28= - amazon web servicesframeweld-workshop.s3.amazonaws.com/files/4f5e004c... · 3huvxdvlyh ydolg...

Grant Wiggins - on Feedback

$amp(

$amp()+( -+01231

4+5(678998( grantauthenticeducationorg

1

)(+-0(

bull $(56+lt=gt+gt866lt6))AB5C5(A5AD8E bull 76(A66565(A6+D8A6lt8Flt)AB5 bull GAB58)lt8()+5H(5B6gt560A8AI98D(58J95ltKCGAB58(65AD8++58L Blt5E

2

1$amp((-0(20(-0(((34( 3-0(

bull Mlt5N78lt8565O5(5lt08P bull $amp()+-$0amp+123(3

-$(40(13amp14(56667 819-13$9(-$(ampamp13(1+($+ -$9amp22(3$1+85)582(2(1 )(+6 Black and Wiliam (1998) Inside the Black Box

Raising Standards through Classroom Assessment Phi Delta Kappan volume 80 2 (October)

3

copy Grant Wiggins 2011 1


567789(82amp0(( 6amplt-=gt(

4030 15

0

50 60

70

80

90

10REVERSE

Developmental

Effects

Typical

Teacher

Effects

ZONE OF DESIRED EFFECTS

50(ABC0-0( Rank Influence ES

1 Self-report self-assess 144

5 Reciprocal teaching 74

8 Feedback 72

9 Formative evaluation to teachers 70

11 Meta-cognition strategies 67

5

54=40(gt0(DampE=(amp2400(

bull QB898(6R86D+5(A D+5958(5+85ltR86 8+65()S85(AA658ltA )AB5KT6A(6D+gtlt8(9lt0 ++665668(9lt68+65(6 8(9+A8(6)+58(95+ UHD89V(9+58A+(( 589((65(AS8WWK

OX85+AY896 6


<8(9<0>mailtoAB5KT6A(6D+gtlt8(9lt0



bull QT6A(65065686ltAB 8Blt8(+658(+696 8A856)AB5K0 9966566+)+ltA 5(A65(=5lt)5( =ltlt(65(gt+KZ

7

$amp(0((FampGH(

bull QT(Alt0KKK5(D+gtlt8(9 5[+8605+(D8(A65668+ B6lt5+(8(965lt5gt(60 5D55(6B865(5+lt0 D+8()68+gt+I96A658ltA )AB55(A+8H8I5(A6( 5(A8(5J(5lt+D8AD+8(Z

8

$amp(0((FampGH(

bull Q]5(06A(6B+D656 68+6+5Bltlt5+(8(9 =+8(5D)+ +gt+ +6(8H5++H(lt80KZ

9



I14gtE=(0000gtJ(

bull ]5(0O5ltltA)+5HD 5(65+$^6+lt0 )+5HDP (O6S8WW_6SH(A(`6 ++ $6(98(95(6)05+O(A 95lt

10

K(amplt-=gt(3-0(L(M( 1$amp(00gtNN(

bull Glt56++9+5AD+Ha ]50B6+Blt8(66 Q658(9Z+6Q6A(6ZB6 6-+)(283K

11

Olt(($ampN(

12



P((gt(0(M4GGG(

13

N

H

IOlt0(lt-0NJ(

IOlt0($NJ(

14

IOlt0($NJ(

15


16


IK(Mlt(8(MQJ(

I5(lt240 )AB506

RS($0((lt(04T(

7(3amp -+)(28=

17

UampV(6W-gt(( $amp(

3Kamp5+=5ltCbcTEgt86((O =5ltC$Ê)5(6K

1KdA(H)06A8H(988(9 5+56+8H)5K

eK60+6+05958(6(gt 5K

fKXJ(0+(6I5(AAK 18


b5+gt568(9686+ )5I(66


X9R(9YgtVC0(1(F4CH(1$amp(

bull B5ltltO656gt005+gt8(98(95(A 88(9K bull 66(A)685+59+58(66+00 gt+6Idgt5WWltAD+65+56+` HDg8)656gt50+8(6(6I86gt+AKZ bull d(6h+Blt096+896I0 +(6A5lt985lt+)g8(6e(0 96gt+(90A8A(`6gt0++5(8(9K

19

X9R(9YgtVC0(1(B=4$C( 1$amp(

bull $(lt59A560+[5B668(ltg60 lt59A5+Hlt0560+gt+[ bull e)0+A8((+96)+gt(Agt(605gt6 5ltI5(A18A5668+lt56)+6)65ltK bull 7(58(965A8(gt59V(9+5(A +(6A9)68+58+506ltA66+5Dlt 6+0IB6gt(0=lt58(A6B58)56)6 (6+0I5(0ltB5JA960K bull 06A8AAlt(86I0+5lt8W6560+ gt5lt665eC6+ifE

20

KP((1$amp(

bull 4A[Bj bull 70A8A0A656a bull +05+A+j bull $=6HI55(6lt8( J+6K bull Qb+6+05B65(6adltD 5(6jZ 21


(0=<58(A6B58)56>mailto6+0IB6gt(0=lt58(A6B58)56


Z[(24(0M4(Mlt(-0(1$ampS( ltN(

bull 756A8H(986 =5lt)+6 ((O=5lta

22

YES NO

d5(`65+0j

4Aj

T5k+j 23

Feedback YES NO Q5+5A+Idgt5(959A(Hlt6

lt5659g6+Idlt68(6+6B5dltA(`6)ltltgt0+

lt98Z

l55+Id656lt5+65+H(96JA965(A6=6

(68+(m

Q756gt50+68(8(9(59faZ 24



63-S(Mlt(-0(1$ampN(

bull 756A8H(986 0)+6(a 756amp)AB5a

25

Olt(-0(1$ampN(AC0T(

bull756gt56B6)AB5 060gt+D+8(a bullk+5+8(9Pgt568( 65ltlt66+8_gt5686+ )6B6)AB5I8( 9(+5lta

26

78+(gt(lt(-gtVC-amp-(YVC-amp-(

bull 8J+)+5(95lt5(A +lt56A+86+855+k(68lt886+ D((lt5+g56=lt8865(A lt5+ GAB58B6)+5A8(6+)6 lt98)95ltL+lt6I8(6(6LU6

7(05+(+)695ltI6566 )AB58(dGL-c$6+

27



K(lt(gt2amplt(-0(-gtVC-amp-(

bull nH(gt56+08(96gt+868(5gt86 5+505(A+88( bull gt+86+86+08(9658D5+658( U6(6+5A+ bull 5+86+08(96(9596 5A8(5(A58D5+lt6+lt56A6 +N865H(

28


bull c=5ltP QX5ltlt65668(6gt56(959 65A8(KM6gt(0+5A)+ 0+(65+A5(A58Ao`5(Ao+` 065+6A6lt6I5996A B068+05(ABA0lt5(959Z

29


bull 56`+5ltlt068(6)+B+8 gt86+8A+86+5(A 8(A856+P65D56+5lt8(A (86(6068(gt8 )AB5898D(S8lt05(A D5lt8Alt0K

30



EV(P6]^Z9R_]7R( bull TI6)AB58(6+)6 95lt5(A+lt6P QA8(N+5+05gt(gtK 78ltd5lt5+(65A8(d5 (lt5+(6+5(A+`gt0PZ

QdG0+58gt565)+896(AI -c$86gt+A8(6J+6(8(6 5(6AB6(66(AKZ

31

X2(gt-3lt($(lt--3T(

bull d5$^508(9PA(`65 SH(IA(`6+58IA(`6 ltAIA(`698D5AD8IA(`6 D5lt56K bull d5+lt0508(9656)AB5 8A8U+(6)+5ltlt)65BDK

32

àmp((a20E(YgtVC(-(1amp(b(

bulldA8A5SH(IdA8A +58I5(Ad5lt8(+A656 +8DA)AB5K bullY56+Id95D85AD8K

33



A(=-amp((a20E(

bull dA+gt$5(A- bull dA+gt665+6)5($5(AA+gt A6(6ltk65(A+896BF 5(A6ltA86+5H6$I6( -I6(58(6+(I658(9(6) 665+H(98(6

34

80(P)((V4-0QQ(

bullMpO+58 A(`6960 BF+

35

80(P)((3-=(=-ampQQ( bullMp65AD8I6 S8lt0IA(`6lt5+8)06 +lt6IB8ltA56(0I+ 8+Dlt)O5(6_ 5ltlt)gt8ltABlt(9O 6+58

36


<<)>8mailto5ltlt)gt8ltABlt(9O


80(P)((0( c20E0QQ(

bull Mp65(0SH(AA9 68)lt8(9lt5+(+ (A+65(Agt5660A8A5(A A8A(`6AK(D8I8(5+Hlt5+I gt8ltltB(lt8lt065(gt+6 SH(+9668+8(6K bull C705+0865(6698D A8+6)AB5a$58E

37

$ampS([(

bullp)lt8()+5H(( (Ù6++lt6I 98D(58J95lt GAB580amp4-VE=I(6D5lt5HD GAB58+58+Blt5

38

6=-ampS([(

bullp)lt8()+5H(( gt566A68+D +)+5(IB5A( 6)AB55(A6 95ltCE

39


42

68++5Ha


(_012C(EV( bull 7(05+0+lt)50Q4A [BZ+Q$I(6+896Z8A856lt0 507-b8(6+)95ltL+lt6_ gt+)05A(959A+896 )+665+65(A656`gt56UHD gt+8H(9AK A13$amp30A8A(`698D568I 095D5lt58gt866+(9Blt8)K

40

(_012C(EV( bull d6ltA(D+66 6A(66566[B86lt5 0g86ltA+5F+) )56O65660A8A+A8A(6A gt56gt5(5+0)+58D8(9 6lt5+A8+A+lt6K

41


(A+PgtgtltA0+ 6+565A8)gt(lt06 6lt5)J(8B6A8A13


<58>866+(9B<8)K>mailto095D5lt58gt866+(9Blt8)K


9Y4amp-0(

bull+098D8(9^$Yb)AB565 65+gt8(658(9 68+lt(lt5+I(9598(9 6lt5I+(6A5lt8(9gt86 B5D8+

43

YES NO $=6HI6+06D85lt8Wgt0+

5A8(850gt+86Kd6gt8ltlt lt058D0++K

780+5A8()+68

5+a

k+6J+65+59+5I86gt5D+0 lt5+6gt0gt+gt+8H(9 )+P0++Kdgt5(`6+5ltlt0+ gt560++gt5I69K 44

8(M(Mlt(0gt(1(2(4( lt--3T(

45


5(`6+5<<0>mailtoP0++Kdgt5(`6+5ltlt0


94-amp(Ad240(Z04amplt(-( +lt0-amp0((54=4(

bull k+328(6I]5W+5SH( 656+S8+(65lt(A+65(A8(9 C5H5H(96A8lt5(6)5 60B568(5B566BEK T6A(6gt+8668+5(gt+(565(A8A(H)068+ ltDlt)(JA(8(65(gt+K

d(58+I5F66(D8(6+)68+5(gt+K T6A(66(5(gt+6SH(5(AH5(A++6 68+(JA(ltDlt5958(K

gtltlt58ltltA5958(5B668+5(gt+K

46

I4amp(UampV(8=4J(

bull$amp($)+amp-+-- amp(+amp01222 bull 3(+(45+567amp8($9+( (amp+57amp8$(7lt+7amp5$5amp +--+8amp(amp-+=amp+54+5405amp- amp(amp0(5amp$amp($054+(ltgt

lt(14ampF0H(ampE3((lt($CC(-0(F4H(

+lt amp)amp=(amp7+--4$)5)+(4+-$5)amp+amp+4- 47(+501)+(48$(72

lt +amp+4-47(+501)+(48$(78($9amp9$95ampamp -+=amp+5405amp-amp(+7ampamp1$5amp$54 )7amp(+amp+4-57(+58$(7$8(+=amp+ amp+--amp7-$(amp$+(amp2

7lt +7$5amp+5amp4$)5)+(48$(7$8(+=amp+-$5)amp+5 01)+(48$(7amp+ampamp+4-47(+05amp-amp+-- (+7ampamp1$5amp+8amp()7amp($5-amp 7$5amp+5amp4$)5)+(48$(7$8(+=amp2

4lt +7$5amp+5amp4$)5)+(48$(7$8(+=amp$5-2



Ad240((

bull 6A(6+)+A(8A+5Blt0 BF+(65(A5+A08+ =5 bull 6A(6+A89+(5+ )6+5A8H(5lt+BltltD8(9 bull 6A(6+A89+8( (65lt(A+65(A8(9

49

Ad24((

bullQ$lt6++IgtD+ (9598(95(Alt8AI5( 58D68ltDlt) 8+D(65(A 5+H85H(8lt0B0 58(9KZ

50

]0($(ampC4($2(lt($-3(-( lt4(

bullYQ658(9Z5(A +Q)AB5Zi MccX+lt6ID( (6085lt66j

51



K((024V4-0S(4CC(lt-(1GGG(

bullB(55-C3DE1$Famp$+ bull7^Xqltlt5(A 9+55+ bullY5+(8(9c(9lt855e05+ltA bullY5+(8(96gt5lt $A8+6658(9glt6)lt5+(8(9

52

7lt20S(gt-0ampampVE((0(

bull Qd5D65(06A(65(A6 6oD+`Z oampD+59`88(6ltgt866 (65(68(9)+(A+65(A8(9 b(A(6B6(lt0)AB5 98D+ B6)AB5068(88W 6)5(O+D8AA)AB5

53

4gt(amp()amp)+(+-(

bull QT6A8)5A5HD=+HIlt5+(8(9I 6+5()+I5(A5+lt0ADlt(6gt656 )AB58=6+lt08+65(6KT6A(6r 68(8(96B5AD88BltC6+9 A88(I5+I+66EI5(A)AB5 6B+D8AAKKKK5AA8H() +6(8H)+)+5HD5(6 8(+56A(6rlt5+(8(95(A6+5()+I5(A 60lt5+(6D5lt+6(8H6+D8Z

54


)+


55

5XEULFIRU6HOI$VVHVVPHQW 7HDFKHU$VVHVVPHQW(VVD

3HUVXDVLYH ampOHDU 7KRURXJK 3ROLVKHG

9HUSHUVXDVLYH FRPSHOOLQJHYLGHQFHVRXQGUHDVRQLQJHIIHFWLYHLQFRXQWHULQJRWKHUDUJXPHQWV

6RPHZKDWSHUVXDVLYH WKHUHDUHVRPHJDSV LQWKHORJLFVRPHHYLGHQFHLVPLVVLQJDQGRULQDSSURSULDWHGRHVQRWDGGUHVVFRXQWHUDUJXPHQWVRUGRHVVRLQHIIHFWLYHO

ZHLJKWsup2

3HUVXDVLYHYDOLG HYLGHQFHORJLFDOUHDVRQLQJDGGUHVVHVRWKHUDUJXPHQWV

8QSHUVXDVLYHQRWORJLFDO$125 PLVVLQJRULQDSSRUSULDWHHYLGHQFHGRHVQRWFRQVLGHURWKHUDUJXPHQWV

9HUFOHDUKHOSIXODQGSUHFLVHXVHRIODQJXDJHWKHLGHDVDUHH[SOLFLWDQGWKHDUJXPHQWLVHDVWRIROORZ

ampOHDUDFFXUDWHXVHRI ODQJXDJHPRVWLGHDVDUHH[SOLFLWDQGWKHUHDGHUFDQIROORZWKHDUJXPHQW

6RPHZKDWFOHDUVRPH YDJXHDPELJXRXVRU LQDFFXUDWHODQJXDJHVRPHLGHDVDUHLPSOLHGDQGDELWKDUGWRIROORZ

8QFOHDUWRRPXFKYDJXHDPELJXRXVDQGRULQDFFXUDWHODQJXDJHVRPHLGHDVDUHLPSOLHGDQGKDUGWRIROORZ

1RWWKRURXJKWKHUHLVLQVXIAgraveFLHQWGHWDLODQGWRROLWWOHGLVFXVVLRQRIDOOWKHLVVXHVWRDVVHVVWKHTXDOLW RIWKHDUJXPHQW

6RPHZKDWWKRURXJKWKHUH LVDQHHGIRUPRUHGHWDLODQGGLVFXVVLRQRIDOOWKHUHODWHGLVVXHVLQRUGHUWRDVVHVVWKHTXDOLWRIWKH DUJXPHQW

7KRURXJKWKHUHLVVXIAgraveFLHQWGHWDLODQGGLVFXVVLRQRIDOOWKHUHODWHGLVVXHVWR DVVHVVWKHTXDOLWRIWKH DUJXPHQW

9HUWKRURXJKWKHUHLVULFK GHWDLODQGFRPSUHKHQVLYHGLVFXVVLRQRIDOOWKHUHODWHGLVVXHVWRDVVHVVWKHTXDOLW RIWKHDUJXPHQW

9HUSROLVKHGWKHUH DUHQRHUURUVRIVQWD[PHFKDQLFVRUXVDJH7KLVLVSXEOLVKDEOH TXDOLW

3ROLVKHGWKHUHDUHQRGLVWUDFWLQJHUURUVRIVQWD[PHFKDQLFVRUXVDJH

6RPHZKDWSROLVKHG WKHUHDUHDIHZGLV WUDFWLQJHUURUVRIVQWD[PHFKDQLFVDQGRUXVDJHVRPHHGLWLQJDQGUHFRSLQJZDVQHHGHG

8QSROLVKHGWKHUHDUHDQXPEHURIGLVWUDFWLQJHUURUVRIVQWD[PHFKDQLFVDQGRUXVDJHRRNVOLNHDURXJKGUDIWQHHGLQJHGLWLQJDQGUHFRSLQJ

1H[WWLPHPDNHDQDUJXPHQWOOGRDOLWWOHPRUHUHVHDUFKRQWKHWRSLFDQGWKLQNDERXWZKDWRWKHUSHRSOHDUHJRLQJWRDUJXHHVSHFLDOOWKRVHZKRGLVDJUHHZLWKPH0ZULWLQJLVSUHWWJRRGEXWLWVKDUGIRUPHWRPDNHDORJLFDODUJXPHQWEHFDXVHWRPHPYLHZVDUHMXVWULJKW

RDOV$FWLRQV

alt(O($04=(14((12CC( 4($(404amplt40(

bull Qstu)D+068(9058Agt5 8()+5H(KKK7A8A(`6B+D0 +588(9+ltA8(9lt50+KKKZ bull Qlt50+lt5+(A6=6+5H5lt ++H(5k+D+0+++I8A856lt0 5k+86gt55AKZ

bull GH(01I3(3J145H(0K($1+

56

6C=4(UCC3(

bull 3tu)D+09+5A86 5+50)66A(6`lt)O 5(6I5F5A6gt+ 605(A8( cK9K68+366555)+5(P 5Blt8lt0IB66369+5A8 68+lt)O5(6)68+65lt

57



58

9YampCC(1$amp(amp4-4-(

bull T)66(lt0O(H(A +86+85P 8lt0 +O)+8(Alt0O8(5+55(A5(6 q+8HDN8J+P+)+5( amp(86(65+H5(Alt c=+6 +56 -(6I06(6+HD q+8DA)+(+665(A5+A (O98(9 59

`-0(02(1(lt($0(ampCC3( amplt40(

bull Q76A8A+65(h2+)+)+ D5+8A88lt8(66+06A6+8(gt56 665(A8(965+A8(8A5(A68A 68+lt5+656896=lt58(68+ 5lt8(6K bull (Agt(gt=58(A8(5+Hlt5+gt 9A65+(A6lt5Igt)(A656 60)ltltgtD+5lt(+8(8ltKKKKZ


60

61

62


`-0(404amplt(

bull QG8+6I60+565(56+5lt+8H5lt lt5+(8(9(D8+((6K bull (A8+65(6lt(68 98A5(8(lt8(96A(6 (A+65(A689(8J5()6 SH(K bull (A68+Alt0Z

`-0(404amplt( bullQd(5ltlt6=5ltI6A(6 ((6+5)06 5ltlt(98(9(A8H(8( gt8605(6+0I)58ltI +8D)AB5I5(A6+0 5958(B)+)58(95 5+0D5lt5H(KZ

8=E=(o(+4ampEampC(+4$Cgt(RC=4(F6=3G(jGhjH( ipg(A(4(9Yamp(qlt(4(9YVampE0(

FeH( 8KR_8U89K7(

fg( FeGhH( ig(

FjH(6++ZP6U59R( ikg(

FjGhH( jlg(

FiH(A997R( jig(

FiGhH( ekg(

FlH(9mU99nR( lg(

C3Ed$TpGGdampdc$ 3Kt C1EXâmp-cT 1Kt CeE]ccT eKt CfEcvampccqT



7-V0(14(-gtV4=-3(1$amp(

bull qO+(5lt8W6o06`8(66)56) 6(55(A6$53 bull +D8AltHltAlt6+695lt5(A +B+8 bull 6A(66lt)O55958(6695lt B)+6+(8(9gt+8( bull p(lt0A+8HDlt5(9598(+B+85(A +)+6656lt5(959gt(98D8(9+5lt )AB5

64

7-V0(14(-gtV4=-3(ramp-amp(

bull -89lt896)AB5669+(6 8+65(68(6 bull qDlt8ltlt8(++D8gt bull p68A)AB598D+ bull p((O5()AB5AD85(A 5+5

65

1$amp(

bull7ltltI8))AB5 ltD+0( 8+D

66



$amp(14(CC(

bull(gt565B6 65+a+8(85lta A8(86+56+a bulleh2A9+)AB5

67

R2(1$amp(

bull7+665(=860j se225(gt+lt5605+ (+]T5(A-T +D0

68

]MBamplt(8Y(U4(=4(4-(

bull756gt+A)+068 gta70a

bull756A8A(`6gt+)+0 68gta70a

69



70

71

IA0(840E3(O4J( bull X5+8(95+(gt5A5A+9+5ltlt8 +Blt8(5lt65(Agt5[68(6+H(9lt5+(8(95ltlt 5B665AA8H(5(Agt8665D+6+(K

bull (505B6-G8((B8(95+586(DltKd6gt5 8(6+H(9B5d5A65+958(6dA8A(`6 Blt8D8(K

bull ]58(958A`B8(5lt6K8gt56 8(6+H(9B5dgt55Blt6(A+65(Agt lt+lt5660(9+8ltA+(696559 5+K

7 2


5A5A+9+5<<8>mailtoX5+8(95+(gt5A5A+9+5ltlt8


IA0(840E3(O4J( bull 78lt+5A8(9Lamp55(M28amp1)amp$+I0c(9lt8 65+5A0lt5655+D05B6)+ 6+586C0lt+I58+lt+I8(lt+I896Iw) 8A856)58lt0B+I5(A5(06+EK (=6A50I5A6A(6B5+56A8(66 x(+5ltltx5(A6xlt5DxK+966 lt5I6lt5D5A6A$b-d$4665+ 5A6A)+66+(+5lt6A(6I5(A 665+5H(96+5865+6(Hlt6(A)6 lt5K86(8SltA+5ltlt0+5lt8Wgt A8+88(5H(lt505+lt8(+D+0A50lt8DK

7 3

IA0(840E3(O4J( bull d(05lt9B+51lt5Igt5A6A5J(5lt+[6K^+ 589((6gt56J(A5+5ltlt8)=5lt656 8(DltDA)6568A5gt5Alt5+(A656 05+KcD+0(A8A5A8U+(668Kd)ltlt8d96 +6)656+[665(d5D8(5(06+ +[6KdA8A8((+ltlt+56+8(98gt8 )(H(5(A+9+8(S5H(6J(A66 S5H()66+5Kd5lt)(A65(9lt) A(68(98(6(69+5KKK6+gt5+I B686r66lt86K(0gt50I68+[6+5ltlt0 (A005(Ad565ltlt0([0AA8(986K

7 4

IA0(840E3(O4J(

bull d(08lt90lt5gtA8A56A0gt+gtgt(6 65ltlt)6lt(656lt5+8A5(A[656 gt86A8U+(69+)lt5(A6A09+ B5D8+K(gt5A66gtltlt( +gt86gt+A8U+(69+6085ltlt056Kd6 gt58(6+H(9B5896696)0 )+6W(5(A6A0ltKK bull Y5605+I8(05+6lt5I668(6+H(98d A8Agt55(0+[6K75A6)+ A8U+(65+H660lt5(A58(6(0)+5 60ltKd6+(6A55ltlt(9B686gt5)(K 7

5


<86Kquot(0>50I68+[6+5<<0>mailtoB686r66lt86K(0gt50I68+[6+5ltlt0


IA0(840E3(O4J(

bull [+(5lt656gt5A68(-86+0lt5K 75A6gt+8656+05B6gt5686gtltA Blt88)gtgt+5+658(5+56+A+8(9 6G+(XDltH(I5(Agt5A+658( 686gt+865B6gt865(6+0K+ gt+h(6+8K

7 6

IA0(840E3(O4J(

bull Y5605+8(0T5(8lt5gtgt+5A 655D86+58lt+8(T5(8I5(A+ 9+gt5=6+lt0(959A8(665K ]6lt8lt0B5gt([0AJlt8(9+ +[68(9+gt(+86I5(A(6 68(966+86K7gt+5ltltgtA6 =5(A+8A55(A+(66K bull (8(6+H(9+[6gtA8Agt58( 46+0Kd6gt56(6+8A+[6K

7 7

78


5=6+<0(959A8(665K>mailto9+gt5=6+lt0(959A8(665K
+8656+05B6>5686>mailto75A6gt+8656+05B6gt5686gtltA


79

Oltlt4(4((2(V4Eamp2C4C(C-(lt( amplt4(4(lt(ampS(-(Mlt-amplt(ampC00(lt=(2(

C4(lt(gt0S((MltN(( bull M8(B5d)(A868(6+H(95(A86gt5)(+lt5H(968()+5H(6

+5ltlt8)K bull -5lt6B5865lt86 bull c(9lt8lt5B586r5HDK bull -(+4D+((6O((H(6668Agt+ltAK bull 7+ltAlt5(959B586DS8lt05(AgtAlt6)5HD8H6

+8()+lt5+(8(9 bull 6ltHK8665A88lt8(I86(6I5(A605D8965(A5+A bull dlt5+(A668(c(9lt8lt58(-TK]065++6A5(A5ltltgtA

65+gt(A88(+95+A8(9gtgtgt5(6A6B5A8(+ +5A8(9K+gt+5(B+)8OgtltA5D5()+(gt86+I 556++5A8+55I+98D5(+5lt+(65H(Kd6gt5gt+8(96 B5Blt6568K

80

81


+5(B+)8O>86+I>mailto5A8(9K+gt+5(B+)8OgtltA5D5()+(gt86+I

<05(A>A<6)5HD8H6>mailto7+ltAlt5(959B586DS8lt05(AgtAlt6)5HD8H6

+mailto4D+((6O((H(6668Agt+ltAK


RgtVC(Z00(Alt(n-0C-( bull M56+858Jgt506A68(95(A6+8(+ )++5HD860K

bull dA(r6Blt8D6566)656gtlt5+(gt8ltlt5lt068( +gt(5++5k+89ltK

bull d5D6+Blt+B+8(95ltlt6+lt5(A5ltlt66+K bull M+8(9IltI8(5lt85Blt8ltlt bull +8+HH(8(56I8685ltlt5B6A+8ltlt8(9(Hlt 09686+896K

bull d5D+08(6+6A8(lt5+(8(9gt568566A50I5(A5D( 8(6+68(lt5+(8(95B6)+lt5K

bull dlt8]566lt56B5d68(868B+8(95(A6+8( +5HD8608(lt5gt+K75+[6A8(9=+85ltlt6H 5(A656886565ltlt0K

82

83

84


<8D6566)656><5+(>8<<5<068>mailtodA(r6Blt8D6566)656gtlt5+(gt8ltlt5lt068


8gtVC-ampE0(14(U244-amp2C2gt(o( 60000gt(

bull ++(65+566A89() lt(I(86I+I5(A+9+5 gt+5958(6H5lt)AB55(A86 7(AltI(6lt8(5+D+59 7(A+OIA+8(9I5(A6O5(6 8(96T]cSH(L655(A95lt

7(A69+5A5958(6+9+6gt5+A 95ltI(65ltlt5665()5ltlt9+5A 85

8(0lt4T(

bull +0_ Y658(9I+)AB5 Y+585(ABlt5I+)AB5 ]+((O5()AB5o06` ]56A(6lt)O5(6(6 Tlt886+9lt5+lt)lt)AB5)+ 6A(6C5(A65+E

86

Z024amp0(

bull 460gtB59P gtgtgtK56(HA5H(K+9 bull amplt8()ltA+656+)+6 Q56+85lt)+0+8(gt86 4+5(678998(Z bull 7i$1231

87


FPLLgtgtgtKltB85KALL95LMLXcTcXamp-L5W+K6ltFPLLgtgtgtKBAKL$gtltF+5+HltL5W++HDK6lt

FPLLgtgtgtKA8(6ltK+9L55(LBlt5yz32K6FPLL(9lt8K(86(lt90K5K(WL++L++L

FPLL(gt6(K(5KAL6ltLgtlt3L

FPLLgtgtgtK5(H(6KL)+L(5O


84(Z024amp0(

^(c+8]5W+08658(9 bull bull

^(Mlt5N78lt85+5+ bull bull lt5+lt5+(8(9K6lt

M+8H7B86(G+5HD(6 bull FPLLgtgtgtKS5K+9KLshtyK6lt bull FPLLgtgtgtKS5K+9KL1yee1ehK6lt bull FPLLgtgtgtKS5K+9KLAgt(lt5AL(lt8(9KA)

88

Z024amp0(

H9NO5K($1 bull

(6lt80 bull B5lt5(A5KA)

MP bull P+2(40E13I4+5(678998( bull E13-$K($1amp1I5ltMlt565lt bull Q3+13Ramp1050+E13-$K($1amp1IX8 TH998(

89

$amp((gt(

bull9+5(6|56(HA5H(K+9

bullamp60Blt9P 9+5(6gt8998(Kgt+A+K

90


>>KS5K+9KLA>(<5AL(<8(9KA>mailtoFPLLgtgtgtKS5K+9KLAgt(lt5AL(lt8(9KA


567789(82amp0(( 6amplt-=gt(

4030 15

0

50 60

70

80

90

10REVERSE

Developmental

Effects

Typical

Teacher

Effects

ZONE OF DESIRED EFFECTS

50(ABC0-0( Rank Influence ES

1 Self-report self-assess 144

5 Reciprocal teaching 74

8 Feedback 72

9 Formative evaluation to teachers 70

11 Meta-cognition strategies 67

5


bull QB898(6R86D+5(A D+5958(5+85ltR86 8+65()S85(AA658ltA )AB5KT6A(6D+gtlt8(9lt0 ++665668(9lt68+65(6 8(9+A8(6)+58(95+ UHD89V(9+58A+(( 589((65(AS8WWK

OX85+AY896 6


<8(9<0>mailtoAB5KT6A(6D+gtlt8(9lt0




7

$amp(0((FampGH(


8

$amp(0((FampGH(


9



I14gtE=(0000gtJ(


10



11

Olt(($ampN(

12



P((gt(0(M4GGG(

13

N

H

IOlt0(lt-0NJ(

IOlt0($NJ(

14

IOlt0($NJ(

15


16


IK(Mlt(8(MQJ(

I5(lt240 )AB506

RS($0((lt(04T(

7(3amp -+)(28=

17

UampV(6W-gt(( $amp(


1KdA(H)06A8H(988(9 5+56+8H)5K

eK60+6+05958(6(gt 5K

fKXJ(0+(6I5(AAK 18


b5+gt568(9686+ )5I(66




19



20

KP((1$amp(






bull 756A8H(986 =5lt)+6 ((O=5lta

22

YES NO

d5(`65+0j

4Aj

T5k+j 23



lt98Z

l55+Id656lt5+65+H(96JA965(A6=6

(68+(m

Q756gt50+68(8(9(59faZ 24



63-S(Mlt(-0(1$ampN(

bull 756A8H(986 0)+6(a 756amp)AB5a

25

Olt(-0(1$ampN(AC0T(


26



7(05+(+)695ltI6566 )AB58(dGL-c$6+

27





28



29



30





31

X2(gt-3lt($(lt--3T(


32



33



A(=-amp((a20E(


34

80(P)((V4-0QQ(


35


36




80(P)((0( c20E0QQ(


37

$ampS([(


38

6=-ampS([(


39


42

68++5Ha



40


41






9Y4amp-0(


43



780+5A8()+68

5+a


8(M(Mlt(0gt(1(2(4( lt--3T(

45








46

I4amp(UampV(8=4J(






4lt +7$5amp+5amp4$)5)+(48$(7$8(+=amp$5-2



Ad240((


49

Ad24((


50

]0($(ampC4($2(lt($-3(-( lt4(


51





52



53

4gt(amp()amp)+(+-(


54


)+


55





ZHLJKWsup2
















RDOV$FWLRQV

alt(O($04=(14((12CC( 4($(404amplt40(


bull GH(01I3(3J145H(0K($1+

56

6C=4(UCC3(


57



58



`-0(02(1(lt($0(ampCC3( amplt40(



60

61

62


`-0(404amplt(




FeH( 8KR_8U89K7(

fg( FeGhH( ig(


FjGhH( jlg(

FiH(A997R( jig(

FiGhH( ekg(

FlH(9mU99nR( lg(




7-V0(14(-gtV4=-3(1$amp(


64



65

1$amp(


66



$amp(14(CC(


67

R2(1$amp(


68




69



70

71




7 2





7 3


7 4

IA0(840E3(O4J(


5




IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 6

IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 7

78


5=6+<0(959A8(665K>mailto9+gt5=6+lt0(959A8(665K


79






80

81











82

83

84







8(0lt4T(


86

Z024amp0(


87







84(Z024amp0(

^(c+8]5W+08658(9 bull bull



88

Z024amp0(

H9NO5K($1 bull



89

$amp((gt(

bull9+5(6|56(HA5H(K+9


90






7

$amp(0((FampGH(


8

$amp(0((FampGH(


9



I14gtE=(0000gtJ(


10



11

Olt(($ampN(

12



P((gt(0(M4GGG(

13

N

H

IOlt0(lt-0NJ(

IOlt0($NJ(

14

IOlt0($NJ(

15


16


IK(Mlt(8(MQJ(

I5(lt240 )AB506

RS($0((lt(04T(

7(3amp -+)(28=

17

UampV(6W-gt(( $amp(


1KdA(H)06A8H(988(9 5+56+8H)5K

eK60+6+05958(6(gt 5K

fKXJ(0+(6I5(AAK 18


b5+gt568(9686+ )5I(66




19



20

KP((1$amp(






bull 756A8H(986 =5lt)+6 ((O=5lta

22

YES NO

d5(`65+0j

4Aj

T5k+j 23



lt98Z

l55+Id656lt5+65+H(96JA965(A6=6

(68+(m

Q756gt50+68(8(9(59faZ 24



63-S(Mlt(-0(1$ampN(

bull 756A8H(986 0)+6(a 756amp)AB5a

25

Olt(-0(1$ampN(AC0T(


26



7(05+(+)695ltI6566 )AB58(dGL-c$6+

27





28



29



30





31

X2(gt-3lt($(lt--3T(


32



33



A(=-amp((a20E(


34

80(P)((V4-0QQ(


35


36




80(P)((0( c20E0QQ(


37

$ampS([(


38

6=-ampS([(


39


42

68++5Ha



40


41






9Y4amp-0(


43



780+5A8()+68

5+a


8(M(Mlt(0gt(1(2(4( lt--3T(

45








46

I4amp(UampV(8=4J(






4lt +7$5amp+5amp4$)5)+(48$(7$8(+=amp$5-2



Ad240((


49

Ad24((


50

]0($(ampC4($2(lt($-3(-( lt4(


51





52



53

4gt(amp()amp)+(+-(


54


)+


55





ZHLJKWsup2
















RDOV$FWLRQV

alt(O($04=(14((12CC( 4($(404amplt40(


bull GH(01I3(3J145H(0K($1+

56

6C=4(UCC3(


57



58



`-0(02(1(lt($0(ampCC3( amplt40(



60

61

62


`-0(404amplt(




FeH( 8KR_8U89K7(

fg( FeGhH( ig(


FjGhH( jlg(

FiH(A997R( jig(

FiGhH( ekg(

FlH(9mU99nR( lg(




7-V0(14(-gtV4=-3(1$amp(


64



65

1$amp(


66



$amp(14(CC(


67

R2(1$amp(


68




69



70

71




7 2





7 3


7 4

IA0(840E3(O4J(


5




IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 6

IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 7

78


5=6+<0(959A8(665K>mailto9+gt5=6+lt0(959A8(665K


79






80

81











82

83

84







8(0lt4T(


86

Z024amp0(


87







84(Z024amp0(

^(c+8]5W+08658(9 bull bull



88

Z024amp0(

H9NO5K($1 bull



89

$amp((gt(

bull9+5(6|56(HA5H(K+9


90




I14gtE=(0000gtJ(


10



11

Olt(($ampN(

12



P((gt(0(M4GGG(

13

N

H

IOlt0(lt-0NJ(

IOlt0($NJ(

14

IOlt0($NJ(

15


16


IK(Mlt(8(MQJ(

I5(lt240 )AB506

RS($0((lt(04T(

7(3amp -+)(28=

17

UampV(6W-gt(( $amp(


1KdA(H)06A8H(988(9 5+56+8H)5K

eK60+6+05958(6(gt 5K

fKXJ(0+(6I5(AAK 18


b5+gt568(9686+ )5I(66




19



20

KP((1$amp(






bull 756A8H(986 =5lt)+6 ((O=5lta

22

YES NO

d5(`65+0j

4Aj

T5k+j 23



lt98Z

l55+Id656lt5+65+H(96JA965(A6=6

(68+(m

Q756gt50+68(8(9(59faZ 24



63-S(Mlt(-0(1$ampN(

bull 756A8H(986 0)+6(a 756amp)AB5a

25

Olt(-0(1$ampN(AC0T(


26



7(05+(+)695ltI6566 )AB58(dGL-c$6+

27





28



29



30





31

X2(gt-3lt($(lt--3T(


32



33



A(=-amp((a20E(


34

80(P)((V4-0QQ(


35


36




80(P)((0( c20E0QQ(


37

$ampS([(


38

6=-ampS([(


39


42

68++5Ha



40


41






9Y4amp-0(


43



780+5A8()+68

5+a


8(M(Mlt(0gt(1(2(4( lt--3T(

45








46

I4amp(UampV(8=4J(






4lt +7$5amp+5amp4$)5)+(48$(7$8(+=amp$5-2



Ad240((


49

Ad24((


50

]0($(ampC4($2(lt($-3(-( lt4(


51





52



53

4gt(amp()amp)+(+-(


54


)+


55





ZHLJKWsup2
















RDOV$FWLRQV

alt(O($04=(14((12CC( 4($(404amplt40(


bull GH(01I3(3J145H(0K($1+

56

6C=4(UCC3(


57



58



`-0(02(1(lt($0(ampCC3( amplt40(



60

61

62


`-0(404amplt(




FeH( 8KR_8U89K7(

fg( FeGhH( ig(


FjGhH( jlg(

FiH(A997R( jig(

FiGhH( ekg(

FlH(9mU99nR( lg(




7-V0(14(-gtV4=-3(1$amp(


64



65

1$amp(


66



$amp(14(CC(


67

R2(1$amp(


68




69



70

71




7 2





7 3


7 4

IA0(840E3(O4J(


5




IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 6

IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 7

78


5=6+<0(959A8(665K>mailto9+gt5=6+lt0(959A8(665K


79






80

81











82

83

84







8(0lt4T(


86

Z024amp0(


87







84(Z024amp0(

^(c+8]5W+08658(9 bull bull



88

Z024amp0(

H9NO5K($1 bull



89

$amp((gt(

bull9+5(6|56(HA5H(K+9


90




P((gt(0(M4GGG(

13

N

H

IOlt0(lt-0NJ(

IOlt0($NJ(

14

IOlt0($NJ(

15


16


IK(Mlt(8(MQJ(

I5(lt240 )AB506

RS($0((lt(04T(

7(3amp -+)(28=

17

UampV(6W-gt(( $amp(


1KdA(H)06A8H(988(9 5+56+8H)5K

eK60+6+05958(6(gt 5K

fKXJ(0+(6I5(AAK 18


b5+gt568(9686+ )5I(66




19



20

KP((1$amp(






bull 756A8H(986 =5lt)+6 ((O=5lta

22

YES NO

d5(`65+0j

4Aj

T5k+j 23



lt98Z

l55+Id656lt5+65+H(96JA965(A6=6

(68+(m

Q756gt50+68(8(9(59faZ 24



63-S(Mlt(-0(1$ampN(

bull 756A8H(986 0)+6(a 756amp)AB5a

25

Olt(-0(1$ampN(AC0T(


26



7(05+(+)695ltI6566 )AB58(dGL-c$6+

27





28



29



30





31

X2(gt-3lt($(lt--3T(


32



33



A(=-amp((a20E(


34

80(P)((V4-0QQ(


35


36




80(P)((0( c20E0QQ(


37

$ampS([(


38

6=-ampS([(


39


42

68++5Ha



40


41






9Y4amp-0(


43



780+5A8()+68

5+a


8(M(Mlt(0gt(1(2(4( lt--3T(

45








46

I4amp(UampV(8=4J(






4lt +7$5amp+5amp4$)5)+(48$(7$8(+=amp$5-2



Ad240((


49

Ad24((


50

]0($(ampC4($2(lt($-3(-( lt4(


51





52



53

4gt(amp()amp)+(+-(


54


)+


55





ZHLJKWsup2
















RDOV$FWLRQV

alt(O($04=(14((12CC( 4($(404amplt40(


bull GH(01I3(3J145H(0K($1+

56

6C=4(UCC3(


57



58



`-0(02(1(lt($0(ampCC3( amplt40(



60

61

62


`-0(404amplt(




FeH( 8KR_8U89K7(

fg( FeGhH( ig(


FjGhH( jlg(

FiH(A997R( jig(

FiGhH( ekg(

FlH(9mU99nR( lg(




7-V0(14(-gtV4=-3(1$amp(


64



65

1$amp(


66



$amp(14(CC(


67

R2(1$amp(


68




69



70

71




7 2





7 3


7 4

IA0(840E3(O4J(


5




IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 6

IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 7

78


5=6+<0(959A8(665K>mailto9+gt5=6+lt0(959A8(665K


79






80

81











82

83

84







8(0lt4T(


86

Z024amp0(


87







84(Z024amp0(

^(c+8]5W+08658(9 bull bull



88

Z024amp0(

H9NO5K($1 bull



89

$amp((gt(

bull9+5(6|56(HA5H(K+9


90



16


IK(Mlt(8(MQJ(

I5(lt240 )AB506

RS($0((lt(04T(

7(3amp -+)(28=

17

UampV(6W-gt(( $amp(


1KdA(H)06A8H(988(9 5+56+8H)5K

eK60+6+05958(6(gt 5K

fKXJ(0+(6I5(AAK 18


b5+gt568(9686+ )5I(66




19



20

KP((1$amp(






bull 756A8H(986 =5lt)+6 ((O=5lta

22

YES NO

d5(`65+0j

4Aj

T5k+j 23



lt98Z

l55+Id656lt5+65+H(96JA965(A6=6

(68+(m

Q756gt50+68(8(9(59faZ 24



63-S(Mlt(-0(1$ampN(

bull 756A8H(986 0)+6(a 756amp)AB5a

25

Olt(-0(1$ampN(AC0T(


26



7(05+(+)695ltI6566 )AB58(dGL-c$6+

27





28



29



30





31

X2(gt-3lt($(lt--3T(


32



33



A(=-amp((a20E(


34

80(P)((V4-0QQ(


35


36




80(P)((0( c20E0QQ(


37

$ampS([(


38

6=-ampS([(


39


42

68++5Ha



40


41






9Y4amp-0(


43



780+5A8()+68

5+a


8(M(Mlt(0gt(1(2(4( lt--3T(

45








46

I4amp(UampV(8=4J(






4lt +7$5amp+5amp4$)5)+(48$(7$8(+=amp$5-2



Ad240((


49

Ad24((


50

]0($(ampC4($2(lt($-3(-( lt4(


51





52



53

4gt(amp()amp)+(+-(


54


)+


55





ZHLJKWsup2
















RDOV$FWLRQV

alt(O($04=(14((12CC( 4($(404amplt40(


bull GH(01I3(3J145H(0K($1+

56

6C=4(UCC3(


57



58



`-0(02(1(lt($0(ampCC3( amplt40(



60

61

62


`-0(404amplt(




FeH( 8KR_8U89K7(

fg( FeGhH( ig(


FjGhH( jlg(

FiH(A997R( jig(

FiGhH( ekg(

FlH(9mU99nR( lg(




7-V0(14(-gtV4=-3(1$amp(


64



65

1$amp(


66



$amp(14(CC(


67

R2(1$amp(


68




69



70

71




7 2





7 3


7 4

IA0(840E3(O4J(


5




IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 6

IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 7

78


5=6+<0(959A8(665K>mailto9+gt5=6+lt0(959A8(665K


79






80

81











82

83

84







8(0lt4T(


86

Z024amp0(


87







84(Z024amp0(

^(c+8]5W+08658(9 bull bull



88

Z024amp0(

H9NO5K($1 bull



89

$amp((gt(

bull9+5(6|56(HA5H(K+9


90



b5+gt568(9686+ )5I(66




19



20

KP((1$amp(






bull 756A8H(986 =5lt)+6 ((O=5lta

22

YES NO

d5(`65+0j

4Aj

T5k+j 23



lt98Z

l55+Id656lt5+65+H(96JA965(A6=6

(68+(m

Q756gt50+68(8(9(59faZ 24



63-S(Mlt(-0(1$ampN(

bull 756A8H(986 0)+6(a 756amp)AB5a

25

Olt(-0(1$ampN(AC0T(


26



7(05+(+)695ltI6566 )AB58(dGL-c$6+

27





28



29



30





31

X2(gt-3lt($(lt--3T(


32



33



A(=-amp((a20E(


34

80(P)((V4-0QQ(


35


36




80(P)((0( c20E0QQ(


37

$ampS([(


38

6=-ampS([(


39


42

68++5Ha



40


41






9Y4amp-0(


43



780+5A8()+68

5+a


8(M(Mlt(0gt(1(2(4( lt--3T(

45








46

I4amp(UampV(8=4J(






4lt +7$5amp+5amp4$)5)+(48$(7$8(+=amp$5-2



Ad240((


49

Ad24((


50

]0($(ampC4($2(lt($-3(-( lt4(


51





52



53

4gt(amp()amp)+(+-(


54


)+


55





ZHLJKWsup2
















RDOV$FWLRQV

alt(O($04=(14((12CC( 4($(404amplt40(


bull GH(01I3(3J145H(0K($1+

56

6C=4(UCC3(


57



58



`-0(02(1(lt($0(ampCC3( amplt40(



60

61

62


`-0(404amplt(




FeH( 8KR_8U89K7(

fg( FeGhH( ig(


FjGhH( jlg(

FiH(A997R( jig(

FiGhH( ekg(

FlH(9mU99nR( lg(




7-V0(14(-gtV4=-3(1$amp(


64



65

1$amp(


66



$amp(14(CC(


67

R2(1$amp(


68




69



70

71




7 2





7 3


7 4

IA0(840E3(O4J(


5




IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 6

IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 7

78


5=6+<0(959A8(665K>mailto9+gt5=6+lt0(959A8(665K


79






80

81











82

83

84







8(0lt4T(


86

Z024amp0(


87







84(Z024amp0(

^(c+8]5W+08658(9 bull bull



88

Z024amp0(

H9NO5K($1 bull



89

$amp((gt(

bull9+5(6|56(HA5H(K+9


90





bull 756A8H(986 =5lt)+6 ((O=5lta

22

YES NO

d5(`65+0j

4Aj

T5k+j 23



lt98Z

l55+Id656lt5+65+H(96JA965(A6=6

(68+(m

Q756gt50+68(8(9(59faZ 24



63-S(Mlt(-0(1$ampN(

bull 756A8H(986 0)+6(a 756amp)AB5a

25

Olt(-0(1$ampN(AC0T(


26



7(05+(+)695ltI6566 )AB58(dGL-c$6+

27





28



29



30





31

X2(gt-3lt($(lt--3T(


32



33



A(=-amp((a20E(


34

80(P)((V4-0QQ(


35


36




80(P)((0( c20E0QQ(


37

$ampS([(


38

6=-ampS([(


39


42

68++5Ha



40


41






9Y4amp-0(


43



780+5A8()+68

5+a


8(M(Mlt(0gt(1(2(4( lt--3T(

45








46

I4amp(UampV(8=4J(






4lt +7$5amp+5amp4$)5)+(48$(7$8(+=amp$5-2



Ad240((


49

Ad24((


50

]0($(ampC4($2(lt($-3(-( lt4(


51





52



53

4gt(amp()amp)+(+-(


54


)+


55





ZHLJKWsup2
















RDOV$FWLRQV

alt(O($04=(14((12CC( 4($(404amplt40(


bull GH(01I3(3J145H(0K($1+

56

6C=4(UCC3(


57



58



`-0(02(1(lt($0(ampCC3( amplt40(



60

61

62


`-0(404amplt(




FeH( 8KR_8U89K7(

fg( FeGhH( ig(


FjGhH( jlg(

FiH(A997R( jig(

FiGhH( ekg(

FlH(9mU99nR( lg(




7-V0(14(-gtV4=-3(1$amp(


64



65

1$amp(


66



$amp(14(CC(


67

R2(1$amp(


68




69



70

71




7 2





7 3


7 4

IA0(840E3(O4J(


5




IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 6

IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 7

78


5=6+<0(959A8(665K>mailto9+gt5=6+lt0(959A8(665K


79






80

81











82

83

84







8(0lt4T(


86

Z024amp0(


87







84(Z024amp0(

^(c+8]5W+08658(9 bull bull



88

Z024amp0(

H9NO5K($1 bull



89

$amp((gt(

bull9+5(6|56(HA5H(K+9


90




63-S(Mlt(-0(1$ampN(

bull 756A8H(986 0)+6(a 756amp)AB5a

25

Olt(-0(1$ampN(AC0T(


26



7(05+(+)695ltI6566 )AB58(dGL-c$6+

27





28



29



30





31

X2(gt-3lt($(lt--3T(


32



33



A(=-amp((a20E(


34

80(P)((V4-0QQ(


35


36




80(P)((0( c20E0QQ(


37

$ampS([(


38

6=-ampS([(


39


42

68++5Ha



40


41






9Y4amp-0(


43



780+5A8()+68

5+a


8(M(Mlt(0gt(1(2(4( lt--3T(

45








46

I4amp(UampV(8=4J(






4lt +7$5amp+5amp4$)5)+(48$(7$8(+=amp$5-2



Ad240((


49

Ad24((


50

]0($(ampC4($2(lt($-3(-( lt4(


51





52



53

4gt(amp()amp)+(+-(


54


)+


55





ZHLJKWsup2
















RDOV$FWLRQV

alt(O($04=(14((12CC( 4($(404amplt40(


bull GH(01I3(3J145H(0K($1+

56

6C=4(UCC3(


57



58



`-0(02(1(lt($0(ampCC3( amplt40(



60

61

62


`-0(404amplt(




FeH( 8KR_8U89K7(

fg( FeGhH( ig(


FjGhH( jlg(

FiH(A997R( jig(

FiGhH( ekg(

FlH(9mU99nR( lg(




7-V0(14(-gtV4=-3(1$amp(


64



65

1$amp(


66



$amp(14(CC(


67

R2(1$amp(


68




69



70

71




7 2





7 3


7 4

IA0(840E3(O4J(


5




IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 6

IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 7

78


5=6+<0(959A8(665K>mailto9+gt5=6+lt0(959A8(665K


79






80

81











82

83

84







8(0lt4T(


86

Z024amp0(


87







84(Z024amp0(

^(c+8]5W+08658(9 bull bull



88

Z024amp0(

H9NO5K($1 bull



89

$amp((gt(

bull9+5(6|56(HA5H(K+9


90






28



29



30





31

X2(gt-3lt($(lt--3T(


32



33



A(=-amp((a20E(


34

80(P)((V4-0QQ(


35


36




80(P)((0( c20E0QQ(


37

$ampS([(


38

6=-ampS([(


39


42

68++5Ha



40


41






9Y4amp-0(


43



780+5A8()+68

5+a


8(M(Mlt(0gt(1(2(4( lt--3T(

45








46

I4amp(UampV(8=4J(






4lt +7$5amp+5amp4$)5)+(48$(7$8(+=amp$5-2



Ad240((


49

Ad24((


50

]0($(ampC4($2(lt($-3(-( lt4(


51





52



53

4gt(amp()amp)+(+-(


54


)+


55





ZHLJKWsup2
















RDOV$FWLRQV

alt(O($04=(14((12CC( 4($(404amplt40(


bull GH(01I3(3J145H(0K($1+

56

6C=4(UCC3(


57



58



`-0(02(1(lt($0(ampCC3( amplt40(



60

61

62


`-0(404amplt(




FeH( 8KR_8U89K7(

fg( FeGhH( ig(


FjGhH( jlg(

FiH(A997R( jig(

FiGhH( ekg(

FlH(9mU99nR( lg(




7-V0(14(-gtV4=-3(1$amp(


64



65

1$amp(


66



$amp(14(CC(


67

R2(1$amp(


68




69



70

71




7 2





7 3


7 4

IA0(840E3(O4J(


5




IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 6

IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 7

78


5=6+<0(959A8(665K>mailto9+gt5=6+lt0(959A8(665K


79






80

81











82

83

84







8(0lt4T(


86

Z024amp0(


87







84(Z024amp0(

^(c+8]5W+08658(9 bull bull



88

Z024amp0(

H9NO5K($1 bull



89

$amp((gt(

bull9+5(6|56(HA5H(K+9


90






31

X2(gt-3lt($(lt--3T(


32



33



A(=-amp((a20E(


34

80(P)((V4-0QQ(


35


36




80(P)((0( c20E0QQ(


37

$ampS([(


38

6=-ampS([(


39


42

68++5Ha



40


41






9Y4amp-0(


43



780+5A8()+68

5+a


8(M(Mlt(0gt(1(2(4( lt--3T(

45








46

I4amp(UampV(8=4J(






4lt +7$5amp+5amp4$)5)+(48$(7$8(+=amp$5-2



Ad240((


49

Ad24((


50

]0($(ampC4($2(lt($-3(-( lt4(


51





52



53

4gt(amp()amp)+(+-(


54


)+


55





ZHLJKWsup2
















RDOV$FWLRQV

alt(O($04=(14((12CC( 4($(404amplt40(


bull GH(01I3(3J145H(0K($1+

56

6C=4(UCC3(


57



58



`-0(02(1(lt($0(ampCC3( amplt40(



60

61

62


`-0(404amplt(




FeH( 8KR_8U89K7(

fg( FeGhH( ig(


FjGhH( jlg(

FiH(A997R( jig(

FiGhH( ekg(

FlH(9mU99nR( lg(




7-V0(14(-gtV4=-3(1$amp(


64



65

1$amp(


66



$amp(14(CC(


67

R2(1$amp(


68




69



70

71




7 2





7 3


7 4

IA0(840E3(O4J(


5




IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 6

IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 7

78


5=6+<0(959A8(665K>mailto9+gt5=6+lt0(959A8(665K


79






80

81











82

83

84







8(0lt4T(


86

Z024amp0(


87







84(Z024amp0(

^(c+8]5W+08658(9 bull bull



88

Z024amp0(

H9NO5K($1 bull



89

$amp((gt(

bull9+5(6|56(HA5H(K+9


90




A(=-amp((a20E(


34

80(P)((V4-0QQ(


35


36




80(P)((0( c20E0QQ(


37

$ampS([(


38

6=-ampS([(


39


42

68++5Ha



40


41






9Y4amp-0(


43



780+5A8()+68

5+a


8(M(Mlt(0gt(1(2(4( lt--3T(

45








46

I4amp(UampV(8=4J(






4lt +7$5amp+5amp4$)5)+(48$(7$8(+=amp$5-2



Ad240((


49

Ad24((


50

]0($(ampC4($2(lt($-3(-( lt4(


51





52



53

4gt(amp()amp)+(+-(


54


)+


55





ZHLJKWsup2
















RDOV$FWLRQV

alt(O($04=(14((12CC( 4($(404amplt40(


bull GH(01I3(3J145H(0K($1+

56

6C=4(UCC3(


57



58



`-0(02(1(lt($0(ampCC3( amplt40(



60

61

62


`-0(404amplt(




FeH( 8KR_8U89K7(

fg( FeGhH( ig(


FjGhH( jlg(

FiH(A997R( jig(

FiGhH( ekg(

FlH(9mU99nR( lg(




7-V0(14(-gtV4=-3(1$amp(


64



65

1$amp(


66



$amp(14(CC(


67

R2(1$amp(


68




69



70

71




7 2





7 3


7 4

IA0(840E3(O4J(


5




IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 6

IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 7

78


5=6+<0(959A8(665K>mailto9+gt5=6+lt0(959A8(665K


79






80

81











82

83

84







8(0lt4T(


86

Z024amp0(


87







84(Z024amp0(

^(c+8]5W+08658(9 bull bull



88

Z024amp0(

H9NO5K($1 bull



89

$amp((gt(

bull9+5(6|56(HA5H(K+9


90




80(P)((0( c20E0QQ(


37

$ampS([(


38

6=-ampS([(


39


42

68++5Ha



40


41






9Y4amp-0(


43



780+5A8()+68

5+a


8(M(Mlt(0gt(1(2(4( lt--3T(

45








46

I4amp(UampV(8=4J(






4lt +7$5amp+5amp4$)5)+(48$(7$8(+=amp$5-2



Ad240((


49

Ad24((


50

]0($(ampC4($2(lt($-3(-( lt4(


51





52



53

4gt(amp()amp)+(+-(


54


)+


55





ZHLJKWsup2
















RDOV$FWLRQV

alt(O($04=(14((12CC( 4($(404amplt40(


bull GH(01I3(3J145H(0K($1+

56

6C=4(UCC3(


57



58



`-0(02(1(lt($0(ampCC3( amplt40(



60

61

62


`-0(404amplt(




FeH( 8KR_8U89K7(

fg( FeGhH( ig(


FjGhH( jlg(

FiH(A997R( jig(

FiGhH( ekg(

FlH(9mU99nR( lg(




7-V0(14(-gtV4=-3(1$amp(


64



65

1$amp(


66



$amp(14(CC(


67

R2(1$amp(


68




69



70

71




7 2





7 3


7 4

IA0(840E3(O4J(


5




IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 6

IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 7

78


5=6+<0(959A8(665K>mailto9+gt5=6+lt0(959A8(665K


79






80

81











82

83

84







8(0lt4T(


86

Z024amp0(


87







84(Z024amp0(

^(c+8]5W+08658(9 bull bull



88

Z024amp0(

H9NO5K($1 bull



89

$amp((gt(

bull9+5(6|56(HA5H(K+9


90



42

68++5Ha



40


41






9Y4amp-0(


43



780+5A8()+68

5+a


8(M(Mlt(0gt(1(2(4( lt--3T(

45








46

I4amp(UampV(8=4J(






4lt +7$5amp+5amp4$)5)+(48$(7$8(+=amp$5-2



Ad240((


49

Ad24((


50

]0($(ampC4($2(lt($-3(-( lt4(


51





52



53

4gt(amp()amp)+(+-(


54


)+


55





ZHLJKWsup2
















RDOV$FWLRQV

alt(O($04=(14((12CC( 4($(404amplt40(


bull GH(01I3(3J145H(0K($1+

56

6C=4(UCC3(


57



58



`-0(02(1(lt($0(ampCC3( amplt40(



60

61

62


`-0(404amplt(




FeH( 8KR_8U89K7(

fg( FeGhH( ig(


FjGhH( jlg(

FiH(A997R( jig(

FiGhH( ekg(

FlH(9mU99nR( lg(




7-V0(14(-gtV4=-3(1$amp(


64



65

1$amp(


66



$amp(14(CC(


67

R2(1$amp(


68




69



70

71




7 2





7 3


7 4

IA0(840E3(O4J(


5




IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 6

IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 7

78


5=6+<0(959A8(665K>mailto9+gt5=6+lt0(959A8(665K


79






80

81











82

83

84







8(0lt4T(


86

Z024amp0(


87







84(Z024amp0(

^(c+8]5W+08658(9 bull bull



88

Z024amp0(

H9NO5K($1 bull



89

$amp((gt(

bull9+5(6|56(HA5H(K+9


90




9Y4amp-0(


43



780+5A8()+68

5+a


8(M(Mlt(0gt(1(2(4( lt--3T(

45








46

I4amp(UampV(8=4J(






4lt +7$5amp+5amp4$)5)+(48$(7$8(+=amp$5-2



Ad240((


49

Ad24((


50

]0($(ampC4($2(lt($-3(-( lt4(


51





52



53

4gt(amp()amp)+(+-(


54


)+


55





ZHLJKWsup2
















RDOV$FWLRQV

alt(O($04=(14((12CC( 4($(404amplt40(


bull GH(01I3(3J145H(0K($1+

56

6C=4(UCC3(


57



58



`-0(02(1(lt($0(ampCC3( amplt40(



60

61

62


`-0(404amplt(




FeH( 8KR_8U89K7(

fg( FeGhH( ig(


FjGhH( jlg(

FiH(A997R( jig(

FiGhH( ekg(

FlH(9mU99nR( lg(




7-V0(14(-gtV4=-3(1$amp(


64



65

1$amp(


66



$amp(14(CC(


67

R2(1$amp(


68




69



70

71




7 2





7 3


7 4

IA0(840E3(O4J(


5




IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 6

IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 7

78


5=6+<0(959A8(665K>mailto9+gt5=6+lt0(959A8(665K


79






80

81











82

83

84







8(0lt4T(


86

Z024amp0(


87







84(Z024amp0(

^(c+8]5W+08658(9 bull bull



88

Z024amp0(

H9NO5K($1 bull



89

$amp((gt(

bull9+5(6|56(HA5H(K+9


90








46

I4amp(UampV(8=4J(






4lt +7$5amp+5amp4$)5)+(48$(7$8(+=amp$5-2



Ad240((


49

Ad24((


50

]0($(ampC4($2(lt($-3(-( lt4(


51





52



53

4gt(amp()amp)+(+-(


54


)+


55





ZHLJKWsup2
















RDOV$FWLRQV

alt(O($04=(14((12CC( 4($(404amplt40(


bull GH(01I3(3J145H(0K($1+

56

6C=4(UCC3(


57



58



`-0(02(1(lt($0(ampCC3( amplt40(



60

61

62


`-0(404amplt(




FeH( 8KR_8U89K7(

fg( FeGhH( ig(


FjGhH( jlg(

FiH(A997R( jig(

FiGhH( ekg(

FlH(9mU99nR( lg(




7-V0(14(-gtV4=-3(1$amp(


64



65

1$amp(


66



$amp(14(CC(


67

R2(1$amp(


68




69



70

71




7 2





7 3


7 4

IA0(840E3(O4J(


5




IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 6

IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 7

78


5=6+<0(959A8(665K>mailto9+gt5=6+lt0(959A8(665K


79






80

81











82

83

84







8(0lt4T(


86

Z024amp0(


87







84(Z024amp0(

^(c+8]5W+08658(9 bull bull



88

Z024amp0(

H9NO5K($1 bull



89

$amp((gt(

bull9+5(6|56(HA5H(K+9


90




Ad240((


49

Ad24((


50

]0($(ampC4($2(lt($-3(-( lt4(


51





52



53

4gt(amp()amp)+(+-(


54


)+


55





ZHLJKWsup2
















RDOV$FWLRQV

alt(O($04=(14((12CC( 4($(404amplt40(


bull GH(01I3(3J145H(0K($1+

56

6C=4(UCC3(


57



58



`-0(02(1(lt($0(ampCC3( amplt40(



60

61

62


`-0(404amplt(




FeH( 8KR_8U89K7(

fg( FeGhH( ig(


FjGhH( jlg(

FiH(A997R( jig(

FiGhH( ekg(

FlH(9mU99nR( lg(




7-V0(14(-gtV4=-3(1$amp(


64



65

1$amp(


66



$amp(14(CC(


67

R2(1$amp(


68




69



70

71




7 2





7 3


7 4

IA0(840E3(O4J(


5




IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 6

IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 7

78


5=6+<0(959A8(665K>mailto9+gt5=6+lt0(959A8(665K


79






80

81











82

83

84







8(0lt4T(


86

Z024amp0(


87







84(Z024amp0(

^(c+8]5W+08658(9 bull bull



88

Z024amp0(

H9NO5K($1 bull



89

$amp((gt(

bull9+5(6|56(HA5H(K+9


90






52



53

4gt(amp()amp)+(+-(


54


)+


55





ZHLJKWsup2
















RDOV$FWLRQV

alt(O($04=(14((12CC( 4($(404amplt40(


bull GH(01I3(3J145H(0K($1+

56

6C=4(UCC3(


57



58



`-0(02(1(lt($0(ampCC3( amplt40(



60

61

62


`-0(404amplt(




FeH( 8KR_8U89K7(

fg( FeGhH( ig(


FjGhH( jlg(

FiH(A997R( jig(

FiGhH( ekg(

FlH(9mU99nR( lg(




7-V0(14(-gtV4=-3(1$amp(


64



65

1$amp(


66



$amp(14(CC(


67

R2(1$amp(


68




69



70

71




7 2





7 3


7 4

IA0(840E3(O4J(


5




IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 6

IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 7

78


5=6+<0(959A8(665K>mailto9+gt5=6+lt0(959A8(665K


79






80

81











82

83

84







8(0lt4T(


86

Z024amp0(


87







84(Z024amp0(

^(c+8]5W+08658(9 bull bull



88

Z024amp0(

H9NO5K($1 bull



89

$amp((gt(

bull9+5(6|56(HA5H(K+9


90



)+


55





ZHLJKWsup2
















RDOV$FWLRQV

alt(O($04=(14((12CC( 4($(404amplt40(


bull GH(01I3(3J145H(0K($1+

56

6C=4(UCC3(


57



58



`-0(02(1(lt($0(ampCC3( amplt40(



60

61

62


`-0(404amplt(




FeH( 8KR_8U89K7(

fg( FeGhH( ig(


FjGhH( jlg(

FiH(A997R( jig(

FiGhH( ekg(

FlH(9mU99nR( lg(




7-V0(14(-gtV4=-3(1$amp(


64



65

1$amp(


66



$amp(14(CC(


67

R2(1$amp(


68




69



70

71




7 2





7 3


7 4

IA0(840E3(O4J(


5




IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 6

IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 7

78


5=6+<0(959A8(665K>mailto9+gt5=6+lt0(959A8(665K


79






80

81











82

83

84







8(0lt4T(


86

Z024amp0(


87







84(Z024amp0(

^(c+8]5W+08658(9 bull bull



88

Z024amp0(

H9NO5K($1 bull



89

$amp((gt(

bull9+5(6|56(HA5H(K+9


90




58



`-0(02(1(lt($0(ampCC3( amplt40(



60

61

62


`-0(404amplt(




FeH( 8KR_8U89K7(

fg( FeGhH( ig(


FjGhH( jlg(

FiH(A997R( jig(

FiGhH( ekg(

FlH(9mU99nR( lg(




7-V0(14(-gtV4=-3(1$amp(


64



65

1$amp(


66



$amp(14(CC(


67

R2(1$amp(


68




69



70

71




7 2





7 3


7 4

IA0(840E3(O4J(


5




IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 6

IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 7

78


5=6+<0(959A8(665K>mailto9+gt5=6+lt0(959A8(665K


79






80

81











82

83

84







8(0lt4T(


86

Z024amp0(


87







84(Z024amp0(

^(c+8]5W+08658(9 bull bull



88

Z024amp0(

H9NO5K($1 bull



89

$amp((gt(

bull9+5(6|56(HA5H(K+9


90



61

62


`-0(404amplt(




FeH( 8KR_8U89K7(

fg( FeGhH( ig(


FjGhH( jlg(

FiH(A997R( jig(

FiGhH( ekg(

FlH(9mU99nR( lg(




7-V0(14(-gtV4=-3(1$amp(


64



65

1$amp(


66



$amp(14(CC(


67

R2(1$amp(


68




69



70

71




7 2





7 3


7 4

IA0(840E3(O4J(


5




IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 6

IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 7

78


5=6+<0(959A8(665K>mailto9+gt5=6+lt0(959A8(665K


79






80

81











82

83

84







8(0lt4T(


86

Z024amp0(


87







84(Z024amp0(

^(c+8]5W+08658(9 bull bull



88

Z024amp0(

H9NO5K($1 bull



89

$amp((gt(

bull9+5(6|56(HA5H(K+9


90




7-V0(14(-gtV4=-3(1$amp(


64



65

1$amp(


66



$amp(14(CC(


67

R2(1$amp(


68




69



70

71




7 2





7 3


7 4

IA0(840E3(O4J(


5




IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 6

IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 7

78


5=6+<0(959A8(665K>mailto9+gt5=6+lt0(959A8(665K


79






80

81











82

83

84







8(0lt4T(


86

Z024amp0(


87







84(Z024amp0(

^(c+8]5W+08658(9 bull bull



88

Z024amp0(

H9NO5K($1 bull



89

$amp((gt(

bull9+5(6|56(HA5H(K+9


90




$amp(14(CC(


67

R2(1$amp(


68




69



70

71




7 2





7 3


7 4

IA0(840E3(O4J(


5




IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 6

IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 7

78


5=6+<0(959A8(665K>mailto9+gt5=6+lt0(959A8(665K


79






80

81











82

83

84







8(0lt4T(


86

Z024amp0(


87







84(Z024amp0(

^(c+8]5W+08658(9 bull bull



88

Z024amp0(

H9NO5K($1 bull



89

$amp((gt(

bull9+5(6|56(HA5H(K+9


90




70

71




7 2





7 3


7 4

IA0(840E3(O4J(


5




IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 6

IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 7

78


5=6+<0(959A8(665K>mailto9+gt5=6+lt0(959A8(665K


79






80

81











82

83

84







8(0lt4T(


86

Z024amp0(


87







84(Z024amp0(

^(c+8]5W+08658(9 bull bull



88

Z024amp0(

H9NO5K($1 bull



89

$amp((gt(

bull9+5(6|56(HA5H(K+9


90





7 3


7 4

IA0(840E3(O4J(


5




IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 6

IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 7

78


5=6+<0(959A8(665K>mailto9+gt5=6+lt0(959A8(665K


79






80

81











82

83

84







8(0lt4T(


86

Z024amp0(


87







84(Z024amp0(

^(c+8]5W+08658(9 bull bull



88

Z024amp0(

H9NO5K($1 bull



89

$amp((gt(

bull9+5(6|56(HA5H(K+9


90




IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 6

IA0(840E3(O4J(


7 7

78


5=6+<0(959A8(665K>mailto9+gt5=6+lt0(959A8(665K


79






80

81











82

83

84







8(0lt4T(


86

Z024amp0(


87







84(Z024amp0(

^(c+8]5W+08658(9 bull bull



88

Z024amp0(

H9NO5K($1 bull



89

$amp((gt(

bull9+5(6|56(HA5H(K+9


90




79






80

81









82

83

84







8(0lt4T(


86

Z024amp0(


87







84(Z024amp0(

^(c+8]5W+08658(9 bull bull



88

Z024amp0(

H9NO5K($1 bull



89

$amp((gt(

bull9+5(6|56(HA5H(K+9


90







8(0lt4T(


86

Z024amp0(


87







84(Z024amp0(

^(c+8]5W+08658(9 bull bull



88

Z024amp0(

H9NO5K($1 bull



89

$amp((gt(

bull9+5(6|56(HA5H(K+9


90








84(Z024amp0(

^(c+8]5W+08658(9 bull bull



88

Z024amp0(

H9NO5K($1 bull



89

$amp((gt(

bull9+5(6|56(HA5H(K+9


90



28= - amazon web servicesframeweld-workshop.s3.amazonaws.com/files/4f5e004c... · 3huvxdvlyh ydolg...

Documents