a summary of research into the irlen method - june 2014[1] · what causes irlen syndrome? as is the...

11
1 A Summary of Research into the Irlen Method (Updated June 2014) Irlen Syndrome is a disorder that many people are not familiar with, and as such, it often goes unidentified and untreated, leaving children to struggle well into adulthood. This document is intended to provide a thorough background of the disorder and its treatment, offer a current and up-to-date analysis of the scientific research that has been conducted on the disorder and the efficacy of treatment over the last 30 years, and explain the impact that this disorder can have on not just school success, but future job and life success, if left unidentified and untreated. Within this document, you will find the following: A definition of Irlen Syndrome and the areas of functioning it can impact An explanation of the Irlen Method of Colored Overlay and Spectral Filters used to treat the disorder A review of some of the most current and relevant scientific research, as well as highlights from key educational pilot studies and reports presented to school districts around the world that have chosen to implement Irlen Screening methods and Colored Overlays Defining Irlen Syndrome Irlen Syndrome (sometimes referred to in the literature as Meares-Irlen Syndrome, Scotopic Sensitivity Syndrome, or Visual Stress) is a problem with the brain, not the eye. It is a perceptual processing disorder, not a visual problem, a finding that the most current brain imaging research supports. In simplistic terms, when an individual suffers from Irlen Syndrome, their brain has difficulty or an inability processing certain wavelengths of light. In this way, light (especially bright and fluorescent lighting) becomes a stressor on the brain. This stress causes certain parts of the brain (e.g., the visual cortex) to become overactive. It is this over-activity and inability to effectively process visual stimuli that creates a variety of visual, physical, cognitive, emotional, and neurological symptoms. As one might expect, symptoms of Irlen Syndrome include difficulty with reading and comprehension, issues with stability and clarity of print, and difficulty with high contrast (black print on white paper, patterns). But because Irlen Syndrome involves the brain’s inability to process all visual information it receives, and the stress on the brain can have a cascading effect throughout the entire body, it affects much more than just reading. Irlen Syndrome can also result in significant physical symptoms, such as headaches, migraines, nausea, fatigue and anxiety, as well as difficulties with math computation, handwriting, copying, reading music, depth perception, sports performance, listening, attention and concentration. Irlen Syndrome is not identified by current educational, psychological, ophthalmological, or medical tests. In fact, many individuals with Irlen Syndrome go unidentified well into adulthood, simply being told they are dumb, stupid, or lazy because all the tests show there is nothing wrong with them. When left untreated, Irlen Syndrome can lead to school failure, unrealized adult potential, and, research suggests, even a path into the criminal justice system.

Upload: others

Post on 26-Jun-2020

10 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: A Summary of Research Into the Irlen Method - June 2014[1] · What Causes Irlen Syndrome? As is the case with many educational and psychological disabilities (including dyslexia and

1

ASummaryofResearchintotheIrlenMethod(UpdatedJune2014)

IrlenSyndromeisadisorderthatmanypeoplearenotfamiliarwith,andassuch,itoftengoesunidentifiedanduntreated,leavingchildrentostrugglewellintoadulthood.Thisdocumentisintendedtoprovideathoroughbackgroundofthedisorderanditstreatment,offeracurrentandup-to-dateanalysisofthescientificresearchthathasbeenconductedonthedisorderandtheefficacyoftreatmentoverthelast30years,andexplaintheimpactthatthisdisordercanhaveonnotjustschoolsuccess,butfuturejobandlifesuccess,ifleftunidentifiedanduntreated.Withinthisdocument,youwillfindthefollowing:

• AdefinitionofIrlenSyndromeandtheareasoffunctioningitcanimpact

• AnexplanationoftheIrlenMethodofColoredOverlayandSpectralFiltersusedtotreatthedisorder

• Areviewofsomeofthemostcurrentandrelevantscientificresearch,aswellashighlightsfromkeyeducationalpilotstudiesandreportspresentedtoschooldistrictsaroundtheworldthathavechosentoimplementIrlenScreeningmethodsandColoredOverlays

DefiningIrlenSyndrome

IrlenSyndrome(sometimesreferredtointheliteratureasMeares-IrlenSyndrome,ScotopicSensitivitySyndrome,orVisualStress)isaproblemwiththebrain,nottheeye.Itisaperceptualprocessingdisorder,notavisualproblem,afindingthatthemostcurrentbrainimagingresearchsupports.Insimplisticterms,whenanindividualsuffersfromIrlenSyndrome,theirbrainhasdifficultyoraninabilityprocessingcertainwavelengthsoflight.Inthisway,light(especiallybrightandfluorescentlighting)becomesastressoronthebrain.Thisstresscausescertainpartsofthebrain(e.g.,thevisualcortex)tobecomeoveractive.Itisthisover-activityandinabilitytoeffectivelyprocessvisualstimulithatcreatesavarietyofvisual,physical,cognitive,emotional,andneurologicalsymptoms.

Asonemightexpect,symptomsofIrlenSyndromeincludedifficultywithreadingandcomprehension,issueswithstabilityandclarityofprint,anddifficultywithhighcontrast(blackprintonwhitepaper,patterns).ButbecauseIrlenSyndromeinvolvesthebrain’sinabilitytoprocessallvisualinformationitreceives,andthestressonthebraincanhaveacascadingeffectthroughouttheentirebody,itaffectsmuchmorethanjustreading.IrlenSyndromecanalsoresultinsignificantphysicalsymptoms,suchasheadaches,migraines,nausea,fatigueandanxiety,aswellasdifficultieswithmathcomputation,handwriting,copying,readingmusic,depthperception,sportsperformance,listening,attentionandconcentration.

IrlenSyndromeisnotidentifiedbycurrenteducational,psychological,ophthalmological,ormedicaltests.Infact,manyindividualswithIrlenSyndromegounidentifiedwellintoadulthood,simplybeingtoldtheyaredumb,stupid,orlazybecauseallthetestsshowthereisnothingwrongwiththem.Whenleftuntreated,IrlenSyndromecanleadtoschoolfailure,unrealizedadultpotential,and,researchsuggests,evenapathintothecriminaljusticesystem.

Page 2: A Summary of Research Into the Irlen Method - June 2014[1] · What Causes Irlen Syndrome? As is the case with many educational and psychological disabilities (including dyslexia and

2

WhoIsAffected?

IrlenSyndromeaffects12-14%ofthegeneralpopulation,approximately50%ofindividualswithreadingdifficulties,dyslexia,andlearningdisabilities,andabout30%ofthosewithADHDandautism.Thesechildrenaremisidentifiedandnotgettingthehelptheyneed.Itisapervasiveproblemthataffectsstudentsofallacademiclevelsfromthelearningdisabledandstrugglingstudenttothegiftedstudent.

WhatCausesIrlenSyndrome?

Asisthecasewithmanyeducationalandpsychologicaldisabilities(includingdyslexiaandautism),adefinitivecauseforIrlenSyndromehasyettobedetermined.Whilethereisastronghereditarycomponent,IrlenSyndromecanalsobeacquiredthroughbraininjuryorillness.TherearepresentlytwotheoriesthattrytoexplainthevisualprocessingdeficitsassociatedwithIrlenSyndrome:thetransientvisualsubsystemdeficitandthecorticalhyperexcitabilitytheories.Thefirstsuggeststhatthereareissueswiththemagnocellularpathwaythatbringsinformationtotheprimaryvisualcortex,conveyinginformationaboutmotion.Thesecondproposesthatthereisalackofinhibitionintheorientationcolumnsinthevisualcortex,andthislackofinhibitioncausesexcitationtospreadthroughoutthevisualsystemresultingindifficultyinprocessingvisualInformation.Ineithercase,itissuggestedthatcolorcanimproveperceptualprocessingforindividualsexperiencingdifficulties.

TheTreatment:ColoredOverlaysandPrecision-TintedSpectralFilters

In1983,whileworkingunderafederalresearchgrantattheCaliforniaStateUniversityofLongBeach,HelenIrlendiscoveredthatfilteringthevisualinformationbeforereachingthebrainthroughtheuseofeithercoloredoverlaysorspectralfilters(wornasglasses),couldallowthebraintocorrectlyprocessthevisualinformationitreceived.Indoingso,thesecoloredoverlaysandspectralfilterscouldeliminatesymptomsassociatedwithIrlenSyndromeandimprovereadingfluency,accuracy,andcomprehension,improvinggradesandtestscores.Assuch,atitsoutset,theIrlenMethodwasdesignedtoaddressproblemsassociatedwithreadingdifficulties.Coloredoverlaysinparticularareeffectiveprimarilyforaddressingissuesrelatedtoreading.Inaclassroomsetting,coloredoverlaysareaneasy,inexpensive,andnon-invasiveinterventionthatcancomplementanyotherprogramofremediationandreadinginstruction.Issuesthatgobeyondreading,includingwriting,mathcomputation,copying,listening,depthperception,attentionandconcentrationissuesandheadachesandstomachaches,oftenrespondbettertotheuseofspectralfilters,whichcanbewornasglassestofilterlightfromtheentirevisualfield.

IrlenColoredOverlaysandIrlenSpectralFiltersareusedbymillionsofchildrenandadultsinmorethan45countriesaroundtheworld.Coloredoverlaysand/orcoloredfiltersarerecognizedasastandardaccommodationforstandardizedtestinginmanystatesinAmerica,includingCalifornia,Arkansas,Florida,Oklahoma,Nevada,Massachusetts,NewMexico,andWashington.TheSAT,LSAT,ACT,LearningAlly,IllinoisDepartmentofRehabilitation,IndianaOfficeofVocationalRehabilitation,MichiganRehabilitationServices,TexasCommissionfortheBlind,NevadaVocationalRehabilitationServices,andWisconsinVocationalRehabilitationallofficiallyrecognizeIrlenSyndrome.InAustralia,thefollowingareasamplingofagencieswhichhaveofficiallyrecognizedIrlenSyndrome:DepartmentofEmployment,Education&Training,

Page 3: A Summary of Research Into the Irlen Method - June 2014[1] · What Causes Irlen Syndrome? As is the case with many educational and psychological disabilities (including dyslexia and

3

DepartmentsofArmy,Navy,andAirForce,BoardofStudies–NSW,BoardofSecondaryEducation–WA,DepartmentofChildren’sServices–WA,CommonwealthEmploymentService(CES),DepartmentofRehabilitation,GeelongMedicalFund,andTechnicalandFurtherEducation(TAFE).

SummaryoftheScientificResearchThereiscurrentlyabodyofresearchrelatedtoIrlenSyndrome,ColoredOverlaysandColoredFiltersthatspansmorethan30years.TheIrlenMethodandtheefficacyofcoloredoverlaysandcoloredlenseshasbeenthesubjectofover200researchstudiesencompassingthedisciplinesofeducation,psychology,andmedicine.Todate,morethan100ofthesestudiessupportingtheuseofcoloredoverlaysandlensestotreattheperceptualprocessingdifficultiesassociatedwithIrlenSyndromearepublishedinpeer-reviewedacademicandscientificjournals,includingtheJournalofLearningDisabilities,AustralianJournalofSpecialEducation,PerceptualandMotorSkills,AustralianJournalofLearningDisabilities,JournalofClinical&ExperimentalNeuropsychology,JournalofResearchinReading,BehavioralOptometry,andOphthalmologicalandBehavioralOptics,amongothers.Thisresearchhasestablishedahereditarycomponentofthedisorder(Loew&Watson,2012;Robinson,Foreman,&Dear,2000;Robinson,Foreman,Dear&Sparkes,2004),anumberofbiochemicalmarkersforproblemsassociatedwithIrlenSyndrome(Robinson,Roberts,McGregor,Dunstan,&Butt,1999;Robinson,McGregor,Roberts,Dunstan&Butt,2001;Sparkes,Robinson,Dunstan,&Roberts,2003),anddifferencesbetweenboththeanatomyandfunctioningofbrainsofindividualswithIrlenSyndrome(Chouinard,Zhou,Hrybousky,Kim,&Commine,2012;Huang,Zong,Wilkins,Jenkins,Bozoki,&Cao,2011;Lewine,Davis,Provencal,Edgar,&Orrison,1997;Riddell,Wilkins,&Hainline,2006;Yellen&Schweller,2009).Theresearchhasrepeatedlydocumentedefficacyofbothcoloredoverlaysandspectralfilters,asmeasuredbyimprovementsinavarietyofreadingskills(Bouldoukian,Wilkins,&Evans,2002;Nobel,Orton,Irlen&Robinson,2004;Park,Kim,Cho,Joo,2012;Robinson&Foreman,1999;Tyrrell,Holland,Dennis,&Wilkins,1995;Williams,LeCluyse,&RockFaucheux,1992;Wilkins,Evans,Brown,Busby,Wingfield,Jeanes&Bald,1994),reductioninphysicalsymptomsthatincludeheadaches,migraines,eyestrain,fatigue,andlightsensitivity(Barbolini,Lazzerini,Pini,Steiner,DelCecchio,Migaldi,&Cavallini,2009;Bulmer,1994;Chronicle&Wilkins,1991;Huangetal.,2011;Wilkins&Wilkinson,1991),andimprovedfunctioningandsuccessinbothacademiaandtheworkplace(Bulmer,1994;Irlen&Robinson,1996;Robinson&Conway,1994;Robinson&Conway,2000;Whiting&Robinson,1988;Whiting,Robinson,&Parrot,1994).

Notably,themostcurrentresearchonIrlenSyndromeandtheuseofcolorutilizesadvancedbrain-mappingtechnologytoshowactualchangesandnormalizationofbrainfunctioningthatisnotachievedthroughophthalmologicaltreatments(plainlenses,prisms,orvisiontherapy).Researchershaveutilizedfunctionalmagneticresonanceimaging(fMRI),visualevokedresponses(VER),andsinglephotonemissioncomputedtomography(SPECT)scanstoobjectivelydocumenttheprofoundeffectsofvisualsensoryoverloadonthebrainandthenormalizationofbrainactivitywhenindividually-prescribed,precision-tintedcoloredfiltersare

Page 4: A Summary of Research Into the Irlen Method - June 2014[1] · What Causes Irlen Syndrome? As is the case with many educational and psychological disabilities (including dyslexia and

4

worn.InonestudybyAmenandcolleagues,comparingthebrainsof42peoplewithIrlensyndrometo200age-matchedindividualswithoutanyevidenceofIrlensyndrome,SPECTscansshowedincreasedactivityinthebrain’semotionalandvisualprocessingcentersanddecreasedactivityinthecerebellum(anareathathelpstointegratecoordinationandnewinformation).WITHOUTIRLENSPECTRALFILTERS WITHIRLENSPECTRALFILTERSOveractiveBrain CalmBrainwithNormalFunction

SPECTscanscourtesyoftheAmenClinic

YellenandSchweller(2009)utilizedstate-of-the-artVisualEvokedResponses(VER),aportionoftheircomprehensiveneuroelectricalevaluationofpatientscalledtheDESA®,anddiscoveredthatindividualswithIrlenSyndromehaveearlyhyperreactivitytovisualstimulisomewherebetween30-60milliseconds,anditis3-9standarddeviationsabovenormal(theYellen-SchwellerEffect).IrlenSpectralFiltersreducethestandarddeviationabnormalitiesoftheYellen-SchwellerEffect,lesseningofthedelayofthebraincomingback“online”andallowingittoclearsooner.

Page 5: A Summary of Research Into the Irlen Method - June 2014[1] · What Causes Irlen Syndrome? As is the case with many educational and psychological disabilities (including dyslexia and

5

Lewineetal.(1997)utilizedmagnetoencephalography(MEG)tocharacterizevisualresponsesinconditionswithandwithoutlenses.Inallcases,theevokedmagneticsignalreflectedacomplicatedpatternofbilateralactivationofmultiplecorticalgenerators.Amajordifferenceinwithandwithoutlensconditionswasseenbetween170and200msecpost-stimulus.ThedatasuggestthatthecoloredIrlenlensesprovidefornormalizationandcrystallizationofvisualinformationprocessinginindividualswithIrlenSyndrome.

Lewine(1997)

Chouinardetal.(2011)comparedtheneurologicalcharacteristicsofapersonwithIrlenSyndromewithcontrolsubjectswhowereparticipatinginalanguage.ThedescriptiveresultsindicatedthattherearenumeroussignificantdifferencesinmanyareasofthebraincortexbetweenthecontrolsubjectsandtheindividualwithIrlenSyndrome,providingevidenceofaneurobiologicalfoundationtoIrlenSyndrome.

Page 6: A Summary of Research Into the Irlen Method - June 2014[1] · What Causes Irlen Syndrome? As is the case with many educational and psychological disabilities (including dyslexia and

6

Huangetal.(2011)usedfMRItoinvestigatedifferencesbetweenindividualssufferingvisualstressandcontrolsinrelationtomigraineandtodeterminetheeffectivenessofprecision-tintedcoloredfiltersforindividualssufferingfromvisualstress.Theresearchshowedanormalizationofcorticalactivationandspatialfrequencytuninginthemigraineursbyprecisiontintedfiltersthatsuggestsaneurologicalbasisforthetherapeuticeffectoftheselensesinreducingvisualcorticalhyperactivationinmigraine.

HighlightsFromSchoolDistrictReportsandPilotStudies

Inadditiontocurrentbrainresearch,andahistoryofeducationalresearchpublishedinscientificjournalsthatdocumentsthebenefitsofIrlenColoredOverlaysandSpectralFiltersforadultsandchildrenfromavarietyofpopulations,therehavebeenalargenumberofinformaleducationalreportssubmittedtoadministratorsanddecision-makingpersonnelinschooldistrictsaroundtheworldthatdocumenttheimpactofimplementingIrlenTestingandColoredOverlayswithintheschoolsystem.Belowwedetailhighlightsfromafewkeyreports.Asexpected,thesereportsandthedatatheypresentarenotsubjecttothescrutinyofthescientificjournalreviewprocess,buttheseresultshavebeenusedtomakebudgetary,staffing,andcurriculumdecisionswithintheschooldistrictandhighlightrealresultsfromrealschoolsaroundtheworld.Inallcases,studentsusingcoloredoverlaysshowedsignificantimprovements,andrecommendationsweretocontinueusingcoloredoverlayswithintheschools.Belowareselectionspulleddirectlyfromthesereports.

2006PilotProject:StoddardElementarySchool,AnaheimCitySchoolDistrict,California,USA.All4th,5th,and6thgradersintheschoolwerescreenedforIrlenSyndrome.Twenty-fivepercentofstudentstestedweredeterminedtohaveIrlenSyndromeandweregiventheirpreferredIrlenColoredOverlaytousebothatschoolandathome.StudentswhoweregivenoverlayswereabletousethemontheCaliforniaStateTest(STAR).Results:Testscoresfortheschoolwentupby25%.ThebiggestgainfortheoverlaystudentswasattheProficientLevel(gradelevel).OfthestudentsscoringProficientin2005,54%ofthestudentsusingoverlaysmoveduptothe“advanced”(abovegradelevel),whileonly17%ofthegroupnotusingoverlaysmovedupto“advanced”onthe2006tests.

2000BoydSchool,Colorado,USA.AllstaffatBoydSchoolweretrainedintheIrlenMethodtoidentifyandreferstudentsforIrlenTesting.Ofthetotalpopulationof207thirdgraders,10%wereidentifiedashavingIrlenSyndromeandweregivenIrlenColoredOverlaystouse.50%ofthestudentsusingColoredOverlaysmadesignificantgainsinreading.Thestudentswerepre/posttestedusingthefollowingassessmenttools:NorthWestEducationAssessment,ColoradoStudentAssessmentProgram,QuantitativeReadingInventory-II,andanindividuallyadministered45-minutereadingperformanceassessment.Results:AdefinitecorrelationwasshownbetweenidentificationofIrlenSyndrome,consistentuseofcoloredoverlays,andadvancementinreading.Manystudentsshowedgainsofovertwogradelevels.

1999PioneerValleyPilotProject,Massachusetts,USA.AstudyfundedbytheMassachusettsStateLegislatureandtheMassachusettsDepartmentofEducationwasconductedtotesttheeffectivenessofusingcoloredoverlaysasaninterventionforincreasingreadingperformanceforstudentsidentifiedwithIrlenSyndrome.All4thgraders(172children)intheSouthHadleySchoolDistrictwerescreenedforIrlenSyndrome.Twenty-sevenpercentwereidentifiedashavingmoderatetoseveresymptomsandtestedtodeterminetheirappropriatecoloredoverlay.Ofthisgroup,30mettheadditionalcriteriaofhavingaminimumofasecondgrade

Page 7: A Summary of Research Into the Irlen Method - June 2014[1] · What Causes Irlen Syndrome? As is the case with many educational and psychological disabilities (including dyslexia and

7

wordattackskillsandlackedmultiplelayersofproblems.Fifteenofthestudentswerereceivingspecialeducationservices.All30studentswerepre/posttestedusingtheRosnerTestofAuditoryAnalysisSkills,theWoodcock-JohnsonTestsofAchievementFormB,andtheGrayOralReadingTest-3FormA&B.Posttestingwasdonetwoweeksafterandagainthreemonthsafterthechildrenweregiventheircorrectcoloredoverlays.Results:100%ofthestudentsdemonstratedstatisticallysignificantimprovementinaccuracyand/orcomprehension.Meanincreaseswere2.6yearsinaccuracyand2.3yearsincomprehension.83%ofstudentsreadingbelowgradelevelincreasedtheirscoresby9monthsto4.1yearsinaccuracy.97%ofstudentsgainedatleastoneyearinonekeyreadingskill:rate,accuracy,comprehensionorpassagefluency.90%ofstudentsgainedoneyearintwokeyreadingskills.73%ofstudentsgainedatleastoneyearinthreekeyreadingskills.67%ofstudentsimprovedatleastoneyearinallfourreadingskillareastested.

1994TheeffectofIrlencoloredoverlaysonimprovingstudentreadingachievement.ReporttoDistrict25Queens:NewYorkCity,BoardofBoardofAdministrationStudies,NewYork,USA.Thestudentsofreadingteachersandresourceroomteachersinthreeelementaryandthreejuniorhighschoolswerescreened.Onehundredfifty-onestudentswhoshowedevidenceofreadingstrainordifficultyonapre-assessmentquestionnaireparticipatedinthestudy.Fifty-fiveofthosestudentsusedtheIrlencoloredoverlayonthe1993standardizedcitywidereadingtest.Results:Therewasasignificantdifferenceingainscoresfrom1992to1993forthosewhousedtheoverlays.Thosestudentswhousedtheoverlaysalsoreportedgreatereasewhenreading.Staffwiththesamereadingstrainofdifficultyproblemswhohadsufferedfrom“readingrelated”headachesnolongerhadheadacheswhentheyusedtheoverlaysorfilters(tintedlenses).

1990AnInterventionforStudentswithLowReadingAchievement:AReportfortheNewYorkCitySchools,NewYork,USA.Twenty-sixstudentsidentifiedashavingIrlenSyndromewererandomlyassignedtoeithertheexperimentalorcontrolgroup.TheexperimentalgroupwasgivenandusedtheirselectedColoredOverlayfor4monthsintheirreadingremediationclass,whenreadingathome,andwhenreadinginclass.Thecontrolgrouponlyreceived4monthsofreadingremediation.Allstudentswerepre/posttestedusingtheGORT-R(GrayOralReadingTest)andtwosubtestsoftheWRMT-R(WoodcockReadingMasteryTests)wordidentificationandpassagecomprehension.Results:Theuseofcoloredoverlaysincreasedreadingachievementincomprehension,speedanderrorefficiencyonboththeGORT-RreadingtestandWRMT-Rreadingachievementsubtests.Allresultswerestatisticallysignificant.Studentsinthecontrolgroupwhowerenotgiveacoloredoverlaydidnotshowanygrowthincomprehension,speedorefficiency,evenwithanintensivereadinginterventionprogram.

1995SpecialNeedsStudentsinKent,England.TwentyspecialneedsstudentswithmoderatetosevereIrlenSyndromeweredividedinto3groups:givencorrectIrlenSpectralFilters,givencorrectIrlenColoredOverlay,givenaclearoverlay.AgroupofspecialneedsstudentswhodidnothaveIrlenSyndromewereusedasacontrolgroupandgivenaclearoverlay.AllstudentswereadministeredtherevisedBritishversionoftheNealeAnalysisofReadingComprehensionandAccuracy.FormsAandBwereusedforpre/posttestingwhichwasdonelessthanamonthaparttoeliminateanypossibilitythatgrowthcouldbeattributedtoinstruction.Results:showedstatisticallysignificantimprovementsinreadingcomprehensionandaccuracyforonlythosestudentsusingthecorrectIrlenSpectralFiltersandIrlenColoredOverlays.Allstudentsweremonitoredaftercompletionoftheproject,andallstudentsidentifiedashaving

Page 8: A Summary of Research Into the Irlen Method - June 2014[1] · What Causes Irlen Syndrome? As is the case with many educational and psychological disabilities (including dyslexia and

8

IrlenSyndromecontinuetousetheirIrlenSpectralFiltersorIrlenColoredOverlay.Someofthestudentshavenowbeenabletoberemovedfromspecialeducationandplacedinregulareducation,savingtheeducationauthoritymoney.

1991-1992DioceseofPalmBeachPilotStudy,PalmBeach,Florida,USA.Studentsintwoelementaryschoolsandonehighschoolwerechosenforthestudy.Studentswerepre-screenedforIrlenSyndrome,andidentifiedstudentswereindividuallytestedandprescribedacoloredoverlay.Pre/posttestingwasdonetwoweeksapartusingtheWoodcockReadingMasteryTestintheelementaryschoolsandtheSkim-ScanSubtestsoftheStanfordDiagnosticReadingComprehensionTestinthehighschool.Results:inthehighschooltherewasameanaverageimprovementinscoreof19percentilesintwoweeks.Resultsintheelementaryschoolsshowedameanaverageimprovementof11+monthswithintwoweeks.

1992LasCrucesPublicSchools,NewMexico,USA.Thirty-ninelearningdisabledstudentswerescreenedforIrlenSyndrome.Twenty-TwowereidentifiedashavingIrlenSyndromeandweregiventheirpreferredIrlenColoredOverlaytouse.Studentswerepre/posttestedusingtheWoodcockJohnsonPsycho-educationalBattery–Revised(achievementandreadingsubtests).Studentsweredividedintothreegroupsdependingonwhethertheyhadusedtheiroverlaysmostofthetime,occasionally,ornever.Results:themorethestudentsusedtheiroverlays,thegreaterthegaininreading,withthoseusingtheiroverlaysmostofthetimeshowinggainsof1yearand2months.Asaresultoftheproject,demandforIrlenScreeningincreasedacrossthedistrict,withmostoftheeducationaldiagnosticiansinthedistrictultimatelygettingtrainedtoadministerthepre-assessmentandincorporatingitintotheirstandardevaluationprocess.

InConclusion

IrlenSyndromeisarealcondition,withsevereconsequecesifleftundiagnosed.Sadly,thedisorderispoorlyunderstood,andregularlyleftuntreated,ormistakenforotherproblems.Ironically,itisquickandeasytoscreenfor,diagnose,andtreatwithnon-invasive,inexpensivecoloredoverlayandspectralfiltertechnology.Reliefandimprovementareimmediate,therbyallowingstudentstotakefulladvantageofstandardinstructionandremediationofferedtothem.MoreinformationaboutIrlenSyndromeandtheIrlenMethodcanbefoundatwww.irlen.com.

Page 9: A Summary of Research Into the Irlen Method - June 2014[1] · What Causes Irlen Syndrome? As is the case with many educational and psychological disabilities (including dyslexia and

9

References

Amen,D.G.(2004).LightandtheBrain.BrainintheNewsNewsletter,AmenClinics.com,June30.

Barbolini,G.,Lazzerini,A.,Pini,L.A.,Steiner,F.,DelVecchio,G.,Migaldi,M.,Cavalllini,G.M.(2009).Malfunctioningconesandremedialtintedfilters.Ophta,2(209),101-105.

Bouldoukian,J.,Wilkins,A.J.,&Evans,B.J.W.(2002).Randomisedcontrolledtrialoftheeffectofcolouredoverlaysontherateofreadingofpeoplewithspecificlearningdifficulties.OphthalmologicalandPhysiologicalOptics,22,55-60.

Bulmer,J.(1994).Sensoryoverloadandgeneralwellbeing:CanadultsbehelpedbyusingIrlenlenses?Unpublishedhonorsthesis,ChesterCollegeofHigherEducation,Chester,UK.

Chouinard,B.D.,Zhou,C.l.,Hrybousky,S.,Kim,E.S.,Cummine,J.(2012).AfunctionalneuroimagingcasestudyofMeares-Irlensyndrome/visualstress(MISViS).BrainTopography,25(3):293-307.

Chronicle,E.P.,&Wilkins,A.J.(1991)Colourandvisualdiscomfortinmigraineurs.TheLancet,338,890.

Evans,B.J.W.,Patel,R.,Wilkins,A.J.,Lightstone,A.,Eperjesi,F.,Speedwell,L.,&Duffy,J.(1999).Areviewofthemanagementof323consecutivepatientsseeninaspecificlearningdisabilitiesclinic.OphthalmologicalandPhysiologicalOptics,19(6),454-466.

Evans,B.J.W.,Wilkins,A.J.,Brown,J.,Busby,A.,Wingfield,A.,Jeanes,R.,&Bald,J.(1996).ApreliminaryinvestigationintotheaetiologyofMeares-Irlensyndrome.OphthalmicandPhysiologicalOptics,16(4),286-296.

Evans,B.J.W.,Wilkins,A.J.,Busby,A.,&Jeanes,R.(1996).Optometriccharacteristicsofchildrenwithreadingdifficultieswhoreportabenefitfromcolouredfilters.InC.M.Dickinson,I.J.,Murray,&D.Garden(Eds.),JohnDalton'scolourlegacy(pp.709-715).London:TaylorandFrancis

Huang,J.,Zong,X.,Wilkins,A.,Jenkins,B.,Bozoki,A.,Cao,Y.(2011).fMRIevidencethatprecisionopthalmictintsreducecorticalhyperactivationinmigraine.Cephalagia,31(8):925-36.

Irlen,H.,&Robinson,G.L.(1996).TheeffectofIrlencolouredfiltersonadultperceptionofworkplaceperformance:apreliminarysurvey.AustralianJournalofRemedialEducation,1,7-17.

Lewine,J.D.,Davis,J.,Provencal,S.,Edgar,J.,Orrison,W.(1997).AmagnetoencephalographicinvestigationofvisualinformationprocessinginIrlen’sScotopicSensitivitySyndrome.ConductedatTheCenterforAdvancedMedicalTechnologies,TheUniversityofUtahSchoolofMedicine,SaltLakeCity,Utah,andDepartmentofPsychology,TheUniversityofNewMexico,Albuquerque,NewMexico.

Loew,S.J.,&Watson,K.(2012).AprospectivegeneticmarkerofthevisualperceptiondisorderMeares–Irlensyndrome.PerceptualandMotorSkills,114(3),870-882.

Noble,J.,Orton,M.,Irlen,S.,Robinson,G.(2004).Acontrolledfieldstudyoftheuseofcoloredoverlaysonreadingachievement.AustralianJournalofLearningDisabilities,9,14-22.

Park,S.H.,Kim,S.,Cho,Y.A.,Joo,C.(2012).TheEffectofColoredFiltersinPatientswithMeares-IrlenSyndrome.JKoreanOphthalmolSoc.,53(3):452-459.Korean.Publishedonline2012March15.http://dx.doi.org/10.3341/jkos.2012.53.3.452

Riddell,P.M.,Wilkins,A.,Hainline,L.(2006).Theeffectofcoloredlensesonthevisualevokedresponseinchildrenwithvisualstress.OptomVisSci,83(5),299-305.

Robinson,G.L.(1994).Colouredlensesandreading:areviewofresearchintoreadingachievement,readingstrategiesandcausalmechanisms.AustralianJournalofSpecialEducation,18,3-14.

Page 10: A Summary of Research Into the Irlen Method - June 2014[1] · What Causes Irlen Syndrome? As is the case with many educational and psychological disabilities (including dyslexia and

10

Robinson,G.L.,&Conway,R.N.F.(1994).Irlenfiltersandreadingstrategies:effectofcolouredfiltersonreadingachievement,specificreadingstrategiesandperceptionofability.PerceptualandMotorSkills,79,467-483.

Robinson,G.L.,&Conway,R.N.F.(2000).Irlenlensesandadults:asmallscalestudyofreadingspeed,accuracy,comprehensionandself-image.AustralianJournalofLearningDisabilities,5,4-13.

Robinson,G.L.,&Foreman,P.J.(1999).Theeffectsofcoloredfiltersoneyemovement:along-termplacebocontrolledandmaskedstudy.BehavioralOptometry,7(4),5-17.

Robinson,G.L.,&Foreman,P.J.(1999).Scotopicsensitivity/Irlensyndromeandtheuseofcoloredfilters:Along-termplacebocontrolledstudyofreadingstrategiesusinganalysisofmiscue.Perceptual&MotorSkills,88,35-52.

Robinson,G.L.,&Foreman,P.J.(1999).Scotopicsensitivity/Irlensyndromeandtheuseofcoloredfilters:Along-termplacebocontrolledandmaskedstudyofreadingachievementandperceptionofability.Perceptual&MotorSkills,89(1),83-113.

Robinson,G.L.,Foreman,P.J.,&Dear,K.G.B.(2000).ThefamilialincidenceofsymptomsofScotopicsensitivity/Irlensyndrome:comparisonofreferredandmass-screenedgroups.PerceptualandMotorSkills,91,707-724.

Robinson,G.L.,Foreman,P.J.,Dear,K.G.B.,andSparkes,D.(2004).TheFamilyIncidenceofaVisual-PerceptualSubtypeofDyslexia.NovaSciencePublishers,27-40.

Robinson,G.L.,Roberts,T.K.,McGregor,N.R.,Dunstan,R.H.,&Butt,H.(1999).Understandingthecausalmechanismsofvisualprocessingproblems:apossiblebiochemicalbasisforIrlenSyndrome?AustralianJournalofLearningDisabilities,4(4),21-29.

Robinson,G.L.,McGregor,N.R.,Roberts,T.K.,Dunstan,R.H.,&Butt,H.(2001).AbiochemicalanalysisofpeoplewithchronicfatiguewhohaveIrlensyndrome:speculationconcerningimmunesystemdysfunction.PerceptualandMotorSkills,93,486-504.

Scott,L.,McWhinnie,H.,Taylor,L.,Stevenson,N.,Irons,P.,LewisE.,Evans,M.,Evans,B.,&Wilkins,A.(2002).Coloredoverlaysinschools:orthopticandoptometricfindings.OphthalmologicalandPhysiologicalOptics,22,156-165.

Sparks,D.L.,Robinson,G.L.,Dunstan,H.,&Roberts,T.K.(2003).PlasmacholesterollevelsandIrlenSyndrome:preliminarystudyof10-to17-yr.,oldstudents.PerceptualandMotorSkills,97,745-752.

Tyrrell,R.,Holland,K.,Dennis,D.,&Wilkins,A.(1995).Colouredoverlays,visualdiscomfort,visualsearchandclassroomreading.ResearchinReading,18,10-23.

Yellen,A.&Schweller,T.(2009).TheYellen-SchwellerEffect:VisualEvokedResponsesandIrlenSyndrome.http://www.yellenandassociates.com/pdf/Yellen_Schweller_Effect.pdf

Whiting,P.,&Robinson,G.L.(1988).UsingIrlencolouredlensesforreading:Aclinicalstudy.AustralianEducationalandDevelopmentalPsychologist,5,7-10.

Whiting,P.,Robinson,G.L.,&Parrot,C.F.(1994).Irlencoloredfiltersforreading:asixyearfollowup.AustralianJournalofRemedialEducation,26,13-19.

Williams,M.C.,LeCluyse,K.,&RockFaucheux,A.(1992).Effectiveinterventionsforreadingdisability.JournaloftheAmericanOptometricAssociation,63,411-417.

Wilkins,A.J.,Evans,B.J.W.,Brown,J.A.,Busby,A.E.,Wingfield,A.E.,Jeanes,R.J.,&Bald,J.(1994).Double-maskedplacebo-controlledtrialofprecisionspectralfiltersinchildrenwhousecoloredoverlays.Ophthalmological&PhysiologicalOptics,14,365-370.

Page 11: A Summary of Research Into the Irlen Method - June 2014[1] · What Causes Irlen Syndrome? As is the case with many educational and psychological disabilities (including dyslexia and

11

Wilkins,A.,&Wilkinson,P.(1991).Atinttoreduceeyestrainfromfluorescentlighting:Preliminaryobservations.OphthalmologicalandPhysiologicalOptics,11,172-175.