4. conclusions regarding the annual scale generation, it is clear that the value computed from...
Post on 19-Dec-2015
213 views
TRANSCRIPT
4. CONCLUSIONSRegarding the annual scale generation, it is clear that the value
computed from historical record is well within the range of the synthetic series values and, in most cases, close to the average from 1000 series computed. This shows that the synthetic series reasonably preserve most of the historical record’s statistics in terms of annual precipitation.
Next task for the MDM conclusion is a debug procedure, in order to find what is wrong with the monthly step generation.
1. MONTHLY DISAGGREGATION MODEL - DUMThis model is based on a monthly time step, which avoids reproducing
zero rainfall sequences what is a rather complicated procedure. By selecting a disaggregation model one take advantage of the fact that in humid regions annual precipitation has an essentially normal distribution. This has the Central Limit Theorem support and also has been successfully verified by many statistical tests.
2. DESCRIPTION OF THE MODEL
SYNTHETIC RAINFALL SERIES GENERATION - MDM
Heinz D. Fill, André F. Santana, Miriam Rita Moro MineContacts: [email protected]
REFERENCES:HOMBERGER, G. M., RAFFENSBERGER, J. P., WILBERG, P. L. Elements of physical hydrology, John Opkins, University Press, Baltimore, 1998.KELMAN. J. Modelos estocásticos no gerenciamento de recursos hídricos. In:______. Modelos para Gerenciamento de Recursos Hídricos I. São Paulo: Nobel/ABRH. 1987. p. 387 - 388.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS:The research leading to these results has received funding from the
European Community's Seventh Framework Programme (FP7/2007-2013) under Grant Agreement N° 212492. Third author also would like to thank “Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico-CNPq” for the financial support.
Annual time step precipitation generation
Disaggregation in a monthly time step
2.1. Annual PrecipitationIt has been assumed that total annual precipitation is not serially
correlated, but cross correlation among rainfall stations was considered. Also annual precipitation has been assumed to be normally distributed what is supported both by empirical evidence (Homberger et al., 1998) and also by the Central Limit Theorem. So, generation of multisite annual precipitation series is reduced to a multivariate normal distributed random numbers generation.
In serially uncorrelated hydrologic variables case, they may be modeled by the equation (Kelman, 1987):
Where x(t) is a vector of k (number of sites) cross-correlated random variables, z(t) is a size k independent random variables vector and B is a coefficients matrix, obtained from the sites correlation matrix. Variables are attached to a time index t.
2.2. Monthly PrecipitationThe chosen method uses disaggregation coefficients computed from
historical records. It is called Hydrologic Scenarios Method.
For each historical record year, a matrix Dj (j=1, 2, …, m) (m = length of historical record) with size k x 12 (k = number of sites) is constructed. Its elements are:
3. MDM’S VALIDATIONFor MDM validation some synthetic
series statistics have been compared to those computed from the historical records on the selected sites within the La Plata Basin. Figure 2 shows their geographical location within the study area.
All the algorithms were developed in Matlab (R13, The Mathworks Inc, 2000, under license) software.
3.1. Annual Validation
It have been generated 1000 series of 62 year long each one (the same length as the historical record) and the following statistics have been computed: Figure 2: Selected Sites for Validation
# Convention Site Name
1 Monte Carmelo2 Monte Alegre3 Usina Couro do Cervo4 Franca5 Fazenda Barreirinho6 Tomazina7 União da Vitória8 Lagoa Vermelha9 Caiuá
Table 1: Sites number convention
)(.)( tt zBx
)(
)()(
jP
jPjd
i
imim
Where Pim(j) represents the month m, site i and year j precipitation, while Pi(j) is the site i and year j annual precipitation. Given an annual precipitations series, disaggregation proceeds randomly combining each matrix Dj with the annual amounts.
The model is structured in 2 Modules and performs sequentially the following steps (Figure 1):
Compute mean and variance at each site
Standardize mean annual precipitation
Compute the correlation matrix
Compute the coefficient matrix (B)
Compute the disaggregation matrices (Dj)
Generate k independent standard
normal random number
Transform standard normal vector into cross correlated
random vector, using:
Obtain the length m cross correlated annual
precipitation series
Apply the Hydrologic Scenarios Method to
disaggregate annual in monthly precipitation
)(.)( tt zBx
Module 1
Module 2
Figure 1: Procedures Sequence in MDM
•Mean, Standard Deviation and Skew Coefficient;•Number of consecutive years below/above mean;•Each synthetic series correlation matrix;•Maximum cumulative deficit for 80% of mean.
The last item has an important effect on flow regulation studies because influences significantly hydropower generation in well regulated systems, such as the Brazilian interconnected system. Some of the results are shown in Figures 3, 4 and 5; sites convention numbers are expressed in Table 1.
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Site
Mea
n (m
m)
Minimum Maximum Average Observed
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Site
Sta
ndar
d D
evia
tion
(m
m)
Minimum Maximum Average Observed
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
SiteC
umul
ativ
e D
efic
it (m
m)
Minimum Maximum Average Observed
Figure 3: Validation - Mean
Figure 4: Validation – Standard Deviation
Figure 5: Validation – Cumulative Deficit
3.2. Monthly ValidationIn the monthly step mean, standard deviation and autocorrelation
seasonal values were computed, for both historical and synthetic values. Besides, analogous procedure of annual validation was followed for synthetic values, with maximum, minimum and average values calculated.
The first results, however, showed a discrepancy between the original and generated series for some of the sites. This fact was attributed to some programming bug, which will be revised and fixed soon.