26647449 retrofitting of earthquake affected buildings ppt

Upload: reva

Post on 14-Apr-2018

222 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    1/131

    RETROFITTING OFEARTHQUAKE AFFECTED

    BUILDINGS

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    2/131

    WHATIS

    RETROFITTING

    IS 13935To upgrade the earthquake resistence up to the levelof the level of the present day codes by approriatetechniques.

    CEB 1995Concepts including strengthening, repairing andremoulding

    Newman , 2001It is an upgrading of certain building system, such asmechanical, electrical, or structural, to improveperformance, function or appearance

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    3/131

    Seismic retrofitting is the modification ofexisting structures to make them more resistant

    to seismic activity, ground motion, or soil failuredue to earthquakes.

    The retrofit techniques are also applicable forother natural hazards such as tropical cyclones,tornadoes, and severe winds fromthunderstorms.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    4/131

    CIRCUMSTANCES

    (i ) earthquake damaged buildings ( ii) earthquake vulnerable buildings.

    WHEN & FOR WHAT?

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    5/131

    WHYRETROFITTING

    Thisprovestobeabetteroptioncateringtotheeconomicconsiderationsand

    immediateshelter

    problems

    rather

    than

    replacementofbuildings

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    6/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    7/131

    RETROFITPERFORMANCEOBJECTIVES STRUCTUREFUNCTIONALITY.Primarystructure

    undamagedand

    the

    structure

    is

    undiminished

    in

    utilityforitsprimaryapplication.Ahighlevelofretrofit,thisensuresthatanyrequiredrepairsare

    only

    "cosmetic"

    for

    example,

    minor

    cracks

    in

    plaster,drywallandstucco.Thisistheminimumacceptablelevelofretrofitforhospitals.

    STRUCTUREUNAFFECTED.Thislevelofretrofitispreferredforhistoricstructuresofhighculturalsignificance.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    8/131

    NEEDIN

    EARTHQUAKE

    VULNERABLE

    BUILDINGS

    (a)thebuildingshavebeendesignedaccordingtoaseismiccode,butthecodehasbeenupgradedinlateryears;

    (b)buildings

    designed

    to

    meet

    the

    modern

    seismic

    codes,

    butdeficienciesexistinthedesignorconstruction;

    (c)essentialbuildingsmustbestrengthenedlikehospitalshistorical

    monuments

    and

    architectural

    buildings;

    (d)importantbuildingswhoseserviceisassumedtobeessentialevenjustafteranearthquake;

    (e)buildingstheuseofwhichhaschangedthroughtheyears;

    (f)buildings

    that

    are

    expanded,

    renovated

    or

    rebuilt.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    9/131

    SEISMICEVALUATION

    OF

    BUILDINGS

    toassesstheseismiccapacityofearthquake

    vulnerablebuildings

    or

    earthquake

    damaged

    buildingsforthefutureuse.

    helpfulfordegreeofinterventionrequiredin

    seismicallydeficientstructure

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    10/131

    Methodologies

    (i)qualitative

    methods

    (ii)analyticalmethods

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    11/131

    QUALITATIVEMETHODS

    basedonthebackgroundinformation

    availableof

    the

    building

    and

    its

    constructionsite

    architecturalandstructuraldrawings

    pastperformance

    of

    similar

    buildings

    under

    severeearthquakes,

    visualinspectionreport,

    somenon

    destructive

    test

    results.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    12/131

    methods FieldEvaluationMethod,

    RapidVisual

    Screening

    Method,

    ATC14methodologyetc.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    13/131

    AN

    ANALYTICALMETHOD

    Basedontheconsiderationofthecapacityandductilityofbuildingsonthebasisofavailabledrawings.

    METHODS

    Capacity/Demand(C/D)method, Screeningmethod,

    Pushoveranalysis,

    Nonlinearinelasticanalysisetc.

    Evaluationprocedureshouldbeverysimpleandimmediate

    based

    on

    synthetic

    information

    that

    can

    prove

    suitable

    for

    riskevaluation

    on

    large

    populations.

    Therefore,qualitativeevaluationofthebuildingsisgenerallybeingcarriedout.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    14/131

    COMPONENTSOFSEISMICEVALUATION

    METHODOLOGY

    1.CONDITIONASSESSMENTbasedon (i)

    data

    collection

    or

    information

    gathering

    of

    structuresfromarchitecturalandstructuraldrawings

    (ii)performance

    characteristics

    of

    similar

    typeof

    buildingsinpastearthquakes

    (iii)rapidevaluationofstrength,drift,materials,

    structural

    components

    and

    structural

    details.

    usedbasicallyforundamagedexistingstructures'

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    15/131

    2.VISUALINSPECTION/FIELDEVALUATION

    basedon

    observed

    distress

    and

    damage

    in

    structures.

    Visualinspectionismoreusefulfordamaged

    structureshowever

    it

    may

    also

    be

    conducted

    for

    undamagedstructures.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    16/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    17/131

    SOURCEOFWEAKNESSINRCFRAME

    BUILDING

    (i)discontinuousloadpath/interruptedload

    path/irregularload

    path

    (ii)lackofdeformationcompatibilityofstructuralmembers

    (iii)qualityofworkmanshipandpoorqualityofmaterials

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    18/131

    CONCRETE

    RETROFITTING

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    19/131

    BASICCONCEPTS

    at

    (CEB,

    1997):

    (a)upgradationofthelateralstrengthofthe

    structure;

    (b)increaseintheductilityofstructure;

    (c)

    increase

    in

    strength

    and

    ductility.

    It is suggested that the cost of retrofitting of a

    structure should remain below 25% of thereplacement as major justification of retrofitting

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    20/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    21/131

    CONSIDERATIONINRETROFITTINGOF

    STRUCTURES

    METHODUSEDdependson

    thehorizontal

    and

    vertical

    load

    resisting

    systemofthestructure

    the

    type

    of

    materials

    used

    for

    parent

    construction.

    Onthetechnologythatisfeasibleand

    economical.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    22/131

    CONSIDERATIONINRETROFITTINGOF

    STRUCTURES

    SELECTIONOFRETROFITTINGMETHODSOF

    BUILDINGSALSO

    DEPENDS

    ON:

    asderivedfromtheearthquakedamagesurveysby

    understandingof

    mode

    of

    failure,

    structuralbehavior

    weakandstrongdesignaspects

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    23/131

    STRUCTURALDAMAGEDUETO

    DISCONTINUOUSLOAD

    PATH

    seismicforcesshouldbeproperlycollectedby

    thehorizontal

    framing

    system

    and

    properly

    transferredintoverticallateralresisting

    system

    discontinuity/irregularityinthisloadpathorloadtransfermaycause structuraldamage

    during

    strong

    earthquakes.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    24/131

    SOURCEOFWEAKNESSINRCFRAME

    BUILDING

    (i)discontinuousloadpath/interruptedload

    path/irregularload

    path

    (ii)lackofdeformationcompatibilityofstructuralmembers

    (iii)qualityofworkmanshipandpoorqualityofmaterials

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    25/131

    STRUCTURALDAMAGEDUETO

    DISCONTINUOUSLOAD

    PATH

    seismicforcesshouldbeproperlycollectedby

    thehorizontal

    framing

    system

    and

    properly

    transferredintoverticallateralresisting

    system

    discontinuity/irregularityinthisloadpathorloadtransfermaycause structuraldamage

    during

    strong

    earthquakes.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    26/131

    STRUCTURALDAMAGEDUETOLACK

    OFDEFORMATION

    MAINPROBLEMS

    limitedamount

    of

    ductility and

    theinabilitytoredistributeloadinordertosafelywithstandthedeformationsimposedupon

    inresponsetoseismicloads.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    27/131

    STRUCTURALDAMAGEDUETOLACK

    OFDEFORMATION

    The most common regions of failurein an existing reinforced concrete frame

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    28/131

    ColoumnsIn reinforced concrete columns several interaction mechanisminfluences its lateral load behaviour. The main actions areassociated with axial, flexure, shear, and bond

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    29/131

    Beams

    Inreinforcedconcretebeams,themajor

    problemsexist

    at

    the

    right

    end,

    considering

    seismicforceslefttoright

    Abrittleshearfailurecouldoccurduetosuperposing

    of

    shear

    forces caused

    by

    verticalloadingandseismicloading.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    30/131

    Beamcolumnjoints

    incaseofstrongcolumnweakbeam

    behaviour, thejoint maybeheavilystressedafterbeam

    yieldinganddiagonalcrackingmaybeformedin

    the

    connection. Wideflexuralcracksmaydevelopatthebeamend

    partiallyattributabletotheslipofbeamreinforcement withintheconnection.

    Suchshearcrackingmayreducethestiffnessofabuilding.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    31/131

    Behaviorofbeamsforverticaland

    seismicloading

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    32/131

    QUALITY

    OF

    WORKMANSHIP

    AND

    MATERIAL

    faultyconstructionpractices

    lack

    of

    amount

    and

    detailing

    of

    reinforcement

    as

    per

    requirementofcode

    theendoflateralreinforcementisnotbentby135degree

    lackofqualitycontrol of

    design

    material

    strength

    as

    specified,

    spallingofconcretebythecorrosionofembeddedreinforcingbars,

    porousconcrete,

    ageof

    concrete,

    Propermaintenanceetc

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    33/131

    CLASSIFICATION

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    34/131

    RETROFITTINGSTRATEGIESFORRC

    BUITDINGS StructuralLevel(orGlobal)RetrofitMethods

    Twoapproaches

    (i)conventionalmethodsbasedonincreasingtheseismicresistanceofexisting

    structure

    (ii)nonconventionalmethods.basedon

    reduction

    of

    seismic

    demands.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    35/131

    CONVENTIONALMETHODS

    ADDINGNEWSHEARWALLS

    Frequentlyused

    for

    retrofitting

    of

    non

    ductile

    reinforcedconcreteframebuildings.

    Theaddedelementscanbeeithercastinplaceor

    precast

    concrete

    elements.

    Newelementspreferablybeplacedattheexteriorofthebuilding.

    Notpreferred

    in

    the

    interior

    of

    the

    structure

    to

    avoidinteriormouldings.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    36/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    37/131

    TECHNICALCONSIDERATIONS:

    (a)determining

    the

    adequacy

    of

    existing

    floor

    and

    roofslabstocarrytheseismicforces;

    (b)transferofdiaphragmshearintothenewshearwallswithdowels;

    (c)addingnewcollectoranddragmemberstothediaphragm;

    (d)increaseintheweightandconcentrationof

    shearby

    the

    addition

    of

    wall

    which

    may

    affect

    the

    foundations

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    38/131

    CONSTRUCTIONALCONSIDERATION

    tofindlocationswherewallscanbeaddedandwelllocatedwhichmayaligntothefullheightofthebuildingtominimize

    torsion

    desirabletolocatewallsadjacenttothebeambetweencolumnssothatonlyminimumslabdemolitionisrequired

    withconnectionsmadetobeamatthesidesofcolumns

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    39/131

    Thelongitudinalreinforcementmustbeplacedattheendsofthewallrunningcontinuouslythroughtheentireheight.

    thereinforcementhastopassthroughholesinslabsandaroundthebeamstoavoidinterference.

    Wallthicknessalsovariesfrom15to25cm(6to10inch)andisnormallyplacedexternally

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    40/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    41/131

    ADDING

    STEEL

    BRACINGS aneffectivesolutionwhenlargeopeningsarerequired. Potentialadvantageoverotherschemesforthe

    followingreasons:

    higherstrengthandstiffness,canbeproved, openingfornaturallightcanbemadeeasily,

    amount

    of

    work

    is

    less

    since

    foundation

    cost

    may

    be

    minimized,

    thebracingsystemaddsmuchlessweighttotheexistingstructure,

    mostoftheretrofittingworkcanbeperformedwithprefabricated

    elements

    and

    disturbance

    to

    the

    occupants

    maybeminimized.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    42/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    43/131

    TECHNICALCONSIDERATIONS

    can

    be

    used

    for

    steel

    structures

    as

    well

    as

    concretestructure.

    Theeffectiveslendernessratioofbracekeptrelativelylowsothatbracesareeffectivein

    compressionas

    well

    as

    tension,

    suggestedratioare80to60orevenlower Collector'smembersarerecommendedfor

    transferringforces

    between

    the

    frame

    and

    bracingsystem.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    44/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    45/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    46/131

    JACKETING

    Mostpopularmethodforstrengtheningofbuildingcolumns

    Steeljacket,reinforcedconcretejacket,fibrereinforcedpolymercompositejacketetc

    Purposeforjacketing:1.Toincreaseconcreteconfinement

    2.Toincreaseshearstrength

    3.

    To

    increase

    flexural

    strength

    RECTANGULARANDCIRCULARCROSSSECTIONS

    Transversefibreiswrappedalongentirecircumferenceofthememberstoincreaseconcreteconfinementandshearstrengthmember

    Forsquareorrectangularcrosssections,circular/oval/ellipticaljacketsareusedandthespacebetweenthejacketandcolumnisfilledwithconcrete.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    47/131

    Multishapedjacketsprovideahighdegreeofconfinement moreeffective.

    Rectangularjacketstypicallylacktheflexuralstiffnessneeded tofullyconfinetheconcrete.

    Circularandovaljacketsislessdesirabledueto

    1.Need

    of

    large

    space

    in

    the

    building

    2.Ovalorellipticaljacketabilitytoconfinetheconcretealongthelong

    dimensionisopentoquestion.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    48/131

    TECHNICALCONSIDERATIONSJacketing

    ObjectiveToincreasetheseismiccapacityofframedstructures.

    Jacketingofreinforcedconcretecolumnsyieldsbetterconfinementthanthatofconcretebeamswithslabs slabcauseshindrance

    Waffleslab increasedstiffnessisobtained,jacketingcolumnsandribs.

    Foundationgridsarestrengthenedandstiffenedbyjacketingtheirbeams.

    Improvethelateralstrengthandductilitybyconfinementofcompressionconcrete

    Retrofittingofafewmembersmightnotbeeffectiveenoughtoimprovetheoverallbehaviourofthestructure,iftheremainingmembers arenotductile.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    49/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    50/131

    Reinforcedconcretejacketing

    Damagedregionsoftheexistingmembersshouldberepairedpriortotheirjacketing

    Therearetwomainpurposeofjacketingofcolumns:(i)

    increase

    in

    shear

    capacity

    of

    columns

    strong

    column

    weak

    beam

    design)

    (ii)toimprovethecolumnsflexuralstrength

    Itis

    done

    by

    passing

    the

    longitudinal

    reinforcement

    through

    holes

    drilledintheslabandplacingnewconcreteinthebeamcolumnjoints.

    Rehabilitatedsectionsaredesignedinthiswaysothattheflexuralstrengthofcolumnsshouldbegreaterthanthatofthebeams.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    51/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    52/131

    Detailsforreinforcedconcretejacketing

    Propertiesofjacket hMatchwiththe existingstructure

    hCompressivestrength > existingstructuresby5N/mm

    (50kg/cm),oratleastequaltothatoftheexisting

    structure.

    Minimumwidthofjacket h10cm concretecastinplace

    4cm shotcrete.

    hMonolithic

    behaviour

    hNarrowgap topreventincreasesinflexuralcapacity.

    Minimumareaoflongitudinalh3A/fy

    hSpacing

    should

    not

    exceed

    6times

    the

    width

    of

    the

    jacket

    h% ofsteelinthejacketw.r.tthejacketareashouldbe

    limitedbetween0.015and0.04.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    53/131

    Minimumareaoftransverse hDesignedandspaced

    hMinimum

    bar

    dia

    used

    for

    ties

    is

    not

    less

    that

    10mm

    hThetiesshouldhave135degreehooks

    hDuetothedifficultyofmanufacturing135degreehooks

    onthefield,tiesmadeuptomultiplepieces,canbeused

    Shearstressintheinterface hProvideadequatesheartransfermechanismtoassured

    monolithicbehaviour.

    hrelativemovementbetweenthejacketandtheexisting

    elementshouldbeprevented.

    hChipping

    the

    concrete

    cover

    of

    the

    original

    member

    and

    rougheningitssurfacemayimprovethebondbetweenthe

    oldandthenewconcrete.

    hFoursidedjackettiesshouldbeusedtoconfine

    andforshearreinforcementinthecompositeelement.

    h1,

    2,

    3side

    jackets

    special

    reinforcement

    should

    be

    providedtoenhanceamonolithicbehaviour.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    54/131

    SteelJacketing

    Local

    strengthening

    of

    columns

    has

    been

    frequently

    accomplished

    by

    jacketing

    withsteelplates.

    Detailsofsteeljacketing

    Steelplate

    thickness hAt

    least

    6mm

    Heightofjacket hFlexuralcolumns 1.2to1.5timessplicelength

    hshearcolumnsfullheightofcolumn

    Shapeofjackets h Rectangularjacketing,prefabricatedtwoL

    shapedpanels

    hTheuseofrectangularjacketshasbeensuccessfulin

    caseofsmallsizecolumnsupto36inchwidthbut

    hasbeen

    less

    successful

    on

    larger

    rectangular

    columns.Onlargercolumns,rectangularjackets

    appeartobeincapabletoprovideadequate

    confinement.

    Bottom clearance h38 mm (1 5 inch)

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    55/131

    Bottomclearance 38mm(1.5inch)

    Gapbetweensteeljacket h25mm(1inch)fillwithcementationsgrout.

    Andconcretecolumn

    Sizeofanchorbolt h25mm(1inch)indiameter

    hBoltswereinstalledthroughpredrilledholes

    onthesteeljacket

    Numberofanchorbolts hTwoanchorboltsareintendedtostiffenthesteel

    jacketandimproveconfinementofthesplice.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    56/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    57/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    58/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    59/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    60/131

    Slab column connection

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    61/131

    Slabcolumnconnection

    The most critical structural damage is the slab column connection whichresultsinthepunchingshearfailureduetothetransferofunbalancemoments.

    Retrofitting PreventionofpunchingshearfailuresAdding concrete capitals or steelplates on both sides of slab canprevent

    punchingshear

    failure

    Foundations

    The repair and retrofitting offoundations isprincipally required due to twotypesofproblems:

    (i) the change of loads on the foundation by strengthening the

    structure

    (ii)thefailureoffoundationitself.

    In

    thefirst

    case,

    reinforced

    concrete

    jacketing

    of

    basement

    beams

    and

    the

    additionofnewpilesaredone.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    62/131

    CASESTUDIES

    CASESTUDY1:SEISMICRETROFITTINGOFRCBUILDINGWITH

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    63/131

    C S S U S S C O G O C U G

    JACKETINGANDSHEARWALLS

    TypicalFeaturesoftheBuilding

    NumberofStories eightstorieswithbasement

    Lateralload

    resisting

    system

    reinforced

    concrete

    frames

    Floorsystem two wayslabwithbeam

    Foundation gridfoundationwithretainingwallsaroundthe

    perimeter

    FeaturesofDamagesinMexicoEarthquake,1979

    Minorcracksinbeamsandcolumns

    RetrofittingTechniques

    Employed

    after

    Mexico

    Earthquake,

    1979

    Additionofconcreteshearwall inaxis2andA

    Additionofmasonrywallinaxis5

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    64/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    65/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    66/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    67/131

    RetrofittingTechniquesEmployed

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    68/131

    Crackedbeams

    and

    columns Repaired

    with

    epoxy

    injection

    ThecolumnsofFrames1and5 Encasedinsteelthroughtheforthstorey

    level

    Frame1and5Bracedsteelframeswereattachedontheoutsideofthe

    buildinginEWdirection.

    ExpectedPerformance

    Resultsindicatethatthesteelbraced

    framesattachedtothebuildingstrengthened

    andtheystiffenedthestructure,movingits

    naturalperiod

    away

    from

    the

    predominant

    groundperiodof2.0sec

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    69/131

    Thebuildingalsoexperiencedlargeinterstoreydeformationsofitsframe:

    resulting in damage to the exterior walls (both longitudinal and transverse).

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    70/131

    resultingindamagetotheexteriorwalls(bothlongitudinaland transverse).

    Thelongitudinal

    and

    transverse

    partition

    walls

    were

    badly

    cracked

    at

    several

    levels

    Noindicationsofthefoundationfailurewereobserved.

    RetrofittingTechniques

    Employed

    Diagonalsteel

    bracing wasaddedto

    thecentralbayof

    frames1,

    2and

    3in

    the

    transversedirection

    Insertionofnew

    reinforcedconcrete

    infillwalls of4cm

    thicknessto

    all

    bays

    of

    theexteriorlongitudinal

    frames

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    71/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    72/131

    CASESTUDY5:SEISMICRETROFITTING OFRCBUILDINGWITHSHEAR WALLS

    ANDJACKETING

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    73/131

    TypicalFeaturesoftheBuilding

    Numberofstories Eightstoreyreinforcedconcreteapartmentbuilding

    Buildingdimension floorarea245m andstoreyheightis3.0mabovethe

    foundationlevel,includingpenthouse

    Designand

    construction

    1984

    Lateralloadresistingsystems momentresistingRCframes.Astructuralwall

    aroundtheelevator

    Floorsystem concreteslabsinthefirststoriesandjustslabsinthetoptwo

    stories

    Foundationsystem stripfoundationinboththedirection.

    FeaturesofDamagesinAdana Ceyhan(Turkey)Earthquake,1998

    Buildingundermoderatedamagecategory

    Extensivedamage

    was

    observed

    in

    beams

    especially

    between

    the

    first

    and

    fifth

    floors

    RetrofittingTechniquesEmployed

    Infillingof

    appropriate

    frame

    bays

    by

    in

    situ

    reinforced

    concrete

    shear

    walls with

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    74/131

    CASESTUDY6:SEISMICRETROFITTINGOFRC BUILDINGBYADDING

    FRAMES

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    75/131

    FRAMES

    TypicalFeaturesofthebuilding

    Numberofstories eightstoriesconsistingofgroundfloorwithseven

    upperfloors

    Typicalfeatures

    soft

    storey,

    mixed

    construction

    masonry

    with

    reinforced

    concrete

    Yearofconstruction 1979

    Lateralloadresistingsystems masonrybearingwallsexceptattheground

    floor.Columnsareonlyatthegroundfloor

    Floorsystem

    waffle

    slab

    at

    the

    first

    level

    and

    beam

    block

    slab

    at

    the

    otherlevels

    Foundationsystem gridandslabwithfrictionpileslocatedundereach

    column

    Typicalfloor

    plan

    and

    elevation

    FeaturesofDamagesinMexicoEarthquake,1985

    Severedamageoccurredinmasonrywalls

    Foundationofthecolumnsatthefirstlevelsufferednodamage

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    76/131

    Principal

    failure

    direction

    was

    east

    west

    due

    to

    irregularities

    in

    plan

    andinsufficientareaofwallsineast westdirection.

    RetrofittingTechniquesEmployed

    Addingofreinforcedconcreteframesovertheexistingcolumnin the

    groundfloor

    along

    axis

    1,3,

    4and

    6

    Addingtwoconcreteshearwallsfromfirstleveltotheupperstoreywere

    placedinaxis3and4

    Theexistingmasonrywallswereretrofittedusingwiremeshand30mm

    of

    mortarThecoveroftheexistingcolumnswasremovedtopermitthecontinuity

    ofthenewlongitudinalreinforcement. Thedimensionsoftheexisting

    columnswereincreased

    Themonolithicbehaviourbetweenthenewframesandthefloorsystem

    wasprovided

    by

    eliminating

    part

    of

    the

    floor

    system

    so

    that

    the new

    reinforcementoftheframewascasttogetherwithslab

    Foundation Thefoundationgridwasencasedtopermittheanchorage

    tothenewlongitudinalreinforcement

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    77/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    78/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    79/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    80/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    81/131

    NECESSITY OF RETROFITTING OF EXISTING MASONRY

    BUILDINGS

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    82/131

    Majority of seismically deficient buildings.

    Economic considerations & immediate shelter requirements

    Earthquake damaged buildings cant be replaced or rebuilt in a shorttime.

    Retrofitting schemes depend upon :-

    1)Material of parent construction

    2) type of masonry

    3) location and amount of damage

    4) Failure mode

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    83/131

    1) OUT OF PLANE FAILURE:

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    84/131

    Structural walls perpendicular to seismic motion subjected toout-of-plane bending.

    vertical cracks at corners andmiddle of walls

    CAUSE

    Inadequate anchorage of thewall into the roof diaphragm.

    Limited tensile strength ofmasonry & mortar

    Resulting flexural stress exceedstensile strength of masonry

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    85/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    86/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    87/131

    3) DIAPHRAGM FAILURE

    R h i th t f i i ti

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    88/131

    Rare phenomenon in the event of seismic motion.

    Damage to the diaphragm never impairs its gravity load carrying capacity.

    CAUSE - Lack of tension anchoring produces a non-bending cantilever

    action at the base of the wall resulting from the push of diaphragm against

    the wall.

    The in-plane rotation of the diaphragm ends and the absence of a

    good shear transfer between diaphragms and reacting walls

    RESULT - damage at the corners of the wall.

    In strengthened buildings, separation remains worse at or near the centerlineof the diaphragm.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    89/131

    4) FAILURE OF CONNECTION

    Seismic inertial forces that originate in all elements of the building are

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    90/131

    Seismic inertial forces that originate in all elements of the building aredelivered to horizontal diaphragms through structural connections.

    FORCE DISTRIBUTIONdiaphragms vertical elements foundation.

    * transfer in-plane shear stress from the diaphragms to the verticalelements

    to provide support to out-of-plan forces on these elements

    diagonal cracks disposed on both the walls edges causingseparation and collapse of corner zones.

    inadequately strengthened openings near the walls edges and byfloors insufficiently connected to the external walls.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    91/131

    5) NON-STRUCTURAL COMPONENTS

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    92/131

    These non-structural elements behave like cantilevers if they remainunrestrained and are subjected to greater amplification as compared to groundmotion becoming prone to failures.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    93/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    94/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    95/131

    2. Local/Member Retrofitting

    It enhances the shear resistance of un-reinforced masonry componentsespecially against in-plane forces

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    96/131

    especially against in plane forces.

    Feasible retrofitting techniques are:

    (1)surface coatings

    (2) Shotcrete overlays or adhered fabric with wire mesh or FRP materials

    (3) use of RC and steel frames in openings.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    97/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    98/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    99/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    100/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    101/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    102/131

    THROUGH STONES/BOND STONES

    "Through" stones of full-length equal to wall thickness may be inserted at an

    interval of 0.6 m in vertical direction atI.2m in horizontal direction.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    103/131

    In the non-availability of full-length stones, stones in pairs each of about3/4 of thewall thickness may be used providing an overlap between them.

    use of "S" shape elements of bars 8 to 10 or a hooked link with a cover of 25 mmfrom each face of the wall or wooden bars of size 38 mm x 38 mm cross section orequivalent.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    104/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    105/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    106/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    107/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    108/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    109/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    110/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    111/131

    STRUCTURAL OVERLAY / ADHERED

    FABRIC

    FRP used for repair and retrofitting

    high strength to weight ratio

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    112/131

    high strength to weight ratioStiffness to weight ratiocorrosion resistant

    fatigue resistant

    Adhered fabric materials - Carbon Fibre Reinforced Plastic (CFRP) sheets

    Glass Fibre Reinforced Polymer (GFRP) sheets

    latest developments as medium of retrofitting of RC structures.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    113/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    114/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    115/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    116/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    117/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    118/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    119/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    120/131

    CONNECTION BETWEEN INTERSECTING WALLSSTITCHING OF WALL CORNERS

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    121/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    122/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    123/131

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    124/131

    2) Creation of a composite structure formed by the wood structure and by areinforced concrete thin slab.

    Requires complicated operations and the use of resins or special screws, toensure the cooperation between the reinforced concrete slab and the woodgirders.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    125/131

    PRE-STRESSING

    To increase the lateral strength, stability and integrated behavior of load bearing

    walls, prestressing is very effective and viable method of retrofitting.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    126/131

    In prestressing of wall, two steel rods are placed on the two sides of the wall and

    tightened by turnbuckles.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    127/131

    SPLINT AND BANDAGE TECHNIQUE

    to strengthen the walls as well as bind them together economically.

    The horizontal bands are called bandage while vertical steel are called splints.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    128/131

    g p

    The welded mesh type of steel is to be provided on both outdoor and inner surfaces at

    critical sections.

    The welded mesh should be nailed to the masonry and then be covered with micro-

    concrete.

    As a minimum provision these must be provided on all-external walls along with cross-tiebars across the building in both directions and embedded in external bands.

    The cross-tie bars are necessary to ensure integral action of bearing walls like a crate.

    INSERTING NEW WALLS

    To increase strength and to correct deficiency caused due to asymmetry.

    The main problem in such modification is the connection of new wall with

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    129/131

    old wall.

    The link to the old walls is maintained by means of a number of keysmade in old walls.

    EXTERIOR SUPPLEMENTAL ELEMENTS

    Provision of shear walls at the perimeter of the building or external buttresses

    To increase in-plane strength of the existing masonry walls

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    130/131

    Must have sufficient capacity against overturning forces and uplift forces

    Requires an additional foundation

    It should have proper connection with the existing walls through dowel so that the

    forces are transferred from the existing building to the new external vertical resisting

    elements

    This technique has limitations in case of buildings constructed at the property lines or

    not having much space.

    STRENGTHENING OF PARAPETS

    * bracing parapets, roofs and connecting floor diaphragms towalls through anchor.

  • 7/30/2019 26647449 Retrofitting of Earthquake Affected Buildings Ppt

    131/131

    * parapets with height to thickness ration of less than 2.5 to bestable and in no need of strengthening.