35+2 ,]+-, 0 +2 , 8( #?micro.econ.kit.edu/downloads/puppe_journal_18_modelling... · 2009-12-09 ·...

32

Upload: others

Post on 27-Dec-2019

19 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 35+2 ,]+-, 0 +2 , 8( #?micro.econ.kit.edu/downloads/Puppe_journal_18_Modelling... · 2009-12-09 · , " 0 %)*+-,/.1 +2 #" +-0 ( +-35461( ("! , 0 %)*35+2 , 4 +-,#& ! 35+2 , 798( %-%

� ������������� ������������������������������! "��#�%$

&('�)+*-,/./02143+576-8

9;:=<?>A@CBEDF:=G�BIHAJLKNMOH�G2H�DFPQM=R=S2TIG2P U�:=@VRCP BXW(HAJNYZ>A[ P J\H�@EG2PQ>/>]B;9^>_U�PQR9^>_U�PQR=S`YZacb�dAe2fge2ShT!i jki a!i

>AG?l

m '�02n;026-,/o^*4p2p20

9;:=<?>A@CBEDF:=G�BIHAJqKNMOH�G2H�DFPQM=R=ShTIG2P U�:=@VRCP BXW(HAJqrZH�G2Ga;lh:=G?>As2:=@V>A[ [ :=:!t]uAvwu�thS�9%x�dAy2f�fgy/rZH�G2G4S?z^:=@ED(>AG�W

{|:=U�PQRC:gl+S?j�:=<hBE:=D~}`:=@^tA����t

�C�]�����_�X� �g� �_�h�X���|�|�X�O�����V�_�����_�����X����� ���_���+�Z�V�������w�E����� �_�����^�O�����Q�V�!�+�V�_�|�_��V�����_�X�C���L�V�_� �X�h�A�V� ���������� �V¡�����¢|£-�C�V�Q�=���_�-�]�V����� �X� �]�V�O���+�V�����_���X���g� �X���X�_�X�I¤�¥4�_�-¦`�X���_���|� �X�k�V�h�k� �=�_� §O�X����� �7¢g¨N�E�+©Lª«�g�V�O�w�N�+�V��¬]�V�w�g�­ �X¢!®�¯�¯g°��2�V�_�!�7�+�^�V�_���O¢g�|���_������� �X���X�X�C±N�2� �]�V�_�X� �V�?���_�_�A�������V�k���_�|���X�g�����w�_�|�]�������w�=�_�_�������X�|�X� �_���w�]�E� �² ���2�q³+�_�_�_�X�-���w�V�O�-´`�~°C¯�µO¶V·E w°q� �-�V� ���#���w�E����� �_� � ¢^�V�w¸=�_�C�-� �X�_���X��±

Page 2: 35+2 ,]+-, 0 +2 , 8( #?micro.econ.kit.edu/downloads/Puppe_journal_18_Modelling... · 2009-12-09 · , " 0 %)*+-,/.1 +2 #" +-0 ( +-35461( ("! , 0 %)*35+2 , 4 +-,#& ! 35+2 , 798( %-%

�������������� �������������������������������� �!�#"$��%&���'�!�(����)*��+-,/.��,�" 0�% )*+-,/.�1�+2�#"+-0���(��+-35461(�����("!�,��0�% )*35+2�,����4 +-,#&�����!�35+2�,�798(�%-% �(" 3:���;���/4% ��.<��,���35+28=35���(�>�!�#"$��% ?6@��/+-% �A�0�+2"+-,/.!3:���B��35���,/.������35��+28�35+2�,����C&D@E��+-3:F��!�,HG �JICK�L$L�M�NPOQ8�% �$"+R��35+28/ST���$�����#�$8(�<793:�������/4% ��.<��,���35+28T35���(�=�!�#"$��%H����U3Q�+-,���� )�8(���C&�3:���T�!�3:�����!�35+28(�%V��+-�B��% +28�+-354W�C&�3:���J8�% �$"+R��35+28 �!�#"$��% ?>X�,������35+28�)*% ��(7�+-,Y3:������/4% ��.<��,���35+28A35���(�>�!�#"$��%�3:���A"+-0���(��+-354��C&=�,�4�����39�C&B�5���(8�+2���=8(�,�1(�'���(8�)*�(��+-0��% 4!"$��3Q����� +-,��("&(����Z3:���[���+-��\;+R���J"+R�(��+-� +-% ���+-35+2���!1(��35\9�(��,]3:�����!?! ����T������35��+28�35+2�,��A+-�B�������("D1�4!3:���^���/4% �U.<��,���35+28T35���(�T�!�#"$��%��,Y3:��� )*,�"$����% 4+-,/.W"+R�(��+-� +-% ���+-354W�!��35��+28J����J8(������$8�3Q����+ F#�("E�,�"!�����\;,3Q�_1(��\9�(�#`$���E3:���,a3:�������Y��,�3Q�+-% �("b1�4c3:���]8�% �$"+R��35+28Y�!�#"$��% ?ed>,f���5���(8�+2�%-% 4E����(��+-�!�,��)/�0���(��+2�,Y�C&=3:���9���/4% ��.<��,���35+28T35���(�=�!�#"$��%H+R���$1�3Q�+-,��("61�4J+-,�0�#`+-,/.D�,]���$����������+2�3Q�T,��35+2�,Y�C&35���,���% �35+2�,]+-,�0���+2�,�8(�#?

Page 3: 35+2 ,]+-, 0 +2 , 8( #?micro.econ.kit.edu/downloads/Puppe_journal_18_Modelling... · 2009-12-09 · , " 0 %)*+-,/.1 +2 #" +-0 ( +-35461( ("! , 0 %)*35+2 , 4 +-,#& ! 35+2 , 798( %-%

� ��������� ����������

���2PQR|<?>A<`:=@;>�l2lh@E:gRERC:gRZB��2:!<2@EH�}2[ :=D HAJ�B��2:!DFHhlh:=[ [ P G��(HAJq}2P HhlhP U�:=@VRCP BXW�i��2@EH�D >AG :gMOH�G2H�DFPQM<`:=@VRC<`:gM�BEP U�:�SLB��2:�MO:=G�BE@V>A[�BV>�R�� PQR!BEH <2@EH]U�PQlh:��#>_WhR!HAJ;MOH�G?RXBE@Es?M�BEP G�� RCHhMOP :OBXW�� R!<2@E:OJ\:=@E:=G?MO:gRH]U�:=@"lhP k:=@E:=G�B!MOH�G?RC:=@EU]>]BEP H�G <`H�[ PQMOP :gR=i��2@EH�D >�}2P H�[ H!��PQM=>A[�<`:=@VRC<`:gM�BEP U�:�SkB��2:(PQRERCs2:/PQR^BEH lh:OvU�:=[ H�<�>A<2<2[ PQM=>A}2[ :(DF:g>�RCs2@E:gR�HAJI}2P HhlhP U�:=@VRCP BXW�i�"�G$#Ea%���2:=H�@EW HAJI9;P U�:=@VRCP BXW'&)(+*I:,�2@EP G�� >AG?l-�s2<2<`:.(�tA����t!/�S!�2:=G?MO:OJ\H�@CB����|90(�tA����t!/�/�S!�Z:1�?>_U�:Ilh:=U�:=[ H�<`:gl(> � )*% 35+-U �3535��+21�)*3Q�=���$�����#�$8(� BEHU]>A[ s2P G�� >AG?l DF:g>�RCs2@EP G���lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW�i2"wBVR"}?>�RCPQM!PQlh:g>«PQR;BEH«B��2P G�� HAJ�B��2:(lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW HAJZ>�RC:OB"HAJ:=G�BEP BEP :gR#>�R#lh:=@EP U�:gl(J\@EH�D B��2:^G�s2D~}`:=@|>AG?l��Z:=P �!��B#HAJ4B��2:�lhP k:=@E:=G�B �3535��+21�)*3Q��� <`H�RERC:gRERC:gl(}�WB��2:=D i3�:g>�RCs2@E:gR�HAJ+lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW�B��?>]BN>A@E:#}?>�RC:gl4(\:�5h<2[ PQMOP BE[ W~H�@qP DF<2[ PQMOP BE[ W�/LH�G/B��2:1��:=G2:=@V>A[�PQlh:g>HAJLMOH�s2G�BEP G��F>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR2(�#XJ\:g>]BEs2@E:gR=S &6#EM7�?>A@V>�M�BE:=@EPQRXBEPQM=R�&8/9�?>_U�:^}`:=:=G�<2@EH�<`H�RC:glFJ\@E:;:�s2:=G�BE[ W P GB��2:I[ P BE:=@V>]BEs2@E:.(�RC:=:�S�>ADFH�G���HAB��2:=@VR=S!<�>AG2:Ov>= @EP �!��BgS8?Is2DF<��2@EP :gRN>AG?l@= P [ [ PQ>AD(RA(Xfgb�b2fB/�S8�?>AP B��(Xfgb�b�t!/�S!= :=P B�C=D(>AGD(Xfgb�b�thS?fgb�b!E8/�Shj�H�[ HF��S8-LH�[Q>�R���W/>AG?l rZ@EH�>�lhs?RA(Xfgb�b�y8/�S8�?>AP B���>AG?lG= >A[ ��:=@(Xfgb�bAuH/�S'= P [ [ PQ>AD(RI>AG?lI?Is2DF<��2@EP :gRJ(Xfgb�b�e8/�S��#P [ D(>AG)(Xfgb�bHKL/�S'= :=P �]>A@VlM(�tA����t!/�S?>AG?l«B��2:�U�H�[ vs2DF:gR«:glhP BE:gl }�W z">�RXBEH�GN(Xfgb�b�e8/(>AG?lO-LH�[Q>�R���WP(�tA���2fB/�/�iRQ;G2: ��H�>A[IHAJ.�|9S(�tA����t!/FPQR(BEHJ\H�@ED(>A[ P C=:�B��2PQR;PQlh:g>(P G >���:=G2:=@V>A[->AG?l�s2G2P T?:gl J\@V>ADF:,�ZH�@��ki1���2:~D~s2[ BEP v�>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:/>A<2<2@EH�>�M7�>A[ [ HF�IR/J\H�@ U]>A@EP H�s?R lhP k:=@E:=G�B«P G�BE:=@E<2@E:OBV>]BEP H�G?RFHAJ"B��2:U#C:=G�BEP BEP :gR�&M�1�2H�RC: lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW�PQR DF:g>]vRCs2@E:gl+i2���2:gRC:~D(>_W }`:���:=G2:gR=S`P G?lhP U�PQlhs?>A[LH�@���>AG2PQRCD(R=S`RC<`:gMOP :gR=SkH�@;:gMOH�RCWhRXBE:=D(R=i^9;:=<`:=G?lhP G��H�G«B��2:!M7�2H�RC:=G�[ :=U�:=[+HAJLlh:gREMO@EP <hBEP H�G4S�B��2:�@E:=[ :=U]>AG�BI>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR1�|P [ [+}`:!lhP k:=@E:=G�Bgi"�G�B��2:!M=>�RC:HAJLRC<`:gMOP :gR=Sh:�52>ADF<2[ :gRZHAJ�@E:=[ :=U]>AG�BI>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR|>A@E:4#ERCs?M7��[ P G��~B��2:=P @|W�H�s2G��?S & #C[ P U�P G��~J\H�@|DFH�@E:B��?>AG�fg�����;W�:g>A@VR=S &�#XJ\:=:glhP G��"H�G/DFH�[ [ s?REM=R=S &;H�@2#Elh:gREMO:=G?lhP G��^J\@EH�D >A@VM7�2:=H�<hBE:=@EW85+i &IK52>ADF<2[ :gRHAJ�>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gRZHAJ�:gMOH�RCWhRXBE:=D(RZ>A@E:V#EMOH�G�BV>AP G2P G��/>~<?>A@CBEPQMOs2[Q>A@#RC<`:gMOP :gR=S &!H�@@#EMOH�G�BV>AP G2P G��~>~<?>A@CvBEPQMOs2[Q>A@~RC:OB~HAJIMOH�DF<2[ :=DF:=G�BV>A@EW RC<`:gMOP :gR�&�RCs?M7��>�R�<?>A@CBEPQMOs2[Q>A@!<2@E:gl2>]BEH�@Cvw<2@E:=W�@E:=[Q>]BEP H�G?R��2P <?R=i"�G�B��2PQR|<?>A<`:=@gS'�Z:2�|P [ [4}`:!MOH�G?MO:=@EG2:glV�|P B�� �5���(8�+2��� lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW HAJL>/<?>A@CBEPQMOs2[Q>A@1��P G?l+i

Q;G2:"G2:=:gl2RZBEH(MO[ :g>A@E[ W lhPQRXBEP G���s2PQR��«B��2:�[ :=U�:=[+HAJ�DF:g>�RCs2@E:=DF:=G�B#J\@EH�D B��2:�[ :=U�:=[kHAJqMOH�G?RC:=@CvU]>]BEP H�G >�M�BEP H�G4i/a;R"BEH«B��2:([Q>]BCBE:=@gS+B��2:=@E:FPQR">�}2@EH�>�l MOH�G?RC:=G?RCs?R;B��?>]B�:� k:gM�BEP U�:F}2P HhlhP U�:=@VRCP BXWMOH�G?RC:=@EU]>]BEP H�G�<`H�[ PQMOP :gRFG2:=:gl�BEH }`:�lhP @E:gM�BE:gl >]B(@E:gRC:=@EU�: RCP BE:gRFH�@F:=U�:=G�:=G�BEP @E: :gMOH�RCWhRXBE:=D(R,WJ\@E:;:�s2:=G�BE[ W�S?P B;PQRIP DF<2@V>�M�BEPQM=>A[�S2H�@I:=U�:=G H�shBE@EP �!��BIP GhJ\:g>�RCP }2[ :�S?BEHFBV>A@���:OB;RCP G���[ :!RC<`:gMOP :gRIP G�PQRCHAv[Q>]BEP H�G4i*IH�G2:OB��2:=[ :gRER=ShP BX�|P [ [+HAJ7BE:=G�}`:"B��2:�MOH�G?RC:=@EU]>]BEP H�G HAJLRC<`:gMOP :gRY(\G2HABI@E:gRC:=@EU�:^RCP BE:gR7/�B��?>]BH�G2:Zs2[ BEP D(>]BE:=[ W!M=>A@E:gR�>A}`H�shBgi9���2PQR-BZ�ZHAvw<2@EH�G���:gl�>A<2<2@EH�>�M7��PQR-BV>L��:=G4S_J\H�@�P G?RXBV>AG?MO:�S]}�W!aIG?lhH?SYZ>ADFD S[-LH�[Q>�R���W«>AG?l�j�H�[ HF�\(Xfgb�b!E8/2(�RC:=:!>A[QRCH aI@ED(R��ZH�@CB��4S^]":=G?l2>A[ [->AG?l�9^>_U�PQRJ(�tA����t!/NJ\H�@>AG H]U�:=@EU�P :,�A/�i_*IHABE:"B��?>]B;H�G�B��2PQR|U�P :,��ShB��2:!:gMOH�[ H!��PQM=>A[kP G�BE:=@E@E:=[Q>]BEP H�G?R|>ADFH�G��(RC<`:gMOP :gR#B��?>]Blh:OBE:=@EDFP G2:"B��2:�H�shBVMOH�DF:gR#HAJqMOH�G?RC:=@EU]>]BEP H�G�<`H�[ PQMOP :gR|>A@E:�>AG?>A[ W�BEPQM=>A[ [ W«RC:=<?>A@V>]BE:;J\@EH�D B��2:!>�RXvRC:gRERCDF:=G�B~HAJ#B��2:«@E:gRCs2[ BEP G�� }2P HhlhP U�:=@VRCP BXW�i�"�G B��2:«[Q>AG���s?>L��:FHAJI:gMOH�G2H�DFPQM=R=S-B��2: J\H�@EDF:=@~>A@E:<?>A@CB!HAJ#B��2:`#XBE:gM7�2G2H�[ H!��W'&«HAJ|}2P HhlhP U�:=@VRCP BXW MOH�G?RC:=@EU]>]BEP H�G4Sa�1�2P [ :(B��2: [Q>]BCBE:=@!PQR!>�D(>]BCBE:=@!HAJRCHhMOP :OBV>A[+<2@E:OJ\:=@E:=G?MO:gRY(�RC:=:!j�:gM�BEP H�G thi e~}`:=[ HF��J\H�@I>AG�:=[Q>A}`H�@V>]BEP H�G[/�i

"�G > }2P H�[ H!��PQM=>A[qMOH�G�BE:�5�BgS-H�G2: M=>AG lhPQRXBEP G���s2PQR�� B��2@E:=:(D(>AP G BXW�<`:gR�HAJ|RC<`:gMOP :gR!lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW�b��:=G2:OBEPQM^lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW�S�J\s2G?M�BEP H�G?>A[4lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW�S�>AG?l <���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQM^lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW�i�?I:=@E:�S�H�s2@ZJ\HhMOs?RZPQRZH�GB��2:([Q>]BCBE:=@gi«rZW <���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQMFlhP U�:=@VRCP BXWI�Z:(DF:g>AG B��2:(DFH�@E<��2H�[ H!��PQM=>A[qlhP U�:=@VRCP BXW�HAJ|RC<`:gMOP :gR}?>�RC:gl~H�G/B��2:=P @�:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G?>A@EW�lh:gREMO:=G�Bgi_Q;s2@q:=DF<2P @EPQM=>A[?RXBV>A@CBEP G��"<`H�P G�B�PQR�B���s?RLB��2:|:=U�H�[ shBEP H�Ghv>A@EW/BE@E:=:^lh:gREMO@EP }2P G��!B��2:c��:=G2:g>A[ H!��W~HAJ�RC<`:gMOP :gR=i���2:^@E:=[ :=U]>AG�B#>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gRZ>A@E:V#��2H�DFH�[ H!��P :gR=S &P�i :�iqR��?>A@E:gl�M7�?>A@V>�M�BE:=@EPQRXBEPQM=R�P G��2:=@EP BE:gl J\@EH�D > MOH�DFDFH�G >AG?MO:gRXBEH�@gSLP G MOH�G�BE@V>�RXB~BEHd#��2H�DFHAv<2[Q>�RCP :gR=S &�P�i :�ihR��?>A@E:gl M7�?>A@V>�M�BE:=@EPQRXBEPQM=R�lhs2:;BEH~B��2:">�l2>A<hBV>]BEP H�G(BEH/>/MOH�DFDFH�G��#>_W/HAJ-[ P J\:�i_�2H�@P G?RXBV>AG?MO:�S�B��2:;RCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW/}`:OBZ�Z:=:=G >�}2P @Vl2R,�!�|P G��~>AG?l(>Y��s2D(>AG >A@ED @E:=<2@E:gRC:=G�BVR�>Y�2H�DFH�[ H!��W(7B��2:�P G��2:=@EP BE:gl«}2shB;lhP k:=@E:=G�BE[ W«>�l2>A<hBE:gl«@E:=<hBEP [ PQ>AG«J\H�@E:=[ P D~}[/�S'�1�2P [ :^B��2:!RCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW(}`:OBZ�Z:=:=GB��2:Y�|P G��FHAJq>/}2P @Vl >AG?l B��2:Y�|P G��FHAJq>/}?>]B;MOH�@E@E:gRC<`H�G?l2R�BEH >��2H�DFH�<2[Q>�RCW�i

Q;G2: HAJ;B��2:�T?@VRXBG�ZH�@��]>A}2[ :�DFHhlh:=[QRFHAJ"lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW }?>�RC:gl�H�G :=U�H�[ shBEP H�G?>A@EW P GhJ\H�@ED(>]BEP H�G�#>�R�lh:=U�:=[ H�<`:gl }�W6= :=P B�C=D(>AGU(Xfgb�b�t!/�i«K k:gM�BEP U�:=[ W�S9�2PQR�DFHhlh:=[Z>�RERCs2DF:gR^B��?>]B/>A[ [�@E:=[ :=U]>AG�B

f

Page 4: 35+2 ,]+-, 0 +2 , 8( #?micro.econ.kit.edu/downloads/Puppe_journal_18_Modelling... · 2009-12-09 · , " 0 %)*+-,/.1 +2 #" +-0 ( +-35461( ("! , 0 %)*35+2 , 4 +-,#& ! 35+2 , 798( %-%

>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR;MOH�@E@E:gRC<`H�G?l BEH(B��2:~M7�?>A@V>�M�BE:=@EPQRXBEPQM=R|R��?>A@E:gl�}�W �%-% RC<`:gMOP :gR|P G�B��2:~RE>ADF:I#EMO[Q>�lh:�S &P�i :�ih}�W«>A[ [4RC<`:gMOP :gRNB��?>]B;lh:gREMO:=G?l J\@EH�D >FMOH�DFDFH�G�>AG?MO:gRXBEH�@gi����s?R=S'�Z:c�|P [ [4@E:OJ\:=@ZBEH@= :=P B�COvD(>AG�� R;DFHhlh:=[L>�R|B��2: 8�% �$"+R��35+28J�!�#"$��% i2���2:~D(>��XH�@;@E:gRXBE@EPQM�BEP H�G�HAJqB��2PQR;DFHhlh:=[qlh:=@EP U�:gR#J\@EH�DB��2:"J�>�M�B|B��?>]B;>A[ [-MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM�>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR@#C[ P U�:^J\H�@E:=U�:=@;b &~H�G?MO:�>(RC<`:gMOP :gR��?>�R#J\H�s2G?lh:gl >FMO[Q>�lh:�S>A[ [#lh:gREMO:=G?l2>AG�BVR/R��?>A@E:«P BVR/MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM�M7�?>A@V>�M�BE:=@EPQRXBEPQM=R=S�}�W lh:�T?G2P BEP H�G4i)���2PQR/:=G�BV>AP [QR=SLJ\H�@/P GhvRXBV>AG?MO:�S�B��?>]BZ[Q>]BE:=@#RC<`:gMOP :gR#>A@E:;RCs2<`:=@EP H�@NBEH~:g>A@E[ P :=@NH�G2:gRNP G�>AG :�5�BE@E:=DF:;J\H�@ED�bL>~RC<`:gMOP :gR��?>�R,�� D(>A@���P G?>A[hlhP U�:=@VRCP BXW~U]>A[ s2:I>�Rq[ H�G���>�RqH�G2:|HAJkP BVRNRCs?M=MO:gRERCH�@VRLRCs2@EU�P U�:gR=i�a @E:=[Q>]BE:gl/MO@EP BEPQMOPQRCD�?>�R#}`:=:=G�<2shB|J\H�@��#>A@Vl }�W4�?>AP B��)(Xfgb�bAuH/��1�2H(>A@���s2:gl B��?>]BgS2P DF<2[ PQMOP BE[ W�S2B��2:!MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM"DFHhlh:=[>�RERCs2DF:gR|>FMOH�G?RXBV>AG�BIRC<`:=:gl«HAJL:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G4i

�-H H]U�:=@VMOH�DF:"B��2:gRC:FMO@EP BEPQMOPQRCD(R=S[�Z:~<2@EH�<`H�RC:J�2:=@E:!B��2:D#C<���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQM"BE@E:=:~DFHhlh:=[ &«>�R;>G?>]BEs2@V>A[[��:=G2:=@V>A[ P Cg>]BEP H�G(HAJa= :=P B�C=D(>AG�� R#MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM;DFHhlh:=[�S�@E:OBV>AP G2P G��/D~s?M7� HAJ-P BVRZD(>]B��2:=D(>]BCvPQM=>A[�RCP DF<2[ PQMOP BXW�iG���2:FD(>AP G G2:,� J\:g>]BEs2@E:FHAJZB��2:F<���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQM!BE@E:=:FDFHhlh:=[�PQR"P BVR�>A}2P [ P BXW�BEH>�M=MOH�s2G�B^J\H�@"G2H�Ghv�MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM/>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR�RCs?M7� >�R;B��2H�RC:(lh:=@EP U�:gl�J\@EH�D B��2:M#��4P G2G2:g>AG^& BV>F5hH�GhvH�D~W HAJ#RC<`:gMOP :gR=i@"�G?lh:=:gl+S4B��2:(<2@E:gRC:=G�B"<?>A<`:=@!M=>AG }`:(U�P :,�Z:gl >�R�>AG >A@���s2DF:=G�B"P G J�>_U�H�@^HAJ>!G2:=HAvw[ P G2G2:g>AG }2@EH�>�lh:=G2P G��~HAJ4BV>F5hH�G2H�D~W�(7J\H�@|>!<2[ :g>!J\H�@�#�*I:=H�[ P G2G2:g>AG�"�DF<2@E:gRERCP H�G2PQRCD S &!RC:=:�-s?l'��:G(�tA�����8/�/�i

���2:"<?>A<`:=@#PQR#H�@���>AG2P C=:gl >�RZJ\H�[ [ HF�IR=i�"�G«B��2:^J\H�[ [ HF�|P G��(j�:gM�BEP H�G�thS'�Z:"}2@EP :��?W(@E:=U�P :,��B��2:}?>�RCPQM�MOH�G?MO:=<hBVR;>AG?l«BEH�H�[QRIHAJ�B��2:~D~s2[ BEP v�>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:~>A<2<2@EH�>�M7��P G�BE@EHhlhs?MO:gl�P G �|9 (�tA����t!/�i�"�G<?>A@CBEPQMOs2[Q>A@gSa�Z: lh:�T?G2:(B��2:«G2HABEP H�G HAJI>�lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW J\s2G?M�BEP H�G�>�R!>AG�>A<2<2@EH�<2@EPQ>]BE:(>L�!��@E:,��>]BEH�@HAJ�>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:A�Z:=P �!��BVR=iqa%lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW~J\s2G?M�BEP H�G«G?>]BEs2@V>A[ [ WFP G?lhs?MO:gRZ<?>AP @��|PQRC:;lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BEP :gRN}`:OvBZ�Z:=:=G«RC<`:gMOP :gR=i�= :^>A[QRCH~P G�BE@EHhlhs?MO:IB��2:^MOH�G?MO:=<hBZHAJA#CDFH�G2HABEH�G2PQMOP BXW/P G«lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW�S &Y�1�2PQM7�@E:;:�s2P @E:gR;B��2:(lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW�HAJ#>AG >A@E}2P BE@V>A@EW�RC:OB�HAJ#RC<`:gMOP :gR;BEH }`: lh:OBE:=@EDFP G2:gl }�W�B��2:F<?>AP @��|PQRC:lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BEP :gR�}`:OBZ�Z:=:=G P BVRN:=[ :=DF:=G�BVRNP G«>!DFH�G2HABEH�G2:|J�>�R��2P H�G4i���2:^RC:gM�BEP H�G MOH�G?MO[ s?lh:gR��|P B��>/}2@EP :OJqlhPQREMOs?RERCP H�G�H�G«B��2:�:gMOH�G2H�DFPQM^P G�BE:=@E<2@E:OBV>]BEP H�G«HAJqlhP U�:=@VRCP BXWFB��2:=H�@EW�i

"�G�j�:gM�BEP H�G«y2S8�Z:IBEs2@EG(BEH~:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G?>A@EW!BE@E:=:gRN>AG?l lhPQREMOs?RERqBZ�ZH~<`H�[Q>A@��#>_WhRqHAJ4DFHhlh:=[ [ P G��lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW!}?>�RC:gl/H�G(:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G?>A@EW�P GhJ\H�@ED(>]BEP H�G4iLa;RN>"DFHhlh:=[?HAJkDFP G2P D(>A[`RC<`:gMOP T2BXW�S8�Z:|P G�BE@EHAvlhs?MO:^B��2:I#XBE@E:=:"DFHhlh:=[ &F>AG?l�R��2HF� B��?>]BIP BIPQRZBEH�HFs2G?RXBE@Es?M�BEs2@E:gl BEH RC:=@EU�:">�R#>/s?RC:OJ\s2[4DFHhlh:=[HAJ4}2P HhlhP U�:=@VRCP BXW�i9= :;B��2:=G«@E:=U�P :,�O= :=P B�C=D(>AG�� R#MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQMIDFHhlh:=[[�1�2PQM7�«@E:=<2@E:gRC:=G�BVRqB��2:^HAB��2:=@:�5�BE@E:=DF:#HAJkD(>F5hP D(>A[?RC<`:gMOP T2BXW�i����2:IMO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM#DFHhlh:=[2PQRqM7�?>A@V>]BE:=@EP C=:gl!}�W/>"RCP DF<2[ :IMOH�G?lhP BEP H�GH�GFB��2:IJ�>ADFP [ W/HAJ4@E:=[ :=U]>AG�BN>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR=S�B��2:V#�*I:gRXBEP G��.-�@EH�<`:=@CBXW�S &c�1�2PQM7�«RXBV>]BE:gRqB��?>]BZ>AG�W~BZ�ZH>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gRI>A@E:":=P B��2:=@;MOH�DF<2[ :OBE:=[ W�s2G2@E:=[Q>]BE:gl«H�@IH�G2:�PQR|DFH�@E:�RC<`:gMOPQ>A[+B��?>AG�B��2:!HAB��2:=@giNa;RI>MOH�G?RC:;:�s2:=G?MO:"HAJ�B��2PQR|<2@EH�<`:=@CBXW�S2lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW P G�B��2:!MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM"DFHhlh:=[-M=>AG�}`:!lh:OBE:=@EDFP G2:gl�s?RCP G��> RCP DF<2[ : @E:gMOs2@VRCP H�G�J\H�@ED~s2[Q>2i ?IHF�Z:=U�:=@gSqB��2:�MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM�DFHhlh:=[|HL k:=@VR~BEH�H [ P BCBE[ :��?:�5hP }2P [ P BXWRCP G?MO:|B��2:c*I:gRXBEP G��.-�@EH�<`:=@CBXW~P DF<`H�RC:gR�U�:=@EW/RXBE@EH�G���@E:gRXBE@EPQM�BEP H�G?RqH�GFB��2:IJ�>ADFP [ W/HAJ4>�lhDFPQRERCP }2[ :>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR=i@= :FB��2:=G lhPQREMOs?RERY�?>AP B���� RG(Xfgb�b�t!/|J\@E:;:�s2:=G�BE[ W s?RC:gl DFHhlh:=[qHAJ#<���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQM/lhP vU�:=@VRCP BXW�i�=O�2P [ :"B��?>]BIDFHhlh:=[4H]U�:=@VMOH�DF:gR�B��2:Y�Z:g>L��G2:gRERCG2:gRZHAJ-B��2:!MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM"DFHhlh:=[�S2P BI:=G�BV>AP [QRHAB��2:=@|<2@EH�}2[ :=D(>]BEPQM^@E:gRXBE@EPQM�BEP H�G?R=Sh>�R|R��2HF�|G�P G j�s2}?RC:gM�BEP H�G y2i u?i

"�G j�:gM�BEP H�G u?S �Z:/<2@E:gRC:=G�B"H�s2@"<2@EH�<`H�RE>A[-J\H�@"DFHhlh:=[ [ P G�� }2P HhlhP U�:=@VRCP BXW�S`B��2:F<���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQMBE@E:=:�DFHhlh:=[��1�2PQM7� >A[ [ HF�IRZH�G2:"BEH MOH�D~}2P G2:�:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G?>A@EWG�|P B�� BV>F5hH�G2H�DFPQM"RCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW«P GhJ\H�@CvD(>]BEP H�G4iFa;R^B��2:FD(>AP G @E:gRCs2[ BgS��Z:FM7�?>A@V>�M�BE:=@EP C=:!B��2:F<���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQM!BE@E:=:FDFHhlh:=[qP G BE:=@ED(R"HAJ>�:�s?>A[ P BV>]BEP U�:(MOH�DF<?>]BEP }2P [ P BXW @E:gRXBE@EPQM�BEP H�G H�G B��2:FJ�>ADFP [ W HAJ#@E:=[ :=U]>AG�B!>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR=S�M=>A[ [ :gl B��2:#�= :g>L�J*I:gRXBEP G��J-�@EH�<`:=@CBXW�i &X"wB�M=>AG/}`:|s?RC:gl/>�RL>AG/:=DF<2P @EPQM=>A[2MO@EP BE:=@EP H�G!BEH"U�:=@EP J\W"B��2:I>A<2<2[ PQM=>]v}2P [ P BXW/HAJ+B��2:IDFHhlh:=[�iqa�<2@E:=[ P DFP G?>A@EW/lhPQREMOs?RERCP H�G RCs��!��:gRXBVR�B��?>]BNB��2:A= :g>L�@*I:gRXBEP G��.-�@EH�<`:=@CBXWD(>_W RXBV>AG?l s2<M�Z:=[ [q:=DF<2P @EPQM=>A[ [ W�i�= : >A[QRCH R��2HF� B��?>]B�<���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQM~BE@E:=:FDFHhlh:=[QR�>�lhDFP B!>RCP DF<2[ :�@E:=<2@E:gRC:=G�BV>]BEP H�G«U�PQ>F>AGM(\H�@VlhP G?>A[ /NP G?lh:�5�HAJc#C@E:=DFHABE:=G2:gRERNJ\@EH�D B��2:�H�@EP ��P G4i &

a MOH�@EH�[ [Q>A@EW�HAJZB��2: M7�?>A@V>�M�BE:=@EP Cg>]BEP H�G P G BE:=@ED(R�HAJZB��2:G= :g>L�D*I:gRXBEP G�� -�@EH�<`:=@CBXW PQR"B��2:@E:gMOs2@VRCP U�:FM7�?>A@V>�M�BE:=@�>AG?l DFH�G2HABEH�G2PQMOP BXW�P G�lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW�HAJZB��2:(<���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQM~BE@E:=:(DFHhlh:=[�S>�RFR��2HF�|G�P G j�:gM�BEP H�G dhi ���2: <`H�RERCP }2P [ P BXW HAJ"lh:OBE:=@EDFP G2P G�� B��2:�lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW HAJ">AG >A@E}2P BE@V>A@EW

t

Page 5: 35+2 ,]+-, 0 +2 , 8( #?micro.econ.kit.edu/downloads/Puppe_journal_18_Modelling... · 2009-12-09 · , " 0 %)*+-,/.1 +2 #" +-0 ( +-35461( ("! , 0 %)*35+2 , 4 +-,#& ! 35+2 , 798( %-%

RC:OBFHAJ"RC<`:gMOP :gR~J\@EH�D B��2:=P @(<?>AP @��|PQRC:�lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BEP :gR.�?>�R/H�}�U�P H�s?R/>�lhU]>AG�BV>L��:gR~P G�<2@V>�M�BEPQM=>A[>A<2<2[ PQM=>]BEP H�G?R=S2RCP G?MO:"B��2:!G�s2D~}`:=@|HAJL<?>AP @��|PQRC:�lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BEP :gR1��@EHF�IR�:�s?>�lh@V>]BEPQM=>A[ [ WG�|P B�� B��2:BEHABV>A["G�s2D~}`:=@ HAJ/RC<`:gMOP :gR=Sc�1�2P [ : P G�B��2: s2G?MOH�G?RXBE@V>AP G2:gl�D~s2[ BEP v�>]BCBE@EP }2shBE: J\@V>ADF:,�ZH�@�� B��2:G�s2D~}`:=@|HAJL<`HABE:=G�BEPQ>A[4>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR1��@EHF�IRZ:�5h<`H�G2:=G�BEPQ>A[ [ W�i

z^P U�:=G�B��2:~<2@EH�<`:=@CBXW HAJqDFH�G2HABEH�G2PQMOP BXW«P G lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW�S?H�G2:Y�ZH�s2[Ql [ P ��:"BEH���G2HF�P�1�2PQM7�lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW DF:OBE@EPQM=R!>A@E:(MOH�G?RCPQRXBE:=G�BJ�|P B���> <���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQM~BE@E:=:(DFHhlh:=[�i4���2PQRJ:�s2:gRXBEP H�G PQR>�l2lh@E:gRERC:gl�P GFj�:gM�BEP H�GFe2SF�1�2:=@E:��Z:ZM7�?>A@V>�M�BE:=@EP C=:qB��2:#@E:gRXBE@EPQM�BEP H�G?R4B��?>]B�B��2:#<���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQMqBE@E:=:DFHhlh:=[�P DF<`H�RC:gR-H�G�B��2:Zs2G?lh:=@E[ W�P G��^lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW^DF:OBE@EPQMAi����2:���:=W"@E:gRXBE@EPQM�BEP H�G!PQR�>;MOH�G?lhP BEP H�GHAJY#��Z:g>L� s2[ BE@V>ADF:OBE@EPQMOP BXW'&@�1�2PQM7� @E:=[Q>F5h:gR#B��2:J�Z:=[ [ v>��G2HF�|G�s2[ BE@V>ADF:OBE@EPQMOP BXW�MOH�G?lhP BEP H�G�HAJLB��2:MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM DFHhlh:=[�i%j�:gM�BEP H�G e PQR(D(>]B��2:=D(>]BEPQM=>A[ [ W�DFH�@E:�lh:=D(>AG?lhP G�� B��?>AG B��2:�@E:gRXB HAJ^B��2:<?>A<`:=@I>AG?l�D(>_W(}`:!R���P <2<`:gl4�|P B��2H�shBI[ H�RER#HAJqMOH�G�BEP G�s2P BXW�i

���2:�<���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQM;BE@E:=:�DFHhlh:=[->A[ [ HF�IR#H�G2:^BEH(P G?MOH�@E<`H�@V>]BE:"P GhJ\H�@ED(>]BEP H�G >A}`H�shB;lhP k:=@E:=GhvBEPQ>A[NRC<`:=:gl HAJZ:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G4iG"�G B��2:@T?G?>A[Nj�:gM�BEP H�G K�Sa�Z:FHL k:=@!>AG P G�BE:=@E<2@E:OBV>]BEP H�G >A[ H�G��«B��2:gRC:[ P G2:gRqs2G?lh:=@qB��2:IG?>ADF:#HAJ1#C:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G?>A@EW�MO[ HhM7�~DFHhlh:=[�i &c= :;>A[QRCH"<2@EH�<`H�RC:|>AGF:gRC<`:gMOPQ>A[ [ W!<?>A@CvRCP DFH�G2H�s?R�U�:=@VRCP H�G P G�U�H!��P G�� > G2HABEP H�G HAJ#BE@V>AG?RC[Q>]BEP H�G P G�U]>A@EPQ>AG?MO:�iI�-@V>AG?RC[Q>]BEP H�G P G�U]>A@EPQ>AG?MO:>ADFH�s2G�BVR|BEH PQlh:=G�BEPQM=>A[Llhs2@V>A}2P [ P BXW�<?>]BCBE:=@EG?RIHAJN>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR|B��2@EH�s��!� B��2:~:=G�BEP @E:!:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G?>A@EWBE@E:=:�i"�G�<?>A@CBEPQMOs2[Q>A@gS�B��2PQRI>A[ [ HF�IRZH�G2:^BEHF@E:glhs?MO:!MOH�DF<?>A@EPQRCH�G?RN}`:OBZ�Z:=:=G�RC<`:gMOP :gRZB��?>]B;>A@E:^J�>A@>A<?>A@CB"BEHO#C[ HhM=>A[ &�MOH�DF<?>A@EPQRCH�G?R^HAJ#G2:=P �!��}`H�@EP G���RC<`:gMOP :gR=i«aI[ [�<2@EH�HAJ�R"HAJZJ\H�@ED(>A[�@E:gRCs2[ BVR�>A@E:MOH�[ [ :gM�BE:gl«P G�>AG >A<2<`:=G?lhP 5+i

� ���Y�����.����I���� ����� ���7������ �a���_���I�V����� ������`���� �! "�X�$#��7��%

���2PQR#RC:gM�BEP H�G�}2@EP :��?W(@E:=U�P :,�IR�B��2:"}?>�RCPQM^MOH�G?MO:=<hBVR#>AG?l(BEH�H�[QRZHAJ-B��2:2��:=G2:=@V>A[`D~s2[ BEP v�>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:J\@V>ADF:,�ZH�@�� lh:=U�:=[ H�<`:gl«P GI�|9%(�tA����t!/�i

&('*) +-,/.0,21436587�9�:;145�34<�=?>8@$ACBEDGFa;RZ>!RCP DF<2[ :;:�52>ADF<2[ :�S�MOH�G?RCPQlh:=@Z>�s2G2P U�:=@VRC:IH MOH�G?RCPQRXBEP G���HAJ+B��2@E:=:;lhPQRXBEP G?M�B|RC<`:gMOP :gR,b9�1�?>A[ :gR(KJEL[/�S�@��2P G2HhMO:=@EH�RC:gRG(KMNL[/~>AG?l�R��?>A@��hR�(POQL[/�i "�G�BEs2P BEP U�:=[ W�S �Xs?l'��:=DF:=G�BVR!H�G B��2:�lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW HAJlhP k:=@E:=G�BFRCs2}?RC:OBVR!HAJ|B��2:gRC:«RC<`:gMOP :gR.�|P [ [N}`:«}?>�RC:gl H�G B��2:=P @~<`H�RERC:gRERCP G�� lhP k:=@E:=G�B &��(�35)*����� i�2H�@"P G?RXBV>AG?MO:�S��1�?>A[ :gR">AG?l @��2P G2H�R;<`H�RERC:gRER;B��2:/J\:g>]BEs2@E:M#C}`:=P G�� >�D(>ADFD(>A[�S &V�1�2P [ :(R��?>A@��hR<`H�RERC:gRER^B��2:(J\:g>]BEs2@E:`#C}`:=P G�� >4T`R��4i & �4:OB"R }`:(B��2:(BEHABV>A[ P BXW HAJI>A[ [qJ\:g>]BEs2@E:gR!lh:=:=DF:gl @E:=[ :OvU]>AG�B"P G B��2:(RC<`:gMOP T`M/MOH�G�BE:�5�BgS+>AG?l lh:=G2HABE:/}�WTS�UVH�WTR B��2:D#CP G?MOPQlh:=G?MO:;&«@E:=[Q>]BEP H�G�B��?>]Blh:gREMO@EP }`:gRZB��2:"J\:g>]BEs2@E:gR#<`H�RERC:gRERC:gl«}�W :g>�M7��H�} �X:gM�BgShP�i :�ia(KXZY\[ /(]�SN�1�2:=G2:=U�:=@#H�} �X:gM�BIX�]�H<`H�RERC:gRERC:gRLJ\:g>]BEs2@E:E[�]�RFiLa�RE>ADF<2[ :IHAJ+:=[ :=DF:=G�BVR�HAJ^S�P G(H�s2@�:�52>ADF<2[ :IPQRqB���s?RA(KJEL^Y\[`_8a!_Y/�S(KMNL^Y\[`_8a!_2/�S`>AG?lM(POQL^Y\[NbdcfeGg8/�S^�1�2:=@E:�[`_8a!_c>AG?l�[NbdcfeGg lh:=G2HABE:"B��2:"J\:g>]BEs2@E:gRG#C}`:=P G�� >/D(>AD/vD(>A[ &!>AG?lM#C}`:=P G��~>YT`R��4S &�@E:gRC<`:gM�BEP U�:=[ W�i����2:;}?>�RCPQM|PQlh:g>�}`:,�2P G?lFB��2:;D~s2[ BEP v�>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:;DFHhlh:=[PQR;BEH�U�P :,�cB��2:(lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW HAJZ>�RC:OB�h HAJZRC<`:gMOP :gR">�R^}`:=P G�� lh:OBE:=@EDFP G2:gl }�W B��2:/G�s2D~}`:=@�>AG?lB��2:~U]>A[ s2:~HAJLB��2:FlhP k:=@E:=G�BIJ\:g>]BEs2@E:gR;<`H�RERC:gRERC:gl�}�W�B��2:/RC<`:gMOP :gRIP Gih#i^j�<`:gMOP T`M=>A[ [ W�S`J\H�@;:g>�M7�@E:=[ :=U]>AG�B�J\:g>]BEs2@E:E[T]�RFS�[ :OB8j;blk��J:�s?>AG�BEP J\W/B��2:;U]>A[ s2:;HAJkB��2:^@E:g>A[ P Cg>]BEP H�GFHAJZ[�iqTI<`H�G G2H�@CvD(>A[ P Cg>]BEP H�G4S;j;b«M=>AG�B���s?RI}`:�B��2H�s��!��BIHAJ�>�R#B��2:!@E:=[Q>]BEP U�:�P DF<`H�@CBV>AG?MO:�S2H�@ \9��+ .��/3 HAJ�J\:g>]BEs2@E:[�i_���2: "+-0���(��+-354�0�% )�� HAJL>FRC:OBEh�HAJqRC<`:gMOP :gR#PQRIlh:�T?G2:gl >�R

m (Ph_/�b n obNprqts u vNw bdxyprz � ���4�����|� vNp0{j;b6| (�thi fB/

y

Page 6: 35+2 ,]+-, 0 +2 , 8( #?micro.econ.kit.edu/downloads/Puppe_journal_18_Modelling... · 2009-12-09 · , " 0 %)*+-,/.1 +2 #" +-0 ( +-35461( ("! , 0 %)*35+2 , 4 +-,#& ! 35+2 , 798( %-%

?I:=G?MO:�S�B��2:"lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW/U]>A[ s2:;HAJ->~RC:OB#HAJ-RC<`:gMOP :gRNPQR���P U�:=G }�W/B��2:;BEHABV>A[[�Z:=P �!��BZHAJ->A[ [klhP k:=@E:=G�BJ\:g>]BEs2@E:gR"<`H�RERC:gRERC:gl }�W RCH�DF:(RC<`:gMOP :gR�P Gh#i�*IHABE:(:gRC<`:gMOPQ>A[ [ W�B��?>]B!:g>�M7� J\:g>]BEs2@E:FHhM=MOs2@VR�>]BDFH�RXB!H�G?MO:(P G B��2:«RCs2D i4"�G <?>A@CBEPQMOs2[Q>A@gS-:g>�M7� RCP G���[ : RC<`:gMOP :gR!MOH�G�BE@EP }2shBE:gR"BEH lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW B��2:U]>A[ s2:"HAJq>A[ [kB��2H�RC:"J\:g>]BEs2@E:gRZB��?>]BI>A@E:"G2HABI<`H�RERC:gRERC:gl }�W�>AG�W >A[ @E:g>�lhW(:�5hPQRXBEP G�� RC<`:gMOP :gR=i

���2:(@E:=[ :=U]>AG�B!J\:g>]BEs2@E:gR!M=>AG }`:�MO[Q>�RERCP T?:gl >�M=MOH�@VlhP G���BEH �1�2PQM7� RC:OBVR!HAJ|H�} �X:gM�BVR�<`H�RERC:gRERB��2:=D S�>�R�J\H�[ [ HF�IR=i���P @VRXBgS]B��2:=@E:I>A@E:|>A[ [hPQlhP H�RCW�G?MO@V>]BEPQM�J\:g>]BEs2@E:gRqHAJ?B��2:I>A}`H]U�:|RC<`:gMOP :gR=S]B��2:IRC:OBVRHAJ^�1�2PQM7�.�Z:#lh:=G2HABE:N}�W R ��� g�� SNR ��� g�� >AG?l�R � e g�� SA@E:gRC<`:gM�BEP U�:=[ W�i9?I:=G?MO:�SNR ��� g�� PQR-B��2:#RC:OBLHAJ`>A[ [J\:g>]BEs2@E:gR�B��?>]B|>A@E:;<`H�RERC:gRERC:gl(:�52MO[ s?RCP U�:=[ W/}�WG�1�?>A[ :gR=S�>AG?l«>AG?>A[ H!��H�s?RC[ W!J\H�@(R ��� g�� >AG?l�R � e g�� i�2H�@FP G?RXBV>AG?MO:�SZR��?>A@��hR/}`:=P G�� B��2: H�G2[ W)T`R�� P G�B��2PQR(:�52>ADF<2[ :�S R � e g�� MOH�G�BV>AP G?R~B��2:�J\:g>]BEs2@E:#C}`:=P G��«>@T`R��4i &VQ;G B��2:~HAB��2:=@A�?>AG?l+S2B��2:=@E:J�|P [ [-BXW�<2PQM=>A[ [ W«:�5hPQRXBIJ\:g>]BEs2@E:gR �XH�P G�BE[ W�<`H�RERC:gRERC:gl}�W RC:=U�:=@V>A[4H�} �X:gM�BVR=iX�2H�@^>AG�W RCs2}?RC:OB�� U H HAJ�RC<`:gMOP :gR^lh:=G2HABE:!}�W�R�B��2:/RC:OB;HAJqJ\:g>]BEs2@E:gRB��?>]B|>A@E:I<`H�RERC:gRERC:glF}�W ���/�$8�35% 4 B��2:;H�} �X:gM�BVRNP G �JW�B���s?R=S�:g>�M7�FJ\:g>]BEs2@E:;P G R PQRN<`H�RERC:gRERC:glF}�W>A[ [`:=[ :=DF:=G�BVRNHAJ��%>AG?l(G2HABZ<`H�RERC:gRERC:glF}�W(>AG�W/:=[ :=DF:=G�B#HAJ^H����!i�2H�@NP G?RXBV>AG?MO:�SH�1�?>A[ :gRN>AG?l@��2P G2H�Rq}`:=P G���B��2:IH�G2[ W~D(>ADFD(>A[QRqP GFB��2:I:�52>ADF<2[ :�SAB��2:|J\:g>]BEs2@E:G#C}`:=P G��~>"D(>ADFD(>A[ &"}`:=[ H�G���RBEH/B��2:!RC:OB�R ��� gNw � g�� i= P B���B��2PQR|G2HABV>]BEP H�G4S�(�thi fB/ZM=>AG }`:�@E:,�|@EP BCBE:=G >�R

m (Ph_/�b n o��4{�����

obNprq�� j;b | (�thi f�� /

"�G�BEs2P BEP U�:=[ W�S]>AG�W;J\:g>]BEs2@E:NR��?>A@E:gl"}�W"RC:=U�:=@V>A[AH�} �X:gM�BVR�MOH�@E@E:gRC<`H�G?l2R`BEH^>IRCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW^}`:OBZ�Z:=:=GB��2:gRC:�H�} �X:gM�BVR=i`�2H�@/P G?RXBV>AG?MO:�SqB��2: �XH�P G�B/J\:g>]BEs2@E: #CD(>ADFD(>A[ & @E:=G?lh:=@VR.�1�?>A[ :gR/>AG?l�@��2P G2H�RRCP DFP [Q>A@c�|P B�� @E:gRC<`:gM�B;BEH B��2:=P @;BV>F5hH�G2H�DFPQM~MO[Q>�RERCP T`M=>]BEP H�G4i"j�s2<2<`H�RC:�S`J\H�@;B��2:/DFH�DF:=G�BgS`B��?>]BB��2:�J\:g>]BEs2@E:!HAJY#C}`:=P G�� >(D(>ADFD(>A[ &FPQR|P G�J�>�M�BIB��2:!H�G2[ W«G2H�GhvwPQlhP H�RCW�G?MO@V>]BEPQM;J\:g>]BEs2@E:~lh:=:=DF:gl@E:=[ :=U]>AG�B^P G H�s2@^:�52>ADF<2[ :�S4>AG?l�[ :OB�j _8a!_ lh:=G2HABE:/P BVR2�Z:=P �!��Bgi2"�G B��2PQR"M=>�RC:�S(�thi fB/IH�@@(�thi f�� /W�P :=[Ql m (��dJEL^Y\OQL��F/ n m (��dJEL��F/ � m (��`OQL��F/�SZP�i :�iqB��2: lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW U]>A[ s2: HAJ2�1�?>A[ :�>AG?l R��?>A@��RC<`:gMOP :gRIBEH!��:OB��2:=@;:;:�s?>A[QR|B��2:/RCs2D HAJqB��2:/U]>A[ s2:!HAJ�:g>�M7� RC<`:gMOP :gRIBV>L��:=G RC:=<?>A@V>]BE:=[ W�icQ;G�B��2:HAB��2:=@9�?>AG?l+S�RCP G?MO: m (��dJEL^Y*MNL��F/2n m (��dJEL��F/�� m (��dMNL��F/�!�j _8a!_FS_B��2:|lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW"U]>A[ s2:NHAJ^�1�?>A[ :>AG?l�@��2P G2H RC<`:gMOP :gRZBEH!��:OB��2:=@IPQR % ���(� B��?>AG B��2:!RCs2D HAJ�B��2:~MOH�@E@E:gRC<`H�G?lhP G��/P G?lhP U�PQlhs?>A[4U]>A[ s2:gR}�W�B��2:@�Z:=P �!��B"HAJNB��2:(MOH�DFDFH�G J\:g>]BEs2@E:M#CD(>ADFD(>A[�i &4���2PQR"M=>A<hBEs2@E:gR;B��2: MO:=G�BE@V>A[LP G�BEs2P BEP H�GB��?>]B|B��2:!lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW(HAJq>FRC:OBIPQR#@E:glhs?MO:gl«}�W�RCP DFP [Q>A@EP BEP :gR#}`:OBZ�Z:=:=G�P BVR|:=[ :=DF:=G�BVR=i

a;RqP GG�|9N(�tA����t!/�SL�Z:1�|P [ [?RCs2<2<2@E:gRERL:�5h<2[ PQMOP BN@E:OJ\:=@E:=G?MO:ZBEH"B��2:|s2G?lh:=@E[ W�P G��!lh:gREMO@EP <hBEP H�GlRHAJN@E:=[ :=U]>AG�B;J\:g>]BEs2@E:gR^}�W PQlh:=G�BEP J\W�P G���J\:g>]BEs2@E:gR ���$3Q��,���+2�,��%-% 4 i/j�<`:gMOP T`M=>A[ [ W�SkJ\H�@":g>�M7� RCs2}?RC:OB� U H lh:=G2HABE:~}�W j"db n$# bNprq�� j;b«B��2:~BEHABV>A[9�Z:=P �!��B"HAJN>A[ [�J\:g>]BEs2@E:gRA�|P B�� :�5�BE:=G?RCP H�G%�!S�|P B���B��2:~MOH�G�U�:=G�BEP H�G�B��?>]B j" n��G�1�2:=G2:=U�:=@�R n'&hi�= P B�� B��2PQRIG2HABV>]BEP H�G4S9(�thi f�� /IM=>AG�}`:J\s2@CB��2:=@I@E:,�|@EP BCBE:=G >�R

m (Ph_/2n o��4{�����

j"(| (�thi f�� � /

���2:#BEHABV>A[ P BXW~HAJ+>A[ [hJ\:g>]BEs2@E:gR�[T]�R6�|P [ [2}`:IPQlh:=G�BEP T?:gl��|P B��FB��2:=P @�:�5�BE:=G?RCP H�G(�!S�>AG?l��Z:1�|P [ [@E:OJ\:=@IBEH«B��2:/RCs2}?RC:OB�� >�R;> <?>A@CBEPQMOs2[Q>A@ �3535��+21�)*3Q� ic?I:=G?MO:�S+>«RC:OB�� U�P :,�Z:gl�>�R^>AG >]BCBE@EP }2shBE:MOH�@E@E:gRC<`H�G?l2R|BEH«B��2:~J�>ADFP [ W�HAJZ>A[ [�J\:g>]BEs2@E:gR;<`H�RERC:gRERC:gl�}�W�:�52>�M�BE[ W�B��2:F:=[ :=DF:=G�BVR;HAJ)�!i.�2H�@P G?RXBV>AG?MO:#B��2:I>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:*�dJEL��;MOH�@E@E:gRC<`H�G?l2R-BEH"B��2:IMOH�G��Xs2G?M�BEP H�G(HAJ+>A[ [2PQlhP H�RCW�G?MO@V>]BEPQMNJ\:g>]BEs2@E:gRHAJ��1�?>A[ :gR�(�#C}`:=P G�� >V�1�?>A[ :;&8/�S��1�2:=@E:g>�RIB��2:F>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:+�dJEL^Y*MNL��(MOH�@E@E:gRC<`H�G?l2R|BEH #C}`:=P G���>D(>ADFD(>A[�i &-,V���2:�J\s2G?M�BEP H�G j B��?>]B >�RERCP ��G?R~BEH :g>�M7� >]BCBE@EP }2shBE:.� P BVRG�Z:=P �!��B�j"#SNP�i :�iqB��2:BEHABV>A[��Z:=P �!��B"HAJ#>A[ [�J\:g>]BEs2@E:gRc�|P B�� :�5�BE:=G?RCP H�G%�!S4PQR"@E:OJ\:=@E@E:gl BEH�>�R;B��2: �3535��+21�)*3Q�J\9��+ .��/35+-,/./ �=�_¬_�������q�V�10%���=�_���w�V¸��#���!�|�_���_¬_� �Z����� �N�V�L�������L���I¬A�Z��§��V� �]�E���X�~� �^���X���|���V�k�_� §O�X����� �7¢"���"���_�Z���_�

�]�V�_���]�V�_�^�V�k�+�X� ���O���X�"�E������� ¬_�g���X�4���I���_�L�V���_�X�C±"27�;�����_�X�k���Z�_�V�w�E��� ���]�V� � ¢I�_� ����� �_���_� ���I���_�X���L����� �X�k�+�-�-� � ��V� �4�X¢g�4�_�X�_�V�������X�_�X��� �q���_¬_�������-¬O¢|���_�q��¢g�Z¬A���k¤43-¨Z�-�_�X�_��§O�X�4���_��¢^�V���L§g� ���+�X�^�V���E������� ¬_�g���X�C�A�V�_�;¬O¢I���_���¢g�Z¬A���+¤�5h¨Z�V���_�X���-� ����±

u

Page 7: 35+2 ,]+-, 0 +2 , 8( #?micro.econ.kit.edu/downloads/Puppe_journal_18_Modelling... · 2009-12-09 · , " 0 %)*+-,/.1 +2 #" +-0 ( +-35461( ("! , 0 %)*35+2 , 4 +-,#& ! 35+2 , 798( %-%

&()*,�8�35+2�, i_���2:!RC:OB|HAJ ����% ��0�,�3 >]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR#PQR1��P U�:=G�}�W(B��2:!RC:OB� b n � �Pb j"��n�� �0|

aIG�:=[ :=DF:=G�B X�]VH �����(�����(����� B��2: >]BCBE@EP }2shBE: � P J X�]'�!SZP�i :�iqP J X <`H�RERC:gRERC:gR~H�G2:�SZ>AG?lB��2:=@E:OJ\H�@E:F>A[ [�SkJ\:g>]BEs2@E:gR^P G R#i��2s2@CB��2:=@EDFH�@E:�S+RE>_W B��?>]B!>AG >]BCBE@EP }2shBE:(� PQR ���(�% + F#�(" }�W�B��2:RC:OB"h�P J|P B!PQR�<`H�RERC:gRERC:gl }�W >]B![ :g>�RXB�H�G2:F:=[ :=DF:=G�B!HAJIh#S-P�i :�i4P J ���ih��n &hi a;M=MOH�@VlhP G���BEH(�thi f � � /�ShB��2:!lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW(U]>A[ s2: m (Ph_/ZPQRZB���s?R#B��2:"BEHABV>A[ �Z:=P �!��B|HAJq>A[ [4>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR|@E:g>A[ P C=:gl }�W�h#i&('P& ����2F^3��� 1N<� I9�,�:;1��G52,�

a J\s2G?M�BEP H�G m HAJ#B��2:FJ\H�@EDS(�thi f�� � /2�|P B�� j"�k ��J\H�@~>A[ [ � PQR!M=>A[ [ :gl > "+-0���(��+-354 &()*,�8�35+2�, S>AG?lD�Z:G�|P [ [Z>A[ �#>_WhR">�RERCs2DF:FB��2:(G2H�@ED(>A[ P Cg>]BEP H�G m ( &!/ n �2i�YN[ :g>A@E[ W�S�>AG�W ��P U�:=G >]BCBE@EP }2shBE:�Z:=P �!��BEP G��!J\s2G?M�BEP H�G�j�k��~lh:OBE:=@EDFP G2:gR#>!<?>A@CBEPQMOs2[Q>A@ZlhP U�:=@VRCP BXW/J\s2G?M�BEP H�G«U�PQ>�J\H�@ED~s2[Q>V(�thi f�� � /�iYNH�G�U�:=@VRC:=[ W�S?>AG�W���P U�:=G lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW J\s2G?M�BEP H�G m )*,�+���)���% 4 lh:OBE:=@EDFP G2:gRIB��2:/MOH�@E@E:gRC<`H�G?lhP G�� MOH�[ v[ :gM�BEP H�G-j"cHAJ">]BCBE@EP }2shBE:��Z:=P �!��BVR�(�RC:=:��|9 (�tA����thS_�?>�M�B«thi fB/�/�i "�G <?>A@CBEPQMOs2[Q>A@gSN>AG�W)��P U�:=GlhP U�:=@VRCP BXWFJ\s2G?M�BEP H�G m s2G?>AD~}2P ��s2H�s?RC[ W lh:OBE:=@EDFP G2:gRZB��2:!MOH�@E@E:gRC<`H�G?lhP G��!J�>ADFP [ W � HAJ�@E:=[ :=U]>AG�B>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR=ic���2PQR;}?>�RCPQM"J�>�M�B">A[ [ HF�IR|H�G2:!BEH�lh:gREMO@EP }`:!<2@EH�<`:=@CBEP :gRIHAJN>«lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW J\s2G?M�BEP H�G P GBE:=@ED(R#HAJqMOH�@E@E:gRC<`H�G?lhP G��/<2@EH�<`:=@CBEP :gRZHAJ�B��2:!>�RERCHhMOPQ>]BE:gl«>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:Y�Z:=P �!��BEP G��~J\s2G?M�BEP H�G4i

aIG«:gRERC:=G�BEPQ>A[k<2@EH�<`:=@CBXWFHAJL>/lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW/J\s2G?M�BEP H�G�PQRZB��?>]BZB��2:"D(>A@���P G?>A[`U]>A[ s2:"HAJ�>/RC<`:gMOP :gRX "$�(8����(������� P G«B��2:!RCP C=:�HAJ�:�5hPQRXBEP G��(RC<`:gMOP :gR,WhJ\H�@ED(>A[ [ W�S�J\H�@I>A[ [Zh�Y���>AG?l Xh U���� m (Ph��.�dX��F/! m (Ph_/(k m (����.�dX��F/! m (��c/!| (�thi t!/

"�G?lh:=:gl+S2s?RCP G��I(�thi f�� � /�S2H�G2:":g>�RCP [ W U�:=@EP T?:gRNB��?>]B

m (Ph��.�dX��F/! m (Ph_/2n o��rvNw ��4{ ���

j" Y

�1�2PQM7�«PQR#lh:gMO@E:g>�RCP G��~P G�h�lhs2:;BEH~B��2:"G2H�GhvwG2:,��>]BEP U�P BXW/HAJ�j4i_-�@EH�<`:=@CBXWI(�thi t!/�SH��G2HF�|G«>�R ��)�1�U�!�#")*% ���+-354 S�PQRZ>�U�:=@EW/G?>]BEs2@V>A[?<2@EH�<`:=@CBXW~HAJ-lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW�W�P G?lh:=:gl+S�P B#M=>A<hBEs2@E:gRqB��2:IJ\s2G?l2>ADF:=G�BV>A[P G�BEs2P BEP H�G�B��?>]B^P B^}`:gMOH�DF:gR|B��2:.�?>A@Vlh:=@IJ\H�@^>AG�H�} �X:gM�BIBEH�>�l2l�BEH B��2:/lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW«HAJN> RC:OB;B��2:[Q>A@���:=@ZB��?>]B;RC:OBI>A[ @E:g>�lhW(PQR=i �

&(' � �������*A��*DG@�3�� 1N<aIG�W lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW�J\s2G?M�BEP H�G m G?>]BEs2@V>A[ [ W P G?lhs?MO:gR�>�G2HABEP H�G HAJZ<?>AP @��|PQRC:/lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW�}`:OBZ�Z:=:=GRC<`:gMOP :gR=iNj�<`:gMOP T`M=>A[ [ W�S2lh:�T?G2:"B��2: "+R�(��+-� +-% ���+-354'&(���� X 3Q�"! }�W

# (KXZY ! /�b n m (��dXZY ! �F/! m (�� ! �F/!| (�thi y8/���2:«lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW # (KXZY ! /"J\@EH�D X�BEH ! PQR�B���s?R~RCP DF<2[ W B��2: D(>A@���P G?>A[NlhP U�:=@VRCP BXW HAJ8X�P G�>RCP BEs?>]BEP H�G�P GI�1�2PQM7� ! PQR|B��2:!H�G2[ W�HAB��2:=@I:�5hPQRXBEP G��«RC<`:gMOP :gR=i#T;RCP G��6(�thi f�� � /#H�G2:!:g>�RCP [ W«U�:=@EP T?:gRB��?>]B

# (KXZY ! /2n o��rvNw ��%$

j" YB��?>]B�PQR=S # (KXZY ! /;:;:�s?>A[QR;B��2:��Z:=P �!��B"HAJZ>A[ [q>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR"<`H�RERC:gRERC:gl�}�W�X }2shB�G2HAB"}�W ! i.*IHABE:B��?>]BgSNP G ��:=G2:=@V>A[�S # G2:=:gl�G2HAB(}`: RCW�DFDF:OBE@EPQMASZ>AG?l B���s?R/J�>AP [QR~BEH }`:�> <2@EH�<`:=@FDF:OBE@EPQMLW#P B

&(' �����|���-�]�E�2���������_���X�2�_�����A�X���7¢O���C�V� � �X�*),+-),.-/E���_¬_�|�=�_�_� �V��� �7¢O�V� �q�Q�V���?�w�]�V�w�V�����X��� 0X�X�?�_� §O�X����� �7¢q� �_�_����� ���_�C����X�q¥-� ² ®�¯�¯�®g�A�A�V���L®g± ®O³w±

d

Page 8: 35+2 ,]+-, 0 +2 , 8( #?micro.econ.kit.edu/downloads/Puppe_journal_18_Modelling... · 2009-12-09 · , " 0 %)*+-,/.1 +2 #" +-0 ( +-35461( ("! , 0 %)*35+2 , 4 +-,#& ! 35+2 , 798( %-%

lhH�:gR=Sa�2HF�Z:=U�:=@gS->A[ �#>_WhR"RE>]BEPQRXJ\W B��2:(BE@EPQ>AG���[ :FP G2:;:�s?>A[ P BXW�i4���2:FJ\s2G?M�BEP H�G # PQR~RCW�DFDF:OBE@EPQMFP J>AG?l�H�G2[ W P J m (��dX��F/ n m (�� ! �F/�J\H�@(>A[ [8XZY ! ]VH�S�P�i :�iqP J">AG?l�H�G2[ W P J�RCP G���[ : RC<`:gMOP :gR��?>_U�:PQlh:=G�BEPQM=>A[+lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW(U]>A[ s2:�i�= :2�|P [ [+@E:OJ\:=@ZBEHF>/lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW/J\s2G?M�BEP H�G�B��?>]B���P U�:gRZ:;:�s?>A[kU]>A[ s2:;BEH>A[ [4RCP G���[ :OBEH�G?R|>�R|> )*,�+ &����� lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW(J\s2G?M�BEP H�G4i

&('�� � 587IFZD�5�� ����2F^3��� 1N<a�G2H�Ghvw:=DF<hBXW^J�>ADFP [ W"HAJ?>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR��CU t�� �"��&-�NPQR-@E:OJ\:=@E@E:gl^BEH^>�R�> �!�#"$��%HIC�C&["+-0���(��+-354(N iqalhP U�:=@VRCP BXWIJ\s2G?M�BEP H�G m PQR 8(��B���35+21�% � �|P B���B��2:NDFHhlh:=[� P JhB��2:ZMOH�@E@E:gRC<`H�G?lhP G��IRC:OB � HAJ2@E:=[ :=U]>AG�B>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR�PQRqMOH�G�BV>AP G2:gl�P G�(SAP�i :�i_P J � U��(iLa DFHhlh:=[�B���s?RL@E:=<2@E:gRC:=G�BVR�> ��)��% +-3Q�35+-0� >;<2@EP H�@EP@E:gRXBE@EPQM�BEP H�G4ShG?>ADF:=[ W(B��?>]BIG2H(>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR|H�shBVRCPQlh:�� M=>AG4�?>_U�:�RXBE@EPQM�BE[ W <`H�RCP BEP U�:2�Z:=P �!��Bgi_�2H�@P G?RXBV>AG?MO:�SLP G�>�}2P HhlhP U�:=@VRCP BXW MOH�G�BE:�5�BgSq>AG :�52>ADF<2[ :«HAJIRCs?M7��>AG�> <2@EP H�@EP�@E:gRXBE@EPQM�BEP H�G)�ZH�s2[Ql}`: B��2:�@E:;:�s2P @E:=DF:=G�B!B��?>]BF>A[ [N@E:=[ :=U]>AG�B/>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR/>A@E: }2P H�[ H!��PQM=>A[qBV>F52>2SqRCs?M7��>�R #C}`:=P G�� >U�:=@CBE:=}2@V>]BE:�S & #C}`:=P G�� >�D(>ADFD(>A[�S & :OBVMAiV���2PQR�@E:;:�s2P @E:=DF:=G�B�[ :g>�l2R"BEH >AG :gRC<`:gMOPQ>A[ [ W RCP DF<2[ :J\s2G?M�BEP H�G?>A[+J\H�@ED HAJq>AG�W MOH�DF<?>]BEP }2[ :!lhP U�:=@VRCP BXWFJ\s2G?M�BEP H�G4S?>�R��Z:�R��?>A[ [-RC:=:"}`:=[ HF��i

&('� ����2F^3��� 1N<�@ +�����36F���@t14F �������*A��*DG@�3�� 1N<"�G�<2@V>�M�BEPQM=>A[A>A<2<2[ PQM=>]BEP H�G?R=SgH�G2:�|P [ [!�?>_U�:�BEH;MOH�G?RXBE@Es?M�B+B��2:NlhP U�:=@VRCP BXW|J\s2G?M�BEP H�G"J\@EH�D�<2@EP DFP BEP U�:l2>]BV>2i_Q;G2:I<`H�RERCP }2P [ P BXW/PQR=S�HAJ4MOH�s2@VRC:�SABEHYT?@VRXBZlh:OBE:=@EDFP G2:;>A<2<2@EH�<2@EPQ>]BE:|>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:X�Z:=P �!��BVR�>AG?lBEH�MOH�DF<2shBE:#B��2:IlhP U�:=@VRCP BXW"J\s2G?M�BEP H�G(>�M=MOH�@VlhP G��;BEHG(�thi f�� � /�iL9;:OBE:=@EDFP G2P G��!>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:1�Z:=P �!��BVR�PQR>!MOH�DF<2[ :�5~BV>�R��kS8�2HF�Z:=U�:=@gSARCP G?MO:|B��2:=@E:;>A@E:I>�R�D(>AG�W~<`HABE:=G�BEPQ>A[`>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gRN>�RqB��2:=@E:I>A@E:IG2H�Ghv:=DF<hBXW ��)�1�����32� HAJ4RC<`:gMOP :gR=S�P�i :�iht�� ! fX�1�2:=G(B��2:=@E:^>A@E:�� RC<`:gMOP :gR=iLaIG«>A<2<`:g>A[ P G��~>A[ BE:=@EG?>]BEP U�:PQR"BEH BE@EW BEH lh:=@EP U�:FB��2: lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW HAJ|>�RC:OB!J\@EH�D B��2: <?>AP @��|PQRC:(lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BEP :gR�}`:OBZ�Z:=:=G P BVR:=[ :=DF:=G�BVR=i����2PQRqPQR�>"D~s?M7�(RCP DF<2[ :=@qBV>�R��~RCP G?MO:�S!�|P B��� RC<`:gMOP :gR=SAB��2:=@E:I>A@E:|>]B�DFH�RXB�����(���! fB/G2H�Ghv>C=:=@EH lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BEP :gR=i^j�<`:gMOP T`M=>A[ [ W�SkRE>_W«B��?>]B"> DFHhlh:=[�� PQR �!�,��3Q�,��J+-,c"+R�(��+-� +-% ���+-354P JXS�J\H�@~>AG�W MOH�DF<?>]BEP }2[ :«lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW J\s2G?M�BEP H�G m >AG?l >AG�W h#S-B��2:«lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW m (Ph_/"PQR!s2G2P :�s2:=[ Wlh:OBE:=@EDFP G2:gl/}�W!B��2:|U]>A[ s2:|HAJ+>A[ [?RCP G���[ :|RC<`:gMOP :gRqP G�h >AG?l~B��2:|<?>AP @��|PQRC:|lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BEP :gR��|P B��2P Gh#S2>AG?l�P JXS2DFH�@E:=H]U�:=@gS�B��2:!lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW m (Ph_/#PQR|>/DFH�G2HABEH�G2:^J\s2G?M�BEP H�G HAJ�B��2:gRC:�lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BEP :gR=i

���2: <2@EH�}2[ :=D HAJIlh:OBE:=@EDFP G2P G���B��2:�MOH�G?lhP BEP H�G?R!s2G?lh:=@.�1�2PQM7��> DFHhlh:=[ZPQR!DFH�G2HABEH�G2: P GlhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW�PQRIH�G2:�B��2:~D(>AP G�BV>�R��hRIHAJ_�|9 (�tA����t!/�i;jh>_W«B��?>]B^> DFHhlh:=[�� PQR �$8�4$8�% +28 P JqJ\H�@G2H�� k�y!B��2:=@E:":�5hPQRXB|RC<`:gMOP :gR(X , Y�| | | Y*X;_c>AG?l�>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR � , Y�| | | Y���_ ]�� RCs?M7� B��?>]BgS�J\H�@|>A[ [� n�frY�| | | Y�� ! f ��c � �dX , Y�| | | Y*X;_ �En �dX;cGY*X;c � , ��S�>AG?l ��_�� �dX , Y�| | | Y*X;_ � n �dX;_"Y*X , ��i�����s?R=SJ\H�@~P G?RXBV>AG?MO:(P G B��2:«M=>�RC:�� n y2SL>�MOWhMO[ PQMOP BXW @E:;:�s2P @E:gR^B��?>]B~B��2:=@E: }`: G2H�BE@EP <2[ : HAJIRC<`:gMOP :gRRCs?M7� B��?>]B":g>�M7� <?>AP @^HAJ�B��2:=D <`H�RERC:gRERC:gR^>AG >]BCBE@EP }2shBE:~B��?>]B�PQR;G2HAB"<`H�RERC:gRERC:gl�}�W B��2:~B��2P @VlRC<`:gMOP :gR=i�a�D(>AP G @E:gRCs2[ B|HAJ�|9%(�tA����t!/�:gRXBV>A}2[ PQR��2:gRZB��?>]B;>/DFHhlh:=[4HAJqlhP U�:=@VRCP BXW(PQR|DFH�G2HABEH�G2:P G�lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW(P J�>AG?l«H�G2[ W P JLP BIPQRI>�MOWhMO[ PQMAi �

&('�� , 1"!IF =�:�52,I52A��*:-.0,214F^36B�36F 14@t1��G52, 5�� ����2F^3��� 1N<$#%!IF^5�34<�2@EH�D >AG/:gMOH�G2H�DFPQMZ<`:=@VRC<`:gM�BEP U�:�S]B��2:|<2@EH�}2[ :=D <`H�RC:gl~}�W!}2P HhlhP U�:=@VRCP BXW~MOH�G?RCPQRXBVR�P G/B��2:IM7�2H�PQMO:HAJ->AG«>A<2<2@EH�<2@EPQ>]BE:;MOH�G?RC:=@EU]>]BEP H�G(<`H�[ PQMOW�ShRCs?M7�«>�R�P G�U�:gRXBEDF:=G�BZP G�MOH�G?RC:=@EU]>]BEP H�G RCP BE:gR=S�@E:gRXBE@EPQM�vBEP H�G?R�HAJ#[Q>AG?l lh:=U�:=[ H�<2DF:=G�BgS�>AG�BEP vw<`H�>�M7�2P G���DF:g>�RCs2@E:gR=S4H�@"B��2: @E:glhs?M�BEP H�G HAJ|M=>A@E}`H�G?lhP HB5hPQl:=DFPQRERCP H�G4i���2PQR|M=>AG�}`:�DFHhlh:=[ [ :gl�>A[ H�G��~B��2:"J\H�[ [ HF�|P G��/[ P G2:gR=iqa�<`H�[ PQMOW«lh:OBE:=@EDFP G2:gR|>]B|:g>�M7�<`H�P G�B;HAJ�BEP DF:~>F<2@EH�}?>A}2P [ P BXW«lhPQRXBE@EP }2shBEP H�G�H]U�:=@|RC:OBVR|HAJq:�5hPQRXBEP G�� RC<`:gMOP :gRI>AG?l MOH�G?RCs2DF<hBEP H�G4i�2H�@ED(>A[ [ W�SZ> <`H�[ PQMOW'& M=>AG }`: B��2H�s��!��B(HAJ"> RC:;:�s2:=G?MO:&Vn ( &)(Z/ (+*-, S��1�2:=@E:�:g>�M7�%&)(!PQR(><2@EH�}?>A}2P [ P BXW�lhPQRXBE@EP }2shBEP H�G H�G t�� W/.�0� �|P B��1&)( (Ph�(\Y324(Z/^>�RIB��2:F<2@EH�}?>A}2P [ P BXW�B��?>]B!>]B^BEP DF:56 ¥4�_�q�_�X�X�X����� �7¢^�V�?�V��¢g�X� � �X� �7¢^�_� �_���X�-���"�N�+�C�V¸I���X���_� �V��� �7¢;���87=�_� ���X�|�X�O�C�_���X�q¥-� ² ®�¯�¯�®g���=�X����� ����9O³w±

e

Page 9: 35+2 ,]+-, 0 +2 , 8( #?micro.econ.kit.edu/downloads/Puppe_journal_18_Modelling... · 2009-12-09 · , " 0 %)*+-,/.1 +2 #" +-0 ( +-35461( ("! , 0 %)*35+2 , 4 +-,#& ! 35+2 , 798( %-%

B��2:!RC:OBEh�(NPQRZB��2:~RC:OB|HAJL:�5hPQRXBEP G�� RC<`:gMOP :gR|>AG?l 24(NPQR#B��2:!MOH�G?RCs2DF<hBEP H�G�U�:gM�BEH�@gi�9;:=G2HABEP G��F}�W� B��2:�RC:OBIHAJ�J\:g>�RCP }2[ :"<`H�[ PQMOP :gR=S2RCHhMOP :OBXW�� R#<2@EH�}2[ :=D M=>AG«B���s?R|}`:Y�|@EP BCBE:=G�>�R

D(>F5� p�����,����

( �� ����� m (Ph ( /�����( 2 ( /�� # 5!Y (�thi uH/

�1�2:=@E:�� lh:=G2HABE:gRFB��2: lhPQREMOH�s2G�B @V>]BE: >AG?l� � B��2: :�5h<`:gM�BV>]BEP H�G �|P B�� @E:gRC<`:gM�B(BEH�&-id���2:H�} �X:gM�BEP U�:«J\s2G?M�BEP H�G�P G (�thi uH/!PQR(MOH�DF<`H�RC:gl�HAJ^shBEP [ P BXW J\@EH�D >L�!��@E:,��>]BE:«MOH�G?RCs2DF<hBEP H�G���( 24(Z/>AG?l B��2:�:�5hPQRXBE:=G?MO:�U]>A[ s2:�RC:=@EU�PQMO:gR m (Ph�(�/NJ\@EH�D B��2:!RC:OBEh�(�HAJqRCs2@EU�P U�P G��FRC<`:gMOP :gR=i

9;P U�:=@VRCP BXW"B��2:=H�@EW"BE@EP :gR�BEH2�2:=[ <Fs?Rqlh:OBE:=@EDFP G2:#B��2:#P G�BE@EP G?RCPQMZU]>A[ s2:��Z:#<2shB�H�G~B��2:IRCs2@EU�P U]>A[HAJqlhP k:=@E:=G�B;RC<`:gMOP :gR1�1�2PQM7� PQR|@E:=<2@E:gRC:=G�BE:gl«}�W(B��2:�J\s2G?M�BEP H�G m i����2:�<2@EH�}?>A}2P [ P BEP :gR�&)(N@E:��?:gM�BRCHhMOP :OBEP :gR|:�5h<`:gM�BV>]BEP H�G?R|>A}`H�shB|B��2:~MOH�G?RC:;:�s2:=G?MO:gR#HAJLP BVRI>�M�BEP H�G?R,WhB��2:gRC:�S2P G BEs2@EG4S2@E:��?:gM�BIH�s2@��G2HF�|[ :gl'��:�HAJ":gMOH�G2H�DFPQM�>AG?l :gMOH�[ H!��PQM=>A[Z<2@EHhMO:gRERC:gR=i �2H�@(P G?RXBV>AG?MO:�SNB��2:�@EH�[ : HAJc��:=WhRXBEH�G2:RC<`:gMOP :gR#B��?>]B^>A@E:!MO@Es?MOPQ>A[+J\H�@|B��2:~RCs2@EU�P U]>A[4HAJ�>AG :=G�BEP @E:!:gMOH�RCWhRXBE:=D%�|P [ [-}`:~M=>A<hBEs2@E:gl P G B��2:@E:=[ :=U]>AG�B~<2@EH�}?>A}2P [ P BXW lhPQRXBE@EP }2shBEP H�G4i ����s?R=S�B��2: U]>A[ s2:�lh:=@EP U�:gl J\@EH�D B��2:«<2@E:gRC:=G?MO:(HAJIRCs?M7�RC<`:gMOP :gR ��)�� ��:=WhRXBEH�G2:�RC<`:gMOP :gR#:=G�BE:=@VR|>�R|>AG�P G?lhP @E:gM�BI@V>]B��2:=@ZB��?>AG P G?RXBE@EP G?RCPQM^shBEP [ P BXW�i �

a;R > RCP DF<2[ :�:�52>ADF<2[ :�S#MOH�G?RCPQlh:=@FBZ�ZH RC<`:gMOP :gR ! >AG?l�� :g>�M7� HAJ2�1�2PQM7� M=>AG }`: RE>_U�:glJ\H�@E:=U�:=@�(�>]B�B��2:«RE>ADF: MOH�RXB / WLDFH�@E:=H]U�:=@gS-RCs2<2<`H�RC:FB��?>]B!P B~PQR!G2HAB!<`H�RERCP }2[ :FBEH RE>_U�:F}`HAB�� HAJB��2:=D iP=O�2PQM7� H�G2: R��2H�s2[Ql�RCHhMOP :OBXW M7�2H�H�RC: BEH�RE>_U�:�� a;RERCs2DFP G���MOH�G?RXBV>AG�B MOH�G?RCs2DF<hBEP H�G8(��3Q����+R�9�����+21�)/� ShB��2:^shBEP [ P BXW���>AP G�>]B 5�J\@EH�D RE>_U�P G��/RC<`:gMOP :gR X-S'��P U�:=G B��?>]B|HAB��2:=@��|PQRC:IB��2:�RC:OBh�(NHAJLRC<`:gMOP :gRIRCs2@EU�P U�:gR=S�PQR

m (Ph ( �.�dX��F/! m (Ph ( /�n o��rvNw ��4{ � ���

j" |

9;:=G2HABE: }�W���( (KX�/�b n # ��rv j" � & M��! F( � � h�( n &!/!B��2: :�5h<`:gM�BE:gl�D(>A@���P G?>A[ZU]>A[ s2:�>]B5HAJ;RE>_U�P G���X-S_�1�2PQM7� PQR.��P U�:=G }�W B��2:�RCs2D HAJ|B��2:V�Z:=P �!��BVR!HAJ;>A[ [#>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR~<`H�RERC:gRERC:gl }�WX�D~s2[ BEP <2[ P :gl }�W�B��2: <2@EH�}?>A}2P [ P BXW B��?>]B�X�PQRFB��2:�s2G2P :�s2: RC<`:gMOP :gRF<`H�RERC:gRERCP G�� B��2:=D iP���2::�5h<`:gM�BE:gl�<2@E:gRC:=G�B|U]>A[ s2:"HAJ�B��2:�shBEP [ P BXWV��>AP G«J\@EH�D RE>_U�P G��"X�PQR1��P U�:=G�}�W

���,� ��

( �"� ( (KX�/ # 5!|�2H�@qMOH�G?MO@E:OBE:=G2:gRER=S_[ :OB ! }`:#H�G2:NHAJ?B��2:NJ\:,� RC<`:gMOP :gR�HAJ?@��2P G2HhMO:=@EH�RC:gR=S_>AG?l#�">Is2G2P :�s2:#:=G?lh:=DFPQMRC<`:gMOP :gR.�1�2PQM7��MOs2@E@E:=G�BE[ WD�?>�R/> RCP C=:g>A}2[ : G�s2D~}`:=@/HAJ|J�>AP @E[ W lhPQRXBV>AG�B/@E:=[Q>]BEP U�:gR=i "�G�U�P :,� HAJB��2: J�>�M�B(B��?>]B«>A[ [|@��2P G2H RC<`:gMOP :gR(>A@E:�MOs2@E@E:=G�BE[ W�:=G?l2>AG���:=@E:gl+S�B��2PQR([ :g>�l2R/BEH B��2: J\H�[ [ HF�|P G��BE@V>�lh:OvwHL �}`:OBZ�Z:=:=G D(>F5hP DFP C=P G�� lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW P G B��2: R��2H�@CBCvw@Es2G >AG?l P G B��2:([ H�G��Avw@Es2G4i«jh>_U�P G��B��2:�:=G?lh:=DFPQM"RC<`:gMOP :gR$�FW�P :=[Ql2R|>FRCP ��G2P T`M=>AG�B|R��2H�@CBCvw@Es2G«}`:=G2:�T2BgS^�1�2P [ :^B��2:�:�5h<`:gM�BE:gl«}`:=G2:�T2BJ\@EH�DcRE>]J\:,��s?>A@VlhP G��|B��2:Z[Q>�RXB�@��2P G2H"RC<`:gMOP :gRa�ZH�s2[Ql�}`:ZU�:=@EW2�2P �!�4i9���2PQRLRCs��!��:gRXBVR+B��2:NJ\H�[ [ HF�|P G��:�s?>A[ P BV>]BEP U�:�}`:,�?>_U�P H�@/HAJ;B��2:�RXBE@E:g>AD(R/HAJ^P G�BE:=@CBE:=DF<`H�@V>A[Z}`:=G2:�T2BVR >�M=MO@Es2P G�� J\@EH�D B��2:�BZ�ZH<`H�[ PQMOP :gR,b% ' � ���X���]�E��� §O�X� ¢O�A���_�Z�Z�_� ���  \�E������� ¬_�g���q� �w�V�|���+����¸I�C�V�!�V� ���|¬A�N� �O���X���_�������X�!� �^���X���|���V��+'& ))( ++*-, .-/ .�/C���V�

�'0g�_� �V� �_�X�!� ��¥-� ² ®�¯�¯�®g����± °�°�9+1O³w± ' �q�|���X���_� �C���|�C�V���_���X�L�V�k¬_� �=�_� §O�X����� �7¢"¬]�V���X�!�������]�E���_�V��� ���������_�w�~�V����_�����_�q�_�����A�����X�^� �^´2��� �V��¸O¢O�A�=��� �C� �V�_���k���O�V�_�_� ² °32+2�·O³w���V� ���54_�-� �O���#���_�4� �w�V�|���+����¸A±

K

Page 10: 35+2 ,]+-, 0 +2 , 8( #?micro.econ.kit.edu/downloads/Puppe_journal_18_Modelling... · 2009-12-09 · , " 0 %)*+-,/.1 +2 #" +-0 ( +-35461( ("! , 0 %)*35+2 , 4 +-,#& ! 35+2 , 798( %-%

� 5

�_�_�_� ���X���_�O���X��I�V����� �]�V��¬A�X�_�'4_�L�E���

��(7( �H/��(7( ! /

� + .�)*��� K���� 35���(��T���C&T�������(8�3Q�("J�!��5.�+-,��%�1(��,���32�

���2:#RXBE@EH�G��;P G?MO@E:g>�RC:NP G~B��2:Z:�5h<`:gM�BE:gl~D(>A@���P G?>A[�U]>A[ s2:ZHAJ`RE>_U�P G�� ! RXBE:=D(R-J\@EH�D�B��2:NJ�>�M�BLB��?>]BgSlhs2:^BEH~B��2:"[ P DFP BE:gl�MOs2@E@E:=G�B#G�s2D~}`:=@#HAJ�@��2P G2H�R=S�B��2:":�5�BEP G?M�BEP H�G«<2@EH�}?>A}2P [ P BXW(HAJ4B��2:=P @|s2G2P :�s2:>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR#}`:gMOH�DF:gR��2P �!� >�R 5���@EHF�IR=i�YN[ :g>A@E[ W�S�B��2:�@��2P G2HFRC<`:gMOP :gR ! R��2H�s2[Ql«}`:�RE>_U�:gl P J�B��2:lhPQREMOH�s2G�B;@V>]BE:�PQR|[ HF��:=G2H�s��!��W?HAB��2:=@��|PQRC:�S � R��2H�s2[Ql }`:~RE>_U�:gl+i����2:~lh:gMOPQRCP H�G B���s?R;lh:=<`:=G?l2RH�G B��2@E:=:~J�>�M�BEH�@VR,bIB��2:(lhPQREMOH�s2G�B"@V>]BE:�S`B��2:FU]>A[ s2:/HAJNB��2:F@E:=[ :=U]>AG�B">]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR�>]B�RXBV>L��:�S+>AG?lB��2:�<2@EH�}?>A}2P [ P BXW HAJ-B��2:!RCs2@EU�P U]>A[+HAJLMO[ H�RC:"@E:=[Q>]BEP U�:gRZH]U�:=@ZBEP DF:�i

� � �! "�X�$#��7��% ��� #t�X ��� � ��"�,�V��������Y��% �����L�.��� �c������= :^G2HF� BEs2@EG(BEH~H�s2@ZD(>AP G PQRERCs2:�S�B��2:^DFHhlh:=[ [ P G��~HAJ-lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW/}?>�RC:gl(:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G?>A@EW~P GhJ\H�@ED(>]vBEP H�G4i �4:OB8H }`:^B��2:�RC:OB|HAJ�>A[ [4RC<`:gMOP :gRNB��?>]B|:=U�:=@#:�5hPQRXBE:gl+S2>AG?l�RCs2<2<`H�RC:;B��?>]B#B��2:2��:=G2:g>A[ H!��WHAJkRC<`:gMOP :gR�PQRqlh:gREMO@EP }`:gl!}�W!>^<?>A@CBEPQ>A[�H�@Vlh:=@(k����|H�G�H�SF�|P B��/B��2:#P G�BE:=@E<2@E:OBV>]BEP H�G�B��?>]B ! k�����XP JZX PQR#>AG«>AG?MO:gRXBEH�@ZHAJ ! i���2:^<?>A@CBEPQ>A[`H�@Vlh:=@�k�����PQR#>�RERCs2DF:glFBEH/}`:"> 35���(�����"$��� ShP�i :�i H �?>�R>FDFP G2P D(>A[-:=[ :=DF:=G�B�(7B��2:~@EH�HABgS?lh:=G2HABE:gl }�W X , /|>AG?l+S2J\H�@;>A[ [ ! ]TH�ShB��2:~RC:OB �dX6b ! k����EX��HAJq>A[ [4>AG?MO:gRXBEH�@VRZHAJ ! PQR#BEHABV>A[ [ W H�@Vlh:=@E:gl }�WTk�����i"�G�B��2PQRIM=>�RC:�S k����J��P U�:gR#@EPQRC:;BEH >���@V>A<��2PQMBE@E:=:�������S2P G��1�2PQM7� :g>�M7� RC<`:gMOP :gR|PQR|MOH�G2G2:gM�BE:gl�}�W«:gl'��:gRZBEH(P BVR|P DFDF:glhPQ>]BE:!>AG?MO:gRXBEH�@|>AG?l«BEH>A[ [+HAJLP BVR|P DFDF:glhPQ>]BE:!lh:gREMO:=G?l2>AG�BVR2(�RC:=:J��P ��s2@E:!thShP G��1�2PQM7�?X������ ! /�i

������� �!��"���$#�%$�$&('

) X ,) *

**

**

**

)+)

)+)

)+)

++)X,,, ))+

++ )!

**

*)

� + .�)*����M-�[d>,Y��0�% )*35+2�,����4�35���(�

�('*) #%!IF/.-FZ,IF^36@$D#"36F^F � 587IFZDa�G?>]BEs2@V>A[2DFP G2P D(>A[`@E:;:�s2P @E:=DF:=G�B�H�G >�DFHhlh:=[`HAJ4lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW~}?>�RC:glFH�G(:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G?>A@EW!P GhJ\H�@ED(>]vBEP H�G�PQR#B��?>]BI>A[ [4@E:=[ :=U]>AG�B|>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR|}`:�MOH�G2G2:gM�BE:gl�P G«B��2:�:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G?>A@EWFBE@E:=:�iqaIG�>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:

E

Page 11: 35+2 ,]+-, 0 +2 , 8( #?micro.econ.kit.edu/downloads/Puppe_journal_18_Modelling... · 2009-12-09 · , " 0 %)*+-,/.1 +2 #" +-0 ( +-35461( ("! , 0 %)*35+2 , 4 +-,#& ! 35+2 , 798( %-%

� PQR������ U 8(�,�,��(8�3Q�(" �1�2:=G2:=U�:=@ � MOH�G�BV>AP G?RX�|P B�� >AG�W«BZ�ZH RC<`:gMOP :gR|B��2:~:=G�BEP @E:~R��2H�@CBE:gRXBI<?>]B��P G ������MOH�G2G2:gM�BEP G���B��2:=D i�9;:=G2HABE:;}�W � ���^B��2:IJ�>ADFP [ WFHAJ->A[ [ �����_v�MOH�G2G2:gM�BE:gl(RCs2}?RC:OBVRNHAJ H`W�}�WMOH�G�U�:=G�BEP H�G4S�[ :OB &�] � ����i= :2�|P [ [+@E:OJ\:=@ZBEH � ���~>�RNB��2: 35���(�A�!�#"$��% >�RERCHhMOPQ>]BE:glG�|P B�� k�����i�a;RPQRI:g>�RCP [ W«U�:=@EP T?:gl+S2B��2:~@E:;:�s2P @E:=DF:=G�B � U � ���(>ADFH�s2G�BVR#BEH(B��2:!J\H�[ [ HF�|P G��FBZ�ZH MOH�G?lhP BEP H�G?RIP GBE:=@ED(R#HAJ�B��2:�H�@Vlh:=@ k�����i_�2H�@I>A[ [��V] � S� .�������� � �� � � ��/��� ��� XZY ! ] ��P DF<2[ P :gR(J ������X >AG?l J ����� ! J\H�@IRCH�DF: J ] �!i� .�������� � � �� � ������� �/� ��� � XZY ! ] �c>AG?l X������ � ����� ! P DF<2[ P :gR �l] �!iYNH�G?lhP BEP H�G`�|{�f«RE>_WhR"B��?>]BF>AG�W BZ�ZH RC<`:gMOP :gR~R��?>A@EP G�� >AG�>]BCBE@EP }2shBE: D~s?RXB/lh:gREMO:=G?l J\@EH�D >MOH�DFDFH�G«>AG?MO:gRXBEH�@��|P B�� B��2:"RE>ADF:;>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:�iZYNH�G?lhP BEP H�GV�|{;t!RE>_WhRqB��?>]B|>AG«>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:^H�G?MO:[ :OJ7B(}`:,�2P G?l�}�W�>AG�:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G?>A@EW [ P G2:g>L��:«PQR/G2:=U�:=@/@E:gMOH]U�:=@E:gl+i rZHAB���RC:=:=D BEH }`:�G?>]BEs2@V>A[@E:;:�s2P @E:=DF:=G�BVRZs2G?lh:=@;>���:=G2:g>A[ H!��PQM=>A[`P G�BE:=@E<2@E:OBV>]BEP H�G�HAJL>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR=i

=O�2P [ :~<2[Q>As?RCP }2[ :/>�R;> � +-,�+-�!�% @E:;:�s2P @E:=DF:=G�BgS?B��2:/>�RERCs2DF<hBEP H�G�HAJ������gv�MOH�G2G2:gM�BE:glhG2:gRERIPQR>A@���s?>A}2[ W"G2HABq:=G2H�s��!�4ia"�G?lh:=:gl+SAB��2:���:=G2:=@V>A[�BE@E:=:ZDFHhlh:=[ � ���;PQR�P G?RCs"! MOP :=G�BE[ W~@E:gRXBE@EPQM�BEP U�:Z>�RL>DFHhlh:=[�HAJ?lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW"}?>�RC:gl�H�G!:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G?>A@EW^P GhJ\H�@ED(>]BEP H�G4i9���2:N@E:g>�RCH�G�PQR-B��?>]B�B��2:NBE@E:=:NDFHhlh:=[� ���#W�P :=[Ql2R-G2H^RCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW^@E:gRXBE@EPQM�BEP H�G?R4H�G�B��2:#RC:OB �(KHD/ U H HAJ ���$3Q�,�3��5���(8�+2��� i9= P B��2H�shBL[ H�RERHAJ_��:=G2:=@V>A[ P BXW�S��Z:!PQlh:=G�BEP J\W B��2:/RC:OB;HAJNMOs2@E@E:=G�BE[ W«:�5hPQRXBEP G���RC<`:gMOP :gRX�|P B���B��2:!BE:=@EDFP G?>A[-G2Hhlh:gRHAJ|B��2:«:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G?>A@EW�BE@E:=:�SqP�i :�iZX ] �(KHD/�P J;>AG?l H�G2[ W P JIX �?>�R!G2H RCs?M=MO:gRERCH�@gi #\���2:V��:=WH�}?RC:=@EU]>]BEP H�G/PQRqB��2:|J�>�M�B�B��?>]BZ>AG�W~RCs2}?RC:OB%$ U� �(KHD/LHAJ`BE:=@EDFP G?>A[?G2Hhlh:gR�M=>AGF}`:IH�}hBV>AP G2:gl(>�RB��2:^P G�BE:=@VRC:gM�BEP H�G HAJ-RCH�DF:^>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:��V] � ���Y�|P B���$ i�"�G«HAB��2:=@��ZH�@Vl2R=S�J\H�@ �,�4 RCs2}?RC:OB&$ HAJMOs2@E@E:=G�BE[ W :�5hPQRXBEP G�� RC<`:gMOP :gRZB��2:=@E:�PQRI>F<`HABE:=G�BEPQ>A[->]BCBE@EP }2shBE:"B��?>]BIPQR|<`H�RERC:gRERC:gl«}�W�>A[ [4RC<`:gMOP :gRP G'$ }2shBI}�W G2HFHAB��2:=@;MOs2@E@E:=G�BE[ W(:�5hPQRXBEP G��(RC<`:gMOP :gR=i (

�('P& #%!IF*) DG@$7���r1��*: � 587IFZDa;R�Z:��?>_U�: �Xs?RXBN>A@���s2:gl+S]B��2:1��:=G2:=@V>A[�BE@E:=:#DFHhlh:=[ � ���;W�P :=[Ql2RqG2H"@E:gRXBE@EPQM�BEP H�G?RLH�G~B��2:IRCP DFP [Q>A@CvP BXW�@E:=[Q>]BEP H�G?R-}`:OBZ�Z:=:=G/:�5�BV>AG�BqRC<`:gMOP :gR=iLj�P G?MO:#H�G2:��ZH�s2[Ql!:�5h<`:gM�B�RCs?M7�/RCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW"@E:=[Q>]BEP H�G?R4BEH�2H�[Ql+SAH�G2:��?>�R�BEH2T?G?l~DFH�@E:|RC<`:gMOP T`M#@E:gRXBE@EPQM�BEP H�G?R�H�G~B��2:#J�>ADFP [ W!HAJ+>�lhDFPQRERCP }2[ :|>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gRL@E:Ov�?:gM�BEP G���B��2:gRC:^RCP DFP [Q>A@EP BEP :gR=i����2:I<2@EH�<`H�RE>A[2D(>�lh:IP GG= :=P B�C=D(>AG6(Xfgb�b�thS2fgb�b!E8/LM=>AG(}`:;U�P :,�Z:gl>�RI>AG�:�52>ADF<2[ :!HAJLB��2PQR;RXBE@V>]BE:,��W�i|z^P U�:=G B��2:~:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G?>A@EW(BE@E:=: ������S^= :=P B�C=D(>AG RC:=[ :gM�BVR|B��2:J�>ADFP [ W�HAJN>A[ [2#EMO[Q>�lh:gR�& >�RIB��2:~J�>ADFP [ W�HAJZ>�lhDFPQRERCP }2[ :/>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR=i!j�<`:gMOP T`M=>A[ [ W�S �2:/<2@EH�<`H�RC:gRB��2:FDFHhlh:=[,+ ���4b n �.- vIb;X ] H ��S��1�2:=@E:/- v b n � ! b ! k����"X��(PQR;B��2: 8�% �$"$� J\H�s2G?lh:gl }�WRC<`:gMOP :gR�X-S+P�i :�i?B��2:FRC:OB^HAJZ>A[ [LRC<`:gMOP :gRIB��?>]B"lh:gREMO:=G?l�J\@EH�D/X-ic"�G B��2:~J\H�[ [ HF�|P G��?S[�Z:~@E:OJ\:=@IBEH+ ���(>�RIB��2: 8�% �$"+R��35+28!�!�#"$��% i!YN[ :g>A@E[ W�Sk>AG�W MO[Q>�lh:~PQR������gv�MOH�G2G2:gM�BE:gl+S��2:=G?MO:0+ ����U � ����iA"�Ghvlh:=:gl+SAB��2:;MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM#DFHhlh:=[2PQR�M7�?>A@V>�M�BE:=@EP C=:gl~}�W/MOH�G?lhP BEP H�GG�|{�fZBEH!��:OB��2:=@_�|P B��FB��2:#J\H�[ [ HF�|P G��RXBE@E:=G��AB��2:=G2P G��FHAJLMOH�G?lhP BEP H�GI�|{;thi�2H�@I>A[ [��!S� .���1EX�] ��>AG?l ! k����IX�P DF<2[ P :gR ! ] �!i

3�H�@E:=H]U�:=@gS_B��2:^MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM|DFHhlh:=[�+ ����RE>]BEPQRZT?:gRqB��2:IJ\H�[ [ HF�|P G���<2@EH�<`:=@CBXW�i��2H�@Z>A[ [ �V]�+ ����S2'34��2 �/��� ��� � 3 � �5 �<���768� ����$ �n & � � �VU�$ H�@9$ U �$�wi����s?R=SAP G/B��2:IMO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM#DFHhlh:=[?>AG�W�BZ�ZH�>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gRq>A@E:#:=P B��2:=@�lhPQR �XH�P G�B�H�@qH�G2:#PQR�MOH�G�BV>AP G2:gl~P G(�#CDFH�@E:NRC<`:gMOPQ>A[ P C=:gl"B��?>AG^&8/+B��2:NHAB��2:=@gi9�2H�[ [ HF�|P G��A�|9 (�tA����t!/�SB�Z:N@E:OJ\:=@4BEH">]BCBE@EP }2shBE:�J�>ADFP [ P :gRRE>]BEPQRXJ\W�P G��;B��2PQR�<2@EH�<`:=@CBXW!>�R �/+2�������8(�/+28(�% DFHhlh:=[QR=iL9;P U�:=@VRCP BXW�P G/>A�2P :=@V>A@VM7�2PQM=>A[�DFHhlh:=[h>�lhDFP BVR

:<; ���X���_�������=���_�X�����V�����V� ���C�V�g¢|�'0=��� �_���+���A�X�X� �X�`�-�_� �w�;�V� ���q�]�V�I�_���_�X���X�X�_�]�V�O���C±k�]���`���_�k�_�_���A�����X�k���_�w����A�X�X� �X���V���q� �����X� ��§��V�O�-�V�_�^�+�q�_�X��� �X���-���_�X� �_�X���L� ���4��� �|�_� � �X� �7¢O±= �]���q§O�X��� 4]�C�E��� �����h�X���_��� �_�X��� �����V�O¢!��� §O�X�/���_¬_�����&>��V�+���X���|� �]�V�2�_�=�_�X�����_�|����� 3 �V�-�V� �`�V�_�X�X���������N�V����_�Z���A�X�X� �X�q� �?>Z±Zªk� �C�V��� ¢O��3A@CB ² 0�³EDF>��V�_� 3 � �,GIHKJ� 7�X���_�_�X�����X���h�_�X�_�X� 3 ���X�_���X���X�O�����V�~�V�_�|� ����� ¬_� �

�E������� ¬_�g��� 3'LNMOHKJ#���]�E��� �4�A�������X�����X�^�'0_�V����� ¢^¬O¢I���_�������,> �V�2�X�_�����X�O��� ¢;�'0g� ����� �_�#���A�X�X� �X�C±

b

Page 12: 35+2 ,]+-, 0 +2 , 8( #?micro.econ.kit.edu/downloads/Puppe_journal_18_Modelling... · 2009-12-09 · , " 0 %)*+-,/.1 +2 #" +-0 ( +-35461( ("! , 0 %)*35+2 , 4 +-,#& ! 35+2 , 798( %-%

B��2:/J\H�[ [ HF�|P G���RCP DF<2[ :/@E:gMOs2@VRCP H�G�J\H�@ED~s2[Q>2SkH�@EP ��P G?>A[ [ W <2@EH�<`H�RC:gl�}�WI= :=P B�C=D(>AG (Xfgb�b�t!/�iJ�2H�@>A[ [Zh >AG?l�>A[ [ m MOH�DF<?>]BEP }2[ :Y�|P B���RCH�DF:2�2P :=@V>A@VM7�2PQM=>A[`DFHhlh:=[�S

m (Ph��.�dX��F/! m (Ph_/2n�DFP G$Qp0{ # (KXZY ! /!| (�y2i fB/

����s?R=S�B��2:ID(>A@���P G?>A[?lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW~HAJ4>!RC<`:gMOP :gR�XV��P U�:=G/B��2:^RC:OB(h HAJ->A[ @E:g>�lhW!:�5hPQRXBEP G��~RC<`:gMOP :gR�PQRRCP DF<2[ W�B��2:#DFP G2P D(>A[?lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW�HAJ XFJ\@EH�D >AG�W�DF:=D~}`:=@qHAJ h#ia"wB�PQR�P DFDF:glhPQ>]BE:#J\@EH�D%(�y2i fB/B��?>]B-B��2:#MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM�DFHhlh:=[�+ ����SA>AG?l�DFH�@E:_��:=G2:=@V>A[ [ W^>AG�W2�2P :=@V>A@VM7�2PQM=>A[ADFHhlh:=[�S]PQR-DFH�G2HABEH�G2:�P GlhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW�i�"�G?lh:=:gl+S�(�y2i fB/Z>A[ [ HF�IRZH�G2:^BEHF@E:gMOs2@VRCP U�:=[ W lh:OBE:=@EDFP G2:^B��2:�lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW(HAJq>AG�W RC:OBHAJ`RC<`:gMOP :gR�J\@EH�D�B��2:=P @LU]>A[ s2:#>�RLRCP G���[ :OBEH�G?RL>AG?l�B��2:=P @L<?>AP @��|PQRC:#lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BEP :gR,WADFH�@E:=H]U�:=@gS=B��2:lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW~PQR�DFH�G2HABEH�G2PQM=>A[ [ W~P G?MO@E:g>�RCP G���P GFB��2:^lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BEP :gR=i9"�G��|9R(�tA����t!/�S!�Z:IR��2HF� B��?>]BB��2:;@E:gMOs2@VRCP H�G/J\H�@ED~s2[Q>�(�y2i fB/qP G(J�>�M�B#M7�?>A@V>�M�BE:=@EP C=:gR�B��2:^MO[Q>�RER�HAJ->A[ [^�2P :=@V>A@VM7�2PQM=>A[2DFHhlh:=[QR=iqa;R>(@E:gRCs2[ BgS2B��2:!@E:gMOs2@VRCP H�G M=>AG2G2HABA�2H�[Ql�J\H�@X��:=G2:=@V>A[-lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW DF:OBE@EPQM=R=i1���2:~lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXWDF:OBE@EPQM=R#B��?>]B^>A@E:�MOH�G?RCPQRXBE:=G�BX�|P B�� >@�2P :=@V>A@VM7�2PQM=>A[+DFHhlh:=[->A@E:"B��2:~RCHAv�M=>A[ [ :gl #Cs2[ BE@V>ADF:OBE@EPQM=R=i &"�G B��2:Fs2G2P J\H�@ED M=>�RC:�(\:;:�s?>A[qU]>A[ s?>]BEP H�G HAJ#RCP G���[ :OBEH�G?R7/�S+s2[ BE@V>ADF:OBE@EPQMOP BXW�PQR^B��2:F@E:;:�s2P @E:=DF:=G�BB��?>]B|B��2:"BZ�ZH@��@E:g>]BE:gRXB#<?>AP @��|PQRC:�lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BEP :gRZ}`:OBZ�Z:=:=G�B��2@E:=:":=[ :=DF:=G�BVR|D~s?RXBI}`:�:;:�s?>A[�i

�(' � )i3�� 1����(9IF 5�� 1"!IF*) DG@$7���r1��*: � 587IFZD= :|G2HF�`�#>AG�BLBEH�>A@���s2:NB��?>]BqB��2:|MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQMZDFHhlh:=[2PQR�BEH�H"@E:gRXBE@EPQM�BEP U�:NBEH�>A<2<2@EH�<2@EPQ>]BE:=[ W"@E:��?:gM�B}?>�RCPQM«J\:g>]BEs2@E:gRFHAJ"<���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQM�lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW�i a;R(> RXBV>A@CBEP G�� <`H�P G�BgS|MOH�G?RCPQlh:=@/B��2: J\H�[ [ HF�|P G��:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G?>A@EWFBE@E:=:�i

**

**

**

**

* *

)X �

++)X )

! �+

+)!

)++)�iiii

i

� + .�)*����� �[d ������35��+28�35+2�, �C&=3:��� 8�% �$"+R��35+28 �!�#"$��%"�G�B��2:!RCP BEs?>]BEP H�G lh:=<2PQM�BE:gl�P GI��P ��s2@E:�y2S�B��2:!MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM"DFHhlh:=[+:=G�BV>AP [QRZB��?>]B

# ( ! Y*X�/(k # ( ! Y �H/!Y (�y2i t!/G2H D(>]BCBE:=@A�2HF��J�>A@ ���?>�R|:=U�H�[ U�:gl«J\@EH�D ! ��S?P BVR;MOH�DFDFH�G >AG?MO:gRXBEH�@1�|P B�� ! i1�-H(U�:=@EP J\W«B��2PQR=SH�}?RC:=@EU�:^B��?>]B # ( ! Y*X�/ n j � $�� � j�����OS2P�i :�i2B��2:~lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW HAJ ! J\@EH�D X :;:�s?>A[QR#B��2:J�Z:=P �!��BHAJ ! � R�PQlhP H�RCW�G?MO@V>]BEPQM/M7�?>A@V>�M�BE:=@EPQRXBEPQM=R^<2[ s?R"B��2:��Z:=P �!��B�HAJ9- $ � S4B��2: H�G2[ W <2@EH�<`:=@!MO[Q>�lh:FHAJ !B��?>]BZP B#lhH�:gR�G2HABZR��?>A@E:1�|P B���X-i�Q;GFB��2:;HAB��2:=@��?>AG?l+S # ( ! Y �H/$n j � $�� RCP G?MO: �!}`:=[ H�G���RqBEH~>AG�W(\<2@EH�<`:=@ /ZMO[Q>�lh:^BEHG�1�2PQM7� ! }`:=[ H�G���R=i

K�DF<2P @EPQM=>A[ [ W�S^(�y2i t!/�PQR�>"<2@EH�}2[ :=D(>]BEPQM#>AG?lFs2G?lh:gRCP @V>A}2[ :#@E:gRXBE@EPQM�BEP H�G4i��-H!RC:=:#B��2PQR=S�MOH�G?RCPQlh:=@B��2:"J\H�[ [ HF�|P G��(MOH�G?MO@E:OBE:^:�52>ADF<2[ :�i

fg�

Page 13: 35+2 ,]+-, 0 +2 , 8( #?micro.econ.kit.edu/downloads/Puppe_journal_18_Modelling... · 2009-12-09 · , " 0 %)*+-,/.1 +2 #" +-0 ( +-35461( ("! , 0 %)*35+2 , 4 +-,#& ! 35+2 , 798( %-%

������� �!��"���$#�%$�$&('

) **

**

**

) J++

++) )

++

++

++)

�������` ���% �!�, �����8�)#��+-,��

� + .�)*����� �[d ��� .��!��,�3^�C&A3:��� ��0�% )*35+2�,����4�35���(�"�G ��P ��s2@E:�u?S�J lh:=G2HABE:gRF> MOH�DFDFH�G�>AG?MO:gRXBEH�@/HAJ ���% �!�, >AG?l �����8�)#��+-,�� B��?>]BFPQR/G2HAB(>AG>AG?MO:gRXBEH�@|HAJ �������` i�"�G >AG?>A[ H!��W(BEH(B��2:~>A}`H]U�:"@E:gRXBE@EPQM�BEP H�G)(�y2i t!/�S2B��2:~MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM"DFHhlh:=[4J\H�@VMO:gR# ( ���% �!�, Y �����8�)#��+-,�� / � # ( ���% �!�, Y �������` /�i�"�G«<?>A@CBEPQMOs2[Q>A@gS�J\H�@#>AG�W/s2G2P J\H�@ED lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW~J\s2G?M�vBEP H�G`�|P B�� � U + ����B��2:�RC:OB � ���% �!�, Y �����8�)#��+-,�� �«PQR4( �Z:g>L��[ W�/"[ :gRER~lhP U�:=@VRC:(B��?>AG B��2:�RC:OB� ���% �!�, Y �������` ��S^�1�2PQM7� RC:=:=D(R;MOH�s2G�BE:=@EP G�BEs2P BEP U�:�i1���2:!@E:g>�RCH�G�PQR|B��?>]B;B��2:~MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM�DFHhlh:=[G2:,��[ :gM�BVR^B��2:FP DF<`H�@CBV>AG�B!MOH�DFDFH�G?>A[ P BXW�HAJ ���% �!�, >AG?l �������` B��?>]B!lh:=@EP U�:gR;J\@EH�D B��2:=P @�}`:Ov[ H�G���P G��"BEH�B��2:^RE>ADF:J(\G2H�Ghv�MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM;/�BV>F5hH�G)#ZT`R��^&G(�MOH�@E@E:gRC<`H�G?lhP G��"BEH�B��2:;lhHABCBE:gl >]BCBE@EP }2shBE:P GI��P ��s2@E:"uH/�i

a;R(>AG2HAB��2:=@(:�52>ADF<2[ : P [ [ s?RXBE@V>]BEP G�� B��2:�<2@EH�}2[ :=D(>]BEPQM M7�?>A@V>�M�BE:=@/HAJG(�y2i t!/�SZMOH�G?RCPQlh:=@FB��2:J\H�[ [ HF�|P G��I@E:=D(>A@��]>A}2[ WIJ\@E:;:�s2:=G�B�<?>]BCBE:=@EG!HAJ2RC<`:gMOPQ>]BEP H�G4SgB��2:�#EM=>]BE:=@E<2P [ [Q>A@+BE@E:=:;&J(7J\H�@4B��2:ZD(>AG�W:�52>ADF<2[ :gR#HAJ-B��2PQR|<?>]BCBE:=@EG4S?RC:=:Y�-s?l'��:G(�tA�����8/�/�i

**

**

**

**

)+)! , )+

) )+) )+

)!�� )+) )+

) )+) )+

)! _

� + .�)*�������[d 8(�3Q���5��+-%-% ���35���(�"�G B��2: RCP BEs?>]BEP H�G lh:=<2PQM�BE:gl P G)��P ��s2@E: d�>�DFHhlh:=[NR��2H�s2[Ql G2HAB�<2shB/>�<2@EP H�@EPL@E:gRXBE@EPQM�BEP H�G?R^H�GB��2:(@E:=[Q>]BEP U�:/D(>L��G2P BEs?lh:FHAJNB��2: lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW # ( !�� Y ! , /^HAJNB��2:(DFPQl2lh[ : RC<`:gMOP :gR !�� J\@EH�D ! ,>�RNMOH�DF<?>A@E:gl/BEH!B��2:^lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW # ( !�� Y ! _c/�HAJ !�� BEH ! _!i�"�G�BEs2P BEP U�:=[ W�S�B��2:gRC:^lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BEP :gRR��2H�s2[Ql H�G2[ W lh:=<`:=G?l H�G B��2:F@E:=[Q>]BEP U�:6#Elh:,��@E:=:~HAJN:=U�H�[ U�:glhG2:gRER�& HAJ !�� i.�2H�@"P G?RXBV>AG?MO:�S+P J !���?>�R"}2@V>AG?M7�2:gl HL MO[ H�RC:/BEH ! , Sa�1�2P [ : ! _ PQR"D~s?M7� DFH�@E:F:=U�H�[ U�:gl+S+H�G2:G�ZH�s2[Ql :�5h<`:gM�B�B��?>]B# ( !�� Y ! , /�� # ( !�� Y ! _2/�i?IHF�Z:=U�:=@gSA}�W�(�y2i t!/�S�H�G2:;>L��>AP G(H�}hBV>AP G?RN>AG(s2G?>AD~}2P ��s2H�s?R�>AG?R��Z:=@�}�WB��2:!MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM^DFHhlh:=[ b # ( !�� Y ! , /(k # ( !�� Y ! _2/�i

a;R|>.T?G?>A[4:�52>ADF<2[ :�S2MOH�G?RCPQlh:=@I>FRCP DF<2[ :�[ P G2:g>L��:^HAJqlh:gREMO:=G�BgS2>�R|R��2HF�|G�P GI��P ��s2@E:�e2i

f�f

Page 14: 35+2 ,]+-, 0 +2 , 8( #?micro.econ.kit.edu/downloads/Puppe_journal_18_Modelling... · 2009-12-09 · , " 0 %)*+-,/.1 +2 #" +-0 ( +-35461( ("! , 0 %)*35+2 , 4 +-,#& ! 35+2 , 798( %-%

) X ,)))) X;_

� + .�)*����� �[d % +-,��(��.<�J�C&T"$����8(��,�3aI[ H�G�� > [ P G2:g>L��:«HAJ^lh:gREMO:=G�BgSqB��2:�MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM«DFHhlh:=[#P DF<2[ P :gR~B��?>]B # (KX � Y*X�� /�n �6�1�2:=G2:=U�:=@� ���Xi9"�G?lh:=:gl+S�B��2:;lh:gREMO:=G?l2>AG�B2X��+}`:=[ H�G���RLBEH~>AG�W/MO[Q>�lh:|BEHJ�1�2PQM7�(P BVRN>AG?MO:gRXBEH�@$X � }`:=[ H�G���R=ij�P G?MO:"B��2:!MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM^DFHhlh:=[+@Es2[ :gR#H�shB|B��?>]BI>AG?MO:gRXBEH�@VR��?>_U�:�>AG�W >]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR|G2HABIR��?>A@E:glV�|P B��>A[ [#B��2:=P @«lh:gREMO:=G?l2>AG�BVR=SZP B(J\H�@VMO:gRFH�G2:�BEH BE@E:g>]B [Q>]BE:=@ RC<`:gMOP :gR(>�R(RCs2<`:=@EP H�@FBEH :g>A@E[ P :=@(H�G2:gRP G >AG :�5�BE@E:=DF:!J\H�@ED�b;>AG :g>A@E[ P :=@^RC<`:gMOP :gRA�?>�R ,�� D(>A@���P G?>A[�lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW�U]>A[ s2:F>�R;[ H�G���>�RIH�G2:RCs?M=MO:gRERCH�@LRCs2@EU�P U�:gR=ia���2PQR=S�P G?lh:=:gl+S�RC:=:=D(R-BEH"}`:ZB��2:#J\s2G?l2>ADF:=G�BV>A[2lh@V>B�|}?>�M7�^HAJ?B��2:|MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQMDFHhlh:=[ bL>A[ [?>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gRA(\P�i :�i�MO[Q>�lh:gR7/q>A@E: +-� �!���3Q�% i�a�@E:=[Q>]BE:glFMO@EP BEPQMOPQRCD >L��>AP G?RXB= :=P B�C=D(>AG�� RMO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQMFDFHhlh:=[��?>�R�}`:=:=G <2shB~J\H�@��#>A@Vl }�WM�?>AP B��U(Xfgb�bAuH/�Sa�1�2H >A@���s2:gl B��?>]B~P B~P DF<2[ PQMOP BE[ W>�RERCs2DF:gR|>(MOH�G?RXBV>AG�B;RC<`:=:gl�HAJL:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G4i��2H�@IP G?RXBV>AG?MO:�S2H�G�B��2PQRI>�M=MOH�s2G�B#B��2:!:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G?>A@EWMO[ HhM7� �?>�R�@Es2G J�>�RXBE:=@!H�G B��2: }2@V>AG?M7� J\@EH�D J BEH ���% �!�, P G`��P ��s2@E:Fu�>A}`H]U�:/B��?>AG H�G B��2:}2@V>AG?M7�«J\@EH�D�J%BEH �����8�)#��+-,�� S2D(>L��P G�� ���% �!�, MO[ H�RC:=@ZB��?>AG �����8�)#��+-,�� BEH �������` i �

�?>AP B��)(Xfgb�b�t!/��?>�R|<2@EH�<`H�RC:gl�>(DF:g>�RCs2@E:2�1�2PQM7��H]U�:=@VMOH�DF:gRNB��2:gRC:~lhP ! MOs2[ BEP :gR;>AG?l4�1�2PQM7��?>�R(}`:=:=GU�|PQlh:=[ W s?RC:gl P G�<2@V>�M�BEPQMO:�iP= : �|P [ [^lhPQREMOs?RERFB��2: MOH�@E@E:gRC<`H�G?lhP G�� DFHhlh:=[;P G�B��2:J\H�[ [ HF�|P G���RCs2}?RC:gM�BEP H�G >AG?l >A@���s2:!B��?>]B"P BY�?>�R^lhP ! MOs2[ BEP :gR"HAJNP BVR"HF�|G4i �->]BE:=@gSkP G j�:gM�BEP H�G u?S�Z:G�|P [ [ZR��2HF� B��?>]B~H�G2: M=>AG >�M=MOH�DFDFHhl2>]BE: >A[ [�HAJ#B��2:gRC:«MO@EP BEP :�s2:gRY�1�2P [ : D(>AP G�BV>AP G2P G�� B��2:lh:gRCP @V>A}2[ :"<2@EH�<`:=@CBXW(HAJLDFH�G2HABEH�G2PQMOP BXW(P G�lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW�i

�('�� #%!IF�� 9I@ �� ��) DG@$7���r1��*:�� � 587IFZD�?>AP B��D(Xfgb�b�t!/�?>�RZ<2@EH�<`H�RC:glFB��2:;J\H�[ [ HF�|P G��/DF:g>�RCs2@E:;HAJ-}2P HhlhP U�:=@VRCP BXWF}?>�RC:gl(H�G«:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G?>A@EWP GhJ\H�@ED(>]BEP H�G4ic�2H�@">AG�W RC:OB"HAJNRC<`:gMOP :gR h#S+lh:=G2HABE:~}�WTh &9(Ph_/#B��2:FRC:OB^HAJN>A[ [LRC<`:gMOP :gRIB��?>]B�>A@E:H�G�RCH�DF: R��2H�@CBE:gRXB �����gvw<?>]B���}`:OBZ�Z:=:=G�BZ�ZH RC<`:gMOP :gR~P G h%(\P�i :�i�B��2: RC<`:gMOP :gR/H�G B��2: RCs2}hBE@E:=:RC<?>AG2G2:gl }�W h_/�i�2s2@CB��2:=@EDFH�@E:�S�J\H�@#>AG�W ! �n-X , Shlh:=G2HABE:^}�W !

B��2:"P DFDF:glhPQ>]BE:^<2@E:glh:gMO:gRERCH�@

HAJ ! i���2:�DF:g>�RCs2@E: m�PQR|lh:�T?G2:gl >�RZJ\H�[ [ HF�IR=i�2H�@I>A[ [Zh#S

m�(Ph_/�n 2 � o

$ds � $Qw $��"��� { � uf{0x�'( ! Y ! /!Y (�y2i y8/

�1�2:=@E: 2 k��FPQRI>(MOH�G?RXBV>AG�BgS2>AG?l �'(8� Y � /8k��FPQRI>AG :�5hH!��:=G2:=H�s?RC[ WG��P U�:=G�RCW�DFDF:OBE@EPQM"lhPQRXBV>AG?MO:J\s2G?M�BEP H�G�B��?>]BIPQR �$"$"+-35+-0� P G�B��2:!RC:=G?RC:^B��?>]B

�'(KXZY �H/�n �'(KXZY ! /�� �'( ! Y �H/!Y�1�2:=G2:=U�:=@ ! PQRNH�G(B��2:;<?>]B��«}`:OBZ�Z:=:=G�X�>AG?l �?i*IHABE:IB��?>]BNB��2:"RCs2DFD(>]BEP H�G(P GD(�y2i y8/qPQR�BV>L��:=GH]U�:=@#>A[ [4lhPQRXBV>AG?MO:gR|RCs?M7�«B��?>]BI}`HAB�� ! >AG?l !

>A@E:"P G�h &9(Ph_/ WhP G <?>A@CBEPQMOs2[Q>A@gS m

�(��dX��F/�n 2;J\H�@

>A[ [NRCP G���[ : RC<`:gMOP :gR X-i��2H�@~>AG�W BZ�ZH�RC<`:gMOP :gR X�>AG?l �?S�[ :OBV( ! , Y ! � Y�| | | Y ! �+/2�|P B�� ! , n X�>AG?l� ' � �����I�V�2���X�_���X���X�O�w�E��� ���F�V�+���_�|�_�V��� ���/�V�-�;�X���_���w�V�O�Z���q§��V��� �V¬_� �!¤����A�X�X�/�V�4��§O��� �g��� ���_¨�� �q��� §O�X�/� �

�=�X����� �����N¬A�X� �C��±

f_t

Page 15: 35+2 ,]+-, 0 +2 , 8( #?micro.econ.kit.edu/downloads/Puppe_journal_18_Modelling... · 2009-12-09 · , " 0 %)*+-,/.1 +2 #" +-0 ( +-35461( ("! , 0 %)*35+2 , 4 +-,#& ! 35+2 , 798( %-%

! ��n � }`:~>(<?>]B�� MOH�G2G2:gM�BEP G�� X6�|P B�� �(P G�������iX*IHABE:�B��?>]B;B��2PQRIP DF<2[ P :gR;:=P B��2:=@ ! c � , n ! c SH�@ ! cZn ! c � , i�rZW6(�y2i y8/#>AG?l�RCW�DFDF:OBE@EW HAJ �~H�G2:"H�}hBV>AP G?R=S

m�(��dXZY � �F/$n 2 �

�o c � �

�'( ! c, Y ! c /!Y

>AG?l6�2:=G?MO:�S #�(KXZY �H/.b n m

�(��dXZY � �F/ ! m

�(���� �F/En # c �'( ! c

, Y ! c /�i rZW >�l2lhP BEP U�P BXW HAJ$��S4B��2PQRP DF<2[ P :gR

#�(KXZY �H/�n �'(KXZY �H/!Y

P�i :�ihB��2:!lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW(DF:OBE@EPQM�>�RERCHhMOPQ>]BE:gl��|P B�� m�PQR|RCP DF<2[ W B��2:Y��P U�:=G lhPQRXBV>AG?MO:^J\s2G?M�BEP H�G ��i

= :A�|P [ [`G2HF��R��2HF� B��?>]BNB��2:IJ\s2G?M�BEP H�G?>A[?J\H�@ED (�y2i y8/�MOH�@E@E:gRC<`H�G?l2RLBEH/>!RC<`:gMOP T`M^RXBE@Es?M�BEs2@E:HAJ#B��2: s2G?lh:=@E[ W�P G�� >]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR=i�j�<`:gMOP T`M=>A[ [ W�SL:g>�M7� @E:=[ :=U]>AG�B~>]BCBE@EP }2shBE: � PQR!:=P B��2:=@/> MO[Q>�lh:( ��n - vFJ\H�@^RCH�DF: X�/�SkH�@^>AGO#E>AG�BEP v�MO[Q>�lh:�S &/P�i :�i?B��2:/MOH�DF<2[ :=DF:=G�B;HAJN> MO[Q>�lh:V( ��n H � - vJ\H�@IRCH�DF: X�/�i��2H�@ED(>A[ [ W�Sh[ :OB

� , b n�+ ��� �.�dH �)� b �V]�+ �����0Y�1�2PQM7���Z:"@E:OJ\:=@#BEH(>�RZB��2:I#�:�s?>�RCP v�MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM,&!DFHhlh:=[�i3 � �5� � � � ���������� d &()*,�8�35+2�, m

��C&^3:���V&�����ZI �<? ��N=�����'�A)*,�+���)��[��� ����������,�3Q�35+2�,6+-,�3Q�����T�

�C&T�,Y�3535��+21�)*3Q��\9��+ .��/35+-,/.'&()*,�8�35+2�, j 7�.�+-0��, 1�4

j" n���� ���� + & � �] � ,�'(KX

Y*X�/ + & � n - v �,�" X �n X ,�'(KX

Y*X�/ + & � n-H �&- v �,�" X �n-X ,

2)!� + & � n-HY (�y2i uH/

\ ������� � b n # $��� v� �'( ! Y ! / ? ���,�0���(����% 4�7*&���>�,�4T�3535��+21�)*3Q�^\9��+ .��/35+-,/.�&()*,�8�35+2�,����35+R�:&(4+-,/.I �<? �N]3:���E8(��������5���,�"+-,/.J&()*,�8�35+2�, m�"$��,��("Y1�4 m

�(Ph_/"n # Zs ��4{����� j" +R�W�C&�3:���'&�����I �<? ��N$?[X�,J�����35+28�)*% ��(7 m

�+R�T�6"+-0���(��+-354>&()*,�8�35+2�,]+ &T�,�"6�,�% 4!+ & 2Ek�� ?

=O�2P [ :;B��2:Y:�s?>�RCP v�MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQMIDFHhlh:=[kH]U�:=@VMOH�DF:gRqB��2:�MO@EP BEPQMOPQRCD(RNHAJ4B��2:�MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM;DFHhlh:=[k<2shBJ\H�@��#>A@VlFP G(B��2:^<2@E:=U�P H�s?RZRCs2}?RC:gM�BEP H�G4S�P B��?>�RN<2@EH�}2[ :=D(RNHAJ4P BVRZHF�|G4i����2:gRC:;<2@EH�}2[ :=D(RZ>A<2<`:g>A@P G"B��2:=P @�RXBV>A@���:gRXB+J\H�@ED�P G~>#[ P G2:g>L��:qHAJ2lh:gREMO:=G�B�>�R+P GJ��P ��s2@E:Ne|>A}`H]U�:�i�=O�2P [ :�G2HF� >AG!>AG?MO:gRXBEH�@�?>�RN<`H�RCP BEP U�:^D(>A@���P G?>A[klhP U�:=@VRCP BXWFU]>A[ s2:�S�P G�BE:=@EDF:glhPQ>]BE:"RC<`:gMOP :gRZlhH/G2HABgiNYNH�G?MO@E:OBE:=[ W�S�H�G2:c�?>�Rm�(��dX , Y*X � Y�| | | Y*X;_ �F/�n m

�(��dX , Y*X;_ �F/��1�2:=G2:=U�:=@(X � Y�| | | Y*X;_

, >A@E:"P G�BE:=@EDF:glhPQ>]BE:"}`:OBZ�Z:=:=G?X ,>AG?l X;_/i_3�H�@E:2��:=G2:=@V>A[ [ W�S�B��2:J:�s?>�RCP v�MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM;DFHhlh:=[4P DF<2[ P :gR#B��?>]BgShJ\H�@I>A[ [Zh#S

m (Ph_/�n m (Ph &9(Ph_/�/!| (�y2i d!/"�G J�>�M�BgS4>ADFH�G���>A[ [Ls2G2P J\H�@ED lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW�J\s2G?M�BEP H�G?R�MOH�DF<?>]BEP }2[ :��|P B�� B��2:~BE@E:=: ������S+<2@EH�<`:=@CBXW(�y2i d!/NM7�?>A@V>�M�BE:=@EP C=:gRqB��2:Y:�s?>�RCP v�MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQMIH�G2:gR=i �4����s?R=S�B��2:":=G�BEP @E:">�l2lhP BEP H�G?>A[kMOH�G�BE:=G�B#HAJ-B��2::�s?>�RCP v�MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM;DFHhlh:=[-RXBE:=D(R#J\@EH�D B��2:�<2@EH�}2[ :=D(>]BEPQM^@E:gRXBE@EPQM�BEP H�GD(�y2i d!/�i

"�G lh:OJ\:=G?RC:"HAJ-B��2:J:�s?>�RCP v�MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM;DFHhlh:=[�ShH�G2:�MOH�s2[Ql�>A@���s2:;B��?>]B.(�y2i d!/N:=G�BV>AP [QRZG2H(lhP @E:gM�B@E:gRXBE@EPQM�BEP H�G H�G�B��2:FlhP U�:=@VRCP BXW HAJ�:�5�BV>AG�B�RC<`:gMOP :gR �(KHD/.(7BE:=@EDFP G?>A[LG2Hhlh:gR7/�S+RCP G?MO: h &9(Ph_/IM=>AGlhP k:=@!J\@EH�D h�H�G2[ W P G G2H�Ghvw:�5�BV>AG�B/RC<`:gMOP :gR=i YNH�G?RCPQlh:=@gS9�2HF�Z:=U�:=@gS�>L��>AP G B��2: #EM=>]BE:=@E<2P [ [Q>A@7&<?>]BCBE:=@EG4i� 27�_�_�X�X���4� ��� ² 5?³��D�� ² 5�� ² 5?³�³w�+���_�X� ���_�X���"�Z�_���#�'0g� ���I�V�«�E������� ¬_�g���*3��L M��"�-� ��� ������� ����� ¢F�A����� ��� §O�

�+�X� ���O�C±

fgy

Page 16: 35+2 ,]+-, 0 +2 , 8( #?micro.econ.kit.edu/downloads/Puppe_journal_18_Modelling... · 2009-12-09 · , " 0 %)*+-,/.1 +2 #" +-0 ( +-35461( ("! , 0 %)*35+2 , 4 +-,#& ! 35+2 , 798( %-%

**

**

**

**

)�� /+)� / )+

)� & i ii )����+)� �

)+) i ii )+

)����� / )�� �+)���

� + .�)*��� �! ���� 8(�3Q���5��+-%-% ��J��.<�+-,

a;RERCs2DF:�B��?>]B �'(KX;c*Y ! c / n���!J\H�@;>A[ [ � n frY�| | | Y�� S`>AG?l«B��?>]B �'(KX;_, Y*X;_2/� ��2i�"�G B��?>]B^M=>�RC:�SB��2:J:�s?>�RCP v�MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM;DFHhlh:=[4P DF<2[ P :gR#B��?>]B

m�(�� ! , Y ! _

, Y !�� �F/�� m

�(�� ! , Y ! _

, Y ! _*�F/!Y

G2H~D(>]BCBE:=@��2HF� [Q>A@���: �'( ! , Y !�� /N>AG?l �'( !�� Y ! _c/Z>A@E:�S�>AG?l(G2H/D(>]BCBE:=@��2HF��RCD(>A[ [��'( ! _, Y ! _2/PQR=i@"�G HAB��2:=@Y�ZH�@Vl2R=S ��P U�:=G B��2:(RCs2@EU�P U]>A[qHAJ#RC<`:gMOP :gR ! , >AG?l ! _

, S4B��2:FD(>A@���P G?>A[qlhP U�:=@VRCP BXWHAJ ! _ PQR�>A[ �#>_WhRG��@E:g>]BE:=@(B��?>AG B��?>]B�HAJ �,�4 RC<`:gMOP :gR !�� ] � ! � Y�| | | Y ! _

� ��SX�1�2PQM7��RC:=:=D(RP DF<2[Q>As?RCP }2[ :�i

���2:!lhPQ>L��G2H�RCPQRZHAJ�B��2:!@E:gRXBE@EPQM�BEP U�:=G2:gRERZHAJ�B��2:.:�s?>�RCP v�MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM;DFHhlh:=[-PQR#B��?>]BIP B;@Es2[ :gR#H�shB8(��!1�+-,��35+2�,�� HAJ�>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR=i�2H�@#P G?RXBV>AG?MO:�S�P G4��P ��s2@E:YK!>A[ [`<`HABE:=G�BEPQ>A[ [ W(@E:=[ :=U]>AG�B#>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gRHAJ�B��2:qJ\H�@ED - v����1(KH ��- v��,/`J\H�@ � ���J(�#Elh:gREMO:=G?lhP G��#J\@EH�D X;c2}2shB-G2HAB4J\@EH�D X��B&8/k>A@E:q:�52MO[ s?lh:gl+irZshB^B��2:FlhPQRXBEP G?M�BEP U�:=G2:gRER;HAJ !�� J\@EH�D ! , >AG?l ! _ PQR;G?>]BEs2@V>A[ [ W lh:gREMO@EP }`:gl <2@E:gMOPQRC:=[ W�}�W�RCs?M7�>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR=ia"�G.��:=G2:=@V>A[�S_P BqRC:=:=D(R4B��?>]BLMOH�D~}2P G?>]BEP H�G?R-HAJ2@E:=[ :=U]>AG�BL>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR�(7J\H�@ED(>A[ [ W�b+B��2:=P @P G�BE:=@VRC:gM�BEP H�G?R7/N>A@E:^HAJ7BE:=G�@E:=[ :=U]>AG�BZB��2:=D(RC:=[ U�:gR=Sh>/<`H�P G�B#B��?>]B1�?>�RNJ\@E:;:�s2:=G�BE[ W(}`:=:=G H�}?RC:=@EU�:glP G/B��2:I[ P BE:=@V>]BEs2@E:Y(�RC:=:�S�:�i �?i S!= P [ [ PQ>AD(R�>AG?l@?Is2DF<��2@EP :gRA(Xfgb�b�e8/�/�i9*IHABE:�S!�2HF�Z:=U�:=@gS_B��?>]BNP JkH�G2:�#>�RZBEH P G?MO[ s?lh:!>A[ [4P G�BE:=@VRC:gM�BEP H�G?R|HAJqMO[Q>�lh:gRI>AG?l >AG�BEPQMO[Q>�lh:gR=ShH�G2:Y�ZH�s2[Ql�}`:�B��2@EHF�|G }?>�M7�(BEHB��2:J��:=G2:=@V>A[+BE@E:=:!DFHhlh:=[ � ����i�"�G B��2:~G2:�5�B^RC:gM�BEP H�G4S^�Z:Y�|P [ [-D(>L��:~>F<2@EH�<`H�RE>A[+B��?>]B;:=G?RCs2@E:gRB��?>]B;MOH�D~}2P G?>]BEP H�G?R#HAJL@E:=[ :=U]>AG�BI>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gRI>A@E:^@E:=[ :=U]>AG�BI>�R1�Z:=[ [�i_3�H�@E:�RC<`:gMOP T`M=>A[ [ W�S��Z:�>A@E:[ H�H!��P G��«J\H�@!>«DFHhlh:=[ � �|P B�� + ����� ��� � ���(B��?>]B!PQR�RXBV>A}2[ :Fs2G?lh:=@"BV>L��P G���P G�BE:=@VRC:gM�BEP H�G?R(�MOH�D~}2P G?>]BEP H�G?R7/!HAJ">]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR=i�rZW B��2:�<2@E:gMO:glhP G�� >A@���s2DF:=G�BgS_�Z: >A@E:«J\H�@VMO:gl BEH :�52MO[ s?lh:����!� >AG�BEPQMO[Q>�lh:gR=i aI@���s?>A}2[ W�SX�1�2P [ : RCH�DF: >AG�BEPQMO[Q>�lh:gR«MO:=@CBV>AP G2[ W MOH�@E@E:gRC<`H�G?l BEH @E:=[ :=U]>AG�B>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR=SNG2HAB >A[ [|lhH?i �2H�@FP G?RXBV>AG?MO:�SqB��2: >AG�BEPQMO[Q>�lh:�MOH�@E@E:gRC<`H�G?lhP G�� BEH B��2:4T?@VRXBF@E:=<hBEP [ :(\P�i :�i�B��2:">]BCBE@EP }2shBE:V#C<2@E:Ovw@E:=<hBEP [ :;&8/�PQRN<2@EH�}?>A}2[ W/@E:=[ :=U]>AG�Bgi �«rZW(MOH�G�BE@V>�RXBgSAB��2:^>AG�BEPQMO[Q>�lh:�#C<2@E:Ov<`H�@VMOs2<2P G2:;&FRC:=:=D(RZBEHF}`:�}2P H�[ H!��PQM=>A[ [ WG�?>A@Vlh[ W«RCP ��G2P T`M=>AG�Bgi

���2:|RCHAv�M=>A[ [ :gl6# &2vwDF:glhPQ>AG/DFHhlh:=[ &^<2@EH�<`H�RC:gl~}�W.�?>AP B��(>AG?l�= >A[ ��:=@X(Xfgb�bAuH/4PQR�>A[QRCH�MO[ H�RC:gls2G?lh:=@ZP G�BE:=@VRC:gM�BEP H�G?RN>AG?l«lhH�:gR=S�B��2:=@E:OJ\H�@E:�S�G2HAB#RCs' k:=@ZJ\@EH�D B��2: �Xs?RXB|RXBV>]BE:gl��Z:g>L��G2:gRERqHAJ4B��2::�s?>�RCP v�MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM�DFHhlh:=[�iU"�G MOH�G�BE@V>�RXBFBEH B��2:�<���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQM«BE@E:=:�DFHhlh:=[;lh:=U�:=[ H�<`:gl�}`:=[ HF��S�2HF�Z:=U�:=@gSNP B(BXW�<2PQM=>A[ [ W�:�52MO[ s?lh:gR RCH�DF: MO[Q>�lh:gR(>�R(@E:=[ :=U]>AG�B >]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR,W;DFH�@E:=H]U�:=@gS�P BGT�5h:gR>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:Y�Z:=P �!��BVRZP G�>FRC<`:gMOP T`M2�#>_W�i� 27�_�_�X�X���g���_�L�E������� ¬_�g���|¤ 4]���_¨N�X��� ��� �C�V�]�������_�+�V�����_�|�X�O�k���_�������_�_�_� �_���2� ���_�����N�V¬A�C§O���C�V�I¬A���X���_�������_�X��V�4���_�q� �O���X�����X����� ���"�V�h���_���X� �V�_�;¤�§O�X�����X¬_�w�E���X��¨;�V�_�;���_�N�V�O��� �X� �V�_�^¤��_���� 7���X�g��� � ��± ¨

f=u

Page 17: 35+2 ,]+-, 0 +2 , 8( #?micro.econ.kit.edu/downloads/Puppe_journal_18_Modelling... · 2009-12-09 · , " 0 %)*+-,/.1 +2 #" +-0 ( +-35461( ("! , 0 %)*35+2 , 4 +-,#& ! 35+2 , 798( %-%

� �����C�l%?�������A�������� �$�I� � �������I'*) �-F�� ,�� 1��G52,���2:(}?>�RCPQM/PQlh:g> HAJZB��2:(<���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQM/DFHhlh:=[qBEH�}`: lh:gREMO@EP }`:gl P G B��2PQR~RC:gM�BEP H�G PQR"BEH�:=G2@EPQM7�B��2:�J�>ADFP [ W«HAJqMO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM�>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gRIP G�>(MOH�G�BE@EH�[ [ :glV�#>_W�i����2PQR|PQR;lhH�G2:�P G�BZ�ZH RXBE:=<?R,b���P @VRXBgS>AG >A<2<2@EH�<2@EPQ>]BE:IRC:OBNHAJkJ\s2@CB��2:=@#>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR + U � ���2�|P B��«>Y�2P :=@V>A@VM7�2PQM=>A[2RXBE@Es?M�BEs2@E:IPQRN>�l2lh:gl+i"�G�> RC:gMOH�G?l�RXBE:=<4SZ>A[ [|P G�BE:=@VRC:gM�BEP H�G?R/HAJIB��2: >]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR/P G + ��� >AG?lF+ SZ@E:gRC<`:gM�BEP U�:=[ W�SN>A@E:P G?MO[ s?lh:gl+i� ��� �8� � �����a DFHhlh:=[� + PQRqM=>A[ [ :glF> ���/4% ��.<��,���35+28'35���(�B�!�#"$��% P JkB��2:=@E:|:�5hPQRXBVRq>2�2P :=@V>A@VM7�2PQM=>A[J�>ADFP [ W + U � ���/RCs?M7�«B��?>]B

� + UP( + � + ���L/ 1 b n � ����$\b��V]A+ >AG?l�$ ]�+ �����0| , ,�-H DFHABEP U]>]BE:�B��2PQR lh:�T?G2P BEP H�G4S|MOH�G?RCPQlh:=@ >L��>AP G�B��2: RC:,��DF:=G�B(HAJ^B��2:�:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G?>A@EW BE@E:=:

lh:=<2PQM�BE:gl P G4��P ��s2@E:Iu?i�= :c�?>_U�:;>A@���s2:gl+S�B��?>]BZH�G2:;<2@EH�}2[ :=D\�|P B�� B��2:"MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQMIDFHhlh:=[kPQRNP BVRG2:,��[ :gM�B;HAJqB��2:~G2H�Ghv�MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM^BV>F5hH�GO#ZT`R��^& (�lhHABCBE:gl�P G ��P ��s2@E:!uH/I>�RI>(<`HABE:=G�BEPQ>A[L>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:�iQ;G2:J�ZH�s2[Ql«B���s?RX�#>AG�B|BEH«MOH�D~}2P G2:�B��2:!s2G?lh:=@E[ W�P G�� :=U�H�[ shBEP H�G?>A@EW(BE@E:=:Y�|P B���B��2:~RCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXWP GhJ\H�@ED(>]BEP H�G/P G~B��2:#BV>F5hH�G2H�DFPQMZMO[Q>�RERCP T`M=>]BEP H�G~HAJkRC<`:gMOP :gR=iLa�<2@EP DF:|M=>AG?lhPQl2>]BE:ZJ\H�@�B��2:#J�>ADFP [ W+ P GFB��2:^>A}`H]U�:|lh:�T?G2P BEP H�G PQRqB���s?RN>"G2H�Ghv�MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQMG#��4P G2G2:g>AG^&^BV>F5hH�G2H�DFPQM��2P :=@V>�M7��W + ( a!v�HAJRC<`:gMOP :gR=i."�G?MO[ s?lhP G�� P G�BE:=@VRC:gM�BEP H�G?R^HAJ#MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM/>AG?l BV>F5hH�G2H�DFPQM/>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR"PQR^G?>]BEs2@V>A[qRCP G?MO:P G�BE:=@VRC:gM�BEP H�G?R|MOH�@E@E:gRC<`H�G?lFBEH MOH�G��Xs2G?M�BEP H�G?R#HAJ�B��2:!>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:Ov�lh:�T?G2P G��/J\:g>]BEs2@E:gR=i

a;RF> RC:gMOH�G?l�:�52>ADF<2[ :�SNMOH�G?RCPQlh:=@(>L��>AP G B��2: M=>]BE:=@E<2P [ [Q>A@~BE@E:=:�P G ��P ��s2@E:�dhi ?I:=@E:�S�B��2:P G?>A<2<2@EH�<2@EPQ>]BE:F@E:gRXBE@EPQM�BEP H�G?R�H�G lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BEP :gR�:=G�BV>AP [ :gl }�W B��2:«MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQMFDFHhlh:=[Z>A@E:(G?>]BEshv@V>A[ [ W�H]U�:=@VMOH�DF:«}�W�P G?MO[ s?lhP G�� B��2: J\H�[ [ HF�|P G�� RC:=[ :gM�BEP H�G HAJ�>AG�BEPQMO[Q>�lh:gR(>�R/J\s2@CB��2:=@ @E:=[ :=U]>AG�B>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR,b � � n � ! , Y�| | | Y !�� �*� �dX b X ����� !�� � (�RC:=:���P ��s2@E:GE8/�iV*IHABE:FB��?>]BgS-P G MOH�G�BE@V>�RXBBEH B��2:�:�s?>�RCP v�MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM�DFHhlh:=[�SkG2HAB �%-% >AG�BEPQMO[Q>�lh:gR;>A@E:!P G?MO[ s?lh:gl+ic"�G <?>A@CBEPQMOs2[Q>A@gS?B��2:!J�>ADFP [ W+ n � � � b � ncfrY�| | | Y�� ���?>�R�>X�2P :=@V>A@VM7�2PQM=>A[�RXBE@Es?M�BEs2@E:�S]>�R-@E:;:�s2P @E:gl�P G!B��2:#>A}`H]U�:Zlh:�T?G2P BEP H�G4i

**

**

**

**

)+)

! , )+) )+

)!�� )+) )+

) )+) )+

) )+)! _

� �

� + .�)*���� �[d>)$.��!��,�35+-,/.J3:��� 8�% �$"+R��35+28 �!�#"$��%V+-,�3:��� 8(�3Q���5��+-%-% ��*IHABE:«B��?>]B(P J;H�G2:�@E:=[Q>]BEP U�P C=:gR!B��2: MOH�@E@E:gRC<`H�G?lhP G�� <���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQM BE@E:=:«DFHhlh:=[#BEH B��2: RC:OBFHAJ:�5�BV>AG�B;RC<`:gMOP :gR �Cn � ! , Y�| | | Y ! _*��ShB��2:�@E:gRCs2[ BEP G��(DFHhlh:=[�� +�� a (�� � MOH�G?RCPQRXBVR#HAJq>A[ [-RC:OBVR|HAJ�B��2:J\H�@ED $ n � ! �NY�| | | Y !�� Y�| | | Y ! �4���|P B������ � � �XiJ���2PQR;DFHhlh:=[qH�G�� PQR"M7�?>A@V>�M�BE:=@EP C=:gl }�W B��2:/ � �]���q�|�|�=�_�X���|���+�N�_�X�_�V���Z¬O¢����Z���_��¤�� �O���X�����X����� ���g 7�X� �����_����� ¨;�Q± ��±_���_�N�Q�V�|� � ¢;�V�k�V� �h� �O���X�����X����� ���_�q�V����_���X� �X�|�X�O���4�V���|±

f_d

Page 18: 35+2 ,]+-, 0 +2 , 8( #?micro.econ.kit.edu/downloads/Puppe_journal_18_Modelling... · 2009-12-09 · , " 0 %)*+-,/.1 +2 #" +-0 ( +-35461( ("! , 0 %)*35+2 , 4 +-,#& ! 35+2 , 798( %-%

<2@EH�<`:=@CBXW�B��?>]BY�1�2:=G2:=U�:=@ $ MOH�G�BV>AP G?RIBZ�ZH RC<`:gMOP :gR=S+B��2:=G P B!>A[QRCH�MOH�G�BV>AP G?R">A[ [qRC<`:gMOP :gR^B��?>]B>A@E:FP G�BE:=@EDF:glhPQ>]BE:FP G BE:=@ED(R"HAJZB��2:=P @ #Elh:,��@E:=:/HAJ#:=U�H�[ U�:glhG2:gRER=i &�Q;}?RC:=@EU�:~B��?>]BgS-P G MOH�G�BE@V>�RXBBEH B��2:���:=G2:=@V>A[4BE@E:=:~DFHhlh:=[�S � +�� a (�� � lhH�:gR;P DF<`H�RC:~B��2:~<2[Q>As?RCP }2[ :~@E:gRXBE@EPQM�BEP H�G?RIHAJ�B��2:!J\H�@ED# ( !�� Y ! �B/ � # ( ! � Y ! �B/��1�2:=G2:=U�:=@ � � � ���Xi

�I'P& #%!IF � 143 9�:;169I36F 5����%!2<IDG5���FZ,IF 1��*: #"36F^F � 587IFZD�=O�?>]BI@E:gRXBE@EPQM�BEP H�G?R|>A@E:":=G�BV>AP [ :gl�}�W«>�RERCs2DFP G��/B��?>]B^>/DFHhlh:=[-M=>AG }`:!lh:gREMO@EP }`:gl >�R|>F<���W�[ HAv��:=G2:OBEPQM"BE@E:=:!DFHhlh:=[�S?J\H�@ ����!� >A<2<2@EH�<2@EPQ>]BE:"J�>ADFP [ WA+ �)���2PQRA:�s2:gRXBEP H�G�PQR;>AG?R��Z:=@E:gl�}�W«B��2:M7�?>A@V>�M�BE:=@EP Cg>]BEP H�G!HAJ`B��2:|:=G�BEP @E: 8�% ���(� HAJ`<���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQMNBE@E:=:#DFHhlh:=[QRqP G/BE:=@ED(RLHAJ`B��2:#J\H�[ [ HF�|P G��MOH�G?RCPQRXBE:=G?MOW <2@EH�<`:=@CBXW(H�G�B��2:"J�>ADFP [ W HAJL@E:=[ :=U]>AG�BI>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR=i� 2'3 ��� �/� ��2 �/��� ��� � 3 � �5 �<���768� �2H�@L>A[ [h>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR�� Y�$ SA>AG?l~>A[ [ XZY ! Y �A�|P B�� � ������X>AG?l � ����� ! S2P J �l] ����$ >AG?l XT] � �%$ ShB��2:=G G2HAB ! ]'$ �)�!i*IHABE:(B��?>]B/P J|H�G2:��Z:=@E:FBEH lh@EH�< B��2: @E:;:�s2P @E:=DF:=G�B~P G)=U*A-�B��?>]B ��}`:�> MOH�DFDFH�G >AG?MO:gRXvBEH�@"HAJ2X >AG?l ! S+H�G2:��ZH�s2[Ql H�}hBV>AP G B��2:G*I:gRXBEP G��I-�@EH�<`:=@CBXW�iJ���2:�= :g>L� *I:gRXBEP G��I-�@EH�<`:=@CBXWD(>_W }`:«P G�BE:=@E<2@E:OBE:gl >�R!>�@E:;:�s2P @E:=DF:=G�B!HAJIMOH�G?RCPQRXBE:=G�B~H�@Vlh:=@EP G���HAJI>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR!P G BE:=@ED(R!HAJ#C:=G�BE@E:=G?M7�2DF:=G�BgS &�>�R!P [ [ s?RXBE@V>]BE:gl }�W B��2: J\H�[ [ HF�|P G���T^��s2@E:�iI"�G B��2:«@gi �4i R=i-HAJX��P ��s2@E:«b2S�B��2:>]BCBE@EP }2shBE: � PQR�#CDFH�@E:":=G�BE@E:=G?M7�2:gl�&/B��?>AG�$ P G B��2:~RC:=G?RC:�B��?>]B;P G�B��2:!:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G HAJ�RC<`:gMOP :gRB��2:;>]BCBE@EP }2shBE: � M=>AG2G2HAB�}`:I[ H�RXB_�|P B��2H�shBZ>A[QRCH�[ H�H�RCP G�� $ S8�1�2P [ :#B��2:;MOH�G�U�:=@VRC:|lhH�:gRqG2HAB_�2H�[Ql(�RC:=:�S?:�i �?i?RC<`:gMOP :gR8X�/�i�"�G B��2:![�i �4i R=i2HAJ_��P ��s2@E:!b2S��1�2:=GI=U*A- PQR|U�P H�[Q>]BE:gl+S?G2H RCs?M7� @E:=[Q>]BEP H�G}`:OBZ�Z:=:=G ��>AG?l�$ :�5hPQRXBVR=i

)�������

) �)

) ��))

�������

)�

)!

����)X

) ��� �)

$

@��f0#+2�% �3Q�("

)�������

) �)

) ��))

�������

)�

)!

����)X

) ��� �)

$

@�� ���35+R� ��("

� + .�)*���TL �! ����]@E�(�#`��T����35+-,/. �����������354

��� � �.� � � d �!�#"$��%V+R�T�=���/4% ��.<��,���35+28 35���(���!�#"$��%V+ &T�,�"6�,�% 4�+ &A+-3�+R� 8(�,�3Q�+-,��("�+-, � ����,�"J���35+R� ����A3:����@E�(�#`��T����35+-,/.������������354$?

rZWI���2:=H�@E:=D f�S�=U*A-�:�5'�?>As?RXBEP U�:=[ W lh:gREMO@EP }`:gRIB��2:@:�s?>A[ P BV>]BEP U�:~RXBE@Es?M�BEs2@E:~HAJ�<���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQMBE@E:=:NDFHhlh:=[QR=SA>AG?l"B���s?R-<2@EH]U�PQlh:gR->;RCP DF<2[ :Z:=DF<2P @EPQM=>A[ABE:gRXBLHAJhB��2:#>A<2<2[ PQM=>A}2P [ P BXW"HAJhB��?>]BLDFHhlh:=[�iaI@E:/B��2:=@E:F:=DF<2P @EPQM=>A[qMOH�s2G�BE:=@E:�52>ADF<2[ :gRIBEH�B��2:G= :g>L�6*I:gRXBEP G��I-�@EH�<`:=@CBXW �U���2:(MO[ H�RC:gRXB2�Z:MOH�s2[Ql.��:OBLBEH"RCs?M7�F>AG/:�52>ADF<2[ :ZPQRq>�R�J\H�[ [ HF�IR=i ,�, �4:OB ��lh:=G2HABE:NB��2:G#ETI@Cvw@E:=<hBEP [ :;&;>AG?l/MOH�G?RCPQlh:=@B��2: MO[Q>�lh: -��(J\H�s2G?lh:gl }�W �?S-MOH�G�BV>AP G2P G�� :�i �?i4>A[ [�}2P @Vl2R�>AG?l >A[ [qD(>ADFD(>A[QR=i �4:OB X�lh:=G2HABE:RCH�DF:;}2P @Vl+Sh>AG?l ! RCH�DF:;D(>ADFD(>A[�i��2s2@CB��2:=@EDFH�@E:�S�lh:=G2HABE:^}�W(��B��2:"RC:OB#HAJ->A[ [kRC<`:gMOP :gRZP G�-��/�/ ¥4�]�E�`�+�4�X���_� �|�_�V�k�X���|�+�_�#�-� ���|�L�|�����+�X���|�A�X� � � �_�L�'0_�V�|�_� �4�I�X¢N¬A�-�_�_�+�������_�`� � �|� ���X�N¸=�_�C�-� �X�_����V��¬_� ��� ���V¢��=�+���_���A�-���]�E�4�����|�4¬_� ��� ����� �����k�-� � ��4]�_�I� �`�+�������O�-�_� � �4���Z�'0_�V�|� �_�4���_���X�|�_� ��� �C�V�_§��V� � �_� �7¢#���+�E�

� �C�V���-�_� �V�_��� ¬_� � � �7¢I�V�h���_�����-´«� �;�����C�E���X�-�_���w�V� �Q±

fge

Page 19: 35+2 ,]+-, 0 +2 , 8( #?micro.econ.kit.edu/downloads/Puppe_journal_18_Modelling... · 2009-12-09 · , " 0 %)*+-,/.1 +2 #" +-0 ( +-35461( ("! , 0 %)*35+2 , 4 +-,#& ! 35+2 , 798( %-%

B��?>]B;>A@E:^G2HAB|D(>ADFD(>A[QR=S2>AG?l«}�WA$ B��2:!RC:OB|HAJL>A[ [4RC<2P :gMO:gR#P G'-��"B��?>]B;>A@E:^G2HAB|}2P @Vl2R=i"wJ�H�G2:lh:=:=D(Rq}`HAB�� >]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR �N(�#CG2H�GhvwD(>ADFD(>A[ &8/�>AG?l $%(�#CG2H�Ghvw}2P @Vl�&8/�>�Rq@E:=[ :=U]>AG�BgS�H�G2:|H�}hBV>AP G?R>/U�P H�[Q>]BEP H�G�HAJ9=U*A- >�R|R��2HF�|G�P G�B��2:"J\H�[ [ HF�|P G��.T^��s2@E:�i

)�++

++

++*

) X

*)�

)���*

**

**

*+)!

+)J

� $

� + .�)*��� K������>� ��35+-% ���(7�1�+-��"�� �,�"!�!�� �!�% �a MOH�s2<2[ :«HAJ;@E:=D(>A@��hR~>A@E: P G�H�@Vlh:=@giM*IHABE:VT?@VRXB~B��?>]BgS�P G�H�@Vlh:=@!BEH H�}hBV>AP G�> U�P H�[Q>]BEP H�G�HAJ=U*A- B��?>]B#M=>AG(}`:;DFHABEP U]>]BE:glFP G(BE:=@ED(R�HAJ+BE:=@EDFP G?>A[?G2Hhlh:gR�HAJ+B��2:IBE@E:=:�S�P BZPQR�G2:gMO:gRERE>A@EW!B��?>]BB��2:F>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR�� >AG?l $ P G?MO[ s?lh:(RC<`:gMOP :gRV#CH�G B��2:/HAB��2:=@�RCPQlh:;& HAJ5�?S+P G?lhPQM=>]BE:gl �2:=@E:/}�W�JJ\H�@ � >AG?l � J\H�@?$ i a;R/> D(>]BCBE:=@~HAJI:=DF<2P @EPQM=>A[NJ�>�M�BgS�>�M=MOH�@VlhP G�� BEHD�-s?l'��:D(�tA�����2S���>A}2[ :fFKL/�S->A[ [ ���$3Q�,�3 G2H�GhvwD(>ADFD(>A[ PQ>AG DF:=D~}`:=@VR^HAJZB��2:F@E:=<hBEP [ :(MO[Q>�lh:(>A@E:/P G B��2:(<`H�RCP BEP H�G HAJ � SG2H�G2:(P G B��?>]B!HAJ(J!i«a;R!> @E:gRCs2[ BgS4J\H�@"B��2:(<2s2@E<`H�RC:(HAJ#lh:gREMO@EP }2P G��)(�lhPQR7/XRCP DFP [Q>A@EP BEP :gR!>ADFH�G�����$3Q�,�3 RC<`:gMOP :gR=SLB��2:�>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:+� PQR!:;:�s2P U]>A[ :=G�B~BEH B��2: MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM >]BCBE@EP }2shBE:�-�� � WN@E:=<2[Q>�MOP G��� }�W -�� � :=U�PQlh:=G�BE[ W @E:=DFH]U�:gRFB��2: U�P H�[Q>]BEP H�G�HAJJ=U*A-Li�"�G�>AG�W M=>�RC:�S|P B�RC:=:=D(R <2[Q>As?RCP }2[ :B��?>]B/B��2:�@E:=[Q>]BEP U�:=[ W J\:,� :�5�BEP G?M�BF@E:=<hBEP [ : RC<`:gMOP :gR~P G�B��2:�<`H�RCP BEP H�G�HAJ�J M=>AG�}`:�U�P :,�Z:gl�>�R#C<2@E:OvwD(>ADFD(>A[QR�& P GM�1�2PQM7� M=>�RC:/B��2:F}2P H�[ H!��PQM=>A[q>A<2<`:g>A[qHAJ � >�R�>AG >]BCBE@EP }2shBE:@�ZH�s2[Ql RC:=:=D�Z:g>L�ki

Q;G�B��2:!HAB��2:=@X�?>AG?l+S2B��2:!:�52>ADF<2[ :!MO[ :g>A@E[ W P [ [ s?RXBE@V>]BE:gR#B��?>]BIB��2:=@E:�PQRIG2HAB��2P G��(P G B��2:!G2HAvBEP H�G HAJq<���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQM"lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW �����A��� �1�2PQM7���ZH�s2[Ql�<2@E:gMO[ s?lh:�U�P H�[Q>]BEP H�G?R#HAJLB��2:Y=U*A-�lhs2:BEH"B��2:I:�5hPQRXBE:=G?MO:|HAJ+@E:=[ :=U]>AG�BN>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gRqHAJkB��2:#J\H�@ED -���� - $ |>AG?l -���� - v�AS!�1�2:=@E: - $ |>AG?l- v�^>A@E:"lhPQR �XH�P G�BIRCs2}kMO[Q>�lh:gR#HAJ -��G( �2:=@E:^B��2:�MO[Q>�lh:gRZHAJ�D(>ADFD(>A[QR#>AG?l«}2P @Vl2R=Sh@E:gRC<`:gM�BEP U�:=[ W�/�i"wBZRCP DF<2[ W/>A<2<`:g>A@VR�BEH!}`:I>G(\@V>]B��2:=@�@E:=D(>A@��]>A}2[ :B/-:=DF<2P @EPQM=>A[hJ�>�M�BqB��?>]BZRCs?M7�FG2H�GhvwG2:gRXBE:gl/<?>AP @VRHAJZ>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR;HhM=MOs2@^H�G2[ W :�52MO:=<hBEP H�G?>A[ [ W�>�RV#CG?>]BEs2@V>A[a��P G?l2R=S & P JZ>]B�>A[ [�ic"wJNH�G2:F>�M=MO:=<hBVRIB��2:#C:=DF<2P @EPQM=>A[qU]>A[ PQlhP BXW'&�HAJZB��2:G=U*A-LS-H�G2:(M=>AG @E:g>�lD���2:=H�@E:=D f >�R":�5h<2[Q>AP G2P G�� D(>]B��2:=D(>]BEP vM=>A[ [ W \ �/4 P B~PQR�<`H�RERCP }2[ :(BEH >A@E@EP U�:F>]B/>�RE>]BEPQRXJ�>�M�BEH�@EW DFHhlh:=[�HAJ|<���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQMFlhP U�:=@VRCP BXW }�W>As���DF:=G�BEP G��(B��2:!J�>ADFP [ W HAJNMO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM~>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gRI}�W�>FJ�>ADFP [ W HAJNRCs2<2<2[ :=DF:=G�BV>A@EW >]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gRB��?>]B"PQR^H�@���>AG2P C=:gl �/+2�������8(�/+28(�%-% 4 P G B��2:FD(>AG2G2:=@^HAJ �4P G2G2:g>AG BV>F52>2iY"�G MOH�G'T?@ED(>]BEP H�G4SkP B"PQRP G�BE:=@E:gRXBEP G��~BEHFG2HABE:;B��?>]BX�-s?l'��:!� R2(�tA�����8/�DFH�@E:;B��?>AG tA�~G2H�Ghv�MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM^>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR#@E:gMOH�@Vlh:glP G��2PQR���[ H�}?>A[+:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G?>A@EWFBE@E:=:�RE>]BEPQRXJ\W(B��2:J*I:gRXBEP G���-�@EH�<`:=@CBXW�i

�I' � � FZAC5$14FZ,IF � ��� F^B�36F 0FZ,214@t1��G52, 5�� �%!2<IDG5���FZ,IF 1��*: #"36F^F � 587IFZD�-_��W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQM~BE@E:=:(DFHhlh:=[QR~>�lhDFP B/>�RCP DF<2[ : @E:=<2@E:gRC:=G�BV>]BEP H�G P G BE:=@ED(R�HAJI>AG P G?lh:�5 HAJ@#C@E:OvDFHABE:=G2:gRER�&^J\@EH�D B��2:;@EH�HABgS�>�RLJ\H�[ [ HF�IR=i��2H�@Z>AG�W/RC:OB(h HAJ-RC<`:gMOP :gR=S�lh:=G2HABE:I}�W�� 2��4h B��2:I[Q>]BE:gRXBMOH�DFDFH�G�>AG?MO:gRXBEH�@ZHAJ-B��2:�RC<`:gMOP :gRZP G�h#iNz^P U�:=G�>~DFHhlh:=[��CU � ����S2lh:�T?G2:�>~}2P G?>A@EW(@E:=[Q>]BEP H�GH�G?H >�RZJ\H�[ [ HF�IR=i�2H�@I>A[ [ XZY ! S

!�� XIb � B��2:=@E:�:�5hPQRXBVR �V]��R�|P B�� � 2��"�dXZY ! � ] � Y*XT] �c>AG?l ! �] �$� (\u?i fB/"�G�BEs2P BEP U�:=[ W�S !��� X DF:g>AG?R|B��?>]B"RC<`:gMOP :gR ! PQRIDFH�@E:!@E:=DFHABE:�J\@EH�D B��2:!@EH�HABIB��?>AG RC<`:gMOP :gR�XRCP G?MO: ! �?>�R;[ H�RXB�RCH�DF:/>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:~B��?>]B X RXBEP [ [qR��?>A@E:gRA�|P B�� B��2:=P @"[Q>]BE:gRXB"MOH�DFDFH�G >AG?MO:gRXBEH�@gi

fFK

Page 20: 35+2 ,]+-, 0 +2 , 8( #?micro.econ.kit.edu/downloads/Puppe_journal_18_Modelling... · 2009-12-09 · , " 0 %)*+-,/.1 +2 #" +-0 ( +-35461( ("! , 0 %)*35+2 , 4 +-,#& ! 35+2 , 798( %-%

*IHABE:«B��?>]B@=U*A- PQR/:;:�s2P U]>A[ :=G�B/BEH B��2: >�RCW�DFDF:OBE@EW HAJ �� i�TIG?lh:=@@=U*A-LS�B��2:�P G�BE:=@E<2@E:OvBV>]BEP H�G HAJ �� >�R�lh:gREMO@EP }2P G�� #C@E:=DFHABE:=G2:gRER;J\@EH�D B��2:(@EH�HAB7&«PQR�MOH�G'T?@EDF:gl }�W�B��2:FJ\H�[ [ HF�|P G��H�}?RC:=@EU]>]BEP H�G4i� ������ ��� X:& �CU � ��� ���35+R� ����J@��97H3:����,!3:���[����% �35+2�,��a"$��,��("=+-,�I � ?-K(NA+R�^+-�������[���$+-0��7����4� �!��35��+28J�,�"!35���,���+-35+-0�#?�2@EH�D �?>�M�BIu?i f"P B|J\H�[ [ HF�IRNB��?>]BX�Z:�M=>AG M7�2H�H�RC:�>AG�P G?lh:�5���bNH�� . RCs?M7�«B��?>]B

!�� X ���( ! / ��(KX�/!| (\u?i t!/j�s2<2<`H�RC:;>AG(P G?lh:�5��.�?>�R�}`:=:=G lh:=@EP U�:glFU�PQ>G(\u?i fB/q>AG?lI(\u?i t!/�J\H�@Z>�DFHhlh:=[-� U � ����RE>]BEPQRXJ\W�P G��=U*A-LikaIG�W�>]BCBE@EP }2shBE: � ]%� M=>AG }`:/lh:gREMO@EP }`:gl�>�R|J\H�[ [ HF�IR,b�"wJ � H�@EP ��P G?>]BE:gR#J\@EH�D/X-S`B��2:=G� MOH�G?RCPQRXBVRI:�52>�M�BE[ W�HAJN>A[ [LRCs?M=MO:gRERCH�@VR#HAJ�X B��?>]B�>A@E:�G2HAB^DFH�@E:!@E:=DFHABE:�J\@EH�D B��2:~@EH�HABIB��?>AGRCH�DF:2��P U�:=G�U]>A[ s2: M"k���(KX�/�i��2H�@ED(>A[ [ W�S�J\H�@I>AG�W�XT]?H >AG?l >AG�W M"k���(KX�/�S`lh:=G2HABE:

��vNw � b n � ! b ! k�����X >AG?l ��( ! / � M��0|� ������ � ��� ��3 ��U � ��� ���35+R�:&(4 @�� �,�"�� � �$8(8(���"+-,/.D3Q�]I � ? M�N$?E �����,�7B�,�4D�3535��+21�)*3Q��V]�� +R�T�C&=3:���9&����� � n ��vNw � &���A����!� X �,�"J����!� M"k���(KX�/ ?

*IHF� RCs2<2<`H�RC:(B��?>]B��|P B���B��2: BE@E:=: ����� H�G H�B��2:=@E:«PQR~P G?lh:=<`:=G?lh:=G�BE[ WM��P U�:=G�>AG�P G?lh:�5��bNH�� . RE>]BEPQRXJ\W�P G��

! k����IX����( ! / k���(KX�/!Y (\u?i y8/>AG?l�MOH�G?RCPQlh:=@#B��2:"J�>ADFP [ W

� +��Jb n � ��vNw � bNXT]?HTY*M"k��(KX�/ �0|��� � �.� � � d �!�#"$��%�+R�=�B���/4% ��.<��,���35+28A35���(�'�!�#"$��%�+ &=�,�"!�,�% 4 + &>+-3;+R�A8(�,�3Q�+-,��("T+-, � + �&���A����!��+-,�"$��� � ���35+R�:&(4+-,/.YI � ? ��N$?rZW B��2PQR!@E:gRCs2[ BgS9�Z:«M=>AG�>�RERCs2DF:G�|P B��2H�shB~[ H�RER!HAJ1��:=G2:=@V>A[ P BXW�B��?>]B/>I��:=G2:=@EPQMF<���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQMBE@E:=:�DFHhlh:=[+BV>L��:gR#B��2:�J\H�@ED � + ��i����2PQRIRCP DF<2[ P T?:gR|B��2:"J\H�[ [ HF�|P G�� >AG?>A[ WhRCPQR|MOH�G?RCPQlh:=@V>A}2[ W�S2>�RRCs��!��:gRXBE:gl }�W�B��2:~J\H�[ [ HF�|P G��«RCP DF<2[ :���@V>A<��2PQM�@E:=<2@E:gRC:=G�BV>]BEP H�G HAJ � +���i2���2:/MO@Es?MOPQ>A[4J\:g>]BEs2@E:P GI��P ��s2@E:Ff�f"PQRZB��?>]BI:g>�M7� >]BCBE@EP }2shBE:":=G?l2R|H�G >AG�W }2@V>AG?M7� >]B#B��2:!RE>ADF:���vw[ :=U�:=[�i

����� � ������' �$& �$#�#����)X �������

) �)

) ��))

�������

)

)

����)

) ��� �)

��vNw �

v�vAv�vAv�vAv�vAv;M

� + .�)*��� K$K����^�������/+28 �>� ����������,�3Q�35+2�, �C& � + �

f;E

Page 21: 35+2 ,]+-, 0 +2 , 8( #?micro.econ.kit.edu/downloads/Puppe_journal_18_Modelling... · 2009-12-09 · , " 0 %)*+-,/.1 +2 #" +-0 ( +-35461( ("! , 0 %)*35+2 , 4 +-,#& ! 35+2 , 798( %-%

� � �! "�X�$#��7��% �,� �C�l%?�������A�������� �$�I��� ������ #"�G�B��2PQRIRC:gM�BEP H�G4S��Z:2��:=G2:=@V>A[ P C=:^B��2:�@E:gMOs2@VRCP H�G J\H�@ED~s2[Q>FM7�?>A@V>�M�BE:=@EP C=P G��~B��2:!MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM"DFHhlh:=[�iYNH�G?RCPQlh:=@I>AG�W�lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW(J\s2G?M�BEP H�G m �|P B�� � U � +��~>AG?l >AG�>A@E}2P BE@V>A@EW RC:OBEhn'�dX , Y�| | | Y*X � �HAJLRC<`:gMOP :gR=i= P B��2H�shBI[ H�RERZHAJ9��:=G2:=@V>A[ P BXW�Sh>�RERCs2DF:^B��?>]B#B��2:!RC<`:gMOP :gR(X;c�>A@E:^:=G�s2DF:=@V>]BE:gl«RCs?M7�B��?>]B ��(KX , /�� ��(KX � /���| | | � ��(KX � /�i;9;:=G2HABE:~}�W��X � >AG�W�RC<`:gMOP :gR;P G �dX , Y�| | | Y*X �

, �!B��?>]Bc�?>�RB��2:�DFH�RXB|@E:gMO:=G�BIMOH�DFDFH�G >AG?MO:gRXBEH�@1�|P B���X � i_�2H�@ED(>A[ [ W�S��X � PQR|lh:�T?G2:gl�}�W

� 2��"���X � Y*X � � k���� � 2��"�dX;cGY*X � �"J\H�@;>A[ [ � � � | (�dhi fB/*IHABE:/B��?>]B��X � PQR"G2HAB"s2G2P :�s2:=[ W lh:OBE:=@EDFP G2:gl }�W`(�dhi fB/�i.��P ��s2@E:�f_t P [ [ s?RXBE@V>]BE:gR;B��2:FM7�2H�PQMO:/HAJ�X � W2P G�B��2:!lh:=<2PQM�BE:gl RCP BEs?>]BEP H�G�H�G2:Y�?>�R��X � n-X���(�>A[ B��2H�s��!����(KX��F/�����(KX �

, /�/�i

�)�� � � ��� � /�� �����**

**

*

) � � � ��� � �����++)X��En��X � )+

++

+)X �

++

++

++

) **

))X �,

� + .�)*��� KM-��� ��3Q����� +-,�+-,/. �X �� ������ ��� X:& �X �D���35+R� ����JI �$?-K(N�7

m (��dX , Y�| | | Y*X � �F/�n m (��dX , Y�| | | Y*X �, �F/�� # (KX � Y �X � /!|

aI<2<2[ W�P G��(B��2:~RE>ADF:!>A@���s2DF:=G�B|BEHFB��2:~RC:OB �dX , Y�| | | Y*X �, ��S?H�G2:�H�}hBV>AP G?R|J\H�@;RCH�DF:!>A<2<2@EH�<2@EP v>]BE:=[ W«M7�2H�RC:=G RC<`:gMOP :gR��X �

, ] �dX , Y�| | | Y*X �

� ��S

m (��dX , Y�| | | Y*X � �F/�n m (��dX , Y�| | | Y*X �� �F/�� # (KX �

, Y �X �

, /�� # (KX � Y��X � /!|

rZW P G?lhs?M�BEP H�G4S9�Z:FB���s?RY�?>_U�:/B��2:(J\H�[ [ HF�|P G�� @E:gRCs2[ BJ�1�2PQM7� P DF<2[ P :gR"B��?>]B/>AG�W <���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQMBE@E:=:"DFHhlh:=[4PQR|DFH�G2HABEH�G2:^P G�lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW�i3 � �5� � � � ���� � ��� � ��3 m 1(� 8(��B���35+21�% �T\;+-3:�D����!�����/4% ��.<��,���35+28 35���(�A�!�#"$��% � +�� 7��,�"!% ��3h n �dX , Y�| | | Y*X � � 1(� �,�4J����3^�C&=�5���(8�+2���A��)�8(�D3:���3 ��(KX , / � | | | ����(KX � / ?! �����,�7

m (��dX , Y�| | | Y*X � �F/�n m (��dX , �F/���o c � �

# (KX;c�Y �X;c>/!| (�dhi t!/

� � �����_����� �I#����_�����������# ��� �C�l%?�������A��������� �$�I��� ������ #a;RV�Z: �?>_U�: �Xs?RXB RC:=:=G4SI>)��:=G2:=@V>A[ P C=:gl U�:=@VRCP H�G�HAJ�B��2: @E:gMOs2@VRCP H�G J\H�@ED~s2[Q>U(�y2i fB/F@E:=D(>AP G?RU]>A[ PQl~J\H�@qB��2:I<���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQMNBE@E:=:|DFHhlh:=[�i9"�G(<?>A@CBEPQMOs2[Q>A@gS]B��2:|s2G?lh:=@E[ W�P G��!lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW!DF:OBE@EPQM(7BEH!��:OB��2:=@X�|P B���B��2:!U]>A[ s2:!HAJ�RCP G���[ :OBEH�G?R7/Zs2G2P :�s2:=[ W lh:OBE:=@EDFP G2:gR|B��2:~lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW«HAJ�>AG�W�RC:OB;HAJ

fgb

Page 22: 35+2 ,]+-, 0 +2 , 8( #?micro.econ.kit.edu/downloads/Puppe_journal_18_Modelling... · 2009-12-09 · , " 0 %)*+-,/.1 +2 #" +-0 ( +-35461( ("! , 0 %)*35+2 , 4 +-,#& ! 35+2 , 798( %-%

RC<`:gMOP :gR=iI"�G�H�@Vlh:=@�BEH�J\s2@CB��2:=@/RCP DF<2[ P J\W B��2:«DFHhlh:=[ZP B~D(>_W RC:=:=D G?>]BEs2@V>A[�BEH >�RERCs2DF:(B��?>]BlhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW PQR|>�l2lhP BEP U�:�>A[ H�G��F[ P G2:gR#HAJqlh:gREMO:=G�BgShP�i :�ihB��?>]B

# (KXZY �H/2n # (KXZY ! /�� # ( ! Y �H/�1�2:=G2:=U�:=@ �^lh:gREMO:=G?l2R4J\@EH�D ! S]>AG?l ! J\@EH�DVX-i , �V���2PQR=SL�2HF�Z:=U�:=@gS=BEs2@EG?R-H�shB�BEH^}`:Z@E:=D(>A@��]>A}2[ W@E:gRXBE@EPQM�BEP U�:�id"�G�B��2: ��:=G2:=@V>A[#BE@E:=: DFHhlh:=[�S#P B J\H�@VMO:gR >A[ [;@E:=[ :=U]>AG�B >]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR(BEH�}`: MO[Q>�lh:gRH�@�>AG�BEPQMO[Q>�lh:gR=S|P�i :�iZP B�@E:glhs?MO:gR(B��2:6��:=G2:=@V>A[|BE@E:=: DFHhlh:=[IBEH�B��2:D:�s?>�RCP v�MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM H�G2:�i rZWMOH�G?RC:;:�s2:=G?MO:�S�> <���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQM~BE@E:=:FB��?>]B/>�lhDFP BVR!> G2H�Ghv�lh:,��:=G2:=@V>]BE:F>�l2lhP BEP U�: lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXWDF:OBE@EPQM�D~s?RXB;BV>L��:�B��2:!J\H�@ED HAJ�> RCP G���[ :![ P G2:~HAJNlh:gREMO:=G�BgiX�2H�@ED(>A[ [ W�S?H�G2:J�?>�R|B��2:!J\H�[ [ HF�|P G��@E:gRCs2[ BVR=i3 � �5� � � � ���������� d ����� U 8(��B���35+21�% � "+-0���(��+-354>&()*,�8�35+2�, m +-,�")�8(�����6"+R�(��+-� +-% ���+-3546�!��35��+28#]3:���3�+R�T�$"$"+-35+-0�!�% �,/.�% +-,����T�C&T"$����8(��,�3�+ &��,�"D�,�% 4!+ & � U � , ?� � ���� �*�O6 ����� � ��3 m 1(�T8(��B���35+21�% � \;+-3:���'���/4% ��.<��,���35+28 35���(�A�!�#"$��% � +�� ?^X:&=3:��� ���(���#8�+-U�3Q�(" "+R�(��+-� +-% ���+-354 �!��35��+28B+R�'�$"$"+-35+-0�A�% �,/. % +-,����'�C&>"$����8(��,�3;�,�"A��35��+28�35% 4�������+-35+-0��7;3:����, ������ )/��3�1(�>�A% +-,��#? ���,�0���(����% 4�7 + & ����� +R�>�A% +-,���7;"+-0���(��+-3549&()*,�8�35+2�,��^\;+-3:�!3:���^��3Q�3Q�("�������������35+2������$+R��3Q?���2: [Q>]BCBE:=@ @E:gRCs2[ B P DF<2[ P :gR«B��?>]B�P G%>�<2@EH�<`:=@�<���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQM BE@E:=:�S^lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW�D~s?RXB�}`:��)�1 >�l2lhP BEP U�:�i.=O�?>]B�HAB��2:=@"<2@EH�<`:=@CBEP :gR^lhH�lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW�DF:OBE@EPQM=R">�RERCHhMOPQ>]BE:glI�|P B�� <���W�[ H!��:OvG2:OBEPQM"BE@E:=:�DFHhlh:=[QRI<`H�RERC:gRER � "�G B��2:�J\H�[ [ HF�|P G��?S��Z:J�#>AG�B|BEH lh:OBE:=@EDFP G2:�B��2:=D }�W >AG?R��Z:=@EP G��B��2:IJ\H�[ [ HF�|P G��.:�s2:gRXBEP H�G4iNYNH�G?RCPQlh:=@Z>AG�W/<���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQM#BE@E:=:IDFHhlh:=[ � +��;H�G(B��2:;:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G?>A@EWBE@E:=: �����HW�J\s2@CB��2:=@EDFH�@E:�S-RCs2<2<`H�RC:G�Z: >A@E:@��P U�:=G > <?>A@CBEPQMOs2[Q>A@�U]>A[ s?>]BEP H�G m ,H(KX�/"HAJ|>A[ [NRCP G���[ :RC<`:gMOP :gR=S�>AG?l+SLJ\H�@F>AG�W <?>AP @~HAJ;RC<`:gMOP :gR�XZY ! SqB��2: lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW # (KXZY ! / k �2i TIG?lh:=@��1�?>]BMOH�G?lhP BEP H�G?R�H�GFB��2:gRC:^l2>]BV>!lhH�:gRqB��2:=@E:;:�5hPQRXBZ>!lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW~J\s2G?M�BEP H�G m B��?>]BZPQRNMOH�DF<?>]BEP }2[ :A�|P B��B��2:J��P U�:=G DFHhlh:=[ � +��~>AG?l�B��?>]B;P G?lhs?MO:gR|<2@E:gMOPQRC:=[ W B��2:J��P U�:=G U]>A[ s?>]BEP H�G�HAJqRCP G���[ :OBEH�G?RI>AG?lB��2:c��P U�:=G(<?>AP @��|PQRC:;lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BEP :gR �4"wBZBEs2@EG?RNH�shBNB��?>]BZB��2:;DF:OBE@EPQMI@E:gRXBE@EPQM�BEP H�G?RNM=>AG }`:"MO[Q>�RXvRCP T?:gl P G�BEH B��2H�RC: �% �,/. [ P G2:gR^HAJNlh:gREMO:=G�B�>AG?l B��2H�RC: �$8������(� [ P G2:gR^HAJNlh:gREMO:=G�Bgi2= :FMOH�G?RCPQlh:=@B��2:"J\H�@EDF:=@�T?@VRXBgi

jh>_W B��?>]B«>D��P U�:=G�lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW�DF:OBE@EPQM PQR 1(�)*,�"$�(" P JXSZJ\H�@ >A[ [IXZY ! S # (KXZY ! /�� m , (KX�/�i*I:�5�BgS�MOH�G?RCPQlh:=@^J\H�s2@!RC<`:gMOP :gREX �PY*XZY ! >AG?l ! ��RCs?M7� B��?>]B X � �����lX-SZX ����� ! S^X ����� ! �q>AG?l��( ! / ����( ! � /2(�RC:=:J��P ��s2@E:Ffgy8/�i

�) X �) X�

����)! �

���) !

� + .�)*��� K � ���]�,��3Q�,�+28�+-354D�,�" � )�1��!�#")*% ���+-3546�C& #jh>_W B��?>]B # PQR �!�,��3Q�,�� P J^P G�B��2PQRFRCP BEs?>]BEP H�Gd(\P / # ( ! Y*X � / k # ( ! Y*X�/�SZ>AG?lU(\P P / # (KXZY ! � /�k# (KXZY ! /�i��2s2@CB��2:=@EDFH�@E:�ShRE>_W(B��?>]B # PQR ��)�1��!�#")*% �� P J

# (KX � Y ! /! # (KXZY ! /(k # (KX � Y ! � /! # (KXZY ! � /!|/ & �-�V�������]�E�^���_� �;� �|�+�C�V¸��X�;���]�V� ���_�~�V�_�_� ��� §g� �7¢��X���_�_� ��� ��� �X���_��� �_�X���X� � ���=�X����� ��� ·g± �(�V¬A�C§O���L��� �_�X��V�_�_� ��� §g� �7¢;� �4���87=�_� ���X�^�_�X���L���#�_��� �^���_� ¢^�V� ���_�#� � �_�X�4�V�?�_�X���X�X�O�C±

tA�

Page 23: 35+2 ,]+-, 0 +2 , 8( #?micro.econ.kit.edu/downloads/Puppe_journal_18_Modelling... · 2009-12-09 · , " 0 %)*+-,/.1 +2 #" +-0 ( +-35461( ("! , 0 %)*35+2 , 4 +-,#& ! 35+2 , 798( %-%

"�G�BEs2P BEP U�:=[ W�S�RCs2}2DFHhlhs2[Q>A@EP BXWFRE>_WhRqB��?>]B�B��2:^P G?MO@E:g>�RC:|P G«lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW~J\@EH�D >!RC<`:gMOP :gR ! �1�2:=G@E:=<2[Q>�MOP G��"X�}�W«RCH�DF:"HAJ�P BVRI>AG?MO:gRXBEH�@VRNPQRZB��2:!RCD(>A[ [ :=@ZB��2:�DFH�@E:"@E:=DFHABE: ! PQR=i�Q;}?RC:=@EU�:;B��?>]BRCs2}2DFHhlhs2[Q>A@EP BXW P DF<2[ P :gRIRCs2}?>�l2lhP BEP U�P BXW�>A[ H�G��/[ P G2:gR|HAJLlh:gREMO:=G�BI}�W(BV>L��P G��lX�n ! i�a;RIR��2HF�|G}�WV���2:=H�@E:=D y~}`:=[ HF��S�B��2:�MOH�G?lhP BEP H�G?RZHAJ�}`H�s2G?lh:glhG2:gRER=ShDFH�G2HABEH�G2PQMOP BXW >AG?l�RCs2}2DFHhlhs2[Q>A@EP BXW:�5'�?>As?RXBEP U�:=[ W«lh:gREMO@EP }`:^B��2:�DF:OBE@EPQM^@E:gRXBE@EPQM�BEP H�G?R|>A[ H�G��/[ P G2:gR|HAJLlh:gREMO:=G�Bgi

= :;G2HF� BEs2@EG(BEH!B��2:^@E:gRXBE@EPQM�BEP H�G?R�>�MO@EH�RERq[ P G2:gRNHAJ-lh:gREMO:=G�BgiNYNH�G?RCPQlh:=@�B��2@E:=:^RC<`:gMOP :gR2XZY ! ,>AG?l ! � Sa�1�2:=@E:���(KX�/"k D(>F5 � ��( ! , /!Y ��( ! � / �«>AG?l � 2��"�dXZY ! , �?n � 2��"�dXZY ! � � (�RC:=:���P ��s2@E:�f=uH/�i"�G�B��2PQRIM=>�RC:�ShMOH�DF<?>]BEP }2P [ P BXWV�|P B���>/<���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQM;BE@E:=:"DFHhlh:=[4P DF<2[ P :gR

# (KXZY ! , /�n # (KXZY ! � /!| (�e2i fB/�-H/RC:=:|B��2PQR=ShRCP DF<2[ WFH�}?RC:=@EU�:#B��?>]B#>AG�WF>]BCBE@EP }2shBE: ��<`H�RERC:gRERC:gl/}�WlX�MOH�G�BV>AP G?R ! , P J�>AG?lFH�G2[ WP JZP B�MOH�G�BV>AP G?R ! � iJ"�G?lh:=:gl+S+P J � ] � +��(MOH�G�BV>AP G?R�X >AG?l H�G2:/:=[ :=DF:=G�B"HAJ � ! , Y ! � ��SkP B�D~s?RXBMOH�G�BV>AP G � 2��"�dXZY ! , �En � 2��"�dXZY ! � �8Wh}2shBIB��2:=G ��� � ! , Y ! � �!RCP G?MO: ��(KX�/(k�D(>F51� ��( ! , /!Y ��( ! � / ��i

�)�

�������)X

**

**

*

)��)! ,

)��)! �

� + .�)*��� K � �Bd ��+-35)��35+2�,]+-,]\ �/+28(�E,��(8(���(�����+-% 4 # (KXZY ! , /�n # (KXZY ! � /

��� � �.� � � � ��3 � + � 1(� �D���/4% ��.<��,���35+28 35���(���!�#"$��% 76�,�"b8(�,���+2"$���Y�Y.�+-0��,f0�% )��35+2�,m ,.b0H� . � �C& �%-%V��+-,/.�% ���5���(8�+2��� �,�"D�D"+R�(��+-� +-% ���+-354D�!��35��+28"# b0H W�H� . � ?6 �����������$+R��32�A�!"+-0���(��+-354B&()*,�8�35+2�, m \;+-3:� � U � +�� ��)�8(�63:���3 m (��dX��F/�n m ,8(KX�/ �,�" m +-,�")�8(���'3:���.�+-0��,P"+R�(��+-� +-% ���+-35+2���W+ &6�,�"Y�,�% 4�+ & # +R�D1(�)*,�"$�("�7=�!�,��3Q�,���7'��)�1��!�#")*% ��D�,�"E���35+R� ����I ��?-K(N$?��]����(�0���(7 m +R�A)*,�+���)���% 46"$��3Q����� +-,��("D1�4 m , �,�" #�?

���2:^RCP ��G2P T`M=>AG?MO:IHAJ����2:=H�@E:=D y!PQRqB��?>]BZP B ������)/��35+-0��% 4 lh:gREMO@EP }`:gRqB��2:^@E:gRXBE@EPQM�BEP H�G?RqP DF<`H�RC:glH�G"B��2:NlhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BEP :gR+}�W;B��2:N<���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQM�BE@E:=:�DFHhlh:=[�ia"wB4B���s?R4<2@EH]U�PQlh:gR4>|RCP DF<2[ :N:=DF<2P @EPQM=>A[BE:gRXBX�1�2:OB��2:=@I>@��P U�:=G�lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW DF:OBE@EPQM^PQRIMOH�G?RCPQRXBE:=G�B1�|P B���>/<���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQM;BE@E:=:"DFHhlh:=[�i

QIJ|B��2:«G2:gMO:gRERE>A@EW <2@EH�<`:=@CBEP :gR!HAJ|B��2: lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW DF:OBE@EPQM s2G?lh:=@E[ W�P G�� > <���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQMBE@E:=:�DFHhlh:=[�SNB��2: @E:gRXBE@EPQM�BEP H�GP(�e2i fB/!PQR(>A@���s?>A}2[ W B��2: DFH�RXB(<2@EH�}2[ :=D(>]BEPQMAi *IHABE:�B��?>]B (�e2i fB/lh:gREMO@EP }`:gR/B��2: @E:gRXBE@EPQM�BEP H�G :=G�BV>AP [ :gl�}�W > �����35+28�)*% �� <���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQM«BE@E:=: DFHhlh:=[�(\P�i :�iqJ\H�@ >��P U�:=G P G?lh:�5��'/�i3�H�@E:A��:=G2:=@V>A[ [ W�S�MOH�G?RCPQlh:=@NB��2@E:=:^RC<`:gMOP :gR2XZY ! Y �~RCs?M7�(B��?>]B$��n � 2��"�dXZY ! �^>�RP G�B��2:"J\H�[ [ HF�|P G��.T^��s2@E:�i

)����)X

���) !

� + .�)*��� K ��� ��n � 2��"�dXZY ! �

thf

Page 24: 35+2 ,]+-, 0 +2 , 8( #?micro.econ.kit.edu/downloads/Puppe_journal_18_Modelling... · 2009-12-09 · , " 0 %)*+-,/.1 +2 #" +-0 ( +-35461( ("! , 0 %)*35+2 , 4 +-,#& ! 35+2 , 798( %-%

rZW)(�e2i fB/�SkMOH�DF<?>]BEP }2P [ P BXW HAJ�B��2:/lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW�DF:OBE@EPQMJ�|P B�� ����!� <���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQM"BE@E:=:~DFHhlh:=[@E:;:�s2P @E:gRZP G�B��2PQRIRCP BEs?>]BEP H�G4S

# (KXZY ! /2n # (KXZY �H/ZH�@ # ( ! Y*X�/2n # ( ! Y �H/!| (�e2i t!/"�GFB��2:;s2G2P J\H�@ED M=>�RC:IHAJ4MOH�G?RXBV>AG�B�U]>A[ s?>]BEP H�GFHAJ4RCP G���[ :;RC<`:gMOP :gR=S[(�e2i t!/LPQR�:;:�s2P U]>A[ :=G�B�BEH�@E:;:�s2P @CvP G��":;:�s?>A[ P BXW�HAJ?B��2:ZBZ�ZHc��@E:g>]BE:gRXBqlhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BEP :gRL>ADFH�G��">AG�W"BZ�ZH"RC<`:gMOP :gRLHAJ?B��2:ZBE@EP <2[ :�i����2PQRPQR�B��2:A�Z:=[ [ v>��G2HF�|GFs2[ BE@V>ADF:OBE@EPQMOP BXW(MOH�G?lhP BEP H�G(HAJ+B��2:^MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQMIDFHhlh:=[�S�}2shB#G2HF��@E:gRXBE@EPQM�BE:gl/BEHB��2:~RC<`:gMOPQ>A[�MOH�G?RXBE:=[ [Q>]BEP H�G��1�2:=@E:!H�G2:!HAJLB��2:�B��2@E:=:~RC<`:gMOP :gRIPQR|B��2:![Q>]BE:gRXB^MOH�DFDFH�G >AG?MO:gRXBEH�@HAJ#B��2: BZ�ZH�HAB��2:=@VR=i����2PQR!@E:��?:gM�BVR�B��2: @E:=[Q>F52>]BEP H�G HAJ#B��2:V*I:gRXBEP G��D-�@EH�<`:=@CBXW�BEH�B��2:�= :g>L�*I:gRXBEP G���-�@EH�<`:=@CBXW�i

���2: #��Z:g>L� s2[ BE@V>ADF:OBE@EPQMOP BXW'& MOH�G?lhP BEP H�G (�e2i t!//D(>_W�>A<2<`:g>A@ MOH�s2G�BE:=@EP G�BEs2P BEP U�:�i �2H�@(P GhvRXBV>AG?MO:�S]B��2:|U�:=@EW!<2PQM�BEs2@E:|HAJ?B��2:#BE@E:=:|P GG��P ��s2@E:"f_d;DFP �!��B�RCs��!��:gRXBLB��?>]B �"PQR�RXBE@EPQM�BE[ W!}`:OBZ�Z:=:=GX >AG?l ! S��2:=G?MO:"B��?>]B # (KXZY �H/ � # (KXZY ! /|>AG?l # ( ! Y �H/�� # ( ! Y*X�/�i����2PQR|PQRIMO:=@CBV>AP G2[ W(BE@Es2:"J\@EH�D>.��:=G2:OBEPQM;<`H�P G�B|HAJ�U�P :,��S�}2shB|G2HAB|G2:gMO:gRERE>A@EP [ W/J\@EH�D H�s2@#<2@E:gRC:=G�B#<���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQMI<`:=@VRC<`:gM�BEP U�:�i"�G?lh:=:gl+S�@E: �X:gM�BEP G���B��2: @E:gRXBE@EPQM�BEP H�G (�e2i t!/"RCP DF<2[ W >ADFH�s2G�BVR^BEH�@E: �X:gM�BEP G�� B��2:G= :g>L�D*I:gRXBEP G��-�@EH�<`:=@CBXW�i��-H(RC:=:�DFH�@E:"MOH�G?MO@E:OBE:=[ W��1�?>]BIPQR#P G�U�H�[ U�:gl+ShMOH�G?RCPQlh:=@#B��2:"J\H�[ [ HF�|P G��.T^��s2@E:�i

) **

**

**

** *

)++

++

) **

))

)

++

++

++)�������` ���% �!�, 35���)*3

�����8�)#��+-,��� + .�)*��� K � ���E+R��8(��%-% �,��(�)/� � +R���]�,�" [���8�)#��+-,����

���2:^<2@E:gRC:=G?MO:^HAJ4B��2:�lhHABCBE:gl«>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:�#ZT`R��^&!P G4��P ��s2@E:/fge!:=G�BV>AP [QRNB��?>]B �����8�)#��+-,�� PQRZDFH�@E:@E:=DFHABE:�J\@EH�D B��2:/H�@EP ��P G�B��?>AG >A[ [�T`R��4ic?I:=G?MO:�S`}�WM(�e2i fB/|H�@�(�e2i t!/�S # ( �����8�)#��+-,�� Y ���% �!�, /(n# ( �����8�)#��+-,�� Y 35���)*3 /�i����2PQR!lhH�:gR!G2HAB~RC:=:=D P DF<2[Q>As?RCP }2[ :�i4"wJXS9�2HF�Z:=U�:=@gS4H�G2:(P G?RCPQRXBVR!H�G4S�RE>_W# ( �����8�)#��+-,�� Y ���% �!�, /� # ( �����8�)#��+-,�� Y 35���)*3 /�S;H�G2: PQR�MOH�DFDFP BCBE:gl BEH P G�BE@EHhlhs?MOP G���>AG%>]BCvBE@EP }2shBE: MOH�DFDFH�G�BEH �����8�)#��+-,�� >AG?l 35���)*3 }2shB(G2HAB/BEH ���% �!�, SqB��2:=@E:=}�W U�P H�[Q>]BEP G��6=U*A-Li*IHABE:�>A[QRCH B��?>]BFB��2:�@E:gRXBE@EPQM�BEP H�GP(�e2i t!/FlhH�:gRFG2HAB >A<2<2[ W BEH B��2: BE@EP <2[ : �����8�)#��+-,�� S ���% �!�, S�������` i."�G?lh:=:gl+S-RCP G?MO:�� 2��"� �����8�)#��+-,�� Y �������` � ������� 2��"� �����8�)#��+-,�� Y ���% �!�, ��S+H�G2:��ZH�s2[Ql :�5�v<`:gM�B # ( �����8�)#��+-,�� Y �������` / # ( �����8�)#��+-,�� Y ���% �!�, /�i ,8�

� �����������7��,��� �����L�.��� �c������ ��� �$�������i�I�X ��� � ��"�,�V������� '*) #%!IFV= �252D*981��G52,I@�34< ) DG58:$� 587IFZD���2:/@E:=<2@E:gRC:=G�BV>]BEP H�G P G BE:=@ED(R^HAJ�B��2:F@E:=DFHABE:=G2:gRERXvwP G?lh:�5 � RCs��!��:gRXBVR;W�:OB�>AG2HAB��2:=@^P G�BE:=@E<2@E:OvBV>]BEP H�G HAJ-B��2:!<���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQMIBE@E:=:�DFHhlh:=[��1�2:=G�B��2:=@E:"PQR|:�5�BE:=@EG?>A[+P GhJ\H�@ED(>]BEP H�G�H�G�B��2:!RC<`:=:glHAJ":=U�H�[ shBEP H�G4id���2: P G�BEs2P BEP H�G�PQR«>�R/J\H�[ [ HF�IR=id���2: lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW�HAJ�> RC<`:gMOP :gR X J\@EH�D P BVR/ 6 ¥4�_��� �O���_� ��� §O�N�V�_�A�C�V�2�V�2���_��� �E�����X��� �_�87=�]�V� � �7¢"� �-�X���"4]���|�X�^¬O¢;���_�q�Q�V���-���]�E�L�I�V�|�I�V� �+�V�_�"�w�V� �|���_����]�V�����V�^� �|�A�����w�V�O�4�_�O¢g� �����X�_����� ��� �C�E���_�����]�C�V����� � �V��� �_���_�-¬A���_�X�C�_�-�_� �w�^���]�V��¸=�4�_�#�_�V�-�]�X§O��±

t�t

Page 25: 35+2 ,]+-, 0 +2 , 8( #?micro.econ.kit.edu/downloads/Puppe_journal_18_Modelling... · 2009-12-09 · , " 0 %)*+-,/.1 +2 #" +-0 ( +-35461( ("! , 0 %)*35+2 , 4 +-,#& ! 35+2 , 798( %-%

P DFDF:glhPQ>]BE:(>AG?MO:gRXBEH�@"M=>AG }`:FU�P :,�Z:gl >�R"lh:OBE:=@EDFP G2:gl }�W�B��2:M#CG�s2D~}`:=@"HAJZRXBE:=<?R�& BV>L��:=G }�W:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G BEH <2@EHhMO:=:gl BEH�X�J\@EH�D P BVR!P DFDF:glhPQ>]BE:«>AG?MO:gRXBEH�@gi Q;G2: D(>_W >A[QRCH�P G�BE:=@E<2@E:OB!B��2PQRG�s2D~}`:=@^>�R|B��2: #ERC<`:=:gl HAJ�:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G4i &G���2:~lh:OBE:=@EDFP G?>]BEP H�G�HAJLB��2PQR;G�s2D~}`:=@;HAJ�RXBE:=<?R=S`H�@IHAJB��2:(RC<`:=:gl HAJN:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G4S+PQR^HAJZMOH�s2@VRC:F>AG :=DF<2P @EPQM=>A[LD(>]BCBE:=@gS4>AG?l �Z:��|P [ [q}`:(RCP [ :=G�B"H�G B��2:PQRERCs2:|HAJ �2HF��BEH�H�}hBV>AP G/B��2PQR�P GhJ\H�@ED(>]BEP H�G4i9=O�?>]BNPQR�P DF<`H�@CBV>AG�BqJ\H�@�H�s2@�<2s2@E<`H�RC:gRLPQRqB��?>]B�B��2:>A}`H]U�:!P G�BEs2P BEP H�G @E:=[ P :gRIs2<`H�G B��2:~G2HABEP H�G HAJN>)#ERXBE:=< HAJ�:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G4S & >AG?l B���s?R;W�P :=[Ql2R;s?RC:OJ\s2[>�l2lhP BEP H�G?>A[4RXBE@Es?M�BEs2@E:^B��?>]BIH�G2:�M=>AG�:�5h<2[ H�P Bgi

�-H/D(>L��:;B��2PQRZJ\H�@ED(>A[ [ W(<2@E:gMOPQRC:�ShMOH�G?RCPQlh:=@ZB��2:^BE@E:=: �����/>As���DF:=G�BE:gl }�W >FRC:OB#HAJc#CU�P @CBEs?>A[RC<`:gMOP :gR=S &!:g>�M7� HAJ��1�2PQM7�«@E:=<2@E:gRC:=G�BEP G��!H�G2:^RXBE:=<«HAJ-:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G (�RC:=:2��P ��s2@E:~fFK2�|P B�� XZY ! Y �/>�R>�M�BEs?>A[4RC<`:gMOP :gR7/�i

��������

�X�

��

��

�! ����

��� �

��� ��'���� #�� �$% � �$#+

* �

� + .�)*��� K� �Bd>8�35)��%V�,�"!0#+-��35)��%H�5���(8�+2����2H�@|>AG�W�XZY ! �|P B���X ����� ! lh:=G2HABE:"}�W �'(KXZY ! /NB��2:�G�s2D~}`:=@|HAJLRXBE:=<?R#G2:=:glh:gl«BEH@��H~J\@EH�DX BEH ! >A[ H�G���B��2:«>As���DF:=G�BE:gl BE@E:=:�iV= :��|P [ [�@E:OJ\:=@�BEH��'(KXZY ! /�>�R"B��2: "+R��3Q�,�8(� }`:OBZ�Z:=:=G X

>AG?l ! ic�2H�@;P G?RXBV>AG?MO:�S`P GD��P ��s2@E: fFK�S��'(KXZY ! /8n�u�>AG?l �'( ! Y �H/8n�y2ic�2H�@^RCP DF<2[ PQMOP BXW�S��Z:.�|P [ [�2:=G?MO:OJ\H�@CB�� G2HABIlhPQRXBEP G���s2PQR�� }`:OBZ�Z:=:=G U�P @CBEs?>A[4>AG?l�>�M�BEs?>A[4RC<`:gMOP :gRI>AG?l�RCP DF<2[ W�MOH�G?RCPQlh:=@#B��2:>As���DF:=G�BE:gl«BE@E:=:~lh:�T?G2:gl�H�G�B��2:~s2G2P H�G�HAJq}`HAB��4i1����s?R=S �'(KXZY ! /IMOH�P G?MOPQlh:gRX�|P B�� B��2:.��@V>A<��hvlhPQRXBV>AG?MO:;H�G B��2:">As���DF:=G�BE:glFBE@E:=:�i���2:"lhPQRXBV>AG?MO:;DF:OBE@EPQM ��G?>]BEs2@V>A[ [ W/P G?lhs?MO:gRNB��2:;J\H�[ [ HF�|P G��P G?lh:�5 �.bNH�� . S �'(KX�/�b n �'(KX , Y*X�/!|����s?R �'(KX�/;PQR"RCP DF<2[ W B��2:(lhPQRXBV>AG?MO:/HAJ2X J\@EH�D B��2:/@EH�HAB X , S �1�2PQM7�D�Z:.�|P [ [q@E:OJ\:=@;BEH >�R;B��2:��0�% 0�(",����(� HAJqRC<`:gMOP :gR(X-i

z^P U�:=G�B��2PQR(>�l2lhP BEP H�G?>A[|P GhJ\H�@ED(>]BEP H�G4SNP B RC:=:=D(RFG?>]BEs2@V>A[ZBEH MOH�G?RCPQlh:=@/B��2:�<���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQMBE@E:=:~DFHhlh:=[ � +

�SkP�i :�i?BEH(BV>L��:!B��2:~:=U�H�[ U�:glhG2:gRER �(>�R|B��2:/@E:=DFHABE:=G2:gRERXvwP G?lh:�5+i1= :��|P [ [�@E:OJ\:=@

BEH � +�>�RqB��2: ��0�% )*35+2�,����4�8�% �#8(`J�!�#"$��% i�Q;}?RC:=@EU�:|B��?>]BgS�P G«MOH�G�BE@V>�RXB�BEH~B��2:^lh:=@EP U�:gl(P G?lh:�5

���1�2PQM7� RC:=@EU�:gRZ<2s2@E:"@E:=<2@E:gRC:=G�BV>]BEP H�G«<2s2@E<`H�RC:gR=S�B��2:�P G?lh:�5 �~PQR#G2HF�%>/<2@EP DFP BEP U�:!l2>]BEs2D ia;RIPQR;:g>�RCP [ W«U�:=@EP T?:gl+S?B��2:~DFHhlh:=[ � +

�PQR;M7�?>A@V>�M�BE:=@EP C=:gl�}�W«B��2:!J\H�[ [ HF�|P G��«RC:OB;HAJNMOH�G?lhP v

BEP H�G?R=i��2H�@N>A[ ["� ] � +�S���RE>]BEPQRZT?:gR_�|{�fJ(wYNH�DFDFH�G(aIG?MO:gRXBEH�@ /�S8�|{;t@(�TIG�}2@EH!��:=G �4P G2:g>L��:B/

>�R#}`:OJ\H�@E:�S2>AG?l� . �4"wJ �'(KX�/ n �'( ! /�S � �����IX-S � ����� ! >AG?l �l] �!ShB��2:=G)(KXT] � ! ] �c/�i*IHABE:^B��?>]BIP JLH�G2:�lh@EH�<?RZB��2:!MO[Q>As?RC: �'(KX�/ n �'( ! /ZP GI�|{Iy2S�B��2:!MOH�G?lhP BEP H�G RE>_WhRNB��?>]B;>AG�W lhPQRXvBEP G?M�BEP H�G?RI}`:OBZ�Z:=:=G�X >AG?l ! D~s?RXB^}`:!H�G MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQMY��@EH�s2G?l2R=iIYNH�G?lhP BEP H�GI�|{Iy(@E:;:�s2P @E:gR#B��2PQRH�G2[ W J\H�@I:;:�s?>A[ [ W«:=U�H�[ U�:gl�RC<`:gMOP :gR=i����2PQRX:�s?>A[ P T?:gl�>A<2<2[ PQM=>]BEP H�G HAJ�B��2:~MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM"P G�BEs2P BEP H�G�PQRMOH�DF<?>]BEP }2[ :A�|P B��«B��2:"MO@EP BEP :�s2:gRNHAJ+B��2:G(\s2G^:�s?>A[ P T?:gl^/NMO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQMIDFHhlh:=[���P U�:=G«>A}`H]U�:�i9"�G?lh:=:gl+SH�G?MO:IB��2:":=U�H�[ shBEP H�G?>A@EWFRC<`:=:gl PQRNBV>L��:=G P G�BEHF>�M=MOH�s2G�BgS�B��2:c��P U�:=G«:�52>ADF<2[ :gRN[ H�H�RC:IB��2:=P @ZJ\H�@VMO:>�R|MOH�s2G�BE:=@E:�52>ADF<2[ :gR=i

aIG P G�BE:=@E<2@E:OBV>]BEP H�G�HAJ �/>�R|RC<`:=:gl�HAJL:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G�@E:;:�s2P @E:gR|>FM=>A[ P }2@V>]BEP H�G�HAJq>FRXBE:=<�HAJ�:=U�HAv[ shBEP H�G P G BE:=@ED(RNHAJ-lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW�b���>L��P G��!H�G2:^RXBE:=< :=G�BV>AP [QR�B��2:^RE>ADF:^lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW/}`:OBZ�Z:=:=G

tAy

Page 26: 35+2 ,]+-, 0 +2 , 8( #?micro.econ.kit.edu/downloads/Puppe_journal_18_Modelling... · 2009-12-09 · , " 0 %)*+-,/.1 +2 #" +-0 ( +-35461( ("! , 0 %)*35+2 , 4 +-,#& ! 35+2 , 798( %-%

G2:=P �!��}`H�@EP G�� RC<`:gMOP :gRG(�>�M�BEs?>A[�H�@"U�P @CBEs?>A[ /^>AG�WH�1�2:=@E:/P G B��2:FBE@E:=:�iG�2H�@ED(>A[ [ W�S+B��2PQR!>ADFH�s2G�BVRBEH/B��2:"J\H�[ [ HF�|P G��F@E:;:�s2P @E:=DF:=G�Bgi�2H�@I>A[ [ XZY ! S

# (KX Y*X�/2n # ( ! Y ! /#>AG?l # (KXZY*X /2n # ( ! Y ! /!Y (>K�i fB/�1�2:=@E: X

(\@E:gRC<4i !

/!lh:=G2HABE:gR!B��2:�P DFDF:glhPQ>]BE: >AG?MO:gRXBEH�@~HAJIX (\@E:gRC<4i ! /�S�>�R~}`:OJ\H�@E:�iM���2:

@E:;:�s2P @E:=DF:=G�B@(>K�i fB/;R��2H�s2[Ql�}`:/U�P :,�Z:gl >�R^>«MOH�G�U�:=G�BEP H�G >A}`H�shB2�1�?>]B">AG :=U�H�[ shBEP H�G?>A@EW RXBE:=<PQR=i

���2:�:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G?>A@EW^MO[ HhM7�^DFHhlh:=[�R��2HF�IR+B��?>]B-B��2:ZMO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM�U�P :,��M=>AG�}`:Z>A<2<2[ P :gl"BEH;:;:�s?>A[ [ W:=U�H�[ U�:gl RC<`:gMOP :gR=i�"wJZH�G2:@�Z:=@E:~BEH >A<2<2[ W�B��2:(MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM/U�P :,� BEH >A[ [�RC<`:gMOP :gR":�5hPQRXBEP G�� >]B!>AG�W<`H�P G�BNHAJkBEP DF:�S�H�G2:X�ZH�s2[Ql/P DF<2[ PQMOP BE[ WFPQlh:=G�BEP J\WF:=U�H�[ U�:glhG2:gRER��|P B��(BEP DF:I:=[Q>A<?RC:gl+iLrZshBZP G(U�P :,�HAJY(>K�i fB/IB��2PQRY�ZH�s2[Ql DF:g>AG B��?>]B�B��2: RC<`:=:gl HAJ#:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G PQR 8(�,���3Q�,�3 >�MO@EH�RER;B��2:FBE@E:=:!b"B��2:lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW~HAJ4>2��P U�:=G(RC<`:gMOP :gRN>]B 5�J\@EH�D B��2: ����!� RC<`:gMOP :gRN>]B 5 ! � PQRqB��2:;RE>ADF:;>�RLB��?>]BNHAJ>AG2HAB��2:=@#RC<`:gMOP :gRZ>]B 5qJ\@EH�D P BVRZ>AG?MO:gRXBEH�@Z>]B 51! � iqrZshBNB��2PQR#MOH�G�BE@V>�lhPQM�BVRN>�J\s2G?l2>ADF:=G�BV>A[`J�>�M�B>A}`H�shBN:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G?>A@EWJ�2PQRXBEH�@EW�SAG?>ADF:=[ W~B��?>]BZ>A[ DFH�RXBN>A[ [?:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G?>A@EW!M7�?>AG���:|HhM=MOs2@VRLB��2@EH�s��!�RC<`:gMOPQ>]BEP H�G4S+}2shB�H�G2[ W U�:=@EW [ P BCBE[ :@�|P B��2P G RC<`:gMOP :gR=i ,'�U�2H�@�>«MO@EP BEP :�s2:/HAJ�B��2:(MO[Q>�lhPQRXBEPQM~DFHhlh:=[>A[ H�G��~B��2:!RE>ADF:"[ P G2:gR=S?RC:=:Y�?>AP B��)(Xfgb�bAuH/�i

� 'P& #"36@$,� DG@t1��G52, .0, ��@�3��G@$,�:�F"�G j�:gM�BEP H�G d(>A}`H]U�:�S��Z:J�?>_U�:!R��2HF�|G B��?>]BIB��2:/lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW«HAJ�>AG�W RC:OB;HAJ�RC<`:gMOP :gR;P G >(<���W�[ HAv��:=G2:OBEPQM|BE@E:=:IDFHhlh:=[kPQRNlh:OBE:=@EDFP G2:gl }�W~B��2:=P @Z<?>AP @��|PQRC:;lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BEP :gR=i9= :c�?>_U�:I>A[QRCH~>A@���s2:glB��?>]B/B��2PQR���@E:g>]BE[ W @E:glhs?MO:gR!B��2:�P GhJ\H�@ED(>]BEP H�G�G2:=:glh:gl BEH lh:OBE:=@EDFP G2:«B��2: lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW HAJ^>A@E}2P vBE@V>A@EW RC:OBVR=S�RCP G?MO:@�|P B�� � RC<`:gMOP :gR"B��2:=@E:(>A@E:(>]B�DFH�RXB��/�'(�� !�fB/;G2H�Ghv>C=:=@EH lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BEP :gR=i?IHF�Z:=U�:=@gS+B��2:FBV>�R�� HAJ|lh:OBE:=@EDFP G2P G�� >A[ [NlhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BEP :gR"}`:OBZ�Z:=:=G RC<`:gMOP :gR!RXBEP [ [�P G�U�H�[ U�:gR^B��2:MOH�DF<?>A@EPQRCH�G HAJNRC<`:gMOP :gR|B��?>]B">A@E:�J�>A@^>A<?>A@CBgSk> MOH�DF<?>A@EPQRCH�G��1�2PQM7� D(>_W�}`:/lhP ! MOs2[ B^BEH <`:=@CvJ\H�@ED P G <2@V>�M�BEPQMO:�i YZ>AG H�G2: @E:glhs?MO:FB��2PQR�BV>�R�� BEHU#C[ HhM=>A[ & MOH�DF<?>A@EPQRCH�G?R=S-RE>_W MOH�DF<?>A@EPQRCH�G?RB��?>]B"H�G2[ W P G�U�H�[ U�:!>«RC<`:gMOP :gR^>AG?l P BVR;P DFDF:glhPQ>]BE:F>AG?MO:gRXBEH�@+��T;RCP G�� B��2:~:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G?>A@EW MO[ HhM7�DFHhlh:=[�S��Z: G2HF� HL k:=@/>�<2@EH�<`H�RE>A[qBEH�B��2PQR~:� k:gM�B!B��?>]B/PQR~>A<2<2[ PQM=>A}2[ : P G B��2:«s2G2P J\H�@ED M=>�RC:�SP�i :�i[�1�2:=G m (��dX��F/8n m (�� ! �F/ZJ\H�@^>A[ [tXZY ! iA= P B��2H�shB^[ H�RERIHAJ_��:=G2:=@V>A[ P BXW�S^�Z:/>�RERCs2DF:�B��2:~G2H�@CvD(>A[ P Cg>]BEP H�G m (��dX��F/In f~P G >A[ [9�1�?>]B;J\H�[ [ HF�IR=ic*IHABE:~B��?>]B^s2G2P J\H�@EDFP BXW�P DF<2[ P :gR^RCW�DFDF:OBE@EW HAJB��2:(lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW�DF:OBE@EPQMAS4P�i :�i # (KXZY ! / n # ( ! Y*X�/�iF{|:gM=>A[ [LB��?>]B # (KXZY ! /2:�s?>AG�BEP T?:gR;B��2:/BEHABV>A[�Z:=P �!��B|HAJq>A[ [4>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR|<`H�RERC:gRERC:gl«}�W�X�}2shB;G2HABI}�W ! i"�G <?>A@CBEPQMOs2[Q>A@gShP J�X������ ! S�B��2:!lhPQRXvRCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW # (KXZY ! /�DF:g>�RCs2@E:gR�B��2:c�Z:=P �!��BZHAJ->A[ [�#CH�[Ql�&!>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gRNB��?>]B��?>_U�:I}`:=:=G«[ H�RXB#P G B��2::=U�H�[ shBEP H�G?>A@EW(BE@V>AG?RCP BEP H�G J\@EH�D X BEH ! S^�1�2:=@E:g>�R # ( ! Y*X�/|DF:g>�RCs2@E:gR#B��2:.�Z:=P �!��BIHAJ�>A[ [A#CG2:,�X&>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gRqB��?>]B��?>_U�:#}`:=:=G���>AP G2:gl+i9���2:;>�RERCs2DF<hBEP H�G(HAJks2G2P J\H�@EDFP BXW/PQRqB��?>]B�B��2:gRC:|DF:g>�RCs2@E:gR>A@E:�P G <`:=@CJ\:gM�B^}?>A[Q>AG?MO:�icQ;G2:!D(>_W B���s?R;@E:OJ\:=@IBEH(B��2:~s2G2P J\H�@ED M=>�RC:~>�R�#C:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G��|P B��2H�shB<2@EH!��@E:gRER=i &(YN[ :g>A@E[ W�S2B��2PQRIPQR;@E:gRXBE@EPQM�BEP U�:!W2H�G B��2:~HAB��2:=@X�?>AG?l+S?B��2:~:;:�s2P U]>A[ :=G�B;>�RERCs2DF<hBEP H�G�HAJ:;:�s?>A[+U]>A[ s?>]BEP H�G�HAJq>A[ [4RCP G���[ :�RC<`:gMOP :gR|lhH�:gR|G2HABIRC:=:=D P DF<2[Q>As?RCP }2[ :�>�R|>/}`:=G?M7�2D(>A@��ki

"�G/B��2:Is2G2P J\H�@ED M=>�RC:�SAB��2:=@E:I>A@E:I>]B�DFH�RXB����7(��*!�fB/��At^lhP k:=@E:=G�BNG2H�Ghv>C=:=@EH�lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BEP :gR=S>AG?l �2:=G?MO: >AG�:;:�s?>A[;G�s2D~}`:=@ HAJ�lh:,��@E:=:gR(HAJ^J\@E:=:glhH�D i ���2:�J\H�[ [ HF�|P G�� <2@EH�<`H�RE>A[#J\s2@CB��2:=@@E:glhs?MO:gR(B��2PQR G�s2D~}`:=@«BEH �qS#B��2: BEHABV>A[;G�s2D~}`:=@«HAJ~RC<`:gMOP :gR=i$"wBVR }?>�RCPQM�PQlh:g> PQR BEH�lh:=@EP U�:B��2: :=G�BEP @E: lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW�DF:OBE@EPQM J\@EH�D B��2: lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW }`:OBZ�Z:=:=G G2:=P �!��}`H�@VR(P G B��2:�BE@E:=:>As���DF:=G�BE:gl }�W U�P @CBEs?>A[qRC<`:gMOP :gR=iY"wB�PQR;P DF<`H�@CBV>AG�B^BEH�@E:g>A[ P C=:!B��?>]B!>A[ B��2H�s��!� (>K�i fB/1T�5h:gR;B��2:lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW«:=G�BV>AP [ :gl }�W �,�� RXBE:=< HAJq:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G4S?P B"lhH�:gRIG2HAB^lh:OBE:=@EDFP G2:�B��2:/lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW@E:gRCs2[ BEP G��^J\@EH�D >"RC:;:�s2:=G?MO:#HAJ � RXBE:=<?R=i�YNH�G?RCPQlh:=@gS_J\H�@qP G?RXBV>AG?MO:�SAB��2:|RC<`:gMOP :gR$X , Y�| | | Y*X;_�>A[ H�G��/ % ' ������� ¸=� �_�q�'0_�V�|�_� �+� �2���_�4�Q�V�|���_��� +3/�/ .�� .+* ) �L�-�_� �w�#�]�V�`�_����¬]�V¬_� ¢Z�'0g� �����X�|� �#�V� �|�����?�_�_�w�]�V�_���X�|� ������ ���4�|�����-���]�V�/°C¯�¯Z�|� � � � ���|¢O�C�V���C±

t]u

Page 27: 35+2 ,]+-, 0 +2 , 8( #?micro.econ.kit.edu/downloads/Puppe_journal_18_Modelling... · 2009-12-09 · , " 0 %)*+-,/.1 +2 #" +-0 ( +-35461( ("! , 0 %)*35+2 , 4 +-,#& ! 35+2 , 798( %-%

H�G2:/[ P G2:FHAJ#lh:gREMO:=G�B�>�R^P GM��P ��s2@E:Fe >A}`H]U�:�iJ=O�2P [ : # (KX � � , Y*X � /;PQR�MOH�G?RXBV>AG�B"}�W`(>K�i fB/�S+H�G2:�?>�R#P G���:=G2:=@V>A[ # (KX � Y*X , /��n # (KX � Y*X � /�i_���2:"J\H�[ [ HF�|P G��F>�RERCs2DF<hBEP H�G�@Es2[ :gRZB��2PQR|H�shBgi� �� � � � �*� ������ ��� �*� � � � �� ���2:=@E:/:�5hPQRXBVR�> BE@V>AG?RXJ\H�@ED(>]BEP H�Gi[�RCs?M7� B��?>]B"J\H�@�>A[ [$XZY ! �|P B��X������ ! S

# (KXZY ! /2n [�( �'(KXZY ! /�/!|���2:;MOH�G�BE:=G�BNHAJ+BE@V>AG?RC[Q>]BEP H�GFP G�U]>A@EPQ>AG?MO:|PQRqB���s?R�B��?>]B�B��2:^lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW~}`:OBZ�Z:=:=G(BZ�ZH!RC<`:gMOP :gR>A[ H�G��F>~[ P G2:"HAJLlh:gREMO:=G�B|H�G2[ W lh:=<`:=G?l2R|H�G B��2:=P @IlhPQRXBV>AG?MO:�ShP�i :�i�B��2:�G�s2D~}`:=@#HAJLRXBE:=<?R#G2:=:glh:gl}�W�:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G BEH«<2@EHhMO:=:gl�J\@EH�D H�G2:�BEH B��2:~HAB��2:=@giX*IHABE:!B��?>]B^P G�B��2:!BE@V>AG?RC[Q>]BEP H�G P G�U]>A@EPQ>AG�BM=>�RC:�S_B��2:ZBE@V>AG?RXJ\H�@ED(>]BEP H�G"[ lh:OBE:=@EDFP G2:gR�U�PQ>"MOH�G?lhP BEP H�G4(�e2i fB/4B��2:#:=G�BEP @E:#lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW�DF:OBE@EPQM(�>A[QRCH/J\H�@IRC<`:gMOP :gR#G2HABIH�G«B��2:!RE>ADF:"[ P G2:g>L��:"HAJLlh:gREMO:=G�B /�i

jh>_WFB��?>]B|B��2:"J\s2G?M�BEP H�GT[ PQR 8(�,�8(�0� P JXShJ\H�@I>A[ [ � Y � ��Sf � � � � � � [�( � � /�! [�( � � ! fB/ �-[�( � /! [�( � ! fB/!|

��� � �.� � � � ��3 #Y1(�T�!35���,���% �35+2�,�+-,�0���+2�,�3["+R�(��+-� +-% ���+-354��!��35��+28A���35+R�:&(4+-,/.�I ��?-K(N!\;+-3:��,e+-,�8����(����+-,/.b35���,��:&�����!�35+2�,c&()*,�8�35+2�, [ ��)�8(� 3:���3 [�(��8/ n � �,�" [�( � / ��f &���c�%-%� ?P ��������D���$+R��32�6�E)*,�+ &����� "+-0���(��+-354T&()*,�8�35+2�, m \;+-3:� � U � +

�3:���3>+-,�")�8(���!3:��� .�+-0��,

"+R�(��+-� +-% ���+-354��!��35��+28A+ &A�,�"��,�% 4J+ & [ +R��8(�,�8(�0�#? �]����(�0���(7 m +R�=)*,�+���)���% 4!"$��3Q����� +-,��("�1�4[ ?�-@V>AG?RC[Q>]BEP H�G P G�U]>A@EPQ>AG?MO:/HAJ # P DF<2[ P :gR^BE@V>AG?RC[Q>]BEP H�G P G�U]>A@EPQ>AG?MO:/HAJNB��2: >]BCBE@EP }2shBE:@�Z:=P �!��BVR

P G B��2:~P G�BE:=@EP H�@^HAJqB��2:~BE@E:=:�S+>�R|J\H�[ [ HF�IR=i"9;:=G2HABE:~}�W ��vNw � B��2:F>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:FRXBV>A@CBEP G��«>]BEX >AG?l[Q>�RXBEP G��!J\H�@ � RXBE:=<?R=i���2:^>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:c�Z:=P �!��BEP G���J\s2G?M�BEP H�G�j«PQRZM=>A[ [ :gl 35���,���% �35+2�,E+-,�0���+2�,�3 P Jj"��

� �H�G2[ W(lh:=<`:=G?l2RZH�G � J\H�@#>A[ [k>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR ��vNw � �|P B�� X �n-X , >AG?l � RXBE@EPQM�BE[ W(RCD(>A[ [ :=@NB��2:=GB��2:�DFP G2P D(>A[4G�s2D~}`:=@|HAJqRXBE:=<?RZJ\@EH�D�X�BEH(>AG�W(BE:=@EDFP G?>A[+G2Hhlh:�i

� ����� ��� X:&*#]+R�A35���,���% �35+2�,]+-,�0���+2�,�32793:����, j +R�A35���,���% �35+2�,]+-,�0���+2�,�3Q?���2:«P G�BE:=@E@E:=[Q>]BEP H�G }`:OBZ�Z:=:=G B��2:«BE@V>AGhJ\H�@ED(>]BEP H�G J\s2G?M�BEP H�G [�>AG?l B��2: >]BCBE@EP }2shBE:V�Z:=P �!��BEP G��J\s2G?M�BEP H�Gj)�1�2PQM7� @E:=<2@E:gRC:=G�BVR;B��2:)#Elhs2@V>A}2P [ P BXW <?>]BCBE:=@EG^& HAJ#>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR�PQR!>�R^J\H�[ [ HF�IR=i����2:DFH�@E: MOH�G?M=>_U�: [�S-B��2: DFH�@E: MOH�G?MO:=G�BE@V>]BE:gl PQR"j H�G >]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR ��vNw � �|P B���RCD(>A[ [ � S�P�i :�i4H�GR��2H�@CBCvw[ P U�:gl >]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR=i YNH�G�U�:=@VRC:=[ W�S�[ :gRER~MOH�G?M=>_U�: [ DF:g>AG?R�B��?>]B/[ H�G���:=@Cvw[ P U�:gl >]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR��:OB#>![Q>A@���:=@��Z:=P �!��Bgi����2:;J\H�[ [ HF�|P G���BZ�ZH/>A@E:|B��2:^:�5�BE@E:=DF:^M=>�RC:gR=i9"wJ�[�(��8/�n �/>AG?l [�( � /�n�fJ\H�@F>A[ [Z<`H�RCP BEP U�: � SqB��2:=G j�PQR/MOH�G?MO:=G�BE@V>]BE:gl H�G�>A[ [#RCP G���[ :OBEH�G�>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR,WNP G�B��?>]B(M=>�RC:�S mPQR^RCP DF<2[ W�B��2: 8(�)*,�35+-,/.6�!�(����)*��� S+>�M=MOH�@VlhP G��FBEHV�1�2PQM7��B��2:FlhP U�:=@VRCP BXW«HAJN>«RC:OB^HAJNRC<`:gMOP :gR;PQR��P U�:=G }�W B��2:=P @~G�s2D~}`:=@giDQ;G B��2:«HAB��2:=@.�?>AG?l+SLP JE[�PQR![ P G2:g>A@gS-B��2:�lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW DF:OBE@EPQM #MOH�P G?MOPQlh:gR��|P B��«B��2:"lhPQRXBV>AG?MO:^DF:OBE@EPQM �HWhP G«<?>A@CBEPQMOs2[Q>A@gS�J\H�@#[ P G2:g>A@8[�B��2:"lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXWFDF:OBE@EPQMPQR|>�l2lhP BEP U�:�i_���2PQR#P DF<2[ P :gR=S2}�W YNH�@EH�[ [Q>A@EW(e2i f�S�B��?>]B|B��2:�s2G?lh:=@E[ W�P G��~BE@E:=:������!D~s?RXBI}`:!>/[ P G2:>AG?l B��?>]BIP G�BE:=@EDF:glhPQ>]BE:!RC<`:gMOP :gR��?>_U�:^G2H(D(>A@���P G?>A[kU]>A[ s2:�i

a;RZ>YT?G?>A[k>A<2<2[ PQM=>]BEP H�G4S�MOH�G?RCPQlh:=@NH�G?MO:^>L��>AP GFB��2:4#EM=>]BE:=@E<2P [ [Q>A@7&"<?>]BCBE:=@EG«>�RNP GV��P ��s2@E:~f;E}`:=[ HF��iG"wJ$�'( ! c>/�k �'( ! �B/c�1�2:=G2:=U�:=@ X;cEk�����X���S4B��2:=G B��2:(:=U�H�[ shBEP H�G?>A@EW MO[ HhM7� DFHhlh:=[ � +

�@E:=[Q>]BEP U�P C=:glFBEH � n � ! , Y�| | | Y ! _ �^W�P :=[Ql2R�B��2:�#C[ P G2:;DFHhlh:=[ &!H�G � i���?>]B#PQR=S�J\H�@#>AG�W(>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:�V] � +�B��2:ZP G�BE:=@VRC:gM�BEP H�G � � ��PQR�>AG +-,�3Q����0�% P G�B��2:ZG?>]BEs2@V>A[�H�@Vlh:=@EP G�� ! , � ! � � | | | � ! _~i

���2PQR|P DF<2[ P :gRZB��?>]B|B��2:!lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW m ( ��/ZPQR���P U�:=G�}�W

m ( ��/2n m (�� ! , �F/��_o c � �

# ( ! c*Y ! c, /

t�d

Page 28: 35+2 ,]+-, 0 +2 , 8( #?micro.econ.kit.edu/downloads/Puppe_journal_18_Modelling... · 2009-12-09 · , " 0 %)*+-,/.1 +2 #" +-0 ( +-35461( ("! , 0 %)*35+2 , 4 +-,#& ! 35+2 , 798( %-%

(�M�JXi��|9 (�tA����thSIj�:gM�BEP H�G�y8/�/�i0"wJXSIP G�>�l2lhP BEP H�G4S �'(KX;c*Y ! c / n �'(KX��0Y ! �;/«>AG?l �'(KX;c�Y*X;c � , /Tn�'(KX��0Y*X��3� , /LJ\H�@Z>A[ [ � Y �?S�B��2:=G(BE@V>AG?RC[Q>]BEP H�GFP G�U]>A@EPQ>AG?MO:IH�GFB��2:IBE@E:=:I:=G�BV>AP [QR�BE@V>AG?RC[Q>]BEP H�GFP G�U]>A@EP v>AG?MO:�HAJLB��2:�P G?lhs?MO:gl [ P G2:!DFHhlh:=[-H�G � ( �2HF�Z:=U�:=@gShP GI��:=G2:=@V>A[+G2HABA�|P B�� B��2:~RE>ADF:"BE@V>AG?RXJ\H�@CvD(>]BEP H�G«J\s2G?M�BEP H�G [ /�i

**

**

**

**

) X ,+)! , ) X �+

)! � )+) )+

) )+) )+

) )+) ) X;_+

)! _

� + .�)*��� K �! ����J8(�3Q���5��+-%-% ���&���A3:����% ����3�35+-�!�

+ B�B FZ,�7�� >�� � 365(5��-

3 � ��?��3 � �5� � � � ���� �����6���2:(s2G2P :�s2:=G2:gRER�HAJ#B��2:«>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:��Z:=P �!��BEP G���J\s2G?M�BEP H�G j PQR�Z:=[ [ v>��G2HF�|G P G B��2:F[ P BE:=@V>]BEs2@E:�(�M�JXi��|9 (�tA����thS �?>�M�B!thi fB/�/�i.����s?R=S4P B!RCs"! MO:gR;BEH R��2HF�cB��?>]Bm��?>�R�B��2:IJ\H�@ED (�y2i y8/qP J�j«RE>]BEPQRZT?:gRc(�y2i uH/q>AG?l(P J m

�PQRZlh:�T?G2:gl(J\@EH�D j«U�PQ>V(�thi f�� � /�i�-H~U�:=@EP J\W

B��2PQR=S`H�}?RC:=@EU�:"B��?>]BgS?J\H�@^>AG�W�h >AG?l�>A[ [ZX-S h �'- v �n &FH�@ h��M(KH �9- v8/ �n'&hi13�H�@E:=H]U�:=@gS2P JX��n�X , S4H�G2:��?>�R@(Ph ��- v �n$& �,�" h �)(KH � - v8/ �n$&!/IP J#>AG?l H�G2[ W P J �dXY*X�� U�h &9(Ph_/�i

���2PQRNP DF<2[ P :gR2(�y2i y8/q}�W/B��2:A��P U�:=G��Z:=P �!��B�J\H�@8j � i���2:;[Q>�RXB#RXBV>]BE:=DF:=G�B#P GV-�@EH�<`H�RCP BEP H�G y2i fIPQRP DFDF:glhPQ>]BE:�J\@EH�D (�y2i uH/|>AG?l�B��2:~lh:�T?G2P BEP H�G HAJ�lhP U�:=@VRCP BXW J\s2G?M�BEP H�G?R;>�R#B��2H�RC:�J\s2G?M�BEP H�G?RA�|P B��j�k��2i3 � �� �� ��� � �.� � � ��2 �/��/�#� � �76 �� � 2'3 � = :.T?@VRXB"<2@EH]U�:�B��2:FG2:gMO:gRERCP BXW HAJ�=U*A-Li���2: <2@EH�HAJ;HAJ;B��2:�RCs"! MOP :=G?MOW <?>A@CBF@E:=[ P :gR/H�G�B��2:�MOH�G?RXBE@Es?M�BEP H�G�HAJIB��2: @E:=DFHABE:=G2:gRERXvwP G?lh:�5<2@EH]U�PQlh:gl«}�WV�?>�M�BVR#u?i f�>AG?l«u?i thS2>AG?l�PQR���P U�:=G >]J7BE:=@#B��2:gRC:�@E:gRCs2[ BVR��?>_U�:^}`:=:=G <2@EH]U�:gl+i

?I:=G?MO:�S�>�RERCs2DF:ZB��?>]B � + U ( + �9+ ���!/ 1 J\H�@NRCH�DF:��2P :=@V>A@VM7�2PQM=>A[ + iNYNH�G?RCPQlh:=@ � Y�$ ] � +>AG?l"XZY ! Y �Y�|P B�� � ������X-S � ����� ! S � ] � �N$ S�>AG?l"XT] � � $ i9= :;R��2HF��B��?>]B ! �]�$ ����}�W>!MOH�G�BE@V>�lhPQM�BEP H�G(>A@���s2DF:=G�Bgi�����s?R=S�>�RERCs2DF: ! ]�$ ���!i �4:OB)� n � , � � � >AG?l/$ n $ , �0$ ��1�2:=@E:*� , Y�$ , ]�+ >AG?l � � Y�$ � ]A+ ����iZj�P G?MO: ��PQR|G2HAB;>FMO[Q>�lh:�S��Z:2�?>_U�: �dXZY � � U � , >AG?l! �] � , i�j�P DFP [Q>A@E[ W�S�RCP G?MO:C$ PQRNG2HAB#>~MO[Q>�lh:�S"� ! Y � � U $ , >AG?llX �]�$ , iqrZshBNB��2PQRZMOH�G�BE@V>�lhPQM�BVRB��2:"J�>�M�B|B��?>]B + PQR1�2P :=@V>A@VM7�2PQM=>A[�i3 � �� �� � ���� � ����"�@E@E:��?:�5hP U�P BXW HAJ �� PQRIP DFDF:glhPQ>]BE:�i#a;RCW�DFDF:OBE@EW«HAJ �� PQRI> RXBE@V>AP �!��BCvJ\H�@��#>A@Vl!MOH�G?RC:;:�s2:=G?MO:ZHAJ^=U*A-LiF"wBq@E:=D(>AP G?R-BEH"R��2HF� B��?>]B �� PQR-BE@V>AG?RCP BEP U�:�i9?I:=G?MO:�S�RCs2<2<`H�RC:B��?>]B � ���! >AG?l ! �� XaWa�Z:@�?>_U�:~BEH�R��2HF�cB��?>]B � �� X-iF9;:=G2HABE:F}�WTJ , b n � 2��"�dXZY ! �>AG?lJ � b n � 2��"� ! Y � ��i rZW�>�RERCs2DF<hBEP H�G4SqB��2:=@E:�:�5hPQRXBVR � , ] � RCs?M7��B��?>]B � , � �dJ , Y*X��>AG?l ! �] � , S�>AG?l%� � ] � RCs?M7� B��?>]B � � � �dJ � Y ! � >AG?l ���] � � i �4:OB m , b n � 2��-� , >AG?lm � b n � 2��-� � iNj�P G?MO:�}`HAB�� m , >AG?l m � >A@E:�>AG?MO:gRXBEH�@VRZHAJ ! S'�Z:2�?>_U�: m , k���� m � H�@ m � k���� m , i

tAe

Page 29: 35+2 ,]+-, 0 +2 , 8( #?micro.econ.kit.edu/downloads/Puppe_journal_18_Modelling... · 2009-12-09 · , " 0 %)*+-,/.1 +2 #" +-0 ( +-35461( ("! , 0 %)*35+2 , 4 +-,#& ! 35+2 , 798( %-%

�������JK�� m , k���� m �j�P G?MO: � � MOH�G�BV>AP G?R�B��2: RCs?M=MO:gRERCH�@ ! HAJ m , SN>AG?l�RCP G?MO: ! �] � , S_�Z:«D~s?RXB@�?>_U�: � � � � ,}�W`=U*A-LiZj�P G?MO:.� � B���s?R MOH�G�BV>AP G?R/}`HAB�� J , >AG?l J � P B«>A[QRCH MOH�G�BV>AP G?R � 2��"�dXZY � ��}�W�B��2:�����gv�MOH�G2G2:gM�BE:glhG2:gRER=i?I:=G?MO:�S'�Z:c�?>_U�: � � � ��� 2��"�dXZY � �0Y*X��^>AG?l � �] � � i�rZW lh:�T?G2P BEP H�G4S�B��2PQRP DF<2[ P :gR � �� X-i�������TM-� m � k���� m ,"wJ� , MOH�G�BV>AP G?R5�?SH�1�2PQM7� PQR#>/RCs?M=MO:gRERCH�@NHAJ m � ShH�G2:;D~s?RXB��?>_U�: � , � � � }�W@=U*A-Li2rZshBZB��2PQRMOH�G�BE@V>�lhPQM�BVR#B��2:�J�>�M�BIB��?>]B ! �] � , i1?I:=G?MO:�S � �].� , iIj�P G?MO: � � MOH�G�BV>AP G?R � 2��"� ! Y � ��S2>A[QRCH(� ,MOH�G�BV>AP G?R � 2��"� ! Y � �8W�DFH�@E:=H]U�:=@gS � , MOH�G�BV>AP G?R � 2��"�dXZY ! �;>�R��Z:=[ [k>�R2X�}�W(>�RERCs2DF<hBEP H�G4i?I:=G?MO:�S� , D~s?RXB;>A[QRCHFMOH�G�BV>AP G � 2��"�dXZY � �2�1�2PQM7��W�P :=[Ql2R � �� X-i3 � ��N���� ���� � � �I��>L��:/>AG�W � ] �(i!rZW �����gv�MOH�G2G2:gM�BE:glhG2:gRER;HAJ �!S X`b n � 2��-� ] �JW4[ :OBMGb n�D(>F51� ��( ! /1b ! ] �*��S`>AG?l [ :OB �! ] �c}`:/RCs?M7��B��?>]B ��( �! /(n M�i^YNH�G?RCPQlh:=@;>AG�W�RCs?M=MO:gRERCH�@� HAJ X)�|P B�� ��( �H/ � M�i«j�P G?MO:(}`HAB�� ��>AG?l �! >A@E:(RCs?M=MO:gRERCH�@VR;HAJ X-S�H�G2:��?>�R � 2��"��� Y �! �?] �}�W �����gv�MOH�G2G2:gM�BE:glhG2:gRER#HAJ �!iNrZshB|B��2:=G � ] �!S?RCP G?MO:�HAB��2:=@��|PQRC:G(\u?i fB/��ZH�s2[Ql�P DF<2[ W � �� �!>AG?lV�2:=G?MO: ��( �H/ M~}�W6(\u?i t!/�i3 � ��0�� ��� � �.� � � ������� � � � 6 �� � 2'3 � �4:OB � U � ���«RE>]BEPQRXJ\W =U*A-Li4rZW6�?>�M�Bu?i thShB��2:=@E:!:�5hPQRXBVR ��RCs?M7� B��?>]B^>AG�W+��]'� PQRIHAJLB��2:�J\H�@ED � n ��vNw � i#rZshBIB��2PQRIDF:g>AG?R|B��?>]B��U ( + � ��+ ���L/�1V�|P B�� + �Mb n � �dXPb ��(KX�/ � M��Mb$M ] . �4�1�2PQM7��PQR��2P :=@V>A@VM7�2PQM=>A[�i rZWlh:�T?G2P BEP H�G4S)� PQR|>F<���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQMIBE@E:=:�DFHhlh:=[�i3 � ����� ��� � �.� � � a;R�P G(B��2:;<2@EH�HAJ+HAJa���2:=H�@E:=D f�S�H�G2:X�?>�R � +�� n$( + ���N+ ���L/�1X�|P B��B��2:.�2P :=@V>A@VM7�2PQM=>A[+J�>ADFP [ W�+ �Gb n�� �dXMb ��(KX�/ � M���b4M ]%. ��ic?I:=G?MO: � +��~PQR^> <���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQMBE@E:=:"DFHhlh:=[�i

YNH�G�U�:=@VRC:=[ W�Sh[ :OB � + }`:~>(<���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQM"BE@E:=:�DFHhlh:=[�iI9;:�T?G2: �«U�PQ> (\u?i fB/|>AG?l)(\u?i t!/|>AG?lH�}?RC:=@EU�:�B��?>]B ! k���� X P DF<2[ P :gR@(\G2HAB X ��� ! /�iY���2:=@E:OJ\H�@E:�S � M=>AG }`:FM7�2H�RC:=G RCs?M7��B��?>]B"P BRE>]BEPQRZT?:gRY(\u?i y8/NP G�>�l2lhP BEP H�G4i�rZWV�?>�M�BIu?i thS�� +/U � +���i3 � ��C�� � ���� � ���4�-H U�:=@EP J\W«B��2:/RXBV>]BE:gl J\H�@ED~s2[Q>2S^�Z:.�?>_U�:"BEH�R��2HF�%B��?>]B">AG�W >]BCBE@EP }2shBE:�V] � + �#B��?>]B�lhPQRXBEP G���s2PQR��2:gRtX � J\@EH�D �X � P G~B��2:|RC:=G?RC:ZB��?>]B$X � ] ��>AG?l �X � �] ��>A[QRCH"lhPQRXBEP Ghv��s2PQR��2:gRZX � J\@EH�D%B��2:Z:=G�BEP @E:NRC:OB)�dX , Y�| | | Y*X �

, ��S_P�i :�i�� � �dX , Y�| | | Y*X �

, � n &hi�K�:�s2P U]>A[ :=G�BE[ W�SB�Z:D~s?RXB|R��2HF� B��?>]B|>AG�W(>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:;B��?>]B(X � R��?>A@E:gR_�|P B���RCH�DF:^RC<`:gMOP :gRNP G.�dX , Y�| | | Y*X �

, �^PQRZ>A[QRCH<`H�RERC:gRERC:gl�}�W �X � ] �dX , Y�| | | Y*X �

, ��i.����s?R=S4>�RERCs2DF:~B��?>]B ��vNw � �$�dX � Y*X;c �/J\H�@�RCH�DF: � � � i

���2PQRIP DF<2[ P :gRIB��?>]BEX ������� 2��"�dX;c Y*X � ��S^�2:=G?MO:!}�W�B��2:~M7�2H�PQMO:!HAJ �X � >A[QRCH X ����� � 2��"���X � Y*X � ��i"�G <?>A@CBEPQMOs2[Q>A@gS �X � PQR!> RCs?M=MO:gRERCH�@"HAJ X-i�3�H�@E:=H]U�:=@gS4RCP G?MO:lX � ] ��vNw � Sa�Z:@�?>_U�:"MTk ��(KX � /�S>AG?l6�2:=G?MO:lMTk ��(��X � /�iG�-H!��:OB��2:=@gS+B��2:gRC:FH�}?RC:=@EU]>]BEP H�G?R;P DF<2[ W B��?>]B �X � ] ��vNw � S�>AG?l6�2:=G?MO:B��2:!RXBV>]BE:gl«J\H�@ED~s2[Q>2i3 � ������3 � �5� � � � ���� � ���.�2H�@ED~s2[Q>�(�dhi t!/�J\H�[ [ HF�IR�}�W/P G?lhs?M�BEP H�G(J\@EH�D\�?>�M�B#dhi f;>�RNR��2HF�|GP G�B��2:�D(>AP G«BE:�5�Bgi3 � ��C�� 3 � �5� � � � ���� �����«rZW lh:�T?G2P BEP H�G4S?B��2:/lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW«DF:OBE@EPQM # PQR;>�l2lhP BEP U�:~>A[ H�G��[ P G2:gR|HAJLlh:gREMO:=G�B|P JLJ\H�@I>A[ [ XZY ! Y �@�|P B���X ����� ! ����� �?S

oZs � vNw � ���- ����

j" n oZs � $Qw � ���- ����

j" ! oZs $Qp j" � o

Zs � vNw $����- ����j" | (�a!i fB/

"wB!PQR�:g>�RCP [ W U�:=@EP T?:gl B��?>]BgS4J\H�@~>AG�W � ] � ,�S$j"�HhM=MOs2@VR�>�R�>�RCs2DFD(>AG?l H�G B��2: [ :OJ7BCv>�?>AG?lRCPQlh:�HAJ1(�a!i fB/#P Jq>AG?l�H�G2[ W«P JLP B^>A[QRCHFHhM=MOs2@VR#H�G�B��2:�@EP �!��BCv>�?>AG?l�RCPQlh:�(\<`H�RERCP }2[ W BZ�|PQMO:Y�|P B���><`H�RCP BEP U�:#RCP ��GF>AG?l!H�G?MO:��|P B��(>;G2:,��>]BEP U�:ZRCP ��G[/�i����2PQRqR��2HF�IR4B��?>]B � U � , P DF<2[ P :gRq>�l2lhP BEP U�P BXWHAJ # >A[ H�G��F[ P G2:gR#HAJqlh:gREMO:=G�Bgi

t8K

Page 30: 35+2 ,]+-, 0 +2 , 8( #?micro.econ.kit.edu/downloads/Puppe_journal_18_Modelling... · 2009-12-09 · , " 0 %)*+-,/.1 +2 #" +-0 ( +-35461( ("! , 0 %)*35+2 , 4 +-,#& ! 35+2 , 798( %-%

YNH�G�U�:=@VRC:=[ W�SARCs2<2<`H�RC:#B��?>]B(j�� ��^J\H�@NRCH�DF: �� �] � ,�iNY��2H�H�RC: ! ] ���>AG?l �l] �(KHD/�� ��RCs?M7� B��?>]B#�ik���� ! i«j�s?M7� RC<`:gMOP :gR ! >AG?l � :�5hPQRXB~RCP G?MO: �� PQR"G2HAB~> MO[Q>�lh:!WL>A[QRCH G2HABE:FB��?>]BB��2: @EH�HAB X , PQR�G2HAB!P G �� RCP G?MO: �� PQR�G2HAB/>AG >AG�BEPQMO[Q>�lh:�i�*IHF� H�}?RC:=@EU�:~B��?>]B.�|P B�� X n X , Sj�� lhH�:gR�G2HAB~HhM=MOs2@~H�G B��2:«[ :OJ7BCv>�?>AG?l RCPQlh: HAJJ(�a!i fB/"}2shB~BZ�|PQMO:��|P B���>�<`H�RCP BEP U�:«RCP ��G >AG?lH�G?MO:1�|P B��«>"G2:,��>]BEP U�:IRCP ��GFH�GFB��2:I@EP �!��BCv>�?>AG?l/RCPQlh:�iqrZW!B��2:IBE@EPQ>AG���[ :#P G^:�s?>A[ P BXW�S�B��2PQR�P DF<2[ P :gR# (KX , Y �H/�� # (KX , Y ! /�� # ( ! Y �H/�S'�2:=G?MO: # PQR#G2HAB;>�l2lhP BEP U�:�i3 � ��9��C� � ���� �*�O6 ����� rZW4-�@EH�<`H�RCP BEP H�G�e2i f�S2>�l2lhP BEP U�P BXW�>A[ H�G��F[ P G2:gR|HAJqlh:gREMO:=G�BIP DF<2[ P :gRB��?>]B/>A[ [N@E:=[ :=U]>AG�B~>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR~>A@E:(:=P B��2:=@/MO[Q>�lh:gR�H�@~>AG�BEPQMO[Q>�lh:gR,WL}�W RXBE@EPQM�B~<`H�RCP BEP U�P BXW HAJ#B��2:lhPQRERCP DFP [Q>A@EP BXW!DF:OBE@EPQMAS �%-% >AG�BEPQMO[Q>�lh:gRLD~s?RXBN@E:gMO:=P U�:|RXBE@EPQM�BE[ W!<`H�RCP BEP U�:1�Z:=P �!��BgiLrZW~MOH�DF<?>]BEP }2P [ vP BXWV�|P B�� >/<���W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQM^BE@E:=:"DFHhlh:=[�S2B��2:"J�>ADFP [ W«HAJq>A[ [->AG�BEPQMO[Q>�lh:gR#D~s?RXBIJ\H�@ED >@�2P :=@V>A@VM7��W�i"�G?lh:=:gl+S�G2H�>AG�BEPQMO[Q>�lh:|M=>AG/}`:|H�}hBV>AP G2:gl/>�R�B��2:|P G�BE:=@VRC:gM�BEP H�G/HAJkMO[Q>�lh:gR��|P B��FHAB��2:=@�>AG�BEPQMO[Q>�lh:gR=irZshB|B��2:2�2P :=@V>A@VM7�2PQM=>A[+RXBE@Es?M�BEs2@E:^HAJq>A[ [4>AG�BEPQMO[Q>�lh:gRNJ\H�@VMO:gR �����!BEHF}`:!>/[ P G2:�i"�G?lh:=:gl+S2RCs2<2<`H�RC:}�W��#>_W�HAJZMOH�G�BE@V>�lhPQM�BEP H�G B��?>]B �����(PQR;G2HAB�> [ P G2:!WkB��2:=G4SkB��2:=@E:~:�5hPQRXB^B��2@E:=:/RC<`:gMOP :gR�X , Y*X � Y !RCs?M7� B��?>]B X , k���� ! >AG?lTX � k���� ! }2shB�G2:=P B��2:=@ X , k����"X � S4G2H�@ X � k����"X , iJ"�G B��2PQR�M=>�RC:B��2:/>AG�BEPQMO[Q>�lh:gRIH � - v

�>AG?l�H � - v

�>A@E:!G2HAB^G2:gRXBE:gl+S[�2:=G?MO:!B��2:~J�>ADFP [ W HAJ�>A[ [L>AG�BEPQMO[Q>�lh:gR

M=>AG2G2HAB#J\H�@ED >@�2P :=@V>A@VM7��W�i�2H�@�B��2:^<2@EH�HAJ4HAJ9���2:=H�@E:=D y2SH�Z:;G2:=:gl«RCH�DF:^>�l2lhP BEP H�G?>A[`G2HABV>]BEP H�G«>AG?l >![ :=DFD(>2i��P @VRXBgS

H�}?RC:=@EU�:;B��?>]B;>AG�W �V] � +��!M=>AG�}`:Y�|@EP BCBE:=G P G�B��2:"J\H�@ED� n � XZY ! �ab n ����b �lk����IX >AG?l ��( �H/ ���( ! / �0Y

J\H�@ RCH�DF: ! k����iX-iO"�G?lh:=:gl+S � XZY ! � n ��vNw � �|P B�� M n���( ! /�iO�2H�@(:g>�M7� X �n X , S#lh:=G2HABE:}�W�XP BVR"P DFDF:glhPQ>]BE:F>AG?MO:gRXBEH�@giY�2s2@CB��2:=@EDFH�@E:�S?J\H�@�>AG�W�X lh:=G2HABE:/}�W � _8a!vv B��2:FRC:OB"HAJZ>A[ [

D(>F5hP D(>A[ [ W«@E:=DFHABE:~RCs?M=MO:gRERCH�@VR#HAJ$X-S`P�i :�i?B��2:~RC:OB;HAJ�>A[ [ ! k���� X RCs?M7��B��?>]B;J\H�@IG2H � k���� X-S��( �H/ ��( ! /�iA��P G?>A[ [ W�S?J\H�@^>AG�W�<?>AP @�XZY ! �|P B�� ! k���� X >AG?l ! �] � _8a!vv S+lh:=G2HABE:!}�W ! � >AG�WRCs?M=MO:gRERCH�@ZHAJtX�B��?>]B|PQR#DFH�@E:^@E:=DFHABE:;J\@EH�D B��2:"@EH�HABZB��?>AG ! >AG?l«DFP G2P D(>A[4>ADFH�G��/>A[ [kB��2:gRC:�SP�i :�i

! � ]�>A@���DFP G1� ��( �H/�b��lk�����X >AG?l ��( �H/ ���( ! / �0|� � � � ��� ��� � ��3 m b�t���� . �J����3 &()*,�8�35+2�,�\;+-3:� m ( &!/�n�� 7��,�"J% ��3 j�b�t���� . 1(��3:���)*,�+���)�� &()*,�8�35+2�,D\;+-3:� j � n � ��)�8(��3:���327/&���=�%-% h 7 m (Ph_/�n # Zs ��4{����� j" ? ,�# � )#�$�������'3:���3� U � +�� &���!����!�=���/4% ��.<��,���35+28635���(���!�#"$��% ?P �����,�7�&���D�%-% X �nCX , �,�"]�%-% ! �] � _8a!vv\;+-3:� ! k�����X 7

j�� vNw $�� n � # (KX Y ! /�! # (KXZY ! /�� ! � # (KX Y !� /�! # (KXZY ! � /��y| (�a!i t!/

� )*��3:�������!�����7�&��� �,�4 ! �]�� _8a!vv� 7

j�� v�!w $�� n # (KX , Y ! � /�! # (KX , Y ! /!Y�,�"B&��� �,�4 X �n-X , �,�"6�,�4 ! 1E]�� _8a!vv 7

j�� vNw $�� n # ( ! 1 Y*X /�! # ( ! 1 Y*X�/!Y�,�"B&��� �,�4 ! 1E]�� _8a!vv� 7

j�� v�!w $�� n m (��dX , �F/! # (KX , Y ! 1 /!|/ : �]���N�V�/�V��¬_� ���w�V��¢!�����q� �_�_����� ��� �]�����_�#� �_�_����� ��� �/� �q�C�V� � �X�~���_� � ++*��'.�� .-) /�� +3/�� ( .� ( *�, /����'/C�����X�#¥-�

² ®�¯�¯�®O³w±

tLE

Page 31: 35+2 ,]+-, 0 +2 , 8( #?micro.econ.kit.edu/downloads/Puppe_journal_18_Modelling... · 2009-12-09 · , " 0 %)*+-,/.1 +2 #" +-0 ( +-35461( ("! , 0 %)*35+2 , 4 +-,#& ! 35+2 , 798( %-%

3 � �� �� � � � � �!� ���J= :|<2@EH]U�:2(�a!i t!/ W�B��2:|HAB��2:=@LB��2@E:=:ZJ\H�@ED~s2[Q>�R�J\H�[ [ HF� >A[ H�G��^B��2:IRE>ADF:[ P G2:gR=i_����s?R=S�BV>L��:�>AG�W�X �n-X , >AG?l >AG�W«RCs?M=MO:gRERCH�@ ! �] � _8a!vv W2H�G2:2�?>�R

# (KXZY ! � /�! # (KXZY ! /2n o������� v j�� ��w $�� | (�a!i y8/

j�P DFP [Q>A@E[ W�S# (KX Y !

� /�! # (KX Y ! /�n o������� v j�� ��w $�� | (�a!i uH/

j�s2}?RXBE@V>�M�BEP G��I(�a!i uH/NJ\@EH�D (�a!i y8/ZH�G2:�H�}hBV>AP G?RZJ\H�@ED~s2[Q>4(�a!i t!/�i3 � ��A�� ��� � �.� � � *I:gMO:gRERCP BXW�HAJ^}`H�s2G?lh:glhG2:gRER=SNDFH�G2HABEH�G2PQMOP BXW�SZRCs2}2DFHhlhs2[Q>A@EP BXW�>AG?lMOH�G?lhP BEP H�GM(�e2i fB/NJ\H�@#B��2:":�5hPQRXBE:=G?MO:�HAJL>AG�:�5�BE:=G?RCP H�G�PQR|:g>�RCP [ W U�:=@EP T?:gl+i���2:�RCs"! MOP :=G?MOW«<?>A@CBPQRqU�:=@EP T?:glF>�RLJ\H�[ [ HF�IR=iLaIG�W.��P U�:=G m ,;>AG?l # RE>]BEPQRXJ\W�P G���(�e2i fB/LM=>AG(}`:Is2G2P :�s2:=[ W~:�5�BE:=G?lh:gl/BEH!>RC:OB�J\s2G?M�BEP H�G m b�t � � . �|P B�� � U � +��;U�PQ>"B��2:I@E:gMOs2@VRCP H�G/J\H�@ED~s2[Q>G(�dhi t!/�i�Q;}?RC:=@EU�:ZB��?>]B mPQR1�Z:=[ [ v�lh:�T?G2:gl�}�WM(�e2i fB/#RCP G?MO:"B��?>]B^MOH�G?lhP BEP H�G :=G?RCs2@E:gR#B��?>]B # (KX � Y �X � / n # (KX � Y � �X � /ZJ\H�@;>AG�W�X � Y � �X � RE>]BEPQRXJ\W�P G�� (�dhi fB/�iIrZW��4:=DFD(> a!i f�S`RCs2}2DFHhlhs2[Q>A@EP BXW�HAJ # ��s?>A@V>AG�BE:=:gR#G2H�GhvwG2:,��>]BEP U�P BXWHAJ j >]B�>A[ [�P G�BE:=@EP H�@^>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR=i!j�P DFP [Q>A@E[ W�S`}�W B��2:~HAB��2:=@;B��2@E:=:~J\H�@ED~s2[Q>�RX��P U�:=G P G �4:=DFD(>a!i f�S-DFH�G2HABEH�G2PQMOP BXW >AG?l }`H�s2G?lh:glhG2:gRER2��s?>A@V>AG�BE:=:/G2H�GhvwG2:,��>]BEP U�P BXW >]B~>A[ [qHAB��2:=@!>]BCBE@EP }2shBE:gR=i?I:=G?MO:�S m PQR|>FlhP U�:=@VRCP BXW(J\s2G?M�BEP H�G4i3 � �� �� ��� � �.� � � ���2:«@E:gRCs2[ B/PQR/> RCP DF<2[ :�MOH�@EH�[ [Q>A@EW HAJA���2:=H�@E:=D y2i6"�G?lh:=:gl+SqP B/PQR:g>�RCP [ W U�:=@EP T?:gl�B��?>]B�P G B��2:/BE@V>AG?RC[Q>]BEP H�G P G�U]>A@EPQ>AG�B"M=>�RC:�S4RCs2}2DFHhlhs2[Q>A@EP BXW HAJ # PQR^:;:�s2P U]>A[ :=G�BBEH�MOH�G?M=>_U�P BXW�HAJ [�i"j�P DFP [Q>A@E[ W�S # PQR^DFH�G2HABEH�G2:!P JN>AG?l�H�G2[ W P J([ PQR;P G?MO@E:g>�RCP G��?S`>AG?l�P G U�P :,�HAJ�B��2:�G2H�@ED(>A[ P Cg>]BEP H�G m (��dX��F/�ncf�Sh}`H�s2G?lh:glhG2:gRER#HAJ # MOH�@E@E:gRC<`H�G?l2R�BEH [�( � / �%f�S�J\H�@I>A[ [ � i3 � ��'�� � ���� � ��� YNH�G?RCPQlh:=@�>AG�P G�BE:=@EP H�@«>]BCBE@EP }2shBE: � XZY ! �2�|P B�� �'(KXZY ! / n � i0"wJ # PQRBE@V>AG?RC[Q>]BEP H�GFP G�U]>A@EPQ>AG�BNH�G2:X�?>�R�}�W�(�a!i t!/�S6j�� vNw $�� n � [�( � � fB/"!�[�( � /�� ! � [�( � � t!/"!�[�( � � fB/��wS�2:=G?MO:�j�� vNw $�� H�G2[ W«lh:=<`:=G?l2R|H�G � i

tAb

Page 32: 35+2 ,]+-, 0 +2 , 8( #?micro.econ.kit.edu/downloads/Puppe_journal_18_Modelling... · 2009-12-09 · , " 0 %)*+-,/.1 +2 #" +-0 ( +-35461( ("! , 0 %)*35+2 , 4 +-,#& ! 35+2 , 798( %-%

� �I�N�X�$�A���8�I#� f ���/6�������������� m )-n;n��� ���o��-'�)�,���� >AG?l���� ��-'���� (Xfgb�b!E8/�S?j�<`:gMOP :gR;9;PQRXBE@EP }2shBEP H�G4S

�->AG?lV<�>A[ s2:gR=S2>AG?l K ! MOP :=G�B^YNH�G?RC:=@EU]>]BEP H�G4S �H8�+2��,�8(� � ��� S?thf_tAe]vXthf_tLE2i

� t����/3+n^,����-3��+1��|o�� !��#"$� %��Z&(026��k)-'�'�>AG?l'&�� ()�+*!)�,�5\,�(�tA����t!/�S-aIG)"�G�BE@EHhlhs?M�BEP H�GBEH(rZP HhlhP U�:=@VRCP BXW�YNH�G?MO:=<hBVRZJ\H�@;K�G�U�P @EH�G2DF:=G�BV>A[kKNMOH�G2H�DFPQRXBVR=S � +-�!�(� i

� y���&`)-5-�+1���*.� o���(Xfgb�b�t!/�ShYNH�G?RC:=@EU]>]BEP H�G(K�U]>A[ s?>]BEP H�G(>AG?l�-_��W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQM|9;P U�:=@VRCP BXW�S0/ +2�% ��.�U+28(�% ���,�������0�35+2�, � �`S+fOvVfg�2i� u!��&`)-5-�+1���*.� o���(Xfgb�bAuH/�S^-_��W�[ H!��:=G2:OBEPQMY-q>]BCBE:=@EG >AG?l�B��2:�1;s?>AG�BEP T`M=>]BEP H�G�HAJ�Q;@���>AG2PQRCD(>A[rZP HhlhP U�:=@VRCP BXW�S ��/+-% ?> *���,���? �>�4$? �H�#8#? � �,�"$? /�� ��� Shu�d_vXdLE2i� d���&`)-5-�+1���*.� o��+>AG?l o�� ���(�)-'���023 (Xfgb�bAuH/�Sk9;P U�:=@VRCP BXW�bI{|:OJ\:=@E:=G?MO:/>AG?l T;RC:=@;� R"z^s2PQlh:�SYZ>AG�}`:=@E@V>�b�Y#jH"X{XQc9;P U�PQRCP H�G�HAJ�= P [Qlh[ P J\:~>AG?l�KNMOH�[ H!��W�i

� e��$2/)�,3���-6��N&�� ����(\:gl+i /�(Xfgb�b�e8/�S�/ +2�#"+-0���(��+-354$?9d / +2�% ��.�4Y�C& �A)*�!1(���(�!�,�"���+ 4>������,�8(� SrZ[Q>�M7�H�Z:=[ [�S^QX5�J\H�@Vl+i

� K"�~./02143+576-8��^&���>AG?l m �Io^*4p2p20U(�tA����t!/�Sqa ���2:=H�@EW HAJ;9;P U�:=@VRCP BXW�S+5 8(�,���!��35��+28(� ��6 Sf�f_d�d_vVf�fgb!E2i

� E��!o��-'�)�,����+�� ��a(\:gl+i /2(�tA���2fB/�S ���� 5 8(�,��� +28��T�C& / +2�#"+-0���(��+-354 ���,�������0�35+2�, S`a;R�����>]BE:-�s2}2[ PQR��2:=@VR=i

� b��!o��-'�)�,����+�� ������� ��-'���� >AG?l�����""37�k)��-*-,�(Xfgb�b�y8/�S2j�:g>A@VM7�2P G��~J\H�@ITIG?MO:=@CBV>AP G rZ:=Ghv:�T2BVRF>AG?l�B��2: YNH�G?RC:=@EU]>]BEP H�G�HAJ^rZP H�[ H!��PQM=>A[#9;P U�:=@VRCP BXW�S#5 ,�0#+-���,��!��,�3Q�%B�,�" �>�����)*��8(�5 8(�,��� +28�� �4S+fFK�fOvVf;E2f�i

� fg���$ ��-'����8�9���� ���o��-'�)�,����(>AG?l����0""37�k)��-*-,X(Xfgb�b�y8/�SLQ;G�B��2:�3�:g>�RCs2@E:=DF:=G�B-HAJ?rZP H�[ H!�AvPQM=>A[49;P U�:=@VRCP BXW�S�: �)*��,��%V�C& 5 ,�0#+-���,��!��,�3Q�% 5 8(�,��� +28�� �,�" �]�,���.<���!��,�3 � � S2e��]v�e!E2i

� f�f ��;�57'�nI)-6���*.�J(Xfgb�bHKL/�S|rZP HhlhP U�:=@VRCP BXW�>AG?l KNMOH�RCWhRXBE:=D �2s2G?M�BEP H�G2P G��?SIP G�b�9^>AP [ W�S^z/i Y;i(\:gl+i /�S �T�35)*����G �!�H����0#+28(����? �H�#8�+2��3Q�% � � ����,�"$��,�8(�>�, �T�35)*���% 5 8(����4���3Q���T� SL"XRC[Q>AG?l.-�@E:gRER=S= >�R��2P G��ABEH�G4S29~i Y;i

� f_t���;�*���8-0�� m ��(�tA�����8/�S ����=< ���+2��3546�C& � + &�� S QX5�J\H�@Vl�TIG2P U�:=@VRCP BXW�-�@E:gRER=S[QX5�J\H�@Vl+i� fgy��?>Z)-640�@A( 3+5\8-1��B�C !� DE�� m � ���GF/*4n;p2143+570?,�>AG?l o�� F�H( 57'�'�5Q)-n^,6(Xfgb�b2fB/�S_=O�?>]BFBEH

-�@EHABE:gM�B+� x�j�WhRXBE:=D(>]BEPQM=R(>AG?l�B��2: aX��H�G�W HAJ~Y��2H�PQMO:�SI/ +2�% ��.�+28(�% ���,�������0�35+2�, � � StAy�d_vXt�d]u?i

� f=u!�?( 025J�-)-3�����F� @Co�� (�tA����t!/�S�9;P U�:=@VRCP BXW@�2s2G?M�BEP H�G?RZ>AG?lFB��2:c<�>A[ s2:;HAJ-rZP HhlhP U�:=@VRCP BXW�S � �,�"5 8(�,��� +28�� ��K S?tA�]vXt8K�i

� f_d��?( 025-��LAnI)-6���MN��(Xfgb�b�t!/�S[Q;G 9;P U�:=@VRCP BXW�S�O )����3Q����% 4 : �)*��,��% �C& 5 8(�,��� +28�� � 6�� S?y�e�y]vu���dhi

� fge��?( 025-��LAnI)-6���MN��(Xfgb�b!E8/�S'���2:J*IH�>L��� R|aI@��V-�@EH�}2[ :=D S�5 8(�,���!��35��+28(� ���4S4f_t8K]b]vVf_tAb!E2i

� fFK"�!o�� F�H( 57'�'�5Q)-n^,�>AG?l m � ���GF/*4n;p2143+570?,M(Xfgb�b�e8/�S#YNH�DF<?>A@EP G���Y��?>A@V>�M�BE:=@(9;P U�:=@VRCP BXW>ADFH�G�� rZP HABV>�R=S�P G�b z">�RXBEH�G4S�]Fi P?i1(\:gl+i /�SI/ +2�#"+-0���(��+-354$?'d / +2�% ��.�4b�C&�A)*�!1(���(�W�,�"��+ 4>������,�8(� S2rZ[Q>�M7�H�Z:=[ [�S[QX5�J\H�@Vl+i

y��