· • • • form nis-1 owner's report for inservice inspections as required by the...

' l : I

ENCLOSURE

CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY PALISADES PLANT

DOCKET 50-255

• SPECIAL REPORT ON 1996 INSERVICE INSPECTION

OF STEAM GENERA TOR TUBES

r· - 9709oso170 970829 I PDR ADOCK 05000255 I G PDR '~::...._-~~----------- ----·--

\\ l -· l....J_ ----- _,

t --- I

•

PALISADES NUCLEAR PLANT

SPECIAL REP.ORT

· EDDY CURRENT INSPECTION OF

A&B STEAM GENERATORS NOVEMBER 1996

PREPARED BY THOMAS D. REXIDS

CONSUMERS ENERGY PALISADES NUCLEAR PLANT

27780 BLUE STAR HWY. COVERT, MI 49043 .

,,

•

CONSUMERS ENERGY


1996 STEAM GENERA TOR INSERVICE INSPECTION

· REPORT OF EDDY CURRENT TESTING

DATA EVALUATION

REVIEWS AND APPROVALS

Prepared By Thomas D. Rexius

Reviews

Eddy Current -::tf_J!!' ~ Level Ill Exami~ ~

Steven R. Wellman

Corrosion Programs _...q.±=b: -::::\-.~ Section Head ~ ~

Thomas H; Fouty

Approval

Engineering Programs Dept. Manager

Judy K. Ford

Date

6'k/o 7 .

Date

Date ·

Date

•

•

•

FORM NIS-1 OWNER'S REPORT FOR INSERVICE INSPECTIONS As required by the Provisions of the ASME Code Rules

1. Owner Consumers Energy, 1945 West Parnall Road, Jackson.MI 49201 (Name and Address of Owner)

2. Plant Palisades Nuclear Plant,277SOBlue Star Mem Hwy,eovert,MI49043 (Nam! and Address of Plant)

1 rt/A 3. Plant Unit _________ 4. Owner Certificate of Authorization (if required) ________ _

S. Commercial Service Date 12 / 3 l / J l 6. N.itional Board Number for Unit _ _......_,._..~--------

7. Components Inspected

-Manufacturer

Component or Manufacturer or Installer· State or National Appurtenance or Installer Serial No. Province No. Board No.

Steam Gen. Combustion Eng. S/G "A" Michigan S/G A Tubing CE-70271-1 Vl'~c;f\1 7AM 22864

S/G "B" Michigan S/G "Bu

CE-70277-2 M~t:;f\1 7c;M 22865

'

. .

. .

Note: Supplemental sheets in form of lists, sketches . .,r Jr Jwings may be used, provided (1) size is sin in. x 11 in., (2) information in items 1 through 6 on this report 1~ 1n.:luJ~J on each sheet, and (3) each sheet is numbered and the number of sheets is recorded at the top of this form

(12/82) Ttiis Form (E00029) ~ay be obtained from the Orde~ Dept.~·ASME, 345 E. 47th St., New York, N.Y .. 10017

FORM NIS:.1 (Back)

8. ExaminationDatesll/10/96 toll/28/96 9. lnspectionlntervalfrom5/12/95 to5/ll/05

10. Abstract of ·Examinations. Include a list of examinatiom: and a statement concerning status of work required for current interval.

11. Abstract of Conditions Noted

12. Abstract of Corrective Measures Recommended and Taken

We certify that the statements made in this report are correct and the examinations and corrective measures taken conform fo the rules of the ASME Code, Section XL

Certificate' of Authorization No. (if applicable) ___ :r-_r_/ __ A ___ --'- N/A

1?.;j;_ Date _M~a""'v,___2=->~---- 19 --2.1_ Signed · Cons um_e_r_s ____ ~ Owner

CERTIFICATE OF INS:.ER'VICE INSPECTION

I, the undersigned, hoiding a valid commission issued by the l'htional Board of Boiler and Pressure Vessel Inspectors and the State or Province of Ml CJ.Ji'efltt111 :md employed by P!?<>rec.TjoH Mk.P..A'- of

/\/oR.Woo{) . "'1A liave inspected the components described in this Owner's Report during the period 8 -z Z -'9 S to I Z - Z 1 % , and state that to. the best of my knowledge and belief, the Owner

has performed examinations and taken corrective measures described in this Owner's Report in accordance with the requirements ·oft.he ASME Code, Section XI.

By signing this certificate. neither the Inspector· nor his employer makes any warranty, expressed or implied, concerning the examinations and corrective measures described in this Owner's Report. Furthermore, neither the Inspector nor his employer shall be liable in any manner for any personal injury or property damage or a loss of any kind arising from or connected with this inspection.

· . ~ . Commissions £'1/. 7fe..2. · ~ 8,I Inspector's Signature National Board, State, Province, and Endorsements

Date 4 -;lo 19 !lL_

(12/82)

•

·< '

consumers Power

Palisades Nuclear ·p1ant: 27780 Blue Star Memorial Highway, Covert, Ml 49043

December 6, 1996

U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Document Control Desk Washington, DC 20555

DOCKET 50-255 - LICENSE DPR-20 - PALISADES PLANT

Thomas C. Bordine Manager. Licensing

STEAM GENERA TOR TUBE SURVEILLANCE REPORT - TUBES PLUGGED

Palisades Technical Specification 6.6.9a requires that the _number of tubes plugged in each steam generator shall be reported to the NRC within fifteen days following the · completion of an inservice inspection of steam generator tubes. On November 28, 1996, an inservice inspection of the Palisades steam generator tubes was completed.·

A total of four tubes were plugged in Steam Generator E-50A on November 28, 1996. No additional tubes were required to be plugged in Steam Generator E-50B as a result of this inspection. The total number of tubes plugged in Steam Generator E-50A is 313. The total number of tubes plugged in Steam Generator E-50B is 309.

In accordance with Palisades Technical Specification 6.6.9b, a complete steam generator inservice inspection report will be submitted within 12 months.

A CJiS ev'e?GY COMPANY .

SUMMARY OF COMMITMENTS

This letter contains no new commitments and no revisions to existing commitments.

- -,:,j'l-.,-.....,.......--: . ------·- \

. ----·t·:.:...o:·

Thomas C. Berdine Manager, Licensing

CC Administrator, Region Ill, USNRC Project Manager, NRR, USNRC NRC Resident Inspector - Palisades

2

CUSTOMER:' SITE: DA TE OF SER VICE: FIELD SERVICE REPORT:

A. INTRODUCTION

Consumers Power Company Palisades Nuclear Plant November 3, 1996 through December 10, 1996

CPAL-9

CPAL-9; Pressurizer Manway Cover Removal & Installation, Steam Generator Primary Manway Cover Removal and Installation, CE _Nozzle Dam Installation and Removal, Steam Generator Eddy Current Inspection, Mechanical Tube Plugging, Tube Stabilization, Steam Generator Secondary Manway Cover Removal and Installation, Handhole Cover Removal and Installation, Steam Drum Inspection, Upper Support Plate Inspection, SID Inspection, Sludge Lance (fubesheet) Cleaning, Foreign Object Search and Retrieval and Main Condenser Eddy Currentlnspection

During .the 1996 refueling outage (96 REFOUT) of the Palisades Nuclear Plant, the Steam· Generator_ Services Group of the Westinghouse Nuclear Services Division (WNSD) provided services in support of Consumers Power Company's planned outage inspection and maintenance program for steam generators. This was the fourth refueling outage since replacement steam generators have been in service. The Palisades Nuclear Power Plant is located in Covert, Michigan, and is a Combustion Engineering designed two loop system with two Series 2530 steam generators. The tubes are made from Inconel 600, are 0.750 inches outside diameter with a 0.042 inch nominal wall thickness. ~

The services provided were pressurizer manway cover removal and installation, steam generator primary m1Ulway cover removal and installation on both steam generators, CE nozzle dam . installation and removal in all four primary steam gen~rator channelheads, steam generator eddy current inspection ~ both hot leg steam generator channelheads, mechanical tube plugging in both inlet and outlet channelheads of Steam Generator A, tube stabilization in steam generator A hot leg, steam generator secondary side manway cover removal and inst8llation, handhole cover removal and installation, steam drum inspection, upper support plate inspection, SID inspection, sludge lance cleaning, foreign object search and retrieval and main condenser eddy current inspection.

At the Palisades Nuclear Power Plant the pressurizer manway cover is removed to allow a vent path for the primary coolant system. This vent path was left open until the plant status allowe4 for the re-installation of the manway cover.

All four steam generator primary manway covers were removed to permit access to the steam generator channelheads for the performance of the planned inspections and maintenance activities. Six Combustion Engineering nozzle dams which consist of two dams each (a wet - lower and dry -upper), were installed by NES personnel with Westinghouse/NES supervision and support in all four channelheads to allow steam generator primary side work to continue in parallel with reactor cavity work.

Two Westinghouse ROSA III robotic arms were installed in Steam Generator's A and B hot leg channelheads for performing the hot leg eddy current inspection programs. Initially the eddy current bobbin inspection programs consisted of approximately 20% of the open tubes in each steam

1

CPAL-9

generator. Also all tubes with prior indications were required to be inspected. A +Point rotating pancake coil (RPC) probe was used to test the transition area at the top of the tubesheet (TTS) in the same 20% open tubes

that were inspected with the bobbin probe in each steam generator. In addition a +Point RPC probe was used to inspect the TTS of tubes adjacent to stay rods. And finally a 20% +Point RPC inspection of row I U-Bends. Due to axial indications found during the initial +Point RPC inspections in Steam Generator A the +Point RPC programs were expanded to 100% TIS and 100% of rows I and 2 U-Bends in Steam Generator A only ..

Upon completion of the reactor core reload, the water in the reactor cooling system was drained to mid-loop, the nozzle dams removed and the manway covers were reinstalled.

All four steam generator secondary manway covers were removed to permit access to the steam· generator secondary side for the performance of the planned steam drum inspections and maintenance activities. Also the upper handhole cover on Steam Generator B was removed to allow for the upper support plate inspection. All five covers were re-installed after the inspection work was performed in the steam generators ..

The two lower handhole covers were removed from each steam generator to allow for tubesheet cleaning (sludge lancing) and Foreign Object Search and Retrieval (FOSAR).

Remote Field Non-DestrUctive Eddy Current Testing of approximately 21% of the tubes in the main condensers were initially scheduled. The scope of the inspection included all of the periphery tubes, all tubes surrounding plugged tubes and a random sample of tubes across the interior ofthe bundles. Testing was performed in both the east and west condenser banks. Due to pitting indications additional tubes were added to the initial inspection scope.

2

CPAL-9

B. SERVICES PROVIDED

1.0 Pressurizer Manway Cover Removal and Installation

The pressurizer manway cover was removed and installed in accordance with CPCo procedure PCSM-50, Detensioning and Tensioning of Pressurizer Manway (refer to Appendix I), in order to allow the Primary Coolant System a vent path during maintenance activities. Work was performed in accordance with Consumers Power Company (CPCo) maintenance procedure PCS-M-50, Detensionirig and Tensioning of Pressurizer Manway. The pressurizer studs and stud holes were cleaned and inspected prior to re-installation of the pressurizer manway cover. The CPCo NDT inspection results can be found in Appendix I, A of this report. No studs or nuts were replaced this outage.

2.0 Steam Gen.erator Primary Manway Cover Removal and Installation

The manway cover removal and installation was performed by Westinghouse personnel in accordance with Westinghouse/CPCo procedure MRS 2.2.2 PAL-20, Primary Manway Cover Removal and Installation at Palisades Nuclear Plant (refer to Appendix II). All manway cover related components including studs, nuts, manway covers, manway inserts (gasket retainer plates) and gasket seating surfaces were inspected by Westinghouse QC and CPCo NDT in accordance with the requirements of the procedure. Both gasket retainer plates on Steam Generator B were replaced this outage because they stuck during removal and had to be tapped off with a hammer. A similar cortdition existed on

... :~r

Steam Generator A the previous outage at which time the gasket retainer plates were replaced which ,._ corrected the.sticking problem .. All other components were inspected and found to be acceptable for ·:~,,

'" re-use. -The CPCo NOT inspection results can be found in Appendix 11.C for Steam Generator A and :t;:; Appendix 11.D for Steam Generator B of this report.

3.0 CE Nozzle Dam Installation and Removal

The Combustion Engineering (CE) nozzle dam installation and removal was performed. in accordance with Westinghouse/CPCo procedure MRS 2.2.2 PAL-22, Steam Generator Primary Nozzle Dam Installation and Removal at the Palisades Nuclear Site {refer to Appendix III). All six nozzle dams (note that each CE nozzle dam consists of a lower - wet dam and upper - dry ·dam) were installed using NES Inc. supervisors and technicians under Westinghouse control. Prior to the outage all tWelve ~ozzle dams were refurbished, inspected and functionally checked at the Westinghouse Waltz Mill facility. Also. prior to installation all twelve no~e dams were assembled and visually checked by NES Inc. personnel.

During installation of the nozzle dams in the first Steam Generator (A) the lower - wet dam failed the ·acceptance air pressure check criteria for the pre-flood up test. The dam was removed at which time it was discovered that the seal had rolled off the daoi. The seal was re-seated on the dam and the dam was re-installed, a second pre-flood up test was performed· and the dam held air pressure. During reactor cavity flood up at approximately six feet above the reactor flange the Site detected a cavity leak. The leak was determined to be coming from the Steam Generator A wet dam. Due to the leak a drain line was run from the nozzle dam leak off tank to a holding tank in lower containment (590'

3

;)

CPAL-9

elevation) and recirculated back to the reactor cavity. At full flood up of the reactor cavity the leak rate was calculated to be ap'proximately 1200 gallons per day. An emergency primary manway cover installation plan (refer to Appendix II, CJ & C.2) was developed in case of a catastrophic failure of the nozzle dams in Steam Generator A. Once the emergency plan was in·place refueling activities were allowed to continue.

As in previous installations of the nozzle dams in these steam generators the locking pin at the 7 o'clock position (labeled as #6) on the hot leg dry dams in both steam generators would not fully engage. CPCo has an analysis that allows for one nozzle dam pin not being engaged. Therefore, nozzle dam installation was considered complete.

Upon removal of the nozzle dams the wet dam from Steam Generator A (the dam that leaked) was visually inspected. The rubber bladder along the bottom of the seal was found to be tom, ·apparently from stress. Pictures were taken of the tom nozzle dam seal and given to CPCo:

4.0 Steam Generator Eddy Current Inspection

Background

The steam generators that are currently in use at the Palisades Nuclear Plant, are replacement steam generators and were installed in the fall of 1990. A preservice 100% eddy current inspection was· performed in April of 1990 and was conducted prior to the units being installed. The preservice inspection indicated there was no active degradation mechanisms present within the steam generators prior to service. However, a large number of manufacturing type mdications were found in the free span of the tubing. To confirm these indications several tubes were removed and evaluated to determine the cause of the eddy current responses. It was verified that these responses were caused by the manufachiring process of removing slight surfaces imperfections with a buffmg tool. This causes slight tube wall thinning in these areas. Of the indications that were identified, none exceeded the >= 40% through wall plugging criteria required by the Palisades Technical Specification.

Prior to the installation of these steam generators the manufacturer, advised CPCo that the area · around the center stay cylinder region was potentially susceptible to fretting wear at the bat wing

locations. This region was subsequently preventatively plugged.

After one cycle of operation of the new steam generators a 20% random inspection program of bobbin eddy current was perf~tmed in each steam generator along with any prior tubes with indications >= 20%. The 20% random pattern examination indicated that the condition of both steam generators has remained constant since the preservice inspection performed in April of 1990. All previously

· identified reportable indications were found to be unchanged since the preservice inspection. The eddy current testing showed that the steam generators could be operated in accordance with the current Palisades Technical Specification requirements. ·

Inspection Plan Description

The intent of the bobbin coil inspection plan was to ensure that Palisades Nuclear Plant met the plant

4

.... ' ••

CPAL-9

Technical Specification for steam generator eddy current testing, as well as the EPRI Steam Generator Guidelines of inspecting 100% of all steam generator tubing over the period of five refueling outages by inspecting a minimum of 20% of the tubing per outage. In addition since the bobbin probe technique is not recognized to detect flaws at the top of tubesheet transition region a Zetec +Point Rotating Pancake Coil (RPC) probe, was used to inspect this area in the 20% random tube sample. In addition to the random sample all tubes around the stay rods in the steam generators were inspected with the +Point RPC probe. The last inspection was a 20% random inspection of the row .1 U-Bends using a +Point RPC U-Bend probe.

Inspection Plan Implementation

The eddy current inspection was performed in accordance with Westinghouse/CPCo procedure MRS 2.4.2 GEN-3S, Eddy Current of Preservice and Inservice Heat Exchanger Tubing (refer to Appendix IV), utilizing the Westinghouse ROSA III robotic arm in both inlet channelheads simultaneously. Eddy current data was collected and analyzed utilizing the Westinghouse UNIX based ANSER system. Both acquisition stations were"networked to data analysis through a fiber optic cable and then over a T-1 telephone line to the Westinghouse Waltz Mill Site for primary and secondary analysis enabling the on-line analysis of data.

The planned eddy current inspection program was made up of three basic parts. First, the bobbin program which consisted of a 20% inspection of the open tubes in each steam generator.

The second part of the inspection program was to inspect the same 20% open tubes as were inspected with the bobbin probe but at the top of tubesheet (TTS) transition with a +Point Rotating Pancake Coil (RPC) probe. In addition to the random TTS inspection, tubes around the stay· rods were inspected at the TTS. However, due to ·an axial indication (R34 CS 1) at the ITS transition zone discovered during the initial 20% RPC eddy current inspection in Ste~ Generator A the TIS program in Steam Generator A was expanded to 100%

. .,. ..

The third part of the inspection program was to inspect 20% of· row 1 tubes through the . U-Bend (top support plate on the cold leg through the top support plate on the hot leg) utilizing a +Point Rotating Pancake Coil (RPC) probe in both steam generators. As with the TIS RPC initial inspection the initial U-Bend RPC inspection discovered an axial indication in a row 1 U-Bend (RI CS4) in Steam Generator A. Because of this indication the U-Bend RPC inspection in Steam Generator A was expanded to 100% of rows 1 and 2.

The RPC programs used the EPRl/RPC G.uide Tube standards which CPCo purchased (4) for this outage. During the RPC inspection in Steam Generator A hot leg one EPRI/RPC standard (guide tube part of ACGT-066-96) was bent. Therefore, only three complete EPRI/RPC Guide Tube CPCo standards currently exist.

· The planned eddy current inspections are summarized in the following table:

s

\ .... ...

CPAL-9

Planned Eddy Current Inspection Programs

SIGA SIG B

Bobbin, inlet 1609 1624

TIS +Point RPC, inlet 1714 1719

U-Bend +Point RPC, inlet 24 24

. Completed Eddy Current Inspection Programs As A Result Of Indications Found

SIG A SIG B


TIS +Point RPC, inlet 7910 1719

. U-Bend +Point RPC, inlet 118 24

Bobbin Inspection

All tubes in the inspection programs for both steam generators were tested to completion including the expansion programs in Steam Generator A.. · ·

The bobbin eddy current inspection programs were performed in accordance with Acquisition Technique Specification (ACTS) Sheet CPAL-01-196 (refer to Appendix XIV.A.3). The probe withdrawal speeds, or test speeds, were 40 inches per second at 1400 samples per second ·with test frequencies of 550 kHz, 300 kHz, 150 kHz and 20 kHz. The. bobbin probes utilized were

_manufactured by the Echoram Products Group of Westinghouse, and the primary-test probe used was EB-610-LLMC (0.610" dia. long life).· In some cases aq EB-590-LLMC (0.590" dia. long life) probe was utilized to traverse the U-Bends of lower row tubes.

Top of Tubesbeet +Point RPC Inspection

The intent of the tubesheet +Point RPC inspection was to detect the presence of axial or . circumferential cracking at the top of the bot leg tubesheet transition region.

A 20% random sample program was planned and initially performed in both steam generators, this averaged about 1610 tubes per steam generator. In addition to the random Top of Tubesheet RPC inspection additional tubes around the stay rod were inspected, this totaled about another 110 tubes. All tubes were tested utilizing a Zetec Inc. manufactured +Point RPC probe, +Point-610-115-36-SSO (0.610" dia.). The +Point RPC tests were performed in accordance with Acqui~ition Technique

6

9.·.

e·•

.e

CPA~9

Specification (ACTS) Sheet CPAL-03-196, for 300 rpm and Acquisition Technique Specification (ACTS) Sheet CPAL-07-196, for 900 rpm (refer to Appendix XIV.A.3). The probe test speed was 0.2 inches per second, rotating at 300 rpm's, at 450 samples per second and 0.6 inches per second, ·rotating at 900 rpm's, at 1350 samples per second. Test frequencies used were 600 kHz, 300 kHz, 200 kHz, l 00 kHz and l 0 kHz for both ACTS. The extent tested was 3 inches above and below the top

· of .the tubesheet.

As a result of indications found during the planned Top of Tubesheet +Point RPC eddy current inspection the TTS program in Steam Generator A was expanded.

U-Bend +Point RPC Inspection

The intent of the U-Bend +Point RPC inspection was to detect the presence of tight radius stress cracking in the U-Bend region.

The U-Bend +Point RPC inspection was performed initially on a random 20% of the Row 1 u~Bend tubes of both steam generators. All U-Bend tubes were tested as planned using a Zetec Inc. manufactured U-Bend style +Point RPC probe, M+Point-580-MRPC-FH (0.580" dia.). The U-Bend +Point RPC tests were performed in accordance with ACTS, CPAL-05-196 (refer to Appendix XIV.A.3). The probe test speed was 0.2 inches per second, rotating at 300 rpm's, at 450 samples per second. The test frequencies used were 300 kHz, 200 kHz, 100 kHz and 10 kHz. The test extents were from the top tube support plate on the cold leg to the. top tube support plate on the hot leg.

Data Analysis

Westinghouse performed an on-line network primary and secondary analysis of all eddy current data. All data analysis utilized for both primary and secondary used the Westinghouse designed UNIX . based ,4.NSER Acquisition and Analysis System. The data analysis was performed on-line with data acquisition through 'the utilization of a fiber optic network via a T-1 telephone line to the · Westinghouse Waltz Mill Site where primary and secondary analysis was performed. Resolution analysis was also performed at the Waltz Mill site.

-~ .

· The guidelines governing data analysis were determined by the CPCo cognizant ET Level III and contained in Palisades Nuclear P!ant Data Analysis Guideline~, DAT:.GYD-001 (refer to Appendix IV.A.5 and B.6).· . . .

5.0 Mechanical Tube Plugging

As a result of the tube degradation (axial cracking and wear) found during the eddy current testing, a total of four tubes (two for axial cracking Rl C54 and R34 CS l and two for volumetric wear Rl 16 Cl2S and Rl28 ClOS) were required to be plugged iii Steam Generator A tliis outage. All mechanical plugs were ins.tailed in accordance with Westinghouse/CPCO MRS 2.3.2 GEN-13, Mechanical Plugging of Steam Generator Tubes (refer to Appendix V), all mechanical plugs installed this outage were Inconel 690 (refer to Appendix XV.D). The following table summarizes the tubes plugged this outage:·

7

' 1

,.

CPAL-9

Summmy of Tubes Plugged This Outage

SIGA SIG B

4 0

Detailed plugging lists and tubesheet maps showing tubes mechanically plugged this outage cari be found in Appendix V.A.3, 4 and S of this report. The mechanical plugging Process Control Sheets and plug log sheets can be found in Appendix V.A.2.

The four mechanical plugs in the hot leg of Steam Generator A were installed robotically using ROSA, the four in the cold leg were installed hands on which required pre-marking of the tubesheet in accordance with Westinghouse/CPCo procedure MRS 2.2.2 GEN-12, Steam Generator Tubesheet Marking (refer to Appendix V.A.l).

6.0 Tube Stabilization

Due to wear detected by eddy current in one tube (Rl28 Cl OS) in Steam Generator A hot leg at the top of tubesheet a Westinghouse stabiliz.er was installed. The tube was pre-marked, in accordance with Westinghou-se/CPCo procedure MRS 2.2.2 GEN-12, Steam Generator . .

Tubesheet Marking (refer to Appendix V.A.l)~ then the stabiliz.er was installed remotely using a ROSA single eddy current end effector and 718" guidance conduit. To hold the stabiliz.er in place until a mechanical plug could be installed a carrier assembly, that screws into the

... expan~ioil device in the mechanical plug that's swaged onfo the end of the stabiliz.er, was installed on the end of the stabiliz.er. · After the installation of the stabiiiz.er the tube end in the hot leg was mechanically plugged .with an Inconel 690 plug. The following table summariz.es the tubes stabilized this outage:

Summmy of Tubei Stabilized This Outage ·

SIGA SIG B

1 0

A stabilization lists and tubesheet map showing the tube' stabiliz.ed this outage can be found in .Appendix V.A.3 and 4 of this report .. The stabilization Record Data Sheet can be found in procedure MRS 2.3.2 GEN-13, Mechanical Plugging of Stean;t Generator Tubes, page 64,

. Appendix V.A.2. ·

8

e·

CPAL-9

7.0 Steam Generator Secondary Manway Cover Removal and Installation

Steam Generator A and B manway covers were removed, studholes, studs, nuts, flanges and covers were cleaned and inspected and any abnormalities were recorded. The CPCo NOT inspection results can be found in Appendix VI.A and B of this report. Westinghouse removed and installed the secondary manway covers on Steam Generators A and B in accordance procedure SSS 2.4.2 CPAL-1, Steam Generator Secondary Manway Cover Removal and Reinstallation (refer to Appendix VI.A. I & 2 and B. l & 2). Note, Steam Generator B outboard manway stud number 9 was replaced this outage.

8.0 Handhole Cover Removal and Installation

Due to eddy current identifying a possible loose part at the top of the tubesheet on the secondary side in Steam Generator A one handhole cover (west side) was removed, in accordance with Westinghouse/CPCo procedure SSS-CPALl-MSS-M-3, Removal and Installation of Secondary Handhole Covers of Steam Generators (refer to Appendix VIII.A), early so that FOSAR could be performed prior to sludge lancing. After the FOSAR the handhole cover was reinstalled so the Steam Generator could be filled with water to perform the secondary side inspections. After the secondary side inspections were completed the secondary side water was drained and both handholes were removed for sludge lancing.

Handhole cover removal and installation was performed in accordance with Westinghouse/CPCo procedure SSS-CPALI-MSS-M-3,. Removal and Installation of Secondary Handhole Covers of Steam Generators (refer to Appendix VIII.B and C). The studs, studholes, .nuts, flanges and covers were cleaned and inspected in accordance with the procedure and were found to be acceptable for re-installation, refer to Appendix VIII.B and C for CPCo NOT inspection results.

9.0 Steam Drum Inspection

Steam Drum Inspections were performed in accordance with Westinghouse/CPCo procedure SSS 2.4.2 CPAL-2, Secondary Side Steam Generator Inspection (refer to.Appendix XII.A, B, C and D), in Steam Generators A and B. These inspections consisted of the following:

o Below Separator Can Deck. o Tube Supports o Feedring o J Nozzles o Above Separator Can Deck o Above Dryer Deck

The inspections were visual and portions were video taped, The video tapes were given to the Consumers Power Company representative. In Steam Generator A, two of the bat wings were discovered to be bent, this condition was reported to the Consumers Power Company representative.

9

CPAL-9

10.0 Upper Support Plate Inspection

Westinghouse/Brooks performed a support plate inspection in accordance with Westinghouse/CPCo procedure SSS 2.4.2 CPAL, Remote Examination and Removal of Foreign Objects from Steam Generator Secondary Side (refer to Appendix IX.C), in Steam Generator B only, using a Welsh Allyn camera probe. The top of the support plate was inspected using one of the inspection ports located at the U-Bend. This inspection was in addition to the Brooks performed SID inspection in Steam Generators A and B, see Section 11.0 of this report. All edited copies of the video inspections were turned over to Consumers Power Company.

11.0 SID Inspection

Brooks SID inspection equipment was used in accordance with Westinghouse/CPCo procedure SSS 2.4.2 CPAL-3, Steain Generator Upper Bundle Support Plate Inspection (S.I.D.) (refer to Appendix XI), to inspect tube to support plate crevice flow holes, quatrefoils and egg crates at each elevation up to the bat wings. This inspection was performed in both Steam Generators A and B.

12.0 Sludge Lance Cleaning and Bundle Flushing

Tubesheet Cleaning was performed in both Palisades CE series 2530 steam generators in· accordance with procedure SSS 2.2.2 CPAL-2, C.E. Replacement Steam Generator Tubesheet Cleaning (refer to Appendix IX). A total of 166 lbs. of sludge was removed .. A minimum of three complete tubesheet coverages were applied. Cleanliness inspection videos showed each of the two steam generators to be clean. As part of the steam generator cleaning a bundle flush was performed prior to sludge lancing which consisted of high pressure water being sprayed at the top of the tube bundle including the egg crates and support plate to wash down any loose sludge.

Sludge samples were collected from each steam generator, and were turned over to Consumers Power Company Chemistry for analysis.

Tubesheet Cleaning was performed on both the Palisades Series 2530 steam generators with the following results:

$lr81·~~N1~M.1911 i -$1i~Gl:1t1t\¥~n A 82.5 lbs.

83.5 lbs.

166 lbs.

10

CPAL-9

NOTE The Westinghouse lance system was used to direct high pressure water spray between the tube columns while peripheral headers created an annulus flow to aid in removal of sludge by the suction headers. The sludge and water slurry was introduced to the filter system where the sludge was gathered and the water recirculated. The Tubesheet Cleaning computer, programmed to index and oscillate for a CE Series 2530 steam generator, controlled movement of the lance once water alignment was visually set between the tube columns. A specific variable angular velocity program was used to control the sweeping motion of the lance jets for more efficient cleaning of the tubesheet.

Cleanliness inspection was performed using a video probe and processor. The inspections showed the tubesheet annulus and tubelanes to be clean of sludge. Sludge samples were collected for each steam generator and turned over to Consumers Power Company Chemistry for analysis.

13.0 Foreign Object Search and Retrieval (FOSAR)

An additional FOSAR in accordance with Westinghouse/CPCo procedure SSS 2.4.2 CPAL, Remote Examination and Removal of Foreign Objects from Steam Gener.ator Secondary Side (refer to Appendix X.A) was performed in Steam Generator A prior to sludge lancing because eddy current identified a possible loose part at the top of the tubesheet at tube locations Rl33 Cl04/Rl32 Cl05. The loose part was located but wasn't able to be removed during this attempt. However, during the post sludge lance FOSAR it was retrieved.

Visual inspections of the Steam Generator tubesheet annulus and tubelanes were performed in accordance with Westinghouse/CPCo procedure SSS 2.4.2 CPAL, Remote Examination and Removal of Foreign Objects from Steam Generator Secondary Side (refer to Appendix X.B and C) using the Welsh Allyn system. Inbundle inspections were performed in Steam Generators A and B using the tubesheet cleaning handhole ports. The inspections were video taped and duplicate copies were turned over to Consumer Power Company for review.· Positions of identified objects were listed in accordance with the procedure for future reference. Retrieval efforts were accomplished using Wolf tools and specially designed· retrieval equipment relative to the objects position in the steam generator. Attempts to retrieve objects found in the steam generators were made by the FOSAR crew based on Consumers Power Company request.

11

. ._-• _, > ...

' H "I ·' -:~;

~

~ ..... J ;~

CPAL-9

A list of objects found during the FOSAR inspection is listed in the following table:

Sludge Rock R89 C20 Cold Leg Removed

Bundle of Wire Bristles Rl26 C50 Cold Leg Removed

14.0 Main Condenser Eddy Current Inspection

Background

During the 1990/1991 Palisades Steam Generator replacement outage, a complete rebuild of the main condenser was performed. The design of the unit .was changed to improve the heat transfer characteristics of the unit. ·

· To help accomplish this, the manufac~re, Yuba Inc., used a tubing material made from 1.00" O.D. x 0.028" wall 439 stainless steel. The condenser tubing .is 70 feet in length and. supported by 33 carbon steel support plates located on approximately 24.5" centers. The inlet and outlet tubesheets are manufactured from 304 stainless steel 1.25" thick.

Palisades has two condensers, east and west with three banks of tubes each. Each bank contains 4,099 tubes for a total of 12,297 tubes per condenser.

A baseline eddy current examination .of the replacement main condensers was conducted by .the NOT Services Department and was requested by the Energy Supply Services, ProjectConstruction and Equipment Department. To accomplish this an evaluation of testing methods was performed to determine the best method presently available in the industry to inspect this type of material.

The 400 series stainless steel material is a ferromagnetic alloy that is not easily inspectable by conventional eddy current methods. There were three methods that were evaluated that appeared to have the greatest potential of success; i) remote-field eddy current, ii) flux-leakage and iii) magnetic biased eddy current. A study performed by the Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI) NOE Center indicated that for this particular application the magnetic biased technique would provide the best results. In addition to the information provided by the EPRI results, the added benefit to the magnetic biased technique was that it was compatible with

12

CPAl.r9

conventional eddy current instrumentation.

Two prototype probes, Carter 1 probes, were obtained from Chalk River Laboratories of Canada, who had m.anufactured the probes for the EPRI study. The intention was to determine the reliability and repeatability of the technique. The evaluation indicated that the technique did have the ability to detect and siu A.S.M.E. type defects within the limits of normal eddy current capabilities. The limitation to this method is that no defect information can be obtained in the area adjacent to and under the carbon steel support plates. This is due to the effect of the magnetic fields of the satUration magnets taking the path of least reluctance through the carbon steel support plates. This results in an insufficient saturation in the tube material, which is required for suppression of the permeability variations inherent in the 439 . stainless steel material .. With the exception ofthis limitation the probe did provide repeatable results on the machined O.D. defects of the A.S.M.E. calibration standard. The other methods evaluated by EPRI, although providing repeatable detection capabilities, did not have the sizing capabilities required for this examination. For these reasons it was decided by NOT Services that the magnetic biased technique would provide the most reliable defect information and should ~e implemented for the main condenser baseline eddy current examination~

This probe, the Carter 1, was used for the 1992 and the 1993 miilit condenser eddy current inspections. A second probe, called the Hilborn probe, was also ~sed during the 1992· and 1993 eddy current inspections in addition to the Carter 1 probe. The Hilborn probe was designed to be used only as a GO NO-GO gauging device for detection of gross fretting wear under support plate structures. To that point, none was detected with this probe.

In a continuing effort to improve the examination techniques for inspection of the main condensers, the Remote Field Technology (RFT) was qualified in January 1995. This technique was proven to be reliable for the detection of repairable indications at the support plate and was also able to reliably detect and siu free span indications. This technique was proven to provide a "total test" for the Palisades main condensers.

The RFT technique utilius the "remote" or "fat" field induced by an energized coil to detect flaw indications. Conventional eddy current testing makes use of a "direct-coupling" or "near field" technique which is not very efficient when testing permeable material. The RFT technique is also relatively unaffected by deposits, scale, geometry and permeability variations and is very effective in testing ferrous tub'ing.

Scope of Examination

The scope of the main condenser examination was to be a 20% sample which included all peripheral tubes in all banks of both water boxes. ·All work was performed in accordance with Westinghouse/CPCo procedure MRS 2.4.2 GEN-39, MIZ40 Remote Field Technology Examination of Heat Exchanger Tubes (refer to Appendix XIII). The following table lists the total number of main condenser tubes inspected:

13

CPAl.r9

Original Scope Expanded Scope ·

West Water Box 2628 2847

East Water Box 2661 2908

· The expansions bounded areas where indications were found.

Examination Results

A separate report "RFT Examination Final Report, Palisades Nuclear Plant, Consumers Power Company, Main Condenser, November 1996" will be issued by ANATEC covering the details of this examination.

14

--

-•.

CPAL-9

C. GENERAL

All applicable personnel qualifications, equipment calibration, standard certifications and supporting data can be found in the various Appendices of this report as listed in the TABLE OF CONTENTS. Procedures and sign-offs can be found in the various CPCo Work Orders as listed in the TABLE OF CONTENTS.

15

CPAL-9

D. CERTIFICATION

The services provided as described in this report meet the contract requirements of Westinghouse General Order Number DTE 50246.

Prepared By:

![. (l . /Utt;(' R. A. Pollice Senior Field Service Engineer Steam Generator Services

and

R.R. Daubar Senior Field Service Engineer Steam Generator Services

16

Approved By:

~ Manager, Steam Generator Field Service Operations

T. H. Dent Manager, Steam Generator Services

«*~~<'OQA-jo o~A-o<• D. Alsing Manager, W NSD Operations Quality Assurance

SUPERTUBIN REPORT USERS' GUIDE

REPORT RECORD FIELD DESCRIPTIONS

1: ROW· COL - COLUMN coo~dinate system

tube identifier numbers an X-Y

2. PLAN - a number representing a set or sets of test extents and tube locations that define which tubes and what sections of these tubes will be tested

3. RE-B - REQUIRED BEGIN TEST - tube location ~here the tape recorder is to be turned on and the test is to begin -defined by PLAN

4. RE-E - REQUIRED END TEST tube location where the tape recorder is to be turned off and the test is to end; typically one of the tube ends .; defined. by PLAN

5. CE-B - COMPLETED BEGIN TEST - tub~ location where the test actually began - tape recorder turned-bn

6. CE~E COMPLETED END ·TEST - tube location where the test actually ended - tape recorder turned.off

7. PROBE - diameter of probe used in test

8. TYPE - characters representing the TYPE of PROBE used, e.g., . BBM, SFRM, etc.

9. IND INDICATION character codes and numerics that ·represent the analysis results of the data for the tube, e.g.,. NOD~ 25%, etc. this is the key field in the data record

10. LOCN - .LOCATION - the location in the tube of the INDICATION called

11. INCH1 - distance above or below LOCATION where the INDICATION . is found.

- 1 - November 20, 1996


12. INCH2 - typically the distance above INCH1 that a particular INDICATION extends as in a copper deposit extending over a portion of a tube above a support plate - in special cases, INCH2 may represent other measurements as in F Star, and Cracking algorithm applications ·.

13. CHAN CHANNEL describes the data channel used in determining the indication value listed in the INDICATION field

14. VOLTS and . DEG DEGREES characteristics of the analysis ·field

these describe the signal result in the INDICATION

15. TAPE - sequential, number of the data cartridge containing the data that the INDICATION was called from

16. OPER OPERATOR INITIALS - the initials of the operator who collected the data re~orted in this record

17. ANA - ANALYST INITIALS - the initials. of the analyst who analyzed the data reported in this record

18. COMMENTS holds 50 character phrases that provide further meaning to the INDICATION in the record, e.g., retest extent remarks, etc.

·- 2 - November 20, 1996

e

e

e.


INDICATION TERMS

· The .following are brief descriptions of the terms that can be found in the INDICATION field of SUPERTUBIN data records. These terms generally impart the key meaning to the data record. This meaning is supported by information in the other fields. These descriptions are not intended to be comprehensive from a technical analysis point of view. For · further info~mation concerning the meaning and use of these terms, you may consult the lead analyst on the job or the Westinghouse data analysis guidelines.

It is important to note the following definitions of. terms used in these descriptions:

ANOMALY - A REPORTED TUBE CHARACTERISTIC THAT DOES NOT DEPICT POSSIBLE TUBE WALL LOSS OR TUBE WALL INTEGRITY DEGRADATION, E.G., D, PV.

INDICATION - AN ANALYSIS RESULT THAT DEPICTS A POSSIBLE TUBE WALL LOSS CONDITION OR TUBE WALL INTEGRITY DEGRADATION

DEFECT - AN INDICATION WHOSE VALUE EQUALS OR EXCEEDS AN ESTABLISHED PLUGGING LIMIT .

.,

~ . Note: For definitions of indication codes used during this inspection, please see the site or Westinghouse analysis guidelines. See Appendix A, pa.'l es 49 - 5-9- 54.

- 3 - November 20, 1996

•.


LOCATION TERMS DESCRIPTION

. TERMS:

1.

2.

3.

4.

TEH, TEC - TUBE END HOT and COLD

TRH, TRC - TOP OF ROLL HOT and COLD (tube end roll)

TSH, TSC - TOP OF TUBESHEET HOT and COLD

BPH, BPC·. - BAFFLE PLATE HOT and COLD (in certain S/G series, e.g. , 51 -F, 44-F, D, F, etc.) .

. ·, /, ,., \ ..

- 4 - November 20, 1~96

-·

SUPERTUBIN REPORT USERS 1 GUIDE ...

5.

SLEEVE LOCATIONS

LXH, LXC lower expansion hot/cold LRH, LRC ~ lower roll hot/cold URH, URC - upper roll hot/cold UXH, UXC - upper expansion hot/cold STH, STC - sleeve top hot/cold

6. #H, #C - (#=NUMBER) of SUPPORT PLATE HOT and COLD, e.g., 03H, 04C, 07H, etc

. 7. TH, TC - TANGENT POINT HOT and COLD (location just above top support plate where bending begins)

8. AV1, AV2, AV3, AV4, AV5,. AV6, -·ANTI-VIBRATION BARS

9. V14, V23 - used in AVB geometry analysis to refer to the two AVB. bars respectively .

10. BW1, BW2, BW3 - BAT WINGS - CE S/G'S

11. VS1, VS2, VS3 - VERTICAL STRAPS -·CE $/G'S

12. UB - describes area from TOP SUPPORT PLATE HO"t to TOP SUPPORT PLATE COLD

- 5 - November 20, 1996

)

. )

SUPERTUBIN REPORT USERS' GUIDE ,.

PROBE TYPE CODE DESCRIPTION TABLE

CODE DESCRIPTION ·

EB . WESTINGHOUSE - LLMC - LONG LIFE BOBBIN

ZP

UP

zc

ZETEC

ZETEC

ZETEC

PLUS POINT.

U-BEND PLUS POINT

3 - COIL

note: "xxx" represents the numeric diameter of the probe, e.g., .720, 680, etc.

- 6 - November 20, 1996

·e

e.

•

APPENDIX A

LETTER CODES

The following is a list of terms, and the definitions for each, that are co11111only used during the field analysis process. As each plant has its own preferences, there may be an occasfon where a term.is needed that is not listed. In such a case the analyst would confer with the Overall Lead Analyst and with the Lead Data Management individual to establish the necessary term that best.describes the condition so that the customer receives as accurate a report as possible. The terms used herein are separated into 7 sections. The first section contains codes which are coD1Don to all probe types and a corresponding definition for each.

Section II through VII apply to each individual probe.type.

The letter codes to be used with a particular type of probe and their corresponding definitions shall be included in thei~ corresponding sections~ Codes which are common to all probe types without definitions will be included with each section to simplify referral.

A. CODES COMMON TO ALL PROBE TYPES

The following codes may be used for any probe type:

1. BOA - ·~ad Data• Used to.signify th~t the data for a particular . tube· cannot be .analyzed for one or more reasons, ·e.g., noise lever,

bad probe, etc. Requires completed test and extent, and shall be retested over required extent.

2. NOD - •No Detectable Degradation• Only requirement for reporting is S/G, Row, Column, and extent tested.

3. NT - •No Test• Tube is e~coded on ~he.T-li~t but no data or recognizable data is recorded. N~ extent tested required. .

4. PIO - •Positive I.o.• Utilized to verify the tube/I.D. of.~n indication from a tube containing an indication which was tested previously during the same inspection. Normally associated with pluggable indications. Graphics plot required. ·

5 .. PLG •.Plugged Tube•

6. PLP •Possible Loose Part• ,.

7. PVN - •Permeability Variation•· Requires location, range (if applicable), volts, phase angle, and channel.

8. RST - •Restricted Tube• Tube contains a restriction which prevents passage of the probe being used. Analysis required for portion of tube completed. Also requires message from collector that tube is restricted. Requires extent of tube inspected .

Page 49 ANALR[V6:49

9. ,S.tH - •see Conment• Allows for an analyst to describe the condition of a call or reason for making the particular call. To be used only as a way to further quantify or describe a·tube cond i ti-on • ·

10. TIU - •rube ID Uncertain• The tube will be retested for I.D. verification.

8. BOBBIN COIL CODES

ANALR[V6:50

1. ADS - •Absolute Drift Signal• Used when the analyst detects a positive •y• and negative •x• component on an absolute OD mix elimination signal. Considered an unquantifiable signal flagged for future monitoring. Has been determined under laboratory · examination of S/G tube samples to signify a possible •1GA• condition; however, it is not confined to such a phenomenon. Requires location and range if applicable and channel. GRAPHICS PLOT REOU I RED

2. ANF - •Anomaly Not Found" Used by an analyst when a previously reported anomaly cannot be located within o.so• of the previously ca l1 ed anomaly.

3. ANR - •Anomaly Not Reportable• Used by an analyst when a previously reported anomaly does not meet the present reporting criteria.

4. BOA - •ead Data•

s. BLG - •eulged• tube Requires location, volts, phase angle, and channel.

6. CUD-· Indicates the presence of •copper• deposits. Requires location and range if applicable, volts, phase angle and channel.

7. ONT - Indicates •oent• in the tubing. To be analyzed from prime frequency or mix as applicable recording locatfon, volts, phase angle, and channel. ·

8. 1lJ. - Indicates •oistorted Indication• to be used in lieu of a percent (~) through wall value on a signal that the analyst believes to be an indication but too distorted to quantify~ Further clarification with RPC is required. This code is only used instead of NQI, OSI, and OTI if site specifics requires. This code is changed to DIN if subsequent RPC test does not confinn. GRAPHICS PLOT REQUIRED.

9. ORI - Indicates a •oistorted Roll Transition Indication•. This is a special case ·1-code• used to define suspect roll transitions

.occuring at the top of tubesheet, or in partially expanded tubes near the tube end. This indication is treated the same as all other I-codes in the data base and requires RPC for further clarification. This code is changed to ORN if subsequent RPC test does not confirm the indication. Graohics olot required.

Page 50

(

•

i e ANAlR(Vfi: 51

Bobbin Coil Codes (continue<I>

IO. OSI - Indicates •oistorted Support Indication• - An I-code used in lieu of a(~) through·wa11· value on a signal located within or extending out from a suoport structure which the analyst believes to be an indication but too distorted to quantify. This indication is treated the same as all other I-codes in the database and requires RPC for further clarification~ This code is changed to OSN if subsequent RPC does not.confirm the indication. Graphics Plot Required.

11. DTI - Indicates •01storted Tubesheet Indication• - I-code used in lieu of a (~) through wall value on a signal starting within o.s• of the top of tubesheet and extending out from or down into the tubesheet which the analyst believes to be an indication but too distorted to quantify. This indication is treated the same as all other I-codes in the database and requires RPC for further clarification. This code is changed to OTN if subsequent RPC does not confirm the indication. Graphics Plot Regui'red.

12. INF - Indicates •1i:adication Not Found•. Used by an analyst when a previously reported indication cannot be detected within o.so• of the previously reported indication.

13. INR - Indicates •Indication Hot Reportable•. Similar to •1Nf• except signal is present; however, current analysis results do not meet pre-established guidelines on signal reporting.

14. MBH - Indicates •Manufacturing Buff Hark. Reference Appendix 0 for suggested disposition techniques. This call should be us.~ for baseline examinations only.

-15. MMB - .Indicates •Multiple Manufacturing Buff Harks•, usually-over a

range. Reference Appendix 0 for suggested disposition techniques. Normally used in baseline examinations only. t

16. NOD - •No Detectable Degradation•.

17. t!Ql - Indicates •Non Quantifiable Indication• - An 1-cOde used in lieu of a (~) through wall value on a signal located in free span area of the tube which the analyst believes to be an indication but too distorted to quantify. This indication is treated the same as· a 11 other. I -codes in the database and requires RPC for further clarification. This code is changed to NQN Jf subsequent RPC does not confirm the.indication. Graphics Plot Required. ·

18. NT - ·No TEsT·

19. NTE "No Tubesheet Expansion•

20. PIO "PosiUve m•. Graphics Plot Required

21. PLG - "Plugged Tube•

22. PLP - "Possible loose Part"

Page SI

i

Bobbin Coil Codes <continued)

23. ~ - Indicates the presence of a •Permeability Variation•.

24.

25.

26

Requires 1 ocat ion, and range ·if app 1i cab 1 e, vo 1 ts, phase ang 1 e and Ch:' ·el.

Rs·

<".

~·L-•• de··

•Restricted Tube•

•see Convnent•

- Indicates •sludge•. Used in measuring or quantifying ·~its which lie on the 0.0. of the tubing.

27. sp,: - Indicates •shot Peen Anomaly.• Located either at start point or throughout shot peened region. This region is typically from inside tubesheet to about 3 inches above tubesheet. Signal resembles a bulge but rotates closer to the flaw plane on differential channels.

28. SOR - lndica.tes a •squirrel•. ·Considered to be a special case of distorted indication confined to within-the unexpanded portion of the tubesheet (TS) regions only. A defect that historically has proven detrimental to the tube integrity and indicates a normally pluggable condition even though the signal is unquantifiable .. GRAPHICS PLOT REQUIRED . .

29. TIU - Indicates •rube ID Uncertain•. The tube will be retested. for fc),·eri fi cat ion.

30. UD~ Indicates •undefinable Signal•. To be used when an analyst ~ de~ . ts a signal that cannot be classified as tube degradation, W

·how·· ~r, it is reconmended that during future examinations .this pan·. ::ular signal should be mon.itored. Can best be described as a mea~- of establishing a data ba~e on unclassifiable signals to better understand their meaning from future analysis. GRAPHICS PLOT REQUIRED.

C. ROTATING PANCAKE COILS CRPC) CODES

ANALREV6:SZ

The RPC probe is normally used as a supplemental test to clarify Sxl and bobbin coil results. It is useful in all areas of tubes, particularly roll or expansion transitions, tubesheet and support plate intersections, and low row-u-bend tangent points. When used in these areas to clarify previous calls, it is anticipated that.the predominant mode of degradation will be the presence of cracks, from.either primary side or secondary side of the tubing. These indfcations are typically oriented close to the transition being inspected. For those areas contained in the scan area of the test, the analyst must continually be aware that other forms of degradation may exist which may not be cracks. This is more likely to be true at locations •away• from the transition being inspected. Those non-directional signals which appear to be characterisitic of pitting or general wastage may be assigned a percent value if appropriate. In this case the analyst must also be aware that multiple cracks can also appear to be nondirectional. For

Page 52

this reason. the analyst must exercise caution when assigning a percent c,all to an indication. The following letter codes apply to crack-like indications only. . . . . . .

1. SCI - •single Circumferentially Oriented Indication•. This term is to be used when the isometric plot depicts a crack-like indication whose _axial extent is usually less than. its circumferential extent. This type of indication is normally located within transition areas or dented support plate edges.

' '

2. MCI - •Multiple Circumferentially Oriented Indications• Same definition as SCI except more than one SCI is present. Requires LIG measurements.

3. SAi - •single Axial Indication• When displayed in an isometric plot, this indication will usually have an axial extent which is greater than its circumferential extent. This indication may be found immediately adjacent to transitions (or dents) and may run into or through the transition (or dent)°. in free length tubing. e.g., in sludge pile areas, as well as in small radius u-bends.

4. MAI - "Multiple Axial Indications• Same definition as SAi except more than one SAi is present. Requires LIG meas~rements.·

5. LIG - •Liga~ent• Used as an additional measurement where multiple crack-like indications are present in the same axial location are called. •L1G• denotes the "clean• space between the indications. LIG is measured in circumferential degrees and extends from null return of one indication to null departure of the illlllediately adjacent indication. All ligaments must be measured and in combination with the indications, should total approximately 360 degrees when a 11 c i rcumferent i a 1 degree measurements are added.

Other letter codes which may be used with RPC are:

6. BOA - "Bad Data"

7. MBM - "Manufacturing Buff Hark•

8. NOD - "No Detectable Degradation•

9. NT - "No Test•

10. PIO "Positive I.o.•

II. PLP - "Possible Loose Part

12. PVN - "Permeability Variation"

13. ·RST - "Restricted"

14. SCH - "See Convnent"

- 15. TIU - "Tube 1.0. Uncertain"

Page 53 ANALR[VG:~J

16. ~ - •undefinable Signal• This indication is used to identify a signal which the analyst cannot characterize as a crack-like indication but believes should be brought to the attention of the customer ··and· Overa 11 Lead Analyst ·for· further· di seus·si on· and· a· potential decision to either continue ~alling and track on subsequent inspections, investigate further by other techniques (e.g., UT or tube pull), and/or repair actions on the basis of conservatism.

0. SURFACE RIDING 8xl COILS C8xll

AllALAEV6:54

1. fl - •Possible Indication• This term can be used for indications detected by the 8xl coil. Percentage calls are not assigned to indications because calibration curves~ not established and the reliability of accurate depth estimates from the Sxl probe is questionable. These indications which stand after the resolution process require confirmation with RPC. Graohics Plot Required

2. Non-indication codes which may also be used are: BOA, NOD, NT, PIO, PLP, PVN, RST, SCM, and Tiu.·

Page 54

• • SG A BOBBIN INSPECTION PROGRAM

x

* [QI

• 1609 TEST FULL LENGTH

25 STAY RODS 309 PLUGGED TUBE

tU1\ Pofisodes Unit 1

\gJ 11-25-1996

CPL -A

11:02 HRS.

SERIES. 2530

SUPERTUBIN

.,._ ·"· .......... ·"· "w".". • . · ... -:-·.. .. ':: .. :: ::- .. · .. · ::·.r. .... . 135

... -: : .... ·: .. : .•: .... :-:•. : . ·= .•. : :- :-" . 130 •• ·.,,.:.· • .. • • : .. • .. ·.,..· :····" • .... :.· • ... ·"ac :,..· • • .. • ':'·· .. • • •• . · .. · .. =· :- : ·: . : . : ... .. =·: : .. ·: : -: : :· .... 125

... :: :: .: •. : .... :: .· .: .. :. ::. ... · .: .. ~: ...... : .:::: ....... · :: .. : ...... :: .: .. : ...... : : . ::;: ." 120 .M ,..• M M.• ... IC ... M ... • M M 11111.• M Jiii .111 M 1111• M M.• M •

. f :a: . .E.. ~~ .E. ·':· }~ .. .E. ·':· ~2 .. : . .E. -~~ .: .. : .. 2~ ~a:- .E..:. g .... 2. -~~ .:. ·':· f ~:. _;_ ·':· ~2: :: . . ~~ ·= .. :: .. : :.: E .. :: : E ... :: " : ':: : .. :: :" : .. :: ... : :.: : .. :: :M : .. :: .. :·. 105

.. : ·: .... :.:. .. : .:.: : .. :: :-. : ... :: ·"· : . : : ~ .. :: : . : .... :: ... : .:.: : ... :: :•. : .. :: .... : . : :- 100 : .......... • :·• M •,..• :••M• M •M:••M•M• M :-• • •,..• -:••11111• • •M:•· ·,..• • :-· 1111. •,..• :••M• M • ... :.• • • M jM• • •,..• ':'··~

•:• :.. M •': M M •: : M ... : M M •': : M: M :• :M M •: JI •: : JI ./4•: : M •M : M: M • • 95 • .... • .. ... "a.. ... ... ... ..· .... :.c. ·.. .. ... . . .. .... . .. .. . .. .. ... .. ..· ·" " . • " " . . .. .

.:.· ·:: ::. . ·:· · .. · :;·.:.. ·:· ·~; ·:···:.· ·::: .. ·:·.:.. ::· · .. · ·:·. ;: ·:· · .. : ·:: ::. . ·:· · ... · =:· ... ·:· ·~: ·:·. ~. ·:: :·: ·:·. ~. ::· ·.··:·.a::·:··.··=· 8.590 ... • -:-.. ·M :- .. M :- .. M M:- M M :.. M ;,• ·=-- M :- M M :- M .. •C: • M M :... M • • M M:-

• = =Z· ·z· ·==: . ..z. -a:-:;.·.·. a:. -a::.:.·.· -Z=:. · .:. ·. · =Z· ·':· .:. · =: .z_.o: .. :=:. · .z. ·':· ==· ·. · .z. -a::.:.·.· .z= :a:··=··.· =z. ·':· ·=· · :: .z ...... := :: . . so • • .. ... • .. .. ·.. -<:: ... .. •• ... .. ... .. ... • • .. .... • .. .. ·... .. ... .. ... ·"' "' ·,. .. ... . • .. ,.·. ·.. 75 •·• .. ...... .. • ...... · ....... ·. .. .. ·.. .. ... .. ..·.1111 " · ...... · ... 1111 .. ·. "' ·.. .. .... ... • .... .

.. : _;.: : •• :: : ... : •• :-: .... : • : : : .... :: : • : .... :: •• : .:.: : •• :: : ... : •• :: •• : • -: : .'\c :: : • : ·"· :: •• : _;.: : •• :: : ... :: • 70 ·=· ::· .. ·.)' ·:::····· .. ::· ..... -::·:· . · .. ::" ·:· ··:-:· .. ·:· ::· ... ·:::· · .. · .. ::· ·.· .. · -::·:· . ··::"' ...... :':'· .. ·:· ·~· .. · . ·:::· · .. · . ... ;.- .. .. ... . .. .. ... .. ... .. ... . .. .... .. .. ·. .. .. ... . " .. ·.. .. ... " •. ·" "' ·.. " " .. ,.. .. ... . .. ... 65 ·:: .-: : .. ::::".:: .. :;. :. : .:: : .". :=: . : .·.:: .. : .':: ': .. :::".: .. :: .. : .:: : .•. ::: . : :.:: .. : .':':: .. :::" .... :- 60 • • .. • • • .. • • • • M • • • • • M • • • • • M • • • • • M • • • • • M • • • • • M • • • • • IC• • • • • .. • • • • • M·• • • • • 1i11 • • • • • N •"'• • • :· M :: .. M ::: : M:: M -::: ::: : :: Ill: ::Ill M ::: : 1111:: : -::: :::• M :: M: ::: M ::: : "::. ____ 55

• M Ill • • M M ... • M M • • M M• M ... •M M •" M M • • "'• • M M •" M ... M "• •• M •"' 11111 11111 • 11111 11111. • M .11111. • .. .· ...... ... .. .·.. .. .· ..... · .. . .• .. .·.. .. .· ...... · ..... · •.·.. .. ·"· 50 .......... ·.·.•.·.·.•.·.·.•.·.· ........... ·.- .... ·.·.•.·.·.•.·.·.•.·.·.•.· .·.·.•.·.·.•.·.- ..... ••• .... ·.•.·.·.· .... ••• .... ••• .... • ·.11111.·.· .... ·.• .... ·---.. • .. • .. ... ... .. ... .. .. • ..... •.· .. .. ... ... ... .... '\c "·. • ""'·" • • • ... • .. ... .

: ~; .. ; .. a.-~~ .E .. ; .. a~ L- .E. .;. ~; ...... E. -~~.a ...... E~ ~~ .. a.. =.. _;.-Ft ..... 2j ~;. -~--.. ~~; .. ;. t -~~ .E. -~· t C. .E. .;. ~2. :::-~ •• ·: : ·: :: :-:• : ·: • :: -: : ,. :·: : I : -: : " :-: • • ·= -: •: : :· >c : ·: .. • ·-- 35 • •,. M M •. M M .. •• • M M ... M M,. M ,.•. M • 1111 "'• 1111 ........ 1111 •,.. 1111 M •. Iii M IC•• IC M ·.. • ;;· ~=· .... ·:·. ~: ·:· .... ·=~ ;;.· ·:· · .. · ~=·. ;." ·:· ·~: ·:· ";.. ·=~ : .. · ·:·. ·:· ·~: ·:· ";.. ·=~ :·· ·=·.;.. ~=· · .. · ·:·. ;: ·:· ... ·=~ ::. . ·:· .... } ";.. =: ~

.:· :;. .. : ..-: .... :::" .... :": .... ;.: : .... :: .. : • •.• ;.: : .... ::. : • :~ " : ':':.. -:::" ... :: • ·:C • . . . . ·=· ... ·=· .. : ·=· ...... :.: .. ·=· ... ·=· ... ·=· .. : ·=· ... ·=·: .. ·=·:. ·=· .. : ·=· ... ·=·: ........... ·=· ... ·=· .. : ·=· ... ·=·: .. ·=· ... ·=· ... -~ 20 : .. :: ... : ~: : .. :::- : .. :a: .. : :: : • ::: :: : :: : .. ::: ... ~ . :: .. : ~: : .. :::- : ·.:: •. :- 1.5

:: ·':'· :Z· · .. · .:. ·:: .z. · .. ·.:;:a:· .z. · .. · ;:. ·':· .;. -~: .:. ·':· -Z::. ·? =~: .:. ·':· -Z::... .z. ·':· :Z· · .. · .:. ·:: .;. · .. · -E: :':· -~· · .. · ::. ·':·. ':: :- 10 : •: M : •:: M :•: : M •: : -: : :•:M-• M:: :•:IC : •: M : •:: :•: : M •: : ~5 1·':'·r··j·"··r-"·j····1·':·T"·.·r·~i"".·1···-r··l·-= 1· ... -r· ... 1····j··':·r··j·"··t·"·j····i=·':·T··r··~i .... ·

1.Q:I\ UU\ ii\" '°'1\ 1Ac; 1An 141c; 1"11\ fl')C fl'lft 4U:: 441'\ 41\C 41'\I\ l\r ""' f'\r '"'" -.r .... ,... ...... _ ,.._ ...... _ -- · - · - -- -- - - - - - ·· 167 160 15!> l~O 145" llfO ·~5" ·~o 1z.-r '~ ,,, llO lo? 100 9~ ·90 85 so 75 ?O 6~ 60 55 5° 4? "lo ,, '30 2S 1.o 15" 10 )

• • • SG - A TOP OF TUBESHEET RPC PROGRAM

ORIGINAL PROGRAM I 1714 TEST TOP OF TUBESHEET +/- 3"

HOT LEG WITH RPC PROBE ® Palisades Unit 1 CPL-A SERIES 2530 EXPANDED PROGRAM

I 6196 TEST TOP OF TUBESHEET +/- 311 WITH RPC PROBE

11-25-1996 . 11:32 HRS. SUPERTUBIN * 25 STAY ROD

IQ] 309 PLUGGED TUBE

• • • U-BENO RPC PROGRAM

X : 2 4 ORIGINAL PROGRAM X : 59 FIRST EXPANSION X : 35 SECOND EXPANSION

* : 25 STAY !QI : 309 PLUGGED TUBES

w rarisaaes ~nit 1

.• ·.·····:~········::·····.· .. : . ·.·. 135 .•..••••.•• · .........• · .•••. •.·. . 130 ...... :·· ... :·· ... :·· ... :·· ... : ....

. · . . :: :: .. · :: . . . . 125 .·.• . . .· • . . .· . . . . 120 . . ..... : ........ : : ........ : : ........ : : ....... ~ : : ........ : : ........ : : ........ : : ....... .

. ·• . ·: •· .· .· .· .· .· . . 115 .. · ·::.·.· .·. "j~ .·.·.···j~ .·.· ···:=j .·.·.· ·"jj·· .·.···jj .· ... ·.·~j .· ·:. · .. :j· ·.·. ···~j .· ... · .. : '.· ·. ·. . . ~~

.. :~·: ... ·.·~j········ ~~ .·.· .·.·~~········~j········~j······ ··j~ .·.· .·.·~j .· .·. ·.·~j· .. ·.·. ·)j····· ... ) ~- ·.· .... :::·. ~~ ... : . ": ~ ........ : ~ ........ :i .... : ... : ~ ........ : ~ ........ :: ........ :: ........ : ~ ........ : ~ ........ :: ........ :: ........ :: ..... :~ 90

:- . :- :- :- :: • : :- :- -: • :: . . . 85 . : ~ ~ ... ·.· .. : j ........ ~j ... · .... ~ ~ ....... · ~ ~ ........ ~ j ........ ~ ~ ........ ~ ~ ........ ~ j ........ ~ j ........ ~ j ........ j ~ ........ ~ ~ ........ ~::.: ~~

. : : . : ~· ....... \l .; ...... j j ........ ) ~ ... · .... ~) ...... -:~j ........ ~ j ........ j ~ ........ j ~ ... ; .... ~ ~ ........ j ~ ........ j ~ ........ ~~· ....... :: .... :. ~ .. : . · .. : : ....... ·:: ... · .... :: ........ :: ........ :: ........ : : ........ :: ........ ~: ........ :: ........ ~: ........ ~: ........ ~: ........ :: ........ ~: ....... :: 60

: : : .•.· .. :: .... ". ·): ........ :: ... " ... :j ........ :: .... ·" .: : ........ :: . : : .... :: .. " .... :: ........ : : .· ...... :: ........ :: ........ :: ....... )::. ~ :-: .... :: .... :: .... :: .... :: .... :: . . . . :- :- :- :- :- :- ·. 40 .;.· ••. :-· ..• :-· .•. :-· ••• :-· ••• :-· . . . .·.· ·.· .. :········ .. ··:·.·.·.·.· ·.··:·.·.·.·.· ·.··:·.·.·.·.· ·.·::-·.·.·.· .. · ... ·.· ... ·-__ 35

:·:: :: :: :: :: :: ·:-:: ... ·.·.·::.·.·.·.-::.=.·.·.·::.·.·.·.·::.·.·.·.·::.·.·.·. I, I I · .... :; ........ ::.·.·.·.·::.·.·.·.·::.·.·.·.·::.·.·.·.·::.·.·::-30 • . :: :: :: :: :· :: :: :: :: :: :: -: 25 = . : .... ·= .... ·: .... ·= .... : .... ·: ... ·• I ·I ·· :- :- · :- :- ·. ·. · 20 .. ·=· ... ==· ... :=· ... ::- ... :=·........ I i·::·::········::········::········::··-·.·.·::-·.·.·.·::······:

: . : -: : ·= . . 1· !I. ::~=.: ........ :.:_ .. : ...... :.:_ .. ·.·.·.·:.:_ .. ·.·.·.·:.:_ .. ·.·.·.:: .. ~.- .... : .. ·- ~ : : ... :: ........ : : . · ...... ~: ........ :: ........ :: ........ :: ... . ; I. 1 ;· ;· 1 ;· I ;··I 1 1 1 t~+~1~~t1~r1+r!-

5

;;s ;;, ;;;- ;~~ ;;;, ;;;;,;is- ;3~ ;;.~ iio ;;~ ;;;, ;;,5 ,-;,~ 9;- 9;, s~ 80 1;, .;o 6-:; 60 55- 5o ~;- 4o 35- 3~ ;~ i_; ;s- io s-

• • • SG - A INTERSECTION RPC PROGRAM

2 1 TEST 2H +/- 311

* : 25 STAY ROD IQI : 309 PLUGGED TUBE

tU1\ Pafisades Unit 1

\g_) 11-25-1996 13:20 HRS.

CPL -A SER[S 2530

SUPERTUBIN ·

.. ·.·····:~········:~·····.· .. : . ·.·. 135 .·.·:·.·.·.··:··-·.·.·=:··-·.·.·=:··-·.·.·::.·.·.·.·:::·.·.. '00

. . :: :: :- :: : . . 125 .·:·:·.·.·.·.-:: ... ·.·.·:: ... ·.·.·:: ..... : ... : ... ·.·.·.: ... ·.·.-:: ... ·.·.·.·.·.·.·. 120

. • • . . • :. : : : : : : ~ . ~: : : : : • . 115 •• : : ......... : : .•..•••.• : ......... : : ......... : : •.••••.• : •••.••.•.• : .......... : : .......... : : .......... : •.• : . • 1'1>

.· ·. • -: :: :: :: :: :: • ·: :: :· . 105 ·: •• ••• •• ·: •• • ·: . • 1()()

.. ;: : : .· .· .. ~ ~ ... · .... ~: ........ ~~ .· ...... ~ ~ ........ ~~ ........ ~: ........ ~: ........ ~: ........ ~: ........ ~ ~ ........ :::.. 95

.. · .· :· .· . . :· .· .· -: -: 90 . · == · · :=· · ··· · ·· n · · · ·. · ·· =~ · · · · · · ·· ~~ · · · · · · ·· ~~ · · ·· · · ·· .. :j · · · · ·: · · ~j · · · · · · · · ~~ · · · · · · · · ~~ · · · · · · · · ~ = ·: · · · · · · ~ = · · · · · · · · ~ = · · · · · ·: 85

. .· . ·.· .· .· .· .· .· :: 80 . ::: ; .·. ···~~· ·.· .· .. ~~. · ...... ~~ .· ... · .. ~~ .· ..... · ~ ~ ....... ·~~ ... · .... =~ ..... · .. ~~ ... ·. · .. ~ ~ ..... · .. ~ ~ ........ ~ ~ ........ :: ........ :::.: 75

. . . . . .· .· .· .. · .· .· .· . . ··. ·. ·. ·. ·. · ... · .· .. · .· .· . ·--70 .. : . : • .•.••.• -~~ .; ..••• -~ ~ ••• • •... ~~ .....••. ~~ ....... ;~~ ........ ~~ ......•. ~~ ........ ~ ~ ... ; .... ~: ....•... ~ ~ ........ ~ ~ ........ ~~· ....... ~;...... . 65

: •• : .... -: .... -: .... -: .... :: .... -: .... :: .... -: .... -: .... -: .... -: .... -: .... -: .... -: ... :- 60

... :.: . : . ::: . : . : . ) :.:.:.:. :: : . : . : . : . (.: .: . : . :: : . : . : . : . : : : . : . : . : . :: .. :. :: ... : . : . : : : . : . : . : . : : : . : . : . : . : : : . : . : . : . : : : . : . : . : . : : : . : . : . : . : : : .: . : . :.: : : : . ~ :: =.=. :: :: :: ·~::d'~-~~ ...... -: .... : .... -: .... · ..... -: . . . . ... :: ... ·.- .. :: ... ·.· .. :: ... ·.·.·:: ... ·.·.·:: ... ·.·.·:: .. ::_40 -:-· .•. ::· ... ::· ... ::· •.. ::· ... ::· .. . . ..· .. · ' .· .· .· .· . J5

:+········::··;·.·.·:l·'······::··.·.·.·:>·.·.·::······f :: ·= ~· .. :·.:!J .. :·.:·.:·.:.i.·:.·:·.:_::.J.:·.:·.:·.:.···.:·.:·.:·.:.J.:·.:.·:.·:J .. :·.::.·:.. ~ :·.·=:··-·.·.·::-·.·.·.·::.•.·.·.·::··-·.·.·::-·-·.·.·=:·····:=· . .: . .: :: :: :: . ·=) ........ \: ..... ) ....... ) ... ·.·.) ... ·.·.) ..... ·i:- ~

. :····::········::········~~········::········~~········::-·:· . . . . . . ~5 ;.. .. .: : .. •j .... : : .................. : : . ·.i .... ( .. •j .... j ... : i: .. 'i .... i: .. •j .... i: .. 'i ... 'i: .. •j ... 'i: .. 'i .... i: .. •j ... : .!_ .!. -- l. J_ J .. l_ .!_ ·-- ·-- ··- ···- ·-- ·-- ·- -- -- -- -- -· ·- .. -- -· ·- . . -- -- -- . . ... . ·-lib llP 15) t'S'O I'/) 11/0137 /JO 12~ IZO ttS- 110 105°100 ~S- ~ 8S° 80 7$° 70 6'5' 6o 'i'i ~O 45" 40 35" 30 25" Lt7 I~ 10 :i

• FARTHEST EXTENT TESTED W~H BOBBIN PROBE

l(i)\ Palisades Unit 1

.~ 11-25-1996

CPL-A

08:42 HRS.

SERIES 2530

SUPERTUBIN

• • I 1609 TESTED FULL LENGTH FROM H/L

25 STAY ROD 309 PLUGGED TUBE

INDICATION LISTING - BOTH LEGS CUMULATIVE

Palisades Unit 1 CPL -A/2530 INSPECTION: Nov-96 1 -Jun-97 11: 6

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+-------;·-----------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS I +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------~--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------:·-----------~----+

12 3 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM DBH 15.63 .oo 3 1 .22 35 SHT 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 12 3 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD WDM 31 I

I 14 3 TEC .TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 5.51 .oo 3 .74 97 SHT 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 14 3 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD WDM 31 I

I 4 9 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 15.05 .oo .57 151 WDM 16 I 4 9 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD WDM 31 I

I 10 9 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H .78 .oo . M1 .47 120 SHT 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 10 9 ---------------------------------------------------·---:-----------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 10 9 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H -1.29 . oo 1 . .68 154 SHT 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 10 9 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -·- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 10 9 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 20.54 .oo 1 .23 142 SHT 16 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 10 · 9 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 10 9 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 23.37 .oo .17 71 SHT 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 10 9 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 10 9 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD WDM 31 I

I 14 9 TEC TEH 610-EB INF TSH 14.69 .oo WDM 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 14 9 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 15.33 .oo 1 1.41 152 SHT 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 14 9 ----------------'-------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

e 14 9 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD WDM .31 I I

28 ,9 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 22.86 .oo 3 .66 126 SHT 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 28 9 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 .41 .oo M1 5.90 176 SHT 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

28 9 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1 WDM 31 I I

2 11 TEC TEH 590-EB MBM 03H 16.20 .oo 3 1.80 111 WDM 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

2 11 TEC TEH 590-EB MBM 05H .46 .oo .60 157 WJS 15 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION

2 11 TSH .TSH 610-ZP NOD WDM 31 I 2 11 OSC 05H 610-UP NOD DAL 35 I

I 9 12 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 33.33 .oo 3 .74 113 WDM 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

9 12 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD WDM 31 I I

17 12 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM OSH 2.84 .oo .36 159 WDM 16 I 17 12 TEC TEH 610-EB INF OSH 1. 71 .oo WDM 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

17 12 TSH TSH 610-ZP NoO WDM 31 I I

26 1.3 TSH TSH 610-ZP MBM TSH 4.47 .oo 4 .62· 73 BEA 76 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 28 15 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 22.49 .oo .57 159 WDM 16 !HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

28 15 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 02H 21.30 .oo WDM 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION·

28 15 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD JTS 31 I I

44 15 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H -1.87 .oo .45 130 WDM 16 !HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

+----+----+---·-~-·------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----·~-------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

PAGE TUBES 12


Palisades Unit 1 CPL -A/2530 INSPECTION: Nov·-95 1-Jun-97 11: 6

+----+----+---+---+-----~+---+---+--------+-----~--+----+------+---+----+----+-------------------------~------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

44 15 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 30.99 .00 1 .45 30 SHT 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 44 1 5 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 44 15 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD JTS 31 I

I 48 15 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 21. 97 . 00 1 . 27 96 SHT 16 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 48 15 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 48 15 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD JTS 31 I

I 3 18 TEC TEH 590-EB MBM 04H 19.04 . 00 .25 141 WDM . 15 !HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 3 18 TEC TEH 590-EB INF 04H 18.11 .00 WDM 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 3 18 TEC TEH 590-EB INR 04C 28.36 .00 SHT 15 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 3 18 TEC TEH 590-EB MBM 03C 19.43 .00 3 .55 104 SHT 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 3 18 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD WDM 31 I I 3 18 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD A.JD 76 I I

I I 11 18 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 4.20 .00 .29 70 WDM. 16 !HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 1.1 18 TSH TSH 610-ZP MBM TSH 3.88 .00 4 .93 96 WDM 31 I

I 15 .18 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 24.60 .00 .60 162 WDM 16 I 15 18 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD JTS 31 I 15 18 TSH TSH 610-,ZP NOD. A.JD 76 I

I 59 18 TEC. TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 26.40 .00 .32 135 WDM 16 !HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

e 59 18 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD JTS 29 I 59 18 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD A.JD 76 I

I 8 21 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 01C 8.70 .00 WDM 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 8 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 10.07 .00 1 .47 148 SHT 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 8 21 ---~-------------------------------------------'.'-----------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED· 8 21 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD WDM 31 I

I 22 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 9.76 .00 3 .86 56 JTS 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

22 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 5.22 .00 3 1.06 68 JTS 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

22 21 TSH. TSH 610-ZP NOD JTS 30 I I

26 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 31 .19 .00 3 .79 50 JTS 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

26 21 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 .. 27 .00 M1 7.09 178 JTS 9 I 26 21 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD JTS 30 I

I

I 42 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 34.38 .00 1 .20 106 SHT 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 42 21 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 42 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 4.52 .00 1 .52 153 SHT 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I

I 42 21 ---------------------~--------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I

I 42 21 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 05H 7 .21 .oo JTS 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I

I 42 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 8.21 .00 .20 120 JTS 9 !HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I

I 42· 21 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 05C 10.40 .00 JTS 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I

I 42 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05C 11.02 .00 .53 132 JTS 9 !HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I

I 42 21 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD JTS 30 I I +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - • - - -+- - -+- - -+;- - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+-. - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS

9, +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

PAGE 2 TUBES 22

INDICATION LISTING · BOTH LEGS CUMULATIVE

Palisades Unit 1 CPL ·A/2530 INSPECTION: Nov-96 1-Jun-97 11: 6

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+-------~-----------------;·-----------------------+

IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

44 21 TEC TEH 610-EB 10 VS4 44 21 TEC TEH 610·EB 16 VS4 44 21 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

48 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 48 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 48 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM DBC 48 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM DSC 48 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM DSC 48 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM OSC 48 21 TEC TEH 610·EB MBM 04C 48 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 48 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 48 21 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

60 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM OSC 60 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 60 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 60 . 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 60 21 TEC TEH 610·EB MBM 02C 60 21 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

68 21 TEC TEH 610-EB 16 VS4 68 21 TEC TEH 610-EB 11 VS4 68 21 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

I. 88 21 TEC TEH 610-EB 8 VS4 I 88 21 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

I I 17 24 TEC TEH 610 ·EB MBM 02H I 17 24 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

I I 33 24 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H I 33 24 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

I I 99 26 TEC TEH 610·EB ONT 07H I 99 26 TEC TEH 610-EB ·11 VS4 I 99 26 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

I I .rs 27 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H I 18 27 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H I 18 27 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H I .18 27 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H I 18 27 TSH TSH'610·ZP NOD

I I 24 27·TSH TSH 610-ZP MBM TSH

I

.. 48 . 77

14.78 24.10

- .40 1.30 2.06

17.28 28.46 25.66 24.15

10.15 32.74 22.46 5.70 4.80

.78 .. 98

.. 61

35.78

33.56

26. 75 -.92

9.67 5.47 8.33 9.14

3.45

.00 M2

.00 M2

.oo 3

.oo 3

.oo 3

.oo 3

.00 3

.oo 3

.00 ·3

.oo 3

.oo 3

.oo 3

.oo 3

.oo 3

.oo 3

.oo 3

.00 M2

.00 M2

.. 00 M2

.oo 3

.oo . 3

.oo 1

.00 M2

.00 3

.oo 3

.oo 3

.oo. 3

.00 4

. 77

1.38 JTS 9 SHT 9 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION· JTS 30 I

.89 63 JTS

.94 85 JTS 1.34 74 JTS

. 91 82 JTS

.98 42 JTS

.72 98 JTS

.95 55 JTS

.84 40 JTS

.99 53 JTS JTS

. 52 90 JTS

.73 101 JTS

.47 83 JTS

.47 103 JTS

.50 95 JTS DAL

1.49 JTS . 87 SHT

DAL

.68 WDM DAL

. 78 109 JTS JTS

.60 68 JTS JTS

7.39 193 RJP . 93 JTS

DAL

.48 91 JTS

. 51 98 JTS

.54 . 80 JTS

.69 82 JTS JTS

.41 76 WRH

I 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION . 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

30 I I

9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

29 I I

9 I 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

29 I I

1~ I 29 I

I 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

30 I I

9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 30 I

I 8 !RESULT 'OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION s I

29 I I

9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

30 I I

78 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I

I I I I I.

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

PAGE 3 TUBES 32

e


Palisades Unit 1 CPL -A/2530 INSPECTION: Nov-96 1-Jun-97 11: 6

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+------------------------~-------------------------+

IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+----~-·---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

42 27 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 03C 32.90 .00 3 JTS 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION· 42 27 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 33.93 .00 3 1.07 113 JTS 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 42 27 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD JTS 30 I

I 100 . 27 TEC TEH 610-EB 8 VS4 - .54 .00 M2 .67 JTS 8 I 100 27 TEC TEH 610-EB 12 VS4 1.24 .00 M2 1.07 JTS 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 100 27 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD DAL 29 I

I 15 30 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 14.36 .00 1 .46 152 SHT 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 15 30 - - - - - - - - - - --- - - - - - · · · · · - - - · - · · · · · - · - - - - - - - · · · · · · · - - · - - - - • · · · · · · · · · · I HISTORY REV! EW PERFORMED 15 30 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD -JTS 30 I

I 95 ·30 TEC TEH 610-EB 17 VS4 .-.72 .00 M2 1.62 JTS 8 I 95 30 TEC TEH 610-EB 19 VS4 1.15 .00 M2 1.96 JTS 8 I 95 30 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD DAL 29 I

I 8 33 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 14.15 .00 1. .25 105 SHT 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 8 33 ------------------------------------------------------------------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 8 33 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 22.71 .00 .29 125 SHT 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 8 33 · · · - - - · - - - - - - · · · · - · · - - · · · · · - - - :- · - · · · - · · · · · · · - - - - · · · · · · · · - - · · · · · · · · I HISTORY REV! EW PERFORMED 8 33 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD WDM 31 I

I 14 33 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 3.76 .00 .26 57 SHT 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY.RESOLUTION

14 33 ------------------------------------------------------------------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 14 33 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 34.78 .00 3 .77 69 JTS 9 !RESULT. OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

. 14 33 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 02C 33.19 .00 JTS 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 14 33 TEC TEH 610-EB INR 02C 34.42 .00 3 SHT 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 14 33 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD JTS 30 I


30 33 --------------------------------------------------------~---------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 30 -33 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD' JTS 30 I

I 34 33 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 34 33 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 34 33 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

7.66 9.08

.00 3

.00 3

.69 -88 JTS 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

.62 69 JTS 9 .I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION JTS 30 I

I 44 33 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM DBH 20.18 .00 3 .79 87 SHT 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

44 33 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM DBH 21.01 .00 1 .31 114 SHT 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

44 33 - - - - - - - - ' - - - - - - - - - - - ~ - - - - - - - - - , - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REV! EW PERFORMED 44 33 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD - JTS 30 I

I 48 33 TEC TEH.610-EB MBM TSH 11. 78 .00 3 1.03 47 JTS 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

48 33 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 25.18 .00 3 .92 62 JTS 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

48 33 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD JTS 30 I _I

102 33 TEC. TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 22.43 .00 3 .92 108 JTS 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

102 33 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1 DAL 28 I +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- -- - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - --- - - - - - - ... - - - - - - - - - - - - -+


+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+---:+--------------------------------------------------+

PAGE 4 TUBES 43



+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+-----~--+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

!ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LDC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - ':' - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -·- - -+

I ·I 108 33 TEC TEH 610-EB 13 VS4

108 33 TEC TEH 610-EB 11 VS4 1"08 33 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

1.00 - . 57

.00 M2

.00 M2 1.17

.88 JTS 8 JTS 8 DAL 28

5 36 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 5

5

36 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 36 610·ZP TNT

13.42

9 36 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 02H 28.91 9 36 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 29.94 9 36 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 03H 10.02 9 36 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 11.31 9 36 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

21 36 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 -.92 21 36 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 2.54 21 36 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

4 39 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 4 39 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C

4.22 16.82

;OO 3

.oo

.oo

.oo

.oo

.00 M1

.oo 3

.oo 3

.oo

.50 89 JTS 9

WDM 31 DAL 81

JTS 9 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION .58 147 JTS 9

JTS 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION .70 156 JTS 9 I

WDM 31 I I

5.67 176 WDM 10 I .65 96 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

RJP 30 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I .60 82 JTS .20 91 SHT

9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

4 39 -------------------------:------------,---------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 4 39 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 26.44 .00 3 .49 .68 JTS 9 I 4 39 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD DAL 28 I

46 39 TEC H:H 610-.EB MBM TSH 46 39 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

110 39 TEC TEH 610-EB 13 VS2 110 39 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

42 41 TEC TEH 610-EB 10 VS4 42 41 TEC TEH 610-EB 15 VS4 42 41 TSH .TSH 610-ZP NOD


26.63

1. 21

.91 -.86

- .81

.oo 3

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

I .48 92 SHT 10 I RESULT .OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION.

1.12

.83 1.42

1.42

DAL 28 I I

RJP 8 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION DAL 28 I

I WDM 10 I WDM 10 I DAL 28 I

I WDM 10 I DAL 28 I

I 3 42 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 27.26 .00 1 .24 151 BEA 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 3 42 -----------------·------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 3 42 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD DAL 28 I

I 59 42 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS4 59 42 TS.H TSH 610-ZP NOD

6.55 .oo 3 .54 113 SHT DAL


I 14 I .14 I 14

I 45 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM DBH 23.00 .00 1 1.18 13 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 45 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -·- - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 45 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 8.65 .00 3 .63 76 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

+----+----+---+-·--+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ !ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LDC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

PAGE 5 TUBES 54

e



+.----+----+---+---+------+---+---+------~-+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+---~--+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

14 45 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD OAL 28 I .

I 22 45 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 04H 12.91 .00 3 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 22 45 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 5.34 .00 1 .36 59 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 22 45 ---.---------------------------------------------------------------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 22 45 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 14.02 .00 1 .36 61 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 22 45 ------------------------------------------------------------------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED. 22 45 TSH TSH 610-ZP·NDD DAL 28 I

I 40 45 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS4 19.93 .00 .90 20 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 40 45 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ; - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -.- - - - - - - · · - - - - - - -·······I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 40 45 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD DAL 28 I

I 44 45 TEC TEH 610-EB .MBM 04C 44 45 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

32.54 .00 3 .64 86 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION DAL 28 I

I 46 45 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 91.65 .00 3 1.75 26 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 46 45 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS4 21.22 .00 1 .47 33 SHT 10. !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 46 45 ---------------------------------,--------------------------------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 46 45·TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS4 2.39 .00 .17 103 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 46 45 ----------------------------------------------------······:·······IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 46 45 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD DAL 28 I

I 15 46 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H -.14 .00 M1 .47 64 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION. 15 46 -------------------------:·--------··----------------~------------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 15 46 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD DAL 28 I

I 9 48 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H -.80 .00 M1 .26 69 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

9 4S ...... : .... -------------------------------------------------------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 9 48 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 28.49 .00 1 .35 155 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

9 48 ------------------------------------------------------------------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 9 48 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 02H 23.20 .00 3 WDM 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

9 48 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 02H 18.79 .00 3 WDM 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUT~ON

9 48 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM.02H 24.15 .00 1 .65 153 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

9 48 --------------.----------------------------------------------------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 9 48 TEC TEH 610-E~ MBM 02H 21.68 .00 .27 143 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION.

9 48 ------------------------------------------------------------------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 9 48 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 19.62 .00 1 .32 140 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

9 48 ------------------------------··:·--------------------------------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED


101 48 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 12.58 .00 3 .60 105 JTS 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION


2 51 TEC TEH 590-EB INR. 01C 7.43 .00 DAL 14 I ·2 51 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD JTS 29 I

2 51 OSC 05H. 580-UP NOD RVP 98 I I

+----+----+---·-~-·------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+----------------------.----------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+---------.-----------------------------------------+

PAGE 6 TUBES 63



+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+-------------------------~~-----------------------+

IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LDC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

I

16 51 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 01H 16 51 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H

4.50 5.69

.00 3

.00 WDM 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

.63 150 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 16 51 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REV! EW PERFORMED 16 51 TEC TEH 610-EB. MBM 04H 5.88 .00 1 .25 37 SHT 10 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 16 51 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - · - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 16 51 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD JTS 29 I

22 22 22

51 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 51 TEC TEH 610-EB INR 03C 51 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

1.14 36.35

.00 M1

.00 3

5.74 178 SHT WDM JTS

I 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 29 I

I 34

34 34

34 34 34

51 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 11.66 .00 1 .41 149 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 51 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 51 TSH TSH 610-ZP PIO TSH - .07 .00 .81 15 JTS 30 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY.RESOLUTION 51 ------------------------------------------------------------------!>>>>>POSITIVE I.D. ESTABLISHED<<<<< 51 TSH TSH 610-ZP SA! TSH - .05 .·oo 8 2.40 8 WJS 30 I RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 51• - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I RETEST FOR POSITIVE I. D.

34 51 TSH TSH 610-ZP DIM TSH 323.0Q·

56 51 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 56 51 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 56 51 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 05H 56 51 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 05H 56 51 TSH TSH_610-ZP NOD

102 102 102

·51 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 02H 51 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 51 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

37.26 14.01 12. 81 -3.46

9.79 11.00

.00

.00 3 .. 00 3

.·00 3

.00

.00

.00

80.00 50 WJS 30 !RESULT OF.LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION

I 1.73 121 WDM 2.23 118 WDM

WDM

10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 10 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY .RESOLUTION 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION JTS 30 I

JTS .37 150 JTS

WDM

I 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 0 I

26 I I

I 106 I 106

I

51 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 51 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

10.82 .00 3 ·1

.51 81 JTS WDM

8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION-26 I

I .I 110

.118 118 118

51 TEC. TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 51 TEC .. TEH 610-EB INF 01C 51 TEC' TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 51 TSH. TSH 610-ZP NOD

95 52 TEC TEH 610-EB 11 VS2 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EB 15 VS4 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EB 17 VS6 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EB 25 VS6 95 52 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

46 53 TEC TEH 610-EB 12 VS4 46 53 TEC TEH 610-EB 15 VS4 46· 53 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

70 53 TEC TEH 610-EB 8 03C

22.92. 7.00 8.11

-1.15 -. 77

-.60 .94

.94

-1.03

.20

.00 3

.00 3

.00

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00

. 72 97 JTS 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION. 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

JTS .26 94 JTS

.89 1.38 1.68 3.02

1.01 1.40

WDM 26 I I

JTS 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION JTS 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION JTS 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION JTS 8 I WDM 26 I

I WDM 10 I WDM 10 I WDM 110 I

I .56 158 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

·-~--·----+---+---+------+---+---+; .... ---+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~+

PAGE 7 TUBES 72



+----+----~---+---+------+·---+---+--------+~-------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ jRow· COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS +-.- - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+:- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

70 53 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD WDM 27

54 05C 05H 580-UP SAI 05H 9. 23 . 00 1 -1. 43 · 25 WJS 33 I RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 54 - - - - - - -.-·- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - : - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - , - - - - - - - - - - - - I RETEST FOR POSITIVE I. D. 54 05C 05H 580-UP DIM 05H 504.00 .oo .U 100.00 51 WJS 33 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 54 05C 05H 580-UP PIO 05H 9.57 .oo 2 9.65 31 WJS 34 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 54 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I >>>>> POSITIVE I.D. ESTABLISHED <<<<<

. 1 54 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1 JTS 83 I I

47 54 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 04H 14.88 .oo SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 47 54 TEC TEH 610-EB INA 04H 15.83 .oo SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 47 54 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RVP 111 I

I .2 57 TEC T~H 590-EB MBM TSC 20.34 .oo 3 .67 84 RJP 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

2 57 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD JTS 29 I 2 57 05C 05H 580-.UP NOD · RVP 98 I

I 32 57 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 16.08 .oo 3 .55 103 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 32 57 TEC TEH .610-EB ONT VS4 .94 .oo M1 5.53 176 WDM 10 I 32 . 57 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RVP 111 I

I 9 60 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 7.86 .oo 3 .59 109 WDM 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 60 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C .3.06 .00 1 .43 153 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION - 9 60 - - - - - - - - -.. - - - - - - - : _ '- - - - - - - - - - - - - - :- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - _·: _: _ - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

9 60 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 04C. 2.10 .oo SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION


17 60 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 14.38 .oo 1 1.00 24 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 17 60 - - -· - - - - - - - : - - '. - - - - - - - - - - - - - : - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REV! EW PERFORMED 17 60 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1 JTS 29 I

I 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EB 12 VS1. .37 .oo M2 1 .04 . DAL 7 I 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EB 21 VS2 1.09 .oo M2 2.27 DAL 7 I 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EB. 15 ·vs6 1.16 .oo M2 1.35 DAL 7 I 135 66 TEC TEH 61"0-EB 33 VS6· .-.60 .oo M2 4.83 DAL 7 I

. 135 66 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD JTS 25 I I

134 67 TEC TEH 610-EB 13 VS4 - .97 .oo M2 1.11 DAL 7 I 134 67 TEC TEH 610-EB 19 VS7 - .87 .oo M2 1. 92 RJP 7 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

134 67 TEC TEH 610,EB 17 VS7 _87 .oo M2 1.69 RJP 7 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

134 67 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD JTS 25 I· I

48 69 TEC TEH 610-EB 17 VS4 1.55 .oo M2 1.66 WDM 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

48 69 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD WRH 103 I I

126 69 TEC TEH 610- EB 15 VS4 .88 .oo M2 1.46 DAL 7 I 126 69.TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD JTS 25 I

I +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ jROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS +- - - -+- ---+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

PAGE 8 TUBES 83

INDICATION LISTING BOTH LEGS CUMULATIVE


+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+-------------------------·-------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+----------------------------------------~---------+ 134 69 TEC TEH 610-EB 18 VS7 134 69 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD




104 75 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 104 75 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 02H 104 75 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 104 75 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 104 75 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 03H 104 75 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

138 75 TEC TEH 610-EB 10 DBH 138 ·75 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

136 77 TEC TEH 610-EB 18 DBC 136 77 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

138 77 TEC TEH 610-EB 30 VS6 138. 77 TEC TEH 610-EB 34 VS7 138 77 TEC TEH 610-EB. 17 VS7 138 77 TEC TEH 610-EB 17 DBC 138 77 TEC TEH 610-EB 14 DBC 138 77 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

133 78 TEC TEH 610-EB 15 VS1 133 78. TEC TEH 610-EB 8 VS4 133 78 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

135 78 TEC TEH 610,·EB 18 VS6 135 78 TSH TSH ~10-ZP NOD

137 78·TEC TEH 610-EB 10 VS4 137 78 TEC TEH 610-EB 14 VS4 137 78 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

138 79 TEC TEH 610-EB 13 DBH 138 79 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

138 81 TEC .TEH 610-EB ·a DBH

.86

.. 77

.69

.. 60

.80

18.72 17.60 23.39 24.91 24.00

2.06

-1.43

.. 83 .74

•. 77

2.23 -1.06

.. 29 .06

.88

1.37 : . 72

2.20

2.09

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2 1

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00

.00

.00

.00

.oo

.oo r.i2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

1. 79

1. 30 1.01

1.15

1.00

DAL 5 JTS 25

DAL 5 DAL 5 JTS 25

DAL 5 . JTS 25

DAL 5 JTS 25

.31 150 DAL 7 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION RJP 7 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

.30 143 DAL 7 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

.19 140 DAL 7 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

.83

1.86

4:01 5.08 1.70 1 .68 1.29

1.40 .66

1.78

.86 1.24

1.19

.67

RJP 7 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION JTS 25

DAL 5

JTS 25

DAL 5 JTS 24

DAL DAL DAL DAL .DAL

5

5

5

5

5

JTS 24

DAL 5 DAL 5 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION JTS 24

DAL 5 JTS 24

. DAL 5

DAL 5 JTS 24

DAL 5 JTS 24

DAL 5

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+------------------------~-------------------------+

PAGE 9 TUBES 95



+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ !ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LDC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

138 81 TEC TEH 610-EB 16 VS6 1.00 .oo. M2 1.52 DAL 5 138 81 TEC TEH 610-EB 16 VS6 - . 71 .oo M2 1.57 DAL 5 138. 81 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD JTS 24

81 84 TEC TEH 610-EB 11 VS4 .91 .00 M2 .94 DAL 6 81 84 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1 . JTS 24

138 85 TEC TEH 610-EB 13 DBC 1.80 .oo M2 1.19 BEA 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 138 85 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD JTS 24 I

I 104 87 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 24.19 .oo .25 49 ~s 6 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 104 87 --------------------------------------~----------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 104 87 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD DAL 23 I

I 138 91 TEC TEH 610-EB 13 VS1 .83 .oo M2 1.11 DAL 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 138 91 TEC TEH 610-EB 14 DBC -1 .20 .oo M2 1.32 BEA. 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 138 91 TEC TEH 610-EB 15 DBC 2.03 .oo M2 1.34 BEA 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 138 91 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD DAL 23 I

I 60 93 TEC TEH 610-EB INR 05H 19.98 .oo BEA 11 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RES_OLUTION 60 93 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD DAL 23 I

I 132 93 TEC TEH 610-EB INF VS1 .84 .00 M2 BEA 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

e 132 93 TEC TEH 610-EB 17 VS2 1.00 .00 M2 1.65 BEA 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 132 93 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD DAL 23 I

I 136 95 TEC TEH 610;EB 27 VS6 1.11 .oo M2 3.42 DAL 5 I 136 95 TEC TEH 610-EB 18 VS7 .83 .oo M2 1. 77 DAL 5 I 136 95 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD DAL 23 I

. I 92 99 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06H 15. 76 .oo .65 155 .A.JD 5 I 92" 99 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD DAL 22 I

I 104 99 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 14.82 .oo 3 1.03 112 SHT 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 104 99 TSH TSH -610-ZP NOD DAL 22 I

I 106 99 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 12.47 .oo 1 .35 140 SHT 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 106 99 ---------------------------------------.---------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 106 99 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD DAL 22 I

I 107 102 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H . 16.55 .oo .29 145 SHT . 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

107 102 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 107 102 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD DAL 22 I

I 93 104 TEC TEH 610-EB 15 VS4 - .40 .oo M2 1.48 WDM 4 I 93 104 TEC TEH 610-EB 12 VS6 1.00 .00 M2 1.09 SHT 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 93 104 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD DAL 22 I I

I I +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LDC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+----·----+--------+----+------+---+----+----+-----------------------------~--------------------+

PAGE 10 TUBES 108



+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+---------------------------------------------------+ IRbW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+-----~·--~+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

10 105 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 34.05 .00 .24 151 DAL 12 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 10 105 TSH TSH.610-ZP·NDD JTS 18 I

I 16 105 TEC TEH 610-EB INR 05C 2.54 .00 DAL 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 16 105 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD JTS 18 I

I 50 105 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 12.02 .00 3 .86 99 AJD 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 50 105 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD JTS 18 I

I 52 105 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 12.15. .00 3 .68 101 SHT 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 52 105 TSH TSH.610-ZP NOD JTS 18 I

I 108 105 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 29.53 .00 3 1.01 118 SHT 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 108 105. TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H ·1.55 .00 3 .98 119 SHT 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 108 105 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 26.49 .00 3 .56 95 SHT 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 108 105 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD DAL 22 I

I 116 105 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 14.40 .00 3 . 57 91 SHT 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 116 105 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD DAL 22 I

I, 128 105 TEC TEH 610-EB NOD 1 SHT 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION ·I 128 105 TSH TSH 610-ZP VOL TSH .49 . 00 4 . .33 126. DAL 22 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 128 io5 ·············---······:···········---~-----················-······IRETEST FOR POSITIVE I.D .. e 128 105 TSH TSH 610-ZP VOL TSH .25 .00 4 .30 85 BEA 22 I RESULT OF .. DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 128 105 · · · · · · · · · · · · - · · · - · · · · - · · · · · · - · · · · · · -· · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · - · · · · .·. · · · · · ·. - I RETEST FOR POSITIVE I. D. f28 105 TSH TSH 610-ZP DIM TSH 469.00 . .00 0 100.00 53 BEA 22 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 128 105 TSH TSH 610-ZP PIO TSH . 01 .00 4 .37 116 WDM 32 I_»»> POSITIVE I·. D. ESTABLISHED <<<<<

I 130 105 TEC TEH 610-EB NOD WDM 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 130 105 TSH TSH·610-ZP PLP TSH .37 .00 7 .34 _.331 DAL 22

132 105 TEC TEH 610-EB NOD 1 WDM 4

132 105 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .37 .oo 7 .32 151 DAL 22

98 107 TEC TEH 61.0·EB 16 VS2 1.03 .00 M2 1.57 WDM 4

98 107 TEC TEH 610-EB 13 VS4 -.75 .00 M2 1.24 WDM ·4

98 107 TEC TEH S10-EB 14 VS6 .79 .00 M2 1.30 WDM 4

98 107 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD DAL 22

.53 108 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 32.83 .00 3 .59 106 SHT 3 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

53 108 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD JTS 18

53. 108 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 47

125 108 TEC TEH 610-EB 18 VS1 . .66 .00 M2 1.84 WDM 4.

125 108 TEC TEH 610-EB 13 VS4 1.07 .oo M2 1.23 WDM 4

1°25 108 TEC·TEH 610-EB 12 VS4 -.52 .00 M2 1.13 WDM 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

125 108 TSH TSH. 610-ZP NOD· DAL 22 I I

+----+-~--·~--+-~-·-----~+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+----------------------~--------------~~-----------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS

e +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

PAGE 11 TUBES 120



+----+----+---+---+------+--·-+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------~-----------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+---.-----+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

113 110 TEC TEH 610-EB 26 VS4 113 110 TSH TSH .610-ZP NOD

2 111 TEC TEH 590-EB INF 03H 2 111 TEC TEH 590-EB MBM 03H 2 111 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 2 111 05C 05H 580-UP NOD

14 111 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 14 111 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

.. 95

11. 60 12.68

30.43

.00 M2

.oo

.oo

.oo

3.15 SHT DAL

JTS .91 20 JTS

JTS RVP

.64 140 DAL JTS

4 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 22 I

I 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 14 I 18 I 98 I

I 12 I 18 I

I 18 111 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 25.39 .00 1 .18 114 BEA 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 18 111 · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · - · · · · · · ·······I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 18 111 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD JTS 18 I

I . 48 111 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM DBC 4.70 .00 3 1.00 75 BEA 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

48 111 ···········-···-·····-~---········································IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 48 111 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD JTS 18 I

106 111 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06C 106 111 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

113 112 TSH TSH 610-ZP MBM TSH

126 113 TEC TEH 610-EB 13 VS1 126 1'13 TEC TEH 610-EB 14 VS4 126 113 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

,35 114 TEC.TEH 610-EB ONT vs~ 35 114 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 02C 35 114 TEC T~H 610-EB INR 02C

7.86

3.08

.. 49 ·1.29

.. 86 27.79 28:96

35 114 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C -1.51 35 114 TSH TSH 61 0 · ZP NOD ·

34 117 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM.02C 22.87 34 117 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

46 117 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 12.24 46 117 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 8.13 46 117 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 35.37 46 117 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C' 37.09 46 117 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

48 117 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 22.22 48 117 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 10.10 48 · 117 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

98 117 TEC TEH 610-EB 19 VS2 .14

.oo 3

.00 ·4

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M1

.oo 1

.oo . 3

.oo 3

.oo 3

.oo 3

.00 3

.oo 3

.oo 3

.oo 3

.oo 3

.00 M2

I . 77 95 SHT 4 I RESU_L T OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

DAL 22 I

.57 117 BEA

1.26 WDM 1.29 WDM

DAL

11.13 175 WD.M WDM SHT


I 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

22 I I

15 I 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION-16 I RESULT. OF . o'ISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

1. 40 120 SHT 16 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION JTS 18 I

I 1.30 55 JTS 3 I

JTS 18 I I

.88 119 SHT 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

.70 86 SHT 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 1 . 1.6 116 JTS 3 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

.64 96 JTS 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION JTS 18 I

I .97 86 JTS 3 I .80 60 JTS 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

JTS 18 I I

2.10 SHT 4 I RESULT OF .DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

+--.--+-:·-+---+---+------+---+---+-~------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I R'OW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+------------------------------------~-------------+

PAGE 12 TUBES 132

e


Palisades Unit 1 CPL ·A/2530 INSPECTION: Nov-96 1 -Jun-97 11: 6

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +~---+----+-~-+---+------+-.--+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+---------------------------------------------------+

98 117 TEC TEH 610-EB 31 VS4 1.05 .00 M2 4.31 WDM 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 98 117 TEC TEH 610-EB 19. VS6 .71 .00 M2 1.96 WDM 4 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY .RESOLUTION 98 117.TEC TEH 610-EB 18 VS6 .. 08 .00 M2 1.91 WDM 4 I RESULT OF. DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 98 117 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD DAL 21 I

I 29 120 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 15.02 .00 1 .32 37 SHT 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 29 . 120 · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · .· · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · ·······I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 29 120 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD JTS 18 I

2 123 TEC TEH 590-EB MBM 04H 2 123 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 2 123 05C 05H 580-UP NOD

14 123 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C

9.95 .00 3

28.56 .00

I .70 66 JTS 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

JTS 18 I RVP 98 I

I .24 131 RJP 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

14 123 ·····················-······-·-·······-·····---····---·······--·-·IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 14 123 TSH TSH 610,ZP NOD JTS 18 I

I 20 123 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 14.07 .00 3 .75 70 RJP 2 · 1 RESULT O.F DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 20 ·123 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD JTS 18 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 28 123 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 34.03 .00 3 1.32 78. RJP 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY R~SOLUTION 28 123 TSH TSH 610-ZP.NDD . JTS 18 I

I 30 123 TEC TEH .610-EB MBM 04H 5.11 .00 .19 133 RJP 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

30 123 ----············-···-······---····-·········-······---···-·--·o···IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 30 123 TSH TSH 610-ZP RBD JTS 18 I 30 123'TSH TSH 610-:ZP NOD WDM 32 I

I 34 123 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 2.91 .oo 3 1.01 122 JTS· 2 !HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

34 123 TSH TSH 610'ZP NOD JTS 19 I I

116 125 TSH TSH 610-ZP VOL TSH .00 .00 4 · 1.79 125 BEA 50 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

116 125 · · · · · · - - · · · · · · · · · · · · - - · · · - - · · · · · - · · · · ·: · - · · · - · - · · · · · - · · · · · - · - ·····I RETEST FOR POSITIVE I. D. 116 125 TSH TSH 610,ZP DIM TSH 116 125 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH 116 125 TSH TSH 610-ZP PIO TSH

327.00 .00 .02

.00

.oo

.00

0 100.00 53 BEA 7 .66 84 BEA 4 2.04 144 DAL

50 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 50 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTiON 87 !RESULT.OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

116 125 · · · - - - - · - - - · · · ·: - - - · · · · - - · · · - - · · · · - - · · · - - - - - · - - - - - · · - - - - · · · · - - - - ··I»>» POSITIVE L D. ESTABLISHED «<«

I 15 126 TEC. TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 30.32 .00 .75 157 JTS 2 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY R.ESOLUTION


27 126 TE~ TEH 610-EB INF 02C 12.79 .00 JTS 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

27 126 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 14.34 .00 .35 142 JTS 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

27 126 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C .35.98 .00 . 21 145 RJP 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

27 ·126 ------···--···-------··--··--···---·-·-----------·----~---···----·IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 27 126 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD JTS 19 I

I 59 126 TEC TEH 610-EB INF VS4 9.30 .00 JTS 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I· I I I I I I I I I I

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+------------------------------=-------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS

+----+---~·---+---+------+-.--+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

PAGE 13 TUBES 143



+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+-------------------------~------------------------+

IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I I I I I

59 126 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS4 10.11 .00 .93 156 JTS 2 !HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 59 126 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS4 8.22 .00 1 .14 92 RJP 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 59 126 · · · - · · - · - - - · - · - · - · · · - - - · - · - - - - - - - · - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 59 126 TEC TEH 610·-EB MBM VS4 13.32 .00 1 ·.32 171 RJP 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 59 126 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - J HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 59 126 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD JTS 19 I

I 8 129 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 16.30 .oo 3 .88 115 BEA 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 8 129 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 11.89 .oo .23 133 BEA 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 8 129 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD JTS 19 I

I 28 129 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 18.65 .oo .18 91 RJP 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTI9N 28 129 - - - .. - -- -- -- - -- - -- - - - - - - - - -------- - - - - - - - - - -- - -- -- - - - - ---- --- - - - - - HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 28 129 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

48 129 TEC TEH 610-EB INF TSC 48 129 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 48 129 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

93 130 TEC TEH 610-EB 19 VS4 93 130 TEC TEH 610-EB 11 VS4 93 130 TSH TSH 61 0- ZP. NOD

9 132 TEC TEH 610-EB INA 01H 9 132.TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD


33 132 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 33 132 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

41 132 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 41 132 TEC TEH 610-EB INF TSH

-41 132 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 41 132 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 41 132 TSH TSH 61 0-.ZP NOD

16 135 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 16 135 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 02H 16 135 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H

21.07 21.97

.93 - .88

22.59

2.48

12.33

15.22 14.69 27.30 26.95

35.01 -4.80 10.22

1

.oo 5

.oo

.00 M2

.oo i.12

.oo

.oo

.oo

.oo

.oo

.oo

.oo

.oo

.oo

.oo

JTS 19

JTS 2

.30 62 JTS 2 JTS 19

1.97 .97

WDM 4 WDM 4 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION WDM 21

DAL 12 JTS 19

. 73 149 JTS 2

JTS 19

.37 149 JTS 2

JTS 19

.84 157 JTS JTS

. 21 150 JTS

.36 138 JTS JTS

. 32 131 JTS JTS

.21 48 RJP

2 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 2 JRESULT OF.DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

19 I I

2 I 2 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

16 135 - - - - · - - - - -- - --.--- ---- - -- - -- ------- - -- --------- - ---- --- - ---- --- ----!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 1°6 135 TSH TSH.610-ZP NOD JTS 19 I

I 18 135 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 34.90 .00 .25 98 RJP 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 18 ·135. ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW.PERFORMED 18 .135 TEC TEH 610-EB .MBM 02C 18 135 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C

10. 77

34.22 .oo .oo

.40 155 JTS

.55 154 JTS 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

+-·- - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -.- - -+

IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+-: - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

PAGE 14 TUBES 153



+----+---~+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LDC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+---~----+--------+----+------+---+----+----+-----------------------------------------~--------+

I 18 135 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD JTS 19 I . I I

22 135 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 12.02 .00 .36 80 JTS 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION ·22 135 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD JTS 19 I

I 50 135 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 20.73 .00 .37 144 JTS 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 50 135 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD JTS 19 I

I 106 1.35 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM DBH 27.02 .00 .30 131 SHT 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 106 135 --------~---------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 106 135 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD WDM 21 I

I 98 137 TEC TEH 610-EB 16 VS4 .00 .00 M2 1. 71 SHT· 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 98 137 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD WDM 20 I

I 27 138 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 04H 1.80 .00 JTS 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 27 138 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 3.22 .00 .68 152 JTS 2 I 27 138 TEC TEH 610-EB INF.Q5H 4.90 .00 JTS 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 27 138 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 6.15 .00 1 .62 150 JTS. 2 I 27 138 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 .. -1.08 .00 M1 17.90 176 JTS 2 I 27 138 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD WOM 20 I

I 35 138 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 9.84 .oo 3 1.15 .120 RJP 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

e. 35 138 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD SHT 20 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 18 141 TEC 1EH 610-EB INF TSH 19.29 .00 JTS RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 18 141 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 20.06 .00 '.96 158 JTS 18 141 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD WOM 20

28 141 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 8.75 .00 3 1.43 121 JTS 1 28 141 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD WOM 20

68 141 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 22.14 .00 3 .48 113 JTS 1 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 68. 141 TSH TSH 610-ZP RBD WDM 20 68 141 TSH TSH.610-ZP NOD WOM 32

9 144 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 36.33 .00 .13 140 BEA 12 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 144 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -.- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

9 144 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 37.04 .00 1 .32 94 BEA 12 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION·.

9 144 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 9 144 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD WOM 20 I

I 53 144 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 13.52 .00 .50 155 JTS I 53 144 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 32.15. .00 . 23 142 JTS 1 I 53 144 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD WDM 20 I

I 40 147 _TEC TEH 610-EB 10 VS4 -1.22 .00 M2 .83 JTS !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

40 147 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD WOM 20 I +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+ - - -+- - - - - ~+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - ~ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

IROW COL CE~ CEE PROBE IND LDC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ••.•.••.•.•••••• ·+

PAGE 15 TUBES 166



+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+----------------------~---------------------------+

IROW. COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+---------------------------------------------·-----+

58 147 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 01C. 58 147 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 58 147 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

15 150 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 15 150 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 15 150 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

16 153 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 16 153 TSH TSH 610-.ZP NOD

18 153 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 18 153 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 18 153 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

44 153 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 44 153 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 44 153 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

50 153 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 50 153 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD .50 153 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

56 153 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 56 153 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 56 153 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 56 153 TSH TSH· 610-ZP NOD 56 153 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

8 159 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 8 159 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 8 159 TEC TEH 610-EB NOD 8 159 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

31.50 32.50

4.17

1.39

5.96 14.84

31.65

14.57

5.33 31.67. 29.04

33.99 23.41

.00

.00

.00 3

.00 3

.oo 1

.00 3

.00 . 3

.00

.. 00

.00

.00

.00 3

.00 3

JTS . 74 153 JTS


WDM io I

I 1 . 02 11 7 JTS 1 I

RJC 101 ·1 JTS 106 I

I 1.03 102 RJP 1 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

JTS 104 I

.44 151 DAL

.69 98 RJP 1 JTS 104

I I !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I I

.55 81 RJP 1 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION RJC 99 JTS 104

.73 163 DAL 1 RJC 99 JTS 104

.24 151 DAL

. 50 156 DAL 1

.'75 157 DAL 1 RJC 99 JTS' 104

.90 123 JTS

.82 82 RJP DAL 12

'JTS 106

RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

14 159 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H .57 .00 M1 .27 78 BEA 12 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 14 1 59 ~ - - -. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -·~ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REV! EW PERFORMED 14 15~ TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD JTS 108 I

I 16 159 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 10.83 .00 1 .27 151 BEA 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 16 159 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 16. 159 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 25.04 .00 .11 100 BEA - 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 16 .159. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -.- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - , - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 16 159 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD JTS 108 I

48 159 TEC. TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 48 159 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

26.21 .oo 3 I

.88 80 WDM 11 !RESULT ·OF DISCREPANCY·RESOLUTION RJC 99 I

I +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- .:..-+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - .. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - .. - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

PAGE 16 TUBES 177



+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------~-----------------------+

jROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+--.----+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+---------------------~----------------------------+


34.45 .oo . 51 1 50 DAL 12 I JTS 108 I

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+---~+----+----------------------------------------------~:--+ jROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------~

PAGE 17 TOTAL TUBES 177

e

SG - A INDICATION DISTRIBUTION REPORT 11 -25- 1996 13: 51

Palisades Unit 1 CPL -A /2530 Inspection: Nov-96

Indication

INF INA PLP MBM MMB VOL ADA NQI ORI

0 OSI <40

DI PI

WAR

1-19 • 20-29 • 30-39 • 40-49 • 50-59 • 60-69 • 70-79 • 80-89 • 90-99

100 SOR PAI PCI SAI MAI SCI MCI MMI

Total

Most Severe I n_dicat ion Per Tube

Cum.

6

2 122

2

37 3

3

2

177

Iner. Cum. Rep.

6

2

122

2

37 3

3

2

177

3

3

2

8

Most Severe Indication Per Tube Leg

Hot Leg

All Final Indications (Includes Multiple Tests)

Cumulative Hot

Incremental Cum. Reportable Cumulative Incremental Cum. Reportabre

1

3

2

82

2

36 3

3

2

134

Hot Hot Hot

1

3

2

82

2

36 3

3

2.

134

3

3

2

8

25 3

3

122

3

71 4

4

2

237

Hot Hot

25 3

3

122

3

71 4

4

·2

237

4

4

2

10

•Incremental• reflects data since the last shift report only_- 'Final• indications exclude multiple tests.

• Reportable indication

Indication Vs. Probe for Final Indications 11-25-1996 13:51

Palisades Unit CPL -A /2530 Inspection: Nov-96

Hot Leg

590 . 610 APC

INF 2 23 INA 3 PLP 3 MBM 5 113 4

VOL 3 '1-19 71

20-29 4

·30-39 4

SAI 2

All Calls Vs. Location (Includes Multiple Tests) 11-25-1996 13:52

Palisades Unit 1· CPL -A /2530 Inspection: Nov-96

e Hot Leg

TSH 01H 02H 03H 04H 05H 06H 07H DBH VS1 VS2 VS3 VS4 VS5 VS6 VS7 DBC

PIO 3 ONT 2 2 2 102 ONG PVN 2 DIM 3 NTE 1 TRA 31 DSN RBD INF 3 7 3 4 5 INR PLP 3 MBM 17 14 15 16 32 11 5 7 4 VOL 3

1-19 3 7 5 34 10 6 6 20-29 2

30-39 2

SAI

All ca.Us Vs. Probe (Includes Multiple Tests) 11-25-1996 13:52

Palisades Unit 1 CPL -A /2530 Inspection: Nov-96 - Hot Leg

590 610 RPC

PIO 4

DNT ·113 DNG 1 PVN 2 DIM 4

NTE TRA 31 DSN RBD INF 2 23 INR 3 PLP 3 MBM 5 113 4

VOL 3 1-19 71

20-29 4

30-39 4

SAI 2

SG · A INDICATION DISTRIBUTION REPORT 11 ·25·1996 13:55

Palisades Unit 1 CPL ·A /2530 Inspection: Nov-96

Indicatic;>n

INF INA PLP MBM MMB VOL ADA NQI ORI

0 OSI

-<40 DI PI

WAR 1 ·19

• 20·29 • 30·39 • 40-49 • 50·59 • 60-69 • 70-79 • 80-89 • 90·99

100 SOR

·* PAI PCI SAI MAI SCI MCI MMI

Total

Most severe Indication Per Tube

Cum.

6

2

122

Iner.

6

2

122

2 2

37 3

3

2

177

37 3

3

2

177

Cum. Rep.

3 ·3

2

8

Cold Leg


Cumulative Cold

3

53

57

Incremental Cold

3

53

57

Cum. Reportable Cold

0


Cumulative Cold

10 6

72

1 ·

89

Incremental Cold

10 6

72

89

Cum. Reportable Cold

0

"Incremental" reflects data since the last shift report only. "Final" indications exclude multiple tests.


·e

Indication Vs. Location for Final Indications 11-25-1996 13:55

Palisades Unit CPL -A /2530 Inspection: Nov-96

Cold Leg

06C osc 04C 03C 02C 01C TSC

INF 3 3 INR 1 2 MBM 3· 20 ·13 14 12 9

1-19

·Indication Vs. Probe for.Final Indications 11-25-1996 13:55

Palisades Unit CPL ·A /2530 Inspection: Nov-96

Cold Leg

590 610

INF 10 INA 2 4

MBM 2 70

1 ·19

All calls Vs. Location (Includes Multiple Tests) 11-25-1996 13:55

Palisades Unit 1 CPL ·A /2530 Inspection: Nov-96

Cold Leg

06C 05C 04C 03C 02C 01C TSC

ONT ONG 3 INF 3 3 INA 1 1 2 1 MBM 3 20 13 14 12 9

1-19

,.

'.

All calls Vs. Probe (Includes Multiple Tests) 11-25-1996 13:55

Palisades Unit 1 CPL -A /2530 Inspection: NOV-96

e Cold Leg

590 610

D_NT 1 ONG 4

INF 10 INA 2 4

MBM 2 70 1-19

.,

LIST OF ALL PERCENT INDICATIONS


+- - - -+:- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- -_- - -.-+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

!ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+-------------------------------------------~------+

44 44

68 68

88

99

100 100

95 95

108 108

21 TEC TEH 610-EB 10 VS4 21 TEC'TEH 610-EB 16 VS4

21 TEC TEH 610-E~ 16 VS4 21 TEC TEH 610-EB 11 VS4

21 TEC TEH 610-EB 8 VS4

26 TEC TEH 610-EB 11 VS4

27 TEC TEH 610-EB 8 VS4 27 TEC TEH 610-EB 12 VS4



110. '39 TEC TEH '610-EB 13 VS2

42 41'TEC TEH 610-EB 10 VS4 42 41 TEC TEH 610-EB 15 VS4

48 41 TEC TEH 610-EB 15 VS4

95 !12 TEC TEH 610-EB 11 ·vs2 95 52.TEC TEH 610-EB 15 VS4 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EB 17 VS6 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EB 25 VS6

46· 53 TEC TEH 610-EB 12'VS4 46 53 TEC TEH 610-EB 15 VS4

70 53 TEC TEH 610-EB 8 03C

135 66 TEC TEH 610-EB 12 VS1 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EB _21 VS2 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EB 15 VS6 135 66 TEC TEH.610-EB 33 VS6

134. 6? TEC TEH 610-EB 13 VS4 134 67 TEC TEH 610-EB 19 VS? 134 67 TEC TEH 610-EB 17 VS?

48 69 TEC TEH 610-EB 17 VS4

- .48 . 77

.78 - .98

-.61

- .92

-.54

1.24

-: 72

1.15

1.00 - . 57

1.21

.91 - .86

- .81·

-1.15 - . 77

- .60 .94

.94

-1.03

.20

.37 1.09 1.16 - .60

- .97 - .87 . 87

1.55

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2 ·

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

. 77

1.38

1.49 .87

.68

.93

.67 1.07

1.62 1. 96

1.17

.88

1.12

.83 1.42

1.42

.. 89 .1.38 1.6B 3.02

1.01 1.40

JTS 9 SHT 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I JTS 9 I SHT 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I WDM 16 I

I JTS 8 I

I JTS 8 I JTS' 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I JTS 8 I JTS 8 I

I JTS 8 I JTS 8 I

I RJP 8 !RESULT OF'DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I WDM 10 I WDM 10 I

I WDM 10 I

I JTS 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION JTS . 8 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION JTS 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION. JTS 8 I

I WDM 10 I WDM 10 I


1.04 DAL I

7 I 7 I 7 I 1 I

2.27 DAL 1.35 DAL 4.83 DAL

1.11 DAL 1.92 RJP

I 1 I 7 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

1.69 RJ P 7 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION .

I 1.66' WDM 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I +----+----+---+~--+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ !ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS

+----+----+---·-~-·------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

PAGE TUBES 17



+----+--~-+---+---+------+---+--~+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------·------+ 126 69 TEC TEH 610-EB 15 VS4

134 69 TEC TEH 610-EB 18 VS7

135 72 TEC TEH 610-EB 14 VS1 135 72 TEC TEH 610-EB 12 VS1

137 72 TEC TEH 610-EB 13 VS6

130 73 TEC TEH 610-EB 12 VS7

138 75 TEC TEH 610-EB 10 DBH

136 77 TEC TEH 610-EB 18 DBC

138 77 TEC TEH 610-EB 30 VS6 138 77 TEC TEH 610-EB 34 VS7 138 77 TEC TEH 610-EB 17 VS7 138 . 77 TEC TEH 610-EB 17 DBC 138_ 77 TEC TEH 610-EB 14 DBC

-133 78 TEC TEH 610-EB 15 VS1 133 78 TEC TEH 610-EB 8 VS4

135 78 TEC TEH 610-EB 18 VS6

137 78 TEC TEH 610-EB 1o' VS4 137 78 TEC TEH 610-EB 14 VS4

138 79 TEC TEH 610-EB 13 DBH

138 81 TEC TEH 610-EB 8 DBH 138 81 TEC TEH 610-EB 16 VS6 138 81 TEC TEH 610-EB 16 VS6

81 84 TEC TEH 610-EB 11 VS4

13S 85 TEC TEH 610-EB 13 DBC

138 91 TEC.TEH 610-EB 13 VS1 ·139 91 .TEC TEH 610-EB 14 DBC 138 91 TEC TEH 610-EB 15 DBC

132 93 TEC TEH 610-EB 17 VS2

136 95 TEC TEH 610-EB 27 VS6 136 95 TEC TEH 610-EB 18. VS7

.88

.86

- . 77

.69

- .60

.80

2.06

-1.43

- .83 .74

- . 77

2.23 -1.06

- .29 .06

.88

1.37

- -72

2.20

2.09 1.00 - . 71

.91

1.~o

.83 -1.20 2-03

1.00

1 . 11 '

.83

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

1.46

1. 79

1.30 1 .01

1.15

1.00

.83

1.86

4.01 5.08 1.70 1.68 1.29

1.40 .66

1. 78

.00 M2 .86

.00 M2 1.24

.00 M2 · 1.19

.00 M2 .67

.00 M2 1.52

.00 M2 1.57

.00 M2 .94

_ oo M2 1.19

.00 M2 1.11

.00 M2 1.32

.00 M2 1 _34

.00 M2 1_.65

.00 M2 3.42

.00 M2 1. 77

DAL

DAL

DAL DAL

DAL

DAL

DAL

DAL

DAL DAL DAL DAL

7

5

5

5

5

5

5

5

5

5

5

5 DAL . 5

DAL 5 DAL 5 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

DAL 5

DAL 5 DAL 5

DAL' 5

DAL 5 DAL 5 DAL 5

DAL 6

BEA 5 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION _

I DAL 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION BEA · 5 I RESULT OF DISCREPANC.Y RESOLUTION BEA 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I BEA 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I DAL 5 I DAL 5 I

I +----+;---+---+---+------~---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG.ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS

+----+----~---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

PAGE 2 TUBES 35

' j



+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------~-----------------------------------+

IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I 93 104 TEC TEH 610-EB 15 VS4 I 93 104 TEC TEH 610-EB 12 VS6

I . j 98 107 TEC TEH 610-EB 16 VS2


125· 108 TEC TEH 610-EB 18 VS1 125 108 TEC TEH 610-EB 13 VS4 125 108 TEC TEH 610-EB 12 VS4

113 110 TEC TEH 610-EB 26 VS.4·


98 117 TEC TEH 610-EB 19 VS2 98 117 TEC TEH 610-EB 31 VS4 98 ·117 TEC TEH 610-EB 19 VS6 98 117 TEC TEH 610-EB 18 VS6

93 130 TEC T.EH 610-EB 19 VS4 93 130 TEC TEH 610-EB 11 VS4

·gs 137 ~EC TEH 610-EB 16 VS4

40 147 TEC TEH 610~EB 10 VS4

- .40 1.00

1.03 - . 75 .79

- .66 1.07 - .52

- .95

- .49 .

-1.29

.14 1.05

. 71 - .08

.93 - .88

.00

-1.22

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

1.48 1.09

1.57 1.24 1.30

1.84 1.23 1.13

3.15

1.26 1.29

2.10 4.31 1.96 1.91

1.97 .97

1. 71

.83

WDM SHT

WDM WDM WDM

WDM WDM WDM

SHT

WDM WDM

SHT WDM WDM WDM

WDM WDM

SHT

JTS

4 I 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 4 I 4 I 4 I

I 4 I 4 I 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION


I 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 4 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 4 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY. RESOLUTION 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOL~TION

I 4 I 4 !RESULT OF .DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION


I !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY.RESOLUTION

+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+-. -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - ~ - ~+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - ·-+- - -t- _._ -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ . . IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS

+~---+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+-~-+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ PAGE 3 TOTAL TUBES . 43

• • • SG - A PERCENT CALLS

X : 37 OX TH{U 19x ltfllCA TIONS

x : 1 20X . n~u 29x INDICATIONS * : 17 STAY ROD U : 212 A..UGGED TUBE

X : 2 07. THRU 1~ & 207. THRU 297. INDICATIONS

Pafisades Unit 1 CPL-A SER[S 2530 X : 2 Ox THRU 19x & 30x THRU 39x INDICATIONS

11-26-1996 12:11 HRS. SUPERTUBIN X : 1 Ox T~U 19x & 20x T~U 29x & 30x T~U 39% INDICATIONS

X • • X • X )\,XX ... •.· ••• ••• ··"'><· ·.><. . 135 . . . ·. ·.>< "·,.·.,;c.,--.. ----------

. • . x :· . . x . . . .. · .

. ·.·:·.·.·.<·.·.· .. ·.·.·.·.·.·.·:·.·.·.><.·:·.·.·.·.·:-:·.·. 130 . . . . . . .·,. ·. ·. . ·. :x . 125 .·.· ·.x • . . . . . . . .

.·.·.·.·.·.·.·:·.·.·.·.·:·.·.·.·.·:·.·.·.·.·:·.·.·.·.·:·.·.·.·.·:·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·-. ------120 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ·------11.5 . . x: . . . . . . .

. . : ......... : ......... : ......... : ......... : ......... : ......... : ......... : ......... : ......... :x .. :.. 11() • • • • • • . • • • • • • • • • • • • x . . . . . ----t>5 . . . . . . . . . . . .

• • •••• • ••••• • ••••• • ••••• • ••••• • ••••• • ••••• • ••••• • ••• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •

0><.,------100 :-·x· · · :·· • · ":··x· · · :··x· · · :-· · · · :-· · · · :·· · · · :-· · · · :-· · · · :-· · · · :-· · · · :-· ~ .. . .. · .· .... ,..· . "· ·---95 . . x: . ·: I( •• • • • • • •

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . : ......... : ......... : ......... : ......... : ......... : ......... : ......... : ......... : ......... : ......... : . . . . . . . . 9() •• •• •• •• • • •• •• . • •• • x . . . . . .. ---85

. . .-:·.·.·.-:·.·.·.·.·:·.·.·.·.·:: ... ·.·.·:~.-.·.·.·:·.·.·.·.·:: ... ·~·.·:: ... ·.·.·:: ... ·.·.·:: ... ·.·.·:: ... ·.·.·:: ... ·.·.·:·.·.·.·.·:·:·-. --80 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. --75 . . . . . . . . . . . . .

. •:•:·.·.·.·.·:·.·.·.·.·:·.·.·.·.·:·.·.·.·.·:·.·.·.·.·:·.·.·.·.·:·.·.·.·.·:·.·.·.·.·:·.·.·.·.·:·.·.·.x.·:·.·.·.·.·:·.·.·.·.·:·.·.·.·.·.·. ·.·.·--70 • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • . . • x.. .

--65 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . :·.·.·:·.·.·.·.·:·.·.·.·.·:·.·.·.·.·:·.··.·.·.·:·.·.·.·.·:·.·.·.·.·:·.·.·.·.·:·.·.·.·.·:·.·.·.·.·:·.·.·.·.·:·.·.·.·.·:·.·.·.·.·:·.·.·.·.·:·.·.·.·.··-. -60 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

. -: : : ·. : : ·. . . . . . . . <·-55 .: .... ~: .... :: .... :: .... :: .... :: .... :: .... :~.-•• :-.;~ ••... :: .... :: .... :: .... :: .... :: .... :: .... :::._50 •• • • • ·.·: •• ••• • • • ••• ••• · ••. • • ••• • •. ••• ............... •.•.-.·.- "x' .•• ·.• .. • ...•.. ·,.·.· ... • ....... • •.. ·•· •

. ·. ·. ·. ·. ·. ··.'!.·":!.······":!.·············· ·. ,.·. ·. ·. ·. · .. 45 ·. ·. ·. ·. ·. ·. ·. ··~-.-.·.·.-.·.············ ·. ·. ·. ·. ..·. ·. ·-. . . . . . . . •• , .-•••• -. =-: • • • • • . . . . . . . • • • • • • • ·g=-=·~· L-. • •-• •- W • • • • x • • • • • • . • • . • • • • .-.---... .-. • • • • . . . . . . 40 ....... "... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. ~ ..... •-• •••••............................. ·-.·.· ... ·.· ... ·.· ... ·.· ... ·.· ... ·.·.. .•. ,_ .......................... ·.· ... ·.· ... ·.· ... ·.· ... ·.· ... ·.· ·. i I i I i- I i I i I i I i I-~ r·i·r·i··1 i I i I i I i I i I i I

iii> i~5" '~" 145" i40 ;~ ifO jiff 12.0 fr5" Iii> ;o; ioo ~ 90 ~ 80 is 7o 65" 60 5S" 50 45' 40. 35" 30 z> '2D t'i" 10 ~ I

• • • SG-A MANUFACTURERS BUFF MARK LOCATIONS / 123 TUBE WITH MBM

~ Palisades Unit 1 CPL -A SERIES 2530

\E!;) 11-25-1996 14:50 HRS. SUPERTUBIN

IQ! : 309 PLUGGED TUBE * : 25 STAY ROD

.· • .· .. ·.··~~········~~····· . : . . 135 .·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·:·:·.·. 130

.· •. · .· :: :: :: :: :: . . 125 ... : : : ~ ........ : ~ ... : .... : ~ ...•.•.. : ~ ..... : .. : ~ ........ : ~ ........ : ~ ....... ;: ~.:.::.. 120

. :· ,/ . :: =· :· :· =· . . . . 115 •

1 •••• i ~ ........ ~ i ....... ; ~ j ... ; .. ;: j~ ........ ~ i. ~ ...... ~ i ... ~ .... ~ ~ ........ ~ ~ ....... ) ~ ........ ~ ~ .. :... ~~

.·, ·t : .... ·:: · ·. · · · · -::· · · ·. · · r· · ·.· .-:: · · · · · · · · :: · · · · · · · · :: · · · · · · · · :: · · · · · · · ·:: · · · · · · · '! :, · · · · · · ·:: · · · · ·, · ·:, = · =. llO

..... ·=: ........ ( .. · .... :! .·.· .. ·)···· ... ·:1 ······ .. ::· .. · .·.-:: .· ...... :: .· .· .... :: ........ : :·: ...... :: ... · .... :: .... : :: . . 5 . : ~ j: ....... j j ........ ~ ~ ........ ~~ ........ ~ j ........ ~ ~ ........ ~ j ........ ~ ~ ........ ~ ~ ........ ~ ~ ........ ~ ~ ........ ~ ~ ........ ~ ~ ........ :::.: ~

... ==·:~·······;j~·:······~~········~j········jj·······:~~········~j········\~········\~···:····~~-·.·.·.·~~-·.·.·.·~~-·.·.·.·i~········i~····:: . ~ ==·:··~:·;····· ·::·""···~~-·,, .. ·.· ~~·· ... ·.·=~··. · ... -:~ .·.·.· .·:~ ... · .·.·: ~ ........ ~~ ... · .... : ~ ...... ) ~ ...... ,·: ~ ........ : ~ ....... < ~,,· ..... :: 60

/···: .-;: .... '. .. }. ·' .·. ·:i····· .. · (i ... ·.;t .~ .·.-=:··. ·.·... . .... :: ..... ···!: ........ :: .·.; .... ii ..... ;·.:: ....... ;:: ... ;· .. ·::::: : :::.·.·.·.·::.·.·.·.·::.·.·.·~·::.·.·.·.·::.·.·.·.·::.·.·.·. •• •• :: •· •• •· .• :: •• J .• .• :: •• .• •• •. :: -~ .• •• -~ :: •• .• .• •. :: .• _:_ 40

.

.. =. ·. : .,, : . . . . . -: -: -: -: -: -: : ' 35 . / :· / / :· ·. ;•. ·. ,/ ·. ·. ·. ·-•. · :· :: • ; :: •· .· • • .... :.··.'·.·.·.·=.· .. ·.·.·.·:.· .. ·.·.l.·=.· .... ·' ... ·:.· .. ·.·.·.·=.· .... ·= .. -30

•:; • :.: •••••••• ·.·.: ••••••• ;: •• =; ••••••• =.".· .. ;. -~·. ~ .. = ......... =.= ...... . :: :: :: :: -:: I I :~ _: 25

.: 11 :: :: ,/ :: :: :: .• ••· .... :: ... ·.·.·=.: ... ~.- ... ::.-'.·· .... :.:.~.- ... ~=.·.·.·.·.·.·=.·.·.·.·.···=---. 20 .·.•:•,r,·.·.·.·.·.·. ·.;. ·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.; .·.·. ·. ·.·. ·.· .· .·.·. • ,~ ~ ;: :: ~ / :: :: /:: :· ·. /: ,.:: " -: -: " / -: /-: . 15

/.-+·.:.·.·::···· , ... }·····. ·:~· .: .. : .. ::-- ..... '. :: .. ( : : ~: ........ : :,: . '. .. :. il ·. :· .;, ·1: ....... i :: ..... ,::i · .... ;: :-~ t··r···i"··r·"i"·r·"i""r·"("i""i·"'r·" i·J.i.·.·i·.·.i····i·.·.i····i·.·.i····i·.·.i.·;,i·.·.i···· ii~ ltP 1'i5' i~-& 14~ i4i> iW •30 ii~ iii> ti? iii> ii;i5" ii>i> c)S- 9i> es- So 7~ 7l:> 6~- 6o 5S" so 4S- qo 3S" 30 ZS" "l..0 I'S° 10 5"

LIST OF ALL MBM'S


+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+-------------------------~------------------------+

IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 !NCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------~---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

12 3 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM DBH 15.63 .00 3 1.22 35 SHT 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 14 3 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 5.51 .00 3 .74 97 SHT 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 4 9 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 15.05 .00 .57 151 WOM 16 I

I 10 9 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H .78 .00 M1 .47 120 SHT 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 10 · 9 --------------------------------------------------------·'·-------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 10 9 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H ·-1 .29 .oo .68 154 SHT 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 10 _9 .: .. --------------------------------------------------------------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 10 9 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 20.54 .00 1 .23 142 SHT 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 10 9 ------------------------------------------------------------------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 10 9 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 23.37 .00 1 .17. 71 SHT 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 10 9 ------------,-----------------------------------------------------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I t4 9 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 15.33 .00 1 1.41 152 SHT 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 14 9 ------------------------------------------------------------------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED


I 2 -11 TEC TEH 590-EB MBM 03H 16.20 .00 3 1.80 1f1 WOM 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

2 11 TEC TEH 590-EB MBM 05H .46 '.00 .60 157 WJS 15 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION

I 33.33 .00 3 .74 113 WOM 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION e 9 12 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C

I 17 12 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 2.84 .00 .36 159 WOM 16 I

I 26 13 TSH TSH 610-ZP MBM TSH 4.47 .00 4 .62 73 BEA 76 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 28 15 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 22.49 .00 .57 159 WOM 16 !HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 44 15 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H -1.87 .00 .45 130 WOM 16 I HISTORY. REVIEW PERFORMED 44 15 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 30.99 .00 1 .45 30 SHT 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 44 1 5 ~ - '.. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - " - - - - - - -·. - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REV! EW PERFORMED

I 48 15 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 21.97 .00 1 .27 96 SHT 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 48 15 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -· - · - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ·I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 3 18 TEC TEH 590-EB MBM 04H 19.04 .00 1 .25 141 WOM 15 JHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

3 18 TEC TEH 590-EB MBM 03C 19.43 .00 3 .55 104 SHT 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 11 18 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 4.20 .00 .29 70 WOM 16 !HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

11 18 TSH TSH 610-ZP MBM TSH 3.88 .00 4 .93 96 WOM 31 I I

15 1B TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 24.60 .00 .60 162 WOM 16 I I

59 18 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 26.40 .00 .32 135 WOM 16 !HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+~-------+--------+----+------+---+----+~---+-------------------------·-------------------------+ JROW COL .CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----·-~--·--------------------------------------------------+

PAGE TUBES 18

LIST OF ALL MBM'S


+----+----+---+---+------+---+~--+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND.LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

8 21 TEC.TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 10.07 .00 1 .47 148 SHT 16 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY .RESOLUTION 8 21. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - , - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -.- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

22 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 22 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H

26 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H


9.76 5.22

31.19

34.38

.oo 3

.oo 3

.oo 3

.oo

. 86 56 JTS 1.06 68 JTS

.79 50 JTS

.20 106 SHT



1,

9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 42 21 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 42 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 4.52 .00 1 .52 153 SHT 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION. 42 21 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 42 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 8.21 .00 ·1 .20 120 JTS 9 !HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 42 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05C

48 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 48 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 48 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM DSC 48 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM DBC 48 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM DBC

. 48 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05C 48 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 48 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 48 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C

60 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05C 60 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 60 60 60

17

33

18 18 18 18

24

42

21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C

24 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H


27 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 27 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 27 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 27 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H

27 TSH TSH 610-ZP MBM TSH

27 TEC.TEH 610-EB MBM 03C

11.02

14.78 24.10

- .40 1.30 2.06

17.28 28.46' 25.66 24.15

10.15 32.74 22.46 5.70 4.80

35.78

33.56

9.67 5.47 8.33 9.14

3.45

33.93

.oo

.oo 3

.oo 3

.oo 3

.oo 3 ' .oo 3

.oo 3

.oo 3

.oo. 3

.oo ,3

.oo ·3

.oo 3 .. oo 3

.oo 3

.00 3

.oo 3

.00 3

.oo 3

.00 3

.oo 3

.oo 3

.oo 4

.oo 3

.53 132 JTS

.89 63 JTS

. 94 85 JTS 1.34 74 JTS

.91 82 JTS

.98 42 JTS

. 72 98 JTS

.95 55 JTS

.84 40 JTS

.99 53 JTS

. 52 9o JTS

.73 101 JTS

.47 83 JTS

.47 103 JTS

.50 95 JT~

. 78 109 JTS

.60 68 JTS

.48 91 JTS

. 51 98 JTS

. 54 80 JTS

.69 82 JTS

.41 . 76 WRH

1.07 113 JTS

9 I HISTORY .REVIEW PERFORMED

I 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION . 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 .!RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY.RESOLUTION 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 !RESULT.OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION



I 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION . 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION



I 15 30 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 14.36 .00 .46 152 SHT 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 15 30· ~ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+-------------------------~------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

PAGE 2 TUBES 30

e

LIST OF ALL MBM'S


+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

8 33 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 14. 15 . 00 1 . 25 105 SHT 9 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION . 8 33 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 8 33 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 22. 71 . 00 1 . 29 125 SHT 9 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 8 33 ----------,----------------------------------------,--------------!HISTORY REVIEW.PERFORMED

I 14 33 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 3.76 .00 1 .26 57 SHT 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 14 33 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 14 33 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 34.78 .00 3 .77 69 JTS 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 30 33 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 4.41 .00 1 .25 43 SHT 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 30 33 -----------------------------------------------------:------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

34 33 TEC TEH 610-EB.MBM TSH 34 33 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H

44 33 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM DBH 44 33 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM DBH

7.66 9.08

20.18 21.01

.00 3

.00 3

.00 3

.00

I .69 88 JTS 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION· .62 69 JTS 9 I RESULT. OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I .79 87 SHT 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION .31 114 SHT 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

44 33 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 48 33 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 11. 78· .00 3 1.03 47 JTS 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 48 33 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 25.18 .00 3 .92 62 JTS 9 !RESULT OF DISCR~PANCY RESOLUTION

I 102 33 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 22.43 .00 3 .92 108 JTS 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 5 36 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 13.42 .00 3 .50 89 JTS 9 I

I 9 36 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 29.94 .00 . 58 147 JTS 9 I 9 36 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 11.31 .00 .70 156 JTS 9 I

I 21 36 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 2.54 .00 3 .65 96 SHT 10 I RESULT OF DI_SCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 4 39 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 4.22 ,oo 3 .60 82 JTS 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 4 39 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 16.82 .00 1 .20 91 SHT 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 4 39 ----------------------------~-------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 4 39 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C . 26.44 .00 3

46 · 39 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 26.63 .oo 3

3 42 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 27.26 .00

.49 68 JTS 9 I

I .48 92.SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I .24 151 BEA 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

3 42 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 59 42 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS4 6.55

14 45 TEC TEH 610:EB MBM DBH 23.00

.00 3

.00

.54 113 SHT 10 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 1.18 13 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESO.LUTION

14 45 : - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - --- - - - - - - - - - .- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 14 . 45 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 8.65 .00 3 .63 76 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 22 45 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 5.34 .00 .36 59 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+------------------------------------------------:-+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LDC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+----------------------------------------·----------+

PAGE 3 TUBES 45

e

LIST OF ALL MBM'S


+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+-------------------------------~------------------+

jROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+~--+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

22 45 - - - - - - - - - - - - -- -- - - - - - -- - - - - - -·- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - --- - - - - ---- - - --- - - -I HISTORY. REVIEW PERFORMED 22 45 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 14.02 .00 1 .36 61 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 22 45 - - - - - - - - - - -- -·- - - -- -- -- - - - - - - - ---- - - - - - ---------- - --- - -- ---- - - - - --- !HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 40 45 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS4 19.93. .00 1 .90 20 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 40 45 --------------------------------------------------'.·--------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 44 45 TEC TEH 610,-EB MBM 04C 32.54 .00 3 .64 86 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 46 45 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 91.65 .00 3 1.75 26 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 46 45 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS4 21.22 .00 1 .47 33 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 46 45 ~-----------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 46 45 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS4 2.39 .00 1 .17 103 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 46 45· - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REV~EW PERFORMED

I 15 46.TEC TEH 610-EB MB.M 03H -.14 .00 M1 .47 64 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 15 46 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 9 -48 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H -.80 .00 M1 .26 69 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 48 ---------------:·-------------------------------------------------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 9 48 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 28.49 .00 1 .35 '155 SHT 10 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTIQN

9 4.8 . - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -,- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - : · - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 9 48 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 24.15 .oo . 65 153 SHT 1 0 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION .

9 48 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 9 48-TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 21.68 .00 1 .27 143 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 48 - - - - : - - - - , - : - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -·- - - - - - - - : - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 9 48 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 19.62 .00 1 ·· .32 140 SHT 10 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION·


I 101 48 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 12.58 .00 3 . 60 105 JTS 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 16 51 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 5.69 .00 1 .63 150 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 16 51 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 16 51 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 5.88 .00 .25 37 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 16 51 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 34 51 TEC TEH p10-EB MBM 05H 11.66 .00 1 .41 149 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

34 51 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 34 51 TSH TSH 610-ZP PIO TSH -.07 .00 .81 15 JTS 30 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION·

34 51 ------------------------------------------------,------------------1>>>>> POSITIVE I.D. ESTABLISHED<<<<< 34 51 TSH TSH 610-ZP SAI TSH -.05 .00 8 2.40 8 WJS 30 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION

34 51 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I RETEST FOR POSITIVE I .D. 34 51 TSH TSH 610-ZP DIM TSH 323.00 .00 80.00 50 WJS 30 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION

I 56 51 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 56 51 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H

37.26 14.01

.00 3

.00 3

1. 73 121 WDM 2.23 118 WDM

10.jRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 102 51 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 11.00 ,oo .37 150 JTS 8 I

+----+--·--+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+----------------------------.----------------------+ jROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------~-----+

PAGE 4 TUBES 56

LIST OF ALL MBM'S


+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+-~--+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--:·----------------------------------------~-----+

106 51 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 10.92 .00 3 .51 81 JTS 8 !RESULT OF.DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 118 51 TEC TEH 610-.EB MBM 04C 22.92 .00 3 .72 97 JTS 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 118 51 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 8.11 .00 .26 94 JTS 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 2 57 TEC TEH 590-EB MBM TSC 20.34 .00 3 .67 84 RJP 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 32 57 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 16.08 .oo 3 .55 103 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 9 60 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 7.86 .00 3 .59 109 WDM 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 60 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 3.06 .00 1 .43 153 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 60 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -·- - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 17 60 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 14.38 .oo 1 1.00 24 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 17 60 ·------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 104 75 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 18. 72 .00 .31 150 DAL 7 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 104 75 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 23.39 .00 .30 143 DAL 7 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 104 75 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 24.91 .00 .. 19 140 DAL 7 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 104 87 TEC TEH 610-·EB MBM 01C 24.19 .oo ·1 .25 49 WJS 6 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 104 87 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED·

e I 92 99 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06H 15. 76 .oo .65 155 AJD 5 I

I 104 99 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 14.82 .00 3 ) .03 112 SHT 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 106 99 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 12.47 .00 .35 140 SHT 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 106 99 - - - - - - - - - - '. - - ; - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -, - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 107 102 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 16.55 .00 1 .29 145 SHT 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 107 102 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 10 105 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 34.05 .00 .24 151 DAL 12 !RESULT.OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 50 105 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 12.02 .00 3 .86 99 AJD 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION


I 108 105 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 29.53 .00 3 1.01 118 SHT 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

108 105 TEC TEH 610-,EB MBM 03H . -1.55 .00 3 .98 119 SHT 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 108 105 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 26.49 .00 3 .56 95 SHT 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 116 105 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 14.40 .00 3 .57 91 SHT 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 53 108 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 32.83 .00 3 . 59 106 SHT 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I +----+----+---+-.--+------+---+---+----.----+--------+----+------+---+----+----+---------------------~-~--------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS· DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

PAGE 5 TUBES 74

e

LIST OF ALL MBM'S


+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+-------------------------~------------------------+


I I I I I I I I

2 111 TEC TEH 590-EB MBM 03H 12.68 .00 .91 20 JTS 14

14 111 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 30.43 .00 .64 140 DAL 12

18 111 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 25.39 .00 1 .18 114 BEA 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 18 111 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REV! EW PERFORMED

I 48 111 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM DBC 4.70 .00 3 1.00 75 BEA 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 48 111 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -.- - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 106 111 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06C 7.86 .00 3 . 77 95 SHT 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 113 112 TSH TSH 610-ZP MBM TSH 3.08 .00 4 .57 117 BEA 47 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 35 114 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C -1.51 .00 3 1.40 120 SHT 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 34 117 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 22.87 .00 3 1.30 55 JTS 3 I

I 46 117 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 12.24 .00 3 .88 119 SHT 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 46 117 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 8.13 .00 3 .70 B6·SHT 3 IRE~ULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 46 117 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 35.37 .00 3 1.16 116 JTS 3 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY. RESOLUTION 46 117 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 37.09 .00 3 .64 96 JTS 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 48 117 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 22.22 .00 3 .97 86 JTS 3 I 48· 117 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 10.10 .00 3 .80 60 JTS ·3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 29 120 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 15.02 .00 .32 37 SHT 3 !RESULT Of DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

29 120 --------------------------:--~------------------------------------IHIS10RY REVIEW PERFORMED

I .2 123 TEC TEH 590-EB MBM 04H· 9.95 .00 3 .70 66 JTS 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 14 123 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 28.56 .00 1 .24 131 RJP 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION


I 20 123 TEG TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 14.07 .00 3 .75 70 RJP 2·IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 28 123 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 34.03 .00 3 1.32 78 RJP 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 30 123 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 5.11 .00 1 .19 133 RJP 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 30 123 --------------------------------------------------------------~---!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 30 123 TSH TSH 610-ZP RBD JTS 18 I -

I 34 123 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 2.91 .00 3 1.01 122 JTS 2 !HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 15 126 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 30.32 .00 .75 157 JTS 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 27 126 TEC TEH. 610-EB MBM 02C 14.34 .00 .35 142 JTS 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

27 126 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 35.98 .00 .21 145 RJP 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+~-------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL .CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - •• - • - - - - - - - - - - - • - - • - - - - - -+

PAGE 6 TUBES 92

LIST OF ALL MBM'S


+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ !ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

27 126 ···················-···································:··········!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 59 126.TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS4 10.11 .00 .93 156 JTS 2 IHISTO.~Y REVIEW PERfORMED 59 126 TEC TEH ·510 ·EB MBM VS4 8. 22 . 00 1 . 14 92 RJP 2 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 59 126 ·················-··-·············································!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 59 126 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS4 13.32 .00 1 .32 171 RJP 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 59 . 126 · · · · · · · · · · - · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · ·.-- · ·······I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 8 129 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 16.30 .oo 3 .88 115 BEA 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 8 129 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 11.89 .oo .23 133 BEA 12 I RES.ULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 28 129 TEC TEH 610·EB MBM TSC 18.65 .oo 1 .18 91 RJP 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION: 28 129 ···············-··-···-······-····································!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I I 48 129 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 21.97 .. oo .30 62 JTS 2 I I

I I 17 132 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 2.48 .oo .73 149 JTS 2 I I

I I 33 132 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 12.33 .oo .37 149 JTs· 2 I I

. I I 41 132 TEC. TEH 610·EB MBM TSH 15.22 .oo .84 157 JTS 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 41 132 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 27.30 .oo ·.21 150 JTS. 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 41 132 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 26.95 .00 .36 138 JTS 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I

e I 1. 16 135 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 35.01 .oo .32 131 JTS 2 I I 16 135 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 10.22 .00 1 .21 48 RJP 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 16 1 35 ... · · · - · . - · · · · · - · - - · · · · · · · · · - · · · · · · · · · · · · · ·. · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I

I I 18 135 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 34.90 : .oo .25 98 RJP 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 18 135 ---~·-··········-···-··-···················--···········-·········!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 18 135 TEC TEH e10:EB MBM 02C . 10. 77 .oo .40 155 JTS 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 18 135 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 34.22 .oo .55 154 JTS 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 22 135 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 12.02 .oo .36 80 JTS 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION .

I 50 135 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 20.73 .oo .37 144 JTS 2 !RESULT.OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 106 135 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM DBH 27.02 .00 1 .30 131 SHT 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 106 135 ···:······--··-·-·············--··································!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 27 138 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 3.22 .00 .68 152 JTS 2 I 27 138 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 6.15 .00 .62.150 JTS 2 I

I 35 138 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 9.84 .oo 3 1.15 120 RJP 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 18 141 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 20.06 .oo .96 158 JTS I

I 28 141 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 8.75 .oo 3 1 .43 121 JTS 1 I

+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

!ROW COL CEB C~E PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 ·CHAN VOL TS DEG ANAL TAPE I COMMENTS

+----+---~·---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+------------·--~-~---------------------------------+

PAGE 7 TUBES 109

e

LIST OF ALL MBM'S


+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+---------------------------------------------~----+

68 141 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 22.14 .00 3 .48 113 JTS 1 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 68 141 TSH TSH 610-ZP RBD WDM 20 I

I 9 144 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 36.33 .00 1 .13 140 BEA 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 144 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 9 ·144 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 37.04 .00 .32 94 BEA 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 144 ----------------------------------------------------------------.--IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 53 144 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 13.52 .00 .. 50 155 JTS I 53 144 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 32.15 .00 .23 142 JTS 1·

I 58 147 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 32.50 .00 .74 153 JTS 1 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 15 150 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 4.17 .00 3 1.02 117 JTS I

I 16 1,53 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 1.39 .00 3 1.03 102 RJP 1 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 18 153 TEC·TEH 610-EB MBM 02H ·5.96 .00. 1 .44 151 DAL I 18 153 TEC TEH 610-EB.MBM 03H 14.84 .00 3 .69 98 RJP 1 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION.

I 44 153 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 31.65 .00 3· .55 81 RJP !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 50 15.3 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 14.57 .00 . 73 163 DAL I

I 56 153 TEC TEH 610- EB MBM 04H 5.33 .00 .24 151 DAL I 56 153 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 31.67 .00 .50 156 DAL I 56 153 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 29.04 .00 .75 157 DAL I

I 8 159 TEC TEH 610-EB·MBM 03H 33.99 .00 3 .90 123 JTS !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 8 159 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 0.1C 23.41 .00 3 .82 ·82· RJP !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 14 159 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H .57 .00 M1 .27 78 BEA 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I· 14 1 59 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I I I I I I I I I I

16 .159 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C io:83 .00 1 .27 151 BEA 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION .16 1 59. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - : - -.- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 16 159 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 25.04 .00 .17 100 BEA 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 16 159 -------------·--:---------------------------------------·:··------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 48 159 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 26.21 .00

27 162 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 34.45 .00

3 .88 80 WDM

.51 150 DAL


I 12 I

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+----------------~---------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 .INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS

+----~----+---+---+-·--~--·---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+-------------------------------~------------------+ PAGE 8 TOTAL TUBES 123

LIST OF ALL TRA'S


+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+ - - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+ - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+-:-+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

23 4 TSH TSH 610-ZP TRA TSH .47

24 5 TSH TSH 61 0 -ZP. TRA TSH .56

71 14 TSH TSH 610-ZP TRA TSH 2.22

Z1 16 TSH TSH 610-ZP TRA TSH 1 .57


60 25 TSH TSH 610-ZP TRA TSH - .41





93 ?O TSH TSH 610-ZP.TRA TSH .08

96 73 TSH TSH 610-ZP TRA TSH :00

106 ·73 TSH TSH 610-ZP TRA TSH .oo




129 106 TSH. TSH 610-ZP TRA TSH .43



83 110 TSH TSH 610-ZP TRA TSH -.12

109 110 TSH.TSH 610-ZP TRA TSH -2.50

127 110 TSH TSH 610-ZP TRA TS~ 1.07

-:129 110 TSH TSH 610-ZP·TRA TSH .62


.00 4

.00 4

.00 4

.00 4

. 00 4

.00 4

.00 4

.00 4

.00 4

.00 4

.00 4

.00 4

.00 4

.00 4

.00 4

.00 4

.00 4

.00 4

.00 4

.00 4

.00 4

.00 7

.00 7

.00 4

.77 202"MAR 73 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 1.48 208 MAR 73 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 1.67 195 BEA 38 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION



I 2.76 168 WAH 78 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION



I 2.72 191 BEA 39 !RESULT OF.DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

1. 1.89 184 BEA 39 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 1.22 17 BEA 63 !RESULT OF .~ISCREPANCY RESOLUTION



I 1.56 182 WJS 22 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION

I 3.69 168 WJS 27 IRESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION



I 1.47 155 WAH 90 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION




I .50 152 MAR 56 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I .46 151 MAR 56 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION


·-~--·----+---+-~-+------+---+---+~-------+--------+:---+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS

+---:+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+~-------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

PAGE TUBES 25

LIST OF ALL TRA'S


+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ JROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEJ COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

115 126 TSH TSH 610-ZP TRA TSH - .01 .00 4 1.73 138 BEA 52 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 116 127 TSH TSH 610-ZP TRA TSH .00 .00 4 .69 103 BEA 52 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 99 130 TSH TSH 610-ZP TRA TSH 2.13 .00 4 1.47 177 WRH 51 I

I 107 · 130 TSH TSH 610-ZP TRA TSH .39 .00 4 3.02 149 WRH 51 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 109 130 TSH TSH 610-ZP TRA TSH .32 .00 4 3. 77 332 DAL 51 I

I 32 131 TSH TSH 610-ZP TRA TSH .85 .00 4 1.31 133 DAL 91 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 73 148 TSH TSH 610-ZP TRA TSH .10 .00 4 1.08 129 WRH 90 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY.RESOLUTION

+~---+----+---+---+------+---+-.--+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+----------------~---------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+---~--+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+-------------------~:-----------------------------+

PAGE 2 .TOTAL TUBES 31

LIST OF ALL DENTS

Palisades Unit 1 CPL -A/2530 INSPECTION: Nov-96 1-Jun-97 11: O


+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

20 3 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4


28 3 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 28 3 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4


20 9 TEC TEH.610-EB ONT VS4
















24 · 21 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4



1.33

.66

1.12 . 72

- . 72

1.33

.75

.32

.41

.75

.90

·- .58 - .89

1.15

.37

.55

.60

-1.30

- . 78

-1.13

- .98

. 81

.73

.27

- .57

. 00 M1 7 . 37 1 77 WDM 16

.00 M1 5.59 176 WDM 16

.00 M1 5.10 179 WDM 16

.00 M1 5.19 178 WDM 16

.00 M1 5.18 175 WDM 16

. 00 M1 28. 76 175 WDM 16

.00 M1 11.41 176 WDM 16

.00 M1 5.16 176 WDM 16

.00 M1 5.90 176 SHT 16 RESULT OF DiSCREPANCY RESOLUTION

.00 M1 6.28 175 WDM 16

.00 M1 11.14 177 WDM 16

.00 M1 5.05 178 WDM 16

.00 M1 5.76. 177 WDM 16

·.00 M1 27.77 175 WDM ·15

.00 M1 13.40 174 WDM 16

.00 M1 7.88 177 WDM 16

. 00 M1 7. 26 1 77 WDM 1 6

.00 M1 27.27 178 WDM 16

.00 M1 11.41 174 WDM 16

.00 M1 5.45 176 WDM 16

.00 M1 6.56 179 WDM 10

.00 M1 28.10 175 SHT 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

.00 M1 7. 78 177 SHT

.oo· M1 7.09 178 JTS

.. 00 M1 5.18 178 SHT


I 9 I


+----+----+: .. +---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+-------------------------------------------~------+

PAGE TUBES 24

LIST OF ALL DENTS

Palisades Unit 1 CPL ·A/2530 INSPECTION: Nov-96 1-Jun-97 11: o

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ !ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------~-----+

99 26 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT 07H 26.75

20 27 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 .00




23 30 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 - . 75

20 33 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 .oo





42 33 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 -1. 78

21 36 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 .. 92'

29 36 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT DBH 2.45

20 39 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 .83 .

22 39 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 . 77





23. 42 TEC TEH 610~EB ONT VS4 -.69

27 42 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT ·vs4 .. 72

39 . 42 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 -1.00


.00 7.39 193 RJP

.00 M1 38.94 175 JTS

.00 M1 5.13 176 JTS

.00 M1 5.50 176 JTS

.00 M1 5.37 178 JTS

.00 M1 5.81 176 SHT

.00 M1 26.01 176 JTS

.00 M1 9.14 177 SHT

.00 M1 6.57 177 JTS

.00 M1 5.13 176 SHT

.00 M1 5.62 177 JTS


I 9 I

I 9 I

I 9 I

I 9 I


I 9 I


I 9 I

I 9 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTIO.N

I 9 I

I .00 5.38 180 SHT 9 !RESULT O~ DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

.00 M1

.• OQ

I 5.67 176 WOM 10 I

I 7.04 179 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I .00 M1 41.15 177 WOM 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY.RESOLUTION

I .00 M1 6.60 177 WOM 10 I

I .00 M1 8.17 177 WOM 10 I

I .00 M1 6.25 177 WOM 10 I

I .00 M1 5.56 178 WOM 10 I

I .oo M1 5.16 178 WOM 10 I

I .00 M1 8.76 175 WOM 10 I

I .00 M1 11.89 175 WOM ·10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I .00 M1 8.43 177 WOM 10 I

I .00 M1 28.19 177 WOM 10 I

I I I I I I I ·I I I I I I I I I

+----+----+---+-·~-·------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+---------------------~--------------------------~-+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS

+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - • :+. - -+- - :.+. - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - .. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

PAGE 2 TUBES 48

LIST OF ALL DENTS

Palisades Unit 1 CPL ·A/2530 INSPECTION: Nov-96 1-Jun-97 11: o

+----+----+---+---+------+·---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+-------------------------r------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

24 45 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 .88 .00 M1 11 .88 178 WDM 10

28 45 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 .48 .00 M1 10.84 175 WDM 10


21 48 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 -1.06 .00 M1 7.82 178 WDM 10

29 48 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 - .43 .00 M1 7.21 178 WDM 10

20 $1 TEC. TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 1.03 .00 M1 21.23 175 WDM 10

22 51 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 1.14 .00 M1 5.74 178 SHT 10 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

26 51 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 .34 :OO M1 7.84 176 WDM 10


32 51 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 :48 .00 M1 8.18 178 SHT 10 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

36 51 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 . 7.7 .00 M1 6. 79 177 WDM 10

e 126 51 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT 02C 5.54 .00 ' 5.20 181 RJP 8 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

27 · 54 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 - .66 .00 M1 6.70 177 WDM 10

20 57 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 1.31 .00 M1 27.14 175 WDM 10

22 57 TEC TEH 610-EB 'ONT VS4 1.20 .00 M1 5.33 178 WDM 10

24 57 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 .83 .00 M1 12. 98 176 WDM 10

26 57 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 .60 .oo M1 5. 29 177 WDM. 10


32 57 TEC 'TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 .94 .00 M1 5.53 176 WDM 10






+-;--+-·---+--~+---+------+---+---+~-------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------~-----------+ e PAGE 3 TUBES 72

LIST OF ALL DENTS

Palisades Unit 1 CPL -A/2530 INSPECTION: Nov-96 1-Jun-97 11: O

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ JROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC -INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEJ COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+-------~--------------·---------------------~------+

46 69 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 -1.26

106 81 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 1.31

132 99 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS7 .93

20 105 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 . 91

22 - 105 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 1.14

24 105 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 .85

26 105 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 .73

28 105 TEC TEH 610:EB ONT VS4 .39

21 108 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 - .66

29 108 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 - .89

20 111 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 1.06

26 111 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 .57

28 111 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 .51

60 111 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS3 .86

27 114 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT V~4 -.94

35 114 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 -.86

24 117 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 .85

26 117 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 .65

28 117 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 .46

124 117 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS1 - .26

22 123 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 .85

26 123 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 .57

60 123 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS3 . 77

120 123 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS1 .00

.oo_ M1 7.00 179 WDM 11

.00 M1 20.62 178 BEA 6 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

.00 M1 6.50 177 AJD 5

.00 M1 9.73 176 DAL 12

.00 M1 9.03 175 WDM 16

.00 M1 8.40 175 WDM _ 16

.00 M1 10.03 174 WDM 16

.00 M1 5.00 175 WDM 16 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I .00 M1 6._39 177 WDM 16 I

I . 00 M1 7. 16 176 WDM 16 I

I .00 M1 7.30 175 WDM 16 I

I . 00 M1 11 . 30 175 WDM 16 I

I .00 M1 5.31 176 WDM 16 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I .oo M1 5.70 180 AJD 3 I

I . 00 M1 5. 55 177 SHT 16 J _RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I .oo M1 11.13 175 WDM 16 I

I .00· M1 7.85 179 JTS 3 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

.00 M1 6.98 180 JTS

.00 M1 5.14 179 JTS

.00 M1 6.58 179 WDM

.00 M1 6.85 177 JTS

.00 M1 6. 70 177 JTS

.00 M1 5.89 180 JTS

.00 M1 6.28 179 WDM

3

3

4

2

2

3 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 4 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I I I I I I I I I I I I II

+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

JROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEJ COMMENTS

+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

PAGE 4 TUBES 96

LIST OF ALL DENTS


+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+~--+----+----+---------------------------------------------.-----+

24 129 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 .85 .00 M1 8. 76 177 JTS 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION·

I 26 129 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 .51 .00 M1 6.15 176 JTS 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 29 132 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 - .80 .00 M1 12.54 176 JTS 2 I

I 26 135 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 .70 .00 M1 11.40 175 JTS 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 104 135 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS2 .00 .00 M1 9.86 179 A.JD 3 I 104 135 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS6 .65 .00 M1 5.03 179 A.JD 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 27 138 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 -1.08 .00 M1 17.90 176 JTS 2 I

I 24 141 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 .92 .00 M1 10.64 174 JTS !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 26 141 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 .40 .00 Mi 8.68 175 JTS I

I 29 144 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 - .64 .00 M1 6.10 179 RJP !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 26 1_47 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 .19 .00 M1 7.32 176 JTS RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

20 1_53 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4. 1.41 .00 M1 5. 89 176 DAL - 22 153 TEC TEH 610-EB.DNT VS4 .82 .00 M1 6.96 177 DAL

24 153 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 .67 .00 M1 23. 83 175 DAL

26 153 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 .56 .00 M1 9.09 176 DAL


42 159 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT DBH 24.96 .00 13.83 181 BEA . 11 RESULT OF.DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

+----+-·---+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+---~-------------------------------~--------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - .. - - - - - - - - - - - - - ... - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

PAGE 5 TOTAL TUBES 111

• • • SG - A HOT lE G INDICATION DISTRIBUTION

V 2 VOLUMETRIC INDICATION ( PLUGGABLE )

X 2 AXIAL INDICATION (PLUGGABLE) L. 2 POSSIBLE LOOSE PARTS

lft1\ Palisades Unit 1 CPAL 1-A SERIES 2530 .

\g) 12-06-1996 12: 10 HRS. SUPERTUBIN

1 36 0% TO 19% INDICATION 2 3 20r. TO 29r. INDICATION .3 3 30% TO .39% INDICATION / 82 MANUFACTURERS BUFF MARKS

IQ! : 309 PLUGGED TUBE * : 25 STAY ROD

.. ·.·····::···'····:::~·'··:·.:·.•. . 135

.·.·· ;··:(:;:.:.~:··.·.:·)·····~-·~~········~i·······)>.·. . . ~~ .·:·::.·-·.·.·::.·.·.·.·::.·-·.·.·::.·-·.·.·::.·-·.·.·::.·-·.·.·::.·.·.·.·::.·-·:·. 120

• • .... w : : , :: : : : : : : : : : : : : • • 115 _,. .· ·i~. ·.· .· .· ~~ ... ·.· .. :: .· ·;· ·;· :~ ... ·.·. ·~~ .·.· .... :~·· ... · .. ~~ .· .· ... ·: ~ ... · .... ~~ ........ ~:·. :-. 110 . . . . • :, . : . , : . • : . . . . 105 .. : ·.:::: ..... ~ :.: ........ ~ ·.~.; .... < -~.; ...... ~ ~- ........ ~ :.< ...... ~ -~ ........ ~ :.: ........ ~ :.: ...... -~~ :~ .... '. .. ~ :.: ........ j >: . 95100

• • •. • • t ·~ • • • • • :: • • • • •

. ·. -~~········ i:········~~ .·. ·.·.;~~- .. ·.· .· ~: .· .·.· .-~~-· .·. ·.· :: .· ... · .. ~~ .· .·. ·.·~~ ....... -~~. :· .. ·.·: ~. · ..... ·~ ~. · ... :'---: ----~ :::·.·. ···::.·.·.· ··:~-·.·.·.· ::.·.·. ·. -~~- ·.·. ·.· :~-·.·.·.·:~ ... · :- .· ~: .· .· ... -~: ... ·. ·. -~:. · ... · .. ~ :.· ..... -~~- ...... -~~- ....... :::.. 80

·.· .· .· .· .· .· .· .· .· .· .· .· .· . . 75 . . .· :: -: :" .· -: -: :· .· :· .· .· . : : : . ~ ~ ...... -;~ ~ ·:· ..... ~: ........ ~ ~ ........ ~ ~ ...... -:~ ~ ........ ~-: ........ ~ ~ ........ ~ j .. ·:· ... j j ........ ~ j ........ j .j ........ j~· ...... :: ~ .... : :---~ : .. ·: .... ·: ..... : .... ·: ..... : ..... : .... : .... ·: .... ·: .... ·: .... ·: .... · ...... : .... ~: ... ::....___

.:= ·; ::· ... ~:· ... ::·, .. ~:· ... ::· ... ::· ... ::·. ·_· ~~- ·.· .. · .. ~.·~.· ... · .. · .. ·.~-~ .. · .. ·.·.·.·,·~.<.·.· •. · .. ·.' .. ~.:·:···· .. · .. · .. ~:~-· ... · .. · .. ·.~:~·,··· .. · .. ·.·:j=.:·:·-.-555060 ,. : ... ·' .. :: ....... -: .. : ..... · ... : = ......... ·.· : .. ,· ..... ,· : .. :: .. ~ .... : :.· ........ :. .. .-

~~----~· ~· .· .· ·.· / .· /.· .·. : : : : : : : : " : • :

0

•: I •: / 0 ~ / •: I

0: / •:

0

•- 45 ·.· .· .· ~ .· .· .· .... :: ........ ::. . ., ... :::. .... ·.·>·.·.·.~::. ...... ·:: .. ::_40 .::.:········::········::········::········::········::······· . . . . . . .

. . ., :: .. :: :-. , :-. :-. >. ·.-35 : : : : : : : , ' : : : : : : •"• 11 11 II ·~·:: • • , • • • • ' • • ' • • • • • 30 :;·::· ·.·. · .. ::· ·.·.·.;: :; ·. ·. ·. ·::··· ··' ··:: ... ·.· .. :: . ·.·. ·-~~~=- i::~::· ·.·:: ..... ·. ·:: ........ : :· ... .' .·:: .· .... -~:: .. ·;·~· ·> ... ::-25 .

-: -: , : -: -: • ·:-.-~: ...... ): ...... ):.·.··.·.·~<.·.·.< ..... ·): ..... :: 20 ~-.·~:·····~--~:·······;~:···;····~:··.·.'.·~~ ... ·.·.·.·::····.::: ·. ,. .· .· .·, , .· , .· . 15

. ·~ . ·: ·: ·: . /:• :::.~.·.·.-.~~~.<~.·.·~~.· .... .: .. :.~ .. ·.·.·.·:._~: ... ·.·.::.:.: ..... ~~.--10 : :- .. :~ ........ :: ........ :: ........ : ~ ........ :: ........ : :- . :" , , ,

. :- :-. :- :- :- . :- : : : : : , :; : : ·:: : : :-- 5 1· ··i ·.· ·i · · ·· i"( f · · · r · · ·i"" · ·r ·· ·i ·' ·· i. ···i ···'i · · ·. i ·. ·f ·. · i · · · ·i · · · · i · · · ·i · ·.· i · · ·.i · · · · i -~· ·j· ._,i ·.· ·i""·· 176 i6o ;~~ 15"0 14~ i4o 13i ijD ii~ iio ii"!; ;;c, i~ ;o:o 9S"" 9o ~ 80 75" 7o ifi" 60 ~; s-<> 4S- 40 3S- 30 i~ io 15" 10 ? I . . .

• • • SG - A COlD lEG INDICATION DISTRIBUTION ) 1 10r. TO 19r. INDICATION

53 MANUFACTURERS BUFF MARK

tUf\ Palisades Unit 1 CPL -A SERIES 2530

\g) 11-25-1996 12:40 HRS. SUPERTUBIN

* : 25 STAY ROD IQ! : 309 PLUGGED TUBE

......... . . ·.·•·· ::· ... :·· . ·.· .. · . . . 135

.·.<·.·.·.··:··.·.·.·::.·.·.·.-::.·.·.·.·::.·.·.·.=:::·.·.. 130 . . :: :: :: :: : . . 125

.:: ...• -: ..•. · ...•. : .. :.-: ... :-: .... -:........ 120 · .. ·· . =:· ... ~~· ·; . ~=· ... { ... j~· ... j~· ... ( .. ·,:~· . . . . . 1?>

..... : ~ ....... · i ~ ....... ; ~ ~ ... ; ... ~ l~ ........ ~ ~. ~ ...... ~ ~ ........ ~ ~ ... ~ .... : i · ...... ; : ~ ........ : : . . . . . . . : .·: : ... ·. ·:: ..... · .. :: .· .... · .. :: ... · ... · :: .·. ·. · .. : ..... · .... :: .·. · .... : ...... · .. : .......... ~=: .......... :: ...... ~ .. : :: . . 1CX) .· .· .· .· .· .· .· .· .· .· .· . . ·.· ·: <· -: -: -: -: -: -: -: -: 95

.: ... =.·.·.·.·=:.·.·.·.·=:.·.·.·.·=:.·.·.·.·=:.·.·.·.·=:.·.·.·.·==········=:.·.·.·.·=:.·.·.·.·=:.·.·.·.·=:.·.·.·.·=:······· 90 :: ~= :: :: :: . : :: ~= . :: :: 85 .· .... · •.... · .......... · ..... · ..... · .......... · .......... · ..... · ..... · ..... ·.·. 80 :-· ... :-· ... :·· ... :-· ... :-· ... :-· ... :-· ... :-· ... :-· ... :·· .... :-· .... :-· ... :-· ... :-·:

.::: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: ,....----75 •• • •· •• •• . .• •· •· .· .• .· . .· . . 70 :-··:········~~·=······~~········~~········~~·······:~~········~~········:~········~~···:····~~·····'··~~········~~··-·.·.·~~··-·.·.·~~·····: . 65

• . .· . . • . . . .· . . . . 60 . :·· ·; .· ::·;··. ···~: ..... · .. ~~ ..... · .· ~~ ..... · .· j: ..... · .. ( ....... ~~ .· .. ~. / .... ·. \ ... ·. · .. j~ ........ ~ ~ ........ ~ ~ ....... \. · .... ·'~ ~ ... · .... ~: :--55

.. : .. · ... ·=.~ .. / .. ·=.~ .. ·' .· .. :.: .... · ... -=.7-:- .... -=.~ .. ·'. ·.·.:~ ... · .· ... · . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 50 .:: , :: :: =· -: ; :: :: ·.·.··:········~~··-·.·.·~~···~····~~·····;··~~·······;/··;····~~-==-45

:.;.·.·.·.·:;.·.·.·.··:··.·.·.·:;.·.·.·.·::.·.·.·.·=:······· .·.·::.·.·.·.·::.·.·.·.·::.·.·.·.·::.~.-.·.~::.·.·.·.·::.·.:-40 : :: :: :: • :: " :: "·4' :: •• • • • .. • :: :: :: :: :: :: ·:-35 ·:-:-.·.·.·.<·.·.·.·.-:·.·.·.·.<;.·.·.·.<·.·.·.·.·>.·.·.·.:~ "' • ·~ .. · ..... · ..... · ..... · ..... · ..... · ... ·.-30 : ·: :: :: :: ' ' :: :: ::• I•=::· • ~=· • • • ~=· • • • ~=· • • • ~=· • • . ~=· • • • ~=· • ·~25

;=.·:=·· ... · .. ~: ..... ·. -~=· ··;· ·:. ~ : ........ ~= ..... · ): .... : : :· ·:::. :.: ....... ·:: .. -~ .... :: .. -~ ...... :: .......... : : ..... · ... -: =.· · ... ::--- 20 , . • , • . . ·. ·. ·. . . 15 : :: . ~: :: :: , , :: . . . ·. · .. " ·. " ·. ·. .·. ·-:: ... :; ........ : : .... , ... : : ........ =~ ........ :: ........ : : .. : . . : ~ ~ ........ ~ ~ ........ ~ ~ ..... ; .. ~ ~ ....... ; ~ ~ ...... ; . ~ ~ ...... : :- 10

. .· -: -: . -: -: ·. ·. "; ; ·. . . ., :-5 r··1·· ·.i ·· ·· 1 ··· ·i · · · ·1 · · · ·i ·· ·· 1· · · ·i · ·. · 1 · · · ·i · · · · i · · · · 1 · ·' ·i · · · · 1 · · · ·i · · · · 1 · · · ·j· · · · 1 ·· · ·i · · · · 1 ·~ · ·i · · · · 1 · · · ·j· ·. · ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~§

PLUGGABLE LISTING - BOTH LEGS CUMULATIVE

Palisades Unit 1 · CPL -A/2530 INSPECTION: Nov-96 26-Nov-96 13:23 - . +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+

I I I I I I I I I

e: . 1

34 51 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 11.66 .00 1 .41 149 10 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 34 51 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 34 51 TSH TSH 610-ZP.PID TSH -.07 .00 .81 15 30 !RESULT OF oiscREPANCY RESOLUTION 34 51 - - ---- -- --- • --- ----- - - ---- -- --- --- - ------ ----- - -- ------------1»»> POSITIVE I .D. ESTABLISHED «<«

34 51 TSH TSH 610-ZP SAI TSH -.05 .00 8 2.40 8 30 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 34 51 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I RETEST FOR POSITIVE I. D. 34 51 TSH TSH 610-ZP DIM TSH 323.00 .00 80.00 50 30 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION

128 128 128 128 128 128 128

116 116 116 116 116 116

I 54 05C 05H 580-UP SAI 05H 9.23 .00 1 1.43 25 33 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 54 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -. - - - - - - - - - '. - - - - - - - - - - - - I RETEST FOR POSITIVE I . D. 54 05C 05H 580-UP DIM 05H 504.oo· 54 05C 05H 580-UP PIO 05H 9.57

.00 U 100.00 51 33 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION

.00 2 9.65 31 34 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 54 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -.- -- - - - I»»> POSITIVE I.D. ESTABLISHED <««

54 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 83

105 TEC TEH 610-EB NOD 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 105 TSH TSH 610-ZP VOL TSH· .49 .00 4 .33 126 22 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 105 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I RETEST FOR POSITIVE I. D. 105 TSH TSH 610-ZP VOL TSH .25 .00 4 .30 85 22 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 1 05 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I RETEST FOR POSITIVE I. D. 105 TSH TSH 610-ZP DIM TSH 469.00 105 TSH. TSH · 61 0-ZP PI.D TSH . 01

.00 0 100.00, 53 22 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

.00 4 .37 116 32 j>>>>> POSITIVE I.D .. ESTABLISH~D <<<<<

I .125 TSH TSH 610-ZP VOL TSH .00 .00 4 1.79 125 50 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 125 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I RETEST FOR POSITIVE I. D. 125 TSH TSH 610-ZP OIM.TSH 327.00 125 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH 125 TSH TSH 610-ZP PIO TSH

.00 _02

.00. 0 100.00 53 50 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

.00 7

.00 4

.66 84 50 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 2.04 144 87 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

125 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - : - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -. - I»»> POSITIVE LO. ESTABLISHED ««<

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ jROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS

+----+----·-~-·---+------+---~---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+-----~--------·------------------------------------+ PAGE . 1 TOTAi,. TUBES 4

During eddy current inspection of steam generator E-50A, a total of four tubes were .identified as requiring plugging. C-PAL-96-13.86 has been issued. Steam generator tube plugging results in a change to the facility as described in the FSAR.

Row-128, Column-105

Volumetric indication at top-of-tubesheet .. Possibly caused by fretting wear from a· loose part. ·

Row-34, Column-51

Axial crack indication at tubesheet transition. 1.0. initiated and 0.32 inches in length. ·

Row-1, Column-54

Axial crack indication at tight radius U-bend. 1.0. initiated at extrados.

Row-116, Column".125

Volumetric indication at top-of-tubesheet. May be MBM. No adjacent tubes appear to be affected; .

After pluggi.ng four tubes in E-50A, the total plug count in each steam generator will be as follows: 313 plugs in E-50A (7906 active tubes) and 309 plugs in E-508 (791 O active tubesL The .total percentage of tubes plugged in both steam generators will be 3. 78%.

TO:

·FROM:

DATE:

Al Williams, Palisades Scott Hawn, Palisades Tim Duffy, Palisades

Tom Rexius, Palisades

November 26, 1996

. SUBJECT: STEAM GENERATOR TUBE .PLUGGING

CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY

Internal Correspondence

Steam generator eddy current examinations performed during the 1996 Refueling Outage have indicated the need to plug four tubes in E-50A. These four tubes will be plugged under work order 24513651 prior to startup. The ~ou~ tubes that will be plugged in E-50A are located in the following positions:

Row-128 Row-· 34 Row- 1 Row-116

Column-105 Column-51 Column-54 Column-125 ·

Following this plugging activity in E-SOA, the tot.al number of tubes plugged in each steam generator will be as follows:

. E-SOA E-SOB

313 plugs 309 plug~

7906 active tubes 7910 active tubes

The total percentage of tubes plugged in both steam generators will be 3 .. 78%.

. e • SG-A · MAP OF TUBES TO BE PlUGGED X : 3 TUBE TO BE PLUGGED

X : 1 TUBE TO BE STABILIZED AND

tUf\ ·Palisades Unit 1 CPAL 1~A SERIES 2530

\g_) 11-26-1996 14:24 HRS. SUPERTUBIN

PLUGGED

* : 25 STAY ROD igi : 309 PLUGGED TUBE

......... . . · ...... ·:·:·:. -~~ ........ ~:· ... ·:·: :; ... ::::-. . :

.·.· .. :·:-.:'.·.·~·-·y·_·.·.-.ir.·_·:·.:r.·.·.·.c.·.·.·.c.·.·:.::.. 125

• • M• • • .. • • • ( • • • ( • • • ~~· • • • ( • • • ( • • • ( • • • ( • • • • • :

••••••••••••••• -. • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • .. • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 11() . . ...... : : .... : : .... : : .... : : .... : : .... : : .... : : .... : : .... ;. ... . . . :: :: ·:: . :: :: :: • : :: :. 105

.· .... · ...•. · ..... · ....... · ..... · ..... · ..... · ..... · ..... · ..... · ..... ·.·. 100 .. -:~· ... ~:· ... ~~· ... ~=· ... ~=· ... ~~· .. ··~_:· ... ~=· ... ~=· ... ~:· ... ~~- ... :·· . . 95 ••••••• ·: •••• • ••••• ·: •••• ·: •••• • ••••• : •••• ·: •••• ·: •••• ·: •.•• • ••••• •• • .• • 9()

.·· . :·· ... ::· ... ::· ... ::· ... ::· ... ::· . ·•· ·:· ... ::· .... ::· ... ::·.· ·-· ::· ... ::· . . . 85

.· .......... :: .... : : .... : : .... :: ... .:: ..... : .... : : .... : : .... : : .... : : .... : : ....... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 80 .· .· .· .· .. · .· .· .· .· .· .· .· .· . . .:::~ ... ) .... :~ .. -. ) ... ) ... ) ... ) ... ) ... ) ... ) ... ) ... ) ... -=~ .... · ... ·. 75 • . • • • . • . • • • • . • . • • . • . . • . • • • . . . . • . . . . .. . . • . . • . . . . . . . . • • . . . . . • . . . . . . . . . . . . 70

. :: • :: :: . :: ·:: . :: ' ' :: :: • :: :: :: :: :· . 65 ........ :: .... :: .... : ..... :: ..... -: .... : ..... :: .... :: .... :: .... :: .... :: .... :: .... :: ... : 60 ... : .... ·• : ..... : .... · . : ..... : ...... : ..... : ..... : ..... :· .... : ..... : ..... : ..... : ..... : ..... .

. · .· .· .· .· .· .· .· :· :: :· :: ':· :: :::--55 : : : : : : ' . :: :: . : : :: -- -: . . . ~····· ·.·i~ .·.·.·•"ii"·.· ... ·~~··.· .. ··~~-·.·.· .. j~ ....... · ~~ .·. ·.·.. . .· .. : ~ ..... · .. ~ j ........ ~ ~ .· ...... ~ ~ ........ ~ j ........ ~ ~ .... :. ··~ ~ ::==:

. ::~. ·.·. ···::· .. ·. · .. =~·· .· ... ·~ j· ....... :j· ....... :j ... ·. ·. . ... ~ j ...... -~~ j· ....... ~ ~ ........ ~ j ........ ~ j· ....... ~ j .. : ~.-~ ··. ·. · .. ·. ·. ·. ·••• ·I •••···. ·. ·. ·. ·. ·. · 30 ~=-~~········~~········t·······~~········~~········i~·······~ = ~ ' I:~~····~~-·.·.·.·~~-·.·.·.·~~-·.·.·.·~~-·.·.·.·~~-·-·.·.·~~···-=~- 25

. :: . :: ~. :·~.:.:: :·:. :·: ·:~:.: ·: ·:.: ~:.: ·:·:.: ~:: .. :.:.: ·: ~ '..:.: :-'° ·==: ::.:_.:::::: ::::_:··:::: :: : : : :: ~.:_: .: :: :::::•:::::: :: : •:=:: :: : : : : ._: .• : : : : : : :::_ 25~ . . . : . . . . . -~: . . . . ~: . . . . ~: . . . . : : . . . . : . . : i;.. ••• :: ••••••••••••.•••••••••••.•••.•••••••.• : •.••.•••. : •.• : : ...• • ....... : ......•.. : ......... : .... ~ .... : ......... : .....•... I I I I I . -I I· I ·I I · I · 1 I I. I I I I I I I I I I

,15 1io i5S- ;5c, ;4~ ;4-0 iiS- ,30. iit; iio ,;~ ,·,c; 1cs ;;,o 9> 90 85" so 15 ?o 6S- 60 ss- $0 4;- 4o 3~ 30 2.S- 2.o 1~ ;o s-

e e

SG B BOBBIN INSPECTION PROGRAM x

* lldl

• 1624 TEST FULL LENGTH

25 STAY RODS 309 PLUGGED TUBE

tUf\ Palisades Unit 1

\gJ 11-22-1996

CPL- B

10:35 HRS.

SERIES 2530

SUPERTUBIN

.... ·"··>=· ·"·~~~··2· ·:·~~··:· ·=> ":"·;;·· .. :-. 135 .. ::· ., .. ~ .. :: ·=· · ... · ·;.:: .. ·=· ."". ::· ... ·=· ·~: ·=· ... ·:: : .. · ·=· 130

... :::·;;: .. :: .. : ~:: .. ~=:: .. : : := .. : :: : .. :::· : .. ::·:·.. 125 .~· ·=·: .. ·=· .. ·=· .. ·:· ·": ·:· ... ·:· : .. · ·:· ... ·:· .•. ·:· .. : ·:· ·•· ·=·: .. ·=· .•. ·;.· ... ·=· 120

.... ..: •"' M >· M M : • Ill Ill JC:• N M >" " : o K JC: ,M M :.c M ... • • • 115 ,..• M 11111 0 •,.. Ill

0M M .. 0 • M JC 0 M Jiii 0 M N M" Ill 111 0 "ac M 0 M M M • M 0 ... : .... :-: . : . ·: .. : ... : : .. :-:-. : .. ·= ..... : . -: : .•. :-: . : ...... ;. .. : ... : :·. 110

••• • • •,..• •• • • •. ·,.· • • •.•,.· • ••• •""• • •.• • ·,..• •.• • • "ac"•" • • • "•" • • • • •• ... • • •

0 : ~: :, M :::.C : M .:: Ill : .:: : M .. ::JC : : :: M : -~:: .... ::>C : M :; '\. :" :: w: M ":: 105

• .. .. • ... .. •• "" ... .• "" • • • JC "" ""·. .. "' • ... "' • • ... '"· ·... ,. • .... "' .. • • .. "" "·.. 100 ::· · .. · ·: ... :: ·=·""" ·::: .. ·=· · .. · ::· ... ·=· ·i:-: ·:· .... ~": : .. · -;.· ... ::· ·~· ·=·.:: ·=· · .. · ·::: .. ·=· ·•· ::· ... ==·~: -:~ ... ·::: ... . . . ,.. .. : . : .... :·: .. ·= .. -: : ... >· : . . •' : . : ... :·: .... -~ • -: : •. >· =· 95 : ::.:: ......... ~: .: ..... :: :: .. : .... :: .. : .. : .. : : .: .. : .. ~:: ... : .. :. :: ..... : .. ;.: .: ..... :: :: .. : .... :: .. : .. : .. : : .: .. : .. :: : ... :: :: 90

:: :: .. : :: : .. ::: : :; : a:-:: :::· : • :: .. : :: : .. ::: : ,. :,: • : i:: : ::.:· : . . 85 ... : ~ ·: .... -: : .. :-: : .. ·: .. : .. : : "·>· : ·= .. : -: : .. :-: . : . ·: : -: : ' :-: : ·~·

.. : ........ : ......... -~· ....... •: ·':'· ...... : ... -i:· ..•. : •. ·.··i:'· .. : ... ·=-·--.: ..... ~ ... ·':'· ......... : ·':'· ...... : ... i; •.... : .. •. -~· .. : ... ·"· ·':·:.:.. 80 ... : : M •: IC ~.: : :-:M : •: M : -: : II :-: M M •: : -: : :-:- : •: .. : -: : .. :•

0

: M •: 0

0 7s M• •" M

0M M IC • • M IC ... • M M "• • ""• JC

0

•"' M 0

M JC J'I, • M M M0

• M Jiii 0

X M M. M M0

• M M MM

: ::: :~· .:. ·•· ::.:~·;. -~: .;. ·~· .:: :"· .:. ·. · :;. · .. · ·2·:~: .:. ·.c .:: :~· .:. ·•· ::. ·~· .:. ·: :· .:.:~· .:: : .. · .:. ·i:· ::. ·,.· .:. ·~: .?-'· .. · .:::~· .;. ·,.· ::. ·':· :: 70 • ::: .. : -:: )C: ~:: M :::·: :: IC:~:: .. ::: .. : IC::,,..; .. ::: MM:::M :·,,.:~--: ~:: M :::M: M:: M ::: 65

: o • o 011: •,.• •"• • 0

o :1111. ~ .. ~ 0

o • o: o 0 M0

•,.• 0

1111: • 0 • 0 K 0 o ,.• :M. • 0 • 0 M 0 •;.• 0 11 0 • 0 o 0 M: •,..• •"• • 0 • :-. • ,.• •""• •: • 0 M 0 • M• .•: • 0 • 0 M 0 •.• :M. • 0 • 0 IC 0 • :..• 0 M0 • • • 0 K: • 0 • 0 M 0 _• • • :M. ")Ill," 0 K 0 °: 60 : :-: . : .. ·: : .. : : :-: .. : ' ·: .. : -: : .... -: : .. ·: : ·: : :-:.. : ... • : -: : " :-: : .. ·: :· ·: 55 . }.~ .. :\ ... : .. <:. ·'.'· .:. / .:. ·'.'· .:~:~ .. :. ·'.'· ~= .. ~- .:):..:. -~· .~:: ·.. . .: .. : : .:. ·~· -=~ :~ .. : .. <:. -~· .: .. ;: .:. -~· .:~: ... : .. ~- ~:. -~· .: .. <== 50

: : . :-:- : ·: .. : -: : .. :-: : ·: .. : .. : -:-: ,._ :-: : .. -~ : ": :_' ;-:- : ·: " : -: ~ 45 "• 115 II .. • ... II ..... II...--."• IC ...... M "ac Ill M ,.• •M X "X M IOI • • X M M• • K M "w; M "• ... ·---

. :~: ·=· .... :: : .. · .:. ·~· :;. · .. · ·?-'·~: ·=· ..... :: :~-.: .... ::. ·~· .:. . .:: :~· .:~ ·.· :~. -~· .:. ~~: .:. ·~· .:: :~· .:. ·':~:~. ·~· .:. -~: .:::--- 40 0 •~:: :::.c : :: II M :: : IC ::: : M :: : ::: : M :: : ~:: ::: : :: M : :: : ·~35

.. : . : : .:. · .. · .:: : ... : .. :. ::. ~ ... : .. ~: .: ..... :: :: .. : .... :: .. : .. :. . . ... :: :: .. : .... :~ .. : .. = .. :: .: .. : .. :: : ... : .. :. :: ..... : .. ~:. ': .. : ·-- 30 : -:; :•:M : •: M Jll •:: M :•: : .• •: : M :•:. : M •: : M:: :•: : •: M : •:: M: . 25 ::): .:. ·~· .:> .. :. ·~· ~=- -~·. ;_ .;: .:: .. ~ .. :~ :~ .. :: .. ; . ~=- ·~· .::· -~. -=~ '.-: .. : .. ~- ~=- ·7· .:. / .:. ·':· .:~ :~ .. :. ·~· ~=- ·~ .. : .. ;: ·"·. \ 20 :: ~::a ::: .. ·: Ill:: IC : ~: : IC :::· : : M •M •::::M : K :z .~ : ~: : M' s::K s M. ·: M : .~:: M :_ 15

: ::. -~: ·=· .. <~ > .:. · .. · ~:. ·'.'· ·=· ·~: .:. -~· ·=~ > .:. ·~· ~=· ·~· -=: > .:. -~· ~~-. ~' .:. -7: .:. · .. ·. :~: ... :. · .. · ~:. ·':· .:. <.:. ·':· :~ 10 : : -: : M :-: : J1C •: IC M:.: :-:M : •: ,. <• : •: ~ : : : lll :-: : K •: : M: M e- 5 ·"·r··f · ... 1·~·l·.·i""·'.'i .... ·1·· .. f···r··l·'.'·i""·: i·.·-r·':r.·-i ... ·r···j····1·· l···(·7(··1··K-r·"

16i i~ ,~~ ,~:.o ;.;~ ,4;, ;3~ ;~ iiS- iw i;~ iio ;os- ioo 95' 9;, 85 80 75-. =;; 65- 60 55" 5-o 4i- 4o 3;- 3o i;- 2.~ i5- 10 ~

e e e SG - 8 TOP OF TUBE SHEET RPC PROGRAM

X : 1719 TEST TOP OF TUBESHEET +/- 311

. W~H RPC PROBE

HOT LEG * : 25 STAY ROD 0f!) Palisades Unit 1 · CPL- B SERIES 2530 ~ : 309 PLUGGED TUBE

11-22-1996 12:30 HRS. SUPERTUBIN

M •••• •.•":~··=··:•:':'•";."•./".... 135 M •"• • o •-c "\coo M ,M IC o o .!"o • o • o

.. ::: :,.:~. ·:: ·=· ·.· -~: :':· .:. ·.· ::. ·':· .:. ·:c: .:. ·':· ·=: :;.- ·=· 130 .•. ·: ·= • : . : : . =·: . " ·= : : : :· :· : ... . 125

,,/". Jiii K M • )II • M ~ IC • M M • M •w: K

•• :~:':'. ·"· .•. :: ..•.. • •. ;.: .: ••. ·':'M: : •• -~~':'- :~. ••· .: .. : : .•. ·,.· .:: : ... •. ·-·: .. ~~: :•. 120 0

M0

0

• ::: :-c : :: IC : -: : • :: :. : IC :: : : : : :: :• : :: • : • 0 • 115 M" IC M 0 "JC M 0 1C M M IC M 0 IC M 0 M M "'" M M 0 o)C M •" M M • K 0

. : : .:. ·':'· .:: : ... : ... :: ..... :. ·':': .: ..... :: >:·· .: .... ::. ·':'· .: .. : : .:. -~· .:: : ... :. ·6:· :;. ..... : .. ~: .:: . . 110 .... ;.: .... ::: : ...... ::: .. 3: ::: :: .. : ; .. :: :: ;;. .. :: ;.: 3::: ::: :.. .. .. ::: .... .... :-: ;:.. .. ... 105

:=: ..... ~ .. ~~ .; ....... ;~ ~':'· .; ..... ~2. ·':'· ·=· :~~ .;. ·':'· .=~ ~ .. · .~. ·':'· ~; ...... ; .. ~ ~ ·=· :: .. 2~ ~':'· .2 ..... :s. ·':'· .s.) .2. ·':'·}::.: 100

. _;: :?'. : ;: : . E: : .. : :E • : :: : "' :: : .. : "' >· M : : :. : M :: :M : M :: M : ~: : M :: :"" :. • 95 • •,.•.•. o • o •"'• "x" •"'• • • • •"'• •,.• •M• • • • •"'• •,.• .•. • • • .•. "M" • o • • • • .•. "•" •"• • • • •"'• •,,.• .•. • • "•"'• • • • .•. • • • .•. "x" •M• • • • .w. '""" •""'• • • • •"""• • 90

0 M 0 M M M 0 • M M ~·M M 0 M M JC' M M 0 •M ~ M 0 M M, JC 0 • M M JC 0 • JC M .;,;,. M M M• .... 111 0 • .... M

JC"•: :: M M : : : M ;;>;:· : JC :: : ;.: : :: :M ;(iceM :: M : : : : M :: : : M :1.("•M : : : : :: : : .° 0

85 . •: • .=.':'· :';. •. • .:. ·':: ,':. •. • .:: :':• ,':, •, • ::. •':• 0 ';, •:: ,:, ·':~, •::, • .;. , • :':. •. • .:. •'::. ':, •. • .:: :7 .. 7. •. • :':, •a:x.':. •:: .:. ·7·. 7::. • .:. ·~· :7: •. 80

llll: :. : M :: M M -:: : .. :: :M : M :: M : ;.: : M :: :,. M IC :: JC : •: : JC :: :M : JC :: M : :c: : M :: : : M :: :C• 75 0M 0 • M 0 M M 0 o M M 0 o M 0 M Jiii 0 0 M 0 • .IC •"' M 0 • M M 0 • M 0 M IC 0 • ""' .M 0 o Ill •"' •

•: ::: :':• .:. '•' :~::·;, ·~: .:. ·':• ·=: :,.• .:. 0 0

0

::. "•' ·S:::: ·=· '•' ·=: :':• ·=· •,.• ::. •':• ·=· 0

:: ·~::• ·=: :-· ·=· •':• ::. 0

•

0

.:. ·:: .?'·x· -~:2· .:. '""' ::. •':• ::. 70 0 M 0 M 0 Mo M oM 0 IC 0 JC 0 Ji\cxo M •M • IC • Ill 65

JIC' o JIC M '11 JIC M, JIC •' ,M M '• M JC o o JC M JC" o JC M 'ac M "' ,,.• o M JC" ,M JC. M M M K' M M M• • M M 'M M N' •

: 0

• 0 ,:: ::. ,:,

0 o 0 ::, .:. ~':, 0

:: ,:, .: •• :: : o • ,:, 0 M 0 ::. 0 o 0 ,:, .~: ,:. 0 o 0

.:: ::. ,:. 0 o 0

::, 0 M 0

,:, 0:: ,:, .: •• :: : o 0

,:, 0 M 0

::. 0 • 0 ,:, .,:: ,:,

0 o" .:: :~. ,:, •, 0 ::, 'x' ,:, : o 60

.~~·.=~~:-. .E..~.~~.·':'·.: .. ~~·=··':'·.~·.: .. :-.t.~ .. :.x1.~ .. ~~~ = = := ... 1.r.: .. ~.I~~·.=.·':'·~; .. :.) t.~ .. =~~_.t.~.~:.·':'·.~~~== ~ • M, 'M M ,M JC M ,• M M • • M ,M M M 11' •'..C: ~ Jo&,• M M • • M M• M '°'• •M .M •"" .M • • M 5

,• JC M M, 'M M M ,M JC ,,/4,,,, M' JC M,•,. "' ,M IC M • o • M, "x K ·~ ;,.( Jill • o :::. M X:• • M M •"' JC ""'" '·--- 4 ,:: : 0 0 ::: 0 : •• ,:: ,· 0 > . .:c:: 0 0 ::: •• ; 0 .:: •"'•: .' M 0 ::: •• : .:~ 0 M 0 : :<:: 0 M 0 ::: : .M.:: 0 , 2 .~: :·~---4-0 •':•'•'

0 0 :•"' '•'

0 :•• M '•' :•'Ill' M •,..:,•

0 0 :·•

0 0 0 ""

0M:••

0 ° K ><' • • • ""•'>~.° 0

' :•'°' 0111'

0'4.:·· M 0

111° :•• 0

o,

• 0 JC: : :• :M : ,M M M o: : M :•: : M •: :•: : M •: : >': : : .. : : : M : :.,: : 'x-- 35

• • • "' ac' • JC "' "2::•"' "' x. ,,. •' ·"' JC ·,.. M •JC x" .x "' • • ""' ;.c • • "" #(.. .,,/"'.~ ~ .... 'K M • JC • JO :: ·~: ·=· ... -:: :;; ·=· .... :.· -~· .x. ·i:.: ·=·. ;.' -:: :·· ·=· ·; ::· ·,.· ':· -:: :-· ·=·. ~. ::· .""'. ·=· -~: ·=· ·,..· -:::~· ·=· .""'. ::·. :..' ·=· ·~: ·.:.· ·~:--"' •-: M 0 M M )C 0 M JC 0 M "' M o M M M • M ~ • M M ~ • M • 25

:2· ·t~ ·=· ·~· ·2~ (· .;. ·:· ~2· · ~. ·~· ·:~ ·2· · ~ .. 2~ ~:· -s- ·.·I·:·:::· ·:: :s~ ~:- -s- · ~. ~~· ·:· -~·. :~. ;. ·:· -s~ ~~. ·~- ·:· ~s-. ~- .3. ·z~ ·=·. ~:: 20

::: :: 3:·= ::::: :: ::: : .. : : :: : ~::: :: .. :: . ::: : : : ::::·: : :: : =< : :: : ::::·~;. .. : :- 15 :-;.•'-: •:• o • ' . .-;.-: o o •=• 'JC°.;.o .. o •:• ·,.: •:.• o o o •:-: .. -.;., o o -.:. '•' K-:'""• ._:.- •' •7• ·.~"._:. • ': •:.°M" ·~-:'' •=• ',,(° ,~.° ,' •:• •,...:-~·' '•.::-10 : : :: : M ::: : M :: • :.: : :::. : :: ;.I :: .. : ·: ~ : ':: ~ ::: : . :: : ,:: "" ;.--5 i ,M, 'f""•j •' •"i •7• T' •' 0

( •':'i •"• 'i' •"f' •"i'' • 'j' ·~• (': • 0

0

0

,><, ·~• : ... 0 0

• •"• ·~• ,'<, 0

0

0

,K: 0

•

0

,M, • 0

0

:M .. ':'• •"• 0

:

0

•"• '~',M

,;g ;;;,; ;5~ 150, 14i"i'4<> ii!i i~o ;2s- ,·i<> ,;~ ;;;, 105 100 95" 9'> 8S' so 15" 7o 65 &:> ?> jo q':i 40 35 3D 2.~ 20 /';] 10 s

U-BEND RPC PROGRAM ralisaaes ~nit l ~~ - ~ 5ffilt~ 2~J~

X : 24 TEST U- BEND

* : 25 STAY IQl : 309 PLUGGED TUBES

.. ·.···· :-· ... ·.· . ·.·. . 135 . . .. . · .· .· ·.·. 130 .·.·.·.·.·.·::········::········::········::········:······ . .. . -: -: .· . . . .125 . . . : . . . : . ·:: . .

.·.·.·.·.·.·.··:··-·.·.··:··-·.·.··:··-·.·.··:··-·.·.··:··-·.·.··:··-·.·.··:·······. 120 ... ·: :: :: :: :: :: :: : . 115

.. :- ........ : ......... : ........ ·: .. · ...... :- ....... ·: ...... · .. : .... · .... : ......... : .............. ·. 110 . . . -~ :: . .-: :_.: :.~ . :: • ·: :~ ·. ·. 105

·:··-·.·.·.:-·-·.·.·::.·-· .. ·.·::.·.·.: .. ::.·.·.·.·.:.·.·.·.··:··-·.·.·::.·.·.·.·::.·.·.·.·::.·.·.·.··:··-·.· .. ·:::-. 100 . -: . :: : : :: : : . : : . : : : : : : : : : : 95 . . . . . . . :- . :- . . . . . 90 .. ·.··:··-·.·.·::.·-·.·.·::.·-·.·.·-:-·-·.·.··:·········:··-·.·.··:-·.·.·.·::.·-·.·.··-:··-·.·.··:-·-·.·.··:··-·.·.··:··-·.·-.. ---

. . . . :: :: :: :: :: • : :: :: :: • : :. 85 .·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·:·.·.·.·.·:·.•.•".•.•':: ... ·.·.-:: ... ·.·.·:·.·.·.·.·:·.·.· .·.-:: ... ·.·.-:: .. ~·.·.·:·.·. ·.·.· :·.·.·. ·.·:·. ·. ·.·.·: ·:·. 80

. : : ~ ~ ... y ... ) ... ) ... ) ... ) .. ~ y .... ~ ~ ... y ... ) ... y ... y .... ~ j .... : : . . . . . 75

.· ·.· ... ~:··· .. ·:· ... ~:· ... ~:· .. ·~~:· ... ~:· ... ~:· ... ~:· ·.· . ·:· ... ~:· ... ~:· ... ~:· ... : . . . . ~ . : . ·.·.: ... ·. ·. -:: ... · ... -:: ........ :: ........ :: ........ :: . · ...... :: ........ : : ........ : : ... · .... : ......... :: ........ :: ........ ::................... 60

. . :~ . :~ :~ :~ :~ ~~ :: :: :: :: :: :: :: <·-55

·.·.·.·.·~~········j~········~~········(·····:.·~~-·-·.·.·~~-·-·.·.· ~ · ...... :~.·.·.·.·)~········):········)~········):········):········)::::-~ . ~:j ........ ~j· ·. · ... -~~-· ... ·. ·.::. · ... · .. :j ........ ~j .. ~·... . ... :~ ........ : ~ ..... _· .. ~ ~ ... · .... ~ ~ ........ ~ ~· ....... ~·~ .. -~= ~ . . . . . . . • . . . . . . • • • • • ~. : . : . : . : • . : . : . : 30 ~:-~~~·-·.·.·~~-·-·.···j~··-·.·.·~~-·-·.···j~········j~·······s=~· · ·. -== ~-···:~········:~········:~·····- .. :~········:~········:~·····~- 25

.·.·.·.·.·.·.·:: ... ·.·.·:: ... ·.·.·:: ... ·.·.·:: ... ·.·.·:: ... ·.·:· ·: .. -:: ... ·.·.·:: ... ·.·.·:: ... ·.·.·:: ... ·.·.·:: ... ·.·.·:: ... ·.:-: 20

... ~. ~ .. :_~ ... y ... -~.: ... _:f .... : ... · ·:::~~: .. ·.·.·.·~:;:.:·~······::;:.:··.·.·.·::::.········:::: .. ·.·.·.:j::·;:·~····j:_·-5~ ....... ::· ... ::· ... ::· ... ::· ... ·.·. : :- . : :-

j •" · "( · ": ( · ·r· ·j · "•'. i ". "•j · · · r · · · ( · "i "•" · (~· i · ··· . I"· ··i··· f ···i··~·1· · ·~i· · ··1· · ··i····1····i···f ··1··· · iii iiP i$5" i~o ,41~ itio 11? i3o 1i~ iio 1is iio iC6100 %'" ~ sS'. gc, 75- 7o 65- 6o 5~ io ~/~ .4o 3~ 30 z. s- z.o 1 'i 10 ,.

e SG - B INTERSECTION RPC PROGRAM

I 1 TEST DBH +/- 311 WITH U-BEND PA~JCAl<E COIL

(\if\ Palisades Unit 1 CPL - B SERIES 2530 -

~ 11-22-1996 15:55 HRS. SUPERTUBIN

I 1 TEST 1H THRU TSH - WITH 3-COIL DELTA PROBE

* : 25 STAY ROD ~ : 309 PLUGGED TUBE

.. •.···· ::· ... ·:· • ·---::· ·-:--:_-.~---- ... 135 . . . . . 130

.· .. ··::········~~········~~········:~··.·.·.·~~·········~:··.·;:· -. ~-------·-·-·:==-~=~_:_----125

.. :::: ... ·.·.-:: ... ·.·.~:: ... ·.·~-:: ..... :_.:: ... ·.·.-:: ... ·.·.-:: ... ·.·.-.:.:.:_.:--- . -120 .· .· :: ::. ::. :: ·.:. ·.: ·.: . . . . . . . . . . . . . . : : . ;:----·--·--------- ------- _115 :'.':::.:::.::::::::::.::::::::.:::::::::_.::::::::::::::::::::::::::::·:::::::::::.:.:::::: .. : .. · ...• :·.·:·:·: .. ~====~

. . . . . . . . . . . . 95 ... :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: . . -- ---· --90 ...... : ........ : : ........ : : ........ : : ........ : : ........ : : ..... : ... : ........ : : ........ : : ........ : : . ~ ...... : : ........ : : ...... :-:-:-·

. ": :: :- :- :- :- .. :- > :- :- :- :.. ·-85 ::: ·.·.·. ·::·· .· .· ··:: .· .·. ···: :.·.·.· ·::: .· .· ... · :: .· .·.·. ·:: .· .·. ·;· ::.· ... · .· :: ... ·:· .. :: .· ...... :: ... · ... ·:: ... · .... :: ..... · .. :::. ;------ 80

: : : ~ ~ .. · ...... ~ ~.: ...... ~ ~ ........ ~ ~ ........ ~ ~ ....... : ~ ~ ......... ~ ~ ........ ~ ~ ........ ~ ~ ... : .... ~ ~ ........ ~ ~ ........ ~ ~ ........ ~ j ........ ~ ~ ... ~. =-= ;~ ,::::::::!J::::::::•/:::::::://::::::::i.::::::::li::::::::i/::::il)i:.:::::://·::::.·:/J·:::····i/·:·.·:·.ii::·····:i!·:·:·::_•··~- E . . . . . . . . . . . . . ·6-F_.:..--==-=-~~......... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . - 45 -: . :- . :- :- :- :- :.•.• -;:::~~~~-·=-=-~=·· > :- :- :- :- :- . • 40 :::· ·.·. ·. ·::· ..... ··::. ·.· ... · :: . ·.·. ·.· ::·· .·.·.·::· .... ··§E:E~..::=::::::=.::::::::::-..:::::· ... :: ........ : : ........ :: ........ :: ........ : : ........ : : ... :-35

.::::.::::::::i!::::::::!i:'::::::.i::::::::•i::::::::!•::::::;?"~ . ~.:::i•::.:::::i•·:·:.::.:••·.::::.:•·::·:·:::i•.::.··:.:i•:·:.:.. ~ ·.·.·.~ ... : .... ; ~- ·.·.·.· ~~ ... ·.· .. j~ ..... · .· j~ .·. ·.·. ·:: .·.. ·: :j j ........ j j.: ...... j ~ ........ ~ ~ ........ ~ ~ ....... :jj .~ .... j= ~~

. :: . :: :: :: : : : : : : i-5 i .... i .... i .... i ... '. i .... i .... i .... i ... •j .... i .... i .... i.... . i .... i .... i .... i .... i .... i .... i .... i .... i ... •j .... i .... i .... 1CC iCI\ <tCC 4CI"\ <fAC' 4At'\ 47C' 471'\ <41'\C' "'"" "'"C" ""'" <11•u; ,.,...,... l"\r- """ ,...,.. ,.,.,... ....,,... -"!'"' ,..,.. ,...,... .-.- ,...,.. ,,,.. ,,.. - .... -- ..,._ -- ·- ·- -

16~ 160 I~ lfjO /fl; J40 1)5 130 125° 120. 115° 110 /OS ~00 95' ~ BS° 80 "?$° 70 65° 60 55° 50 4? 40 3:} 30 2~ 2.0. 15° 10 5

S ot _51 · o-Z. 5?. of· 5£ 017 .517 OS ~5 09 ~9 OL .5L 08 S8 ~ ~(, 001 ,Sol oll Sii oZI .5?1 cnr ,5{1.0,;1 S17t c5t .!61 o'lt .5'11

,.J., . .T.J ... J .. J .. T .. T,.J.J ... J .. T .. T -- -- -- -- -- -- -- --· --~ .. J, .. ~r .. ~t)~,.~r.,T .. ~!~ .. ~r.,.~I:..J,.~-,C,T I' • / • • / • / • • • , • / • / • ., , (\--s I'•// "•/ ~· •./ / /•; ,· / "• I'/"• I'· /••/ /•/ '•/ / •. / /•. •

!S /0 o J.:; o~o o .~: / o~o .::~. / .~.:: o;o •' .~: o o~o ,,:: ;' .~: I O~O ,,::~. 0 .~.:; o~O 0 .~: / o~o .=:~. 0 .~.:: .~.: Ql.-1':·1·; ;:· ~ ./. =·:· . ~. ::; .. ~ :.:· .~ .. ~:· ... · :, . ::~. : • ~:·,..· ; . =:~ .,. ; ::· / .,. ;:· . ~ ·,::; .. ~ :~· ;:· gi-· / I' :-· ~ / ~ ~ <·~ :: : . ~- I' ~ :-~· / ~- ~ :-~ / ~ :- ~ I' ~· ~ ·<·~ • ~:I' ~-

: .. •.< .' ... < ~ ..... -:". ~ ·"··· ·"· . •"· . ,I',~<<·. .~: . -~= . -~· ~-=~· . ,I',·~·'· . -~= ~ -~· .-:~ ... ~.-: .~: oz---: . I':~·~./.~:·,,· ~ ·/::~ "/ ~ ::: ~ ·,,· ~:·,.: ~ "<:~ ·~ •"I'.,.<" . / "·<:, ·,· ~ :,·; ./'. ,:·,,· / ·,,::,, .,. / :;· ,. 7 ,I' • I' • I' • / • • • / :~ ,.. I • I • / • I • ;.• •

St.--:/ ~ :: ; / ;: ; ::~ '; :;. ; ~: / ~ :·:~ I :•. ..:-:·~ ~: / ~ ::~ ·,, ~ :: I I ~: ~ ,::~ . , :; ~ nr --·:. •• · .~. 0

1°. •• • ,,: •1

• • 1·. •• :/· ·". • " •• :. • " •• /. • ":. •• • /0

•

1 • :/·. • :-= • .• • •. , .. 1 • • 1:. •• • ". ·". ;1·. •• 0

1· ·~. • ,, •• •• • 1: ·'. · ,. · ·. :1· ·". · , .. : . :1 Vl. • / •/ / / 0 / / ~ e 0 / / / •. / / •. / ;•.I • • • • / I 1 0 / ;•.I /. •; I • 1 0 I I • 0 / I • 0 •

g£--1. ~ :: ~ / ~: ; ::~ ~ :~ ~ ~: / ~ ::~- ~ ~:I ~ ::~ I ~ :: I / ~: . ~ /::~ ~ :~.· • • / •/ i • /• / •I I •I I• I • I • I••

Qt---;·~·:;··~·./ .. ~:.; .. ~·_,,::~·.; .. ~·:~;.~·.;-.;:./ .. ~-.;::~·. . ~· ._;·. ~: .... ~,. i: =~· .1 •• ~· :;· ;~· ·' •• ~:. ;·. ~· ·': :~· •••• ~· :~: 0

/ • 0

/ / 0

/ • 0

/ / • 0

/ /0

/ •"I • 0 I 1° I • 0 I I • • ;• I • 0

I I • 0

sv---·; :~ ~ / ~: / ~ /::~/ / /~ :; ~ /I~:/ ~ "::~ // ~1:- ~:i ~ ~ ~: ~ '::~ I ~ :~ /~/ ~ ~=I ~ ~::~ I ~ :•

os---/:: :·· ~· · ;. · ~: · · · · ~· · ·: :"· · · · · ~- :;· · " ... ·.· ~:. i· · " .. ·: :~·. i· ~"·:: .. · ~·. . • ,, ... ·. ·. · ~· :i·· ,. · · · · ~:. i· · 1·. ·::~·. i· · 1· :: • • , •• ;. • ~=. ·. · ~·. ;: :,·. ·•· ~=. ----:< / /: / / -:/ / / -: / / .1: I /-:1 / -: I <,.. / -:/ I /-: I I'< I ".;; I·~ I 1: I I -:1 I 1:

gg :/ ~ ~- / ~ >~ / ~ :- ~ / ;. ~ 1:-~ ~ :/ ~ ~- / ~ :-/ / ~ : . ~ , ~- ~ ;;.~ ~ :1 ~ ~· / ~ =-~ ~ 09 : .. / 0

/ •• /: •••• /0 ••• :,.· •••• /

0 ·~ •• / 0 •••• /: ·" •• ,, •••• :1.· ·" .. /0

.: •• /0

...... /: ••• /0

..... :1· .... ,. -~ .. ,. ..... /: ·.'·. ,, .... :1· ·" .. ,, .. : .... ·" .. /:• ... ,. ·". :;· .. ·: • / / "• /' ;•./ / •; / "• / / •./ / I•. / / /• / ;•./ / 0 1 / "• I •.I I I•. I / I. I 1°•/ 0

rrf\ •.I / 0 / / •.I / / •. / / •0

/ ;•.I · / • 0 1 I / 0 / / • 0 1 / I• / I 1 0 I ;• 0 1 I";· I I. I I • 0 1 •

~.-:7 ·~ ;. ~ :•; ~ :- . ~· / =-~/•I :- ~ i• . ~ >1 ~:-.I ~· I =-~ ; :- I e ;• ~ :-, .•

OL------/: · ; .. ~: ·" ·. ~· · ;: :~· ·" · ;~· :>. ~· ·" ·. ~: · ; .. ~· ·": :~· · ;·. ~·:: ·. ~· · ; .. ~: ·" ·. ~· · ;: :~· ·" ·. ~· :;·. ~· ·' ·. ~: ... ·. ~· ·": :~· · ; .. ~· :~ ·. '/ · ; .. ~: ·' ·. ~· · ;: :~: · /

0 / •

0/ / •" / 1° / ,•,1 I • 0 I / 0 I •" I •

0 I ;• / • 0

/ I •0

I 1° I •01°

SL ·~ ~= / ~ : :~ / ~ :~ ~ / ~= / ~ /: :~ / ~ : : ~ , ~: / ~ I:=~ I ~ :~ ~ I ~: ; ~ ;: =~ , ~ :i , I ~: I ~ /: :1

08 .. : . : . ;- . , .... : ... ; .. /".: .... .1;- .. : .•.••.. ;. :1· ....... ;- . ,, ...... : .· ·" , .... : . ·. i·. , .. : ..... ;- · 1: .... .:· ·i· :1· .· ..... ;·. ,, ...... : -;·. , .. : .. < • ~ : :~ ~ :

0 ~ ~: / ~ : :~ I . ~ : : ~ / ~: ~ 1: :I ~ =~ ~. ~: / ~ : :~ I ~ : : I ; ~: I ~•,I

gg--------- ~ /:•~ ~ :/ ~ • ~· / ~ :·~·· / ~ :• ~ / ~· • ~ /:•~ ~ :1 ~ ~· ~ :·~ I ~ :• ~· I ~· ~· 06 .. / ..... /" ·' .. ,, ..... ,, .. 1 •• ,, ••••• ,, ••••• ,, ••••• ,,. ·" •• /" ••• • 1· ·". "1" •••••• ·" •• , ••• • 1· ·' •• , •••• "1" .1 •• , ••••• ,, • • 1 •• ,, ••••• ,. ·" ••

·.~ ::/ / ~ :: / / ~: / 1::~ /-: ~ ~: / ~ ::1 I ~ :: I , ~= I ;::~ / :; I ~: ,.· ss----------- / "</ / < / -: / / -:1 '. / • / I / "-:/ I·~ I 1: I -:1 / /-: I I 1 1:

OOl .. : : :~·. i· -~·=~~ -~·. ;. ·~: ·". ·~·. ;: :~· ·". ·~·::. -~· ·". ·~:. ;. ·~ .. 1: :,,· .;. ·~· :~. -~·. ;- ·~: .1. ·~·. ;: :~· .11·~·: ;.··~ • • 1. :~· •I /• / / I •/ /• / / I •/ I• I / I •I I• I •

tv\J :/ / /-: ' / -: I ,,-:/ • / .•; / /:I / -:/ I / 0:• I I /: / ;-:/ / •; / .: :f\llo / /~ :/ // / ~· / / :-~ / /: ~ I ~· / ~ /:- .~ :/ / ~· ; / :·~ / I :- "•" Ql.i .. :.1·. ; .. , ..... 1:. ; .. / .... :.1·. ; .. ,, .. : .. ,, .. ; .. /: .... / .. ;. :1· .... / 0

• ;.· , ••••• /: ••• • 1· ••• :,,·. ;. "1".: .. •/.:: ~ I ;: ~ /::~ ~ :~ ~ ~: I ~ ::/ / ~ :: ~ / ~: ~ 1::~ ~.:1

g~ ----------------__. • • ~ / ~· ~ <·~ ~ :- ~ ~· / ~ :-~ I ~ :- ~ I ~· ~ .r:-~ . 0

•1

ozi · ,: : ·: · ;: ·" · · /. · ·: :~· ·" · · /.:: · · ~· ·" · · ~= · ·: · ~· ·": :1 ;·· • • ~· :~. ·,,·. •• • ~:. •• • ,, •• • ::~: ·" • • /" / / • • / / / • • / / I" / / • • / / • .1 / I" I 1 1 0 1 0 • SZI. -----------------------• • / /-: / / -: / < / / -: / I / -: / I < ,,. /

00. -~· .": ·~· ... ·~· :/. ·~· ... ·~·.I'.·~· .. :·~ .. 1. ·~·: ;. ·~· ·'. ·~· •• ·-:/ .. ~. ~ :: ~ / ~: ~ /::~ ~=-.·~·,·· ro -----------------------------'-..-/ • • • • 11. • ~ • • ;: .~ • ·~• .~: .• ~ • /" • ;" I

NIBnHBdnS ·s~H L£:n

:3Bn1 03~~n1d 60£ 00~ J.. 'v' 15 gz

!QI Q£gz S31~3S 8-ldJ *

966L -6L -LL ~

l l!Un sapoS!IDd ~

l/H V'JO~U Hl~NJl 1111.:l 031531 tZ9~ I J80~d Nl8808 H]M OJlSJl lNJlXJ lSJHl~V j e e e


Palisades Unit 1 CPAL1-B/2530 INSPECTION: Nov-96 1-Jun-97 10:41

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+---------~----------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB GEE PROBE IND LOG INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

6 1 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT TSH 16.09 .00 11.91 179 RJC 24 6 1 TEC TEH 610-EB NTE TSH .00 .00 1 1. 27 105 SHT 24 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 6 1 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 20.36 .00 3 .43 65 RJC 24 I 6 1 TSH. TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 36 I

I 3 4 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 19.88 .00 3 .55 75 RJC 23 I 3 4 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 34_59 .00 3 .62 85 RJP 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 3 4 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 9.78 .00 3 .45 64 RJC 23 I 3 4 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 36 I

I 7 4 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 37.45 .00 3 .75 108 RJP 23 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION ·

I 15 4 TEC TEH 610'EB INR 02H 7.21 .00 RJC 23 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 15 4 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 36

4 7 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 27.64 .00 .63 147 RJC 23 4 7 TEC TEH 610-EB INR 03H 26.40 .00 RJC 23 4 7 TEC TEH 610-EB INR 03C 5.61 .00 RJC 23 4 7 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 36

8 7 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C '15.82 .00 .45 150 RJC 23 8 7 TEC TEH 610-EB INR 02C 15.00 .00 RJC 23

e 8 7 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 36

26 7 TEC TEH 610-EB INR 04H 7_00 .00 1 'RJC 23 26 7 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 8.22 .00 3 .73 114 RJP 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 26 7 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 5.06 .00 3 .64 98 RJC 23 I

' 26 7 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 36 I I

36 7 TEC.TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 1.15 .00 M1 .43 133 RJP 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 36 7 :-----------------------------------------------------------------JHISTORY RE~IEW PERFORMED 36 7 TSH TSH.610-ZP NOD AJD 36 I

I 40 7 TEC TEH 610-EB INR 01C 26.32 .00 RJC 23 I 40 7 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 36 I

I 42 7 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM'02C 4.21 .00 3 .86 104 RJC 23 I 42 7 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 36 I

I 44 7 TEC TEH 610-EB I.IBM DBH 21.72 .00 1 .55 141 RJP 23 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

44 7 -·-···-----------------·-··---------··········----···---·-···-----IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED . 44 7 TSH T~H 610-ZP NOD AJD 37 I

I 12 9-TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 15.17 .oo 3 .84 38 RJC 23 I 12· 9 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 36 I

I 9 10 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 14.33 .00 3 .60 85 RJC 23 I

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ JROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOL TS DEG ANAL T_APE J COMMENTS +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - .. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - . - - - - - - - . - -+

PAGE TUBES 13


Palisades Unit 1 CPAL1-B/2530 INSPECTION: Nov-96 1-Jun-97 10:41 ,

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ !ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------~---+----+----+-------------------.-------------------------------+

9 10 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

17

. 17

17

29 29

10 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 10 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 10 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

10 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 10 TSH TSH 61Q-ZP NOD

15.37 14.09

14.38

.00

.00

.00

3

3

3

.A.JD 36

. 72 38 RJC

. 52 49 RJC .A.JD

. 81 40 RJC .A.JD

23 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 36 I

I 23 I 36 I

I 53 10 TEC TEH.610-EB MBM 02C .03 .00 M1 .46 50 RJP 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 53 10 ------------------------------------------------------------------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 53 10 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD .A.JD 37 I



5.10

33.09

.00 3

.00 3

I .82 35 RJC 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

.A.JD 36 I I

.65 100 RJP 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION .A.JD 36 I

I 8 13 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM DBH 20.94 .00 1 2.76 7 RJP 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 8 13 ------------------------------------------------------------------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 8 13 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD .A.JD 36 I

10 1.3 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 10 13 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

24 13 TEC TEH 610-EB INA 02C 24 13 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 24 13 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

28 13 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 28 13 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

30. 13 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 30 13 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD


34 13 TEC TEH 610-EB INA DBH 34 13 TEC TEH 610-EB INA DBH 34 13 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

42 .42 42

44

13 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 13 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 13 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD


7.29

8.92 9.77

3.18

4.28

31.78

-2.20 -3.70

34.09 33.00

37.14

.00 3

.00

.00

.00

.00

.00

.oo

.00

3

3

3

.00 3

.00 3

·.00 3

I .62 36 RJC 23

.A.JD· 36 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I

RJC .44 153 RJC

.A.JD

. 72 94 RJP .A.JD

. 71 63 RJC .A.JD

.. 78 102 RJC .A.JD

I 23 I 23 I 36 I



I 23 I 37 I

I RJC 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION RJC 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION .A.JD 37 I

.50 88 RJC

. 36 69 RJC .A.JD

.38 79 RJP

I 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 23 !RESULT.OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION· 37 I


+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------~-----------------+ jROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - .. - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - •••.•• ·+

PAGE 2 TUBES 27



+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+~---+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----~------+---+----+----+-------------------------------------------~------+

44 44

48 48

13 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 13 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

13 TEC ·TEH 610-EB 6 VS4 13 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD



68 13 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 68 i3 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD


3 16 DBH TEH 610-EB MBM TSH .3 16 DBH TEH 610-EB OBS UB 3 16 TEC TEH 610·- EB MBM TSH 3 16 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

35 35 35 35

22 22

34 34

40 40 40

56 56 56

58 . 58

58

16 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 16 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 16 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 16 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

19 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 19 TSH TSH 610.- ZP NOD

19 TEC. TEH 610-EB INR 01C 19 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

19 TEC TEH 610-EB INR 04H 19 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 19 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

19 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 19 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 19 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

19 TEC TEH 610-EB INR 06C 19 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06C 19 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

14.85

.18

12.10

29.13

17.12

19.01

11 :56 .00

11.50

'8.61 -3.50 -4.49

18.98

9.04

12.90 14.15

10.86 10.13

3.70 4.44

.00 3 '

.00 M3

.00 3

.00 3

.oo .3

.00 3

.00 3

.00

.oo 3

.00

.00

.00

.00

.00

.00

.00

.00

.00

.00

.00

3

3

3

3

3

3

.47 108 RJP AJD

. 30 RJC AJD

23 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 37 I

I 23 I 37 I

I .63 113 RJP 23 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

AJD 37

.36 105 RJC 23 AJD 37

.59 86 RJC. 23 AJD 37

1.39 113 RJC 23 AJD 37

.59 55 RJC 23 RJC 23 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

.60 59 SHT 24 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION AJD 36 I.

.60 94 RJC

.so· 101 RJc

.49 66 RJC AJD

.29 79 RJC AJD

RJC RJC

RJC .31 153 RJC

RJC

.58 70 RJC

.69 85 RJC RJC

RJC .19 116 RJC

RJC

I 23 I RESUL_T OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 37 I

I ·23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 36 I

I 23 , .

36 I I

23 I 23 I 36 I


23 I 36 I

I 2s I 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 36 I

I 62 19 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS5 9.80 .00 1 2.41 8 RJP 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 62 19 ------------------------~-----------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I I I

+----+----+---·~--·------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+---~----------------~-----------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - .. - - - -+- .. - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

PAGE 3 TUBES 40


Palisades Unit 1 CPAL 1 -B/2530 INSPECTION: Nov-96 1-Jun-97 10:41

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+-------------------------·-------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+.----+---+---+----~-+---+---+--------+-----.---+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

62 19 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS5 14.02 .00 1 2.02 10 RJP 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 62 19 - - - · - - - - · · - - - - · · - - - - - - - · · · · · · - - - · · · · · · · · · · - - - - · - - - - - - - · · · · · · · · · - ··I HISTORY REV! EW PERFORMED 62 19 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 36 I

I 70 19 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 29.20 .00 3 .66 107 RJC 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 70 19 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 29.68 .00 3 .56 105 RJC 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 70 19 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 36 I

I 78 19 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 25.69 .00 3 .65 40 RJC 23 I 78 19 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 36 I

I 38. 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 13.42 .00 1 .32 132 RJP 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 38 21 · · - · - - - - · · · · · · - - · · · · · - - - - · · · · - - - · · · · · - - - - · · · · - - - - - - · · · · · · · - - - - - - - ·I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 38 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 27.16 .00 3 . 71 76 RJC 23 I 38 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 33.69 .00 3 .96 102 RJP 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 38 21 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 36 I

I 5 22 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 17. 77 .00 3 .88 78 RJP 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 5 · 22 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 17.02 .00 3 1.36 92 RJP 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 5 22 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 36 I

I '17 .22 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 12:54 .00 3 .43 78 RJC 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

17 22 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 36 I • I 29 22 TEC TEH '610-EB MBM 04C 20 .. 33 .00 1 1 .17 8 RJP 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 29 22 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ; - -· - · · - - - - - - - · · · - - - - .'. - · · · - - - - - - · · · I HISTORY REV! EW PERFORMED 29 22 TSH.TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 36 I

I 33 22 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 27.00 .00 3 .65 113 RJP 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 33 22 TEC TEH 610-EB INR 05C 15.50 .00 3 RJP 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 33 22 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 36 I

I 69 22 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 17.44 .oo 3 .78 94 RJC 23 I

d 69 22 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 18.37 .00 3 .60 88 RJC 23 I 69 22 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 36 I

I 2 25 TEC TEH 590-EB MBM TSH 23.97 .00 .27 133. RJP 22 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 2 25 TEC TEH 590-EB INF 01H -5.80 .00 RJP 22 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 2 25 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 36 I

I 18 25 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 5.87 .00 3 .40 56 RJC 23 I RESULT OF. DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

18 25 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 35 I I

24 25 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 17.88 .00 3 .44 80 RJP 23 I RESULT OF .DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 24 25 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 35 I I

I I 38 25 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 32.15 .00 3 .51 105 RJC 17 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 38 25 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 35 I I

+-.- - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+·- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+·- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - :- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

fROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+----.--+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

PAGE 4 TUBES 53


Palisades Unit 1 CPAL1-B/2530 INSPECTION: Nov-96 1 -Jun-97 10:41


42 25 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 22.18 .00 1 .23 90 SHT 17 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 42 25. ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED· 42 25 TEC TEH 610-EB INA 04C 42 25 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

68 25 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 68 · 25 TEC TEH 610-EB INA 01H 68 25 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

72 25 TEC TEH. 610-EB 6 VS3 72 25 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

84 25 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 84. 25 TEC TEH 610-.EB INA 01H 84 25 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06H 84 25 TEC TEH 610~EB INA 06H 84 25 TEC TEH 610-EB INA 04C 84 25 TSH TSH.610-ZP NOD


71 28 TEC TEH 610-EB INA 06H 71 28 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

87 28 TEC TEH 610-.EB MBM 03C 87 28 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

24.50

24.12 -5.80

-. 53

25.57 -4.50 3.86 2.81

30.61

8.23

-5.30

21. 73·

.oo

.oo

.oo

.00 M3

.oo

.oo

.oo 1

.oo 1

.oo 5

.oo 3

.oo

.oo 3

RJC 17 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION RJC 35 I

I . 38 142 RJC

RJC 17 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 17 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 35 I

.28

RJC

I SHT 17 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION RJC 35 I

I .45 149 RJC 23 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

RJP 23 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION . 71 15.1 RJC 23 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

RJC 23 I RJC 23 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION RJC 35 I

I .56 99 RJP 23 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

A.JW 33 I

I RJP 16 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION RJC 35 I

I .64 46 RJC 16 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

A.JW 33 I

I 95 28 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS2 25.06 .00 1 .37 21 RJP 23 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 95 28 ---------------~------------------.--------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 95 28 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD A.JW 33 I

2 31 TEC TEH 590-EB MBM 05H 2 31 TSH TSH 6.10-ZP NOD

34 31 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 34 31 TEC TEH 610-EB 'INA 01C 34 31 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

30.37

24.48 23.81

12.30

.oo 3

.oo

.oo

.oo

I 1'. 49 11 0 RJ P 22 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

RJC 34

.53 156 RJC 15 RJC 15 RJC 35

. 71 155 RJC 15 40 31 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 31 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD I 40

I I

RJC 35

I I I I I

44 44

31 TEC TEH 610-EB 10 VS4 31 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

64 · 31 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 64 31 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS3

- . 79

9.23 11.09

.00 M3

.oo 3

.oo 3

.45 RJC RJC

.41 63 RJC

.54 73 RJC

15 35

16 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

+----+----+---+---+------+---~---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ JROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEJ COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

PAGE 5 TUBES 65



+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+------------------------·--------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+--.-+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

64 31 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 35

78 31 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 1_Q.33 .00 1 .46 49 RJP 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 78 31 - - - - - - - - - ~ - - - - - - - - - - - ~ - - - - - : - ~ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - : - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 78 31 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 33 I

I 82 31 TEC TEH 610-EB 24 VS3 .82 .00 M3 1. 51 RJC 16 I 82 31 TEC TEH 610-EB 8 VS4 - .98 .00 M3 .37 RJC 16 I 82 31 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 33 I

I 86 31 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 34.08 .00 3 ;41 69 RJC 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 86 31 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 33 I

I 92 31 TEC TEH 610'EB MBM 04C 14.12 .00 1 .52 44 RJP 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 92 31 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 92 31 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 33 I

I 98 31 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 24.56 .00 3 .63 103 RJC 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 98 31 TEC TEH 610-EB NOD RJC 23 I 98 31 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW . 33 I

I 100 31 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 10.18 .00 3 .50 89 RJC 23 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY. RESOLUTION 100 31 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 33 I

e I 102 31 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 7.70 .oo .41 25 RJP 23 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION. 102 31 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 102 31 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 33 I

I 106 31 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 07C 6.29 .. 00 3 .60 40 RJC 23 I 106 31 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 33 I

I 45 32 TEC TEH 610-EB 7 VS4 .29 .00 M3 .32 RJC 15 I 45 32 TEC TEH.610-EB 5 VS4 - . 76 _oo M3· .22 RJC 15 I 45 32 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 35 I

I 29 34 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 32.43 .00 3 .56 108 RJC 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 29 34 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 34 I

I 33 34 TEC TEH 610-EB INA 03C -3.80 .00 1 RJC 15 I 33 34 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 37.13 .00 1 .31 138 RJC 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

3~ 34 TSH TSH 610-ZP.NDD RJC 34 I I

·45 34 TEC TE.H 610-EB 8 VS4 .00 .DO M3 .38 RJC 15 I 45 34 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 34 I

I 69· 34 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05C -1.16 .op 1 .32 134 RJP 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 69 34 --------------------:---------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 69 34 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C· 1.82 .00 .63 156 RJP 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -.+

IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

PAGE 6 TUBES 78



+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+------------:-------------------------------------+ JROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEJ COMMENTS +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - -.- - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - : - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

69 34 ----- --- ---- --- -- ---- -- - -------- --------------------- ------------- I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 69 34 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 34 I

. I . 77 34 TEC TEH 610-EB 5 VS3 . 71 .oo M3 .25 RJC 16 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

77 34 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 33 I I

81 34 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 9.87 .oo .59 153 RJC 16 I 81 34 TEC TEH 61Q-EB INF 02C 8.90 .oo RJP 16 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 81 34 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 33 I

I 93 34 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 19.24 .00 3 .67 101 RJC 16 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION


45 36 TEC. TEH 61 0 -EB 8 VS4 .35 .oo M3 .36 RJC 15 I 45 36 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 34 I

I 71 36 TEC TEH 610-EB 4 VS4 .91 .oo M3 .16 RJC 16 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 71 36 TEC TEH 610-EB. 7 VS5 .03 .oo M3 .33 RJC 16 I 71 36 TSH TSH 6.10-ZP NOD AJW 33 I

I 4 37 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C . 14.98 .oo 3 1.26 109 RJP 15 !RESULT .OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 4 37 TEC TEH 610-EB ~BM 03C 13:25 .oo 3. .58 104 RJC 15 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION


e 26 37 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS4 10.64 .oo 1 .39 47 RJP 15 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

26 37 ------------------------------------------------------------------ HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED


30 37 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 25.54 .oo 3 .63 46 RJC 15 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY .RESOLUTION

30 37 TEC TEH 610:EB MBM TSC 10.92 .oo 3 .62 86 RJC 15


44 37 TEC TEH 610-EB 8 VS4 .00 .oo M3 .35 RJC 15


46 37 TEC TEH 610-EB 5 VS4 .93 .oo M3 .22 RJC 15

46 37 TSH TSH 610-ZP ~DD RJC 34

60 37 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 23.39 .oo 3 .43 80 RJC 15 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION·


76 37 TEC TEH .610-EB MBM 05C 21 .94 .00 3 .76 74 RJC 16 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

76 37 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 33 I· I

so 37 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 16.94 .oo 3 .63 62 RJC 16 !RESULT.OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

80 . 37 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06C 1.51 .00 3 .. 80 58 RJC 16 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION


+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - --- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

JROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEJ COMMENTS +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

PAGE 7 TUBES 92


Palisades Unit 1 CPAL1 -B/2530 INSPECTION: Nov-96 1-Jun-97 10:41

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE I COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--:--------------~--------------------------~-----+

106 37 TEC TEH 610-EB 7 VS2 - .85 .00 M3 .33 RJC 16 I 106 37 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS4 7.11 .00 1 .51 25 RJP 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 106 37 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - · - - - - - · - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REV! EW PERFORMED 106 37 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS4 11.36 .00 1 .87 176 RJP 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 106 37 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ - - - - - - -.- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 106 37 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS4 12.75 .00 1 .28 54 RJP 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 106 37 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 106 37 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD f>..JW 33 I

I 108 37 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 13.57 .00 1 .44 25 RJP 16 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

108 37 ------------------------------------------------------------------ HISTORY REVIEW.PERFORMED

108 37 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 4.82 .00 3 1.01 106 RJC 1.6

108 37 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD .1 f>..JW· 33

114 37 TEC TEH 610-EB 5 VS2 - .03 .00 M3 .25 RJC 16

114 3.7 TEC TEH 610-EB 10 VS4 .82 .00 M3 .52 RJC 16

114 37 TEC TEH 610-EB INA 01C 28.81 .00 RJC 16 114 37 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 29.57 .00 .31 160 RJC 16

114 37 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD f>..JW 33

3 40 DBH TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 19.16 .00 3 .56 73 RJC 23 .1 3 40 DBH TEH 610-EB OBS UB .00 .00 1 RJC 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

3 40 TEC'TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 19.12 .00 3 .59 83 RJC 24 I

·e 3 40_TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 34 I I

15 40 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 14.19. .00 . 3 .44 83 RJC . 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 15 40 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD f>..JW 34 I I

I I 35 40 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 03C 5.81 .06 RJC 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 35, 40 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C- 6.62 .00 .32 143 RJC 15 I I 35 40 TEC TEH 610-EB INR TSC 8.51 .00 RJC 15 I I 35 40 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD f>..JW 34 I I

I . I 51 40 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 18.64 ,oo 3 .71 100 RJC 15 I 51 40 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1 f>..JW 34 I

I 107 40 TEC TEH 610-EB 5 VS2 1.00 .00 M3 .23 RJC 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

107 ·.40 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD f>..JW 33 I I

42 41 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 12.82 .00 .29 123. RJC 15 I 42 41 TEC TEH 610~EB i VS4 .61 .00 M3 .30 RJC 15 I 42 .41 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD f>..JW 34 I

I 98 41 TEC TEH 610-EB 6 VS4 .59 .00 M3 .28 RJC 16 I 98 41 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD f>..JW 33 I

I 107 42 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 3.85 .00 3 .56 87 RJC 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

107 42 TEC TEH 610-EB 8 VS2 .91 .oo M3 .39 RJC 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

+--~-+----+---+~·-+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+------~--~-----------~--~-------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL·TAPEI COMMENTS

+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

PAGE 8 TUBES 102


Palisades Unit 1 CPAL1 ·B/2530 INSPECTION: Nov-96 1-Jun-97 10:41

+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - .:. - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

107 42 TEC TEH 610-EB 6 VS2 - . 73 .00 M3 .30 RJC 16 107 42 TEC TEH 610-EB 9 VS4 .72 .00 M3 .42 RJC 16 107 42 TEC TEH 610-EB 5 VS4 .14 .00 M3 .24 RJC 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 107 42 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD BEA 33 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 12 43 TEC TEH 610-EB INR 04C 26.52 .00 RJC 15 I 12 43 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 34 I

I 14 43 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 1.64 .00 4 2.57 106 RJP 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 14 43 -------------··············----------------------------------------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 14 43 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 34 I

I 16 43 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 24.22 .00 3 .45 112 RJC 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 16 43 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 34 I

I 22 43 TEC TEH 610-EB INR 01H 23.29 .00 RJC 15 l 22 43 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 34 I

I 42 . 43 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 16.56 .00 .40 23 RJP 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 42 43 ------------------------------------------------------------------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 42 43 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 34 I

I 46 43 TEC TEH 610-EB INR 01H .85 .00 RJC .. 15 I

e 46 43 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 34 I I

48 . 43 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 20.11 .00 3 .60 112 RJC 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION


50 43 TEC TEH 610-EB INR 01H 29.90 .00 RJC 15 I 50 43 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 34 I

I 56 43 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 19.10 .00 3 .32 84 RJC 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 56 43 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 34 I

I 70 43 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 25.86 .00 3 .59 60 RJC 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION


72 43 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06C 3.112 .. 00 1 .16 109 RJP 16 !RESULT .OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

72 43 ------- 0 -----"--------------------------------------------·········IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 72 43 TSH TSH 610·ZP NOD AJW 33 I

I 74 43 TEC TEH 610·EB 5 VS4 .. 72 .00 M3 .21 RJP 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION


I 82 43 TEC TEH 610·EB 5 VS3 .56 .. 00 M3 .24 RJC 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 82 43 TEC·TEH 610-EB 9 VS3 ·.15 .00 M3 .46 RJC 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 82 43 TEC TEH 610-EB 4 VS5 .23 .00 M3 .19 RJC 16 I

I 82 43 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1 AJW ·33 I +----+:---~---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +- - - -+- - - -+- --+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+· - - - - - ~ -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

PAGE 9 TUBES 116



+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+-~--+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS +-~--+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

88 43 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 12.29 .00 3 1.46 99 RJC 16 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 88 43 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 33

106 43 TEC TEH 610-EB 17 VS4 .78 .00 M3 .97 RJC 16 106 43 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 33

112 43 TEC TEH 610-EB 5 VS2 - .85 .00 M3 .24 RJC 16 112 43 TEC TEH 610-EB 4 VS2 1.05 .00 M3 .16 RJC 16

. 112 43 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW . 33

116 43 TEC TEH 610-EB 4 VS4 .92 .00 M3 .16 RJC 16 116 43 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 33

118 43 TEC TEH 610-EB INA 06C 12.41 .00 RJC 16 118 43 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06C 13.36 .00 .30 107 RJP 16 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 118 43 ----------~-------------------------------------------'---,--------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 118 43 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 4.92 .00 .34 42 RJP 16 !RESULT _OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 118 43 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -.- - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW. PERFORMED 118 43 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 33 I

I 120 43 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 17.62 .00 1 .29 37 RJP 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 120 43 -----------------------------------------------------------------·IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

e 120 43 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 33 I I

80 45 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06H -.. 18 .00 M3 .47 101 RJP 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 80 45 - - - - - - - - - - -.- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -.- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 80 45 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 33

9 46 TEC TEH 610-EB 6 DBH .26 .00 M3 .28 RJC 15 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

9 46 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 34

17 46 TEC TEH 610-EB INA 01H 12.40 .00 RJC 15 17 46 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 34

41 46 TEC TEH 610-EB INA TSC 19.60 .. 00 RJC 15 41 46 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 34

45 46 TEC TEH ·610-EB MBM 03C - .03 .00 1 .41 121 RJP 15 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

45 46 --------------------------------------:·--------------------------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED . 45 46 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 34 I

I 113 -46 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 21.90 .00 3 .69 102 AJD 17 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION


106 47 TEC TEH 610-EB 9 VS2 . 38 .00 M2 .84 . AJD 17 IRESULT_OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

106 47 TEC TEH 610-EB 13 VS4 .92 .oo M2 1.31 SHT 17 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

106 47 TEC TEH 610-EB 11 VS6 1.01 .00 M2 1.08 SHT 17 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

+----+----+---+---+------+---~---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 7' - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

PAGE 10 TUBES 128

e



+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+~--+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

106 106

45 45 45

10 10

12 12

38 38

76 76 76 i6

7B 7B 78 78 78

84 84 84

106 106 106

118 118 118

11 11

I· 11

I I 95

I 95

I 95

I 95

I 95

47 TEC TEH 610-EB 11 VS6 - .95 .00 M2 47 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

48 TEC TEH 610-EB INR 04H 11.14 .00 3 48 TEC TEH 610-EB 9 VS4 .37 .00 M2 48 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1

49 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 34.36 .00 3 49 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

49 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 13. 29 .00 3 49 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

49 TEC TEH 610-EB 6 VS4 .74 .. 00 M3 49 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

1.09 SHT 17 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION AJW 33 I

I SHT 17 RESULT OF.DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

.86 SHT 17 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION AJW 34

.84 101 RJP 15 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION AJW 34

. 56 98 RJC 15 AJW 34

.29 AJW 14 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION AJW 34

49 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 5.10 .00 .30 135 BEA 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 49 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06H 41. 73 .00 1 .22 31 BEA 14 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 49 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 49 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 32 I

I 49 TEC TEH 61.0-EB MBM 06H 16.15 .00 .25 55 BEA 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 49 -------------,-----~----------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED ·49 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06H 15.03 .00 1 .18 53 BEA 14 !RESULT.OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 49 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~·- - - - - - - -·- - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 49 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 32 I

I 49 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS6. 8.13 .00 1 .91 24 BEA 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 49 - - - - - - - - - - - - - , - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -·- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 49 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 32 I

I 49 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 22.95 .00 .56 13 BEA 14 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY. RESOLUTION 49 -------'----------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 49 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 33 I

I 49 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM DBC 4.97 .00 2.00 7 BEA 14 !RESULT OF DISCR~PANCY RESOLUTION 49 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 49 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1. AJW 33 I

I 52 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM DBH 11.41 .00 1 1.72 11 BEA 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 52 -------------------------------------------------------:----------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 52 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD. AJW 34 I

I 52 TEC TSH 610-EB MBM 03H 35.36. .00 1 .15 126 BEA 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 52 _ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 52 TEC TSH 610-EB MBM 04H -1.62 .00 .14 120 BEA 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 52 --:---------_------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 52 TEC TSH 610-EB MBM VS2 20.01 .00 .26 135 BEA 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+-------------------------------------·-------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+------------;·------------------------------------+

PAGE 11 TUBES 139



+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+---~----------------------------------------------+

I I I I.

95 95 95 95 95 95 95 95 95 95

107 107 107

16 16 16

52 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -.- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 52 TEC TSH 610-EB MBM OSC 8.51 .00 1 .10 92 BEA 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 52 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 52 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 52 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 52 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H

35.06 -1.55 33.68

.00 3

.00 3

.00 3

1.00 108 SHT .88 89 AJD .47 90 SHT

17 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 17 I 17 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

52 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS2 20.20 .00 1 .21 115 SHT 17 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION . 52 - - - - - - - - - - :- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -· - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

52 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM OSC 8.34 .00 3 .64 78 AJD 17 I 52 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 32 I

I 52.TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 6.05 .00 1 .10 88 BEA 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 52 -----------------------------------------------:------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 52 TSH TSH 610-ZP·NDD AJD 32 I

I 55 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 29.49 . 00 1 . 12 75 BEA 14 J RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 55 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 55 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 34 I

.1 50 55 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 50 55 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

4.45 .00 3 1.19 109 AJW 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION RJC 41 I

68 55 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM OSC 68 55 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

4.20 .00 . 21 171 I

AJW 14 I AJD 32 I

I 76 55 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H. 15.06 .00 1 . 73 131 BEA 14 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 76 55 - - - ~ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 76 55 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 33.05 .00 1 .13 85 BEA 14 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 76 55 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -.- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 76 55 JEC TEH 610-EB MBM DBH 9.40 · .00 1 1.27 16 BEA. 14 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 76 55 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -.- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -·- - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 76 55 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 32 I

I 98 55 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM .01 H 8. 64 . 00 1 . 19 21 BEA 14 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 98 55 - - - - - : - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 98 55 TEC TEH 610-EB 7 VS2 -.91 .00 M3 .32 AJW 14 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 98 55 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 32 I

I 102 55 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 7.66 .00 1 .27 43 BEA 14 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 1 02 55 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HI STORY REVIEW PERFORMED 102 55 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 32 I

I 110 55 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 26.18 .00 .20 46 BEA 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 110 55 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 110 55 TEC TEH 610-EB 6 VS1 -1.10 .00 M3 .29 BEA 14 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 110 55 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 11.43 .00 1 .22 24 BEA 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 110 55 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 110 55 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 32 I

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1. INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEJ COMMENTS +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

PAGE 12 TUBES 148

e



+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+-------~------------------------------------------+

JROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEJ COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------.------+

17 58 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TEC 26.30 .00 1 .16 46 BEA 13 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 17 58 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - J HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 17 58 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD A.JW 34 J

I 21 58 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 21.44 .00 3 .13 124 BEA 13 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 21 58 ------------------------------------------------------------------JHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 21 58 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD A.JW 34 J

I 33 58 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 30:06 .00 .25 45 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 33 58 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW.PERFORMED 33 58 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD A.JW 34 I

I 53 58 TEC.TEH 610-EB MBM 05C 7.56 .00 .21 123 BEA 13 JRESULT OF DISCREPAN~Y.RESOLUTION 53 58 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -·. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 53 58 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 35.00 .00 1 .20 143 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 53 58 ----------------------------------------------------------------·-JHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 53 58 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD. RJC 41 J

I 57 58 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 11.20 .00 1 .15 31 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 57 58 ------------------------------------------···-----··-------------·JHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 57 58 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06C 5.98 .00 ·.11 74 BEA 13 !RESULT OF.DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 57 58 - - - - - - - - - - - - - · · - - - - - - - - - · - - - - - - · · - - - - - · - - - - - - - : - - - - - - · - - - - - · - · - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED. 57 58 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 41 J

I 65 58 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 2.45. .00 3 .85 107 A.JW 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 65 58 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD A.JD 32 I

I 69 58 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 16.60 .ob .22 49 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 69 58 ------··--------------------···-----------------··-----·-·--------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 69 58 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD A.JD 32 J

I 125 58 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05C 13.01 .00 . 1 .29 134 BEA 13 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 125 58 ------------------·------------------------------------------------JHISTORY REVIEW PERF~RMED 125 58 TSH TSH 610'ZP NOD A.JD 32 I

I 14 61 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 02H 23.52 .00 A.JD 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 14 61 TEC TEH 610-EB. MBM 02H 25.02 .00 1 .40 151 A.JO. 13 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 14 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 1. 75 .00 3 1.41 116 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 14 61 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD A.JW 34 I

I 18 .61 TEC TEH 610;EB MBM 01C 27.92 .00 1 .34 147 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 18 61 ----------------------------------------------------------··------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 18 61 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD A.JW 34 I

I · 20 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 9.36 .00 1 .29 127 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESO.LUTION

20 61 ------------------------------------------------------------------JHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 20 61 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD A.JW . 34 I

I I I I I I I I I·

·I I I

+----+----+---+:--+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+---------------------~----------------------.~-----+ JROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LDC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEJ COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

PAGE 13 TUBES 159 .



+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+-------------------------·-------------------------+ JROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEJ COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I J 36 J 36 J 36 I

61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 34.58 .00 1 .85 155 BEA 13 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 61 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - J HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 61 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 41 J

I J 42 J 42

I

61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 61 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

10.00 .00 .51 146 BEA RJC

13 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 41 I

I 48 48

61 TEC TEH 610- EB MBM 01 C -1 . 62 . 00 1 . 41 156 BEA 13 J RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 61 ------------------------------------------------------------------JHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

48 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC - 48 61 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD


14.35

29.95

.00 3 1.06

.00 .33

117 A.JW 13 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION RJC 41 I

I 142 BEA 13 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

RJC 41 I I

70 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 29.94 .00 1 .20 139 BEA 13 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 70 61 ---------------------'--------------------------------------------JHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 70 - 61 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD A.JD 32 J

I 76 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 29.31 .00 1 .29 32 BEA 13 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 76 .61. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - J HISTO_RY REVIEW PERFORMED 76 61 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD A.JD 32 I


84 61 TEC TEH 610-EB INA 03C 84 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 84 61 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

92 61 610-EB TNT

13.46

2.95 37.53

.00 .32

.00 1

.00 3 1. 72

I 124 BEA 13 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

A.JD 32 I I

A.JW 13 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 119 A.JW 13 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

A.JD 32 I I

A.JW 13 I 92 - 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS2 25.01 .00 1 .26 82 SHT 17 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 92 61 ------------------------------------------------------------------JHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 92 61 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD A.JD 32 I

I 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 07H 6.21 .00 .62 - 10 BEA 13 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 94

94 94

61 ------------~----------------•------------------------------------JHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 61 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 32 J

I 102 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 9.69 .00 .09. 92 BEA 13 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 102 61 ------------------------------------------------------------------JHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 102 61 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD A.JD 32 J

I 104 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 28.53 .00 .16 27 BEA 13 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 104 61 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - J HISTORY REV! EW PERFORMED 104 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 6.35 .00 .22 52 BEA 13 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 104 61 ------------------------------------------------------------------JHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

+-.- - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+-- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ - - - - - - - - - - - - - ... - - - - - - ~ - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

j'ROW COL. CEBCEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEJ COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+---~----------------------------------------------+

PAGE 14 TUBES 170



+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+---------------------------------~----------------+

104 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 10.98 .00 .20 59 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 104 61 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - · - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 104 61. TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 32 I

I 110 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 14.98 .00 1 .14 55 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 110 61 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ; - - - - - - - - - - - - : - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 110 61 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 32 I

I 126 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 35.87 .00 1 . 37 37 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 126 61 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW. PERFORMED 126 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM OSH 23.79 .00 1 .32 56 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 126 61 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 126 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM OSH 24.44 .00 1 .15 51 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 126 61 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 126 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM DBC 6.56 .00 1 .11 46 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 126 61 ---,------------------------------------------------:-------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 126 61 TSH TSH 61Ci-ZP NOD AJD 32 I

I 130 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 28. 77 .00 .32 122 AJW 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 130 61 TSH TSH 610-ZP TRA TSH .24 .00 4 2.55 199 BEA 32 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 66 63 TEC TEH 610-EB 11 VS3 - .32 .00 M2 .82 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 66. 63 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 32 I

e I 83 64 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 13.62 .00 3 .79 60 SHT 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 83 64 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM OSH 19.36 .00 3 .87 82 AJD 12 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 83 64 TSH TSH 610,ZP NOD AJD 32 I

I 87. 64 TEC· TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 21.22 .00 3 .47 77 SHT 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 87 64 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 18.51 .00 3 .46 88 SHT 12 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 87 64 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 32

48 65 TEC TEH 610-EB 14 VS4 - .58 .00 M2 i.11 AJD 12 48 65 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 41

135 66 TEC TEH 61.0-EB 17 VS7 - . 79 .00 M2 1. 53 AJD 12 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EB 17 CBC .79 .00 M1 .85 115 AJD 12

135 66 TSH TSH 610-ZP.NDD AJD 32

50 67 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM OSC 15.30 .00 3 .95 98 AJD 12 ·so 67 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 41

58 67 TEC TEH S10-EB INA TSH 6.87 .00 SHT 12 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION


60 67 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 22.77 .00 3 ;73 ·95 SHT 12 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

60 · 67 TEC TEH 610-EB INF OSH 11 .22 .00 . AJD 12 !RESULT.OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

60 67 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM OSH 12.43 .00 .34 141 AJD 12 !HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- --+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+


+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

PAGE 15 TUBES 181


Palisades Unit 1 CPAL1·B/2530 INSPECTION: Nov-96 1-Jun-97 10:41

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+------------------------.--------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +-.---+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------~----------------~------------------------+


64 67 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 31.53 .00 3 .74 44 SHT 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 64 67 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 31 I

I 68 67 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 29.77 .00 3 .72 83 AJD 12 I 68 67 TSH TSH 610·ZP NOD AJD 31 I

I 98 -67 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 18.60 .00 3 .65 85 AJD 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 98 67 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06C 25.28 .00 3 .40 88. SHT 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 98 67 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 32 I

I ·104 . 67 TEC TEH 610·EB MBM VS6 15.14 .00 1 .92 33 SHT 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 104 67 · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · - · - · · ··· · · · · · · · · · · · .'. · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · ·······I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED . 104 67 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD ,A.JD 32 I

I 112 67 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 13.32 .00 3 .76 84 AJD 12 I 112 67 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD . AJD 32 I

I 130 67. TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 21.39 .00 3 .58 71 SHT 12 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 130 67 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 7.21 .00 .17 89 AJD 12 !HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 130 67 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 32 I

I

e 132 ·57 TEC TEH 610-EB.MBM 04C 12.47 .00 3 .69 42 SHT 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 132 67 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 32 I

I 47 68 TEC TEH 610-EB INR VS4 ·1. 76 .00 SHT 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 47 68 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 41 I

I 81 70 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 03C 2).98 .00 3 AJD 12 !RESULT ~F DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 81 70 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 23.13 .00 .44 155 AJD 12 !HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 81 70 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1· AJD 31 I

I 129 70 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05C 10.97 .00 3 1. 34 100 AJD 12 I 129 70 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM OSC 13.86 .00 3 .91 60 AJD 12 I 129 70 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 25.20 .00 3 .63 65 SHT 12 !RESULT OF DISCRE~ANCY RESOLUTION 129 70 TEC TEH 610·EB MBM 02C ·1-; 78 .oo 3 1.35 89 AJD 12 I 129 70 TSH TSH 610·ZP NOD AJD 31 I

I 64 71 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 06C 19.41 .00 3 AJD 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

64 71 TEC TEH 610·EB MBM 06C 20.12 .00 1 . 90 151 WJS 12 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION

64 71 ·····.···-···;··-····---·--··--·············--····-··--············IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

'64 71 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 31 I I

137 72 .TEC TEH 610·EB 17 VS1 .. 79 .00 M2 1. 52 AJD 12 I 137. 72 TEC TEH 610-EB 15 VS4 ·.53 .00 M2 1.20 AJD 12 I 137 72 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 34.25 .oo 3 1.11 99 SHT 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

137 72 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 31 I +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

PAGE 16 TUBES 194


Palisades Unit 1 CPAL1 -B/2530 INSPECTION: Nov-96 1 -Jun-97 10:41

e +- - - -+- - - - +- - -+ - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - ~ - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - '7 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+------:-------------------------------------------+

50 73 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 17.87 .00 3 .47 68 SHT 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 50 73 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 31 I

I 52 73 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 21 .30 .00 3 .76 88 SHT. 12 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 52 73 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 31

60 73 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 18.14 .00 3 .81 104 AJD 12 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 60 73 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD_ AJD 31

82 73 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 3.75 .00 .33 136 AJD 12 HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 82 73 "TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD-· AJD 3~

122 73 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 22.19 .00 3 .88 74 AJD 12 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 122 73 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 31

126 73. TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H -1.84 .00 3 .79 83 AJD 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 126 73 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 31 I

I 59 76 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C -7.48 .00 3 .40 103 SHT 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 59 . 76 TSH TSH 610-z'P NOD AJD 31 I

I 107 76.TEC TEH 610-EB INA TSH 5.03 .00 3 SHT 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

e 107 76 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 9:61 .00 3 .63 110 SHT 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 107 76 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 23.58 .00 3 .52 112 SHT -12 I RESU_L T OF DISCREPANC.Y RESOLUTION f07 76 TEC.TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 29.95 .00 3 .46 96 SHT 12 I RESULT· OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 107 76 TEC TEH.610-EB MBM 06C 24.78 .00 3 .41 103 SHT 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 107 76 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 31 I

I 58 79 _TEC TEH 610-EB INA 02C 7.02 .00 AJD 11 1 58 79 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 31 I

I 62 79 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 9.94 .00 3 1.21 92 SHT 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 62 79 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 31 I

I 72 79 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 16.42 .00 1 .38 44 SHT 11 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION · 72 79 ------------------------------------'-------------------------~'-·!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 72 79 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 31 I

I 76 79 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 19.36 .00 3 .38 94 SHT 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 76 79 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD ·1 AJD 31 I

I 90 .79 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 33.18 .00 3 .49 79 SHT 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTIO~ 90 79 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1. AJD 31 I

I 102 79 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 25.01 .00 3 .41 90 SHT 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 102 79 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 31 I

I +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+-----------------------------·---------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+------------------------------------------------:-+

PAGE 17 TUBES 208



+---·+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------:·----+

104 79 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 11.19 .oo 3 .64 73 SHT 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 104 79 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 31 I

I 126 79 TEC TEH 610-.EB MBM 06C 8.25 .oo 1 .56 13 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 126 79 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - : - - · - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 126 79 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 7.69 .oo 1 .47 39 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 126 79 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 126 79 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 31 I

I 138 7.9 TEC TEH 61 0- EB 6 VS1 - .55 .oo M3 .28 RJC 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 138 79 TEC TEH 610-EB 6 VS2 .75 .oo M3 .29 RJC 4 I 138 79 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 31 I

I 107 82 TEC TEH 610-EB 6 VS2 1.08 .oo· M3 .30 RJC 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 107 82 TEC TEH 610-EB 9 VS2 -.96 .oo M3 .48 RJC 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 107 82 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 31 I

I 109 82 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 10.07 .oo 3 .94 97 RJP 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 135 82 TEC TEH 610-EB INA VS7 -.94 .. oo M3 RJP 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 135 82 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1 AJD 31 I

I 79 84 TEC TEH 610-EB INA 04H 29.58 .oo 3 SHT 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

e 79 84 TEC TEH 610-EB INA 06H 23.65 .oo 3 SHT 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 79 84 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS4 11.43 .oo 1 .61 152 SHT 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 79 B4 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ' - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 79 84 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS4 4.44 .oo 3 .34 85 SHT 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 79 . 84 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1· RJC 30 I

I 56 85 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 22.23 .oo 3 .55 95 AJD 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 56 85 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 9.12 .oo 3 .43 71 SHT 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 56 85 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 31 I

I ·1 58 85 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 12.04 ._oo 3 .89 41 SHT 12 I RESULT OF. DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 58 85 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 31 I

I 62 85 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM OSc -1.88 .oo 3 .33 115 AJD 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 62 85 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 30 I

I 72 85 TEC TEH 610-EB RBD AJD 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 72 85 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06H 20.54 .oo .51 146 AJD 12 !HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

72. 85 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 30 I I

74 85 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 7.66 .00 3 .59 103 SHT 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 74 85 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 30 I

I 76 85 TEC TEH 610-EB INA 04C 35.50 .oo SHT 11 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 76 85 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 30 I

+----+----+---·-~-+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+----------------------·----------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEJ COMMENTS

- +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

PAGE 18 TUBES 221



+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+------------------------~-------------------------+

IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+-----~-------------~------------------------------+

7B B5 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 1B.20 .00 3 .73 60 SHT 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 7B B5 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 19. 73 .00 3 .62 71 SHT 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 7B B5 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD RJC 30 I

I BB B5 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 35.0B .00 1 .64 17 RJP 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 88 85 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 88 85 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD RJC 30 I

I 126 85 TEC TEH 610-EB. MBM TSC 11.95 .00 3 1.02 91 RJC 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 126 85 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD RJC 30 I

I 59 88 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 35.24 .00 3 .67 109 A.JD 12 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 59 88 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD RJC 30

63 88. TEC TEH 610-EB INR 05C 4.14 .oo SHT 12 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 63 88 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD RJC 30

99 . 88 TEC TEH 610-EB NDD RJC 3 99 88 TSH TSH 610-ZP MBM TSH 1.43 .00 4 .70 58 SHT 30 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

131 ·88 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS2 22.86 .00 1. 56 164 RJC 3 131 88 TEC TEH 61.0-EB MBM 02C 15.22 .00 : 1 .30 34 RJP 3 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

e 131 88 - - ------- -------- -------- --------- - - - ---------- - ---------- - - ------ HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED . 131 88 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD RJC" 30

137 88 TEC TEH 610-EB 25 VS6 .88 .00 M3 1.54 RJC 3 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 137 88 TEC TEH 610-EB 12 VS6 - .88 .00_ M3 .63 RJC 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 137 88 TEC TEH 610-EB 16 VS7 .91 .00. M3 .85 RJC 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 137 88 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD RJC 30 I

I 136 89 TEC TEH 610-EB 10 VS2 .57 .00 M3 .51 RJC 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 136 89 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD RJC 30 I

I 138 89 TEC.TEH 610-EB 13 VS7 .91 .00 M3 .69 RJC 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 138 89 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD RJC 30 I

I 56 91 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 06H 1.73 .00 3 A.JD 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 56 91 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06H 3.14 .00 .61 146 A.JD 12 !HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

56 91 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD RJC 30 I I

64 91 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 19.86 .00 3 1.24 99 A.JD 12 I 64 91 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD RJC 30 I

I 70 91 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C -5.42 .00 3 .78 98 SHT 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

70 91 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD RJC 30 I I

72 91 TEC TEH 610-EB INR 03H 29.34 .00 3 SHT 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION +-·- - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - .. - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -.+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ... - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

IROW COL . CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS I. +----+----+---+---+------+--:+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

PAGE 19 TUBES 234



+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+---------------~----------------------------------+

IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+-·--+~-------+:-------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+


88 91 TEC.TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 34. 59 .oo 1 1.25107RJP 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 88 91 - - - - - - - ' - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - · - - - · · · · · · · · · · - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REV! EW PERFORMED 88 91 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 30 I

I 126 91 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS7 15.88 .00 1 1.54 18 RJP 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 126 91 - - - - - -·- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - · · - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - · - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 126 91 TSH TSH 610~ZP NOD RJC 30 I

I 132 91 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 07C 19. 72 .oo 3 .72 88 RJP 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 132 91 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 30 I

I 121 92 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 22.23 .oo 1. 79 135 MAR 3 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 121 92 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 8.24 .oo .23 130 RJC 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 121 92 TSH TSH 610.-ZP NOD RJC 30 I 121 92 TSH 02H 620-ZC MBM TSH 22.51 .oo 4 2.35 100 MAR 42 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 135 92 TEC TEH 610-EB 12 VS7 - .60 .00 M3 .63 RJC 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 135 92 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 30 I

I 77 94 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 17.20 .oo 3 .44 111 SHT 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 77 94 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 30 I e I 81 94 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 21.07 .oo .32 128 A.JD 12 !HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 81 94 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 30 I

I 137 94 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 02H 30.90 .oo RJP 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 137 94 TEC TEH.610-EB MBM 02H 31. 71 .oo 1 .38 153 RJP 3 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION . 137 94 TEC TEH 610-EB 22 VS7 .09 .oo M3 1.33 RJC 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 137 94 .TEC TEH 61 0- EB 14 VS7 -.66 .oo M3 .73 RJC 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 137 94 TEC TEH 610-EB 22 DBC -1.83 .oo M3 1..31 RJC 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 137 94 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 30 I

I 54 9.7 TEC TEH 610- EB MBM 05H 17. 71 .oo 3 .50 36 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

54 97 - - - · - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - · - - - - - - · - - - - - - - · - · - - - - - - · - - · · · - - - - · · · - · - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 54 97 TEC TEH 610-EB .MBM 06H ·20.09 .oo 3 .89 41 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

54 97 ------------------------------------------------------------------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 54 97 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C . 22. 72 .. oo 1 .12 70 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

54 97 ------------------------------------------------------------------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 54 97 TEC TEH 610:EB INA 03C 30.2.8 .00 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION


60 97 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 17.27 .oo 3 .32 71 BEA 13 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

60 97 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - · · - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -.- - - · - - - - - · - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 60 97 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 30 I

I 64 97 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM .03H 19.93 .oo .22 52 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+


+----+·-~-+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

PAGE 20 TUBES 245


Palisades Unit 1 CPAL1·B/2530 INSPECTION: No"v-96 1 ·Jun-97 10:41

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---~--------+--~-----+----+------+---+----+----+------~-----------------~-------------------------+

I ROW _COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 ,CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I 64 97 - · · · · · · .. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - · - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -. - - · - - - - - - - - - · - - · - - · - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 64 97 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 30 I I I I 74 97 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 01C 9.95 .00 AJD 13 ·I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 74 97 TEC TEH 610-EB INA oic 11.03 .00 AJD 13 I RESULT OF DISCREPAN,CY RESOLUTION

I 74 97 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 30 I I I I 76 97 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 19.63 .00 1 .21 48 BEA 13 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 76 97 - - - - - · · - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

1. 76 97 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 30 I I

88 97 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 23.63 .00 3 2.14 116 BEA 1 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 88 97 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C - .60 .00 .79 167 AJW 1 I 88 97 TSH TSH 61 o·- ZP NOD RJC 30 I

I 47 98 TEC TEH 610-EB 10 VS4 .81 .00 M2 .83 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 47 98 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 8.15 .00 .08 52 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 47 . 98 - - - - · · - - - - - - - - .- - - - - - -.- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 47 98 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 7.05 .00 .. 1 .08 80 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 47 98 - -·. - - - - - - - - - -.- - - - - - , - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 47 98 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 4.65 .00 .19 13 BEA 13 I RESULT· OF DI.SCREPANCY RESOLUTION 47. 98 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -,- - - - -.- - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 47. 98 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 30 I

e I 133 98 TEC TEH 610-EB 22 VS4 -1.06 .00 M3 1.40 AJW 1 I 133 98 TEC TEH 610-EB 18 VS6 • 77 .00 M3 1.07 AJW . 1 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY.RESOLUTION 133 98 TEC TEH 610-EB 7 VS6 -1 .03 .00 M3 . 31 AJW 1 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 133 98 TEC TEH 610-EB 10 VS7 - .9:4 .00 M3 .49 AJW 1 I 133 98 TSH TSH 610-ZP.NDD RJC 30 I

I 47 100 TEC TEH 610'EB 22 VS4 - .82 .00 M2 2.08 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 47 100 TEC TEH 610-EB 22 07C .67, .00 M2 2.18 AJD 13 I 47. 100 TSH TSH. 610-ZP NOD RJC 30 I

I 51 100 TEC.TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 8.02 -.oo 1 .12 142 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

51 100 ---------------------------------:·---'---------------------------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 51 . 100 TSH TSH 61 0-:ZP NOD RJC. 30 I

I 71 100 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06C 15.24 .00 3 1.17 89 SHT 6 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

71 100 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 30 I

I· I I 26 103 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H . 10.14 .00 3 .78 46 RJC 24 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 26 103 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 28 I

I I

I 28 103-TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 12.56 .00 3 .51 91 RJC 24 I

I 28 103 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 11.18 .00 3 .60 104 RJC 24 I

I 28 103 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 32.64 .00 3 .66 99 SHT 24 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION . I 28 103 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 18.99 .00 3 .69 97 SHT 24 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

+----+----+---+---+------+·---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE pROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS

. +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

PAGE 21 TUBES 255



+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LDC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS. DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+------:-------------------------------------------+

28 .103 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 28

44 103 TEC TEH 610-EB 11 VS4 .91 .oo M3 .49 RJC 24 . 44 103 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 28 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 74 103 TEC TEH 610-EB INR 04H 23.58 .oo 3 SHT 6 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 74 103 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD A.JD 26 I

I 84 103 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 01H 21. 81 .oo RJC 3 I 84 103 TEC TEH-610-EB MBM 01H 23.14 .00 .44 155 RJC 3 I 84 103 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD A.JD 26 I

I 100 103 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 25.50 .oo .36 120 BEA !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 100 103 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 100 103 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD A.JD 26 I

I 102 103 ·TEC TEH 610-EB INR 01H 2.49 .00 BEA 1 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 102 103 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD A.JD 26 I

I 114 103 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 17.56 .oo 1 .21 71 BEA 1 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 114 103 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 114 103 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD A.JD 26 I

I e 134 103 TEC TEH 610-EB 8 VS4 -1.03 .oo M3 .41 AJW 1 I 134 103 TEC TEH 610-EB 27 VS7 - .83 .oo M2 3.2:3 AJW 1 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 134 103 TSH ~SH 610-ZP NOD A.JD 26 I

I 131 104 TEC TEH 610-EB 5 VS7 .80 .oo M3 .26 AJW 1 I 131 104 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD A.JD 26 I

I 41 106 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 21.19. .oo 3 1.02 107 A.JD 18 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 41 106 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 15.25 .00 1 .36 134 SHT 18 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

41 106 ----------------------------------------'-------------~-----------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 41· 106 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 28 I

I 47 106 TEC TEH 610-EB 19 VS4 1. 72 .oo M2 2.07 A.JD 18 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

47 106 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 12.69 .oo 1 .25 143 SHT 18 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY.RESOLUTION

47 106 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 47 106 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 28 I

I 69 1'06 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 28.37 .oo 3 1.32 71 A.JD 6 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION - .

69 106 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD A.JD 26 I I

81 106 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS3 4.28 .oo 3 .84 88 A.JD 6 !RESULT.OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION


133 106 TEC TEH 610-EB 7 VS7 . -1.06 .oo M3 .34 AJW 1 I 133 106 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD A.JD 26 I

+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+.

IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LDC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

PAG.E 22 TUBES 269



+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------·------+

12 109 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 02H 30.58 .00 3 A.JD 24 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY.RESOLUTION 12 109 TEC TEH 610-EB INR 02H 31 .88 .00 SHT 24 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 12 109 TSH TSH 610.ZP NOD AJW 28 I

I 20 109 TEC TEH 610-EB INR 03H 3.54 .00 3 SHT 24 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 20 109 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 28 I

I 24 109 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 1.96 .00 1 .35 98 SHT 24 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 24 109 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - : - - - - : - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 24 109 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 30.58 .00 3 . 72 91 A.JD ·24 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 24 109 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 28 I

I 26 109 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH. 3.16 .oo 3 .68 61 SHT 24 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 26 109 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 28 I

I 32 109 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 25.68 .00 1 .56 29 SHT 24 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 32 109 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -· - - - - - - •: - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 32 109 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 28 I

I 40 · 109 TEC TEH 61 0- EB MBM 03C 30.01 .00 3 .50 34 A.JD 18 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 40 109 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 31.82 .00 3. .47 40 SHT 18 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY.RESOLUTION

. 40 109 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 28 I

e I 44 109 TEC TEH 610-EB 19 VS4 .76 .00 M2 2.02 SHT 18 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 44 109 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 23.90" .00 3 .78 114 A.JD 18 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 44 109 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 28 I

I 62 109 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 8.04 .00 3 1.05 98 SHT 6 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

62 109 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H. 21.46 .00 3 .. 91 83 A.JD 6 I 62 ·109 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 20.18 .00 3 .88 70 A.JD 6 I 62 109 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD A.JD 26 I

I 68 109 TEC TEH 610-EB INA 01C 16.50 .00 SHT 6 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION


76 109 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 15.13 .00 3 1.21 81 A.JD 6 I 76 109 TEC TEH 610-EB M~M 04H 10.67 .00 3 .95 77 A.JD 6 I 76 109 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD A.JD 26 I

I 126 109 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 17.35 .00 .25 44 BEA 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

126. 1"09 - - - - - - - - - - - , - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -·- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 126: 109 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD A.JD 26 I

I 130 109 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 11.16 .00 1 .35 50 BEA 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

130 109 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 130 109 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 6.13 .00 1 .36 38 BEA 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

130 109 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED +- - - -+- - - -+- - .+.: .• -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - .. - ... - - - - - - - - - - - .. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

jROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

PAGE 23 TUBES 280



+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+-------------------------~------------------------+

IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+-·---+--------------------------------------------------+

130 109 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 07C 15.03 .00 .29 47 BEA 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 130 109 · · · · - · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · - · · · · · · · - · - - - - - - - ·I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 130 109 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 26 I

I 35 112 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 10.59 .oo 3 .85 96 AJD 24 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 35 112 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW · 27 I

I 107 112 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 03H 28.50 .oo RJC 3 I 107 112 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 30.19 .oo .4~ 151 RJC 3 I 107 112 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 26 I

I 123 112 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 07H 19.45 .oo .59 133 RJP 3 !,RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 123 112 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 07H 18.70 .oo RJP 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 123 112 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 26 I

I 6 115 DBH TEH 610-EB MBM 04H .00 .oo 1 .15 112 BEA 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 6 115 ·············-·········-----·························-············IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 6 115 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 19.07 .oo .15 111 BEA 20 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 6 115 TSH TS~ 610-ZP NOD AJW 28 I

I 16 115 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 21.11 .oo 3 . 52 63 SHT 24 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION . 16 115 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 28 I

I - 40 115 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 23.36 .oo 3 .80 89 SHT 6 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 40 115 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 27 I

. -I

44 115 TEC TEH 610-EB INA TSH 10.80 .oo SHT 6 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY R°ESOLUTION . 44 115 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 27 I

I 70 115 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 34.40 .oo 3 .96 81 SHT 6 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 70 115 TSH TSH 6.10-ZP NOD AJW 27 I

I 82 115 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05C 13.99 .oo 3 .73 66 SHT 6 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

82 115 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 26 I I

124 115 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 22.23 .oo 1 :23 99 RJP 3 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

124 115 ----~------····--·-···-·················-·························JHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 124 115 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJD 26 I I I I 39 116 TEC TEH 610-EB 10 VS4 .80 .00 M2 .82 SHT 6 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESO_LUTION

I 39 116 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1. AJW 27 I I I I 123 11.6 TEC TEH 6.10-EB 11 VS6 ··. 76 .oo M3 .57 RJC 3 L I 123 116 TSH.TSH 610-ZP NOD 'AJD 26 I I I

r 93 118 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 4.19 .oo 1 .26 43 RJP 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 93 118 ............ - - .. - - - .. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -·- - · · - - · - -· · · - · - - - ···.···I H_ISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 93 .118 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 21 I +-:. - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - ~ -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

IROW COL -CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS I· +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+ - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- -·- -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ - - - - - - - - - -+

PAGE 24 TUBES 294


Palisades Unit 1 CPAL1-B/2530 INSPECTION: Nov-96 1 -Jun-97 10:41

+----+----+---+---+------+--~+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

105 118 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 105 118 TSH.TSH 610-ZP NOD

113 118 TEC TEH 610-EB INF TSH 113 118 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 113 118 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD



42 121 TEC TEH 610-EB 17 VS4 42 121 TSH TSH 610.-ZP NOD

44 121 TEC TEH 610-EB INR·02H 44 121 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

52 121 TEC TEH 610-EB INR 02C 52 121 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

58 .121 TEC TEH 610-EB INR 02H 58 121 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

62 121 TEC TEH 610~EB MBM 05H 62 121 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD


84 121 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM·05H 84 121 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

88 121 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 02H 88 121 TEC TEH 610-EB .MBM 02H 88 121 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 02H 88 121 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 88 .121 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

90 121 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 90 121 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 90 121 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

6.76

21.30 22.42

-1.02

.64

.51

32.65

5.08

24.08

4.67

33.93

20.90

19.50 21.00 3.00 3.85

4.17

22.15

.oo 3

.oo

.oo

.00 M3

.00 M2

.00 M2

.oo

.oo 3

.oo 3

.oo . 3

.oo 3

.oo . 3

.oo

.00

.oo

.oo

.oo 3

.oo 3

. 42 89 RJC 3 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION AJW 27

RJC 3 .85 162 RJC 3

AJW 27

.63 RJC 3 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION AJW 27

1.63 A.JD 6

AJW 27

1.54 A.JD 6

AJW 27

SHT 6 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION AJW 27 I

I SHT 6 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION AJW 27 I


I .87 62 SHT 6 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION.

AJW 27 I


.99 100 A.JD AJW

RJC . 71 156 RJC

RJP .30 149 RJP

AJW

I 6 !RESULT OF.DISCREPANCY RESOLUTidN

21 I I

4 I 4 I 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

21 I I

.68. 90 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

.66 87 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION AJW 27 I

I 96 121 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 6.57 .00 1 .26 89 RJP 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96 121 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - · · · - · - - - - - - - - - - - · · · · · - - - - - - - - · · · · - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 96 121 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM .01H 6.38 .oo .30 32 RJP 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION


+----+---.-+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

PAGE 25 TUBES 307



+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ !ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

96 121 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 96 121 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 27 I

I 106 121 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 13.09 .00 1 .. 25 79 RJP 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 106 121 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - : - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 106 121 TEC TEH 610-EB 8 VS2 .83 .00 M3 .42 RJC 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 106 121 TEC TEH 610-EB 22 VS2 .11 .00 M3 1.37 RJC 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 106 121 TEC TEH 610-EB 9 VS2 - . 57 . 00 M3 . 48 RJC 4 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 106 121 TEC TEH 610-EB 8 VS6 .79 .00 M3 .40 RJC 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 106 121 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 27 I

I 108 121 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 17.35 .00 1 .23 64 RJP 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 108 ·121 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 108 121 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 27 I

I 110 121 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 5.06 .00 3 .84 76 RJC 17 I 110 121 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06H 110 121 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 110 121 610-EB TNT

118 121 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 118 · 121 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

27 124 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 27 124 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 27 124 TSH TSH S10-ZP NOD


59 124 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H. 59 124 TSH TSH. 610-ZP NOD

107 124 TEC TEH 610-EB INF OSC 107 124 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

100 125 TEC TEH 610-EB 12 VS2 100 125 TEC TEH 610-EB 9 VS2 100 125 TEC TE_H 610-EB 7 VS4 100 125 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

· 14 127 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 14 127 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 14 127.TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD


16.93

6.70

.97 11.55

.75 -1.06

26.89

12.50

.03 - . 74 .90

35.35 24.41

22.98

.00 3 . 1.04 59 RJC 17 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION AJW 27 I

.00

.00 M1

.00 3

.00 M2

.00 M2

.oo· 3

.00 3

.00 M3

.00 M3

.00 M3

.00 3

.00 3

.00 3

AJW 99 I I

.40 159 RJC 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 21 I AJW

I 10.11 179 AJD

. 77 88 SHT 6 I 6 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

28 I

.44 1. 77

AJW

I SHT 6 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION SHT 6 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION AJW 28 I


AJW 28 I I

RJP 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION AJW 27 I

.63 RJC

.49 RJC

.37 RJC AJW

. 71 102 AJD

. 74 67 SHT AJW

I 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

21 I I

6 I S !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

28 I I

3.09 117 SHT 6 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION AJW 28 I

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ !ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

PAGE 26 TUBES 319

e.



+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI .COMMENTS +----+----+-:·+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+~-------------------------------------------------+

I I 38 127 TEC TEH 610-EB INA TSH I 38 127 ~EC TEH 610-EB INA TSH I · 38 ·127 TEC TEH 610-EB 19 VS4

I I I I 1·

38 127 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD


7.23 18.75

.73

6.91

76 127 TEC TEH _610-EB MBM 02C . 29.48 76 127 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

96 127 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 03H 96 127 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 96 127 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

102 127 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 102 127 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 102 127 TSH TS~ 610-ZP NOD





8 133 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 8. 133 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

14 133 TEC TEH 610-EB INA 01H 14 133 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

30. 133 TEC !EH 61 O ·EB MBM 03H 30 133 TEC TEH.610-EB MBM 04C 30 133 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 30 133 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 30 133 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM.03C 30 133 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 30 133 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

12.50 13.46

9.78 6.44

36.15

-.69

.76

.74

4.46

16.59

3.07 23.79

3.91 4.48 7 .12

10.84

.oo 3

.oo 3

.00 M2

.00 3

.oo 3

.oo

.oo 3

.oo 3

.oo 3

.00 3

.00 M2

.00 M3

. 00 M2

.oo 3

.oo 3

.oo 3

.00 3

.oo 3

.00 3

.oo 3

.oo 3

S_HT SHT

1. 78 AJD 1'.JW

.66 84 SHT 1'.JW

.62 107 RJC AJW

6 I RESULT OF OIS°CREPANCY RESOLUTION 6 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 6 I

28 I I



21 I I

RJC 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 1.70 11"7 SHT 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

1'.JW 27 I I

.55 91 RJC 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

.81 105 SHT 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION AJW 27 I

I .65 94 "'-JO 7 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

AJW 28 I

I 1.22 AJO 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

RJC . 29 I .

I .23 BEA 7 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION,

AJW 29 I

I . 76 . AJO _7 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

1'.JW 29 I

.68 81 AJO AJW

BEA AJW

.48 103 "'-JO

.67 105 AJO

.82 91 "'-JD

. 72 58 AJD 1.29 91 AJO

.63 58 BEA AJW


29 I I


I 1 I 1 I 1 I 7 I 7 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 7 IRESUlT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

29 I I

32 133 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 22.46 .00 3 .55 97 BEA 7 !RESULT OF OISCREPANCY_RESOLUTION 32 133 ------···········-······--·--····--·············-······-··········IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

+----+----+---+:--+------+---+---+---------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------~-----------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

PAGE 27 TUBES 331



+----+----+---+---+-~--·--+---+---+---.-----+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------·------+

32 133 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD A..JW 29

50 133 TEC TEH 610-EB INR 05H 3.00 .00 BEA 7 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 50 133 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 29.10 .00 .35 8 A.JD 7 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 50 133 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 29 I

I 58 133 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H - .80 .00 M1 .57 147 SHT 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 58 133 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 58 133 TSH TSH $10-ZP NOD RJC 29 I

I 62 133 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 6.09 .00 3 .96 81 SHT 5· !RESULT. OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 62 133 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 29 I

I 64 133 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 13.83 .00 3 .66 91 SHT 5 !RESULT.OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 64 133 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJC 29 I

I 74 133 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 06H 7.20 .00 3 A.JD 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 74 133 TEC TEH 610-EB INA 06H 7.90 .00 SHT 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 74 133 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 29 I

I 88 · 133 TEC TEH 610-EB INA 05C 13.28 .00 SHT 5 RESULT.OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 88 133 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 29

e 98 133 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 13.83 .00 ·3 .51 93 SHT 5 RESULT Of DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 98 133 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 29

45 134 TEC TEH 610-EB 15 VS4 .73 .00 M2 1.19 A.JD 7 45 134 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 29

69 134 TEC TEH 610-EB 13 VS4 - . 76 .00 M2 1.26 A.JD 5 69 134 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT 04C -.90 .00 M1 7.99 180 A.JD 5 69 .134 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1 RJC 29

3 136 DBH TEH 610-EB NOD A.JD 19 3 136 TEC TEH 590-EB MBM 02C 2.41 .00 .12 122 BEA 21 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 3 136 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -·- - - - - ~ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

3 136 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD A.JD 37

15 136 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 33.83 .00 3 .80 93 A.JD 7

15 136 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 13.01 .00 3 1.21 107 A.JD 7 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 15 136 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD A.JD 37 I

I 45. 136 TEC TEH 610-EB 16 VS4 .75 .00 M2 1.34 A.JD 7 I 45 136 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJC 29 I

I 63 136 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06H 18.17 .00 3 2.56 120·SHT 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 63 136 TSH TSH 610-ZP ~DD AJC 29 I

I +----+----+---+~.--+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+---------------------·----------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

PAGE 28 TUBES 345






4 139 DBH TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 4 139 DBH TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 4 139 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 4 139 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 4 139 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

20 139 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 20 139 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD



.44 1.39 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 44 139 TEC TEH 610-EB INR 01H 44 139 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

48 139 TEC TEH 610-EB INR 04H 48 139 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

62 139 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 62 139 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06H 62 139 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS3 62 139 TEC TEH 610-EB. ONT VS3 62 139 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD


100 139 TEC TEH 610-EB 36 DBH 100 139 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 100 139 DBH 07H 580-UP WAR DBH


82 143 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 02· 143 TEC TEH 610-EB 10 VS3 82 143 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

21.92

1.05

21.78 20.32 21 .76 20.27

5.16

8.18

2.78

22.76 22.55

12.81

19. 71 12.18 '.58

-1.29

8.24

1.Hl

1.87

3.80

5.41 - .85

.oo 3

.00 M2

.oo 3

.oo 3

.oo

.00

.oo 3

.oo

.00 3

.oo

.oo

.oo

.oo 3

.oo 3

.00 M1

.00 M1

.oo 3

.OO M2

.oo

.oo

.oo 3

.00 M2

.48 86 SHT RJC

1.78 SHT RJC

1.28 112 AJD .98 107 AJD .40 151 BEA .28 155 BEA

AJD

4.04 109 AJD

5 !RESULT OF·DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 29 I

I 5 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

29

19 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 19 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 20 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 20 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 37

7 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION AJD · 37

.82 170 AJD 7 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOL~TION RJC 29 I

I .93 105 AJD 7 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

RJC 29 I

I 1.22 158 AJD 7 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

BEA 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION RJC 29 I

I BEA 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION RJC 29 I

.66 73 SHT

.92 80 AJD 12.25 175 AJD 30. 52 177 AJD

RJC

.57 69 AJD RJC

5.00 AJD RJC

1 .42 61 WJS

1,

5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 5 1.RESUL T OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTI9N 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

29 I I

5 I 29 I

I 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION.

29 I 39 IRESULT OF LEAD ANALXST RESOLUTION

I BEA 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION RJC 29 I

I 1 .01 102 AJW 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

.78 AJW 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION RJC 29 I

I +-:--+----+---+---+------+---+---+:-------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

PAGE 29 TUBES 358



+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+----~---------------------------------------------+ !ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----~--------------------------------------------------+

16 145 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 2.45 .00 3 1.22. 101 BEA 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 16 145 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REV! EW PERFORMED 16 145 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD A.JD 37 I

I 38 145 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 1.29 .00 3 4.66 106 AJW 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 38 145 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD A.JD 37 I

I 40 145 TEC TEH 610-EB INA 02H 3.94 .00 BEA 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 40 145 TEC TEH 610-EB INR 04H 37.01 .00 BEA 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 40 145 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD A.JD 37 I

I 44 145 TEC TEH 610-EB INR TSH 7.74 .00 BEA 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 44 145 TEC TEH 610-EB INR TSH 23.13 .00 BEA 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 44 145 TEC TEH 610-EB INR 04H 2.9.18 .00 BEA 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 44 145 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD A.JD 37 I

I 52 145 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 22.42 .00 3 1.18 118 BEA 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 52 145 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 52 145 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD A.JD 37 I


64 145 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM OSC 64 145 .TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

33.00

16.03

.00

.00 3

80 145 TEC TEH 610~EB MBM 01H 18.32 .00 3

.29

1.54

2.00

I 110 BEA 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

A.JD 37 I I

112 AJW 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION RJC 29 I

I 98 BEA 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

80 145 - - - - - - - -- - - - - -- -- - - -- - - --- -- - ----.--- - - - - - - -- ---.- --- - - - - - --- ---- --- !HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 80 145 TEC TEH 610-EB INR 02H 24.04 .00 1 BEA 8 IRESU.LT OF_ DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 80 145 TEC TEH 610-EB 17 VS4 -.86 .00 M2 1.56 AJW 8 I 80 145 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 9.00 .00 3 1.30 88 BEA 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 80 145 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - .- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -:- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 80 145 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD RJC 29 I

I 82 ·145 TEC TEH 610-EB 9 VS3 -.55 .00 M2 . 71 AJW 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

82 145 TEC TEH 610-EB 12 VS4 .86 .00 M2 .98 AJW 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION


45 148 TEC TEH 610-EB 4 VS4 .70 .00 M3 .19 AJW 9 !RESULT OF .DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION


6 151 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 02C 18.52 .00 A.JD 18 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

6 151 TEC TEH 610-EB INR.02C 19.49 .00 SHT 18 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

6 151 TSH JSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 41 I I

16 151 TEC TEH 610-EB INA 03H 15.63 .00 BEA 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION


+ - - - -+ - - - -+ - - -+ .- - - + - - - - - -+ - - -+ - - - + - - - - - - - -+ - - - - - - - -+ - - - -+ - - - - - -+ - - -+ - - - -+ - - - -+ - - - - - - .- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - '.: - - - - - - - - - - ·- - - - - - - - - - - - -+

!ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

PAGE 30 TUBES 370




32 151 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 35.83 .00 .32 87 RJP 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION· 32 151 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD l>..JW 41 I

I 40 151 TEC TEH 61-0-EB MBM 02C 13.38 .00 1 .19. 60 RJP 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 40 151 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 40 151 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD l>..JW 41 I

I 46 151 TEC TEH 610-EB 10 VS4 . 77 .00 M2 .97 l>..JW 9· I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 46 151 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD l>..JW 41 I

I 50 151 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 13. 76 .00 1 .23 125 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 50 151 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - -, - - -- - - - - --- - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 50 151 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD l>..JW 41 I

I 62 151 TEC TEH 610-EB INA 03C 9.52 .00 RJC 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 62 151 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD l>..JW 41 I

I 64 151 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM DBH 11 .95 .00 3 1 .. 08 55 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 64 151 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD l>..JW 41 I

I 68 151 TEC TEH 610-EB 5 VS3 - .59 .00 M3 .27 RJP 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 68 151 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD l>..JW 41 I

I

e 29 154 TEC TEH 610-EB INA 02C 4.63 .00 RJC- 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 29 154 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD l>..JW 41 I

I 45 154 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 14.59 .00 3 1.06 109 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 45 154 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD l>..JW 41 I

I 53 154 TEC TEH 610-EB INA 02H 10.31 .00 RJC 10 I 53 154 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD .l>..JW 41 I

I 4 157 DBH TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 19.60 .00 3 .72 112 !>.JD 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 4 157 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 18.75 .00 .10 133 BEA 20 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 4 157 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD l>..JW 41 I

I 8 ·157 TEC TEH 610-EB INA 01C 15.42 .00 RJC 10 I 8 157 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD l>..JW 41 I

I 14 157 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 1.30 .00 3 1.06 116 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 14 157 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD . l>..JW 41 I

I ·30 157 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 36.60 .00 1 .71 151 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 30 157 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 30 157 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD · 1 l>..JW 41 I

I 42 157 TEC TEH 610-EB INA 02H 18.01 .00 RJC 10 I 42 157 TSH TSH 61.0-ZP NOD · 1 l>..JW 41 I

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+-----.-+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - • - • - - ••. - - -+

PAGE 31 TUBES 385

e



+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -.- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

48 157 TEC TEH 610-EB INR 03H 27. 50 .00 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 48 157 TEC TEH 610-EB INR 04H 29.51 .00 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 48 157 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 41 I.

I 54 157 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06C 6.19 .00 .42 27 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 54 157 · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · - · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · ·······I HISTORY REV! EW PERFORMED 54 157 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 41 I

I 3 160 DBH TEH. 610-EB NOD BEA 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 3 160 TEC TEH 590-EB MBM 01C -1.64 .00 1 .27 19 BEA 21 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 3 160················-····-········-·································-··IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 3 160 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 41 I

I 15 160 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 15 160 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD .

14.59 .00 3 .62 114 A.JD 18 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION AJW 41 I

12 12 12 12 12 12 12 12 12

16 16 16 16 16 16 16

I 163 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 16.78 .00 .20 66 SHT 18 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 163 · · · · · · · · - · · · · · · - · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · - · · · · · · - · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · ·······I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 163 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 36.38 .00 3 1.26 109 SHT. 18 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 163 TEC TEH 610-EB INR 02H -3.59 .00 1 SHT 18 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 163 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 30.97 .00 3 .45 94 AJD 18 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 163 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 36.23 .00 3 .48 63 SHT 18 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 163 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 31.33 .00 3 .44 105 SHT 18 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 163 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 36.15 .00 3 .48 63 SHT 18 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 163 TSH.TSH 610-ZP NOD AJW 41 I

I 163 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 1.56 .00 .14 135 AJD 18 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 163 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM DBC -3.79 .00 1 1.02 138 SHT 18 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 163 ~--················---···-······--······-··;···········-··········!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 163 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 05C 163 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 163 TEC TEH 610-EB INF 02C 163 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD

-3.20 2.06

.87

.00 3

.00

.00 3

SHT 18 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 1.02 148 AJD 18 !HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

SHT 18 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION AJW 41 I

+-···•···-•····--~+-·····•···•·--•········•········•····+······+-··•····+····•······-············-··-·····-·-·--·-·····--·······+

IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------~---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ PAGE 32 TOTAL TUBES 390

e

Indication Distribution Report 11-22-1996 10:20

Palisades Unit· 1 CPAL1-B /2530 Inspection: Nov-96

Indication

INF INA PLP MBM MMB VOL AOR NCI ORI

0 OSI <40

DI PI

WAR 1-19 ·saR PAI PC! SA!-MAI SCI MCI M_MI

To~al

. Most severe Indication Per Tube

Cum. · Iner, Cum. Rep.

44

272

·1

69

387

44

272

1

69

387

1

69

70

Hot Leg


cumulative Hot

28

182

1

69

Incremental Cum. Reportable Hot Hot

28

182

. 1

69

280

69

70


Cumulative Hot

14 48

250

1

93

406

Incremental Cum. Reportable Hot Hot

14 48

250

1

93

406

1

93

94

.'Incremental• reflects data since the last shift report only. 'Final' indications exclude multiple tests.


Indication Vs. Location for Final Indications 11-22-1996 10:20

Palisades Unit CPAL 1 -8 /2530 Inspection: Nov-96

Hot Leg 9.

TSH 01H 02H 03H 04H 05H 06H 07H DBH VS1 VS2 VS3 VS4 VS5 VS6 VS7 DBC

INF· 1 2 5 2 2 INA 7 9 9 5 9 4 2 1 MBM. 49 31 37 32 38 24 11 2 5 5 2 6 2 2 3 WAR

1-19 3 18 8 45 2 8 8

Indication Vs. Probe for Final Indications 11-22-1996 10:20

Palisades Unit 1. CPAL1-B /2530 Inspection: Nov-96

Hot Leg

590 610 RPC

INF 13 INR . 48

MBM 2 24.6 2 WAR

1-19 93 l._,.

All. calls Vs. Location (Includes Multiple Tests) 11·22·1996.t0:20

Palisades Unit 1 CPAL 1 ·B /2530 Inspection: Nov-96

e Hot Leg

TSH 01H 02H 03H 04H 05H 06H 07H 08H OBH VS1 VS2 VS3 VS4 UB VS5 VS6 VS7 DBC

ONT 2 4 3 9 PVN l

NTE 1 . PTE 1

TRA 3 OBS 5 INF 1 2 5 2 2 INR 7 9 9 5 9 4 2 1 MBM 49 31 37 32 38 24 11 2 5 5 2 6 2 2 3 WAR

1 ·19 3 18 8 45 2 8 8 20-29 2 2 30-39

All Calls Vs. Probe (Includes Multiple Tests) 11 . 22. 1996 1 0: 20

Palisades Unit 1 CPALl·B /2530 Inspection: Nov-96

Hot Leg

590 610 RPC

ONT 22 PVN NTE PTE TRA 3 OBS 5 INF 13 INR 48 MBM 2 246 2 WAR

.1-19 93 20-29 8 30-39

e.

Indication Distribution Report 11-22-1996 10:21

Palisades Unit 1 CPAL1-B /2530 Inspection: Nov-96

Indication .

INF INR PLP MBM MMB VOL ADR NQI ORI

0

OSI <40

DI PI

WAR 1-19

SOR PAI PCI

SAI MAI

SCI MCI

MMI

Total

Most Severe Indication Per Tube

Cum.

44

272

69

387

Iner:. Cum. Rep.

44

272

1

69

387

69

70


Cold Leg


Cumulative Incremental Cum. Reportable Cumulative Incremental Cum. Reportable Cold Cold Cold Cold

21

119

1·

21

119

----------------·-----------·--------------142 142

9

31

145

186

Cold Cold

9

31

145

186

'Incremental' reflects data since the last shift report.only. 'Final' indications exclude multiple tests.


Indication Vs. Location for Final Indications 11 -22-1996 10: 21

PalisadE!s UnH 1 CPAL1-B /2530 Inspection: Nov-96

Cold Leg

OBC 07C 06C 05C 04C 03C 02C 01C TSC TEC

INF 1 2 2 3 1 INA 2 3 4 6 7 7 2 MBM 3 11 12 19 28 28 22 21 .1

1-19.

Indication Vs. Probe for Final Indications 11 ·22-1996 10:21

Palisades Unit CPAL1·B /2530 Inspection: Nov-96

Cold Leg

590 610

INF .9 INA 31 MBM 2 143

1 ·19 1

All Calls Vs. Location (Includes Multiple Tests) 11-22-1996 10;22


Cold Leg

00c 07C 06C 05C 04C 03C 02C 01C TSC TEC

ONT INF 1 2 2 3 INA 2 3 4 6 7 7 2 MBM 3 11 12 19 28 28 22 21

1-19 . 20-29

All Calls vs. Probe (Includes Multiple Tests) 11-22-1996 10:22


Cold Leg

590 610

ONT 1 INF 9 INA 31 MBM 2 · 143

1-19 20-29



+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

48 13 TEC TEH 610-EB 6 VS4

72 25 TEC TEH 610-EB 6 VS3

44 31 TEC TEH 610-EB 10 VS4

82 31 TEC TEH 610-EB 24 VS3 82 . 31 TEC TEH 610-EB 8 VS4


45 ·34 TEC TEH 610-EB 8 VS4

77 34 TEC TEH 610-EB 5 VS3

45 36 TEC TEH 610-EB 8 VS4

71 71

36 TEC TEH 610-EB 36 TEC TEH 610-EB

44 . 37 TEC TEH 610-EB

46 37 TEC TEH 610-EB

4 VS4 7 VS5

8 VS4

5 VS4

.18

- .53

- . 79

.82 - .98

.29 - . 76

.00

.71

~35

.91

.03

.oo

.93

.00 M3

.00 M3

.00 M3

.00 M3

.00 M3

.00 M3

.00 M3

.00 M3

· .00 M3

.00 M3

.00 M3

.00 M3

.00 M3

.00 M3

.30

.28

.45

1. 51 .37

.32

.22

.38

.25

.36

.16

.33

.35

.22

RJC 23

SHT 17 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

RJC 15

RJC 16 RJC 16

RJC 15 RJC 15

RJC 15

RJC 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I RJC 15 I

I RJC 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION RJC 16 I

I RJC 15 I

I RJC 15 I

I 106 106 106

37 TEC TEH 610-EB 7 VS2 -.85 .00 M3 .33 RJC 16 I 37 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS4 7 .11 . 00 1 . 51 25 RJP 16 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 37 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -.- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REV! EW PERFORMED

106. 37 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS4 11.36 .00 .87 176 RJP 16 !RESULT' OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 106 37 ------------------------------------------------------------------IHISTORY·REVIEW PERFORMED 106 37 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS4 12.75 .00 1 .28 54 RJP 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

. 106 37 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - : - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - : . - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 114 37 TEC TEH 610-EB 5 VS2 -.03 .00 M3 .25 RJC 16 I 114 37 TEC TEH 610-EB 10 VS4 .82 .00 M3 .52 RJC 16 I 114 37 TEC .TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 29.57 .00 .31 160 RJC 16 I

107 40 TEC TEH 610-EB 5 VS2

42 41 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 42 41 TEC TEH 610-EB 7 VS4

.98 41 TEC TEH 610-EB 6 VS4

107 42 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 107. 42 TEC TEH 610-EB 8 VS2 107 42 TEC. TEH 610-EB 6 VS2

1.00

12.82 .61

.59

3.85 .91

- . 73'

.00 M3

.00 '1

.00 M3

.00 M3

.00 3

.00 M3

.00 M3

.23 RJC

.29 123 RJC :30 RJC

.28 RJC

.56 87 RJC

.39 RJC

.30 RJC


I 15 I 15 I

I 16 I


I I

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+-------------------------.-------------------------+ I ROW COL CEB 'cEE PROBE . IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+-----~+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

PAGE TUBES 17


Palisades Unit 1 CPAL 1 ·B/2530 INSPECTION: Nov-96 1-Jun-97 10:40



·74 43 TEC TEH 610-EB 5 VS4

82 43 TEC TEH 610-EB 5 VS3 82 43 TEC TEH 610-EB 9 VS3 82 43 TEC TEH 610-EB 4 VS5

106 43 TEC TEH .610-EB 17 VS4


116 43 TEC TEH 610-EB 4 VS4

9 46 TEC TEH 610-EB 6 DBH

106 47 TEC TEH 610-EB 9 VS2 106 47 TEC TEH 610-EB 13 VS4 106 47 TEC TEH 610-EB 11 VS6 106 47 TEC TE~ 610-EB 11 VS6

45 48 TEC TEH 610-EB 9 VS4

38 49 TEC TEH 610-EB 6.VS4

.72

.14

- . 72

.56 - .15 .23

.78

- .85 1.05

.92

.26

.38

.92 1.01 - .95

.37

.74

.00 M3

.00 M3

.00 M3

.00 M3

.00 M3

.00 M3

.00 M3

.00 M3

.00 M3

.00 M3

.00 M3

.42

.24

.21

.24

.46

.19

.97

.24

.16

.16

.28

.00 M2 .84

.00 M2 1.31

.00 M2 . 1.08

.00 M2 1.09

.00 M2 .86

.00 M3 .29

RJC 16 RJC 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I RJP 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

· RJC RJC RJC

RJC

RJC RJC

RJC


I 16 I

I 16 I 16 I

I 16 I

I RJC 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I AJD 17 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION SHT 17 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION SHT 17 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION SHT . 17 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY·RESOLUTION

I SHT 17 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I AJW 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 98 55_ TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 8.64 .00 1 .19 21 BEA 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 98 55. - - - - - - - --- --- --- - - - -- -- --- --·- - - - - ------ - --- - - - - - -- - - - - ------ ---- - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 98 55 TEC TEH 610-EB 7 VS2 - .91 .00 M3 .32 AJW 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 110 55 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 26.18 .00 1 .20 46 BEA 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 110 55 --------------------------:----------------------------------------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 110· 55 TEC.TEH 610-EB 6 VS1 -1.10 .00 M3 .29 BEA 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 110 55 TEC TEH.610-EB MBM 03C 11.43 .00 1 .22 24 BEA 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 11 O 55 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -· - - - - _. - -·- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -. - - - - - - I HISTORY REV! EW PERFORMED

66 63 TEC TEH 610-EB 11 VS3

48 65 TEC TEH 610-EB 14 VS4

135 66 TEC TEH 610-EB 17 VS7 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EB 17 08C

137 72 TEC TEH 610-EB 17 VS1 137 72 TEC TEH 610-EB 15 VS4 137 72 TEC TEH 610-EB_MBM 03C

- .32

- .58

-.79 .79

-.79 -.53

34.25-

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M1

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 3

.82 BEA

1.11 AJD

1.53 AJD .85 115 AJD

·1.52 AJD 1.20 AJD 1.11 99 SHT


I 12 I

I 12 I 12 I

I 12 I 12 I 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

PAGE 2 TUBES 33



+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+--·--+----+--------------------------------------------;·----+

13S 79 TEC TEH 610-EB 6 VS1 138 79 TEC TEH 610-EB 6 VS2


137 88 TEC TEH 610-EB 25 VS6 137 88 TEC TEH 610-EB 12 VS6 137 . 88 TEC TEH 610-EB 16 VS?

136 89.TEC TEH 610-EB 10 VS2

138 89 TEC TEH 610-EB. 13 VS?

135 92 TEC TEH 610-EB · 12 VS?

137 94 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 137 94 TEC TEH 610-EB 22 VS? 137 94 T.EC TEH 610-EB 14 VS? 137 9~ TEC TEH 610-EB 22 DBC

47 98 TEC TEH 610-EB 10 VS4

- .55 .75

1.08

-.96

.88 -.88

.91

.57

.91

- .60

31. 71 .09·

- .66 -1.83

.81

.00 M3

.00 M3

.00 M3

.00 M3

.00 M3

.00 M3

.00. M3

.00 M3

.00 M3

.00 M3

.00 1

.00 M3

.00 M3

.00 M3

.00 M2

.28

.29

.30

.48

.1.54

.63

.85

.51

.69

.63

RJC RJC

RJC RJC

RJC RJC RJC

RJC

RJC

RJC



I 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 3 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION




I .38 153 RJP 3 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY. RESOLUTION

3 !RESULT OF DISCREP,4NCY RESOLUTION 1..33 RJC .73

1.31

. 83

RJC 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY.RESOLUTION RJC 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION .

.47 98 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 8.15 .00 1 .08 52 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 47 98 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -. - - - - - -.- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - : - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY R.EVIEW PERFORMED 47 98 TEC °TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 7-05 .00 1 .08 80 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY·.RESOLUTION 4 7 98 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - " - - - - - - - - - - - -· - - - - - - - - - - - ~ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 47 98 TEC .TEH 610-EB MBM.TSC 4.65 .00 .19 13 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 4 7 98 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - , - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - : - - -· - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 133 98 .TEC TEH 610-EB 22 VS4 -1.06 .00 M3 1.40 /l..JW · 1 I 133 98 TEC TEH 610-EB 18 VS6 133 98 TEC TEH 610-EB 7 VS6 133 98 TEC TEH 610-EB 10 VS?

47 100 TEC TEH. 610-EB 22 VS4 47 100 TEC TEH 610-EB 22 07C

44 103 TEC TEH 610-EB 11 VS4

134 .103 TEC TEH 610-EB 8 VS4 134 103 TEC TEH 610-EB 27 VS?

131 ·104.TECTEH610-EB 5VS7

. 77

-1.03 -.94

- .82 .67

.91

-1 .03

-.'83

.80

.00 M3

.00 M3

.00 M3

1.07

.31

.49

.oo i.42 2.08

.00 M2 2.18

.00 M3 .49

.00 M3 .41

.00 M2 3.23.

.00 M3 .26

/l..JW /l..JW /l..JW

!RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I I

BEA 13 IRESUL T OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUT.ION /!..JD 13 I

I RJC 24 I

I /l..JW I /l..JW !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION·

I /l..JW I

I · 47 106 TEC TEH 610-EB 19 VS4 1.72 .00 M2 2.07 /!..JD 18 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

.4.7 106 TEC TEH 610-EB· MBM TSC 12. 69 . 00 1 . 25 143 SHT 18 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 47 106 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -.- - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I I. +----+----+---+-~-+----~-~---+---+--------+--------+----+------+--~+----+----+----------------------·----------------~-----------+ IROW COL CEB. CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+-·- - - - - - -+- - - -+_,_ - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

PAGE 3 TUBES 47


Palisades Unit 1 CPAL1-B/2530 INSPECTION: Nov-96 1 -Jun-97 10: 40

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+; _________________________ . ________________________ ;


133 106 TEC TEH 610-EB 7 VS7

44 109 TEC TEH 610-EB 19 VS4 44 109 TEC TEH 610-EB. MBM 01C

39 116 TEC TEH 610-EB 10 VS4

123 116 TEC TEH 610-EB 11 VS6

123 ,18 TEC TEH. 610-EB 12 VS6

40 121 TEC TEH 610-EB 18 VS4

42 121 TEC TEH 610-EB 17 VS4


-1.06

.76 23.90

.80

- . 76

-1.02

.64

.51

13.09

.00 M3

.00 M2

.00 3

.00 M2

.00 M3

.00 M3

.00 M2

.00 M2

.oo

.34 AJW

2.02 SHT . 78 114 AJD

.82 SHT

.57 RJC

.63 RJC

1.63 AJD

1.54 AJD

.25 79 RJP

1 I I


I 6 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

3

3 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

6

6


106 121 ------------------------------------------------------------------ HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 106 121 TEC TEH 610-EB 8 VS2 .83 .00 M3 .42 RJC 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 106 1.21 TEC TEH 610-EB 22 VS2 · .11 .00 M3 1.37 RJC 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 106 121 TEC TE.H 610-EB 9 VS2 -.57 .00 M3 .48 RJC 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 106 121 TEC TEH 610-EB 8 VS6 . 79. .00 M3 .40 RJC 4 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

47 124 TEC TEH 610-EB .9 VS4 47 124 TEC TEH 610-EB 19 VS4

100 125 TEC TEH 610-EB 12 VS2 100 125 TEC TEH 610-EB 9 VS2 -100 125 TEC TEH 610-EB 7 VS4

38 127 TEC TEH 610-EB 19 VS4

105 130 TEC TEH 610-EB 13 VS2

41 132 TEC. TEH 610-EB 6 VS4

45 132 TEC TEH 610-EB. 10 VS4

45 134 TEC TEH 610-EB 15 VS4

69 134 TEC TEH 610-EB 13 VS4

45 136 TEC TEH 610-EB 16 VS4

95 138 TEC TEH 610-EB 17 VS4

.100· 139TECTEH610-EB 36DBH

82 143 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM'01H

.75 -.1.06

.03 - . 74

.90

.73

- .69

.76

.74

.73

- . 76

.75

1.05

1 .19

5.41

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M3

.00 M3

.00 M3

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M3

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.00 M2

.oo 3

.44 1. 77

.63

.49

.37

1. 78

1.22

.23

.76

1.19

1.26

1.34

1. 78

5.00

SHT SHT

RJC RJC RJC

AJD

AJD

BEA

AJD

AJD

AJD

AJD

SHT

AJD

1.01 102 AJW


I 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 6 I


I 7 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION


I 1 I

I 5 I

I 1 I




·-~--·----+---+---+------+---+---+;·------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+---------------------------------.-----------------+ IAOW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

PAGE 4 TUBES 66


Palisades Unit .1 CPAL1·B/2530 INSPECTION: Nov-96 1-Jun-97 10:40

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--.--+--------------------------------------·------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG·ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

82 143 TEC TEH 610-EB 10 VS3 - .85 .00 M2 .78 AJW 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I I I

80 145 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 18.32 .00 3 2.00 98 BEA 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 80 145 · - - - - - - : - · · · - - - · · - - - - · · - - - - - · · - - - · · - - · - - - - · · · - · · · - - - - · · · · · · - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 80 145 TEC TEH 610-EB 17 VS4 - .86 .00 M2 1. 56 AJW 8 I I 80 145 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C . 9.00 .00 3 1.30 88 BEA 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 80. 145 - - - · - · · - - - - - - · - - - - · · · · - - · · · - - - · · · · - - · · · · · · - - - - - - · · · - - - · · · · · - - - - - - · I HISTORY REV! EW PERFORMED 1.

I I" 82 145 TEC TEH 610-EB .9 VS3 -.55 .oci M2 .71 AJW 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 82 145 TEC TEH 610-EB 12 VS4 .86 .. 00 M2 .98 AJW 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I

I I 45 148 TEC TEH 610-EB 4 VS4 .70 .00 M3 .19 AJW 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I

I I ·. 46 151 TEC TEH 610-EB 10 VS4 .77 .00 M2 .97 AJW 9 .1 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I

I I 68 151 TEC TEH 610-EB 5 VS3 - .59 .00 M3 .27 RJP 9 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY 'RESOLUTION I

+----+--·--+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--~-+-------------------------------------~------------+


+----+----+---·-~-·------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---·~---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ PAGE 5 TOTAL TUBES 71

• SG - B PERCENT CAllS

., 2

63 0% TO 19r. INDICATION

. ralisaaes . ~nit 1

-y ' )

x 1 20% TO 29% INDICATION i .:JC);-~ 1·c1 .:-JS)% 11\JDICATION

6 Or. TO .19r. & 20r. TO 29r. INDICATION

IQJ : 309 PLUGGED TUBE

* : 25 STAY ROD

.. :·:·~·:>~~·:"::y·:·:·:·:~<·:·:·::; . .-.-:::-.. 135 ............ ·.· ......... ·.· ....... " 130 . . .. . . . :: :: :: :: : . . 125

............. -: .... -: .. :.: ..... : .... ·......... 120 • • ~ • :- • • • • : : • • • o :: • • •. o :: • • • • : : • • • • : : • • • o :: • • • • : : • • 'I• •

. . .· :: :: :: :: : : : : : . • 115 .· ..... · ... · ....... · ........... · ... · ... · ....... · ....... · ... · ................. '· · ... : ..... : ... : . . . . . 110

. . . ": ~ : ~ . : ~ : ~ . : ~ : ~ . . ; : ~ . " : : . . . . 105 .•:· ...... : .. ·. • ... ·: .... · .... :· ....... ·: .. · ... · .. :· ... · ... ·: ...... · .. :· ... · .... : ......... : ......... : ......... :.:.. 100

_.-::. ~~ ~~ ~~ ~~ ~~ ~~ ~~ ~~ • ~ \ :. . 95 .... ·.:. · ...... :: .· ..... · :: ~ ....... :: ..... · .· :: ..... · .. :: . ·.· ... ·.: ..... · .. :: ... · .... :: ..... · .. :: ..... · .. :: ........ ::....... 90

:: .:7 :: :: :: • : ::- :: :: • .· :: 85 .·:·.:.: ... : ... ·.·.·:: ... ·.·.·:: ... ·.·.·:: ... ·.·.·:: ... ·.·.·:: ... ·.·.·:: .. : ... ·.·:: ... ·.·.·:: ... ·.·.·:: ..... : ... : ... ·.·.~:: ... ·.·-·:·:·. 80

.. : : .: ~ :. : : ~ : : :_. : . ·.: : .: : : : . :. : :. : . . : . . . : . : . . 75 .·.·: ......... : .... · ..... ·: .... : .... : .... : .... -: .... : ......... · .. • ... ·:.: .. :... 70

.-·"::· ... ~~·-· •. ~~- ... ~~- ... ~~- ... ·-~~- ... ( ... ~~· ... ~:· ..... · :~· ... ~~· ... ~~- ... ~:· .... ::· . ·. . 65

.·.·.·::··-·.·.·::··-·.·.·::··-·.·.·::········::········::········::··-·.·.·::-·.·.·.·::········::········::··-·.·.·::-·.·.·.·::.·.·.·.·::.·.·.·.·. 60 :' :: :: :: :: ::- :: :: ·:: .:: :: . :: :: :: :: :::-55 ::·.·.·.·::.·.·.·.·::.·.·.·.·::.·.·;···::.·.·.·.·::.·;·····~:;·····~··· .·~····::.·.;.·.·::.·.·.·.·::.·.·.·.·::.·.·.·.·::.·.·.·.·::.·.··:··::::-50

-: ·-:· -: .•. -: -: .; . -: • • ~ ·: .,. -: :· . .,., -: .: .,_45

/j~ .... ·.·j~········\j··.·.·:·\j·:··-·.:i~·"'·")·"'·'· . ==--. 5 •• ~ •• ~ .·.·\j"·"""\~···""\···~·.-·)"····"\~·""'"\j·<:-~ .·.·: .... ·: .... ·:: ... ·: .... ·: .... ·: . . . . • ... ·: .... ·: . ~ .. ·: .... ·: . •' .. ·: .... ·: . ··--30 :· ~:~ ... ~:· ... ~:· . · .. ~:· ... ~:· ... ~:· .. ·=--=-- . ·=--::· . ~:· -.. ~:· ... ~:· ... ~:· ... ~:· ... ~:· . ·-: 25

.: ... : ... ·.·.-:: ... ·.·.·:: ... ·.·.·:: ... ·.·.·:: ... ·.·.·:: ... ·.·:· . ·:-.-:: ... ·.·.·::.·.·;·.·:: ... ·.·.·:: ... ·.·.·:: ... ·.·.·:: .... ·.:-: 20

: . : . : . : . : . : . : . : . : . : . : . : . : : i.:.: : . : : •. : . : . :··: •.. : . : . : . : : .. : .. : . . • : ••. : ...•. : • : ... : . : . : ••. : .•. : . : ••. : . : ....••...•... : ••.. : . : •• -~ 1· · i · l · i :' l. i · l · i · r · i · l · i · · i · r · i · l · i · r · i · l · i · l · i · l ·

ilk i60 ;~ ;S1> ;qs- ;q;, ;;s- ;3;, ~:;, ;2~ ;;~ .~·~ ;;,;- ;~ ;-, 9o ss- so ;;- 7~ ;;~ ~ 55 ~~ 45- 4o 35- i; ·~5- i~ ,·;; 10 ~ I .

e e • SG/B - MANUFACTURING HUFF Ml\RK LOCATIONS

/ : 288 TUBE WITH MBM

* : 25 STAY ROD 161\ Palisades Unit 1 CPL~ 8 - SERIES 2530 Cl : 309 PLUGGED TUBE

~ 11-22-1996 09:33 HRS. SUPERTUBIN

----~--------135 .·J::.:.·.·:.~.-·.·.·.~:~~·.·.·.·:~.·.·.·.·;:.~.-.·.;:::·.·. 130

.. · ./ ·<: / :~ / :: "'·> . . 125 .· .·)f .:.: .. :·~~ .· .·.·.· >· .· .< ·~~·· .· .~·t·· ... ~.) ... · ... -~~··· ·.· .. :/·: :~.. 120 • • ••I • I • • • • • • • • . • , ", "/ 115

• •" •" :~• •.• •"·~~~:· •" ·";"~~:.· •" .·.~ :: •" •" •" • ·~~·· .• .·,·~~·";'•' • • ~~ .~_. • .·./:~·· .1 ··;·~~·· • • ,•;•~~.~:·.••I• :

.. : ~::: .. ; .. ~) ·: ..... :) ~ ~ ....... ~ j .... ·' .. ~ j ........ ) j,· ...... )~ ........ )) .;. : .. ·~)) ... ;. ·:. ~) ........ ~ ~ ...... ·~~ ~:.:.. : '-------90

1:- /• 85 ---80 ::...._ __ 75

---70 •/ /.• ·<•/ -:/ /> /• 65

----60

::; .... _,:~.·.~.·.·~~··.·J.·:~········~~··.·.·.·:=··;·····~.~.;·······: - -: . . / . . >· . :- :- :; . /

:-: ... /-: .... ·; .... -: . . .· / -; / .-.~:: ....... -:: ... ·.~.~:: ... ·.·.<: ... : ... -:;_ .... ~.<:.~.~-4-0 .:-.· ·.·· ... ::· ...... ·.· ·.·· ... ::· . ~···· ·.· ·.:··· .·.··=······· . . / / ·. ·• / ·. /:: :: ;: ,,:: :: , :: / : __ 35 : :- 1;. ;1 • I :- ;. > •. II •• "ii ... ~ ;.' ;. . ;. I :• I ;. I ;. : 30

~··~~~,: ·. ·.· ~~· ·.·.·. ·~~· ·.·.' ··~~ .'. ·;··· ~~ ... · ... · ~~. ·.·. ~·~= =· I==~· ... ::.· ..... ':: ..... · .. ::·'.·,· .. ::.· .... ,·::.· .. '~··~:.·.·. :-25

:: • .;: ....... .;: ....... -:;•"•"•"•.;: ••• •.•.-:: ••• •.·.-:: ••• ·.-:· • •, ::, :: :: I :: I :; I :: I ~ 20

,:; .. ;:.:.: ... -:: ... : .... :[ .. :·.;-·::.: ... ·.-[[ ... :.- .. ::.·:· =· . . :::.->: :::.:r ;::,,::,: ·:._C' __ ,:_J,::::,::~.r,: : ,,::d : .. /: ~ .... : .... -~ ·' · ... : ..... : .... : . r · i · r · i :· l · i · r ·- i · l · i · l · i · · 1""·r····i·.·.i"".·i·.·.i.·"'i"··1""i'"f ·.·i" .. f ...

·ii.~ i;~ ;~;- ;s-? ;~s- ;q;; ;;~ ;~ ii~ ~~ ;;~ ;;o ;~ ,·;,;, 95- ~ §5- s~ 75- 7~ 6~ 6~ 55 5-l> 45- 4o 35-. 30 l5- 20 i5' io ~ ! .

LIST OF ALL MBM'S


- +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ - I ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

6 1 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 20.36 .00 3 .43 65 RJC 24

3 4 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 19.88 .00 3 .55 75 RJC 23 3 4 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 34.68 .00 3 .62 85 RJP 23 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 3 4 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC '9. 78 .00 3 .45 64 RJC 23

7. 4 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 37.45 .00 3 .75 108 RJP 23 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

4 7 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 27.64 .oo .63 147 RJC 23

8 7 TEC T_EH 610-EB MBM 02C 15.82 .00 .45 150 RJC 23

26 7 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 8.22 .00 3 . 73 114 RJP 23 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 26 7 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 5.06 .00 3 .64 98 RJC 23

36 7 TEC TEH 610'EB MBM 03H 1.15 .00 M1 .43 133 RJP 23 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 36 7 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 42 7 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 4.21 . .00 3 .86 104 RJC 23 I

I 44 7 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM DBH 21.72 .00 1 .55 141 RJP 23 I RESULT OF .DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 44 7 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

e I 12 9 T.EC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 15.17 .00 3 .84 38 RJC 23 I


I 17 10 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 15.37 .oo 3 .72 38 RJC 23 I 17 10 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 14.09 .00 3 .52 49 RJC 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 29 10 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 14.38 .00 3 .81 40 RJC 23 I

I 53 10 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C .03 .oo M1 .46 50 RJP 23 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY' RESOLUTION 53 10 - - - - · - - - - : - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - : - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - , - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 4 13 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 5.10 .00 3 .82 35 RJC 23 IRESULT·OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION


I ·8 13 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM DBH 20.94 .oo 1 2.76 7 RJP 23 IRESULT_OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 8 13 ----------------------------------------~-------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 10 13 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 7.29 ._00 3 .62 36 RJC 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 24 13 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 9.77 .00 .44 153 RJC 23 I 1----

I I 28 13 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 3.18 .00 3 .72 94 RJP 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I

+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+:- -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - .. - - - - - .. - -+

IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +- - - -+- .. - -+- - -+- - -+- - .... - -+- .. -+- - -+- - - .. - - - -+- - .. - - - - -+- - - -+- - - .... -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - .. - - - - .. - - .. - - - - - - - ...... - - ...... - - - - - - • - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

PAGE TUBES 21

LIST OF ALL MBM'S

Palisades Unit 1 . CPAL1 ·B/2530 INSPECTION: Nov-96 1-Jun-97 10:55

+----+----+---+~--+------+---+---+--------+--------+-.---+------+---+----+----+------------------------~-------~----~------------+

IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+~--+------+---+---+-~-----~+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

30 13 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 4.2B .00 3 . 71 63 RJC 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 32 13 TEC TEH. 610-EB MBM 04H 31.78 .oo 3 .78 102 RJC 23 I

I 42 13 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 34.09 .oo 3 .50 88 RJC 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 42 13 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H . 33.00 . oo 3 .36 69 RJC . 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

·1

44 13 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 37 .14 .oo 3 .38 79 RJP 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 44 13 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 14.85 .oo 3 .47 108. RJP 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 54 13 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 12.10 .oo 3 .63 113 RJP 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 64 13 TEC TEH '610-EB MBM 01H 29.13 .oo 3 .36 105 RJC 23 I

I 68 13 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 17.12 .oo 3 .59 86 RJC 23 1 ·

I 70 13 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 19.01 .oo 3 1 .39 113 RJC 23 I

I 3 16 DBH TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 11.56 .oo 3 .59 55 RJC 23 I .3. 16 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 11.50 .oo 3 .60 59 SHT 24 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I

I I 35 16 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 8.61 .oo 3 .60 94 RJC 23 !RESULT OF.DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I

e 35 16 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H -3.50 .oo 3 .50 101 RJC 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION. I 35 16 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H -4.49. .oo 3 .49 66 RJC 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY ~ESOLUTION I

I 1. 22 19 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 18.98 .oo 3 .29 79 .RJC 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I

I I 40 19 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H . 14.15 .oo .31 153 RJC 23 I I

I I 56 19 T~C TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 10.86 .oo 3 .58 70 .RJC 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 56 19 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 10.13 .oo 3 .69 85 RJC 23 I I

I I 58 19.TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06C 4.44 .oo 1· . 19 116 RJC 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I

I I 62 19 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS5 9.80 .oo 1 2.41 8 l'!JP 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

62 19 ····---·-·-··-··--··-···--·······--··············:·--·······------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 62 19 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS5 14.02 .oo 1 2.02 10 RJP 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

62 19 · · · · · · · · - · · · · · - · · - · · · · · - · · - · · - - · · · · · · · - - ~· · - · - - - - - · · · · · · · · - ·:······I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I

70 19 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 29.20 .oo 3 .66 107"RJC 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

70 19 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 29.68 .oo 3 .56 105 RJC 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY·RESOLUTION

I 78 19 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 25.69 .oo 3 .65 40 RJC 23 I

I 38 . 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 13.42 .oo .32 132 RJP 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

38 21 ······-······-·--···-····-···-·-······-----···········-·········-·IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 38 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 27.16 .oo ·3 .71 76 RJC 23 I

+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------~

PAGE 2 TUBES 38

LIST OF ALL MBM'S


+- - - -+-·- - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----t---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

38 21 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 33.69 .00 3 .96 102 RJP 23 !RESULT.OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I

5 22 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 17. 77 .00 3 .88 78 RJP 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 5 22 TEC TEH S10-EB MBM 01C 17.02 .00 3 1. 36 92 RJP 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 17 22 TEC TEH 610;EB MBM 03C 12.54 .00 3 .43 78 RJC 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 29 . 22 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 20.33 .00 1 1.17 8 RJP 23 l.RESUL T OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 29 22 -------------····---------------------------------------------····IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 33 22 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 27.00 .00 3 .65 113 RJP 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 69 22 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 17.44 .00 3 .78 94 RJC 23 I 69 22 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 18.37 .00 3 .60 88 RJC 23 I

I 2 25 TEC TEH 590-EB MBM TSH 23.97 .00 .27 133 RJP 22 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 18 25 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 5.87 .00 3 .40 56 RJC 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 24 25 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 17.88 .od 3 .44 80 RJP 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 38 25 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 32.15 .00 3 .51 ·105 RJC 17 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I

e 42 25 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 22.18 .00 1 .23 90 SHT 17 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 42 25 ------------------·····-·············--··············---------~---!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 68 25 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 24.12 .00 .38 142 RJC 17 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 84 25 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 25.57 .00 .45· 149 RJC 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 84 25 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM ·o6H 3.86 .00 . 71 151 RJC 23 !RESULT OF qISCREPANCY RESOLUTION


I 87 28 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 21.73 .00 3 .64' 46 RJC 16. !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 95 28 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS2 25:06 .00 1 .37 21 RJP 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

95 28 -----------------------------------------------------············-IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 2 31 TEC TEH 590-EB MBM 05H 30.37 .00 3 1.49 110 RJP 22 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION·

I 34 31 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 24.48 .00 .53 156 RJC 15 I

I 40 31 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 12.30 .00 .71 155 RJC 15 I

I 64 31 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 9.23 .00 3 .41 63 RJC 16 !RESULT.OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

64 31 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS3 11.09 .00 3 .54 73 RJC 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 78 31 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 10.33 .. oo .46 49 RJP 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION


+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

PAGE 3 TUBES 58

LIST OF ALL MBM'S


+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ jROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+----~---+----+------+---+----+----+---------------------------------------------~----+

7g 31 ···································································!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

86 31 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 34.08 .oo 3 I


I 92 31 TEC . TEH 610 -EB MBM 04C 14. 12 . 00 1 . 52 44 RJP 16 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 92 31 ·····················-········-·····························-·····IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 98 31 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM_02H 24.56 .oo 3 .63 103 RJC 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 100 . 31 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 10.18 .oo 3 .50 89 RJC 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 102 31 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 7.70 .oo .41 25 RJP 23 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 1 02 31 - - - - - - · · -. - - · · - · · · · - - - · · · - · · · · · - · · · · · · · · · · · · ··· · · - · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · I HISTORY REV! EW PERFORMED


I 29 34 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 32.43 .oo 3 .56 108 RJC 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 33 · 34 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 37.13 .oo .31.138 RJC 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 69 .34 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM OSC -1.16 .oo .32 134 RJP 16 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 69 34 ·:······-··:·······-··-···········.·····-···-'·:··········-·······-·IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 69 34 TEC TEH 610 -EB MBM 04C 1. 82 . 00 1 . 63 156 RJP 16 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 69 34 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - · - - - - - · · · · · - - · · · · · · · - · · · · ·: · - · · · · · · - · - · · · · · · - ····I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 81 34 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 9.87 .00 .59 153 RJC 16 I


I 4 37 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 14.98 .oo 3 1.26 109 RJP 15 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 4 37 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 13.25 .00 3 . 58 104 RJC 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 26 37 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS4 10.64 .oo 1 .39 47 RJP 15 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 26 37 -········--··-·····-··-·.···--····································-JHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 30 37 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 25.54 .oo 3 .63 46 RJC 15 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

30 37 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 10.92 .00 3 .62 86 RJC 15 I I

60 37 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 23.39 .oo 3 .43 80 RJC 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 76 37 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM OSC 21.94 .oo 3 .76 74 RJC 16 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION


80 37 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06C 1.51 .oo 3 .80 58 RJC 16 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 106 37 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS4 7 .11 .oo 1 .51 25 RJP 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

106 37 ······-···········---·-······-------·························-····IHISTORY REVIEW" PERFORMED 106 37 TEC_TEH 610-EB MBM VS4 11.36 .oo .87 176 RJP 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

--1--~

I I

+----+----+---+--.-+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+----------------------~----~----------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+-----~+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

PAGE 4 TUBES 76

LIST OF ALL MBM'S

Palisades unit 1 CPAL1-8/2530 INSPECTION: Nov-96 1-Jun-97 10:55

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------.------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+---·-+--------------------------.------------------------+

106 37 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 106 37 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS4 12.75 .00 1 .28 54 RJP 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 106 37 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 108 37 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 13.57 .00 .44 25 RJP 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 108 37 ------------------------------------------------------------------ HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 108 37 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 4.82 .00 3 . 1.01 106 RJC 16

114 37 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 29.57 .00 .31 160 RJC 16

3 40 DBH TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 19.16 .00 3 .56 73 RJC 23 3 40 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 19.12 .00 3 .59 83 RJC 24

15 40 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 14.19 .00 3 .44 83 RJC 15 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

35 40 TEC TEH 610-EB. MBM 03C 6.62 .00 .32 143 RJC 15

51 40 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 18.64 .00 3 .71 100 RJC 15

42 41 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 12.82 .00 .29 123 RJC 15

107 42 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 3.85 .00 3 .56 87 RJC 16 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

14 43 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 1.64 .00 4 2.57 106 RJP 15 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION . 14 . 43 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - : - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -· - - - - I HISTORY REV! EW PERFORMED

16 43 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 24.22 .00 3 I


I 42 43 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 16.56 .00 1 .40 23 RJP 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 42 43 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ' - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 48 43 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 20.11 .00 3 .60 112 RJC 15 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY. RESOLUTION

I 56 43 TEC.TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 19.10 .00 3 .32 84 RJC 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 70 43 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 25.86 .00 3 .59 60 RJC 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 72 43 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06C 3.62 .00 1 .16 109 RJP 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION. 72 43 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -·- - - - - - - - - - - ~ - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 88 43 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 12.29 .00 3 1 .46 99 RJC 16 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 118 43 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06C 13.36 .00 1 .30 107 RJP 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 118 43 ---------------------:--------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 118 43 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 4.92 .00 1 .34 42 RJP 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

· 118 · 43 - - - -.- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I

120 43 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 17.62 .00 .29 37 RJP 16 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

·-~--·----+---+---+------+---+---+-·-------+--------+-~--+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------.------------------------------------+

PAGE 5 TUBES 94

e

LIST OF ALL MBM'S


+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+---------------------------~----------------------+

!ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS +----+----+---+:--+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------~-----------------+

120 43 --------------------------------------------------------------····IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 80 45 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06H -.18 .. 00 M3 .47 101 RJP 16 _!RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION. 80 45 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - · · · - - - · · · - - - - · · - · - - - - - · · · - - - - - · · · - - - · · · · · · · · · · · · · · - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 45 46 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C -.03 .00 1 .41 121 RJP 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 45 46 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - , - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -·. - I HISTORY REV! EW PERFORMED

I 113 46 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 21.90 .00 3 .69 102 AJD 17 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION


I 12 49 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 13.29 .oo 3 . 56 · 98 RJC 15 I

76 76 76

78 78 78 78

84 84

106 106

118 118

11 11

95 95 95 95 95 9"5

95 95 95 95 95 95 95

I 49 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 5.10 .oo .30 135 BEA 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 49 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06H 41. 73 .00 1 .22 31 BEA 14 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 49 ------------------------------------------------------------------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 49 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06H 16.15 .oo .25 55 BEA 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 49 ------------------------------------------------------------------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 49 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06H 15.03. .00 1 .18 53 BEA 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 49 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ - - - - - - - · · · - - - - - - - · · ·: - - - -·- - ·I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 49 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS6 8.13 · .00 1 .91 24 BEA 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 49 - : - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REV! EW PERFORMED

I 49 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 22.95 .oo .56 13 BEA 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 49 ----------------------------------~------------'.·-----------------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 49 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM DBC 4.97 .00 1 2.00 .7 BEA 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 49 ------------------------------------------------------------------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 52 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM DBH 11.41 .00 1 1.72 11 BEA 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 52 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 52 TEC TSH 610-EB MBM 03H 35.36 .oo. .15 126 BEA 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 52 .... : ................. --------------------------------------------IHISTORY. REVIEW PERFORMED 52 TEC TSH 610- EB MBM 04H -1 . 62 . 00 1 . 14 120 BEA 14 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 52 ------------------------------------------------------------------IHISTORY REVIEW· PERFORMED 52 TEC TSH 610-EB MBM VS2 20. 01 . 00 1 . 26 135 BEA 14 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 52 ----------------------------'.-------------------------------------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 52 TEC TSH 610-EB MBM 05C · 8.51 .00 1 .10 92 BEA 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 52 - - - - - -_- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ·I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 52 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM.03H 35.06 .00 3 1.00 108 SHT 17 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 52 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H -1.55 .00 3 .88 89 AJD 17 I 52 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 33.68 .00 3 .47 90 SHT 17 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION S2 "TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS2 20.20 .00 1 .21 115 SHT 17 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 52 ------------------------------------------------------------------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL. CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

PAGE 6 TUBES 106

LIST OF ALL MBM'S


+----+----+--~+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

95 52 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05C 8.34 .00 3 .64 78 AJD 17

107 52 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 6.05 .00 1 .10 88 BEA 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 107 52 -·---·----------·-·------···------····--··---···~---·-----···----·IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 16 55 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 29.49 .00 1 .12 75 BEA 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 16 .55 ····---------------··------···-·--------···-----------······-·····IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

50 55 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 4.45

68 55 TEC TEH 610-EB.MBM 05C 4.20

.00 3

.00

I 1.19 109 AJW 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I .21 171 AJW 14 I

I ·55 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 15.06 .00 1 .73 131 BEA 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 55 ---------···'------------·---------------··---------·-------------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 55 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 33.05 .00 1 .13 85 BEA 14 !RESULT OF DISCREf'ANCY RESOLUTION 55 ··--·---·--------·------··-----··---------··--------·-----·-------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 55 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM DBH 9.40 .00 1.27 16 BEA 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 55 -----··--------------------------·------'.·--------------------···-!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 55 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H . 8.64 .00 1 .19 21 BEA 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 55 ---··-----·---------·----···---------··--·-----··-·-·-----·---'---IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 55 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 7.66 .00 1 .27 43 BEA 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 55 - · · - - - - · · - - - -.- - - - - - - - - - · - - - - - - - - - · · · - - - - - - - · - - - - - · - - - · - - - · - - - - · - · - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 55 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 26.18 .00 1 .20 46 BEA 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 55 · - · - - - - - · · - - - - - - - · - - - - - - - - - - - - - · · - - - - - - - - - - · - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -.- · - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 55 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 11.43 .00 1 .22 24 BEA 14 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 55 - - · - - - · - - - - - - - - -. · - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - · · · · · - - - - - - - - - - - - - · - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 58 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TEC 26.30 .00 1 . .16 46 .BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 58 -·------·--------·-------------·-·----·-----·-·--------·----------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

1 . 58 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 21.44 .00 3 . 13 124 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 58 - - · · - - · - - - - - - - - · - - - - - - - -.- - - · - - - - : - - - - - - - - - · - - - - - - - · · · - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I ·59 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM .02H 30.06 .00 1 .25 45 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 58 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - · - - ; - - - - - - - · - - · - - - - - · - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 58 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05C 7.56 .00 1 .21 123 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 58. ·--------------------------------------------·-···----------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 58 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 35.00 .00 1 .20 143 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 58 · - - - · - -.- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - · - - - · - - - · - · - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 58 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 11.20 .00 .15 31 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY'RESOLUTION SB ····-----·-------------·--------·---···----··-----------·------·-·IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 58 TEC · TEH 610-EB MBM 06C 5. 98 . 00 1 . 11 74 BEA 13 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 58 - - - - - · · - - - - - - - - - -· - - - - - - · - - - - - - · · - - - - - - - - - · · - - - · - - - - - - - - · - - - - · - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ JROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - ·i:- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - • - -+

PAGE 7 TUBES 120

e

LIST OF ALL MBM'S


+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+-------7------------------------------------------+

65 58 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 2.45 .oo 3 .85 107 AJW 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 69 58 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 16. 60 . 00 1 . 22 49 BEA 13 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 69 58 ,------------'----------------------------------------------------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 125 58 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05C 13.01 .OO 1 .29 134 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 125 58 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

14 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 14 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C

25.02 1.75

.oo 1

.oo 3

I .40 151 AJD 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

1.41 116 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 18 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 27.92 .00 1 .34 147 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 18 61 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 20 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 9.36 .oo .29 127 BEA 13 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION


36 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 34.58 .00 .85 155 BEA 13 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION


42 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 10.00 .00 .51 146 BEA 13 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

48 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C -1.62 .oo .41 156 BEA 13 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 48 61 -----------------------------------------------------.------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 48 61· TEC TcH 610-EB MBM TSC 14.35 .oo 3 1.06 117 AJW 13 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

52 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 29.95 .oo .33 142 BEA 13 RESULT OF Dr°SCREPANCY RESOLUTION

70 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 29.94 .00 1 .20 139 BEA 13 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 70 61 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ' - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY. REVIEW PERFORMED

I 76 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 29.31 .00 1 .29 32 BEA 13 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 76 61 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~I HISTORY REVIEW PERFO.RMED

78 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 13.46 .oo

84 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 37.53 .oo 3


I 1.72 119 AJW 13 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 92 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS2 25.01 .00 1 .26 82 SHT 17 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 92 61 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 94 61- TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 07H 6.21 .00 1 .62 10 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 94 . 61 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY .REVIEW PERFORMED

I 102 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 9.69 .oo .09 92 BEA 13 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 102 61 - - - - - - -·- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - • - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+· - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

!ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS I +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

PAGE 8 TUBES 137

LIST OF ALL MBM'S


+-~--+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +---;+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

104 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 28.53 .oo 1 .16 27 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 104 61 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - · · · - - - - - - - · · · · · · · - - - - - - - - - - · · - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ···I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 104 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 6.35 .oo 1 .22 52 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 104 61 - - - - - - - - - - - -·. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - · · · · · · - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REV! EW PERFORMED 104 61 TEC. TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 10.98 .00 1 .20 59 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 104 61 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - · · · · · - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 110 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 14.98 .oo 1 .14 55 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 110 61 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - · · - - - - - - - - - - - · - I HISTORY REVIEW· PERFORMED

I 126 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 35.87 .00 1 .37 37 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

126 61 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - .· - - - - - - - - - - - - - · · · · - - - - - - - - - - · - - · · · - - - - - - - ·: · · · - I HISTORY REV! EW PERFORMED 126 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 23.79 .oo .32 56 BEA 13 I RESULT OF .DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 126 61 ---------------···················································IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 126 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 24.44 .oo 1 .15 51 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

126 61 ·---------------------·······:·····································IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 126 61 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM DBC 6.56 .00 .11 46 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 126 61 --···················: ... , ..... :-·····--··························IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 130 61 TEC TEH· 610-EB MBM 03H 28. 77 .oo . 32 122 A.JW 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 130 . 61 TSH TSH 610-ZP TRA TSH .24 .00 4 2.55 199 BEA 32 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RES9LUTION

I ·83 64 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 13.62 .oo 3 .79 60 SHT 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

e 83 64 TEC TEH 61o:EB MBM 05H 19.36 .00 3 .87 ·82 A.JO 12 !RESULT OF· DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 87 64 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 21.22 .oo 3 . 47 77 SHT 12 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION .

87 64 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 18.51 .00 3 .46 88 SHT 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 50 67.TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05C 15.30 .oo 3 .95 98 A.JD 12 I

I 60 67 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 22.77 .oo 3 .73 95 SHT 12 ·1 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

60 67 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 12.43 .oo .34 141 A.JD 12 !HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED


I 68 67 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 29. Tt .oo 3 .72 83 A.JD 12 I

I 98 67 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 18.60 .00 3 .65 85 A.JD 12 I RESULT .OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

98 67 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06C 25.28 .oo 3 .40 88 SHT 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 104 67 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS6 15.14 .oo .9Z 33 SHT 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

104 67 - - - - - - - - .... : - - - - - - - - - -.· - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - · · · · I HISTORY REV! EW PERFORMED. I

112 67 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 13.32 .oo 3 .76 84 A.JO 12 I I I I

130 67 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 21.39 .oo 3 .58 71 SHT 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 130 67 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 7.21 .oo .17 . 89 A.JD 12 !HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I

I I +----+----+---+-~·-+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+----------------------:·--------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS

+----+----+---+;--+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

PAGE 9 TUBES 151

LIST OF ALL MBM'S


+----+----+---+.---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------·------------------------+ jROW COL CEB GEE PROBE IND LOG INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS +----+----*---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------7-----------------------+

132 67 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 12.47 .00 3 .69 42 SHT 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 81 70 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C · 23.13 .00 .44 155 AJD 12 !HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 129 70 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05C 10.97 .00 3 1.34 100 AJD 12 I 129 70 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05C 13.86 .00 3 .91 60 AJD 12 I 129 70 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 25.20 .00 3 .63 65 SHT 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

" 129 70 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C -1. 78 .00 3 1.35 89 AJD 12 I I

64. 71 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06C 20.12 .00 1 .90 151 WJS 12 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 64 71 -- · · - · -- · - · · · --- · · --- · -- · - · - · · · · · · · · · -· -· · · · · · · · · · · -- · · · · · · · · · · · · - I HISTORY REV! EW PERFORMED

I 137 72 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 34.25 .oo 3 1.11 99 SHT 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION



I 60 73 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 18.14 .oo 3 .81 104 AJD 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 82 73 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 3.75 .oo .33 136 AJD 12 !HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 122 73 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 22.19 .oo 3 .88 74 AJD 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

e I 126 73 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H -1.84 .oo 3 .79 83 AJD 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 59 76 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C -7.48 .oo 3 .40 103 SHT 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 107 76 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 9.61 .oo 3 .63 110 SHT 12. !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

107 76 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 23.58 .oo 3 .52 112 SHT 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION.

107 76 TEC .TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 29.95 .oo 3 .46 96 SHT 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

107 76 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06C 24.78 .oo 3 .41 103 SHT 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 62 79 TEC'TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 9.94 .oo 3 1.21 92 SHT 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 72 79 .TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 16.42 .oo 1 .38 44 SHT 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

72 79 - ·.- · - · · - .. -- · -- - - · -- · - · · -- -- - - · - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - · · · - - - - · - - - - - - · - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I

76 79 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 19.36 .oo 3 .38 94 SHT 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANC~ RESOLUTION

I 90 79 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 33.18 .oo 3 .49 79.SHT 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 1. . 102 79 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 25.01 .00 3 .41 90 SHT 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I

I I 104 79 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 11.19 .oo 3 .64 73 SHT 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I

I I 126 79 TEC TEH .610-EB MBM 06C 8.25 .oo 1 .56 13 SHT 1.0 jRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 126 .79 - - - - ... - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - · - - - · - · - - - - - -·- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - · - - · - · - - - - ·····I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I

+--~-+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB GEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

PAGE 10 TUBES 170

e

LIST OF ALL MBM'S


+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+~-----+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+----------------------:---------------------------+

·I I I I

126 79 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 7.69 .00 1 .47 39 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 126 79 ----------------------------------------------------------·-···---IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED


I 79 84 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS4 11 .43 .00 1 .61 152 SHT 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 79 84 - - - - - - - - : - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - • - - - - - - - - -·. - - - - - - - - - -.- - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 79 84 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS4 4.44 .00 3 .34 85 SHT 11 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY .RESOLUTION

I 56 85 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 22.23 .00 3 .55 95 AJD 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

56 85 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 9.12 .00 3 .43 71 SHT 12 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 58 85.TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 12.04 .00 3 .89 41 SHT 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 62 85 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C -1.88 .00 3 .33 115 AJD 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 72 85 TEC TEH 610-EB RBD AJD 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

72 85 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06H· 20.54 .00 .51 146 AJD 12 !HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 74 85 TEC TEH .610-EB MBM TSH 7.66 .00 3 .59 103 SHT 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 78 · 85 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 18.20 .00 3 .73 60.SHl 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

78 85 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 19.73 .00 3 .62 71 SHT 11 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 88 85 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 35.08 .00 1 .64 17 RJP 4· I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION ·

.88 85 -----------------:·-----------------------------------------------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 126 85 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 11.95 .00 3 1.02 91 RJC 4 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 59 88 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 35.24 .00 3 .67 109 AJD 12 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 99 88 TSH TSH 610-ZP MBM TSH 1.43 .00 4 .. 70 58 SHT 30 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

131 88 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS2 22.86 .00 1.56 164 RJC 3

131 ·99 TEC TEH MO-EB MBM 02C 15.22 .00 1 .30 34 RJP 3 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION


56 91 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06H 3.14 .00 .61 146 AJD 12 HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

64 91 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 19.86 .00 3 1.24 99 AJD 12

70 91 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C -5.42 .00 3 .78 . 98 SHT 12 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

88 91 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 34.59 .00 1.25 107 RJP· 3 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

88 91 -------------------------------------------------------.-----------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I

126 91 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS7 15.88 .00 1 1.54 18 RJP 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

126 91 - - - -·~ - - - ....... - - - - -.- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -·-I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+-: __________ ~-------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS

+----+----~---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

PAGE 11 TUBES 189

e

LIST OF ALL MBM'S


+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+-------------------------~------------------------+

!ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS +----+----+--~+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

132

121. 121 121

77

81

137

54 54

54

54

54

54

60 60

64

64

76 76

91 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 07C 19. 72 .oo 3 .72 88 RJP 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 92 TEC TEH 610'-EB MBM TSH 22.23 .oo 1.79 135 MAR 3 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 92 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 8.24 .oo .23 130 RJC 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 92 TSH 02H 620-ZC MBM TSH 22.51 .oo 4 2.35 100 MAR 42 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 94 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 17.20 . .oo 3 .44 111 SHT 12 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 94 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 21.07 .oo .32 128 A.JD 12 !HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 94 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 31. 71 .oo .38 153 RJP 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 97 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 17. 71 .oo 3 .50 36 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 97 ----------------------------------,-------------------------------IHISTOR~ REVIEW PERFORMED 97 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06H 28.09 .00 3 .89 41 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 97 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REV! EW PERFORMED 97 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 22. 72 . 00 1 . 12 70 BEA 13 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 97 - - -· - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REV! EW PERFORMED

I 97 TEC TEH 610-EB M.BM 04H 17. 27 . 00 3 . 32 71 BEA 13 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION ·97 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - , - - - - - - - - - - - - - _-_ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 97 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 19.93 .oo .22 52 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 97 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 97 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 19.63 .00 1 .21. 48 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

97 ------------------------------------:- .. --------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I

88 97 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 23.63 .oo 3 2.14 116 BEA !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 1 I 88 97 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C - .60 .oo . 79 167 A.JW

I 47 98 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 8.15 .00 1 .08 52 BEA 13 !RESULT o·F DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 4 7 98 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - '. -·. - - - - I HISTORY REV! EW PERFORMED 47 98 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 7.05 .00 1 .08 80 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 47 98 --'··-------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 47 .98 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 4.65 .00 1 .19 13 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 47 98 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 51 100 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 8.02 .oo .12 142 BEA 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 51 100 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -·- - - - -·. - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 11 100 TEC TEH.610-EB MBM 06C 15.24 .oo 3 1.17 89 SHT 6 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 26 103 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H . 10.14 .oo 3 .78 46 RJC 24 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 28 103 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 12.56 .00 3 .51 91 RJC 24 I 28 103 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 11.18 .oo 3 .60 104 RJC

' 24 I

+----+---.-+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LDC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+---------------~----------------------------------+

· PAGE 12 TUBES 203

e

LIST OF ALL MBM'S


+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+------.:+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----~----+-------p·-----------------------------------------+

28 103 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 28 103 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H

.84 103 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H

100 103 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C

32.64 18.99

23.14

25.50

.oo 3

.oo 3

.oo

.oo

.66 99 SHT 24 !RESULT OF DIS~REPANCY RESOLUTION

.69 . 97 SHT 24 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I .44 155 RJC 3 I


· 1 00 103 · · · · · · · · · · · - · · · · - · · · - · · · · · · - - · · · .· · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 114 103 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 17.56 .00 1 .21 71 BEA ·.1 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 114 103 - - - · · _. · · • - - - - - - - - · · · · · · - · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · ·······I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 41 106 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 21.19 .00 3 1.02 107 A.JD 18 !RESULT .OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 41 106 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 15.25 .00 1 .36 134 SHT 18 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 41 106 ·······------·-·················-···-·-···························IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 47 106 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 12.69 .00 1 .25 143 SHT 18 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 47 106 ···················-··························'--············--···IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 69 106 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 28.37 .00 3 1.32 71 A.JD 6 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 81 106 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM VS3 4.28 .oo 3 .84 88 A.JD 6 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 24 109 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 1.96 .oo .35 98 SHT 24 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 24 109 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - · - · · - - - - - · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · - · · · · · · · · · · · · · ·······I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 24 109 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 30.58 .oo 3 . 72. 91 A.JD 24 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 26 109 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 3 .. 16 .oo 3 .68 61 SHT 24 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 32 109 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 25.68 .oo 1 .56 29 SHT 24 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 32 1 09 - : - - - - - - - -·. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - · · I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 40 109 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 30.01 .oo 3 .50 34 A.JD 18 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESo'LUTION 40 109 TEC.TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 31 :82 .oo 3 .47 40 SHT 18 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 44 109 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 23.90 .oo 3 .78 114 A.JD 18 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 62 109 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 8.04 .00 3 1.05 98 SHT 6 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

62 109 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 21.46 .oo 3 .91 83 A.JD 6 I 62 109 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 20.18 .oo 3 .88 70 A.JD 6 I

I 76 109 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 15.13 .oo 3 1.21 81 A.JD 6 I 76 109 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 10.67 .oo 3 .95 77 A.JD 6 I

I 126 109 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 17.35 .oo 1 .25 44 BEA 2 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

126 109 -·································································IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I

130 109 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 11 .16 .00 1 .35 50 BEA 2 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 130 109. - - - - - - - - . - . - .... - - - - - - - - - - - - - · · · · · · · · · ·. - - - - · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · ·······I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEJ COMMENTS +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

PAGE 13 TUBES 219

LIST OF ALL MBM'S


+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+----~---+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEJ COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ . .

130 109 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 6.13 .00 .36 38 BEA 2 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 130 1 09 - - · · - - - - - · · · - - - - · · - - - - · · - - - - - · · · - - - - · · - - - - - - - · - · · · · · · · · - - - - - - · · · · · J HISTORY REV! EW PERFORMED 130 109 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 07C 15.03 .00 1 .29 47 BEA 2 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 130 109 - - - - - - - - - - - - , - - - - - - - - - - - - - · - - - - - · · · · - · · · - - - - - - - - - - - - - - · · · - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 35 112 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 10.59 .00 3 .85 96 AJD 24 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 107 112 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 30.19 .00 .48 151 RJC 3 I

I 123 112 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 07H 19.45 .00 .59 133 RJP 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 6 115 DBH TEH 610-EB MBM 04H .00 .00 1 .15 112 BEA 19 JRESULT OF.DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

6 115 --------··········-··················---··························JHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 6 115 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 19.07 .00 .15 111 BEA 20 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION ·

I 16 115 ·TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 21 .11 .00 3 .52 63 SHT 24 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 40 115 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 23.36 .00 3 .80 89 SHT 6 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION


I 82 115 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05C 13.99 .00 3 ;73 66 SHT 6 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I

e 124 115 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 22.23 .00 .23 .99 RJP 3 !RESULT OF-DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

124 11 5 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -. - - - - - - - - - - - - -·_ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REV! EW PERFORMED

I 93 118 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 4.19 .OD 1 .26 43 RJP 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

93 11 & - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ .- • I HISTORY REV! EW PERFORMED

I 105 118 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 6. 76 .00 3 .42 89 RJC 3 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 113 118 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 22.42 .00 .85 162 RJC 3 I

I 62. 121 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 4.67 .00 3 .87 62 SHT 6 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 84 121 TEC.TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 20.90 . 00 3 . .99 100 AJD 6 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 88 121 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 21.00 .00 . 71 156 RJC 4 I 88 121 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 3.85 .00 .30 149 RJP 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 90 121 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 4.17 .oo 3 .68 90 SHT 10 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

90 . 121 TEC TEH 610-fB MBM 03C 22.15 .00 3 .66 87 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 96 121 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 6.57 .oo. 1 .26 89 RJP 4 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION.

96 121 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ - - - - - - - - - - - - - ·. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REV! EW PERFORMED 96 121 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 6.38 .00 1 .30 32 RJP 4 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

96 121 -·. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - · - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - · J HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I

+----+----+---+-~·-+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+----------------------~---------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEJ COMMENTS

+----+----+---+~--+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+-----------~--------------------------------------+

PAGE 14 TUBES 237

LIST OF ALL MBM'S

Palisades Uhit 1 CPAL1 -B/2530 INSPECTION: Nov-96 1-Jun-97 10:55

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------~-----------------------+


106 121 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 13.09 .oo .25 79 RJP 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 106 121 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 108 121 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 17.35 .oo 1 .23 64 RJP 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 108 121 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 110 121 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 5.06 .oo 3 .84 76 RJC 17 I 110 121 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06H 16.93 .oo 3 1.04 59 RJC 17 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 118 121 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 6.70 .oo .40 159 RJC 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 27 124 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 11 .55 .oo 3 . 77 SB SHT 6 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION


I 14 127 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 35.35 .oo 3 . 71 102 A.JD 6 I 14· 127 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 24.41 .oo 3 .74 67 SHT 6 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 30 127 TEC TEH 610-EB. MBM 01H 22.98 .oo 3 3.09 117 SHT 6 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 64 127 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 6.91 .oo 3 .66 84 SHT 5 !RESULT OF.DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 76 127 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 29.48 .oo· 3 .62 107 RJC 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

e I ·96 127 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H .13.46 .00 3 1. 70 117 SHT 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 102 127 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM. TSH 9.78 .oo 3 .55 91 RJC 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

102 127 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 6-44 .oo ·3 . 81 105 SHT 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 17 130 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 36.15 .oo 3 .65 94 A.JD 7 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION .

I 8 133 TEC TEH 610-EB· MBM 01H 4.46 .oo 3 .68 01 A.Jo 7 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 30 133 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 3.07 .oo 3 .48 103 A.JD 7 I 30 133 TEC .TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 23.79 .oo 3 .67 105 A.JD 7 I 30 133 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 3.91 .00 3 .82 91 A.JD 7 I 30 133 TEC TEH·610-EB MBM 03C 4.48 .oo 3 .72 58 A.JD 7 I 30 133 TEC TEH 610-EB.MBM 03C 7 .12· .oo 3 1.29 91 A.JD 7 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

30 133 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC 10.84 .oo 3 .63 58 BEA 7 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 32 133 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 22.46 .00 3 .55 97 BEA 7 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

32 133 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -,- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I

50 133 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 29.10 .oo .35 8 A.JD 7 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I . 58 133 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H - .80 .oo M1 .57 147 SHT 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

58 133 ----------------------------------------------------------------c-IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I

+--£·+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+--.-+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

PAGE 15 TUBES 255

e.

e·

LIST OF ALL MBM'S



62 133 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 6.09 .oo 3

64 133 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 13.83 .oo 3

98 133 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 13.83 .00 3

.96 81 SHT

.66 91 SHT

.51 93 SHT




I 3 .136 TEC TEH 590-EB MBM 02C 2.41 .00 1 .12 122 BEA 21 !RESULT.OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 3 136 - - - - - - : - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 15 136 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 33.B3 .00 3 .80 93 A.JD 7 I 15 136 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 13.01 .00 3 1.21 107 A.JD 7 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION


71 136 TEC.TEH 610-EB MBM TSH

4 139 DBH TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 4 139 DBH TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 4 139 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 4 139· TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H

20 1~9 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSC




18.17

21.92

21.78 20.32 21.76 20.27

5.16

8.18.

2.78

22.76

62 139 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 19. 71 62 139 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06H 12.18

70 139 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 8.24

82 143 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H. 5.41

16 145 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 2.45

.oo 3

.oo 3

.oo 3

.oo 3

.oo

.00

.oo 3

.oo

.oo 3

.oo

.oo 3

.oo 3

.oo 3

.00 3

.oo 3

2.56 120 SHT

.48 86 SHT



I 1.28 112 A.JD 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

.98 107 A.JD 19 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

. 40 151 BEA 20 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY: RESOLUTION .

.28 155 BEA 20 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

4.04 109 A.JD 7 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

. 82 170 A.JD

.93 105 A.JO

1.22. 158 A.JO

.66 73 SHT ·.92 80 A.JD

.57 69 A.JD

1.01 102 AJW

1.22 101 BEA





I 5 I




I 38 145 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 1.29 .00 3 4.66 106 AJW 8 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 52 145 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 22.42 .00 3 1.18 ·118 BEA 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 52 145 -------------------------------------_.·---------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

56 145 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03C 33.00 .00

64 145 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05C 16.03 .00 3

. 29 110 BEA

1.54 112 AJW

I 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOL~TION


I +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------~--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+

PAGE 16 TUBES 275

LIST OF ALL MBM'S

Palisades Unit 1 CPAL 1 -B/2530 INSPECTION: Nov-96 1-Jun-97 10:55

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+----------------------------------------------~---+

80 145 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 18.32 .OO 3 2.00 98 BEA 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 80 145 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - · - - - - - - - · - - - - - - - · · - - - - - - - - · - - - - - - - - · - - - - - - I HISTORY REV! EW PERFORMED 80 145 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 9.00 .00 3 1 .. 30 88 BEA 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 80 145 ------------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

32 151 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 03H 35.83 .oo . 32 87 RJP I


I 40 151 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 13. 38 . 00 1 . 19 60 RJP 9 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 40 151 -----------------------------------------'--------------.----------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 50 151 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 05H 13.76 .00 1 .23 125 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 50 1 51 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ - : · - - - - - - - - - - -·- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - · - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 64 151 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM OBH 11.95 .oo 3 1.08 55 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 45 154 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04C 14.59 .oo 3 1 .06 109 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 4 157 DBH TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 19.60 .oo 3 . 72 112 A.JO 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 4 157 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 04H 18.75. .oo . 10 133 BEA 20 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 14 157 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02H 1.30 .oo 3 1.06 116 SHT 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 30 157 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 36.60 .00 1 . 71 151 SHT 10 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 30 157. -------·----------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I 54 157 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 06C 6.19 .oo .42 27 SHT· 10 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION


I 3 160 TEC TEH 590-EB MBM 01C -1.64 .00 1 .27 19 BEA 21 !RESULT Of DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

· 3 1 60 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

I· 15 160 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 14.59 .oo 3 .62 114 A.JO 18 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 12 163 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM TSH 16.78 .00 1 .20 66 SHT ·18 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 12 163 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -. - - - - - - - - - - - - - , - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 12 163 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 36.38 .00 3 1.26 109 SHT 18 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 12 163 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 30.97 .00 3 .45 94 A.JO 18 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 12 163 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 36.23 .00 3 .48 63 SHT 18 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY.RESOLUTION 12 163 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 31.33 .00 3 .44 105 SHT 18 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 12 163 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01C 36.15 .00 3 .48 63 SHT 18 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RES_OLUTION

I 16 163 TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 01H 1.56 .00 .14 135 A.JO 18 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 16 163 TEC TEH·610-EB MBM OBC -3.79 .00· 1 1.02 138 SHT 18 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 16 163 ---··-·-----------------------------------------------------------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 16 163. TEC TEH 610-EB MBM 02C 2.06 .oo 1.02 148·AJD 18 !HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED

+----+~---+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--~-----+----+~-----+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I.ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ PAGE 17 TOTAL TUBES 288

LIST OF ALL TRA'S


+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+-----------------------~--------------------------+


128 61 TSH TSH 610-ZP TRA TSH .08 .oo 4 2.53 201 BEA 32 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 130 61 TSH TSH 610-ZP TRA TSH .24 .oo 4 2.55 199 BEA 32 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 70 151 TSH TSH 610-ZP TRA TSH .17 .oo 4 1. 50 205 MAR 41 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

+----+~---+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPEI COMMENTS

+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ PAGE TOTAL TUBES 3

LIST OF AL DENTS


+----+----+-~-+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+--------------------------------------------------+ !ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----+-------------------------------------------:------+

6 1 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT TSH

8 1 TEC TEH 61 0.- EB ONT TSH

102 37 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT 06H










95 124 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS2 95· 124 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS2 95 124 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS2 95 124 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4 95 124 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT VS4

119 124 TEC TEH 610:EB ONT. 02H



69 134 TEC TEH 610-EB ONT 04C


16.09

16.09

8.65

.44

16.05

.73

- .84

-2.12

.91

- .57

2.65

.97

.97 - . 71

-1.22 -29-95 -31.29

21.53

23.59

-1.05

-.90

--58 -1.29

.00 11.91 179 RJC 24

.00 15.59 180 RJC 23

.00 7.81 185 RJC 16

.00 M1 6.91 178 AJW 14 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

.00 M1 6.66 178 AJW 14 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

.00 M1 8.17 179 SHT 12 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

.00 M1 5.30 179 SHT 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

.00 M1 5.11 178 AJW

.00 M1 28.03 175 AJW

.00 M1 5.21 181 SHT

.00 M1 12.79 176 RJC

.00 M1 10.11 179 AJ.D

.00 M1

.00 M1

.00 M1

.oo

.oo

.oo

6.12 178 RJC 8. 32 177 RJC 5.19 177 RJC 7.35 181 RJC-7.67 180 RJC

10 .. 08 182 RJP

.00 1 21.65 182 AJD

.. oo M1 6_ 29 1 BEA

.00 M1 7.99 180 AJD

.00 M1 12.25 175 AJD

.00 M1 30.52 177 AJD

I !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I I I



I 6 I

I 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I· 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

I 7 I RESULT OF DI.SCREPANCY RESOLUTION


I 5 I


+ - - - -.+ - .:. - -+ - - - + - - - + - -.- .- - .. ~ ~ - -+ - - -+ - - - - - .. - -+ - - - - - - - -+ - - - -+ - - - - ~ -+ - - -+ - - - -+ - - - -+ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ·- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -·+

IROW .COL. CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG ANAL TAPE! COMMENTS +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - -- - - -+- - - - - -- -+-- --+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+

PAGE TOTAL TUBES 18

• • HOT lEG NDCATON DSTRBUTON

\ : 63 ·10% TO 19% INDICATION

0 : ~ 38~ i-8 3~~ lN8:8!Tl8N / : 184 MANUFACTURERS BUFF MARK

Palisades Unit 1 CPL - B SERIES 2530 ~ : 309 PLUGGED TUBE * 25 STAY ROD

. 11-24-1996 11:12 HRS. SUPERTUBIN

" .

·• • COlD lEG ND CAT ON D STR BUT ON

\

j I '1()% TO ·1q% lt'-JDICATIOt'-J 1 20% TO 29% INDICATION

119 MANUFACTURERS BUFF MARK

t1ffi Palisades Unit 1

\gJ 11-24-1996 12:36 HRS.

CPL - B SERIES 2530 IQJ : 309 PLUGGED TUBE * 25 STAY ROD

SUPERTUBIN

........ ··::-·-·.·.·::··-·._,_.. . . . 135

... -~=- ...... :: ..... ·. ~: :~ ...... -:: ... •',. "~: -~ .. ".:: >".. 130

0-: ,

0

0 : : : : : I • :: : : : :/ : : • 125 .·:·:·.·.·.·.·'.·.·.·.·.·'.·.·.·.·~·=·.·.·.·.·:·.·.·.·.·:·.·.·.·.·:·.·.·.·.·:·.·.·>. 120

00

•

00

-: -: :.=. ::, :".· :_.: •: I 00 115 -: :: . ; :: . ·. . .. :: / ::· ....

.. ···::·······;~~-·-·.·.·~~···'.·"·:~~-·-·.·.·~~·······'~:··;·····~~."·>·::._:··J.·.·~~-·-·.·.·~:.";:--... ,-----~6~ .. . .. . :- . . . . . :- :; : . :- . :- . . ·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·,1.·,·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·.·J.·.·. 100 .-: -: -: -: -: -: -: -: / -: -: < .

• • 0 • :-, • :-. :- :-. ', • 0 :- I :- :- 95 .· .· . :-' . .· . :- :- .· .· .· '" ·. 90

•••••• : : •••••••• ·.:: •••••• J :: •••••••• : : •••••••• : : • ;- •••. ;: ~ ••. ·.: •• :~ .•.•• • .• : ~ ••• • .•.• :: ••.••••. ·.: ~.: •..•.. :_ ~ ........ : ~;...... 85 . . . . . . .. . . .. . . . . /.. . ..

• : : : • J •••• ~ ~ •••••••• ~j. :· ..... ~.j .· -~ .... ~ j ........ ~ j ..... · .. ~ j .. ·;· .. · ~ j .· ..... -~~ ....... '. ~ ~ ........ ~ j ........ ~ ~ -~. -~ .. ;~ ~ ........ :~:.: ~~

: :. : : ........ ~: ·:· ..... ~: ........ ~: .· ...... ~: ....... / .. : ... ,/~: ... · .... ~= ........ ~: .. -:- ... ~: ... ;- ... ~: .... -~ .. ~: .... /' .. ~: ........ :: .... :; 70 ... • . :=. / :.: ; :=. :: , . :: :: :: :: •<: .:>· :: :: :: :: . 65 0 0 , , .' .' .' ,' I J • ' 0

0 0

"

0 0

0 0

0 0 0 60 . t:: : ( :;::: :::: ::::::: :: :: : : : : :: :c::::: ::: : :: : : : :;:;:: : : : : : :c;; ·x '::::: ::::: : : : : ::=:::::::: ::::: : . ;: : : : : : : : : : : :c::::: r::: <k== ~

:: I :: . :- :- :- :/ : •. •• I •, • 0 ', :: :,_ 45 : : : ...... <: ........ :: ........ :: ........ :: ........ =~....... . . -~~ ~ ........ ~ ~ ........ ~ ~ ... · ... ·'~ ~ ... ;- .. ;~ ~ ........ ~ ~. ~:~- 40 • • •

0

•

0

•

0 0

0 0

•, • • :- :- ~, I < , :- :- : - 35

~:-i~~'······j:· ·. ·.·.·j:·: .. ,,.·i:····;···i:· ·.·.·. ·~j-···· ·'.~~-r · ~-· .· ~ ~-· · · · · ··~ j · · ····.·~~,I.·.·· ·~j .·.··. · ,·~j · · .·. :· ·~j·:· · :~- ~~ :·.·=:··-·.·.·::········~f .·.·.·.·~j· ·.·. ·.· j~······ .·::. ·.·.:: ·:· .. : : ... · .... : : . · ... · .. :: ........ :: ..... · .· :: .· .· .... :: .· ... :-: 20

: '.;:}::::::::ii:::::::::::::::::::::::::::: i::::: :: : : '.::::. . ::: (: , : : : : i::::::,:: ii:::::::: i:::: ,: :; : ii::::::: :,i: ;:(T ~ .L ,L .L ,Ll.lr .l~ .1.r ,L ,L ,L L L "'r ""' Ar AA Ar M -.r -.. A Ar. L L L L L 1 1 L L L L r 16$"1/,o 1!7$" 1~0 1q'11<10 1})·130 1-Z.S" ii.o 11> 110 1CJl7 _100 95" '° 8:r SO 75 7o 6S- <..o S"S' s-o 4'> qo !.) 3o l5"" 2.o 1> 10 S""

9·

TECHNICAL SPECIFICATION REPORTING REQUIREMENTS

It is the intent of this special report to provide all information required to meet the NRC twelve month reporting requirements of Palisades Technical Specification 6.6.9b. The specific information required is identified below:

1. Number and extent of tubes inspected.

2.

This information is provided in the "Services Provided" section and is summarized below:

I Inspection Type I SIGA I SIGB


TTS +Point RPC, inlet 7910 1719

U-Bend +Point RPC, inlet 116 24

Location and percent of wall-thickness penetration for each indication of an imperfection.

I

This information is provided for each steam generator in the "SIG A ECT Data" and "SIG B ECT Data" sections. Both sections contain a summary listing of all percent indications identified. The percent through-wall value for each indication is listed in the "Ind" column.

3. Identification of Tubes Plugged.

There were four tubes plugged in SIG A at the·following locations:

R-128, C-105 R-34, C-51 R-1, C-54 R-116, C-125

More details concerning tube plugging in SIG A is provided in the "SIG A ECT Data" section. There were no tubes plugged in SIG B.

6.0 AQt1INISTBATIVE CONTROLS

6.5.8 Steam Generator Tybe Syrveillance Program

This program provides controls for surveillance testing of the Steam Generator (SG) tubes to ensure that the structural integrity of this portion of the Primary Coolant System (PCS) is maintained. The program shall contain controls to ensure:

a. Steam Generator Tybe Sample Selection and Inspection

The inservice inspection may be limited to one SG on a rotating schedule encompassing 6% of the tubes if the results of previous inspections indicate that both SGs are performing in a like manner.· If the operating conditions in one SG are found to be more severe than those in the other SG, the sample sequence shall be modified to inspect the most severe conditions.

The SG tub~ minimum sample size, inspection result classification, and the corresponding action required shall be as specified in Table 6.5.8-1. The tubes selected for each inservice inspection shall include at least 3% of the total number of tubes in all SGs; the tubes selected for these ~nspections shall be selected on a random basis except:

1. Where experience in similar plants with similar water chemistry indicates critical areas to be inspected,·then at least 503 of the tubes inspected shall be from these critical areas.

2. The first sample of tubes selected for each inservice inspection of each SG shall include:

a)

b)

c)

All nonplugged tubes that previously had detectable wall ·penetrations greater than 203.

Tubes in those areas where exp•rien~e has indicated potential problems. ·

A tube in spec_t ion sha 11 be performed on each . se 1 ected tube. If any selected tube does not permit the passage of the eddy current probe for a tube inspection, this shall be recorded and an adjacent tube shall be selected and.subjected to a tube inspection.

6-9

Amendment No. H, -1-5, -1-6, ~, ~, 4-S, ~, 9-1-, ~, ffi, m, -141-, 174 October 31, 1996 ·

6.9

6.5.8

AQMINISTBATIYE CONTROLS

Steam Generator Tybe Syryeillance Program (continued)

3. The tubes selected as the second and third samples (if required by Table 6.5.8-1) during ea~h inservice inspection may be subjected to a partial tube inspection provided:

a) The tubes selected for these samples include the tubes· from those areas of the tube sheet array where tubes with imperfections were previously found.

b) The inspections include those portions of the tubes where imperfections were previously found.

4. The results of each sample inspection shall be classified into one of the following three categories: ·

Category Inspection Results

C-1 Less than 5% of the total tubes inspected are degrad~d tubes and none of the inspected.tubes are defective.

C-2 One or more tubes, but not more than 1% of the total tubes inspected are defective, or between 5% and 10% of the total tubes inspected are degraded tubes.

C-3

Note:

More than lai of the total tubes inspected are degraded tubes or more than 1% of the inspected tubes are .defective.

In all inspections, ·previously degraded tubes must exhibit significant (greater than 10%) further wall penetrations to be included in the above percentage calculations.

b. · Insoection Fregyencies

The above required inservice inspection of SG t~bes shall b• performed at the following frequencies:

1. Inservice inspections. shall be performed at intervals of not less than 12 nor more than 24 calendar months after the previous inspection~ If two consecutive inspections following service under AVT conditions, not including the preservice inspection, result in all inspections results falling into the C-1 category or if two consecutive inspections demonstrate that previously observed degradation has not ~ontinued and no . additional degradation has occurred, the inspection interval may be extended to a maximum of once per 40 months.

6-10

Amendment No. a.9, 4i, Y, ~, m, m, ~, 174 October 31, 1996

6.0

6.5.8

ADMIHISTRATIYE CONTROLS

Steam Generator Tybe Surveillance Pro9ram (continued)

2. If the results of the inservice inspection of a SG conducted in accordance with Table 6.5.8-1 at 40 month intervals fall into Category C-3, the inspection frequency shall be increased to at least once per 20 months. The increase in inspection frequency shall apply until the subsequent inspections satisfy the criteria of Specification 6.5.8.b.l; the interval may then be extended to a maximum of once per 40 months.

3. Additional, unscheduled inservice inspections shall be performed on each SG in accordance with the first sample inspection specified in Table 6.5.8-1 during the shutdown subsequent to any of the following conditions:

a)

b)

Primary-to-secondary tube leaks {not including leaks originating-from tube-to-tube sheet welds) in excess of the limits of Specification 3.1.5.

A seismic occurrence greater than the Operating Basis·. Earthquake.

c) A loss-of-coolant accident resulting in initiation of ·I flow of the engineered safeguards.

d) A main steam line or main feedwater line break.·

c. Acceotance Criteria

1. As used in this Specification:

a)

b)

c)

d)

Imoerfection means an exception to the dimensions, finish or contour of a tube from that required fabrication drawings or specifications. Eddy-current testing indications below 20% of the nominal tube wall thickness, if detectable, may be considered as imperfections.

pegradation means a service-induced cracking, wastage, wear or general corrosion occurring on either inside or outside of a tube. ·

Degraded Tybe means a tube containing imperfections greater than or equal to 2oi of the nominal wall thickness caused by degradation.

I pegradation means the percentage of the tube wall thickness affected or removed by degradation.

6-11

Ainendment No. a-9, H, ~' H-3, ~' ™', 174 October 31, 1996

6.9

6.5.8

AQMINISTBATIYE CQNTROLS

Steam Generator Tybe Surveillance Program (continued)

e) Defect means an imperfection of such severity that it exceeds the plugging limit. A tube containing a defect is defective.

f) Plugging Limit means the imperfection depth at or beyond which the tube shall be removed from service and is equal to 4~ of the nominal tube wall thickness.

g) Unserviceable described the condition of a tube if it · leaks or contains a defect large enough to affect its structural integrity in the event of an Operating Basis Earthquake, a loss-of-coolant accident, or a steam line or feedwater line break as specified in 6.5.8.b.3, above.

h) Tybe.Inscection means an inspection of the SG tube from the point of entry (hot leg side) completely around the. U-bend to the top support of the cold leg.

i) Preservice Inspection means an inspection of the full length of each tube in SG performed by eddy current techniques prior to service to establish a baseline condition of the.tubing. This inspection shall be performed after the shop hydrostatic test and prior to initial POWER OPERATION using the equipment and techniques expected to be used during subsequent inservice inspections.

2. . The SG shall be determined OPERABLE after completing the corresponding actions (plug all tubes exceeding the plugging limit and all tubes containing through-wall cracks) required by Table 6.5.8-1.

6-12

Amendment No. ~, Q, ~' ~, m, l44-, 174 · October 31, 1996

TABLE 6.5.8-1 STEAM GENERATOR TUBE INSPECTION

lST SAMPLE INSPECTION 2ND SAMPLE INSPECTION' . 3RD SAMPLE INSPECTION

Sample Size Result Action Required Result Action Required Result Action Required

A minimum of C-1 None N/A N/A N/A N/A S Tubes per S.G.

C-2 Plug defective tubes . C-1 None N/A N/A and inspect additional 2S tubes in this S.G. C-2 Plug defective tubes C-1 None

and inspect additional 4S. tubes in this s~G. C-2 Plug defective tubes

C-3 Perform action for C-3 result of first Sample

C-3 Perform act ion for · ,.

C-3 ~esult of first N/A N/A Sample

C-3 Inspect all tubes in All other None N/A N/A this S.G., plug de- S.G.s are fective tubes and C-1 inspect 2S tubes in each other S.G. Some S.G.s Perform action for N/A N/A

C-2 but no C-2 result of second additional sample

24 hour verbal S.G. are notification to NRC C-3 with written follow up within next Additional Inspect all tubes 30 days S.G. is each S.G. and plug

C-3 defective tubes. N/A N/A

S "' 6/n %. Where n is the number of steam generators inspected during an inspection

6-13

Amendment No. -l-4+, 174 Oct~ber 31, 1996

6.0 ADMINISTRATIVE CONTROLS

6.6.8

6.6.9

Containment Structyral Integrity Surveillance Report

Reports shal) be submitted to the NRC covering Prestressing, Anchorage, and Liner and Penetration tests within 90 days after completion of the tests.

Steam Generator Tybe Syrveillance Report

The following reports shall be submitted to the Commission following each inservice inspection of steam generator tubes:

a. The number of tubes plugged fn each steam genera~or shall be reported to the Corrunission within 15 days following the completion of each inspection, anq

b. · The complete results of the steam generator tube inservice inspection shall be reported to the Corrunission within 12 months following completion of the inspection~ This report shall include:

1. Number and extent of tubes inspected.

2. Location and percent of ~all-thickness penetration for each indication of an imperfection.

3. Identffication of tubes plugged.

c. Results of steam generator t~be inspections that fall into Category C-3 shall require 24 hour verbal notification to the NRC prior to

·r•*umption of plant operation. A written followup ~ithin the next 30 days shall provide a description of investigations and corrective measures taken to prevent recurrence.

6-22

Amendment No. -l-98, ~, 174, October 31, 1996

ASME BOILER AND PRESSURE VESSEL CODE

AN AMERICAN NATIONAL STANDARD

.SECTION V

Nondestructive Examination

· 1989 EDITION

JULY 1, 1989

ASME BOILER AND PRESSURE VESSEL COMMITTEE SUBCOMMITTEE ON NONDESTRUCTIVE TESTING

THE AMERICAN SOCIETY OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERS

United Engineering Center 345 East 47th Street New York, N.Y. 10017

Date of Issue - July I, 1989 (Includes all Addenda dated December 1988 and earlier)

This code or standard was developed under procedures accredited as meeting the criteria for American National Standards. The Consensus Committee that approved the code or standard was balanced to assure that individuals from competent and concerned interests have had an opportunity to participate. The proposed code or standard was made available for public review and comment which provides an opportunity for additional public input from industry, academia, regulatory agencies, and the public-at-large.

ASME does not .. approve," "rate," or "endorse" any item, construction. proprietary device, or activity. ASME does not take any position with respect to the validity of any patent rights asserted in connection with any items

mentioned in ihis document, and does not undertake to insure anyone utilizing a standard against liability for infringement of any applicable Letters Patent,· nor assume any such liability. Users of a code or standard are expressly advised that determination of the validity of any such patent rights, and the risk of infringement of such rights, is entirely their own resp6nsibility.

Participation by federal agency representative(s) or person(s) affiliated with industry is not to be interpreted as government or industry endorsement of this code or standard. .

ASME accepts responsibility for only those interpretations issued in accordance with governing ASME proc;:dures and policies. · which preclude the issuance of interpretations by individual volunteers.

The footnotes in this document are part of this American National Standard.

ASME collective membership mark

The above ASME symbols are registered in the U.S. Patent Office .. "ASME" is the trademark of the American Society of Mechanical Engineers.

Copyright © 1989 by THE AMERICAN SOCIETY OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERS

All Rights Reserved

The Specifications published and copyrighted by The American Society for Testing and Materials are reproduced with the Society's permission.

No part of this document may be reproduced in any form, in an electronic retrieval system or otherwise, without the prior wntten permission of the publisher.

Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 56-3934 Printed in the United States of America

Adopted by the Council of the American Society of Mechanical Engineers, 1914. Revised 1940, 1941, 1943, 1946, 1949, 1952, 1953, 1956, 1959, 1962, 1965, 1968, 1971, 1974, 1977, 1980, 1983, 1986, 1989

T-810 T-820

T-821 T-830 T-840 T-850 T-860 T-870

Appendix I

I-800 I-810 I-820 I-830

I-831 e I-850 I-860

I-861 I-862 I-863 I-864 I-865

I-870 I-871 I-872

I-880 I-881

I-890 I-891

Figures I-862-1

I-862-2

I-865-1

ARTICLE 8

Scope . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 117 General ........................ .' . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .1 I 7 Written Procedure . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 117 Description of Method .............................................. : . . . . . . . . . . . 11 7 Reference Specimen . , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 117

·Equipment Qualification . : . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 117 Acceptance Requirements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 118 Procedure Requirements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 118

Eddy Current Examination Method for Installed Nonferromagnetic Steam Generator Heat Exchanger Tubing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 119

Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 119 Scope . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 119 General Requirements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 119 Equipment ..................................... : . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 119 Frequency of Calibration . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 119 Technique· . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 119 Calibration . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 119 Calibration Tube Standards . ·. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 119 Basis Frequency Calibration Procedure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 120 Auxiliary Frequency(s) Calibration Procedure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 121 Calibration Confirmation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 121 Correlation of Signals to Estimate Depth of Discontinuities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 121 Examination . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 122 General ................................................ '. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 122 Probe Speed ............................................... '..................... 122 Evaluation .................. ·. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 122 General ... .' .... '................................................................. 122 Documentation· ..................................................... :............. 123 Procedure Requirements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 123

Typical Signal Response From a Properly Calibrated Differential Bobbin Coil Probe System ........................ " . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 120

Typical Signal Response From a Properly Calibrated Absolute Bobbin Coil Probe System . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 121

Phase Angle vs Flaw Depth Inconel Tube, 400 kHz (Typical 0.050 in. Wall Tube) .. . .. .. . .. .. . .. . .. .. .. .. .. .. . . .. . . .. . . . .. .. .. . .. .. .. . . . . .. 122

115

ARTICLE 8 EDDY CURRENT EXAMINATION

OF TUBULAR PRODUCTS

T-810 SCOPE

(a) This Article describes the method to be used when a referencing Code Section requires eddy current or other electrical examination to this Article. The methods conform substantially with the following Standards listed in Article 26 and reproduced in Subsection B:

SE-243 Electromagnetic (Eddy Current) Testing of Seamless Copper and Copper-Alloy Heat Exchanger and Condenser Tubes ·

SE-309 Eddy Current Testing of Steel Tubular Products With Magnetic Saturation ·

SE-215 Standardizing Equipment for Electromagnetic Testing of Seamless Aluminum-Alloy Tube

SE-268 Terms Relating to Electromag~etic Testing (b) The requirements of Article 1, General Require

ments, and Appendix A, Glossary of Terms Used in Nondestructive Examination, also apply when eddy current examination to Article 8 is required by a referencing Code Section.

T-820

T-821

GENERAL

Written Procedure

All eddy current or other electrical examinations shall be performed to detailed written procedur~s. unless otherwise stated in the referencing Code S~ction.

T-830 DESCRIPTION OF METHOD

The procedure for eddy current or other electrical examination methods shall provide a sensitivity which will consistently detect discontinuity indications equal to or greater than those in the reference specimen described in T-840. Products with discontinuities

117

which produce indications in excess of the reference standards shall be processed in accordance with T-860.

T-840 REFERENCE SPECIMEN

(a) The reference specimen shall be a part of and shall be processed in the same manner as the product being examined. It shall be of the same nominal diameter and the same nominal composition as the product being examined. Unless specified in the referencing Code Section, the reference discontinuities shall be transverse notches or drilled holes as described in paragraph 5.4, Calibration Standard, of Standard Method SE-243.

(b) The reference specimen shall be long enough to simulate the handling of the product being examined through the inspection equipment. The separation between reference discontinuities placed in the same reference specimen shall be not less than twice the length of the sensing unit of the inspection equipment.

T-850 EQUIPMENT QUALIFICATION

(a) The proper functioning of the examination equipment shall be checked and calibrated by the use of the reference speeimens as follows:

(J) at the beginning of each production run of a given diameter and thickness of a given material;

(2) after each hour during the production run; (3) at the end of the production run; (4) at any time that malfunctioning is suspected.

(b) If, during any check it is determined that the testing equipment is not functioning properly, all of the product tested since the last check shall be reexamined.

T-860 1989 SECTION V

T-860 ACCEPTANCE REQUIREMENTS

Acceptance requirements shall be as specified in the referencing Code Section.

T-870 PROCEDURE REQUIREMENTS

A written procedure, when required according to T-150, shall include at least the following:

(a) frequency · (b) type of coil or probe (e.g., differential coil) (c) type of material and sizes to which applicable (d) reference specimen notch or hole size (e) additional information as necessary to permit

retesting

118

T-870

ARTICLE 8 - APPENDIX I

EDDY CURRENT EXAMINATION METHOD FOR INSTALLED

NONFERROMAGNETIC STEAM GENERATOR HEAT EXCHANGER TUBING

ARTICLE I-800 INTRODUCTION

I-810 SCOPE

This Appendix defines the eddy current (ET) examination method and equipment requirements applicable to installed nonferromagnetic steam generator heat exchanger tubing. When specified by the referencing Code Section, the eddy current techniques described in this Appendix shall be used.· The methods and techniques described in this App~ndix are intended to detect and quantify degradation in the tubing.

I-820 GENERAL REQUIREMENTS

(a) The basis frequency ET examination is required and shall be done in accordance with 1-862.

(b) The requirements for test equipment and examination procedures shall be in accordance with 1-830.

(c) Calibrations shall be done in accordance with 1-860.

(d) Examination shall be done in accordance with 1-870.

I-830 EQUIPMENT

Eddy current nondestructive testing equipment capable of operation in the differential mode or the absolute mode, or both, shall be used for this examination. A device for recording data, real time, in a format suitable for evaluation and for archival storage, shall

119

be provided when required by the referencing Code Section. ·

I-831 Frequency of Calibration

Electronic instrumentation of the eddy current· system shall be calibrated at least once a year or whenever the equipment has been overhauled or repaired as a result of malfunction or damage.

I-850 TECHNIQUE

Single frequency or multiple frequency techniques are permitted for this examination. Upon selection of the test frequency(s) and after completion of calibration, the probe shall be inserted into the tube where it is extended or positioned to the region of interest. Resulting eddy current signals at each of the individual frequencies shall be recorded for review, analysis, and final disposition.

I-860 CALIBRATION

I-861 Calibration Tube Standards

The calibration tube standard shall be manufactured from a length of tubing of the same nominal size and material type (chemical composition and product form) as that to be examined in the vessel. The intent of this reference standard is to establish and verify system response. The standard shall contain calibration. discontinuities as follows.

1-861 1989 SECTION V 1-862

(a) A single hole drilled 100% through the wall 0.052 in. diameter for Y.i in. 0.D. tubing and smaller and 0.067. in. diameter for larger tubing.

(b) Four flat bottom holes, 1;6 in. diameter, spaced 90 deg. apart in a single plane around the tube circumference, 20% through the tube wall from the 0.D.

(c) A /i 6 in. wide, 360 deg. circumferential groove, 10% through from the inner tube surface (optional).

(d) All calibration discontinuities shall be spaced so that they can be identified from each other and from the end of the tube .

. (e) Each standard shall be identified by a serial number.

(j) The depth of the calibration discontinuities, at their center, shall be accurate to within ± 20% of the specified depth or ± 0.03 in., whichever is smaller. All other dimensions shall be accurate to 0.010 in.

(g) The dimensions of the calibration discontinuities and the applicable ET system response shall become part of the permanent record of the standard.

1-862 Basis Frequency 1 Calibration Procedure

The examination system shall be calibrated utilizing the standard described in 1-861.

(a) Basis Frequency Calibration Using Differential Bobbin Coil Technique

(1) Adjust the ET instrument for a basis frequen- · cy chosen so that the phase angle of a signal from the four 20% flat bottom holes is between 50 deg. and 120 deg. rotated clockwise from the signal of the throughthe-wall hole (Fig. 1-862-1).

(2) The trace display for the four 20% flat bottom holes shall be generated, when pulling the probe, in the directions illustrated in Fig. 1-862-1: down and to the left first, followed by an upward motion to the right, followed by a downward motion returning to the point of origin ..

(3) The sensitivity shall be adjusted to produce a minimum peak-to-peak signal from the four 20% flat bottom holes of 30% of the full scale horizontal presentation with the oscilloscope sensitivity set at 1 V per division.

(4) Adjust the phase or rotation control so that the signal response due to probe motion, or the 10% deep circumferential inside diameter groove, or both, is positioned along the horizontal axis of the display

1The basis frequency is that test frequency selected for the examination which provides responses from the 20% flat bottom holes and the 100% through-the-wall hole references in the calibration tube standard .that have a phase angle dift'erence between SO deg. and 120 deg.

120

25%

25% 20% flat bottom hole response

100% throughwall hole response

50 deg. to 120 deg.

Probe motion and 1.0. groove

50% L--------------------1.--------------------Screen width

FIG. I-862-1 TYPICAL SIGNAL RESPONSE FROM A PROPERLY CALIBRATED DIFFERENTIAL

BOBBIN COIL PROBE SYSTEM

± 5 deg. The responses from the calibration holes shall be maintained as described in (a)(l), (2), and (3) above.

(b) Basis Frequency Calibration Using Absolute Bobbin Coil Technique

(I) Adjust the ET instrument for a basis frequency so that the phase angle between a line drawn from the origin to the tip of the response from the t.hroughthe-wall hole and the .horizontal axis is approximately 40 deg. The phase angie formed by a line drawn from the origin to the tip of the response of the four 20% flat bottom holes and the through-the-wall response line is between 50 deg. and 120 deg. (see Fig. 1-862-2).

(2) The sensitivity shall be adjusted to produce a minimum origin-to-peak signal from the four 20% flat bottom holes of 30% of the full scale horizontal presentation with the oscilloscope sensitivity set at 1 V per division.

(3) Adjust the phase or rotation control so that the signal response due to probe rotation, or the 10% deep circumferential inside diameter groove, or both, is positioned along the horizontal axis of the display := 5 deg. The response of the calibration reference shall be maintained as described in (b)(l) and (2) above.

. e

1-862 ARTICLE 8 APPENDIX I 1-865

25%

25%

20% flat bottom,.......,. hole response

SO deg. to 120 deg.

l.D. groove response

100% through wall hole response

Screen width

FIG. I-862-2 TYPICAL SIGNAL RESPONSE FROM A PROPERLY CALIBRATED ABSOLUTE .

BOBBIN COIL PROBE SYSTEM

(4) The response may be rotated to the upper quadrants of the display at the option and convenience of the operator.

(5) Repeat withdrawing the probe through the calibration tube standard at the probe speed selected for the examination. Record the responses of the applicable calibration discontinuities. Ascertain that they are clearly indicated by the instrument and are distin- . guishable from each other as well as from probe motion signals.

1-863 Auxiliary Frequency(s) Calibration Procedure

(a) Auxiliary frequency(s) may be used to examine the tube wall. Reference standards other than that specified in 1-861 may be used to establish examination specific sensitivity settings and an impedance plane phase reference.

(b) Auxiliary frequency(s) may be combined (mixed) with the basis frequency or with each other for ·extraneous variable suppression. When auxiliary frequency(s) are combined with the basis frequency for

121

extraneous variable suppression, the basis frequency shall meet the requirements of I-862 .

(c) Reference standards simulating the extraneous variables shall be used to establish mixing parameters. Auxiliary frequency response to the extraneous variable reference standard, or basis frequency response to the extraneous variable reference standard, or both, shall be a part of the calibration record.

(d) Repeat withdrawing the probe through the calibration standard at the probe speed selected for examination. Record the auxiliary frequency response of the applicable reference discontinuities.

(e) The basis frequency and auxiliary frequencies shall be recorded.

1-864 Calibration Confirmation

(a) Calibration shall include the complete ET examination system. Any change of probe, exte~sion cables, ET instrument, recording instruments, or any other parts of the ET examination system hardware shall require recalibration.

(b) The system calibration hardware shall be confirmed as required by the referencing Code Section.

(c) Should the system be found to be out of calibration (as defined in 1-862) the equipment shall be recalibrated. The recalibration shall be noted on the recording. The data analyst shall determine which tubes, .if any, shall be reexamined.

1-865 Correlation of Signals to Estimate Depth of Discontinuities

The depth of discontinuities is primarily shown by the phase angle of the ET signal· they produce. A relationship of reference comparator depths versus signal phase angle shall be developed for the examination being performed (see Fig. 1-865-1). The following reference comparators may be used.

(a) The reference comparators shall be manufac" tured from a length of tubing of the same nominal size (diameter and wall thickness) and material (chemical composition and product form) as the tubes being examined.

(b) The reference comparators may be fiat bottom holes drilled to varying depths.

(c) The drilled holes in the calibration standard (see I-861) may be used to establish this relationship where additional depths are required.

(d) The tolerance for the dimensions of the fiat bot-· tom holes shall be the same as those specified for the calibration tube standards [see I-86l(g)].

(e) Except for the holes specified in (f)(l) below, all

1-865 1989 SECTION V 1-881

100 -............. . ............

90

80

..

-.............. ..........._

~ ..... .. 70 ., c: ,,.

.!::! £ 60

ii ~

50 ;: ., ~ ., 40 Q.

I .c Q. 30 ., 'O

~ 20 ~ u.

' 10

" '-.. "' ' " ' ."\ \.. '\

I\ . o:

20 30 . 40 50 60 70 BO 90 100 110 120 130 140 150 160 170 180

Single phase angle, deg.

FIG. I-865-1 PHASE ANGLE vs FLAW DEPTH INCONEL TUBE, 400 kHz <TYPICAL 0.050 in. WALL TUBE>

references shall be far enough apart to avoid interference between signals.

(j) When drilled holes are used, the dimensions shall be as follows:

(1) four flat bottom drill holes, 1i6 in. diameter, 20% through the wall [same as the calibration tube standard (b) in I-861(b)];

(2) one flat bottom drill hole, 1i6 in. in diameter x 40% through the wall from the outside surface;

(3) one flat bottom drill hole, }64 in. in diameter X 60% through the wall from the outside surface;

(4) one flat bottom drill hole, 7'64 in. in diameter X 80% through the wall from the outside surface;

(5) one through-the-wall drill hole [same as the calibration tube standard in I-86l(a)].

(g) Other reference comparators may be used, provided that they can be demonstrated to be comparable to the intended discontinuity to be evaiuated.

(h) Signal amplitude may be used to estimate depth for defects which exhibit a known regularity in their growth history. Standards representative of the defect shall be used to generate an amplitude versus. depth calibration curve.

122

1-870 EXAMINATION

1-871 General

Data shall be recorded as the probe traverses the tube.

1-872 Probe Speed

The nominal probe speed during examination shall not ex.ceed 14 .in./sec. Higher probe speeds may be used if system frequency response and sensitivity to the applicable calibration standards described in 1-861 can be demonstrated.

1-880 EVALUATION

1-881 General

The evaluation of examination data shall be made in accordance with the referencing Code Section.

l L

1-890 ARTICLE 8 APPENDIX I

1-890 DOCUMENTATION

1-891 Procedure Requirements

When required by the referencing Code Section, Eddy Current (ET) examinations shall be performed in accordance with a written procedure. Each procedure shall include at least the following information: .

(a) tube material, diameter, and wall thickness; (b) size and type of probes; (c) mode of operation (differential or absolute or

both); (d) examination frequency or frequencies; (e) manufacturer and model of ET equipment; (j) scanning speed during examination; (g) examination technique, i.e., hand probe, mech

anized probe drive, remote control fixture, etc.; (h) calibration procedure and calibration tube stan-

dards; ·(i) data recording equipment and procedures; UJ ·procedure for interpretation of results;

(k) additional information as necessary to describe the examination.

123

1-891

ASME BOILER AND PRESSURE VESSEL CODE

AN AMERICAN NATIONAL STANDARD

SECTION XI

Rules for Inservice Inspection of Nuclear Power Plant Components

1989 EDITION

JULY l, 1989

ASME BOILER AND PRESSURE VESSEL COMMITTEE SUBCOMMITTEE ON NUCLEAR INSER VICE INSPECTION

THE AMERICAN SOCIETY OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERS

United Engineering Center 345 East 47th Street New York, N.Y. 10017

ARTICLE IW A-6000 RECORDS AND REPORTS

IW A-6100 SCOPE

The requirements for retention of records and re. ports (IW A-6300) also apply to those records and re

ports of Section III, Divisions l and 2 as identified by IWA-6310.

IW A-6200 REQUIREMENTS

IW A-6210. OWNER'S RESPONSIBILITY

(a) The Owner shall prepare plans and schedules for preservice and inservice examinations and tests to meet the requirements of this Division.

(b) The Owner shall prepare records of the examinations, tests, replacements, and repairs.

(c) The Owner shall prepare preservice and inservice inspection summary reports for Class 1 and 2 pressure retaining components and their supports.

IWA-6220 PREPARATION

(a) Examination, test, replacement, and repair records shall be prepared in accordance with the requirements of respective Articles of this Division.

(b) A preservice inspection summary report shall be prepared prior to commercial service.

(c) Inservice inspection summary reports shall be prepared at the completion of each inspection conducted during a refueling outage. Examinations, tests, replacements, and repairs conducted since the preceding summary report shall be included.

(d) Each summary report required by (b) and (c) above shall contain the following information:

(J) refueling outage number (when applicable); (2) Owner's Report for Inservice Inspections,

Form NIS-1, as shown in Appendix II; and (3) Owner's Report for Repair or Replacements,

Form NIS-2, as shown in Appendix II. (e) Plans, schedules, records, and summary reports

45

shall have a cover sheet providing the following information:

. (1) date of document completion (2) name and address of Owner (3) name and address of generating plant (4) name or number designation of the unit (5) commercial service date for the unit

IWA-6230 SUMMARY REPORT SUBMIITAL

Prior to commercial service, the Owner shall file a preservice inspection summary report, and within 90

· days of the completion of the inservice inspection conducted during each refueling outage, the Owner shall file inservice inspection summary reports with the enforcement and regulatory authorities having jurisdiction at the plant site.

IW A-6300 RETENTION

IWA-6310 MAINTENANCE OF RECORDS

The Owner shall retain records and reports identified in IWA~6330 and IW A-6340 as a minimum. The records and reports shall be filed and maintained in a manner which will allow access by the Inspector. The Owner shall provide suitable protection from deterioration and damage for all records and reports, in accordance with the Owner's Quality Assurance Program, for the service lifetime of the component or system. Storage shall be either at the plant site or at another location that will meet the access and Quality Assurance Program requirements.

IW A-6,320 REPRODUCTION AND MICROFILMING

Records and reports shall be either the original or a reproduced, legible copy. Radiographs may be micro-

IWA-6320 1989 SECTION XI - DIVISION I IWA-6340

filmed; however, the Owner's Quality Assurance Program shall include a system of monitoring the accuracy of the reproduction process so that when the microfilm is projected to the original size it will provide the same information retrieval capability as the original radi

. ograph. The accuracy of the reproduction process includes the exposure (or multiple exposures for density coverage), focusing, contrast, and resolution. The Quality Assurance Program shall also provide a system for identifying film artifacts that might appear as material discontinuities in the reproduction.

IW A-6330 CONSTRUCTION RECORDS

Records designated by the Owner in accordance with NCA-4134.17 shall be retained.

46

IW A-6340 INSERVICE INSPECTION RECORDS AND REPORTS

The Owner shall be responsible for designating the records to be maintained. Such records shall include the following as a minimum:

(a) an index to record file; (b) preservice and inservice inspection plans and

schedules (IW A-6220); (c) preservice and inservice inspection reports

(IW A-6220); (d} repair records and reports (IWA-4000); (e) replacement records and reports (IW A-7000); (/) nondestructive examination procedures (IW A-

1000); (g) nondestructive examination records, including

radiographs and review forms (IW A-1000); (h} pump records and reports (IWP-6000); (i) valve records and reports (IWV-6000); (j) pressure test procedures (IW A-5000);.

(k) pressure test records (IW A-5000).

APPENDIX II - MANDATORY

FORM NIS-1 OWNER'S REPORT FOR INSERVICE INSPECTIONS As required by the Provisions of the ASME Code Rules

Form NIS-1

1. Owner----------------------------------------~ (Name and Address of Owner)

2. Plant -------------------------------------------~ (Name and Address of Plant)

3. Plant Unit _______ 4. Owner Certificate of Authorization (if required) ________ _

5. Commercial Service Date ______ 6. National Board Number for Unit-------------

7. Components Inspected

Component or Appurtenance

Manufacturer or Installer

Manufacturer or Installer State or National

Board No.

Note: Supplemental sheets in form of lists, sketches. or drawings may be used, provided (I) size is 8\/i in. x 11 in., (2) information in items I through 6 on this report is included on each sheet, and (3) each sheet is numbered and the number of sheets is recorded at the top of this iorm.

Thi• Form (E000291 m_ey be obtained from the ASME Order Dept., 22 Lew Drive. Box 2300, Fairfield, NJ 07007-2300

281

Form NIS-1 1989 SECTION XI - DIVISION 1

FORM NIS-1 (Back)

8. Examination Dates ----------- to ----------

9. Inspection Period Identification: ---------------------------------

10. Inspection Interval Identification:---------------------------------

11. Applicable Edition of Section XI ---------- Addenda ----------

12. Date/Revision of Inspection Plan: --------------------------------

13. Abstract of Examinations and Tests. Include a list of examinations and tes and a statement concerning status of work required for the Inspection Plan.

14. Abstract of Results of Examinations and Tests.

15. Abstract of Corrective Measures.

Certificate of Authorization Date-------...,.-----

I, the undersigned, holding a and the State or Province of

Expiration Date

~!l!!!llllii:~--:::--------BY~-------

ued by the National Board of Boiler and Pressure Vessel Inspectors ;...____. ______ and employed by of

ted the components described in this Owner's Report during the period ---------- to , and state that to the best of my knowledge and belief, the Owner has performed examinations and tests and taken corrective measures described in this Owner's Report in accordance with the Inspection Plan and as required by the ASME Code, Section XI.

By signing this certificate neither the Inspector nor his employer makes any warranty, expressed or implied, concerning the examinations, tests, and corrective measures describCd in this Owner's Report. Furthermore, neither the Inspector nor his employer shall be liable in any manner for any personal injury or property damage or a loss of any kind arising from or connected with this inspection.

---------------------Commissions---,.-------------------Inspector's Signature National Board, State, Province, and Endorsements

Date -------------19 __

282

IWB-2412 REQUIREMENTS FOR CLASS I COMPONENTS IWB-2430

TABLE IWB-2412-1 INSPECTION PROGRAM B

Maximum Inspection Period, Minimum Examinations

Inspection Calendar Years of Examinations Credited, % Interval Plant Service Completed, % [Note <lll

1st 3 lb 34 7 50 b7

10 100 100

2nd 13 lb 34

17 50 b7

20 100 100

3rd 23 lb 34

27 50 b7

30 100 100

4th 33 lb 34

37 50 100

40 100

NOTE: (l) Except as noted in Table IWB-2500·1, Bl.30.

enable an inspection to coincide with a plant outage, within the limitations of IW A-2430(c).

IWB-2412 Inspection Program B

(a) With the exception of the examinations that may be deferred until the end of an inspection interval as specified in Table IWB-2500-1 and for steam generator tubing, the required examinations in each examination category shall be completed during each successive· inspection interval in accordallce with Table IWB-2412-1.

(b) The inspection period specified in (a) above may be decreased or extended by ·as much as 1 year to enable an inspection to coincide with a. plant outage, within the limitations of IWA-2430(d).

IWB-2413 Inspection Program for Steam Generator Tubing

The examinations shall be governed by the plant Technical Specification.

IWB-2420 SUCCESSIVE INSPECTIONS

(a) The sequence of component examinations established during the first inspection interval shall be re-

61

peated during each successive inspection interval, to the extent practical.

(b) If flaw indications or relevant conditions are evaluated in accordance with IWB-3132.4 or IWB-3142.4, respectively, and the component qualifies as acceptable for continued service, the areas containing such flaw indications or relevant conditions shall be reexamined during the next three inspection periods listed in the schedules of the inspection programs of IWB-2410.

(c) If the reexaminations required by (b) above re-veal that the flaw indications remain essentially un-changed for three successive inspection periods, the component examination schedule may revert to the original schedule of successive inspections.

(d) For steam generator tubing, the successive ex-aminations shall be governed by the plant Technical Specification.

IWB-2430 ADDITIONAL EXAMINATIONS

(a) Examinations performed in accordance with Ta-. ble IWB-2500-1 that reveal indications exceeding the acceptance standards of Table IWB-3410-1 shall be extended to include additional examinations at this outage. The additional examinations shall include the remaining welds, areas, or parts1 included in the inspection item2 listing and scheduled for this and the · subsequent period. 3 If the examinations for that inspection item are not scheduled in the subsequent period, the most immediate period containing scheduled examinations shall be taken as the subsequent period.

(b) If the additional examinations required by (a) above reveal indications exceeding the acceptance standards of Table IWB-3410-1, the examinations shall be further extended to include additional examinations at this outage. The additional examinations shall include all the welds, areas, or parts of similar design, size, and function.

(c) For the inspection period following the period in which the examinations of (a) or (b) above were completed, the examinations shall be perlormed as normally scheduled in accordance with IWB-2400. · ·

1Welds, areas, or pans arc those described or intended in a panicular inspection item of Table IWB-2500-1. 2An inspection item, as listed in Table IWB-2500-1, may comprise a number of welds, areas, or parts of a component required to be examined in accordance with the inspection plan and schedule (IW A-2420). .

lThc subsequent period is the next following period, even if it is in the following interval. · ·

IWB-2430 1989 SECTION XI - DIVISION 1

(d) For steam generator tubing, additional examinations shall be governed by plant Technical Specifications.

IWB-2500 EXAMINATION AND PRESSURE TEST REQUIREMENTS

(a) Components shall be examined and tested as specified in Table IWB-2500-1. The method of examination for the components and parts of the pressure retaining boundaries shall comply with those tabulated in Table IWB-2500-1 except where alternate examination methods are used that meet the requirements of IW A~2240.

(b) Table IWB-2500-1 is organized as follows.

Examination Category Examination Area

B-A Pressure Retaining Welds in Reactor Vessel B-B Pressure Retaining Welds in Vessels Other

Than Reactor Vessels B-D Full Penetration Welds of Nozzles in. Vessels B-E Pressure Retaining Partial Penetration Welds

B-F B-G-1

B-G-2

B-H B-J B-K-1

B-L-1 B-L-2 B-M-1 B-M-2 B-N-1 B-N-2

B-N-3 B-0

B-P B-Q

in Vessels Pressure Retaining Dissimilar Metal Welds Pressure Retaining Bolting, Greater Than 2 in.

in Diameter Pressure Retaining Bolting, 2 in. and Less

in Diameter Integral Attachments for Vessels Pressure Retaining Welds in Piping Integral Attachments for Piping, Pumps, and

Valves Pressure Retaining Welds in Pump Casings Pump Casings Pressure Retaining Welds in Valve Bodies Valve Bodies Interior of Reactor Vessel Integrally Welded Core Support Structures and

Interior Attachments to Reactor Vessels Removable Core Support Structures Pressure Retaining Welds in Control Rod

Housings All Pressure Retaining Components Steam Generator Tubing

62

IWB-2500

I

00 N

Item Parts No. Examined

Blb.10 Steam Generator Tubing in Straight Tube Design

Blb.20 Steam Generator Tubing in u~ Tube Design

NOTES:

TABLE IWB-2500-1 <CONT'D) EXAMINATION CATEGORIES

EXAMINATION CATEGORY B-Q, STEAM GENERATOR TUBING

Extent and

Examination -1st Requirements/ Examination Acceptance Inspection

Fig. No. Method Standard Interval

Entire length Volumetric •• • of tubing

Tubing hot .Volumetric IWB-3521 • leg side, U-bend portion

· and option-ally cold leg side

• The extent and frequency of examination shall be governed by the plant Technical Specification .. •• 1n course of preparation.

frequency of Examination

Successive Inspection Intervals,

2nd, 3rd, 4th

•

*

Deferral of Inspection to

End of Interval

tl

< ...... Vl

0 z

IWB-3520.2 1989 SECTION XI - DIVISION 1 IWB-3523.3

{a) structural distortion or displacement of parts to - the extent that component function may be impaired;

(b) loose, missing, cracked, or fractured parts, bolting, or fasteners;

(c) foreign materials or accumulation of corrosion products that could interfere with control rod motion or could result in blockage of coolant flow through fuel;

(d) corrosion or erosion that reduces the nominal section thickness by more than 5%;

(e) wear of mating surfaces that may lead to loss of function; or

(j) structural degradation of interior attachments such that the original cross-sectional area is reduced more than 5%. ·

IWB-3521 Standards for Examination Category B-Q, Steam Generator Tubes

IWB-3521.1 Allowable Flaws for U-Tube Steam Generators. For single or multiple flaws of cracks, wastage, or intergranular corrosion in tubing of SB-163 material meeting the requirements ofNB-2550 and having an r/t ratio of less than 8.70, the depth of an allowable O.D. flaw shall not exceed 40% of the tube wall thickness.

IWB-3521.2 Allowable Flaws for Straight-Tube Steam Generators •. In the course of preparation.

IWB-3522 Standards for Examination Category B-E, Pressure Retaining Partial Penetration Welds in Vessels, and

. Examination Category B-P, All Pressure Retaining Components

IWB-3522.1 Visual Examination, VT-2. The follow-· ing relevant conditions8 that may be detected during the conduct of system pressure tests shall require correction to meet the requirements of IWB-3142 and IW A-5250 prior to continued service:

(a) leakage from noninsulated components (IWA-5241);

(b) leakage in excess of permissible levels defined by the Owner from components provided with leakage limiting devices (IW A-5243);

'Relevant conditions are· defined in IW A-9000; they do not include conditions that result in condensation on components, normal collection of Ouid in sumps, and drips from open drains.

120

(c) leakage9 from insulated components or inaccessible components that will require location of leakage source (IW A-5242);

(d) areas of general corrosion of a component resulting from leakage [IWA-5250(b)];

(e) discoloration or accumulated residues on surfaces of components, insulation, or floor areas that may be evidence of borated water leakage9 [IW A-5242(c)]; or

(j) leakages or flow test results from buried components (IWA-5244) in excess of limits established by the Owner:

IWB-3523 Standards for Examination Category B-0, Pressure Retaining Welds in · Control Rod Drive Housings

IWB-3523.1 Allowable Planar Flaws {a) The size of ari allowable planar flaw within the

boundary of the examination surfaces and volumes delineated in Fig. IWB-2500-18 shall not exceed the limits specified in IWB-3523.2 and IWB-3523.3, as applicable.

{b) Where a flaw extends beyond the boundaries of the examination surfaces and volumes, or separate flaws are detected that lie both within and beyond the boundaries but are c.haracterized as a single flaw by the rules of IWA-3300, the overall flaw size shall be compared with the standards of (a) above.

(c) Any two or more coplanar aligned flaws characterized as separate flaws by IWA-3300 are allowable, provided the requirements of IW A-3390 are met.

IWB-3523.2 Allowable Flaw Standards for Surface Examination

(a) The size of allowable flaws shall not exceed ?'; 6

in. for the preservice examination and Xi in. for the inservice examination.

(b) Where a flaw on the outer surface of the housing exceeds the allowable standards, the housing may be examined using the volumetric method, and the acceptance standards of IWB-3523.3 shall apply.

IWB-3523.3 Allowable Flaw Standards for Volumetric Examination

(a) The depth of an allowable preservice flaw shall not exceed 10% of weld thickness; the length shall not exceed 60% of weld thickness.

(b) The. depth of an allowable inservice flaw shall

9The leakage is the through-wall leakage that penetrates the pressure retaining membrane:

APPENDIX IV EDDY CURRENT EXAMINATION

OF NONFERROMAGNETIC STEAM GENERATOR HEAT EXCHANGER TUBING

303

ARTICLE IV-1000 INTRODUCTION

IV-1100 SCOPE

This Appendix supplements Article 8 - Appendix I of Section V to define additional requirements· on items such as personnel qualification, procedure, records, evaluation, and reporting applicable to the Eddy Current Test (En examination method for installed nonferromagnetic steam generator heat exchanger tubing.

JOS

ARTICLE IV-2000 EXAMINATION PERSONNEL AND PROCEDURE

IV-2100 GENERAL REQUIREMENTS

Article IW A-2000, Examination and Inspection, of this Section and Article I, General Requirements; Article 8 - Appendix I, Eddy Current Examination Method for Installed Non-Ferromagnetic Steam Generator Heat Exchanger Tubing, and Appendix A, Glossary of Terms of Section V, apply when eddy current examination according to this Appendix is required.

IV-2200 PERSONNEL REQUIREMENTS

In addition ·to the qualification requirements of IW A-2300 for personnel performing nondestructive

306

examination operations, personnel interpreting ET data shall be qualified in accordance with SNT-TClA, Level II or higher, specifically for the evaluation of data from nonferromagnetic tubing.

IV-2300 PROCEDURE REQUIREMENTS

ET examinations shall be performed in accordance with a written procedure. Each procedure shall include at least the information required by I-890 of Article 8 - Appendix I of Section V. In addition, each procedure shall include the scanning direction and speed during examination (insertion, retraction, or both, from inlet or outlet end).

ARTICLE IV-3000 CALIBRATION

System calibration shall be performed per Article 8 - Appendix I of Section V. In addition, the following requirements apply. ·

(a) Calibration confirmation shall be performed and recorded on each magnetic tape or other data recording medium (e.g., floppy disk or laser disk), and at least every 4 hr.

(b) System calibration shall be performed dynami-cally. ·

(c) If recalibration is required, the data interpreter shall determine which tubes, if any, shall be reexamined.

( d) The calibration tube standard shall be per 1-861 of Article 8, Appendix I of Section V, and be manufactured from a length of tubing of the same heat treatment as that to be examined in the vessel.

307

ARTICLE IV -5000 RECORDS

IV-5100. GENERAL

The data from all tube examinations shall be recorded as the tesi probe traverses the tube.

IV-5200 RECORD IDENTIFICATION

Recording media shall contain the following infor-mation:

(a) Owner (b) plant site (c) heat exchanger identity (d) recording media identification (e.g., reel number) (e) date of examination (/) serial number of the calibration standard (g) operator's ide~tification and certification level (h) nominal operating frequency · (i) lengths of probe and probe extension cables (j) size and type of probes

308

(k) probe manufacturer's name and probe description or part number

IV-5300 TUBE IDENTIFICATION

Each tube examined shall be identified on the recording media.

IV-5400 FIXTURE LOCATION VERIFICATION

(a) The ability of the fixture to locate specific tubes shall be verified visually and recorded upon installation of the fixture and before relocating or removing the fixture.

(b) Should the performance of fixture location ver- · ification reveal that an error has occurred in the recording of probe location, all tubes examined since the previous location verificatiOn shall be· reexamined.

ARTICLE IV-6000 EVALUATION

IV~6100 GENERAL

All indications recorded during the examination shall .be evaluated.

IV-6200 TIME OF EVALUATION

The evaluation may be performed as each tube is being examined or at a later time using the recorded data to recreate the cathode ray tube patterns.

IV-6300 RECORDING OF RESULTS

Flaws producing a response equal to or greater than 20% wall penetration shall be identified and the depth. noted. The percent .of tube wall penetration for each flaw equal to or greater than 20% shall be recorded in a summary sheet [see Appendix B (Form NIS-BB)]. The report shall include the axial location along the length of the tube.

309

ARTICLE IV· 7000 REPORT OF EXAMINATION

(a) The Owner or his agent shall prepare a report of the examinations performed during each inservice · inspection. The report shall be prepared, filed, and maintained iii. accordance with IW A-6000. Procedures and equipment used shall be identified sufficiently to permit comparison of the examination results with new examination results run at a later date; this shall include initial calibration data for each ET examination system and subsequent rechecks.

· (b) The report shall include a record indicating the tube(s) examined (this may be marked on a tubesheet sketch or drawing), any scanning limitations, the location and depth of each reported flaw, and the identification and certification level of the operator(s) and data evaluator(s) who conducted each examination or part thereof.

310

e·

CASES OF ASME BOILER AND PRESSURE VESSEL CODE

Approval Date: Mey 4. 1988

See Numerical Index for expiration and any reaffirmation dates.

Case N-401·1 Eddy Current Examination Section XI, Division 1

Inquiry: Is it permissible, as an alternative to the Section XI, Division l, Appendix IV, requirement for magnetic tape and strip chart reeording of eddy current test data, to use digitized collection and storage of data as the permanent record for eddy current examinations, and to what . extent do the calibration requirements of IV -3oo0 apply?

Reply: It is the opinion of the Committee that. when demonstrated equivalent to the Authorized Nuclear Inservice Inspector, digitized collection and storage of eddy current test data may be used as an alternative to magnetic tape and strip chart recor~g of eddy current test data· required by Section XI, Division· 1, Appendix IV. Periodic calibration in accordance with IV -3000 is required only for the analog elements of the digital eddy current data collection and storage equipment.

CASE

N-401-1

PALISADES NUCLEAR PLANT ENGINEERING MANUAL PROCEDURE

- Procedure No EM-09-05 Revision 6 Issued Date 7 /29/96

. TITLE: STEAM GENERATOR INSERVICE INSPECTION ·

17 /z.6~6 Procedure Sponsor Date

RHilterman I 5/29/96

Technical Reviewer Date

User Reviewer Date

\ .


Proc No EM-09-05 Revision 6 Page i

TITLE: STEAM GENERATOR INSERVICE INSPECTION

Table of Contents

1 :o PURPOSE ................................... · ...... , ... ·. 1

2.0 SCOPE ............................................. ·1

2.2 DEFINITIONS ................ : ................ .

. 2.2.1 2.2.2 2.2.3 2.2.4 2·.2.5 2.2.6

Authorized Inspection Agency ....... ·. . . . . . . . . 1 Authorized Nuclear lnservice Inspector ...... ·. . . . 2 Flaw Indication . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Eddy Current Test . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . -2 Examination Agency . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ~ . . . 2 Technical Specifications 4.14.5 Definitions ..... _ .. 2

3.0 REFERENCES ........... ; .. : ... : .· ._· ............. · ......... 3

'3.1 3.2

SOURCE DOCUMENTS : ....... : , .. , ............. , . 3 REFERENCE DOCUMENTS· .. '., .... · ... : . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3

4.0 RESPONSIBILITIES - GENERAL .... ; ... :" . .'. · ............... ·, .. 4

4.1 SYSTEM.ENGINEERING DEPARTMENT,.PLANT · . . PERFORMANCE SECTION .............. · .... : ....... 4

'4.2 EXAMINATION AGENCY ... '. ..... .' ........... , ... ·. 5 4;3 REVIEWS/APPROVALS .......................... ·. 5 ·

5.0 PREOUTAGE PLANNING ........... , .......... · : ...... · .... · 5

5.1 ECT WORK REOUEST(S)/WORK ORDER(Sl, .. · ........... 5 . 5.2 EXAMINATION AGENCY PROCEDURES ..... · .......... 5 5.3 SIG TUBE LISTINGS ..................... : ....... 5 5 .4 NEW INSPECTION TECHNIQUES .................... 6 5.5 CONTRACTING WITH EXAMINATION AGENCIES ......... 6 5.6 EXAMINATION SCHEDULES ....................... 6

. 5.7 NOTIFICATION($) ............................... 6


Proc No EM-09-05 Revision 6 Page ii


Table of Contents

6.0 ONSITE ACTIVITIES ..................... ~ .............. 7

6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 6.5 6.6 6.7 6.8 6.9

PREINSPECTION ACTIVITIES ...... ·. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 INSPECTION ACTIVITIES .......................... 7 AUDITS .... · .......................... , ..... : . 7 REPORTABLE INDICATIONS ...... ~ ................ 8 INDICATION EVALUATION .. ; ... ,. ................. 8 INDICATION DISPOSITION .................... · .... 8

. . . '

ADMINISTRATIVE ANOMALIES ............... ; . . . . 1 0 REVIEW OF ONSITE ACTIVITIES ............ ·. . . . . . . 1 0

. TECHNICAL S~ECIFICATION SURVEILLANCE PROCEDURE . COMPLETION .............. , .. -.. ~ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 0

7.0. POST ONSITE ACTIVITY REPORTS ......................... 10

7. 1 EXAMINATION AGENCY REPORT(S) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 0 e · ) . 2- - · REPORT -DISTRIBUTION ~ ·•- .~ .. '· .~ ·- .... : .. ~; _ ..... · .... , . . . . 11

8.0 RECORDS/DOCUMENTS .. ;- .. ; ...... " : .. •· ............... 12

8.1 · SIG ISi RECORD ..... ~ .......................... 12 . 8.2 DESIGN DRAWINGS I FSAR ~· .' ............ ~ ........ 12 8. 3 MISCELLANEOUS RECO.RDS ...... '. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 2

. ' .

9.0 ATTACHMENTS .... , .......... ; ...................... 12

ATTACHMENTS ·

' . Attachment 1, "Steam Generator lnservice Inspection Matrix"

. PALISADES NUCLEAR PLANT ENGINEERING MANUAL PROCEDURE

Proc No EM-09-05 Revision 6 Page 1 of 12


USER ALERT REFERENCE USE PROCEDURE

Refer to the procedure periodically to confirm that all procedure segments of an activity will be or are being performed. Where required, sign appropriate sign-off blanks to certify that all segments are complete.

1.0 PURPOSE

2.0

2.1

To provide guidance for the Palisades Steam Generator (S/G) Program Manager(s), responsible for the Steam Generator (S/G) lnservice Inspection Program .

. To justify continued 9perability of S/G tubing through periodic eddy current testing.

SCOPE

Instructions for the periodic inservice inspection of the Palisades steam generator tubing, and

2.2 Instructions for plugging and repair of the Palisades steam generator tubing, and .

2.3 Instructions for the generation and is~ue of various report documents associated with the steam generator tube inspection and tube plugging.

2.2 DEFINITIONS

2. 2. 1 Authorized lnspectjon Agency

An Authorized Inspection Agency is one designated by, or acceptable to, the appropriate legal authority of one of the cities or states of the United States of America, or Province of Canada, that has adopted Section XI of the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code. Such agencies shall meet the criteria of Section XI of the ASME Code and of the National Board of Boiler and Pressure Vessel Inspectors.

, ..

2.2.2

2.2.3

2.2.4

2.2.5

2.2.6


Proc No EM-09-05 Revision 6. Page 2 of 12


Authorized Nuclear lnservice Inspector

An inspector employed by an Authorized Inspection Agency.

Flaw Indication

An ET signal which may denote the presence of tube degradation.

Eddy Current Test

A nondestructive test method that is based on the generation of eddy currents in a conductive material that is used to ( 1) detect and measure S/G tube wall degradation and (2) monitor tube damage precursors such as denting.

Examination Agency

An Examination Agency is an agency designated by·the Palisades Nuclear Plant for the purpose of performing the S/G tub,ing eddy current e insp·ection .required by Technical-Specifications and.Section XI of the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code, 1989 Edition. When applicable · by code and Plant requirements, personnel shall be certified in accordance with ASNT-TC-1 A. All requirements of Palisades Plant Administrative Procedures that are applicable shall be met by the Examination Agency.

Technical Specifications 4.14. 5 Definition~

a. Imperfection means an exception to the dimensions, finish or contour of a tube from that required fabrication drawings or specifications. Eddy current testing indications below 20% -of the nominal tube wall thickness, if detectable, rnay be considered as. imperfections.

b. Degradation means a service-induced cracking, wastage, wear or general corrosion occurring on either inside or outside of a tube.

c, Oegraded Tube means a tube containing imperfections greater than or equal to 20% of the nominal wall thickness caused by degradation.

d. % Oegradation means the percentage of the tube wall thickness affected or removed by degradation.

3~0 ..

3.1




e. Defect means an imperfection of such severity that it exceeds the plugging limit. A tube containing a defect is defective.

f. Plugging Limit means the imperfection depth at or beyond .which the tube shall be removed from service and is equal to 40% of the· nominal tube wall thickness.

g. Unserviceable describes th1:i condition of a tube if it leaks or contains a defect large enough to affect its structural: integrity in . the event of an operating basis earthquake, a 16ss-of-coolant accident, or a steam line or feedwater line breakas specified in Technical Specifications Section. 4.14.4.c.

h. Tube Inspection means an inspection of S/G tube from the point of entry (hot leg side) completely around the.U-bend to.the top support of the cold leg.

REFERENCES

. SOURCE DOCUMENTS

3'.1 .1 American Society of Mechankal Engineers Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code, 1989 edition, Section V >·.

3.1.2 . Regulatory Guide 1.83, "lnservice Inspection of .Pressurized Water· · Reactor Steam.Generator Tubes"

3.1.3 Palisades Administrative Procedure 10.05, "Procurement of Services"

· 3.1 .4 FSAR Sections 1 .2.4, Table 1 ~2, 4.3.4, Table 4-4, 5. 7 .5.1 .. 2, 6.9, i 4.15, 14.16.3.2

. .

3.1.5 Technical Specific~tions, Chapter 4, Sections 4.0.5, 4.3, 4.'14, and 4.15

3. 2 REFERENCE DOCUMENTS

3.2.1 · Technical Specification Surveillance Procedure RT-60, "Inspection Program for Steam Generator Tubing"

3.2.2 American Society for Nondestructive Testing (ASNT), Recommended· Practice No SNT-TC-1 A

.. •• ·t:°'l.

I 3.2.3

3.2.4

3.2.5

3.2.6

. 3.2.7

3.2.8

3.2.9

PALISADES NUCLEAR Pl.ANT ENGINEERING MANUAL PROCEDURE



American Society of Mechanical Engineers Boiler and Pressure Vessel· Code, 1989 edition, Section XI.

Palisades Administrative. Procedure 5. 1 7, "Training and Qualification for Non permanent Plant Employees and Contracted Services Personnel"

Palisades Administrative Procedure 10.03, "Procurement of Material"

Palisades Administrat.ive Procedure 10.41, "Procedure Initiation and Revision"··

Palis.ades Administrative Procedure 10.01, "Material Storage and Control"

NRC Information Notice 94-05, "Potential Fail.ure of Steam Generator Tubes with Kinetically Welded Sleeves".

NRC Generic Letter 95~03, "Circumferentiai c.racking of Steam Generator Tubes"

'.

3.2.10 ·FES 93-l62; "Steam Generator Tube Plugging"· , ,

3.i.11 Palisades Administrative Procedure 3.12, "FSAR and _VSC Licensing Basis Book Control and Maintenance"

3.2.12 Palisades Administrative Procedure 9,44, "Design Document Control"

3.2.13 Palisades Administrative Procedu.re 1 OA6, "Plant Records"

3.2.14 Palisades Administrative Procedure 3.15, "Design Basis Document Maintenance"

3.2.1 5 EMF-95-042, "Palisades Cycle 12 Principle Plant Parameters"

3.2.16 EMF-95-016, ."Palisades Cycle 12 Safety Analysis Report"

4 .. 0 RESPONSIBILITIES - GENERAL

4. 1 SYSTEM ENGINEERING DEPARTMENT, PLANT PERFORMANCE SECTION

Overall responsibility for the administration of the inservice inspection of SIG tubing.




4.2 EXAMINATION AGENCY

Responsible for the accuracy of-the data collected during the S/G tube inspection.· ·

4.3 REVIEWS/APPROVALS

The matrix in Attachment 1 summarfzes preparation, review and approval of documents produGed in accordance with this procedure.

. .

. 5.0 PREOUTAGE PLANNING


Refer to the procedure periodically to confirm that all procedure segments of an

· activity will be or. are being performed .. Where required, sign appropriate sign-off blanks to certify that all segments are

·complete .

:. ;

. 5.1 EC! WORK REQUEST(S)/WORK ORDER(S)

The Program Manager shall ensure the Work Request(s)/Work Order(s) controlling the Examination Agency performance are generated to assure

· adequate control on code use, personnel and equipment utilization, onsite · 'activities and examination procedures .

. 5.2 EXAMINATION AGENCY PROCEDURES

5.3

.5.3.1

The Program Manager shall ensure all procedures are reviewed and . approved in accordance with Palisades Administrative Procedure 10.41, "Procedure Initiation and Revision," prior to use.

SIG TUBE LISTINGS

The Program Manager shall review and approve the proposed S/G tube listing to ensure that the correct tubes have been selected for this inspection and to verify that the proper eddy current techniques will be used.

PALISAPES NUCLEAR PLANT ENGINEERING MANUAL PROCEDURE



5.3.2 . Tubes selected for examination shall be based on the following:

5.3.3

5.4

a. Palisades Technical Specifications 4. 14, "Augmented lnservice Inspection Program for Steam Generators."

b. . Palisades response to NRC Generic Letter 95-03, "Circumferential Cracking of Steam Generator Tubes" which commits to EPRI guidelines: 20% bobbin {full length tube inspection) and 20% rotating pancake coil inspection or equivalent at the top of the tubesheet.

In addition, supplemental examinations may be performed to aid in characterization of the S/G tube indications or other special requirements.

NEW INSPECTION TECHNIQUES

New inspection techniques shall be considered for evaluation and inclusion in the eddy current test program as specified in Palisades

· .. Technical Sp'eCific'ations, Section 4:3, "System Surveillance."

5. 5 CONTRACTING WITH EXAMINATION AGENCIES

·The Program Manager shall ensure Examination Agencies have been contracted to perform S/G inservice inspection as required.

5. 6 EXAMINATION SCHEDULES

Planning for onsite inspection activities shall include, as required, · preparation of examination activity cri.tical path, daily schedules within Plant constraints and preoutage meetings with Examination Agencies.

5.7. NOTIFICATION(S)

The Program Manager shall notify the Enforcement Authority {Michigan Department of Labor - Boiler Division) and the Authorized Inspection Agency of the scheduled S/G inspection.


Proc No EM-09-05 · Revision 6 Page 7 of 12


6.0 ONSITE ACTIVITIES

.6.1 PREINSPECTION ACTIVITIES

Examination crews are directed to appropriate Plant personnel for any requ.ired Plant indoctrination (ie: Security, Radiation Protection, Confined Space Training, etc). The Program Manager shall conduct a review of personnel, equipment' and material certifications provided by the examination agencies. Training requirements of Palisades Administrative Procedure 5. 1 7, "Training and Qualification for Nonpermanent Plant Employees and Contracted Services Personnel," shall be met.

6.2 IN~PECTION ACTIVITIES

6.2.1 The Program Manager shall coordinate Examination Agency, Authorized Nuclear lnservice Inspector, State, and .NRC activities. A Work Order shall be used to control Examination Agency activities. As work progresses, The Program Manager shall review data to provide engines.ring justification and recommended dispositions of reportable

· inqications. The Program Manager shall Initiate changes in the Work ·Order to facilitate performing additional examinations or reexaminations, if necessary.

6.2.2 . After the lnservice Inspection examinations start, the inspection progress is monitored and the examination data is reviewed to ensure that all

. scheduled items are properly inspected according to approved procedures'. The Program Manager shall interface with personnel who monitor examinations to ensure that the results are as complete and accurat!=l as possible. The Prog~am Manager shall keep the' Outage Plann~ng and Scheduling Administrator appraised of. inspection progress and problems as they occur, as well as the status of evaluations and corrective actions which must be completed prior to returning the Plant to service. ·

6.3 AUDITS

The Program Manager shall ensure any audit observation/findings conducted by the Authorized Nuclear lnservice Inspector, NRC, or any designate audit group are dispositioned in accordance with the Plant's corrective action system.

·,;;

• . , ·'11:

.t..;




6.4 REPORTABLE INDICATIONS

· The Program Manager shall ensure that any indications which exceed code acceptance standards or Plant Technical Specifications and cannot be resolved by the Examination Agency as non-relevant are documented on Condition Reports describing indication resolution, disposition instructions, action taken, and the results of any reexamination. All indications in this category shall be dispositioned prior to returning the Plant to service. Indications considered non-relevant shall be adequately documented by the Examination Agency. on the data sheet or other document which becomes part of the ISi Record.

6.5 INDICATION EVALUATION

6.5.1

6.5.2

6.6.

. 6.6:1

. The Program Manager shall be responsible for coordinating the characterization and evaluation of all indications documented on Condition Reports. The engineering evaluations of the indications are performed by the Program Manager, other_ members of the Plant staff, or out.side contractor(s). Close liaison shall be maintained by t.he Program Manager with the evaluating agency to ensure timely resolution of the indications. . e

. Any engin-eeririg-evaluati6ns-perform_ed ·shall ·be reviewed by the Program M·anager. ·

It has been demonstrated by metallographic analysis of tubes removed from service in operating steam generators, .that the plus-point probe can detect lower levels of stress corrosion cracking than other techniques. Therefore, after initial screening using the plus-point probe, those tubes showing ari indication may be reexamined using a 3-coil probe to determine if these tubes have degraded to a level that justifies repair. Those .tubes showing a plus-point indication but no 3-coil indication will be scheduled for reinspection during subsequent steam generat_or examinations.

INDICATION. DISPOSITION

The Program Manager shall be responsible for recommending dispositioning indications by determining whether adequate engineering justification exists to return the Plant to service without repair or if a

· repair must be made. Where conflicts arise in the evaluations or recommended dispositioning of indications, the Program Manager shall refer them to the System Engineering Manager for final review and . determination for the course of action to be .followed. It should be noted that, in some cases, PRC review may be required in accordance with the Palisades Plant Administrative Procedures.

e.




NOTE: FES 93-1 62 (Reference 3. 2. 10) was completed in 1 993 to plug 1 tube and justify the installation of Westinghouse 1-690 steam generator

·mechanical tube plugs. The current Cycle 12 accident and transient analysis reports (EMF-95-042, ... Palisades Cycle 1 2 Principle Plant Parameters" and EMF-95-016, "Palisades Cycle 12 Safety Analysis Report") allows up to 15% of the total tubes in the steam generators to be plugged with a maximum 9% difference between the two generators.

. .

6.6.2 If steam generator tube plugging or sleeving is required, the Program Manager shall coordinate these activities in accordance with approved working level procedures and the following requirements:

a. The Program Manager shall approve a tube plugging list based on a review of examination results. A Condition Report and the associated plugging list shall be issued tor evaluation and

b.

disposition. · ,. .

The Program Manager shall initiate a ne~ Work Order or ·replan an. existing Work Order to included steps fo~ steam generator tube pluggin·g or sleeving as applicable.

c. Verify with the Reload'. Design Supervisor that the plugging limits will not change for the next cycle.

d. Verify that Technical Speeification 4.15 requirement to perform a . primary system flow measurement following a refueling outage or . after plugging 1 0 or more steam generator tubes will be met.

e. The Program Manager shall notify Reactor Engineering of the number and locations of all stea.m generator tubes to be plugged.

f. The program manager shall perform a safety evaluation to ensure the change to the facility as described in the FSAR (number of tubes plugged) does not involve an unreviewed safety que.stion.

g. The Program Manager shall review NRC Information Notice 94-05, "Potential failure of. Steam Generator Tubes with Kinetically Welded Sleeves" Prior to approving the insertion of kinetically (explosively) welded sleeves.




6.7 ADMINISTRATIVE ANOMALIES

. Deviations addressing inservice activities other than indication evaluation shall be resolved by the Program Manager.

6.8 REVIEW OF ONSITE ACTIVITIES

All examination results are analyzed either on.site or offsite via T-1 connection to an appropriate analysis facility. All resolution results and tube plugging lists generated as a result of the inspection shall be approved by the Program Manager. A complete record of all data . obtained including examination agency reviews, deviation notifications, procedures, and personnel/equipment certifications shall be forwarded to the Program Manage~ after completion of. all onsite work.

6. 9 TECHNICAL SPECIFICATION SURVEILLANCE PROCEDURE COMPLETION

Program Manager shall complete RT-60, "Inspection Program for S/G Tubing." ·

~POST ONSITE ACTIVITY REPORTS

7. 1 EXAMINATION AGENCY REPORT($)

7. 1 . 1 . An Examination Report, reviewed and approved. by Level 111 personnel, must be submitted to the Program Manager within 30 days after completion of the Examination Agencies portion of the onsite examination activities.

7. 1 . 2 The report shall C?ntain:

7.1.3

a. Field Data/Exam Results Summary (General Listing)

b. Tube Repair Listings

c. History

d. Examination Scope

e. Updated S/G Tube Sheet Drawings

The report shall meet the criteria established in American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME) Boiler and Pressure Vessei Code, Section XI, Section IWA-6200.




7. 2 REPORT DISTRIBUTION

. The following outside agencies shall receive reports as described below:

7.2.1 NRC

7.2.2

a. Results of S/G tube inspections that fall into Category C-3 shall require 24 hour verbal notification to the NRC prior to resumption of Plant operation. A written follow-up withiri ·the next ·30 days shall provide a description of investigations and corrective measures taken to prevent recurrence.

b. · · Within 1 5 days following the completion of each inservice inspection 9f S/G tubes, the· number of tubes plugged In each S/G shall be reported to the Commission in a Special Report pursuant to·

c.

· lOCFR50.4. - . '!

The complete results of the S/G tube inservice inspection shall be · submitted to the Commission in a Special Report pursuant to 1,0CFf{50.4 within 1.2 months following completion of the inspection. This Special Report shall include:

,.

1 . Number and extent of tubes inspected.

2. Location and percent of wall-thickness penetration fo'r' each·. indication of an imperfe".tion. ·

3. Identification of tubes plugged. ·

State of Michiga·n; Michigan Department of Labor-Boiler Division

Authorized Inspection Agency

·, .z

"'




8.0 RECORDS/DOCUMENTS

8. 1 S/.G ISi RECORD

8.2

The completed Work Order, NIS-1, NIS-2, NRC Report, and all appendices, constitutes the completed SIG ISi Record as identified in Americ.an Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME) Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code, Section XI, Section IWA-6200. The S/G ISi Record, which includes the Examination Agency Report (Section 7 .1) shall be reviewed and entered into the Uniform File Index in accordance with Palisades. Administrative Procedure 10.46, ·"Plant Records" within 12 months of completion ·of the last onsite examination .

DESIGN DRAWINGS I FSAR . ,

8.2.1 The Program Manager shall update S/G Tube Sheet Drawings M1 FK . Sheets 1 and 2 in accordance with Palisades Administrative Procedure

9 .44, "Design Document Control" to reflect changes resulting from steam ,generator tube plugging·.

8.2.2 - The·Program' Manager·shall update·FSAR i .2.4, and Table 4-4 in , accordance with Palisades ·Administrative Procedure 3.12, "FSAR and VCS Licensing Basis ·Book Control and Maintenance" to reflect changes resulting from steam generator tube plugging. · ·

8.2.3 The Program Manager shall update DBD 2.04 Section 3.3.2 in accordance · with Palisades Administrative Procedure 3.15, "Design Basis Document · Maintenance" to reflect changes resulting from steam generator tube plugging.

8.3 MISCELLANEOUS RECORDS

All documentation concerning the SIG inservice inspection not included' in Section 8.1 above, is indexed and shall be entered into the Uniform File Index by the Program Manager in accordance with Palisades Administrative Procedure 10.46, "Plant Records."

9.0 ATTACHMENTS

Attachment 1, "Steam Generator lnservice Inspection Matrix"

DOCUMENT TITLE

SIG Tube Listing

S/G ISi Report

Examination Procedures

Personnel Certifications

Equipment Certifications

Material Certifications

.PREPARATION/ REVISION

Examination Agency

Program Manager

Examination Agency

Examination Agency

Examination Agency

Examination Agency

e:

STEAM GENERATOR INSERVICE INSPECTION MATRIX

REv'IEW

Pro.g_ra.m Manager

Level Ill

PRC, ALARA, Safety Review, Technical Review (Level Ill)

Program Manager

. Program Manager

.;

Program Manager

APPROVAL

Program Manager

System Engineering Manager

Predictive Testing Section Head

N/A

N/A

Chem · (Consumable · Controls) or Material ·

· Management as required

UFI AND RETENTION

22.21.04/LP

22.21 .06/LP

*

06.03

*

*

* These are not stand alone records:· but are filed as part.of ISi Report. etc.

e Proc No El\n-09-05 Attachment 1 Revision 6 Page 1 of 2

REFERENCE DOCUMENT

N/A

:

ASME Section XI Tech Spec 4.14

Tech Spec 4.14 Admin: 10.41

Admin 10.01 Admin 1.03

. Admin 10.05

DOCUMENT TITLE

NIS-1 Form

NIS-2 Form

S/G Tube Plugging List

S/G Tube Plugging Safety Evaluation

PREPARATION/ REVISION

Program Manager

Program Manager

Examination Agency

Program Manager

STEAM GENERATOR INSERVICE INSPECTION MATRIX

REVIEW

N/A

N/A

Program Manager

Safety Review Team

APPROVAL

Authorized Inspector .

Authorized Inspector

Program Manager

Safety Review Team

UFI AND RETENTION

*

*

*

*

9'ese are not. stand alone records, but ar~ filed as part of ISi Re~-etc.

Proc No EM-09-05 . Attachment 1 Revision 6 Page 2 of 2

REFERENCE DOCUMENT

ASME Section XI

ASME Section XI

ii!!!_"''~'?•;g;;.ll., l!l~-,..!I~ !!il-iiti .. •. ~ .• ililii··-~· ... ii~:'-l'''ji.~ ... !li ........... ~_Eli,lil!i •. •. ~ .. ~ •• !liliP~A~.~~:-~D"E;N ~~~~i ~:_;;,c~:;.-~N~~-.. -~ .. -~Jg-~-.:·"··· .g!),,.~..s!'-J.ll!! •. =.!l!.~~ .... ~. ---~----~-~---~---!li.1!!Ptli!ro~:iii!i. Niji_ ~:t;,Rl!IT~---~~Oii.Ji-.~--!!!li.,,.....,.,~,-~

TECHNICAL SPEC!FICA TION SURVEILLANCE Revi~uun 9 AND SPECIAL TEST PROCEDURE

ISSUE t..:·JD ROUTING SHEET

TITLE: INSPECTION PROGRAM FOR STEAM GENERATOR TUBING

. ISSUED TO S/G Program FREQUENCY Refueling COLD SHUTDOWN REQUIRED {Y/N) Yes

SPECIAL ,RF.QUIREMENTS PCS drained or Steam Generator nozzle dams installed. Testing shall be . .,erformed at an interval of not less than 12 or more than 24 rn'Jnths after the previous inspection. unless directed by the Steam Generator Program Manager in accordance with Technical Specification 4. 14. 1 .25/3.25 extensions are not a11 '1_\•'o::.=.i.--------------

EQUIPMENT EQUIPMENT EQUIPMENT ·EQUIPMENT

E-50A E-508

1 1st LINE SUPV

*2 · SS/SE

. RX E~f;IN EER i----...i

OPS:$E/:$UP SUPV . .

5 SYS J~tf;J,GSEC HD

HP TECH .SUPV i-----i

CHEM'SlJPT .___ ENG PROG SEC HD

ROUTE AFTER COMPLETION (ORDER NO IN BOX)

"IP 1-1 -ie~' 3 SURV PROG. SCH ED

J)5J 11 /~<t/~? 4 systi:M ENG !SI ENG -- DESIGN BNG

92= 1f '?A/r~.....,__- Fl.RE P.ROT SUPV

. li&C ENG· SU.FN -- .G:PS SW.PF-'€>RT SUPV ....

. ··;if · $l:l1RM: RRQ'.G..'SCHED

f ~9:C!>l~t©:~~~~~qt~~-·-· * R¢.:quired oflly if ir:iopera·ble equipmeAt.

ASSOCIATED EQUIPMENT

.f .. :~

[111s:;


Procedure No RT-60 Revision 9 Issued Date 07/30/96

· TECHNICAL SPECIFICATION SURVEILLANC~ PROCEDURE


Procedure Sponsor

·· ....

RHiltennan . I 5/30/96

Technical Reviewer Date

User :Reviewer· Date

Y.

' I-~ :~ . ... I

.i. ,, '.~~ ·" 'i;

,.(._

1 :} -~

Ii .i

'!-

-~

~ .,

:- .. .•.

:~! [1780i _,

~;

? .

r. ;

~.

l f

1 .

2.

3.

4.

5.

6.

: ~ . . ··~~ . . 'PALI SAC' ES NU CLEA~-, PLANT

TECHNICAL SPECIFICATION SURVEILLANCE PROCEDURE .A.CCEPTANCE CRITERIA AND OPERABILITY SHEET

Proc No RT-60 R1:::111sion 9 Page 1 of 2

TITLE: INSPECTION PROGRAM FOR STEAM GENERJ..\ TOR TUBING

Is Section 6.0 acceptance criteria mP.t? DYES ~NO

If "NO'.' box checked, then provide explanation on page 2. (Include justification for equipment operability if applicable.) /)

~ f(~ First Line Supervisor

Is all tested equip111ent operable? DYES

If "NO" box checked, then provide explanation onage 2. . . ~a,.E.

I 11/20Abt First Line Supervisor Date

. Are the Limiting Safety System Settings, applicable LCO Action Statements, or Surveillance Requirements required by Technical Specificc:itions met?

. Chapter 2 Section(s) ~N_o~ne~----------Chapter 3 S.ection(s) _,_.N_,.o,....ne __________ _ Chapter 4 Section(s) 4,0.5. 4,3. 4, 14

DYES

If "NO" box is checked, provide explanation and justification fo~ contir,-.ied Plant

Date

~NO·

'i"! Z..b p.,. .. ;. Time

ftJ NO

operation on page 2. ~. ;';)

-~ fr~ ·r 11/~hb First Line Supervisor Date

If "NO" box was checked in Item 1, 2, or 3 above, identify corrective action docum_ent. ·

CR: ~YES

WR/WO: ~.YES

ONO

ONO

# c-f/-JL-96- 1491 # 2. 4 'ii 3 6 ~I

If "NO" box was checked in Item 1, 2, r

Technical Review Acceptable:

Time

mYES ONO

Retest Required: 0 YES ~NO · Change Frequeney To: ____ _.__

If Technical Review not acceptable, then identify correcti.vP ,~ .. 'on documentfs\:

CR: # Pll L -~6- 14'01_

Signature

5 ... I . ·a ,Pt W•ntsd w·.

Proc ••u RT-60 - ··:1 Revision 9

• :. I PALISADES NUCLEAR :-'LbNT TECHNICAL SPECIFIC,O.TION SURVEILLANCE PROCEDURE

ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA AND OPERABILITY SHEET Page 2 of::

TITLE: INSPECTION PROGRAM FOR STEAM GENERAl OR TUBING

1. Acceptance Criteria _Q.._t ............... r __ , ',..,.....,1-.+-P ..... e-"_£_r_""'-"-" ..... c..,e_-'o'-f''---_e=· J.~bJ~y-_c __ ..... _,._,.. ___ e __ ~'-'f-'-----

F0 ... ,.. f ... Je vv~e,.r (oy viJ fo have

~ob o

I

c-PllL-'76~ 1481 i.vqf 1:,,J,·c.feJ. ne ~1.c.....- . -r~te locc<f:o..,J

9re (fl.,...., - rz. 8 Co!~ .... .., -10.,-) . (((04.1 - 34. G /'-4..,.., -S-1 ) . •

(((ow -J Co/"«...,"i -?4} ( R.owr 116 _C._o/._<-c..,_,..,_-_1'2._.S-2 ______ _

2. Equipment Operability [,., scc.o..-Js...,cf .,..,;fb Tec411ic.sf f'eer-;{;c.i:..f.'o?

Ke ~ *°~ ~ e.-tel"5/or ~; f'1 12/.,,'1'7S hie 1:.,0L.af:0 4J' 6.5,B. c. 2. • S~Q (( ~~r;_,, l"IP f be. J~ fe,,,.,..., ;;i e) c;,(?erq/Je c.c.., f,-1 co '""l'k l-17

3. Technical Specification Requirements 1'1 9cco,.....Jc;.,ce -:f4 ~,4,,;,9 f

I

· ,~J:c.s f-:0.,.,5

Q// re

· lak)e 6.s-. g /. r . . >

PALISAL'ES NUCLEA:1 P~ANT Proc No RT-60 TECHNICAL SPECIFICATION SURVEILLANCE PROCEDURE Revision 9

Page i

TITLE: INSPECTION PROGRAM FOR STEAM GENER'"'TOR TUBING

Table of Contents

1 .0 PURPOSE ........................................... 1

2.0 REFERENCES ......................................... 1

2.1 SOURCE DOCUMENTS . . . . . . .................... 1 .2.2 REFERENCE DOCUMb.iTS ............ : ............ 2

3.0 PREREQUISITES ........................................ 2

3.1 AUTHORIZATION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ................ 2 3.2 SPECIAL NOTIFICATIONS ......................... 2 3.3 PLANT CONDITIONS ............................. 2 3.4 SYSTEM CONDITIONS ........................... 2 3.5 MINIMUM PERSONNEL SKILL LEVEL .................. 3 · 3.6 SPECIAL TOOLS/EQUIPMENT .... , .................. 3

3. 6. 1 Calibrated Egujpment · . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 3. 6. 2 Noncalibrated Egujpment .................. · . 3

3.7 SPECIAL RADIATION PROTECTION REQUIREMENTS ...... 3 3. 8 EXAMINATION/TEST REQUIREMENTS ................ 3

. 4.0 PRECAUTIONS AND LIMITATIONS .......................... 4 .

4. 1 ·OUT OF TOLERANCE DAT A ..... · ................... · 4 · 4.2 PERSONNEL SAFETY ....................... · ..... 4 4.3 EQUIPMENT/PLANT SAFETY OR LIMITS ............... 4 4.4 LIMITING CONDITIONS OF OPERATIONS ENTERED DURING

PERFORMANCE OF THIS SURVEILLANCE TEST .......... 4

5.0 PROCEDURE ........................................ ; 5

6.0

5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4

INSPECTION ........ , .......................... 5 REPAIR .. · .................................... 6 COMPLETION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 REPO.RTS....... . . . . . . . . . . . . ................ 7

ACCEPTANCE CRITERl·A . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ................. ; . . 7

[1783"' .,

j. ~ r ~·

. . . .. : : P'ALISP DES NU CLE hd DLA NT

TECHNICAL SPECIFICATION SURVEILLANCE PROCEDURE Proc No RT-60 Re\11£>1on 9 Page ii

TITLE: INSPECTION PROGRAM FOR STEAM GENEftATOR TUBING

Table of Contents

7.0 ATTACHMENTS AND RECORDS ........................... 7

7.1 ATTACHMENTS ................................ 7 7 .2 RECORDS .................................... 8

[1784]1

PALISACES NUCLEA:-1 P~ANT TECHNICAL SPECIFICATION SURVEILLANCE PROCEDURE

Proc No RT-60 Revision 9 Page 1 of 8

TITLE: INSPECTION PROGRAM FOR STEAM GENER"" TOR TUBING


Refer to the procedure periodically to confirm that all procedure segments of an activity will be or are being performed. Where required, sign ~ooropriate sign-off blanks to certify that c111 segments are complete.

1.0 PURPOSE

To verify operability of steam generator tubing th{ough periodic eddy current testing and repairs. Testing shall be in accordance with Technical Specificati.on 4.14 and Engineering Manual EM-09-05, "Stearr: Generator lnservice inspection."

2.0 REFERENCES

2.1 SOURCE DOCUMENTS

2. 1. 1 Technical Specification Chapter 2 ~ None

2.1 .2 Technical Specification Chapter 3· - None

2.1.3 Technical· Specification Chapter 4 - 4.0.5, 4.3, and 4.14

2.1 .4. · FSAR - 1.2.4, Table 1-2, 4.3.4, Table 4-4, 5. 7 .5.1.2, 6.9,. 14.15, 14.16.3.2

2. 1 . 5 Regulatory Guide 1 . 83, "lnservice Inspection of Pressurized Water Reactor Steam Generator Tubes"

2.1. 6 Palisades Administrative Procedure 10.41, "Procedure Initiation and Revision"

2.1. 7 Palisades Administrative Procedure 9.20, "Te,. 1.-.i_ al Specification Surveillance and Special Test Program"

. :··:,. ·~.

.•.

e

. :PALISADE~ NUCLEAR f>lANT TECHNICAL SPECIFICATION SURVEILLANCE PROCEDURE

Proc No RT-60 Re·Jisinn 9 Page 2 of 8


2. 2 REFERENCE DOCUMENTS

2.2.1. NRC Information Notice 94-05,. "Potential Failure of Steam Generator Tubes with Kinetically Welded Sleeves"

2.2.2 · ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code, Section XI, 1989 Edition

2.2.3 ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code, Section V, 1989 Edition

· 2.2.4 Engineering Manual Procedure EM-09-05, "Steam Generator lnservice Inspection"

2.2.5

2.2.6

·2.2.7

3.0

3.1

Palisades Administrative Procedure 7 .03, "Radiation Work Permit (RWP)"

Palisades Administrative Procedure 7. 15, "Contamination Control"

Pali'sades Administrative Procedure 10.46, "Plant Records"

. PREREOUIStTES

AUTHORl·ZATION

Obtain permission from the Shift Supervisor to perform this test. Shift Supervisor shall read Sections 1 .0 through 4 .. 0 prior to granting perm1ss1on. ·

3. 2 SPECIAL. NOT.IFICATIONS.

3.3

3.4

None

PLANT· CONDITIONS

Cold Shutdown or Refueling Shutdown

SYSTEM CONDITIONS

PCS level no greater than midloop or steam genr aLC.,: nozzle <:lams installed.

[1786"' _,

. I

. PALISADt:S NUCLEAR PlANT TECHNICAL SPECIFICATl.'.)N SURVEILLANCE PROCEDURE=

Proc No RT-60 Ravif:"'1 9 Page 3 of 8


3. 5 MINIMUM PERSONNEL SKILL LEVEL

As required by ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code, Section XI and j

Section V, 1989 Edition.

3.6. SPECIAL TOOLS/EQUIPMENT

Only calibrated Measuring and Test Equipment (M&TE) and Installed Plant Instrumentation (I Pl) shall be us"'<i •o measure parameters which are compared to acceptance criteria.

3 . .6. 1 Calibrated Egujpment

3.6 . .2

. 3.7.

3.7 .1

3.7.2

3.8

3.8.1

.3.8.2

Listed in approved working level procedures.

Noncalibrated Equipment

Listed in approved working level procedures.

SPECIAL RADIATION PROTECTION REQUIREMENTS

Work in Radiation Controlled Are.as shall be performed in acco.rdance with Palisades Administrative Procedure 7 .15,. "Contamination Control" and with the appropriate Radiation Work Permit (RW.P).

The RWP shall be submitted to the Radiation Safety Group in accordance with Palisades Administrative Procedure 7.03, "Radiation Work Permit (RWP)~" .

EXAMINA Tl ON/TEST REQUIREMENTS

Examination requirements and a listing of tubes to be examined shall -have been developed and approved in accordance with Engineering Manual Procedure EM-09-05, "Steam Generator lnservice Inspection."

Vendor's Test Procedures shall be reviewed and aJ;>proved in ac;:cordar:iGe · with Palisades Administrative Procedure 10.41, "Procedure lniti:ati.on· 'clnd Revision."

I

I '"

[1787j

--

. :PALISADE~ NUCL~AR '"".~NT TECHNICAL SPECIFICATION SURVEILLANCE PROCEDURE:

Proc No RT-60 Revi!.> .... ;n 9 Page 4 of 8 ·

TITLE: INSPECTION PROGRAM FOR STEAM GENERAT.JR TUBING

4.0 PRECAUTIONS AND LIMITATIONS

4.1 OUT OF TOLERANCE DATA

Palisades Administrative Procedure 9.20, "Technical Specification Surveillance and Special Test Program," specifies that "all out of tolerance data shall be circled in red by the person recording that data." In lieu of this specification, all indications of tube wall degradation exceeding the plugging limit sha;· 1 1 reported on a Condition Report for disposition.

4.2 PERSONNEL SAFETY

4.3

4.4

Care shall be used when working from elevated µlatforms and scaffolding. Ensure that adequate lighting exists on platforms and scaffolding.

EQUIPMENT /PLANT SAFETY OR LIMITS

All tubes with eddy current indications meeting the repair criteria .of Technical Specification 4.14.s.hall be repaired prior to startup following the examinations.

LIMITING CONDITIONS OF OPERATIONS ENTERED DURING PERFORMANCE OF THIS SURVEILLANCE TEST

None

[ 1 7 8 c

-··---· -· ~~.-.... -~

PALISADES NUCLEAR Pl~ TECHNICAL SPECIFICATION SURVEILLANCE PROCEDURE

Proc No RT-60 Rcvisio·' '3 Page 5 of 8

TITLE: INSPECTION PROGRAM FOR STEAM GENERATOq TUBING

5.0 PROCEDURE

5.1


Refer to the procedure periodically to confirm that all procedure segments of an activity will be or are bein~ : ;rformed. Where required,_ sign appropriate sign-off blanks to certify that all segments c:ire complete.

INSPECTION

Perform eddy current examinations of steam generator tubing in _accordance with Engineering Manual EM-09-05, "Steam Generatur lriservice Inspection." The specific tubes to be examined shall be. as approved by the Steam Generator Program Manager. Record the following:

Work Order Number(s) E-S-oA {i.45"/~65/)

1 E-S-oB (24S-1369G)-

·. Inspecting Organization Wes f;rzcr ho '1 s e.

Contract/Purchase Order No* coo /88 44

Location of Test Records D cc u,,,,Jer 2- 2 . 21. 04 u F [

" ·() Completed By: IC __ /(~ ' 11/z_s/~6

Steam G-enerator Ptogram Manager bate ·

*Applicable only if an external agency performs the inspection.

'

1

•. PALISADES l\'UCLEAR PL\NT

TECHNICAL SPECIFICATION SURVEILLANCE PHOCEDURE

... ~~ . ' .

. ····-·- ·····~

Proc No RT-60 Revision 9 Page 6 of 8

TITLE: INSPECTION PROGRAM FOR STEAM GENERATOri TUBING

I 5.2

1-. 5.3.

5.3.1

5.3.2

REPAIR

CAUTION

The use of kinetically welded sleeves may increase tube stresses and induce tube cracking per NRC Information Notice S4-05, "Potential Failure of Steam Generator Tubes with Kinetically Welded Sleeves."

Based on the ECT results, plug or sleeve defective t· ;bes in accordance with Engineering Manual EM-09-05, "Steam Generator lnservice Inspection."

Work Order Number(s) ) !3-'501} (z.451365"1

Repair Organization Wesf,t?/404Se.

Contract/Purchase Order No* Coo/8844

Locatign of Repair Records Fled ....,; f4 i-vorK ordp..- 245"136r;-1 c;..,cJ· sc-96- 06 €>

~ /?~ 111 /zeh6 Completed By: Steam Generator Program Manager Date

*Applicable only if an external agency performs the repair.

COMPLET,ION

Upon completion of the above, fill out the Acceptance Criteria and . Operability Sheet. The test and repair records of Steps 5.1 and 5.2 form the basis for the operability determination on the Acaeptance Crioteria and Operability Sheet.

Documentation of final steam gene-rater closeout to allow refill.in!!:J and pressurizing the PCS are controlled by Work Orders.

;

} ;. .1

[1790

------!!la------~~"-· -== _ .. ,

.PALISADE~ NUCLEAR •. 1-.ANT TECHNICAL SPECIFICATION SURVEILLANCE PROCEDURE

Proc No RT-60 Revi:::. ~n 9 Page 7 of B

TITLE: INSPECTION PROGRAM FOR STEAM GENERATQR TUBING

5.3.3

5.4

The Steam Generator Program Manager shall inform the Surveillance Scheduler of what the next surveillance interval shall be.

REPORTS

NOTE: The clock for all reports starts when item 3 on the Acceptance Criteria and Operability Sheet is signed off. ·

a. Within 15 days following .: .:: completion of each inservice inspection of steam generator tubes, the number of tubes plugged in each steam generator shall be reported to the NRC in accordance with Technical Specification 4.14.

b.

c.

The complete results. of the steam generator tube inservice inspection shall be submitted to the NRC within 1 2 months following completion of the inspection in accordance with Technical Specification 4. 14.

In accordance with Technical Specification 4.14, results of steam ·generator tube inspections that fall into Category C-3 shall· require 24 hour verbal notification to the NRC prior to resumption of plant operation. A written report followup within the next 30 days is required.

6.0 ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA

6. 1 The steam generator tubes are operable upon ~ompletion of examinations · required l:i>y Technical Specification 4.14 and the satisfactory repair of any defective tubes.

6.2 Acceptance criteria for the steam generator tubes are specifi~d in Technical Specification 4.14.

7 .0 ATTACHMENTS ANO RECORDS.

7.1 ATTACHMENTS

. None

I

[17911.

--

• )~: ..

PALISADES NUCLEAR P:..A~~1 TECHNICAL SPECIFICATION SURVEILLANCE PROCEDURE .

... ···-······--·- -· --------··--~·--""""

Proc No RT-60 Revisiu11 9 Page 8 of 8

.... ITLE: INSPECTION PROGRAM FOR STEAM GENERATuR TUBING

.7.2 . RECORDS

7.2.1 All inspection records generated in accordance with Steps 5.1 and 5.2 shall be entered into the Uniform File Index in accordance with Engineering Manual EM-09-05, "Steam Generator lnservice Inspection."

7. 2. 2 This procedure shall be entered into the Uniform File Index if' accordance with Palisades Administrative Procedure 10.46, "Plant Recorps."

· • • • form nis-1 owner's report for inservice inspections as required by the...

Documents