a service of the child care bureau state policies supporting inclusion abby j. cohen, j.d., nccic...
TRANSCRIPT
A Service of the Child Care Bureau
State Policies Supporting Inclusion
Abby J. Cohen, J.D., NCCIC technical assistance specialist for Administration
for Children and Families Region IX
July 23, 2008
**Special thanks to Angela Crowley for contributing photographs to this presentation**
3
Who and How Many Children Are We Talking About?
More than 14 million children younger than 6 years need child care (U.S. Census Bureau, 2006)
21.8 percent of households have children with special health care needs, which is approximately 10.2 million children (U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 2007)
4
Who and How Many Children Are We Talking About?
A recent Pediatrics journal article found that approximately 13 percent of children in its sample (using direct assessment of the children) had developmental delays, making them eligible for Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) Part C services
The study found that the prevalence of developmental delays is much higher than previously thought
For purposes of comparison, in 2002, Part C served 2.2 percent of children younger than 3
(www.pediatrics.org/cgi/content/full/121/6/e1503)
5
Definitions of Disability Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA)
definition: Physical or mental impairment that
substantially limits one or more major life activities (not specific conditions but functional impairments);
History/record of above; Regarded as above; or Associated with the above
States define “special needs child” for purposes of child care subsidy (i.e., CCDF)
States have their own civil rights laws with varying definitions
6
Definitions of Disability, con.
IDEA for Section 619 of Part B: A child who is a child with one of a
specific list of conditions who, by reason thereof, needs special education and related services; at state option can include a child experiencing developmental delays and who, by reason thereof, needs special education and related services
See Section 602(3)
7
Definitions of Disability, con.
IDEA for Part C: An infant or toddler who needs early
intervention because of experiencing developmental delay or has a diagnosed physical or mental condition that has a high probability of resulting in developmental disability; at state option can include at risk infants and toddlers as well as children who have received Part C and are now eligible for Part B until they enter kindergarten or elementary school
See Section 602(16) and Section 632(5)
8
Definitions of Disability, con.
Challenging behaviors and other behaviors and conditions may be viewed as disabilities, but have no legal protections under applicable statutes
14
Which Children Are We Considering?
Who has a disability can be defined by the law or not, but as a starting point, consider the following: Mobility issues Special health care needs Mental health issues Social/emotional issues Developmental disabilities Communication issues Learning issues Challenging behaviors
15
New Haven, CT Children With Special Health Care Needs
A study examining the impact of child care health consultants on health and safety in 5 child care centers yielded the following results: 16 percent of 206 children enrolled had at least 1
special health care need Diagnoses:
Asthma Down’s SyndromeChronic otitis media EczemaCommunication disorder Food, environmental, insect Cerebral palsy allergiesChronic benign neutropenia Gastroesophageal refluxCongenital scoliosis Growth delayDevelopmental delay SeizuresDiabetes Vision impairment
(Crowley, 2006)
16
What Is Inclusion?
Once again, there are varying definitions
The Division of Early Childhood, Council of Exceptional Children position statement on inclusion states the following: “Inclusion as a value, supports the right of
all children, regardless of abilities, to participate actively in natural settings within their communities . . .” (2000)
17
Inclusive Practice In the view of those who developed Beginning
Together, inclusive practice occurs when the following conditions are met: “The interests, strengths, unique characteristics,
and needs of ALL children are considered when planning activities, environments and interactions”
“Family members, [infant care] teachers, and specialists talk together about how to promote each child’s belonging in the setting”
“Appropriate adaptations, accommodations, supports and services are available and provided whenever needed to promote authentic belonging” (From Beginning Together, CIHS-SSU)
18
It Is About Belonging
“When inclusion . . . is fully embraced, we abandon the idea that children have to become ‘normal’ in order to contribute to the world. Instead, we search for and nourish the gifts that are inherent in all people. We begin to look beyond typical ways of becoming valued members of the community, and, in doing so, begin to realize the achievable goal of providing all children with an authentic sense of belonging.” (Norman Kune, disability rights advocate)
19
It Is About Attitude
The “A” in ADA should have stood for attitude
Attitude is approximately 90 percent of compliance with the law
It is important to take the time to reflect on how our experiences shaped and continue to shape our attitudes toward persons with disabilities
20
Legal and Emerging Issues
Understanding the Law and Identifying the Issues, Concerns, and Barriers
21
Major Laws Impacting Inclusion of Children in Child Care ADA Section 504 (when Federal funding is involved) State civil rights laws/local human rights
ordinances IDEA (covers those entitled to early intervention
and special education) State child care licensing laws/regulations Head Start requirements State medical, nursing, and related health
professions’ professional practice acts
It is important to know all these laws and how they interact
22
ADA: Who Is Covered? Coverage is for those who meet the following
conditions: Those with a physical or mental impairment
that substantially limits one or major life activities;
Those with a record of impairment; Those who are regarded as having the
impairment; and Those who are associated with persons with
impairments or entities connected to these persons
Interesting note: Only category one currently has disabilities
23
Who Must Comply?
Child care centers and family child care homes are considered to be “public accommodations” under the law
It applies to Territories; Tribes may not be sued by individuals, but the Title III provisions covering public accommodations can be enforced by the U.S. Department of Justice
Programs directly operated by religious entities are exempted from compliance
24
Making Reasonable Accommodations
Do not use admissions policies that screen out or tend to screen out persons with disabilities
Make modifications to policies, practices, or procedures unless to do so would fundamentally alter the nature of the service
Provide auxiliary aids and services unless this would create an undue burden or would fundamentally alter the nature of the service
Make physical modifications to existing facilities if they are readily achievable
25
Modification of Policies, Practices, and Procedures:
In a settlement between the U.S. Department of Justice, which enforces ADA, and a private provider, Smyrna Playschool dba Cumberland Child Care, the program agreed to modify policies to assist with allergy care and administer medication with an inhaler
Many programs have been willing to make reasonable accommodations to administer medications, but have found opposition or barriers in place from their State’s medical, nursing, or health professions’ professional practice acts or professional boards and/or licensing statutes/regulations
26
Modifications, con. In an administrative ruling (University of
Wisconsin Colleges, No. 05-02-2010 (OCR 04/09/02)) and an unpublished judicial decision (McDavid v. Arthur, 32 NDLR 186 (D.Md. 2006)), injection of insulin has been found to be a fundamental alteration of child care and not required by ADA
A number of States do allow use of an EpiPen In an effort to comply with ADA, California
licensing allows for exceptions that enable providers to empty ileostomy bags and do gastrostomy tube (G-Tube) feedings under certain conditions
27
Emerging Issue:Medication Administration
Increasing numbers of children require medication while in care
Child care licensing laws generally give programs the option of providing medication; if they choose to do so, they must meet certain conditions
Alvarez v. Fountainhead, 55 F. Supp 2d 1048 (1999) indicated that the decision to administer medication might no longer be optional when the child impacted had a disability protected by ADA and the medicine administered was a reasonable accommodation
It remains optional for a program to administer medication when the child does not have a disability protected by law (e.g., an acute infection requiring antibiotics)
28
Responding to Limitations
California, by statute, has allowed the administration of inhaled medication (California Health & Safety Code Section 1596.798)
California, by statute, has allowed for blood prick testing (Cal. Health & Safety Code Section 1596.797)
Connecticut’s Board of Nursing ruled that medication training is a professional activity not delegation for the nurse trainers; NJ is following this interpretation, which will encourage more nurses to do the training; Connecticut is one of the States that requires medication training for child care providers
29
Responding to Limitations
A recent lawsuit has been filed against the military under Section 504, which parallels ADA to require the administration of Diastat, a drug administered rectally when a child has prolonged seizures
Increasing numbers of States are requiring medication administration training for child care providers (see handout)
30
Bottom Line
Work must be done in States to eliminate barriers to full compliance with ADA or State law
In some instances, this may require a new law; in others, it may require new regulations or new administrative policies
Policymakers need to think about elimination of barriers and laws and policies that promote inclusion
Changes in society/technology require continuous review
31
Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973
Very similar to ADA Must receive Federal funding from
programs such as CCDF, Head Start, and the Child and Adult Care Food Program
No State immunity No exemption for religious groups
operating child care
32
State Civil Rights Laws Learn more about your own State’s civil
rights laws; they may be more protective of persons with disabilities than ADA or Section 504
Unlike most situations, where Federal law is supreme, the most protective civil rights laws are those that govern, meaning that even a local law can trump Federal law For example, California requires only a limitation,
not a substantial limitation, meaning many more people are considered to have disabilities protected by law under California law than under ADA
33
State Civil Rights Laws, con. A recent New Jersey case (a State that also has
a more expansive law than ADA) ruled that a preschool is a place of public accommodation, and a boy with diabetes could not have enrollment rescinded once the program learned he required an insulin pump; the case will return to a jury to determine if the request to use the pump is a reasonable accommodation (Ellison v. Creative Learning Center)
Use of an insulin pump is allowed in California through an exception process
34
Some Other States With Generous Civil Rights Laws
Maine, Massachusetts, New Jersey, New York, and Washington are among the States that have more generous provisions in certain respects than ADA
A bill in Congress would restore the original intent of the framers and expand the current interpretation of who is covered
35
Balance and Tension
Providing access to the greatest extent possible for persons with disabilities
Ensuring the health and safety of all the children in care
Limiting the liability exposure of child care providers (and those who train them) to promote their willingness to support inclusionary practices—training about best practices and the law becomes key
36
IDEA
IDEA has a more limited definition of who is covered and entitled to services than ADA; children must not only fit into a category but also require early intervention or special education
Under IDEA, if one is eligible for special education, one is entitled to not only the special education, but also the “related services,” or services without which students cannot benefit from their education
37
IDEA
Services for children birth to 3 must presumptively occur in “natural environments” and for 3–5 in “least restrictive environments” or LRE—which to a large extent is child care
Emerging issue: Pressure on States as a result of indicator 6 of State performance plans to document “preschool LRE”
Emerging issue: How are universal/targeted, publicly funded preschool programs ensuring that they are including children with disabilities and not having parallel programs?
38
Contrast ADA and IDEA
Different definitions of who is eligible for protection Different requirements imposed on those who are
expected to comply IDEA is the responsibility of school districts for 3–5
year olds (may be another entity for early intervention) that have school nurses (though this may be something of a legal fiction in many locales!)
Child care has limited access to health care providers (though some child care licensing laws require health consultants), underscoring the importance of emerging health care consultation systems
IDEA is an entitlement; ADA a civil rights law
40
Strategies to Promote Inclusion: Licensing
Review of licensing statute and regulations Eliminate barriers from licensing regulations
Specialized regulations that are not warranted; issue of emergency plans
Increases in staffing regardless of individualized assessments Ambulatory/nonambulatory issue in fire codes
Promote affirmative provisions in licensing regulations Screening of children at enrollment to help with ChildFind If child has an Individualized Education Plan or an Individual Family
Services Plan,have provider, with consent, involved with it Medication administration training; ability to administer medications Accessibility of facilities Inclusion training requirements part of licensing requirements Problem of inconsistency with Federal statutes and enforceability
41
Strategies to Promote Inclusion: Subsidy System
Definition of who is a special needs child under CCDF is given to the States; some States define it broadly and do not limit the definition to IDEA’s definition (see handout)
Use of optional authority under CCDF to define children with disabilities eligible for care older than 13 but younger than 19 (52 jurisdictions)
42
Strategies: Subsidy System
Taking into account increased costs of caring for children with disabilities in making eligibility determinations based on income:
“The income spent on any regular, ongoing cost that is specific to a child’s disability is excluded from definition of income” (Iowa)
“Recurring expenses for medical care or prescribed adaptive equipment for special needs children shall be subtracted from gross family income” (Maine)
43
Strategies: Subsidy System Guarantee subsidy eligibility (12
States) or give priority over other CCDF eligible families (33 States)
Special needs rates through the subsidy program (some flat rate increase, percentage increase, individual documentation)—lack of information on utilization and effectiveness of each method and how they compare (see handout)
44
Strategies to Promote Inclusion: Quality Money
Increased use of screening and referrals in child care to early intervention/special education, and health, including mental health—requires training and knowledge of systems
Enhanced referral services provided by child care resource and referral agencies
Inclusion specialists—variation in where housed and level of service—information only or coaching onsite? How well is this working?
45
Strategies to Promote Inclusion: Quality Money, Professional
Development Integrating training about inclusion
into all early care and education professional development
Supports/Initiatives to enable the care of children with challenging behaviors
Provision of targeted resources for training on inclusion, special adaptive equipment, and assistive technology
46
Strategies to Promote Inclusion: QRS
Currently, there are 17 States with a statewide quality rating system (QRS)
Of these, a few have incorporated standards at different star levels, which help to promote the inclusion of children with disabilities and recognize its importance to calling a program a quality child care program (see handout)
47
What Can You Share?
What are some other existing State policies you are aware of that promote inclusion?
What are some State policies which should exist that would promote inclusion?
48
Resources
National Early Childhood Technical Assistance Center, www.nectac.org
Center on Social & Emotional Foundations for Early Learning, http://csefel.uiuc.edu
Division of Early Childhood, Council for Exceptional Children, www.dec-sped.org
ADA homepage, U.S. Department of Justice, www.usdoj.gov/crt/ada/adahom1.htm
Access Board, www.access-board.gov
49
Resources, con.
National Professional Development Center on Inclusion, http://community.fpg.unc.edu/npdci
SpecialQuest, www.specialquest.org
Quality Child Care for ALL: Recommendations and Quality Child Care for ALL: Recommendations for Implementation, www.newmexicokids.org
50
Resources, con.
Healthy Child Care Consultant Network Support Center, http://hcccnsc.edc.org
Child Care Law Center, www.childcarelaw.org
NCCIC, http://nccic.acf.hhs.gov, 800-616-2242
51
Homework!
Find out more about your States’ civil rights laws Identify which, if any, health procedures are allowed
or not allowed under your States’ licensing statutes/regulations Is the current framework problematic in terms of child
care interfacing with special education and early intervention?
Find out more about the child care/early education in your State and how it operates Are there points of interface with early
intervention/special education/health/mental health/developmental disability systems?
Could regulations/practices of these systems be changed to strengthen the connection?
Some questions for you to take home to learn more ...
52
Homework, con.
Find out more about the benchmark your State created for preschool LRE in its State Performance Plan submitted to the federal Department of Education and what plans it has to meet it
Generally, what are the systems barriers preventing or making inclusion difficult?
53
Thank You
Prepared by NCCIC
10530 Rosehaven Street, Suite 400 ● Fairfax, VA 22030Phone: 800-616-2242 ● Fax: 800-716-2242 ● TTY: 800-516-2242
Email: [email protected] ● Web: http://nccic.acf.hhs.gov