a winning strategy: combine military force with good governance, by kori schake

8/20/2019 A Winning Strategy: Combine Military Force with Good Governance, by Kori Schake

1/9Cnnv`r Lastltutlna Tnrjlad Drnup na Flhltkry Clstnry

]kitlikh Yuii`ss vs. Ytrkt`dli Rlitnry


2/9

K CNNR@U LAY]L]P]LNA @YYK\ NA ]KI]LIKH YPII@YY RY. Y]UK]@DLI RLI]NU\

K Tlaalad Ytrkt`dyINFELA@ FLHL]KU\ BNUI@ TL]C DNNM DNR@UAKAI@

JNUL YICKJ@

@mfuam Eurj` la ;442 e`st ickrkit`rlz`m tc` aktur` nb tc` prneh`f w` anw

bki`? ‘]c` us` nb bnri` khna` ls eut t`fpnrkry: lt fky suemu` bnr k fnfàt eut

lt mn`s ant r`fnv` tc` aì`sslty nb suemulad kdkla ” kam k aktlna ls ant tn e`

dnv`ra`m tckt fust p`rp`tukhhy e` inaqu`r`m.‖ Lt nahy kmms pnldakaiy tn tc`

r`stìtlna tckt tc` ‘aktlna‖ kenut wclic Eurj` spnj` infprls`m Erltkla“s tclrt`à

rè`hhlnus Anrtc Kf`rlika inhnal`s. La cls ‘Yp`ìc na Inailhlktlna wltc Kf`rlik,‖

Eurj` kpp`kh`m tn cls dnv`rafàt ant tn r`hy na flhltkry f`kas nb suppr`ssladtc` uprlslad, eut last`km tn lfprnv` tc` qukhlty nb dnv`rakai` Kf`rlikas w`r`

`xp`rlàilad. Dklalad tc` vnhuatkry kiqul`siài` nb tcns` Erltkla wnuhm ruh` wks

tc` rldct brkf` nb r`b`rài` bnr Erltkla“s strkt`dy. C` inaslm`r`m flhltkry bnri`

‘k b`èh̀ lastrufàt‖ bnr tckt purpns`.

]c` Palt`m Ytkt̀ s us`m flhltkry bnri` ks tc` prlailpkh f`kas nb stkt` pnw`r la lts

inaqu`st nb Lamlka trle`s ks Kf`rlika s`tth`rs spr`km kirnss tc` inatlaàt kam la

tc` Ckwkllka Lshkams: eut tc` dnv`rafàt“s neoìtlv` wks tc` `xtlaitlna nb tc`

lamldànus wky nb hlb`. La hkams Kf`rlikas wnuhm ant lackelt, Eurj`“s kpprnkic wksr`p`kt`mhy prnvà entc fnr` ̀ bbìtlv` kam ic`kp`r tcka pr`mnflakat r`hlkai` na

flhltkry bnri`.

Unns`v`ht“s Inrnhhkry tn tc` Fnarn` Mnitrla`, prnpnuam`m murlad tc` Rà`zu`hka

mèt irlsls nb ;


3/9

5

Jnrl Yickj` • K Tlaalad Ytrkt`dy? Infela` Flhltkry Bnri` wltc Dnnm Dnv`rakai`

ey ikumlhhn dnv`rafàts prìlpltkt`m k e`vy nb Kf`rlika lat`rvàtlnas la tc`

Mnflalika U`puehli, Ckltl, Alikrkduk, F`xlin, kam Dukt`fkhk wcà tcns`

dnv`rafàts tcr`ktà`m m`bkuht (nbtà, kbt`r k flhltkry inup k ikumlhhn wnuhm

ktt`fpt tn r`pumlkt̀ tc` mèts nb cls pr`mì`ssnrs). Lt wks la tc`s` niiupktlnas

tckt tc` Kf`rlika dnv`rafàt ikf` tn kpprìlkt` Eurj`“s kpprnkic.

]c` Fkrla` Inrps“s ;


4/9

9

Cnnv`r Lastltutlna • Ytkabnrm Palv`rslty

tc` pnhltlikh, ìnanfli, kam snilkh myakflis aì`sskry tn prnmui` strkt`dli

(kam tc`r`bnr` sustklakeh`) nutinf̀ s. T` kr` s`tthlad bnr wckt @mfuam Eurj`

ikutlnà m 59< y`krs kdn ls tc` t`fpnrkry us` nb bnri`.

Kf`rlik“s c`d`fnali fnfàt dkv` us suic k w`khtc nb pnw`r tckt w` w`r`

kbbnrm`m, kam tnnj, tc` nppnrtualty tn e` shnppy la tc` inamuit nb nur aktlnakh

sìurlty. T` mìhla`m tn put nur b`m`rkh spàmlad na k sustklakeh` bnntlad tckt

wnuhm j``p tc` ìnanfy drnwlad kam r`tkla mlsir`tlnakry spki` bnr cldc`r

m`bàs` ̀ xpàmltur`s. T` khhnw`m nur mlphnfktli pnw`r tn ktrnpcy kam trkasb`rr`m

`v`r hkrd`r kfnuats nb lac`ràthy ilvlhlka kitlvlty latn tc` flhltkry last`km nb

erladlad tc` Ytkt` M`pkrtfàt up tn k stkamkrm nb p`rbnrfkai` km`qukt` tn lts

r`spnaslelhltl`s. T̀ r`mui`m nur f`kas nb lasplrlad tcns` wcn kr` nur akturkh khhl`s

ey scutt`rlad tc` PY Labnrfktlna Kdàiy kam ntc`r dnv`rafàtkh prnpkdktlnas

nb Kf`rlika lm`khs kam iuhtur` ” kam khsn ey e`lad tcnudcth`ss nb tc` lfpr`sslnanur e`ckvlnr wks ckvlad. T` sckijh`m nur flhltkry wltc k mysbuaitlnakh w`kpnas

prniur`fàt syst`f kam k tclij kmlpns` hky`r nb kmflalstrktlv` r`qulr`fàts kam

snilkh pnhlil`s tckt lfp`m` lts kelhlty tn dct. T` mìhla`m tn cnhm nur pnhltlikh

h`km`rs kiinuatkeh` bnr wlaalad nur wkrs. Ks Yckj`sp`kr` cks Càry R kiius`

Yirnp`, ‘\nu ckv` e`à rìjh`ss wltc nur rnykh p`rsna.‖ T` nudct tn inaslm`r nur

inuatry v`ry, v`ry bnrtuakt` tckt ̀ a`fl`s ckv` ant ̀ f`rd`m e`tt`r keh` tn tkj`

kmvkatkd̀ nb nur s`hb-lfpns`m mlb iuhtl`s.

Ehkf` bnr tc` bklhur` nb strkt̀ dy la nur iurràt wkrs r`sts rst kam bnr`fnst wltc

tc` ̀ hìt`m pnhltlikh h`km`rsclp. Lt ls tc` r`spnaslelhlty nb tc` pr`slmàt nb tc`

Palt`m Ytkt̀ s tn prntìt kam kmvkai` nur aktlnakh sìurlty. ]c` hkst twn pr`slmàts

ckv` e`à la tcrkhh tn nur stràdtc kam tn nur w`kja`ss, r`spìtlv`hy. Last`km nb

tc` c`khtcy prumài` tckt strkt`dlst/kutcnr Inhla Drky lastruits ls tc` eksls

nb tc` prkitli` nb strkt`dy, tc` hkst twn pr`slmàtlkh kmflalstrktlnas ckv` ant e`à

sirupuhnus la `xkflalad tc` pntàtlkh inas`quài`s nb tc`lr fkonr aktlnakh

sìurlty icnli`s. Wr`slmàt Eusc m` a`m pnhltlikh àm stkt`s bnr Kbdckalstka kam

Lrkq tckt w`r` ant kicl`vkeh̀ ey tc` f`kas c` wks wlhhlad tn lav`st. Wr`slmàt

Nekfk dkv` prlfkiy tn àmlad Kf`rlika lavnhv̀ fàt la tc` wkrs lrr`spìtlv`

nb tc` pnhltlikh àm stkt`s. Tckt entc bklhur`s ckv` la inffna ls ka lakelhlty tn

fkrry àms kam f`kas. Ylai` strkt`dy inaslsts nb fkticlad tcns` twn tclads, lt

ls kxlnfktli tckt a`ltc`r pr`slmàt kit`m strkt`dlikhhy.


5/9


6/9

0


prn ilàiy tcka ls fna`y. ]c` Ytkt` eumd t̀ cks lair`ks`m suestkatlkhhy slai` 577;

kam tc` slz` nb tc` Bnr`lda Y`rvli` cks mnueh`m, eut tc` prneh`fs nb p`rsnaa`h

fkakd`fàt tckt pr`vàt lt brnf eìnflad tc` p``r nb tc` M`pkrtfàt nb M`bàs`

ckv` ant e`à kmmr`ss`m. ]c` Bnr`lda Y`rvli` cks tc` huxury nb e`lad ks s`hìtlv`

ks Ytkabnrm Palv`rslty? lt cks slxt`à qukhl `m kpphlikats bnr `v`ry Bnr`lda Y`rvli`

nb i`r lt clr`s. Kam y`t, ey lts nwa kmflsslna, lt mn`s ant ckv` p`nph` wltc tc`

sjlhhs lt a``ms. Lt mn`sa“t clr` tc` rldct p`nph`, lt j``ps tc`f khh, kam lt mn`sa“t t`kic

tc`f kaytclad. ]c` hkst tcr`` sìr`tkrl`s nb stkt` (Wnw`hh, Uli`, kam Ihlatna) khh

prnvlm`m buamlad kam p`rsnaa`h shnts bnr Ytkt` tn m`v`hnp k prndrkf nb prnb`sslnakh

`muiktlna. La khh tcr`` iks`s, Ytkt` mlv`rt`m tc` fna`y kam p`nph` tn lair`ks`

stkb ad kt `fekssl`s. Lt ls k rìlp` bnr lastltutlnakh bklhur`, ke`tt`m ey fkakd`rlkh

lakttàtlna.

Lb w` kr` tn krr`st tc` ktrnpcylad nb nur aktlnakh sìurlty stràdtc, nur pnhltlikhh`km`rs wlhh a``m tn eìnf` janwh`md`keh` kdkla kenut strkt`dy, sn tckt tc`y m`slda

Kf`rlik“s ̀ adkd`fàt wltc tc` wnrhm r`hylad ant akrrnwhy na tc` lastrufàt

nb nur flhltkry“s pnw`r tn latlflmkt ,̀ eut na tc` fuic wlm`r nric`strk nb nur

inuatry“s kelhlty tn lastuài` kam lasplr`. Wnhltlikh h`km`rs fust h`kra tn eìnf`

nric`strktnrs nb k fuhtlphlilty nb lastrufàts, kam pki` tc` fusli suic tckt tc`y

wnrj tnd`tc`r.

]c` Palt`m Ytkt̀ s nb Kf`rlik ls k inuatry dnnm kt sn fkay tclads, kam fnst

nb tc`f kr` nutslm` tc` r`kic nb nur nwa dnv`rafàt. T` ckv` tc` wnrhm“s

a`st ualv`rsltl`s kam lts fnst myakfli dà`rktnrs nb tìcanhndlikh laanvktlna.

T` m`s`rv` pnhltlikh h`km`rs wcn wlhh r`kic e`ynam tc` akrrnw h`v`rs tc`

dnv`rafàt ika inatrnh tn àdkd` tc` lavnhv`fàt kam ir`ktlvlty nb f`kas

e`ynam dnv`rafàt inatrnh. Lt ls tcns` ‘snbt pnw`rs‖ wltc wclic tc` Palt`m

Ytkt`s sckp`s tc` lat`raktlnakh ̀ avlrnafàt, kam wclic pròumli` fnst inuatrl`s

kam fnst p`nph` la tc` wnrhm ant tn nppns` wckt w` kr` s``jlad tn mn. T` ckv`

uam`r`stlfkt`m bnr tc` pkst twàty y`krs cnw fuic tckt dnnmwlhh mrlv`s mnwa

tc` prli` nb wckt nur inuatry ktt`fpts tn mn la tc` wnrhm.

Nur bklhur`s kr` ant tc` r`suht nb lat`rvàlad la tc` wrnad phki`s. Tclh` w` ika

icnns` wc`tc`r kam cnw tn lat̀ rvà`, tc` ualv`rs` nb kitlvlty ls m` a`m ey wc`r`

tc` prneh`fs kr`. Tckt fkj`s lat`rvàtlnas suii``m nr bklh ls tc` qukhlty nb

tclajlad tckt cks dna` latn m`t`rflalad tc` aktur` nb tc` prneh`f kam irkbtlad

k phka bnr àdkdlad lt.


7/9

2

Jnrl Yickj` • K Tlaalad Ytrkt`dy? Infela` Flhltkry Bnri` wltc Dnnm Dnv`rakai`

Nur bklhur`s kr` tc` r`suht nb drnwlad hkzy kt tc` prkitli` nb strkt`dy. @v`a la tc`

pnst-


8/9

4


]c` puehlsc`r cks fkm` tcls wnrj kvklhkeh` uam`r k Ir`ktlv` Inffnas Kttrleutlna-AnM`rlvs hliàs` 9.7. ]n vl`w k inpynb tcls hliàs`, vlslt cttp?//ir`ktlvìnffnas.nrd/hliàs`s/ey-am/9.7.

Cnnv`r Lastltutlna Wr`ss kssuf`s an r`spnaslelhlty bnr tc` p`rslstài` nr kiiurkiy nb PUHs bnr `xt`rakh nr tclrm-pkrtyLat`ra`t wèslt`s r`b`rr`m tn la tcls puehliktlna, kam mn`s ant dukrkat`` tckt kay inatàt na suic wèslt`s ls, nr wlhhr`fkla, kiiurkt` nr kpprnprlkt`.

Inpyrldct © 57;0 ey tc` Enkrm nb ]rust``s nb tc` H`hkam Ytkabnrm Oualnr Palv`rslty


9/9

a winning strategy: combine military force with good governance, by kori schake

Documents