T

:,.,..:". ,::

:',;:.;..i;....:..-.':-i-'-:-.:.,::.:t i::.1 :-.-..''.:-.::..:'-,.,,;-ir:'...r- ::-r:r-: jJ j: :-,.-.:.:. , "!:::.:.'.. -:..-.-:: j t.t- .V{]"

tsEF.'oRE ?fi-E HoRoT*:i* rlro* ccuRT cF '{ERAI,A

. i ER$AX{{rLA-S,t ,

\!

.. :, F;:p:{,g1.,.Wo,..ggAg! 6f2ebr; ';

z a:.i'.4' ":. .-a

-"

t' a .aa€:

:

.. -; : - : ! :: e *

; Feliiiqner,

i Respondehts,:

Ie..Gt*

n€

:l tt 1:a::' ' :

4l:;:..1,.:

a1a-'a:

. : :..::::I1::' . i .-i;:f'' :i; :

. ,:],'

'] :ii ':..'-

' : : l :::7::-r:l:- it!,: .

] l. ::,'..:,::.

: ',,.;i': .

: . :tl:-i'.

' :::Lli'

: '. :. ]-.|i:.::'g;.}

'.-:r:i.:9., .

F€*S'*{TEts.EEE Hicii CCUA? GFA? ERi{AI{ULA}I

W.P.{C} No. g389t of 2009 b..'

KERJx3"A

Petitioner

Ir{.*Ex',

;:::, ._ 1_--

:iii.n:iti

:lijj: J-r

.}jrr?i;

Itnii

'

*=:EE*

EE,5CFE TH= ::CliC-,J-F,g;LE HI,GH CCLin; C.F :iiFJ;AtrRg-&{tlt6-?,-{

;s.=.ici }fe. GBS9 tr *{ ZAB9.

| ! ati:r.:r. uICiilS.f,i&

n--t .i',..DarrKat-a j\aral,anelt & Oi_s: ..--

. :-Fgijtioner

\ : Ke-cpondents

ys-

$tale:::e:s*, *tr*:i &l€::ee,& t {-&

DG

: e..{ 'ar- .:qj; ij a L-; I

$ureax Cen ir:lre;.F*Ft .c f F.: j:+=T* egese..Ernal:r:ta'

o::1hle .Cb::rtl

I

I

I

I

I

I

2

. T-'t,P -:'?.4

'L'- DepU[' $f:-"e:;i'r-j'la']l ' l'- :'-L"'

respcndenr' ur' nr- +.^k .:: ,&rsc oifrces ci

authorised tc conduc+' a s-utpnse u;:L!r! =*- !-4 ^i Thrissur" AccorC'nglY' orl

Ccmmercia-i Tax DepartrnelrL at aforesaici 4

18.3.O9 he conducted :It*t-:

ctrecks in ttie

Commercia-l Tax of{ices with the assistanct "{":':1,:t::r,t1:,.r -

^fl-rcer sri. v.v. Joby, Dr,rg ttt"ot-"": -_^ Q,,1_,Agricuiturar v+ . , .. _ Officers ingluding

p,olice Sgb: rri rqin ottte1.,,FOhCe Vlltuu!r ,'*:^ -.i_JoShflbrtd' certar.rl' uu+"i : * .'-.-

-^, ^..-, =i:bies, : 'fhe su'p'..se

. -^ r: "A:' i-t-'nSiables aj1ci'-Li:rbLau'-v-''--':'*:-:t"

--, .o*a-="t.-*'b)''tle 't?r:'ee'ftea;--irs E *i- :J-:': :-rchecks L'ere u

-.: . _:- -.=-

htelligence Corqrnercia; Tax ofiices *'l -r i:=5:u- "

. 1' Ofiice of the Inteiiigence

Tax'West Fort' Thrissur' ' ^-rIax OITicer [Works'Contrac*'

ar"2' Office oj :- . n

Luxury Taxi' 'V{es''- Fort' Thrissur'-'

'Tax Offrcer' Circle'l' Alryaatnole'3- Olflce of the Commerclal -

t

0u")-

buiidi::gs, the fci.iowing sigr boarcis in English a;:d

Ttce Gf TiTorLeV at g'rtsir,IaJayalam:" - Liei

are ci'rne- R'ei;ori rnty stc?zinsta*ce ta 1ligilonce anCAnta '

€orrtptt.an Bx g:*" +::,"11T :::;r.fr ffi ::;: "

Vigilance Ofiicials. This is nol see".,.

:e-xhibited 'by the Coremerciaj ,Tax Clfice {lntelligence}

:1:.

-_

{^.r. -::r..s:1 .rf r}: 3'r-.-e].ngt1lt:cash Bock rna:fitEineo-}n ' ' ' ' '

'L1j i ir': -

..:

. '::::.:'

i;: '.l::. :.

iE':'

ian '.::::::. r ''E4 .

?i

4=?::5t

trFB4aFsFE{fIIt-i ,-I ,-,i'i'

beio:e l"u:: b;. ,J:e i-ig,iarce T.a:T.: intir,"a::r-., :Ol S_.;:rr*':-rdha;r, pCs phirip, Shoby and Seresb- The ab*veamonni "'i/as founii ro be Rs" s5oGf -" -w]ntc"h has beenp

seizeC.

4' In the possession of smt..K.N. usha, commercial Tai Inspector'

, of the commerciai Tax office {works contract a'rl L'xury Ta"},iound an. amount of Rs., 500/.

^" rrffornted money, r,rhich has

A)'

.J.

'..'.:'Cut cl the.40 stafl available i;: r-he nffinc r,{ t-t - T.3.r- r.-'t-- -'e

dgilarr-ce

, 1. . .

, rernpjoJegF ai-q.see&,sigftied,in the.Aiteed:;.nce Fredsrer- Dur:r:e.- .-. ? .---- - ----^--" l;rspectici-r, ha haC noticgd,these i::regr:ia;ites a_:rc i.i,e IAC wau

, ,,, urlatle to gr*e any: Ceaa;te answei'rega:-ding the noR-avaijabiiilyof {he stalrwho had not signed in r}e Attenda::r-e pecjsfe- nnieven-leavelmarked. lt'hislt.s happened'because of the iack oi._----supervision' corrmitted by: iAc sri,-:Jaya Naldakumar ovei. his:,..stalf members.

,6- ;lt,is subndtted ttrat on the basis'of .the above. aforemen-r_ioned. :: ;.:l:ii;r1:.,:1-i,-:-1.:_ _ t

:.:'=- i

(2) It js ragarnsi

-cr-i. c.K. l"o**ooea to initjate . ,cieparr;, F

*: J:.^T:.: * .! ,ii

*il?; ';-.: ;::.:,:::'1- if illarrttal'n:ns th",..;l :

'", u':e'1ash book,?rficu-, *, . ,.Yi

," . '' Y , ,--t Yvr-{i ej-lc aiun i'l-*4rrl oa-'arcb-

. ..-::: qr:e.CCOUIlted CaSh

...: .

Rs-

Rs-

tts.

Rs-

rP.s,

127A/=

7ea/_

s'goy-

4+t/_aJOAi_

']:

\

ihe T.ax Cificers by hira,,-',...ie hari fur,rl:er stated *:ai he hadproper$ e:r'-*lained *r*t-€! to iie iicn,bie lvriclister about a-r?

the quar-ies rnade by the,isnble Minister...t.9' lt is most respectfuily.subinitted that the Director, rrl*i1*r.-

and Anti*corruption Bureau,. Thiruvananthapurarn hacifo.varded a petition of Sri. p- Sasidharan, T.C-25i2945, MMRA

:

82 : Dhar*adesam La'e, ivlaroor Road, Thiruvanaxinapurarn.' under',Right-,ib infoination a.t ,, to:*j'orfitc*tior'Lr :"rring,e€;, .':

,,-de.tai1s,;?f .t}:e arcsesaid sgipiise check cendljctei, bi. rilr€ 4, ofiices of Commercial Tax Eepa-rtmenl, ,Thissur cr* l.g:_q.09-'.,'''.:':'::..-..:';,:.:.

sfo.rc= ri:e s-::ipnse ckt*cks ,$,ere conducted b3- the Depuq.,supeintendent of Foiice; the ?ri responcient under hisIeadership and s-upewision, the, :above said request ri,as

.l

forrn-arcidd to hipr'for furnishing thE cietails required by theapplicant under, the Right to Information Act on 23.g.ag-Accordingly, tJ:el Z* ,e"pgndent, ttre Oy.S.e. forwarded hisreport No. T. tglS-lO9/fS-R dateA 2,4.9.A9 to rpy oflice and_in: :...,tri''r, {he

=11: was fo-::*@ed to.the,,p-irgcto1,:Vigi,ance and

r ' 'j. --

j. '.. ... .: - :., r

i.

\l-

a

?qr,as,,per m3f :letter:

i

{'I

I:T

,:'1

-.he above ir:fonnatian iu.--eg**re L,y: ihe Siate Pubic Inlcrmaliorr'

--:"i-"':Cificer l'las fac',-rla1ly inco#' ,r. The oniy iacident vas thai Sil." ----.";:i'' - )P-C- Rcbert, CorlrmerctaJi.{1a-x Inspector {WC & LTi ivas seen

halding o-./ei .*ir"rr.ir'iilt"* j:: a foLd.ed malner to Sr,Salthosh Narayanan, arr. €i,npioiree of Hoiei Kanocs Resiciency,

- "":G;r.rv-ayoorj' whicti toa*.:..i. Ased-,tiy. ilre"above inentione{i

thb'D...g fylsnp. u51ai*itof poiic€,'the 7tr':rCsFJrident axd it,t.

rri{circ,atioi1, ma;l.bg,,becAu5E oi t.I:e faci that he w-as on h-ansfe; --- .:-. .: .'... -., ..;- -' J: , .. -.,-.:: ..: ,1..i.--::.*-.:.:-;--..-:-;:. iii,..:r.?y-.,-:i-:.1::j-ryi.::...-,,-,.

'..1:..,,::r.{iit:=J{Gt Cdg..'et:i..,5e..,*aS nAnrii*g .C-vei tA*,.iaiAJ t*' his',,,.'.:1,:,..:':,',,.:s'*bE€SSOE an 24;9.S9. a-rtdr-oti-th;,,s;; r". rTZto. ltso rennri' xr** ,

.'.-'-'.--..-...'..:-.''-':..''.'..::1..',:J.-l-.....l:.l:-]T.,:.:::--:1:.i*r _ . i,

.. .; _..., : ii,j ,:..,r. - _,.j,__ ..-. -:.:.._.

i . -- -- circumsEanb-es=-Subseqrrentiyrq cof-r"eete* re olv. . , . .. .. :.. ,. ,1. ---.

-i" '

l*=;,'....g..- - , . -;'-

- - =VACe,..fhin;yan-qp.+=#-!f !o _BS_gppgggA,-Fri. Sasicitrarqn ' .' ' ,

'

respondent has :-'r":beer,r tiffi to the Direcroi, ligtieacg

.. -*___,

- . _- __*_.r.sur.eg]{i,?hiruvanaxthapurara

and who inturn fi-irnishe.l rI.^ - 'i:-,1i,-"1r:- -'+ uie s+rqe,Ibn 23._t0.Qg before +;.. Chief Secreta^.;r_, - :;-vl""Tr*"",.o"p..ta.rr;;,;;r:.,,;;"t';r,1,

.,suD4ttj!qg!:that.tlei''.ru;".s,*,:;rr, : ;,",-.'l r,: . ,, .

. .,o,,1y.,,r-",,,.,;*#Hifl1;3#;; .l-:*.4;;":;, :::::", i*.*.' ;",:":.:J,#,J:i:::;#::::. ;::, Covernrngnf , f+i ir.,ir;.*;;_ ^__ ,'"' r,*.rqr4g appropriare further aciion eitherdepar'rn"t1 actiol o1.T*r*;i r;.;;;";';ater on, r havereceived a cla '-

'-- =++=;r-;r

r r: ., nxcqtid. ..1, the Govgrnqrent througn Oi.ector,

,

' vlgrla-nce add Anti corit.bti* grr..^;, rhlruvananthapurarn ,for

lf: ^:1Tt:'^":1'. 1 ;.c;.,"'r,ui;i; ;;; ;;;';r1r.,r,:i:::::fi ,,,],9't'zotg''':.:rfi1g sdme is pendrng ro, ***i.":, ;-prpsEnt Di. s.r- v4,gg.

"o.. :,,,| .-,:*:- :Y- .tf, . , . , ....ri. ,.., " .,

:i;t