accessibility: a code compliance and existing conditions assessment and survey of the limerick town...

23
ACCESSIBILITY: A CODE COMPLIANCE AND EXISTING CONDITIONS ASSESSMENT AND SURVEY OF THE LIMERICK TOWN HALL MAIN STREET LIMERICK, ME ttl-Architects LLC 28 Danforth Street Portland, ME 04101 T (207)761-9662 F (207)761-9696

Upload: samantha-riley

Post on 16-Dec-2015

215 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: ACCESSIBILITY: A CODE COMPLIANCE AND EXISTING CONDITIONS ASSESSMENT AND SURVEY OF THE LIMERICK TOWN HALL MAIN STREET LIMERICK, ME ttl-Architects LLC 28

ACCESSIBILITY: A CODE COMPLIANCE AND

EXISTING CONDITIONS ASSESSMENT AND SURVEY

OF THE LIMERICK TOWN HALL

MAIN STREETLIMERICK, ME

ttl-Architects LLC28 Danforth StreetPortland, ME 04101

T (207)761-9662F (207)761-9696

Page 2: ACCESSIBILITY: A CODE COMPLIANCE AND EXISTING CONDITIONS ASSESSMENT AND SURVEY OF THE LIMERICK TOWN HALL MAIN STREET LIMERICK, ME ttl-Architects LLC 28

AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT (ADA)

REQUIRES THAT “PERSONS WITH DISABILITIES ARE TO BE PROVIDED ACCOMMODATIONS AND ACCESS EQUAL TO, OR SIMILAR TO, THAT AVAILABLE TO THE GENERAL PUBLIC.

ALTERATIONS TO HISTORIC PROPERTIES OUGHT TO BE IN FULL COMPLIANCE WITH THE ALTERATION STANDARDS FOR OTHER TYPES OF BUILDINGS.

ALTERATIONS REQUIRE REVIEW BY THE APPROPRIATE LOCAL OR STATE ACCESS BOARD (STATE FIRE MARSHALL’S OFFICE).

Page 3: ACCESSIBILITY: A CODE COMPLIANCE AND EXISTING CONDITIONS ASSESSMENT AND SURVEY OF THE LIMERICK TOWN HALL MAIN STREET LIMERICK, ME ttl-Architects LLC 28

AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT (ADA)

IF BY FOLLOWING THE USUAL STANDARDS, THE HISTORIC SIGNIFICANCE WOULD BE DESTROYED OR THREATENED, THEN ALTERNATIVE STANDARDS MAYBE USED.

PUBLIC ASSEMBLY SPACES IN HISTORIC STRUCTURES MUST MEET THE MINIMUM STANDARDS REQUIRED BY THE ADA TO THE MAXIMUM EXTENT FEASIBLE.

Page 4: ACCESSIBILITY: A CODE COMPLIANCE AND EXISTING CONDITIONS ASSESSMENT AND SURVEY OF THE LIMERICK TOWN HALL MAIN STREET LIMERICK, ME ttl-Architects LLC 28

MINIMUM STANDARDS REQUIRED BY THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES

ACT (ADA) FOR HISTORIC STRUCTURES

ACCESSIBLE ROUTE FROM A DESGINATED PARKING SPOT TO AN ACCESSIBLE ENTRANCE

AN ACCESSIBLE INTERIOR ROUTE FROM THE ENTRANCE TO PUBLIC SPACES ON THE LEVEL OF THE ENTRANCE.

AN ACCESSIBLE ENTRANCE.

AT LEAST 1 ACCESSIBLE UNISEX TOILET ROOM

COMPLY WITH STANDARDS FOR SIGNAGE, DISPLAYS, DOOR HARDWARE, WATER FOUNTAINS, SYSTEM CONTROLS, EXHIBITS, ETC.

Page 5: ACCESSIBILITY: A CODE COMPLIANCE AND EXISTING CONDITIONS ASSESSMENT AND SURVEY OF THE LIMERICK TOWN HALL MAIN STREET LIMERICK, ME ttl-Architects LLC 28

LIFE SAFETY:

A CODE COMPLIANCE AND EXISTING CONDITIONS

ASSESSMENT AND SURVEY OF THE LIMERICK TOWN HALL

MAIN STREET

LIMERICK, ME

Page 6: ACCESSIBILITY: A CODE COMPLIANCE AND EXISTING CONDITIONS ASSESSMENT AND SURVEY OF THE LIMERICK TOWN HALL MAIN STREET LIMERICK, ME ttl-Architects LLC 28

ASSESSED USING INTERNATIONAL BUILDING CODE AND NATIONAL FIRE PROTECTION AGENCY

PUBLICATIONS

Doors do not meet hardware and egress requirements.

The stairs do not meet the handrail, guardrail, and riser/tread requirements for existing egress stairs.

The electrical system does not have safety features like ground fault interrupters and hardwired smoke detectors.

Page 7: ACCESSIBILITY: A CODE COMPLIANCE AND EXISTING CONDITIONS ASSESSMENT AND SURVEY OF THE LIMERICK TOWN HALL MAIN STREET LIMERICK, ME ttl-Architects LLC 28

There are no hardwired-smoke detectors, heat detectors, carbon monoxide detectors, a sprinkler system or lightning protection.

There is no fire separation between the boiler and oil tank enclosures and the remaining spaces.

The fire escape is rusted and of insufficient design to serve as a second means of egress. In addition, the egress path of the fire escape passes several windows, which pose a significant threat to anyone using the fire escape.

Page 8: ACCESSIBILITY: A CODE COMPLIANCE AND EXISTING CONDITIONS ASSESSMENT AND SURVEY OF THE LIMERICK TOWN HALL MAIN STREET LIMERICK, ME ttl-Architects LLC 28

STRUBLE ENGINEERING, LLC603 Main Street

Reading, MA 01867-3002(781) 942-3845

(781) 942-7083 Fax

“The present stairs and fire escape do not provide handicap access.” Struble Engineering 1/10/2007

“This fire escape appears inadequate for use as public egress in the event of a fire.”

Struble Engineering 1/10/21007

Page 9: ACCESSIBILITY: A CODE COMPLIANCE AND EXISTING CONDITIONS ASSESSMENT AND SURVEY OF THE LIMERICK TOWN HALL MAIN STREET LIMERICK, ME ttl-Architects LLC 28

A new addition would be needed to achieve the goal of providing such access and could also be used to replace the non-Code compliant fire escape now serving the existing building.

Such an addition would have to be structurally separate due to the fact that the present building uses unreinforced masonry as its lateral load resisting system which is prohibited in new construction of the type needed for this (egress) addition.

STRUBLE ENGINEERING, LLC603 Main Street

Reading, MA 01867-3002(781) 942-3845

(781) 942-7083 Fax

Page 10: ACCESSIBILITY: A CODE COMPLIANCE AND EXISTING CONDITIONS ASSESSMENT AND SURVEY OF THE LIMERICK TOWN HALL MAIN STREET LIMERICK, ME ttl-Architects LLC 28
Page 11: ACCESSIBILITY: A CODE COMPLIANCE AND EXISTING CONDITIONS ASSESSMENT AND SURVEY OF THE LIMERICK TOWN HALL MAIN STREET LIMERICK, ME ttl-Architects LLC 28

ACCESSIBLE ROUTE FROM A DESGINATED PARKING SPOT TO AN ACCESSIBLE ENTRANCE

Page 12: ACCESSIBILITY: A CODE COMPLIANCE AND EXISTING CONDITIONS ASSESSMENT AND SURVEY OF THE LIMERICK TOWN HALL MAIN STREET LIMERICK, ME ttl-Architects LLC 28

NEW SIDE ADDITION WITH A STAIR & ELEVATOR

ACCESSIBLE ROUTE FROM A DESGINATED PARKING SPOT.

AN ACCESSIBLE ENTRANCE.

AN ACCESSIBLE INTERIOR ROUTE FROM THE ENTRANCE TO PUBLIC SPACES ON THE LEVEL OF THE ENTRANCE. (ttl-arch)

Page 13: ACCESSIBILITY: A CODE COMPLIANCE AND EXISTING CONDITIONS ASSESSMENT AND SURVEY OF THE LIMERICK TOWN HALL MAIN STREET LIMERICK, ME ttl-Architects LLC 28

3411.9.2 Multilevel buildings and facilities. An accessible route from an accessible entrance to

public spaces on the level of the accessible entrance shall be

provided.

IBC 2009 Existing Building Accessibility Section 3411

Page 14: ACCESSIBILITY: A CODE COMPLIANCE AND EXISTING CONDITIONS ASSESSMENT AND SURVEY OF THE LIMERICK TOWN HALL MAIN STREET LIMERICK, ME ttl-Architects LLC 28
Page 15: ACCESSIBILITY: A CODE COMPLIANCE AND EXISTING CONDITIONS ASSESSMENT AND SURVEY OF THE LIMERICK TOWN HALL MAIN STREET LIMERICK, ME ttl-Architects LLC 28

Side Addition Location

Page 16: ACCESSIBILITY: A CODE COMPLIANCE AND EXISTING CONDITIONS ASSESSMENT AND SURVEY OF THE LIMERICK TOWN HALL MAIN STREET LIMERICK, ME ttl-Architects LLC 28

Life Safety Cost Estimate in 2007 $’s

Provide GFCI Outlets $1,850 Hardwire Smoke Detectors $1,500 Install Lever Hardware $4,500

Fire Extinguishers $900 Emergency Signs & Lighting $3,200 Lightening Protection $2,100 Sprinkler in Boiler Room $3,000 1 Hr Partitions in Basement $2,500 Remove Fire Escape $2,750 New Electrical Fixtures in Addition $6,000 New Stair Tower $112,000

Total $140,300

Page 17: ACCESSIBILITY: A CODE COMPLIANCE AND EXISTING CONDITIONS ASSESSMENT AND SURVEY OF THE LIMERICK TOWN HALL MAIN STREET LIMERICK, ME ttl-Architects LLC 28

Handicap Accessibility Cost Estimate 2007 $’s

Accessible Exterior Route $750

Accessible Interior Route $1,500

Accessible Entrance $15,000

4 Stop Elevator $130,000

Upgrade Electrical Service $15,000

$162,250

Page 18: ACCESSIBILITY: A CODE COMPLIANCE AND EXISTING CONDITIONS ASSESSMENT AND SURVEY OF THE LIMERICK TOWN HALL MAIN STREET LIMERICK, ME ttl-Architects LLC 28

Life Safety $ 140,300

Handicap Accessibility $ 162,250

Total $ 302,550

+ Architectural Design/Specifications Cost

Page 19: ACCESSIBILITY: A CODE COMPLIANCE AND EXISTING CONDITIONS ASSESSMENT AND SURVEY OF THE LIMERICK TOWN HALL MAIN STREET LIMERICK, ME ttl-Architects LLC 28

Funding Possibilities

Page 20: ACCESSIBILITY: A CODE COMPLIANCE AND EXISTING CONDITIONS ASSESSMENT AND SURVEY OF THE LIMERICK TOWN HALL MAIN STREET LIMERICK, ME ttl-Architects LLC 28

$ 56,000 available & approved

$250,000 in the Capital Improvement Account (unencumbered)

Write a Grant to help off set elevator cost

Fund Raiser – Veterans ‘Hall of Honor’

*********************************

Page 21: ACCESSIBILITY: A CODE COMPLIANCE AND EXISTING CONDITIONS ASSESSMENT AND SURVEY OF THE LIMERICK TOWN HALL MAIN STREET LIMERICK, ME ttl-Architects LLC 28
Page 22: ACCESSIBILITY: A CODE COMPLIANCE AND EXISTING CONDITIONS ASSESSMENT AND SURVEY OF THE LIMERICK TOWN HALL MAIN STREET LIMERICK, ME ttl-Architects LLC 28

Next Steps?

Discussion

Page 23: ACCESSIBILITY: A CODE COMPLIANCE AND EXISTING CONDITIONS ASSESSMENT AND SURVEY OF THE LIMERICK TOWN HALL MAIN STREET LIMERICK, ME ttl-Architects LLC 28