agenda · 2018-04-03 · 2. changes in agenda/motion to accept agenda 3. introduction of guests...
TRANSCRIPT
AGENDA
Annual Board Meeting December 9, 2016
Great Wolf Lodge ~ Grand Mound
7:30 am BREAKFAST 8:00 am MEMBER REPRESENTATIVE MEETINGS (Find your Member Rep) 9:00 am
CALL TO ORDER – President Emmett Heath
1. Roll Call of Members 2. Changes in Agenda/Motion to Accept Agenda 3. Introduction of Guests
Sign-in sheet
DISCUSSION
1. Member Representative Meeting Report and Discussion
Page #
*WP #
FINANCIAL REPORTS –Christianson
1. September 2016 Treasurer’s Report 2. September 2016 Income & Expense Statement 3. September 2016 Balance Sheet 4. September 2016 Claims Report 5. September 2016 Comparative Balance Sheet & Income & Expense
Statement
002 003 006 007 009
EXECUTIVE SESSION
1. Proposed amendments to the Executive Director’s Contract
STAFF REPORTS 1. Executive Staff Report – Hatten & Christianson 2. Annual Report of Paid Events over $100,000 – Christianson 3. Executive Director’s Annual Report - Hatten 4. General Counsel’s Report – Franz 5. Broker’s Report – White
014 023 025 028 031
ACTION ITEMS
1. Minutes – September 30, 2016 2. Governance Policy: Governance Policy: Explained and Defined 3. Approve General Liability / Auto Liability Coverage Document (no changes) 4. Approve Public Officials Liability Coverage Document (no changes) 5. Approve reclassification of one staff position and one new position -
Christianson 6. Approve 2017 WSTIP Budget ($14,578,843) 7. Approve 2017 Member Allocations ($14,578,834) 8. Approve Executive Director’s contract 1/1/2017 to 3/31/2018
042 046 050 061 071
075 103 129
11:00 am EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE & OFFICERS ELECTION, PASSING OF THE GAVEL
MEMBER UPDATES & GUEST FEEDBACK
12:00 pm ADJOURN (Box Lunches available if you ordered one while registering)
NEXT MEETING – March 25, 2017
*WP = Work Plan Item #
Washington State Transit Insurance Pool Treasurer's Report
Date: September 30, 2016
To: WSTIP Board Members
Subject: Treasurer's Report September 30, 2016
The following is a summary of the cash and investment status as of September 30, 2016Item Rate Account Balance % of Total
US Bank Claims 0.05% 200,709 0.505%
US Bank Administration 0.05% 90,577 0.228%
US Bank - Payroll 22,060 0.055%
Wa State Local Government Investment Pool 0.52% 608,605 1.531%
Thurston County Investment Pool 0.86% 38,841,060 97.681%
Cash and Equivalents: 39,763,011 100.00%
No Assurance Is Provided On This Financial StatementSustantially All Disclosures Are Not Included.
Washington State Transit Insurance Pool
Statement of IncomeSeptember 30, 2016% of Fiscal Period Passed:
75.00%
September 30, 2016 YTD INCOME ACTUAL BUDGET YEARLY BUDGET % of Budget
IncomeMEMBER CONTRIBUTIONS
Asotin County 3,758$ 33,824 33,824 45,099$ 75.00%Ben Franklin 80,200 721,802 721,802 962,402 75.00%Clallam 27,284 245,554 245,555 327,406 75.00%Columbia County 3,325 29,927.97 29,928 39,904 75.00%Community 166,106 1,494,952 1,494,953 1,993,270 75.00%C-Tran 77,014 693,126 693,126 924,168 75.00%RiverCities 7,655 68,893 68,894 91,858 75.00%Everett Transit 24,077 216,689 216,689 288,918 75.00%Grant Transit Authority 12,847 115,620 115,620 154,160 75.00%Grays Harbor 18,909 170,183 170,183 226,910 75.00%Intercity 88,779 799,013 799,013 1,065,351 75.00%Island 28,996 260,968 260,968 347,957 75.00%Jefferson 9,880 88,924 88,924 118,565 75.00%Kitsap 65,552 589,964 589,964 786,618 75.00%Link 27,832 250,490 250,490 333,986 75.00%Mason 16,248 146,234 146,234 194,978 75.00%Pacific 5,397 48,575 48,575 64,766 75.00%Pierce Transit 190,973 1,718,759 1,718,759 2,291,678 75.00%Pullman Transit 5,061 45,553 45,553 60,737 75.00%Skagit 28,866 259,797 259,797 346,396 75.00%Spokane Transit 109,394 984,545 984,545 1,312,727 75.00%Twin Transit 4,726 42,533 42,533 56,711 75.00%Valley Transit 9,121 82,092 82,092 109,456 75.00%Whatcom 43,813 394,313 394,313 525,750 75.00%Yakima 16,197 145,771 145,772 194,362 75.00%
Total MEMBER CONTRIBUTIONS 1,072,011 9,648,100 9,648,100 12,864,133 75.00%
NON-OPERATING REVENUE CJI TournamentInterest Income 27,575 250,896 262,500 350,000 71.68%Training Coalition 1,950 50,891 37,500 50,000 101.78%Lease Payments 1,500 13,500 13,500 18,000 75.00%Other Miscellaneous 411 85,318 30,000 40,000 213.30%
Total NON-OPERATING REVENUE 31,436 400,605 343,500 458,000 87.47%
Total Income 1,103,447 10,048,705 9,991,600 13,322,133 75.43%
Expense
CLAIMS ULAE Liability Claims 521,796 4,696,166 4,696,166 6,261,554 75.00% 1st Party Claims 50,339 453,051 453,051 604,068 75.00%
Total CLAIMS 572,135 5,149,217 5,149,217 6,865,622 75.00%
INSURANCE SERVICES - Captive - $3M xs $2M 60,120 541,080 543,083 724,111 74.72%Reinsurance - $10M xs $5M 31,610 284,493 285,750 381,000 74.67%Excess Coverage $5M X $15M 11,333 102,000 102,750 137,000 74.45%1st Party Property 61,741 559,834 585,490 780,653 71.71%Blanket Pollution 3,615 32,535 32,250 43,000 75.66%Underground Storage Tank Cov. 73,322 118,444 50,762 67,682 175.00%Crime & Fidelity 1,239 11,151 12,293 16,391 68.03%
Total INSURANCE SERVICES 242,980 1,649,537 1,612,378 2,149,837 76.73%
CONTRACT SERVICES Administrative Services 2,828 35,731 20,250 27,000 132.34%Contract Web Design - DIS Backup - Driver Record Monitoring - 280,662 186,050 248,066 113.14%Integrated Risk - Contract Services 135 10,970 18,750 25,000 43.88%Rack Space 650 5,219 8,100 10,800 48.32%Software Cooperative
Total CONTRACT SERVICES 3,613 332,582 233,150 310,866 106.99%
STAFF WAGES, TAXES & BENEFITS Wages 91,624 808,490 751,565 1,002,086 80.68%Staff Benefits 17,259 154,377 182,006 242,674 63.62%Retirement Trust ICMA 5,526 48,755 46,073 61,430 79.37%Payroll taxes 1,427 13,592 21,009 28,012 48.52%
Total STAFF WAGES, TAXES & BENEFITS 115,837 1,025,215 1,000,652 1,334,202 76.84%
BROKER FEE 25,300 101,200 92,767 101,200 100.00%
No Assurance Is Provided On This Financial StatementSubstantially All Disclosures Are Not Included.
Page 1 of 3
Washington State Transit Insurance Pool
Statement of IncomeSeptember 30, 2016% of Fiscal Period Passed:
75.00%
September 30, 2016 YTD INCOME ACTUAL BUDGET YEARLY BUDGET % of Budget
LEGAL AND ACCOUNTINGAccounting 3,611 20,948 11,264 15,018 139.48%Legal - General - 0.00%Legal - Other 0.00%
Total LEGAL AND ACCOUNTING 3,611 20,948 11,264 15,018 139.48%
ACTUARIAL 35,000 54,750 54,375 72,500 75.52%-
BOARD EXPENSES - Jeff Ristau Scholarship - 7,350 15,000 20,000 36.75%Board Development 7,500 10,000 0.00%Conference/Travel - WSTIP Board 695 62,359 63,750 85,000 73.36%Board Meeting Expenses - 33,502 44,393 59,190 56.60%
Total BOARD EXPENSES 695 103,210 130,643 174,190 59.25%
STAFF CONFERENCES & TRAVEL Staff Travel 4,486 56,491 52,593 70,124 80.56%Staff Registration 10,754 20,303 7,838 10,451 194.27%Educational Materials 185 2,025
Total STAFF CONFERENCES & TRAVEL 15,424 78,819 60,431 80,575 97.82%
LOSS CONTROL SERVICES Driver Recognition Program 3,600 13,025 Network Security 35,884 45,001 93,750 125,000 36.00%Loss Prevention Projects 2,614 75,893 43,500 58,000 130.85%Vanpool Driver Online Refresher 5,250 7,000 0.00%Guest Rider Program - 4,603 - Contract Services 15,850 23,250 31,000 51.13%LOSS CONTROL SERVICES - Other - Competitve Grant Program - Best Practices Work Plan - Best Practices/Risk Management 10,053 40,500 54,000 18.62%Trainers Showcase 10,308 1,500 2,000 515.40%On-Line Training Programs - Pre Litigation Fund - 17,484 41,250 55,000 31.79%Roadeo Sponsorship 7,000 9,000 12,000 58.33%Video Purchases 53 53 1,125 1,500 3.53%Diamond Award - Golden Coach Award 704 791 6,375 8,500 9.31%Best Practices Award - Risk Management Grants - 27,500 49,500 66,000 41.67%Grants/Training - Other - 9,426 - Recognition 206 - Training Coalition 2,312 39,133 30,000 40,000 97.83%Loss Control Services - Other - 0.00%
Total LOSS CONTROL SERVICES 45,166 276,326 377,083 460,000 60.07%
COMMUNICATIONS Telephone 1,125 10,629 11,124 14,832 71.66%Internet Access 481 4,086 3,245 4,326 94.45%
Total COMMUNICATIONS 1,605 14,714 14,369 19,158 76.81%
OCCUPANCY COSTS Utilities 609 10,157 11,124 14,832 68.48%Janitorial Services 401 2,009 3,750 5,000 40.17%Maintenance/Repairs 1,026 15,734 9,000 12,000 131.12%Office Equipment Lease 482 4,335 4,500 6,000 72.25%
Total OCCUPANCY COSTS 2,517 32,235 28,374 37,832 85.21%
OFFICE EXPENSES Dues and Subscriptions 817 11,706 7,745 10,327 113.35%Postage 150 2,763 2,405 3,206 86.18%Printing & Graphic Services 1,293 11,937 9,821 13,094 91.16%Office Supplies 1,630 15,496 14,013 18,684 82.94%
Total OFFICE EXPENSES 3,890 41,901 33,983 45,311 92.47%
AUDITS St. R/M Audit and Assessment - 11,734 12,581 16,774 69.96%Property Audits 17,094 11,250 15,000 113.96%Annual Audit 1,210 5,493 8,077 10,769 51.01%
Total AUDITS 1,210 34,321 31,907 42,543 80.67%
INFORMATION SERVICESComputer maintenance/support 323 13,598 38,891 51,854 26.22%Software/licenses/upgrades 8,722 103,393 103,575 138,100 74.87%
No Assurance Is Provided On This Financial StatementSubstantially All Disclosures Are Not Included.
Page 2 of 3
Washington State Transit Insurance Pool
Statement of IncomeSeptember 30, 2016% of Fiscal Period Passed:
75.00%
September 30, 2016 YTD INCOME ACTUAL BUDGET YEARLY BUDGET % of Budget
RMIS Purchase 3,515 3,600 4,800 73.23%Hardware/upgrades/replacement 3,077 12,610 14,250 19,000 66.37%New Initiatives Web Site Update 9,990 15,150 20,200 49.46%
Total INFORMATION SERVICES 12,122 143,106 175,466 233,954 61.17%
MISCELLANEOUSLease-Hold Rent Taxes 1,165 CJI TournamentMiscellaneous 1,500 2,000 0.00%
Total MISCELLANEOUS - 1,165 1,500 2,000 58.26%
DEPRECIATION 1,260 11,336 16,200 21,600 52.48%
Total Administration Expenses 1,082,366 9,070,582 9,023,756 11,966,408 75.80%
Net Income 21,081 978,123 1,355,725 72.15%
Other Expense
Total Other Expense
Net Income 21,081$ 978,123$
No Assurance Is Provided On This Financial StatementSubstantially All Disclosures Are Not Included.
Page 3 of 3
Washington State Transit Insurance Pool
Balance SheetSeptember 30, 2016
ASSETS
Current Assets
Cash and Equivalents
U S Bank Claims 200,709$
U S Bank Administration 90,577
U S Bank Payroll 22,060
LGIP # 02448 608,605
TCIP 38,841,060
Total Cash and Equivalents 39,763,011
Other Current Assets
Accounts Receivable 442
Prepaid Expenses 3,585
Prepaid Pollution Liability Insurance 68,685
Prepaid Property Insurance 555,670
Prepaid Underground Storage Insurance 5,640
Prepaid Insurance - Other 312,908
Prepaid Subscriptions 37,083
Total Other Current Assets 984,013
Total Current Assets 40,747,024
Property and Equipment
Building 387,990
Improvements 63,890
Land 91,010 Equipment & Fixtures 213,461 Computer Equipment 27,301
Accumulated Depreciation (385,687)
Net Property and Equipment 397,965
Other Assets
Investment in GEM Insurance Company 1,182,079
Deferred Outflows of Resources
Pension Related 108,318
Total Other Assets 1,290,397
Total Assets 42,435,385$
LIABILITIES & EQUITY
Current Liabilities
Accounts Payable 115,544$
Deferred Compensation Payable 151,633
Deferred Revenue 3,216,033
Due to Leadership Academy 24,403
Payroll Payable 6,559
Reserve for Claims
2008 Reserve Balance 927,175
2009 Reserve Balance 55,545
2010 Reserve Balance 48,174
2011 Reserve Balance 1,326,269
2012 Reserve Balance 245,129
2013 Reserve Balance 1,848,290
2014 Reserve Balance 3,704,368
2015 Reserve Balance 3,662,297
2016 Reserve Balance 4,715,069
ULAE Reserve 600,000
Total Reserve for Claims 17,132,316
Total Current Liabilities 20,646,488
Long Term Liabilities
Deferred Inflows of Resources
Pension Related 110,958
Net Pension Liability 719,451
Total Long Term Liabilities 830,409
Total Liabilities 21,476,897
Equity
Invested in Capital Assets, Net of Related Debt 409,300
Unrestricted Building Reserve Fund 71,193
Beginning Surplus 35,845,704
Reserve for Prior Year Claims (16,309,610)
Net Change in Claim Reserves (36,222)
Net Income 978,123
Total Equity 20,958,488
Total Liabilities and Equity 42,435,385$
No Assurance Is Provided On This Financial StatementSubstantially All Disclosures Are Not Included
Washington State Transit Insurance Pool
September 2016 Claim Liability
As of 9/30/2016 - Report Date 10/31/2016
Event Date UNL Gross Paid Recovery Net Paid Reserves IBNR Net IncurredOutstanding
Liability Total Claims Open Claims Litigation2006 $4,594,680 $5,525,088 $930,408 $4,594,680 $0 $0 $4,594,680 $0 745 0 02007 $2,440,438 $3,330,862 $890,424 $2,440,438 $0 $0 $2,440,438 $0 802 0 02008 * $6,197,458 $7,458,274 $2,187,991 $5,270,283 $927,100 $74 $6,197,384 $927,175 839 1 12009 * $4,479,882 $5,536,908 $1,112,571 $4,424,337 $35,686 $19,859 $4,460,023 $55,545 859 1 12010 * $6,108,384 $6,916,727 $856,517 $6,060,210 $47,715 $459 $6,107,925 $48,174 1,105 1 12011 * $8,394,802 $16,483,957 $9,415,424 $7,068,533 $1,252,465 $73,804 $8,320,998 $1,326,269 1,035 5 32012 * $5,095,462 $6,911,350 $2,061,016 $4,850,333 $75,767 $169,362 $4,926,100 $245,129 1,014 3 22013 * $5,531,144 $4,251,382 $568,529 $3,682,854 $1,746,642 $101,648 $5,429,496 $1,848,290 1,122 23 132014 * $7,285,468 $5,937,377 $2,356,278 $3,581,100 $2,864,505 $839,863 $6,445,605 $3,704,368 1,085 49 62015 * $5,645,673 $2,861,531 $878,154 $1,983,376 $2,030,566 $1,631,731 $4,013,942 $3,662,297 973 128 32016 * $5,241,461 $621,717 $95,324 $526,392 $1,006,340 $3,708,729 $1,532,732 $4,715,069 676 385 1
Totals $61,014,852 $65,835,173 $21,352,636 $44,482,537 $9,986,785 $6,545,530 $54,469,322 $16,532,315 10,255 596 31
ULAE* $600,000
Outstanding Liability $17,132,315
* Ultimate Net Loss (UNL) estimates (2008-2015) from July 2016 PWC Actuary report; "All Coverages, Summary of Net Losses and Reserves - Net of Deductibles", exhibit 1.3* UNL 2016 estimate from PWC December 2015 Actuary Report, "All Coverages, Estimated Payments for Calendar Year 2016", exhibit 1.4 (9 month estimate based on $6,988,615 for calendar year)* Outstanding Unallocated Loss Adjustment Expense (ULAE) Reserve (undiscounted) from July 2016 PWC Actuary Report, "Estimates of Assets and Liabilities", exhibit 1-1
* UNL 2016 estimate from PWC December 2015 Actuary Report, "All Coverages, Estimated Payments for Calendar Year 2016", exhibit 1.4 (9 month estimate based on $6,988,615 for calendar year)
Washington State Transit Insurance PoolComparative Balance Sheet Report
September
Sep 30, 16 Sep 30, 15 $ Change % Change
ASSETS
Current Assets
Checking/Savings
1000 · Bank Accounts
US Bank Claims 200,709.20 300,994.87 -100,285.67 -33.32%
US Bank Administration 90,577.41 102,677.27 -12,099.86 -11.78%
US Bank Payroll 22,059.55 23,474.83 -1,415.28 -6.03%
Total 1000 · Bank Accounts 313,346.16 427,146.97 -113,800.81 -26.64%
105 · LGIP # 02448 608,604.79 606,220.01 2,384.78 0.39%
TCIP 38,841,060.32 35,322,131.65 3,518,928.67 9.96%
Total Checking/Savings 39,763,011.27 36,355,498.63 3,407,512.64 9.37%
Accounts Receivable
118 · Accounts receivable 441.52 102.49 339.03 330.79%
Total Accounts Receivable 441.52 102.49 339.03 330.79%
Other Current Assets
Prepaid expenses 3,585.00 0.00 3,585.00 100.0%
Prepaid Insurance
Prepaid Underground Storage Ins 5,640.27 5,640.22 0.05 0.0%
P · Prepaid Property Insurance 555,669.82 553,606.73 2,063.09 0.37%
Prepaid Pollution Liability Ins 68,684.72 112,064.72 -43,380.00 -38.71%
Prepaid Insurance - Other 312,908.08 285,416.04 27,492.04 9.63%
Total Prepaid Insurance 942,902.89 956,727.71 -13,824.82 -1.45%
Prepaid Subscription 37,083.31 0.00 37,083.31 100.0%
Total Other Current Assets 983,571.20 956,727.71 26,843.49 2.81%
Total Current Assets 40,747,023.99 37,312,328.83 3,434,695.16 9.21%
Fixed Assets
Computer Equipment 27,300.98 27,300.98 0.00 0.0%
Building
Leasehold Improvements 63,889.96 63,889.96 0.00 0.0%
Building - Other 387,990.00 387,990.00 0.00 0.0%
Total Building 451,879.96 451,879.96 0.00 0.0%
Land 91,010.00 91,010.00 0.00 0.0%
200 · Equipment 42,942.92 42,942.92 0.00 0.0%
207 · Equipment & fixtures 170,518.33 170,518.33 0.00 0.0%
250 · Accumulated depreciation -385,687.32 -372,219.82 -13,467.50 -3.62%
Total Fixed Assets 397,964.87 411,432.37 -13,467.50 -3.27%
Other Assets
GEM Insurance Company 1,182,078.55 1,662,569.55 -480,491.00 -28.9%
Deferred Outflows of Resources
Pension Related 108,318.00 68,792.00 39,526.00 57.46%
Total Deferred Outflows of Resources 108,318.00 68,792.00 39,526.00 57.46%
Total Other Assets 1,290,396.55 1,731,361.55 -440,965.00 -25.47%
TOTAL ASSETS 42,435,385.41 39,455,122.75 2,980,262.66 7.55%
LIABILITIES & EQUITY
Liabilities
Current Liabilities
Accounts Payable
300 · Accounts Payable
301 · Claims Payable 47,861.78 69,540.89 -21,679.11 -31.18%
300 · Accounts Payable - Other 67,682.09 40,274.78 27,407.31 68.05%
Total 300 · Accounts Payable 115,543.87 109,815.67 5,728.20 5.22%
Total Accounts Payable 115,543.87 109,815.67 5,728.20 5.22%
Other Current Liabilities
Due · Due to Leadership Academy 24,403.38 0.00 24,403.38 100.0%
Deferred Revenues 3,216,033.10 3,053,242.78 162,790.32 5.33%
365 · Deferred Compensation Payable 151,633.00 145,962.00 5,671.00 3.89%
2000 · Taxes Payable
330 · Payroll taxes payable 6,875.05 5,630.60 1,244.45 22.1%
2100 · Payroll Liabilities
2101 · Employee FSA -315.89 1,383.36 -1,699.25 -122.84%
Page 1 of 2
Washington State Transit Insurance PoolComparative Balance Sheet Report
September
Sep 30, 16 Sep 30, 15 $ Change % Change
Total 2100 · Payroll Liabilities -315.89 1,383.36 -1,699.25 -122.84%
Total 2000 · Taxes Payable 6,559.16 7,013.96 -454.80 -6.48%
380 · Reserve for Claims
398 · 2006 Reserve Balance 0.00 32,383.42 -32,383.42 -100.0%
402 · 2008 Reserve Balance 927,174.69 1,001,394.43 -74,219.74 -7.41%
403 · 2009 Reserve Balance 55,545.14 25,306.50 30,238.64 119.49%
404 · 2010 Reserve Balance 48,173.61 142,611.88 -94,438.27 -66.22%
405 · 2011 Reserve Balance 1,326,269.09 1,561,106.28 -234,837.19 -15.04%
406 · 2012 Reserve Balance 245,128.52 528,388.32 -283,259.80 -53.61%
407 · 2013 Reserve Balance 1,848,290.48 1,503,864.44 344,426.04 22.9%
408 · 2014 Reserve Balance 3,704,368.49 4,645,377.16 -941,008.67 -20.26%
409 · 2015 Reserve Balance 3,662,296.70 4,921,533.09 -1,259,236.39 -25.59%
411 · 2016 Reserve Balance 4,715,069.02 0.00 4,715,069.02 100.0%
400 · ULAE Reserve 600,000.00 598,000.00 2,000.00 0.33%
Total 380 · Reserve for Claims 17,132,315.74 14,959,965.52 2,172,350.22 14.52%
Total Other Current Liabilities 20,530,944.38 18,166,184.26 2,364,760.12 13.02%
Total Current Liabilities 20,646,488.25 18,275,999.93 2,370,488.32 12.97%
Long Term Liabilities
Deferred Inflows of Resources
Pension Related 110,958.00 248,161.00 -137,203.00 -55.29%
Total Deferred Inflows of Resources 110,958.00 248,161.00 -137,203.00 -55.29%
Net · Net Pension Liability 719,451.00 559,494.00 159,957.00 28.59%
Total Long Term Liabilities 830,409.00 807,655.00 22,754.00 2.82%
Total Liabilities 21,476,897.25 19,083,654.93 2,393,242.32 12.54%
Equity
Building Reserve Fund 71,192.74 56,192.74 15,000.00 26.69%
3000 · Surplus for Open Years 9,387,768.04 9,525,301.60 -137,533.56 -1.44%
410 · Members' Reserve 10,521,404.67 10,070,989.09 450,415.58 4.47%
Net Income 978,122.71 718,984.39 259,138.32 36.04%
Total Equity 20,958,488.16 20,371,467.82 587,020.34 2.88%
TOTAL LIABILITIES & EQUITY 42,435,385.41 39,455,122.75 2,980,262.66 7.55%
Page 2 of 2
Washington State Transit Insurance PoolComparative Income and Expense Report
September
Sep 16 Sep 15 $ Change % Change
Ordinary Income/Expense
Income
501 · MEMBER CONTRIBUTIONS
501-25 · Asotin County 3,758.25 3,354.92 403.33 12.02%
501-01 · Ben Franklin 80,200.17 72,185.17 8,015.00 11.1%
501-02 · Clallam 27,283.83 26,910.17 373.66 1.39%
501-21 · Columbia County 3,325.33 3,340.08 -14.75 -0.44%
501-03 · Community 166,105.83 149,286.00 16,819.83 11.27%
501-27 · C-TRAN 77,014.00 71,826.92 5,187.08 7.22%
501-22 · RiverCities 7,654.83 6,430.08 1,224.75 19.05%
501-23 · Everett Transit 24,076.50 22,621.42 1,455.08 6.43%
501-14 · Grant Transit Authority 12,846.67 14,209.17 -1,362.50 -9.59%
501-04 · Grays Harbor 18,909.17 16,649.42 2,259.75 13.57%
501-05 · Intercity 88,779.25 89,075.92 -296.67 -0.33%
501-06 · Island 28,996.42 27,417.75 1,578.67 5.76%
501-07 · Jefferson 9,880.42 8,761.67 1,118.75 12.77%
501-08 · Kitsap 65,551.50 59,679.58 5,871.92 9.84%
501-09 · Link 27,832.17 26,349.42 1,482.75 5.63%
501-11 · Mason 16,248.17 15,724.75 523.42 3.33%
501-10 · Pacific 5,397.17 5,447.58 -50.41 -0.93%
501-26 · Pierce Transit 190,973.17 185,912.50 5,060.67 2.72%
501-16 · Pullman Transit 5,061.42 5,732.00 -670.58 -11.7%
501-12 · Skagit 28,866.33 31,112.58 -2,246.25 -7.22%
501-19 · Spokane Transit 109,393.92 103,526.83 5,867.09 5.67%
501-15 · Twin Transit 4,725.92 5,068.42 -342.50 -6.76%
501-20 · Valley Transit 9,121.33 8,645.92 475.41 5.5%
501-13 · Whatcom 43,812.50 39,707.50 4,105.00 10.34%
501-24 · Yakima Transit 16,196.83 18,771.81 -2,574.98 -13.72%
Total 501 · MEMBER CONTRIBUTIONS 1,072,011.10 1,017,747.58 54,263.52 5.33%
504 · NON-OPERATING REVENUE
505 · Interest Income 27,575.27 23,235.00 4,340.27 18.68%
508 · Other Miscellaneous 410.56 231.75 178.81 77.16%
509 · Lease Payments 1,500.00 1,500.00 0.00 0.0%
507 · Training Coalition 1,950.00 3,100.00 -1,150.00 -37.1%
Total 504 · NON-OPERATING REVENUE 31,435.83 28,066.75 3,369.08 12.0%
Total Income 1,103,446.93 1,045,814.33 57,632.60 5.51%
Gross Profit 1,103,446.93 1,045,814.33 57,632.60 5.51%
Expense
600 · CLAIMS
601 · Liability Claims 521,796.17 512,239.08 9,557.09 1.87%
602 · 1st Party Claims 50,339.00 52,123.92 -1,784.92 -3.42%
Total 600 · CLAIMS 572,135.17 564,363.00 7,772.17 1.38%
610 · INSURANCE SERVICES
626 · Captive - $3M xs $2M Retention 60,120.00 51,783.67 8,336.33 16.1%
Reinsurance - $10M xs $5M 31,610.33 30,788.83 821.50 2.67%
612 · Excess - $5 mill X $15 mill 11,333.33 11,333.33 0.00 0.0%
622 · Property 61,741.09 61,511.85 229.24 0.37%
Blanket Pollution 3,615.00 3,615.00 0.00 0.0%
Underground Storage Tank Cov 73,322.26 5,640.17 67,682.09 1,200.0%
624 · Crime and Fidelity 1,239.02 1,232.86 6.16 0.5%
Total 610 · INSURANCE SERVICES 242,981.03 165,905.71 77,075.32 46.46%
760 · CONTRACT SERVICES
768 · Driver Record Monitoring 0.00 4,412.62 -4,412.62 -100.0%
702 · Actuary 35,000.00 0.00 35,000.00 100.0%
762 · Administrative services
762.2 · Wellness Committee 412.70 8.68 404.02 4,654.61%
762.1 · Credit Card Service Fees 103.79 79.82 23.97 30.03%
762 · Administrative services - Other 2,311.76 4,472.25 -2,160.49 -48.31%
Total 762 · Administrative services 2,828.25 4,560.75 -1,732.50 -37.99%
701 · Broker Fee 25,300.00 25,300.00 0.00 0.0%
Page 1 of 3
Washington State Transit Insurance PoolComparative Income and Expense Report
September
Sep 16 Sep 15 $ Change % Change
769 · Rack space at the State 650.00 653.72 -3.72 -0.57%
767 · Contract Services 135.00 2,098.47 -1,963.47 -93.57%
Total 760 · CONTRACT SERVICES 63,913.25 37,025.56 26,887.69 72.62%
720 · STAFF WAGES, TAXES & BENEFITS
719 · Staff Benefits 17,259.43 15,307.29 1,952.14 12.75%
720.1 · Wages 91,623.70 84,796.37 6,827.33 8.05%
720.1.1 · Retirement Trust ICMA 5,525.99 5,246.55 279.44 5.33%
725 · Payroll Taxes 1,427.42 1,331.26 96.16 7.22%
Total 720 · STAFF WAGES, TAXES & BENEFITS 115,836.54 106,681.47 9,155.07 8.58%
700 · LEGAL AND ACCOUNTING
703 · Accounting 3,610.94 1,025.98 2,584.96 251.95%
Total 700 · LEGAL AND ACCOUNTING 3,610.94 1,025.98 2,584.96 251.95%
730 · BOARD EXPENSES
732.2 · Jeff Ristau Scholarship 0.00 2,700.00 -2,700.00 -100.0%
731 · Conference/Travel - WSTIP Board 695.00 5,087.75 -4,392.75 -86.34%
732 · Board Meeting Expenses 0.00 342.00 -342.00 -100.0%
Total 730 · BOARD EXPENSES 695.00 8,129.75 -7,434.75 -91.45%
733 · STAFF CONFERENCES & TRAVEL
Staff Travel 4,485.83 5,094.51 -608.68 -11.95%
Staff Registration 10,754.00 1,340.00 9,414.00 702.54%
734 · Educational Materials 184.56 0.00 184.56 100.0%
Total 733 · STAFF CONFERENCES & TRAVEL 15,424.39 6,434.51 8,989.88 139.71%
740 · LOSS CONTROL SERVICES
Driver Recognition Program 3,600.00 0.00 3,600.00 100.0%
Network Security 35,883.75 112.50 35,771.25 31,796.67%
Loss Prevention Projects
Collision Avoidance Technology 2,613.51 57,628.75 -55,015.24 -95.47%
Serious loss reviews/videos 0.00 3,000.00 -3,000.00 -100.0%
Total Loss Prevention Projects 2,613.51 60,628.75 -58,015.24 -95.69%
Contract Services 0.00 4,610.00 -4,610.00 -100.0%
Pre-Litigation Fund 0.00 2,386.00 -2,386.00 -100.0%
741 · Grants/Training
Video Purchases 52.91 0.00 52.91 100.0%
Award Programs (Golden Coach et 704.16 325.00 379.16 116.67%
Risk Management Grants 0.00 7,500.00 -7,500.00 -100.0%
Total 741 · Grants/Training 757.07 7,825.00 -7,067.93 -90.33%
800 · Training Coalition 2,311.56 8,100.00 -5,788.44 -71.46%
Total 740 · LOSS CONTROL SERVICES 45,165.89 83,662.25 -38,496.36 -46.01%
770 · COMMUNICATIONS
772 · Telephone 1,124.56 1,113.30 11.26 1.01%
771 · Internet Access 480.51 288.52 191.99 66.54%
Total 770 · COMMUNICATIONS 1,605.07 1,401.82 203.25 14.5%
777 · OCCUPANCY COSTS
778 · Office Maintenance/Repairs 1,025.51 1,329.85 -304.34 -22.89%
773 · Utilities 608.54 585.59 22.95 3.92%
758 · Janitorial Services 400.97 200.97 200.00 99.52%
774 · Office Equipment Lease 481.69 481.69 0.00 0.0%
Total 777 · OCCUPANCY COSTS 2,516.71 2,598.10 -81.39 -3.13%
749 · OFFICE EXPENSES
752 · Dues and Subscriptions 817.10 863.69 -46.59 -5.39%
757 · Office Supplies 1,629.86 1,614.66 15.20 0.94%
754 · Postage 150.02 197.48 -47.46 -24.03%
753 · Printing & Graphic Services 1,293.45 1,108.28 185.17 16.71%
Total 749 · OFFICE EXPENSES 3,890.43 3,784.11 106.32 2.81%
802 · AUDITS
Annual Audit 1,210.30 8,549.90 -7,339.60 -85.84%
Total 802 · AUDITS 1,210.30 8,549.90 -7,339.60 -85.84%
INFORMATION SERVICES
750 · Software/Licenses/Upgrades 8,722.27 3,365.48 5,356.79 159.17%
764 · Computer Maintenance/Support 323.00 4,910.82 -4,587.82 -93.42%
Page 2 of 3
Washington State Transit Insurance PoolComparative Income and Expense Report
September
Sep 16 Sep 15 $ Change % Change
791 · Hardware/Upgrades/replacements 3,077.11 5,518.60 -2,441.49 -44.24%
Total INFORMATION SERVICES 12,122.38 13,794.90 -1,672.52 -12.12%
759 · DEPRECIATION 1,259.50 1,713.33 -453.83 -26.49%
Total Expense 1,082,366.60 1,005,070.39 77,296.21 7.69%
Net Ordinary Income 21,080.33 40,743.94 -19,663.61 -48.26%
Net Income 21,080.33 40,743.94 -19,663.61 -48.26%
Page 3 of 3
Page 1 of 8
December 9, 2016
TO: WSTIP Board of Directors
FROM: Al Hatten, Executive Director & Tracey Christianson, Deputy Director
SUBJECT: Executive Staff Report – December 2016
2017 WSTIP DRAFT BUDGET AND 2017 RENEWALS At the Executive Committee meeting on October 25th, the committee instructed staff to present a 2017
WSTIP budget with a $2.5 million self-insurance retention and a rate increase of 10%. GEM will provide
the captive reinsurance for $2.5 million in excess of $2.5 million. Munich Re will follow from $5 million to
$10 million (as expiring) and ARCH will attach at $15 million with another $5 million (same as expiring).
Total limits remain at $20 million.
Based on our past practices of following Intercity Transit’s general wage increases, the 2017 budget will
include a 3% general wage increase for WSTIP staff and general counsel. It does not include the
Executive Director. The Board will need to vote by a majority on any amendments or changes to the
Executive Director’s contract. A proposed contract is presented as an action item on the Board agenda
with the Executive Committee’s recommendation for approval.
POTENTIAL “NEW” MEMBER Staff has been contacted by the Skamania County Transit for consideration of membership. The WSTIP
governance policy states that to be considered the entity seeking consideration must meet the following
prerequisites: In operation in excess of two years, have at least two modes of service, and a minimum
annual mileage of not less than 200,000.
GEM TRANSIT PROTECTED CELL PROPOSAL On October 6th, staff had a conference call to further define the scope of a proposed transit protected cell
captive with GEM providing the admin support as the parent organization. The initial actuarial was
somewhat unexpected and it appears that the relationship of WSTIP and CalTip may not be in either
entities best interest. We have decided to put the project on the back-burner and wait until CalTip decide
what their board appetite is to increasing their self-insured retention above their current $1.25 million.
GEM UPDATES The following is a synopsis of the major discussions and decisions that occurred at the GEM Board Meeting in Chicago, IL, on October 27 and 28, 2016.
9/30/16 Financials The 9/30 financials reported a net loss of $1,427,310. This was driven primarily by adverse development on three prior-year losses during the third quarter, amounting to $4.46 million.
Page 2 of 8
Members’ Surplus Initiative: Strategic Risk Solutions (SRS) presented their findings, based on
the interviews with GEM’s members. Based on member feedback and discussion during the meeting, two key themes were identified:
Return of Voluntary Surplus Contributions (VSC): the Board agreed in principle that GEM should adopt a policy regarding the return of VSCs, including accrued interest. A draft policy was considered and revisions were proposed. A revised version will be presented to the Board for further consideration, together with projections of accrued interest under alternative scenarios.
Return of Initial Surplus Contributions (ISC) in the event a member leaves GEM: there was discussion around the amount of ISC that should be returned to a member in the event of adverse loss experience. Potential structures will be presented for consideration by the Board. The Board will meet via teleconference during December 2016 to consider next steps. Ultimately, any changes to current practices will be voted on by the membership. Member Surplus Contribution & Withdrawal Policy Pending the outcome of the Member Surplus Initiative, and any changes to Member Accounting, the Board agreed to waive the requirement for additional member surplus contributions based on the member’s surplus account balance.
2017 Budget The budget, as presented, was approved. Included in the Salaries and Employee Benefits expense item is a provision for the services of a Professional Employer Organization, which will provide various payroll and benefits compliance functions, as well as access to a health benefits network for GEM employees. An adjustment will be made to the Travel item, to provide for additional expenses related to attendance at the February 2017 meeting, as described above.
2015 Member Accounting Audit The Board approved the draft audit report based on a recommendation from the Audit Committee. Risk Management Support Policy The Board considered GEM’s position on providing support to members’ risk management initiatives, and the question of whether to establish a policy. Recognizing the time commitment to establish and manage such a policy, and the extensive projects currently in process, the Board agreed to revisit this important topic in the future.
Transit Reinsurance JLT Re provided an update on efforts to develop a reinsurance treaty specifically for GEM’s transit exposure. They are currently awaiting responses from various markets and should know within the next two weeks whether the arrangement may proceed.
JEFFREY S. RISTAU SCHOLARSHIP
A new application was received from Grays Harbor and Clallam Transit.
INVESTMENT STRATEGY REVIEW
Ben Foreman and staff met with the Thurston County Treasurer (TCT) and discussed options to improve
the yield of our investments. While we could certainly remove ourselves from the collective and improve
Page 3 of 8
our yield at Thurston County Investment Pool (TCIP), we also run the risk of any adverse performance
without the sharing relationship of the investment pool. TCT advised that we could invest solely in US
Treasury Bonds with durations up to a year and current yields of 1.24%. Certainly better than our current
0.84% return. TCT has some reservation based on the voluntary nature of WSTIP in the investment pool.
We reassured them that we have no reason to suspect any changes now or in the future. We have asked
TCIP to give us current yields effective as of 10/24/2016 on durations of 5-10 years. Any changes to the
WSTIP investment strategy would require Executive Committee engagement and approval.
We further discussed the prospect of the Thurston County Treasurer’s (TCT) office taking over the WSTIP
treasurer role. We will collect our current banking needs and fees and compare them to the services the
TCT can offer. One advantage to the TCT participation is that all fees are paid by the TCIP which does
provide a savings. Shawn Meyers, Thurston County Treasurer, confirmed that WSTIP may also use their
services for banking needs in a subsequent phone call.
2017 EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE RETREAT Teri Fisher of Insight Strategies will again facilitate the 2017 Executive Committee retreat at the
Alderbrook Resort in Union, WA. The retreat will be held January 11-13. As a reminder, anyone that
runs for the Executive Committee is invited to participate at the retreat. Further, any new Board member
is welcome to participate as well as exiting Executive Committee members. Please confirm your
participation with Anna.
UPCOMING WSTIP MEETINGS
2017 January 11-13 Executive Committee Retreat – Alderbrook - Union, WA
February 23 Executive Committee Meeting – WSTIP Office - Olympia
March 23 & 24 Executive Committee & Quarterly Board Meeting – Campbell’s, Lake Chelan
April 27 Executive Committee Meeting – WSTIP Office – Olympia
May 25 Executive Committee Meeting – WSTIP Office – Olympia
June 22 & 23 Executive Committee & Quarterly Board Meeting – Location TBD
July 20 Executive Committee Meeting – WSTIP Office - Olympia
August 24 Executive Committee Meeting – WSTIP Office – Olympia
Sept 28 & 29 Executive Committee & Quarterly Board Meeting – Location TBD
October 26 Executive Committee Meeting – WSTIP Office – Olympia
Dec 7 & 8 Executive Committee & Quarterly Board Meeting – Location TBD
2018 January 10-12 Executive Committee Retreat – Location TBD
February 22 Executive Committee Meeting – WSTIP Office – Olympia
March 22 $ 23 Executive Committee & Quarterly Board Meeting
STAFF/MEMBER REP OUT-OF-STATE TRAVEL 2017 March 5 – 8, AGRIP Governance & Leadership Conf in Orlando, FL
June 4 – 7, PRIMA in Phoenix, AZ
August 7 -9, AGRIP CEO/Sr. Staff Leadership Institute I Charleston, SC
August 7 – 9, Public Transportation Conference
September 12 – 15, CAJPA Conference, Lake Tahoe, NV
October 1 – 4, AGRIP Fall Education Conf in Baltimore, MD
Page 4 of 8
Board Member Rep travel is in bold.
MEMBER SERVICES ACTIVITIES Transit Agency Visits – Transit Agency Visits – The year has almost ended and all of our field work
has been done. Joanne has visited Asotin, Clallam, C-Tran, Columbia, Grant, RiverCities and Spokane
vanpool programs. Chris has visited Asotin, C-Tran (3 times), Pacific (2 times), Kitsap (2 times), Grant (2
times), Link (3 times), Spokane (2 times), Asotin, Pullman (2 times), Grays Harbor, Everett (2 times),
Mason, Pierce (2 times), Community, Intercity, Jefferson (2 times), Island (2 times), Valley, Ben Franklin,
Columbia, Skagit, Whatcom, Twin, Clallam, RiverCities, and Yakima (2 times). Chris has also taught
Reasonable Suspicion/Drug and Alcohol for Supervisors at Ben Franklin Transit (January 26); Intercity
Transit (February 2); Kitsap Transit (April 12 – 13); RiverCities Transit (August 30); Link Transit (October
5 – 6) and Mason Transit (October 18 – 19). He also completed a one-day supervisor training at the
special request of Jefferson Transit on May 13. Our field work is always focused on Best Practices and in
particular we are focusing on the Best Practice for Operator Training and the Best Practice for Mobility
Device Securement. Joanne’s focus in her field work is the Best Practice for Vanpool Operations.
Best Practices for Mobility Device Securement / Training Program Development – With the RFI for
Simulators done, we are turning back to this training class. The curriculum development and materials
are complete for the class. Seraphim Consulting LLC and Chris DeVoll will be conducting three regional
training classes in 2017.
Best Practices for Technology Environment and Online Banking / Network Security Consulting Work
– Davis Wright and Tremaine (DWT) has completed incident response plans for C-Tran, Skagit Transit,
Link Transit and Intercity Transit. Incident Response Plans for the remaining members will be completed
by the end of this year. Sean re-recorded the webinar on August 22 and it is available on the WSTIP
YouTube channel.
WSTIP Webpages / Association Management Software – We have reported since February about our
purchase of a new Association software, Your Membership. Our design was delivered in May and Anna
and Tracey worked on producing the new website; feedback was taken into consideration from testers in
the September. All of the content from the old WSTIP website, the Board website and the WSTTC site
has been pulled together into the one site. The new website has been turned on as of October 19 and
since been advertised in TransAction as well as requests for ongoing feedback from users.
CLAIMS WSTIP currently has 559 open files with total reserves of $10,566,951 as of 11/29/2016. Staff were asked
what the top 10 outstanding claims are in terms of value a few meetings ago. Without disclosing
reserves, which staff is happy to do in Executive Session, here are the top 15 claims by value (highest
value to lowest). The list has been expanded from 10 to 15 due to reserving changes.
1. Haley vs Pierce (2014)
2. Gilmore vs. Jefferson (2008)
3. Clithero vs. Community (2011)
4. Edwards vs. Ben Franklin (2013)
Page 5 of 8
5. Van Cleave vs. Kitsap (2015)
6. LaLonde vs. Pierce (2016)
7. Balsoma vs. Pierce (2015)
8. Mitchell vs. Spokane (2015)
9. Robertson vs. Whatcom (2013)
10. Bermudez vs. Ben Franklin (2014)
11. Durkin vs Spokane (2014)
12. Okrent vs. Community (2013)
13. Engen vs. Grant (2011)
14. Cox vs. Link (2014)
15. Rosenfeld vs. Whatcom (2016)
Staff are seeking settlement authority on two cases: Haley vs. Pierce and LaLonde vs. Pierce during the
Executive Session of the Executive Committee.
You might recall the Gilmore vs Jefferson Transit case. Jefferson Transit’s bus bumped/rear-ended a
plumbing truck driven by Gilmore. We had an unexpected and adverse judgment for $1.2 million after a
June 2016 jury trial. We filed a motion for a new trial and a remitter motion. Both motions were denied.
We appealed the adverse verdict to the Division 2, Court of Appeals. Appeals take several years to
resolve. Oral argument is scheduled for December 15, 2016.
The Board gave settlement authority for Clithero vs. Dart, but mediation was unsuccessful. Trial has
been rescheduled for April of 2017. Dart is a subcontractor of Community Transit. In 2011 WSTIP was
the primary liability insurer for Dart. Mr. Clithero has cerebral palsy. A Dart vehicle struck Mr. Clithero on
his scooter in a crosswalk.
Edwards vs. Ben Franklin is an auto collision case. Ben Franklin’s bus rear-ended plaintiff Edwards who
was driving his vehicle. This is a significant injury case with medical specials document over $300K. Staff
will likely be seeking settlement authority on this case in February of 2017.
We have one significant claim from 2015 developing. A Kitsap bus hit a cyclist on State Route 305 in
early November (Van Cleave). The cyclist suffered significant injuries from the accident. The cyclist is
still treating and has not filed a lawsuit. He engaged the same attorney that represented the other
bicyclist vs. Kitsap matter recently resolved (Opalinek).
Balsoma vs. Pierce Transit is a bus/car collision accident where liability is in some question. However, the
bike rack of the bus entered the vehicle and portion of metal impaled Balsoma who is a fault free
passenger riding in the car.
Mitchell vs. Spokane Transit is a car collision accident involving a Spokane Transit vanpool. Ms. Mitchell
was a passenger in the vanpool vehicle when another party hit the van broad-side. Ms. Mitchell was
ejected out a window and another vehicle hit Ms. Mitchell. WSTIP has paid out UIM on this case,
however, there is a potential legal action forthcoming.
Page 6 of 8
Robertson vs. Whatcom is a case that recently moved into litigation. Robertson was being loaded on a
Whatcom paratransit bus. Robertson was using a standard wheelchair. Robertson has a host of medical
conditions which result in his inability to feel his feet. While loading, Robertson’s toes were caught in the
lift (twice) resulting in a fractured big toe. The toe required surgical intervention. A struggle to recover
ensued. Sadly Robertson died in February 2014. His estate filed a suit claiming wrongful death in
September.
Durkin vs. Spokane Transit is a bus pedestrian collision. Mr. Durkin was in the cross walk crossing the
street when he encountered a Spokane Transit bus. A companion of Durkin’s grabbed Durkin, pulling
him back. However, his foot/leg was still impacted by the bus. This case is not in litigation yet, but I expect
suit to be filed soon as the statute will toll January 17, 2017.
Okrent vs. Community Transit is another interesting case. Okrent was walking in a park and ride lot when
a Community Transit vanpool struck her with their mirror. Impact was to Okrent’s left arm. She was not
knocked to the ground. However, her shoulder required a surgical repair. Medical bills exceed $60K.
Engen vs. Grant Transit is an auto liability case resulting from a GTA bus striking Engen’s car in the rear.
Early efforts to resolve the case were not successful. Significant treatment over a long period of time has
resulted in very high medical specials.
Cox vs. Link Transit is related to a failure to properly secure a mobility device. Cox’s wheelchair was not
correctly secured and Cox tipped over when the Link paratransit vehicle he was riding in made a turn.
Cox was evaluated for injuries, but released. Cox had a host of other medical problems. Cox passed
away in May of 2014. The estate is bringing a wrongful death claim against Link Transit.
Rosenfeld vs. Whatcom Transportation Authority is a case involving boarding and alighting. Rosenfeld
was making his first trip on paratransit, unassisted. He was utilizing a walker. Rosenfeld fell while
boarding breaking his hip. The operator was near him, but was unable to break his fall (he fell away from
the operator). The hip required a surgical repair. Rosenfeld is 98 years old. Rosenfeld’s attorney has
informed us he intends to file suit although no suit has been received.
Page 7 of 8
Here is an aggregate overview of open claims and reserves:
Claims Report
You might notice an uptick in open litigated cases. We have 32 open litigated files now including four
employment practice cases. We believe two of the employment cases have been favorably resolved but
remain open pending final bills. I expect a few more cases to move into litigation as we still have a fair
number of outstanding claims in 2014 that are unresolved and attorneys will file summons and complaints
to protect the statute for their clients.
TECHNICAL SERVICES ACTIVITIES
Origami
The Origami working group has met twice since our last report. Data entry issues and missing or
miscoded information in Origami has been a challenge for larger Members who would like to use Origami
for their internal risk management needs. Members who have invested time to data cleanup are seeing
the results in more accurate reporting. The data group is looking at configuration changes (fields, forms
and workflow) that would better meet the Member’s internal needs. These enhancements will be
available to all Members.
Pierce and C-Tran are both currently running in-house home grown applications that in many ways
duplicate the Origami data. These parallel systems are becoming unsupportable. Both Pierce and C-
Tran have expressed interest in enhancements to the system that would allow them to utilize Origami to
replace these applications.
Our Origami representative, Andrea Sargent, will be at the WSTIP Olympia office December 6th and 7th
and will be attending the Quarterly Board meeting. We have several Members scheduled for working
sessions with our Origami representative at the WSTIP office on Wednesday December 7th. Please call
Karey Thornton if you have issues you would like to address while she is here.
Page 8 of 8
Origami has provided C-Tran with a quote to enable mobile forms so that their road supervisors can
collect Event information and photographs in the field and submit them directly to Origami. This will be a
2017 project.
Network Infrastructure Refresh The networking equipment currently co-located in the State Data Center is nearing end of life. Rather
than purchasing new hardware, WSTIP will be continuing its move “to the cloud” by transitioning the
WSTIP servers to the Private Cloud Services hosted by the State.
More information on the Private Cloud Services offered by the State can be found here:
http://watech.wa.gov/solutions/it-services/private-cloud-service
20000Date Received First MI Last Agency Current Position Years in Transit Learning Facility Goal Grant Request AWARD Supervisor
01/25/16 Utchay Okorie Intercity Network System Analyst 2 U of W Certified I S.S. Professional 1,000$ 1,000Mr. Brent Campbell, Information Services Manager, Intercity Transit
02/05/16 Krista Mitchell Clallam Lead Admin Services Asst 9 Nat'l Institute of Gov't Puchasing Procurement Management 1,000$ 1,000Ms. Melinda Smithson, Finance Manager, Clallam Transit
02/10/16 Kimberly McGilvery Pierce Transit Vanpool Coordinator 17 WGU BS in Business Administration 1,000$ 1,000Ms. Lani Fowlkes, Vanpool Program Manager, Pierce Transit
02/12/16 Theresa Teschlog Community TransitProcurement & SBE/DBE
Specialist 9 Portland State U Certification in Public Construction 1,000$ 1,000Kunjan Dayal, Procurement and Contracts Manager, Community Transit
02/15/16 Virginia Ponce de Leon Community TransitProcurement Project
Coordinator 9 Everett Community College Associate of Arts 600$ 600Kunjan Dayal, Procurement and Contracts Manager, Community Transit
02/29/16 Whitney Fernandes Skagit Transit Dispatcher/Scheduler 3 Skagit Valley College Associate of Arts / Business Management 750$ 750Mr. Robert Gummere, Operations Supervisor, Skagit Transit
03/17/16 Samantha Benedict Clallam TransitAdministrative Services
Assistant 8 monthsInternational Institute of Municipal Clerks / Washington State University Certified Municipal Clerk $1,000 1,000
Ms. Mary Bower, Executive Office Manager, Clallam Transit System
04/28/16 Tunisia Price Pierce TransitSenior marketing Design
Specialist 3 U of W Web Design 1,000$ 1,000Kathy Walton. Marketing Assist. Manager ‐ Pierce Transit
07/18/16 Susan Dickinson WTA Accounting Technician 14 Whatcom Community College AA in Accounting 700$ 700Shonda Shipman, Director of Finance Whatcom Transportaion Authority
07/25/16 Tina Givens Pierce Transit Payroll Specialist 3 Western Governors University BS Accounting 1,000$ 1,000Liz Passmore, Finance Assistant Manager, Pierce Transit
08/05/16 Scott Fiskness Intercity Transit Dial‐A‐Ride Dispatcher 6 WGU ‐ Washington MS, Mgmt and Leadership 1,000$ 1,000Emily Bergkamp, Dial‐A‐Lift Manger, Intercity Transit
08/12/16 Jennifer Hayslip Everett Transit Para‐Transit Scheduler 12 Everett Community College AA ‐ Business 1,000$ 1,000 Ton Hingson, Transit Director ‐ Everett Transit
08/12/16 Lynda Fox WTA Accounting Tecnitian II 20+ Whatcom Community College AA 1,000$ 1,000 Shonda Shipman, Dir of Finance ‐ WTA
08/15/16 Michael Schmieder Everett Transit Transit Supervisor 8+ U of W Cert Prog in H/R Management 1,000$ 1,000Marc Bollard ‐ Everett Transit Operations Program Manager
11/16/16 Patricia O'Hare` Grays Harbor Supervisor 23 Grays Harbor College Records Information Management 1,000$ 1,000 Patty Carlin, Ops Manager
TOTAL 14,050 5,950 Balance
Jeffery S. Ristau Scholarship 09/30/16
November 23, 2016 TO: WSTIP Board of Directors FROM: Tracey Christianson, Deputy Director SUBJECT: Annual Report of Settled Claims $100,000 and Above This report is informational only. No action is required. WSTIP staff annually provides a recap of incurred losses that settled during the year, which exceeded $100,000 in value. Here is a list of those matters with a brief overview for each case.
AUTO LIABILITY Opalenik vs. Kitsap Date of Loss: 5/7/2014 Auto liability: bodily injury A bicyclist made contact with a Kitsap Transit bus. Bicyclist sustained substantial injuries. Claim settlement was $2,750,000, (non-legal) expenses $100,135.54, and legal expenses $254,508.52. GEM reimbursed WSTIP $1,746,356.57. Incurred $1,358,287.49. Larson vs. Kitsap Date of Loss: 5/14/2013 Auto Liability Bus turning left collided with car in intersection. Claim settlement $100,000, (non-legal) expense $5,932.42, and property damage payment $7,228.50. Incurred $113,160.92. Berlin vs. Mason Date of Loss: 6/18/2015 Auto Liability: Bodily Injury Claimant fell backwards into bus from lift, broke hip. Claim settlement $100,000, (non-legal) expense $2,283.35. Incurred $102,283.35.
PROPERTY Sound Transit & Pierce Transit Date of Loss: 10/14/2015 Auto Physical Damage Bus fire. Claim settlement $606,274.01, (non-legal) expense $4,459.10, and legal expense $1,084. Member paid deductible of $10,000. Markel reimbursed WSTIP $356,274.61. Incurred $245,543.10. Community Transit Date of Loss: 9/9/2015 Auto Physical Damage
Bus damage caused by a head-on collision (other party at fault). Paid $129,103.46 for the bus repair, expense $952.50. Received $10,000 from responsible party insurer and $5,000 from the member. Total $120,055.96.
Page 2 of 2
PUBLIC OFFICIALS LIABILITY Fulbright vs. Columbia County Date of Loss: 2/1/2012 Public Officials Alleged sexual assault by a transit rider to another transit on board bus. Claim settlement was $187,500, (non-legal) expense $100,461.06 and legal expenses $273,402.43. Incurred $500,363.49. (Serious loss report available.)
EMPLOYMENT PRACTICES Guerrero vs. Pierce Transit Date of Loss: 3/20/2013 Employment Practices Claimant alleged a racially hostile working environment. (Non-legal) expense $2,173.05, legal expense $87,369.08, claimant compensation $90,000. The member paid their $5,000 deductible. Incurred $174,542.13.
Executive Director’s Annual Report of Staff Activities November 29, 2016
Page 1 of 3
This report is an effort to give the WSTIP Board of Directors a quick overview of staff activity for the year. First and foremost is to ensure that the staff are meeting the goals and objectives stated for the year and activity is consistent to the overall mission and vision the Board has set. WSTIP Mission: The Pool’s mission is to reduce Member’s cost of risk.
WSTIP Vision: The Pool’s vision is to be the premier provider of high-quality, cost-effective risk management products and services.
Administration
1. Financial – The State Auditor Office completed their audit review with no findings for 2015. 2. WSTIP total assets grew 1.5% between July 2015 and July2016. 3. WSTIP’s surplus position grew 6% from $19.3 million to $20.5 million between July 2015 and July
2016. 4. Insurance coverage renewed for: Property, Liability, Crime, Pollution, and Underground Storage
Tank. 5. 2017 Budget and Member Allocations completed. 6. Jeffrey S. Ristau Scholarship awarded almost $20,000 in scholarships. 7. New risk management information system, Origami, went live in January 2016. 8. Established the Risk Pool Leadership Development Program with other risk pools in the state.
Two staff members in the program (with completion in 2017). 9. Four Quarterly Board Meetings, 10 Executive Committee meetings, and the Executive Committee
Retreat. 10. Assisted WSTA with the Claim Jumper Invitational Golf Tournament.
Claims Management
1. Handled 1123 claims in 2013; handled 1085 claims in 2014, 975 in 2015, and 755 in 2016. 2. There are 597 open claims in total with 33 in current litigation. 3. Denied 133 claims during fiscal year 2016. 4. Collected $400k in subrogation recoveries during 2016. 5. Paid out $7.2 million in claims payments and claims expenses as of November 28, 2016 during
fiscal year 2016. 6. Coordinated Claims Coordinator Conference. 7. Trained all WSTIP users in Origami. Hosted 3 regional Origami training sessions for Members. 8. 12 members made requests for pre-litigation funds during 2016 totalling $18k in litigation advice 9. Resolved several large exposure claims against WSTIP members (see report on losses above
$100,000). 10. 20 Origami Roundup newsletters.
Executive Director’s Annual Report of Staff Activities November 29, 2016
Page 2 of 3
Member Services
1. 40 Best Practice review visits, 7 Vanpool Best Practice Review visits. 2. Taught Reasonable Suspicion for Supervisors at the following member locations: Link, Kitsap, Ben
Franklin, Intercity, Mason, and RiverCities. 3. 111 ASKS. 4. 24 TransACTION newsletters (with two scheduled prior to the end of the year). 5. Best Practices for Technology Environment/Network Security – second year of contract. 6. 2015 Risk Profiles. 7. 2015 Annual Report. 8. Collision avoidance technology study looking at the viability and application of collision avoidance
technology to the transit industry. Awarded $100K grant from Transportation Research Board for state-wide collision avoidance pilot. Received additional grants from GEM, Munich Re, and Alliant. Established a relationship with the University of Washington for data review.
9. Participation in the Public Transportation Symposium and sponsorship of the 2016 State Roadeo (including a scholarship program funded by WSTIP). Conducted training programs in conjunction with the Roadeo.
10. Training Coalition course management - 21 classes, including second dispatch training program, four Board meetings, and Transit Trainers Showcase.
11. Continuation of the Guest Rider Program. 2016 participants included: Clallam, Community, Grant, Island, Kitsap, Link, Mason, Pierce, Pullman, RiverCities, and Yakima.
12. Continuation of the Driver Record Monitoring program. First year of new contract. 13. Continuation of the Municipal Research and Services Center program. 14. 10 issues of Charting Our Course newsletter. 15. WSTA/WSTIP Joint Board Leadership Development in Spokane. 16. Renewed the Vanpool Winter Driving Campaign (started in November 2015 and ran into 2016). 17. Safety STARS winners: Community, Whatcom and RiverCities (Second year of the award). 18. Processed 20 risk management grants (to date). 19. Mobility Device Securement training program development, 3 regional trainings to take place in 2017. 20. Association Software review, purchase and new website launch. 21. Continuation of MSDS Online services. 22. Implementation of Driver Recognition Program. 23. Implementation of Above and Beyond Recognition Program.
Executive Director’s Annual Report of Staff Activities November 29, 2016
Page 3 of 3
Board Action and Development
11. Executive Committee Retreat – Redraft Strategic Plan. 12. Approved the amended WSTIP Strategic Plan. 13. Approved the Underground Storage Tank policy. 14. Approved the engagement of WSTIP financial commitment in the Collision Avoidance Study. 15. Reviewed all WSTIP Governance Policies. All revised to new format and correction of minor
typos. 16. Conducted “non-transit” risk survey. 17. Approved Driver Recognition Program. 18. Approved the updated WSTIP Employee manual. 19. Accepted the 2016 Actuarial Study. 20. Fiduciary and Fidelity report. 21. Approved the WSTIP Purchasing Policy increasing credit card authority from $36,000 to $50,000. 22. Approved the revised Assessment Allocation Policy. 23. Conducted Board meeting surveys. 24. Conducted the annual Executive Director and General Counsel evaluations. 25. Established the Executive Director’s Succession Committee. 26. Approved the 2016-2017 property program. 27. Board Development Committee meetings, Governance Committee meetings, Emerging Risks
Opportunities Committee meetings, and Driver Recognition Committee meetings.
MEMORANDUM
To: Board of Directors, Washington State Transit Insurance Pool
From: Ronald A. Franz, General Counsel
Subject: Activity report
Date: December 1, 2016
This memorandum lists some of the things I have worked on since my last activity report provided to
you at the September meeting.
1. Attend staff meetings—6 hours.
2. Preparation of contract template for non transit activities (see template attached)—1.5 hours.
3. Preparation of executive director contract extension—1 hour.
4. Distribute material re contractual liability and additional insureds—1 hour.
5. Preparation of general liability coverage document amendment re release precedent for UIM
recovery—1.5 hours.
6. To/from Spokane and attendance at October Executive Committee meeting—10 hours.
7. Attend agenda set telephone conference for October Executive Committee agenda set—1 hour.
8. Attend (via telephone conference) Board Development Committee meeting—1 hour.
9. Travel to/from Everett and attendance at September Executive Committee meeting, work session,
and Board meeting—16 hours.
10. Review documents and attend telephone conference re Kitsap Transit/Bremerton transit center
contract issues—3 hours.
11. Review proposed Spokane Transit contract re electric vehicles and letter to M. Toole—1.5 hours.
12. Collaborate with staff and P. Shinners re Kitsap Transit additional insured issues—2.5 hours.
13. Review and revise policy on non transit risks—2 hours.
14. Attend (via telephone) Governance Policy committee meeting—1 hour.
15. Review and revise Member Guest policy—1 hour.
16. Attend insurance law seminar—8 hours.
17. Attend ethics seminal (via webcast)—5 hours.
18. Attend on line ethics seminar—1.5 hours.
19. Review documents re Pierce Transit FTA grant—3 hours.
20. Review Link Transit contract and letter to N. Covey—1.5 hours.
21. Review 2017 GL and POL coverage documents—1 hour.
22. Review files and preparation of this activity report—2 hours.
That’s it. Feel free to ask questions.
RAF: 11‐2‐16
Agreement Regarding Use of Transit Property
This agreement is between _________________ (User) and _____________Transit (Transit) and regards the use of certain Transit property by User. In consideration of the mutual covenants set forth herein, the parties agree as follows:
Section 1. Description of property. The Transit property which is the subject of this agreement is described as follows: ___________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________.
Section 2. Use. User may use the property described herein only as follow: _________ _______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________.
Section 3. Compensation. User shall pay Transit for the use of the property as follows:
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________.
Section 4. Term. This agreement shall commence on _________________________and
shall terminate on __________________________.
Section 5. Termination. Transit may terminate this agreement for cause by giving written notice thereof to User. Transit or User may terminate this agreement without cause by giving thirty days written notice thereof to the other party.
Section 6.Hold harmless and indemnity. User shall hold harmless, defend, and indemnify Transit, its officers, agents, and employees, from any and all damages, injuries, or claims arising from the use of the property by User.
Section 7. Insurance. User shall obtain and maintain comprehensive general liability insurance with limits no less than $1 million per occurrence for its use of the property. Transit shall be named as an additional insured under the policy. This coverage shall be primary with respect to any claims or losses. Upon request User shall provide Transit a copy of the policy.
Section 8. Disputes. The parties shall seek to resolve any disputes by mediation prior to commencing litigation. The successful party shall be entitled to its costs and reasonable attorneys fees.
RAF: 11‐2‐16
Section 9. Compliance with laws. The parties shall comply with all local, state, and federal laws.
Section 10. Other terms and conditions. ______________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________.
Dated this _________day of ___________, 20______.
____________________________________________
User
Dated this __________day of ____________, 20______.
_______________________________________________
Transit
[ If this agreement is for the use of Transit property by a community organization for a community purpose without compensation, the insurance requirement of Section 7 may be eliminated]
Presented by:
ALLIANT INSURANCE SERVICES Seattle, WA
Lilian Vanvieldt, Senior Vice President Brian A. White, First Vice President
BROKER REPORT December 2016
Washington State Transit
Insurance Pool
Alliant Insurance Services, Inc. 1420 Fifth Avenue, Suite 1500
Seattle, WA 98100206-204-9140
www.alliant.com
Alliant Insurance Services, Inc. Property & Casualty Insurance Market Conditions Report – December, 2016
This market conditions report is based on insurance industry financial results for the first half 2016, as reported by the Insurance Information Institute on October 5, 2016:
• Overall profit (net income after taxes) in the property and casualty insurance industry for the first 6 months of 2016 was $26.5 Billion. This was a decrease of 19% as compared to the 6 months performance a year earlier in 2015 which delivered profitability of $31.6 Billion. The decrease was driven in part due to an increase in incurred losses and loss adjustment expenses, as well as weaker investment returns relative to last year.
• Net written premiums in the first half 2016 increased 3% over the first half 2015. This was less than the rate of increase in the first half of 2015, which was 4.1%. Despite softening, this is the 25th consecutive quarter of premium growth which speaks steady growth since 2010. Premium growth is attributed to two areas: rate increases and/or an increase in insurable exposures (typically driven by increased economic activity).
• The industry’s combined ratio for the first half of 2016 improved slightly to 96,
compared with 97.6 in the first half 2015. Combined ratio is the sum of incurred losses plus other carrier expenses divided by earned premium. It does not take into consideration investment income.
o Combined ratios must be lower in a low interest rate environment, relative to periods of high yield, as carriers have less ability to offset expenses with investment income. A combined ratio of less than 100 signifies an “underwriting profit”.
• Overall industry capacity (policyholder surplus) rose to $680.6 Billion as of June 30, 2016,
as compared to $673.1 Billion at the end of the first half 2015, and is a new record high surplus level for the industry. “The bottom line is that the industry is, and will remain, extremely well capitalized and financially prepared to pay very large scale losses in 2016 and beyond.”
Summary: The property and casualty insurance industry continues to perform well as a whole and policyholder surplus remains plentiful, although there are segments of the market that are performing less well and have presented challenges as of late, which we discuss below. The overall results are driven by a combination of economic growth – albeit recently at a slower rate – and a lack of meaningful catastrophic loss activity. All this despite a continued low interest rate environment.
In the brokerage space, Alliant sees the market as stable to softening with respects to property related placements. While available capacity for Earthquake and other Natural Catastrophe related exposures continues to grow, properties prone to Earthquake and Flooding risk are carefully rated according to their perceived exposure and coverage still remains relatively scarce when compared to insurance available for other causes of loss. Furthermore, insureds experiencing meaningful loss activity should expect upward rate pressure.
The public entity liability insurance marketplace is increasingly challenging, with some exceptions, as historically key markets have continued to reevaluate their risk appetite, and some even withdrawing from the space altogether. Good risks with higher attachment points and a lack of police related exposures continue to fare relatively well. Public Transit business continues to be impacted by this market shift; however it has been a more manageable change for well performing insureds especially those with the ability to take large retentions. New capacity into the marketplace is helping to offset some of the pressure caused by those markets that have withdrawn or re-evaluated their portfolio. Excess workers’ compensation market remains the least competitive segment of the market, and even though signs of stabilization and in the rarer case softening are present, those with premiums of less than $100,000 have very few options available in the market. Cyber continues to move into the forefront in terms of risk and coverage awareness. The recent San Francisco Muni “ransomware” attack highlighted a unique scenario and exposure to the transit sector, including business income interruption and extra expenses incurred by the transit employees to regain operational status. These were costs incurred despite having proper data back-ups and not yielding to the hacker’s demands. A detailed industry income statement the 6 months ending June 30, 2016 is included below.
First Half 2016 Financial Results* ($ billions)
Net Earned Premiums $257.07 Incurred Losses (Including loss adjustment expenses) 183.7
Expenses 73.8 Policyholder Dividends 1.0
Net Underwriting Gain (Loss) -1.5 Investment Income 22.1
Other Items 2.2 Pre-Tax Operating Gain 21.4
Realized Capital Gains (Losses) 4.4 Pre-Tax Income 25.8
Taxes 4.1 Net After-Tax Income $21.69
Surplus (End of Period) $680.64 Combined Ratio 99.8**
*Figures may not add to totals due to rounding. Calculations in text based on unrounded figures.
**Includes mortgage and financial guaranty insurers.
WSTIP Pool Insurance/Reinsurance Policies
Insured Policy
Dates Line of Coverage Carrier Policy Number Limits WSTIP
Deductible/ Retention
Premium Policy(ies)/ Binder
Asotin County PTBA Ben Franklin Transit Link Transit Clallam Transit Clark County PTBA (C-
TRAN) Columbia County Public
Transpiration Community Transit Everett Transit Grant Transit Authority Grays Harbor
Transportation Authority Intercity Transit Island Transit Jefferson Transit
Authority Kitsap Transit Twin Transit Mason County
Transportation Authority Pacific Transit System Pierce Transit Pullman Transit Skagit Transit Spokane Transit
Authority Valley Transit WSTIP Office Whatcom Transportation
Authority Whatcom Transportation
Authority Employee Benefit Plan Board
City of Yakima Transit Division
1/1/16-1/1/17
Commercial Crime Insurance - Including
Employee Theft, Forgery or Alteration, Theft of Money and
Securities, Robbery or Safe Burglary Inside the Premises , Theft Out of the Premises,
Computer Fraud, Funds Transfer Fraud
and Money Orders and Counterfeit
Money
National Union Fire Ins. Co. of Pittsburgh,
PA
035870619
$1,000,000
$10,000
$17,492
Policy emailed 6/30/16
WSTIP Pool Insurance/Reinsurance Policies
Insured Policy
Dates Line of Coverage Carrier Policy Number Limits WSTIP
Deductible/ Retention
Premium Policy(ies)/ Binder
Asotin County PTBA Ben Franklin Transit Link Transit Clallam Transit Clark County PTBA (C-
TRAN) Columbia County Public
Transportation Everett Transit Grant Transit Authority Grays Harbor
Transportation Auth. Intercity Transit Island Transit Jefferson Transit
Authority Kitsap Transit Twin Transit Mason County
Transportation Authority Pacific Transit System Pierce Transit Pullman Transit RiverCities Transit Skagit Transit Community Transit Spokane Transit Valley Transit WSTIP Office Whatcom Transportation
Authority City of Yakima Transit
Division
1/1/16 -1/1/17
Liability Reinsurance of WSTIP Liability &
Public Officials Liability Coverage Documents
Including General Liability, Automobile
Liability, Public Officials E&O Liability
and Employment Practices Liability
Government Entities
Mutual, Inc.
GEM0006A16001 BG0005-0001
$3,000,000 Excess
WSTIP SIR of $2,000,000
Total $5,000,000
$2,000,000
$721,440
Policy emailed 9/12/16
1/1/16 -1/1/17
Liability Reinsurance of WSTIP Liability &
Public Officials Liability Coverage Documents
Including General Liability, Automobile
Liability, Public Officials E&O Liability
and Employment Practices Liability
Munich
159007-3062582-2016
$10,000,000 excess of
WSTIP SIR & GEM Layers -
Total $15,000,000
$5,000,000
$379,324
Agreement emailed 7/8/16
1/1/16 – 1/1/17
Excess Liability including General
Liability, Automobile Liability, Public
Officials E&O Liability and Employment Practices Liability
Arch Insurance Company
UXP0057923-01 $5,000,000 excess of
WSTIP SIR, GEM & Munich
Layers Total
$20,000,000
$15,000,000 $136,000 Policy emailed 9/12/16
WSTIP Pool Insurance/Reinsurance Policies
Insured Policy
Dates Line of Coverage Carrier Policy Number Limits WSTIP
Deductible/ Retention
Premium Policy(ies)/ Binder
Ben Franklin Transit Link Transit Clallam Transit Grant Transit Authority Grays Harbor Transit Intercity Transit Island Transit Jefferson Transit Kitsap Transit Twin Transit Mason County
Transportation Authority Pacific Transit Skagit Transit Community Transit Spokane Transit Valley Transit Whatcom Transit
4/4/15 - 4/4/18
Pollution Liability Insurance
Indian Harbor Ins.
Co.
PEC003726901
$5,000,000 Each Pollution
Condition $5,000,000
Pool Aggregate
$100,000 Each
Pollution Condition
$127,463 Three Year Premium
Clallam Transit System Community Transit Grays Harbor Intercity Transit Jefferson Transit Kitsap Transit Chelan/Douglas Public
Transportation Pacific Transit Valley Transit Pullman Transit
9/25/16-9/25/17
Pollution Liability Insurance
for Underground Storage Tanks
Liberty Surplus
Insurance Corporation
TXELA103563116
$1,000,000 Per Each Pollution
Incident $3,000,000 Aggregate
Limit $250,000 Aggregate
Claims Expense Limit
$25,000 Locs. 2-9 $250,000
Loc. 1
$66,290
WSTIP Pool Insurance/Reinsurance Policies
Insured Policy
Dates Line of Coverage Carrier Policy Number Limits WSTIP
Deductible/ Retention
Premium Policy(ies)/ Binder
Asotin County PTBA Ben Franklin Transit Link Transit Clallam Transit Clark County PTBA (C-
TRAN) Columbia County Public
Transportation Cowlitz Transportation
Authority (RiverCities Transit)
Grant Transit Authority Grays Harbor Transit Intercity Transit Island Transit Jefferson Transit Kitsap Transit Twin Transit Mason County
Transportation Authority Pacific Transit Pierce Transit Skagit Transit Community Transit Spokane Transit Valley Transit WSTIP Whatcom Transit
7/1/16 - 7/1/17
Commercial Property and Boiler &
Machinery Insurance - On Premises Vehicles Included, Off Premises
Coverage, Not Included
Various Carriers
017471589/02 (Dec 11)
$1,000,000,000 All Risk
$100,000,000 Boiler &
Machinery $50,000,000 Flood (Pool Aggregate) $10,000,000
Flood Zones A & V (Pool Aggregate Included in Flood Limit) $25,000,000 Earthquake
(Pool Aggregate) $500,000
Unscheduled Business
Interruption $50,000,000
Extra Expense
$250,000
$551.356.69
Policy review in process
WSTIP Pool Insurance/Reinsurance Policies
Insured Policy
Dates Line of Coverage Carrier Policy Number Limits WSTIP
Deductible/ Retention
Premium Policy(ies)/ Binder
Asotin County PTBA Ben Franklin Transit Link Transit Clallam Transit Clark Co PTBA (C-TRAN) Columbia County Public
Transportation Cowlitz Transportation
Authority (RiverCities Transit)
Grant Transit Authority Grays Harbor Transit Intercity Transit Island Transit Jefferson Transit Kitsap Transit Twin Transit Mason County
Transportation Authority Pacific Transit Pierce Transit Skagit Transit Community Transit Spokane Transit Valley Transit WSTIP Whatcom Transit
7/1/16 - 7/1/17
Vehicle Physical Damage – private
passenger automobiles, commercial automobiles,
(including hired automobiles, trucks,
trailers, or semi trailers) and any other
licensed vehicles designated for travel
on public roads owned or operated by the Named Insured.
Alterra Excess & Surplus
Insurance Company
MAX4IM0047230
Each Occurrence
Limit $20,000,000 Not to exceed maximum on
any one vehicle:
$1,250,000 Newly Acquired Vehicles limit per vehicle: $1,250,000
$250,000 with an Annual
Adjustment Rate of 50% of the Annual Policy Rate
of $.0273 per $100 of values
reported
$185,638 Policy review in process
WSTIP Pool Insurance/Reinsurance Policies
Insured Policy
Dates Line of Coverage Carrier Policy Number Limits WSTIP
Deductible/ Retention
Premium Policy(ies)/ Binder
Asotin County PTBA Ben Franklin Transit Link Transit Clallam Transit Clark Co PTBA (C-TRAN) Columbia Co Public
Transportation Cowlitz Transportation
Authority (RiverCities Transit)
Grant Transit Authority Grays Harbor Transit Intercity Transit Island Transit Jefferson Transit Kitsap Transit Twin Transit Mason County
Transportation Authority Pacific Transit Skagit Transit Community Transit Spokane Transit Valley Transit WSTIP Whatcom Transit Pierce Transit
7/1/16 - 7/1/17
Commercial Cyber Liability Insurance
Including Information Security & Privacy Liability, Privacy
Notification/Monitoring Costs, Regulatory
Defense & Penalties, Website & Media
Content Liability, First Party Data
Protection& Business Interruption Loss
Beazley Group
017471589 (Dec 11)
$2,000,000 Pool Aggregate
$500,000 Privacy
Notification/ Monitoring
Costs (Pool Agg)
$100,000
Included in Property Premium
Policy review in process
Washington State Transit Insurance Pool (WSTIP)LIST OF STAND ALONE INSURANCE POLICIES/COVERAGES WITH ALLIANT INSURANCE SERVICES, INC.
Broker/Account Status as of December 2016
Member Name Type of Coverages/Policy No.Carrier/Underwriter Contact ,
AddressEffective Date
Policy (ies)/ Binder
Community Transit
Excess Workers Compensation
Policy No. SP 4055713
Safety National Casualty Corporation 21832 SchuetzSt. Louis, MO 63146-3540Ph: 314-995-5300Fax: 314-995-3843
October 1, 2016 to October 1, 2017 Policy review in process.
Pierce Transit
Excess Workers Compensation
Policy No. SP 4052746
Safety National Casualty Corporation 1832 SchuetzSt. Louis, MO 63146-3540Ph: 314-995-5300Fax: 314-995-3843
April 1, 2016 to April 1, 2017 Policy emailed to client 9/12/16
Spokane Transit
Excess Workers Compensation
Policy No. SP 4054730
Safety National Casualty Corporation 21832 SchuetzSt. Louis, MO 63146-3540Ph: 314-995-5300Fax: 314-995-3843
April 1, 2016 to April 1, 2017 Policy emailed to client 9/12/16
Marine Transportation of Kitsap
Directors & Officers Liability
Policy No. PHSD1147596
Philadelphia Indemnity Insurance CompanyOne Bala Plaza, Suite 100, Bala Cynwyd, Pennsylvania 19004818-772-1774Fax 818-772-2796
July 1, 2016 to July 1, 2017 Policy emailed to client 9/12/16
Everett Transit
Cyber Liability
Policy No. MPL178592416
Hiscox-AmWins Brokerage601 S. Figueroa Street, Suite 4350Los Angeles, CA 90017213-254-2220
August 17, 2016 to August 17, 2017 Policy review in process.
Clark County Transportation
Business Travel Accident
Policy No. 9907-13-33
Chubb Accident and Health275 Battery St., Suite 12000San Francisco, CA 94111415-273-6432
February 16, 2016 to February 16, 2017 Policy delivered to client - 3/2/15
Pierce Transit
Misc. Bond
Maintenence BondPierce TransitBond No. 52BSBHI3348
The Hartford Financial Services Group, Inc.PO Box 958461Lake Mary, FL 32795888-656-0817, Option 4877-257-2166 (Fax)
October 30, 2015 to April 30, 2017 In Force
Washington State Transit Insurance Pool (WSTIP)LIST OF STAND ALONE INSURANCE POLICIES/COVERAGES WITH ALLIANT INSURANCE SERVICES, INC.
Broker/Account Status as of December 2016
Member Name Type of Coverages/Policy No.Carrier/Underwriter Contact ,
AddressEffective Date
Policy (ies)/ Binder
WSTIP
Misc. Bond
Notary BondJoanne M. Jerabek-KerriganBond No. 15117688N
CNA SURETY101 So. Phillips AvenueSioux Falls, S.D.Attn: Marlys D. Kuil800-331-6053605-335-0357 (Fax)
March 18, 2016 to March 18, 2020 In Force
WSTIP
Misc. Bond
Notary BondLaura MerryBond No. 7199124N
CNA SURETY101 So. Phillips AvenueSioux Falls, S.D.Attn: Marlys D. Kuil800-331-6053605-335-0357 (Fax)
February 25, 2016 to February 25, 2020 In Force
WSTIP
Misc. Bond
Notary BondJennie R FosterBond No. 71240249N
CNA SURETY101 So. Phillips AvenueSioux Falls, S.D.Attn: Marlys D. Kuil800-331-6053605-335-0357 (Fax)
March 1, 2016 to March 1, 2020 In Force
WSTIP
Misc. Bond
Notary BondMarisa Espinoza Snohomish County Public Transp CorpBond No. 71319898N
CNA SURETY101 So. Phillips AvenueSioux Falls, S.D.Attn: Marlys D. Kuil800-331-6053605-335-0357 (Fax)
November 17, 2016 to November 17, 2020 In Force
WSTIP
Misc. Bond
Notary BondJanet E WatsonBond No. 24795682N
CNA SURETY101 So. Phillips AvenueSioux Falls, S.D.Attn: Marlys D. Kuil800-331-6053605-335-0357 (Fax)
July 13, 2014 to July 13, 2018 In Force
Snohomish
Misc. Bond
Notary BondVirginia Ponce de LeonBond No. 16116881N and 16116881N01
CNA SURETY101 So. Phillips AvenueSioux Falls, S.D.Attn: Marlys D. Kuil800-331-6053605-335-0357 (Fax)
May 12, 2014 to May 12, 2018 In Force
Minutes of the
June Quarterly Meeting
September 30, 2016
Holiday Inn ~ Everett
Board Members Present
Amy Asher, RiverCities Transit
Lynn Bourton, Link Transit
Danette Brannin, Mason Transit
Mike Burress, Community Transit
Wendy Clark-Getzin, Clallam Transit
Rich Evans, Pacific Transit
Ben Foreman, Large Member Rep, Intercity
Transit
Kevin Futrell, Yakima Transit
Jenny George, Asotin County PTBA
Stephanie Guettinger, Columbia County Public
Transportation
Emmett Heath, President, Community Transit
Tom Hingson, Everett Transit
Rob Huyck, Pierce Transit
Staci Jordan, Medium Member Rep, Island
Transit
Rob LaFontaine, Small Member Rep, Twin
Transit
Ken Mehin, Grays Harbor Transit
Ed McCaw, Valley Transit
Mike Nortier, Island Transit
Dale O’Brien, Skagit Transit
Diane O’Regan, Secretary, C-Tran
Motoko Pleasant, Skagit Transit
Tammi Rubert, Jefferson Transit
Paul Shinners, Vice-President, Kitsap Transit
Pete Stark, Whatcom Transportation Authority
Jim Thoelke, Ben Franklin Transit
Mike Toole, Spokane Transit
Michael Wagner, Grant Transit
Guests Present
Brian White, Alliant Insurance Services
WSTIP Staff Present
Anna Broadhead, Member Services Assistant
Tracey Christianson, Acting Deputy Director
Chris DeVoll, Transit Risk Consultant
Marisa Espinoza, Finance Specialist
Ron Franz, General Counsel
Al Hatten, Executive Director
Joanne Kerrigan, Risk and Training Coordinator
Andrea Powell, Information Technology Program
Manager;
Karey Thornton, Claims and Information Technology
Assistant
The Washington State Transit Insurance Pool (WSTIP) Board of Directors held their September Board Meeting on
September 30, 2016, at the Holiday Inn, in Everett, Washington. Board Members present:. Guests present:.
Staff present:
Call to Order
President Heath called the meeting to order at 9:02 am. A sign in sheet was passed around the room.
Discussion Items
Member Representative Meeting Report and Discussion
LaFontaine stated the small members discussed local audits, transients and the issues that seem to be across all
our agencies and how law enforcement handles transients. We also discussed the presidential election, WSTIP
organization plan, and aced the quiz.
Jordan said the medium members discussed near misses and how we deal with them, preventative versus
punitive encouraging operators to report near misses as an opportunity to learn from them. We also talked about
pre-employment testing regarding mobility device securement and seeing if they can drive the bus or if the bus
drives them before going into extensive training. Discussed medical exams for current drivers who are having
trouble passing other than just three months at a time. Heath said 53 percent of their coach operators have
accessed their on-site physical therapy and pain management services.
Heath did a quick poll to see what people are putting into their budgets for salary adjustments, answers ranged
from 2 to 3.5 percent. Bourton felt it would be beneficial at the WSTA Human Resources Committee to discuss
the salary surveys that are taking place and perhaps doing a joint one as there are at least three agencies doing a
salary survey this year.
Foreman said the large group focused on the funding study, passed the quiz, and had some great stories about
bait cars. As a group we are supportive of going to a seven percent minimum rate increase and maybe even more
we are on track to go to $5 million SIR in 2020-2021 we may need to accelerate that plan, and are willing to do
that but are unsure about small and medium members willingness. LaFontaine and Jordan said they hadn’t
discussed that as a group.
There was a brief discussion regarding the 2017 budget and asked staff to provide options for both a $2.5 million
SIR and a $3 million SIR. Staff will try to have numbers before the October meeting but may not have solid
numbers for the $5 million in excess of $15 million layer.
Underground Storage Tank Report
White said there are nine members who participate, there is a $1 million limit, and the deductible has historically
been $25,000. The tanks in the program are quite old and this impacts all members in the program. We ran into
issues this year with underwriting. Intercity Transit’s deductible was raised to $250,000 and everyone else is still
$25,000. The raise corresponds to Intercity’s action to remove the tanks which means the risk goes up
substantially. White also discussed that next year older tanks will likely also see an increase in their deductible or
any tanks in the process of decommissioned and warned the participants to be prepared for that. White
answered questions from members.
Nominations and Elections Committee
Shinners said an email would be coming out to solicit nominations for the Executive Committee, he will try to
reach out and encourage everyone to run for office. Please send him your ideas on what you would like to see the
Pool focus on in 2017.
Financial Reports
July 2016 Treasurer’s Report, Income and Expense Statement, Balance Sheet, Claims Report, and Comparative
Income and Expense, and Balance Sheets
Hatten said there isn’t a lot to highlight on the financial reports. Heath asked what the Board members should
focus on when they look at these reports. Foreman said equity and cash position relative to current liabilities. If
you have questions regarding the financial statements, please contact Hatten.
Staff Reports
Executive Staff Report
Hatten said the 2017 draft budget you have is the high point, we will be going through several reiterations of the
budget including higher SIR scenarios, he is also having preliminary discussions regarding a potential captive
transit protected cell within GEM (captive within a captive scenario), but that may have less appeal if we raise the
SIR. Hatten said Intercity Transit had approached WSTIP as they are getting ready to expand their facilities and
may be a possibility of shared space for Board meetings and expanding training. There are funds remaining in the
Jeffrey S. Ristau Scholarship fund, next deadline November 15. Hatten and Foreman will be meeting with the
Thurston County Treasurer to discuss the Pool’s investment strategy and may look at going from our current
passive investment strategy to a more active strategy similar to what Community Transit has done, we may be
able to generate more interest income per year. If you have questions give Hatten a call.
Christianson said DeVoll has visited most members, visits are going well, and he is teaching reasonable suspicion
to members, and Kerrigan has finished her vanpool visits for the year. We plan to roll out the securement training
soon. The webpage is close to launch and should launch in the next couple of weeks. The information regarding
claims has been updated. Hatten said the matter between Clark County and WCRP has settled and been pulled
from the Supreme Court so the question will remain unanswered. If you have questions please don’t hesitate to
contact Christianson.
Powell gave an update on Origami, work continues on reporting, Origami will be at our December meeting, and if
you are interested in OSHA reporting through Origami you will soon have the capability for a small fee. If you
have questions regarding the Executive Staff Report, contact Hatten or Christianson.
General Counsel’s Report
Franz asked for questions regarding his recent activities and had no intention of going through the list, however,
he did make the requested changes to the non-transit liability governance policy. Franz pointed out that
paragraph five had been removed but paragraph four remained with the requirement of yearly reporting. Board
members discussed the language and asked Franz to revise the language to report only if there is a significant
change. This policy will be on the agenda for the October Executive Committee meeting. Clark-Getzin asked if it
was necessary to remove the word insurance from all documents. Franz said it is laborious and may take a
couple years but we need to start thinking of ourselves not like an insurance company but as a governmental
entity that provides risk management. The language change is a cooperative effort by all the pools in Washington.
A brief discussion regarding WSTIP’s name and what the letter “I” could be ensued. Heath noted this potentially
could be a retreat topic.
The Board took a short break at 10:30 am and resumed their meeting at 10:47 am.
Broker’s Report
White gave an update on the state of the insurance market and fielded questions from Board members.
Action Items
Minutes – March 25, 2016
McCaw moved to approve the minutes from June 24, 2016. Shinners seconded the motion and the motion
passed.
Underground Storage Tank Renewals
Foreman moved to approve Underground Storage Tank Coverage as bound. McCaw seconded the motion
and it passed.
Executive Session
There was no Executive Session.
Member Updates
Heath thanked everyone for the great discussion, 2% to 3.5% general wage increases amongst members, staff
will prepare budget options for 2017, Underground Storage Tank Coverage has been bound for another year, our
financials look solid, a lot of discussion regarding our SIR and GEM, said goodbye to Jerry Spears,
congratulations to Christianson, Kerrigan, and Powell, thanked all the guest speakers. Hatten thanked White for
his hospitality in hosting beverages. Franz jokingly requested higher limits. He noted he will see most everyone at
the Joint Leadership Training in Spokane and the Executive Committee will hold their meeting at the end of that
event. A few members gave brief updates.
Adjournment
Heath adjourned the meeting at 11:16 am.
Submitted this _9th _ day of December 2016
Approved: ____________________________
Diane O’Regan, Secretary
Policy Governance Defined and Explained Governance Section: Operations
Revision Date: 6/23/201112/9/2016 Page: 1 of 2
Purpose
To assist all persons interested in the Pool's governance locating and interpreting the documents which
contain and embody that governance.
Authority
1. Interlocal Agreement, Section 5 (Bylaws); and
2. Bylaws, Article XIII, Governance Documentation Procedure.
Policy Statement
1. Except for matters contained in its Interlocal Agreement and Bylaws, the Pool shall memorialize
its governance in this "WSTIP Policy Manual."
2. The Policy Manual shall be divided into the following categories: (1) finance; (2) governance; (3)
operations; and (4) organizational. On a quarterly and rotating basis the Pool’s Executive
Committee or a subcommittee established by it shall review the policies in each category, and if
appropriate, recommend revisions. The review shall be for currencey and clarity.
3. The Pool has phased out its traditional resolution style of governance in favor of policy
governance as defined and explained in this document. The reason for this shift is to make the
Pool's governance easier to understand by establishing a comprehensive set of policy statements
organized by topic.
4. The Pool shall memorialize its governance in writing to the maximum extent possible. This will
reduce one's need for institutional knowledge to understand the Pool’s goals, procedures, and
functions.
5. The Pool has reviewed all resolutions and has repealed all resolutions except for those it has
decided to retain as legacy resolutions. All legacy resolutions are referenced in Policy on Legacy
Resolutions.
6. The hierarchy of control for the Pool's governance documents is:
a. Interlocal Agreement;
b. Bylaws;
c. WSTIP Policy Manual and its policy governance segments;
d. Retained legacy resolutions; and
e. Passed motions documented in meeting minutes authenticated by the Pool’s Secretary.
Responsibilities
1. The governing bodies of the Pool's members are responsible for the Interlocal Agreement.
2. The Pool's Board is responsible for the Bylaws and those specific topics reserved to it in the Bylaws.
3. The Pool's Executive Committee is responsible for all governance except as set forth above.
Amendment
The Board may amend this policy.
Repealer
Resolutions No. 2-2003 “Comprehensive Financial Management Program” passed on November 20,
2003 and No. 2-1999 “Associate Membership Program” passed on March 18, 1999 and Governance
Responsibilities and Procedures passed May 22, 2008 are hereby repealed.
Policy Governance Defined and Explained Page: 2 of 2
Policy History
None.
Passed by the Board of Directors on December 9, 2016.
Emmett Heath, President
Attest:
Diane O’Regan, Secretary
Approved as to form:
Ronald A. Franz, General Counsel
Policy Governance Defined and Explained Governance Section: Operations
Revision Date: 12/9/2016 Page: 1 of 2
Purpose
To assist all persons interested in the Pool's governance locating and interpreting the documents which
contain and embody that governance.
Authority
1. Interlocal Agreement, Section 5 (Bylaws); and
2. Bylaws, Article XIII, Governance Documentation Procedure.
Policy Statement
1. Except for matters contained in its Interlocal Agreement and Bylaws, the Pool shall memorialize
its governance in this "WSTIP Policy Manual."
2. The Policy Manual shall be divided into the following categories: (1) finance; (2) governance; (3)
operations; and (4) organizational. On a quarterly and rotating basis the Pool’s Executive
Committee or a subcommittee established by it shall review the policies in each category, and if
appropriate, recommend revisions. The review shall be for currency and clarity.
3. The Pool has phased out its traditional resolution style of governance in favor of policy
governance as defined and explained in this document. The reason for this shift is to make the
Pool's governance easier to understand by establishing a comprehensive set of policy statements
organized by topic.
4. The Pool shall memorialize its governance in writing to the maximum extent possible. This will
reduce one's need for institutional knowledge to understand the Pool’s goals, procedures, and
functions.
5. The Pool has reviewed all resolutions and has repealed all resolutions except for those it has
decided to retain as legacy resolutions. All legacy resolutions are referenced in Policy on Legacy
Resolutions.
6. The hierarchy of control for the Pool's governance documents is:
a. Interlocal Agreement;
b. Bylaws;
c. WSTIP Policy Manual and its policy governance segments;
d. Retained legacy resolutions; and
e. Passed motions documented in meeting minutes authenticated by the Pool’s Secretary.
Responsibilities
1. The governing bodies of the Pool's members are responsible for the Interlocal Agreement.
2. The Pool's Board is responsible for the Bylaws and those specific topics reserved to it in the Bylaws.
3. The Pool's Executive Committee is responsible for all governance except as set forth above.
Amendment
The Board may amend this policy.
Repealer
Resolutions No. 2-2003 “Comprehensive Financial Management Program” passed on November 20,
2003 and No. 2-1999 “Associate Membership Program” passed on March 18, 1999 and Governance
Responsibilities and Procedures passed May 22, 2008 are hereby repealed.
Policy Governance Defined and Explained Page: 2 of 2
Policy History
None.
Passed by the Board of Directors on December 9, 2016.
Emmett Heath, President
Attest:
Diane O’Regan, Secretary
Approved as to form:
Ronald A. Franz, General Counsel
2017 WSTIP Liability Coverage Document RAF 11/28/2016
2017
Liability
Coverage Document
2017 WSTIP Liability Coverage Document RAF 11/28/2016
i Washington State Transit Insurance Pool
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Introduction ................................................................................................................................................. 1
Layered Coverage ....................................................................................................................................... 1
Section 1. Coverage Agreement ............................................................................................................... 2
Coverages ................................................................................................................................................. 2
Coverage A. Bodily injury and property damage ................................................................................... 2
Coverage B. Personal injury and advertising injury ............................................................................... 2
Coverage C. Contractual liability ........................................................................................................... 2
Coverage D. Vanpool Driver Medical Expense Protection ................................................................... 2
Coverage E. Underinsured Motorists Coverage ................................................................................... 2
Coverage F. Cyber intrusion Coverage ................................................................................................ 2
Investigation, Settlement, and Defense ..................................................................................................... 2
Supplementary Payments ......................................................................................................................... 3
Limits of Liability ........................................................................................................................................ 3
Section 2. Who is Covered? ...................................................................................................................... 3
Section 3. Exclusions ................................................................................................................................ 4
Intentional Acts .......................................................................................................................................... 4
Workers' Compensation ............................................................................................................................ 4
Aircraft ....................................................................................................................................................... 4
Pollution ..................................................................................................................................................... 4
War, Insurrection, Terrorist Activity ........................................................................................................... 5
Owned, Rented, or Occupied Property ..................................................................................................... 5
Certain personal injury and advertising injury Activities ............................................................................ 5
Employment-Related Practices ................................................................................................................. 5
Fines or Punitive Damages ....................................................................................................................... 5
Watercraft .................................................................................................................................................. 5
Nuclear Material ........................................................................................................................................ 5
Asbestos, Lead, Mold ................................................................................................................................ 5
Section 4. General Policy Conditions ...................................................................................................... 5
Duties in the Event of occurrence, claim or suit ........................................................................................ 6
Legal Action Against Us ............................................................................................................................ 6
Other Coverage ......................................................................................................................................... 6
Primary Coverage .................................................................................................................................. 6
Excess Coverage ................................................................................................................................... 6
Method of Sharing .................................................................................................................................. 6
Contributions, Audits, and Assessments ................................................................................................... 6
Subrogation ............................................................................................................................................... 7
Section 5. Definitions ................................................................................................................................. 7
Additional covered parties ......................................................................................................................... 7
Advertising injury ....................................................................................................................................... 7
2017 WSTIP Liability Coverage Document RAF 11/28/2016
ii Washington State Transit Insurance Pool
Bodily injury ............................................................................................................................................... 7
Contractual liability .................................................................................................................................... 7
Cyber intrusion .......................................................................................................................................... 7
Medical and hospital benefits .................................................................................................................... 7
Member ..................................................................................................................................................... 7
Occurrence ................................................................................................................................................ 7
Personal injury ........................................................................................................................................... 7
Products/Completed Operations Hazard................................................................................................... 8
Pollutants ................................................................................................................................................... 8
Property damage ....................................................................................................................................... 8
Suit............................................................................................................................................................. 8
Underinsured motor vehicle ...................................................................................................................... 8
2017 WSTIP Liability Coverage Document RAF 11/28/2016
1
INTRODUCTION
The Washington State Transit Insurance Pool (Pool) is not an insurance company. It is
an entity created pursuant to RCW 48.62. It is controlled and governed by applicable
state statutes and regulations, the Interlocal agreement through which the Pool was
formed, and its own bylaws and governance documents.
The state statutes and regulations, which apply to insurance companies, do not apply to
the Pool. The state insurance commissioner does not regulate the Pool. The judicial
cases which apply to the construction and interpretation of insurance policies do not
apply to this coverage document.
This shall be construed, applied, and interpreted in accordance with the Pool’s rules,
regulations, and bylaws.
Various provisions in this coverage document restrict coverage. Please read the entire
document carefully to determine rights, duties, and what is and is not covered.
Throughout this policy the words "you" and "your" refer to the member shown in the
Coverage Declarations and any other person or organization qualifying as an additional
covered party. The words "we," "us," "our," “WSTIP” or “Pool” refer to the Washington
State Transit Insurance Pool.
Words and phrases that appear in bold italics have special meaning. Please refer to
definitions in Section 5.
LAYERED COVERAGE
The coverage provided by the Pool’s program is in layers. The first layer of coverage is
funded by the Pool and its terms and conditions are as set forth in this coverage
document. Above the Pool’s layer of coverage are coverages provided by excess or
reinsurers. For the most part, the coverages provided by the excess or reinsurers “follow
the form” of the Pool’s coverage but there are some differences. Coverage for any loss
above the Pool’s layer shall be determined by the terms, conditions, and exceptions as
set forth in the excess or reinsurance coverage documents.
2017 WSTIP Liability Coverage Document RAF 11/28/2016
2
COVERAGE PART
Section 1. Coverage Agreement
A. Coverages
1. The Pool will pay those sums which the member or additional covered party becomes legally
obligated to pay as damages arising from the following activities or events:
a. Coverage A. Bodily injury and property damage liability
Damages from bodily injury or property damage caused by an occurrence that takes
place during the coverage period.
b. Coverage B. Personal injury and advertising injury liability
Damages from personal injury or advertising injury caused by an offense that was
committed during the coverage period; Provided, the total limit available for any loss involving
more than one line of coverage shall be no greater than the highest limit available for the
lines of coverage involved. c. Coverage C. Contractual liability
Damage arising from contractual liability arising during the coverage period.
2. The Pool will pay:
a. Coverage D. Vanpool Driver Medical Expense Protection
Medical and hospital benefits to any vanpool driver who suffers bodily injury as a result of
an occurrence while operating a van within the terms and conditions of a vanpool agreement
with member.
3. The Pool will pay those sums which member or additional covered party is legally entitled to
recover as compensatory damages arising from the following event:
a. Coverage E. Underinsured Motorists Coverage
Bodily injury sustained by member or additional covered party as a result of an
occurrence caused by the owner or driver of an underinsured motor vehicle and
involving that vehicle; Provided, there is no coverage for an additional covered party who
is covered by workers’ compensation. b. Coverage F. Cyber intrusion Coverage.
For this coverage only in addition to compensatory damages, coverage shall include those
amounts incurred by the member or additional covered party to provide notification or
monitoring as required by statute, ordinance, or regulation to persons or organizations
affected by the cyber intrusion.
B. Investigation, Settlement, and Defense
1. The Pool has the right and duty to defend any suit seeking damages from a member or
additional covered party under Coverages A through E. We may, at our discretion, investigate
and settle any claim or suit as we consider appropriate. The member or additional covered
2017 WSTIP Liability Coverage Document RAF 11/28/2016
3
party has an obligation to cooperate with us in our investigation and defense. Our duty to defend
or settle ends when the limit of liability for the applicable coverage has been exhausted by
payment of judgments, settlements, or supplementary payments.
2. A member is obligated to pay its deductible.
C. Supplementary Payments
We will pay, but not in addition to damages, with respect to any claim or suit we defend:
1. All defense costs and expenses we incur.
2. All reasonable expenses incurred by the member or additional covered party at our request to
assist us in the investigation or defense of the claim or suit.
3. All interest on the amount of any judgment that accrues after entry of the judgment and before we
have paid, offered to pay, or deposited in court the part of the judgment that is within the
applicable limit of liability.
D. Limits of Liability
1. The most we will pay as damages and supplementary payments for any coverage arising out of
any one occurrence, an advertising or personal injury offense, or contractual liability is the
limit of liability shown in the Coverage Declarations; Provided, when an occurrence, offense, or
contractual liability spans more than one coverage period, the most we will pay is the highest
limit of liability as shown in the Coverage Declarations.
2. The most we will pay as damages and supplementary payments for liability arising from
products/completed operations hazard arising out of one or more occurrences in a Coverage
Period is the limit of liability shown in the Coverage Declarations. 3. We will not cover any matter for which member or additional covered party has coverage under
the Public Officials’ Liability coverage document issued by Pool to member.
Section 2. WHO IS COVERED?
The coverage afforded by the Coverage Document applies to:
A. The member identified in the Coverage Declarations;
B. Additional covered parties as follows:
1. Any official, trustee, employee, or volunteer of the member but only while acting within the scope
of his or her official duties.
2. Any person or entity to which the member is obligated by virtue of a written contract to provide
coverage such as is provided by this coverage document but only in respect to operations or
services provided to the member at its request as set forth in the written contract; Provided, any
such written contract shall meet the Pool’s underwriting standards and if it does not then this
coverage document shall provide no coverage to the person or entity; Provided further, any such
written contract must contain a hold harmless provision endorsed by the Pool.
3. For underinsured motorist coverage only, any occupant of a vehicle for which a member has
purchased underinsured motorist coverage.
4. For motor vehicle coverage only, any vanpool driver.
2017 WSTIP Liability Coverage Document RAF 11/28/2016
4
5. For motor vehicle coverage only, any person driving a motor vehicle owned by a member with
permission of the member for which the Pool provides coverage, Provided:
a. any such permissive user has a valid driver’s license;
b. the permissive user is at least 21 years of age;
c. the coverage provided to the permissive user by this coverage document is excess to any
other coverage in favor of the permissive user;
d. the limits of coverage provided to the permissive user by this coverage document are
$300,000 for bodily injury and $100,000 for property damage; and
e. the permissive user may not provide permission to any other person to drive the motor
vehicle.
6. Any person or entity named as an additional insured on a certificate of insurance issued by the
Pool.
7. The Pool and the employees of the Pool while acting within the scope of his, her or its official
duties.
Section 3. EXCLUSIONS
This coverage document does not apply to and there is no coverage for:
A. Intentional Acts
Bodily injury or property damage expected or intended from the standpoint of the member or
additional covered party. This exclusion does not apply to:
1. The use of force to protect persons or property; or
2. Member’s liability for damages as a result of vicarious liability for acts of its employees.
B. Workers' Compensation
Any obligation under a workers' compensation law or any similar law. This exclusion does not apply
where an employee of member is injured in the course of such employment where it is determined that
the employee is not entitled to receive worker’s compensation benefits.
C. Aircraft
Liability arising out of the ownership, maintenance, use, or entrustment to others of any aircraft or
operation of any airfield.
D. Pollution
Bodily injury, property damage, or personal injury which would not have occurred in whole or in part
but for the actual, alleged, or threatened discharge, dispersal, seepage, migration, release, or escape of
pollutants at any time. This exclusion does not apply to:
1. Bodily injury, property damage or personal injury caused by heat, smoke, or
fumes from a hostile fire. A hostile fire means one which becomes uncontrollable
or breaks out from where it was intended to be; or
2. The discharge, dispersal, seepage, migration, release, or escape of pollutants
caused directly by the upset, overturn, or damage of a motor vehicle for which
this coverage document provides liability coverage.
2017 WSTIP Liability Coverage Document RAF 11/28/2016
5
E. War, Insurrection, Terrorist Activity
Bodily injury or property damage due to war, whether or not declared, or any act or condition incident
to war. War includes civil war, insurrection, rebellion, revolution, or terrorist activity.
F. Owned, Rented, or Occupied Property
Property damage to:
1. Property you own, rent, or occupy; or
2. Property loaned to you.
G. Certain personal injury and advertising injury Activities
1. Personal injury or advertising injury:
a. Arising out of oral or written publication of material, if done by or at the direction of member
or additional covered party, with knowledge of its falsity;
b. Arising out of oral or written publication of material the first publication of which took place
prior to the coverage period; or
c. Arising out of the willful violation of a penal statute or ordinance committed by or with the
consent of member or additional covered party.
2. Advertising injury arising out of:
a. Breach of contract;
b. The failure of goods, products, or services to conform with advertised quality or performance;
or
c. The wrong description of the price of goods, products, or services.
H. Employment-Related Practices
Any actual or alleged wrongful termination, discipline, or discrimination related to hiring or employment.
I. Fines or Punitive Damages
Fines, punitive damages, or exemplary damages.
J. Watercraft
Liability arising out of the ownership, maintenance, use (including loading, unloading, embarking, or
disembarking), or entrustment to others of any watercraft.
K Nuclear Material
Liability arising out of the hazardous properties of nuclear material.
L. Asbestos, Lead, Mold
Liability arising out of, resulting from, caused or contributed to by asbestos, lead or mold or exposure to
asbestos, lead, or mold or for the costs of abatement, mitigation, removal or disposal of asbestos, lead, or
mold.
Section 4. General Policy Conditions
The coverages in this coverage document are subject to the following conditions:
2017 WSTIP Liability Coverage Document RAF 11/28/2016
6
A. Duties in the Event of occurrence, claim or suit
1. You must notify us as soon as practicable of an occurrence which appears likely to involve
coverage. Notice should include:
a. How, when, and where the occurrence took place;
b. The names and addresses of any injured person(s) or witness(es); and
c. The nature and location of any injury or damage arising out of the occurrence.
2. If you receive a claim, notice, or suit which appears likely to involve this coverage document you
must record the date and time received and promptly provide us a copy.
B. Legal Action Against Us
No person or entity may:
1. Join us as a party or otherwise bring us into a suit seeking damages from member or additional
covered party; or
2. Sue us unless all of the terms of this coverage document have been met.
C. Other Coverage
If other coverage is available to member or additional covered party for an occurrence or offence, our
obligations are limited as follows:
1. Primary Coverage. This coverage is primary except as provided by Section 4C2. If this
coverage is primary, our obligations are not affected unless the other coverage is also primary in
which case we will share coverage by the method described in Section 4C3.
2. Excess Coverage.
a. This coverage is excess over other coverages where the other coverage is available to you
as an additional covered party or additional insured under a coverage document or policy
issued by a contractor or service provider performing work for you.
b. When this coverage is excess, we have no duty to defend any suit or claim that some other
entity has a duty to defend. However if such other entity fails or refuses to defend, then we
will do so on the condition that you transfer to us your rights to proceed against that entity.
c. When this coverage is excess, we will pay the amount of damages not paid by underlying
coverages but only to our limits of liability.
3. Method of Sharing.
a. If the other coverages permit contribution by equal shares, we shall follow this method so that
each entity providing coverage contributes equal amounts up to its coverage limits.
b. If the other coverages do not permit contribution by equal shares, we shall contribute by limits
so that each entity providing coverage shall contribute based on the ratio of its applicable limit
to the total limits of all entities providing coverage.
D. Contributions, Audits, and Assessments
We will compute all contributions and assessments and perform all audits in conformity with the Pool’s
governance documents and Bylaws.
2017 WSTIP Liability Coverage Document RAF 11/28/2016
7
E. Subrogation
If you have the right to recover all or part of a payment we have made on your behalf, you must transfer
those rights to us and do nothing to impair those rights; Provided, you may waive subrogation but only
prior to any occurrence. Upon request, you must bring suit at our expense to enforce such rights and/or
cooperate with us in enforcing such rights.
Section 5. DEFINITIONS
A. Additional covered parties are those persons or entities set forth in Section 2 B
B. Advertising injury means injury arising out of one or more of the following offenses committed in the
course of advertising your goods, products, or services:
1. Oral or written publication of material that slanders or libels a person or organization or
disparages a person's or organization's goods, products, or services;
2. Oral or written publication of material that violates a person's right of privacy;
3. Misappropriation of advertising ideas or style of doing business; or
4. Infringement of copyright, title, or slogan.
C. Bodily injury means physical injury, mental injury, shock, sickness, or disease sustained by a
person, including death resulting from any of these at any time.
D. Contractual liability means liability for bodily injury, property damage, advertising injury, or
personal injury arising from the operation of a hold harmless provision in a written agreement where
member has agreed to hold another person or entity harmless; Provided, there shall be no
contractual liability coverage under this coverage document arising in an agreement for
professional architectural, engineering, or surveying services.
E. Cyber intrusion means injury or damage caused by the unauthorized access, misappropriation,
manipulation, or corruption of electronically stored information
F. Medical and hospital benefits means payments for reasonable and necessary medical expenses
incurred as a result of a covered occurrence and includes payments for dental services,
prescriptions, prosthetic devices, ambulance expenses, and funeral expenses. Benefits do not
include loss of income or expenses for household services.
G. Member means a Washington State public transit entity that participated in the formation of the Pool
or has been approved for membership in the Pool.
H. Occurrence means an accident, including continuous or repeated exposure to substantially the same
general harmful conditions, which results in bodily injury or property damage.
I. Personal injury means injury arising out of one or more of the following offenses:
1. False arrest, detention, or imprisonment;
2017 WSTIP Liability Coverage Document RAF 11/28/2016
8
2. Malicious prosecution;
3. Defamation;
4. Wrongful eviction from, wrongful entry into, or invasion of the right of private occupancy of a
room, dwelling, or premises that a person occupies;
5. Oral or written publication of material that slanders or libels a person or organization or
disparages a person's or organization's goods, products, or service;
6. Oral or written publication of material that violates a person's right of privacy;
7. Assault and battery not committed by, at the direction, or with consent of Member; or
8. Discrimination prohibited by state or federal law including discrimination based upon race,
religion, nationality, national origin, color, creed, sex, sexual preference, age, employment, or
disability.
J Products/Completed Operations Hazard means all bodily injury and property damage which
occurs away from premises you own or rent and arising out of your products or work that has been sold,
transferred, or performed for others except:
1. Products that are still in your physical possession; or
2. Work that has not yet been completed.
K. Pollutants means any solid, liquid, gaseous or thermal irritant or contaminant, including smoke,
vapor, soot, fumes, acids, alkalis, chemicals, lead, asbestos, and waste. Waste includes materials to be
recycled, reconditioned, or reclaimed.
L. Property damage means physical injury to tangible property, including all resulting loss of use of that
property.
M. Suit means a civil proceeding in which damages are sought. Suit includes:
1. An arbitration proceeding in which such damages are claimed and to which you must submit or
do submit with our consent; or
2. Any other alternative dispute resolution proceeding in which such damages are claimed and to
which you submit with our consent.
N. Underinsured motor vehicle means a land motor vehicle:
1. For which no liability bond or policy applies at the time of an occurrence;
2. For which a liability bond or policy applies at the time of the occurrence, but the amount paid
under all of the bonds or policies to a covered party is not enough to pay the full amount the
covered party is legally entitled to recover as damages caused by the occurrence;
3. For which all insuring or bonding companies deny coverage or are or become insolvent; or
4. That is a hit-or-run vehicle and neither the driver nor owner can be identified.
2017 Public Officials Liability Coverage Document RAF: 11/28/2016
2017
PUBLIC OFFICIALS LIABILITY COVERAGE DOCUMENT
2017 Public Officials Liability Coverage Document RAF: 11/28/2016
i Washington State Transit Insurance Pool
TABLE OF CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................. 1
LAYERED COVERAGE ....................................................................................... 1
COVERAGE PART ............................................................................................... 2 Section 1. Coverage Agreement .............................................................................. 2
A. Coverage ............................................................................................................. 2 B. Claims .................................................................................................................. 2
C. Investigation, Settlement, and Defense .......................................................... 2
Section 2. Exclusions ................................................................................................. 3
Section 3. Who is Covered? ...................................................................................... 4
Section 4. Limits of Coverage ................................................................................... 5
Section 5. Conditions .................................................................................................. 5
Section 6. Extended reporting period ...................................................................... 6
Section 7. Definitions .................................................................................................. 6
Additional covered parties ...................................................................................... 6 Advertising injury ...................................................................................................... 6
Bodily injury ............................................................................................................... 7
Claim .......................................................................................................................... 7
Claim expenses ........................................................................................................ 7 Loss ............................................................................................................................ 7
Member ...................................................................................................................... 7
Offense....................................................................................................................... 7
Personal injury .......................................................................................................... 7
Pollutants ................................................................................................................... 8
Professional services ............................................................................................... 8
Property damage ...................................................................................................... 8 Suit .............................................................................................................................. 8 Wrongful act .............................................................................................................. 8
2017 Public Officials Liability Coverage Document RAF: 11/28/2016
1 Washington State Transit Insurance Pool
INTRODUCTION
The Washington State Transit Insurance Pool (Pool) is not an insurance company. It is an entity created
pursuant to RCW 48.62. It is controlled and governed by applicable state statutes and regulations, the
Interlocal agreement through which the Pool was formed, and its own bylaws and governance
documents.
The state statutes and regulations which apply to insurance companies do not apply to the Pool. The
Pool is not regulated by the state insurance commissioner. The judicial cases which apply to the
construction and interpretation of insurance policies do not apply to this coverage document.
This coverage document shall be construed, applied, and interpreted in accordance with the Pool’s rules,
regulations, and bylaws.
Various provisions in this coverage document restrict coverage. Please read the entire document
carefully to determine rights, duties, and what is and is not covered.
Throughout this policy the words “you” and “your” refer to member shown in the Coverage Declarations
and any other person or organization qualifying as an additional covered party. The words “we,” “us,”
“our, “WSTIP” or “Pool” refer to the Washington State Transit Insurance Pool.
Words and phrases that appear in italics have special meaning. Please refer to definitions in Section 7.
LAYERED COVERAGE
The coverage provided by the Pool’s program is in layers. The first layer of coverage is funded by the
Pool and its terms and conditions are as set forth in this coverage document. Above the Pool’s layer of
coverage are coverages provided by excess or reinsurers. For the most part, the coverages provided by
the excess or reinsurers “follow the form” of the Pool’s coverage but there are some differences.
Coverage for any loss above the Pool’s layer shall be determined by the terms, conditions, and
exceptions as set forth in the excess or reinsurance coverage documents.
2017 Public Officials Liability Coverage Document RAF: 11/28/2016
2 Washington State Transit Insurance Pool
COVERAGE PART
Section 1. Coverage Agreement
A. Coverage
1. We will pay on behalf of member or additional covered party those sums that member or additional covered party becomes legally obligated to pay as loss because of a wrongful act(s) to
which this coverage applies.
2. This coverage applies to a wrongful act(s) only if:
a. The wrongful act(s) takes place after the Retroactive Date shown in the Declarations and
before the end of the policy period; and
b. A claim is first made against member or additional covered party as set forth in paragraph
B below during the coverage period or any extended reporting period we may provide
according to Section 6 – Extended Reporting Period.
B. Claims
1. A claim will be deemed to have been made at the earlier of the following:
a. When notice of such claim is received and recorded by us; or
b. When you become aware of a wrongful act(s) which may subsequently give rise to a claim
being made and you give written notice to us of such circumstances immediately but not later
than:
1. The end of the coverage period; or
2. The end of any applicable extended reporting period.
2. All claims based on or arising out of the same wrongful act, or a series of related wrongful
act(s), by one or more covered entities shall be considered first made when the first of such
claims is made.
C. Investigation, Settlement, and Defense
1. The Pool has the right and duty to defend any suit or claim seeking damages from a member or
additional covered party for wrongful act(s) to which this coverage applies. We may, at our
discretion, investigate and settle any claim or suit as we consider appropriate. The member or
additional covered party has an obligation to cooperate with us in our investigation and
defense. Our duty to defend or settle ends when the limit of liability has been exhausted by payment of damages, judgments, settlements, and claim expenses.
2. A member is obligated to pay its deductible.
2017 Public Officials Liability Coverage Document RAF: 11/28/2016
3 Washington State Transit Insurance Pool
Section 2. Exclusions
This coverage does not apply to a loss:
A. Arising out of any wrongful act(s) that take(s) place prior to the earlier of the inception date or
retroactive date(s) of this coverage document.
B. Which represents cost, civil fine, penalty or expense levied or imposed from any complaint or
enforcement action by any federal, state or local governmental regulatory agency.
C. Arising out of obligations under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA),
including subsequent amendments or any similar federal, state or local law or regulation.
D. Arising out of condemnation, inverse condemnation, adverse possession, dedication by adverse use,
or disputes involving the application of impact or linkage fees. This includes but it not limited to,
takings and partial takings of private property resulting from the application of a land use, zoning,
building, subdivision or similar laws or regulations.
E. Arising out of or attributable to the member or additional covered party obtaining profit, advantage
or remuneration to which the member or additional covered party is not entitled; Provided, an
adverse fact or finding attributable to a member or additional covered party shall not be imputed to
any other member or additional covered party.
F. Arising out of bodily injury, property damage, personal injury, or advertising injury. This
exclusion does not apply to loss by an employee, former employee, or prospective employee or by
the spouse or child thereof resulting from:
1. refusal to employ;
2. termination of employment; or
3. coercion, demotion, evaluation, reassignment, discipline, defamation, harassment, humiliation,
discrimination or other employment-related practices or policies.
G. Brought about or contributed to by fraud, dishonesty, or bad faith or arising from the deliberate
violation of any federal, state, or local statute, ordinance, rule, or regulation; Provided, an adverse fact or finding attributable to a member or additional covered party shall not be imputed to any other
member or additional covered party.
H. Arising out of directly or indirectly, debt security financing, including but not limited to bonds, notes
and debentures.
I. Arising out of the actual, alleged or threatened discharge, dispersal, seepage, migration, release or
escape of pollutants at any time.
J. Arising out of, resulting from, caused or contributed to by asbestos, lead, or mold or exposure to
asbestos, lead, or mold, or for the costs of abatement, mitigation, removal or disposal of asbestos,
lead or mold.
2017 Public Officials Liability Coverage Document RAF: 11/28/2016
4 Washington State Transit Insurance Pool
K. Arising from breach of contract.
L. Arising out of the destruction or disappearance of money, securities or the loss of use thereof.
M. Arising out of or contributed to by your failing to place or maintain any insurance, bond, or self-
insurance.
N. Arising out of rendering or failure to render professional services.
O. By reason of the assumption of liability in a contract or agreement. This exclusion does not apply to
loss that you would have in the absence of the contract or agreement.
P. Arising out of:
1. any tax assessments or adjustments;
2. the collection, refund, disbursement, or application of any taxes; or
3. failure to anticipate tax revenue shortfalls.
Q. Arising out of demands or actions seeking relief or redress in any form other than monetary damages,
for any fees, costs or expenses which you may become obligated to pay as a result of any adverse
judgment for declaratory relief or injunctive relief, or for punitive or exemplary damages.
R. Bodily injury or property damage due to war (declared or not) or any act or condition incident to
war. War includes civil war, insurrection, rebellion, revolution, or terrorist activity.
S. Liability arising out of the hazardous properties of nuclear material.
Section 3. Who is covered?
The coverage afforded by this Coverage Document applies to:
A. The member identified in the Coverage Declarations.
B. Each of the following are additional covered parties while acting within the scope of his, her, or its
duties on behalf of member:
1. elected, appointed, and employed officials;
2. current or former members of commissions, boards, or other units operated by you;
3. your current or former employees;
4. all persons who perform a service on a volunteer basis for you, provided such performance is
under your direction and control. This does not include any person or entity working on retainer
or as an independent contractor;
5. all persons or organizations providing service to you under any mutual aid or similar agreement;
and
6. the estate of any person or entity described in this subsection, provided any claim is first made
within one year of that person’s death.
2017 Public Officials Liability Coverage Document RAF: 11/28/2016
5 Washington State Transit Insurance Pool
C. The Pool and its employees while acting within the scope of his, her, or its official duties.
Section 4. Limits of Coverage
A. The most we will pay for all loss arising from a wrongful act during any coverage period is the limits
of liability as shown in the Declarations.
B. The limits of liability as set forth above is the most we will pay regardless of the number of covered
persons or the number of suits or claims.
C. If the wrongful act(s) originated in a coverage period prior to this coverage document, the wrongful
act(s) shall be deemed to be covered solely by the limits provided by the Pool’s earlier coverage
document.
D. We will not cover any matter for which there is coverage for member or additional covered party
under the Liability Coverage Document issued by Pool to member.
Section 5. Conditions
A. Duties in event of wrongful act, claim, or suit:
1. if a wrongful act occurs which you believe may result in a claim, you must notify us in writing
immediately. Such notice should include how, when, and where the wrongful act occurred and
the names and addresses of the people involved;
2. if you receive a claim or suit which may involve coverage under this Coverage Document, you
must record the time and date on which you received the claim or suit and immediately provide a
copy of all documents received to us; and
3. in connection with any claim or suit you must:
a. authorize us to obtain records or other information; and b. cooperate with us in the investigation, settlement, or trial of any claim or suit.
B. Subrogation
1. When we have paid a loss on your behalf, you must transfer to us your rights to recover
payments for that loss from others; and
2. You must cooperate with us in all proceedings to recover payments from others we have made
on your behalf.
3. You may waive subrogation but only prior to any claim or suit.
C. Legal action against us
No person or entity may:
1. join us as a party in a suit seeking damages from a covered party; or
2017 Public Officials Liability Coverage Document RAF: 11/28/2016
6 Washington State Transit Insurance Pool
2. sue us regarding coverage under this Coverage Document unless all terms and conditions have
been fulfilled.
D. Other insurance
If there is other valid and collectible coverage or insurance for a loss covered by this Coverage
Document, our coverage shall be excess.
E. No assignment.
Your rights and duties under this Coverage Document may not be assigned or transferred without our
consent.
Section 6. Extended reporting period
A. If this coverage is canceled or not renewed, we will provide a basic extended reporting period without
additional charge or, at your option, a supplementary extended reporting period for an additional
charge. An extended reporting period does not change the scope of coverage or extend the
coverage period. It only extends the reporting period to report a claim to us.
B. The basic extended reporting period starts with the termination of coverage and lasts for sixty days.
The basic extended reporting period does not apply to claims that are covered under any subsequent
coverage or insurance you purchase, or that would be covered but for the exhaustion of the amount
of coverage or insurance applicable to such claims.
C. Supplementary extended reporting period
1. a supplemental extended reporting period of one year duration is available but only by an
endorsement;
2. this supplemental period starts when the basic extended reporting period ends;
3. you must give us a written request for the endorsement within 60 days after the end of the
coverage period. The supplemental extended reporting period will not go into effect unless you
pay the additional contribution promptly when due;
4. the additional contribution shall be twenty-five percent of the member’s annual contribution for
public officials’ liability coverage; and
5. the coverage afforded through the supplementary extended reporting period shall be excess over
any other valid and collectible coverage or insurance.
Section 7. Definitions
The following terms are defined as follows:
A. Additional covered parties are those persons or entities set forth in Section 3B.
B. Advertising injury means injury arising out of one or more of the following offenses committed in the
course of advertising your goods, products, or services:
2017 Public Officials Liability Coverage Document RAF: 11/28/2016
7 Washington State Transit Insurance Pool
1. oral or written publication of material that slanders or libels a person or organization or disparages
a person’s or organization’s goods, products, or services;
2. oral or written publication of material that violates a person’s right of privacy;
3. misappropriation of advertising ideas or style of doing business; or
4. infringement of copyright, title or slogan.
C. Bodily injury means physical injury, mental injury, shock, sickness, or disease sustained by a
person, including death, resulting from any of these at any time.
D. Claim means written notice from any person or entity that it is his, her or its intention to hold member
or additional covered party responsible for damages arising out of a wrongful act.
E. Claim expenses means:
1. claim investigations costs;
2. legal expenses; and
3. litigation costs, pre- and post-judgment interest on awards and judgments, and the cost of bonds
to release attachments or to appeal.
Claim expenses do not include salaries and expenses of employees of member, overhead, or any
fees paid for claim administration.
F. Loss means the amount (less the deductible or retention) the member or additional covered party
becomes legally obligated to pay as damages, judgments, settlements, including claim expenses for
any wrongful acts.
G. Member means a Washington State public transit entity that participated in the formation of the Pool
or has been approved for membership in the Pool.
H. Offense means any of the offenses included in the definitions of advertising injury or personal
injury.
I. Personal injury means injury arising out of one or more of the following offenses
1. false arrest, detention, or imprisonment;
2. malicious prosecution;
3. defamation;
4. the wrongful eviction from, wrongful entry into, or invasion of the right of private occupancy of a
room, dwelling, or premises that a person occupies;
5. oral or written publication of material that slanders or libels a person or organization or disparages
a person’s or organization’s goods, products, or services; or
6. oral or written publication of material that violates a person’s right of privacy;
7. assault and battery not committed by, at the direction, or with consent of member; or
8. discrimination prohibited by state or federal law including discrimination based upon race,
religion, nationality, national origin, color , creed, sex, sexual preference, age employment, or
disability.
2017 Public Officials Liability Coverage Document RAF: 11/28/2016
8 Washington State Transit Insurance Pool
I. Pollutants means any solid, liquid, gaseous or thermal irritant or contaminant, including smoke, vapor,
soot, fumes, acids, alkalis, chemicals, and waste. Waste includes materials to be recycled,
reconditioned, or reclaimed.
J. Professional services means:
1. the practice of medicine, such as (but not limited to) physician, surgeon, osteopath, chiropractor,
anesthesiologist, dentist, psychiatrist, psychologist, nurse, paramedic, emergency medical
technician, or pharmacist; or
2. services by architects, engineers, surveyors, or draftsmen.
K. Property damage means physical injury to tangible property, including all resulting loss of use of that
property.
L. Suit means a civil proceeding which seeks damages arising out of a wrongful act. Suit includes:
1. an arbitration proceeding in which such damages are claimed and to which you must submit or do
submit with our consent; or
2. any other alternative dispute resolution proceeding in which such damages are claimed and to
which you submit with our consent.
M. Wrongful act means:
1. any actual or alleged error, misstatement, or misleading statement, or any act, omission, or
neglect including malfeasance, misfeasance, and nonfeasance by member or additional
covered party rendered in the discharge of his or her duties for you; and
2. any actual or alleged wrongful termination, discipline, or discrimination related to hiring or
employment.
November 22, 2016 TO: WSTIP Board of Directors FROM: Tracey Christianson, Deputy Director SUBJECT: Reclassification of Staff Position and New Claims Manager Position Action Requested Staff seek approval on the following items:
1. Reclassification of the Information Technology Program Manager to the Administrative Services Manager as of December 16, 2016.
2. Elimination of the Information Technology Program Manager position. 3. New Claims Manager position for 2017
Position Reclassification Staff seek the approval of the Board for the reclassification of the Information Technology Program Manager to the Administrative Services Manager position. This reclassification changes over 50 percent of the job duties for the Information Technology Program Manager and adds supervisory duties of two existing employee positions. This eliminates the Information Technology Program Manager position. This reclassification places the position in a new salary scale. WSTIP seek this position be reclassified as of December 16, 2016. The increased cost of this position is already anticipated in the 2017 budget before the Board at this meeting. An overview of the job description is below. Excerpt from Administrative Services Manager Job Description
DESCRIPTION This position manages the Administrative Services Department which includes managing WSTIP’s information technology infrastructure and facilities, supervising finance and underwriting, and supporting members, internal WSTIP departments, and WSTA by providing project and records management and data analytics for the organization. The Administrative Services Manager supervises the following positions: Finance Specialist and Receptionist. The Administrative Services Manager serves as the Public Records Officer for the organization. ESSENTIAL JOB DUTIES
1. Develop, manage, and control the agency’s administrative services department including
budget development and accountability, service development and management, assess
staffing needs, coordinate work assignments, and staff supervision.
2. Support the Deputy Director to successfully manage and operate the Pool within its
Board adopted policies and state regulatory requirements.
3. Manage scope of financial operations including accounting, payroll, monthly and annual
reports, and reconciliations.
4. Manage the collection of underwriting information including, but not limited to property, vehicles, miles driven, and employee counts.
5. Manage WSTIP information technology infrastructure including the Risk Management
Information System (Origami), Voice over IP phone system, websites, Office 365 and other cloud services.
6. Manage and maintain the WSTIP facility including building services (janitorial, HVAC,
security system) including procurement and management of vendors for any services for the building in accordance with adopted policies on purchasing and procurement. Work with department managers, Deputy Director, Executive Director, and WSTA to determine office space needs related to staffing.
7. Manage purchasing activities, contract negotiation and vendor relationships for the
information technology infrastructure and facilities including technology hosting, office equipment acquisition, lease maintenance agreements and special purchases in accordance with adopted policies on purchasing and procurement.
8. Manage, monitor and control the operations, projects, systems upgrades, and activities of
the WSTIP information technology infrastructure to meet established WSTIP information technology operational guidelines and best practices, schedules and processes; while ensuring that all equipment is operated in the most efficient cost effective and reasonably secure manner possible.
9. Monitor the compliance of all hardware and software systems with established standards,
procedures, and WSTIP business practices including effective back up, disaster recovery, and contingency plans/procedures.
10. Recommend procedures, best practices and innovative solutions to improve efficiency in
data processing, data reporting and analytics, network and website operations. 11. Support the Claims Department by managing Medicare secondary payer mandatory
reporting requirements.
12. Manage electronic records archiving and disposition in compliance with Washington State retention schedules. Provides record retention consultation to Members and respond to public records requests. Serve as the Public Records Officer.
13. Supervise and develop assigned staff through periodic goals and objectives, training,
disciplinary actions, and performance reviews.
14. Support the users, desktop, network infrastructure and Office 365 implementation for the Washington State Transit Association (WSTA).
Claims Manager Staff request approval for a new Claims Manager position for 2017. WSTIP’s Claims Specialist is retiring
in May of 2017. Staff request approval to hire a Claims Manager position which will have supervisory duties over the claims department. If recruiting goes well, there will be some overlap between the Claims Specialist and the Claims Manager. However, we anticipate by mid-year the Claims Specialist will have proceeded to the retirement phase of her life. Unlike the reclassification (above), we are not seeking elimination of the Claims Specialist position. However, the position is not funded in 2017 budget beyond the retirement date of the current Claims Specialist. If staff feel this position needs to be re-filled, it will require either a budget amendment or new funding in a new budget year. The cost of this position is already anticipated in the 2017 budget before the Board at this meeting. An overview of the job description is below for your information: Except from Claims Manager Job Description
DESCRIPTION This position manages the Claims Department and is responsible for administering the various claims incurred by WSTIP members which include claims that can be described as general liability, auto liability, errors and omissions, property, crime, boiler and machinery. The Claims Manager manages internal and vendor-serviced claims and lawsuits and directs the litigation of complex cases. The Claims Manager supervises the Claims Department staff. ESSENTIAL JOB DUTIES
1. Oversee department operations including claim investigation, verification of damages,
subrogation services, claim denials, and claim payments. Assigns case values and monitors loss reserves for adequacy.
2. Evaluate claims, mange independent adjusters, hire experts, research, analyze scope of work estimates, and compile pertinent legal case laws, state laws, and city codes.
3. Provide coverage analysis and determination recommendations for the Executive Director.
4. Create litigation defense plans, collaborate strategies with attorneys. Direct defense counsel and claims adjusters.
5. Attend depositions, mediations, trials, and settlement conferences.
6. Manage the subrogation and restitution of claims.
7. Report claims activity to excess and reinsurance carriers.
8. Supervise and develop assigned staff through periodic goals and objectives, training disciplinary actions, and performance reviews.
9. Provide written and oral reports to management, Board, and committees.
10. Participate in Serious Loss review and work cooperatively with the Member Services and Administrative Services department.
Background on WSTIP Staff Numbers
Positions of December 1, 2016 Positions as of July 1, 2017
Executive Director Executive Director Deputy Director Deputy Director Claims Manager (vacant/funded) Claims Specialist Claims Specialist (until retirement and then
vacant/unfunded) Claims and Technology Assistant Claims and Technology Assistant Member Services Assistant Board Relations Information Systems Manager Administrative Services Manager Receptionist Receptionist Finance Specialist Finance Specialist Member Services Manager Member Services Manager Training and Risk Coordinator (vacant/funded) Training and Risk Coordinator Transit Risk Consultant Transit Risk Consultant Legal Counsel Legal Counsel 12 positions – 12 positions funded – 1 vacant 13 positions – 12 positions funded – 1 vacant
Page 1 of 14
2017 Proposed Budget
Overview, Narrative & Appendices
Page 2 of 14
Table of Contents
Budget Summary 3
Self-Insurance Retention, Insurance, Reinsurance and Excess Insurance 4
Department Budgets:
Administrative Services 6
Technical Services 7
Member Services 8
Board Expenses 9
What Isn’t in the Budget? 10
Driver Record Monitoring 11
Decisions the Board Makes When Adopting the Budget 13 The Strategic Plan and Rate Review 14
Appendix
Spreadsheets Crime Renewal Proposal
Page 3 of 14
Budget Summary
Exposures WSTIP uses employee counts, property values, vehicle values, and even payroll. The most important one, however, is mileage which is used to determine the liability rate and correspondingly, a member’s assessment. The estimated mileage for 2017 is just over 100 million miles. Here are the top three things you need to know about WSTIP’s exposures for 2017: Estimated mileage for 2017 is projected to increase only 1%. Total miles are 101,347,675. Employee counts have increased by 4%. The 2017 estimate is 5,032 employees. Total property values (including vehicles) increased to $821 million which is a 6% increase. Basically, exposures have increased but just slightly.
Loss Fund Staff is recommending an increase in the self-insurance retention from $2 million to $2.5 million. Our loss experience with GEM has deteriorated and GEM costs are increasing. By accepting more risk, the costs for reinsurance are stabilized. The 2017 loss fund, as determined by the actuary, is $8.2 million. An Overall Rate Increase of 10% Staff are proposing an overall rate increase of 10%. The Executive Committee reviewed this rate increase and agreed it was appropriate to send to the Board. This rate increase allows a sizeable investment to the loss fund (called an “increased contribution to surplus”). The increase contribution to surplus is a voluntary amount and is
in keeping with WSTIP’s long-term strategic goal. Liability Insurance Costs The cost for the GEM layer of insurance increased 10% despite the increase in our loss fund. Other insurance costs are relatively stable.
Page 4 of 14
Loss Fund, Self-Insurance Retention,
Insurance, Reinsurance & Excess Insurance
The coverages WSTIP offers is combination of self-insurance, insurance policies, reinsurance (through a captive and from the market) and excess insurance. Here are the most important things to know about WSTIP’s
coverages and their costs. WSTIP staff recommend increasing the self-insurance retention from $2 million to $2.5 million per occurrence. This is due to unfavorable rates for expiring coverage.
WSTIP Loss Fund
0 - $2.5 million
$8,242,546
Staff and broker are recommending renewing with the following carriers and pricing:
Carrier – Liability
Layer
Cost
Governmental Entities Mutual
$2.5 million in excess of $2.5 million
$773,759 (auto liability) $21,335 (liability other than auto) $795,294 Total
Munich Re
$5 million in excess of $5 million
$383,601
Arch
$5 million in excess of $15 million
$136,000
Page 5 of 14
Carrier – Crime
Layer
Cost
National Union Fire (see Appendix for Crime Proposal)
$1 million $10,000 deductible
$14,868
Carrier – Blanket Pollution
Layer
Cost
XL Insurance (Three year policy)
$1 million $10,000 deductible
$43,000 (already bound)
Carrier – UST
Cost
Liberty Surplus Insurance Corporation
$1 million per storage tank incident limit $3 million aggregate limit $250,000 aggregate expense limit $25,000 deductible except for Intercity $50,000 Intercity deductible
$16,995 (already bound)
Page 6 of 14
Department Budget: Administrative Services
Administrative Services
760 · CONTRACT SERVICES 232,435
700 · LEGAL AND ACCOUNTING 18,000
733 · STAFF CONFERENCES & TRAVEL 97,136
770 · COMMUNICATIONS 20,248
777 · OCCUPANCY COSTS 38,277
749 · OFFICE EXPENSES 59,968
802 · AUDITS 42,866
MISCELLANEOUS 2,000
Total Administrative Services 510,930
Administrative Services is a roll up of several budget categories.
Contract Services ($232,435) – Representing 45% of the Administrative Services budget. Contract services includes actuarial services, broker fees, and other administrative contracts such as occasional administrative help.
Staff Travel and Conferences ($97,136) – Includes expenses associated with member visits from the Transit Risk Consultant, professional development for staff (classes and conferences) and miscellaneous travel expenses.
Legal and Accounting ($18,000) – Although labeled as legal and accounting, this category only pays for our certified public accountant. The increased cost is in direct correlation to new reporting requirements from the state auditor.
Page 7 of 14
Department Budget: Technical Services
764 - INFORMATION SERVICES
Risk Management Information System 110,000
764 · Network Maintenance/Support 54,800
Subscription Software Services 30,850
Professional Services (IS) 51,600
New Projects 26,500
Total 764 - INFORMATION SERVICES 273,750
Origami ($110,000) – Origami, our Risk Management Information System (RMIS) accounts for 40% of
the Technical Services Budget. The 2017 cost is slightly increased from the contracted year two cost due
the licensing of additional users.
Network Infrastructure ($54,800) – In 2016 WSTIP transitioned several major services (RMIS and Web
sites) to hosted “cloud” services. WSTIP will continue this trend in 2017 with the retirement of our end of
lifecycle network hardware and a move to the Private Cloud Services provided by the State of
Washington (WaTech).
Professional Services ($51,600) – The professional services budget has increased from 2016 to provide
contracted desktop support for WSTIP and WSTA staff and Network Administration. These functions
were previously provided by the Information Technology Program Manager, which position has been
eliminated in 2017.
2017 Project Work ($26,500) – Technical Services project for 2017 include: a pilot program for Tableau,
a data visualization tool that will integrate with Origami and provide more advanced reporting functionality;
updates to the West Olympia phone system (Shoretel); and creating an interactive version of the Risk
Profiles using Origami Data.
Page 8 of 14
Department Budget:
Member Services / Risk Management Services
Three highlights from the Risk Management Services budget include the following:
Collision Avoidance Technology Project ($120,000) – WSTIP Board approved the Pierce Transit pilot
project utilizing after-market collision avoidance technology. This loss prevention campaign aims at
reducing at fault rear-end accidents and pedestrian strikes. The Emerging Risks and Opportunities
Committee have identified other loss and risk items for further research or review and inclusion in the
Executive Committee work plan.
Network Security ($85,000) - These funds will be utilized for the network security loss prevention
campaign. The backbone of this work is continuing the implementation of the “to do” items identified in
the Best Practices for the Technology Environment.
Grants, Awards and Sponsorships ($102,500) – The Risk Management Grants are $2500 annual
awards to each member; Safety Stars Program awards, $5,000 for large, $3,500 for medium, and $1,500
for small. Driver Recognition Award Program to recognize accident free driving. Above and Beyond
Award to honor individuals for courage that minimized losses to the agency or the public. Sponsorships
include statewide Roadeo, State-wide Conferences, and Trainer’s Showcase.
740 - RISK MANAGEMENT SERVICES 2017
Contract Services 31,000
Vanpool Refresher Program 5,200
Best Practices/Risk Mgmt Scvs 35,000
Network Security 85,000
Loss Prevention Projects 155,000
Pre-Litigation Fund 55,000
Grants/Training 102,500
Training Coalition 40,000
Total 740 · RISK MANAGEMENT SERVICES 508,700
Page 9 of 14
Department Budget: Board Expenses
730 · BOARD EXPENSES
731 · Conference/Travel - WSTIP Board 100,000
Jeff Ristau Scholarship 20,000
Board Development 10,000
732 · Board Meeting Expenses 65,109
Total 730 - BOARD EXPENSES 195,109
The Board expense budget pays for travel-related expenses of the Board members to attend quarterly Board meetings, and the Executive Committee members to attend their monthly meetings.
Highlights of this area include:
Conferences/travel for the Board meetings ($100,00) – This pays for the expenses of Board members and guests to attend the quarterly Board meetings, and Executive Committee members to attend their monthly meetings. Electronic device grants and reimbursement for devices is included in this budget.
Jeffrey S. Ristau Scholarship ($20,000) – 2017 will be the third year for the Jeffrey S. Ristau Scholarship program. Funding is established at $20,000.
Board Development ($10,000) – Speaker, facilitator, and consulting fees.
Board meeting expenses ($65,109) – Hotel costs for quarterly Board meetings.
Page 10 of 14
What Isn’t in the Budget?
Building Remodel
With the transition of much of our technical services “to the cloud,” there is no longer a need for a dedicated
server room at the West Olympia location. WSTIP is working with Alona Pernula of Pernula Design on plans to remodel and recover the space currently occupied by the server room for staff workstations. This work will be funded from the Building Reserve Fund. You might notice, however, that we have added a new category to the budget called “furniture.” Furniture for the space is anticipated in the 2017 budget.
Driver Record Monitoring
Driver record monitoring costs are accounted for basically as a secondary business. The WSTIP Board approved driver record monitoring rates increases on an annual basis to recoup the costs incurred in the last contract (costs for the vendor to take over the DOL pull). Additional money will also be collected to fund a review of the vendor for contract compliance. This is the first year of collecting funds, however, it was the Board’s direction that once a positive balance was realized, the funds should be kept in a separate reserve account. The member costs for driver record monitoring follows on the pages 11 and 12.
Risk Pool Staff Leadership Development Program
WSTIP entered into a memorandum of understanding with other risk pools in Washington to fund and manage a Risk Pool Staff Leadership Development Program. WSTIP volunteered to manage the finances of the development program. Upon conferring with the state auditor, staff were told to keep these funds separated from the rest of the pool’s finances.
Page 11 of 14
Driver Record Monitoring
2016 Adjustments (actual vs estimate)
Page 12 of 14
Driver Record Monitoring
2017 Budget (with 2016 Adjustments)
Page 13 of 14
When the Board Adopts the Budget,
What Decisions Does the Staff Think You Have Made?
Approval of an overall budget number.
Approval of a per mile rate increase of 10%.
Approval of a contribution of surplus.
Permission to bind all coverages.
Approval of a new Claims Manager position.
Reclassification of an existing position.
Approval of a general wage increase to staff of 3%.
Funding for the Jeffrey S. Ristau Scholarship Program ($20,000).
Page 14 of 14
The Strategic Plan and Rate Review
The WSTIP Strategic Plan established a goal of no greater than a 5% rate increase over the previous year for liability. Staff are proposing an overall increase of 10%. The 2016 auto liability rate was $.0955 (per mile) in 2016. The proposed auto liability rate for 2017 is $.1076 (per mile). This is an increase of 12.6%. The 2016 general liability rate was $286.49 (per employee) in 2016. The proposed general liability rate for 2017 is $267.22 (per employee). This is a decrease of 6.7%. The 2016 property rate (not including vehicles) was .1938 (per $100 in value) in 2016. The proposed property rate (not including vehicles) for 2017 is .1699 which is a 12.3% decrease. The 2016 property vehicle value rate was .2929 per $100 in value. The proposed rate is .3377 (per $100 of value). This is a 15% increase. The under/uninsured motorist coverage rate (non-vanpool) in 2016 was .0060. The proposed rate for 2017 is .0006. There is no increase or decrease. The under/uninsured motorist coverage rate (vanpool) rate in 2016 was .0075. The proposed rate is .0075.
2017 Estimated Insurance Costs and Operating Budget
12/01/2016
2017 2017 2016 2016Revenues Expenses Actuarial Exhibit 8-1 Revenues Expenses Actuarial Exhibit 8-1
14,578,843 8,242,546 2017 Loss Fund - actuarially determined 12,864,133 7,244,972 2016 Loss Fund - actuarially determined2,119,968 Estimated insurance costs 2,022,764 Estimated excess insurance costs2,970,242 Estimated operating costs 2,682,000 Estimated operating costs-350,000 Estimated Interest Income -350,000 Estimated Interest Income-430,590 UIM Cost of APD -455,641 UIM Cost of APD
2,011,892 Estimated contribution to surplus 1,448,412 Estimated contribution to surplus14,564,058 Subtotal 12,592,507 Subtotal 15.66%
14,241,500Minus adjustments for 1st party deductibles Exhibit 8-2 (see below) 12,213,160
Minus adjustments for 1st party deductibles Exhibit 8-2
369,047 Exhibit 8-5 components (see below a18-a22) 375,139 Exhibit 8-5 components (see below)-31,704 Prior period adjustments Exhibit 8-5 Column 19 -179,807 Prior period adjustments
14,578,843 Subtotal 12,408,492 Subtotal
Exhibit 8-5 Exhibit 8-5430,590 UIM 455,641 UIM67,882 UST Coverage (10 members) 67,682 UST Coverage (10 members)43,000 Pollution Coverage (18 members) 43,000 Pollution Coverage (18 members)
241,170 Driver Record Monitoring (All) 248,066 Driver Record Monitoring (All)16,995 Crime Coverage (22 members) 16,391 Crime Coverage (22 members)
369,047 Total 375,139 Total
Exhibit 8-2502,427 (1) APD Ultimate Loss Net of Deductible872,039 (2) APD Ultimate Loss Gross of Deductible136,844 (4) Property Ultimate Loss Net of Deductible183,898 (6) Property Ultimate Loss Gross of Deductible
14,564,0580
2017 Estimated Insurance Costs and Operating Budget
12/01/2016
Budget Budget Num % Change
2017 2016 Change 2017 to 2016
610 - INSURANCE SERVICES
611 · GEM Coverage 795,294 724,111 71,183 10%
$10 Mill X $5 Mill Excess Coverage 383,601 381,000 2,601 1%
$5 Mill X $15 Million Exces Coverage 137,000 137,000 0 0%
622 · Property & APD 804,073 780,653 23,420 3%
Blanket Pollution 43,000 43,000 0 0%
Underground Storage Tank Cov 67,882 67,682 200 0%
624 · Crime and Fidelity 16,995 16,500 495 3%
Total 610 · INSURANCE SERVICES 2,247,845 2,149,946 97,899 5%
760 · CONTRACT SERVICES
702 · Actuary 74,675 72,500 2,175 3%
762 · Administrative services 27,810 27,000 810 3%
Rack Space at DES 0 10,800 (10,800) -100% dBroker Fee 101,200 101,200 0 0%
Contract Services 28,750 25,000 3,750 15%
Total 760 · CONTRACT SERVICES 232,435 236,500 (4,065) -2%
720 · STAFF WAGES, TAXES & BENEFITS
Staff Benefits 291,300 242,674 48,626 20%
720.1 · Wages 1,093,132 1,002,086 91,046 9%
720.1.1 · Retirement Trust ICMA 68,098 61,430 6,668 11%
725 · Payroll Taxes 29,223 28,012 1,211 4%
Total 720 · STAFF WAGES, TAXES & BENEFITS 1,481,753 1,334,202 147,551 11%
700 · LEGAL AND ACCOUNTING
703 · Accounting 18,000 15,018 2,982 20%
Total 700 - LEGAL & ACCOUNTING 18,000 15,018 2,982 20%
2017 Estimated Insurance Costs and Operating Budget
12/01/2016
Budget Budget Num % Change
2017 2016 Change 2017 to 2016
730 · BOARD EXPENSES
731 · Conference/Travel - WSTIP Board 100,000 85,000 15,000 18%
Jeff Ristau Scholarship 20,000 20,000 0 0%
Board Development Speaker 10,000 10,000 0 0%
732 · Board Meeting Expenses 65,109 59,190 5,919 10%
Total 730 - BOARD EXPENSES 195,109 174,190 20,919 12%
733 · STAFF CONFERENCES & TRAVEL
Staff Travel 77,136 70,124 7,012 10%
Staff Registration and Education Materials 20,000 10,451 9,549 91%
Total 733 · STAFF CONFERENCES & TRAVEL 97,136 80,575 16,561 21%
740 - RISK MANAGEMENT SERVICES
Contract Services 31,000 31,000 0 0%
Vanpool Refresher Program 5,200 7,000 (1,800) -26%
Best Practices/Risk Mgmt Scvs 35,000 35,000 0 0%
Network Security 85,000 125,000 (40,000) -32%
Loss Prevention Projects 155,000 77,000 78,000 101% aPre-Litigation Fund 55,000 55,000 0 0%
Grants/Training 102,500 90,000 12,500 14%
Training Coalition 40,000 40,000 0 0%
Total 740 · RISK MANAGEMENT SERVICES 508,700 460,000 48,700 11%
770 · COMMUNICATIONS
772 · Telephone 15,277 14,832 445 3%
771 · Internet Access 4,971 4,826 145 3%
Total 770 · COMMUNICATIONS 20,248 19,658 590 3%
2017 Estimated Insurance Costs and Operating Budget
12/01/2016
Budget Budget Num % Change
2017 2016 Change 2017 to 2016
777 · OCCUPANCY COSTS
Office Maintenance/Repairs 12,000 12,000 0 0%
773 · Utilities 15,277 14,832 445 3%
758 · Janitorial Services 5,000 5,000 0 0%
774 · Office Equipment Lease 6,000 6,000 0 0%
Total 777 · OCCUPANCY COSTS 38,277 37,832 445 1%
749 · OFFICE EXPENSES
Office Furniture 15,000 - new category
752 · Dues and Subscriptions 10,637 10,327 310 3%
757 · Office Supplies 3,302 3,206 96 3%
754 · Postage 11,785 13,094 (1,309) -10%
753 · Printing & Graphic Services 19,245 18,684 561 3%
Total 749 · OFFICE EXPENSES 59,968 45,311 14,657 32%
802 · AUDITS
Annual Audit 11,092 10,769 323 3%
803 · St. R/M Audit and Assessment 16,774 16,774 0 0%
805 · Property/ Claims/AGRIP Audits 15,000 15,000 0 0%
Total 802 · AUAnnual Audit 42,866 42,543 323 1%
764 - INFORMATION SERVICES
Risk Management Information System 110,000 0 110,000 new category b764 · Network Maintenance/Support 54,800 51,854 2,946 6%
Subscription Software Services 30,850 138,100 (107,250) -78%
Professional Services (IS) 51,600 0 51,600 new category cWeb Presence Update 0 25,000 (25,000) -100%
Upgrades/replacements 0 19,000 (19,000) -100%
New Projects 26,500 0 26,500 new category dTotal 764 - INFORMATION SERVICES 273,750 233,954 39,796 17%
2017 Estimated Insurance Costs and Operating Budget
12/01/2016
Budget Budget Num % Change
2017 2016 Change 2017 to 2016
MISCELLANEOUS 2,000 2,000 0 0%
Total MISCELLANEOUS 2,000 2,000 0 0%
759 · DEPRECIATION 21,600 21,600 0 0%
Total Expense (without insurance) 2,991,842 2,681,783 310,059 12%
Total Expense (with insurance) 5,239,687 4,831,729 407,958 8%
Notes:
b: Risk Management Information System is a new category, previously this expense was part of Subscription Softwarec: Increase in Information Services "Professional Services" due to contracted desktop support services.
a: $100,000 for Pierce Collision Avoidance Grant; additional $20k for forensic accounting audit to determine affect on loss exposure
d: $10,800 "Rack Space at DES" previously part of Contract Services; now part of Information Services, "Network Maitenance/Support"
2017 Estimated Insurance Costs and Operating Budget
12/01/2016
Member UIM Selections2017 Est'd
Mileage
2017 EE
Data2016 Actual
Mileage
% Mileage Change
2016 EE
Data% EE
ChangeASOTIN All of the Above 359,368 16 335,650 7% 15 7%BEN FRANKLIN All of the Above 9,265,000 279 9,324,527 -1% 276 1%CLALLAM All of the Above 2,283,000 91 2,294,174 0% 90 1%COLUMBIA COUNTY Demand Response & Vanpool 333,000 14 367,000 -9% 14 0%COMMUNITY Vanpool 14,770,587 751 14,603,392 1% 676 11%C-TRAN Vanpool 7,973,000 440 7,342,000 9% 426 3%EVERETT All of the Above 2,159,851 154 2,111,884 2% 153 1%GRANT All of the Above 1,362,400 44 1,292,400 5% 37 19%GRAYS HARBOR All of the Above 1,705,000 80 1,688,000 1% 75 7%INTERCITY All of the Above 7,960,000 315 7,919,000 1% 315 0%ISLAND All of the Above 2,762,157 111 3,236,355 -15% 113 -2%JEFFERSON All of the Above 790,000 46 810,000 -2% 46 0%KITSAP All of the Above 5,406,000 375 5,387,000 0% 375 0%LINK Fixed Route & Demand Response 2,115,000 130 2,210,000 -4% 130 0%MASON All of the Above 1,460,848 90 1,334,083 10% 89 1%PACIFIC Fixed Route & Demand Response 454,800 22 460,000 -1% 21 5%PIERCE Vanpool 20,444,852 956 19,916,896 3% 911 5%PULLMAN Fixed Route & Demand Response 416,800 45 455,000 -8% 45 0%RIVER CITIES All of the Above 667,000 33 752,000 -11% 33 0%SKAGIT All of the Above 2,997,036 135 3,012,390 -1% 129 5%SPOKANE Vanpool 9,198,168 543 8,951,825 3% 533 2%TWIN Fixed Route & Demand Response 363,854 28 430,012 -15% 28 0%VALLEY All of the Above 615,000 27 637,000 -3% 26 4%WHATCOM All of the Above 4,112,300 246 3,836,900 7% 228 8%YAKIMA All of the Above 1,372,654 61 1,639,000 -16% 60 2%
TOTAL 101,347,675 5,032 100,346,488 1% 4844 4%
2017 Estimated Insurance Costs and Operating Budget
12/01/2016
Member
2017 Vehicle Values
2017 Property Values
2016 Vehicle Values
2016 Property Values
Veh % Change
Prop % Change
APD Deductible
ASOTIN 406,997 1,541,433 721,200 1,474,800 -44% 5% $5,000BEN FRANKLIN 18,072,534 19,239,969 17,562,100 16,067,800 3% 20% $5,000CLALLAM 6,582,143 17,832,480 7,791,200 17,227,600 -16% 4% $5,000COLUMBIA COUNTY 325,128 124,858 465,800 124,400 -30% 0% $5,000COMMUNITY 76,869,656 73,644,006 58,655,900 75,279,900 31% -2% $5,000C-TRAN 26,010,803 20,591,675 15,976,700 16,574,300 63% 24% $10,000EVERETT NA NA NA NA NA NA $0GRANT 1,880,006 4,827,178 2,468,000 4,557,600 -24% 6% $5,000GRAYS HARBOR 4,008,507 6,828,497 2,794,900 7,389,300 43% -8% $5,000INTERCITY 21,887,629 20,198,656 25,742,200 18,814,400 -15% 7% $5,000ISLAND 4,350,843 19,676,307 6,190,500 15,777,300 -30% 25% $5,000JEFFERSON 1,813,202 7,719,845 2,339,500 8,276,700 -22% -7% $5,000KITSAP 7,320,953 34,060,670 10,745,600 35,941,100 -32% -5% $5,000LINK 5,259,111 18,457,808 6,876,900 16,876,400 -24% 9% $5,000MASON 3,390,822 17,299,592 3,739,000 15,484,900 -9% 12% $5,000PACIFIC 1,582,082 3,401,636 1,877,300 2,694,400 -16% 26% $5,000PIERCE 66,787,692 106,087,001 73,762,100 109,827,800 -9% -3% $25,000PULLMAN NA NA NA NA NA NA $0RIVER CITIES 3,473,651 517,955 3,975,000 513,700 -13% 1% $5,000SKAGIT 6,412,884 22,692,669 7,048,100 17,077,800 -9% 33% $5,000SPOKANE 30,190,572 82,188,850 36,152,900 71,585,500 -16% 15% $25,000TWIN 1,228,154 3,339,042 1,653,800 1,831,500 -26% 82% $5,000VALLEY 2,435,903 7,012,587 2,678,100 7,835,000 -9% -10% $5,000WHATCOM 16,257,512 20,118,583 19,139,100 19,325,200 -15% 4% $5,000YAKIMA 6,735,266 NA 4,871,200 NA NA NA $5,000
TOTAL 313,282,050 507,401,297 313,227,100 480,557,400 0% 6%
Government Crime Insurance Proposal 2017 – 2018
Presented on November 21, 2016 by: Brian White Vice President
Joyce Roberts Assistant Account Manager Lilian Vanvieldt Senior Vice President
Washington State Transit Insurance Pool
Alliant Insurance Services, Inc.
1420 Fifth Avenue, Suite 1500
Seattle, WA 98101
O 206 204 9140
F 206 204 9205
CA License No. 0C36861
www.alliant.com
Date Issued: 11/07/16 Alliant Insurance Services, Inc. | www.alliant.com | CA License No. 0C36861 Page 2
Washington State Transit Insurance Pool | 2017 - 2018 Government Crime Insurance Proposal
Government Crime Coverage
Present Coverage Proposed Coverage
INSURANCE COMPANY: National Union Fire Ins. Co. of Pittsburgh, PA National Union Fire Ins. Co. of Pittsburgh, PA
A.M. BEST RATING: A (Excellent), Financial Size Category: XV ($2 Billion or greater) as of February 27, 2015
A (Excellent), Financial Size Category: XV ($2 Billion or greater) as of June 2, 2016
STANDARD & POOR’S RATING: A+ (Strong) A+ (Strong) as of May 06, 2013
POLICY TERM: January 1, 2016 to January 1, 2017 January 1, 2017 to January 1, 2018
COVERAGE FORM: Discovery Form – CR 00 26 05 06 Discovery Form – CR 00 26 05 06
LIMITS: $1,000,000 Employee Theft – Per Loss Coverage $1,000,000 Employee Theft – Per Loss Coverage
Not Covered Employee Theft – Per Employee Coverage Not Covered Employee Theft – Per Employee Coverage
$1,000,000 Forgery or Alteration $1,000,000 Forgery or Alteration
$1,000,000 Inside the Premises – Theft of Money and Securities
$1,000,000 Inside the Premises – Theft of Money and Securities
$1,000,000 Inside the Premises – Robbery or Safe Burglary of Other Property
$1,000,000 Inside the Premises – Robbery or Safe Burglary of Other Property
$1,000,000 Outside the Premises $1,000,000 Outside the Premises
$1,000,000 Computer Fraud $1,000,000 Computer Fraud
$1,000,000 Funds Transfer Fraud $1,000,000 Funds Transfer Fraud
$1,000,000 Money Orders and Counterfeit Money $1,000,000 Money Orders and Counterfeit Money
DEDUCTIBLE: $ 10,000 Per Occurrence $ 10,000 Per Occurrence
ENDORSEMENT & EXCLUSIONS: (INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED T0)
• Washington Changes • Additional Named Insured – Per submission • Add Faithful Performance of Duty Coverage for
Government Employees – $1,000,000/Per Loss • Protected Information Exclusion
• Washington Changes • Additional Named Insured – Per submission • Add Faithful Performance of Duty Coverage for
Government Employees – $1,000,000/Per Loss • Protected Information Exclusion
Date Issued: 11/07/16 Alliant Insurance Services, Inc. | www.alliant.com | CA License No. 0C36861 Page 3
Washington State Transit Insurance Pool | 2017 - 2018 Government Crime Insurance Proposal
Present Coverage Proposed Coverage
ENDORSEMENTS & EXCLUSIONS (continued):
• Include Designated Person Required to Have Knowledge of Loss (Discovery Form) – Risk Management Department or other department designated to handle insurance matters for the named insured
• Indirect or Consequential Loss Exclusion • Prior Theft or Dishonesty – $10,000 • Economic Sanctions Endorsement • Cancellation of Policy Amended – 90 days • Bonded Employees Exclusion Deleted • Add Credit, Debit or Charge Card Forgery -
$1,000,000/Includes • Include Volunteer Workers as Employees • Include Specified Non-Compensated Officers as
Employees – All • Include Chairperson and Members of Specified
Committees as Employees – All • Include Designated Persons or Classes of Persons
as Employees – Any directors or trustees of any of those named as insured
• Include Treasurers or Tax Collectors as Employees – All
• Include Expenses Incurred to Establish Amount of Covered Loss - $75,000/100%
• Include Designated Person Required to Have Knowledge of Loss (Discovery Form) – Risk Management Department or other department designated to handle insurance matters for the named insured
• Indirect or Consequential Loss Exclusion • Prior Theft or Dishonesty – $10,000 • Economic Sanctions Endorsement • Cancellation of Policy Amended – 90 days • Bonded Employees Exclusion Deleted • Add Credit, Debit or Charge Card Forgery -
$1,000,000/Includes • Include Volunteer Workers as Employees • Include Specified Non-Compensated Officers as
Employees – All • Include Chairperson and Members of Specified
Committees as Employees – All • Include Designated Persons or Classes of Persons
as Employees – Any directors or trustees of any of those named as insured
• Include Treasurers or Tax Collectors as Employees – All
• Include Expenses Incurred to Establish Amount of Covered Loss - $75,000/100%
PREMIUM: $17,492.00 Annual Premium ($2,623.90) Commission Credit $14,868.20 Net Annual Cost
$17,582.00 Annual Premium ($2,637.30) Commission Credit $14,944.70 Net Annual Cost
QUOTE VALID UNTIL: N/A January 1, 2017
BINDING CONDITIONS: N/A Written Request to Bind
See Disclaimer Page for Important Notices and Acknowledgment
Date Issued: 11/07/16 Alliant Insurance Services, Inc. | www.alliant.com | CA License No. 0C36861 Page 4
Washington State Transit Insurance Pool | 2017 - 2018 Government Crime Insurance Proposal
Disclosures
This proposal of insurance is provided as a matter of convenience and information only. All information included in this proposal, including but not limited to personal and real property values, locations, operations, products, data, automobile schedules, financial data and loss experience, is based on facts and representations supplied to Alliant Insurance Services, Inc. by you. This proposal does not reflect any independent study or investigation by Alliant Insurance Services, Inc. or its agents and employees. Please be advised that this proposal is also expressly conditioned on there being no material change in the risk between the date of this proposal and the inception date of the proposed policy (including the occurrence of any claim or notice of circumstances that may give rise to a claim under any policy which the policy being proposed is a renewal or replacement). In the event of such change of risk, the insurer may, at its sole discretion, modify, or withdraw this proposal, whether or not this offer has already been accepted.
This proposal is not confirmation of insurance and does not add to, extend, amend, change, or alter any coverage in any actual policy of insurance you may have. All existing policy terms, conditions, exclusions, and limitations apply. For specific information regarding your insurance coverage, please refer to the policy itself. Alliant Insurance Services, Inc. will not be liable for any claims arising from or related to information included in or omitted from this proposal of insurance.
Alliant embraces a policy of transparency with respect to its compensation from insurance transactions. Details on our compensation policy, including the types of income that Alliant may earn on a placement, are available on our website at www.alliant.com. For a copy of our policy or for any inquiries regarding compensation issues pertaining to your account you may also contact us at: Alliant Insurance Services, Inc., Attention: General Counsel, 701 B Street, 6th Floor, San Diego, CA 92101.
Analyzing insurers' over-all performance and financial strength is a task that requires specialized skills and in-depth technical understanding of all aspects of insurance company finances and operations. Insurance brokerages such as Alliant Insurance typically rely upon rating agencies for this type of market analysis. Both A.M. Best and Standard and Poor's have been industry leaders in this area for many decades, utilizing a combination of quantitative and qualitative analysis of the information available in formulating their ratings.
A.M. Best has an extensive database of nearly 6,000 Life/Health, Property Casualty and International companies. You can visit them at www.ambest.com. For additional information regarding insurer financial strength ratings visit Standard and Poor's website at www.standardandpoors.com.
A.M. Best has an extensive database of nearly 6,000 Life/Health, Property Casualty and International companies. You can visit them at www.ambest.com. For additional information regarding insurer financial strength ratings visit Standard and Poor's website at www.standardandpoors.com.
Date Issued: 11/07/16 Alliant Insurance Services, Inc. | www.alliant.com | CA License No. 0C36861 Page 5
Washington State Transit Insurance Pool | 2017 - 2018 Government Crime Insurance Proposal
NY Regulation 194
Alliant Insurance Services, Inc. is an insurance producer licensed by the State of New York. Insurance producers are authorized by their license to confer with insurance purchasers about the benefits, terms and conditions of insurance contracts; to offer advice concerning the substantive benefits of particular insurance contracts; to sell insurance; and to obtain insurance for purchasers. The role of the producer in any particular transaction typically involves one or more of these activities.
Compensation will be paid to the producer, based on the insurance contract the producer sells. Depending on the insurer(s) and insurance contract(s) the purchaser selects, compensation will be paid by the insurer(s) selling the insurance contract or by another third party. Such compensation may vary depending on a number of factors, including the insurance contract(s) and the insurer(s) the purchaser selects. In some cases, other factors such as the volume of business a producer provides to an insurer or the profitability of insurance contracts a producer provides to an insurer also may affect compensation.
The insurance purchaser may obtain information about compensation expected to be received by the producer based in whole or in part on the sale of insurance to the purchaser, and (if applicable) compensation expected to be received based in whole or in part on any alternative quotes presented to the purchaser by the producer, by requesting such information from the producer.
Other Disclosures / Disclaimers Claims Reporting:
Your policy will come with specific claim reporting requirements. Please make sure you understand these obligations. Contact your Alliant Service Team with any questions.
Changes and Developments It is important that we be advised of any changes in your operations, which may have a bearing on the validity and/or adequacy of your insurance. The types of changes that concern us include, but are not limited to, those listed below:
• Changes in any operations such as expansion to another states, new products, or new applications of existing products. • Travel to any state not previously disclosed. • Mergers and/or acquisition of new companies and any change in business ownership, including percentages. • Any newly assumed contractual liability, granting of indemnities or hold harmless agreements. • Any changes in existing premises including vacancy, whether temporary or permanent, alterations, demolition, etc. Also, any new premises either
purchased, constructed or occupied
• Circumstances which may require an increased liability insurance limit.
Date Issued: 11/07/16 Alliant Insurance Services, Inc. | www.alliant.com | CA License No. 0C36861 Page 6
Washington State Transit Insurance Pool | 2017 - 2018 Government Crime Insurance Proposal
Other Disclosures / Disclaimers - Continued
• Any changes in fire or theft protection such as the installation of or disconnection of sprinkler systems, burglar alarms, etc. This includes any alterations to the system.
• Immediate notification of any changes to a scheduled of equipment, property, vehicles, electronic data processing, etc.
• Property of yours that is in transit, unless previously discussed and/or currently insured.
Certificates / Evidence of Insurance A certificate is issued as a matter of information only and confers no rights upon the certificate holder. The certificate does not affirmatively or negatively amend, extend or alter the coverage afforded by a policy. Nor does it constitute a contract between the issuing insurer(s), authorized representative, producer or certificate holder. You may have signed contracts, leases or other agreements requiring you to provide this evidence. In those agreements, you may assume obligations and/or liability for others (Indemnification, Hold Harmless) and some of the obligations that are not covered by insurance. We recommend that you and your legal counsel review these documents. In addition to providing a certificate of insurance, you may be required to name your client or customer on your policy as an additional insured. This is only possible with permission of the insurance company, added by endorsement and, in some cases, an additional premium.
By naming the certificate holder as additional insured, there are consequences to your risks and insurance policy including: • Your policy limits are now shared with other entities; their claims involvement may reduce or exhaust your aggregate limit. • Your policy may provide higher limits than required by contract; your full limits can be exposed to the additional insured. • There may be conflicts in defense when your insurer has to defend both you and the additional insured.
See Request to Bind Coverage page for acknowledgement of all disclaimers and disclosures.
Date Issued: 11/07/16 Alliant Insurance Services, Inc. | www.alliant.com | CA License No. 0C36861 Page 7
Washington State Transit Insurance Pool | 2017 - 2018 Government Crime Insurance Proposal
Request to Bind Coverage
Washington State Transit Insurance Pool
We have reviewed the proposal and agree to the terms and conditions of the coverages presented. We are requesting coverage to be bound as outlined
by coverage line below:
Coverage Line Bind Coverage for:
Government Crime ☐
This Authorization to Bind Coverage also acknowledges receipt and review of all disclaimers and disclosures, including exposures used to develop insurance terms, contained within this proposal.
Signature of Authorized Insurance Representative Date
Title
Printed / Typed Name
This proposal does not constitute a binder of insurance. Binding is subject to the final carrier approval. The actual terms and conditions of the policy will prevail.
2017 Estimated Member Assessments
ESTIMATED 2017 ASSESSMENTS 9/16/2016
2017 Estimated 2016 Actual Diff 16 to 17 % DifferenceMembers Assessment Assessment Rate Change 2016 to 2017
ASOTIN COUNTY 53,982 45,099 8,883 20%BEN FRANKLIN 1,152,258 962,402 189,856 20%CLALLAM 347,942 327,406 20,536 6%COLUMBIA COUNTY 39,101 39,904 -803 -2%COMMUNITY 2,169,829 1,993,270 176,559 9%C-TRAN 1,159,699 924,168 235,531 25%EVERETT 335,727 288,918 46,809 16%GRANT 177,023 154,160 22,863 15%GRAYS HARBOR 268,343 226,910 41,433 18%INTERCITY 1,188,907 1,065,351 123,556 12%ISLAND 422,615 347,957 74,658 21%JEFFERSON 122,536 118,565 3,971 3%KITSAP 866,291 786,618 79,673 10%LINK 389,017 333,986 55,031 16%MASON 238,034 194,978 43,056 22%PACIFIC 72,084 64,766 7,318 11%PIERCE 2,453,030 2,291,678 161,352 7%PULLMAN 70,240 60,737 9,503 16%RIVER CITIES 105,770 91,858 13,912 15%SKAGIT 413,039 346,396 66,643 19%SPOKANE 1,580,144 1,312,727 267,417 20%TWIN 53,805 56,711 -2,906 -5%VALLEY 103,985 109,456 -5,471 -5%WHATCOM 595,841 525,750 70,091 13%YAKIMA 199,601 194,362 5,239 3%Total 14,578,843 12,864,133 1,714,710 13%
Exhibit 8-6Page 1 of 25
Washington State Transit Insurance PoolRate Assessment Calculation
Member: AsotinRating Year: 2017
Assessment Calculation
Number of IndicatedExposure Experience Deductible Assessment
Rating Unit Units Base Rate Mod. Factor Factor (1)x(2)x(3)x(4)(1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
Fixed Route Mileage 163,484 0.1076 1.072 1.000 18,857Paratransit Mileage 42,904 0.1076 1.072 1.000 4,949
Vanpool Mileage 143,000 0.1076 1.072 1.000 16,495Admin Mileage 9,980 0.1076 1.072 1.000 1,151
Number of Employees 16 267.22 1.072 1.000 4,583Vehicle Insured Values (in hundreds) 4,192 0.3377 1.000 0.848 1,200
Property Insured Values (in hundreds) 15,877 0.1699 1.000 0.967 2,608Other Rating Cost Components 2,857 ** per Exhibit 8-5Prior Premium Audit Adjustment 1,281 ** per Exhibit 8-5
Total Indicated Assessment: 53,982
Mileage Mileage Mileage Mileage Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Actual Relative LossLoss Loss from from from from Number of Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Expected Member ExperienceYear Limit Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin Employees Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin FTEs Member Losses Losses (13)/(12)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14)
2006 25,000 0 0 0 0 0 0.029 0.029 0.029 0.029 50.02 0 0 0.0002007 25,000 45,241 25,999 0 4,212 1 0.026 0.026 0.026 0.026 23.99 1,968 6,740 3.4242008 25,000 100,169 36,845 59,066 4,480 2 0.025 0.025 0.025 0.025 47.51 5,024 0 0.0002009 25,000 99,907 52,181 111,958 9,864 3 0.023 0.023 0.023 0.023 21.18 6,375 2,922 0.4582010 25,000 131,911 52,286 129,440 14,365 13 0.020 0.020 0.020 0.020 27.07 6,952 3,323 0.4782011 25,000 134,000 55,000 158,500 7,200 15 0.018 0.018 0.018 0.018 16.68 6,555 19,497 2.9752012 25,000 133,985 33,079 129,108 12,741 12 0.014 0.014 0.014 0.014 32.69 4,653 0 0.000
2013 25,000 136,767 31,656 132,201 11,539 13 0.019 0.019 0.019 0.019 23.52 6,345 25,000 3.9402014 25,000 144,346 38,287 123,451 11,277 13 0.015 0.015 0.015 0.015 24.20 5,142 0 0.0002015 25,000 144,592 38,196 137,101 7,994 13 0.012 0.012 0.012 0.012 36.46 4,530 8,473 1.870
Total 47,545 65,955 1.387
Latest 3 Years 16,016 33,473 2.090
1. In calculating Pool average loss rates and actual member losses, individual claims are capped at $25,000, $50,000, $100,000, or $250,000 depending upon the number of miles driven each year. 2. Pool average loss rates in columns (7) through (11) are from Exhibit 8-4 and are capped at the loss limit presented in column (1). 3. Expected member losses in column (12) are the exposures in columns (2) through (6) multiplied by their respective loss rates in columns (7) through (11).
Description Explanation (1) Latest Relative Loss Experience: 2.090 Relative Loss Experience for Latest 3 Years from Column (13) above. (2) Prior Experience Modification Factor: 1.034 Experience modification factor from prior rate study. (3) Weight given to Latest Relative Loss Experience: 1.0% Based on size - larger members are more self-rated. (4) Weight given to Prior Experience Modification Factor: 99.0% 1-(3) (5) Off-Balance Adjustment: 1.027 An adjustment factor designed to ensure allocation of the full cost amount (6) Experience Modification Factor: 1.072 [(1)x(3) + (2)x(4)] x (5)
DRAFT
Exhibit 8-6Page 2 of 25
Washington State Transit Insurance PoolRate Assessment Calculation
Member: Ben Franklin TransitRating Year: 2017
Assessment Calculation
Number of IndicatedExposure Experience Deductible Assessment
Rating Unit Units Base Rate Mod. Factor Factor (1)x(2)x(3)x(4)(1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
Fixed Route Mileage 2,740,000 0.1076 0.927 1.000 273,302Paratransit Mileage 2,530,000 0.1076 0.927 1.000 252,355
Vanpool Mileage 3,700,000 0.1076 0.927 1.000 369,057Admin Mileage 295,000 0.1076 0.927 1.000 29,425
Number of Employees 279 267.22 0.927 1.000 69,112Vehicle Insured Values (in hundreds) 186,147 0.3377 1.000 0.848 53,307
Property Insured Values (in hundreds) 198,172 0.1699 1.000 0.967 32,558Other Rating Cost Components 85,382 ** per Exhibit 8-5Prior Premium Audit Adjustment (12,240) ** per Exhibit 8-5
Total Indicated Assessment: 1,152,258
Mileage Mileage Mileage Mileage Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Actual Relative LossLoss Loss from from from from Number of Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Expected Member ExperienceYear Limit Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin Employees Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin FTEs Member Losses Losses (13)/(12)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14)
2006 100,000 2,655,142 2,168,709 2,739,166 167,781 263 0.047 0.047 0.047 0.047 111.21 393,663 36,798 0.0932007 100,000 2,668,798 2,305,753 3,270,763 329,782 267 0.041 0.041 0.041 0.041 56.91 366,917 426,275 1.1622008 100,000 2,640,839 2,361,584 4,454,821 253,967 289 0.041 0.041 0.041 0.041 91.96 428,140 460,637 1.0762009 100,000 2,754,608 2,344,383 4,840,922 253,967 266 0.033 0.033 0.033 0.033 37.19 341,236 312,779 0.9172010 100,000 2,555,871 2,103,456 5,006,827 267,457 251 0.032 0.032 0.032 0.032 57.74 327,597 108,673 0.3322011 100,000 2,202,865 2,134,869 5,614,529 264,227 270 0.031 0.031 0.031 0.031 32.37 329,618 190,282 0.5772012 100,000 2,272,279 2,091,282 4,357,289 266,912 260 0.020 0.020 0.020 0.020 90.11 200,912 187,179 0.9322013 100,000 2,307,999 2,301,204 4,046,851 302,313 263 0.027 0.027 0.027 0.027 57.46 258,939 388,054 1.4992014 100,000 2,307,210 2,366,725 4,081,934 356,900 270 0.020 0.020 0.020 0.020 76.99 206,553 157,376 0.7622015 100,000 2,331,260 2,178,655 3,845,508 318,354 272 0.016 0.016 0.016 0.016 50.56 151,361 80,144 0.529
Total 3,004,937 2,348,197 0.781
Latest 3 Years 616,853 625,574 1.014
1. In calculating Pool average loss rates and actual member losses, individual claims are capped at $25,000, $50,000, $100,000, or $250,000 depending upon the number of miles driven each year. 2. Pool average loss rates in columns (7) through (11) are from Exhibit 8-4 and are capped at the loss limit presented in column (1). 3. Expected member losses in column (12) are the exposures in columns (2) through (6) multiplied by their respective loss rates in columns (7) through (11).
Description Explanation (1) Latest Relative Loss Experience: 1.014 Relative Loss Experience for Latest 3 Years from Column (13) above. (2) Prior Experience Modification Factor: 0.887 Experience modification factor from prior rate study. (3) Weight given to Latest Relative Loss Experience: 12.5% Based on size - larger members are more self-rated. (4) Weight given to Prior Experience Modification Factor: 87.5% 1-(3) (5) Off-Balance Adjustment: 1.027 An adjustment factor designed to ensure allocation of the full cost amount (6) Experience Modification Factor: 0.927 [(1)x(3) + (2)x(4)] x (5)
DRAFT
Exhibit 8-6Page 3 of 25
Washington State Transit Insurance PoolRate Assessment Calculation
Member: Clallam TransitRating Year: 2017
Assessment Calculation
Number of IndicatedExposure Experience Deductible Assessment
Rating Unit Units Base Rate Mod. Factor Factor (1)x(2)x(3)x(4)(1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
Fixed Route Mileage 1,055,000 0.1076 1.003 1.000 113,859Paratransit Mileage 460,000 0.1076 1.003 1.000 49,644
Vanpool Mileage 670,000 0.1076 1.003 1.000 72,308Admin Mileage 98,000 0.1076 1.003 1.000 10,576
Number of Employees 91 267.22 1.003 1.000 24,256Vehicle Insured Values (in hundreds) 67,796 0.3377 1.000 0.848 19,415
Property Insured Values (in hundreds) 183,675 0.1699 1.000 0.967 30,176Other Rating Cost Components 24,035 ** per Exhibit 8-5Prior Premium Audit Adjustment 3,673 ** per Exhibit 8-5
Total Indicated Assessment: 347,942
Mileage Mileage Mileage Mileage Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Actual Relative LossLoss Loss from from from from Number of Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Expected Member ExperienceYear Limit Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin Employees Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin FTEs Member Losses Losses (13)/(12)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14)
2006 50,000 1,120,000 500,000 500,000 115,000 65 0.039 0.039 0.039 0.039 78.76 91,662 20,042 0.2192007 50,000 1,023,638 604,374 403,906 137,021 65 0.034 0.034 0.034 0.034 41.79 76,787 38,370 0.5002008 50,000 1,113,796 477,119 412,459 154,591 67 0.032 0.032 0.032 0.032 72.36 74,726 149,502 2.0012009 50,000 1,163,050 483,475 468,275 134,896 65 0.028 0.028 0.028 0.028 26.77 63,842 9,323 0.1462010 50,000 1,128,356 488,176 479,091 121,841 65 0.026 0.026 0.026 0.026 43.93 59,804 28,265 0.4732011 50,000 1,000,000 490,000 490,000 120,000 85 0.024 0.024 0.024 0.024 21.91 51,796 27,589 0.5332012 50,000 1,032,735 462,605 531,446 95,460 82 0.017 0.017 0.017 0.017 54.81 40,206 67,956 1.6902013 50,000 1,034,577 458,192 589,987 101,491 87 0.024 0.024 0.024 0.024 34.84 54,781 7,999 0.1462014 50,000 1,042,447 473,276 642,259 93,499 89 0.018 0.018 0.018 0.018 46.53 43,890 2,277 0.0522015 50,000 1,051,904 474,093 657,734 98,472 94 0.014 0.014 0.014 0.014 44.12 35,625 75,761 2.127
Total 593,119 427,084 0.720
Latest 3 Years 134,296 86,037 0.641
1. In calculating Pool average loss rates and actual member losses, individual claims are capped at $25,000, $50,000, $100,000, or $250,000 depending upon the number of miles driven each year. 2. Pool average loss rates in columns (7) through (11) are from Exhibit 8-4 and are capped at the loss limit presented in column (1). 3. Expected member losses in column (12) are the exposures in columns (2) through (6) multiplied by their respective loss rates in columns (7) through (11).
Description Explanation (1) Latest Relative Loss Experience: 0.641 Relative Loss Experience for Latest 3 Years from Column (13) above. (2) Prior Experience Modification Factor: 0.993 Experience modification factor from prior rate study. (3) Weight given to Latest Relative Loss Experience: 4.6% Based on size - larger members are more self-rated. (4) Weight given to Prior Experience Modification Factor: 95.4% 1-(3) (5) Off-Balance Adjustment: 1.027 An adjustment factor designed to ensure allocation of the full cost amount (6) Experience Modification Factor: 1.003 [(1)x(3) + (2)x(4)] x (5)
DRAFT
Exhibit 8-6Page 4 of 25
Washington State Transit Insurance PoolRate Assessment Calculation
Member: Columbia CountyRating Year: 2017
Assessment Calculation
Number of IndicatedExposure Experience Deductible Assessment
Rating Unit Units Base Rate Mod. Factor Factor (1)x(2)x(3)x(4)(1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
Fixed Route Mileage 0 0.1076 1.039 1.000 0Paratransit Mileage 225,000 0.1076 1.039 1.000 25,154
Vanpool Mileage 104,000 0.1076 1.039 1.000 11,627Admin Mileage 4,000 0.1076 1.039 1.000 447
Number of Employees 14 267.22 1.039 1.000 3,887Vehicle Insured Values (in hundreds) 3,349 0.3377 1.000 0.848 959
Property Insured Values (in hundreds) 1,286 0.1699 1.000 0.967 211Other Rating Cost Components 2,549 ** per Exhibit 8-5Prior Premium Audit Adjustment (5,734) ** per Exhibit 8-5
Total Indicated Assessment: 39,101
Mileage Mileage Mileage Mileage Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Actual Relative LossLoss Loss from from from from Number of Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Expected Member ExperienceYear Limit Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin Employees Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin FTEs Member Losses Losses (13)/(12)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14)
2006 25,000 0 129,139 108,500 1,500 9 0.029 0.029 0.029 0.029 50.02 7,492 0 0.0002007 25,000 0 161,600 111,800 3,600 10 0.026 0.026 0.026 0.026 23.99 7,378 50,079 6.7872008 25,000 0 165,200 154,200 5,500 12 0.025 0.025 0.025 0.025 47.51 8,555 25,276 2.9542009 25,000 0 202,000 168,000 6,000 13 0.023 0.023 0.023 0.023 21.18 8,940 0 0.0002010 25,000 0 235,529 175,801 6,000 13 0.020 0.020 0.020 0.020 27.07 8,750 3,431 0.3922011 25,000 0 245,000 180,000 6,000 15 0.018 0.018 0.018 0.018 16.68 7,911 0 0.0002012 25,000 0 250,500 157,100 2,500 11 0.014 0.014 0.014 0.014 32.69 6,016 27,274 4.533
2013 25,000 0 252,000 133,000 2,500 11 0.019 0.019 0.019 0.019 23.52 7,755 128 0.0162014 25,000 0 235,500 129,000 3,224 14 0.015 0.015 0.015 0.015 24.20 5,932 0 0.0002015 25,000 0 213,001 113,054 1,500 14 0.012 0.012 0.012 0.012 36.46 4,563 0 0.000
Total 73,291 106,187 1.449
Latest 3 Years 18,249 128 0.007
1. In calculating Pool average loss rates and actual member losses, individual claims are capped at $25,000, $50,000, $100,000, or $250,000 depending upon the number of miles driven each year. 2. Pool average loss rates in columns (7) through (11) are from Exhibit 8-4 and are capped at the loss limit presented in column (1). 3. Expected member losses in column (12) are the exposures in columns (2) through (6) multiplied by their respective loss rates in columns (7) through (11).
Description Explanation (1) Latest Relative Loss Experience: 0.007 Relative Loss Experience for Latest 3 Years from Column (13) above. (2) Prior Experience Modification Factor: 1.024 Experience modification factor from prior rate study. (3) Weight given to Latest Relative Loss Experience: 1.2% Based on size - larger members are more self-rated. (4) Weight given to Prior Experience Modification Factor: 98.8% 1-(3) (5) Off-Balance Adjustment: 1.027 An adjustment factor designed to ensure allocation of the full cost amount (6) Experience Modification Factor: 1.039 [(1)x(3) + (2)x(4)] x (5)
DRAFT
Exhibit 8-6Page 5 of 25
Washington State Transit Insurance PoolRate Assessment Calculation
Member: Community TransitRating Year: 2017
Assessment Calculation
Number of IndicatedExposure Experience Deductible Assessment
Rating Unit Units Base Rate Mod. Factor Factor (1)x(2)x(3)x(4)(1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
Fixed Route Mileage 9,621,531 0.1076 0.965 1.000 999,042Paratransit Mileage 0 0.1076 0.965 1.000 0
Vanpool Mileage 4,800,000 0.1076 0.965 1.000 498,403Admin Mileage 349,056 0.1076 0.965 1.000 36,244
Number of Employees 751 267.22 0.965 1.000 193,658Vehicle Insured Values (in hundreds) 791,757 0.3377 1.000 0.848 226,735
Property Insured Values (in hundreds) 758,533 0.1699 1.000 0.967 124,622Other Rating Cost Components 127,549 ** per Exhibit 8-5Prior Premium Audit Adjustment (36,425) ** per Exhibit 8-5
Total Indicated Assessment: 2,169,829
Mileage Mileage Mileage Mileage Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Actual Relative LossLoss Loss from from from from Number of Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Expected Member ExperienceYear Limit Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin Employees Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin FTEs Member Losses Losses (13)/(12)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14)
2006 250,000 9,247,472 1,974,242 3,992,029 1,074,872 622 0.056 0.056 0.056 0.056 145.10 996,710 1,176,661 1.1812007 250,000 8,890,955 2,114,388 4,322,044 873,898 649 0.049 0.049 0.049 0.049 56.91 827,473 314,305 0.3802008 250,000 9,440,089 2,189,257 5,025,926 1,323,113 692 0.052 0.052 0.052 0.052 99.53 1,011,258 291,068 0.2882009 250,000 9,886,103 2,262,613 4,832,386 1,369,286 707 0.040 0.040 0.040 0.040 43.99 755,954 780,380 1.0322010 250,000 9,564,982 2,214,206 4,693,338 1,284,539 649 0.037 0.037 0.037 0.037 90.54 714,877 156,538 0.2192011 250,000 9,059,000 2,288,000 5,028,000 1,294,000 654 0.043 0.043 0.043 0.043 63.75 798,012 691,973 0.8672012 250,000 7,300,572 0 4,915,857 865,543 539 0.024 0.024 0.024 0.024 126.29 382,736 450,800 1.178
2013 100,000 7,152,972 0 4,888,490 886,776 547 0.027 0.027 0.027 0.027 57.46 383,308 285,414 0.7452014 100,000 7,350,357 0 4,760,518 892,333 557 0.020 0.020 0.020 0.020 76.99 307,956 199,525 0.6482015 100,000 8,076,227 0 4,711,918 846,111 615 0.016 0.016 0.016 0.016 50.56 247,400 128,412 0.519
Total 6,425,686 4,475,076 0.696
Latest 3 Years 938,665 613,350 0.653
1. In calculating Pool average loss rates and actual member losses, individual claims are capped at $25,000, $50,000, $100,000, or $250,000 depending upon the number of miles driven each year. 2. Pool average loss rates in columns (7) through (11) are from Exhibit 8-4 and are capped at the loss limit presented in column (1). 3. Expected member losses in column (12) are the exposures in columns (2) through (6) multiplied by their respective loss rates in columns (7) through (11).
Description Explanation (1) Latest Relative Loss Experience: 0.653 Relative Loss Experience for Latest 3 Years from Column (13) above. (2) Prior Experience Modification Factor: 0.999 Experience modification factor from prior rate study. (3) Weight given to Latest Relative Loss Experience: 17.1% Based on size - larger members are more self-rated. (4) Weight given to Prior Experience Modification Factor: 82.9% 1-(3) (5) Off-Balance Adjustment: 1.027 An adjustment factor designed to ensure allocation of the full cost amount (6) Experience Modification Factor: 0.965 [(1)x(3) + (2)x(4)] x (5)
DRAFT
Exhibit 8-6Page 6 of 25
Washington State Transit Insurance PoolRate Assessment Calculation
Member: C-TranRating Year: 2017
Assessment Calculation
Number of IndicatedExposure Experience Deductible Assessment
Rating Unit Units Base Rate Mod. Factor Factor (1)x(2)x(3)x(4)(1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
Fixed Route Mileage 5,276,000 0.1076 1.049 1.000 595,515Paratransit Mileage 1,794,000 0.1076 1.049 1.000 202,493
Vanpool Mileage 593,000 0.1076 1.049 1.000 66,933Admin Mileage 310,000 0.1076 1.049 1.000 34,990
Number of Employees 440 267.22 1.049 1.000 123,338Vehicle Insured Values (in hundreds) 267,911 0.3377 1.000 0.792 71,655
Property Insured Values (in hundreds) 212,094 0.1699 1.000 0.950 34,233Other Rating Cost Components 15,249 ** per Exhibit 8-5Prior Premium Audit Adjustment 15,292 ** per Exhibit 8-5
Total Indicated Assessment: 1,159,699
Mileage Mileage Mileage Mileage Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Actual Relative LossLoss Loss from from from from Number of Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Expected Member ExperienceYear Limit Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin Employees Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin FTEs Member Losses Losses (13)/(12)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14)
2006 100,000 4,100,702 1,433,392 0 236,154 390 0.047 0.047 0.047 0.047 111.21 315,369 79,007 0.2512007 100,000 4,431,675 1,504,690 0 245,542 390 0.041 0.041 0.041 0.041 56.91 275,756 298,502 1.0822008 100,000 5,053,613 1,579,804 0 306,653 390 0.041 0.041 0.041 0.041 91.96 322,839 250,608 0.7762009 100,000 4,970,828 1,431,783 65,864 316,884 390 0.033 0.033 0.033 0.033 37.19 235,056 217,591 0.9262010 100,000 4,618,039 1,436,388 78,431 310,766 382 0.032 0.032 0.032 0.032 57.74 225,157 136,862 0.6082011 100,000 4,926,692 1,364,116 89,300 344,700 388 0.031 0.031 0.031 0.031 32.37 223,771 514,651 2.3002012 100,000 4,645,968 1,454,013 303,654 268,385 391 0.020 0.020 0.020 0.020 90.11 166,987 190,837 1.143
2013 100,000 4,637,508 1,541,863 412,699 249,914 397 0.027 0.027 0.027 0.027 57.46 209,035 141,422 0.6772014 100,000 4,671,165 1,566,576 452,591 247,285 402 0.020 0.020 0.020 0.020 76.99 172,374 208,821 1.2112015 100,000 5,001,661 1,676,335 398,958 256,604 417 0.016 0.016 0.016 0.016 50.56 137,429 124,691 0.907
Total 2,283,775 2,162,994 0.947
Latest 3 Years 518,839 474,935 0.915
1. In calculating Pool average loss rates and actual member losses, individual claims are capped at $25,000, $50,000, $100,000, or $250,000 depending upon the number of miles driven each year. 2. Pool average loss rates in columns (7) through (11) are from Exhibit 8-4 and are capped at the loss limit presented in column (1). 3. Expected member losses in column (12) are the exposures in columns (2) through (6) multiplied by their respective loss rates in columns (7) through (11).
Description Explanation (1) Latest Relative Loss Experience: 0.915 Relative Loss Experience for Latest 3 Years from Column (13) above. (2) Prior Experience Modification Factor: 1.033 Experience modification factor from prior rate study. (3) Weight given to Latest Relative Loss Experience: 9.7% Based on size - larger members are more self-rated. (4) Weight given to Prior Experience Modification Factor: 90.3% 1-(3) (5) Off-Balance Adjustment: 1.027 An adjustment factor designed to ensure allocation of the full cost amount (6) Experience Modification Factor: 1.049 [(1)x(3) + (2)x(4)] x (5)
DRAFT
Exhibit 8-6Page 7 of 25
Washington State Transit Insurance PoolRate Assessment Calculation
Member: Everett TransitRating Year: 2017
Assessment Calculation
Number of IndicatedExposure Experience Deductible Assessment
Rating Unit Units Base Rate Mod. Factor Factor (1)x(2)x(3)x(4)(1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
Fixed Route Mileage 1,426,684 0.1076 1.123 1.000 172,393Paratransit Mileage 643,167 0.1076 1.123 1.000 77,717
Vanpool Mileage 15,000 0.1076 1.123 1.000 1,813Admin Mileage 75,000 0.1076 1.123 1.000 9,063
Number of Employees 154 267.22 1.123 1.000 46,214Vehicle Insured Values (in hundreds) 0 0.3377 1.000 0.848 0
Property Insured Values (in hundreds) 0 0.1699 1.000 0.967 0Other Rating Cost Components 15,591 ** per Exhibit 8-5Prior Premium Audit Adjustment 12,938 ** per Exhibit 8-5
Total Indicated Assessment: 335,727
Mileage Mileage Mileage Mileage Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Actual Relative LossLoss Loss from from from from Number of Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Expected Member ExperienceYear Limit Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin Employees Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin FTEs Member Losses Losses (13)/(12)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14)
2006 50,000 1,408,751 501,890 0 75,962 124 0.039 0.039 0.039 0.039 78.76 86,690 420,686 4.8532007 50,000 1,473,430 556,473 47,640 83,536 131 0.034 0.034 0.034 0.034 41.79 79,277 86,621 1.0932008 50,000 1,534,522 576,250 0 77,992 136 0.032 0.032 0.032 0.032 72.36 80,716 174,398 2.1612009 50,000 1,617,068 560,943 46,274 95,107 144 0.028 0.028 0.028 0.028 26.77 67,881 153,377 2.2602010 50,000 1,821,978 575,232 33,617 81,795 144 0.026 0.026 0.026 0.026 43.93 70,854 139,730 1.9722011 50,000 1,666,847 583,012 53,341 80,200 145 0.024 0.024 0.024 0.024 21.91 59,850 87,007 1.4542012 50,000 1,552,363 599,662 49,081 70,383 145 0.017 0.017 0.017 0.017 54.81 46,171 38,402 0.832
2013 50,000 1,346,499 548,389 0 84,889 142 0.024 0.024 0.024 0.024 34.84 51,853 38,954 0.7512014 50,000 1,347,725 619,331 0 77,141 144 0.018 0.018 0.018 0.018 46.53 42,789 45,371 1.0602015 50,000 1,371,812 630,494 44,015 74,566 156 0.014 0.014 0.014 0.014 44.12 36,135 10,291 0.285
Total 622,216 1,194,838 1.920
Latest 3 Years 130,778 94,616 0.723
1. In calculating Pool average loss rates and actual member losses, individual claims are capped at $25,000, $50,000, $100,000, or $250,000 depending upon the number of miles driven each year. 2. Pool average loss rates in columns (7) through (11) are from Exhibit 8-4 and are capped at the loss limit presented in column (1). 3. Expected member losses in column (12) are the exposures in columns (2) through (6) multiplied by their respective loss rates in columns (7) through (11).
Description Explanation (1) Latest Relative Loss Experience: 0.723 Relative Loss Experience for Latest 3 Years from Column (13) above. (2) Prior Experience Modification Factor: 1.111 Experience modification factor from prior rate study. (3) Weight given to Latest Relative Loss Experience: 4.5% Based on size - larger members are more self-rated. (4) Weight given to Prior Experience Modification Factor: 95.5% 1-(3) (5) Off-Balance Adjustment: 1.027 An adjustment factor designed to ensure allocation of the full cost amount (6) Experience Modification Factor: 1.123 [(1)x(3) + (2)x(4)] x (5)
DRAFT
Exhibit 8-6Page 8 of 25
Washington State Transit Insurance PoolRate Assessment Calculation
Member: Grant TransitRating Year: 2017
Assessment Calculation
Number of IndicatedExposure Experience Deductible Assessment
Rating Unit Units Base Rate Mod. Factor Factor (1)x(2)x(3)x(4)(1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
Fixed Route Mileage 942,400 0.1076 0.995 1.000 100,895Paratransit Mileage 130,000 0.1076 0.995 1.000 13,918
Vanpool Mileage 275,000 0.1076 0.995 1.000 29,442Admin Mileage 15,000 0.1076 0.995 1.000 1,606
Number of Employees 44 267.22 0.995 1.000 11,699Vehicle Insured Values (in hundreds) 19,364 0.3377 1.000 0.848 5,545
Property Insured Values (in hundreds) 49,720 0.1699 1.000 0.967 8,169Other Rating Cost Components 11,670 ** per Exhibit 8-5Prior Premium Audit Adjustment (5,922) ** per Exhibit 8-5
Total Indicated Assessment: 177,023
Mileage Mileage Mileage Mileage Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Actual Relative LossLoss Loss from from from from Number of Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Expected Member ExperienceYear Limit Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin Employees Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin FTEs Member Losses Losses (13)/(12)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14)
2006 25,000 1,001,770 238,315 11,450 750 2 0.029 0.029 0.029 0.029 50.02 36,974 53,750 1.4542007 50,000 1,056,247 0 54,429 4,925 2 0.034 0.034 0.034 0.034 41.79 38,182 4,945 0.1302008 50,000 1,095,910 278,778 118,545 14,986 3 0.032 0.032 0.032 0.032 72.36 49,055 13,754 0.2802009 50,000 1,099,258 211,047 152,120 16,248 3 0.028 0.028 0.028 0.028 26.77 40,899 1,928 0.0472010 50,000 894,560 142,152 227,015 19,132 3 0.026 0.026 0.026 0.026 43.93 33,078 17,316 0.5232011 50,000 996,000 215,000 220,157 20,000 4 0.024 0.024 0.024 0.024 21.91 34,594 69,146 1.9992012 50,000 956,036 131,249 250,982 19,433 6 0.017 0.017 0.017 0.017 54.81 23,175 17,522 0.756
2013 50,000 912,322 172,536 273,965 18,376 35 0.024 0.024 0.024 0.024 34.84 33,849 1,490 0.0442014 50,000 862,145 111,936 268,045 19,974 37 0.018 0.018 0.018 0.018 46.53 24,003 8,721 0.3632015 50,000 906,420 113,322 277,496 11,293 34 0.014 0.014 0.014 0.014 44.12 19,548 50,000 2.558
Total 333,357 238,571 0.716
Latest 3 Years 77,400 60,211 0.778
1. In calculating Pool average loss rates and actual member losses, individual claims are capped at $25,000, $50,000, $100,000, or $250,000 depending upon the number of miles driven each year. 2. Pool average loss rates in columns (7) through (11) are from Exhibit 8-4 and are capped at the loss limit presented in column (1). 3. Expected member losses in column (12) are the exposures in columns (2) through (6) multiplied by their respective loss rates in columns (7) through (11).
Description Explanation (1) Latest Relative Loss Experience: 0.778 Relative Loss Experience for Latest 3 Years from Column (13) above. (2) Prior Experience Modification Factor: 0.975 Experience modification factor from prior rate study. (3) Weight given to Latest Relative Loss Experience: 2.9% Based on size - larger members are more self-rated. (4) Weight given to Prior Experience Modification Factor: 97.1% 1-(3) (5) Off-Balance Adjustment: 1.027 An adjustment factor designed to ensure allocation of the full cost amount (6) Experience Modification Factor: 0.995 [(1)x(3) + (2)x(4)] x (5)
DRAFT
Exhibit 8-6Page 9 of 25
Washington State Transit Insurance PoolRate Assessment Calculation
Member: Grays Harbor TransitRating Year: 2017
Assessment Calculation
Number of IndicatedExposure Experience Deductible Assessment
Rating Unit Units Base Rate Mod. Factor Factor (1)x(2)x(3)x(4)(1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
Fixed Route Mileage 870,000 0.1076 0.997 1.000 93,331Paratransit Mileage 355,000 0.1076 0.997 1.000 38,083
Vanpool Mileage 390,000 0.1076 0.997 1.000 41,838Admin Mileage 90,000 0.1076 0.997 1.000 9,655
Number of Employees 80 267.22 0.997 1.000 21,313Vehicle Insured Values (in hundreds) 41,288 0.3377 1.000 0.848 11,824
Property Insured Values (in hundreds) 70,334 0.1699 1.000 0.967 11,555Other Rating Cost Components 34,618 ** per Exhibit 8-5Prior Premium Audit Adjustment 6,125 ** per Exhibit 8-5
Total Indicated Assessment: 268,343
Mileage Mileage Mileage Mileage Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Actual Relative LossLoss Loss from from from from Number of Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Expected Member ExperienceYear Limit Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin Employees Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin FTEs Member Losses Losses (13)/(12)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14)
2006 50,000 1,238,742 507,511 21,783 57,367 86 0.039 0.039 0.039 0.039 78.76 77,455 15,459 0.2002007 50,000 1,243,838 553,020 60,246 61,058 92 0.034 0.034 0.034 0.034 41.79 69,351 103,342 1.4902008 50,000 1,228,429 590,815 124,956 66,055 91 0.032 0.032 0.032 0.032 72.36 71,679 23,479 0.3282009 50,000 1,203,470 545,131 226,847 50,980 82 0.028 0.028 0.028 0.028 26.77 58,134 11,573 0.1992010 50,000 1,047,722 455,700 281,783 46,275 79 0.026 0.026 0.026 0.026 43.93 50,506 87,869 1.7402011 50,000 1,100,000 500,000 300,000 50,000 79 0.024 0.024 0.024 0.024 21.91 48,098 5,002 0.1042012 50,000 1,045,575 427,368 399,945 51,062 81 0.017 0.017 0.017 0.017 54.81 36,815 30,851 0.838
2013 50,000 987,027 426,454 355,232 45,873 67 0.024 0.024 0.024 0.024 34.84 45,327 615 0.0142014 50,000 876,851 364,932 407,591 54,996 67 0.018 0.018 0.018 0.018 46.53 33,207 57,463 1.7302015 50,000 949,078 345,906 399,878 53,832 79 0.014 0.014 0.014 0.014 44.12 27,605 71,400 2.587
Total 518,177 407,053 0.786
Latest 3 Years 106,138 129,478 1.220
1. In calculating Pool average loss rates and actual member losses, individual claims are capped at $25,000, $50,000, $100,000, or $250,000 depending upon the number of miles driven each year. 2. Pool average loss rates in columns (7) through (11) are from Exhibit 8-4 and are capped at the loss limit presented in column (1). 3. Expected member losses in column (12) are the exposures in columns (2) through (6) multiplied by their respective loss rates in columns (7) through (11).
Description Explanation (1) Latest Relative Loss Experience: 1.220 Relative Loss Experience for Latest 3 Years from Column (13) above. (2) Prior Experience Modification Factor: 0.961 Experience modification factor from prior rate study. (3) Weight given to Latest Relative Loss Experience: 3.9% Based on size - larger members are more self-rated. (4) Weight given to Prior Experience Modification Factor: 96.1% 1-(3) (5) Off-Balance Adjustment: 1.027 An adjustment factor designed to ensure allocation of the full cost amount (6) Experience Modification Factor: 0.997 [(1)x(3) + (2)x(4)] x (5)
DRAFT
Exhibit 8-6Page 10 of 25
Washington State Transit Insurance PoolRate Assessment Calculation
Member: Intercity TransitRating Year: 2017
Assessment Calculation
Number of IndicatedExposure Experience Deductible Assessment
Rating Unit Units Base Rate Mod. Factor Factor (1)x(2)x(3)x(4)(1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
Fixed Route Mileage 3,150,000 0.1076 1.031 1.000 349,447Paratransit Mileage 1,050,000 0.1076 1.031 1.000 116,482
Vanpool Mileage 3,600,000 0.1076 1.031 1.000 399,368Admin Mileage 160,000 0.1076 1.031 1.000 17,750
Number of Employees 315 267.22 1.031 1.000 86,784Vehicle Insured Values (in hundreds) 225,443 0.3377 1.000 0.848 64,560
Property Insured Values (in hundreds) 208,046 0.1699 1.000 0.967 34,181Other Rating Cost Components 111,722 ** per Exhibit 8-5Prior Premium Audit Adjustment 8,613 ** per Exhibit 8-5
Total Indicated Assessment: 1,188,907
Mileage Mileage Mileage Mileage Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Actual Relative LossLoss Loss from from from from Number of Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Expected Member ExperienceYear Limit Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin Employees Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin FTEs Member Losses Losses (13)/(12)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14)
2006 50,000 2,548,972 778,093 2,283,943 135,704 260 0.039 0.039 0.039 0.039 78.76 242,998 132,912 0.5472007 100,000 2,481,443 789,485 2,633,225 0 265 0.041 0.041 0.041 0.041 56.91 257,250 183,208 0.7122008 100,000 2,838,031 895,558 3,123,220 148,084 289 0.041 0.041 0.041 0.041 91.96 316,232 445,419 1.4092009 100,000 2,885,329 927,095 3,403,526 143,774 285 0.033 0.033 0.033 0.033 37.19 249,821 212,125 0.8492010 100,000 2,760,246 921,565 2,972,366 147,447 294 0.032 0.032 0.032 0.032 57.74 231,360 354,386 1.5322011 100,000 2,885,000 925,000 3,060,000 144,000 295 0.031 0.031 0.031 0.031 32.37 229,844 141,917 0.6172012 100,000 2,880,612 919,256 3,481,730 148,979 307 0.020 0.020 0.020 0.020 90.11 174,397 196,636 1.128
2013 100,000 2,934,299 926,226 3,566,866 217,865 309 0.027 0.027 0.027 0.027 57.46 225,842 181,718 0.8052014 100,000 3,067,736 985,036 3,629,991 148,043 308 0.020 0.020 0.020 0.020 76.99 183,345 93,341 0.5092015 100,000 3,177,485 1,043,655 3,617,992 153,985 318 0.016 0.016 0.016 0.016 50.56 142,888 126,497 0.885
Total 2,253,978 2,068,159 0.918
Latest 3 Years 552,075 401,556 0.727
1. In calculating Pool average loss rates and actual member losses, individual claims are capped at $25,000, $50,000, $100,000, or $250,000 depending upon the number of miles driven each year. 2. Pool average loss rates in columns (7) through (11) are from Exhibit 8-4 and are capped at the loss limit presented in column (1). 3. Expected member losses in column (12) are the exposures in columns (2) through (6) multiplied by their respective loss rates in columns (7) through (11).
Description Explanation (1) Latest Relative Loss Experience: 0.727 Relative Loss Experience for Latest 3 Years from Column (13) above. (2) Prior Experience Modification Factor: 1.037 Experience modification factor from prior rate study. (3) Weight given to Latest Relative Loss Experience: 10.8% Based on size - larger members are more self-rated. (4) Weight given to Prior Experience Modification Factor: 89.2% 1-(3) (5) Off-Balance Adjustment: 1.027 An adjustment factor designed to ensure allocation of the full cost amount (6) Experience Modification Factor: 1.031 [(1)x(3) + (2)x(4)] x (5)
DRAFT
Exhibit 8-6Page 11 of 25
Washington State Transit Insurance PoolRate Assessment Calculation
Member: Island TransitRating Year: 2017
Assessment Calculation
Number of IndicatedExposure Experience Deductible Assessment
Rating Unit Units Base Rate Mod. Factor Factor (1)x(2)x(3)x(4)(1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
Fixed Route Mileage 1,124,260 0.1076 0.957 1.000 115,769Paratransit Mileage 428,536 0.1076 0.957 1.000 44,128
Vanpool Mileage 1,056,259 0.1076 0.957 1.000 108,766Admin Mileage 153,102 0.1076 0.957 1.000 15,765
Number of Employees 111 267.22 0.957 1.000 28,386Vehicle Insured Values (in hundreds) 44,814 0.3377 1.000 0.848 12,833
Property Insured Values (in hundreds) 202,666 0.1699 1.000 0.967 33,297Other Rating Cost Components 29,141 ** per Exhibit 8-5Prior Premium Audit Adjustment 34,530 ** per Exhibit 8-5
Total Indicated Assessment: 422,615
Mileage Mileage Mileage Mileage Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Actual Relative LossLoss Loss from from from from Number of Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Expected Member ExperienceYear Limit Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin Employees Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin FTEs Member Losses Losses (13)/(12)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14)
2006 50,000 1,044,637 900,608 1,088,100 110,000 99 0.039 0.039 0.039 0.039 78.76 129,512 60,337 0.4662007 50,000 1,136,598 1,014,891 919,958 100,000 113 0.034 0.034 0.034 0.034 41.79 113,030 43,633 0.3862008 50,000 1,090,817 873,471 1,025,683 110,000 117 0.032 0.032 0.032 0.032 72.36 108,847 45,536 0.4182009 50,000 1,923,084 315,138 1,348,096 245,935 124 0.028 0.028 0.028 0.028 26.77 109,107 24,070 0.2212010 50,000 1,909,318 354,085 1,190,995 207,517 131 0.026 0.026 0.026 0.026 43.93 99,799 91,616 0.9182011 50,000 1,913,638 342,603 1,243,058 143,419 132 0.024 0.024 0.024 0.024 21.91 89,509 132,222 1.4772012 50,000 1,899,641 459,279 1,231,210 287,986 135 0.017 0.017 0.017 0.017 54.81 72,658 15,277 0.210
2013 50,000 1,899,641 459,279 1,231,210 266,509 135 0.024 0.024 0.024 0.024 34.84 96,077 36,157 0.3762014 50,000 1,246,164 840,534 1,205,972 176,835 108 0.018 0.018 0.018 0.018 46.53 66,277 102,096 1.5402015 50,000 1,248,808 413,084 1,116,335 179,182 114 0.014 0.014 0.014 0.014 44.12 45,821 24,501 0.535
Total 930,637 575,444 0.618
Latest 3 Years 208,175 162,753 0.782
1. In calculating Pool average loss rates and actual member losses, individual claims are capped at $25,000, $50,000, $100,000, or $250,000 depending upon the number of miles driven each year. 2. Pool average loss rates in columns (7) through (11) are from Exhibit 8-4 and are capped at the loss limit presented in column (1). 3. Expected member losses in column (12) are the exposures in columns (2) through (6) multiplied by their respective loss rates in columns (7) through (11).
Description Explanation (1) Latest Relative Loss Experience: 0.782 Relative Loss Experience for Latest 3 Years from Column (13) above. (2) Prior Experience Modification Factor: 0.945 Experience modification factor from prior rate study. (3) Weight given to Latest Relative Loss Experience: 7.7% Based on size - larger members are more self-rated. (4) Weight given to Prior Experience Modification Factor: 92.3% 1-(3) (5) Off-Balance Adjustment: 1.027 An adjustment factor designed to ensure allocation of the full cost amount (6) Experience Modification Factor: 0.957 [(1)x(3) + (2)x(4)] x (5)
DRAFT
Exhibit 8-6Page 12 of 25
Washington State Transit Insurance PoolRate Assessment Calculation
Member: Jefferson TransitRating Year: 2017
Assessment Calculation
Number of IndicatedExposure Experience Deductible Assessment
Rating Unit Units Base Rate Mod. Factor Factor (1)x(2)x(3)x(4)(1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
Fixed Route Mileage 605,000 0.1076 1.021 1.000 66,465Paratransit Mileage 70,000 0.1076 1.021 1.000 7,690
Vanpool Mileage 80,000 0.1076 1.021 1.000 8,789Admin Mileage 35,000 0.1076 1.021 1.000 3,845
Number of Employees 46 267.22 1.021 1.000 12,550Vehicle Insured Values (in hundreds) 18,676 0.3377 1.000 0.848 5,348
Property Insured Values (in hundreds) 79,514 0.1699 1.000 0.967 13,064Other Rating Cost Components 6,393 ** per Exhibit 8-5Prior Premium Audit Adjustment (1,609) ** per Exhibit 8-5
Total Indicated Assessment: 122,536
Mileage Mileage Mileage Mileage Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Actual Relative LossLoss Loss from from from from Number of Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Expected Member ExperienceYear Limit Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin Employees Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin FTEs Member Losses Losses (13)/(12)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14)
2006 25,000 686,933 139,748 84,126 36,432 50 0.029 0.029 0.029 0.029 50.02 30,393 1,846 0.0612007 25,000 662,538 129,226 81,430 23,036 51 0.026 0.026 0.026 0.026 23.99 24,320 4,750 0.1952008 25,000 677,609 98,998 78,640 21,183 44 0.025 0.025 0.025 0.025 47.51 23,630 50,000 2.1162009 25,000 710,123 110,392 90,233 22,506 43 0.023 0.023 0.023 0.023 21.18 22,416 10,925 0.4872010 25,000 486,031 110,127 129,642 17,354 44 0.020 0.020 0.020 0.020 27.07 16,145 1,014 0.0632011 25,000 615,000 100,000 130,000 25,000 44 0.018 0.018 0.018 0.018 16.68 16,197 13,714 0.8472012 25,000 593,897 102,375 102,237 34,035 45 0.014 0.014 0.014 0.014 32.69 12,955 5,546 0.428
2013 25,000 587,389 85,900 107,298 27,644 45 0.019 0.019 0.019 0.019 23.52 16,694 0 0.0002014 25,000 580,393 74,441 89,368 34,572 46 0.015 0.015 0.015 0.015 24.20 12,958 32,071 2.4752015 25,000 598,976 65,532 76,530 28,715 47 0.012 0.012 0.012 0.012 36.46 11,236 2,859 0.254
Total 186,945 122,723 0.656
Latest 3 Years 40,888 34,930 0.854
1. In calculating Pool average loss rates and actual member losses, individual claims are capped at $25,000, $50,000, $100,000, or $250,000 depending upon the number of miles driven each year. 2. Pool average loss rates in columns (7) through (11) are from Exhibit 8-4 and are capped at the loss limit presented in column (1). 3. Expected member losses in column (12) are the exposures in columns (2) through (6) multiplied by their respective loss rates in columns (7) through (11).
Description Explanation (1) Latest Relative Loss Experience: 0.854 Relative Loss Experience for Latest 3 Years from Column (13) above. (2) Prior Experience Modification Factor: 0.998 Experience modification factor from prior rate study. (3) Weight given to Latest Relative Loss Experience: 2.5% Based on size - larger members are more self-rated. (4) Weight given to Prior Experience Modification Factor: 97.5% 1-(3) (5) Off-Balance Adjustment: 1.027 An adjustment factor designed to ensure allocation of the full cost amount (6) Experience Modification Factor: 1.021 [(1)x(3) + (2)x(4)] x (5)
DRAFT
Exhibit 8-6Page 13 of 25
Washington State Transit Insurance PoolRate Assessment Calculation
Member: Kitsap TransitRating Year: 2017
Assessment Calculation
Number of IndicatedExposure Experience Deductible Assessment
Rating Unit Units Base Rate Mod. Factor Factor (1)x(2)x(3)x(4)(1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
Fixed Route Mileage 2,567,000 0.1076 1.070 1.000 295,544Paratransit Mileage 1,416,000 0.1076 1.070 1.000 163,027
Vanpool Mileage 1,000,000 0.1076 1.070 1.000 115,132Admin Mileage 423,000 0.1076 1.070 1.000 48,701
Number of Employees 375 267.22 1.070 1.000 107,222Vehicle Insured Values (in hundreds) 75,406 0.3377 1.000 0.848 21,594
Property Insured Values (in hundreds) 350,825 0.1699 1.000 0.967 57,638Other Rating Cost Components 59,296 ** per Exhibit 8-5Prior Premium Audit Adjustment (1,863) ** per Exhibit 8-5
Total Indicated Assessment: 866,291
Mileage Mileage Mileage Mileage Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Actual Relative LossLoss Loss from from from from Number of Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Expected Member ExperienceYear Limit Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin Employees Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin FTEs Member Losses Losses (13)/(12)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14)
2006 100,000 3,011,257 2,305,353 1,397,989 359,313 410 0.047 0.047 0.047 0.047 111.21 379,045 437,635 1.1552007 100,000 3,018,888 2,279,943 1,345,160 413,999 407 0.041 0.041 0.041 0.041 56.91 312,658 160,327 0.5132008 100,000 2,901,725 2,098,580 1,371,729 400,009 393 0.041 0.041 0.041 0.041 91.96 316,167 122,796 0.3882009 100,000 2,709,366 1,699,407 1,159,888 376,575 355 0.033 0.033 0.033 0.033 37.19 206,447 165,408 0.8012010 100,000 2,455,290 1,586,661 1,196,800 354,549 344 0.032 0.032 0.032 0.032 57.74 196,161 58,163 0.2972011 100,000 2,465,000 1,589,000 1,235,000 353,000 343 0.031 0.031 0.031 0.031 32.37 188,306 217,356 1.1542012 100,000 2,399,744 1,356,258 1,102,159 309,638 347 0.020 0.020 0.020 0.020 90.11 133,318 106,158 0.796
2013 100,000 2,431,056 1,356,575 961,185 365,914 347 0.027 0.027 0.027 0.027 57.46 159,150 224,768 1.4122014 100,000 2,458,218 1,406,263 1,058,252 382,671 354 0.020 0.020 0.020 0.020 76.99 135,406 161,055 1.1892015 100,000 2,522,563 1,425,366 960,552 349,427 368 0.016 0.016 0.016 0.016 50.56 102,022 189,976 1.862
Total 2,128,680 1,843,642 0.866
Latest 3 Years 396,578 575,799 1.452
1. In calculating Pool average loss rates and actual member losses, individual claims are capped at $25,000, $50,000, $100,000, or $250,000 depending upon the number of miles driven each year. 2. Pool average loss rates in columns (7) through (11) are from Exhibit 8-4 and are capped at the loss limit presented in column (1). 3. Expected member losses in column (12) are the exposures in columns (2) through (6) multiplied by their respective loss rates in columns (7) through (11).
Description Explanation (1) Latest Relative Loss Experience: 1.452 Relative Loss Experience for Latest 3 Years from Column (13) above. (2) Prior Experience Modification Factor: 1.008 Experience modification factor from prior rate study. (3) Weight given to Latest Relative Loss Experience: 7.6% Based on size - larger members are more self-rated. (4) Weight given to Prior Experience Modification Factor: 92.4% 1-(3) (5) Off-Balance Adjustment: 1.027 An adjustment factor designed to ensure allocation of the full cost amount (6) Experience Modification Factor: 1.070 [(1)x(3) + (2)x(4)] x (5)
DRAFT
Exhibit 8-6Page 14 of 25
Washington State Transit Insurance PoolRate Assessment Calculation
Member: Link TransitRating Year: 2017
Assessment Calculation
Number of IndicatedExposure Experience Deductible Assessment
Rating Unit Units Base Rate Mod. Factor Factor (1)x(2)x(3)x(4)(1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
Fixed Route Mileage 1,750,000 0.1076 1.252 1.000 235,752Paratransit Mileage 275,000 0.1076 1.252 1.000 37,047
Vanpool Mileage 0 0.1076 1.252 1.000 0Admin Mileage 90,000 0.1076 1.252 1.000 12,124
Number of Employees 130 267.22 1.252 1.000 43,493Vehicle Insured Values (in hundreds) 54,169 0.3377 1.000 0.848 15,512
Property Insured Values (in hundreds) 190,115 0.1699 1.000 0.967 31,235Other Rating Cost Components 17,568 ** per Exhibit 8-5Prior Premium Audit Adjustment (3,713) ** per Exhibit 8-5
Total Indicated Assessment: 389,017
Mileage Mileage Mileage Mileage Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Actual Relative LossLoss Loss from from from from Number of Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Expected Member ExperienceYear Limit Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin Employees Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin FTEs Member Losses Losses (13)/(12)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14)
2006 50,000 1,539,785 291,416 26,861 98,253 112 0.039 0.039 0.039 0.039 78.76 84,572 66,560 0.7872007 50,000 1,613,458 422,839 77,670 91,854 127 0.034 0.034 0.034 0.034 41.79 80,638 68,927 0.8552008 50,000 1,772,992 431,190 63,940 69,592 135 0.032 0.032 0.032 0.032 72.36 85,467 33,788 0.3952009 50,000 1,894,097 379,232 18,473 69,038 130 0.028 0.028 0.028 0.028 26.77 68,650 7,506 0.1092010 50,000 1,949,136 292,073 0 0 124 0.026 0.026 0.026 0.026 43.93 63,005 88,757 1.4092011 50,000 1,900,000 275,000 0 75,000 128 0.024 0.024 0.024 0.024 21.91 56,305 153,859 2.7332012 50,000 1,633,947 365,359 0 74,223 119 0.017 0.017 0.017 0.017 54.81 41,415 92,745 2.239
2013 50,000 1,666,097 249,215 0 84,791 119 0.024 0.024 0.024 0.024 34.84 51,533 201,860 3.9172014 50,000 1,633,387 270,487 0 76,369 113 0.018 0.018 0.018 0.018 46.53 40,218 46,378 1.1532015 50,000 1,748,233 266,897 0 85,171 113 0.014 0.014 0.014 0.014 44.12 33,954 111,523 3.284
Total 605,758 871,902 1.439
Latest 3 Years 125,706 359,760 2.862
1. In calculating Pool average loss rates and actual member losses, individual claims are capped at $25,000, $50,000, $100,000, or $250,000 depending upon the number of miles driven each year. 2. Pool average loss rates in columns (7) through (11) are from Exhibit 8-4 and are capped at the loss limit presented in column (1). 3. Expected member losses in column (12) are the exposures in columns (2) through (6) multiplied by their respective loss rates in columns (7) through (11).
Description Explanation (1) Latest Relative Loss Experience: 2.862 Relative Loss Experience for Latest 3 Years from Column (13) above. (2) Prior Experience Modification Factor: 1.146 Experience modification factor from prior rate study. (3) Weight given to Latest Relative Loss Experience: 4.3% Based on size - larger members are more self-rated. (4) Weight given to Prior Experience Modification Factor: 95.7% 1-(3) (5) Off-Balance Adjustment: 1.027 An adjustment factor designed to ensure allocation of the full cost amount (6) Experience Modification Factor: 1.252 [(1)x(3) + (2)x(4)] x (5)
DRAFT
Exhibit 8-6Page 15 of 25
Washington State Transit Insurance PoolRate Assessment Calculation
Member: Mason County TransitRating Year: 2017
Assessment Calculation
Number of IndicatedExposure Experience Deductible Assessment
Rating Unit Units Base Rate Mod. Factor Factor (1)x(2)x(3)x(4)(1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
Fixed Route Mileage 877,704 0.1076 1.116 1.000 105,396Paratransit Mileage 344,064 0.1076 1.116 1.000 41,316
Vanpool Mileage 203,760 0.1076 1.116 1.000 24,468Admin Mileage 35,320 0.1076 1.116 1.000 4,241
Number of Employees 90 267.22 1.116 1.000 26,840Vehicle Insured Values (in hundreds) 34,925 0.3377 1.000 0.848 10,002
Property Insured Values (in hundreds) 178,186 0.1699 1.000 0.967 29,275Other Rating Cost Components 12,828 ** per Exhibit 8-5Prior Premium Audit Adjustment (16,331) ** per Exhibit 8-5
Total Indicated Assessment: 238,034
Mileage Mileage Mileage Mileage Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Actual Relative LossLoss Loss from from from from Number of Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Expected Member ExperienceYear Limit Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin Employees Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin FTEs Member Losses Losses (13)/(12)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14)
2006 25,000 497,532 319,937 167,767 22,882 79 0.029 0.029 0.029 0.029 50.02 33,636 37,156 1.1052007 50,000 497,410 315,068 157,350 23,634 84 0.034 0.034 0.034 0.034 41.79 37,438 96,773 2.5852008 25,000 572,109 367,021 277,580 31,457 84 0.025 0.025 0.025 0.025 47.51 34,667 51,130 1.4752009 50,000 532,119 363,072 288,653 25,343 80 0.028 0.028 0.028 0.028 26.77 35,521 98,127 2.7632010 50,000 584,236 327,504 289,317 21,842 79 0.026 0.026 0.026 0.026 43.93 34,877 54,254 1.5562011 50,000 590,000 340,000 320,000 32,000 80 0.024 0.024 0.024 0.024 21.91 32,236 60,009 1.8622012 50,000 604,013 321,953 292,889 0 78 0.017 0.017 0.017 0.017 54.81 24,785 82,810 3.341
2013 50,000 639,890 315,347 280,854 20,803 81 0.024 0.024 0.024 0.024 34.84 32,601 17,173 0.5272014 50,000 656,129 349,605 293,437 0 80 0.018 0.018 0.018 0.018 46.53 26,658 2,826 0.1062015 50,000 711,884 364,373 217,701 36,844 85 0.014 0.014 0.014 0.014 44.12 22,106 80,134 3.625
Total 314,524 580,390 1.845
Latest 3 Years 81,365 100,132 1.231
1. In calculating Pool average loss rates and actual member losses, individual claims are capped at $25,000, $50,000, $100,000, or $250,000 depending upon the number of miles driven each year. 2. Pool average loss rates in columns (7) through (11) are from Exhibit 8-4 and are capped at the loss limit presented in column (1). 3. Expected member losses in column (12) are the exposures in columns (2) through (6) multiplied by their respective loss rates in columns (7) through (11).
Description Explanation (1) Latest Relative Loss Experience: 1.231 Relative Loss Experience for Latest 3 Years from Column (13) above. (2) Prior Experience Modification Factor: 1.083 Experience modification factor from prior rate study. (3) Weight given to Latest Relative Loss Experience: 2.7% Based on size - larger members are more self-rated. (4) Weight given to Prior Experience Modification Factor: 97.3% 1-(3) (5) Off-Balance Adjustment: 1.027 An adjustment factor designed to ensure allocation of the full cost amount (6) Experience Modification Factor: 1.116 [(1)x(3) + (2)x(4)] x (5)
DRAFT
Exhibit 8-6Page 16 of 25
Washington State Transit Insurance PoolRate Assessment Calculation
Member: Pacific TransitRating Year: 2017
Assessment Calculation
Number of IndicatedExposure Experience Deductible Assessment
Rating Unit Units Base Rate Mod. Factor Factor (1)x(2)x(3)x(4)(1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
Fixed Route Mileage 332,800 0.1076 1.020 1.000 36,525Paratransit Mileage 93,000 0.1076 1.020 1.000 10,207
Vanpool Mileage 0 0.1076 1.020 1.000 0Admin Mileage 29,000 0.1076 1.020 1.000 3,183
Number of Employees 22 267.22 1.020 1.000 5,996Vehicle Insured Values (in hundreds) 16,295 0.3377 1.000 0.848 4,667
Property Insured Values (in hundreds) 35,037 0.1699 1.000 0.967 5,756Other Rating Cost Components 7,601 ** per Exhibit 8-5Prior Premium Audit Adjustment (1,852) ** per Exhibit 8-5
Total Indicated Assessment: 72,084
Mileage Mileage Mileage Mileage Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Actual Relative LossLoss Loss from from from from Number of Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Expected Member ExperienceYear Limit Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin Employees Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin FTEs Member Losses Losses (13)/(12)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14)
2006 25,000 326,729 116,302 0 8,803 24 0.029 0.029 0.029 0.029 50.02 14,505 250 0.0172007 25,000 318,520 104,612 0 17,500 24 0.026 0.026 0.026 0.026 23.99 11,931 0 0.0002008 25,000 327,171 103,645 0 21,380 24 0.025 0.025 0.025 0.025 47.51 12,254 550 0.0452009 25,000 340,122 101,604 0 19,503 24 0.023 0.023 0.023 0.023 21.18 11,137 0 0.0002010 25,000 340,122 101,604 0 19,634 25 0.020 0.020 0.020 0.020 27.07 9,961 300 0.0302011 25,000 335,000 110,000 0 19,500 25 0.018 0.018 0.018 0.018 16.68 8,673 4,117 0.4752012 25,000 331,651 96,198 0 19,000 25 0.014 0.014 0.014 0.014 32.69 6,981 445 0.064
2013 25,000 332,451 100,071 0 18,041 25 0.019 0.019 0.019 0.019 23.52 9,304 28,446 3.0572014 25,000 336,598 98,126 0 0 23 0.015 0.015 0.015 0.015 24.20 7,169 626 0.0872015 25,000 332,735 92,695 0 28,303 22 0.012 0.012 0.012 0.012 36.46 6,415 6,824 1.064
Total 98,329 41,559 0.423
Latest 3 Years 22,888 35,896 1.568
1. In calculating Pool average loss rates and actual member losses, individual claims are capped at $25,000, $50,000, $100,000, or $250,000 depending upon the number of miles driven each year. 2. Pool average loss rates in columns (7) through (11) are from Exhibit 8-4 and are capped at the loss limit presented in column (1). 3. Expected member losses in column (12) are the exposures in columns (2) through (6) multiplied by their respective loss rates in columns (7) through (11).
Description Explanation (1) Latest Relative Loss Experience: 1.568 Relative Loss Experience for Latest 3 Years from Column (13) above. (2) Prior Experience Modification Factor: 0.985 Experience modification factor from prior rate study. (3) Weight given to Latest Relative Loss Experience: 1.4% Based on size - larger members are more self-rated. (4) Weight given to Prior Experience Modification Factor: 98.6% 1-(3) (5) Off-Balance Adjustment: 1.027 An adjustment factor designed to ensure allocation of the full cost amount (6) Experience Modification Factor: 1.020 [(1)x(3) + (2)x(4)] x (5)
DRAFT
Exhibit 8-6Page 17 of 25
Washington State Transit Insurance PoolRate Assessment Calculation
Member: Pierce TransitRating Year: 2017
Assessment Calculation
Number of IndicatedExposure Experience Deductible Assessment
Rating Unit Units Base Rate Mod. Factor Factor (1)x(2)x(3)x(4)(1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
Fixed Route Mileage 13,761,853 0.1076 0.810 1.000 1,199,428Paratransit Mileage 725,285 0.1076 0.810 1.000 63,213
Vanpool Mileage 4,668,920 0.1076 0.810 1.000 406,924Admin Mileage 1,288,794 0.1076 0.810 1.000 112,326
Number of Employees 956 267.22 0.810 1.000 206,924Vehicle Insured Values (in hundreds) 687,913 0.3377 1.000 0.721 167,494
Property Insured Values (in hundreds) 1,092,696 0.1699 1.000 0.919 170,611Other Rating Cost Components 104,117 ** per Exhibit 8-5Prior Premium Audit Adjustment 21,991 ** per Exhibit 8-5
Total Indicated Assessment: 2,453,030
Mileage Mileage Mileage Mileage Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Actual Relative LossLoss Loss from from from from Number of Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Expected Member ExperienceYear Limit Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin Employees Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin FTEs Member Losses Losses (13)/(12)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14)
2006 250,000 13,051,097 887,238 4,188,442 1,273,540 926 0.056 0.056 0.056 0.056 145.10 1,213,986 463,058 0.3812007 250,000 13,186,668 846,479 4,132,257 1,287,607 929 0.049 0.049 0.049 0.049 56.91 1,002,076 899,758 0.8982008 250,000 13,809,808 843,933 4,022,997 1,324,945 1,056 0.052 0.052 0.052 0.052 99.53 1,153,545 633,672 0.5492009 250,000 13,121,416 867,455 4,476,894 1,164,397 980 0.040 0.040 0.040 0.040 43.99 818,516 522,700 0.6392010 250,000 13,423,319 853,583 4,542,567 1,277,194 885 0.037 0.037 0.037 0.037 90.54 822,692 762,760 0.9272011 250,000 13,640,271 865,203 4,308,000 1,552,960 1,022 0.043 0.043 0.043 0.043 63.75 936,935 429,340 0.4582012 250,000 12,034,407 665,644 4,718,159 1,148,715 866 0.024 0.024 0.024 0.024 126.29 555,965 320,423 0.576
2013 250,000 12,450,653 704,709 4,869,229 1,149,665 728 0.029 0.029 0.029 0.029 83.33 616,299 477,861 0.7752014 250,000 13,333,664 706,476 4,708,917 1,256,790 768 0.024 0.024 0.024 0.024 89.57 544,634 427,088 0.7842015 250,000 13,071,049 688,348 4,580,152 1,241,870 786 0.019 0.019 0.019 0.019 50.56 415,841 182,352 0.439
Total 8,080,488 5,119,011 0.634
Latest 3 Years 1,576,774 1,087,302 0.690
1. In calculating Pool average loss rates and actual member losses, individual claims are capped at $25,000, $50,000, $100,000, or $250,000 depending upon the number of miles driven each year. 2. Pool average loss rates in columns (7) through (11) are from Exhibit 8-4 and are capped at the loss limit presented in column (1). 3. Expected member losses in column (12) are the exposures in columns (2) through (6) multiplied by their respective loss rates in columns (7) through (11).
Description Explanation (1) Latest Relative Loss Experience: 0.690 Relative Loss Experience for Latest 3 Years from Column (13) above. (2) Prior Experience Modification Factor: 0.818 Experience modification factor from prior rate study. (3) Weight given to Latest Relative Loss Experience: 22.3% Based on size - larger members are more self-rated. (4) Weight given to Prior Experience Modification Factor: 77.7% 1-(3) (5) Off-Balance Adjustment: 1.027 An adjustment factor designed to ensure allocation of the full cost amount (6) Experience Modification Factor: 0.810 [(1)x(3) + (2)x(4)] x (5)
DRAFT
Exhibit 8-6Page 18 of 25
Washington State Transit Insurance PoolRate Assessment Calculation
Member: Pullman TransitRating Year: 2017
Assessment Calculation
Number of IndicatedExposure Experience Deductible Assessment
Rating Unit Units Base Rate Mod. Factor Factor (1)x(2)x(3)x(4)(1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
Fixed Route Mileage 324,500 0.1076 1.137 1.000 39,700Paratransit Mileage 68,300 0.1076 1.137 1.000 8,356
Vanpool Mileage 0 0.1076 1.137 1.000 0Admin Mileage 24,000 0.1076 1.137 1.000 2,936
Number of Employees 45 267.22 1.137 1.000 13,672Vehicle Insured Values (in hundreds) 0 0.3377 1.000 0.848 0
Property Insured Values (in hundreds) 0 0.1699 1.000 0.967 0Other Rating Cost Components 6,227 ** per Exhibit 8-5Prior Premium Audit Adjustment (650) ** per Exhibit 8-5
Total Indicated Assessment: 70,240
Mileage Mileage Mileage Mileage Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Actual Relative LossLoss Loss from from from from Number of Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Expected Member ExperienceYear Limit Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin Employees Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin FTEs Member Losses Losses (13)/(12)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14)
2006 25,000 294,503 59,873 0 0 36 0.029 0.029 0.029 0.029 50.02 12,235 16,478 1.3472007 25,000 310,817 62,176 0 0 29 0.026 0.026 0.026 0.026 23.99 10,308 939 0.0912008 25,000 304,019 63,900 0 29,585 29 0.025 0.025 0.025 0.025 47.51 11,147 34,720 3.1152009 25,000 318,728 63,506 0 30,721 45 0.023 0.023 0.023 0.023 21.18 10,469 30,873 2.9492010 25,000 337,805 75,795 0 27,408 44 0.020 0.020 0.020 0.020 27.07 10,065 49,551 4.9232011 25,000 341,128 60,000 0 30,000 45 0.018 0.018 0.018 0.018 16.68 8,413 30,818 3.6632012 25,000 326,108 65,898 0 0 46 0.014 0.014 0.014 0.014 32.69 6,911 3,940 0.570
2013 25,000 350,893 66,883 0 26,525 46 0.019 0.019 0.019 0.019 23.52 9,677 3,122 0.3232014 25,000 344,790 75,382 0 0 43 0.015 0.015 0.015 0.015 24.20 7,431 30,065 4.0462015 25,000 352,403 72,001 0 25,955 46 0.012 0.012 0.012 0.012 36.46 7,248 4,534 0.626
Total 93,906 205,040 2.183
Latest 3 Years 24,357 37,721 1.549
1. In calculating Pool average loss rates and actual member losses, individual claims are capped at $25,000, $50,000, $100,000, or $250,000 depending upon the number of miles driven each year. 2. Pool average loss rates in columns (7) through (11) are from Exhibit 8-4 and are capped at the loss limit presented in column (1). 3. Expected member losses in column (12) are the exposures in columns (2) through (6) multiplied by their respective loss rates in columns (7) through (11).
Description Explanation (1) Latest Relative Loss Experience: 1.549 Relative Loss Experience for Latest 3 Years from Column (13) above. (2) Prior Experience Modification Factor: 1.102 Experience modification factor from prior rate study. (3) Weight given to Latest Relative Loss Experience: 1.3% Based on size - larger members are more self-rated. (4) Weight given to Prior Experience Modification Factor: 98.7% 1-(3) (5) Off-Balance Adjustment: 1.027 An adjustment factor designed to ensure allocation of the full cost amount (6) Experience Modification Factor: 1.137 [(1)x(3) + (2)x(4)] x (5)
DRAFT
Exhibit 8-6Page 19 of 25
Washington State Transit Insurance PoolRate Assessment Calculation
Member: River Cities TransitRating Year: 2017
Assessment Calculation
Number of IndicatedExposure Experience Deductible Assessment
Rating Unit Units Base Rate Mod. Factor Factor (1)x(2)x(3)x(4)(1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
Fixed Route Mileage 375,000 0.1076 1.005 1.000 40,552Paratransit Mileage 217,000 0.1076 1.005 1.000 23,466
Vanpool Mileage 40,000 0.1076 1.005 1.000 4,326Admin Mileage 35,000 0.1076 1.005 1.000 3,785
Number of Employees 33 267.22 1.005 1.000 8,862Vehicle Insured Values (in hundreds) 35,779 0.3377 1.000 0.848 10,246
Property Insured Values (in hundreds) 5,335 0.1699 1.000 0.967 876Other Rating Cost Components 5,215 ** per Exhibit 8-5Prior Premium Audit Adjustment 8,442 ** per Exhibit 8-5
Total Indicated Assessment: 105,770
Mileage Mileage Mileage Mileage Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Actual Relative LossLoss Loss from from from from Number of Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Expected Member ExperienceYear Limit Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin Employees Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin FTEs Member Losses Losses (13)/(12)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14)
2006 25,000 215,200 0 0 1,721 16 0.029 0.029 0.029 0.029 50.02 7,188 1,056 0.1472007 25,000 216,715 0 0 1,312 16 0.026 0.026 0.026 0.026 23.99 6,003 0 0.0002008 25,000 215,766 0 0 3,317 16 0.025 0.025 0.025 0.025 47.51 6,145 611 0.0992009 25,000 216,235 170,630 0 1,707 16 0.023 0.023 0.023 0.023 21.18 9,293 1,434 0.1542010 25,000 218,708 0 0 4,786 18 0.020 0.020 0.020 0.020 27.07 4,985 5,755 1.1552011 25,000 260,000 0 0 2,000 20 0.018 0.018 0.018 0.018 16.68 4,990 1,697 0.3402012 25,000 227,023 193,549 0 14,539 24 0.014 0.014 0.014 0.014 32.69 6,786 248 0.037
2013 25,000 289,224 194,702 0 20,440 30 0.019 0.019 0.019 0.019 23.52 10,463 7,265 0.6942014 25,000 369,750 211,693 0 28,660 30 0.015 0.015 0.015 0.015 24.20 10,006 7,207 0.7202015 25,000 375,306 217,143 2,000 31,470 33 0.012 0.012 0.012 0.012 36.46 8,946 8,771 0.980
Total 74,804 34,045 0.455
Latest 3 Years 29,414 23,244 0.790
1. In calculating Pool average loss rates and actual member losses, individual claims are capped at $25,000, $50,000, $100,000, or $250,000 depending upon the number of miles driven each year. 2. Pool average loss rates in columns (7) through (11) are from Exhibit 8-4 and are capped at the loss limit presented in column (1). 3. Expected member losses in column (12) are the exposures in columns (2) through (6) multiplied by their respective loss rates in columns (7) through (11).
Description Explanation (1) Latest Relative Loss Experience: 0.790 Relative Loss Experience for Latest 3 Years from Column (13) above. (2) Prior Experience Modification Factor: 0.982 Experience modification factor from prior rate study. (3) Weight given to Latest Relative Loss Experience: 1.6% Based on size - larger members are more self-rated. (4) Weight given to Prior Experience Modification Factor: 98.4% 1-(3) (5) Off-Balance Adjustment: 1.027 An adjustment factor designed to ensure allocation of the full cost amount (6) Experience Modification Factor: 1.005 [(1)x(3) + (2)x(4)] x (5)
DRAFT
Exhibit 8-6Page 20 of 25
Washington State Transit Insurance PoolRate Assessment Calculation
Member: Skagit TransitRating Year: 2017
Assessment Calculation
Number of IndicatedExposure Experience Deductible Assessment
Rating Unit Units Base Rate Mod. Factor Factor (1)x(2)x(3)x(4)(1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
Fixed Route Mileage 1,288,022 0.1076 0.955 1.000 132,355Paratransit Mileage 424,000 0.1076 0.955 1.000 43,569
Vanpool Mileage 1,131,892 0.1076 0.955 1.000 116,311Admin Mileage 153,122 0.1076 0.955 1.000 15,735
Number of Employees 135 267.22 0.955 1.000 34,451Vehicle Insured Values (in hundreds) 66,053 0.3377 1.000 0.848 18,915
Property Insured Values (in hundreds) 233,734 0.1699 1.000 0.967 38,401Other Rating Cost Components 26,788 ** per Exhibit 8-5Prior Premium Audit Adjustment (13,486) ** per Exhibit 8-5
Total Indicated Assessment: 413,039
Mileage Mileage Mileage Mileage Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Actual Relative LossLoss Loss from from from from Number of Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Expected Member ExperienceYear Limit Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin Employees Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin FTEs Member Losses Losses (13)/(12)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14)
2006 50,000 619,976 299,300 493,057 99,140 80 0.039 0.039 0.039 0.039 78.76 64,827 46,584 0.7192007 50,000 715,402 325,439 626,975 106,553 88 0.034 0.034 0.034 0.034 41.79 64,273 4,685 0.0732008 50,000 705,411 341,638 742,851 104,548 91 0.032 0.032 0.032 0.032 72.36 67,929 1,758 0.0262009 50,000 792,915 403,000 817,292 98,773 114 0.028 0.028 0.028 0.028 26.77 61,352 65,515 1.0682010 50,000 858,659 438,710 749,217 101,988 101 0.026 0.026 0.026 0.026 43.93 59,616 74,912 1.2572011 50,000 878,208 476,440 755,592 110,919 106 0.024 0.024 0.024 0.024 21.91 55,138 2,840 0.0522012 50,000 1,027,819 379,884 933,137 158,481 109 0.017 0.017 0.017 0.017 54.81 48,031 6,031 0.126
2013 50,000 1,166,349 328,115 1,071,918 127,737 115 0.024 0.024 0.024 0.024 34.84 67,837 87,107 1.2842014 50,000 1,273,439 327,735 1,126,682 140,866 120 0.018 0.018 0.018 0.018 46.53 56,229 57,934 1.0302015 50,000 1,176,888 378,861 1,068,314 155,224 122 0.014 0.014 0.014 0.014 44.12 43,717 34,305 0.785
Total 588,950 381,671 0.648
Latest 3 Years 167,783 179,346 1.069
1. In calculating Pool average loss rates and actual member losses, individual claims are capped at $25,000, $50,000, $100,000, or $250,000 depending upon the number of miles driven each year. 2. Pool average loss rates in columns (7) through (11) are from Exhibit 8-4 and are capped at the loss limit presented in column (1). 3. Expected member losses in column (12) are the exposures in columns (2) through (6) multiplied by their respective loss rates in columns (7) through (11).
Description Explanation (1) Latest Relative Loss Experience: 1.069 Relative Loss Experience for Latest 3 Years from Column (13) above. (2) Prior Experience Modification Factor: 0.922 Experience modification factor from prior rate study. (3) Weight given to Latest Relative Loss Experience: 5.5% Based on size - larger members are more self-rated. (4) Weight given to Prior Experience Modification Factor: 94.5% 1-(3) (5) Off-Balance Adjustment: 1.027 An adjustment factor designed to ensure allocation of the full cost amount (6) Experience Modification Factor: 0.955 [(1)x(3) + (2)x(4)] x (5)
DRAFT
Exhibit 8-6Page 21 of 25
Washington State Transit Insurance PoolRate Assessment Calculation
Member: Spokane TransitRating Year: 2017
Assessment Calculation
Number of IndicatedExposure Experience Deductible Assessment
Rating Unit Units Base Rate Mod. Factor Factor (1)x(2)x(3)x(4)(1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
Fixed Route Mileage 6,090,435 0.1076 1.198 1.000 785,086Paratransit Mileage 1,417,913 0.1076 1.198 1.000 182,776
Vanpool Mileage 1,261,384 0.1076 1.198 1.000 162,598Admin Mileage 428,436 0.1076 1.198 1.000 55,227
Number of Employees 543 267.22 1.198 1.000 173,830Vehicle Insured Values (in hundreds) 310,963 0.3377 1.000 0.721 75,714
Property Insured Values (in hundreds) 846,545 0.1699 1.000 0.919 132,178Other Rating Cost Components 35,372 ** per Exhibit 8-5Prior Premium Audit Adjustment (22,638) ** per Exhibit 8-5
Total Indicated Assessment: 1,580,144
Mileage Mileage Mileage Mileage Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Actual Relative LossLoss Loss from from from from Number of Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Expected Member ExperienceYear Limit Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin Employees Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin FTEs Member Losses Losses (13)/(12)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14)
2006 100,000 6,056,478 1,512,773 613,615 317,061 510 0.047 0.047 0.047 0.047 111.21 457,386 427,196 0.9342007 100,000 6,193,382 1,305,017 814,262 346,771 522 0.041 0.041 0.041 0.041 56.91 384,889 288,565 0.7502008 100,000 6,235,562 1,481,129 1,012,136 443,227 547 0.041 0.041 0.041 0.041 91.96 429,570 352,472 0.8212009 100,000 6,307,479 1,455,799 1,015,322 368,532 555 0.033 0.033 0.033 0.033 37.19 317,960 245,607 0.7722010 100,000 6,287,438 1,362,977 907,418 374,192 540 0.032 0.032 0.032 0.032 57.74 312,713 367,596 1.1762011 100,000 5,720,000 1,282,206 888,699 368,532 528 0.031 0.031 0.031 0.031 32.37 276,502 362,466 1.3112012 100,000 5,807,094 1,378,111 1,192,508 420,505 525 0.020 0.020 0.020 0.020 90.11 221,049 166,942 0.755
2013 100,000 5,805,943 2,856,000 1,126,943 432,096 526 0.027 0.027 0.027 0.027 57.46 308,416 523,005 1.6962014 100,000 5,911,102 1,486,461 1,174,536 431,708 527 0.020 0.020 0.020 0.020 76.99 224,117 530,400 2.3672015 100,000 5,944,531 1,483,057 1,114,100 444,040 539 0.016 0.016 0.016 0.016 50.56 169,809 231,474 1.363
Total 3,102,411 3,495,723 1.127
Latest 3 Years 702,343 1,284,879 1.829
1. In calculating Pool average loss rates and actual member losses, individual claims are capped at $25,000, $50,000, $100,000, or $250,000 depending upon the number of miles driven each year. 2. Pool average loss rates in columns (7) through (11) are from Exhibit 8-4 and are capped at the loss limit presented in column (1). 3. Expected member losses in column (12) are the exposures in columns (2) through (6) multiplied by their respective loss rates in columns (7) through (11).
Description Explanation (1) Latest Relative Loss Experience: 1.829 Relative Loss Experience for Latest 3 Years from Column (13) above. (2) Prior Experience Modification Factor: 1.069 Experience modification factor from prior rate study. (3) Weight given to Latest Relative Loss Experience: 12.9% Based on size - larger members are more self-rated. (4) Weight given to Prior Experience Modification Factor: 87.1% 1-(3) (5) Off-Balance Adjustment: 1.027 An adjustment factor designed to ensure allocation of the full cost amount (6) Experience Modification Factor: 1.198 [(1)x(3) + (2)x(4)] x (5)
DRAFT
Exhibit 8-6Page 22 of 25
Washington State Transit Insurance PoolRate Assessment Calculation
Member: Twin TransitRating Year: 2017
Assessment Calculation
Number of IndicatedExposure Experience Deductible Assessment
Rating Unit Units Base Rate Mod. Factor Factor (1)x(2)x(3)x(4)(1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
Fixed Route Mileage 281,944 0.1076 1.059 1.000 32,127Paratransit Mileage 65,910 0.1076 1.059 1.000 7,510
Vanpool Mileage 0 0.1076 1.059 1.000 0Admin Mileage 16,000 0.1076 1.059 1.000 1,823
Number of Employees 28 267.22 1.059 1.000 7,924Vehicle Insured Values (in hundreds) 12,650 0.3377 1.000 0.848 3,623
Property Insured Values (in hundreds) 34,392 0.1699 1.000 0.967 5,650Other Rating Cost Components 2,864 ** per Exhibit 8-5Prior Premium Audit Adjustment (7,716) ** per Exhibit 8-5
Total Indicated Assessment: 53,805
Mileage Mileage Mileage Mileage Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Actual Relative LossLoss Loss from from from from Number of Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Expected Member ExperienceYear Limit Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin Employees Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin FTEs Member Losses Losses (13)/(12)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14)
2006 25,000 356,757 48,617 0 5,576 26 0.029 0.029 0.029 0.029 50.02 13,401 1,938 0.1452007 25,000 357,416 51,412 0 500 26 0.026 0.026 0.026 0.026 23.99 11,173 26,762 2.3952008 25,000 401,984 51,627 0 2,480 28 0.025 0.025 0.025 0.025 47.51 12,540 7,685 0.6132009 25,000 319,167 50,291 0 3,582 27 0.023 0.023 0.023 0.023 21.18 9,168 8,277 0.9032010 25,000 391,655 48,261 0 3,523 26 0.020 0.020 0.020 0.020 27.07 9,627 312 0.0322011 25,000 435,868 55,000 0 3,500 28 0.018 0.018 0.018 0.018 16.68 9,254 25,000 2.7022012 25,000 351,701 42,967 0 9,501 30 0.014 0.014 0.014 0.014 32.69 6,556 95 0.014
2013 25,000 356,237 44,627 0 11,094 27 0.019 0.019 0.019 0.019 23.52 8,604 15,144 1.7602014 25,000 366,182 62,565 0 5,499 28 0.015 0.015 0.015 0.015 24.20 7,283 13,360 1.8352015 25,000 285,542 61,658 0 15,856 28 0.012 0.012 0.012 0.012 36.46 5,512 1,041 0.189
Total 93,117 99,613 1.070
Latest 3 Years 21,399 29,545 1.381
1. In calculating Pool average loss rates and actual member losses, individual claims are capped at $25,000, $50,000, $100,000, or $250,000 depending upon the number of miles driven each year. 2. Pool average loss rates in columns (7) through (11) are from Exhibit 8-4 and are capped at the loss limit presented in column (1). 3. Expected member losses in column (12) are the exposures in columns (2) through (6) multiplied by their respective loss rates in columns (7) through (11).
Description Explanation (1) Latest Relative Loss Experience: 1.381 Relative Loss Experience for Latest 3 Years from Column (13) above. (2) Prior Experience Modification Factor: 1.027 Experience modification factor from prior rate study. (3) Weight given to Latest Relative Loss Experience: 1.3% Based on size - larger members are more self-rated. (4) Weight given to Prior Experience Modification Factor: 98.7% 1-(3) (5) Off-Balance Adjustment: 1.027 An adjustment factor designed to ensure allocation of the full cost amount (6) Experience Modification Factor: 1.059 [(1)x(3) + (2)x(4)] x (5)
DRAFT
Exhibit 8-6Page 23 of 25
Washington State Transit Insurance PoolRate Assessment Calculation
Member: Valley TransitRating Year: 2017
Assessment Calculation
Number of IndicatedExposure Experience Deductible Assessment
Rating Unit Units Base Rate Mod. Factor Factor (1)x(2)x(3)x(4)(1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
Fixed Route Mileage 376,000 0.1076 1.066 1.000 43,128Paratransit Mileage 164,000 0.1076 1.066 1.000 18,811
Vanpool Mileage 70,000 0.1076 1.066 1.000 8,029Admin Mileage 5,000 0.1076 1.066 1.000 574
Number of Employees 27 267.22 1.066 1.000 7,691Vehicle Insured Values (in hundreds) 25,090 0.3377 1.000 0.848 7,185
Property Insured Values (in hundreds) 72,230 0.1699 1.000 0.967 11,867Other Rating Cost Components 7,684 ** per Exhibit 8-5Prior Premium Audit Adjustment (984) ** per Exhibit 8-5
Total Indicated Assessment: 103,985
Mileage Mileage Mileage Mileage Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Actual Relative LossLoss Loss from from from from Number of Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Expected Member ExperienceYear Limit Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin Employees Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin FTEs Member Losses Losses (13)/(12)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14)
2006 25,000 281,579 154,527 0 28,088 47 0.029 0.029 0.029 0.029 50.02 16,019 3,337 0.2082007 25,000 239,864 202,148 0 34,530 48 0.026 0.026 0.026 0.026 23.99 13,433 7,172 0.5342008 25,000 303,329 169,821 2,188 29,730 49 0.025 0.025 0.025 0.025 47.51 14,741 32,665 2.2162009 25,000 316,976 148,139 25,043 36,731 47 0.023 0.023 0.023 0.023 21.18 13,137 3,214 0.2452010 25,000 316,557 154,289 56,761 36,895 48 0.020 0.020 0.020 0.020 27.07 12,659 348 0.0272011 25,000 318,000 152,000 57,642 35,000 49 0.018 0.018 0.018 0.018 16.68 10,818 58,764 5.4322012 25,000 360,981 155,544 61,149 37,959 49 0.014 0.014 0.014 0.014 32.69 10,094 1,328 0.132
2013 25,000 351,899 162,987 66,629 39,448 50 0.019 0.019 0.019 0.019 23.52 13,189 12,671 0.9612014 25,000 362,526 164,686 74,017 27,274 54 0.015 0.015 0.015 0.015 24.20 10,866 7,493 0.6902015 25,000 310,448 189,664 63,624 50,701 55 0.012 0.012 0.012 0.012 36.46 9,606 14,497 1.509
Total 124,561 141,490 1.136
Latest 3 Years 33,661 34,661 1.030
1. In calculating Pool average loss rates and actual member losses, individual claims are capped at $25,000, $50,000, $100,000, or $250,000 depending upon the number of miles driven each year. 2. Pool average loss rates in columns (7) through (11) are from Exhibit 8-4 and are capped at the loss limit presented in column (1). 3. Expected member losses in column (12) are the exposures in columns (2) through (6) multiplied by their respective loss rates in columns (7) through (11).
Description Explanation (1) Latest Relative Loss Experience: 1.030 Relative Loss Experience for Latest 3 Years from Column (13) above. (2) Prior Experience Modification Factor: 1.038 Experience modification factor from prior rate study. (3) Weight given to Latest Relative Loss Experience: 1.9% Based on size - larger members are more self-rated. (4) Weight given to Prior Experience Modification Factor: 98.1% 1-(3) (5) Off-Balance Adjustment: 1.027 An adjustment factor designed to ensure allocation of the full cost amount (6) Experience Modification Factor: 1.066 [(1)x(3) + (2)x(4)] x (5)
DRAFT
Exhibit 8-6Page 24 of 25
Washington State Transit Insurance PoolRate Assessment Calculation
Member: Whatcom TransitRating Year: 2017
Assessment Calculation
Number of IndicatedExposure Experience Deductible Assessment
Rating Unit Units Base Rate Mod. Factor Factor (1)x(2)x(3)x(4)(1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
Fixed Route Mileage 2,244,170 0.1076 0.925 1.000 223,362Paratransit Mileage 1,002,930 0.1076 0.925 1.000 99,822
Vanpool Mileage 661,200 0.1076 0.925 1.000 65,809Admin Mileage 204,000 0.1076 0.925 1.000 20,304
Number of Employees 246 267.22 0.925 1.000 60,806Vehicle Insured Values (in hundreds) 167,452 0.3377 1.000 0.848 47,953
Property Insured Values (in hundreds) 207,221 0.1699 1.000 0.967 34,045Other Rating Cost Components 36,308 ** per Exhibit 8-5Prior Premium Audit Adjustment 7,432 ** per Exhibit 8-5
Total Indicated Assessment: 595,841
Mileage Mileage Mileage Mileage Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Actual Relative LossLoss Loss from from from from Number of Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Expected Member ExperienceYear Limit Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin Employees Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin FTEs Member Losses Losses (13)/(12)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14)
2006 50,000 1,630,780 964,312 574,264 176,167 226 0.039 0.039 0.039 0.039 78.76 147,343 122,955 0.8342007 50,000 1,859,419 871,503 571,018 187,036 232 0.034 0.034 0.034 0.034 41.79 128,846 90,365 0.7012008 50,000 2,171,946 840,400 537,339 209,966 232 0.032 0.032 0.032 0.032 72.36 138,530 58,206 0.4202009 50,000 2,168,831 873,021 640,287 196,731 235 0.028 0.028 0.028 0.028 26.77 113,365 16,988 0.1502010 50,000 1,853,845 783,503 664,762 177,089 207 0.026 0.026 0.026 0.026 43.93 98,445 57,784 0.5872011 50,000 1,646,970 765,000 721,199 200,000 205 0.024 0.024 0.024 0.024 21.91 83,748 53,158 0.6352012 50,000 1,771,998 784,069 687,091 180,824 218 0.017 0.017 0.017 0.017 54.81 69,566 16,851 0.242
2013 50,000 1,777,273 834,706 693,971 198,536 220 0.024 0.024 0.024 0.024 34.84 90,695 67,843 0.7482014 50,000 1,983,230 901,076 589,493 202,829 227 0.018 0.018 0.018 0.018 46.53 75,471 58,148 0.7702015 50,000 2,031,977 944,418 518,812 198,378 229 0.014 0.014 0.014 0.014 44.12 61,048 45,052 0.738
Total 1,007,057 587,350 0.583
Latest 3 Years 227,214 171,043 0.753
1. In calculating Pool average loss rates and actual member losses, individual claims are capped at $25,000, $50,000, $100,000, or $250,000 depending upon the number of miles driven each year. 2. Pool average loss rates in columns (7) through (11) are from Exhibit 8-4 and are capped at the loss limit presented in column (1). 3. Expected member losses in column (12) are the exposures in columns (2) through (6) multiplied by their respective loss rates in columns (7) through (11).
Description Explanation (1) Latest Relative Loss Experience: 0.753 Relative Loss Experience for Latest 3 Years from Column (13) above. (2) Prior Experience Modification Factor: 0.912 Experience modification factor from prior rate study. (3) Weight given to Latest Relative Loss Experience: 7.2% Based on size - larger members are more self-rated. (4) Weight given to Prior Experience Modification Factor: 92.8% 1-(3) (5) Off-Balance Adjustment: 1.027 An adjustment factor designed to ensure allocation of the full cost amount (6) Experience Modification Factor: 0.925 [(1)x(3) + (2)x(4)] x (5)
DRAFT
Exhibit 8-6Page 25 of 25
Washington State Transit Insurance PoolRate Assessment Calculation
Member: Yakima TransitRating Year: 2017
Assessment Calculation
Number of IndicatedExposure Experience Deductible Assessment
Rating Unit Units Base Rate Mod. Factor Factor (1)x(2)x(3)x(4)(1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
Fixed Route Mileage 721,614 0.1076 1.156 1.000 89,758Paratransit Mileage 360,714 0.1076 1.156 1.000 44,868
Vanpool Mileage 250,762 0.1076 1.156 1.000 31,191Admin Mileage 39,564 0.1076 1.156 1.000 4,921
Number of Employees 61 267.22 1.156 1.000 18,843Vehicle Insured Values (in hundreds) 69,373 0.3377 1.000 0.848 19,866
Property Insured Values (in hundreds) 0 0.1699 1.000 0.967 0Other Rating Cost Components 11,013 ** per Exhibit 8-5Prior Premium Audit Adjustment (20,860) ** per Exhibit 8-5
Total Indicated Assessment: 199,601
Mileage Mileage Mileage Mileage Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Pool Avg. Actual Relative LossLoss Loss from from from from Number of Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Loss Rate Expected Member ExperienceYear Limit Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin Employees Fixed Route Paratransit Vanpool Admin FTEs Member Losses Losses (13)/(12)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14)
2006 50,000 747,930 222,248 272,671 29,859 53 0.039 0.039 0.039 0.039 78.76 53,455 22,633 0.4232007 50,000 793,648 243,117 392,089 262,569 69 0.034 0.034 0.034 0.034 41.79 60,647 29,518 0.4872008 50,000 830,645 547,706 535,148 97,370 74 0.032 0.032 0.032 0.032 72.36 70,469 9,698 0.1382009 50,000 736,034 300,042 475,879 303,787 65 0.028 0.028 0.028 0.028 26.77 51,863 63,399 1.2222010 50,000 837,875 472,651 545,229 38,423 63 0.026 0.026 0.026 0.026 43.93 51,413 212,200 4.1272011 50,000 846,218 485,116 638,246 59,220 75 0.024 0.024 0.024 0.024 21.91 49,884 18,878 0.3782012 50,000 850,858 431,586 579,887 42,331 71 0.017 0.017 0.017 0.017 54.81 35,942 56,996 1.586
2013 50,000 1,065,145 466,291 462,706 45,007 55 0.024 0.024 0.024 0.024 34.84 50,229 89,942 1.7912014 50,000 727,350 461,578 383,121 77,529 55 0.018 0.018 0.018 0.018 46.53 31,681 17,839 0.5632015 50,000 729,745 418,529 343,317 38,186 59 0.014 0.014 0.014 0.014 44.12 23,703 14,710 0.621
Total 479,287 535,814 1.118
Latest 3 Years 105,613 122,491 1.160
1. In calculating Pool average loss rates and actual member losses, individual claims are capped at $25,000, $50,000, $100,000, or $250,000 depending upon the number of miles driven each year. 2. Pool average loss rates in columns (7) through (11) are from Exhibit 8-4 and are capped at the loss limit presented in column (1). 3. Expected member losses in column (12) are the exposures in columns (2) through (6) multiplied by their respective loss rates in columns (7) through (11).
Description Explanation (1) Latest Relative Loss Experience: 1.160 Relative Loss Experience for Latest 3 Years from Column (13) above. (2) Prior Experience Modification Factor: 1.124 Experience modification factor from prior rate study. (3) Weight given to Latest Relative Loss Experience: 4.0% Based on size - larger members are more self-rated. (4) Weight given to Prior Experience Modification Factor: 96.0% 1-(3) (5) Off-Balance Adjustment: 1.027 An adjustment factor designed to ensure allocation of the full cost amount (6) Experience Modification Factor: 1.156 [(1)x(3) + (2)x(4)] x (5)
DRAFT
RAF: 10/31/1612/11/2015
Employment Agreement Executive Director
This employment agreement between the Board of the Washington State Transit Insurance Pool (Pool) and the Executive Director Allen F. Hatten (Executive Director) is set forth as follows: Section 1. Duties and Responsibilities The duties and responsibilities of the Executive Director shall be in accordance with the goals, objectives, policies, and plans established by the Pool Board. Section 2. Hours of Work The Executive Director shall work an unscheduled workweek. The Executive Director is entitled to establish his working hours as those required to accomplish the necessary business of managing the Pool. Section 3. Termination A. Termination without Cause
The Board has the right to terminate the Executive Director from employment without cause. Termination without cause of the Executive Director shall require a majority vote of all members of the Pool Board of Directors, both present and absent. Such termination may either be effective immediately, or may take effect up to 180 days after the date of notice to the Executive Director. Regardless of the effective date of the termination, during the180-day period, the salary and benefits paid to the Executive Director shall continue.
B. Termination with Cause
The Board has the right to immediately terminate the Executive Director from employment for any, dishonest, or illegal conduct on his part. In addition, the Executive Director may be terminated for failure to perform the duties of his position.
Section 4. Salary The salary of the Executive Director for 20176 shall be $173,351 plus the percentage salary increase provided to other Pool employees for 2017. The monthly salary for 2018 shall be the salary for 2017 plus the percentage salary increase provided to other Pool employees for 2018 . Salary payments are subject to withholding and other deductions as authorized and required by law. Section 5. Employee Benefits/Leave of Absence/Travel and Related Expenses The Pool shall provide Employee Benefits, Leave of Absence, Holidays, Travel and Related Expenses as provided in the WSTIP Emplyee Handbook. General leave shall be based on the maximum allowable accrual approved by the Board pursuant to the WSTIP Employee Handbook.
12/1109/2015 2016 Employment Agreement Page 2 Executive Director The Executive Director shall be allowed an additional 10 days of personal leave for each year of this agreement. Section 6. Life / Disability Benefits – (Exception to the WSTIP Employee Handbook) The Pool shall pay the premiums for term life insurance for the Executive Director with limits of three times his annual salary. The Pool shall pay the premium for disability insurance for the Executive Director with the monthly benefit in the amount of his net monthly salary with a 60-day waiting period. Section 7. Other Terms, Conditions of Employment, and General Provisions The Executive Director shall be an employee of the Pool and not an independent Contractor. Such employment shall be on a full time basis. The Board shall fix any such terms and conditions as it may determine from time to time relating to the performance of the Executive Director, provided such terms and conditions are not inconsistent or in conflict with the provisions of this agreement. This agreement shall become effective January 1, 20176, except as otherwise noted herein, and shall continue through MarchDecember 31, 20187. Section 8. Optional Contract Extension. The parties may extend this agreement for three (3) 30 day periods, not to exceed 90 days commencing on 401/01/2018. Section 9. Hold Harmless Agreement. The Pool shall hold harmless and defend the Executive Director against all claims and suits arising from his employment: Provided this obligation to hold harmless and defend shall not extend to any alleged criminal or intended acts by the Executive Director. In witness whereof, the Board of the Pool and the Executive Director have signed and executed this Employment Agreement effective except as otherwise noted herein, on this ____ day of ____________ 20165. _________________________________ _____________________________ Allen F. Hatten President WSTIP _________________________________ _____________________________ Date Date
RAF: 10/31/16
Employment Agreement Executive Director
This employment agreement between the Board of the Washington State Transit Insurance Pool (Pool) and the Executive Director Allen F. Hatten (Executive Director) is set forth as follows: Section 1. Duties and Responsibilities The duties and responsibilities of the Executive Director shall be in accordance with the goals, objectives, policies, and plans established by the Pool Board. Section 2. Hours of Work The Executive Director shall work an unscheduled workweek. The Executive Director is entitled to establish his working hours as those required to accomplish the necessary business of managing the Pool. Section 3. Termination A. Termination without Cause
The Board has the right to terminate the Executive Director from employment without cause. Termination without cause of the Executive Director shall require a majority vote of all members of the Pool Board of Directors, both present and absent. Such termination may either be effective immediately, or may take effect up to 180 days after the date of notice to the Executive Director. Regardless of the effective date of the termination, during the180-day period, the salary and benefits paid to the Executive Director shall continue.
B. Termination with Cause
The Board has the right to immediately terminate the Executive Director from employment for any, dishonest, or illegal conduct on his part. In addition, the Executive Director may be terminated for failure to perform the duties of his position.
Section 4. Salary The salary of the Executive Director for 2017 shall be $173,351 plus the percentage salary increase provided to other Pool employees for 2017. The monthly salary for 2018 shall be the salary for 2017 plus the percentage salary increase provided to other Pool employees for 2018. Salary payments are subject to withholding and other deductions as authorized and required by law. Section 5. Employee Benefits/Leave of Absence/Travel and Related Expenses The Pool shall provide Employee Benefits, Leave of Absence, Holidays, Travel and Related Expenses as provided in the WSTIP Emplyee Handbook. General leave shall be based on the maximum allowable accrual approved by the Board pursuant to the WSTIP Employee Handbook.
12/09/2016 Employment Agreement Page 2 Executive Director
The Executive Director shall be allowed an additional 10 days of personal leave for each year of this agreement. Section 6. Life / Disability Benefits – (Exception to the WSTIP Employee Handbook) The Pool shall pay the premiums for term life insurance for the Executive Director with limits of three times his annual salary. The Pool shall pay the premium for disability insurance for the Executive Director with the monthly benefit in the amount of his net monthly salary with a 60-day waiting period. Section 7. Other Terms, Conditions of Employment, and General Provisions The Executive Director shall be an employee of the Pool and not an independent Contractor. Such employment shall be on a full time basis. The Board shall fix any such terms and conditions as it may determine from time to time relating to the performance of the Executive Director, provided such terms and conditions are not inconsistent or in conflict with the provisions of this agreement. This agreement shall become effective January 1, 2017, except as otherwise noted herein, and shall continue through March 31, 2018. Section 8. Optional Contract Extension. The parties may extend this agreement for three (3) 30 day periods, not to exceed 90 days commencing on 4/01/2018. Section 9. Hold Harmless Agreement. The Pool shall hold harmless and defend the Executive Director against all claims and suits arising from his employment: Provided this obligation to hold harmless and defend shall not extend to any alleged criminal or intended acts by the Executive Director. In witness whereof, the Board of the Pool and the Executive Director have signed and executed this Employment Agreement effective except as otherwise noted herein, on this ____ day of ____________ 2016. _________________________________ _____________________________ Allen F. Hatten President WSTIP _________________________________ _____________________________ Date Date