academic writing.docx
TRANSCRIPT
1.0 Introduction
When we tried to search about the definition of culture, there are many different results
came out. Many philosophers describe culture based on their own perspective and knowledge.
As for me, I could describe culture is a group of people that share the same cumulative beliefs,
values, attitudes, religions and also concepts of the universe and pass it from generations to
another. According to Thomas Wolfe, “Culture is the arts elevated to a set of beliefs”, which
concluded that culture is something to do with beliefs in one’s self. Culture is like the food to the
soul of human body, without it, a human will be pointless and soul will be regardless empty.
Malaysia is a special country because Malaysia has an extremely culturally diverse to
offer. This multiracial country has a population of 23.27 million consisting of (61%) Malays,
(30%) Chinese and (8%) Indians. The Chinese community, for example, uses a number of
dialects including Hokkien, Hakka, Cantonese and Mandarin. For the Indian society, the
language spoken is Tamil, and for the Malay, the language spoken is Bahasa Malayu (Hassan,
2005). These three largest ethnic groups which are Malays, Chinese and Indians follow different
cultures and traditions, and commonly profess different religions. They have different codes of
dress, customs, value systems and beliefs (Jamil & Abd. Razak, 2010). Other groups (13%) that
make up the population include the Eurasians and indigenous groups in the Sabah and
Sarawak regions like the Kadazans, Dusuns, Muruts, Ibans, Bidayuhs, Penans, just to name a
few (Ishak, 2009).
Total population of 60.4% using Islam religion, Buddhism 19.2%, Christianity 9.1%,
Hinduism 6.3% and others 5.0%. Malaysia has a plural society with people of different religions
and races living harmony under one roof even each person maintains its traditional culture.
Each citizen can freely practice their culture, religion and belief without any complication faced.
This uniqueness of races, religions and cultures become one of Malaysia’s ways to attract
tourists from all over the world.
Cultural diversity in Malaysia has affected many ways in Malaysian’s life styles, food,
music and others but all this difference significantly good for the country itself. The same case
goes when multicultural students in one same class. Therefore, before implementing any
lesson, teacher need to carefully using this aspect of multicultural for gain successful outcome.
This is because cultural difference is not something simple and easy that can be left out from
the sight. As teachers, we must know about multicultural effect towards teaching and learning in
classroom and prevent any bad consequences from happen.
After age 9, racial attitudes tend to stay the same unless the child has a life-changing
experience (Aboud, 1988). However, before that happen, we still have a good chance to help
children develop positive perspective about their racial and cultural identity. We can also
challenge the immature thinking that is typical of very young children. That's important because
this type of thinking can lead to prejudice (York, 1991). Here, I can wrap up that teacher clearly
hold a crucial role to gain positive effects from multicultural aspect in the classroom.
2.0 Implication of multiculture toward teaching and learning in classroom
2.1 Cultural Awareness
The presence of varied ethnic groups in classroom has resulted in cultural awareness in
the students’ self. Teachers who are aware of the impacts of cultural differences are more likely
to bring children’s different cultures into the classroom (Gay, 1994). Therefore, teacher can
highlight about the art of culture in topic “Culture and Tradition”, Unit 9 in the English Year 5
syllabus. In this topic, teacher will able to introduce to the students about cultural diversity in
Malaysia and what arts are represented by each of the culture. Example, Malay’s unique art
forms such as wayang kulit, silat, makyong and gamelan while the Indians have enriched the
country with ancient dance traditions such as Bharatanatyam and Odissi, as well as the
energetic Bhangra from Punjab. On the other hand, the Chinese also have their own lion dance
and war drums that play firm part in country’s culture. Other minorities in Malaysia also have
their traditional dances like the Sumazau from the Kadazandusun in Sabah and the Ngajat by
the Iban of Sarawak.
When the students are learning about other cultures, they will trying to embrace
differences between cultures and accept it without hesitation. Their views and perspectives
became broader and this will make them to show sensitivity for the differences between
cultures. Example, Chinese students are interested to get to know better about Indian’s dance
and also give it a try. For exchange, the Indian students are also showing efforts to learn about
Chinese’s taboo, cuisine and dance. As a result, the cultural awareness will be implemented,
while racism and discrimination will be erased indirectly.
Multicultural education is both a concept and deliberate process designed to teach
learners to recognize, accept and appreciate differences in culture, ethnicity, social class,
sexual orientation, religion, special needs and gender (Baruth, L.G & Manning, M.L 2008). This
statement obviously supported that teacher can use the aspect of cultural diversity in the
classroom to enhance cultural awareness and promote acceptance of culture between the
students. When the students are aware with the cultural difference between them, they will more
understand about the nature of culture and how it works. Therefore, all the unwanted
consequences will be banned and students also become more comfortable to expose and share
their culture.
According to Winkelman (2005), awareness of cultural differences and their impact on
behavior is the beginning of intercultural effectiveness. He states that “cultural self-awareness
includes recognition of one’s own cultural influences upon values, beliefs, and judgments, as
well as the influences derived from the professional’s work culture”. When students are
successfully aware about cultural differences, they will being conscious of other’s values,
beliefs, perceptions and religions.
Cultural awareness implies to being open to the idea of changing cultural attitudes. It is
important as a way to help members of a multicultural team identify where things may be going
wrong to best leverage their differences. Without some sort of formal cross cultural awareness
training it is difficult for multicultural teams to identify areas that need attention.
2.2 Unity
For a number of years teachers have become more interested in multicultural education,
with the assumption that such approaches help children feel more welcomed, validated,
integrated, and able to cooperate with others in their classroom (Allen, McNeill, & Schmidt,
1992; Bredenkamp, 1986; Byrnes & Kiger, 1992; Gollnick & Chin, 1994). The statement above
definitely think that teaching using multicultural aspect will able the students to cooperate and
unite in their community. When the students know better about each other’s culture, they will not
feel neglected and left out. It is because all the students feel that they are belong into the class
community and the unity become stronger. One of the way to show unity is when the festival
season.
There are tons of festivals and celebrations held at Malaysia. Teacher can teaches
about the festival season in Unit 2, “Proud to be a Malaysian” in Year 6 syllabus. One of
Malaysia’s customs when the festival season is the ‘Open House’ concept where celebrating
community will play host to the others in their homes. For example, when Hari Raya celebration,
families and friends from different cultures would visit their homes that celebrating. The guests
come to share the happiness and enjoy the feast prepared by the hosts. It is an unspoken rule
that everybody is welcome at an open house. Teacher can asks the students to act out this
particular scenery in the classroom to give them clearer view about the situation in ‘Open
House’ during Hari Raya or other festivals.
When this activity is being carry out in the classroom, students will know how the Malays
celebrating Hari Raya, their traditional festival cuisine and clothes. To make it even livelier,
teacher can bring the actual food such as lemang, ketupat, rendang and biscuits. As the host of
‘Open House’, Malays students can wear their traditional Baju Kurung and Baju Melayu.
Therefore, as the guest, Chinese, Indian and Iban students need to politely enter the ‘Open
House’ and start a simple conversation with the hosts. They can converse about how delightful
the foods are and get to know each other like what is their name and where do they live.
According to Keow, 2008, “education serves as a common platform upon which all
ethnic groups can come together and interact with each other in order to achieve a significant
degree of understanding and tolerance”. Throughout the conversation process, the students will
learn to respect about other cultures and finally become closer with each other. After all, this
activity help to strengthen the ties among themselves.
When unity between the students are strong and unbreakable, they can reject any idea
or possibility of racism to happen. Like Henry Ward Beecher said, “That is true culture which
helps us to work for the social betterment of all.”
2.3 Mutual Respect
Earn respect to be respected. If one wants to be respected for their culture, belief and
religion, then one has to show that they have respect for others and their respect is always true
blue and cannot easily be swaged. Mutual respect takes constant maintaining and effort to keep
it. Even a smallest mistake can make a huge damage to the respect, and once it gone, people
will always walk away and it is hard to get nearer to them anymore. Differences in culture, belief
and religion is not something that easily can be accepted especially for young children who still
have narrow and immature thinking about life. Coexisting peacefully, based on mutual respect,
is not a given but instead has to be learned, with the target group being all students (Batelaan,
2004: 54). Therefore, teacher need to be wise and creative to develop mutual respect even
though there is a fine boundary between them.
In the multicultural classroom, teacher must shed old practices such as biasness in the
students based their races and then, modify the lesson and change the traditions. Instead of
asking questions to students which compels them to respond in terms of just one particular
culture group, teachers need to be more universal in asking question. Open-ended question
technique encourages all the students to participate actively in the lesson because each student
feels that they are able to speak out their opinion. By embracing these principles in teaching,
teachers enable to create a climate of diversity and fostering mutual respect in the classroom.
This is because the students feel that their opinion is respectfully taken by everybody in the
classroom include the different races students. In short, mutual respect is one of the positive
implications from the open ended question technique using multi culture aspect in the
classroom.
To create a safe environment in multi culture classroom, teacher need to emphasize
each students’ duty which is to learn how to deal with these variations, accept and respect the
difference.
Too much example either similarities or differences will make the students feel prejudice
and lose their respect to other culture. Does not mean that less powerful groups of students who
is the minority of the class deserve the least respect and attention. Thus, a good multicultural
education need to be balanced to fulfill each student’s needs and requirements.
Other than that, teacher indeed to make it very clear that that there is no room for
disrespect of different cultures in the classroom. In this way, targeted students who is young
children know immediately that is not appropriate to be rude and underestimate about other
culture. Multi culture element in the classroom can transform the students to be the person with
much better judgment about differences in culture. With this cleverer thinking, each student will
get the respect that they are deserved to.
Respecting difference is important for preventing the exploitation of less powerful groups, but it can be dangerously divisive if it leads to stereotyping. Educators need to provide a balanced view that does not exaggerate either the similarities or the differences that exist among people of different groups or within the same group (Booth, 1999: 23).
All teachers are responsible for teaching students about all kinds of people both during formal instruction and during informal, casual conversations. Experienced teachers do not realize what strong influences and powerful role models they are for young people as they demonstrate the importance of being aware of others, valuing cultural diversity and behaving respectfully toward others. Frequently, young students never even realize how they were exposed to negative role-modeling by their teachers (Cabello & Burstein, 1995).
Teachers serve as essential role models as they demonstrate the importance of learning
and valuing about other cultures. It is because teachers give significant effects on young
students that also include the negative ones. In that case, teachers should expose culture to the
students carefully so that the students will absorb only the good influences from the teachers.
Teachers also can use this advantage to develop mutual respect between the students because
in the students’ eye, they put teachers at a very high position.
According to Kofi Annan, Former Secretary-General of the United Nations, "Tolerance,
inter-cultural dialogue and respect for diversity are more essential than ever in a world where
peoples are becoming more and more closely interconnected." Hence, teacher need to use
multi culture is one of the booster to obtain tolerance and mutual respect in the classroom
community. Without mutual respect, harmony classroom environment is impossible to happen.
2.4 Prejudice Reduction
Studies of the effect of multi culture towards teaching and learning in classroom
commonly reveal a positive effect. Studies have supported about how differences in issue of
race and culture in classroom can lead to less prejudice, (Aboud & Doyle, 1996a, 1996b; Aboud
& Fenwick, 1999; Aboud & Levy, 2000), suggesting that a greater integration of multicultural
curricular content will generally lead to improved rather than worsened or unchanged relations
between the students.
Changing the racial climate between and among students at schools is an important aspect of multicultural educational practice because of the detrimental role that prejudice and racism play in the everyday educational experiences of students of color (Steele, 1997; Zirkel, 2004, 2005, 2008c).
All teachers are responsible for teaching students about all kinds of people both during formal instruction and during informal, casual conversations. Experienced teachers do not realize what strong influences and powerful role models they are for young people as they demonstrate the importance of being aware of others, valuing cultural diversity and behaving respectfully toward others. Frequently, young students never even realize how they were exposed to negative role-modeling by their teachers (Cabello & Burstein, 1995).
As the guider, teacher have to know the most effective way to change the racial climate
in the classroom so that prejudice and racism will never occur. One of the ways is facilitating
open classroom discussion about current issues of culture and racism. Open discussion is
efficient for decreasing prejudice between students and improving their relationships. When the
students know better about other culture, all the nonsense prejudice will be erased. The
students will finally understand that each culture has their own unique beliefs and need to be
give a same fair position. The students will not tolerate with any actions of prejudice and racism
because they think that their friendship is the ultimate culture of all.
According to the study above, it is crystal clear that when the students engage actively in
discussion of their beliefs, the prejudice and racist attitude will be reduced. It is because they
have chance to share about the specialty and uniqueness of their heritage of culture. This
opportunity also give a parallel benefit to the other students that act as the listener of the
discussion.
The exchange of opinions and thoughts will change the way students look at the culture.
Like before, Malay students think that all Chinese and Indian students are outsiders that came
to Malaysia and did not deserve any national integrity. However, after hearing Chinese and
Indian students’ feeling towards culture, and how high level of their patriotism, the Malays will
understand that they absolutely not outsider, but also Malaysians that have different cultures. All
prejudice image, ideas are answered by the outcome of the discussion.
Multicultural classroom has made the students to throw away their negative judgment
about other culture because they will appreciate their relationship with their friends. The strength
of relationship is much tighter and they will not let anything goes between them even it is about
their own heritage of culture. In a whole, prejudice reduction is also helping students develop
more positive attitudes about people of different races and ethnicities because their view in
judgment become wiser.
3.0 Conclusion
Interventions that focus fairly directly on changing students’ attitudes about race and ethnicity by having them engage in direct discussions of their beliefs have proved effective in reducing prejudice and racist attitudes among K–12 students, at least in the short term (Aboud & Doyle, 1996b; Aboud & Fenwick,1999).
Teaching is not the best job most of the time, and teaching in the multicultural classroom
is one of the real challenges that every teacher need to deal with. Despite using the old teaching
strategies, teachers should practice brand new strategy from time to time. However, there is no
real magic potion that teachers can use to make teaching in multicultural class instantaneously
easy; there is no short cut or simple solution. Somehow, teachers must creatively use the
aspect of existence multi culture in classroom to gain positive outcome such as cultural
awareness, unity and mutual respect.
According to Kofi, “almost every country in the world has citizen that practicing different
religions and cultures, and this overlapping identities can help to keep us together”. Unity can be
developed and finally peace can be found everywhere like white sand in the beach. Although
the differences is huge, we can still love and embrace our life without any hatred. Proudly, we
can thrive in our own tradition, but at the same time, we can still learn about other culture and
faith. Within this, they know that respect other culture is a compulsory thing to do in a society.
Although, there are many problems regarding teaching and learning in a multi culture
classroom, a serious benefits also can be taken from it. Furthermore, teaching and learning in
multi culture classroom setting is expected as the globalization of world are surprisingly
increasing nowaday. Multiculturalism offer numerous advantages and we should try to
implement it in ourselves. Each and every Malaysian must consider that cultural differences is
not a big barrier, but it is a challenge to trigger themselves to strive for the excellence and be a
better citizen of this country.
"People of different religions and cultures live side by side in almost every part of the world, and most of us have overlapping identities which unite us with very different groups. We can love what we are, without hating what – and who – we are not. We can thrive in our own tradition, even as we learn from others, and come to respect their teachings." —Kofi Annan, Former Secretary-General of the United Nations