accountability for college and career readiness ......the new challenge of college- and...

72
Accountability for College and Career Readiness: Developing A New Paradigm

Upload: others

Post on 22-Sep-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

AccountabilityforCollegeandCareerReadiness:DevelopingANewParadigm

Page 2: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

ContributorsStephenBowen,CouncilforChiefState

SchoolOfficersAnthonyBryk,CarnegieFounda6onfor

theAdvancementofTeachingRichardCarranza,SanFranciscoUnified

SchoolDistrictMichaelCohen,AchieveLindaDarling-Hammond,Stanford

CenterforOpportunityPolicyinEduca6on

MichaelKirst,CaliforniaStateBoardofEduca6on

PaulLeather,NewHampshireDepartmentofEduca6on

PhilipLovell,AllianceforExcellentEduca6on

2

CarmelMarIn,CenterforAmericanProgress

JalMehta,HarvardUniversityCharmaineMercer,AllianceforExcellent

Educa6onRickMiller,CenterforOrganiza6onal

ReformofEduca6onScoKPalmer,Educa6onCounselLindaPiKenger,Na6onalCenterfor

Innova6oninEduca6on,U.ofKYArunRamanathan,Educa6onTrustWestLarryRosenstock,HighTechHighSchoolGeneWilhoit,Na6onalCenterfor

Innova6oninEduca6on,U.ofKY.

Page 3: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

CreaIngIntelligentAccountability

Anaccountabilitysystemshould: 1)encouragehigh-qualityteachingandlearninginallschools,

2)providetoolsforconInuousimprovement,and 3)meansforidenIfyingandaddressingproblemsthatrequire

correcIon.TestscanofferinformaIonforanaccountabilitysystem,buttheydonotbythemselvescreateaccountability

3

Accountability=

TesIng

Page 4: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

KeyElementsofanNewAccountabilitySystem

4

Page 5: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

AccountabilityShould…1)Bedesignedtoproducecon$nuoussystemimprovement,notjusttestscores;2)Bereciprocal,witheachlevelofthesystemtakingresponsibilityforthecontribuIonsitmustmaketoserveeachchildwell;3)Focusonmeaningfullearningforcollege,careers,andciIzenship,usingmorevalidandauthen$cassessments,reportedindisaggregatedform4)Ensureadequateresourcesallocatedintelligentlytomeetstudentneedswell;5)Developandensureprofessionalcapacityandaccountability6)Usemul$plemeasuresevaluatedthroughsystemsofexpertreview,judgment,andinterven6on7)Focusonsystemcapacitybuilding,shi_ingfromatest-and-rankapproachtoanassess-support-and-improvemodel8)Reflectongoingstudent,parent,educatorandcommunityinputandprovidetransparentandaccessibleinformaIontothepublic.

5

Page 6: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

ChrisW

ardlaw

,"Mathe

maI

csinHon

gKo

ng/

China–Im

provingon

BeingFirstinPISA

"

TheNewChallengeofCollege-andCareer-Readiness:ExpectaIonsforLearningareChanging

ThenewcontextmeansnewexpectaIonsfordeeperlearning,includingabiliIesto:

• ThinkcriIcallyandcreaIvely• CommunicateinmulIpleforms• Collaborate• Conductresearch• Solveproblems• Analyseandconceptualise• Usenewtechnologies• EngageinlearningnewthingsatallImes• Reflectonandimproveone’sownperformance

Page 7: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

Knowledge,Skills,andDisposiDonsforPostsecondarySuccess 7

College&career

readinesscompetencies

CommonCoreStateStandards

SBACorPARCCAssessment

ResearchExperimentaIonCommunicaIonCollaboraIon

Useoftechnology,

etc.

Page 8: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

NewAccountabilityinthe51stState

8

Page 9: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

InteracDveElementsofanAssessmentSystemforMeaningfulLearning

9

Page 10: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

ProfessionalCapacityandAccountability

•  Intensiveclinicalprepara6onandmentoring•  Professionaldevelopmentconnectedtostandards,high-qualitycurriculumresources,anddevelopment/scoringofassessments

•  Job-embeddedPLCs,collaboraIveplanning,andcoaching;subjectmaKernetworks

•  Standards-basedevalua6onandfeedbackpromoInglearningandcollaboraIon

10

Page 11: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

ResourceAccountability

•  WeightedStudentFormulafundsschoolsbystudentneeds

•  CommuniIesengageindecisionsaboutallocaIngfunds

•  Adashboardofmeasuresprovidestransparencyaboutuseofresourcesandoutcomes,disaggregatedbystudentgroups

•  Outcomesareevaluatedandplansareadjustedregularly

11

Page 12: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

12

Page 13: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

AMulDpleMeasuresDashboard 13

Page 14: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

IndicatorsofLearningOpportuniDes 14

Basic

Services

•  QualificaIonsofStaff

•  Safe,adequatefaciliIes

•  Accesstostandards-basedmaterials

•  Accesstotechnologyresources

Engagemen

t

•  Effortstosupportparentalinvolvement

•  Effortstoseekcommunityinput

Curriculum

and

cou

rseaccess

•  Accesstoafull,richcurriculum(arts,PE,STEM,etc.)

•  AccesstoandparIcipaIonincollegeandcareerreadycoursesofstudy

Page 15: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

SchoolQualityReview 15

Page 16: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

SupportforImprovement

•  Teamsofexperteducatorstrainedtoworkwithstrugglingschools

•  Schoolpairsandnetworksforlearning•  Trainedcurriculumcoaches•  Wraparoundservices,includingextendedlearninga_erschoolandinsummer

•  SchoolredesigniniIaIvesbasedonresearchandbestpracIces 16

Page 17: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

Tofindthereport,goto:hKps://edpolicy.stanford.edu

17

Page 18: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

MulDplemeasuresaccountabilitysystems:IncenDvizingandsupporDngschoolsfordeeper

learningandconDnuousimprovement

SoungBaeSeniorResearchandPolicyAnalyst

Page 19: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

Context

§  Theneedsofthe21stcenturyworkforceisrapidlychanging

§  Schoolsanddistrictsmustpreparestudentstoacquire21stcenturycontentandskills

§  Scholars,educators,reformadvocatesarecallingforamoremeaningfulnextphaseofschoolaccountabilitythatpromotesconInuousimprovementandsupport

19

Page 20: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

NewSystemofMulDpleMeasuresofAccountability

Shouldinclude:§ Broadersetofoutcomemeasures§ MeasuresofopportuniIestolearn§ Mixofstateandlocalindicators§ Datadashboards§  Schoolreviews

20

Page 21: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

BroaderSetofOutcomeMeasures

§  Developstudentcompetenciesbeyondbasicskills(e.g.,NewHampshirePerformanceAssessmentforCompetencyEducaIon)

§  Promotethedevelopmentofnon-cogniDveskills(e.g.,CaliforniaOfficetoReformEducaIon)

§  CulIvatecollegeandcareerreadinessinallstudents(e.g.,SouthCarolina’sEducaIonandEconomicDevelopmentAct)

21

Page 22: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

MeasuresofOpportuniDestoLearn

§  Accesstoresources§  Accesstohighlyqualifiedteachers§  Accesstorichcurriculum§  Schoolclimate

22

Page 23: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

MeasuresofOpportuniDestoLearn

§ Accesstoresources§  Accesstohighlyqualifiedteachers§  Accesstorichcurriculum§  Schoolclimate

23

Page 24: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

MeasuresofOpportuniDestoLearn

§  Accesstoresources§ Accesstohighlyqualifiedteachers§  Accesstorichcurriculum§  Schoolclimate

24

Page 25: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

MeasuresofOpportuniDestoLearn

§  Accesstoresources§  Accesstohighlyqualifiedteachers§ Accesstorichcurriculum§  Schoolclimate

25

Page 26: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

MeasuresofOpportuniDestoLearn

§  Accesstoresources§  Accesstohighlyqualifiedteachers§  Accesstorichcurriculum§ Schoolclimate

26

Page 27: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

MixofStateandLocallyDeterminedIndicators

§  IncenDvizesschoolsanddistrictstopayaKenIontocriIcaloutcomesbeyondstudentachievementscoresinmathandEnglish

§  Providesschoolsanddistrictswiththeflexibilitytoberesponsivetolocalneedsandcontexts

§  AllowsschoolsanddistrictstobeYermonitorstudentlearningandprogressthroughouttheyear

27

Page 28: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

DataDashboards

§  ProvideinsightsintocriIcalmeasuresofwhatisworkingandwhatisnot

§  Createtransparencyforeducatorsandthelocalcommunityonkeyaspectsofaccountability

§  FacilitatetheprioriDzaDonofneedsandtargeInglimitedresourcestosupportintervenIonandcorrecIveacIon

28

Page 29: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

SchoolReviews§  ProgramReview(e.g.,Kentucky)

§  SchoolQualityReview(e.g.,NYCDOE’sQualityReview)

§  DiagnosDcReview(e.g.,MassachuseKsReviewofLow-PerformingSchools)

§  AccreditaDonReview(e.g.,WestVirginia)

29

Page 30: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

SchoolReviews§ MakequalitaDvejudgmentsaboutthequalityofteachingandlearninginschools

§  Assessaschool’sperformanceandprogressagainstwell-definedstandardsandcriteria

§  DevelopacultureofinquiryandreflecDonandpromoteconInuousimprovement

§  Refineaschool’sacDonorimprovementplanandtriggerasystemoftargetedandintensivesupport

30

Page 31: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

ConsideraDonsforPracDce

§  ProvideongoingprofessionaldevelopmenttoallstakeholdersondataliteracyandconducIngschoolreviews

§  Engagestakeholdersandbuildconsensus§  CreateorganizaIonalstructurestofast-tracksupporttostrugglingschools

31

Page 32: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

FutureDirecDonsforTeacherPolicythatSupportsProfessionalGrowthandConDnuousImprovement:A

ReviewofEmergingResearch

ElizabethLeisyStosich,Ed.D.�TravisJ.Bristol,Ph.D.

Research&PolicyFellow@lizleisystosich@tjacksonbristol

Page 33: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

Problem•  Thirty-threeyearsa_erANa6onatRisk,teachers’iniIal

preparaIonsIllvariesgreatlyfromprogramtoprogramandthisvariaIonhasdirectconsequencesforstudents’learning(Boydetal.,2009;NaIonalCouncilforAccreditaIonofTeacherEducaIon,2010;NCEE,1983)

•  GeneralqualificaIonsprovideliKleinformaIonaboutteachers’abilitytosupportstudentlearning(Chingos&Peterson,2011;Goldhaber,2007;Rivkinetal.,2005)

•  Although“value-added”techniqueshavebeenusedtomeasureteachers’contribuIontostudentlearning(Rivkin,Hanushek,&Kain,2005;Rockoff,2004),suchstrategiesarenotalwayseffecIve(Darling-Hammond,2015;Raudenbush,2015) 33

Page 34: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

NewDirecDon•  GrowingaKenIontothecondiIonsandprocessesthat

supportconInuousimprovementandgrowthintheprofession(Darling-Hammond,Wilhoit,&PiKenger,2014;Johnson,2012).

•  TeachersmakegreatergainsineffecIvenesswhentheyworkinschoolswithopportuniIesforcollaboraIonwithcolleagues,strongprincipalleadership,andmeaningfulfeedbackaspartoftheevaluaIonprocess(Jackson&Bruegmann,2009;Kra_&Papay,2014).

34

Page 35: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

ANewApproachtoAccountabilityforLearning

35

(Darling-Hammond,Wilhoit,&PiKenger,2014)

Page 36: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

ResearchQuesDons

•  1)Howdoindividualeducatorsgrowoverthecourseoftheircareer?

•  2)HowdoschoolworkingcondiIonsinfluenceeducators’growthanddevelopment?

•  3)HowcanweidenIfyeffecIveeducators?

36

Page 37: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

RQ#1:Howdoindividualeducatorsgrowoverthecourseoftheircareer?

Research•  TeachersaremosteffecIveintheiriniIalyears,thenplateau

(Boyd,Lankford,Loeb,Rockoff,&Wyckoff,2008;Rockoff,2004)

•  ElementaryandmiddleschoolteachersimproveduringfirstfewyearsintheclassroomandconInuetobe“effecIve”longa_ertheirfirstfiveyearsonthejob(Ladd&Sorensen,2015;Papay&Kra_,2015)

Policy•  In2002,WashingtonprovidedmonetaryincenIvesforteachers

whopursuedandaKainedNaIonalBoardCerIficaIon•  2002(99NBCTs)•  2014(946NBCTs;324taughtina“challengeschool”)•  NBCTsmoreeffecIvewhencomparedtonon-NBCTs(Cowan&

Goldhaber,2015)•  37

Page 38: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

RQ#2:HowdoschoolworkingcondiDonsinfluenceeducators’growthanddevelopment?

Research•  Sustainedandfocused•  Includesbothteachersandschoolleaders•  AddressesparIcipants’knowledgeandskillsgapsrelatedto

teachingandlearning•  ResponsivetothecontextsinwhichparIcipantsteachand

studentslearn(Darling-Hammond,Wei,Andree,Richardson,&Orphanos,2009;King&Bouchard,2011) Policy

•  WestVirginia,basedonasurveyofeducatorsabouttheirprofessionallearningexperiences,createdanonlineresourcebankdesignedtosupporthigh-qualitylearningexperiences

•  TeacherscanaccessspecificprofessionallearningmaterialsbasedontheareasfordevelopmentidenIfiedduringevaluaIon

38

Page 39: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

RQ#3:HowcanweidenDfyeffecDveeducators? Research

•  CommonprofessionalstandardsdesignedbyeducatorsandalignedtoperformancebasedassessmentscanserveasanimportantleverforidenIfyingbeginningandaccomplishedteachingandimprovingstudentlearning(Cavalluzzo,Barrow,&Henderson,2014;Sato,2014;Wilson&Hallam,2006). Policy

•  In2002,CaliforniaStateLegislaturerequiredpre-serviceprogramstoincludeaperformancebasedassessmentinteacherpreparaIonprograms

•  12publicandprivateuniversiIescreatedthePerformanceAssessmentforCaliforniaTeachers(PACT)

•  Teachers’PACTscorespredictlatereffecIveness,asmeasuredbystudents’mathandELAstandardizedexamscores(Darling-Hammond,Newton,&Wei,2013)

39

Page 40: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

ImplicaDonsforResearch,Policy,andPracDce

•  TeachereffecIvenessisnot“fixed”

•  SupporIveworkingcondiIonsareessenIalfordevelopingteachersthroughouttheircareer

•  Performancebasedassessmentsalignedtoprofessionalstandardscanbothassessandsupportthecapacityofnoviceandexperiencededucators

40

Page 41: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

FutureDirecDonsforTeacherPolicythatSupportsProfessionalGrowthand

ConDnuousImprovement•  Reviewrecentteacherpolicies

•  UnderlyingassumpIonsbehindthesepolicies

•  Emergingresearchthatcaninformfutureteacherpoliciesdesignedtoprepare,develop,andsupporteducatorsateachstageoftheircareer

41

Page 42: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

ElizabethLeisyStosichJonSnyder

StanfordCenterforOpportunityPolicyinEducation(SCOPE)

KatieWilczak

StanfordCenterforAssessment,Learning,andEquity(SCALE)

HowDoStatesIntegratePerformanceAssessmentsintoTheir

SystemsofAssessment?

Page 43: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

Strategy 1: Performance Assessment for Classroom Purposes

43

Focus:Developeducatorcapacitytodesign,develop,implement,andscoreperformancetasks.ColoradoDepartmentofEducationformed“ContentCollaboratives,”teamsofteacherswhoreview,develop,pilot,andshareperformancetasks.

Page 44: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

Strategy 2: Performance Assessment for High School Graduation

44

Focus:Evaluatestudents’abilitiestoapplytheirknowledgeinwaysthatreflectthedemandsofcollege,career,andlife.Vermontpassedproficiency-basedHSgraduationrequirements,whichallowtopresentmultipletypesofevidenceofproficiency,includingportfolios,performances,andprojects.

Page 45: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

Strategy 3: Include Performance Tasks in State Systems of Assessment

45

Focus:Makestatewideassessmentsmoremeaningfulbyincorporatingperformancetasksorreplacingstatewideassessmentswithlocalperformancetasks.California,NewHampshire,andOregonalladoptedSBACandengagedintheBuildingEducatorAssessmentLiteracy(BEAL)project,whichtrainsteacherstoscoreSBACperformancetasksandmakeinstructionalshiftstosupportstudentsinbeingsuccessfulwiththesetasks.

Page 46: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

Strategy 4: Seek a Waiver to use Performance Assessment for Federal Accountability

46

Focus:Transformstatesystemofassessmenttoincorporateperformanceassessmentsextensively.NewHampshire’sPerformanceAssessmentofCompetencyEducation(PACE)pilotprogramconnectscurriculum,assessment,andinstructionbyintegratinglocallydevelopedandcurriculum-embeddedperformanceassessments,commonsummativeperformanceassessments,andSBAC.

Page 47: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

Implications for Integrating Performance Assessment in State Assessment Systems

47

ü  AllfourstrategiescanbeimplementedunderESSA.

ü  Allstrategiesincludedextensiveinvestmentingrowingeducatorcapacitytodesign,develop,implement,and/orscoreperformancetasks.

Page 48: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

AERA 51st State Symposium

Virginia

April 10, 2016

Page 49: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

Our vision, in collaboration with:

•  The Governor; •  The General Assembly; •  The Board of Education; •  Local School Boards; •  Community Partners; •  Education Stakeholders and Parents;

is to create an excellent statewide system of public education that prepares every Virginia student

for success. 49

Page 50: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

Virginia Highlights

1.  Assessments

2.  College and Career Readiness

3.  Innovation

Page 51: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

Assessments

Page 52: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

52

Public Education in Virginia

132 school divisions in eight regions

Page 53: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

Structure of Schools and the Profile of a Virginia

Graduate

53

Page 54: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

High School Graduate

State Board of Education will develop a “Profile of a Virginia Graduate”

•  In consultation with stakeholders •  Consider critical thinking, creative thinking,

collaboration, communication, and citizenship

•  Opportunities for internships, externships, and credentialing

Page 55: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

55

Page 56: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

Innovation

•  Innovation Grants

•  Workforce readiness

•  Personalized learning

•  Competency based learning

Page 57: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

57

Virginia Public Schools Prepare Students

for

Page 58: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

Thank You

Dr. John W. “Billy” Haun Chief Academic Officer/Assistant

Superintendent of Instruction

[email protected]

58

Page 59: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

NH’SLEADINGEDGEASSESSMENTANDSCHOOLACCOUNTABILITYPILOT

PaulLeather,DeputyCommissioner,NewHampshireDepartmentofEducation

59

DesigningSystemsofSupportandAccountabilityforMeaningfulLearning:EarlyLessonsfromStateEfforts

AERA--April10,2016

Page 60: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

60

19951998-04200520062007-1020082010201120122013201420152016

Interest in Competency based transcripts --NHBIA

NH launches competency education pilot in 27 high schools

NH Rules require credit based on mastery of competencies by 2008

NGA Planning Grant awarded to NH to integrate ELOs with CBE

4 pilot NH HS given substantial financial support and TA by the Nellie Mae Education Foundation (NMEF) to develop comprehensive ELO/CBE programs

NH raises the compulsory age of education from 16 to 18, reducing the dropout rate to 1.26%

NH, VT, and RI pass joint resolutions to form the NESSC

NHDOE convened a task force to design a clear vision for a “fair and equitable” teacher evaluation system, producing the Phase I Report

NH is founding member of CCSSO Innovative Lab Network

ECS selects NH for Newman Innovation Award

The NHCBE is formed, supported by NMEF

The NHDOE Taskforce on Effective Teaching releases 2nd Report

NH Rules amended requiring CBE K-12

NMEF funds PACE Pilot development

USED recognizes PACE Pilot, supported by NMEF

ESSA passes with Innovative Demonstration modeled after PACE

Key Events Shaping NH Education:

Reaching Higher NH and NH Learning Initiative Formed

NH awarded NGA Grant to advance SCL

Page 61: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

AccountabilityForMeaningfulLearningInA51stState–StateAndLocalPartnership:

61

Locallyselected

assessmentsofstudentprogress

(PerformanceAssessmentsandothers)

K-2 3 - 4 5 -6 7 -8 9 – 10 11 -12

State Validation

Assessment

State Validation

Assessment Graduation Portfolio

SAT

AssessmentQualityAssurance(reviews local assessment plans and delivery)

Disaggregated Data

SBAC SBAC

Page 62: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

NH’sBlendofState,PACE,andLocalAssessments

62

GradeCourse/GradeAcademic

CompetencyELA MATH SCIENCE

K-2 þ LocalPAs LocalPBA LocalPBA

3 þ SmarterBalanced CommonPACEPBA LocalPBA

4 þ CommonPACEPBA SmarterBalanced CommonPACEPBA

5 þ CommonPACEPBA CommonPACEPBA LocalPBA

6 þ CommonPACEPBA CommonPACEPBA LocalPBA

7 þ CommonPACEPBA CommonPACEPBA LocalPBA

8 þ SmarterBalanced SmarterBalanced CommonPACEPBA

9 þ CommonPACEPBA CommonPACEPBA CommonPACEPBA

10 þ CommonPACEPBA CommonPACEPBA CommonPACEPBA

11 þ SmarterBalancedSATin2016

SmarterBalancedSATin2016 CommonPACEPBA

12 þ LocalPBA LocalPBA LocalPBA

Page 63: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

WhatisPACE?–WaterTowerProposal!

•  TheProblem:Yourtown’spopulaIonispredictedtoincreaseoverthenext3years.Asoneofthetownplanners,youareaskedtoaddressthisissueintermsofthetown’swatersupply.Inordertomeetthefutureneedsofthetown,youneedtomakeaproposaltoaddawatertowersomewhereontownpropertythatwillbecapableofholding45,000±2,000cubicfeetofwater.ThetownislookingforawatertowertocontainthemostamountofwaterwhileusingtheleastamountofconstrucIonmaterial.

•  StudentTask:YourjobistoprepareaproposalthatcanbesubmiKedtothetownplanningcommiKee.UsingyourcalculaIonsofsurfaceareaandvolumeforthetwodesigns,describeandanalyzethecharacterisIcsthatleadyoutoafinalrecommendaIon.

63

Geometry PACE Common Task

Page 64: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

District Assessment Plan

64

Grade

CLASSROOMCOMPETENCYGRADING[Allcoursesanddisciplines]

DISTRICT STATECOURSECOMPETENCYCOMMONASSESSMENTS COMPETENCY

ASSESSMENT

COMPETENCYCOMMON

ASSESSMENTAssessmentType 1.  NUMBERS&QUANTITIES,2.ALGEBRA,3.FUNCTIONS,4.GEOMETRY,5.STATISTICS&

PROBABILITY

4

UnitSummaIve

Placevalue,rounding,addiIon,subtracIonMeasurementconversions,addiIon,subtracIonFracIonswithlikedenominators

MulIplicaIon/divisionfacts,MulI-digitmulIplicaIon,division(mulI-digit)Geometry

FracIonswithunlikedenominatorsDecimalfracIonsGeometry&symmetry

NWEA(MAP)212.5

SMARTERBALANCE

PerformanceTaskTri1:MappingMigraIngMonarchs

5 UnitSummaIve

PlaceValueMulIplicaIonDivisionFracIonReview

AddiIon/SubracIonMulIplicaIonofFracIonsDivisionofFracIonsArea

VolumeandCapacityAlgebraicExpressionsDataandAnalysisGeometry

NWEA(MAP)221.0

PACE:AlgebraQuanIIes,CreaIng

EquaIons

PerformanceTask Tri1:SummerOlympics

6 UnitSummaIveRaIos,RatesandMeasurementConversions,OrderofOperaIons,ExponentsandAlgebraicExpressions

NWEA(MAP)225.6 PACE:Algebra,EqualiIesandEquaIons

NoteWeightofLocalAssessments!

Page 65: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

CombiningMultipleMeasures65

PACEComparable

AnnualDeterminaIons

PACECommonPerformanceTask

District-LevelCompetency

Scores

Competency1Localperformance

assessments

Competency2Localperformance

assessments

Competency3Localperformance

assessments

Competency4Localperformance

assessments

SBAC/SATinselectgrades

Page 66: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

Yes, this is hard!! •  This is not for the faint of heart, or the Unprepared!

66

Page 67: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

67

TheoryofAction--ProfessionallearningLinkswithschoolaccountability

DistrictsneedtobeIghtonevaluaIng:

Thismayrequire:

Studentlearning

Thequalityofprofessionallearning

InstrucIonalimprovement

Changeinmeasures

Changeinaccountability

emphasis

Greaterrelianceonprofessionaljudgement

Ben Jensen

Page 68: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

SystemDesignisbasedonHighPerformingProfessionalLearningCommunities

Accountability Reform in NH September 23, 2014 68

•  State-modelcompetenciesalignedwithcollegeandcareeroutcomesprovidethemainlearningtargets

•  InstrucDonalsystemtosupportstudentlearningofcompetencies•  Includesstrategiestopersonalizelearning

•  Assessmentsystemtomeasurestudentachievementandgrowthrelatedtocompetencies

•  Validatedperformanceassessmentsoccupyavisibleplaceinthelocalassessmentsystem

•  Educatorsreviewstudentworkonperformancetasksregularly•  SmarterBalancedassessmentadministeredatleastonceinelementaryandmiddleschool

•  SATonceinHighSchool

Page 69: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

Quality Performance Review

69

Examination of Practice

and Learning

Robust Data

Expertise Peer Review

51st State White Paper, 2014 Darling-Hammond, Wilhoit, Pittenger

Page 70: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

70

In-statePartners:Consultants–RoseColby,CenterforAssessment

Tier 3 Planning Districts

Tier 2 Preparing Districts

Tier I Implementing Districts

DoE/NHLearningIniIaIvePACE

ManagementTeam

NaIonalPartners:FoundaIons

CenterforCollaboraIveEducaIonCIE/Stanford

InsItuIonalSupports:StateBoard

Governor’sOfficeNHLegislature

OrganizationtoPACEScaling

ImplemenIngdistricts:PDinCallibraIon/scoring

pracIces

PreparingforimplementaIon:PDinPerformanceAssessment

developmentandimplementaIon

PlanningDistricts:developingCBE:Competencies,instrucIon,

assessment,grading

Page 71: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

Summary• We’velearnedatonandhavehadsomemajorsuccesses!

•  CollaboraIvecapacitybuilding•  DemonstraIonofreciprocalaccountability•  Cross-districtcalibraIon•  AnnualdeterminaIons•  Improvingassessmentquality

•  ImplicaDonsfortheFuture--Thenew“InnovaIveAssessmentandAccountabilityDemonstraIonAuthority”inESSA•  Whatarethebroadtakeaways?

•  NewEraofAssessmentandAccountabilitymaybeuponus!•  MulIpleMeasuresDemandnewconceptualizaIonofvalidity/reliability•  EducatorSkillDevelopmentiskey–“EducatorJudgment”

71

Page 72: Accountability for College and Career Readiness ......The New Challenge of College- and Career-Readiness: ExpectaIons for Learning are Changing The new context means new expectaIons

QuesDons?SoungBae([email protected])TravisBristol([email protected])

BillyHaun([email protected])PaulLeather([email protected])

ElizabethLeisyStosich([email protected])

LearnMore:hYps://edpolicy.stanford.edu/

72