adf propulsion systems symposium 2017 - department · pdf fileeric witkowski m.sc. p.eng . sr....

33
Eric Witkowski M.Sc. P.Eng Sr. Electrical Systems Engineer QSS Inc Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada 1 ADF Propulsion Systems Symposium 2017 Lighting in Inspection “Now you see, now you don’t”

Upload: truongnga

Post on 06-Mar-2018

216 views

Category:

Documents


3 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: ADF Propulsion Systems Symposium 2017 - Department · PDF fileEric Witkowski M.Sc. P.Eng . Sr. Electrical Systems Engineer . QSS Inc . Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada . 1 ADF Propulsion

Eric Witkowski M.Sc. P.Eng

Sr. Electrical Systems Engineer

QSS Inc Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada

1

ADF Propulsion Systems Symposium 2017

Lighting in Inspection

“Now you see, now you don’t”

Page 2: ADF Propulsion Systems Symposium 2017 - Department · PDF fileEric Witkowski M.Sc. P.Eng . Sr. Electrical Systems Engineer . QSS Inc . Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada . 1 ADF Propulsion

Seminar Outline The proper lighting for an inspection is like a “black magic”. This seminar will help you to understand how to use light to see defects, color, texture and/or markings on parts focusing on:

Inspection Light Color Inspection Light Intensity Inspection Light and Camera Angles

2

“Beware of false knowledge; it is more dangerous than ignorance.” George Bernard Shaw

Page 3: ADF Propulsion Systems Symposium 2017 - Department · PDF fileEric Witkowski M.Sc. P.Eng . Sr. Electrical Systems Engineer . QSS Inc . Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada . 1 ADF Propulsion

Thank You

3

Special Thanks to Dollard and Pilsun at Materials Laboratory in Standard Aero in Winnipeg for images and support.

Page 4: ADF Propulsion Systems Symposium 2017 - Department · PDF fileEric Witkowski M.Sc. P.Eng . Sr. Electrical Systems Engineer . QSS Inc . Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada . 1 ADF Propulsion

COLOR

4

All pictures from digital camera with Automatic White Balance, No post processing color correction applied.

Page 5: ADF Propulsion Systems Symposium 2017 - Department · PDF fileEric Witkowski M.Sc. P.Eng . Sr. Electrical Systems Engineer . QSS Inc . Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada . 1 ADF Propulsion

5

The question is:

Page 6: ADF Propulsion Systems Symposium 2017 - Department · PDF fileEric Witkowski M.Sc. P.Eng . Sr. Electrical Systems Engineer . QSS Inc . Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada . 1 ADF Propulsion

Light is ...

radiant energy which enables us to see

Electro-Magnetic radiation in the range of 380-760 nano-meters which is response range of the human eye

Page 7: ADF Propulsion Systems Symposium 2017 - Department · PDF fileEric Witkowski M.Sc. P.Eng . Sr. Electrical Systems Engineer . QSS Inc . Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada . 1 ADF Propulsion

Color of light

Page 8: ADF Propulsion Systems Symposium 2017 - Department · PDF fileEric Witkowski M.Sc. P.Eng . Sr. Electrical Systems Engineer . QSS Inc . Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada . 1 ADF Propulsion

Color of light

8

Page 9: ADF Propulsion Systems Symposium 2017 - Department · PDF fileEric Witkowski M.Sc. P.Eng . Sr. Electrical Systems Engineer . QSS Inc . Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada . 1 ADF Propulsion

9

Halogen lamp CCT = 3000K

LED lamp CCT = 5000K

Color of light

CCT = Correlated Color Temperature

Page 10: ADF Propulsion Systems Symposium 2017 - Department · PDF fileEric Witkowski M.Sc. P.Eng . Sr. Electrical Systems Engineer . QSS Inc . Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada . 1 ADF Propulsion

Color of light

10

Only LED light on

LED light on + room incandescent light on

Page 11: ADF Propulsion Systems Symposium 2017 - Department · PDF fileEric Witkowski M.Sc. P.Eng . Sr. Electrical Systems Engineer . QSS Inc . Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada . 1 ADF Propulsion

• First decision: WARM or COOL? – Consider finishes of the parts, – Color appearance under inspection light,

e.g. bluish light (daylight 5000K+ can emphasize imperfections in chromium plating over nickel plating.

– proximity to other light sources

11

Color of light

Page 12: ADF Propulsion Systems Symposium 2017 - Department · PDF fileEric Witkowski M.Sc. P.Eng . Sr. Electrical Systems Engineer . QSS Inc . Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada . 1 ADF Propulsion

INSPECTION LIGHT INTENSITY

12

Page 13: ADF Propulsion Systems Symposium 2017 - Department · PDF fileEric Witkowski M.Sc. P.Eng . Sr. Electrical Systems Engineer . QSS Inc . Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada . 1 ADF Propulsion

Microscope lighting setup

13

“The voyage of discovery is not in seeking new landscapes but in having new eyes.” Marcel Proust

Page 14: ADF Propulsion Systems Symposium 2017 - Department · PDF fileEric Witkowski M.Sc. P.Eng . Sr. Electrical Systems Engineer . QSS Inc . Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada . 1 ADF Propulsion

Inspection Light Intensity

14

Beware – more light may not help to detect defects.

Page 15: ADF Propulsion Systems Symposium 2017 - Department · PDF fileEric Witkowski M.Sc. P.Eng . Sr. Electrical Systems Engineer . QSS Inc . Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada . 1 ADF Propulsion

Inspection Light Intensity

15

Page 16: ADF Propulsion Systems Symposium 2017 - Department · PDF fileEric Witkowski M.Sc. P.Eng . Sr. Electrical Systems Engineer . QSS Inc . Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada . 1 ADF Propulsion

Inspection Light Intensity

16

90 deg

90 deg extra light

Page 17: ADF Propulsion Systems Symposium 2017 - Department · PDF fileEric Witkowski M.Sc. P.Eng . Sr. Electrical Systems Engineer . QSS Inc . Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada . 1 ADF Propulsion

Inspection Light Intensity

17

Filter “wrong direction” Filter “right direction”

Page 18: ADF Propulsion Systems Symposium 2017 - Department · PDF fileEric Witkowski M.Sc. P.Eng . Sr. Electrical Systems Engineer . QSS Inc . Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada . 1 ADF Propulsion

Inspection Light Intensity

18

Camera tilt worked the best.

Page 19: ADF Propulsion Systems Symposium 2017 - Department · PDF fileEric Witkowski M.Sc. P.Eng . Sr. Electrical Systems Engineer . QSS Inc . Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada . 1 ADF Propulsion

Inspection Light Intensity, Filters

19 Filter “wrong direction”

90 deg 90 deg extra light

Filter “right direction”

Page 20: ADF Propulsion Systems Symposium 2017 - Department · PDF fileEric Witkowski M.Sc. P.Eng . Sr. Electrical Systems Engineer . QSS Inc . Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada . 1 ADF Propulsion

Inspection Light Intensity, Filters

20

Page 21: ADF Propulsion Systems Symposium 2017 - Department · PDF fileEric Witkowski M.Sc. P.Eng . Sr. Electrical Systems Engineer . QSS Inc . Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada . 1 ADF Propulsion

Inspection Light Intensity, Filters

21

Page 22: ADF Propulsion Systems Symposium 2017 - Department · PDF fileEric Witkowski M.Sc. P.Eng . Sr. Electrical Systems Engineer . QSS Inc . Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada . 1 ADF Propulsion

Inspection Light Intensity

22

“Less is more” in inspection lighting.

Page 23: ADF Propulsion Systems Symposium 2017 - Department · PDF fileEric Witkowski M.Sc. P.Eng . Sr. Electrical Systems Engineer . QSS Inc . Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada . 1 ADF Propulsion

INSPECTION LIGHT & CAMERA ANGLE

23

“There are two ways of spreading light: to be the candle or the mirror that reflects it” Edith Wharton

Page 24: ADF Propulsion Systems Symposium 2017 - Department · PDF fileEric Witkowski M.Sc. P.Eng . Sr. Electrical Systems Engineer . QSS Inc . Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada . 1 ADF Propulsion

How light interact with different surfaces

24

Specular

Spread Diffuse

Page 25: ADF Propulsion Systems Symposium 2017 - Department · PDF fileEric Witkowski M.Sc. P.Eng . Sr. Electrical Systems Engineer . QSS Inc . Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada . 1 ADF Propulsion

Inspection Light & Camera Angle

25

Page 26: ADF Propulsion Systems Symposium 2017 - Department · PDF fileEric Witkowski M.Sc. P.Eng . Sr. Electrical Systems Engineer . QSS Inc . Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada . 1 ADF Propulsion

Inspection Light & Camera Angle

26

Page 27: ADF Propulsion Systems Symposium 2017 - Department · PDF fileEric Witkowski M.Sc. P.Eng . Sr. Electrical Systems Engineer . QSS Inc . Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada . 1 ADF Propulsion

Inspection light and camera angle

27

Top lighting technique

Focused light

Diffused light

Page 28: ADF Propulsion Systems Symposium 2017 - Department · PDF fileEric Witkowski M.Sc. P.Eng . Sr. Electrical Systems Engineer . QSS Inc . Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada . 1 ADF Propulsion

Inspection light and camera angle

28

45deg perpendicular

45deg parallel

Page 29: ADF Propulsion Systems Symposium 2017 - Department · PDF fileEric Witkowski M.Sc. P.Eng . Sr. Electrical Systems Engineer . QSS Inc . Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada . 1 ADF Propulsion

Inspection light and camera angle

29

Oblique perpendicular

Oblique parallel

Page 30: ADF Propulsion Systems Symposium 2017 - Department · PDF fileEric Witkowski M.Sc. P.Eng . Sr. Electrical Systems Engineer . QSS Inc . Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada . 1 ADF Propulsion

Inspection light and camera angle

30

45deg Oblique Top lighting

Focused light

Diffused light

Page 31: ADF Propulsion Systems Symposium 2017 - Department · PDF fileEric Witkowski M.Sc. P.Eng . Sr. Electrical Systems Engineer . QSS Inc . Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada . 1 ADF Propulsion

31

“Now you see, Now you don’t”

Page 32: ADF Propulsion Systems Symposium 2017 - Department · PDF fileEric Witkowski M.Sc. P.Eng . Sr. Electrical Systems Engineer . QSS Inc . Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada . 1 ADF Propulsion

Summary – lighting for an inspection:

• Most effective is selection of Light Direction - best if light is perpendicular to a defect

• Light Intensity – “less is more” • Light Color - use lamps with higher CCT

– 4000K (Cool White ) or 5000K (Daylight). – Be aware of “stray” light.

• Follow OEM instructions for inspection (if provided)

32

“We live in a society exquisitely dependent on science and technology, in which hardly anyone knows anything about science and technology.”

Carl Sagan (American astronomer)

Page 33: ADF Propulsion Systems Symposium 2017 - Department · PDF fileEric Witkowski M.Sc. P.Eng . Sr. Electrical Systems Engineer . QSS Inc . Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada . 1 ADF Propulsion

QUESTIONS ?

33

“Judge a man by his questions rather than by his answers.” Voltaire

Eric Witkowski M.Sc..Eng. Sr. Electrical Systems

Engineer QSS Inc.

81 High Ridge Rd Winnipeg, MB Canada [email protected]