schoo