5t ii .::.. .::.. jtrj 1 lil+-1f-+'::}j ji 151 ji...

16

Upload: others

Post on 24-Jan-2021

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 5t ii .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::}j JI 151 JI 168ts.cpu.edu.tw/ezfiles/85/1085/attach/52/pta_9200_4817583... · 2015. 10. 23. · 5t ii " .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::"}j JI

5t ii " �� .::.. � � .::.. Jtrj

�1�liL+-1f-+'::"}j

JI 151 � JI 168

Journal of Traffic Science

Central Police University

Vol. 2 No. 2

Dec. 2002, pp. 151-168

A Study on Ameliorating Strategies for the Enforcement of

Compulsory Automobile Liability Insurance

Chih-Chiang SUI

Chung-Jen Chao'

Benny Chen'

••••••Ma��.��aka&4.MA.**.�*(�TM.

*.�W••��.M•••�-,�••*a**.�.M�•••��

.M.'�0.�M••••••Mm��a*�*.��.*�.����

.��.�.�*����#'����m�a*�.����M���.'

��.����.MM�&4�*���.�*����#••••••M�

���M�.'RM4.*••a*��.����.M&4M*'�•••

M.i.*.M��*4t.

M_�:���****�'��.�

l�*••*"5tii"��&�5tii�.i.*'�*(ii�ft�:�OO�_w�*�#�A

� 56 � ; 't"ii< ; 03-3281991 ; E-mail: [email protected]).

2 � i iI;l,\' *".i. *.I.{l"� �F!i'jf*Jjl.� �1.(ii�1HJ1: : 106 iI:lt 'if **ljU'lUif#'� 4

$lt 1 � ; 't"ii< : 02-23625920 #- 112 ; E-mail: d90521 [email protected]) •

, f'\JjI!r.�.jIt"'1** •• �7dMl�-'f¥I'jt#Jli'l(ii�ft;J1:: III iI:lt'if**g �*#t

36 � ; 't"ii< : 02-28820449 ; E-mail: Is671lll@ sun4.cpu.edu.lw).

151

Page 2: 5t ii .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::}j JI 151 JI 168ts.cpu.edu.tw/ezfiles/85/1085/attach/52/pta_9200_4817583... · 2015. 10. 23. · 5t ii " .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::"}j JI

M�#.�«.'t*���.�•••••A•••••M.#A*M�

A�R*�����'��'*�A���������'��M����

iid�*4'tAi!����J!-kpT :

•••M4*.�.���!������.&.A••••�••t

*(A*•••*��*'�+�.'-.'-.)E.��*.��'�k•

••M.#�_�.�.��A••�••tt,�.»��*��•. �

M����t:*4'tAij,iA1.iJtaJl-kpT :

- , ���"f�iH"*.

**.�*T.�M.+�••�:r*.��.��••*•••

�'#•••••M��•••��•••M���.&.*'A*.

�A�M�A�.E••����;*••�*' ••�A� ••••

��.M•• 'J��*.4'tA*•••*.�*'�.'�••�:

'i�.MJ!.�.1*��.M(MI5t,*)1f#��.' k.�."f�A{Jt1lJf•

• Ma1*MI5t�. M 1f#(;t�k{�A 1f#,*{)})J!.{jiji!-iI,f,*4't(#.-tnlll

••�A1f#{*1li!-'A."Ji'- ••�) .

� , �*�l:iI.iU

•••M#���.&.�•••t*'*.���A*M�A�

••A*.*���'*�••*��k��***.�ft.*.�.

'M8����1f##r*��R••�.�••#.�.J.��.

�a�����4�#���••�•••���'�.Ma,*�.�

••���••�a�.,�••••�•• r�R.�A*.*��

.{4-ii�. J ii:!ipj\*l'if1fA •

1 ••••••M4*��.�������.*.�*I�+K••

-••�*��*.�a�.*'����••••••MM���r�•

•�.����JAr���a�JZ�R.����,*�A���.M

153

Page 3: 5t ii .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::}j JI 151 JI 168ts.cpu.edu.tw/ezfiles/85/1085/attach/52/pta_9200_4817583... · 2015. 10. 23. · 5t ii " .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::"}j JI

(-=-)11.�*tf 1:�*4t

������.*�R*��*.*�*�*4t*���.#

��*��+A*��:'��������������¥���

�������*'#�**����*���'4T.*'J

(.=.):jl( � tf1:�*4t

��:jl(�tft:*AA*��*��+�*��:' ••��A**

**����*��'4*��_�.�.*�����'�.�

1i<.T 7� .&.$UJl� :

.�������4��������.*�'ro��iT��.

�*��+��L.=.���T��'���••�AA'��*�

�.fJt 1,JU!*� ,

.*��••�.�'ro��iT��.�*�-�-=-+��L;,

���T���'���••�AA'��*�����*�'J

���A.��Afi ••��•• 'M*••R��A••#�

�.*�-:jl(ft•••���'�.I��'

155

Page 4: 5t ii .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::}j JI 151 JI 168ts.cpu.edu.tw/ezfiles/85/1085/attach/52/pta_9200_4817583... · 2015. 10. 23. · 5t ii " .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::"}j JI

(�.n�••.�.: .•��.n.�••ff.*'*••�*��

*�••*,���•• t••n•••n���••�.��MI

������'����*�.���'*T���o

(-=-)"tf1f-amJ�1t.�.iii:.. : 1; .�á1tlfl �1f-a��{;lt•.��$.-11!!.�

.*'t••n•••n���••••W#.*••�MI���

���'����*�.���'�T���o

��M����_M�ff**�*��M�.�.����.'�.

w.�HH-�. ' ��"*pIl2 �-if< 0

fJ"! JoiJl:;jlUUtA "''''1i ... IRi:tI:{;f<Httl:

• '" "'.t1ttt"1f-1};i}Jt-jIH'"

Jt-ll!

A'" .'1j,tJ.l. M1��"

'" '" '1 i' .p.t1t••1}�"l#- {;f. <jo ,.:..'

(.f<.4t1of,,j'-)

Jt-IHJl(1Nl.,,4£-;iJ)

• '"

<tll1J"j� -.,..

<t

lI1JII

..

"fl...

.. .q

• fl '""-

fl

•"-

-=-' .��*,/>.��.�.:;tj(,

ia��.M��.'�.w..��.�.#.�'���8MI

�$J�mt1})-�I'l��(YATAAf4Il1JI����)I'JfJtIl� r *�#1*t'�J �

157

Page 5: 5t ii .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::}j JI 151 JI 168ts.cpu.edu.tw/ezfiles/85/1085/attach/52/pta_9200_4817583... · 2015. 10. 23. · 5t ii " .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::"}j JI
Page 6: 5t ii .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::}j JI 151 JI 168ts.cpu.edu.tw/ezfiles/85/1085/attach/52/pta_9200_4817583... · 2015. 10. 23. · 5t ii " .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::"}j JI

�'�rr��'.�N������OC��

*.t••n••����M�.#��,a90.1�I6��,

,�£liJ.f.#'t JIII�� ��,*t *- ' ;f;.{t1i'< .•lUAtJlJJ '*AHrdt J ��1'1'� it 159,134

1+ ' ,1ij#£:$!1f!.*ft'jlj�it*it 142,0201+ ' jIJ�4"i! 89,25%' A9t1i.1�

��o�ffi�rr�JIII��t'*�.#���JIIIW�����I��'

liJ.f.#'tJIII�M ••••����rr•• '_#�ä�.��'��.�

T-1� , #£ �f;t!£ T 91 r.,"! :

(-)'i##£�l!�*���Aif"t* ' 'fftliJ.f.1f!.{;I. � -,� 11 0 1t�Åj:j �

tUI-( 1f !£ i>-� , Ii Jl'.Å j:j � ;'!-� .iE� if 9HIJ �� (sUHA1t) 0

(�)1i'<�'i#jJU�1i'<��it, JIII W��' ••����liJ.f.#'tJIII"*1f!.{;I.:f,

Mf�i!••• ,.�.#.���aä�.iE�äo

.=. ' r,'��J.f.N��

(- )*ft'�� �r.,,,!

l,�*.�.**�*t'.*;f;..*���ff�'�;f;.�#�.'

�ft*fl�Å�••�,�a*.�••;f;..*��',1ij;f;..�

••**��k�ifa'ft�liJ.f.#'tJIII���J.f.���!£�f��

-t�o

2,�*.��-t�M.�k�a*4"••M"!���'ffi,1ijS4TA

��liJ.f.�rr��M"!'M�A��liJ.f.0/.-t�1IoM!£�T-Y

M"!'��:.���••*��,*��.���, ••••a

*aJlJJ'*�.#T-�*'T-��AliJ.f.�o/�-t����a�

1Hdt� 1II4t 0

(�)'i#� ;f;.lip � � 4Jf�r.'-iI!

LJ.tJ.f.1f!.{;I.��1t.Th"1t�� , 'fit.'i#T-� , 'fft�i!-JtlMIJi1!1t '

51�)'V��ä�.f!0/��rt�*ft'�� 0

2,��M#�*�f*�JlJJ�.'f�AJIIIW����M.ä�*�

JlJJ�T-�'�AliJ.f.Åj:j����i>-�o

(-=-) 0/ � 1t 1+� r., "!

ifJlllm�liJ.f.#'tJIII�ff**�ffä�-t'M.o/�M-iI!�A�

� ffi ' jf#l�lJf,*uT :

1,•• ffi.:��••;f;..a,�alt,�.;f;.•• o

161

Page 7: 5t ii .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::}j JI 151 JI 168ts.cpu.edu.tw/ezfiles/85/1085/attach/52/pta_9200_4817583... · 2015. 10. 23. · 5t ii " .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::"}j JI

(-)1lt�A;/] j-� ,�{��;ji1�ittl>1' �l>1;ji1Jt

.��••��R��A+�.-�-a�.�� .•a�•

••ft�.A;/].t���M�'�*�.�.A*•••�.#

.t•• J'A�*�.�t.��*A�'��.�M4.��

.�.jf.i#]�1lt�a:tJt{�j-#���',*)JLr . f"latA��l}M,lHf\i&l.*'R .

���#j-Mr' •••ft*�••���at�MA�t�*�*

�•••�t.�••t.*A��.ftat��� ••aA;/].

t���.�.�a.�.�•• ' •• '.fit.�*��.n .

• Ji:. • ;j;.. 0Jf ��� ft;J- ,lHfI � X. i@.��#< i\IJ -fi..... M;. -f m ��'fl ( 44' }J'Hill

{1t £. k�{�J'ld\'4'-)' �;fj(:f� nM#£ 't:jillM:fJti!-#l�("�a*4 .Il'-.

ft). :jiIJJt.�tA;/] 'f.liHU�alJ�� . iIÉ;fi1��l>1�itl:l>1;,MJt("*p#*

.�k�••�l>1)'�•••��••�*�i&l.���:fJtn�3

�.

(�).��IM4*�j-#.�••••�.�ta4'-�j-#�at�

1.�.�IM4.�.#.��at�.��.a4'-'�.�.Il'-#l�

••• �j-#at'�*��IM4��••�.��.M.A�a

*j-#�� .•a.����*.n�.�M*�.���'&*

.Il'-�t •• '*A�������A;j;..��.

2.'9:'iJ]if-�A4h1��/.};>J 1tit�1I:iE.�1��'i'H•.•�*A��

M#�.��.�.��.�I*�M.��.�*��-a'A

��.��.œ.;��•••#��*�M.��.�'iIÉ.�

*#l���.at.Il'-�••. ���t.*�#�.�.(�.�

•• ,�.���;j;...��.�.a�.�.M.A�:fJtnœ••)

3 .•*4•• IM�j-'H•••. ��.�a••��••�.��

j-#.ft'iIÉ.�IM4*��.��j-#.�a.�.�at��

£*4.Il'-j-#.'��*4.Il'-.ft*�••����••�m

.�at .••��j-#.�M.��a.aoc.

4.� ••�RtA�-ft*4'�••�a*j-'Haat*•. �.�

.�A�4•• �•••#at'.�.��A�.j-#�4.'iIÉ

163

Page 8: 5t ii .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::}j JI 151 JI 168ts.cpu.edu.tw/ezfiles/85/1085/attach/52/pta_9200_4817583... · 2015. 10. 23. · 5t ii " .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::"}j JI

.� ••���a'.��.aa••��'K�.��.���

�a�.400.' •••�•• ' ••*.�M�*.*'.'�

••#.�a���•• '�4�a.�.a�••�.�'AA�

�{*'+� , fA.��a.'

*���••MA••êa���ff���.��.ff.#AM��#'

��AUM.A•• '4.��.T:

(-) f'l m.�Ji!t.*ê{*,�JJiJR�'f#'t�1bMJJi� , 'i*HIl.�1b4l-.�•

• '.#••• �I�.�� •••• '�.M���ff••A.fi

�.1b••#'t�'.�J.�.�.����••••�M-'a*

••.•••#�.�*a�.£.�Aa.�•• 't��*.ff

#'t���••••A���.�,��••#�£.�'�.*�ff

.f.j�.��a'

(-=-).�� 'f#'t�(MJJi�)'Jl.jjj ...e{*,�••�.�»t•• ;I] , �it�r *

�••• 'a�*�.*.M�•• '*��a�••�A*it��

•• 'Ma••#f'lm�.K*�.�k���'

(..=.)�.a��{*,.#.��A.'i#*.' Jib;1Pll f'l A.�i' fA.a.#

.�#Y�;�••����a�••��La��»tfi.�'�.

a.�J���U1#•.

(11!l)• .ft. r {*,�.#�r*�.J ;MJt' �;.({t.K�I\!*��l;Ja.*�.�Jlt

;Iit.

(�)�.�••••8.f.j.MA.*êa�.#a*�.��, ••�

.�**t•••���&.�....#.'��••aa.MA

••êa��.#�8'�.�I�.���.M�.#.�aa�

••*••I�••••#.'���••••84•••••••

k»t•••••�.*,�� ••4�•••�.#.t�_••�

aa�oc'�•••M�aaaoc� ••a•.

165

Page 9: 5t ii .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::}j JI 151 JI 168ts.cpu.edu.tw/ezfiles/85/1085/attach/52/pta_9200_4817583... · 2015. 10. 23. · 5t ii " .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::"}j JI

J/t .... �AM:.o

(�)itl'à"�-tH:;Îf)�i:. r �tf;��J&,*J �Nr•• li#îf!ll�.tU�*J/tjIJz

il'-/; o [4]

*rA.ffl#A4�.MA••*.I'à".#.�fi••�••�M�

'f . �J;t f!tiH� lIIJ(fi.� ¥-� J¥-{i)f!t1t 4'-1* l'à" i!-# �JJ zJ¥-{i�A Jl tr;t

�1IIJ.��••M�;�*A.��#îMf!t*J¥-{i�tAIA••zM

�.#tr;t ••I'à".�t'f'�•••+IIIJI��''f•••���'

.l'à"t;Îf�IIIJ�t••z�À .••-;tz��••+¥-�afi.J¥-{i(

�•••I'à" •••��'�E+f!t1t••.••.••�tA._�t

J¥-{i)�At�lIIJt�:itaAJl <ftWiJll�' .�zm . �A*�f!ti!-AJl-f-* .

JE "f ti .... 5U1 ;t••*1* l'à" jfi *- o

mm��xJ&.��rz*#��ì�k¥��Am���*# .

•��*#.��r;tAA*#J/t.£.JE�-a'A*.�x�A�

.'.k.�m9��Am���xJ&.��r*#.I�z�.A#î

�'&�¥��Am���xJ&.��r*#£I'.l'à"t;Îf��#�

��I'à"*�#-�.A������*#"f���o

(-*.�••••��i:..I'à"' ••Axì&����W#.'��Aa

�•• ' •• ' ••A.��t�xJ&���#z£•. ��*tr;t

t� IIIJ M. it *#•� i:. #U1 A;lJI. jii, o

(�)��•••• '.�.IIIJA.I'à"�� •••A$•• 'xì&.�'.

�xì&!VJl..tc.�'i#.f-'£�'tìi. o

(�)mm••fi.A.I'à"*#� •• i:.'.*#."f�I��ì&'MA�

.�.�M��'A.�J¥-{i��1txJ&.�&.*'�"f�.��

*���*#.�.��.A.ffl#AzW#'�.MA••*.1'à"

167

Page 10: 5t ii .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::}j JI 151 JI 168ts.cpu.edu.tw/ezfiles/85/1085/attach/52/pta_9200_4817583... · 2015. 10. 23. · 5t ii " .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::"}j JI

It i! "" -fIi.�-4�-Jtil

�Wlft.+-�+'::'}j

Ji 85- Ji 98

Journal of Traffic Science

Central Police University

Vol. 2 No. 2

Dec. 2002, pp. 85-98

An Improving Policy for Traffic Enforcement and Road Safety

.I. �1lI. Ginn-Wang Wang'

.•�.�._,lti!����.�.���-.�'.�.K.�B.'

W�,r�*J�rlti!J���¥��k*�o��'��U¥��M��

.h�T'lti!.a��A.��T.,�.a.�.o.lt.M�#.*#

�' ••�IM�#.�oa.�.�••lti!_*a.�lti!*�M�' •

•••••�••lti!*��•• ,lt••a•••�alti!_*•••��

•• '#�'.8-'����••�A .•��••a�£�_*�.,�

*.N/j�a4;�-tlti!JJ.Jt 0

Abstract

Going along with the progress of society, traffic has become a part of daily life

of people and brought the huge and profound effect. Consequently, public security

and traffic have already been the two major missions for the police. Till now, the

number of deaths due to traffic accidents has decreased year by year, and it's very

effective. But, traffic problems are not only restricted to this. There're a lot of

issues to be solved. We hope that a series of new and planned actions can be made

and carried out by the review of history of traffic safety and the inspection of

present conditions of the traffic accident investigation and statistics of the

achievement of traffic enforcement to forecast policies of traffic enforcement and

j

1

85

Page 11: 5t ii .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::}j JI 151 JI 168ts.cpu.edu.tw/ezfiles/85/1085/attach/52/pta_9200_4817583... · 2015. 10. 23. · 5t ii " .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::"}j JI

��x����rA�����+A'A�;,���-a�4x�*�

.�.�.k.B'�t..X••�'.MW••*�.��M'*

��4�.���z.���'��*����-��4x���$�

;��X�'¥�.��nT'A����4x����rA��;,'

�-�A'.�����••��*�+AM.'�������WA

z��T�'A����4x����rA����'��OAo

�>JIJ �rA� �>JIJ �rA�

65 3632 78 7584

66 4087 79 7333

67 4798 80 7322

68 5281 81 7216

69 5504 82 7367

70 5618 83 7245

71 5475 84 7427

72 5434 85 7077

73 5676 86 6516

74 5517 87 5903

75 6270 88 5526

76 7034 89 5420

77 7524 90 4787

-ti : I. 'I#.� : {TJRI'J\;1tf�;f

2.•�;fM�.�*.���rA.'.ft•••••�.'�••��

��#��'��A*����r�o

�'�����x�*�$.-��x�.��rA.���A

+ AJ-J. r

�����.4X�*�.�.���.k,��t••X.'�

�.�'�••���z���a���4'���*���rn+#�

87

Page 12: 5t ii .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::}j JI 151 JI 168ts.cpu.edu.tw/ezfiles/85/1085/attach/52/pta_9200_4817583... · 2015. 10. 23. · 5t ii " .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::"}j JI

lf-1n- "1f3ti!i!��tt �1JJ.f.�tt

A+Alf- .::. ' 0 ,\ .::. ;il; 7L ' .li...li.. ,\ # - , ,\ � - ;il; -t ' -t ,', A�

A+7Llf- .::. ' - -t 7L ;il; � , .::.0 0 i'!' -,-tO.li..;iI;-'-O-t�

7L+lf- - , 7L -t � ;iI;.::. ' 7LA� {'!' - , -t�7L;iI; ,\ ' �.li...li..�

7L+-lf-- '��.::.;iI;�' --tAi'!' -,-tA.li..;iI;�'-A'::'�

(-.i.7LfJ)

(�7L+-lf--.i.7LfJ_���••��._�.3ti!i!�-'��.::.;iI;

#'f���.f.o'-t.li..#'�7L+lf-�M-'.li...li...::.;iI;#'�y,::,

.::.O;il;#(�y-�%),��3ti!#Mt.a.'���.ma* •

•*M.�"1f-t�O;il;#'��"1f#tt.li...li..%'����•• '

�.&���.�.t.i!�"1f.�.T:

i!JJI.'1i OIJftf.t*J<t

Ivt - .!f- - i Jr.. JJ Jr..+.!f--iJr..JJ �.ti<

i� I!f :Ii; -f-Jft.!f; : - 0 ;li; c::. ' -=. -l:; -=. # lf"- tt : - c::. ;li; Jr.. ' -=. Jr.. c::.# Jft f.t i.U" c::. - %

ite¥! : c::.;lI;11<I'Jr..li.-l:;# ite¥! : c::.;lI;-=,'li.Jr..--l:;# ite¥!!fht>:;'<%

Jt#l.�-b-f-Jft.!f; : -:;,<;lI; c::. • Jr.. AA# lf"- tt : c::. -=. ;li; Jr.. • -l:; Jr.. c::.# Jft f.t,... :y' -=. c::. %

,lJ!j'(::;,<.-l:;:;'<O# ,lJ!j'(:11<I;lI;Jr..':;'<li.c::.# ,lJ!j'(,...:Y. A:;'<%

-tAA-:Ii;-f--tAA-:Ii;-f-:c::.'11<I-l:;-# ite ¥! # tt.,... :Y' c::.

it 4i: • it rt - 11<1 -l:; it Jr.. % ' AtO�:y'(1iII,-f-)

ite¥! : - 11<1-=.# • c::.c::.O A ite1hf : c::.0 0 # • li.A-=.A f;..::..%

,lJ!i!Jfttt:c::.11<IO;ll;:;,<.c::.11<IJr.. lf"-tt : c::.li. -;lf; - , 0 A-

Jft tt,... :Y' 11<1 %# #

�.��, ( 4)Jfttt:-=.11<I;lI;-.-:;'<-l:;# Jft.!f; : -l:; 0 ;li; li. • Jr.. - -l:; # Jft tt i� :Y' li. c::.%

:Ii;-f-

�j!U�-f-Jftf.t::;'<-;lI;A'li.c::.:;,<#

Jftf.t:-Ac::.;lI;-=,'A011<lJfttti�:Y':;'<:;'<%

,f;.�*Nii #

1�m +#.>\ Jfttt:-=.;lI;Jr...011<lO#Jft.!f; : -;lI;-'-AO#

+.Ii)�JJ#tt.!f( Jr.. i + c::. JJ )

+rfJJ -tU- -t.li)�JJ11<I'-=.-=.A#-t.li)�JJc::..-l:;Jr..li.#

ht>li.li.%

Jfttt:--;lI;-'-=.A-=.#Jftf.t: - -=. ;li; li. • -=. -=. c::.1t

-t.li)�JJ#tt.,...,f;.**�>.ll' ( Jr.. i + c::. JJ )

-t.li)�!1-;lI;c::.'11<IA-l:;# �Y f;.-=-.%-t.li)�!1-=.;lI;-=..A-=.-=.#

89

Page 13: 5t ii .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::}j JI 151 JI 168ts.cpu.edu.tw/ezfiles/85/1085/attach/52/pta_9200_4817583... · 2015. 10. 23. · 5t ii " .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::"}j JI

-l:(�lf-#.IJ3.-t-=-Ef1t), 1'l]tE.J!:.i. A2 � (1:�) -l:#(�lf-#.IJ,\;!ri;

#), ,*-�M,}jf.JJ!:.i. A3 �-l:1t�-l:(�lf-#.IJ+ll!1;ii;1t) 0

4. ,*m�jE , i!� x.� :$tUPI i\'�%*- J . ýj}f�1r �$ft x.�:$M:-tÆ

Jl. . AA 1t.»t�*-� . fJ.1� Jl JfJ;,�'#.#dt 0 *-;f3E$t,m 'i!� x.�

:$M:»t�+.J'1rÆ••�t.�'3E••�»t�ÁJl#*-.�o

5. ��-t-*JfJ'J:$}M.»t�x.�:$M:' m 1t.+lf--}]�+-=-}]�jlfd1:$}

�Jf��-t-*ÁJl:$}�»t�x.�:$M:.���»t�£�'#*�,�

���+-���Jf��'-=-+A�:$}��'#�jlf�.'�*-;f,*

##��.A�l�,jE•••••£�æ�.o

6.jlf�-=-Mai!�x.�:$M:.�•••• '*-;f•••�.�a-t-*

ÁJl'$t,.M-.#'3E.��••M���.*jlf�•••• '

�llll.-;ii;A-t-M;Á 0

(-=-)�«A�

1. x.�:$M:.tjclt�jf-Á-�æ

1t.+lf-�����.���x.�:$M:-1t.;!ri;3.'�-=-3.#'�A3.'

3.ll!1ll!1ÁÆr'�;!ri;1t.'A�1t.Á1:�',#A+Alf-��.�A;!ri;

�'O-3.#'Ær-=-'3.1t.-=-Á'1:�3.;!ri;�'A�-Á�_�

*- 2 ' .�1HU';tfw-O;!ri; � , �-01't- (;l'tfw--=-A%)' Ær;l'tfw

1t.A-=-Á(;l'tfwll!10%)'1:�;l'tfwll!1;!ri;-=-'O-AÁ(;l'tfw--­

%)on*-;f'#m�;fx.�:$M:ÆrÁ.M�-tÆ�*���'��

�.d1+�-=-'ll!1�.�A-'ll!13..�*-3'x.�:$M:M�E.�jf

-Á-'tæo

2.x.�:$M:�:$Á��&.*3.+%

*-;f�1t.+lf-�Th�*¥�*��M:$M:.�Jl¥':$M:�*Á'

*�',*��'#��.Æ�Jl.ff-=-�».M••i\"��_:$)�

.i\'M*'�M�M£�Jl¥.�x.�:$M:£�-t��&��M.

*'��:$M:�:$Á���.*Ef:$}-t3.+'»t�£���.*,

*-;fJj1;-Mft&-f.�A E.Æ.AJii 0

91

Page 14: 5t ii .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::}j JI 151 JI 168ts.cpu.edu.tw/ezfiles/85/1085/attach/52/pta_9200_4817583... · 2015. 10. 23. · 5t ii " .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::"}j JI
Page 15: 5t ii .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::}j JI 151 JI 168ts.cpu.edu.tw/ezfiles/85/1085/attach/52/pta_9200_4817583... · 2015. 10. 23. · 5t ii " .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::"}j JI

(-=-HMtA lik-

i. it- <}1; iJA�h ' ;f;. ft- !t y k {tj- � � 14- :

���.���Y'�ffl���������*'���R�ft-!t

{tj-�'.��.���ft-!tA.��ÅMM.��M.4.��+

K#'�;f;.�••Åft-!tYk{tj-�.#,�����.*<}1;iJA

�'R�••••*.�.'�.E����*';f;.ft-!t�R{tj-�

� 14- '

2. Y -fl ft- ff:.i! �.IUh Ii!'. ' iim � � ....i� :7' I"l AK :

�+-.-�IA�'��.�+�.��.���.-.-'�

-�#'��.��.�'�OA#,.��+�ak�M��1"l

AK'��Y-fla.'.h�*T'�ft-ff:.i!a�.,

3. iim��.ft,-ei�:7'�i;-AK ' :i!A'il}J!Mt!ft :

�+-.-�IA��.�.*.�iJa-=-��Åft,-e'+�.�

ft,-e�KÅ'��.���.*.��A�+Åft,-e'.��+�

11i.i� :7' �i; - AK '

4. i�I1*T.�4jj.4'-�i;KAK:

�+-.��.'�����•••�#��*-fl�'�I�a*

T.' �KAK(A.��A, ••�I"lA)'ffl�

••��Å.�Xg�-fl�•••�,������AA-�.,�

.�ffl�.'�����.,���Aat�k�a�'

a�+-.��-a.'������A' ••�ilik�*��'

�*,.(*)���•••��.�T.�.�a.�.�.�.. '

/}t7it{l\;�� ' ••fI::J\:.i!J" ••1f�lii J" ••ii.###lii J' �*"••

�.*m�M*'�E�1;iJ•• '.�+K.Y••• '.h�*'

tT*T'T.A.k�'*.�#4••*.,�/}t7•••*mT.'

a.�.��,�.��•••��ft-!t,

95

Page 16: 5t ii .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::}j JI 151 JI 168ts.cpu.edu.tw/ezfiles/85/1085/attach/52/pta_9200_4817583... · 2015. 10. 23. · 5t ii " .::.. .::.. Jtrj 1 liL+-1f-+'::"}j JI

*������������#��T�#'��k��WÀ+�

#'a*�W�#��'�����*�������a������

�.A'��.#.¥••rn4A��.��a&.4a.m��a*

��.�.�'�••#��••�•••«••• ' •• '.A��

��'�R•• ,.*,���#���•.•�,*.�•• r ••

�M•••R�4��T��#������J'��•••�«���

������'��a&a��A.'�����'�m�+����

-a.Y.'_.�£•••$'�a*A.��_.'

�.*��••��M���.h'*.�+-�4.�r.��

4���M:lt+,*- 't.J!I J ' r �4���M: 't!ID $i-ilf*- il'.J!I J ' r -f'y �-f.*

�T�aikAj)l*-il'.J!IJ' r ��iHf/,*-il'#IJ' r !f.$i-$j��#Jl.-ka�

�1't�*#Jl.-kJF.I.m4il' J' r ��!f.#%���il'.liIJ 'f4l-'J���i)ll� ,

#���-'Aoo��4I-.#_a£�M�'�.*.�.#�.��

M*-il'��'�.-.$�.*'��.*a*£w.

rk*J�r��JM�••�*��'�.�.�A'��M���

�&&�M'��a4��'��.*A.'�.� .�-k�r.*��

i€J*��lh1-rfJJ��J �••.f,ij� , *>t4l-1-rjfH�rHt�#-fJJ r i€J* J' r-0­

**�J�r��*�J.�*t.��'�#A���.��•.f,ij�'�

�����M:�rA�'m�+��.*.rm�T�J'�+����M:�

rA��MT.�.��.'B_�+-�.�.1.R'.�••4I-.-k't

.f,ij�'*.����+�����M:�rA���+-����-A'��

��m�'��.�'�k�.4���,�r��a�hJ'R*an�ft

�'�fJJ•• '.�.�4I-�M.d' ••#.�IE�' •••"_h'

�.�A�-k�#���.*••�ra����J�••�$'�fJJ'.

97