afs group v chairperson of the tender board.reasons .a55-11.schimming-chase,aj

63
REPORTABLE CASE NO: A 55/2011 IN THE HIGH COURT OF NAMIBIA In the matter between: AFS GROUP NAMIBIA (PTY) LTD APPLICANT and CHAIRPERSON OF THE TENDER BOARD OF NAMIBIA 1 st RESPONDENT MINISTER OF WORKS AND TRANSPORT 2 nd RESPONDENT PERMANENT SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF WORKS AND TRANSPORT 3 rd RESPONDENT DPF ENERGY AND MINERALS (PTY) LTD 4 th RESPONDENT PC CENTRE (PTY) LTD 5 th RESPONDENT NAVAYUGA INFOTECH AFRICA (PTY) LTD 6 th RESPONDENT NAM SECURE TECHNOLOGI ES (PTY) LTD 7 th RESPONDENT NAMCOR PETROLEUM TRADING AND DISTRIBUTIO N (PTY) LTD 8 th RESPONDENT PETROTEK NAMIBIA (PTY) LTD 9 th RESPONDENT

Upload: andre-le-roux

Post on 07-Apr-2018

220 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 1/63

Page 2: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 2/63

Page 3: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 3/63

Page 4: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 4/63

Page 5: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 5/63

Page 6: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 6/63

Page 7: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 7/63

Page 8: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 8/63

Page 9: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 9/63

Page 10: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 10/63

Page 11: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 11/63

Page 12: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 12/63

Page 13: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 13/63

Page 14: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 14/63

Page 15: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 15/63

Page 16: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 16/63

Page 17: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 17/63

Page 18: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 18/63

Page 19: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 19/63

Page 20: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 20/63

Page 21: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 21/63

Page 22: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 22/63

Page 23: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 23/63

Page 24: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 24/63

Page 25: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 25/63

Page 26: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 26/63

Page 27: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 27/63

Page 28: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 28/63

Page 29: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 29/63

Page 30: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 30/63

Page 31: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 31/63

Page 32: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 32/63

Page 33: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 33/63

Page 34: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 34/63

Page 35: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 35/63

Page 36: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 36/63

Page 37: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 37/63

Page 38: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 38/63

Page 39: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 39/63

Page 40: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 40/63

Page 41: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 41/63

Page 42: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 42/63

Page 43: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 43/63

Page 44: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 44/63

Page 45: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 45/63

Page 46: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 46/63

Page 47: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 47/63

Page 48: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 48/63

Page 49: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 49/63

Page 50: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 50/63

Page 51: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 51/63

Page 52: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 52/63

Page 53: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 53/63

Page 54: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 54/63

Page 55: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 55/63

Page 56: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 56/63

Page 57: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 57/63

Page 58: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 58/63

Page 59: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 59/63

Page 60: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 60/63

Page 61: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 61/63

Page 62: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 62/63

Page 63: AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

8/6/2019 AFS Group v Chairperson of the Tender Board.reasons .A55-11.Schimming-Chase,AJ

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/afs-group-v-chairperson-of-the-tender-boardreasons-a55-11schimming-chaseaj 63/63