a rapid assessment of the papua new guinean graduate ... · societal imperatives has been...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
ARapidAssessmentofthePapuaNewGuineanGraduateLabourMarket
toinformthedevelopmentofWesternPacificUniversity’s
academicprograms
preparedbytheAcademicDevelopmentTeamDrLudmillaSalonda
ProfessorPhilipSiaguruDrJamesYoko
andWilliamOliver
November2017
![Page 2: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
2
TableofContents
Abbreviations 3Acknowledgements 5Introduction 6ExecutiveSummary 7KeyFindingsandRecommendations 9Methodology 14Section1:ProvincialVoices 21MadangProvince 21HighlandsProvinces 24EastandWestNewBritainProvinces 28ExternallySelectedParticipants 32Section2:PapuaNewGuinea’sLabourMarket:Whatdoestherecentliteraturetellus? 39Section3: Conclusion 53References 58 TablesTable1: RangeofKeyInformantsInterviewed 15Table2: ThemesandResponses 16Table3: DesirableCharacteristicsandTraits 33Table4: Toptenareasofrecruitmentinvolving PacificIslanders 49FiguresFigure1: TransversalSkills 41Figure2: SoftSkills 42Figure3: EmployabilitySkills 43Figure4: EmploymentPreferencesofUNPNG EconomicsGraduates 51
![Page 3: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
3
AbbreviationsAPTC AustraliaPacificTechnicalCollegeADB AsianDevelopmentBankBSP BankoftheSouthPacificCPD ContinuingProfessionalDevelopmentCV CurriculumVitaeDAL DepartmentofAgricultureandLivestockDHERST DepartmentofHigherEducation,Research,ScienceandTechnologyDLIR DepartmentofLabourandIndustrialRelationsENBP EastNewBritainProvinceFDI ForeignDirectInvestmentFGD FocusGroupDiscussionGDP GrossDomesticProductGoPNG GovernmentofPapuaNewGuineaHE HigherEducationHEIs HigherEducationInstitutionsHR HumanResourcesICT InformationCommunicationsTechnologyILO InternationalLabourOrganisationIT InformationTechnologyKI KeyInformant(s)KII KeyInformantInterview(s)LLG LocalLevelGovernmentMSME Micro,SmallandMediumSizedEnterpriseNCD NationalCapitalDistrictNGI NewGuineaIslandsNGO Non-GovernmentalOrganisationPICs PacificIslandsCountry[ies]PIQAF PacificIslandsQualityAssuranceFrameworkPMV PublicMotorVehiclePNG PapuaNewGuineaPNGNQF PapuaNewGuineaNationalQualificationsFrameworkPRQS PacificRegisterofQualificationsandStandardsPRTCBP PacificRegionalTourismCapacityBuildingProgrammeR&D ResearchandDevelopmentSMEs SmallandMediumEnterprisesSTEM Science,Technology,EngineeringandMathematicsTVET TechnicalandVocationalEducationTrainingUN UnitedNationsUNDP UnitedNationsDevelopmentProgramUNFAO UnitedNationsFoodandAgricultureOrganization
![Page 4: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
4
UNESCO UnitedNationsEducationScientificOrganisationUNPG UniversityofPapuaNewGuineaUSA UnitedStatesofAmericaWIL WorkIntegratedLearningWNBP WestNewBritainProvinceWPU WesternPacificUniversity
![Page 5: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
5
AcknowledgementsThesurveyteamwishestothankeachindividualwhocameforwardtoactasaKeyInformantorasamemberofaFocusGroupDiscussion:theirwillingnesstoparticipateandthecandourtheybroughtwiththemwereinvaluabletotheresearch.ThanksmustalsogoinlargemeasuretotheNationalGamingControlBoardforfundingthissurveyfromitsCommunityBenefitFund.WearealsoverygratefultotheWPUteam,basedinDiwaiPacificLtdatDivineWordUniversity,MadangCampus,whoprovidedessentiallogisticalsupporttothesurveyteam.
![Page 6: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
6
IntroductionThissurvey,commissionedbyWesternPacificUniversity(WPU),relatestotheemployabilityofgraduatesintheformalandinformallabourmarketsofPapuaNewGuinea(PNG).Itdiscussestheirstrengths,intermsoftheirknowledge,skillsandpersonalattributesandhowthesedeterminetheirfutureprospectsinrelationtotheeconomyandtheneedsofsocietyatalllevels.Theperspectivesofbusiness,provincialgovernment,industry,publicutilities,NGOs,thehospitalserviceandthechurcheshavebeentakencarefullyintoaccount.Thesurvey’srationaleistoinputresearchfindingsintothedesignanddevelopmentofdegreeprogramsatWPU,thecountry’snewestuniversity,locatedintheSouthernHighlands.Itisenvisagedthatground-breakinginnovationsinprogramcurriculaanddeliverymodeswilltransformthelandscapeoflearningandteachinginhighereducationinPapuaNewGuinea.ThelearningsfromthisresearchindicateunambiguouslythatthecurriculumofferingatWPUmustbringstudentsintothedigitalageoflearningcharacterisedbytheattributesoftheFourthIndustrialRevolutionthatarenowtransformingtheworldofworkandthenatureofemployment.RootedintheneedtodevelophumancapitalforthebenefitofeveryoneinPapuaNewGuineansociety,particularlythosemiredinpoverty,studentswillfollowaformativefoundationyearbeforebeingimmersedinwork-integratedlearningthatisintercalatedthroughouttheirdegreeprogram.Stakeholderswereunanimousincallingforanimprovementingraduateoutcomesintermsofskills,personalqualitiesandthedesiretoservecommunitiesandsociety.Intheeyesofmany,apost-colonialfocusonknowledgeacquisitionthatdoesnotrelatetoeconomicorsocietalimperativeshasbeendetrimentaltothedevelopmentofPapuaNewGuinea.ThemessageforWPUisclear:asanewinstitution,itmustheraldthefutureforhighereducation,notsolelywithinPapuaNewGuineabutacrossthePacificIslandCountries.
TeamLeaderAcademicDevelopmentTeamWesternPacificUniversity
![Page 7: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
7
ExecutiveSummaryThesurveyseekstoreflectthecandidviewsofindividualsandorganisationsfrommanywalksofpublicandprofessionallifewhoareinvolvedintheselection,recruitmentandretentionofgraduatesfromPapuaNewGuineanuniversitiesintotheformalandinformallabourmarkets.Thefindingsofthissurveywillprimarilyinformthedesignanddevelopmentofdegrees,diplomasandcertificatesawardedbyWesternPacificUniversity,inauguratedinaperiodofrenewalandregenerationfortheuniversitysector.TherewasuniformagreementfromwithintherangeofKeyInformantsthatstudentswereoftenbeingfailedbythequalityofcurriculaonofferwhereabstruse,outdatedandirrelevantknowledgepreparedthempoorlyforemploymentopportunities.Graduates,itwassaid,werenotexposedtotheimportanceoftransversalor‘softskills’thataregreatlyvaluedinthemajorityofworkingenvironments.Surprisinglyperhaps,giventheconsiderableinvestmentovertimeineducationatalllevels,amajorconcernwastherelativelypoorleveloforalandwrittenEnglishofmanygraduatesenteringthelabourmarket.Ofconcernalsowasthereticenceofgraduatestoembraceleadershipopportunitiesthatmightbenefittheircommunitiesandsocietyatlarge.Linkedtothisobservationwastheviewthatstudentsmustbroadentheirhorizonsandadoptamoreinternationalperspectiveintermsofthelabourmarket.Worryingly,theattitudesofaminorityofgraduatesthatpreventthemfromdevelopingappropriateworkhabitsandprofessionalbehavioursremainachallengeforcertainemployers.Balancedagainsttheseconcernsthereweregratifyingexamplesofemployersworkinginclosepartnershipwithuniversitiestoprovideabridgebetweeneducationandemployment.Similarly,severalorganisationsinvestheavilyininductionprocesses,particularlywheretherearetechnicalordigitalprocessesinvolved.Indeed,employerslooktouniversitiestopreparegraduateswithskillsforthedigitalage,notonlyinbusinessandindustry,butalso,forexample,ingovernance,communications,medicineandagriculture.Asthesurveyreveals,therearewellestablishedlinksbetweenthequalityofeducationsystemsandacountry’seconomicgrowthandthisisalsotrueofPapuaNewGuinea.Theinfluxofexpatriates,albeitadecliningnumber,tofillprofessionalandmanagerialrolesin-countryprovidesaclearindicationofgapsinthelabourmarketthataredifficulttomeetfromwithinthepoolofgraduates.Examplesoftheseskillsshortagesareevidentinmedicine,aviation,engineering,agriculture,tourismandhospitality,constructionanddigitaltechnologies.
![Page 8: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
8
Giventhat85%oftheworkingpopulationareemployedintheinformallabourmarket,manyoftheminsubsistenceagriculture,self-evidently,GoPNG’scurrentfocusonmicro,smallandmediumsizedenterprises(MSMEs)isanenablingfactorinthisvitalmarket.Keytoitssuccessisnotonlysupportfromthefinancialsectorbutalsothereadinessofhighereducationinstitutionstoofferstudentsaccesstoskillsthatwillallowthemtoestablishthemselvesasconfidententrepreneurs.Workintegratedlearning,intercalatedthroughoutacourseofstudy,waspositivelyregardedbyKeyInformantsasameansofprovidingdegreeapprenticeships,thusbringingemployersintopartnershipwithuniversityteachersinthedesignofprogramsspecifictotheirparticularfieldofactivity.ThesurveyteamwasstruckbytheviewexpressedbymanythatthereisnotimetowasteintransformingPapuaNewGuineanuniversitiestohaltadeclineinstandardssuchasthosedescribedbyJones&McGavinintheirdevastatingcritiqueoftertiaryeducationastheyremark,‘…thequalityofuniversitygraduatesinPapuaNewGuineahasprogressivelydeterioratedandissignificantlybelowtheinternationalstandard’(2015:368).ThesameauthorscallforcloserinvolvementwithuniversitiesinQueenslandasameansofdrivingupstandards.Poorlearningandteachingoutcomesatuniversitylevelinevitablyleadtoadiminutionofhumancapitalandactasadeterrenttoendogenousgrowth.JonesandMcGavin’sseveretreatmentofGarnaut&Namaliu’suniversities’reviewisrelevantwhenconsideringcurrentcausesofthepoorabsorptivecapacityofthetertiarysector:‘ThereportisoverwhelmingforthereaderanditissimplynotimplementablebyPapuaNewGuinea’scurrentpublicsector’(2010:369).WesternPacificUniversityrepresentsabeaconofhopeforPapuaNewGuineainitsdesiretoaddresstheaspirationsofcurrentandfuturegenerationsofyoungpeopledeterminedtoleadandservetheircommunitiesandnation.Thedesignanddevelopmentofprogramsthatacknowledgetheimportanceofendogenousgrowthiscrucialtothesuccessofitsgraduatesnotonlyinnationalbutalsointernationallabourmarkets.Fundamentaltoprogramdesignisthefar-sighteduseofdigitaltechnologiesthatwillequipindividualsforemploymentduringtheFourthIndustrialRevolutionaspresagedbySchwab(2016).
![Page 9: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
9
KeyFindingsandRecommendations
1. InformationCommunicationsTechnology(ICT)isattheheartofWPU’sdigitalstrategytotransformlearningandteachingwithintheUniversity.Alldegree,diplomaandcertificateprogramsmustreflect,deliverandsustainthisaspiration.Sufficientfinancialinvestmentshouldensurenotonlythattheinfrastructureisofworldclassstandard,butalsothatthebenefitsarefar-reachingforthenationasawhole,particularlythosecitizensinruralandremoteareas.Inthisway,theUniversitycanexertapowerfulinfluenceonthereductionofpovertyandthenotorious‘digitaldivide’.Examplesoftheseenablingfunctionsforruraldwellersincludepowerfulaccesstoknowledgeandsocio-economicinteractionsinmicro,smallandmediumsizedenterprises(MSMEs).
2. Atoneandthesametime,WPUshouldworkwithindustrytounderstandwhichdigitalskillsareofparticularstrategicimportancetothenation.TheUniversityhastheopportunitytodevelopitsundergraduateandpostgraduateICTdegreeprogramstoanticipatetheglobaldemands,forexample,ofe-commerce,e-businessande-governance,wherehugevolumesofdatarequireenhancedcybersecuritytopreventdisastrousbreachesandleakageofconfidentialinformation.Thepreparationofgraduatesandpostgraduatesinthisfieldofexpertiserepresentsanemploymentopportunityinnationalandinternationallabourmarkets.
3. Acommitmenttoexcellenceinlearningandteachingwillrelyheavilyonthe
recruitmentandappointmentofoutstandingacademicstaff,ateverylevel,totheUniversity,withaproventrackrecordofexternallyauditedhigh-qualityteaching.Thenatureofthecurriculum,alreadyenvisagedaspartworkandpartcampusbased,willdemandinnovativethinkingonthepartofWPUacademicswhowillutiliseavarietyofteachingmethods,butprimarilyaproblembasedlearningapproachthatseekstogroundtheoryinpractice.
4. CarefulthoughtmustbegiventothestyleandstructureoftheUniversityasan
institution.Historically,PapuaNewGuineanuniversitieshave,ofnecessity,mimickedcolonialandpost-colonialstructures.Thereisnowanopportunitytocreatea21stcenturyinstitution,forexampleadevelopmentaluniversity,onewhichtrulyreflectsthecountry’sambitionsandgoalsinsocial,economicandglobaltermsasoutlinedinitsVision2050.
5. Itisabundantlyapparentthatmanysectorsoftheeconomyareunabletoappoint,
withconfidence,fromwithinthecurrentgraduatetalentpool.Thismaysimplybebecausethecountry’suniversitiesdonotofferteachingforexampleinaircraftengineering,navalarchitectureorbiomedicaltechnology;or,alternatively,theroot
![Page 10: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
10
causemaybeattributedtotheimpoverishednatureofsomedegreeprograms.WPUwillconsistentlystrivetobeattheleadingedgeofcurriculumdevelopmentandshouldnotethesignalsfromtheformallabourmarketrelatingtogapsinmedicine,medicalresearch,biomedicaltechnology,healthcare,aviation,andICTproficiencythatequatestointernationalstandards.
6. Parallelingthedemandforshortageskills,increasinglyemployersareexpectingwell-
developedsoftskills,alsoknownastransversalskills,fromrecentgraduates.Theseskillsenrichnetworking,teambuildingandclient-facingrelationships:theyalsocontributetothedevelopmentofempathy,compassionandresonantleadership.WPU’spublishedGraduateQualitieswillclearlyprovidethefoundationfortheseskills.
7. Theconceptofafoundationyearatthecommencementofanundergraduate
degreeprograminPapuaNewGuineaiswellunderstoodand,inthepast,hasbeenawell-establishedfeatureofprovisioninsomeofitsuniversities.ThemajorityviewhoweverintheprovincessurveyedisthatWPUiscorrect,attheoutset,toadaptthismodel,sincenotonlydoesitprovideabridgebetweentheacademicnormsofGrade12anduniversityprograms,butitalsobecomesalearningspacewithinwhichtheskillsofliteracyandnumeracy,debate,criticalthinkingandproblemsolvingandproblembasedlearningcanallbeproperlyaddressed.KeyInformantswerebroadlysupportiveoftheviewthatapurposefulandwell-designedfoundationyearwouldmakeanoveralldifferencetoagraduate’semployability.
8. Workintegratedlearning(WIL)isalreadyanestablishedfeatureofseveraldegree
programsinthePapuaNewGuineanuniversitysector,rangingfromindustrysponsorshiptoshort-termworkplacementsorindeeddegreeapprenticeships.ThenoveltyofWPU’sapproachisthatallstudentswillbenefitfromthisexperience,regularlyintercalatedwiththeirstudies,throughoutthedegreeprogram.Therewastotalagreementinthefieldthatsuchastrategicmovecouldonlybeofmutualbenefittobothstudentandemployerorreceivingorganisation.Therewerecaveatshowever.SeveralKeyInformants(Kis)tooktheviewthattheywouldwishtobeinvolvedintheselectionofstudentscomingtotheirorganisationand,further,wouldexpectareturnontheinvestmentoftimeandtrainingontheirpart.Thisreturnwouldbeintheformofbeingabletoofferthebestoftheirinternsemploymentattheendofthedegreeprogram.SuchaviewundoubtedlydemandsconsiderationandtheestablishmentofanadvisorybodyofemployersinvolvedinWILatWPUmightbeanobviousfirststepinapartnershipapproachthatprotectstheinterestsofallconcerned.
![Page 11: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
11
9. AsWILisestablished,WPUevidentlyhasthepotentialthroughindustryandbusinesslinkstocoordinateandstimulateResearchandDevelopment(R&D)agendas.AlthoughthisislikelytotaketimeandeffortitmayshapethefutureforWPUasanentrepreneurialuniversitythathasamongstitsprioritiesbusinessincubationandentrepreneurshipeducation.AcloselyrelatedoptionforWPU,aspartofitsoverallvision,istoconsiderthebenefitsofcombiningthebenefitsofbeinganentrepreneurialuniversitywiththetraitsofadevelopmentaluniversity.Suchuniversitiescollaboratewitharangeofexternalagents,notsolelybusinessandindustrylinksorforprofitorganisations,withtheobjectiveofcontributingtotheeconomicandsocialdevelopmentofthecountry(Brundenius,Lundvall&Sutz,2009).
10. Themedicalandhealthprofessionalsinvolvedinthesurveyspokewithgreat
authorityandfeelingabouttheneedsoftheirpatientsandtheirsector.AkeymessageforWPUistheintegrationofmedicaleducationinitsprogramdeliveryeitheratundergraduateorpostgraduatelevel,possiblyboth.MedicaleducationlendsitselftoproblembasedlearningandtheadvanceduseofICT,forexampletherecentdevelopmentinAfricaofMedAfrica,TeleradiologyandCardiopad,allofwhichhaverelevancetoPapuaNewGuineaandhealthcareinremoteareas.KeyInformantscalledforbetterlaboratorytraining,theabilityofdoctorstoconductresearchusinglargedatabasestointernationalstandardsbut,aboveall,theimprovementofliteracyandnumeracyskillstoenablemedicalprofessionalstocontinuetheirprofessionaleducationbeyondfirstdegreelevelandwellintotheircareers.Therewasacallformorespecialists,biomedicaltechniciansandradiographers,variablesthatbearfurtherscrutiny.
11. TheimportanceofWPU’sdegreesbeingaccreditedandtherebyacceptableinother
PacificIslandCountries(PICs)iscrucialtoboththeUniversity’smissionandcommitmenttointernationaloutreachforitsgraduates.ThePapuaNewGuineanNationalQualificationsFramework(PNGNQF),historicallyanelementofthePacificIslandsQualificationFrameworkforseveralyears,doesnotguaranteerecognitionofdegreesgainedatuniversitiesinPNGinotherPICs.Fromtheoutsettherefore,WPUmustensurethatitsqualificationsmeetandexceedthemostrecentexpectationslaiddowninthe2017editionofthePNGNQF(DHERST,2017). .
12. Thepotentialfortheformallabourmarkettoexpanditsreachintourismandleisure
inPapuaNewGuineaisexponential,matchingthegrowthinhotelandconferencecentreaccommodationinthecapital.Securityandtransportdifficultiesimpingeadverselyuponthisgrowthnationally:neverthelesshowever,thecampusofWPU,withanearbyairstrip,offersanidealsiteforsuchnicheecotourismactivitiesasbirdwatching,culturalvisitsandtheexplorationofitsruggedterrain.Atourist
![Page 12: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
12
facilityoncampuswouldnotonlyfetchrevenue,butalsofacilitateworkplacetrainingforthosestudentsmajoringinthisarea.
13. Agriculture,beyondtheinformalsector’srelianceonsubsistencefarming,
representsanareaofinterestforWPUasitisestablishedintheSouthernHighlands.Rice,Tea,andCoffeeareexamplesofcashcropsintheHighlandsasawhole.Theadditionorabsorptionofanagricultural/livestockcollegeasahuboftheUniversityorthedevelopmentofaUniversityfarm,thatincludespastoralaswellasarablefarmingwouldagaincontributesignificantlytothegrowthofthissectorofthelabourmarketineconomicandsocialterms.ParticularnoteshouldbetakenofGoPNG’srecentendorsementofe-agriculture.
14. AsPapuaNewGuineaembracesthebenefitsandchallengesofglobalisation,itmust
alsopreparefortheeraoftheFourthIndustrialRevolutionthatisalreadytakingusbeyondthedigitalrevolutiontothe‘fusionoftechnologiesthatisblurringthelinesbetweenthephysical,digitalandbiologicalspheres’asSchwab(2016),founderoftheWorldEconomicForum,putsit.Forhim,itisitsspeed,scopeandimpactthatisaffectingthepaceofsystemchangeacrosstheworld.TherelevanceoftheFourthIndustrialRevolutiontoPNGisclear,ifwetakeintoaccountthefactthat40%ofitspopulationisaged15orunder.Lifeforthesechildrenandyoungpeopleoverthenextdecadeastheyaccesstertiaryeducationandthencethelabourmarketislikelytohavebeenimpactedbytechnologicalinnovation.WPU’scommitmenttocommunityengagementandthereductionofpovertymustrespondtotheneedforsocialinnovationinthelivesoffuturegenerations.
15. Theevidenceofthissurveyandothersimilarrecentexercises,forexampleJones&
McGavin(2015)andDeloitte/UNDP(2017),highlightsthecriticalimportanceofskillstoPapuaNewGuinea’sfuture.Therehasbeenanunderlyingassumptionthateducationwillgeneratehighratesofeconomicgrowth;yettheexactmeansbywhichthisoccursremainsunclear.Inlabourmarketterms,thecontrastingpurposesofeducationattertiarylevelareseenbysomeasskillstransferandbyothersasameansofrankingandsortingindividualsaccordingtotheirperceivedcapabilities.TheundistinguishedperformanceoftheTechnicalVocationalEducationandTraining(TVET)sectorandpoorlearningoutcomesinhighereducationinstitutions(HEIs),asarguedinpowerfultermsbyJones&McGavin(ibid:368),combinetocreateaproblematicoutlookforthefutureinPapuaNewGuineawheretransformativenewtechnologieswillconfrontworkerswiththeneedtomastercomplexskillsthatdemandacommitmenttolifelonglearning.ThethrustofthisargumentsuggeststhatWPUmustaddressthedelicatebalancebetweenofferingprogramsthatbenefitjobcreationandemploymentintheformalsectorandthechanginglandscapeinPapuaNewGuineatowardsmicroentrepreneurshipassignpostedintheDeloitte&
![Page 13: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
13
UNDPsurvey(2017).Ashiftsuchasthisunderscores,asnotedinSection1ofthissurvey,therelevanceofsoftskillstohelpindividualsnotonlytoadjusttoamutablemarketplacebutalsotomakeinformedandexactchoices.
![Page 14: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
14
MethodologyRatherthanamererecensionorretellingoftheextant,andprofuse,literaturesurroundingthelabourmarketinPapuaNewGuinea,groundedtheoryprovidesthemethodologicalapproachtothesurvey.Theresearchdesignisessentiallyqualitative,underpinnedbyaphenomenologicalstrategyofinquiry(Cresswell,2014).Usingthisapproach,thesurveycontextualisedthethreebroadresearchquestions,asbelow,withintheambitofthevariousstakeholdersatalllevelstoinvestigatetheirsenseofthedynamicsofgraduaterecruitment.
• Whatpersonalqualities,attitudes,knowledgeandskillsarefundamentallyimportanttoagraduateofaPapuaNewGuineanuniversityforemploymentincurrentandfuturelabourmarkets,bothnationalandinternational?
• Howcantheinvolvementofemployersinprogramdesignanddeliveryfacilitatethereshapingofdegreeprogramsandtheregenerationofworkintegratedlearningforthe21stcentury?
• Whatarethechallengesandconcernsforemployersingraduaterecruitmentbothnowandinthefuture?
Arapidsurveyexerciseconstrainedontheonehandbythe2017Easterholidayperiodandthecommencementofnationalelectionsontheothermeantthatdatacollectioninthefieldwasconfinedtoathree-weekwindowacrossthefollowingprovincesMadang;EastNewBritain;WestNewBritain;EasternHighlands;Simbu;WesternHighlandsandtheSouthernHighlands.Inordertowidentheprovincialdemographicofthesurvey,externalrespondentswereinvitedtoparticipateviasocialmediaattractingmuchinterestatthereadinglevel,withseverallengthysubmissionsinresponsetotheresearchquestions.Twoprincipalmethodsofdatacollectionwereemployed:in-depthonetooneinterviewsandfocusgroupdiscussions.Theformerwerecarefullystructuredindividualinterviewswheretheresearcheraskedtheparticipantsquestionsaboutaspectsoftheresearchquestionsofwhichtheyhadparticularknowledgeorexperience.Theresearcherwasabletoprobeinmoredetailthanwouldbepossibleinafocusgroupdiscussion(Creswell,2014).Thefocusgroupdiscussionswerefacilitatedbytheresearcher(PeekandFothergill,2009)duringwhichtheyendeavouredtogainunderstandingofexperiencesandconceptsrelatedtothesurveyquestionsthroughtheinterplaybetweentheparticipants(Morgan,1996).ParticipantsforthesurveywereselectedonthebasisoftheirfamiliaritywiththefunctioningoftheformalandinformallabourmarketsinPapuaNewGuineaworkingatmultiplelevelseitherasamanagerorconsumeringovernment,business,industry,non-governmentalorganisations(NGOs),thechurches,civilsocietyandhighereducationasreflectedinthetablebelow.Thosewhocametothesurveyviasocialmediawerefromdiverseinterestgroups.
![Page 15: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
15
(Table1:RangeofKeyInformantsinterviewed)
DataanalysisAsthetranscriptionswerecompiledandcollatedtheresearchers,allofwhomhadextensiveexperienceinqualitativeanalysis,usedinductivecontentanalysistoinvestigatetheemergingthemes.Initially,thetranscriptswereopencodedinrelationtothefundamentalaimsoftheresearch.Thisprocesswassupplementedbyaxialcoding,orthegrouping
KeyInformantInterviews ENB WNB WHP EHP SHP Madang ExternallySelected
Total
PEA/DEAs
1
1
PublicServiceOrganisation 1 2 1 1 5
MedicalDoctors 1
1
2
HospitalAdministrators
1 1
2
PublicHealth 2 2MedicalEducationandResearch 2 2
NGOs
1
1 1 3
Churches 1
2 1 4
Media
1
1
PostandTelecommunications
1 1 2
Mining
1 2 3
Agriculture/Livestock 1 2
1
1 5
IT
1 1
BankingandFinance 1
1
1 2 5
Aviation
2
2
RuralDevelopmentAgencies
1
1
DesignandConstruction 3
2
5
Retail 2
1 1
4
LeisureandTourism 1
1 2
HumanResource
1
1 2
HEIs 2 2 4
Politicians 1
1
AccreditationBodies 1 1
Law 2 2
SMEs 3 2 1 6
Total 19 5 3 9 1 15 15 68
![Page 16: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
16
togetherofsimilarcodesthatledultimatelytotheagreementofthefinalthemesasshownbelow.
ResearchQuestionsandFacets
Themes ExamplesofDiscourse
ResearchQuestion1:Whatpersonalqualities,attitudes,knowledgeandskillsarefundamentallyimportanttoagraduateofaPapuaNewGuineanuniversityforemploymentincurrentandfuturelabourmarkets,bothnationalandinternational?
Workplaceandemployerexpectations
Performanceoftheorganisation
‘Today’sgraduatesmustbefocusedandpurposedriven…theymustappreciatethecompany’svisionandmissionandappreciatemeetingmonthlytargets’
Foundationyear Improvingemploymentprospects
‘Needabridgetopreparethemforfurtherstudies’‘Yes–definitely–theyalwayshaveanadvantagewithsuchagoodgrounding’
Graduatestrengthsandweaknesses
Aconcernofthelabourmarket
‘Needagoodattitude;apreparednesstocontinuallyimprove;becomeleadersintheirfield;teachothers;developcapacity;leadbyexampleandmaintainhighstandards’‘Needgraduateswhocansolveproblems;leadteamsandbuildrelationshipsaroundtheorganisation’‘Alotofthemlackleadershipskills,creativity,problemsolvingskillsoutinthefield…Ihaveactuallyhearddegradingcommentsfromnon-degreeholderswithregardtothelackofcriticalandlogicalthinkingwhenitcomestotroubleshooting…sometimesIwonderwhether
![Page 17: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
17
theyareuniversitygraduatesornot’‘ThemainstrengthsofgraduatesarethatmanydospeakgoodEnglish,havethelatestknowledgeandskillsinaparticularfieldandpossessgoodICTknowledgeorskills.However,therearemanyweaknessesandtheyincludelackofcommitmentandleadershipskills,moretheoryoriented,notconfident,lackcharacterorhavelowself-esteemandlackmoreindustrialtrainingexperience.’
Workethics Individualandorganisationalhealth
‘Workethicsofgrooming,punctuality,respect,carefulbudgetingofmoneyandtimearelacking.Ethics…mustbeinstilledinpeoplethroughtheacademicprograms’‘Ethicsrevolvearounddiscipline,self-respectandcompanyprinciples.Graduatesthatlackdedicationandloyaltytothecompanyareaskedtoleave’
ResearchQuestion:2Howcantheinvolvementofemployersinprogramdesignanddeliveryfacilitatethereshapingofdegreeprogramsandtheregenerationofworkintegratedlearningforthe21stcentury?
Lackofknowledge,skillsandcompetences
Degreeprogramsnotsyncedtoworkplacerequirements
‘ICTknowledge,skillsandcompetenciesarelackingasworkplacesnowrequiretheuseofICT.AllprogramsmusthaveanICTcomponent’‘Rightnow,thereisnosignificantinteractionbetweentheindustryandtraining’‘Graduateslacksoftskillsandthatneedstobetaughtaswell’
![Page 18: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
18
ResearchQuestion:3Whatarethechallengesandconcernsforemployersingraduaterecruitmentbothnowandinthefuture?
Recruitmentpractices Restructuringlimitingjobcreationandimprovement
‘Frustratedandboundbyrecruitmentregulations’‘Thestatusquoofhistoricallegaciesofthe60sand70sismaintainedbytheoldemployeescompoundedbynon-recruitmentofuniversitygraduatesinrecentstructuralchanges.Theseproblemsneedtobecarefullyanalysedandstepstakentoaddressthem’‘Ifanychangesneedtohappentheyneedtobesubjecttothelegalprocessofamendinglegislation’‘Theageingworkforcedoesnotacceptchange’
OrganisationalCulture Lackofrespectforauthorityandethicsoftheworkplace
‘Liketoseepersonalqualitiesorattitudesbeingemphasised…wehaveissuesoftrust,dependencyandowningthejob.Thisiswhentheorycannotbeputintopractice’‘Workattitudeisaproblem.Olderemployeesaremorefocusedwhilstyounggraduatesarealwaysaproblem.Weareproducing,butqualityisaproblem’‘Intelligenceistherebutmustcomewiththerightattitudeandworkethic’Weneedcommittedanddedicatedpeople.Theycomewithknowledgeandskillsbutneedaqualitycomponent.Weneedpeoplewhoarededicated,willingtolearn,committed,resourceful,respectfulandtakeownershipoftheorganisation’‘Graduatesneedtoacceptethicalbehaviourinbusiness.Theyhaveapoorunderstandingofcultural
![Page 19: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
19
norms’
ICT Globalisationandthetransformationofwork
‘WeneedcompetentandqualifiedITpersonnel,bothsoftwareandhardwaretechnology.ThecompanyandPNGneedICTprogrammers,trainersandtechnicianstooperatedifferentfunctionalitiesandtofixdamagedequipment.Withthelatesttechnologysuchasecommerce,itincreasesefficiencyandmakesmarketingmoreglobalised’‘ICTmustbebroughtdowntotheprimaryschoollevelandtaughtthroughoutthewholeeducationsystem’‘Graduateshavepracticalcompetenciesandexposuretodigitaltechnologiesandtransformationoftheworkplace’‘TheupskillingofpublicservantsinICTismissing.ICTcoursesmustbeprovidedforthepublicservants’‘ITequalsglobalisationandwillprovideresilienceintheremoteareasofthecountry’‘HaveacomputerscienceprogramatWPU’
Literacyandnumeracy RecruitmentandSelection
‘Writingorliteracyisabigneed…universitiesneedtobeofferingwritingcourses’‘Literacyisappallingandpooramongsttoday’sgraduates’‘Whenreadingapplications…Ilookforhowtheyselltheirskills…theyhavetohavealevelofliteracytoexpressthemselves’
21stcenturyjobs Employabilityandthelabourmarket
‘NeedITspecialistswhocanmanagelargescaledatabasesuptointernationalstandards’‘Fromthebankingperspective…alljobsareimportantforthebanktofunctioneffectively…ITisnotonlythejobofITspecialists,itisfor
![Page 20: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
20
everyoneintheorganisation’‘PNGisadevelopingnationandneedsmoreprofessionalsinallfields–medical,engineering,business,environment,miningandoilandgas’‘PNGneedsgraduatelogisticians’
(Table2:ThemesandResponses)Section1:ProvincialVoices
![Page 21: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
21
MadangProvince1.0 Context 1.1 Incontext,MadangProvince,thethirdlargestcentreofpopulationinthecountry,lieswithinstrikingdistanceofseveralofPapuaNewGuinea’smainindustries,forexample,mining,fisheries,forestry,shippingandagriculturethatarecomplementedbytheprovincialcapital’shistoricattractionasatouristdestinationandasauniversitytown.Itactsasacommercialhubforretailoutlets,aviation,transport[bothlandandsea]togetherwithanetworkofSMEsinboththeformalandinformallabourmarkets.TheCatholic,LutheranandAnglicanChurchesmaintainasignificantfootprintinthelocality.Madang’slocalhospitalisvitaltotheareaanditsmedicalstaffcomprisenationalandvolunteerexpatriatestaff:closelinksaremaintainedasateachinghospitalwiththeUniversitymedicalschoolandtheSchoolofNursing.Ahighlyregardedmedicalresearchfacilitysupplementspublichealthprovision.NGOsareactiveinMadang,andintheneighbouringprovinces,workingwith,andalongside,thecommunitiestosupporthealth,educationandcapacitydevelopmentprograms.BusinesslinksarerobustasreflectedintheworkofthelocalChamberofCommercethatdrawsitsmembersfromavarietyofbusinesses,enterprisesandindustries.PhilanthropicactivitiesareconductedbybranchesoftheLionsandRotarians.Thecommunitycomestogetherforfestivalsofmusic,cultureandsportonaregularbasis.Localpoliticiansplaytheirpartinmaintainingtheharmonyoftheprovinceandthetown,forwhichithasbeenwidelyknown.2.0 Synopsis2.1 ArapidassessmentofthelabourmarketinMadangrevealedthatthereisasignificantdemandforemploymentthatcannotalwaysbemeteitherbecauseofskillsshortagesoralackoftalent.Younggraduates,ofparticularinteresttothisstudy,competeforemploymentindiverseoccupations:banking,aviation,communications,IT,publicutilities,medicine,nursingandhealthcare.TheirgraduatespecialismsareofrelevancebutbyfarthegreatestdiscriminatorsinrecruitmentaretodowiththepossessionofsoftskillsandITliteracy.ResearchrevealedalsothatliteracyandnumeracywereofimmenseconcerntoemployerswhonoteageneraldeclineinstandardsofspokenandwrittenEnglish.Thesearelimitingfactorsandcontributetowidespreadconcernsaboutyouthunemploymentexacerbatedbyurbandrift.2.2 Ascanbeseenfromtheabove,MadangProvince,withapopulationapproaching500,000,andgrowing,isamicrocosmofprovinciallifeincoastalPapuaNewGuineawheremanydiverseculturalgroupsmingletocreateavibrantandrobustlocalcommunity.AtotaloffifteenKeyInformantsofferedtheirviewsduringsemi-structuredinterviewsongraduaterecruitmentalliedtothethreeprincipalresearchquestionsasoutlinedinthemethodology.3.0 Findings
![Page 22: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
22
3.1 Personalcharacteristicsandtraitsdominatedthediscussions.KeyInformantsspokevolublyabouttheneedforgraduatestobeforthrightself-starterswithinitiativeandopenness;awillingnesstolearn;leadingbyexample;committedtocapacitydevelopmentandthemaintenanceofhighstandards.Notably,oneinformantcalledforgraduatestohavecompassionand‘ateachablespirit’.3.2 Theimportanceofanethicalperspectiveinbothbusinessandpersonallifereceivedfrequentmention,someKeyInformantsseeingthelackofitasthegreatestprobleminpublicservice.Onewasoftheopinionthata‘moralcompasswasoftenlackingingraduates’;forothers,ethicalbehaviourpromoted‘peaceandharmony’.Christianvaluesandoutlookwereratedhighlyalongsidetheimportanceofethics.Itwasobservedthatgoodgraduates,fromtimetotime,canbecomeinvolvedinthepernicioussocialproblemsposedbyalcoholandothersubstances,whichimpairstheirperformanceconsiderably.3.3 Proactiveleadershipwasanimportanttheme,particularlyinrelationtopublicserviceandexcellenceinagraduate’schosenfieldofendeavour.Theterm‘agentofchange’crystallisedthegeneralexpectationofgraduateswhowouldbecomeinnovatorswithinthecommunity.Indeed,someemployerswereclearthattheypreferredtoappointgraduateswhohadhadsomeinternationalexposure.3.4 Again,KeyInformantswereclearthatsoftskills,whichwerereferredtoaspeopleskillsorrelationshipbuilding,areasimportantastheoreticalknowledge.Someemployersfeltthatgraduatesare‘floodedwiththeory’attheexpenseofsuchskills.Therewasaclarioncallfromthemajorityforuniversitiestonurturecritical,analyticalthinkers,problemsolvers,teamworkersandfacilitatorsasopposedtothesteadyproductionofpassive,submissiveanddependentindividualsforthelabourmarketwhoare‘oftenoutoftheirdepth’.3.5 Althoughalreadyanacknowledgedpriority,informationtechnologywasregardedasbeingofextremeimportance,notonlytotheneedsofbusinessandindustry,butalsotothenationasawhole,wheresomeKIsarguedthatitwasthekeytobringingglobalisation,forexampleviaMSMEsandmicrobanks,totheremotestpartsofPapuaNewGuinea.AfeelingwasexpressedthatITcouldcontributetoanincreaseintheHumanDevelopmentIndex.Specialistteachingisrequiredinthemanagementoflargedatabaseswheregraduatesareabletodealwithresearchandstatisticsatinternationallyacceptablelevels.3.6 Inrelationtoliteracyandnumeracyskills,thegenerallyexpressedviewwasthatcurrentgraduatesaredeficientintheseareas,withmanyunabletocommunicateeffectivelyatareasonablyadvancedlevelinwrittenandspokenEnglish,withabilitylevelsskewedtowardsthebottomendofthenormalcurveofdistribution.Theabilitytocritique
![Page 23: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
23
research,appraise,interpret,implementandplaneffectivelywereallseentobecontingentuponsuchskills.3.7 Graduaterecruitmentissometimesfrustratedbytheregulatoryframeworkinthepublicservicewheretheestablishmentofpositionsiscontrolled,oftenonthebasisofhistoricdataratherthancurrentneed.Elsewhere,HRproceduresneedimprovementandupdatingtoencouragebetterselectionandinductionprocesses,sincethisisanareacriticaltopreparingnewgraduatesforworkplaceandorganisationalculture.Manymorecompetentgraduatesareneeded.3.8 Workintegratedlearningandgraduateprogramsreceivedstrongsupport,qualifiedonlybytheexpectationthatemployerswouldbeconsultedonthenatureofthepartnershipwiththeUniversityandalsotheselectionofundergraduatesthatwouldcometotheirworkplace.Therewasalsoaviewthatacost/benefitanalysisshouldbeapplied,totheextentthatemployerswouldbeabletorecruitdirectlythebestoftheirplacementstudentsupongraduation.3.9 NicheemploymentareaswereofinteresttomanyKIswhopointeduptheneedforaircraftengineersandpilotsontheonehandandthoseskilledinthephysicalsciencesandpetrochemicalengineeringontheother.Demandsformoregraduateswithfinancialliteracy,accountancy,economicsandmanagementskillswereparalleledbycallsforexpertiseincommunitydevelopmentandprojectmanagement.Medicineandthehealthsectorarealsoareasofgreatneed,forexamplebiomedicaltechnicians,radiographersandsonographers.Graduatelogisticians,epidemiologists,laboratorystafftrainedtointernationalstandardsandclinicalresearchersareallingreatdemand,asaresocialworkersandcaremanagers.
![Page 24: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
24
HighlandsProvinces1.0 Context1.1 TheHighlandsregionforthepurposeofthissurveycomprisedfourprovinces,namely,EasternHighlands,Chimbu,WesternHighlandsandSouthernHighlands.TheHighlandsregionoverall,denselypopulatedanddiscoveredinthe1930s,isthehometodiverseethnicgroupings,strikingfloraandfauna,worldfamousArabicacoffee,tea,mining,gasandoil.Increasinglycommercialactivitiesarebecomingcommonfeaturesofdevelopmentintheregion.ThearterialHighlandsHighwaypassesthroughthemountainousCentralRangefromLae,withMomasetothenorthandPapuatothesouth,criticaltoarobustfoodline,infrastructureexpansionandtheeconomicboom.WithintheHighlands,thePogeraGoldMine;HidesGas;KutubuOil;coffeeproducers;agriculture;timbermilling;banking;tourismandretailingbusinessesallprovideemploymentopportunitiesforbothnationalandinternationallabourmarkets.TheUniversityofGoroka,severalteachers’colleges,nursingandtheologicalcollegesprovideforhighereducationopportunitiesandlocalemployment.TheCatholic,Lutheran,SeventhDayAdventist,United,AnglicanandotherChurchesflourishthroughouttheregion.Smallandmediumsizedenterprises(SMEs);Non-GovernmentOrganizations(NGOs);governmentoffices;provincialhospitals;Churchrunhospitals;hotelsandlodges;PrivateMotorVehicles(PMVs);truckingcompanies;buildingandroadconstructioncompanies,andinvestmentbyreputablecompaniesnurturefurtherpossibilitiesfortheengagementandempowermentofpeople,tangiblechangeandanimprovementinthequalityoflife.2.0 Synopsis2.1 Whilstbusinesses,industries,construction,education,health,banking,governmentservices,tonamebutafew,arerapidlyexpandingintheHighlandsRegion,humanresourcesarerequiredbytheseorganizations.Arapidlabourmarketsurveywasconductedtoassessthenatureofgraduaterecruitment.Informedbythefindingsofthisresearch,inputwillbesoughtfromemployersinthedesignofacademicprogramstobetteralignwiththeirownneedsandexpectations.Thechallengesandconcernsofemployerswerebasedonthethreeprincipalresearchquestions,asoutlinedinthemethodology.2.2 KeyInformantInterviews(KIIs)andFocusGroupDiscussions(FGDs)withtwenty-fourpersonsinallheldacrossthefourprovinces,drawnfromprovincialgovernments,constructioncompanies,publicserviceorganizations,business,banking,educationandhealth,yieldedinterestingdata.Whilstsomeorganisationsareconstrainedbytightstaffquotas,thedemandforhighlyknowledgeable,skilled,experiencedandspecialistprofessionalsdoesexistinmanyspheres.Specifically,mostparticipantsexpressedtheviewthatthereishighdemandformorespecialistdoctors;specialistteachersinlanguage,mathematicsandscience(i.e.chemistry,physicsandbiology);engineers;andtechniciansinmanytechnicalfields.Informantsalsosuggestedthatthemostdemandingneedinthe
![Page 25: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
25
regionisforhighlyskilledandcompetentICTspecialistswhowillmanageanddisseminateICTeducationtotheworkforceindifferentsettings.2.3 However,oneofthemajorfactorsintheseprovincesregardingtherecruitmentandnurturingofgraduateswasworkethicanditwasfeltthatuniversitiesortraininginstitutionsmustincorporateethicsintotheiracademiclearning.Participantsreportedthatgraduatescomewithbigexpectationsandmaybeunwillingtocommenceworkatthebaselevelofappointment.Equally,theyreportedfactorssuchaslowself-esteem;absenteeism;commitment;honesty;respectandpoorgrooming;theinabilitytobudgetmoneyandtime;abandoningtheworkplaceortalkingontheirmobilesforlongperiodsoftime.Twoparticipantsfromapublicserviceorganizationstatedthatsomegraduatesdonotintegratewellintheworkplaceenvironmentand,astheemployer,theydescribedtheneedtooffloadsometechnicaltrainingprogramstouniversitiesorimprovetheirowninductionprograms.3.0 Findings3.1 Regionally,themostcommonchallengesandconcernsamongallparticipantswastheworkethicamonggraduates.Manyoftheparticipantsexpressedtheviewthatgovernmentagencies,business,industryandprivatesectorsarenowrequiringwellintegrated,roundedorcompletegraduates.Fromtheintegralhumandevelopmentperspective,Highlandsemployersrequireindividualswhoarephysically,socially,spiritually,politicallyandeconomicallywell-groundedintheirattitudesandpossessapositiveoutlook.Theparticipantshighlightedthat,attheendoftheday,employerswantincreasesinproductivity,efficiencyandqualityoutputsintheworkplace.ManyoftheparticipantsacrosstheHighlandsRegionexpressedtheneedforgraduatestobehonest,committed,dedicated,willingtolearnandbedeservingofthepay.3.2 Notably,allparticipantswantedimmediatestepstobetakentoaddresspoorworkethicsandattitudessuchaslackofcommitment,dishonestyandinvolvementindubiousbehavioursincludingdrunkenness,gamblingandlivingonborrowedmoneyprevalentamonggraduates,ifPapuaNewGuineaistoproducequalityhumancapitalfornationbuildingandmeetingglobaldemandsintheinternationallabourmarkets.TheyemphasizedthatcollegesanduniversitiesshouldincludebusinessethicsorChristianethicsinthedesignoftheiracademicprograms.TwoinformantsmentionedthatoneuniversitydoesplaceemphasisonChristianethicsandmoregraduatesarebeingrecruitedfromthatinstitution.3.3 Ofrelatedconcernwasthelevelofknowledge,skillsandcompetenciesamonggraduates.ParticipantsfromarangeoforganizationsintheHighlandsprovincesvisited,reflectedtheirownexpectationsofwhattypesofgraduatestheywishtorecruit.Thoseinthehealth,education,powergenerationandconstructionsectorswantedqualifiedspecialistsratherthangeneralists.Theparticipantsfurthermentionedthatalackofexperienceandcompetencyprevailsamonggraduatesandthereshouldbeabalance
![Page 26: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
26
betweentheoryandpracticetominimizethisgap.Thismaybeachievedduringthecourseofstudyorduringaninductionprogramintheworkplaces.3.4 MatchingthepaceofdevelopmentandchangeinInformationCommunicationsTechnology(ICT)wasacommonconcernamongalltheparticipants.OneinformantstatedthateverythingiscomputerizedandthefutureiswithICT.TheHighlandsRegionisadaptingtocomputertechnologyaspartofagloballychangingenvironmentandtheparticipantsfeltthatdifferentorganizationsandpeopleofallwalksoflifeneedtobecomecomputerliterate.Issuesraisedamongparticipantsincludedtheneedformorecomputerspecialists;programmers;analysts;theofferingofcomputerscienceprogramsfromsmalltobigdatabasesatuniversitiesandtheofferingofshorttermICTcoursesforarangeofdifferentworkers.3.5 Someparticipantsarguedthatthroughglobalization,internationalization,acculturation,labourandadvancesintechnology,PNGneedstoforgeaheadwithtechnological,managementandeconomicchanges.Oneparticipantstatedthatwiththelatesttechnology,forinstance,e-commerce,itincreasesefficiencyandICTmakesmarketingmoreglobalized.Furthermore,astheworldbecomesmorecomplexandsophisticated,manyoftheparticipantshighlightedtheneedforeducationalinstitutionstonurturemorecriticalandanalyticalthinkers,problemsolvers,peoplewithamatureunderstandingofthecommongood,effectivecommunicationskillsandmeaningfulleadershipqualities.3.6 Aconcernwasraisedbytwoparticipantsdealingwithgovernanceandadministrationthatgraduatesneedtobecomefamiliarwiththeirparticularorganization’svision,mission,corevalues,policies,structuresandprocessesforthemtooperateeffectivelyandproductivelyintheworkplace.Unfamiliarityoranunwillingnesstolearnculturesandprocessesintheworkenvironmentleadstoguesswork,frustrationordismissal.3.7 Thoseparticipantsengagedintheconstructionandbusinesssectors,apartfromwantingmorehighlyspecializedandqualifiedtechnocrats,advocatedstronglythatmorePapuaNewGuineancompaniesshouldbeconsideredandawardedcontractssothatmorejobscanbecreatedtoabsorbgraduates.Currentlytheawardingofbigcontractsfavourscertainforeigncompaniesthatbringtheirownworkersandlanguagebarriersaffectingpropertrainingandgroundingofgraduates.3.8 Inrelationtojobcreation,thoseparticipantsfromtheGovernmentsectorreiteratedtheneedforDepartmentsofPersonnelManagement,Finance,Treasuryandprovincialgovernmentstoassesscolonialorestablishedlegacies,reformstructuralprocessesandreviewthestaffceilingsyndrometomeetnotonlythemanpowerneedsoftherespectiveorganizationsbutprovidealsogreateremploymentopportunitiesforgraduates.
![Page 27: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
27
3.9 Insum,mostinformantsexpressedtheviewthatemployersneedmorecomplete,wellrounded,wellintegrated,vibrant,competent,committed,honestandproductivegraduatestomovethiscountrytoanotherlevel.Theywereoftheviewthatuniversitieshavetheresponsibilitytonurtureasoundworkethic;provideexposuretoICTknowledgeandskills;developproficientreadingandwritingskills,nurturespecialistssuchasdoctors,engineersandteachersinlanguage,mathematicsandscience,andqualitygraduates.Moreover,theinformantsbelievedthateducationalinstitutionscanfurtherpromotecriticalandanalyticalthinking,problemsolvingskills,inquiryandeagernesstolearnandthinkingoutsidetheboxsuchaslearningforself-employment.Participantsarguedforthecreationofmorejobstoabsorbtheever-increasingnumbersofgraduatesnotonlybenefitingorganizations,nationaldevelopmentandglobalinterrelatednessintermsoftechnology,businessandcommunicationsbutalsosatisfyingdemandinnationalandinternationallabourmarkets.
![Page 28: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
28
EastandWestNewBritainProvinces1.0 Context1.1 EastNewBritainProvince(ENBP)wasfirstsettledbyGermanmerchantswhotradedincopraandcocoa.WiththearrivaloftheCatholicChurchtherewasanexpansionofagricultureconsumingvasttractsofthetropicalrainforestthatweregivenovertogrowingcocoa,whichwasthenexportedtothemajorchocolatefactoriesintheUnitedStatesofAmerica(USA)andEuropeand,forotheruses,toSingapore,USA,PhilippinesandMalaysia,Meanwhile,coprawascrushedforcoconutoilextracts.1.2 TheCatholicChurchcontinuestomakeanimmensecontributiontohealthcareandeducationintheprovinceandtheregion,alongsidetheGovernment.TheregionalhighereducationinstitutionsareallbasedinENB,consistingofDivineWordUniversity,intheformofKabaleoTeacher’sCollege,andSt.Mary’sSchoolofNursing,togetherwiththeUniversityofNaturalResources,KokopoBusinessCollegeandBismarkTeacher’sCollege.1.3 Kokopo,asthemainadministrative,commercialandeducationalcentreforENB,hasgrownrapidlyoverthelast23yearsfromasmalldistricttowntobecomingthefourthlargesttowninthecountry.TherelocationtoKokopo,postthe1994volcaniceruptionoverRabaul,alsogeneratedincreasedconstructionandengineeringworkfortherestorationofthetownshipandtheprovince.1.4 Theeconomyconsistsofadualsystem.Themoderncasheconomyoperatessidebysidewiththesubsistenceandinformalfarmingsector.WhileENBPisnowthenation’sleadingcocoaproducer,WestNewBritainProvincehassteadilyrisentoleadthenationinpalmoilexports,andforestryandtimberexports,thelattermainlytoJapan,Singapore,MalaysiaandKorea.2.0 Synopsis2.1 ArecentrapidassessmentofthelabourmarketinEastNewBritainsuggeststhatthegrowthandexpansionofbusinessinterestintheprovinceisreflectedinanincreaseinbasicgovernmentservices.TheredevelopmentofEastNewBritainprovinceafterthevolcanicdestructionin1994andtherelocationofitscapitalRabaultothetownofKokopothathasbecomethemainbusinessanddefactocapitaloftheNewGuineaislandsregionhasseenmajorinvestmentsinmining(landandsea),agriculture,forestry,shipping,roadtransportation,roadconstruction,bridgesandwithitthesupportservices,suchasschools,hospitalsandshops.2.2 Thisphenomenonhasprovidedverygoodemploymentopportunitiesforprofessionals,aswellasyounggraduates,inbanking,communication,hospitalservices,teaching,merchandising,engineering,builtindustry,non-governmentalorganizations,small
![Page 29: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
29
andmediumenterprises,consultancy,surveyingandmining.ItisevidentintheseNGIprovincesthatemployersneedgraduates.Theyneedprofessionalmanpowerandhumanresourcetosupport,guideandofferprofessionalleadershipinbusinessandtheserviceindustries.Recentsignificantdevelopmentsintheprovincesare,forexample,theinvestmentsinoff-shoreunderwaterminingandpalmoildevelopment,whichwillofferadditionalbetterandchallengingjobopportunitiestomoreprofessionals,someofwhomwillberecruitedfromoutsidetheprovince.2.3 TherapidassessmentofthelabourmarketinWestNewBritainsuggeststhatthemajorbusinessandcashincomeintotheprovincehingesonsustainingtheoilpalmindustryintheprovince.Currently,thetwomajoremployersareNewBritainPalmOil,basedatMosa,receivingbasicservicesfromKimbeTownshipandHargyOilPalmCompany,accessingbasicservicessuchashospitals,schools,bankingandpostandtelecommunicationfromBiallaTownship.Bothinvestorshaveplantedvastlandareaswithoilpalmandthebusinessofcrudeoilpalmextractionforexportisincreasing.Withsuchinvestments,businessesintheserviceandfoodindustrysectorswillincreaseanddevelop.Otherprivatesectorbusinesses,suchasfoodsuppliers,schools,thehospitalityindustry,banking,shipping,roadtransportandmanyMSMEsdependlargelyontheoilpalmindustryintheprovince.Notably,thesmall-scalecasheconomysupportedbyoilpalmblockholdergrowersgeneratesacashspinoffforthemandeventuallytheprovince,suggestingthataseriousleaningtowardsMSMEshasaveryhighmarketpotential.2.4 ThedataanddemographicsconfirmthattheacceleratedgrowthandexpansionofbusinessandindustryinbothEastandWestNewBritaincontinuestogeneratetheneedformoreskilledpersonnel.Equally,thisgrowthisanticipatedtotriggeranincreaseinbasicsupportservices,and,thereby,asurgeintheneedforprofessionalhumanresource3.0 Findings 3.1 AtotalofnineteenKeyInformants(KI)offeredtheirviewsinrelationtothethreeprincipalresearchquestions,asdetailedinthemethodology,duringsemi-structuredinterviewsongraduaterecruitmentinEastNewBritain,whilefivedidthesameinWestNewBritain.3.2 KIsexpressedtheviewthattheyaresatisfiedwiththeprofessionaltheoreticalskillsgraduatespossess.Theydorealizethatmanygraduateswillneedtimeandaninternalinductionprogramtobecomefullyintegratedintothecultureandorganisationoftheirbusinessesandindustries.However,majorconcernswereraisedaboutthedeficienciesofsomegraduatesinregardtopersonalconfidence,respect,leadership,discipline,punctuality:manyindeed,itwassaid,donotshowsufficientloyaltyandcommitmentfortheiremployingorganisation.
![Page 30: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
30
3.3 OtherKIsarguedthatunlessthegraduateisreadytolearnandadjusttotheexpectationsoftheworkplace,theywillnotbeabletolearnonthejobeasily.Onepersonsaid,‘Today’sgraduatesmustbefocusedandpurposedriven.Theymustappreciatethecompany’svisionandmissionandappreciatemeetingmonthlytargets.’Itisinthisway,thatmanyuniversitygraduateshavebeenfoundwanting,becausemostthatjoincarrytoomuch‘ego’anddonotappreciatecompanyprinciples.FortheKIscompanyvaluesrevolvearounddiscipline,self-respect,respectforvisionandmission,dedicationandloyalty.Somegraduateslackingthatdedicationandloyaltyorwhodonotattempttochangeareusheredoutofemploymentasquicklyaspossible.3.4 Thepublic-sectororganisationsinvolvedinthesurvey,largelyservicedriven,nowalsofaceanagegapissue.Theyoungergenerationofgraduateshasmoreandupdatedknowledgeanddrive,butaresuppressed,itisasserted,bytheoldergeneration,whooccupypositionsofauthorityand‘cling’tocontrolandsupervision.3.5 Recentgraduatesareinductedwellthroughacomprehensiveinductionprogram.Forexample,theOriginEnergyprogramsupportsselectedgraduatesbyofferingworkplaceattachmentsfortheminyear2oryear3oftheirstudies.Theyarehandpickedandschooledinthecompany’sexpectationsbeforetheygraduateandjointhecompany.AKIsaid,‘Withoutsuchhandpickedcoaching,newgraduatesdostrugglewiththeworkingenvironment.’Newgraduatesalsolackpeoplemanagementandtimemanagementskills.Somesoftskillsarealsomissing.Thesemaytaketimetomasterandalsotrainingmaybecalledupontocomplementthetrainingskills.AnotherKIsaid,‘Intheend,weneedgraduateswhocansolveproblems,leadteamsandbuildrelationshipsaroundtheorganization.’3.6 EthicswasidentifiedbyKIsasaseriousdeficiency,especiallyinthepublicservice.Onementionedthat,‘Ethicsrevolvedarounddiscipline,self-respectandadherencetotheorganisationprinciples.’Yetanothersaid,‘Graduateswhodonotshowrespectandwholackconfidenceareaskedtoleaveassoonaspossible.’Itwasobservedthatgoodgraduateswillnottakeshortcutsordothingsdishonestlytocompleteataskwhenthemanagerisnotwatching.Excessivedrinkingandabuseofalcoholremainchronicproblemsandmanygraduatescannotcontroltheseantisocialhabits.3.7 ManyKeyInformantsacknowledgedthatinformationtechnologyisabsolutelyvital,notonlytotheneedsofbusinessandindustry,butalsotothenationasawhole.SomeKIsarguedthatitwasthekeytoglobalisation.ThemajorityviewswerethatITiscentraltoallaspectsofpersonallifeaswellasbusiness.OneKIsaid,‘LikethebasicEnglish,MathsandSciencethataretaughtinprimaryschooling,ICTmustalsobebroughtdowntothatlevelandtaughtthroughoutthewholeeducationsysteminPapuaNewGuinea.InformationTechnologyhasenteredtheworkplaceandisprovingmoreandmoreessential.’
![Page 31: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
31
3.8 Eachorganizationauditedhadsomekindofcomputerizedoperation.Thelargeroperationshavelocalcomputerizednetworks,whilemostgovernmentdepartmentandagencieshavestand-alonecomputersystems,anecessarycomponentoftheirbusinessoperations.SomeKIsfeltthatmanygraduatescannotfollowsimplewritteninstructionsthatcomewithtoolsorinstrumentstoapplytoajob.Manycannotevenwritereportsoracceptassignedtasks,forexamplethesystematicwriteupofareport.Similarly,spokenEnglishandgrammaticalusageispoor.Numeracyisalsopooramongstgraduates.ItwassaidbyKIsthatmanycannotanalyseaworksituationusingbasicnumbers.Generallyspeaking,bothnumericalandliteracyskillsarepoorerintoday’sgraduatescomparedtopastgraduates.3.9 Inthepublicservice,unlessthereisarestructurewheremoreresponsiblepositionsaremadeavailablegraduatescanremainatanentrylevelforyears,waitingfortheoldergenerationtomoveon.Elsewhere,HRproceduresneedimprovementandupdatingtoencouragebetterselectionandinductionprocesses,sincethisisanareacriticaltopreparingnewgraduatesforworkplaceandorganisationalculture.Withinthebusinessesandindustriessurveyed,manysectionordepartmentmanagersreportedthattheyarehappytoengagegraduates.Theyseegraduatesaspotentialforthecompanyandarehappytoemploythemandtrainthemontherolesandresponsibilitiesoftheinstitution.Onemanagersaid,‘InmycapacityIhavetakenongraduatesfromPNGUniversityofTechnology.TheUniversityDepartmenthasasandwichprogramwhereanengineercomesoutforfieldtrainingforafull12months.Ienjoyedimpartingfieldknowledgeandtrainingduringtheirstay.Iamnoweagertogetmoregraduatestofulfiltheirdegree.HeadOfficemanagesthisrequirementwhilstweattheterminalandbranchlevelexecutetrainingrequirements.’3.10 Workintegratedlearningisperhapsabettermethodofimpartingcorrectskillsexpectedbyprofessionalorganizationstotheyounggraduates,whiletheyarestillstudying.Suchindustry-universityco-trainingarrangementsassistbyfocusingthegraduateontherequirementsoftheworkplace,butmoreso,whatisexpectedofthembytheiremployers.3.11 Thebettergraduatesaremoreeasilysecuringemployment.Theprocessofselectionoftenpreventstheweakergraduatesfromsecuringemployment,simplybecausetheemploymentmarket’srecruitmentproceduresintheformalsectorarerobustandimproving.
![Page 32: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
32
ExternallySelectedParticipants1.0 Acontextdrivenapproachtodatacollection1.1 Thisparticularsectionofthereportpresentstheapproachtodatacollectionandfindingsfromtheparticipantsacrossindustryandpublicandprivatesectorworkforceswhoweresourcedexternally.1.2 Participantswereoriginallyapproachedboththroughtraditionalin-personcontactsandsubsequentlythroughsocialmediaplatformssuchastheprofessionalnetworkingplatformsLinkedInandsocialnetworkingplatformofFacebook.Invitationstoparticipateviasocialmediawereplacedonthetwoplatforms,whilstphonecallsweremadeinadditiontomeetingsinpersonwithotherpotentialparticipants.InterestedsocialmediaparticipantswerethenforwardedinvitationlettersandKeyInformantquestionsandofferedtheoptiontosubmitwrittenfeedbackorhaveaphoneinterview.1.3 Thesocialmediastrategywasmorerewardingthananticipated.Whereastraditionalmethodsbindtheresearchertospecificgeographicspacestosourceparticipants,socialmedianetworkssurmountthephysicalandgeographicalobstaclestoreachparticipantsanywhereinthecountry,subjecttointernetconnectivity.Theresultingnumberofinteractionsandgeographiclocationsmaybeindicativeofthesocio-economicanddigitaldivideinPNGthatstillfavourstheurbanandmultinationalorganisations.1.4 TherewaslittleornoresponsefromtheMomaseandNewGuineanIslandsregions;strikingly,mostoftheinterestandinteractioncamefromprofessionalsintheNationalCapitalDistrictandfromtheminingsitesintheHighlandsRegion.Unsurprisingly,giventheglobalreachofsocialnetworks,theinvitation’sreachonLinkedInhadsignificantviewershipfromAustralia.TherewasalsointerestfromsuchdistantplacesastheUnitedKingdom,NewZealandandIndia.1.5 Theapproachdeliveredatotalofnineteenparticipantsinall,fifteenofwhomwereKeyInformants,whilsttheremaindertookpartinafocusgroupdiscussionsession.OfthefifteenKeyInformants,amajorityoftenparticipantsweresecuredthroughsocialmedianetworks.FromLinkedIneightKeyInformantsoutoffourteenwhowereforwardedinvitationsprovidedfeedbackbythedeadline,whilstFacebookdeliveredthreeresponsesoutofthefivewhowereinvited.Oftheremainingfivewhosubmittedfeedback,onewascontactedexternallybyphoneandtheothersweresourcedinpersonandlocallyinMadang.ThefourwhoparticipatedinthefocusgroupdiscussionwereallemployedbyoneNGOatthetimeofthediscussion,theirperspectiveswereenrichedbyemploymentexperiencesfromtwoorthreeotherNGOorganisations.
![Page 33: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
33
2.0 TheFindings2.1 Thefindingsemergingfromthisdatasetarecollatedunderthefollowingthemes:personalcharacteristicsandtraits;ethicalperspective;proactiveleadership;softskills;InternetandICTliteracies;literacyandnumeracyskills;graduateemployability;graduatestrengthsandweaknesses;proactiveleadership;theoreticalknowledge;work-integratedlearningandgraduatenicheemploymentareas.Thesethemesconvergeontheemployers’concernswithgraduatepreparednessfortheworksetting.Theanalysisofdataaroundthisconcernhelpedtoidentifygraduatestrengthsthatenhancetheirchancesatemploymentandweaknesseswhichdiminishtheirchances.Identifyingweakskillsandattitudesrepresentsthefirststeptoadoptingrelevantstrategiestoenhancegraduatepreparednessfortheworksettingwhilstrespondingtoemployers’concerns.ThisinformationisofvaluetoWPUasitdevelopsprogramsthatareresponsivetoworkforcestudentneeds.2.2 Personalcharacteristicsandtraits2.2.1 Participantsfrequentlymentionedgraduatecharacteristicsandtraitsthatwereimportantattributesforperformanceattheworkplace.Anditisnotjustabouthavingknowledge.Oneinformant,abanker,underscoredtheimportanceofpersonalattributessaying:‘Iwillrecruitthosegraduateswhohaveagoodattitude.Intelligenceistherebutintelligencemustcomewiththerightattitudeandworkethics’.Thesameinformantfurthersaidhishiringdecisionswouldbeinformedbyuniversityreputation,workethics,highmoralstanding,ateamplayerandleadershipskills:Iwouldprefer[recruitingfrom]universitiesthathavehighstandardsonacademicaswellasthebasicprincipleofworkethics….’Anotherinformantstatedthatobservationofweaknessesinsomegraduatesledmanagersintheorganisationtoquestion‘whethertheyareuniversitygraduatesornot.’Yetanothersaid:‘Alotofthemalsolackleadershipskills,creativityandproblem-solvingskillswhenoutinthefield.Ihaveactuallyhearddegradingandnegativecommentsfromsomenon-degreeholders(personnel)attheworkplaceaswellwithregardstolackofcritical/logicalthinkinginourgraduateswhenitcomestotroubleshooting.’2.2.2 ThesepersonalcharacteristicsandtraitsarepresentedonthetableunderValues,ProfessionalismandBehaviours.Again,thefindingsunderthisthemewillinformWPUinitsgraduateemploymentpreparationprograms.
Values Professionalism WorkplaceBehaviours
honestyintegritytransparencycommitmentloyalty
innovativeintuitivegoodworkethicself-learnerpunctuality
ofsoberhabitresourcefulnessmotivatedpassionateself-confidence
![Page 34: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
34
respectserviceChristianvaluesHighmoralcharacter
flexible/adaptablecreativityproblem-solvertroubleshooterreliableabilitytomulti-skillreliabledetailorientedefficientinter-personalskillscriticalthinkerabletodemonstratecompetenceinbusinesswriting
Persistence
(Table3:DesirableCharacteristicsandTraits)
2.3 Softskills2.3.1 Allrespondentsagreedthatsoftortransversalskillswereasimportantforahealthy,harmoniousorganisation,andinsomeworksettings,thesewereevenmoreimportantthantheoreticalknowledge.Anyinstitutionpreparingtheworkforceshouldfurtherensurethatsoftorpeopleskillsaregivenappropriateattentioningraduatetraining.Aninformantfromthecoffeeindustryhadthistosaywhenconsideringrecruitment:‘Itakeintoconsiderationbothacademicaswellasnon-academicperformance,asbeingsociallyinvolvedmakesyouabetterteamplayerandopentocommunication’.
2.4 Workbehaviourandethics2.4.1 Withfewdifferences,allparticipantsagreedontheimportanceofasoundworkethicandmoralcharacter.Informantsagreedthatappropriateworkplacebehaviourandethicswereextremelyimportantfortheworkplace.Suchaconcernisindicativeoftheimportanceoforganisationalwell-beingandproductivity.UniversitiessuchasWPUwouldbewelladvisedtoknowthatacquisitionofthesepositiveworkbehavioursandtheinculcationofanappropriateworkethicincreasestheemployabilityofagraduate.Oneinformantstated:‘Iwillrecruitthosegraduateswhohaveagoodattitude.Intelligenceistherebutintelligencemustcomewiththerightattitudeandworkethics’.2.5 Theoreticalknowledgeapplied:workintegratedlearning2.5.1 Therewasconsensusamongsttherespondentsthat,whilsttheacquisitionoftheoreticalknowledgeisgood,theworksettingwouldalsoliketoseeitspracticalapplication.ParticipantsexpressedstrongviewsontheimportanceofWorkIntegratedLearning.Thefindingssuggestthatwork-integratedlearningwouldgoalongwaytoincreasetheemploymentprospectsofgraduates.Therewereemployerswhowerereadyto
![Page 35: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
35
engagewiththetraininginstitutiontofacilitatetraining.Insomecases,meaningfulcollaborationbetweenemployersandinstitutionwasabsent.2.5.2 Akeyinformantfromthemediaindustrygenerallydidnotfindthebasicattributesofhisprofessioninuniversitygraduatessincehewaslookingforthosewhocanthinkindependently,havethetenacitytostayandgoafternews,aredisciplined;whoarewisemanagersoftime,haveanaturalsenseofcuriosityandareproactive.2.5.3 TheNGOparticipantsinthefocusgroupdiscussionswantedtoseeuniversitiesbeproactiveinarranginginternshipsorindustrytraining.Theysawthisengagementas‘…agoodinduction[which]meansnewgraduateswouldhaveorientationtotheworksettingandnotjustbethrownatthedeependtosurviveorsink.Andworkplacementwasagoodpreparationforthetransitionintotheworkplace’.2.5.4 Abankeralsosawintegratedlearningas‘veryimportantasitguidesthegraduatetothinkoutsidetheboxandalsobuildonhisorherskills.’Anotherinformantstatedthat:‘Ihavealwaysbeenpassionatetoensurethenecessarytrainingthatneedstobeofferedtothegraduatesisdoneinconsultationwiththerelevantdepartmentswhoareresponsibleforthework-integratedlearning’.Abankerinformantsaid:‘Withoutexperiences/internshippracticals,thereisnoconnectionbetweenorganisations,governmentdepartmentsand/orcompanieswiththedifferentstrands/divisionsintheinstitutionssothatgraduatesshouldhaveatasteofwhattheworkplaceenvironmentislikethroughpracticalsorinternshipprograms.’2.6 LiteracyandNumeracy2.6.1 Theverdictonliteracyandnumeracyisloudandnearlyunanimous.Withtheexceptionofafewcontraryvoicesfromorganisationsthatrecruitthecreamofthegraduates,itwasfeltmanygraduatesentertheworkforcewithdeficienciesinthesefoundationalskills.Manygraduatestaketotheworkplacewithbadqualitywritingrepletewithgrammaticalerrors;ortheywriteinamixtureofTokPisinandEnglish.Theylackknowledgeabouthowtostructureessays,‘Theydon’twritewell.’Orally,theywouldrathergiveone-wordanswerstoquestions.2.6.2 Someparticipantscalledonuniversitiestodomoretoraisethestandardsofliteracyandnumeracytobetterpreparegraduatesfortheworkforce.However,someparticipantsplacetheblameonnationalpoliciessuchastheTuitionFreeEducationPolicy,whichtheysaidwaswell-intentionedbuthasimpactednegativelyonthequalityofeducationofthestudents.2.6.3 Oneparentparticipantacknowledgedthattheuniversitiescanonlydosomuch.UniversitylecturersamongsttheKeyInformantswouldtendtoagree,observingthat
![Page 36: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
36
universitiesfacedthesamechallengesofbasiclanguageandnumeracyinstudentswhoenrolled.Althoughtheytriedtoaddresstheconcerns,thecurriculumcontentandstructureandresourcesoftendidnotallowtoomuchscopetodevotetobasicskilldeficienciesinstudents.2.6.4 Oneparticipantinthefocusgroupdiscussionpleadedwiththeuniversitiestoteachwriting.Anothersaid:‘Yes!Yes!Yes!Theyneedtoreadalot!’Hethoughtpaststudentswerebetterastheycouldspeak,writeandreadfluently:theyweremoreoutspokenascomparedtonewgraduates.‘Studentsoftodaylackconfidenceinpublicspeaking…maybetheyareshy’.2.6.5 ThemediaindustryinformantlamentedthattheimpactofeducationreformsinPNGonstudentshasbeenterrible.‘Youexpectuniversitygraduatestobeabletowriteatlevelshigherthanhighschool.’The‘journalese’[poorEnglishandprofessionallanguage]taughtinschoolsisnowcarriedontowork.HeassertedthatstudentswhoprogressedthroughthePNGpubliceducationsystemwerenotarticulate,andunabletothinkthroughandmakelogicalorcogentarguments.‘Thisneedstobefixedattheprimaryschoollevel,asthestudents’argumentsareshallow’.Nevertheless,headmittedthatitwasnotthefaultofuniversities,as‘theygetstudentsthatareill-prepared’.2.6.6 AsWPU’sprogramsareindevelopment,theseemphaticviewssuggestthatliteracyandnumeracyremainpivotalinenhancingstudentlearninganddeficienciesinthesebasicshavetobeconsistentlyaddressedatalllevelsoflearningwithappropriatestrategies.2.7 InternetandICTliteracies2.7.1 Justasconcernswiththetraditionalbasicfoundationalskillsofliteracyandnumeracyremain,newliteraciesareemergingandareequallyimportantforeffectiveperformanceinthe21stcenturyworkplace.AgraduateisbetterworkpreparediftheyareInternetandICTcompetent.Moreover,theICTspaceanticipateshugejobgrowthinternationally(Hughes&Miller,2017).AllparticipantsacrossthedifferentorganisationalsettingscitedtheneedforgraduatestobeInternetandICTliterateastheworkplaceenvironmenttransitionstoICTenabledworkperformance.Abankingandfinancesectorinformantsaid:‘CentralBankingnowinvolvestheuseoftechnologymorethanever’.Themediaparticipantsseea‘…convergenceofnewtechnologies’whichmeansgraduatesneedtoentertheworkforceICTcompetent.AchurchworkerlistedthefollowingICTjobsandcompetenciesthathisworkplacewouldneed:repairandmaintenanceonhardware,upgradingsoftwareandnetworkingmaintenanceandcomputerliterateinusingsoftwaresuchasMicrosoftOfficeproducts.
![Page 37: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
37
2.8 ProactiveLeadership2.8.1 Aslistedunderworkplaceknowledge,attitudeandbehaviours,proactiveleadershipisanattributethatfavourablypositionsthegraduateintheworkforce.Manyparticipantssaidemployersarelookingforgraduateswhodemonstrateinitiativeandachurchinformantsaidofnurses,forexample,thattheyshouldnot‘…waitforinstructions,butusetheirinitiativetofullyutilizetheirknowledgeintheirprofessionalnursingpractice.’Heillustratedthisbysayingthatshowinginitiativeistaughtinthehealthpromotionsubjectinnursingcolleges:
…thegraduatesarefullyawareofit,sowhatthenewgraduatesdoinsteadofprovidingtreatment/focusingoncuringtheycanalsomobilizethevillagepeopleanddohealthpromotion,aimingatpreventingthediseasesfromaffectingpeopleinthefirstplace.Smallinitiativeslike,tellingthepeopletobuildcleanlatrines,puttinganimalswithinfences,healthyhintsonpersonalhygieneandsoon.
2.8.2 Or,asthisinformantfromthemediaindustryobserved,‘…theirwillingnesstolearnwasnotthere.Onecametoworkunpreparedwaitingforustogiveherideastopursue,everymorningwasablank.Notsurprisingly,shequit’.2.9 Graduatestrengthsandweaknesses2.9.1 Obviously,graduatesdonotpresentthemselvescompletelyill-preparedfortheworksetting.Theybringvaryingskillssetssubjecttoinstitutionaldifferencesinfocusandquality,andotherfactorsbeyondHEIs’control.Oneparticipantfromachurchcommunityhealthorganisationfoundtheirgraduatestobecompetent,goodteamplayers,committed,hardworkingandpunctual.2.9.2 Evenwiththepositives,manyinformantshaveobservedweaknessesingraduateswhichimpingeontheirabilitytoperformeffectivelyonthejob.OneprovincialHRadvisorexpressedtheviewthatgraduatesfromthePNGInstitutionswerenotpreparedforwork.Hefoundtheirexpectationsonsalaryandwage‘toohigh’lamentingthat‘moneyseemstobethedrivingforceandnotcareerandpersonaldevelopment’.Poorcommunicationskillsaside,hewentontosay:‘Iamlookingforgraduateswhowillbehonest,transparent,whohaveapositiveattitudetothejob,arerespectable,owningthejob,andthosewhohavethehearttodevelopthisNATION.’Further,hewantedtoseeifgraduatescouldworkandliveintheruralcommunities.Thegraduates’preparednesstoserveinruralcommunitieswasalsoraisedbyaparticipantintheNGOfocusgroupaswellastherespondentfromthechurchhealthservice.Otherinformantslistedthefollowingdeficits:alackofleadershipskillsandself-esteem;theinabilitytowriteaneye-catchingCVand/orresume;havingstudiedgeneralitiesandnotbeingspecificallyinlinetothejobrequirementsintheworkplaceenvironment.‘Coursesofferedintheinstitutionsmustbespecificforeachspecificjobrequirementsoutthereintheworkplaceenvironment,’saidonerespondentfromthebankingsector.
![Page 38: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
38
2.9.3 Employabilityofgraduates:EmergingnewjobspacesThedatasetfromthisgroupofrespondentsrevealjobmarketneedsforsystemsdesigners;computerscientists;mathematicians;computerprogrammersandstart-upentrepreneurs.Aninformantfromtheminingsectorlistedemergingengineeringjobsintheareaofenvironmentalengineering;geotechnicalengineeringandinstrumentandcontrolprocessengineering.TheICTinformantlistedaneedforinternetandcybersecurityprofessionals,informationsecurityexperts,cloudbusinessintegrationexperts,dataminingandbigdataanddataanalyticsexperts,andcloudinfrastructureprofessionals(cfHughes&Miller,2017).
![Page 39: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
39
Section2:PapuaNewGuinea’slabourmarket:whatdoestherecentliteraturetellus? 1.0 GlobalisationandtheestablishmentofWPU
1.1 ThefoundingofWesternPacificUniversityillustratesclearlytherelationshipbetweeneducationandthefutureprosperityofPapuaNewGuinea.GlobalisationinthePacificregiondemandsthatknowledgebeappliedinnovatively,sinceitimpelsbotheconomicandsocialdevelopment.Already,moderntechnologies,coupledwithadvancedknowledge,areimpactingontheneedsofthelabourmarketthroughthenatureofworkitselfandthewayinwhichjobsarebeingshapedandevolved.AsPapuaNewGuineanuniversitiesbegintorespondtotheneedsofaknowledgebasedeconomy,futuregraduateswillhelpdeterminetheextenttowhichtheircountryisabletoassumeitsplaceontheglobalstage.Theextractiveindustriesalonecannotforeversustainthecountry;onthecontrary,itmightnowbearguedthatknowledgeisnowtheforemostresourceofthefuture.WPUisattheleadingedgeofinstitutionsinPapuaNewGuineathatstrivetocreate,disseminateandapplyknowledgetoprovidethecapacityfortechnological,professionalandinstitutionaldevelopment.1.2 AkeycharacteristicofWPUthereforeisitsdeterminationtomoveawayfromwhatremainsofthelegacycurriculumofthe20thCenturydeliveredthroughtraditionalformsofuniversityteachingandtofocusonthenatureoflearningthatwillprepareitsstudentsforwork,citizenshipandlifeinthe21stcentury.Inthisnewworld,asstudentsareexposedtoglobalisation,ground-breakingtechnologies,afluctuatingeconomyandpoliticalandsocialchallenges,howtheyacquirethenecessaryskillsandknowledgetoestablishthemselvesintheirchosenfieldisofimmenseimportance.2.0 21stcenturylearningatHEIs2.1 Equally,itisvitaltoidentifythegenericskillsandknowledgeassociatedwith21stcenturylearning.Wagner’s(2010)widelycitedHarvardstudy,afterin-depthresearchwitheducationandbusinessleaders,arguedthatstudentsneededsevensurvivalskillsintoday’ssocietyandworldofwork:• Criticalthinkingandproblemsolving
• Collaborationandleadership
• Agilityandadaptability
• Initiativeandentrepreneurialism
• Effectiveoralandwrittencommunication
![Page 40: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
40
• Accessingandanalysinginformation
• Curiosityandimagination.
2.2 Across-culturalassemblageofthiskindtypifiestheearlythinkingon21stcenturyskills.Conley(2007),forexample,accentuatedtheneedforthelearnertoacquire‘habitsofmind’amongstwhichanalysis,interpretation,precisionandaccuracy,problem-solving,andreasoningscaffoldthinkingandreflection.Trilling&Fadel(2009)meanwhileclaimthatinquiry,designandcollaborativelearning,combinedwithdirectinstruction,arethefoundationsofacurriculumthatwillbuildknowledge,creativityand21stCenturyskills.Elsewhere,theAsiaPacificEconomicCooperationgroup,ofwhichPNGisanactivemember,(APEC,2008)focusedtheirattentiononthedevelopmentof21stcenturycompetenciesamongstyouthas‘apressinginternationalconcern’,concludingthatfourcompetenciesshouldbewovenintoeducationalsystems:lifelonglearning;problemsolving;self-managementandteamwork.Ananiaduo&Claro’s(2009)summaryneatlyfocusesthediscussion:
Theseskillsandcompetenciesareoftenreferredtoas21stcenturyskillsandcompetencies,toindicatethattheyaremorerelatedtotheneedsoftheemergingmodelsofeconomicandsocialdevelopmentthanwiththoseofthepastcentury,whichweresuitedtoanindustrialmodeofproduction.(AnaniaduoandClaro,2009:5)
2.3 WiththelabourmarketinPNGinmind,andtheneedfortertiaryeducationtorespondtotheemergingmodelsofdevelopmentalludedtoabove,itisimportanttoacknowledgeacritiqueof21stcenturyskillsandcompetenceswhere,attheexpenseofholisticdevelopment,theprincipalgoalofsuchanapproachismerelytoprepareworkersforwhatareoftendescribedasknowledge-intensiveeconomies.Takenastagefurther,thiscritiquealsounderlinesaviewthatthemajorityofyoungpersonsinthedevelopingworld,graduatesincluded,willnotbeemployedinaknowledge-intensiveeconomy.
2.4 Cognisantoftheabove,WPUhowever,inthefoundationyearandbeyond,willfocusonwhatareknownastransversalcompetences(UNESCO,2015a),arefinementof21stcenturyskills.AswillbefurtherelaboratedinrelationtotheUniversity’sGraduateQualities,primarilythisentails:
• Knowinghowtoapplyacquiredknowledgeandbeingabletosolveproblemsinnewsurroundingsorlittleknown,multidisciplinary,broadercontextsrelatedtotheirstudyarea.
• Beingabletointegrateknowledgeanddealingwiththecomplexityofformulatingopinionsonthebasisofinformationthat,whilstitmaybeincompleteorlimited,includesreflectionsaboutsocialandethicalresponsibilitieslinkedtotheapplicationoftheirknowledgeandopinions.
![Page 41: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
41
• Knowinghowtocommunicatetheirconclusionsandknowledgetospecialisedandnon-specialisedaudiencesinaclearandunambiguousmanner
• Possessingthelearningskillsthatenablethemtocontinuestudyinginawaythatwillbelargelyself-directedandautonomous.
2.5 Ribeiro,Severo&Ferreira’s(2016)studyofmedicaleducationsurveyed611undergraduates’self-perceptionsoftheexecutionoftransversalskillsovertheirmedicalcourse.Theirin-depthresearchidentifiestheseskillsasinformationtechnology;timemanagement;literaturesearching;improvinglearning;oralcommunication;dataanalysis;writingcommunication;visualcommunication;Englishproficiency;solvingproblemsandteamwork.Thecoursestructure,togetherwithitsemphasisontransversalskills,wasregardedpositivelybythestudents,particularlythosewhosestudiesinvolvedresearch.
2.6 Care&Luo’s(2016)workacrosstheAsia-Pacificregionamplifiesanunderstandingofexactlywhattransversalskillsmightmeaninthebroadereducationalcontext.Astheycontend,anacceptanceoftransversalskills,itselfanevolvingconcept,ineducationsystemsdemandsareappraisalofhowwebelievelearningandteachinghasalsomovedoninthenewmillennium.Theirgraphicorganiser,shownbelow,providesausefulpointofdeparturefordiscussion.
Figure1:TransversalSkills(SourcedfromCare&Luo,2016:vi)
![Page 42: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
42
2.7 Thetransversalskillsdepictedabove,asmightbeexpected,varyfromoneAsia-Pacificcountrytoanother(UNESCO,2013);however,thefivemainelementsofthejigsawandtheirdescriptorsresonatewiththefindingsofoursurvey.Manyofthedescriptorsfallintothecategoryof‘softskills’aboutwhichseveralKeyInformantsmademention.2.8 Whatthenare‘softskills’andhowaretheyrelevanttothePNGcontext,wheretheinformallabourmarketremainstheemploymentdestinationforthemajorityofyoungpeople,includinggraduates?Disparitiesbetweenthelabourmarketsindevelopinganddevelopedcountriesareunambiguouslydescribedintheeconomicliterature.Brewer(2013:7),forexample,capturesthesituationintheseterms:‘Developingeconomieshaveanabundanceoflabour,ascarcityofcapitalandastarkdualitybetweentheshrinkingbutstilldominanttraditionaleconomiesandthe‘modern’economies(stronglymanifestedacrossruralandurbangeographies).’AnextensiveliteraturereviewcarriedoutbyLippmanetal(2015)forChildTrendsthattookintoaccountemployerperspectivesinthedevelopedanddevelopingworld,includingWestPapuaandSolomonIslands,identifiedasetoffivekeysoftskillsthatcontributetosuccessintheworkforce.
2.9 Thesekeyskills,itisargued,areinterrelatedandsubsumedwithineachtherearenumeroussub-skillsrelatedtospecificworkforceoutcomes,forexampleemployment,performance,incomeandentrepreneurialsuccess.Fivesub-skillsreceiveparticular
Higherorderthinkingskills,includingproblemsolving,criticalthinking
anddecisionmaking
Communicationskills
Socialskills
Self-control Positiveself-concept
Figure2.SoftSkills(SourcedfromLippmanetal,2015)
![Page 43: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
43
attentionintheliterature:hard-workanddependability;self-motivation;teamwork;responsibilityandpositiveattitude.
2.10 Interestingly,theemployabilityskillsframeworkfromtheCTE(CenterforTechnicalandAdultEducation,"EmployabilitySkillsFramework",2017),shownbelow,encapsulatesiniterativeformmuchofwhatLippmanetal(2015)havetosayabouttheglobalviewfromemployersofdesirablequalitiesandattributesintheirworkforce.CTEidentifythreeover-archingsetsofskills:AppliedKnowledge;EffectiveRelationshipsandWorkplaceSkills,linkedtowhichareninesub-skillsagainthatcloselyparallelmanyofthetransversalcompetenciesemanatingfromresearchintheAsia-Pacificregion(UNESCO,2013).
Figure3:EmployabilitySkills(SourcedfromCTE,2017)
3.0SkillsshortagesinthePNGlabourmarket
3.1 HowmightthediscourseonskillsaffectthePNGcontext?Deloitte&UNDP’s(2017)thoughtleadershippaperonthistopicisofconsiderableinteresttoWPUanditsfuture.Strikingapositivenote,thepaperarguesthatshorttermeconomicgrowthhasbeenmadepossiblebyinvestmentintheextractiveindustries;theimportanceofhostingtheAPECsummitin2018andcontinuedinvestmentinandaroundthecapital,PortMoresby.Yet,despitethisenablingenvironment,itremainsthecasethatroughly500,000peopleareemployedintheformalsectorascomparedtoaround2.5millionintheinformalsector.
![Page 44: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
44
Theauthorsmakethepointthatthetransferofonlyasmallpercentageoftheseworkerstotheformalsectorwouldeffectgainsinrevenuefromtaxationandproductivity.Notonlythat,butcapacitybuildingonagrandscalewill,itisargued,allowPapuaNewGuineatopunchaboveitsweightinthedevelopinglabourmarketsintheAsiaPacificregion.Itisindeedthisemphasisonhumancapacitydevelopmentthatconnectsthethinkingofthepaperwiththethrustofthissurvey.TheDeloitte/UNDPresearchmakesclearthatskillsshortagesandhumanfactorsaccountforupto83%and71%ofthedifficultiesrespectivelythatbusinessesfaceinrecruitmentandemployment.Theskillsshortageisfeltacutelythroughoutthecountry,butmoresoawayfromPortMoresby.Thehumanfactorsalludedtointhereport,forexamplepoorproductivityandattendancelinkedtoemployabilitygivestrongsupporttotheviewthatthetalentpoolintheformalsectorislimitedbythelackoftransversalorsoftskills.Again,asWPUisformulatingitsacademicprograms,thethoughtpaper’soccupationalanalysislinkedtoskillsgapsisofrelevancesinceitcategorisestheindexofdifficultyemployersfaceinrecruitmentwithmanagement,professionalservicesandhospitality,wholesaleandretailmostproblematic.ManagementandprofessionalservicesrolesinPNGinvariablyrequirethepossessionofauniversitydegreeforthoseemployedasaccountants,lawyersandITprofessionals.
3.2 Toofewgraduatesgaintheskillstheyneedtofindwork.Nowhereisthischallengemoreevidentthaninthetransitiontotheformalsectorofthelabourmarket.Employersacrosstheregioncomplainofalackofbasic,technicalandtransferableskills.Giventhepressuresforexpansionoutlinedabove,thesteadyabsorptionofgraduatesintothelabourmarketwillbeasignificantundertaking.
3.3 Thesurveyrevealedthatthereiswidespreadconcernabouttheworkreadinessofgraduates.Whileemployersaregenerallysatisfiedwiththedisciplinaryknowledgeofstudents,theyperceivesignificantgapsintheirITskills,personalqualities,forexamplereliability,andtransferableskillsliketeamworkingandproblemsolving.Ourresearchbroughttolightasignificant‘skillsmismatch’betweenemployerrequirementsandgraduates’displayofskillsintheworkplace,particularlyinrelationtocommunication,decision-makingandcriticalthinking.
3.4 ThelackofrobustandreliabledataatalllevelsinGovernmentdepartmentsdealingwiththelabourmarketinPNGiswidelyreportedintheliterature.Markedlyabsentisaviewonthetransitionfromuniversitytotheworkplaceandcausallinksbetweenthedisciplinesstudiedandgraduateemploymentprospects.Thenotionof‘unemployment’iscontextspecificinPNG,andcareisneededininterpretingthelimitedstatisticsatourdisposal.Whileinsomecasesemployersareunabletorecruitbecauseofalackofsuitableapplicants,therearenumerouscausesofunemployment,embracingintricatemacro-economicquestions.WithinPNG,therealextenttowhichgraduateunemploymentisduetomajorskillsgaps,ormerelytoapaucityofjobsremainsamajorresearchquestion.
![Page 45: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
45
3.5 GraduateattributesarepivotaltoPNGuniversities’programplanning,butmostassertionsabouttheirvalueareanecdotal.Beyondthecompletionoftheirdegreecourses,thereisanacutelackofevidenceabouttheknowledge,skillsandvaluesthatgraduateshaveactuallyacquiredandtakewiththem.Wehavereliedonsurveysofemployerperceptions–butthese,necessarily,arelackingindepthsincethereislittleopportunitytocompareacrosscontexts,andovertime.
3.6 AmuchstrongerevidencebaseisneededthereforeinrelationtothekindsofresponsesthatuniversitieslikeWPUshouldmaketothesechallenges.Withoutdoubt,employershavesignificantresponsibilitiesinthepreparationofgraduates;butuniversitiesneverthelesshavetheirowncriticalroleinensuringthatstudentsgaintheskillsrequiredbyemployers,takingmuchgreaternote,forexample,oftheeffectofdepartmentalorfacultyteachingofemployabilityskills.WPUiscommittedtosoundteachingandqualitylearninginitsdegreeprograms,togetherwiththeprovisionofoptimumconditionsforlearning.
3.7 Aswehavefound,employersincreasinglyvalueglobalperspectivesandanunderstandingofculturalandhumandiversity:thesequalitiescanbedevelopedthroughformsofengagementoncampusandbeyond.AsubtlerunderstandingofgraduateneedsisrequiredintherapidlychangingemploymentmarketsinPapuaNewGuineaandthePacificcountries.Aswehavearguedthroughout,transferableskillsandcriticalthinkingthatenablegraduatestoadaptandmakeapositiveimpactonachangingeconomyandsocietyareofcrucialimportancetocurriculumplanning.
3.8 PwC(2012),withafootprintinPNGforoverfiftyyears,bycontraststrikeamoreupbeatnoteintheirassessmentofemergingcountriesand,incallingforanexpansionofuniversityeducation,regardingthenewnationstatesasfactoriesoftalent.DispassionateobserversseePNGmovingupthevaluechaininhealthcare,IT,leisureandprofessionalservices.Growthofthiskindiscontingentupontheimprovementofeducationalsystems;theemployabilityofgraduatesandis,aboveall,aninvestmentintalentdevelopment.Inturn,itmayalsobearguedthatsuchaviewdependsonwiderenablingconditions,forexampletheexistenceofasupportiveinstitutionalgovernanceframeworkandconducivenationalpolicies.
3.9 Helpfully,Jones&McGavinprovideextensiverecentevidenceoftherangeofhardskillsindemandinPNGwiththecaveatthat‘…askilledemployeedoesnotnecessarilymeanuniversityortradeschoolqualifiedortradecollegegraduate’(2015:233).Headingthelistofskillsbeingsoughtafterin2014howeverwassales/clientservicefollowedbyspecialisedtechnicalstaffanddriver,thelatterskillillustratingtheheavyrelianceofbusiness,industryandthecommunityonroadtransportandpassengermotorvehicles(PMVs).Hardontheheelsofthetopthreeskillsweremechanicaltrades,electrician,finance,clerical,IT,plantandmachineryoperatorandbusinessmanagement.Atthefootofthislistareskillsconnectedwithelectricalandmechanicalengineering,agriculture,fisheries
![Page 46: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
46
andforestry,legalandcivilengineering.Tosomeextent,thisphenomenonmightbeexplainedbytheDeloitteUNDP(2016)conclusionthateconomicfactors,sometimesreferredtoastheenablingenvironmentare,byfar,themostlimitingfactorinemploymentgrowth.
4.0 SignpostingforWPU:graduateunderemploymentandunemployment
4.1 Jones&McGavinassertthataPapuaNewGuineanuniversitygraduatecanbynomeansberegardedasaskilledemployeeand,further,areoftheviewthatgovernmentfundedtertiaryinstitutionsarerarelyawardingdegreesonmerit,butrather‘onthepassageoftime’(p.389).Theyclaimalsothat‘themeaningofuniversityhasbeendiminished…theyshouldberebadgedastertiarycollegesorpolytechnics’(2015:389).Inafrankcritiqueoftheuniversitysectortheyclaimthatthequalityofgraduatesisindeclineandgenerallybelowinternationalstandards.
4.2 OfinteresttothisstudyisJones&McGavin’s(2015)anecdotalcontentionthattheUniversityofPapuaNewGuinea(UNPG)andtheUniversityofTechnologyinLae,forexample,areworkingtoobsoleteThirdWorldagendasandthatitmakessensetothinkintermsofre-inventingtertiaryeducation,withselecteduniversities,inpartnershipwiththeinnovativeUniversityofQueenslandtoconfronttheHRdeficitsofPNG.Toacertainextent,theybelievealsothatHRisconstrainedbyafailuretodelivertheessentialservicesofthemarketstate.Formidablyandforthrightly,theygoontorecommendthebuying-inofeducationalservicessince,forthem:‘Thereisnopointrollingmoreandmore“graduates”into“universities”wheretheygainnotangibleincreaseinhumancapital.Andhavelittleprospectofenteringformalwageemployment’(ibid:369)
4.3 Jones&McGavin(2015),ifnothingelse,pointupthecomplexitiesofgatheringreliabledataandtheneedtoaccepttheuniquecontextofthecountry’slabourmarket.TheiroutlookontertiaryeducationpromptsthosewhoaredevelopingthecurriculumatWPUtoguardagainstwhatisknowninthedevelopmentliteratureasisomorphicmimicry.Isomorphicmimicrybecomesproblematicwhenthepursuitofapredefinedsolutionthathasbeeneffectiveinstructuringmoderninstitutionsinadevelopedcontextundermineseffortstoestablishfreshapproachestoaddresstheparticulardifficultiesofbuildinginstitutionsinthedevelopingworld.Pritchett,WoolcockandAndrewsoftheWorldInstituteforDevelopmentEconomicsResearchattheUnitedNationsUniversity(2012:1-2)takeasternerview,contendingthatisomorphicmimicryisatworkwhenorganisationsinthedevelopingworldadopt‘thecamouflageoforganizationalformsthataredeemedsuccessfulelsewheretohidetheiractualdysfunction’.
4.4 WPU’sunswervingcommitmenttoWorkIntegratedLearningforallundergraduatesisasignificantundertaking,giventhenatureofthelabourmarketinPapuaNewGuinea,alliedtomajorconcernsaboutthepoorqualityofeducation(paceJones&McGiven,2015)andthelackofavailablefundingforuniversities.WPU,atthisveryearlystage,positions
![Page 47: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
47
itselfasateachinguniversitywherecurriculumdevelopmentisongoingtorevolutioniseundergraduateandgraduatestudiesandinternshipcanbebothadriverforemploymentandeconomicdevelopment.Onceestablished,WPUhasthechoiceofexpandingeithertobecomearesearchorentrepreneurialuniversity,withthelatteroptionfirmlyfocusedonbusinessincubationandtheteachingofenterpriseeducation.Aboveall,WPUmustseektodistanceitselffromtheinertiaandlackofambitionthathandicapsomeofitssisteruniversitiesinPNG.
4.5 Otherauthors(Brundenius,Lundvall&Sutz,2009)addafurthercategory,thedevelopmentaluniversity,tothisparadigmtodescribecollaborationandinteractionwithabroadrangeofexternalpartners,includingbusiness,shunningprofitinfavourofmakingacontributiontosocialandeconomicdevelopmentatthelocalandnationallevel.WPU’smissionandvisionencompassesinnovationandlearningofakindthatwouldnurturetheinformalsectorofthelabourmarket,themainsourceofincomeforthemajorityofthepopulation.ShouldWPUtakeonthemantleofadevelopmentaluniversity,however,theoverallaimwouldbetomovethesebusinessesontowardsamoreformal,inclusiveandnovelsetofworkingpracticesthatboostedeconomicgrowthanddevelopment.
4.6 Forthemostpart,aswehaveseenthroughoutthecourseofthisstudy,withinPapuaNewGuinea,businessesseetheirlinkswithuniversitiesasaconduitforskilledgraduates.Thelackofskilledlabourisamajorhindrancetothecompetitivenessandinnovativecapacityofbusinessandindustry.WPUwoulddowelltoestablishaconsultativeprocessthroughwhichtheexperienceofsuccessfulbusinessmanagersistakenintoaccountincurriculumdevelopmentsothatitsprogramsareregularlyinformedbytheneedsofthelabourmarket,businessandindustry.DialoguewiththesestakeholdersshouldalsoprovideclarityonthediversityofprovisionrequiredacrosstheUniversity,forexampleon-campus,distance,onlineorshort-coursestructures.
4.7 Withdiversityofprovisioninmind,theliterature(OECD,2014a&b)alsopointsuptheneedtoensurethatallstaffinhighereducationinstitutionsareequippedwiththeskillstousedigitaltechnologiesinlearningandteaching,togetherwiththeabilitytointegratethemintotheirprogramandcoursedelivery.NewmodesoflearningandteachingatWPUwillthereforerequirefromallacademicstaffaverydifferentskill-setfromthemoreconventionalapproachesifthereistobequalitylearningforundergraduates.Qualityteachingwillnecessitateachangeinroleforuniversityteachersfrombeingbeaconsofknowledgeandexpertiseintheirsubjecttobecomingfacilitatorsandmentorsofcriticalthinking.HEIsmustalsobemindfuloftheirobligationtomirrorintheonlineenvironmentthesofterskillsthatareacquiredduringon-campuslearningexperiences.Networkingandinteractingwithpeersisavitalelementofthelearningexperience,andonlineplatformswherethiscansafelyandproductivelyoccur,forexampleGooglehangouts,shouldbecomeafundamentallearningspaceforonlinestudents.
![Page 48: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/48.jpg)
48
4.8 Ofrelevancetothediscussionofthelabourmarketisthecertification,creditandrecognitionofdegreesanddiplomasgainedatPapuaNewGuineanUniversities.WPU’saspirationisthatitsawardswillallowitsgraduatesnotonlytogainemploymentintheirowncountrybutalsointhewiderPacificregion,anintentionworthyofmeritandexamination.GroupedalongsideVanuatuandSolomonIslands,PNGisclassifiedasalowmobilitycountrywith0.2%ofitspopulationasemigrantswhich,becauseofthelimitationsofdata,currentlyrefersonlytoAustraliaasacountryofdestination(Curtain,Dornan,Doyle&Howes,2016).PuttingtoonesideNewZealand’sRecognisedSeasonalEmployer(RSE)schemeandAustralia’sseasonalworkerprogram(SWP)andindeeditsTemporaryGraduatevisa(Subclass485),themainimpedimenttolabourmobilityfromwithinPacificislandscountriesinthesameclassificationasPNGistheperceived‘loweducationlevelsoftheirpopulations’(Curtain,Dornan,Doyle&Howes,2017:viii).
4.9 UNESCOhasbeenatworksince2001indrawingAsia-PacificcountriestogethertoestablishapanPacificRegisterofQualificationsandStandard(PRQS).In2009anAccreditationandStandardsUnit,fundedforfiveyearsbyAustralianAid,wasinstitutedtofacilitatetheproject.AtthispointintimewehaveinplaceaPRQSdatabaseandthePacificIslandsQualityAssuranceFramework(PIQAF).PNG’sownNationalQualificationsFramework(PNGNQF)isreferencedagainstthePQIAF.TheerstwhileOfficeofHigherEducation,nowtheDepartmentforHigherEducation,Research,ScienceandTechnology(DHERST)remainstheleadonthesedevelopments.Thedatabasecoversallskills,tradeandacademicqualificationsuptoandincludingdoctoratelevel.Politicalwillhoweverisstillsoughttobringthisprojecttofruition,asevidencedbytheeffortsoftheGlobalRecognitionConventioninMay2016thathasqualityhighereducationasapillarof‘sustainabledevelopmentofknowledgesocietiesandrelevantlabourmarkets’(UNESCO,2015b).
5.0 Asolutionfocusedapproach
5.1 Whatthenmightbeashort-termsolutionforWPU?IfwetakethehistoryoftheAustraliaPacificTechnicalCollege(APTC)asanexample,despiteby2013havinggraduatedinexcessof5,600studentssinceitsinceptionin2007(Swanton&Ong,2013),barely1.2%ofitsgraduateshavemigratedtoAustralia,largelybecauseoftheveryhighcoststhereofhavingtheirqualificationsrecognised.TheAPTCisundergoingarootandbranchreview,oneoftheaimsofwhichistoexamineitsoriginalcommitmenttolabourmobilitythat,lamentably,hasbeenunfulfilled.WereWPUtoestablisharelationshipwithAPTCitmightgainaccessforitsstudentstoanexistingqualificationrecognitionframeworkandconnectionswithemployersandthelabourmarketthatwouldalsobeofbenefittotheminPapuaNewGuinea.FiguresfromtheAustralianDepartmentofImmigration,forexample,indicatethat,whereasin2011therehadbeen816PapuaNewGuineancitizenswithtemporaryresidencevisaslivingandworkinginAustralia,asofasof2012,thisnumberhadfallento327,73%ofwhomhadbeensponsoredbytheextractiveindustries(Fileretal.,2012).Atthetimeofwritingtheissueoflow-skillimmigrationisbeinghotlydebatedinboth
![Page 49: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/49.jpg)
49
AustraliaandPapuaNewGuinea.Certainly,themessagesarewritlargeforWPUanditsinternationalambitions.
5.2 TheAsianDevelopmentBank’sanalysisofthePacific’semploymentchallenge(ADB,2014),predictedthattheworkingagepopulationinthefourteenPacificislandcountriesofinteresttothemwouldrisefrom6.6millionin2014to9.6millionin2030.Ofthat9.6million,oncurrenttrends,by20306.6millionmightbedeniedwagedemployment.Theirinfographic,inafewwordsdelineatestheenablingenvironment,‘Moreproductiveemploymentopportunitieswillbeneededtoraisetheinclusivenessofgrowth’(ADB,2014:1).WorkforcegrowthacrossthePacific,becauseofasteeplyrisingbirthrate,suggeststhatPNGwillhavefarmorepeopleinitsworkforcethananyotherPacificislandnation.TheADBconcludesthereforethatby2030PNGwillsupplythemajorityofnewworkersintheregion.
5.3 ThereexistsasuperabundanceofgreyliteratureonthelabourmarketinPapuaNewGuinea,butamongstthemostwellresearchedistheworkofVoigt-Graf(2016),attachedtotheNationalResearchInstitute,whooffersameticulousanalysisofthecurrentstateofplayinthePacificislandslabourmarketthatinterpretsPNG’sstance,bycontrast,asthelargestlabourimportingcountryamongstthePacificislandcountriesandwhysofewPacificislandersworkinthecountry.Voigt-Graf’sfindingsareofrelevancetothisstudy.CitingfiguresfromDHERST’s(2015)NationalandTechnicalHigherEducationPlan,shepointsoutthattwo-thirdsofthepopulationintheformallabourmarketwerenoteducatedbeyondGrade8.Inpurenumericalterms,therecentexpansionintheformallabourmarketcouldaccommodatetherisingnumberofgraduatesyearonyear.Discussionswithtrainingprovidersandrecruitmentagenciescorrelatecloselywiththeresultsofourownsmall-scalesurvey:‘…atpresent,thequantityandqualityofhighereducationgraduates,particularlyintechnicalfields,donotfilltheneedsoftheprivatesectorinPNG.Consequently,businessesfillsomeoftheirskilledpositionswithnon-citizenworkers’(Voigt-Graf,2016).
5.4 Attheformallabourmarketlevel,Pacificislanderswererecruitedtomorethan200occupations.ThetablebelowcompiledbyVoigt-Graf(2016)indicatesthetenmostimportantareasofrecruitmentinvolvingPacificislanders.Noticeably,therearenoreferencestotradeortechnicalskills,areflectionofthepoorqualityoftheTVETsectorinthePacificislandcountries.
Occupation NumberofPacificIslanders
%ofPacificIslanders
NumberofFijians
%ofFijians
SalesandMarketingManager 36 7.0 36 8.7
TechniciansandTradeCoordinators 27 5.3 26 6.3
![Page 50: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/50.jpg)
50
Minister,FatherandPastor 26 5.1 10 2.4
AeroplanePilot 25 4.9 22 5.3
OperationsManager 24 4.7 24 5.8
CorporateServicesManager 23 4.5 21 5.1
Ship’sEngineer 21 4.1 19 4.6
GeneralManager 17 3.3 16 3.9
SecurityManager 17 3.3 17 4.1
CEOorManagingDirector 13 2.5 13 3.1
Table4:ToptenareasofrecruitmentofPacificIslanders(Voigt-Graf,2016:8.SourcedfromDLIR,activeworkpermitdata,May2015)
5.5 ThesoberingrealityforallnationalgraduatesisthatPNG’sownformallabourmarketaffordslivelihoodstolessthan12%oftheworkingagepopulation,whilsttheinformalsectorengagesthemajorityofthoseremainingintheworkingagegroupinforestry,fishingandsemi-subsistenceagriculture.Forecasterspredictthat,evenwithasteadygrowthinjobcreation,thebulkofthepopulationwillwaitfordecadestogainaccesstotheformallabourmarketwithpoverty,poorsocialwelfareandinadequatehealthcaretheirconstantcompanions.Economicgrowthiscontingentupononanenablingenvironmentandinfrastructurewheremuchstrongerinstitutionscannotonlyraisethelivingstandardsofthosedependentonaninformallivelihoodbutalsoprovidegreateraccesstomarketsand,insodoing,permitthemtocontributetothecountry’sdevelopment.
5.6 AlimitedamountofrecentdataexistsonthedestinationsofPNGstudentsupongraduation.Threesmallscalestudiesareofinterest.Cornish(2016),surveyingtheemploymentpreferencesofhisgraduatingeconomicsclassatUPNG,agedbetween23-25,reportsthat50%regardedthepublicsector,includingnationalgovernment,astheirfirstchoice,with38%seeingself-employmentasthebestwayforward.Attheotherendofthescale,employmentwithintheNGOsectorwasleastpreferred,withworkinthepublicsectoratLocalLevelGovernment(LLG)levelhardonitsheels.Unsurprisingly,whentheseeconomicsstudentswerepressedontheiremployerofchoice,theBankofPapuaNewGuineawasnamedbytwo-thirdsofthem,withtheDepartmentofTreasuryandtheDepartmentofNationalPlanninginsecondandthirdplace.
![Page 51: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/51.jpg)
51
Figure4:EmploymentPreferencesofUNPNGEconomicsGraduates(SourcedfromCornish2016:9)
5.7 ActualemploymenttooktwoofthegraduatestotheDepartmentofForeignAffairsandoneeachtoPwC;BSP;ElaMotors;OilSearchandMadangDepartmentofProvincialPlanning.Sixofthisnumberwererecruitedthroughgraduatedevelopmentprograms.Somegraduatesreportedthattheirgenerallackofawarenessandreadinessabouthowtomakesuccessfuljobapplicationswereofconcerntothem.
5.8 Amoredetailedsmall-scaletracerstudy(Namunetal.,2016)ofthirtyDivineWordUniversity(DWU)HealthManagementgraduatesrevealsthatthevastmajority,46.7%,havebeenemployedbytheGovernment,whilst20%arewithChurchandFaithbasedorganisations.Thisstudyalsosoughttoestablishtowhatextenttheirdegreeprogramhadpreparedthemfortheirchosencareer.Interestingly,therespondentscitedtheirpreparationforleadershipandmanagement,togetherwithprojectplanninganddesignandfinancialmanagementskillsashavingaddedtotheirpersonalskillsdevelopment.IncommonwiththeUNPGgraduatesinCornish’s(2016)paper,asignificantnumber,26%,indicatedtheirwishtopursuefurtherstudies.
5.9 Athird,largelystatistical,studybyDavid&Kaita(2015),oftheBankofPapuaNewGuinea,examined‘NeedsTheoryandEmploymentPerformance’inagroupof57graduatesdrawnfromfourPNGuniversities.Herethefocuswasmotivation,worksatisfactionandperformanceand,tosomeextent,thestudyilluminatesthediscussiononorganisationalcultureanditsinteractionwiththevaluesandcultureoftheindividualgraduate.Ourownworkyieldednumerousexamplesofemployerdissatisfactionwithsomegraduates’workethicandattitude,tosaynothingoftheculturaloutlooksthattheybringtotheirjob,forexampleadegreeofpassivityandthereluctancetochallengethestatusquo.Theauthorsherehoweverconcludethatitisthejobofmanagementtomakeeffortstounderstandthe
![Page 52: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/52.jpg)
52
needsoftheirgraduatestaffthroughgroundedtheoriesoftheirown.Theyarriveatthisassumptionthroughstatisticalmethodsthatdemandmuchmorerobustinterrogationtoachieveanykindofvalidity.
6.0 Micro,SmallandMediumSizedEnterprises
6.1 WorldBank("SmallandMediumEnterprises(SMEs)Finance",2017)figuresindicatethatupto45%ofemploymentinemergingcountriesislocatedinformalMSMEsthatprovide33%ofGrossDomesticProduct(GDP).InformalMSMEsaddsubstantiallytothesefigures.ThesamesourcesuggeststhatinemergingmarketsfouroutoffivenewjobscomeaboutasaresultofMSMEactivity.MSMEsacrossthedevelopingworldhoweverarehamperedbylackofaccesstoformalcreditfacilities.Yet,GoPNGhaslongrecognisedtheimportanceofMSMEs.Take,forexample,thecommitmentintheDevelopmentStrategicPlantoafour-foldincreaseinthenumberofMSMEsby2030(GoPNG,2010:100;2015).ThemostrecentMSMEpolicydocument(GoPNG,2016)setsoutthegovernment’sambitions:500,000MSMEsby2030;employmenttogrowto2million;unemploymentreducedfrom84%to49%;citizencontroloftheformaleconomytorisefromthecurrent10%to70%andtogrowtheMSMEcontributiontoGDPfrom10%to50%.Significantly,thesemeasures,itishoped,willreducethenumberofthepopulationlivingbelowthepovertylinefrom40%,asitisnow,to30%bytheendofthesameperiod.
6.2 PredatingthereleaseofGoPNG’s(2016)quasiprotectionistSMEpolicywithanextensiveReservesActivityListfor100%PNGownership,TebbuttResearch(2014)offeredanestimateof28,323MSMEsinthecountry’sformalsector.Themajorityofthesebusinesseswerelocatedintheretailtrade;hospitalityandtourism;motorvehiclerelated,includingretail;transportationandconstruction.ThisstudyalsoestimatedthatformalsectorMSMEsprovidepaidemploymentfor434,634staffand33,868unpaidstaff.WPUwoulddowelltotakenoteofthepotentialofMSMEstoplaceitsgraduatesintheforefrontofthissector.Innovativethinkingrelatedtothesurveyofthegraduatelabourmarketsuggeststhatleadership,financialexpertise,projectmanagementandproposalwriting,allinrelationtodevelopmentstudies,wouldrepresentcriticalareasforconsiderationinthedegreeprograms.
![Page 53: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/53.jpg)
53
Section3: Conclusion1.0 Introduction1.1 Asthefindingsofthissurveyaredrawntogether,itisimportanttoacknowledgethatitsmajorlimitationhasbeenthepaucityofcurrentandreliabledatauponwhichtobasefirmconclusionsaboutthestateofthelabourmarketinPapuaNewGuineainrespectofgraduateemploymentprospects.ThisisparticularlythecaseasweconsiderhowWPUwillworkwithintheglobaldevelopmentdiscourse,sothatthemeaningsandpurposesofdevelopinghumancapitaltobolsterthenationstateandempowerallitspeoplecanbeunderstood.Thereisthereforetheevidentdangerofgivingcredenceto,andaccepting,logicalfallaciesofastatisticalnature‘cumhocergopropterhoc’,wherecorrelationimpliescausation.Notwithstandingthiscaveat,itisgoodtonotetheestablishmentinSeptember2017ofthePNGData4DevelopmentGrouphostedatpngdata4development.org.pg/1.2 Fundamentalthemesemergingfromstakeholderinterviewsandtheliterature,particularlyinrelationtograduateemploymentprospectsinthePNGLabourMarket,andtheformulationofdegreeprogramsatWPU,areelucidatedbelow.ManyspokepassionatelyofPapuaNewGuinea,inconstitutionalterms,asadevelopingstateandofthefragileandchangingnatureoftheemploymentmarketinavulnerable,predominantlyagrarian,economy.Skilledemployment,itwaswiselyobservedonmanyoccasions,leadstoprosperityandsecurityforindividuals,whileunskilledemploymentoftenmeanstheopposite.Thefailuretoofferyoungpeopleappropriateopportunitiesinhighereducationtogaintheskills,knowledgeandbehavioursneededfortheworldofworkswiftlyeradicatestheirenthusiasm,potentialanddiminishesthelifechanceswhichtheirparents,universityteachersandadministratorshaveworkedsohardtoprovide.2.0 Findings2.1 Firstandforemost,themajorityofstakeholdersexpressedtheconcernthatgraduateslackthefluencyandcommandoforalEnglishthatunderpineffectivecommunicationskillsintheprofessionalandcommercialenvironment,wheretheexpectationisthatstandardsofspokenEnglishshouldbecommensuratelyhigh.2.2 Similarly,theacquisitionofsoft,ortransversal,skillsiswidelyregardedasanareaofmajorimportanceforallgraduatesinanticipationoftheiremploymentintheformalsector,whereclientfacingrelationshipsfrequentlydominateprofessionalactivity.2.3 NumerousstakeholdersreiteratedtheviewthatthedevelopmentofhumancapitalisfundamentaltothemissionofthosechargedwithleadingHEIs.Thisisbestdescribedbyconcludingthatthemostimportantoutputofhighereducationisnotsolelythecreationofgraduatesinpossessionofaugmentedsubjectknowledge,butrathertheproductofwhattheycontributetowardstheadvancementoflocalcommunitiesandPNGsocietyasawhole.
![Page 54: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/54.jpg)
54
2.4 IntermsoftheenablingenvironmentinwhichHEisdelivered,stakeholdersfrequentlyobservedthatPNGisaresourcerichnation,wheremassiveinvestments,particularlyintheextractiveindustrieshaveunderpinnedandacceleratedratesofgrowthandinternationalrelations.Nevertheless,thisphenomenonhasgeneratedonlymodestdirectemploymentopportunitiesforgraduatesand,thusfar,hasmadeverylittleimpactonthelivesofthoselivinginabsoluteorrelativepoverty,andforwhomurbandriftprovidesatenuousescaperoute.Moreover,acriticalfactemergingfromthemostrecentliterature(Fox,Howes,Nema&Schröder,2017)isthattheabundanceofforeignexchangeinthemineralsandextractiveindustries,atthemacroeconomiclevel,hasunderminedthecompetitivenessofotheractivitiesmakingitdifficulttocreateproductivejobsinothersectors. 2.5 AthemeconstantlyrestatedinthisstudyhasbeentheaspirationofWPUtoinstituteground-breakingprogramsofworkintegratedlearning.Stakeholdersfamiliarwithexistingmodelsofthistypeofprovision,ingeneral,commentedfavourablyuponthisdevelopment.Manyputforwardtheviewthatsuchprogramsofworkmustnotonlybefulfilling,aspirational,clearlyexplainedandattractivetostudentsbutalsodesignedinclosecollaborationwithemployersintheformalandinformallabourmarket.Previousprogramsofthisnature,accordingtomanyrespondents,havenotdemandedenoughofundergraduates.Theclearrecommendationmustthereforebethat,ifWPUwishestoleadgoodpracticeinthisdomain,stepsmustbetakentoexamineworld-classexcellenceprovidedatthehighertechnicallevelinoutstandinguniversitiesand,fromthere,workbackwardstodefinetheworkintegratedlearningpracticesthatwillfreeitfromtheisomorphicmimicrycurrentlybesettinghighereducationinPNG.2.6 Pursuedinthismanner,WPUmaybeconfidentthatmanymorestudentswillgoontomeetthenationalstandardsrequiredbyPNG’semployers.Workrelatedlearning,sometimesdescribedasdegreeapprenticeships,islikelytobecomeanattractiveoptionensuringthereisasupplyofhigh-qualitygraduatesavailabletostrongandresponsiveemployerswiththerightleadershipandvision.IftheskillsgapistobeconfrontedbythedeliveryofWPU’sdegreeprogramsemployersmustplayaleadingroleintheirformulation.Employers,workingwithexpertuniversityeducators,needtosetthestandardsand,crucially,definetheskills,knowledgeandbehavioursrequiredforskilledemploymentintheirsectors.2.7 Correspondingly,therewasalsotheunequivocalviewfromstakeholdersthatmoreneedstobedonetosupportstudents,particularlythoseinthecountry’slessprestigiousinstitutions,wherethereareevidentdifficultieswithinfrastructure,thestaff-studentratioandthequalityoftaughtcourses.Severalstakeholdersunderlinedtheadvantagesanddisadvantagesbroughtbypersonalandfamilyconnections.Indeed,ofthefactorsregarded
![Page 55: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/55.jpg)
55
asdrawbackstoemployment,lackofnetworksandlackofconnectionswereamongstthemostsignificantacrossthesurveyedprovinces.2.8 TheoutcomesofthissurveyconcurwithDeloitte&UNDP’s(2017)findingsthatthePNGeconomyischaracterisedbyenduringpocketsofskillsdeficiency.Employersreporteddirectanddamagingimpactsofskillsgapsandhard-to-fillvacanciescausedbyskillsshortages.Themostcommontypesofskillsshortagesarticulatedbystakeholderswerehigh-leveltechnical,managerial,practicalorjobspecificskillsbestgainedinaworkplacesetting,illustratingthecriticalrolethatemployershavetoplayinovercomingskillsshortagesandbuildingthepipelineofskilledlabour.Skillsgapsweremostcommonlyreportedwhereemployeeswerenewinroleandreflectiveofhighlevelsoflabourturnover.2.9 Forhighereducationplanners,thisreinforcestherealitythatthedemandandsupplyofskillsisnotfullyaligned.Whilesomedegreeofmismatchinthelabourmarketiscommontomanydevelopingcountries,persistentpocketsofskillsdeficiencymayindicatestructuralproblemswithdegreeprogramsinPNG.Self-evidently,failuretoaddresstheseskillsshortagesislikelytohinderthenation’sfutureeconomiccompetitiveness.Additionally,inrelationtoprogramdevelopment,itisworthbearinginmindthatthefuturesthinkingoutlinedelsewhereinthissurvey,viztheFourthIndustrialRevolution,suggeststhattechnologyalonewillnotdrivegrowth,butwillneedtobesituatedalongsideorganisationalchangetoaugmenttechnologicalgains.WPUwill,therefore,needtoadjustovertimetomeettheemergingneedsofthelabourmarketanddeliverlearningthatcrossesdisciplines;focusonwhatemployersneed;optimisetheuseoftechnologyandmotivateandinspireyoungpeople,particularlyfemales,toconsiderSTEMcareers.ThissurveyunequivocallyconfirmsthatthegreatestmarketenablerinPapuaNewGuineawillbetechnologyevolution.2.10 Academicdevelopment,seenintheseterms,shouldbeinformedbyafocusonskillsofstrategicimportancetothenation.WPUmustcollaboratewithindustryandbusiness,bothincountryandacrossthePICs,tounderstandwhichdigitalskillsareofparticularstrategicimportancetotheregionandtoidentifyemergingtrends.Programplanningmusttakeintoaccountskillsshortagesinareasofstrategicimportance,includingcybersecurity,bigdata,theInternetofThings,apps,mobileande-commerce.2.11 Closelyalliedtothecurrentandfuturedigitalneedsofbusinessandindustryarethoseofthenation’sentrepreneurs.Itisworthnotingthatentrepreneurship,eitherofnecessityoropportunity,isoneoftheprincipalsourcesofemploymentinPapuaNewGuineabutthat,inthemain,theseenterprisesarefrequentlytobefoundintheinformaleconomy,beyondtheenablingenvironmentoflabourpolicies.ThechallengeforWPUinaddressingthemultiplicityofinformalenterprisesandtheirpotentialforgraduateemploymentishowtoopenaccesstoskillstraining,microfinance,e-commerce,business
![Page 56: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/56.jpg)
56
advisoryservices,marketinformation,productiveresources,socialprotectionandtradeopportunities,allofwhicharenowreliantontheeffectiveuseoftechnology.2.12 WPUwill,againovertime,needtoimplementprogramstoupdate,onaregularbasis,thedigitalskillsofitsstaff.Academicstaffmustbesupportedtodelivertheinnovativeformsofcurriculumdelivery,includingonlineandworkplacelearning,andtodeveloptheirteachingandlearningstylesinkeepingwithdevelopingtechnology.Thisincludesretraininglecturingstaffthroughaneffectiveprogrammeofcontinuousprofessionaldevelopment(CPD)andensuringthatnewlyappointedstaffareequippedwiththerightskillstoteachthenewcurriculumandabletoaccessCPDprogrammestoacquireandupdatetheirdigitalskills.2.13 Again,therichandextensiveevidencebaserelatingtoagriculturaloutputanditscontributiontoGDPinPapuaNewGuinea,ceterisparibus,suggeststhatfurtherinvestmentinthissectorwillreduceunderemploymentratherthancreatenewjobs.InthediscussionarounddegreeprogramsatWPU,jobcreationinagricultureislikelytooccurthroughgrowthinadjacentindustriessuchasagri-business.OnthebasisofthemostrecentpolicydirectioninofficialcirclestheDepartmentforAgricultureandLivestock(DAL)isworkingwiththeUN’sFoodandAgricultureOrganisation(FAO)todevelope-agriculture.GivenWPU’sproposedinvestmentinIT,itsfutureuseinagriculturerepresentsastrongareaofinterestofteachingandresearch,notwithstandingtheenormouspotentialthereexistsforWIL,sincealmost85%ofthepopulationareregularlyinvolvedinsomeformofagriculture.2.14 WhilstevidentlytheextractiveindustriescontinuetoattractthemajorityofForeignDirectInvestment(FDI),itisalsoclearthattogetherwithforestryandfishing,agriculturehasbenefitedfromtheconsiderablesumsthathavebeenpouredintothepalmoil,sugar,copraandlivestockindustries.ThecontingentissuesforWPUmustbetoconsiderhowbesttodesignitsprogramstoassistinthedevelopmentofadvancedtechnologies,researchanddevelopmentandmanagerialexpertise.Insodoing,theimpactofexistingtechnicalandinstitutionalconstraintstothedevelopmentofhumanandphysicalcapitalcanbelessenedinfavourofeconomicgrowthandthereductionofpoverty.2.15 Romer’s(2017)celebratedvariantofendogenousgrowththeorythatrunsparalleltotechnologicalchangeprovidesalensthroughwhichtoviewthedevelopmentsdescribedintheprecedingparagraphs.Dependentupononpopulationexpansionandcapitalaccumulation,Romer’stheoryrobustlyalliestheincreaseofnewideastothevolumeofpeopleemployedintheknowledgesectorandtherebytoeconomicgrowth.Byextrapolation,WPU’scommitmenttoworkintegratedlearning,designedanddeliveredincollaborationwithemployers,willswellthenumbersofthoseemployedintheknowledgesectorwhosenewideaswillincreaselocalcapabilities,enhanceproductivityandreducerelianceonexpatriateleadershipandmanagementintechnologyandadvancedskills.
![Page 57: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/57.jpg)
57
2.16 SeveralhospitalsinPapuaNewGuinea,includingthoseinTabubil,Kiunga,Kundiawa,andPortMoresbyhave,formanyyears,beeninvolvedineHealthinitiativesandtelemedicinethroughlinkswiththeSwinfenCharitableTrust.WPUwill,intime,forgepartnershipswithlocalhospitalsandbecomeaproviderofmedicaleducation;however,withaneyeonthegraduatelabourmarket,astheUniversitydesignsanddevelopsitsprototypedegreeprogramsfocusedondigitaltechnologies,supportfortelemedicineatthenationallevelwillbevitaltoaspectsoftheirdelivery.Theseincludethetransmissionofx-rays,MRIscansandmedicalphotographytogetherwiththedesignofdatabasesandsecuremessagingplatforms.TheprosandconsofeHealthintransitioninganddevelopingcountrieshavebeenexhaustivelydebatedoverrecentyearsbutclearbenefitsareemerging,notleastthecapacitytousetheexpertiseofin-countrymedicalpractitioners,aswellasofthoseoverseas,inthediagnosisandtreatmentofpatientsinremoteruralareas.2.17 Acaseforexpandingthereachofsustainabletourismintheformalandinformallabourmarketswasmadeconvincinglybykeyinformantswholinkedittotheneedforahighly-trainedandeducatedlabourforce.BoththetourismindustryandGoPNGarehamperedbyalackofreliablelabourmarketdatatoinformpolicy.Milneetal(2013)howeverintheirPacificregionaltourismcapacitybuildingprogramme(PRTCBP)citethetourismtrainingneedsofPNGaslanguageskills,businessmanagement,customer-servicetraining,marketing,basiccommunicationskills,tourguiding,behaviouralskills,inter-culturalcommunicationskills,conferencemanagementandnichemarketdevelopment.Theseinclude,interalia,peopleskills,anunderstandingofconsumerbehaviourandadministrativeskillssuchasfinance,humanresources,marketingandpropertymanagement.WPUiswellplacedtoprovidetherapidlyexpandingindustrywithasteadysupplyofgraduateswhopossessnotonlyskillsetsinthesecruciallyimportantareasbutalsoleadershippotentialidentifiedanddevelopedthroughtheirintercalatedWIL.
![Page 58: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/58.jpg)
58
References Ananiadou,K.andClaro,M.2009.21stCenturySkills andCompetencesforNewMillenniumLearnersin OECDCountries.OECDEducationWorkingPapers, No.41.Paris,OECDPublishing.AsianDevelopmentBank.(2014).PacificEconomicMonitor:Mid-YearReview.ADB. Brewer,L.(2013).EnhancingYouthEmployability:What?WhyandHow?Guidetocoreworkskills.Geneva:InternationalLabourOffice.Brundenius,C.,Lundvall,B.,&Sutz,J.(2009).TheRoleofUniversitiesinInnovationSystemsinDevelopingCountries:DevelopmentalUniversitySystems–Empirical,AnalyticalandNormativePerspectives.HandbookofInnovationSystemsandDevelopingCountries.http://dx.doi.org/10.4337/9781849803427.00019
Care,EandLuo,R.(2016).AssessmentofTransversalCompetencies:PolicyandPracticeintheAsia-PacificRegion.Bangkok:UNESCOConley,D.T.(2007).TowardaMoreComprehensiveConceptionofCollegeReadiness.Eugene:EducationalPolicyImprovementCenter.Cornish,M.,(2016)PapuaNewGuineaeconomicsgraduateexitsurvey.DevelopmentPolicyCentreDiscussionPaper#53.Canberra:ANU
Cresswell,J.(2014).ResearchDesign:Qualitative,QuantitativeandMixedMethodsApproaches(4thed.).ThousandOaks:Sage.
Curtain,R.,Dornan,M.,Doyle,J.,&Howes,S.(2016).PacificPossibleLabourMobility:theten-billion-dollarprize.Washington:WorldBank.Retrievedfromhttp://worldbank.org/PacificPossible
David,D.,&Kaita,P.(2015).NeedsTheoryandEmployeePerformance.Presentation,UniversityofPapuaNewGuinea.
Deloitte,&UNDP.(2017).Fulfillingthelandofopportunity:HowtogrowemploymentinPapuaNewGuinea.PortMoresby:Deloitte,UNDP.DepartmentofHigherEducation,Research,ScienceandTechnology(DHERST).(2015).NationalHigherandTechnicalEducationPlan2015–2024.PortMoresby:DHERST.
DepartmentofHigherEducation,Research,ScienceandTechnology(DHERST).(2017).PapuaNewGuineaNationalQualificationsFramework.PortMoresby:DHERST.
EmployabilitySkillsFramework.(2017).Cte.ed.gov.Retrieved6May2017,fromhttp://cte.ed.gov/employabilityskills/
![Page 59: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/59.jpg)
59
Filer,C.,Andrew,M.,Carr,P.,Imbun,B.,Sagir,B.,&Benjamin,R.etal.(2012).TheSocialandEconomicImpactoftheResourceSectorJobStreaminPapuaNewGuinea.Canberra:ANU.Fox,R.,Howes,S.,Nema,N.,&Schröder,M.(2017).2017PNGEconomicSurvey:UnpublishedManuscript.Garnaut,R.&Namaliu,R.(2010)PNGUniversitiesReview:reporttoPrimeMinistersSomareandRudd.Availableat:http://www.dfat.gov.au/about-us/publications/Documents/png-universities-review.pdf,
GovernmentofPapuaNewGuinea,(2010).DevelopmentStrategicPlan2010-2030.DepartmentforNationalPlanningandMonitoring:PortMoresby.GovernmentofPapuaNewGuinea,(2015).MediumTermDevelopmentPlan22016-2017.DepartmentforNationalPlanningandMonitoring:PortMoresby.GovernmentofPapuaNewGuinea,(2016).SMEPolicyandMasterPlanSummary2016–2030.DepartmentforTrade,CommerceandIndustry:PortMoresbyHughes,D.&Miller,S.(2017).TheQuantCrunch:HowtheDemandforDataScienceSkillsisDisruptingtheJobMarket.BurningGlassTechnologies:Boston.
Jones,L.,&McGavin,P.(2015).GrapplingafreshwithlabourresourcechallengesinPapuaNewGuinea:aframeworkformovingforward.PortMoresby:InstituteofNationalAffairs.
Lippman,L.,Ryberg,R.,Carney,R.,&Moore,K.(2015).WorkforceConnections:Key"SoftSkills"thatfosteryouthworkforcesuccess:towardaconsensusacrossfields.Bethesda:ChildTrends.
Milne,S.,Taumoepeau,S.,Singh,E.,Zhang,K.,Huber,D.,&Cooper,D.(2013).Pacificregionaltourismcapacitybuildingprogramme(PRTCBP):Pacificregionaltourismandhospitalityhumanresourcesdevelopmentplan(Ref.TA/08).NewZealand:NewZealandTourismResearchInstitute.Morgan,D.,(1996).“FocusGroups.”AnnualReviewofSociology,22(1),129-152.Namun,K.,Irumai,A.,Chakumai,K.,Papapu,S.,Sion,P.,&Semos,I.(2016).Wherearetheynow?AtracerstudyofformerHealthManagementstudentsofDivineWordUniversity.ContemporaryPNGStudies:DWUResearchJournal,Vol.25,78-93.OECD.(2014a).TheTeachingandLearningInternationalSurvey(TALIS)2013.Paris:OECD.
![Page 60: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/60.jpg)
60
OECD.(2014b).TALIS2013Results:AnInternationalPerspectiveonTeachingandLearning.Paris:OECD.http://dx.doi.org/10.1787/9789264196261-enPeek,L.,&Fothergill,A.(2009).“UsingFocusGroups:LessonsfromStudyingDaycareCenters,9/11,andHurricaneKatrina.”QualitativeResearch,9(1),31-59.PNGData4Development.(2017).#PNGDATA4DEVELOPMENT.[online]Availableat:http://pngdata4development.org.pg/Pritchett,L.,Woolcock,M.,&Andrews,M.(2012).LookingLikeaState:TechniquesofPersistentFailureinStateCapabilityforImplementation.Helsinki:UNU-WIDER.PwC.(2012).Closingthetalentgapintheemergingworld.PwC.Retrievedfromhttp://www.oxfordeconomics.com/publication/open/250697
Ribeiro,L.,Severo,M.,&Ferreira,M.(2016).Performanceofacoreoftransversalskills:self-perceptionsofundergraduatemedicalstudents.BMCMedicalEducation,16(1).http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/s12909-016-0527-2Romer,D.(2017).Advancedmacroeconomics.Dubuque:McGraw-HillEducation.Schwab,K.(2016).TheFourthIndustrialRevolutionandwhatitmeanstorespond.ForeignAffairs.Retrieved20June2016,fromhttp://ForeignAffairs.com
Swanton,T.,&Ong,A.(2013).APTCGraduatesDowntheTrack.ConsultancyReport.Adelaide:NationalCentreforVocationalEducationResearch.Trilling,B.andFadel,C.2009.21stCenturySkills:LearningforLifeinOurTimes.SanFrancisco,Calif.,Jossey-Bass/JohnWiley&SonsTebbuttResearch,(2014).ReportforSMEBaselineSurveyfortheSmall-MediumEnterpriseAccesstoFinanceProject.UnpublishedReportpreparedfortheDepartmentofCommerce,Trade&Industry,GovernmentofPapuaNewGuinea.http://www.pngsmersf.com/images/reports/SME%20Baseline%20Study%20Final%20Report.pdf(lastaccessedJune6,2016).UNESCO.(2015a).2013Asia-PacificEducationResearchInstitutesNetwork(ERI-Net)RegionalStudyonIntegratingTransversalCompetenciesinEducationPolicy&Practice:RegionalSynthesisReport.Bangkok:UNESCO.UNESCO.(2015b).DraftPreliminaryReportConcerningthePreparationofaGlobalConventionontheRecognitionofHigherEducationQualifications.Paris:UNESCO.Voigt-Graf,Carmen.(2016).WhydosofewpacificislanderstakeadvantageofopportunitiesinPapuaNewGuinea’slabourmarket?PapuaNewGuineaNationalResearchInstitute(PNGNRI)IssuesPaper22.
![Page 61: A Rapid Assessment of the Papua New Guinean Graduate ... · societal imperatives has been detrimental to the development of Papua New Guinea. The message for WPU is clear: as a new](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022043019/5f3b11582f699b5f1811d519/html5/thumbnails/61.jpg)
61
Wagner,T.(2010).OvercomingtheGlobalAchievementGap(online).Cambridge,Mass.,HarvardUniversity.WorldBank.(2017).SmallandMediumEnterprises(SMEs)Finance.Retrieved23May2017,fromhttp://www.worldbank.org/en/topic/financialsector/brief/smes-finance