a primer for understanding new public (gasb) reporting ... · a primer for understanding new public...
TRANSCRIPT
The opinions expressed in this presentation are those of the speaker. The International Foundationdisclaims responsibility for views expressed and statements made by the program speakers.
A Primer for Understanding New Public (GASB) Reporting Guidelines
Mary P. Kirby, FCA, FSA, MAAASenior Vice President and Consulting ActuarySegal ConsultingNew York, New York
PE2-1
Agenda
• Highlights of the new GASB rules for OPEB• What has changed?• Concerns about the new statements• Redesign strategies
PE2-2
GASB Statements No. 74 and 75
• Financial Reporting for Postemployment Benefits other than Pension Plans (No. 74)– Gives new standards for the financial reporting of OPEB plans– Effective for fiscal years beginning after June 15, 2016
• Accounting and Financial Reporting for Postemployment Benefits Other than Pensions (No. 75)– Deals with employer reporting– Effective for fiscal years beginning after June 15, 2017
Many provisions required by the new GASB Statements 67 and 68 for pensions have carried over to OPEB.
PE2-3
Goals and Objectives of GASB
• Financial Reporting Focus– GASB establishes accounting and financial reporting standards,
not funding policies– Focus on OPEB obligation, changes in obligation and attribution
of expense
• Long-Term Nature of Governments– Government financial statements focus on:
• Allocation of resources to government programs• Determination of the cost of services• Provide a long term view of operations
• Employer-Employee Exchange– Employer incurs an obligation to its employees for OPEB benefits– Transaction is in context of a career-long relationship
PE2-4
Objectives of Statements
• Improve accounting and financial reporting by state and local governments for OPEB
• Improve information provided by state and local government employers about financial support for OPEB that is provided by other entities
• Improve the usefulness of information about OPEB included in the general purpose external financial reports of state and local governmental plans for making decisions and assessing accountability
• Establish standards for measuring liabilities, expenses, and deferred inflow/outflow of resources (a.k.a. gain/loss)
• Does not address funding
PE2-5
Scope of Statements
• Standards for measuring and recognizing:– Liabilities– Deferred outflow of resources (losses)– Deferred inflow of resources (gains)– Expense/expenditures
PE2-6
What Are OPEB Benefits?
• Post-employment healthcare benefits– Includes medical, dental, vision, hearing and other
health related benefits
• Other forms of OPEB– Death benefits, life insurance, disability, and long-
term care
• Provided separately from or provided through a pension plan– If provided through a pension plan, would be
accounted for in pensions
PE2-7
What Are OPEB Benefits?
• Does not include termination benefits or termination benefits for sick leave–When a terminating employee’s unused sick
leave credits are converted to provide or enhance defined benefit OPEB, resulting benefit should be considered
• Includes volunteers that provide services to state and local governments– i.e., firefighters, auxiliary police
PE2-8
Major Components
• Net OPEB Liability reported on financials• Calculating the OPEB expense• Accounting for cost sharing plans• Expansion of disclosure information
PE2-9
New Terms vs. Old Terms
• Statement 74/75 Terms and their equivalent 43/45 Terms – Plan Fiduciary Net Position: Market Value of
Assets– Net OPEB Liability: Unfunded Actuarial
Accrued Liability (UAAL)– Deferred Inflow of Resources: Gain– Deferred Outflow of Resources: Loss
PE2-10
Net OPEB Liability
• Net OPEB liability is to be reported on the financial statement– Defined as OPEB liability less the Plan Fiduciary Net
Position (market value of assets)– ACA excise tax to be included– Age adjusted premium for plans that are not
community rated
• Calculated using a blended discount rate• Entry age normal, using a level percent
of pay• No smoothing of assets
PE2-11
Trust Requirements
• Contributions from employers and non-employer contributing entities to the OPEB plan and earnings on those contributions are irrevocable
• OPEB plan assets are dedicated to providing OPEB to plan members– Can be used for administrative costs of plan
• OPEB plan assets are legally protected from– Creditors of employers or plan members– Non-employer contributing entities
– OPEB Plan administrator
PE2-12
What Has Changed
• Based on annual required contribution– Normal cost plus– Amortization of the UAAL• Period not greater than 30 years• Closed or open amortization• Level dollar or level % of payroll
– Can be based on any of 6 actuarial cost methods
• Annual OPEB Cost (AOC)– ARC plus– Interest on Net OPEB Obligation– Adjustment to ARC
• Change in net OPEB liability each year, with deferred recognition of certain elements
• Components of new expense– Service cost– Interest cost– Differences between expected and
actual experience (w/certain deferrals)
– Difference between actual and expected earnings (5 year spread)
– Projected investment returns over the year (if applicable)
– Employee contributions– Other changes in plan net position
Current OPEB ExpenseCurrent OPEB Expense New OPEB ExpenseNew OPEB Expense
PE2-13
Immediate Recognition
• Some changes in OPEB liability are recognized immediately– Service cost– Annual interest on OPEB liability– Projected investment returns over the year, if
applicable– Plan amendments– Benefits paid during the year
PE2-14
Deferred Recognition
• Some changes in OPEB liability are allowed to be deferred– Changes in actuarial assumptions– Actuarial gains and losses– Investment gains and losses
• Deferral periods depend on the type of change
PE2-15
Expanded Employer Disclosures
• Description of plan and assumptions• Policy for determining contributions• Sensitivity analysis of the impact on the OPEB liabilities
under five different scenarios– Assumed discount rate and current healthcare cost trend rate– Discount rate +/-1% and current healthcare cost trend rate– Assumed discount rate and healthcare cost trend rate +/-1%
• Changes in OPEB liability for the past 10 years• Development of long term earnings assumption• If actuarially determined contribution (ARC) is
calculated, 10 year schedule must be disclosed
PE2-16
Expanded Employer Disclosures
Note disclosures on the discount rate of return must include:• Description of how rate was determined• Methods and assumptions used• Expected asset allocation• Real rates of return for each major asset class• Whether the rates of return are arithmetic or
geometric means
PE2-17
Distinctions AmongDifferent Types of Plans
Different plan types, different reporting requirements• Single employer plans• Agent multiple employer plans
– Provide defined benefit OPEB to employees of multiple employers– Plan assets are pooled for investment purposes but separate accounts
are maintained so each employer’s share of assets is only available to pay the benefits of its employees
• Cost-sharing multiple employer plans– Provides defined benefit OPEB to employees of multiple employers– OPEB obligations are pooled and plan assets can be used to pay the
benefits of the employees of any employer in the plan
PE2-18
Cost Sharing plans
• Each employer must disclose on their balance sheets their proportionate share of:– Net OPEB liability– OPEB expense– Deferred outflows and inflows of resources
related to OPEB
• A description of the basis for determining the proportionate share of net OPEB liability must be disclosed in the notes
PE2-19
Concerns
• Both the timing and the scope of the new reporting will require greater coordination between the plan and the employer, as well as between actuary and auditor– Especially true for cost sharing agent plans
• Plan will need to determine whether the cost of reporting the financial information that employers will require for their financial statements will be charged to employers or be borne by the Plan
• Having the net OPEB liability on the balance sheet could mean more involvement by the auditor in actuarial results
PE2-20
Concerns
• The recognition of the net OPEB liability on the balance sheet will force employers to relook at OPEB benefits– Many employer’s OPEB liability is nearly as large as the pension
liability but with no accompanying assets (or very little assets compared to pension plan)
• Will states and local governments be able to raise funds via bonds if the OPEB liability is on the balance sheet?
• How will this affect bond ratings?• The sensitivity analysis required will require four
additional calculations– Will this confuse the reader or make the actual calculation seem
inaccurate?– Is this cost prohibitive for employers and plans?
PE2-21
Concerns
• Structure of trusts that cover more than OPEBwill need to be reviewed– Trusts must be dedicated to OPEB only
• There is a divorcing of expense and funding– Net OPEB liability is based on market value of assets
but expense will reflect asset smoothing
PE2-22
Retiree HealthRedesign Strategies
Establish Parameters• What role does the retiree medical program play in
recruitment and retention/total rewards?• Are there key late career hires? If so, what is an appropriate
service requirement for retiree medical eligibility for them?• What promises have been made to current retired and active
employees?• Could/should the program be different for
new hires?• What age should a long term employee target for retirement?
PE2-23
Retiree HealthRedesign Strategies
• How do you want your program to compare to your peers?
• What aspects of the program are available to change and what are “untouchable”?
• Is the current program sustainable?• What is an acceptable cost for these types of programs
– For the employer? For retirees?
These objectives are critical to managing and have a cost consequence that must be considered in tandem.
PE2-24
The “Levers” ofRetiree Health Design
• Eligibility and/or Vesting– Who receives the benefit (and for how long)?– How much of a benefit do they receive based on service?
• Plan Design– Plan Platform
• Indemnity, HMO, Medigap• Exchange or group coverage
– Cost Sharing• Coinsurance, copays, deductible
• Employer Funding– Level of subsidization– Defined benefit vs. Defined contribution– Pre funded vs. Pay as you go
PE2-25
Eligibility and Vesting
• In many cases, post retirement eligibility is the same as current pension eligibility– Should the two be the same?
• Changing eligibility can have consequences– Could affect pension expense– People may stay in service longer to get retiree health– People may retire prior to eligibility change to get
better benefit
• Most employers want to reward the long service employee, not a mid-career hire
PE2-26
Eligibility and Vesting
• Four groups of participants to consider in the retiree medical plan:1. New hires2. Current actives3. Current actives close to retirement4. Current retirees
Eligibility for benefits for each of these groups needs to be explored separately and in tandem.
PE2-27
Plan Design: Pre Medicare
DEFINED BENEFIT RETIREE MEDICAL
PROGRAMRich Benefit Design
Employer subsidizes a set amount which
increases with trend
DEFINED CONTRIBUTION
RETIREE MEDICAL PROGRAM
Rich Benefit DesignEmployer Caps
contribution
GROUP PRIVATE EXCHANGE
Employer provides an account where plans are purchased in the private marketplace
Could be individual or group coverage
PUBLIC MARKETPLACE
Employer sends retirees to the Public
Marketplace with some DC type subsidy for
premium reimbursement
MOST CURRENT ARRANGEMENTS
EMERGING
PE2-28
Plan Design: Pre Medicare
• Can do all regular plan management– Financial management
• Contribution strategy
– Plan and network management• High performance networks• Contract negotiation
– Individual health management• Health Risk Reduction• Value Based Design
• Plan wouldn’t need to comply with ACA benefit mandates
Retiree Only Plan
PE2-29
Pre Medicare:Individual Market “Off Exchange”
Individual Market “Off Exchange” Coverage• Provides mechanism to assist retirees in selecting coverage including the
use of the public exchange as well as premium tax credits• Variety of plans
Plan Sponsor• Determines (annually) how much to contribute towards coverage through
an HRA or other method, if coverage is elected (defined contribution or DC approach)
• Is no longer in the health care business for retirees• In many ways, this could look like an old-time flexible benefits plan, except
the Plan sponsor has minimized involvement
Retirees• Pick plan that best meets their expected needs• Value based design• Patient safety/care coordination
PE2-30
Health Reimbursement Accounts (HRAs)
● Retirees who are NOT eligible for the federal subsidy would have immediate access to funds in their account
● Distributions are not taxable to the retiree either when credited to the retiree’s account or when distributed from the retiree’s account
● Unused account balances may be used in later years
● Accounts may be used to pay health insurance premiums or medical, dental or vision expenses
● Contributions could continue after the retiree becomes Medicare eligible
● Retirees eligible for the federal subsidy must elect to freeze distributions from their account until the end of the year in which they are no longer eligible for the subsidy
● Unused account balances are forfeited upon death of an unmarried retiree with no covered dependents (or upon the death or loss of eligibility of the spouse and all surviving covered dependents)
AdvantagesAdvantages Disadvantages/LimitationsDisadvantages/Limitations
PE2-31
Freezing HealthReimbursement Accounts
• Freeze election would defer distributions (but not contributions) until the freeze is no longer in effect
• Retirees may elect to freeze or unfreeze their account on an annual basis before the beginning of each year
• An election to freeze distributions must be irrevocable for the full year
• Unused account balance may be used by the retiree after the freeze ends (generally when the retiree becomes eligible for Medicare) to pay:– insurance premiums (including Medicare
Part B, Medicare Advantage Plan premiums or other insurance) or
– other medical, dental or vision expenses (including copays, coinsurance, deductibles)
PE2-32
Excepted Benefits
Medical and RX Benefits Are Not Provided by Plan Sponsor• Dental and Vision Coverage
– Hi frequency, low cost coverage which the vast majority of retirees would utilize
– Predictable cost– Benefit levels (and resulting costs) can vary
tremendously• Voluntary Benefits (but not really)
– Paid for by plan sponsor• Rates should be lower than if voluntary• Could this be self-insured?• Tax consequences should be considered
– Excess major medical– Critical illness– Accident– Hospital indemnity– Long-term care (need to confirm if possible)
These would provide a mechanism for a plan sponsor to provide financial and/or health support even if not providing a core health benefit for a cost that could range from $30 per month to over $400 per month or more depending on the coverages offered.
PE2-33
Plan Design: Medicare Basics
Part AHospital
Insurance
Part AHospital
Insurance
Original Medicare
Combines Part A and Part B
Combines Part A and Part B
Part BMedical
Insurance
Part BMedical
Insurance
MedigapMedicare Supplement
Insurance
MedigapMedicare Supplement
Insurance
Medicare Advantage Plan(such as an HMO or PPO)
Adding Drug Coverage
Part D / EGWP
Medicare Prescription Drug Plan
Part D / EGWP
Medicare Prescription Drug Plan
MAPDMedicare
Advantage + Part D Coverage
MAPDMedicare
Advantage + Part D Coverage
Employer Pharmacy Benefit /
EGWP
Employer Pharmacy Benefit /
EGWP
Part D Medicare
Prescription Drug Plan
Part D Medicare
Prescription Drug Plan
If you join/offer a Medicare Advantage Plan, you don’t
need/can’t take a Medigap Policy
If you join/offer a Medicare Advantage Plan, you don’t
need/can’t take a Medigap Policy
Supplemental Coverage
OR OR
PE2-34
Plan Design: Spectrum ofMedicare Arrangements
DEFINED BENEFIT RETIREE MEDICAL
PROGRAMRich Benefit Design
Employer subsidizes a set amount which
increases with trend
GROUP MEDICARE PLANS
Employer offers Medicare Advantage or
Medigap plansCould be DB or DC
DEFINED CONTRIBUTION
PLANEmployer provides an
account where plans are purchased in the private marketplace or through
Employer
PRIVATE MEDICARE EXCHANGE
Employer provides an account that retiree uses to purchase an individual Medicare
Supplement or Medicare Advantage plan
MOST CURRENT ARRANGEMENT
PE2-35
Plan Design: Medicare Advantage
Many times more affordable than Medicare Supplement Plans due to availability of federal subsidies
Many offer supplemental benefits like dental and/or vision
If retiree resides in a coverage area and the doctor is in-network, generally cost sharing will be lower than current plan
Can be designed to mitigate any network limitation issues
Can negotiate rate guarantees
Experienced plans can offer increased member support
Other benefits may be available (gym memberships)
If physician has opted out of Medicare, retiree pays 100% of all costs
If retiree wants to return to a Medigap (supplement) plan, it may not be guaranteed issue
Physician and hospital networks are generally narrower and balance billing could occur
More care management and precertification requirements to receive care
If CMS subsidies to MA plans are cut:− Premiums could increase significantly− Plan designs could require higher
retiree cost sharing− Carrier could pull out of the market
AdvantagesAdvantages Disadvantages/LimitationsDisadvantages/Limitations
PE2-36
Medicare Advantage Enrollment 2016
PE2-37
Funding: Defined Benefit vs. Defined Contribution
Employer pays a portion of the cost of the benefit:−Could be service based
Employer and retiree share the burden of medical cost trend
Two Types:1. Defined dollar benefit2. DC accounts funded during
active working lifetime
Employer no longer has risk for increasing medical costs (but still longevity risk)
Flexibility in actual annual dollar amounts
Defined BenefitDefined Benefit Defined ContributionDefined Contribution
PE2-38
Funding: Defined Contribution Plans
Employer: Better control of budgeting—move away
from unpredictable long term projections of medical inflation
Reduce OPEB liability Flexibility in plan design
Employee/Retiree For Medicare eligible, Part A, Part B and
Part D federal subsidy may now be sufficient to sustain individual retiree market
Amount in “account” is earned during active service and will not change
Accumulation vehicles available to build savings in conjunction with Employer contribution
Choice of plans to meet individual needs
Employer Depending upon how funded, balances
may not revert back to the employer Depending upon how funded, there
could be a significant financial outlay for past service
Amounts granted each year are fixed
Employee/Retiree Retiree will be subject to all of the cost
volatility
AdvantagesAdvantages Disadvantages/LimitationsDisadvantages/Limitations
PE2-39
Funding: Setting up an OPEB Trust
Net OPEB liability will decrease due to funding and a higher discount rate
Security for active employees that benefit funds will be there
Subject to cost trend volatility Funds are irrevocable Where does the money come from? Diminishes ability to fund other
programs:̶ May compete with ability to
increase compensation Expense of lifetime benefits
AdvantagesAdvantages Disadvantages/LimitationsDisadvantages/Limitations
PE2-40
What Has Been Considered?
PE2-41
What’s Been Done . . .
• Total replacement of Medicare Supplement Plans with Medicare Advantage Plans
• Termination of ALL non-Medicare plans replaced with a small monthly, taxable stipend
• Advanced announcement regarding termination of prescription drug coverage for Medicare retirees in 2020
• Elimination of any retiree health coverage for new hires • Introduction of Medicare Retiree Exchanges with a fixed
dollar HRA• Increase in required contributions for all spouses
The above is a small sample of changes that we have seen. Every situation has their own set of facts and circumstances
that must be considered.
PE2-42
Case Study: Description of Situation
Large public sector employer with a $542M OPEB liability in 2015 that is expected to reach $1B by 2020
No assets, only a small trust that was not specific to OPEB Population of approximately 19,000 active employees,
5,000 of which are eligible to retire Capped benefit rate When measured against their peers,
this employer had a very generous eligibility requirement for OPEB– 60 and 5; 55 and 10
Contributions were based on years of service
PE2-43
Eligibility: Close Plan to New Hires
0
500
1,000
1,500
2,000
2,500
3,000
Impact of Closing Plan to New Hires(in millions)
Current
Closed to New Hires
PE2-44
Plan Design: Total Replacement
With Medicare Advantage
0
50
100
150
200
250
Impact on Over 65 Retiree Liabilityby Moving to MAPD
(in millions)
Current
MAPD
PE2-45
Plan Design: Total Replacement
With Medicare Advantage
0
5
10
15
Impact on Over 65 Retiree Cash Payments by Moving to MAPD
(in millions)
Current
MAPD
PE2-46
Plan Funding: DC for Non-Grandfathered Actives
0200400600800
10001200
Impact of Defined Contributionon Active Liability
(in millions)Current
Defined Contribution
PE2-47
Case Study: Results
Closed plan to new hires Grandfathered current retirees and those that reached
age 60 with 20 years of service by effective date Moved all Medicare eligible retirees to Medicare
Advantage plans with same or similar benefits Eligibility for OPEB was changed to 60 and 20 All others received a defined contribution
plan where the employer subsidy is based on years of service
Moved to creating an OPEB trust with a desire to fully fund benefits in 40 years
Reduced the 2020 liability by half
PE2-48
Session #PE2
A Primer for Understanding New Public (GASB) Reporting Guidelines
• New GASB accounting and reporting rules for OPEB will place OPEB liabilities out of the notes section and into the body of financial statements
• If funded, review your trust documents to ensure they meet the requirements for OPEB fund assets
• Redesign alternatives are many, but need to be balanced with objectives. Focus on:– Eligibility– Plan design– Funding
Website Resourceshttps://www.ifebp.org/news/featuredtopics/gasbpensionstandards/Pages/default.aspxhttps://www.ifebp.org/Resources/infoquick/Pages/default.aspx GASB Postemployment Benefits Other Than Pensions (OPEB) (Members Only)
62nd Annual Employee Benefits ConferenceNovember 13-16, 2016Orlando, Florida
PE2-49
2017 Educational ProgramsPublic Plans
63rd Annual Employee Benefits Conference October 22-25, 2017 | Las Vegas, Nevadawww.ifebp.org/usannual
Public Sector Benefits InstituteHeld in conjunction with Trustees and Administrators Institutes
February 20-22, 2017Lake Buena Vista (Orlando), Floridawww.ifebp.org/psbinstitute
Benefits Conference for Public EmployeesSystem Highlight: Ohio Public Employees Retirement System (OPERS) April 25-26, 2017 | Columbus, Ohiowww.ifebp.org/publicemployee
Certificate of Achievement in Public Plan Policy (CAPPP®)Part I and Part II, June 13-16, 2017 San Jose, CaliforniaPart II Only, October 21-22, 2017 Las Vegas, Nevadawww.ifebp.org/cappp
Fraud Prevention Institute for Employee Benefit PlansJuly 17-18, 2017 | Chicago, Illinoiswww.ifebp.org/fraudprevention
Related ReadingVisit one of the on-site Bookstore locations or see www.ifebp.org/bookstore for more books.
Employee Benefits Glossary, 13th EditionItem #7570www.ifebp.org/glossary
816
NEW!
PE2-50