729809664.tabiin
DESCRIPTION
World economy developmentInterpretationsTRANSCRIPT
-
:!"#$%&'()* +,-" ./01:234567 +89:;?
-
: / !"# $% & '(")*+ ,- '.*/- 0* $1 23"4- .( 6 6:'7- " 80+
!)9 :# ');. @:."1 'A.B)!)9 :# 27- " 80+ );;?/;(
ISBN: 978-600-6350-22-6 ;;EEEE A3:F-G HG *7I J-% K3".
$L%#.;. BB$& $%MN ) ).>. F-- BB$& )$%MN ).
-
P&
F-G \&M
-[ ............................................................................................................................................... ;
$ (1 ..................................................................................................................................... B;B;/G g :,&M "d# ................................................................................................ ;hB;i3 0] 1* A"G *"j" ........................................................................................ >E;B>B;k%L ............................................................................................................................ >E>B>B;W"* N ................................................................................................ >>B;)/% ....................................................................................................................... >B; -- ........................................................................................................... >UUB>B;WG 3 .......................................................................................................................... >T
h;B
-
QTB)" .................................................................................................................................... ?O
>B>W0 $K3 k%L % nIL:("- % "d# ........................... T?;B>B>q3 $& .F- ...................................................................................................... =;>B>B>)v 3L% )v --w . ....................................... =F-- ) ] [3) % ' / W"* 0] ............. =?
$+ :/"r ) $K3 $G G *"j" ! .............................. ;EO oNs k%L ......................................................................................................................................... ;;O
, W"* g"- WG LL# ( -- N eM- .........................................;;= b] &] " 'P3" ^ -
$ ...................................................................................................................................................... ;>; ;BO >B;B?
- R;B
-
>B;B>BO~[ # .............................................................................................. ;=? BOk3/"/% # ................................................................................................ ;=T
>B>BO,% /% ............................................................................................................................ ;=h ;B>B>BOFN-3/ /% ....................................................................................................... ;=h >B>B>BOg) ) oc-- ........................................................................................ >E> B>BO! (L3Gr ............................................................................................................ >E<
EO OBO)/% A" ....................................................................................................................... >ET UBOZ (- ..................................................................................................................... >;;
;BUBO/-/r 3/% ("% ]+[.................................................................................... >;> ;B;BUBOgr J" $ML -r..................................................................>;O >B;BUBO-r Q"L ............................................................................................................... >;?
>BUBO3" !L# %% " ).................................................................................. >;h ;B>BUBO$ -r ................................................................................. >>E >B>BUBO3Gr ] .......................................................................................................... >>< BUBO3Gr A1 $N )"d# ................................................................... >>< OB>BUBO%"L -r .......................................................................................................... >>O UB>BUBO\# /"` p 43r........................................................................... >>U
>? ;B
-
;B;BU %$3| ) "" ......................................................................................... >OO >B;BU+3 F $%LZ (r (r................................................................................. >O= UO OB;BUf7] )#/- k3/" F ................................................................................... >?;
>BU)%# )" r .......................................................................................................... >?O ;B>BU -- W"*
, LL# L0% :') k%L W"* % ...... >??
;B;B>BU! ) ............................................................................................................. >?? >B;B>BU! \)" ,I ............................................................................................. >T; BU%L1I ) % ....................................................................................... >T<
>B>BU o ! q3 $& ..................................................................................... >TT ;B>B>BU$3- K $& .............................................................................................. >Th >B>B>BU$3- 43:G $& ............................................................................................ >h; B>BU%% $& .......................................................................................................... >h>
BUF-- ) & : 7N ................................................................... >hh ;BBUW"*
, LL# A, ( /% F"4` ................................................. >h=
>BBU$0N /% & ............................................................................................. >=> =T
-
>B;B?$%Lm- $0^K 'F0* ! $3- o 43:G 7# F- ................................................................................................................................ U
-
Q $6# F6- 6 $6c $,6-" 6 6 6% 6, 6- )$]" 6]"N 6| 6K3 6- 6) '6 /r 6+ $6M% '/6-
)/% /-/r 6 f6M (r F6m )6 6L#.'(6-L 6% $6}rF-- '()cd F6-- (/- F61) (oc6-- F63 (/6
$]" 3 / $Z W1* /"` $ F- $0^K 3 -% 6| F- ) )"6d 6j "6L "6% nG" 63 601* 6% 6Z 6 )N6-
F-- F- $o V ) .Q $}r 6
Q6 6c3 / 6) :31 $%d L'F-- 01* -% % 6) @6N F,j $% $" % )
F- "d .Q 7N% $3| -% % $ c3 ) ) "6% F33 (r r )" " "N $M Q 3 'LL# "d )
$ML $G3 k1+ / $ML "d ) $6G3 ' L16/ 6)$]" )c- % K% -- )F- $j* oc.
W` / $ Q 3 L"N F- "N% ! Q6 $G3 % ! | 7N 3) 6 c0G6w "6N L% "6 6 "6L $6 6%3
$% %+ $% % $ F- :Z (r / d% \ 6 | 6- .633 / ("d Q P0[ % l: ) 6L^1M $6# F- (
cd " &6* f"M6- 6 g6+ 6L 6)) 6 6-L(F-- ) L}1) 6% 9 .6% Q6 63 /6 / / 6
$6% $6ML "d ) "% ([ 6) 6 $NL6 (6-L 6
-
> 2
________________________________
% 3 $ F- 001&W0 8 "d ) / 1* FNL \" 6)$% W0 3r " % $Gc W g * 8 / qG ).
Q 3 $1 q-" G ,&M !)96 : $"% $% 6) 860+ 7- " 61) $6% 1- 1 zN 1 10* | % F
g6+ 6% 6r $61) / +L3 $ $G "] *+ ,- .*/- 0* d / 3 " . 6d% g+ $L/ Q 3 d F-
&, % $ (3 (7 /"` .
&7 .# # !)9 :# 8 )
-
3#Q k: / F- $/L0%# $4 $$,-"; (r $%
r . 3 $K% /#)"dp6 '$,6-" A6` "N% ( P0[ nIL $L/ P0[ *"j"$#.'(r / 8 $]7N / .)G "j" ) $# r (6 P60[ nI6L .)6%3$6K 6 #6L ."1+3$]7N )WG ) P0[3#d Q4W).6,% g6 6
"%#/ $3G$)3b- /G " ,&M #"d1* "]. (I[3#Q6 (c6d)9 6'#6& (6-L'!6 (6cN"r $1) #KW4dL) #% $! $L/ 6 $]* 6# 6 (7
$ww '#)"d$,-" A` 6 $601 / 63 ( 66 6- .$}r $#3#/ QQ# )361 6c3:6 6L#'6GG / \6&M#06d$6)
3 )-F-#\0w $Q# )$,6-" ,3F6G 6 "6.( L"N%3 Qo \&M bL)"N (r P0[ A"G 3F6G ."6N%
FK[(1 % Q# F%o '$%" "%#p6 (6"N $6% r $6d( _"-.>% 3 , P0[ *"j"Q# 3 /%P60[ f"M6- n
)#-L #(R[- F- .#F&` Q 3,1& $" ' $6% 63 L,#,% $% WG ) $@N /3 }6 6 /6 8#6) 6%
$ww 93 % "G] WG3]N A"G $,&M #L.____________________________________________________________________ 1. The Global Development Network (GDN)
>. p 3 F3- / ("GDN $%r F-.
-
O 2
________________________________
%r$4(I[ 3#]N d QK)L*" q0K .)0c (%/ $%K'3A- fM"#& $Z (r $1 WFKut- % '%3Fb #W6] $3#Q$%A`) $1) J- "& 6(I[ $1) / :6 "6 1) 6 F
L% k0M (r 6`W] #0c (%/ $% QK: F6 6 J6- '.)/% p1`r $% (r ("N3L $&` g"0,2#13L4)" $Q6# 6)"N0c (%/ $%K "#$$%.w1) $% (*X&M F6d'( $6%#6L .3FK#$ $1) #Q .c(6"N A1` :
% (rdL#$& 6$1 #b%"N F$% . 3#Q (61 ' "N l7# $1 $j* ("2% $Z 3(6*X F6 6# $641
F-#7 /3a&" nG"L% .F0* FK[3F- $61 $# 6LG ("6L1) $1Q# )-FK2 $ZK% 6-G (%/ W6# 6r :6$1) $ %)b `7M] ( ! .3 6% $.$6% 76*'6
# Q0c (%/ $% :K (34N"Ld $" F- Z 6#" $3 L6K "6N ( "1*0cK (%/LK.$%.w $1)3F3 )l7 '%L $j* $6-"N:#1F- "% z3( L"N Q#)"NL#.
%(1#/- $ [G 3/ ( % "6N 1* d3N H-# $,-" $ww '#$ww "d ]1) WcdF6-#K% 8 $/F&,G )10**16 (r $1 $01 / 63 #Q6 6
.(rK%L/r 0] l (r "N L# $3#Q6% $66" 66"-F66- '(/66-oc66-- (F66-- 66 P660[ 66,% $66% (} )\0 L# $,-" 3"& (3 / "1) g /- !.(6r
3(% '$ 3 g/p "N L /(p"^K #:!)96 6)860+'6]"N r QL#1- #1) $6F# Q63G 6L 6d (r 6d / 6"G'
d4LL#.G"n$1)rg #)#-L-"N N / L1/3..
-
) #K#L[- $"1*$ #3LZ L[- 6#FF6- $6' #* $"j" (7G6 $6 $% /1)$6d $6 A6 $6%
F )"N .d4 W3 +L#b F6- .6%6LZ#61 Q6/`| '(" LZ /3b- $ " #.A`'d4 W3 F6- 6# $
( (r /#% $ g3$ .L#./ 3)0] A"G#Q'"N$]7N F- ] /$6G "6] 6[2
3% \ N- $]7N l7 g#)#% 1VF- . & (")-4"3{:% # $3#d[% Q(r / ]" F-P#'#$% $6#/ (r ($L/ .)FK.LZ 83 4$# / $ 3#.L6)X $% Q
-F- fML#..L3 /G " (r4 3d$6)36K)L6#I $/ 6,%r3#- $ 3I / $6Z 'F- $ 6361+ n% W01& 7* $Z 3$G` n#F- $,-" % q $'$Z 6,M
(r A"`FK.l/ # 3r# $3 cL)1) % F- d"# 4$,6-" $
# "N $-G :" /4$)$,-"$ML %$6 1 6# F)6 $/3-G %(") K-d)9 WK#)"6d 63/ .6K%/
( . $L/l7 % '$,-" ,&M )6d(/6- 3$6G $6# [d. 3"j" ) #$6" (r 6% 6) 6 $1) $6K).'
# :#1 2]$4L3 $01/:[G $"cZ#)"dG #LL16j '. $6"cZ
-
? 2
________________________________
,j# Q"N $d[% "% FK..LZ,j $%"NQ"N "N1"6. FL& $b $%3'F} $K3 #)"dG% #)"d$,-" 3$G'$6}r $6% $6#
.dZ "N 3K% 3F-. .G %3 3fM "("6Z '#ML $%3% 2(r/ : $# "3 ( LK3% 6-66) / !Z:d)9 (.
3% ]N $*"1+ L* /3 3"6 6)# $6#X63(r W(/- ) ": k%L 6 6# 6 6)/% '6 6N 6 '(7
--.3$I L%L 6% N6-060F6- 6#% $6% 6d 6)I - -w3F- \.3 k%L $% c " %"ZZ / 'db6- 6-
"2G $% 4 LZ-# $3 $% 3Q[ $6% $6" c3F6K 6# $ (r$1) (# #)"dG6` A6 ( $,-" A` F6-)63F- .#r& ( $% "6 6# $6% 6%$6% 6# 6,L]$3- , $Gd"% $.( 3 '6K% 364% 6- 6 c
%K` Q"ZZ$%&, Q"ZZF-.%K` Q"ZZ c3 K` #$% $" $F16-6)/36L%3'
$% @"N)- $% "%3G $:34K "M,6L#. 63F6K#WK $/ 3% % 3W`WG ""b *"j" '.6 6: "# $`7] /- (dF- j .-3G $:346 ("6
G%" ]#23$4L3 IN $% (G6)4'W61 $6% 6# 6r G% % .- " 3K $ '3 ' $1) A- )6G $6- 63
R[7/ ". )3L $%6 $64L3 6K $36- "6N 'L%)3%&"- 3K $ .%d G[ $%+ / 6L 6#$
N%/- '$- *-3K $#1c3 % J &" *-L#6L .K $+L- .- F /3K $'"6% J6- 6&" $6Z 6K% 6N%
)1, ! % l/"r 7 #)"dG W` #.
-
____________________________________________________ bcdT
%K` Q"ZZ:63 F36c 6# $6L3G c3)6 $6% 6KF6) b)%% g+- nIL #)"dK bLWL#.6LZ nML
K3$)3:& $%("- )A% "d#L61 "6.$6% 6| 6, F- A"#$FK ") A $% $}r $# 93 6)6d#)"6d
- 3F- k "]% #)"d$6K)r )'6c3 (6% $6% 63G L1V )"d#(:$%1)W1* $" "6 .61 "6 6) 636]" b
1" ) # "d ("}1)$M 3k%| '#% $#)"d3cG] , / #v6% b ))v W6 $6&6) b6] 63.(
Ld F- 3 "#o#$$%6
"I / 6% 630 n66K W 6dG $%K3$)#$% "d#"d " $N .
'( 3 G * 7N " F1) K% : . 6 6363#v $1) "d) \-L 63\-L 6* $% A` #L663$6% F*6-6
L#F- 'L#$G]" $b :3% 3$* 6%)63Q"6N (/" / 63 k% A1`.)0#$I$) LZ )d"'1("6 $6"1
/" /3L, A1` kFK .-%n34/ "6* 76N 6 6" $6% %dL,$,-" % %+ .7m G'3Q- /%#3n%6M 816K
1L) $ % %W] .) $% (r L# (r "d nG" &$% % #'/ A1`#$#, p% Q" .* A` c1)$% $%+L#%/% $Ln L3G $6% A6`)3%"N F- "# 3%r-$# Q- Z /%# 1L#.
##$3:+ W0 k%L%#"d,'k,-1[ (r Z:F-#/ $|L L*)G:34(6LG'F-$% c3 $6%m64
% $}r $|`7#$|/--6$%F- r F-3F- 3LGF- .`o L# %!- ) $% "% 3#['%3Kb 3i634F )X $ #$#)"dGp"1, $LG6)$NL6 6 '
(LZ dLK.#)"dG$%A"1, "I ,"F#"d) "z* 641) $,6-" (/-
-
h 2
________________________________
; '$%"I $#1 L4LG J6- "6" A6- r3L'$Z"% )"N .3#"d)1` $%/ A3K ( $%F1-,jA6
L#L#W / $d3 % .3LG J g:0K) $Gd 6"" 6016-3G $:3646K "6 6 6% /6% 6%(r /
p1`3/ +3FN- ) *1 g/pF-. $% (1 3\K`% $0^K \& L%"6G $6)% *" $% '"% )"N.#G "d,- / 3)d $M $M (r $% $# $%L
(" 3 '3 eM- /3LG % % p% eM- $% .6 $& .6)" nG"'K )"N##/ $3 $%c3 6 '-% 63 6K
7] $K 3` $ F-7#Z (r:F-#"^ $6 r# 6"% (r $%".K % $% "% ` ( 36K% (64 63 '
"$# FZ):/3 "..| ML,% g 'p61` 6 6N 6 "6% 6)"N .(6
"N $G #$ G3l LJL% .#3% +Ll L$-("%F- . "|L 3G F- #) $ $}r, )'3% F6- I6N
#N% $/# (: ]N %: 3%L% '36-$6% (#W6 cK% $%3F )"N #$FG3 ("% Z3@[ 3"N )3cL% )3F& )(LZ $% g #)3#.3M% $%(r% 76# 6 6b 6# $
#c J-% (: :)]"NW1*L# Lk G6] 6 $%LG" bL o )3L,`#/-m%"0M[ F$6" %
] $%3$"% F.() Gl LJF6- [ * 3 $# $}r#N% (: /L$)g+L)'$%"] *61,6 6
F-[ kb %G] G3 $0]G $.) ,% N 3cW4d 6L) 6#$J6-% (r)6
$ML 30 )30 ("L/ 343cb%L.p1` 06] $0^K ____________________________________________________________________ 1. Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD)
-
____________________________________________________ bcd=
3) +Lc F:)G $% $ 'n3I /"3g"-3c3 /6% 6*"F- .$#+r/ #bL (: &" \"%3)L0"6'
K $4L3 $"cZ" qg $% +L #(: "F61) .3:&-- - "j"FK.'$ 6LZ A6m 6d /476#$
%w ( ~[) #X ".G3 $4L3( g* ~" 6)6*7I#)"6d$,6-" A6`
$% / #)"d$,-" 3$G F1)'\+, (LZ FK :c% .L}1)$%| -# 6% A g"6- ) "L $63F6- 6#6LZ $6" )6K%
b) ") 3W` P0[ $% $,-"")(" " W1* L#L23% \%" % _M)*7I')) $%b
6& n3I $% c $%:)b 6 /L.1) % , 'J 3 MN3Kk6" "6 6 $61) ("%
Gp1`q 36) 6MNL1V k6" / 6 6 .6 6K%3t#')"6d: 3L$)K%, /7, ) %% %% ( $136K663
w 3$0% "]#(r % ( 6$ L#..6) 6% 63c6:6)6G#(: ' $%4$% r J- /I0#$3$G cK% %3.
KG "z` 6$Z"1*$Z]"N6l )3#$ 63 $6M` $6% 6# c % ::)6%L% 3 % 6V F6o )"N .6 (6%p"1,#Gr3LK L# L#K# $6% $636#A"v6d 6 # $,-" (: L2 N%3'q#Gr3L14F- "- 6)3F
( $%F1-XN F"dN % $ % .p1`3"j" $6d3 c:)fM )060 6)63[ 6, .r63"6 #Gr3L $%4/ $+ W1&% (G#Gr3LuF- % 6r $6&6
F-#$g#) W` / $,-": 3L$)3c:6# 6%L.4$6 6#$ ."#%(# .L3F-#$,-" N $Z ':G F- / 6# %
J ) $N"r)#Q/fI (A.
-
;E 2
_______________________________
1)F$3- o KN .d #$F# )0LZ 36+L fM k%L $% "% $- ) :".c $&":)"-3$6 .
%3- c:)3# ) $0 %F# 6)06LZ6c3$3- o N (.)GL#Z LFK u3 .) %3- $#c:6)3
#60 6 ) $6%F#6 6)06LZ6c3 $36- o6 (F# )N.)GL#L$ZV%c:)#(: 0Lu
/- L )/%#3)LK#$#G (: r % W,L#0% 'L 64 $p61 `. L3(d .) F3)/% 6 'F6%G 6$61) ("6% A"16 '6*7I
%% bL" o6k%L /c .:)$%"N#G (: $%1
3r .% W"* (1) 3# A /%c:)G $%3i: c $%:)/ c3#(: 6/ 3p7N % N "- ))6`#..
(4 "L/% 'F- K .(" 6%0 6 6- W6)/%NG'FG3)/%6#6)/% '66)$M6- 6)/% ''6*
)/%K46/ /%$6# g6#) 6 66b6K)LF&p )b:%c:)% G36 )L .6% /6% Z6:6G /3q]$ ~[d " .6)6d 6| '/6%,L$M` G36+ 6 L#6L .3% 6L 63 6% $6M% 6)
(% ) FG | :#3%% '% " c3)/%. /3% W, )/% L}1) c 6:6) (6% '6) f6I 6)
`7]$%"|L$,-"'%3~[d "#$"cZ $(" /)/% (.6) $% q $%!FG) ""$% : FG #.
Nr3"j" 1) 0#- '-F- $,-" .( 3 Z6:(:G / Kb&1` ` * /31- - " .6G
g# $LZ .)"N!- )3-% #.L:$Z 6)363#"6d kb $,-" / @N d% % p1`(" d6r F6G 6 u
$Z )36 F- 41F- .#6"# 6 $6Z 6K% 6L0% 6 :6/63(
-
___________________________________________________ bcd;;
% 'LL 8H- p1` $,-" P&[" u)$%* c3'$,-" (b&[ (") $Z#KK)L($Z u"#)(" 6%/63(63( '6# (6% $4L3 I[ $% $,-" "NuG/'6-- 6|L 6# /6wr `76] g 6L3G $,-"'K)L#g 36,% 6 " 6LZ 6L "6t6- u !6- 6)3
/3F-cK% ,M $%3) t /) "" !#' $6ML "d / $# F- 1)-%)#"d( 3 j !L)"N F.
$b3#`I Q%$)$,-" 6r 6% (3/ ] 0% 'F6K 64 $ " /wr $d m . %(r$- /%$)$,-"#$|/-6-
K)L)3F- .#g )1$%"- $,6-" $6% 6 16 6L3r(% ./ 93 ) . /% % "3F6- 6#(6 (6- $1*!)9 "N / $N"r#)"d$,-" A` .F- #N6- $
3 4'$K3$)% 001&1) 4K 3/ F- !)9 '% 1) A3d$)l ) 3i'"d3" n3F#L.36K[ L !6[%(r /
Z:F-# $1) $.3K0- $0 1) 6,&M 64"3 $,6-" 6 $6 1 " (r% .% :% 1+% W01&'3F- [G $6#$
%3.M .
"&"- % K-LG $F-"Z-
-
: ! "#$ %& ' #(
-
)"*+,-./ 0+12
7% F--%k $% 3/ 3%6)
$&" /#)"d$,6-" A6` 63 #)"6do6 A6` ]$60` $6%$,-" cG3 3/% .[3 # $46 $,6-" $)6L1+6d4/ W66K- 66oc66--'66# (r 66) $366+ 66 $66%o 66
$% # $LZ ! $6]* oc6--F6- $,6-" 6) 6% (. (r /dL#' F-#* $34cZH 16 F6&`#:F6-
G (r \I[ fI$" / L# ( .)#![% $g"- f6 Wb $% 6 "6(r 6% '/"60]$%F- ,&M / r$ML # " ."6 % 'FK[ $64L3
,&M$ML $L/ "1 3. W"* c ,
#'6% LL3,&M #1LZ] $% [ p,b W,G 0] 6%v 6)36#$
` ! 6 n63 6 61 L#6L .g 6$6% k6 $64 F6K[ 6#)"d3#$a&/v)
, 0] 6LL# ,6j%6d F6'\60w
01*4( |/' K% b /343cF- .,&M*"j"$ML
-
______________________
A WG : eM- ;T
.+L ![%3%+ i$ . Nr ![% 6 :6%$6+ 6 6)J )3%,&M#"d/G g F- 6# $$6% k6 6r F6- /
,&M$ML \&M 1)#Q .
343 ! 56/& 678 (1) $" #$! ' 3F- /G W # $3#Q$%$%m 60
F-r ( .A /G )# $41F- W( %, $& *"6j"F6-#eM- $$ML g+ 6 6 .g /6G 6# $63A6- WS 6 6'
d4` / Wb) $,&M#"dF-.
34343 9 ::#,"&; "g#)-% /)$ML %"j" Z ] ./G [FK[%c-N6) W"* ,LL# #1 (7#:F- ,6- .)6G N6- $6]7N /W0 )% #"d%#,&M $% $#"d6/ .
g $,&M' !V )/% -% ."3-% % ( LK6##)/%0] '$%93 /%#- 3$'/ $%3%(:Vo F6m 63 6bL
01* r4$N .01* g"- $,&M4 `r 6N eM6- L3G -% 1 %#cL% )"N % :)"6j" $% 36) 6L8 / % "N R[ 'l/"r$3- o %cL)![% #/6d6 % $N".Z$,&M ~[- 6-6 F6- .(6%
N%oc-- )61 W6* 301* 6b 6+ 64 6 $6% 16
'L3r p#$$L/- -$6" 6 6 63 6% 6n L#L#$Z#N% )"d/F-- )$6% )"6 6% $6" .6w6L 6%
4r FK(#1# 'AL#L.
,&M $ML ' ) %3%"ZZ %6,&M g+#"6d$6% 'K (: /!)9 )" )%+6% "6"6336G$6) 6%
-
;h 2
_______________________________
$G $% $K%)nG "" )L0% - +L 6% $&6-g6+W0 ) % n)N.dZ )/r3L $%$G # 6 .6L}1)/ l73Kb f ]F6- 6 \6&M 6#I / $63~[6d nN6-
L/$)3#-% $ % nj r dF-L}1) #)"d3#/ $ L $)-% L/0 $ W'( j" eM6- e
,&M#"d3)"N -.%" WZ / !3 $6,&M " $ML ! ) / LK A /6G 6 6#F
L .3(cd)9 641) $6% 6%3643c6 6LN 6L}1) / #61$K% ( #% $ kG4$ A#1)[: % 6r $% 63
"%
b- :#.; g 3$ML '/ g+ 63%W6K pr d / !"-/ 1+% 001&A- S { "%.
-
______________________
A WG : eM- ;=
I," #"dK "c& / b$6Z '6 6|/#61$6Z |/#b) '.%" )3 % ( LK3& q$$# ,6j W
Foc--% / $o )--Xk6b F6-'"63 L#L.0 8H-0%"3/ F- 6 g6+ 6 :6 W6"*
r G %%" )%3 6 W6"* 6G W6% $6M% 2v
oc-- 2 a& $% ) $+$+$" )v6
') .F-- )' )Xk6b-6-$6" )v6
.6 6c3~N )/" 'G L $,-"3 l/"r 'F% 'r k/ q3FK.
'(r / 8"3( LK e3d $%$+ 6)06]0 g6+ / W6]` 6 W / .3#% #&" W"* %#j" $ e6#(7!6% /$1) ' F1) F-- )) 3#6K \6" $W63 36 k6 6+
F3% b- &" W"* / $L"'"] 3o .(:G %'L3 "63r3 L# (7#$,&M " "d 61) $6% : L6d )-6-6
% " .g+-" '3f ( LKL) #6 $3i$6% F6- 6r$"cZ *"j" ,&M fM WK ( $%#1L#L.$}r $# /$+ )$%F- 6` / 6r 6b) $6,&M#"6dW6]` 6 "6'$+b0;F-#/ $3%3$K #$%*"j" ,&M6 /6wr
"% -% " +) 1, \" (r n".LZb0 66` 6/3Lw \"(!)9 6 [ )" )#$$& .6) #("6LF- K k : )"N 6.
@43439 #,' 6/&78 3# f $% Q (r $/.g#) 06] W6G Z /6% 34,&M !" "j" Z / $6ML F6- .) / 6) 63 /
r : -%3iA /G J-% F- $,&M " nIL "j" .3% 6\'____________________________________________________________________ 1. Synthesis
-
>E 2
_______________________________
/ A"G3| #F) $ )b )%$ML ~[6d 6 /6-'"6N#%WK .7 Nr WG% F-,&M (cd)9 $" \0#"d$%0K#/G $A3 $c3$" #GF- d r $%.
-
______________________
A WG : eM- >;
$o F-'3$G ( LK3" 1*3F- #)- " % $$6" "6N 3J` )3(d L% /()';3% A` FG3o 3% 6# 6d W6` W6K $
3/ fI \" $L!- )%, t-"6.$6# 61 $6b !6[%1* WG $ / :6 "#o $6% )"6 $63#6LL 61) @6N $601 %3.
,% ![% %K` " "" $dL ' L %6-% !6- F W*36 $6% 6#6L0% 6 n6 WF6- .%$64L3
)"%g#) /3 3$ "" '3( LK# L#L6#$d4% q 7)l -L)"&(6 (LZF6- 6# $61 ("6
(LZ/ *3%3i$%F- W r .$6# 61 $6b : )"6 " 33# nIL $- F3p% $'% W"*
#% Wd:$ .- $G3 1,.3o 6%'6 6" 6% $6% A:G3 L3) (.
"3/ $6% 8H- ( LK 63%346)$6ML 6L 6% 6- (">b4k%L / . "j" Fm $L3F- #$J-% 3$G )6r'(
P0[ nIL "d% F1) $#/(r$01 :3& q'$8/ $3- o $M`KG :34,1 ''Foc6--6#'\6-L (7
/r-F ' ]"N ![% \-L | '#b6 Q"0M F ' /#:) \3$L)F& .7* %3' / ,%/-/r g+]6[61)
v):) o6 A6` 6L 6#)"6d$,6-" A6`1)FL%3 .d4 W3F-+L#$ 3 (Z $1):1)F6 631 63%oc--'$%A`) %"0MF- . 3("3( LK 6&" $% k$6) l$-L LZ" 3L:%3 "6- 6 n$6L $6L/l 6-L
("- )$ML /wr .____________________________________________________________________ 1. Growth Fundamentals 2. Regression-based
-
>> 2
_______________________________
k1 r L%( 1) $%FW0 )L %/$6L;"6 6,&M #"d>L#L.0$% "% Wk%L $% 1) 6- 6#$
(" $L/3$" W0 )' (r )/% $M&:
-
______________________
A WG : eM- >? 2
_______________________________
% L3L* .4&N%3c%{:% /6 ( #6]6[6# 6 6/.( c L"#3 3b i6L) ej" 26% 6(r / !6%63$64
#L#L#$K$)^61M 63 6% 86% 66 63` $6ML/#K%%dF-.rl *" -L)"&($L#L# $63
0](r(" #
LZ:W6&3L64$]$6+ F6-- 6)6$6%a& [#,j / 1% F$L; "'1) 6>6% (c6dL# 6 @N F- .3#//%6L#6#$oc6-- ( 6L31 q6G !6[% kG6L
#Z"4L% '3" , L"#` $4r F"36L $6% F6- 6N%/6 )"[ '/ 3 "N L" L}1) 6)36#$6* "6N 136L 6rLK)'%343L)1) c/-.
3WG % % $%)% g/p![%V `7] g+ o V p 3$,-" WG 3) $N".* A` #r $% .dZ1) 6 F )Xkb 3g +F-- )#61 'L6" 61) $6%6% /6 (1)F # : " 3 / :P& (" )X,b6#$F6," 6)
P0[4 W 2Q(gF-- )#$%W&)N- "#![%V `7] g+ / k $"2R () " g#.
$% $6# 6cL) '\6 1) 6% $6M% 6r6 4` P60[ A46 F6"][3%% -% L#6L ' 636L% 6# $(6LZ61 ("6 $6%$+ #0" 3 F- q%3FG .% .G 63 $6M% %636) $6%
8 ""4-3#"d#,- $/"/% g+ 3$" k# . $% r 63 4 $# #6% W% $M% $%6 %-6-6 F60*G" 6 F
/"/%3N% k/# )"d #N% (rc3'-% $% /%d.g+-"3( LK $%/ b3 (#)"d L#L.f6I 16j 6r
3$,&M LZ i#"d'# #$6% $Lm6- '@6N "6 6LZ3$6K
____________________________________________________________________ 1. Sub-optimal 2. Contracting Problems
-
______________________
A WG : eM- >T
#)"d (4 (LZ c343 % FK 3o .%L%36 6K3%F% 6,&M6d6%l (1) : -Lo g+3.o WG #)"1L) r "36]L* "
0]l 3 -L $# .
K4
-
>h 2
_______________________________
j0 F-/ W"d eM- (r /o "]36 #L1:" ,&MeM- #"d%3 / G 63F6% 6#$G6]
" $b F- Q"N l/"r ' ("%3$ FG $"cZq% W%#b'l/"r F% j66#l/"6r 63F6-- 6)6&)$601 / F6-- 6)[-(Vl/"r % ~[d /-."3LK 1) $% \ %" ,&M g+ $% /#"d$%-% gcL)
*"L *"j"- ("Z-' )oc--#L#.3c 6#$)3F-- )$%"N1) "NF'% 6K% ( 63 F6- i. 6
(d INL##1) $}r $01* F64c"6cZ 6) 6 6L 6%F-- )F-.n1" % L ) $% c "6" F6-- 6)6
#"d'LZ [-/3$}[ (r #"d r (6%/ % ..&6* k6 '#)"6d3LK)#$$% ) .wF-- )K% $33c'401* $% 6) 63i
K%b $L/ F-3$G .k1 ![% L%'IN (d 6 6L##$,&M $#"d1" %1)$ *"6j" f6M W6K $6L/ 6
% .3&` ) $ F-3,&M / 1 %#/ % :3$*"1+ / 63 W6K "j" )'" /} )L3G d[% .
@43C( ;,'L1 :M ;#'' ,0W$%$G 31 WG 3 c06] g 6 n6j` F6- :6 6L3G
}F-#(/ $)$% b
")3 n b (" " 3% .l7 )$G "]%-L3L ~[d W"*6 $6%'$6% .6w $64L3 "b L 'L% ) 1" 61 L 6 6- $61) "6 (#)"d 63` %6 r d%" /#LL . 3+L% V3* '/ b6- 6%
0W13:L) -'0"*#$$%"6I6c#)"6d/ p6% 6#)"d 31 3:/-'-L3".636#/636#$
% (r :1 ),L/#)"d'F- *"6 $%6,&M /6G $%6d $6ML
-
______________________
A WG : eM- >=
F- 6 % $&3b # $3$*"1+ #)"d :& $ML ` 6 6 .%30 W'#)"d3#$$%.w ("% 6K%p6% 6 6% q6 W6"* /'
( 3F--L3".$%'7*#)"d3#K% $q6 W6"* / %3 &* A` p% 3K) L:~[d .63)MN3$$- L% #)"d .dZ $%'"6N f6I $6% 6+L !6- 6)3
"#I / L (d[- $3,&M g+ n#"d-F3LGF-.
34@43+H ,;N -#O: ,": (1) $" #"& $#J;) (%MN $)$% g"-" 6 "NA>66%6(6# F- '
% 3/ "&3F)% . . 6 #6
-
______________________
A WG : eM- "6-% .$%|6-$6 n6 .6) "6z` g:06K 6 W6"* (6/
,F- &(r W.)cK% W%3% W"*
, 6LL# F6- 6 .$% 3 \'/ $% W* ) $L]NcK%636% 6-% $6#(r"6]
3o .L}1) " g:0K 3% #W"* $0]' /3% 63` [d GVcK% )W% 1 %3(".
% $0]G g+ $3- o 3&" + 6 63/ 6b 6366G .$3- o %3% /" P0[ ) 3&" W"* '" k%3FK6- 6%3$
#\ % q37* ("% % V 6#G'6*!L6 / "6 6)N3 L 6|3 36L 6% .% $6% 6 (36N '6c/ W6]` 636`
$3- o cK%6 :% $6*"1+ $% W6"* / .$36- o6 *"6W,X W"* %# 1) 'F-W," 6 $6+3~[6d #6L .%L%3$" )-% 3/ $L'%3cK% )0%66#$6, 6LL#
$+("% ![%3G ) $3- o " $G | .3' F/6%
____________________________________________________________________ 1. Interdependencies 2. Threshold
-
2
_______________________________
$3- o [d F- / $6% $6K%$6L.F6- 6 6# 6*"1+ $$6)bv /)q .)%"%"N $% L0% F3L6% $ + .
,&M $%$ML (" $%("L*7:%0 ( / W$6L (K1) c3FK#$3#I / 30 n"6] $6ML 6) $ W6 6.
nIL / b- $%("6L* 610 6 np61`#I A6L6b6 W6"* /cL)G#% $P0[ nIL b )1* ' K6-/ .$64L3r63
3 F- L"- "3$ '*"j"F-#$/% .)$%(r".$4L3% ("- )%#"d6 ("6 6% 6%$6# v6)%6j
cK%/ $%$L3cK% % W%v ) FG | '$%)A` $6L30% F- F.p"1, - ,&M $&" ' % G3F- #$V3;v@N' /3cv)'F- WK261) $6%& W4w (MNp, ("% 3$c".3&` F- 6# $
$Z K% "334/G#") 3cK% +L, W%'7#cK%63 $6% % $#v $" $% %% eM--F6-.$6% ("6L* 6% 'A6m
n#[d eM- "&% kGL W/$3- o p% $ '- "6-.6K"`$,-" 3$G :j3 .$%7*'31 kGL 64"6] 6L F6-
n3L% #$$3- o $-r eM- / :,LG .%-$% ($M% % ~[dW0 )$ML &$6)*"6j"
66,&M#"66d '6630 / b66- 66% W66G 66066L):31 66-L $66%3cK% ) W%3$-r $N 6 "6.636L}1) W6G X 6% 6#
)"c&-% $% A )Lm-/6 .N 6,&M $601 / 6 $6L/63)b.)` cK% )W% (("6 $6%36 6 6L :P6& l6 >
)( '3&K
-
______________________
A WG : eM-
-
______________________
A WG : eM-
-
______________________
A WG : eM-
- : eM-
-
OE 2
_______________________________
0 WLL#:31'.-$3- o &" /60N ~&6N $6% ("6L*v 6 j"p%31 3: 2 3$%d $+3$G )*"j" p36c
F- ,&M .$-r $3- o # / p% $31 3:6L#'% %%SSF- ].; nI30 - A1` W% p6% 6 $%#)"6d36#$
$-r $3- o n r "K%% / d#)"d3F-# $% $63$-r 1-L)W% ]] .(3% A`'$3- o /636:&
$%"N "N p% $% +L1"21) $% \$3- o 6 :6:"d4g" $%31L.$%("L* 6 g"6 'Am36 )#$$&3 ("% (" $%("L*$d wK] / .6 ("% e33F6#(7
1%('$3- o p% p"1,p% $% 616+ .61)6% "6I*4823L, p% #" $3- o6 63(6 6L .636 3i
(d L) 1).) " FN% (/v)j"@N #6 $% $3$6-r g/p%-%01* $%4Q"0M -.>
$% $" %3j"' /30 W(" $%/ 6 6Z#$6- )"6d $-r F-3FG.34/6 6)#)"6dp6% 6'c6K%
% . W%$3- o )$-r %SS](g"6 )$6-r 6%/6](F- . 3c#)"d$-r p% %$3- o 1 n3% '
3% $0^K # $% $-r / p% (:S/]("6./66%66 #)"66d3$66 (66 663'F66-366466- %$66-r $66%
$3- o $-r #"% nG" F- 36- " % c%$-r $%$3- o '$%p% g"% //] ZF-.
%3v $- 'S#/ "dS# "d 'p% S#/ "6dS#"6d 3'G" %F$- L% ".3 ,L48#1 LL#:6%
____________________________________________________________________ ;.P& l ) ($3- $-r "N $& : o SS$% ] r F- .>." $ F- ~[d q .) $% : - /% / b $& $M% ) / g6) '
1 L3 L3 $% "d# 3 L $- L% " :G.
-
______________________
A WG : eM- O;
7#13F- :.,% -% $%3$0^K $N"# $3v 6 6) ` $Z$- L% #)"dq-" 3# L)"N F6 .36% A6` '
`1) %1 / eM- #! /"L) ':#"6d6# $$6- 6L% 6)6 6$% - d +L '$%-%%d 6 /.6% 6% 'A6m#)"6d
'p% K"] .3 - " %%$6-r $6% $36- o6 "6 'K%$-r ` / p% [d" $%p6% 6 .6wg"6'6-3% k. (#)"d 3 :% 6- " %%$6-r $6%
$3- o L}1) g" 3 $-r ` /'% 3L6 $" F6- .3$% Lm- " L/ (d1),&M g+ F#"d.
K4@43C(OU V$ 0 -K` W % F3d i$%"]3o .0FK[ W$6% 6
A-'$) / $%("L*b- )d ` ".$3- o v /"6L) g"6 6)0]13:#LL#)"d/ p% #)"d3$6 636'$6% 16
r3L.v L 3#$ 63 6(1) 6 F3$6G'6 6#6+F6- .#)"d,LK)#$$%,j 01* .w(db 30 W6(6$6L/,$3- o $% 'p% $M-#+( )p% .
v g ("/r )fM " .$% 3% 3$6# 63v 6) L$1 g $&- %LG %L%3'GL#.# $3)6d
g $1% '_] g1 F6- .61) 6% 'J6- 36K6 $% ("L*b W*4#1 LL% p% 313(".6 ("6 36K
$%$%m !/%p% $3- o6 6Kb6#.63v 6).)cK% /3)j %3\.)cK% /(%3436 c .k6 6cL)$6
| " $"1 6$Z\K`%$3- o $Z \K`%3K 6K.6L% "']#% )"d33c.)".$%$3- '7* 6 o6
)v (:G " % ` g"'(#1# +L3 61 6j" )v
-
O> 2
_______________________________
$% 1 L3r .$%* 6G $-r (: / r K3 $# 3)"d# 'c3$G F- '/ Q"0M F,j "] $3- $-r | $6% /"6L) 'g" o
(:] ( )"d# p% .
ej":"% $N G $% p% A1` : WN 3 .$N) K3 (J $- d% K3 L, $% 1# 3 $# ".
W4SB p% 401* %% 3 401*)%G | v )(
-
______________________
A WG : eM- O 2
_______________________________
~[d N-K%W% q% /dW1 %- W"*-*16cL)G V )"c& % 'g+ ,&M $Z) eM6- #6j )"6d 6 36% .
F- ej#v $
F-- )#0("}1):G3!$3- o l/"r 3/6% #) ( $%"- 6N +$6% "6N "6N V6 6 F6 6L)"N.$% A`)'6%3$6 F6- $36- o6 6N% 6L/$6) 66 / .6*'pr/3FN-3l/"r 6K%V / $36- o6 6L/$6)3F6- 6c .'A6`
!- --3F- #L0% Z $:3 $+#1#(1)F- F. L (/ /g%3'"- $,-" % q ,&M*" '$6NZ
I /wr $M $%3F6- $6d /% "6N .631 6% 6,&M 6#6K% :6% A ) K#0 /wr ." 8H- $%F1-0]L* W#6b (7
"% /L3G \0 3.'" ) W0 ) \0w4$%)63)d% "d#"% .$) `#6 :% F$6% "6|L 6,&M g6+
eM-#/wr )"d3 #$G $$G % 1*34/![% )3/"6` 6)oc--63 , 6 r /1#:.`$6% 6| 6 6-6 $6
)"3#0/ ` 33"% $G .; $) $ | 63 $3- / K% ]L* /|3 $3 ."N % :r 61) $6% .
3 3 .3#1##1 $,6-" (6[ $#:(6 /% 36L% .| 63$6)3 .)$% "N '(dG7- L c %# (7K3$)% "d# /6wr# .$%1)\| '3$)% " % %*W"6K6 .:61
"% '$%F*-v - $%)V %#1 F#b F3LG W"* .#G (r (/ ("L-F- #0 $% % $eM- W#$N )"d "2 3% %3FK3 4 $| FG # $3" / 3#60c6K% 6) "" W%L3G nG" / F0bw3.
____________________________________________________________________ ;.$) A"I WG 3 ( LK3" / 3 F6 Av $,-" 83 $% '7 ./ 6K%
Q - )]% " [![% L% WG ) 63 63 p"61, 26"% 6 L% @N L0% $% $K0 FG3.
-
______________________
A WG : eM- U
%j"01* e4# (7L0%&" '60N ~&N $6% ("6L*&"$G | ".- 3$$%"6] "6"6-3~&6N F6%V $)- F3$$3- o
-
?> 2
_______________________________
N _"` .- $%#&" 60N ~&N $6% ("6L* 6r .6-#FG | .%#)"d$,-" 3$G #$(" $%)3 (d$
' r .-# ` g"-#$G | r W6 "6.6)"d#1 $,6-" $6G3 6 :% .6- / 66#6cL% 6) "6N
&v"N$%#/ ')(6LZ 6r $% "% "6N64 L6K .&` $#N%/,&M' FK% g"- r .- $-6# %K`#)"d#1 $,-" 3$G$%$G ' ,&M3c#dW"* !
K1 &" k% /1[ / F- )%L- Am';.(/ /#"%r $3:>) ("&"-
-
______________ $,-" A` nIL (7# k%L g WG :, /"L) 3r ...?3A nd
-
______________ $,-" A` nIL (7# k%L g WG :, /"L) 3r ...?=
A nd p,c1[ L/. $&31[ $% 3b i%K`L+ .)" '1[R A n6d 6 36%'/ 6| ,%3"^3p1`, $% "% p'n.% W* F % #W6&" W6"* :$6% $6" 6% 636%+ i (" 3$ FG W"* F .6 W6"* / 43 61 36% : 6r 6
F- P0[ nIL . %3-r $K66- 6 A6` 3 nI6L 6% k36c' (" K (r 6- /36 $6- 6) kF6K '36L,:6-3$G:34'-3K $ #).:3';26#1 '> .( 6(
W"* "o- F '3G $:34. 63 W6*361 6+301* :646 $% |-.- F 'W% 3K $13:K\" 66 2
LZ) $# (r F0*" 4- 3K $, $% A- )% W#G $v $Kb
(r(/ A"I ' LF-.$4L3% % #WW"*
&" ` 1[ " $% r .- #cK%3% '6LZ$6% 6| -$1)Frj" (eb )&" 6- F6 / (1) $% 3$
% .$b nI#&J% :L "] '3$K-r6- A` 3k%3Gr 43rp$'(" 3$ 6 6b 6% #W"*&" Wr b \" `//]&" $% /6#'6` b//6- 6 6]3W6* $g6#) / 63 nI6L
".3"- / ![% '1* 01* /4 #)"d,L]F6 /-3G $:34 F-#K% ! #1.
$% 7* F- )d '#% $nIL ]-% F[% #WW6"*&" .)cK% :34- F %3 $.p"1,IL#6- F6 $% $3p6% $F-3$G ' % #W&" W"* p%K)L.6`p6 $6 eM- k%L $% "%#"d'$%|-$.)cK% /636%6
____________________________________________________________________ 1. Young 2. Krugman
-
TE 2
_______________________________
% #W&" W"* - F 3$" .A- $0]G 6) 6 a&/ 3Gr- F 3K% $ 3' / r3c1 nIL3"% :F6-2
% #W&" W"* K% 3 (r 1/\* 663$6ML 6 6% J nIL3c'` / 6j"e6 6) )# W6 "&6'S .( 61) / $0]G)o A` %# !)3&" % FG V6% 6#W
&" W"* 6 $")6#J"H;6#"30}>'S .(# W6 "&6 )S :($L/3(% #W6&" W6"* 63Gr Q"6N $6]7N '6$6
# $$+ r$*"1+ K /p'V %& F-- 6)&% $" W4 # - /3$6# (7 63Gr 6# 66L .6LZ
p7N0 % (% W3+#b"" F-3$'$%bL(%
-
______________ $,-" A` nIL (7# k%L g WG :, /"L) 3r ...T;
]" 'A,#!)A $%(: )/(6) "6% )"NV6 %% Fo )"[ .v 'W%
c,j F76- F
)L /% /3;(" %V 1* 6% 6% 6 6% 6% .7* %3' 93 )N-# / k $3+ *7I ("6'6`
A"I v (/
4'LL"I / L3 n#6 kG6L $6L (
% gw /$ .6)c6-"> !6 $*6 4"&"L 63"6" 6*% 6# !)% &" W"* W# ")p- %3'.(
7* %V#$!' r $%)"9d)"" $*"1+ /c-N) "&%3c%3("% % 6#WW6"* 63Gr' f6MLd# .3c-N)6* 6 F6G / 6% 6%G / 6 F6# 6 $
.K- )#p AL
-
T> 2
_______________________________
ASBSk%L b $%466/ nI6LJ6-% 6 n6#& :LJ% ) ((d) .(1) $" )d $"'$%Lm- 6-r _
' )6K% (6/ A"6I 6 36 . nI6L $61) 636c 6$601 /#)"d$,-" $G3 6A6- / ,% F6G 6Z 6 F6-.$6% "6I ~[6d
) 3Gr N / ,% $ A- F6G % 63" $6 6d $` $%3bL :-F- .
% 3"3;W >) (6 / b- % 6- +L6- 6/ 6)'l:6 ## $4FK)N- 1* )6L / 86 6]6g [#m#"d ' " ) %d3 3 4FK )$ $6) "61 6 .6%
/ b-` '6b3F6}
-
______________ $,-" A` nIL (7# k%L g WG :, /"L) 3r ...T'Sp- 23'& 2
-
______________ $,-" A` nIL (7# k%L g WG :, /"L) 3r ...T=
%j"% b e # )"d.;%)6" 6d 63 !)96 6)%+'$%Lm- A)>:"
-
hE 2
_______________________________
j"" e.$%Kb gcL) 31[ i%+ '%3FK%3b 6)31) P W F'3F- . r W`F |.
d4L% W3 3 $% c4L1["% ".0G")) ( # W6 "& )S (Ap-# #v , $)$6% F6K F- F1-363 cL}1)$% FK% ':&% .:+3$L %6- (" 6 (: V6
g#)v /)j"$%"|L3+| " $%4(% /- Wl"3 "-;F- .# W "& (6d 6 6# 6, 6G $761* 6%
'FK 3"N d /% $% +L4% W:+3% $3- $("".d4WFK['c"cZ-%$%1[ )% /-)F- .6N% /"6
d4( W/3 ' "
")1[L#$63 63 $6G 6 "6'1[ ) /- "6-63l"6 6L)"N "6% .6%$60% 6d 6%4W( /3(" /4Lv):%b-#.
L}1)(r$- /V#"d/"L) $d )d ' "].)c6K% % v)j"6 " 6% 6L)6%6dL6% .$6Z 1[ )L %VF%V> " 1[ ) /-$%F- '6) 63 6#
:)3$L .).dZ (r F )"N "// 3v6
$6"1 ( ) ' ( b- 6 "% $ (r3$+$%F- r F-#$1[L/)
,/)/ ("/r3w'% L0%- (r3L.p6-36) (("6/r /3c%/3%1)K Fv)j"b-L#.6
" 63F6-
$% $0]G1[ | b] I / 3n$*"1+ /A 6)- ("G $%c/ . W] c6 6j 6]3\- '"d b] W ("vo# " $%("L*v 66#$.6) c6K%
" % F-$- L% L#.p6-36%6L63v 'l 6)K/3% - ("'1)% F1 .&6- W)(l76
____________________________________________________________________ 1. Extreme-Bounds Analysis (EBA) 2. Leamer
-
=E 2
_______________________________
#% Q"ZZ / b- % :)c % A:(';g6* A ) % ,M" $" ) F.36r $6G J6-% $6*"1+ (61)6)p6-3 $% 40K /3 3d L##v $)6K%% 6d
)$}r / $#"&3o F0 3"% $G('$%("L*v)6&, F6- F16- .$- "('%601* 646 #6 "6 )"6d .36% A6`& 'F6K63v).'K%/ b &p- FK3F- .& 'kv FK6)3# $("- )% "d# $%
, ("L* LL#)$6G 6| 6V%
"'K%$K%b- " l $% F- . (&$)$% "% $ML '#6m 63 l NL66K% "),% W` l &"1,>-r _ $% "% $& '("- 6)
) q
-
______________ $,-" A` nIL (7# k%L g WG :, /"L) 3r ...=;
v
6 L(1) $" # ,&M $$ML $%f"j(" 3. ,&M$ML 6-r _6
6-r Q"6L6L}1) 643r6p NA1 $3Gr'34))" -d)9$%#G 6 $
3- i:$ 63 F6-.;'$6& 36&6 $6%P# W6 "&6 )S) (%#)"d]3Gr('3c&P# J"H0}3"# )S ()%)o A` ('$Z` /Q[ 6), 63P6)$6r" (6 /
v ) $Z` /L3G)61['>6I6[ r6: .$6% "6% $6&]3Gr %3K i%nIL $1)'$%) :A6` o F- .3& i$) "o3+L $%# $G "6% 6 6) 6% 63i0]r1#: " 1* $%b )3 % (d3& c$)$6ML
)) $14% (\0 " .) $& o6 A` 61 FG6d!)9 )$% "%$% 1r3Z ' # $%+ $63)6 6% A 63
N%%+ )" /F-2$& * A` )1, "N:fI #LL..$+ )d % : $%d :. % &K3 |$ML p .
-
=> 2
_______________________________
, /% & r1[ $/ #$A "N %3F6- 6# $#G "d$- r P A, $- r %# "d3'c /]k3- /#Lw "d L#.# W "& v 6/ | 6&" (6/ 6 :
:3q&$LG | ~[d #j $3K% (r \{:% Fm F-.:G3c!)9 $% )'#1) % F3& qF- $6#$3 $6d
)6 $%+o6 A6` .6# J"H 0}3"6# )S ( 6% 63 $$6%+) / b- % 'o A` 4Lb& $0]%6 6# 6, (/)%L, 3& q$'(d 1 3LN6- :)6%63(364$%d .:EBRD, 1999 .( $}r 3"3[d 'LG | ( LK $%"I '@N* / :.~N )& p7N$# N- % $)$%39,L6] (:(6 (
p7N /F-- )3("Z1- /% / bw 1-61)F66-2S.66 93 66)I66,("66}1) G $066]G:366466)/% /6666%w% LI k%L /,2.A6` (6/ 6% 6Z $6o -- .K- )
uF- V ." $ $,- /-3 .K/% .3i$%r F-'\6& 86%$" )# J"H#"30}'S :SBSS.(
r FK[4: '$0]`v ]
L#L.:63.6bL (/ :%% /-/r&Fm (/ $1* % & p76N 6 $
|" - g#cK% ' Q"+ $%;- /% b ']16- /% %[$06]G '% /#(/ WK ) F ]3.#"1K(d 6) .6j3F6m \
%3v '3$0w V& p7NF- $'&` $#j3bL \6`//-/r $0w&F6- $.:6g (6d / (//63& $6- 6r 6 $6 $
d
L .3/ W]` iK[:0] | % nML !)96 6)F- "% ' $6% 63 6L, 6#& p76N $6)6 / $06]G $/6% / 6
L$)G:34 V 6bL 1* % .3 / W]` i
____________________________________________________________________ 1. CMEA
-
______________ $,-" A` nIL (7# k%L g WG :, /"L) 3r ...=%- !+L-3K $b- ) 3+L
$%4q-" WA- ),1 Wp% F:, A-3P".($% |# W "& / '. 33G$)- - (".6KGMM 0G"6) 63 F-#$$% % 1[(/GMM')"6 6LZ6)'6L 6% "6
W"*
, LL# ] ~[ 3Gr #(/ A"I $%v
3
v% $'31".j3\v/+ 3Gr6#$p"61, !)96 6)
:% .F-r a& $% :L,.) 'F- a&/ #Z".6) /$Lr%L,F-.
-
______________ $,-" A` nIL (7# k%L g WG :, /"L) 3r ...=U
):." 3& "'S :(`(r / #v $M- l/"r e'#q-" % $A- )% (K%(-/ "'V Fm 6% 61* 6 6 :6666j366661[ \ 6666 / v66666666 W/F6666-
), %S/.(%3\ '3j 3(d \) #, $6:6G 3! W'IA- )K%% (6` $6- 6r 6 6 (- /:G A-3!).;# J"H#"30} :("- ))6 $% "%
j 'o A`3K% \p% % v % 7% (-$r F-.- ("36] $6& $63Gr )6:.A6BSBS(63& q6'$
v66),166Gv '66 '#66166)66N)$66% w66/#66166)$66% "66%1)4)LG(v )N| .b )$6ML \6K`%3v K% )ej 6 .63Gr /$6L ,1 "6666% (r / 6d'/$6L
Gv36%%K% $F- b .|/" )%,1 _6 $6ML 'F-r " gr J"F-K%b Fm#(d $) )o6 ,16
V " )%1 *K4 ! F- 396% b #)"6d-r _
3 (c3b#LL.%31)$'$}r $ 3i$%r F- \+, %c 6 ':
%1)("% F" )%6#6 (6d $& $M% V % $66`6%] $ML3Gr N A1 $3Gr F6- .#36K> 3(6c)S:(
3 L#L#$N%/v)#$V")%(-" )6% 6#W(d $"1L) r a& $%%L,.3% A`" '3o ( LK#"67N6%] $&3Gr 63LG#$61)v 6% 6)6 #)"6dN $6
A13Gr K%L,.% 7N3'$& $,&M $% "%43r6p$M% L, %v
$- r $& $M% # W$%F- 6r.
$% "I '@N3~[d $,&M FN6- 6# 6j $361[ \$6& $6M% 6 /
____________________________________________________________________ ;.![% % ) )"N $N "j" 3 $% $& , .l 63 !+L6- "6 $6d3 '6 63 3r
u 1[ 2. Makdisi
-
=? 2
_______________________________
/), S/(F-2 3(d ) #)"d3%"6 6)$6M%, % \-L $&/$0]G A- ) B 6N 6%A6,/% ] / d3c# )"d .
3 3b i7N / / 6 66 6 .364 A6 !)9 )%+3F- #v q-" $
$M% A- $% A- "6 $6&
b- .3% A` '3&6K)S (F6- 6, 6# Q"60M ~N6 $L %"&)|V (1) 'rF- $& $M%#W]` / $Qj
v
6K F1&" 6+ .6- 6 60N ~&6N $6% F6- 6 r63.3% $1) b "j" '3c3F6- 6#r $63v q6-" / 6A6- $6% A6-
" b-'3~N V r2 # W "& * A` 6#6 $ eL) L#L# $3~N 6b 6)61* 6%363c .3 "j" -% L/)r%dF-'/3LZ $%6| 6 6-
# $3i$%6r F- $6% 63 c6K% 6# v $6"cZ $6p6, 6+ - (" ".
)"3(r #] $ML $3Gr 6"1* ," 6% 6Gv F63"6N F66- 66 "66)66#$\66K`%66 (: 66]66dN466/ G66 66;
/ ".(6L}1))"6 "6 /k%6L 6 .6dZ $6%'"6N /63~N 6)6% 6LI \6)" /6,$6-" $6M% 6bL6 6 6% .
%3\ /3jG $d"$#)"6d6L 6% I \6)"6,'%$&% $j* W16L0)&,G 6w F6&" F6 "3$6'6#616 .%V--#$VbL k%6L F6 6% 36# k%6L / b6-'$-"'-r $%\- .
@4
-
______________ $,-" A` nIL (7# k%L g WG :, /"L) 3r ...=T
1K 1*"("ZK)Vo " '/ 6 v"6 '6)v Q[') /F-# $3v ) % Jv)woc6--
v)L%3' )(r $]7N 6- (" 63 $# W6 "&6 )S (RF- .(v \-L (/ $% "% $dL - F6- 6)/ 6) 6%%v)3c' G $%WL#.r 'G F&` #01* ( $46 G]- "dL /F-'c63f6M Ap6- 6 L#6L 6#v $6)w--("}1) 6Gvv '),1" )%6 L6#$
F-- )-LL% / $%3(-L ., $% (4\G] -F6-&` # $3 /3v )w--!&Z $% #'Ld(r % 6
#$F-- )\-L "L/V 6bL "&%63v 6)w-6-L)%3Go` LL (d ):./ g"0%#'82#&"';.(
* $# A` ,%F-1) - % %K F )W"* P0[
, LL# $%3/ #K% ' L/c00 ( 63 ,6j F3 3$6 6 $6 /
r"N$+ )w " (")--6r636 $6% 6 #L6d ., 'g+-
3L4r $3v )w-6-$60w 6 6% 6 L#6L 63 $6 '6L/
$) r>|F-- )3F- 6# $6 #6]N "6d / 61 " 6 6 W$% -$0v)w--%(#dL. 3F-+L#/ dL $636 6.,
v nw --#6 LL'6[d F6&p- Q6[ 6%F6-
% \-L#v (r (/ L .Gv 6 ) 6"6dN 4(.6 63k% '3"] $ZK% $%F-- )36% / 6# $k6b $6% $36- o6
/3FN- )gw )$ML "] % '3 6 V6 \ 6bLGv 6 #!) 3L% .Gvv )--#I / $3nVo / %3FN- )6 $%40wK. 6 $0N6LL '$6}LZ .)6% "6 $6&, '164F6-
.) cK% 3%33c L% $3$" 1[ F %j 3\V L.
____________________________________________________________________ 1. Pul Collier 2. Discretionary Action
-
=h 2
_______________________________
3$% Wz, "N $%"--3c%("- )% "d#36+ L#'(r "K1)33v - v F-)w--)$%393& q6$(
F-.$4L3#- gF- 3 1) (F)"N 'F 61* 6d "6 $6%#v ())]"[ 3& q$(L}1) 3v c)--6
- ("cK%3% .3% $1) (6d )"6 6 6L) &6` $6# 66v)--p"1, $%406 /6-3 W61* P60[ 61 L#'6L$% F- 1 r !3#$N%/v)oc--.)6% (/363c
- % ("L,L%)"&3'F0 S .(`I)/r3d# W6 "& )S(L %#(3$6% 63v6)-6-6 6-% .) cK% :j 3L}1) % \ 3e# A6 W 63v '$6)-6-% V--'4$$ "&3F0 %6 ( 6 63 6 6LL):.ABSBS.(
)"d)9"".) 3K 3 6) $6% F6Kv $*"1+). % " 6("}1)F-- )#(76#G/6% '63
("% /r $%(:#GF $%F1-]"N ![%` '41#G#b6F / '#:) \3L$)F& ):.p6 $61) $6ML '3'F6}S 2
3&K' : 23L.(g#) /3*"1+ $)(" v 6%6)6b0[ (d)3/ ,&M \K`%v Q[6, '6b 61* 6%36c
./ ` 3p g1 '$ML '1) F3v $*"1+ 6) 6/ W6K,3v P63 L#L)$6% "6I '~[6d 6:.A6BS6%63(V6
dv)-- 3% $K 3W"* c
, LL# 6 .(:+ 63 $.- )W"* P0[
, LL# b ) '(/ $% ) b6%v)--w --L"#cK% $ " $%3 r e.
$}r#$[d 3A l: iBS4(L) 6'"6163"%# $v)--- (""v '#1) &
]N[L,F- / "N ) .L}1)" 'F-- )6% "6% 'LZ V !%L#1])N[$6% "6 61r )636%
-
______________ $,-" A` nIL (7# k%L g WG :, /"L) 3r ...==
K% 3;&>) ( /-F- .(K% W% 3 & '# W "& 3LG#$V~&N#1])N[F- Fm'`-F-]6)6!
$G [,jP .$ cr"3( LK'/$) N 66#"6 $ q-" % @N~N )--K%,j "% P6"1 /$)6- ("
o` L#v 'L%j ")- F-#1])N[() "6.63$+:$%W&.dZ /3#$/- W,F-])[#616)
66N$66% "6666r66)MN '66--"66"66 "o66` $G66j("- )% "d#$K% /-. 2
______________________________
7N% "" )")"d)9A:) '3L$)-3$L, L6K 3 " % A # ("% 3/ " & W` R[% o $.
$% .w)d) $1) ""% #v ()&6- '6 ("]"N 40* (, F64'J" 6# J"H 0}3"6# $6% 63 k61 6L% 6- 6# $
Vo ":)3L$)*16d % ( 63 63F6- 6# `76] $- kv
N- g:0K 'L/ )1)4$ *1F6- .(6%4$ *1 '3- .K 1"% [/%- ~ k6# 6 (
![% )r g P0[ .#( :c F L)"[ :F# )#6) /- % % /4" $"2#1) $6d (6G $6% 6%g6+
`7]+ .0] g'K%F- - :' $% /% $,-" $%36+ ) "z` G#]^1M G [64$6 *616 /.$36-
d`- " / '' 1(" " AQ"0M]: 3[6- /% 3, $% 1%0%4$k,F- 1* %% )/% $,-".
g+-$4L3',&M$ML :36G$6)%6d ("6- 6)6 L%1)F) 6) ("d j $6%6% 6+6' /6% 63
66 66LL.# W66 "&66 )S (66%66) ~N66ICRG 66KG "66 `4F" 6) 6L}1) #b6"% F#6-` #16("6 F'$6% 6# 6LG .63"3% % ( LK$# $1) r3LG#$V&N(d {:% K F6- 6
% :G3q-" / !3Gr ) q-" $%6-r01* 6% 64p% 'F6-L :&'3: L0)` 1413"d $- ) q-" /-r301* %4p% '3F- (6A- ) L0% 3:6G ] g"-3! 3% .# J"H#"30})S (%)o6 A` '61)$6*"1+ )ICRG $%LG ; $% 3$L$%L G 6 (6d 6
____________________________________________________________________ ;. )ICRG (d 3 L) :P& ( 6) 6 / (6L1I "6 "6 q6 "6
$% g`Q 2(" (-"% Fb $%("L* 2F6- F6& 601* ("% V / ` $ N \-L M +3 $% +L + F&,G g+ % # )\K # " .
-
_____________ $,-" A` nIL (7# k%L g WG :, /"L) 3r ...;E<
#$ dLZ$ F- " $*"1+#0 /3& q`76] '$ #v (7)`7] $%("6L*v6)#6| A6L '"6 $6G
`$1) r $ " | 6 .$6% (6r A6`) 6 /3i(6dd)9%3F- $3LG#/% `7] $cL)V F-#("6% $6)g/p %##.)G /% FN- .,&M $1)$ML )$%) :/6% (
/% ~N )3/r (/ ("%#86 $%6# 6 $6% 6 63 6, $6+ -L#$3/% 3/r ("%'$% % .)cK% .
3;)SQ(r Fb&[ %3 $+ #$#b ) F/%31) "N " / '("% /r % F$% 1r3L.3% A6` '6
$% .) " /6 6 63v p6 6) $6ML )6"6d)9$L/'3L,/ ~N#86'%/% 3/r + ("%6 ~N >
#b
-
;EO 2
______________________________
~N 6 8#/ (" N1 # 6LLl"6 63 "6-Z %%:+L- F- $ FK" 21 %3 (r F6K 6N6%/6% ("%+1%.;
3 ) ~N "KK 0] $ww .3463F6- 6#$~N "oK%L)X F-L %t- )!- $6 .6%$("6L* 'A6m
(" #"d ) %$%d&%6K% 6 6b F6G 6| . "-I,t- )!- $ 3F- 6#$6)#"6d6
) / p% #"d$6 36'16 e6 6 "6.d4W3$ww g3F- #$ $L%(r d) $) $%7%6 '6 "1,p("- )#/ $% 6d) $6) / G 6 6'$% .40* (, F4K% J" F-'/3$6Z 6K% g+6- #)"6d
p% ')%$%F-r .%$"("6 /4L6v 6 :% b- .3% '3k1 L%- $ LdL "3( L6K
,&M / b- %% "d#'~N )K.6- /6+ F6-34v :% % ) $%# $6% 6r !)96 6)/6
% "d#:3 .6,&M 6)v 63 !+L- " " d) r ) ) (d #$1* kv6) \6" 6b 6)
01*4 ". fM / A`' $Z$+(" uFG
@4
-
_____________ $,-" A` nIL (7# k%L g WG :, /"L) 3r ...;EU
(" / $%3%/"r)6 $G G F6N "6- 6#6% 66:$]7N .& % [dL0% FKp%0"*#$" 6L66LL 6b
` / P0[ nIL3#1+ k]L% W"*3 [*"6 'L% 61W A` 1 3& 'F- (* A`7N |)61* .6) l " -L\-L$Z 6a&/ "/ 6 $6Z 61[ A6"6
..)'$G(" $bLLZk1 L%##$ (1) $%!6 $ (:) r % W"*
, 6LL# 01* 6b 64 6% 6 #)"6d "6'
) r K:)FK.$4L3 /"L) ("% " .) /3i$%F-r$% '6`~[dFN- #$#W* g3 W"* 3 \&w ( (1) ' )6 6% $6"cZVo '/3% `% FdF- 1)#$6-% W6"* $1)'%33cq L3G v Z $,-"
A" ".
-- )"d)9,&M $ML 'K%J` / )$61&* 6$% 39J` )0| / .3$"#-76%+ )"6 6L6% (r 663 LL ./.dZ /oc-- )" '$% "d# $%- (:,06] ,%
1, cL 1.3$G 2 3(% r $ F-L,]3L,(1) W6"* 6d['$% 7*#b) F'3L#L.v $1))3#06] $6K) $63 61
dWL)'F- .$L / "#6v \6)P60[%1) 6 F$6% 6| -L.N% /("- )~[d"$v6)6,"6 6)
%1) 6 3"N 3+0] nML % F-cL 12$% .w" ( 10 . )N%/,&M#"d.
3 3i` $Z 6%oc6-- ( 66]"N $,6-" A6` nI6L 6dc) L"- )KL] t- u3 ( c e3 L"- (LZ $ F- LK .
1I %(L(" $ Fb 3i$%r F-'63 6+6% !6[% 6)06]cL 1 .3/ 'oc-- (F- ^1M . #$J-% r )"
]""['"36) F36#` $#166 6V ("6 FeM6- 6# (71zL#L'#) F6K .3"6- / '6% ,6j6` F# .63A6 6) '
-
;E? 2
______________________________
[d %$ -&FKp%L0%3/#)1#% $3o "]3N 6 '(% $4L3\"&3F31)6r ( 6 $6G 6|%.;38` /3i("- )P60[ 6# $Z $61) 6 F6- .6 :$6%
) r $*"1+ ) !oc-- (Z:1:G3. $}LZ 63 f6M !6- #r $3l7 ) $G "]3("- )% "d# l/ '6dL
3r - % + ' $% $" %3+$% $ r % 'F- $3$ '$6Z 6K% $% ("%"nF-3FG. 'k F6- 61 "6 6, )"6
1)N% F/v)1*0] ("}1)+ l/"r'$%$" $6 L%oc--/- $br (.31) Fg+ ,&M3c$% 6-$064$ $,-"'1 %#:%)/% --6N 6 *"6j" 'f6M
:" L#.$%* c3% 'oc--#$ 6% t6-!6- 6)(d[d K)L '3i("- )% "d#%3 ,&M % 3c66L}1)
" ,&M6" % 1)3#0$%"r .WK *"6j" l NL6"6& 6 f6M3F60 )S(p6- '3
66)(66& '66- W)(0G"66) ')( '# W66 "&66 )S('L-) ( 3(6c'6%r / !64t6- $63t6- 6)3$6% 6L) F6-'!- )3 :%c$[ 2 3 "N 6 6% F6-3$6L 6Kb 6 3i
$% / r F-1['$%39$%"|L b6- oc6--'%63 "6% 6 .!- )3#c"cZ " $3e AV)"6 6| "6
'% "% L)"N fM (1' L)"N d 47/6 6 F )"N $ .
"$Gj#o` (6# $!.6) 6 6 6 (r $6% 6
" #1# (3c"cZ $% i$"1 Q[' $c JK` .$6 I6N $6%
%#$"cZ $ W#"& )S (o` %3$"1)/(/#"1 W$6) '$6%
____________________________________________________________________ ;. '(" " )v .- $3:+ % P0[ ,&M l7 3%$% 2 Kb ` % FK $6% 963
$ "o ( LK3" $ W& 3 l 7d $% $" % | " ) $ 6, NL
$% / 1[ w /I .
-
_____________ $,-" A` nIL (7# k%L g WG :, /"L) 3r ...;ET
3+F-3(6 (" \" $ LGv 6 %6j #61]6)6N[oc--3 .$Z L3G)3%K !+L- .63 "6- 6) "6
'3(LZ L l: ,&M $%$6G 6 6 .6% 0G"6) $6% 6# L3G% b1[63L,-.KGMM 6v FK"/+ 63Gr o`#L'r (%4$)v&"1, 3c $ !(r / b- 6 6' L2% 3'\N%F% / )% A "d 33Gr
/- (" J- / .3 c3$L` '%13%6K` 6 63 $6}r '$ .- "% #&" W"* W$%F- r31* cK%6b&r / Q[ $%
)- .-3G $:34&" k% ( .K%-% /6)%6K`62b&r$% -%$1)#)"d, $,-" A`
'$6 &6W61* (rd4 7/"13(G)% g/p1[b&r F-.
l7 )L-) (%1[K / b&r .)60'$6% $6%m *$% $" % 'F- $"K!- )% "")6 $N-
- F3$LZ 'l7 3) %3KL F$%$%m $%"6- 6K6#$%3Kb g (r ' * A` )"% "% |L36#r $3 6L
)3+ "1[ )1I(L ![% /- .)G .L-6L}1)F- (d#1[ $&" $% 4(r n0M W63 $% 4A nd W66"
3b i % $ .$0^K3c6#/6 (61) $6% $1) 6 F',3v P r !+L- ) $6% F6- (r ~N6 6)6,;6M6%v)-- F- .3&K)S (6% c"6cZ!+L6- Q6[
)(: ("% /% 6j $6 F6- 6 :6" 6d)F6-%t- " 3 $%3ww $)/wr ./"6L) F6- g/p 6)6G
" g+~N )363~N )q , W6 66 .$6]7N $4L3 "-#K /$Ll 6-Lg6+ ("6- 6)6% "6d#
" '%3!)9 FK ) /wr (r % q.____________________________________________________________________ 1. Proxy
-
;Eh 2
______________________________
(:G %(r"- '# :% / :$Ld W` WK 93 6)(r%F- . 3+L%3FK# #$"6d ) @N *"j" WK'K%%$}r / !$#6) V6@6N #"6d);(6d 6 "6'1) F." $,&Mb0)#"d%3 $" " (1) 66#$$%W0 )- "% "d#$" ".3/ : $013c1 )
W A` F- .)1,K%]N / .)$Z ' $L0 eM- $ZeM- $ML " #% $3W`".%$("L* p 'Am$ML (6d
#$ML $43rpL Q* $M3Gr K%v 6 6 (6-" F- [d 6 $%- G63F6- )"6 :6Lm6-3|6
" "K"%3] 3Gr .(-r Q"L( $ML L F- 6# $" / 8$) Fb F1 ') % -3k#"* W&" W6 6
"% .* 3 $%" )F-- )A1* FK 6# $634 (%LN- .)G (r #-L !L$%"6 6)$6) (6d
L)V1+,)G% $&"0 (Q"0M rmLN #6L .36% A6` /"6L) '%3 FK3$ FG Z#)"dk 3$6ML ' 3 6+"63 63$6"
)F-- )\-L F-'LZ3$c 2:Z3(c1"L% L2Z 1#)"d3$ML $%3 (K3` $Mn6G" "6% 6 .6K%/
#)"d43rp$) / %3-$% F- "/ K `7] 6 '/% .) . A"G3&" 660 %6d )6o6 A6` ') ,% # $! L% (r / 6 '"6% d 6G .6) $64L3N6l:#)"d"o /3 #":34" FN"LF- 23"j" %3" 6-%
n .#)1, L$ML 6#6j '(7F6- 6[d $6% "6G$6)#"6d
)$" FG | r 2$% ("Z )1) A`/F- $L 6# $3)--w,M .$% '$ "|L ( $ $- '"j" $ .
____________________________________________________________________ 1. Country Fixed Effects Parameters
-
_____________ $,-" A` nIL (7# k%L g WG :, /"L) 3r ...;E=
FK[$ '$-0cL[6- :63!;6% "6N ( _"6- $6" $% "- b Q"L A1 (3&'(r %# /3.$6% 6| 6-0c6) ':
+ k \"3 A13&(r Q"L / 'd Q"ZZ 6# 6 (7d $ML ) F- $%2` / Q"LF-- )3#$$%"|L"d3&,G n6F
$ML (r 3 +F-'% % .3% '$1) &` $# A13& 6 n G" 3$% -% Q"L3&Z#"1*6nF6- .61)"6N
(d ) #$,-" $'Z:G/34)4L4F- $b.," $%+("Z Q"L3&1G FNL g:0K '6K /$,-"$%$%m L3G &"F-# $
6 '(r 6K% 6 6L, 6 36% .
F- # $V $3$" v)k" % q)4 'Gv 6) 33 ) F3- '" \)o ' 3oL3 :($,-" %6L'/ 6G
Q"ZZF- .` Q"ZZ 34 :Z):/63"6% $3" .3c% | Am 3#$("- 6)6% "d#!" '$ "M, )Z:Ge6j $Kb 6r F6-27m6 $64L3#K&%/ !`'%(3/ % F- . $0^K3 FK#r $3#6K/633% / / !'Q"N F-3% 2$0^K0]3F- #$#K/3636% / !
$"cZ ` " j33]N q(3/ % %.>
g+"#)3%
3$" @6N " 6)/$6L'6j g/pF- . Am3c#% $361, "6 &% 6F6- 6# $(r l:6 $6&
____________________________________________________________________ 1. Prebisch Lecture
>.dG): (F- $K% $ 3 .$%' |$6I 63 ` / !% | b]$6% ("6L*LK G W1* % 31L) .A6- / $ $"% K $ F- nG" " 3 p"] /6]
3 0,G k3+G 0] W* F- $G G 0N ~&N &" 6 610 " )1 $"6 .A- / $-" : (K $"% K / / ("LF6- $6G G ] .$6"% 6K 6
$) 1 3 g" % 3 FK" (K "MZ 'F- 3/ 0N ] 63 u6% $6 )"d N% 3r % K L" 6 u"6 W61 6% (r 6, % 3/ $L3 (% % :
3
, 3 $"% K A"I / :Z $Z 'F- "I uL
-
;;E 2
______________________________
)o A` R 3 F-)# J"H0}3"# 'S .((1) $6" 6#$! .) '&" FG3/ #)"d'"N (K1) 6% J36c
"1)"n%- '"% ( K%k3- ` .g+ 6N%#)q0w3 FG \" $3- o ( 3 % $K36c#)"6d
o A` & .- &" / 6 60N ~&6N g61 63$6% 6 :G3!F . J-%3i$%/ r F-("- ) 6% "6d#'$6& $6
3"N 1,3F- {:%': Am3cF-#1) $ ,&M F4W61 6% ')/% --6 W6K ) '6N /6%136 ./6"6j" ( *
W` $% "%k%L ' 3$% +L "6j" $6% "6|L $0^6K (6 6 ".3r /" "j"v
(-" F-)2 3c%63i
,% V/r )/%(("%+ %' -3%.-r\o3N-v
'q "j" 6 6#$61 6,&M
% "d# r %1# : .3&K)S ((6dIN 6 6L#6# $% )d (/ A"I / !3v c6)6j"ev 6L) 6
$6
F- (cd)9%3(c FK63L6% "6j" ..6dZ / 60 6 /6'" (/ A"I q-Z): 8% " r46L#."c&% *7I (/ A"I d) % F 66` 6
% .) )/% % $M%6$j* 6L#)3648;'S:.(6% I 'Am"% 'A- WZ#-GL$% "6 q6-" \A6,//]$ A- ., % "%#"-GL/6% 6
S/SF- ./ #" v '
3F- .>____________________________________________________________________ 1. Weeks
>.$,6-" 6L3G K F) & '% $ %d (K3 ) F- 1 L0% $Z ) $% : F1) / (1 .("- p"1, % ) $6% $6) 63 63 $6) . q-" '"d 6
$G 6K 6
v )6" LZ A7N " 6 )6d 6 $6L/ "6 .63/ ' ~N
, $"cZ + / $ 3 $% cK% :63 '$6) 63 '$6) . q-"
u$) Z
-
_____________ $,-" A` nIL (7# k%L g WG :, /"L) 3r ...;;;
v
L}1)(-" ') 93 )0]6]63Gr #)"6d%*6eM- #1')43rp6 :F- "% ."6 63Gr '
" % (% ("3 3 9--[- $% / 6r ( .) 6FF60* 3r (G 4 '"1) d&Z% {:%"% (cd)9F- .v
6
/ ` 36-r $6%\o63N6-6%"6 "6 )6#6L, $ (r36KVo3bL /3k! L% d/ RN #A6L#F6- "6d .( 'W6% -r\o3N-",j , / F$,6-" cG6 6% .63 W6"*
% ) F-#- !L6-\6-L 86%1) 6 F6'/63J-% $,-" l: A- ' 93 )#)"d) 6 / 63 6
bL Fmr( '$4L3#gF-- )" X[ L#$6Z $6% (6) LLZ:" F- L3L%'V ." ~[d #-r $\o3N6-6
c-N %3[*1 6 l $M#"3v
3#)"d 63 ' nIL3% "N- ,,`I F-- )F6- .$6% 6|
348& W3(r F- 6# $F6-- 6)6#(76"# 6 '$6% A61` .6wVo ( %c'14F- Vd (v %
'% .
4$"1* 3c#% $3"- #(cd)9"&3F36%'!6 ("% /%3/-/r QK` )NL3G F- .|3$)3/"L) $63("% /%3/r +$%39%#)"d#Z"'W6"* :6 6j6%
%1 . $1) %3L'$%W&dL$6)$6% "6% !+L6- "6 F6Vr )" '. p"1, .$6% $" % $64L3 6LZv 6!6
,
1* LL ("- )% "d# 'F-336%!&6Z 6)3$3)S Q(!% '"% (L6% $64L3 ~N6 6 6 86#/ /$L/-/r+# " $o LF-- )+$%$" K.6
+L- / 1) 6 "
K% F . 63636* 66d :
/# $G3(r /6-/r $6 66+6%6 $66+.
l7 ) $-"%( (d $4L3)r $M% %/-/r
-
;;> 2
______________________________
+01* 4 "'61)6d 63(6d 6 6) .3)S r(N $& p #;)S (/$L 6 '6+G'"G g"b 3 "N %34$]7N WL#:
0 W36 " " $& /6-/ 86'6K%61 #6LLF- .:10W%~N )F6-- 6)6+6cr 'F6- 6 ("6 3$ FG))" $" L %% 01*#)"d3#$$%/6-/r6+-3k/1*n$N ' /3c#)"d F- 'F6K26 6:)"6 76N3 .%~N )K- .+ F- !6" FK 6ck6" $6G, w$G, $%%"N(" #` / )"d/r-+ F-$ 6L%6 .
+ .+`)$%1- ("L*&" /0N ~&N(*".)cK% 6r %LZ F-Z :$" ) G- F&p-'F-r c4$("6% 6K$6M%
-+ $% F- 6 $% +r / 6c) #.)"% "d#636jG$ 3 LL #$#b') F#$v %):%$%%"N ~[d F6-'
$%! $b %r + $6% 6 16r63.6*"3( L6KL %3$L/-/r+V %Fm G %F-'%3* 36%63$*3[ $ 'FK r)".
!)9 )% g+dL /(:G %6r )" - 61 ("6 3$]7N +L .1)#G% F6- 6 ( 6 6#6 $36b 6,&M i0#"d):6 '>63"0
-
_____________ $,-" A` nIL (7# k%L g WG :, /"L) 3r ...;;<
+$%("L*-+ F-G %#. " $3F6- 6#1) $6F-+ F-% 3$% "/ FG /3%##("% $$%*7I 63 /$ $L#: g- /+ F-%d31) F$"cZ ("6 (r $6%-'F-3FG.- - (" $ r $% + FK$+ 6 .6
AK L %$4L3 ("% /%+$6 F6m 6%F6- 6'61 6" / )/!)9 ) G . c!)9 )%3*"6j" 6,% 6) / "b)%.
6r ' $ \&M $% $" % 66 6#6r 6,&M $6 g6+% "d# " k%L 'K/ 3("L"1 .3% A` $6% $" % '
" .+` *"j"l NL6"6b6r 6%6 6 ("6 6LZk1 L% ##/"L) $.)!- )K%% t- / d F-) .% 6 (
)" "" {:%d)9' g+6r 6.6 n'6jF-.
-
;;O 2
______________________________
YGa F:; Abramovitz, Moses (1956). "Resource and Output Trends in the United States
since 1870", American Economic Review, Vol. 46. Barro, Robert J. (1991). "Economic Growth in a Cross Section of Countries",
Quarterly Journal of Economics, Vol. 106. Barro, R. (1997). Determinants of Economic Growth: A Cross-Country
Empirical Study. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Barro, R. and J. W. Lee (1993). "International Comparisons of Educational
Attainment", Journal of Monetary Economics, Vol. 32 (3). __________ (1994). "Sources of Economic Growth", Carnegie-Rochester
Conference Series on Public Policy, No. 40. Barro, R. and X. Sala-i-Martin (1995). Economic Growth, New York: McGraw-
Hill. Baumol, William (1986). "Productivity Growth, Convergence, and Welfare",
American Economic Review, Vol. 76. Ben-David, Dan and David H. Papell (1997). "Slowdown and Meltdowns:
Postwar Growth Evidence from 74 Countries", NBER Working Paper, No. 6266.
Berg, Andrew Eduardo Borenzstein, Ratna Sahay and Jeromin Zettelmeyer (1999). "The Evolution of Output in Transition Economies: Explaining the Differences", Washington DC: IMF Working Paper No.9973.
Berthelemy, Jean-Claude and Ludvig Soderling (2001). "Will There Be New Emerging Countries in Africa by the Year 2020?". A paper presented at the Conference on Development Policy in Africa, Oxford University, CSAE, 29-31 March.
Blanchard, Olivier (1997). The Economics of Post-Communist Transition,Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Bloom, D. and J. Sachs (1998). "Geography, Demography, and Economic Growth in Africa", Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, Vol. 2.
Burnside, C. and D. Dollar (1997). "Aid, Policies and Growth", World Bank Policy Research Working Paper, No. 1777, June.
Campos, Nauro F. and Fabrizio Coricelli (2000). "Growth in Transition: What We Know, What We Dont, and What We Should", Paper Prepared for the Global Research Project on Explaining Growth.
Christensen, Laurits R., Dianne Cummings and Dale W. Jorgenson (1980). "Economic Growth, 1947-73: An International Comparison", in John W. Kendrick and Beatrice Vaccara, (eds.), New Developments in Productivity
-
_____________ $,-" A` nIL (7# k%L g WG :, /"L) 3r ...;;U
measurement and Analysis, NBER Conference Report, Chicago, University of Chicago Press.
Collier, Paul (1998). "Comment on Bloom and Sachs: Geography, Demography, and Economic Growth in Africa", Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, Vol. 2.
Collins, Susan and Barry P. Bosworth (1996). "Economic Growth in East Asia: Accumulation verse Assimilation", Brooking Papers on Economic Activity, No. 2.
De Broeck, M. and V. Koen. "The Great Contradictions in Russia, The Baltics and Other Countries of The Former Soviet Union", IMF Working Paper Wpoo/32.
De Gregorio, Jose, and Jong-Wha Lee (2000). "Economic Growth in Latin America: Sources and Prospects", a paper prepared for the Global Research Project, Explaining Growth
Denison, Edward F. (1967). Why Growth Rates Differ, Washington, DC.: The Brookings Institution.
Dollar, D. and A. Kraay (2001). "Trade, Growth and Poverty", Finance and Development, Vol. 38 (3).
Easterly, W. (1996). "Why Is Africa Marginal in the World Economy?" in G. Maasdrop, (ed.), Can South and Southern Africa Become Globally Competitive Economies?, New York: St. Martin's Press; London: Macmillan Press.
Easterly, William, Michael Kremer, Lant Pritchett and Lawrence H. Summers (1993). "Good Policy or Good Luck? Country Growth Performance and Temporary Shocks", Journal of Monetary Economics, Vol. 32.
Easterly, William and Sergio Rebelo (1993). "Fiscal Policy and Economics Growth; An Empirical Investigation", Journal of Monetary Economics, Vol. 32.
Easterly, William (2000). "Review Comments on Six Regional Growth Studies", mimeo, Global Development Network, Washington, DC.
Estrin, Saul and Giovanni Urga (2000). "Accounting for Growth in Transition Economies, 1970-1995", London Business School and City University Business School, mimeo.
European Bank for Reconstruction and Development (1999), (various issues) "Transition Report", London: EBRD.
Fischer, S. (1994). "Foreword", in W. Easterly, et al., (eds.), Public Sector Deficits and Macroeconomic Performance, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Ganzua, Enrique, Lance Taylor and Rob Vos (eds.) (2000). External Liberalization and Economic Performance in Latin America and the Carribean, New York, United Nations Development Programme.
Guha-Khasnobis, Basudeb and Faisal Bari (2000). "Sources of Growth in South Asian Countries", paper prepared for the Global Research Project "Explaining Growth".
-
;;? 2
______________________________
Hahn, Chin-Hee and Jong-il Kim (2000). "Sources of East Asian Growth: Some Evidence from Cross-country Studies", Paper Prepared for the Global Research Project" Explaining Growth.
Hall, R. and C. Jones (1998). :Why Do Some Countries Produce so Much More Output Per Worker than Others?", mimeo, Stanford University.
Hoeffler, A. (1999). "The Augmented Solow Model and the African Growth Debate", CSAE, University of Oxford, March: Background Paper (revised April 2000).
Jorgenson, Dale W., Frank M. Gollop and Babara M. Fraumeni (1987). Productivity and U.S. Economic Growth, Cambridge, MA, Harvard University Press.
Knack, Stephen and Philip Keefer (1996). "Institutions and Economic Performance: Cross-country Tests Using Alternative Institutional Measure", Economics and Politics, Vol. 7.
Krugman, P. (1994). "The Myth of Asia's Miracle", Foreign Affairs, 73(6). Leamer, Edward E. (1983). "Let's Take the Con out of Econometrics", American
Economic Review, Vol. 73. __________ (1985). "Sensitivity Analysis Would Help", American Economic
Review, Vol. 75. Levine, R. and D. Renelt (1992). "A Sensitivity Analysis of Cross-Country
Growth Regressions", American Economic Review, Vol. 82. __________ (1999). "Where Did All the Growth Go? External Shocks, Social
Conflict, and Growth Collapses", Journal of Economic Growth, Vol. 4. Ley, Eduardo and Mark F.J. Steel (1999). "We Just Averaged over Two Trillion
Cross-Country Growth Regressions", IMF Working Paper, WP/99/101. Makdisi S., Z. Fattah and I. Limam (2000). "Determinants of Growth in the Arab
Countries", Paper Prepared for the Global Research Project "Explaining Growth". Mkandawire, T. and C. Soludo (1999). Our Continent, Our Future: African
Perspectives on Structural Adjustment, Trenton, NJ: Africa World Press. OConnell, Stephen A. and Benno J. Ndulu (2000). "Africas Growth
Experience: A Focus on Sources of Growth", Paper Prepared for the Global Research Project "Explaining Growth".
Pritchett, Lant (2000). "Understanding Patterns of Economic Growth: Searching for Hills among Plateaus, Mountains, and Plains", World Bank Economic Review, Vol. 14, No. 2.
Rodrik, D. (2000a). "Comments on 'Trade, Growth and Poverty by D. Dollar and A. Kraay", October, Harvard University mimeo.
__________ (2000b). "Review Comments on Six Regional Growth Studies", mimeo, Global Development Network, Washington, DC.
-
_____________ $,-" A` nIL (7# k%L g WG :, /"L) 3r ...;;T
Sachs, J. and Andrew Warner (1995). "Economic Reform and the Process of Global Integration", Brooking Papers on Economic Activity, Vol. 1.
__________ (1997). "Sources of Slow Growth in African Economies", Journal of African Economies Vol. 6 (3).
Sacerdoti, Emilio, Sonia Brunschwig, and Jon Tang (1998). "The Impact of Human Capital on Growth: Evidence from West Africa", IMF Working Paper, WP/98/162.
Sala-i.-Martin, Xavier (1997). "I just Ran Two Million Regressions", American Economic Review, Vol. 87.
Sarel, Michael and David J. Robinson (1997). "Growth and Productivity in ASEAN Countries", IMF Working Paper, No. 97/87.
Senhadji, Abdelhak (1999). "Source of Economic Growth: An Extensive Growth Accounting Exercise", IMF Working Paper, No. 99/77.
Solow, Robert M. (1957). "Technical Change and the Aggregate Production Function", Review of Economics and Statistics, Vol. 39.
Stiglitz, Joseph E. (1998). "Towards a New Paradigm for Development: Strategies, Policies, and Processes", Paper Presented at the 1998 Prebisch Lecture at UNCTAD, Geneva. October.
Weeks, John (2001). "Growth Variability among and within African Countries: the Key to Sustained Development". Paper presented at the UN Expert Growth meeting on African Economic Growth, February.
Young, A. (1992). "A Tale of Two Cities: Factor Accumulation and Technical Change in Hong Kong and Singapore", NBER Macroeconomic Annual.
__________ (1993). "Lesson from the East Asian NICS: A Contrarian View", NBER Working Paper, No. 4482.
__________ (1995). "The Tyranny of Numbers: Confronting the Statistical Realities of the East Asian Growth Experience", Quarterly Journal of Economics, 110(3).
-
=+
? +B ;;7$ ' 'G %&
-
T1+) #u)-.#$D #(/D '+
G3 F- $& 3$) >
, W"* % 6 6LL#
6w )"6d# 6N eM- '6 $,6-" 641) (/6- "6z*
-
;>> 2
______________________________
.l7 L# )' ! $% b 3 ..1 / K% L 6 % o V . )8/ '$3- o '
r"K $3- F 6.16 $6+ "N k 36) 6K) $6# L N eM- (7* .3% $" ) '\]% l7 [4
/6wr 6N eM- (7* 3 G % 3% 6 .$6# F6- 63 6% 6G 6+L3 cL% )"N)7* ( -- 3.1 ' b ) ("6Z 6
F3 ) F&,G $% b / .6 6 $6,&M "6 nI6L.K% ( A7N ' "N % b K% %+ .$6Z 6 6 3
cL% G b / `)"% )"N $# .3% 3 % uF- W60 6) $K3
, W"* / P0[ nIL N eM- LL#) -r _ 7m
3Gr %% ($4 F- 41 /- !- 3 $% t- .p )$ML '3 $"cZ $# "% "j" 3 -%F3 )6)
MLcL% G b $% +L $))"N "$6Z 6 63 $# 'W6* 6K% b)r (% (7# eM- .(6d7 6-% $& 3 ( LK3"
/"r / N% G %)0# '6,&M 63 V% $G W4 ! " /% %# .3/"r )$% 3% K ,&M % 1L) *" $%m %
$% "d# eM- # .3/ 60 .6dZ $% $& 3 $% 3% '` p ($ML F6K3c "6d# ,&M .(6# ~[6d 6+L3 6)
. p / r% *"j" 3$ML 6% .+6KL %"Z6Z $j* F- "] L (r % c1) ,&M 3 '"d# ,&M ( LK3".
& c3$) r $# 3)p %$ML ((7# |L /)"&"6-;'.66#SS(66)/% 66|L / ')66">W66}
-
________________
, W"* g"- WG ( -- N eM- LL#;><
G3 (# $]7N$)p $ML .dZ 3# / % q- ! *" '(dLL# b3 "d# ,&M . $& 3 $& W14 6" W6} )SS (
F- )/% ! " .r P]" ML#6 (76* $6# L F&,G $% (r N t- k j` $& '/ ))!L# 3 )((76* q $% N ' -% ") .P63, :c N- '+L3
$G | , ~[d ') )/% n3I / &6` 2" 6r $6#:c c-N $d3)
L#L.
6 6G 6, 6+L3 $6# 6 N- q / d[%A"6 '"6
Q[ 6-% 6-- 6 $6& $# F- -- ) 63 .6* A6`
$% "N/% N (7* )G $4r W&Q[ 6-- 6)W4 $% 1# q L#6b& "6 : $& 3 '$6) 6c3 6% g/p
&$) 6 6)/% % q )6L}1) (6 .)6G 6-- 6 /6- .$% ("L* &` 'Am 6 -- $# g6# $6# /6- F6-- 6) Q6[
'" $4L3 F-- ) $% $"cZ "#o (% L3r 6)"N $Z r "%'F- N (7* G $% "L .$%("L* $6# 6-- 6L3% 'A6m
"K1) 6)"N $# cK% 3 $% 3/ ` 'F- P3, KL %% % ~[ % $"cZ)k%L (( "N; .1 .V6 '\6 61) $6%
$3 P,j G $% 1# $% $# /"r )a&/ 6 ( 6 "6'$6% 6}% 7 cK% (: ' cK% )"N G$6) 36& 76 $6%
~[dL#.(7# WG % j` $& . :31 63 6 : A"G c3 % ` 6
, N W"* $# F- LL#'/ (db 6) nI6L 6% 6L $6 63/
"d# ) ( $40% P0[ .3/ 643r 63Gr "3L6- / [6- 1 (r ( $% p 6N eM6- ("6Z 'F- LL# 6b 6) 63/ )6
.F%d " 4 L, $% 3 )$ML G $# 63 6 /- "*"" 3 % 33Gr*" Q"L -r 6LL# $6K3'F6K2
____________________________________________________________________ 1. Intrahousehold
-
;>O 2
______________________________
$# F- 3 G] " $40%F3 )3 $G | *: .)b $" ".N-3% j` $& F- f .%3 W0 % 0# N-$)N
, W"* $j* LL# .-8H. * 3 6N eM6- 6 (7 e3d V % $"cZ r )G $4L3 o .!6[% '8H-
$& 0])![%S( 6K f P60[ )"6d# nI6L $64L3 / 6 $Z , () 6 F60* $6Z $6% 6 6 6d% F61) W"* g# '
" .:#1 3![% )%)"N cL% )F-.$& (3k1 $% @6N L%r % 41 )K ' -% (r ".
34@? 'G +B : " ' +vB ",'H ' ;;7"'H ?+ "0, 9
. cL% N eM- (7* 3)6)"N 6K)L.("61 6% &" W"* 3% )"N ' :N)$3- 43:G $3- '# 6K (
cL% LL# $j* )$% " 3% $% "#o W"* : #)LG / 6)LL# b- % .(3: )c % .16 63 $6% 6)'46r 6, W6"*
$# "" L6% 6N eM6- 6 6/% 3 _"d L .'!6[% 63 cL% )"N)'$%$% \ -% N".
3434@,+G . .1 3 * ' % "N o V ) '&/ / 8/6
,% WK $% ) r ! A ..1 3 $K% c343 $% ) M (1) / V (r )"N $# 3o .$%("L* 6 $6# L3& 'Am #6 6L)"N
# ( % &- L3: 'LL% ($)3N ("Z 33 ) &6 3 43:G | (r 6r / 6c A61` $6# 6 .) , (/G '
!3:G (/) 43 K $3- $L 3 2$}%$3- o L#6% 'L 6LL# 1# (dL3& $% L3r (r $# 3 .$6% 6r \6[L $6L3: A6`)'
-
________________
, W"* g"- WG ( -- N eM- LL#;>U
| $L3:) F,bL $% cK% .L3:) kGL 3$)&" 1* $)("6Z 3
, "d# $,-" eM- ) '\)"L#* 'L 6 6% $# A` 6
V : L ..1 )"N : c3 . ) ~6[ 1* $# 'V K3F&p )6 6 % .) 3 .$6% ("6L* 6% $6"cZ $64L3 'A6m
K3 6/ 6LL# $6j* 6# 6 6Z $64L3 '6L3r n6G I6[ 3 ).1 &" % $# 3) V o W6"* F6 n3I / 6 .Kw 4&
V : 6 0# 3# "% .G3 $01 /$)$6# F- 3 $,-" [ )" Fm
".1 /- (" J- / )"N ) . 6 9- ' L ) p% % % $36- o6 6 (6/G .6#
.# % $% "N$3- o K $3- p% L) )4%;'G"6>"
-
;>? 2
______________________________
K $3- % $% ..16 / $6*"1+ 63 6% .6 $60` 6)'6V%% /-"1) +3 ".6 6"1* 63 3 6 $6# 63o$% ` p% % &F31` +3 W6 "6] (/ 3) 6 .36
W4 * )/% $# $,-" $6% 6)"N % (4 3 'L%3 "6 (/ " (/ ( / $# 3r'N6 $6% 6
/ .$% 1# )"N M3 LZ "6N 6) 6 !36 {:6% 3/ $% 1* F
v K $3- \& 6 6L) ./6
FN $% % ) .1 % c3 q% $0` 0K 6) $36- o6 6)"N $% & $3- K $3- % " r .86/$6% 6G ) "6|L
" % Ld ("Z L$3- o W61* (6/G 6K $3- $M` #LL.$%* "Nc3 3& 'c3; ".1 L 6 $6# 6LL# Q[
% K $3- W4 $% "N W4 c3 3 L 63 6 3 ) c6K% 6% $% W4 ) $3- o .
-
________________
, W"* g"- WG ( -- N eM- LL#;>T
6cL% ' 41) $,-" (/- d "z* )"d# d% 6) $% 1) Z"# cL% / d% \)$,-" )"d# Z"# $G3)W6&
k" :Z LZ K) 6 6L)"N f6 $ $# L .( 'A6m 6%cL% 3Gr A1 $N){:% )/ !% ##(L 'SW6# 6]
W4d AvL) .A B6cL% ( Av k3/" '6) 6,% "3 $# 'P0[;)S ( .) L# P0[ k%L / r $% "% *7I
F- (d ' ./ A 3 (r"3L- W% $# F- /"r K% (d $,-") :)"d# / N% )"^&6- ':6 '6/ '6Lw 6L((
cL%)(/- Z"# ,L] q0K ) 62&6` )"6d# / 6K% $6#c3'cL% $Z )6 / 6 (, % \-L 6 3/ 1- Z"# >
)43r $% FK(cL% Av .+` ')$% : {:% F6- 63/ A`):$64"3L- $" "N g'"6 q-" eM- )cL% ) 3 $# F- 3
."3)S ( F&` 3q-" (G ).
ABcL% Av .- k3/" / ) P0[ ) )7 '?
J43K4\3\43]J\4
-
;>h 2
______________________________
ABcL% Av .- k3/" / ) P0[ ) )7 '?
J43K4\3\43]J\4
-
________________
, W"* g"- WG ( -- N eM- LL#;>=
g# .cL% " ) + )N- % :c '{:% $3- o6 LG 6 c6K% 6% q6 $6% :6 3 ) 6%3 .~"6 !6 $6% $6
))/% (F% '& ]"N 'N 0N ) -g:& ) '/ 6 6LL# )"N $N 6 r -% % 6 F4& n` L}1) .
cL% 4b)$% '{:% Z"# $% 61 '6K3 644b ("6L* F6- 6LL# .(1) ! $# $" J- ' : L3G cL% W3 1) $,-")6Z"#
)1-w (%cL% $){:% )16- (F6-.;36% $6% 'A6` $6# ,"6 W6&cL%)$" (r % Z"# K% ' / 1-w ![% ( "6
1"LL# L .A6, )6 / 6K% '3%L%)36 eM6- (6G $# L3r ,j LZw ![% /K% 1- {:% % .
@434@1,&; >P #CD ""34@434@,+G
, K 43:G $3- F N eM- )G $# +r 6L#' ( P0[ nIL "N cL% G n $,&M % d3 FK3%$)b
'$%$" n1* $}r $# n3I / ("L#("- )% (6* "d# Pd# ' 4r .$,&M$ML $6% "6% "6j" 6% $6G "6]
(L% N ))('$ ! 3 $# " W6K *"6j" L 6LL# ~[6d $6ML 6) 06] 1* 6r 6,&M cL)61) 6+3
"d#'3 L% (- ."61+ '6N eM- *"j" p $Z L}1)"% nG" 0] *"j" fI ![% 4& '1* (6# ~[6d $6b /
3$) b N ) (- % "d# ,&M %F. "j""b p $-"N | "' `I A $# "% 3
____________________________________________________________________ ;.cL% Z" / $,-" A` )"d $ F, 3 .) &"1, ) 6) ' 6 % bL cK% .
W0 % ) "d)' .0)&2'% (W0 n3I / .) F- - V $% 6) "d 3 WN / -) W&(c3 '2'W- .(
- ;
-
________________
, W"* g"- WG ( -- N eM- LL#;)S ( 7# q % (#- FK3%% b : 6)"N q6 643 (
$% ( q c3 K&-"- :3 o .!)# \" K&-"- q 6K $36- F6 k3- $% "N 3 $# )"N % r K3
/ (/ 3/ K% # $j* .q)( (o ) $%/% ($6% L% $# '1 G % 1 FK3%'!)6# (r ) $# 3 r K3 :G \"
8 / !3:G 1) $% )"N "% (/ # $j* (:.M [d 3'g K[ jG 3 K) 6 $6# L F6K3%
$% $# 6 "d# ,&M k p$ML g+6 ("/r " 6 " .F- r !&Z , $L / .# : F6- % (d1) 43
(% c3 r ("% / .$%"|L(L1I G31 '$6# 6M [d / FK3%____________________________________________________________________ 1. Behrman 2. Ickes
-
; 2
______________________________
$%/I.1 L, G W4 )"N )$'"6N 6G 6 %# b- .$%$6# $6, (6/ !6 "6 *61 6)+L) 'Am ("L*
b] &] )S (L N% / '# ~[d r$))G $+ F-)"N .(K $# " $b F- 41 6L $# :c 3 )(r$6- /
% $# L $% 3)+L)F3"& /6- (d3) .36% '$61)(r $# $" b] &] $% $o / $# 3)+L) 'F- # (%-L' "A- L (## ( # P" / 8 )"K1) .)/6% '@6N G6) %
V d.1 L% $ ) .36% $0^6K 63 !6- '"6] 63 W46
3 '3Gr A1 $N )"d# Z $# 3r *61 6)+L) $"
) .4K % LZ3 &` ' nIL c3 $#'p"] 3$% 3 d (31 $G % / F*- .
'" \ 1) $%(" $6# 6- LZ I[ 3 K3 ! %I[ 3Gr q 3r F6- c3 / :r .W46 6+r 63r 6) 6
LL# 1# K3 % $0% L"% $# 3)/%'&"6# uF- "% 1# F*- %t66- 66L '664 $66% 66 F66K[ $66 L#66L ./ 66d (66r "66
3)K [ )" '(d3 F6- $,6-" 3Gr Gv % .63 W ,M )" 3 $# 1 $b $& 6K)L.36% ("6% $6# "6|L
k
*" K3 $,-" % LL# Gr cG (6d 63% 1` '1% 3{:% 3Gr "" K3 $# K3 / " (r % $0w $6# F6- 36)
343r 3Gr 3 ( 3 %"L -r ("Z c3 nIL (/d# 6) $" r % $o A- FK3 .$6# F6- (r Ap6- "6 63 W4d
$Z K3 % $0w nG" L# (L (r -- F1) K%)F 3 ) ,d&.(%$("L* 'Am(" 6| 6L &"# I[ 3 K3 FG 2K3 L,3 { '.|L .# l% ) .(1) $# $" ;36]>
% -r Q"L " '$ (b] &] A16 $6N $6ML 6%____________________________________________________________________ 1. Ranade 2. Siddiqui
-
________________
, W"* g"- WG ( -- N eM- LL#;
- ;
-
________________
, W"* g"- WG ( -- N eM- LL#;
- ;
-
________________
, W"* g"- WG ( -- N eM- LL#;
- ;
-
________________
, W"* g"- WG ( -- N eM- LL#; " L# 1# 8/ 3- ) $%$3- o0% "6 W3 L .6 $6& 36] )S ("6% $6%
____________________________________________________________________ 1. Mckinnon 2. Financial Deepening
-
;OE 2
______________________________
fM % 3 -r Q"L "61) 6) % 1* -r Q"L )"N $# "# (# $% g 8/ L#L.33Gr )"d# / K%
(r / k * )/% (G "6& 6 (6dG 6G 6)"N $6# F-"# % 6LL# "61) 6 :6 .6]"N A"6 (r $6# 6-r Q"6L 84*6%
g ! ( L)1* :6 16-w 6* /6% ` 3Gr ] '$% / ]"N F4& (G W& 63 Q"#6- 6 6 $6V .4` $# 6 )
F-)'L &"# .($Z6) ("6% A W3p $01 / "N 3 K%dNZ * k+ L c3 *;% c3 / !% 3Gr .
$4L3 c38/ % %% F- JK` : (7# q V .(1) $6# $" % k .# "&"- $& $& ' c-N $" )/% % W}
6% (76# $6]* 6V $6# $6L/ 63 1 *" 'F- (dIN 8 / " F- Q"N2& /-/r ! % 1 3 .# F- .
& .K- $% (L1I !3:G \" V"N " n3"d ) 6 6L#68 /$% ( $% k%L $# 3):Z "- 6cL% F1-6) F36) 6 6L#_"6-
L) .(d $# p% % $% 'F- & k%L %1# L) 06] 6) ("L* !3:G $% F- 41 '& /-/r8/ + .6L " )" 6%
$3- F :G \" , % !3:G $4L3")G>'(6 '# 3 : W1* $# FK 8/ ) !3:G )"N ."4"#)S (
6 W6* (76# eM6- 6 V 86 /6 6-r _6 )6 % $% '1 "N $4L3 .w g"6 .) $# "% & Q"#- !)6#
g % .) )% ).$% LZ |-3 V $# 6 6V% rg" 3'kb $%8/ (r '"% )"N 36 6% 6 / (6r $64L3 (6% .)
LL% LZ \-r .$6L/ $3| 6% 6 !6 86 /6 '6G(r FK ej .) ) .%$("L* 'AmA ))8/ (61* A"I '
% bL 3 .# % V8/'"- ) "" (31 .____________________________________________________________________ 1. Rotating Credit Association 2. Fry
-
________________
, W"* g"- WG ( -- N eM- LL#;O;
-
;O> 2
______________________________
"1 :# o A` ) (r 6 W6K 6) n%- ")W4B.( (/ F#d p% : 3Gr ] F- l: # /%2"6% 3- nIL cN &" $% 1* 3
r F1) " ($%/ FK % :1- )#'\6" " 3 3/ $L3:) !3:G (# {:% c}%$)1"36% V6 \6 6% .6)
1 % Q[ L.
Source: World Bank (2001), World Development Indicators.
W4B ( (/ F&,G L- $0]G$,-" A` nIL 'A-
6 6 63Gr A1 $N $ML 'PI c3 F1- (r $6# '6 $% '# /% (/ F#d 6LZ '(6/ 76 p% K $% $" % 93
$ML "d#3 3 F- ( eM- . 'Am % / 61# (636]# g7* # /% ("z` (/ 2&` (61) 6% :&6 .6 63 $6#
66` 6% 766 / eM6-F6- 66] .b66] &66] )S (\6& 61* $6# 6 3Gr A1 $N LL# *1 )+L)
K1) Fb&[ "1 3& ( 6 6# /% $% (/ -- k $# 6 %3'"6
]
-
________________
, W"* g"- WG ( -- N eM- LL#;O<
$% % )"N .1 % 3 $%m 6 6)"N F#6d k $# 1
"..16 6% 643: 6" (6/ # F#d $#+r/ 6
% %$3- o /G (/ 3 F#d ' ()6# /% (3Gr A1 $N" F6 6% 6 N6 \6* $6% n63I /
$K)r K $3- 'oc% % bL V .JL#;)S (3 3 $# # fM %F3 )l6[ \6" F6- 41 36" (6
FG" 3Gr A1 $N )"d# N6- 73, `7] :r 6 F- j % $# 6d $ .6j 6% "6" *1 )+L)
k '(/ /% # )6dG 6%% 6dL# (6 ):16- $6# 6% % :1-) /'(64 (:6 / 6)+L) 63 63/ !)6# W614 3o6
$-# (/ r % ( :1- .![% )Q[ )"N $# 0wd &" L#% % : L 6 W6#
V 6 : % $+o . $NL \" $# # ~[/% 3"% "')$% 3 (/![% )% $# 3 $% F- .# ( !6[% 6)
% % $# F- 3/ A, 6 - 6 $64L3 "6 6 3 0# LK " % .A )'83"6& 43 / ' -7#
~[/% / kGL 6 k3L6] $6% 16-w 6&" 6- / 6# . F- 1% $,-" $& W` W* 3):.'J6#"& .(
$% /G ) G3 "|LF]G ):6 6r \K# % 6 " $6% 6L LL#] )"d#)# ("] $& 'L- 3 6 $6# 61) q6G
&- )r 6 $# "])I"6 "6d# $6% (6% !)6# / !6% / 6 L% )3/>#-
-
;OO 2
______________________________
F- $G $" " d%2Z"# - Wv ~[ 63 k3L] % 'cL% % `)% % ' L}1) # 'Vo )W6"' .(
.1 # l7 (: V ! $# # $j* $% "% ) Wwd % ) 3 _M Fb#'F- . : % .(1) $6# $6"
$&" 6401* $6# 6# /% 'F- -% % Q# 3 W} % $ -L F-':c)$% G % 3 6 " (6d7 6 r
FK L) /% "Wv / *"6 F $% 'L% (d % /- 3) 6% 3d% $# K $3- F6- '6/H% .6# /6% $6# I6
M, "1 L}1) :# $N L 'F- 3o 6) b# 'o6 ( / !6 n%- " WK /6- 36 F6)6% 6G (
Wv )'% (: / # 3 % :c )# @6N ) !)# : ) )&] 'b]S.(M, 3o * % $# '# /% )) 6 e36] L1j ;Wv6
0v6 l /% 'F- 1) (6# l76 6% (6L## :6c F6-$% P,j K $3- (r F-L#$6L% 0v6 _6M A61` '>:6
!)#) .% (c1) $Z P P0[ )"d# # /% ) b '3 4& V6 % $"cZ P0[ ) $# % 6 o 6')6 r
" LZ .$%-% '0#"I # /% ! $% "% ,&M )'F6- 6d $o 'F- b % K $3- $4L3 3-L / G
)W" ' .( lb- $% "d# ,&M'"6 6L"% 3%3 % L%% $]* .
@4
-
________________
, W"* g"- WG ( -- N eM- LL#;OU
% $L/ )"N 11 " !)(/G , ("$3- o6 /G %(F- $,-" )'J6#"& .( A6 6) 6 63 L K $3- %' G(:6 "6 6)"N Q6[ 'F6K[ $6# "
$3- o
, (d/G % F6- K $3- F LL#2
% $% "% 11 'g$3- o6 $6% 6/G 6% "6I .6) (6/ $6G ". 3$% jb 6- 6V $6% 6%+ 6 %"6N 6 .6,&M
L +L- l/"6r $6# 36) 6` 'P0[ )"d# N *7I % $j* "1* ![% L#'(r / #` $# 6 93 6) 6d "6N
6 (#"# l/"r
, )J6-;J6" >'2'6% .( 63 63 63 '#"6# $6& ( l/"r " $G "] ,&M
L# .6 )6c3 (6d#"# 6K $36- 6% 36& .16 L $ $# L
, 6&" $6N ( 761* K $3- 3 d% $40% ' LL# 6 "6
)' % 2"4"
-
;O? 2
______________________________
A, (d , ) .# 3)"N 'r A J-% F63"& $$%6d 36) % .) K43 LG / A46 $6% F6- 641 A6, F6&` '%
LL# G b0[2$36- p6% 6% 6 (r 6 93 $# '3 eM- A, K $3- A, &"/% $% )"N G 'F- .# K ("6Z '+
"N:c ) G
v % .: K $3- 3 f"M- $#+r/ p% % $% )"N 'F- l/"r )/% (/G $L3:)$3- o
(#"# .# r .6 (r $[d $# p% eM- A, :Z LZ 84*% eM- .# % F- K $3- p6) .63 )/6% "6 $6"
.# % Q[ $% 3& 1) F-p% K $3-$3- o6 _"- (#"# p%) .A 3 %' " . F&p .6 $64r 43
$,-" L3G"] 'LK MN 3) 36 A6, "6d# (r G '"1 )"[ : 3 ) .$-r ` $# cr 4& $6K4 6 "6'
# P" 3 ("% " c3 ./ 6 P63, % " A '3%L% g"b!fM $ "- 3 / L#..1 3 'g W6* "N )
, LL# ! % "d# p"] $# F- $L/ 3 ) (1) 63
$ .* $6% A 3 $# A` (6d %"6N 6 6) 6% 6N 6)G $6"cZ $6#q c343 % (7# )L3% $6"cZ $6# $6L/ 63 6LZ ) r 4& '
"d#" % c3 A, $% A, *" /'$% F-1L).;
63 63 (d : %+ )" 3r "6)r u6>)S (/ b6- 6%)$# FG3 / kM A )( % / % / A6 6)
W1* L-L#L.(" G" 4% 3 F] W46 6LZ % " (d - .W4 R *7ISB6B6 W6# / F6- "1/6%
A- q-" %% % {:% F,1 W ) 06] 6v $6# 'A6-
____________________________________________________________________ ;.6 $6+ 61* 6c3 A, $% A, *" / F` " G" L}1) % [36 6)
l"N 10 & LL.2. Ahituv
-
________________
, W"* g"- WG ( -- N eM- LL#;OT
)"N Q[ K)L.;4% (- G 1j'" " " G"A, ) q6-" W6# 6% 6 6% 36 6 63 !31 % ',A- $-r 3 cd $# 'W ) 3 )vK) A6, L eM6- 6)
A, / 3 p% eM- )L#L.$6- W6# 6% 6 $# 1K qNA- q-" /G d A- iL W ) () )W614 36% 7
(W4 \" zG Z " . F6- F16- k% p% Z F1- k%A, % L 3 p% eM- 3 eM- ) K) (6d 6c3 k% L 6L)
A, 3 ) Q6[ 6% (6LZ 7 3 % (r $# 6) 63LK /- L0% .W4 $1) $# "- qN eM6- c 'F- r )
A- 3 % W# % W ))$6"1 W6# / 6 $-(' 1# 3L#% @N "d# ) i3 ("% $#Q6[ q6-" 6)$6K3
# .(1) | $# $" p6% k6% 1* G )"d# $# ~[d 'FG Z F1-)36 eM- A, (6 6 )"6d# 6L1V )"6d# '6
$% F6- F16- 3 k% A` F*-)p6% eM6- A6, (6 6 .$% p% Z F1- k% )"d# q-" )"d# / 1# \ 6" "
F- 3 F- F1- k%.L )d 3 %) /6- "6 G"6 64% A % .F6K[
/ (r% -L K g+K $# )$ML $%6 .dZ $64r g '"6N (r "d# $# ,% 401* % '.6) 146K c6K% 6%
F- . '6-r _6 63Gr 6] )"6d# G 6- (6d P6I 6 L) .76 63/ % % -r Q"L 33Gr )"d# g1 3
6 Z F1- p% k% .# 6 )36 eM6- A6, .( 6d% 'W6% % % -r _ )"d# 36 k6% (6d)c3 '63/ 7 .#
____________________________________________________________________ ;.A- c $% 'F`] F,I % b [- % F- / (" W ) .'+L3 K1)"n6G %
$% '" G" % c W6 '(r $6 6 6L0% A6, F6&` )"6d $ G L1j "I{:% (" .) (p- cK% $% 6 L%3 - % .
-
;Oh 2
______________________________
$% r ! / $# 'F- F- F1- F34` L0% F1-6L#.)"6d# k% 1) : p 43r (d 3 ' 43: L) A, $% (
F- L0% .1* 3Gr A1 $N $ML )"d# _6 A16 k% 261) $6% :6 6% 'F-p% K (r l/"r eM- $# $6"
F- .[3 $%+ A nML $% ( G "]'$6# "6% *6 FK3%$% 3 F,j k% 3 "" )"d# - % .6% 3 r (6
!)# L) $% p% eM- A, F1- 3 ' eM6- 63 6b` $# L%3 'F- " l/"r $+/% 3 eM- A, $% .
Source: Ibid.
W4SB'3Gr ] "N Q[
%W#
A- q-" W )0 5 10
0
2
4
6
8
Guinea-B
Mali
Niger
Mozambiq
Sudan
Gambia, BeninSierra LLiberia
Cen. Afr
Senegal
Rwanda
Tanzania
Congo DRMalawi
Togo
Uganda
CameroonGhana
KenyaLesotho
Congo, R
Zimbabwe
Zambia
Mauritiu
Swazilan
South Af
Botswana
-
________________
, W"* g"- WG ( -- N eM- LL#;O=
Source: Ibid.
W4B[-r Q"L "N Q'
W4B'3Gr A1 $N "N Q[
0 5 10
0
2
4
6
8
Afghanis
Nepal
Banglade
Pakistan
India
Sri Lank
%W#
"A- q- W )0 5 10
0
2
4
6
8
Iraq
Tunisia
Ira
AlgeriaEgyp
Syria
Bahrai
Jordan
Kuwait
A- q-"W )
%W#
-
;UE 2
______________________________
Source: Ibid.
W4B'-r _ "N Q[
Source: World Bank (2001), World Development Indicators.
W4B'\# p 43r "N Q[
0 5 10
0
2
4
6
8
Haiti Guatemal
Nicaragu
Honduras
Brazil
DominicaEl Salva
JamaicaColombia
Bolivia
Costa Ri
Paraguay
Guyana
EcuadorVenezuelMexico
ChileUruguay
Peru
Trinidad
Panama
Barbados
Argentin
W#
%
A- q-"W )0 5 10
0
2
4
6
8
Myanma
Papua Ne
Indones
ChinaThailan
Malaysi
Singapo
Philippi
Fiji
S
Hong Japan
A- q-"W )
W#
%
-
________________
, W"* g"- WG ( -- N eM- LL#;U;
A- L6 6 Z F1- p% k% % " )"d# d% .L ',% A- WZ(" _6 )"d# $# Fb r6-)6` 6 \6& (/
$o ! $-r .$6ML (61) /"L) -r Q"L 3Gr ] )"d#"1* 6LL# 6I (6K 63% /"6L) 63Gr A1 $N )"d# 22
$-r ` "- ) p 43r )"d# .$Z $# F- 3 !-3 :Z $% F#` / p"I LZ "d# $1) F6- F16- 36 k6%
uF- $/% 6L (d% $# " , 41 ) &6 6%(% LG / *" / '6 V6 6)"N .16 % $# 6L .W63p 36%
L F,1 [ )" $# LG % A6 $61) / !% NL '6AL# (% W* % 3/ .1 $# L F- # "N ) .6%
6 6- Q6[ F," )"N '&/ AL# LG G J- 3/ 7 .# % % %"0M $L3: $& 6 .Ap6- 3
[ )" 1# R '.6dZ $6% 63 63 r 3/ $Z $# "N1(" 6 6&/ AL# LG $% -- b
k63/" / $6) LZ Fo / 8 'Fo L# )"d# / N% p% % (r ' % b 3 ("% "3% ( eM- 6#
W4
):&";' .("& $jG>W3
-
;U> 2
______________________________
$% L1% / A-N (#"# $#)6# 6 ({:6% 6&" "6 W36 A6- 63/ )/66% !3:6G \6" $36- o6 6 66r .66
v $64L3 g
3"&"L4" L) !3:G )/% L)':&"1G") 2;'S (L/ % FG *" /wr $%.
,&M 7 3 )/% $% "% `$ML 63 R '6W4 W3p 4& F6- " $%d r $1) .o6 (r $6# '643r "6
%$% L &"# 'F- 3 ~[d "I) ( l/"6r 36 )/6%$% $6j* p6% 6% % L
$%m 6 L#6L .)/6% '36- nI6L
3/ ]"N $6G | 3/ '*1 )/% $# F- 6 "6.6 # /% p% ]"N /% 6)"N \6w 6% $6# F6K 3/ (LZ
$% 3-$3- o ` $# Z '% G# (#"# l/"r g[6- A61F- 3 +r.
: KL "-" "6 W# W )/% !)# \" .K% [d l/"r KL 4 (r $# '-r Q"L 'F- k-
3])S (# $4 3 $% '6* $6% 6-- (6G 6G $6# /- / 3&$3- o F6- 6# 3: 6 N (/G .$6% W6&
" ! "N 1) ' K $3- F (/ W $# \": !)#F- L0% 7 (.3 7 F61# $6L3:) '(/
Fb# %% (/G 3/ )# "N .1 'p6% 6% kb $%F- 7 $% FK .* '(/ 3 7 $6L3:) 6G p6% \6" A`
: (/G Fb#" $# Z '()(6/G l/"6r 1) $L#L.$,-" $,-" A` )"d# $G3'.6) 6m 6K c6K%
( (/G 7 %)(r" p"1, .) .) / (6/G 7 cK%( 7 (F6- 6 )6d)'J6" J6- .( )"6d#
6% /6% 6# Q6[ LL# *1 )+L) '3Gr A1 $N____________________________________________________________________ 1. Huffman
-
________________
, W"* g"- WG ( -- N eM- LL#;U<
F- r 3 : (/ W )/% $%d 04 $% '(/)'b6] &6]S.(A16 $N )"d# $# $0^K 3 F0* % W1 F- L
k 3
'3Gr3 3 ,% $& 6 % o / $6 6 3Gr ] 6 .643r (c3 % '\# /"` p)S ( $% %3% $4L (7# eM- V
\" & J 3 Fb# L}1) d 6K $36- F6 % -% % $% 'F- $N F1# 6 Fb# Q[ .
(1) (dIN Q# 3 $1N F}3 $# $" L# 6%+ ,&M ' ") (V # l/"r %) (F6- $6G3 .6d%("- )(d L) "d# ) K $3- $& f"M- $#' 6% 6
&` ' F1) (r FK LZ K $3- !3:G $#)W" ' .( )/% 6L% $# F- ]"N )/% p% % W% )d 3 *1
G $%'F16- ]"N )G "6- 6 6) 6% 6) / 61[ 6N ". /)W`1, 3 4r;F- 3:b 6) 6# /6% 6
"] +r ]"N )/%
, $# 'K $3- 6b \6" '6 *1 )/%".$%* 6b $6% 6+L p% ]"N )/% 'c3 *1 )/%"./% # /% '[- c3 $% .):c)F6 % 3
p6% ]"N )/% '/- .)G K $3- / - " 6 6" )/6% 6% 6% /- 3 *1 .$6# F6- &p6- 63 b6] &6] )S (
&$)*"j" F6- 6# f6M 63Gr A16 $N % l2 6L,3# I 93 $, W6 6 (dL3 l/"r (:G/
)J3:>'SF}3 2'.(![% )) (% {:% "1*F-- )$60N 6*" $6# 6# /6% $63"
, : ]"N ![% % $40% "N % L $ g[-L#$% )"N _"- 3) A6- g"b $% 6 7 ` / !% $% $# W6 6) 6L/ F-2 3 1"% !3:G \" "6 G )b6] &6]'S .(
____________________________________________________________________ 1. This Apparent Puzzle 2. Pissarides
-
;UO 2
______________________________
3F-- )NZ (# .# \"$)0v "6 6*% 63 6 $6# % $% "% $d $# W6L 6G 76 1- eM- n3I / 6 "6'
d % $0w $M0- *"$)$ A4 $# %% 3 6 6K $36- 46r (6LZ $6% l6c ) # 'F7N L 6 W6L 6 6# F16- /6- .6# /6%
6% $% ( l &"w ( # RN (r $# PM,L):16- 6% $L3:) # 7 eM- G | (% p% 6% 6` / !% G 'F-
1- 7$3- o L#*61 )/6% !)6# \6" "N 3 L 7".$60) 'nI6L 63 P6M,Lw 6# /6% k 3%L%
FK[)0 (("L* n3"d [G )L#6 6 (r $% 26/ W46 6c3 'g"- $0) 2) r ! g $0) 6L 6K $36- 6)
# F7N(r 6 ) 3/ $0]G % .).16- 7 (r $# -r $%+ " Ap- 3 F- 41
("# K $3- F'$% \+* $6% .6) /"L) 4& 2- | $6%m-r :+, / LG3o \-L L
F-% )'"4"#S.(
F6b# "6 6` / 6-r _6 $6N (6 61* b )K $3- ( " 1- F .\K`% A6- A6- 'W6 6)
` k " $,-" A` )"d# q-" / "0 (LZ -r _
\* F p 43r / .$}r $#"$% -r F3: 6- |'
F6- 36% 7 G F# (: .A6- $06]G 6) 6 N $ML / 6 F6G 6d (6-% kM F# a&/ -r _ / $
L-G (K% kM F# $L "% \* ) .(6d 6N )" 6 6L) $6#7* : J Fb# r F1# %" L#
b )6");
"41# >'S .( "N $"% *7I$% '7 " '36% kM 93K b (d $,-" A` )"d# c3 -r _ ( ).
____________________________________________________________________ 1. Hanushek 2. Kimko
-
________________
, W"* g"- WG ( -- N eM- LL#;UU
c3 /!- )F- 3 q ::6 /"r .K- 3r 6 6" $6% ("6L*W4 $# '# /% / b 3 .1 $% ) 6L/ "N ) F6 $
d .7* 3r u" $G | ' ! K $3-$6) \6" 6# /6% W4 /"r .K- )"J 3 '" /6% j / G L'$36-
Fb# W* -r _ # /% M, ` $Z uLL# +3 "N @N K l/"r % uF- "% 3% 7 % # [d
$36- P60[ g6K l/ 6% 46r e6j .7* PM,L # /% (6-% 361L) 76 F3: 6 j3 % $K3 " 6 K
L3 3| 3% 7 % $K3'A-L#.6G $6% L% 6K $36- ' $6% .) r $# ')"N / F- %/% '$N +3 F6 "6N $6%"
l # /% :Z $Z $4L3 V"' .$6% :6 J6 3r (d !L# W4 1) $% # /%L) J6 $6# "6 6G F- ML u
]"N d% !L#)# /% j %% ((dL) $36- / *"6 $ )"N Q"0M KL#6& J6 " G 3 'L (6LZ
_ .6*% 6r "61* J (# $# 4 )"d# F7* 'F- \[L 0 (p"^K % ) # /" 36& | n3I / '6%
Q[ V - $% ) oc% .A6` )"6d# / 6K% 6% 3 1 _ $,-" %3 ..6) F6- 641 # /% F& 7N A6L# 6% (6/
%$) "] /"r .N )"6d# 6L1) 'F&` 3 A16 $6:c '3Gr) # /% +3 J4, : /"r .K- %3 63 '
.16 %% " , "N $6% "6N $6L% 6 6 "6 r)&6]b] 'S .( "d# eM- " .6dZ 6L 6 $6&" 63 / /
$% ) F-L.
@4@;: ,3 F1K 6cL% F#6