advancing an asian agenda for immigration reform...article title advanc~no an aslan agenda for...

14
Article title Advanc~no an Aslan Agenda for Immlgrat~on Reform Quan. K. ASIAN AMERICAN POLICY REVIEW Bibliographic details 2003, VOL 12, pages 43-68 Publisl~er IOHN F. KENNEDY Coulltry of USA Volume XI1 2003 SCHOOL OF publicatio~~ GOVERNMENT ISBN INTERVIEWS Into the National Consciousness of America: An Interview with the Honorable Gary Locke, Governor of the State of Washington Georgette Bhathena. .................................................................................................................... I Sowing Seeds: An Interview with the Honorable Lon S. Hatamiya, Secretary of California's Technology, Trade, and Commerce Agency T Linh Ho ....................................................................................................................................... 5 Rising to Leadership: An Interview with Christina Lagdameo, National Asian Pacific American Women's Forum Therese Leung ............................................................................................................................... 13 RESEARCH The Increasing Significance of Class, the Declining Significance of Race, and Wilson's Hypothesis ........................................................................................ Arthur Sakamoto and Changhwan Kim 19 Advancing an Asian Agenda for Immigration Reform Katie Quan .................................................................................................................................... 43 CHANGING LANDSCAPES: ELECTIONS, POLICY, AND INFORMATION On the Ballot: Asian Pacific Islander American Candidates Fare Well in 2002 Elections ................................................................................................................. Rodney Jay C. Salinas 69 The Politics of Language: Bilingual Education Review PJ Gagajena ............................................................................................................................... 77 A Numbers Game: APIA 2000 Census Leadership and Education ofAsian Pacifies ................................................................................ 79 APA Web Sites: AAPRS Picks for the Year's Best AAPR Editorial Committee ........................................................................................................... 81 MEMORIAL TRIBUTE Remembering Patsy Mink: An Interview with Herb Lee ................................................................................................................................... Falan Hnug 85 The Life and Legacy: A Tribute to Chancellor Chang-Lin Tien, University of California at Berkeley Wa,vne Ho... ................................................................................................................................. ..89 BOOK REVIEW Everybody Was Kung Fu Fighting: Afro-Asian Connections and the Myth of Cultural Purity Neal Parikh .................................................................................................................................. 93 Courtesy Asian American Policy Review, www.ksg.harvard.edu/aapr Advancing an Asian Agenda for 1 1 Immigration Reform 1 / Katie Quan Immigration policy is one of the most volatile topics of our times. Prior to 11 September 2001, the Bush administration was on the verge of agreeing to a path- breaking proposal for legalizing undocumented immigrants. However, just after September 11, that momentum halted, and immigration policies have instead become more restrictive and punitive, as evidenced in the secrecy provisions of the PATRIOT Act, the citizenship requirements of the Aviation and Transportation Security Act, and lowering of entry allotments for rehgees. Although many post-September 11 policies are targeted directly at Asian immi- grants from Central Asia, South Asia, and Southeast Asia, little has been heard from Asian Pacific Islander (API) communities about their views on these matters. Even prior to September 11, their voices on national immigration policy issues such as legalization were not well known, despite the fact that Asian Pacific Islanders account for 3 1 percent of immigration to the United States between 1991 and 2000 (Immigration and Naturalization Service 2002a). Moreover, other con- cerns particular to API communities have not been heard at all. To begin a dialogue on the immigration policy concerns of Asian Pacific Islander workers, the Center for Labor Research and Education (Labor Center) at UC Berkeley joined with community and union partners to sponsor a conference enti- tled "Advancing an Asian Agenda for Immigration Reform" in March 2002. The conference was attended by 130 representatives of community and labor organiza- Katie Quan is currently an educator and researcher at UC Berkeley k Center for Labor Research and Education, and directs its John I ? Henning Centerfor International Labor Relations. She continues her activism with garment workers as a board member of Sweatshop Watch, a coalition of garment worker advocates that she co-founded, the Worker Rights Consortium, a group of students and academics that monitors compliance with labor standardsfor apparel bearing universig logos, and the International Labor Rights Fund, a non-government organization that builds cross-border solidari~. The author would like to thank Cathi Tactaquin and Lillian Galedo for their valuable advice on this papec and Xiaojing Wang and Maly Purcell for their excellent research assistance.

Upload: others

Post on 27-Aug-2021

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Advancing an Asian Agenda for Immigration Reform...Article title Advanc~no an Aslan Agenda for Immlgrat~on Reform Quan. K. ASIAN AMERICAN POLICY REVIEW Bibliographic details 2003,

Article tit le Advanc~no an Aslan Agenda for I m m l g r a t ~ o n Reform

Quan. K.

ASIAN AMERICAN POLICY REVIEW

Bibliographic details 2003, VOL 12, pages 43-68

Publisl~er IOHN F. KENNEDY Coulltry of USA

Volume XI1 2003 SCHOOL OF publ icat io~~ GOVERNMENT

ISBN

INTERVIEWS

Into the National Consciousness of America: An Interview with the Honorable Gary Locke, Governor of the State of Washington

Georgette Bhathena. .................................................................................................................... I

Sowing Seeds: An Interview with the Honorable Lon S. Hatamiya, Secretary of California's Technology, Trade, and Commerce Agency

T Linh Ho ....................................................................................................................................... 5

Rising to Leadership: An Interview with Christina Lagdameo, National Asian Pacific American Women's Forum

Therese Leung ............................................................................................................................... 13

RESEARCH

The Increasing Significance of Class, the Declining Significance of Race, and Wilson's Hypothesis ........................................................................................ Arthur Sakamoto and Changhwan Kim 19

Advancing an Asian Agenda for Immigration Reform Katie Quan .................................................................................................................................... 43

CHANGING LANDSCAPES: ELECTIONS, POLICY, AND INFORMATION

On the Ballot: Asian Pacific Islander American Candidates Fare Well in 2002 Elections ................................................................................................................. Rodney Jay C. Salinas 69

The Politics of Language: Bilingual Education Review PJ Gagajena ............................................................................................................................... 7 7

A Numbers Game: APIA 2000 Census Leadership and Education ofAsian Pacifies ................................................................................ 79

APA Web Sites: AAPRS Picks for the Year's Best AAPR Editorial Committee ........................................................................................................... 81

MEMORIAL TRIBUTE

Remembering Patsy Mink: An Interview with Herb Lee ................................................................................................................................... Falan Hnug 85

The Life and Legacy: A Tribute to Chancellor Chang-Lin Tien, University of California at Berkeley Wa,vne Ho... ................................................................................................................................. ..89

BOOK REVIEW

Everybody Was Kung Fu Fighting: Afro-Asian Connections and the Myth of Cultural Purity Neal Parikh .................................................................................................................................. 93

Courtesy Asian American Policy Review, www.ksg.harvard.edu/aapr

Advancing an Asian Agenda for 1 1 Immigration Reform 1 / Katie Quan

Immigration policy is one of the most volatile topics of our times. Prior to 11 September 2001, the Bush administration was on the verge of agreeing to a path- breaking proposal for legalizing undocumented immigrants. However, just after September 11, that momentum halted, and immigration policies have instead become more restrictive and punitive, as evidenced in the secrecy provisions of the PATRIOT Act, the citizenship requirements of the Aviation and Transportation Security Act, and lowering of entry allotments for rehgees. Although many post-September 11 policies are targeted directly at Asian immi-

grants from Central Asia, South Asia, and Southeast Asia, little has been heard from Asian Pacific Islander (API) communities about their views on these matters. Even prior to September 1 1, their voices on national immigration policy issues such as legalization were not well known, despite the fact that Asian Pacific Islanders account for 3 1 percent of immigration to the United States between 1991 and 2000 (Immigration and Naturalization Service 2002a). Moreover, other con- cerns particular to API communities have not been heard at all.

To begin a dialogue on the immigration policy concerns of Asian Pacific Islander workers, the Center for Labor Research and Education (Labor Center) at UC Berkeley joined with community and union partners to sponsor a conference enti- tled "Advancing an Asian Agenda for Immigration Reform" in March 2002. The conference was attended by 130 representatives of community and labor organiza-

Katie Quan is currently an educator and researcher at UC Berkeley k Center for Labor Research and Education, and directs its John I? Henning Center for International Labor Relations. She continues her activism with garment workers as a board member of Sweatshop Watch, a coalition of garment worker advocates that she co-founded, the Worker Rights Consortium, a group of students and academics that monitors compliance with labor standards for apparel bearing universig logos, and the International Labor Rights Fund, a non-government organization that builds cross-border solidari~. The author would like to thank Cathi Tactaquin and Lillian Galedo for their valuable advice on this papec and Xiaojing Wang and Maly Purcell for their excellent research assistance.

Brian
Stamp
Brian
Text Box
43
jmacgill
Text Box
Courtesy Asian American Policy Review, www.ksg.harvard.edu/aapr
Page 2: Advancing an Asian Agenda for Immigration Reform...Article title Advanc~no an Aslan Agenda for Immlgrat~on Reform Quan. K. ASIAN AMERICAN POLICY REVIEW Bibliographic details 2003,
Brian
Text Box
44
Page 3: Advancing an Asian Agenda for Immigration Reform...Article title Advanc~no an Aslan Agenda for Immlgrat~on Reform Quan. K. ASIAN AMERICAN POLICY REVIEW Bibliographic details 2003,
Brian
Text Box
46
Page 4: Advancing an Asian Agenda for Immigration Reform...Article title Advanc~no an Aslan Agenda for Immlgrat~on Reform Quan. K. ASIAN AMERICAN POLICY REVIEW Bibliographic details 2003,
Brian
Text Box
48
Page 5: Advancing an Asian Agenda for Immigration Reform...Article title Advanc~no an Aslan Agenda for Immlgrat~on Reform Quan. K. ASIAN AMERICAN POLICY REVIEW Bibliographic details 2003,
Brian
Text Box
50
Page 6: Advancing an Asian Agenda for Immigration Reform...Article title Advanc~no an Aslan Agenda for Immlgrat~on Reform Quan. K. ASIAN AMERICAN POLICY REVIEW Bibliographic details 2003,
Brian
Text Box
52
Page 7: Advancing an Asian Agenda for Immigration Reform...Article title Advanc~no an Aslan Agenda for Immlgrat~on Reform Quan. K. ASIAN AMERICAN POLICY REVIEW Bibliographic details 2003,
Brian
Text Box
54
Page 8: Advancing an Asian Agenda for Immigration Reform...Article title Advanc~no an Aslan Agenda for Immlgrat~on Reform Quan. K. ASIAN AMERICAN POLICY REVIEW Bibliographic details 2003,
Brian
Text Box
56
Page 9: Advancing an Asian Agenda for Immigration Reform...Article title Advanc~no an Aslan Agenda for Immlgrat~on Reform Quan. K. ASIAN AMERICAN POLICY REVIEW Bibliographic details 2003,
Brian
Text Box
58
Page 10: Advancing an Asian Agenda for Immigration Reform...Article title Advanc~no an Aslan Agenda for Immlgrat~on Reform Quan. K. ASIAN AMERICAN POLICY REVIEW Bibliographic details 2003,
Brian
Text Box
60
Page 11: Advancing an Asian Agenda for Immigration Reform...Article title Advanc~no an Aslan Agenda for Immlgrat~on Reform Quan. K. ASIAN AMERICAN POLICY REVIEW Bibliographic details 2003,
Brian
Text Box
62
Page 12: Advancing an Asian Agenda for Immigration Reform...Article title Advanc~no an Aslan Agenda for Immlgrat~on Reform Quan. K. ASIAN AMERICAN POLICY REVIEW Bibliographic details 2003,
Brian
Text Box
64
Page 13: Advancing an Asian Agenda for Immigration Reform...Article title Advanc~no an Aslan Agenda for Immlgrat~on Reform Quan. K. ASIAN AMERICAN POLICY REVIEW Bibliographic details 2003,
Brian
Text Box
66
Page 14: Advancing an Asian Agenda for Immigration Reform...Article title Advanc~no an Aslan Agenda for Immlgrat~on Reform Quan. K. ASIAN AMERICAN POLICY REVIEW Bibliographic details 2003,
Brian
Text Box
68