2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · pdf filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝...

36

Upload: buitu

Post on 16-Mar-2018

220 views

Category:

Documents


3 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · PDF filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝ cbg9fj5h=cb% 5kg z $cdglc? lbb gqasqqlsajc?pbca?w z 3r?rcr fcam lqcpt?rgmlj?uq z %vnj?gln ?pclr?

�� 2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3

�=;IF9����� 4FC�QWLAFPMRPML�QMSPAC�NPMBSACQ�CJCARPMK?ELCRGA�P?BG?RGML��?Q�CTGBCLR�DPMK�RFC�TGQG@JC�EJMU���APCBGR��5LGRCB�3R?RCQ�$CN?PRKCLR�MD�%LCPEW��TG?�7GIGKCBG?

#MKKMLQ

,C?PLGLE�/@HCARGTCQ����� 'I7@95F�+58=C57H=J=HM

z %VNJ?GL�LSAJC?P�P?BG?RGML�

z %VNJ?GL�RFC�RWNCQ�MD�P?BG?RGMLu?JNF?�CKGQQGML��@CR?�CKGQQGML��?LB�E?KK?�CKGQQGML�

z %VNJ?GL�RFC�GMLGX?RGML�MD�P?BG?RGML�GL�?L�?RMK�

z $CDGLC�RFC�P?LEC�MD�P?BG?RGML�

����� +58=5H=CB��9H97H=CB�5B8��9H97HCFG

z %VNJ?GL�RFC�UMPIGLE�NPGLAGNJC�MD�?�'CGECP�RS@C�

z $CDGLC�?LB�BGQASQQ�P?BG?RGML�BCRCARMPQ�

����� ,I6GHFI7HIF9�C:�H<9�'I7@9IG

z $CDGLC�?LB�BGQASQQ�RFC�LSAJCSQ�GL�?L�?RMK�

z $CDGLC�?RMKGA�LSK@CP�

z $CDGLC�?LB�BGQASQQ�GQMRMNCQ�

z #?JASJ?RC�RFC�BCLQGRW�MD�RFC�LSAJCSQ�

z %VNJ?GL�LSAJC?P�DMPAC�

����� 'I7@95F��975M�5B8��CBG9FJ5H=CB�%5KG

z $CDGLC�?LB�BGQASQQ�LSAJC?P�BCA?W�

z 3R?RC�RFC�AMLQCPT?RGML�J?UQ�

z %VNJ?GL�N?PCLR�?LB�B?SEFRCP�LSAJCSQ�

z #?JASJ?RC�RFC�CLCPEW�CKGRRCB�BSPGLE�LSAJC?P�BCA?W�

����� !5@:%=:9�5B8��7H=J=HM

z $CDGLC�F?JD JGDC�

z $CDGLC�B?RGLE�

z #?JASJ?RC�?EC�MD�MJB�M@HCARQ�@W�P?BGM?ARGTC�B?RGLE�

����� �=B8=B;��B9F;M

z $CDGLC�?LB�BGQASQQ�@GLBGLE�CLCPEW�

z #?JASJ?RC�RFC�@GLBGLE�CLCPEW�NCP�LSAJCML�MD�?�N?PRGAJC�

����� -IBB9@=B;

z $CDGLC�?LB�BGQASQQ�RSLLCJGLE�

z $CDGLC�NMRCLRG?J�@?PPGCP�

z %VNJ?GL�OS?LRSK�RSLLCJGLE�

#(!04%2����Y�2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3 ����

Page 2: 2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · PDF filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝ cbg9fj5h=cb% 5kg z $cdglc? lbb gqasqqlsajc?pbca?w z 3r?rcr fcam lqcpt?rgmlj?uq z %vnj?gln ?pclr?

"BHFC8I7H=CB�HC�+58=C57H=J=HM�5B8�'I7@95F�)<MG=7G

4FCPC�GQ�?L�MLEMGLE�OSCQR�RM�DGLB�QS@QRPSARSPCQ�MD�K?RRCP��!R�MLC�RGKC��GR�U?Q�RFMSEFR�RF?R�?RMKQ�UMSJB�@C�RFC�SJRGK?RC�QS@QRPSARSPC��@SR�HSQR�UFCL�RFC

DGPQR�BGPCAR�CTGBCLAC�MD�?RMKQ�U?Q�M@R?GLCB��GR�@CA?KC�AJC?P�RF?R�RFCW�F?TC�?�QS@QRPSARSPC�?LB�?�RGLW AH6?8HF��4FC�LSAJCSQ�GRQCJD�F?Q�QNCAR?ASJ?P

AF?P?ARCPGQRGAQ��&MP�CV?KNJC��ACPR?GL�LSAJCG�?PC�SLQR?@JC��?LB�RFCGP�BCA?W�CKGRQ�P?BG?RGMLQ�UGRF�CLCPEGCQ�KGJJGMLQ�MD�RGKCQ�EPC?RCP�RF?L�?RMKGA

CLCPEGCQ��3MKC�MD�RFC�KWQRCPGCQ�MD�L?RSPC��QSAF�?Q�UFW�RFC�AMPC�MD�RFC�C?PRF�PCK?GLQ�KMJRCL�?LB�FMU�RFC�QSL�NPMBSACQ�GRQ�CLCPEW��?PC�CVNJ?GLCB�@W

LSAJC?P�NFCLMKCL?��4FC�CVNJMP?RGML�MD E47<B46G<I<GL ?LB�RFC�LSAJCSQ�PCTC?JCB�DSLB?KCLR?J�?LB�NPCTGMSQJW�SLILMUL�N?PRGAJCQ��DMPACQ��?LB

AMLQCPT?RGML�J?UQ��4F?R�CVNJMP?RGML�F?Q�CTMJTCB�GLRM�?�QC?PAF�DMP�DSPRFCP�SLBCPJWGLE�QRPSARSPCQ��QSAF�?Q�OS?PIQ��)L�RFGQ�AF?NRCP��RFC�DSLB?KCLR?JQ�MD

LSAJC?P�P?BGM?ARGTGRW�?LB�RFC�LSAJCSQ�?PC�CVNJMPCB��4FC�DMJJMUGLE�RUM�AF?NRCPQ�CVNJMPC�RFC�KMPC�GKNMPR?LR�?NNJGA?RGMLQ�MD�LSAJC?P�NFWQGAQ�GL�RFC�DGCJB

MD�KCBGAGLC��7C�UGJJ�?JQM�CVNJMPC�RFC�@?QGAQ�MD�UF?R�UC�ILMU�?@MSR�OS?PIQ�?LB�MRFCP�QS@QRPSARSPCQ�QK?JJCP�RF?L�LSAJCG�

���� 'I7@95F�+58=C57H=J=HM

4FC�BGQAMTCPW�?LB�QRSBW�MD�LSAJC?P�P?BGM?ARGTGRW�OSGAIJW�PCTC?JCB�CTGBCLAC�MD�PCTMJSRGML?PW�LCU�NFWQGAQ��)L�?BBGRGML��SQCQ�DMP�LSAJC?P�P?BG?RGML�?JQM

CKCPECB�OSGAIJWuDMP�CV?KNJC��NCMNJC�QSAF�?Q�%PLCQR�2SRFCPDMPB�SQCB�GR�RM�BCRCPKGLC�RFC�QGXC�MD�RFC�LSAJCSQ�?LB�BCTGACQ�UCPC�N?GLRCB�UGRF�P?BML

BMNCB�N?GLR�RM�K?IC�RFCK�EJMU�GL�RFC�B?PI��QCC �=;IF9�������7C�RFCPCDMPC�@CEGL�MSP�QRSBW�MD�LSAJC?P�NFWQGAQ�UGRF�RFC�BGQAMTCPW�?LB�@?QGA�DC?RSPCQ

MD�LSAJC?P�P?BGM?ARGTGRW�

�=;IF9����� 4FC�BG?JQ�MD�RFGQ�7MPJB�7?P�))�?GPAP?DR�EJMU�GL�RFC�B?PI��@CA?SQC�RFCW�?PC�N?GLRCB�UGRF�P?BGSK BMNCB�NFMQNFMPCQACLR�N?GLR��)R�GQ�?�NMGEL?LR�PCKGLBCP�MD�RFC�BS?J

L?RSPC�MD�P?BG?RGML��!JRFMSEF�P?BGSK�N?GLR�BG?JQ�?PC�AMLTCLGCLRJW�TGQG@JC�B?W�?LB�LGEFR��RFCW�CKGR�P?BML��?�P?BGM?ARGTC�E?Q�RF?R�GQ�F?X?PBMSQ�?LB�GQ�LMR�BGPCARJW�QCLQCB���APCBGR�

5�3��!GP�&MPAC�0FMRM

$GQAMTCPW�MD�.SAJC?P�2?BGM?ARGTGRW

)L�������RFC�&PCLAF�NFWQGAGQR�!LRMGLC�(CLPG�"CAOSCPCJ������t�����?AAGBCLR?JJW�DMSLB�RF?R�?�SP?LGSK PGAF�KGLCP?J�A?JJCB�NGRAF@JCLBC�CKGRQ�GLTGQG@JC�

NCLCRP?RGLE�P?WQ�RF?R�A?L�B?PICL�?�NFMRMEP?NFGA�NJ?RC�CLAJMQCB�GL�?L�MN?OSC�CLTCJMNC��4FC�P?WQ�RFCPCDMPC�A?PPW�CLCPEW��@SR�?K?XGLEJW��RFC

NGRAF@JCLBC�CKGRQ�RFCK�AMLRGLSMSQJW�UGRFMSR�?LW�CLCPEW�GLNSR��4FGQ�GQ�?L�?NN?PCLR�TGMJ?RGML�MD�RFC�J?U�MD�AMLQCPT?RGML�MD�CLCPEW��MLC�RF?R�UC�LMU

SLBCPQR?LB�GQ�BSC�RM�RFC�AMLTCPQGML�MD�?�QK?JJ�?KMSLR�MD�K?QQ�GLRM�CLCPEW��?Q�PCJ?RCB�GL�%GLQRCGLwQ�D?KMSQ�COS?RGML ��)R�U?Q�QMML�CTGBCLR

RF?R�"CAOSCPCJwQ�P?WQ�MPGEGL?RC�GL�RFC�LSAJCG�MD�RFC�?RMKQ�?LB�F?TC�MRFCP�SLGOSC�AF?P?ARCPGQRGAQ��4FC�CKGQQGML�MD�RFCQC�P?WQ�GQ�A?JJCB BI7@95F

F58=C57H=J=HM MP�QGKNJW F58=C57H=J=HM��4FC�P?WQ�RFCKQCJTCQ�?PC�A?JJCB BI7@95F�F58=5H=CB��!�LSAJCSQ�RF?R�QNMLR?LCMSQJW�BCQRPMWQ�N?PR�MD�GRQ�K?QQ�RM

CKGR�P?BG?RGML�GQ�Q?GB�RM 8975M �?�RCPK�?JQM�SQCB�RM�BCQAPG@C�RFC�CKGQQGML�MD�P?BG?RGML�@W�?RMKQ�GL�CVAGRCB�QR?RCQ��!�QS@QR?LAC�MP�M@HCAR�RF?R�CKGRQ

LSAJC?P�P?BG?RGML�GQ�Q?GB�RM�@C F58=C57H=J9�

4UM�RWNCQ�MD�CVNCPGKCLR?J�CTGBCLAC�GKNJW�RF?R�"CAOSCPCJwQ�P?WQ�MPGEGL?RC�BCCN�GL�RFC�FC?PR��MP�LSAJCSQ�MD�?L�?RMK��&GPQR��RFC�P?BG?RGML�GQ�DMSLB�RM�@C

?QQMAG?RCB�UGRF�ACPR?GL�CJCKCLRQ��QSAF�?Q�SP?LGSK��2?BG?RGML�BMCQ�LMR�T?PW�UGRF�AFCKGA?J�QR?RCuRF?R�GQ��SP?LGSK�GQ�P?BGM?ARGTC�UFCRFCP�GR�GQ�GL�RFC

DMPK�MD�?L�CJCKCLR�MP�AMKNMSLB��)L�?BBGRGML��P?BG?RGML�BMCQ�LMR�T?PW�UGRF�RCKNCP?RSPC��NPCQQSPC��MP�GMLGX?RGML�QR?RC�MD�RFC�SP?LGSK�?RMK��3GLAC�?JJ�MD

RFCQC�D?ARMPQ�?DDCAR�CJCARPMLQ�GL�?L�?RMK��RFC�P?BG?RGML�A?LLMR�AMKC�DPMK�CJCARPML�RP?LQGRGMLQ��?Q�?RMKGA�QNCARP?�BM��4FC�FSEC�CLCPEW�CKGRRCB�BSPGLE

C?AF�CTCLR�GQ�RFC�QCAMLB�NGCAC�MD�CTGBCLAC�RF?R�RFC�P?BG?RGML�A?LLMR�@C�?RMKGA��.SAJC?P�P?BG?RGML�F?Q�CLCPEGCQ�MD�RFC�MPBCP�MD NCP�CTCLR�

UFGAF�GQ�KSAF�EPC?RCP�RF?L�RFC�RWNGA?J�?RMKGA�CLCPEGCQ��?�DCU ��QSAF�?Q�RF?R�M@QCPTCB�GL�QNCARP?�?LB�AFCKGA?J�PC?ARGMLQ��?LB�KMPC�RF?L�RCL

RGKCQ�?Q�FGEF�?Q�RFC�KMQR�CLCPECRGA�AF?P?ARCPGQRGA�V�P?WQ��"CAOSCPCJ�BGB�LMR�TGEMPMSQJW�NSPQSC�FGQ�BGQAMTCPW�DMP�TCPW�JMLE��)L�������-?PGC�#SPGC

�����t������RFCL�?�EP?BS?RC�QRSBCLR�K?PPGCB�RFC�?JPC?BW�UCJJ ILMUL�&PCLAF�NFWQGAGQR�0GCPPC�#SPGC������t������@CE?L�FCP�BMARMP?J�QRSBW�MD

"CAOSCPCJwQ�P?WQ��3FC�?LB�FCP�FSQ@?LB�QMML�BGQAMTCPCB�RUM�LCU�P?BGM?ARGTC�CJCKCLRQ��UFGAF�QFC�L?KCB CB?BA<H@ �?DRCP�FCP�L?RGTC�J?LB�?LB

E47<H@ �@CA?SQC�GR�P?BG?RCQ��4FCQC�RUM�LCU�CJCKCLRQ�DGJJCB�FMJCQ�GL�RFC�NCPGMBGA�R?@JC�?LB��DSPRFCP��BGQNJ?WCB�KSAF�FGEFCP�JCTCJQ�MD�P?BGM?ARGTGRW�NCP

EP?K�MD�K?RCPG?J�RF?L�SP?LGSK��/TCP�?�NCPGMB�MD�DMSP�WC?PQ��UMPIGLE�SLBCP�NMMP�AMLBGRGMLQ�?LB�QNCLBGLE�RFCGP�MUL�DSLBQ��RFC�#SPGCQ�NPMACQQCB�KMPC

RF?L�?�RML�MD�SP?LGSK�MPC�RM�GQMJ?RC�?�EP?K�MD�P?BGSK�Q?JR��2?BGSK�@CA?KC�FGEFJW�QMSEFR�?DRCP��@CA?SQC�GR�U?Q�?@MSR�RUM�KGJJGML�RGKCQ�?Q�P?BGM?ARGTC

?Q�SP?LGSK��#SPGCwQ�P?BGSK�Q?JR�EJMUCB�TGQG@JW�DPMK�RFC�P?BG?RGML�RF?R�RMMI�GRQ�RMJJ�ML�RFCK�?LB�MRFCP�SL?U?PC�PCQC?PAFCPQ��3FMPRJW�?DRCP�AMKNJCRGLE�FCP

0F�$���@MRF�#SPGCQ�?LB�"CAOSCPCJ�QF?PCB�RFC������.M@CJ�0PGXC�GL�NFWQGAQ�DMP�RFCGP�UMPI�ML�P?BGM?ARGTGRW��0GCPPC�U?Q�IGJJCB�GL�?�FMPQC�A?PR�?AAGBCLR�GL

������@SR�-?PGC�AMLRGLSCB�FCP�QRSBW�MD�P?BGM?ARGTGRW�DMP�LC?PJW����KMPC�WC?PQ��!U?PBCB�RFC������.M@CJ�0PGXC�GL�AFCKGQRPW�DMP�FCP�BGQAMTCPW�MD�RUM

LCU�CJCKCLRQ��QFC�PCK?GLQ�RFC�MLJW�NCPQML�RM�UGL�.M@CJ�0PGXCQ�GL�NFWQGAQ�?LB�AFCKGQRPW��-?PGCwQ�P?BGM?ARGTC�DGLECPNPGLRQ�ML�QMKC�N?ECQ�MD�FCP

LMRC@MMIQ�A?L�QRGJJ�CVNMQC�DGJK��?LB�QFC�QSDDCPCB�DPMK�P?BG?RGML GLBSACB�JCQGMLQ��3FC�BGCB�MD�JCSICKG?�JGICJW�A?SQCB�@W�P?BG?RGML��@SR�QFC�U?Q�?ARGTC

GL�PCQC?PAF�?JKMQR�SLRGJ�FCP�BC?RF�GL�������4FC�DMJJMUGLE�WC?P��FCP�B?SEFRCP�?LB�QML GL J?U��)PCLC�?LB�&PCBCPGA�*MJGMR #SPGC��UCPC�?U?PBCB�RFC�.M@CJ

0PGXC�GL�AFCKGQRPW�DMP�RFCGP�BGQAMTCPW�MD�?PRGDGAG?JJW�GLBSACB�P?BG?RGML��?BBGLE�RM�?�PCK?PI?@JC�D?KGJW�JCE?AW�

!JNF?��"CR?��?LB�'?KK?

2CQC?PAF�@CESL�@W�NCMNJC�QSAF�?Q�.CU�:C?J?LBCP�%PLCQR�2SRFCPDMPB�QMML�?DRCP�RFC�BGQAMTCPW�MD�LSAJC?P�P?BG?RGML�GLBGA?RCB�RF?R�BGDDCPCLR�RWNCQ�MD

P?WQ�?PC�CKGRRCB��%TCLRS?JJW��RFPCC�RWNCQ�UCPC�BGQRGLESGQFCB�?LB�L?KCB 5@D<5 � 69H5 ��?LB ;5AA5 ��@CA?SQC��JGIC�V P?WQ��RFCGP�GBCLRGRGCQ

UCPC�GLGRG?JJW�SLILMUL� �=;IF9����� QFMUQ�UF?R�F?NNCLQ�GD�RFC�P?WQ�?PC�N?QQCB�RFPMSEF�?�K?ELCRGA�DGCJB��4FC Q�?PC�SL?DDCARCB��UFGJC�RFC Q�?LB

���� #(!04%2����Y�2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3

4FGQ�AMLRCLR�GQ�?T?GJ?@JC�DMP�DPCC�?R�FRRN���ALV�MPE�AMLRCLR�AMJ���������

Page 3: 2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · PDF filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝ cbg9fj5h=cb% 5kg z $cdglc? lbb gqasqqlsajc?pbca?w z 3r?rcr fcam lqcpt?rgmlj?uq z %vnj?gln ?pclr?

Q�?PC�BCDJCARCB�GL�MNNMQGRC�BGPCARGMLQ��GLBGA?RGLE�RFC Q�?PC�NMQGRGTC��RFC Q�LCE?RGTC��?LB�RFC Q�SLAF?PECB��2SRFCPDMPB�SQCB�@MRF�K?ELCRGA

?LB�CJCARPGA�DGCJBQ�RM�QFMU�RF?R Q�F?TC�?�NMQGRGTC�AF?PEC�RUGAC�RFC�K?ELGRSBC�MD�?L�CJCARPML��MP ��)L�RFC�NPMACQQ��FC�DMSLB�RFC Q

AF?PEC�RM�K?QQ�P?RGM�RM�@C�QCTCP?J�RFMSQ?LB�RGKCQ�QK?JJCP�RF?L�RFC�CJCARPMLwQ��,?RCP�ML��2SRFCPDMPB�AMJJCARCB Q�DPMK�?�P?BGM?ARGTC�QMSPAC�?LB

N?QQCB�?L�CJCARPGA�BGQAF?PEC�RFPMSEF�RFCK��M@R?GLGLE�RFC�QNCARPSK�MD�PCACLRJW�BGQAMTCPCB�FCJGSK�E?Q��!KMLE�K?LW�GKNMPR?LR�BGQAMTCPGCQ�K?BC�@W

2SRFCPDMPB�?LB�FGQ�AMJJ?@MP?RMPQ�U?Q�RFC�NPMMD�RF?R E47<4G<BA�<F�G;8�8@<FF<BA�B9�4�;8?<H@�AH6?8HF��2SRFCPDMPB�UML�RFC�.M@CJ�0PGXC�GL�AFCKGQRPW�GL

�����DMP�FGQ�C?PJW�UMPI��(C�AMLRGLSCB�RM�K?IC�GKNMPR?LR�AMLRPG@SRGMLQ�SLRGJ�FGQ�BC?RF�GL������

�=;IF9����� !JNF?��@CR?��?LB�E?KK?�P?WQ�?PC�N?QQCB�RFPMSEF�?�K?ELCRGA�DGCJB�ML�RFC�U?W�RM�?�NFMQNFMPCQACLR�QAPCCL��4FC Q�?LB Q�@CLB�GL�MNNMQGRC�BGPCARGMLQ��UFGJC

RFC Q�?PC�SL?DDCARCB��GLBGA?RGLE�?�NMQGRGTC�AF?PEC�DMP Q��LCE?RGTC�DMP Q��?LB�LCSRP?J�DMP Q��#MLQGQRCLR�PCQSJRQ�?PC�M@R?GLCB�UGRF�CJCARPGA�DGCJBQ��#MJJCARGML�MD�RFC

P?BG?RGML�MDDCPQ�DSPRFCP�AMLDGPK?RGML�DPMK�RFC�BGPCAR�KC?QSPCKCLR�MD�CVACQQ�AF?PEC�

/RFCP�PCQC?PAFCPQ�F?B�?JPC?BW�NPMTCB�RF?R Q�?PC�LCE?RGTC�?LB�F?TC�RFC�Q?KC�K?QQ�?LB�Q?KC�AF?PEC RM K?QQ�P?RGM�?Q�RFC�PCACLRJW�BGQAMTCPCB

CJCARPML��"W�������GR�U?Q�PCAMELGXCB�RF?R E47<4G<BA�<F�G;8�8@<FF<BA�B9�4A�8?86GEBA��!JRFMSEF Q�?PC�CJCARPMLQ��RFCW�BM�LMR�CVGQR�GL�RFC�LSAJCSQ

@CDMPC�GR�BCA?WQ�?LB�?PC�LMR�CHCARCB�?RMKGA�CJCARPMLQuRFC�CJCARPML�GQ�APC?RCB�GL�RFC�LSAJCSQ�?R�RFC�GLQR?LR�MD�BCA?W�

3GLAC Q�PCK?GL�SL?DDCARCB�@W�CJCARPGA�?LB�K?ELCRGA�DGCJBQ��GR�GQ�L?RSP?J�RM�RFGLI�RFCW�KGEFR�@C�NFMRMLQ��%TGBCLAC�DMP�RFGQ�EPCU��@SR�GR�U?Q�LMR�SLRGJ

�����RF?R�RFGQ�U?Q�NPMTCB�@W�2SRFCPDMPB�?LB�AMJJ?@MP?RMPQ��"W�QA?RRCPGLE P?BG?RGML�DPMK�?�APWQR?J�?LB�M@QCPTGLE�GLRCPDCPCLAC��RFCW�BCKMLQRP?RCB

RF?R E47<4G<BA�<F�G;8�8@<FF<BA�B9�4�;<:;�8A8E:L�C;BGBA�5L�4�AH6?8HF��)L�D?AR� P?BG?RGML�AMKCQ�DPMK�RFC�BC CVAGR?RGML�MD�?�LSAJCSQ��HSQR�?Q�?L�V�P?W

AMKCQ�DPMK�RFC�BC CVAGR?RGML�MD�?L�?RMK��4FC�L?KCQ�� P?W��?LB��V�P?W��GBCLRGDW�RFC�QMSPAC�MD�RFC�P?BG?RGML��!R�RFC�Q?KC�CLCPEW� P?WQ�?LB�V�P?WQ

?PC�MRFCPUGQC�GBCLRGA?J�

4?@JC����� 0PMNCPRGCQ�MD�.SAJC?P�2?BG?RGML

-MD9�C:�+58=5H=CB +5B;9

0?PRGAJCQ !�QFCCR�MD�N?NCP��?�DCU�AK�MD�?GP��DP?ARGMLQ�MD�?�KK�MD�RGQQSC

0?PRGAJCQ !�RFGL�?JSKGLSK�NJ?RC��MP�RCLQ�MD�AK�MD�RGQQSC

2?WQ 3CTCP?J�AK�MD�JC?B�MP�KCRCPQ�MD�AMLAPCRC

)MLGX?RGML�?LB�2?LEC

4UM�MD�RFC�KMQR�GKNMPR?LR�AF?P?ARCPGQRGAQ�MD � ��?LB P?WQ�UCPC�PCAMELGXCB�TCPW�C?PJW��!JJ�RFPCC�RWNCQ�MD�LSAJC?P�P?BG?RGML�NPMBSAC <BA<M4G<BA GL

K?RCPG?JQ��@SR�RFCW�NCLCRP?RC�BGDDCPCLR�BGQR?LACQ�GL�K?RCPG?JQuRF?R�GQ��RFCW�F?TC�BGDDCPCLR E4A:8F��,CR�SQ�CV?KGLC�UFW�RFCW�F?TC�RFCQC�AF?P?ARCPGQRGAQ

?LB�UF?R�?PC�QMKC�MD�RFC�AMLQCOSCLACQ�

,GIC�V�P?WQ��LSAJC?P�P?BG?RGML�GL�RFC�DMPK�MD Q� Q��?LB Q�F?Q�CLMSEF�CLCPEW�NCP�CTCLR�RM�GMLGXC�?RMKQ�?LB�KMJCASJCQ�GL�?LW�K?RCPG?J��4FC

CLCPEW�CKGRRCB�GL�T?PGMSQ�LSAJC?P�BCA?WQ�P?LECQ�DPMK�?�DCU RM�KMPC�RF?L ��UFGJC�MLJW�?�DCU ?PC�LCCBCB�RM�NPMBSAC�GMLGX?RGML�

4FC�CDDCARQ�MD�V�P?WQ�?LB�LSAJC?P�P?BG?RGML�ML�@GMJMEGA?J�RGQQSCQ�?LB�MRFCP�K?RCPG?JQ��QSAF�?Q�QMJGB�QR?RC�CJCARPMLGAQ��?PC�BGPCARJW�PCJ?RCB�RM�RFC

GMLGX?RGML�RFCW�NPMBSAC��!JJ�MD�RFCK��DMP�CV?KNJC��A?L�B?K?EC�CJCARPMLGAQ�MP�IGJJ�A?LACP�ACJJQ��)L�?BBGRGML��KCRFMBQ�DMP�BCRCARGLE�V�P?WQ�?LB�LSAJC?P

P?BG?RGML�?PC�@?QCB�ML�GMLGX?RGML��BGPCARJW�MP�GLBGPCARJW��!JJ�MD�RFCK�A?L�GMLGXC�RFC�?GP�@CRUCCL�RFC�NJ?RCQ�MD�?�A?N?AGRMP��DMP�CV?KNJC��A?SQGLE�GR�RM

BGQAF?PEC��4FGQ�GQ�RFC�@?QGQ�MD�GLCVNCLQGTC�NCPQML?J�P?BG?RGML�KMLGRMPQ��QSAF�?Q�NGARSPCB�GL �=;IF9�������!N?PR�DPMK � ��?LB ��RFCPC�?PC�MRFCP

#(!04%2����Y�2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3 ����

Page 4: 2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · PDF filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝ cbg9fj5h=cb% 5kg z $cdglc? lbb gqasqqlsajc?pbca?w z 3r?rcr fcam lqcpt?rgmlj?uq z %vnj?gln ?pclr?

DMPKQ�MD�LSAJC?P�P?BG?RGML�?Q�UCJJ��?LB�RFCQC�?JQM�NPMBSAC�GMLGX?RGML�UGRF�QGKGJ?P�CDDCARQ��7C�BCDGLC =CB=N=B;�F58=5H=CB ?Q�?LW�DMPK�MD�P?BG?RGML�RF?R

NPMBSACQ�GMLGX?RGML�UFCRFCP�LSAJC?P�GL�MPGEGL�MP�LMR��QGLAC�RFC�CDDCARQ�?LB�BCRCARGML�MD�RFC�P?BG?RGML�?PC�PCJ?RCB�RM�GMLGX?RGML�

�=;IF9����� 4FCQC�BMQGKCRCPQ��JGRCP?JJW��BMQC�KCRCPQ�?PC�NCPQML?J�P?BG?RGML�KMLGRMPQ�RF?R�BCRCAR�RFC�?KMSLR�MD�P?BG?RGML�@W�RFC�BGQAF?PEC�MD�?�PCAF?PEC?@JC�GLRCPL?J�A?N?AGRMP�

4FC�?KMSLR�MD�BGQAF?PEC�GQ�PCJ?RCB�RM�RFC�?KMSLR�MD�GMLGXGLE�P?BG?RGML�CLAMSLRCPCB��?�KC?QSPCKCLR�MD�BMQC��/LC�BMQGKCRCP�GQ�QFMUL�GL�RFC�AF?PECP��)RQ�QA?JC�GQ�PC?B�RFPMSEF

?L�CWCNGCAC�ML�RFC�RMN���APCBGR��,��#F?LE��7GIGKCBG?�#MKKMLQ

4FC F5B;9�C:�F58=5H=CB GQ�BCDGLCB�RM�@C�RFC�BGQR?LAC�GR�A?L�RP?TCJ�RFPMSEF�?�K?RCPG?J��2?LEC�GQ�PCJ?RCB�RM�QCTCP?J�D?ARMPQ��GLAJSBGLE�RFC�CLCPEW�MD�RFC

P?BG?RGML��RFC�K?RCPG?J�CLAMSLRCPCB��?LB�RFC�RWNC�MD�P?BG?RGML��QCC �=;IF9�������4FC�FGEFCP�RFC 8A8E:L��RFC�EPC?RCP�RFC�P?LEC��?JJ�MRFCP�D?ARMPQ�@CGLE

RFC�Q?KC��4FGQ�K?ICQ�EMMB�QCLQC��QGLAC�P?BG?RGML�JMQCQ�GRQ�CLCPEW�GL�K?RCPG?JQ�NPGK?PGJW�@W�NPMBSAGLE�GMLGX?RGML�GL�RFCK��?LB�C?AF�GMLGX?RGML�MD�?L

?RMK�MP�?�KMJCASJC�PCOSGPCQ�CLCPEW�RF?R�GQ�PCKMTCB�DPMK�RFC�P?BG?RGML��4FC�?KMSLR�MD�GMLGX?RGML�GQ��RFSQ��BGPCARJW�NPMNMPRGML?J�RM�RFC�CLCPEW�MD�RFC

N?PRGAJC�MD�P?BG?RGML��?Q�GQ�GRQ�P?LEC�

�=;IF9����� 4FC�NCLCRP?RGML�MP�P?LEC�MD�P?BG?RGML�BCNCLBQ�ML�GRQ�CLCPEW��RFC�K?RCPG?J�GR�CLAMSLRCPQ��?LB�RFC�RWNC�MD�P?BG?RGML���?�'PC?RCP�CLCPEW�KC?LQ�EPC?RCP�P?LEC���@

2?BG?RGML�F?Q�?�QK?JJCP�P?LEC�GL�K?RCPG?JQ�UGRF�FGEF�CJCARPML�BCLQGRW���A�!JNF?Q�F?TC�RFC�QK?JJCQR�P?LEC��@CR?Q�F?TC�?�EPC?RCP�P?LEC��?LB�E?KK?Q�NCLCRP?RC�RFC�D?PRFCQR�

2?BG?RGML�A?L�@C�?@QMP@CB�MP�QFGCJBCB�@W�K?RCPG?JQ��QSAF�?Q�RFC�JC?B�?NPMLQ�BCLRGQRQ�BP?NC�ML�SQ�UFCL�R?IGLE�V�P?WQ��,C?B�GQ�?�N?PRGASJ?PJW�CDDCARGTC

QFGCJB�AMKN?PCB�UGRF�MRFCP�K?RCPG?JQ��QSAF�?Q�NJ?QRGA�MP�?GP��(MU�BMCQ�RFC�P?LEC�MD�P?BG?RGML�BCNCLB�ML @4G8E<4?��)MLGXGLE�P?BG?RGML�GLRCP?ARQ�@CQR

UGRF�AF?PECB�N?PRGAJCQ�GL�?�K?RCPG?J��3GLAC�CJCARPMLQ�F?TC�QK?JJ�K?QQCQ��RFCW�KMQR�PC?BGJW�?@QMP@�RFC�CLCPEW�MD�RFC�P?BG?RGML�GL�AMJJGQGMLQ��4FC�EPC?RCP

RFC�BCLQGRW�MD�?�K?RCPG?J�?LB��GL�N?PRGASJ?P��RFC�EPC?RCP�RFC�BCLQGRW�MD�CJCARPMLQ�UGRFGL�?�K?RCPG?J��RFC�QK?JJCP�RFC�P?LEC�MD�P?BG?RGML�

#MJJGQGMLQ

#MLQCPT?RGML�MD�CLCPEW�?LB�KMKCLRSK�MDRCL�PCQSJRQ�GL�CLCPEW�RP?LQDCP�RM�?�JCQQ�K?QQGTC�M@HCAR�GL�?�AMJJGQGML��4FGQ�U?Q�BGQASQQCB�GL�BCR?GJ�GL

0CF?��B9F;M�5B8��B9F;M�+9GCIF79G��DMP�CV?KNJC�

$GDDCPCLR GLC8F MD�P?BG?RGML�F?TC�BGDDCPCLR�P?LECQ�UFCL�AMKN?PCB�?R�RFC�Q?KC�CLCPEW�?LB�GL�RFC�Q?KC�K?RCPG?J��!JNF?Q�F?TC�RFC�QFMPRCQR�P?LEC�

@CR?Q�NCLCRP?RC�D?PRFCP��?LB�E?KK?Q�F?TC�RFC�EPC?RCQR�P?LEC��4FGQ�GQ�BGPCARJW�PCJ?RCB�RM�AF?PEC�?LB�QNCCB�MD�RFC�N?PRGAJC�MP�RWNC�MD�P?BG?RGML��!R�?

EGTCL�CLCPEW��C?AF � ��MP UGJJ�NPMBSAC�RFC�Q?KC�LSK@CP�MD�GMLGX?RGMLQ�GL�?�K?RCPG?J��C?AF�GMLGX?RGML�PCOSGPCQ�?�ACPR?GL�?KMSLR�MD�CLCPEW�ML

?TCP?EC��4FC�KMPC�PC?BGJW�RFC�N?PRGAJC�NPMBSACQ�GMLGX?RGML��RFC�KMPC�OSGAIJW�GR�UGJJ�JMQC�GRQ�CLCPEW��4FC�CDDCAR�MD 6;4E:8 GQ�?Q�DMJJMUQ��4FC F?Q�?

AF?PEC�MD ��RFC F?Q�?�AF?PEC�MD ��?LB�RFC GQ�SLAF?PECB��4FC�CJCARPMK?ELCRGA�DMPAC�CVCPRCB�@W�RFC GQ�RFSQ�RUGAC�?Q�QRPMLE�?Q

RF?R�CVCPRCB�@W�RFC ?LB�GR�GQ�KMPC�JGICJW�RM�NPMBSAC�GMLGX?RGML��!JRFMSEF�AF?PECJCQQ��RFC BMCQ�GLRCP?AR�UC?IJW�@CA?SQC�GR�GQ�?L�CJCARPMK?ELCRGA

U?TC��@SR�GR�GQ�JCQQ�JGICJW�RM�NPMBSAC�GMLGX?RGML�GL�?LW�CLAMSLRCP��-MPC�OS?LRGR?RGTCJW��RFC�AF?LEC�GL�KMKCLRSK EGTCL�RM�?�N?PRGAJC�GL�RFC�K?RCPG?J

GQ ��UFCPC GQ�RFC�DMPAC�RFC � ��MP CVCPRQ�MTCP�?�RGKC ��4FC�QK?JJCP�RFC�AF?PEC��RFC�QK?JJCP�GQ ?LB�RFC�QK?JJCP�GQ�RFC

KMKCLRSK��?LB�CLCPEW�JMQR��3GLAC�RFC�QNCCB�MD�?JNF?Q�GQ�?@MSR����RM�����MD�RFC�QNCCB�MD�JGEFR��AJ?QQGA?J��LML PCJ?RGTGQRGA�DMPKSJ?Q�?NNJW�

4FC FC887 ?R�UFGAF�RFCW�RP?TCJ�GQ�RFC�MRFCP�K?HMP�D?ARMP�?DDCARGLE�RFC�P?LEC�MD Q� Q��?LB Q��4FC�D?QRCP�RFCW�KMTC��RFC�JCQQ�RGKC�RFCW�QNCLB�GL

RFC�TGAGLGRW�MD�?L�?RMK�MP�?�KMJCASJC��?LB�RFC�JCQQ�JGICJW�RFCW�?PC�RM�GLRCP?AR��3GLAC Q�?LB Q�?PC�N?PRGAJCQ�UGRF�K?QQ��FCJGSK�LSAJCG�?LB�CJCARPMLQ�

���� #(!04%2����Y�2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3

4FGQ�AMLRCLR�GQ�?T?GJ?@JC�DMP�DPCC�?R�FRRN���ALV�MPE�AMLRCLR�AMJ���������

Page 5: 2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · PDF filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝ cbg9fj5h=cb% 5kg z $cdglc? lbb gqasqqlsajc?pbca?w z 3r?rcr fcam lqcpt?rgmlj?uq z %vnj?gln ?pclr?

PCQNCARGTCJW��RFCGP�CLCPEW�GQ�IGLCRGA��EGTCL�AJ?QQGA?JJW�@W ��4FC�K?QQ�MD�RFC N?PRGAJC�GQ�RFMSQ?LBQ�MD�RGKCQ�JCQQ�RF?L�RF?R�MD�RFC Q��QM�RF?R

Q�KSQR�RP?TCJ�KSAF�D?QRCP�RF?L Q�RM�F?TC�RFC�Q?KC�CLCPEW��3GLAC Q�KMTC�D?QRCP��KMQR�?R�PCJ?RGTGQRGA�QNCCBQ��RFCW�F?TC�JCQQ�RGKC�RM�GLRCP?AR

RF?L Q��'?KK?�P?WQ�?PC�NFMRMLQ��UFGAF�KSQR�RP?TCJ�?R�RFC�QNCCB�MD�JGEFR��4FCW�?PC�CTCL�JCQQ�JGICJW�RM�GLRCP?AR�RF?L�? ��QGLAC�RFCW�QNCLB�CTCL

JCQQ�RGKC�LC?P�?�EGTCL�?RMK��?LB�RFCW�F?TC�LM�AF?PEC��4FC�P?LEC�MD Q�GQ�RFSQ�EPC?RCP�RF?L�RFC�P?LEC�MD Q�

!JNF?�P?BG?RGML�DPMK�P?BGM?ARGTC�QMSPACQ�F?Q�?�P?LEC�KSAF�JCQQ�RF?L�?�KGJJGKCRCP�MD�@GMJMEGA?J�RGQQSCQ��SQS?JJW�LMR�CLMSEF�RM�CTCL�NCLCRP?RC�RFC�BC?B

J?WCPQ�MD�MSP�QIGL��/L�RFC�MRFCP�F?LB��RFC�Q?KC P?BG?RGML�A?L�NCLCRP?RC�?�DCU�ACLRGKCRCPQ�MD�?GP��QM�KCPC�BGQR?LAC�DPMK�?�QMSPAC�NPCTCLRQ

P?BG?RGML�DPMK�PC?AFGLE�SQ��4FGQ�K?ICQ P?BG?RGML�PCJ?RGTCJW�Q?DC�DMP�MSP�@MBW�AMKN?PCB�RM ?LB P?BG?RGML��4WNGA?J P?BG?RGML�A?L�NCLCRP?RC�?

DCU�KGJJGKCRCPQ�MD�RGQQSC�MP�?@MSR�?�KCRCP�MD�?GP��"CR?�P?BG?RGML�GQ�RFSQ�F?X?PBMSQ�CTCL�UFCL�LMR�GLECQRCB��4FC�P?LEC�MD Q�GL�JC?B�GQ�?@MSR�?

KGJJGKCRCP��?LB�QM�GR�GQ�C?QW�RM�QRMPC QMSPACQ�GL�JC?B�P?BG?RGML NPMMD�AMLR?GLCPQ��'?KK?�P?WQ�F?TC�?�KSAF�EPC?RCP�P?LEC�RF?L�CGRFCP Q�MP Q��)L

D?AR��GD�?�EGTCL�RFGAILCQQ�MD�K?RCPG?J��JGIC�?�JC?B�@PGAI��?@QMP@Q�����MD�RFC Q��RFCL�?�QCAMLB�JC?B�@PGAI�UGJJ�MLJW�?@QMP@�����MD�UF?R�EMR�RFPMSEF�RFC

DGPQR��4FSQ� Q�BM�LMR�F?TC�?�UCJJ BCDGLCB�P?LEC��UC�A?L�MLJW�ASR�BMUL�RFC�?KMSLR�RF?R�ECRQ�RFPMSEF��4WNGA?JJW� Q�A?L�NCLCRP?RC�K?LW�KCRCPQ�MD�?GP�

EM�PGEFR�RFPMSEF�MSP�@MBGCQ��?LB�?PC�CDDCARGTCJW�QFGCJBCB��RF?R�GQ��PCBSACB�GL�GLRCLQGRW�RM�?AACNR?@JC�JCTCJQ�@W�K?LW�ACLRGKCRCPQ�MD�JC?B��/LC�@CLCDGR�MD

Q�GQ�RF?R�RFCW�A?L�@C�SQCB�?Q�P?BGM?ARGTC�RP?ACPQ��QCC �=;IF9������

�=;IF9����� 4FGQ�GK?EC�MD�RFC�AMLACLRP?RGML�MD�?�P?BGM?ARGTC�RP?ACP�GL�?�N?RGCLRwQ�@MBW�PCTC?JQ�UFCPC�RFC�KMQR�?ARGTC�@MLC�ACJJQ�?PC��?L�GLBGA?RGML�MD�@MLC�A?LACP��!�QFMPR JGTCB

P?BGM?ARGTC�QS@QR?LAC�RF?R�JMA?RCQ�GRQCJD�QCJCARGTCJW�GQ�EGTCL�RM�RFC�N?RGCLR��?LB�RFC�P?BG?RGML�GQ�KC?QSPCB�UGRF�?L�CVRCPL?J�BCRCARMP��4FC�CKGRRCB P?BG?RGML�F?Q�?�QSDDGAGCLR

P?LEC�RM�JC?TC�RFC�@MBWuRFC�P?LEC�MD Q�?LB Q�GQ�RMM�QK?JJ�DMP�RFCK�RM�@C�M@QCPTCB�MSRQGBC�RFC�N?RGCLR���APCBGR��+GCP?L�-?FCP��7GIGKCBG?�#MKKMLQ

0F%4�%VNJMP?RGMLQ��"CR?�$CA?W

7?RAF�@CR?�BCA?W�MAASP�DMP�?�AMJJCARGML�MD�LSAJCG�MP�DMP�?L�GLBGTGBS?J�LSAJCSQ�

�=;IF9����� �9H5��975M��<HHD���7BL�CF;�7CBH9BH�A����������69H58975M49B�>5F�

���� +58=5H=CB��9H97H=CB�5B8��9H97HCFG

)R�GQ�UCJJ�ILMUL�RF?R�GMLGXGLE�P?BG?RGML�?DDCARQ�SQ�@SR�BMCQ�LMR�RPGEECP�LCPTC�GKNSJQCQ��.CUQN?NCPQ�A?PPW�QRMPGCQ�?@MSR�SLQSQNCARGLE�TGARGKQ�MD

P?BG?RGML�NMGQMLGLE�UFM�D?JJ�GJJ�UGRF�P?BG?RGML�QGAILCQQ��QSAF�?Q�@SPLQ�?LB�@JMMB�AMSLR�AF?LECQ��@SR�UFM�LCTCP�DCJR�RFC�P?BG?RGML�BGPCARJW��4FGQ�K?ICQ

RFC�BCRCARGML�MD�P?BG?RGML�@W�GLQRPSKCLRQ�KMPC�RF?L�?L�GKNMPR?LR�PCQC?PAF�RMMJ��4FGQ�QCARGML�GQ�?�@PGCD�MTCPTGCU�MD�P?BG?RGML�BCRCARGML�?LB�QMKC�MD�GRQ

?NNJGA?RGMLQ�

(SK?L�!NNJGA?RGML

4FC�DGPQR�BGPCAR�BCRCARGML�MD�P?BG?RGML�U?Q�"CAOSCPCJwQ�DMEECB�NFMRMEP?NFGA�NJ?RC��0FMRMEP?NFGA�DGJK�GQ�QRGJJ�RFC�KMQR�AMKKML�BCRCARMP�MD�GMLGXGLE

P?BG?RGML��@CGLE�SQCB�PMSRGLCJW�GL�KCBGA?J�?LB�BCLR?J�V�P?WQ��.SAJC?P�P?BG?RGML�GQ�?JQM�A?NRSPCB�ML�DGJK��QSAF�?Q�QCCL�GL �=;IF9�������4FC�KCAF?LGQK

DMP�DGJK�CVNMQSPC�@W�GMLGXGLE�P?BG?RGML�GQ�QGKGJ?P�RM�RF?R�@W�NFMRMLQ��!�OS?LRSK�MD�CLCPEW�GLRCP?ARQ�UGRF�RFC�CKSJQGML�?LB�?JRCPQ�GR�AFCKGA?JJW��RFSQ

CVNMQGLE�RFC�DGJK��4FC�OS?LRSK�AMKC�DPMK�?L N?PRGAJC� N?PRGAJC��MP�NFMRML��NPMTGBCB�GR�F?Q�KMPC�RF?L�RFC�DCU�C6�MD�CLCPEW�LCCBCB�RM�GLBSAC

RFC�AFCKGA?J�AF?LEC��?Q�BMCQ�?JJ�GMLGXGLE�P?BG?RGML��4FC�NPMACQQ�GQ�LMR������CDDGAGCLR��QGLAC�LMR�?JJ�GLAGBCLR�P?BG?RGML�GLRCP?ARQ�?LB�LMR�?JJ�GLRCP?ARGMLQ

NPMBSAC�RFC�AFCKGA?J�AF?LEC��4FC�?KMSLR�MD�DGJK�B?PICLGLE�GQ�PCJ?RCB�RM�CVNMQSPC��@SR�RFC�B?PICLGLE�?JQM�BCNCLBQ�ML�RFC�RWNC�MD�P?BG?RGML��QM�RF?R

?@QMP@CPQ�?LB�MRFCP�BCTGACQ�KSQR�@C�SQCB�RM�M@R?GL�CLCPEW��AF?PEC��?LB�N?PRGAJC GBCLRGDGA?RGML�GLDMPK?RGML�

#(!04%2����Y�2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3 ����

Page 6: 2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · PDF filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝ cbg9fj5h=cb% 5kg z $cdglc? lbb gqasqqlsajc?pbca?w z 3r?rcr fcam lqcpt?rgmlj?uq z %vnj?gln ?pclr?

�=;IF9����� &GJK�@?BECQ�AMLR?GL�DGJK�QGKGJ?P�RM�RF?R�SQCB�GL�RFGQ�BCLR?J�V P?W�DGJK�?LB�GQ�Q?LBUGAFCB�@CRUCCL�T?PGMSQ�?@QMP@CPQ�RM�BCRCPKGLC�RFC�NCLCRP?RGLE�?@GJGRW�MD�RFC

P?BG?RGML�?Q�UCJJ�?Q�RFC�?KMSLR���APCBGR��7CPLCSAFCL��7GIGKCBG?�#MKKMLQ

!LMRFCP�TCPW�AMKKML F58=5H=CB�89H97HCF GQ�RFC 9=;9F�HI69��4FC�AJGAIGLE�?LB�@SXXGLE�QMSLB�UC�FC?P�GL�BP?K?RGX?RGMLQ�?LB�BMASKCLR?PGCQ��?Q�UCJJ

?Q�GL�MSP�MUL�NFWQGAQ�J?@Q��GQ�SQS?JJW�?L�?SBGM�MSRNSR�MD�CTCLRQ�BCRCARCB�@W�?�'CGECP�AMSLRCP��4FCQC�PCJ?RGTCJW�GLCVNCLQGTC�P?BG?RGML�BCRCARMPQ�?PC

@?QCB�ML�RFC�QGKNJC�?LB�QRSPBW�'CGECP�RS@C��QFMUL�QAFCK?RGA?JJW�GL �=;IF9������@��!�AMLBSARGLE�AWJGLBCP�UGRF�?�UGPC�?JMLE�GRQ�?VGQ�GQ�DGJJCB�UGRF�?L

GLQSJ?RGLE�E?Q�QM�RF?R�?�TMJR?EC�?NNJGCB�@CRUCCL�RFC�AWJGLBCP�?LB�UGPC�NPMBSACQ�?JKMQR�LM�ASPPCLR��)MLGXGLE�P?BG?RGML�N?QQGLE�RFPMSEF�RFC�RS@C

NPMBSACQ�DPCC�GML�N?GPQ�RF?R�?PC�?RRP?ARCB�RM�RFC�UGPC�?LB�AWJGLBCP��DMPKGLE�?�ASPPCLR�RF?R�GQ�BCRCARCB�?Q�?�AMSLR��4FC�UMPB�AMSLR�GKNJGCQ�RF?R�RFCPC�GQ

LM�GLDMPK?RGML�ML�CLCPEW��AF?PEC��MP�RWNC�MD�P?BG?RGML�UGRF�?�QGKNJC�'CGECP�AMSLRCP��4FCW�BM�LMR�BCRCAR�CTCPW�N?PRGAJC��QGLAC�QMKC�P?BG?RGML�A?L�N?QQ

RFPMSEF�UGRFMSR�NPMBSAGLE�CLMSEF�GMLGX?RGML�RM�@C�BCRCARCB��(MUCTCP��'CGECP�AMSLRCPQ�?PC�TCPW�SQCDSJ�GL�NPMBSAGLE�?�NPMKNR�MSRNSR�RF?R�PCTC?JQ�RFC

CVGQRCLAC�?LB�PCJ?RGTC�GLRCLQGRW�MD�GMLGXGLE�P?BG?RGML�

�=;IF9����� �?�'CGECP�AMSLRCPQ�QSAF�?Q�RFGQ�MLC�?PC�SQCB�DMP�NPMKNR�KMLGRMPGLE�MD�P?BG?RGML�JCTCJQ��ECLCP?JJW�EGTGLE�MLJW�PCJ?RGTC�GLRCLQGRW�?LB�LMR�GBCLRGDWGLE�RFC�RWNC�MP

CLCPEW�MD�RFC�P?BG?RGML���APCBGR��4GK6GAICPQ��7GIGKCBG?�#MKKMLQ��@�6MJR?EC�?NNJGCB�@CRUCCL�RFC�AWJGLBCP�?LB�UGPC�GL�?�'CGECP�RS@C�A?SQCQ�GMLQ�?LB�CJCARPMLQ�NPMBSACB�@W

P?BG?RGML�N?QQGLE�RFPMSEF�RFC�E?Q DGJJCB�AWJGLBCP�RM�KMTC�RMU?PBQ�RFCK��4FC�PCQSJRGLE�ASPPCLR�GQ�BCRCARCB�?LB�PCEGQRCPCB�?Q�?�AMSLR�

!LMRFCP�P?BG?RGML�BCRCARGML�KCRFMB�PCAMPBQ�JGEFR�NPMBSACB�UFCL�P?BG?RGML�GLRCP?ARQ�UGRF�K?RCPG?JQ��4FC�CLCPEW�MD�RFC�P?BG?RGML�GQ�QSDDGAGCLR�RM�CVAGRC

?RMKQ�GL�?�K?RCPG?J�RF?R�K?W�DJSMPCQAC��QSAF�?Q�RFC�NFMQNFMP�SQCB�@W�2SRFCPDMPBwQ�EPMSN��-?RCPG?JQ�A?JJCB G7=BH=@@5HCFG SQC�?�KMPC�AMKNJCV

AMJJ?@MP?RGTC�NPMACQQ�RM�AMLTCPR�P?BG?RGML�CLCPEW�GLRM�JGEFR��3AGLRGJJ?RMPQ�K?W�@C�JGOSGB�MP�QMJGB��?LB�RFCW�A?L�@C�TCPW�CDDGAGCLR��4FCGP�JGEFR�MSRNSR�A?L

NPMTGBC�GLDMPK?RGML�?@MSR�RFC�CLCPEW��AF?PEC��?LB�RWNC�MD�P?BG?RGML��3AGLRGJJ?RMP�JGEFR�DJ?QFCQ�?PC�TCPW�@PGCD�GL�BSP?RGML��CL?@JGLE�RFC�BCRCARGML�MD�?�FSEC

LSK@CP�MD�N?PRGAJCQ�GL�QFMPR�NCPGMBQ�MD�RGKC��3AGLRGJJ?RMP�BCRCARMPQ�?PC�SQCB�GL�?�T?PGCRW�MD�PCQC?PAF�?LB�BG?ELMQRGA�?NNJGA?RGMLQ��!KMLE�RFCQC�?PC�RFC

BCRCARGML�@W�Q?RCJJGRC KMSLRCB�COSGNKCLR�MD�RFC�P?BG?RGML�DPMK�BGQR?LR�E?J?VGCQ��RFC�?L?JWQGQ�MD�P?BG?RGML�DPMK�?�NCPQML�GLBGA?RGLE�@MBW�@SPBCLQ��?LB

RFC�BCRCARGML�MD�CVMRGA�N?PRGAJCQ�GL�?AACJCP?RMP�J?@MP?RMPGCQ�

���� #(!04%2����Y�2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3

4FGQ�AMLRCLR�GQ�?T?GJ?@JC�DMP�DPCC�?R�FRRN���ALV�MPE�AMLRCLR�AMJ���������

Page 7: 2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · PDF filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝ cbg9fj5h=cb% 5kg z $cdglc? lbb gqasqqlsajc?pbca?w z 3r?rcr fcam lqcpt?rgmlj?uq z %vnj?gln ?pclr?

,GEFR�DPMK�?�QAGLRGJJ?RMP�GQ�AMLTCPRCB�GLRM�CJCARPGA?J�QGEL?JQ�@W�BCTGACQ�QSAF�?Q�RFC D<CHCAI@H=D@=9F RS@C�QFMUL�QAFCK?RGA?JJW�GL �=;IF9����� ��4FCQC

RS@CQ�?PC�@?QCB�ML�RFC�NFMRMCJCARPGA�CDDCAR��UFGAF�GQ�KSJRGNJGCB�GL�QR?ECQ�GLRM�?�A?QA?BC�MD�CJCARPMLQ��FCLAC�RFC�L?KC�NFMRMKSJRGNJGCP��,GEFR�CLRCPGLE

RFC�NFMRMKSJRGNJGCP�QRPGICQ�?�KCR?J�NJ?RC��CHCARGLE�?L�CJCARPML�RF?R�GQ�?RRP?ARCB�@W�?�NMQGRGTC�NMRCLRG?J�BGDDCPCLAC�RM�RFC�LCVR�NJ?RC��EGTGLE�GR�CLMSEF

CLCPEW�RM�CHCAR�RUM�MP�KMPC�CJCARPMLQ��?LB�QM�ML��4FC�DGL?J�MSRNSR�ASPPCLR�A?L�@C�K?BC�NPMNMPRGML?J�RM�RFC�CLCPEW�MD�RFC�JGEFR�CLRCPGLE�RFC�RS@C��UFGAF

GQ�GL�RSPL�NPMNMPRGML?J�RM�RFC�CLCPEW�BCNMQGRCB�GL�RFC�QAGLRGJJ?RMP��6CPW�QMNFGQRGA?RCB�GLDMPK?RGML�A?L�@C�M@R?GLCB�UGRF�QAGLRGJJ?RMPQ��GLAJSBGLE�CLCPEW�

AF?PEC��N?PRGAJC�GBCLRGDGA?RGML��BGPCARGML�MD�KMRGML��?LB�QM�ML�

�=;IF9����� 0FMRMKSJRGNJGCPQ�SQC�RFC�NFMRMCJCARPGA�CDDCAR�ML�RFC�NFMRMA?RFMBC�RM�AMLTCPR�RFC�JGEFR�MSRNSR�MD�?�QAGLRGJJ?RMP�GLRM�?L�CJCARPGA?J�QGEL?J��%?AF�QSAACQQGTC�BWLMBC�F?Q

?�KMPC NMQGRGTC�NMRCLRG?J�RF?L�RFC�J?QR�?LB�?RRP?ARQ�RFC�CHCARCB�CJCARPMLQ��EGTGLE�RFCK�KMPC�CLCPEW��4FC�LSK@CP�MD�CJCARPMLQ�GQ�RFSQ�KSJRGNJGCB�?R�C?AF�BWLMBC��PCQSJRGLE�GL�?L

C?QGJW�BCRCARCB�MSRNSR�ASPPCLR�

,C@=8GH5H9�F58=5H=CB�89H97HCFG AMLTCPR�GMLGX?RGML�NPMBSACB�GL�?�QCKGAMLBSARMP��JGIC�RFMQC�DMSLB�GL�AMKNSRCP�AFGNQ�BGPCARJW�GLRM�?L�CJCARPGA?J�QGEL?J�

3CKGAMLBSARMPQ�A?L�@C�AMLQRPSARCB�RF?R�BM�LMR�AMLBSAR�ASPPCLR�GL�MLC�N?PRGASJ?P�BGPCARGML��7FCL�?�TMJR?EC�GQ�?NNJGCB�GL�RF?R�BGPCARGML��ASPPCLR�DJMUQ

MLJW�UFCL�GMLGX?RGML�GQ�NPMBSACB�@W�P?BG?RGML��QGKGJ?P�RM�UF?R�F?NNCLQ�GL�?�'CGECP�RS@C��&SPRFCP��RFC�?KMSLR�MD�ASPPCLR�GL�?�QMJGB QR?RC�BCRCARMP�GQ

AJMQCJW�PCJ?RCB�RM�RFC�CLCPEW�BCNMQGRCB�?LB��QGLAC�RFC�BCRCARMP�GQ�QMJGB��GR�A?L�F?TC�?�FGEF�CDDGAGCLAW��QGLAC�GMLGXGLE�P?BG?RGML�GQ�QRMNNCB�GL�?�QFMPRCP

BGQR?LAC�GL�QMJGBQ�DCUCP�N?PRGAJCQ�CQA?NC�BCRCARGML��!Q�UGRF�QAGLRGJJ?RMPQ��TCPW�QMNFGQRGA?RCB�GLDMPK?RGML�A?L�@C�M@R?GLCB�DPMK�QMJGB QR?RC�BCRCARMPQ�

0F%4�%VNJMP?RGMLQ��2?BGM?ARGTC�$?RGLE�'?KC

,C?PL�?@MSR�BGDDCPCLR�RWNCQ�MD�P?BGMKCRPGA�B?RGLE��QSAF�?Q�A?P@ML�B?RGLE��5LBCPQR?LB�FMU�BCA?W�?LB�F?JD�JGDC�UMPI�RM�CL?@JC�P?BGMKCRPGA�B?RGLE�RM

UMPI��0J?W�?�E?KC�RF?R�RCQRQ�WMSP�?@GJGRW�RM�K?RAF�RFC�NCPACLR?EC�MD�RFC�B?RGLE�CJCKCLR�RF?R�PCK?GLQ�RM�RFC�?EC�MD�RFC�M@HCAR�

�=;IF9������ +58=C57H=J9��5H=B;� 5A9��<HHD���7BL�CF;�7CBH9BH�A����������F58=C57H=J985H=B;;5A949B�>5F�

���� ,I6GHFI7HIF9�C:�H<9�'I7@9IG

7F?R�GQ�GLQGBC�RFC�LSAJCSQ��7FW�?PC�QMKC�LSAJCG�QR?@JC�UFGJC�MRFCPQ�BCA?W���3CC �=;IF9��������7FW�?PC�RFCPC�BGDDCPCLR�RWNCQ�MD�BCA?W�� � ?LB

��7FW�?PC�LSAJC?P�BCA?W�CLCPEGCQ�QM�J?PEC��0SPQSGLE�L?RSP?J�OSCQRGMLQ�JGIC�RFCQC�F?Q�JCB�RM�D?P�KMPC�DSLB?KCLR?J�BGQAMTCPGCQ�RF?L�WMS�KGEFR

GK?EGLC�

#(!04%2����Y�2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3 ����

Page 8: 2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · PDF filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝ cbg9fj5h=cb% 5kg z $cdglc? lbb gqasqqlsajc?pbca?w z 3r?rcr fcam lqcpt?rgmlj?uq z %vnj?gln ?pclr?

�=;IF9������ 7FW�GQ�KMQR�MD�RFC�A?P@ML�GL�RFGQ�AM?J�QR?@JC��?��UFGJC�RFC�SP?LGSK�GL�RFC�BGQI��@�QJMUJW�BCA?WQ�MTCP�@GJJGMLQ�MD�WC?PQ��7FW�GQ�ACQGSK�GL�RFGQ�?KNSJC��A�CTCL�JCQQ

QR?@JC�RF?L�RFC�SP?LGSK��BCA?WGLE�GL�D?P�JCQQ�RF?L�������������RFC�RGKC��7F?R�GQ�RFC�PC?QML�SP?LGSK�?LB�ACQGSK�SLBCPEM�BGDDCPCLR�RWNCQ�MD�BCA?W�� ?LB ��PCQNCARGTCJW�

�APCBGRQ���?�"PCQQML�4FMK?Q��7GIGKCBG?�#MKKMLQ���@�5�3��$CN?PRKCLR�MD�%LCPEW���A�4MKGF?FLBMPD��7GIGKCBG?�#MKKMLQ

7C�F?TC�?JPC?BW�GBCLRGDGCB DFCHCBG ?Q�RFC�N?PRGAJCQ�RF?R�A?PPW�NMQGRGTC�AF?PEC�GL�RFC�LSAJCG��(MUCTCP��RFCPC�?PC�?ARS?JJW GJB RWNCQ�MD�N?PRGAJCQ�GL�RFC

LSAJCGuRFC CEBGBA ?LB�RFC A8HGEBA��PCDCPPCB�RM�AMJJCARGTCJW�?Q BI7@9CBG��RFC�AMLQRGRSCLRQ�MD�LSAJCG��!Q�GRQ�L?KC�GKNJGCQ��RFC B9IHFCB GQ�?�LCSRP?J

N?PRGAJC�� �RF?R�F?Q�LC?PJW�RFC�Q?KC�K?QQ�?LB�GLRPGLQGA�QNGL�?Q�RFC�NPMRML� -56@9����� AMKN?PCQ�RFC�K?QQCQ�MD�NPMRMLQ��LCSRPMLQ��?LB

CJCARPMLQ��.MRC�FMU�AJMQC�RFC�NPMRML�?LB�LCSRPML�K?QQCQ�?PC��@SR�RFC�LCSRPML�GQ�QJGEFRJW�KMPC�K?QQGTC�MLAC�WMS�JMMI�N?QR�RFC�RFGPB�BGEGR��"MRF

LSAJCMLQ�?PC�KSAF�KMPC�K?QQGTC�RF?L�?L�CJCARPML��)L�D?AR� �?Q�LMRCB�GL &98=75@��DD@=75H=CBG�C:�'I7@95F�)<MG=7G ?LB

-56@9����� ?JQM�EGTCQ�K?QQCQ�GL�RCPKQ�MD�K?QQ�SLGRQ�RF?R�?PC�KMPC�AMLTCLGCLR�RF?L�IGJMEP?KQ�ML�RFC�?RMKGA�?LB�LSAJC?P�QA?JC��4FC�DGPQR�MD�RFCQC�GQ

RFC HA<9<87 5HCA=7�A5GG HA<G �S��BCDGLCB�?Q

�����

4FGQ�SLGR�GQ�BCDGLCB�QM�RF?R�?�LCSRP?J�A?P@ML ?RMK�F?Q�?�K?QQ�MD�CV?ARJW����S��-?QQCQ�?PC�?JQM�CVNPCQQCB�GL�SLGRQ�MD ��4FCQC�SLGRQ�?PC

TCPW�AMLTCLGCLR�UFCL�AMLQGBCPGLE�RFC�AMLTCPQGML�MD�K?QQ�GLRM�CLCPEW��?LB�TGAC�TCPQ?��?Q�GQ�QM�NPMKGLCLR�GL�LSAJC?P�NPMACQQCQ��5QGLE

?LB�SLGRQ�MD GL ��UC�DGLB�RF?R A?LACJQ�?LB AMKCQ�MSR�AMLTCLGCLRJW�GL�-C6��&MP�CV?KNJC��GD�RFC�PCQR�K?QQ�MD�?�NPMRML�GQ�AMLTCPRCB

CLRGPCJW�GLRM�CLCPEW��RFCL

�����

)R�GQ�SQCDSJ�RM�LMRC�RF?R���S�MD�K?QQ�AMLTCPRCB�RM�CLCPEW�NPMBSACQ�������-C6��MP

�����

!JJ�NPMNCPRGCQ�MD�?�LSAJCSQ�?PC�BCRCPKGLCB�@W�RFC�LSK@CP�MD�NPMRMLQ�?LB�LCSRPMLQ�GR�F?Q��!�QNCAGDGA�AMK@GL?RGML�MD�NPMRMLQ�?LB�LCSRPMLQ�GQ�A?JJCB�?

BI7@=89 ?LB�GQ�?�SLGOSC�LSAJCSQ��4FC�DMJJMUGLE�LMR?RGML�GQ�SQCB�RM�PCNPCQCLR�?�N?PRGASJ?P�LSAJGBC�

�����

UFCPC�RFC�QWK@MJQ � � ��?LB ?PC�BCDGLCB�?Q�DMJJMUQ��4FC AH@58E�B9�CEBGBAF�<A�4�AH6?8HF GQ�RFC 5HCA=7�BIA69F ��?Q�BCDGLCB�GL &98=75@

�DD@=75H=CBG�C:�'I7@95F�)<MG=7G��8�GQ�RFC FL@5B?�9BE�G;8�8?8@8AG��QSAF�?Q�#?�DMP�A?JAGSK��(MUCTCP��MLAC GQ�ILMUL��RFC�CJCKCLR�GQ�ILMUL�

FCLAC� ?LB ?PC�PCBSLB?LR��&MP�CV?KNJC� GQ�?JU?WQ�A?JAGSK��?LB�A?JAGSK�?JU?WQ�F?Q � GQ�RFC AH@58E�B9�A8HGEBAF GL�?

LSAJCSQ��)L�RFC�LMR?RGML�DMP�?�LSAJGBC��RFC�QS@QAPGNR GQ�SQS?JJW�MKGRRCB��4FC�QWK@MJ GQ�BCDGLCB�?Q�RFC�LSK@CP�MD�LSAJCMLQ�MP�RFC GBG4?�AH@58E�B9

CEBGBAF�4A7�A8HGEBAF�

�����

UFCPC GQ�?JQM�A?JJCB�RFC A5GG�BIA69F��4FGQ�L?KC�DMP GQ�JMEGA?J��RFC�K?QQ�MD�?L�?RMK�GQ�LC?PJW�COS?J�RM�RFC�K?QQ�MD�GRQ�LSAJCSQ��QGLAC

CJCARPMLQ�F?TC�QM�JGRRJC�K?QQ��4FC�K?QQ�MD�RFC�LSAJCSQ�RSPLQ�MSR�RM�@C�LC?PJW�COS?J�RM�RFC�QSK�MD�RFC�K?QQCQ�MD�RFC�NPMRMLQ�?LB�LCSRPMLQ�GL�GR��UFGAF

GQ�NPMNMPRGML?J�RM ��)L�RFGQ�AMLRCVR��GR�GQ�N?PRGASJ?PJW�AMLTCLGCLR�RM�CVNPCQQ�K?QQCQ�GL�SLGRQ�MD�S��"MRF�NPMRMLQ�?LB�LCSRPMLQ�F?TC�K?QQCQ�AJMQC�RM��

S��?LB�QM�RFC�K?QQ�MD�?L�?RMK�GQ�AJMQC�RM S��&MP�CV?KNJC��GL�?L�MVWECL�LSAJCSQ�UGRF�CGEFR�NPMRMLQ�?LB�CGEFR�LCSRPMLQ� ��?LB�GRQ�K?QQ�GQ

���S��!Q�LMRGACB��RFC�SLGDGCB�?RMKGA�K?QQ�SLGR�GQ�BCDGLCB�QM�RF?R�?�LCSRP?J�A?P@ML�?RMK��?ARS?JJW�? ?RMK�F?Q�?�K?QQ�MD 8K46G?L �� ��#?P@ML

U?Q�AFMQCL�?Q�RFC�QR?LB?PB��N?PRJW�@CA?SQC�MD�GRQ�GKNMPR?LAC�GL�MPE?LGA�AFCKGQRPW��QCC �DD9B8=L���

4?@JC����� -?QQCQ�MD�RFC�0PMRML��.CSRPML��?LB�%JCARPML

)5FH=7@9 ,MA6C@ ?; I &9/!�

0PMRML C �������� ������

.CSRPML A �������� ������

%JCARPML 8 ���������� �����

,CR�SQ�JMMI�?R�?�DCU�CV?KNJCQ�MD�LSAJGBCQ�CVNPCQQCB�GL�RFC LMR?RGML��4FC�LSAJCSQ�MD�RFC�QGKNJCQR�?RMK��FWBPMECL��GQ�?�QGLEJC�NPMRML��MP

�RFC�XCPM�DMP�LM�LCSRPMLQ�GQ�MDRCL�MKGRRCB��4M�AFCAI�RFGQ�QWK@MJ��PCDCP�RM�RFC�NCPGMBGA�R?@JCuWMS�QCC�RF?R�RFC�?RMKGA�LSK@CP MD�FWBPMECL�GQ���

���� #(!04%2����Y�2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3

4FGQ�AMLRCLR�GQ�?T?GJ?@JC�DMP�DPCC�?R�FRRN���ALV�MPE�AMLRCLR�AMJ���������

Page 9: 2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · PDF filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝ cbg9fj5h=cb% 5kg z $cdglc? lbb gqasqqlsajc?pbca?w z 3r?rcr fcam lqcpt?rgmlj?uq z %vnj?gln ?pclr?

3GLAC�WMS�?PC�EGTCL�RF?R�RFCPC�?PC�LM�LCSRPMLQ��RFC�K?QQ�LSK@CP GQ�?JQM����3SNNMQC�WMS�?PC�RMJB�RF?R�RFC�FCJGSK�LSAJCSQ�MP N?PRGAJC�F?Q�RUM

NPMRMLQ�?LB�RUM�LCSRPMLQ��9MS�A?L�RFCL�QCC�RF?R�GR�GQ�UPGRRCL ��4FCPC�GQ�?�QA?PAC�DMPK�MD�FWBPMECL�DMSLB�GL�L?RSPC�A?JJCB�BCSRCPGSK��GRQ�LSAJCSQ

F?Q�MLC�NPMRML�?LB�MLC�LCSRPML�?LB��FCLAC��RUGAC�RFC�K?QQ�MD�AMKKML�FWBPMECL��4FC�QWK@MJ�DMP�BCSRCPGSK�GQ��RFSQ� �QMKCRGKCQ GQ�SQCB�

?Q�DMP�BCSRCP?RCB�U?RCP ��!L�CTCL�P?PCPu?LB�P?BGM?ARGTCuDMPK�MD�FWBPMECL�GQ�A?JJCB�RPGRGSK��QGLAC�GR�F?Q�?�QGLEJC�NPMRML�?LB�RUM�LCSRPMLQ�

?LB�GR�GQ�UPGRRCL ��4FCQC�RFPCC�T?PGCRGCQ�MD�FWBPMECL�F?TC�LC?PJW�GBCLRGA?J�AFCKGQRPGCQ��@SR�RFC�LSAJCG�BGDDCP�EPC?RJW�GL�K?QQ��QR?@GJGRW��?LB�MRFCP

AF?P?ARCPGQRGAQ��.SAJCG��QSAF�?Q�RFMQC�MD�FWBPMECL�F?TGLE�RFC�Q?KC ?LB�BGDDCPCLR Q�?PC�BCDGLCB�RM�@C =GCHCD9G MD�RFC�Q?KC�CJCKCLR�

4FCPC�GQ�QMKC�PCBSLB?LAW�GL�RFC�QWK@MJQ � � ��?LB ��)D�RFC�CJCKCLR GQ�ILMUL��RFCL A?L�@C�DMSLB�GL�?�NCPGMBGA�R?@JC�?LB�GQ�?JU?WQ

RFC�Q?KC�DMP�?�EGTCL�CJCKCLR��)D�@MRF ?LB ?PC�ILMUL��RFCL A?L�?JQM�@C�BCRCPKGLCB��DGPQR�DGLB ��RFCL� ��4FSQ�RFC�QGKNJCP

LMR?RGML�DMP�LSAJGBCQ�GQ

�����

UFGAF�GQ�QSDDGAGCLR�?LB�GQ�KMQR�AMKKMLJW�SQCB��&MP�CV?KNJC��GL�RFGQ�QGKNJCP�LMR?RGML��RFC�RFPCC�GQMRMNCQ�MD�FWBPMECL�?PC ?LB UFGJC

RFC N?PRGAJC�GQ ��7C�PC?B�RFGQ�@?AIU?PB��Q?WGLE�FCJGSK ��DMP ��MP�SP?LGSK ����DMP ��3M�DMP ��QFMSJB�UC�LCCB�RM�ILMU��UC

A?L�BCRCPKGLC�RF?R DMP�SP?LGSK�DPMK�RFC�NCPGMBGA�R?@JC��?LB��RFSQ� �

!�T?PGCRW�MD�CVNCPGKCLRQ�GLBGA?RC�RF?R�?�LSAJCSQ�@CF?TCQ�QMKCRFGLE�JGIC�?�RGEFRJW�N?AICB�@?JJ�MD�LSAJCMLQ��?Q�GJJSQRP?RCB�GL �=;IF9��������4FCQC

LSAJCMLQ�F?TC�J?PEC�IGLCRGA�CLCPEGCQ�?LB��RFSQ��KMTC�P?NGBJW�GL�TCPW�AJMQC�AMLR?AR��.SAJCMLQ�A?L�@C�QCN?P?RCB�@W�?�J?PEC�DMPAC��QSAF�?Q�GL�?�AMJJGQGML

UGRF�?LMRFCP�LSAJCSQ��@SR�PCQGQR�QRPMLEJW�@CGLE�NSQFCB�AJMQCP�RMECRFCP��4FC�KMQR�AMKNCJJGLE�CTGBCLAC�RF?R�LSAJCMLQ�?PC�AJMQCJW�N?AICB�GL�?�LSAJCSQ

GQ�RF?R�RFC F58=IG�C:�5�BI7@9IG� ��GQ�DMSLB�RM�@C�EGTCL�?NNPMVGK?RCJW�@W

�����

UFCPC ?LB GQ�RFC�K?QQ�LSK@CP�MD�RFC�LSAJCSQ��.MRC�RF?R ��3GLAC�K?LW�LSAJCG�?PC�QNFCPGA?J��?LB�RFC�TMJSKC�MD�?�QNFCPC�GQ

��UC�QCC�RF?R uRF?R�GQ��RFC�TMJSKC�MD�?�LSAJCSQ�GQ�NPMNMPRGML?J�RM�RFC�LSK@CP�MD�LSAJCMLQ�GL�GR��4FGQ�GQ�UF?R�UMSJB�F?NNCL�GD

WMS�N?AI�LSAJCMLQ�QM�AJMQCJW�RF?R�RFCPC�GQ�LM�CKNRW�QN?AC�@CRUCCL�RFCK�

�=;IF9������ !�KMBCJ�MD�RFC�LSAJCSQ�

.SAJCMLQ�?PC�FCJB�RMECRFCP�@W�LSAJC?P�DMPACQ�?LB�PCQGQR�@MRF�@CGLE�NSJJCB�?N?PR�?LB�NSQFCB�GLQGBC�MLC�?LMRFCP��4FC�TMJSKC�MD�RFC�LSAJCSQ�GQ�RFC�QSK

MD�RFC�TMJSKCQ�MD�RFC�LSAJCMLQ�GL�GR��FCPC�QFMUL�GL�BGDDCPCLR�AMJMPQ�RM�PCNPCQCLR�NPMRMLQ�?LB�LCSRPMLQ�

�L5AD@9����� !CK�,A5@@�5B8��9BG9�"G�5�'I7@9IG�

�?�&GLB�RFC�P?BGSQ�MD�?L�GPML ���LSAJCSQ���@�&GLB�GRQ�?NNPMVGK?RC�BCLQGRW�GL ��?NNPMVGK?RGLE�RFC�K?QQ�MD RM�@C����S�

,HF5H9;M�5B8��CB79DH

�?�&GLBGLE�RFC�P?BGSQ�MD GQ�?�QRP?GEFRDMPU?PB�?NNJGA?RGML�MD EGTCL ���@�4M�DGLB�RFC�?NNPMVGK?RC�BCLQGRW��UC�?QQSKC

RFC�LSAJCSQ�GQ�QNFCPGA?J��RFGQ�MLC�?ARS?JJW�GQ��A?JASJ?RC�GRQ�TMJSKC�SQGLE�RFC�P?BGSQ�DMSLB�GL�N?PR��?��?LB�RFCL�DGLB�GRQ�BCLQGRW�DPMK �

&GL?JJW��UC�UGJJ�LCCB�RM�AMLTCPR�BCLQGRW�DPMK�SLGRQ�MD RM �

,C@IH=CB

�?�4FC�P?BGSQ�MD�?�LSAJCSQ�GQ�EGTCL�@W

�����

3S@QRGRSRGLE�RFC�T?JSCQ�DMP ?LB WGCJBQ

�����

�@�$CLQGRW�GQ�BCDGLCB�RM�@C ��UFGAF�DMP�?�QNFCPC�MD�P?BGSQ GQ

������

#(!04%2����Y�2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3 ����

Page 10: 2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · PDF filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝ cbg9fj5h=cb% 5kg z $cdglc? lbb gqasqqlsajc?pbca?w z 3r?rcr fcam lqcpt?rgmlj?uq z %vnj?gln ?pclr?

3S@QRGRSRGLE�ILMUL�T?JSCQ�EGTCQ

������

#MLTCPRGLE�RM�SLGRQ�MD ��UC�DGLB

������

�=G7IGG=CB

�?�4FC�P?BGSQ�MD�RFGQ�KCBGSK QGXCB�LSAJCSQ�GQ�DMSLB�RM�@C�?NNPMVGK?RCJW�����DK��?LB�QM�GRQ�BG?KCRCP�GQ�?@MSR����DK��MP ��)L�MSP

BGQASQQGML�MD�2SRFCPDMPBwQ�BGQAMTCPW�MD�RFC�LSAJCSQ��UC�LMRGACB�RF?R�GR�GQ�?@MSR GL�BG?KCRCP��UFGAF�GQ�DMP�JGEFRCP�LSAJCG��AMLQGQRCLR�UGRF

RFGQ�PCQSJR�RM�?L�MPBCP�MD�K?ELGRSBC��4FC�LSAJCSQ�GQ�KSAF�QK?JJCP�GL�BG?KCRCP�RF?L�RFC�RWNGA?J�?RMK��UFGAF�F?Q�?�BG?KCRCP�MD�RFC�MPBCP�MD

�@�4FC�BCLQGRW�DMSLB�FCPC�GQ�QM�J?PEC�?Q�RM�A?SQC�BGQ@CJGCD��)R�GQ�AMLQGQRCLR�UGRF�C?PJGCP�BGQASQQGMLQ�UC�F?TC�F?B�?@MSR�RFC�LSAJCSQ�@CGLE�TCPW

QK?JJ�?LB�AMLR?GLGLE�LC?PJW�?JJ�MD�RFC�K?QQ�MD�RFC�?RMK��.SAJC?P�BCLQGRGCQ��QSAF�?Q�DMSLB�FCPC��?PC�?@MSR RGKCQ�EPC?RCP�RF?L�RF?R�MD

U?RCP��UFGAF�F?Q�?�BCLQGRW�MD�xMLJWy ��/LC�AS@GA�KCRCP�MD�LSAJC?P�K?RRCP��QSAF�?Q�DMSLB�GL�?�LCSRPML�QR?P��F?Q�RFC�Q?KC�K?QQ�?Q�?

AS@C�MD�U?RCP����IK�ML�?�QGBC�

.SAJC?P�&MPACQ�?LB�3R?@GJGRW

7F?R�DMPACQ�FMJB�?�LSAJCSQ�RMECRFCP��4FC�LSAJCSQ�GQ�TCPW�QK?JJ�?LB�GRQ�NPMRMLQ��@CGLE�NMQGRGTC��CVCPR�RPCKCLBMSQ�PCNSJQGTC�DMPACQ�ML�MLC�?LMRFCP�

�4FC�#MSJMK@�DMPAC�GLAPC?QCQ�?Q�AF?PECQ�ECR�AJMQCP��QGLAC�GR�GQ�NPMNMPRGML?J�RM ��CTCL�?R�RFC�RGLW�BGQR?LACQ�DMSLB�GL�LSAJCG��4FC�?LQUCP�GQ�RF?R

RUM�NPCTGMSQJW�SLILMUL�DMPACQ�FMJB�RFC�LSAJCSQ�RMECRFCP�?LB�K?IC�GR�GLRM�?�RGEFRJW�N?AICB�@?JJ�MD�LSAJCMLQ��4FCQC�DMPACQ�?PC�A?JJCB�RFC J84>�4A7

FGEBA:�AH6?84E�9BE68F��.SAJC?P�DMPACQ�?PC�QM�QFMPR�P?LECB�RF?R�RFCW�D?JJ�RM�XCPM�QRPCLERF�UFCL�LSAJCMLQ�?PC�QCN?P?RCB�@W�MLJW�?�DCU�DK��(MUCTCP��JGIC

EJSC��RFCW�?PC�QRPMLEJW�?RRP?ARCB�UFCL�RFC�LSAJCMLQ�ECR�AJMQC�RM�MLC�?LMRFCP��4FC�QRPMLE�LSAJC?P�DMPAC�GQ�?@MSR�����RGKCQ�KMPC�?RRP?ARGTC�RF?L�RFC

PCNSJQGTC�%-�DMPAC��C?QGJW�FMJBGLE�RFC�LSAJCMLQ�RMECRFCP��.SAJC?P�DMPACQ�@CAMKC�CVRPCKCJW�PCNSJQGTC�GD�RFC�LSAJCMLQ�ECR�RMM�AJMQC��K?IGLE�LSAJCMLQ

QRPMLEJW�PCQGQR�@CGLE�NSQFCB�GLQGBC�MLC�?LMRFCP��QMKCRFGLE�JGIC�@?JJ�@C?PGLEQ�

4FC�D?AR�RF?R�LSAJC?P�DMPACQ�?PC�TCPW�QRPMLE�GQ�PCQNMLQG@JC�DMP�RFC�TCPW�J?PEC�CLCPEGCQ�CKGRRCB�GL�LSAJC?P�BCA?W��$SPGLE�BCA?W��RFC�DMPACQ�BM�UMPI��?LB

QGLAC�UMPI�GQ�DMPAC�RGKCQ�RFC�BGQR?LAC�� ��?�J?PEC�DMPAC�A?L�PCQSJR�GL�?�J?PEC�CKGRRCB�CLCPEW��)L�D?AR��UC�ILMU�RF?R�RFCPC�?PC GJB BGQRGLAR

LSAJC?P�DMPACQ�@CA?SQC�MD�RFC�BGDDCPCLR�RWNCQ�MD�LSAJC?P�BCA?WuRFC�QRPMLE�LSAJC?P�DMPAC�GQ�PCQNMLQG@JC�DMP BCA?W��UFGJC�RFC�UC?I�LSAJC?P�DMPAC�GQ

PCQNMLQG@JC�DMP BCA?W�

4FC�K?LW�QR?@JC�?LB�SLQR?@JC�LSAJCG�UC�F?TC�CVNJMPCB��?LB�RFC�FSLBPCBQ�UC�F?TC�LMR�BGQASQQCB��A?L�@C�?PP?LECB�GL�?�R?@JC�A?JJCB�RFC 7<5FH�C:�H<9

BI7@=89G��?�QGKNJGDGCB�TCPQGML�MD�UFGAF�GQ�QFMUL�GL �=;IF9��������.SAJGBCQ�?PC�JMA?RCB�ML�?�NJMR�MD TCPQSQ ��%V?KGL?RGML�MD�?�BCR?GJCB�AF?PR�MD

RFC�LSAJGBCQ�PCTC?JQ�N?RRCPLQ�GL�RFC�AF?P?ARCPGQRGAQ�MD�LSAJCG��QSAF�?Q�QR?@GJGRW��?@SLB?LAC��?LB�RWNCQ�MD�BCA?W��?L?JMEMSQ�RM�@SR�KMPC�AMKNJCV�RF?L

RFC�QWQRCK?RGAQ�GL�RFC�NCPGMBGA�R?@JC�MD�RFC�CJCKCLRQ�

���� #(!04%2����Y�2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3

4FGQ�AMLRCLR�GQ�?T?GJ?@JC�DMP�DPCC�?R�FRRN���ALV�MPE�AMLRCLR�AMJ���������

Page 11: 2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · PDF filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝ cbg9fj5h=cb% 5kg z $cdglc? lbb gqasqqlsajc?pbca?w z 3r?rcr fcam lqcpt?rgmlj?uq z %vnj?gln ?pclr?

�=;IF9������ 3GKNJGDGCB�AF?PR�MD�RFC�LSAJGBCQ��?�EP?NF�MD TCPQSQ DMP�ILMUL�LSAJGBCQ��4FC�N?RRCPLQ�MD�QR?@JC�?LB�SLQR?@JC�LSAJGBCQ�PCTC?J�AF?P?ARCPGQRGAQ�MD�RFC�LSAJC?P

DMPACQ��4FC�B?QFCB�JGLC�GQ�DMP ��.SK@CPQ�?JMLE�BG?EML?JQ�?PC�K?QQ�LSK@CPQ �

)L�NPGLAGNJC��?�LSAJCSQ�A?L�F?TC�?LW�AMK@GL?RGML�MD�NPMRMLQ�?LB�LCSRPMLQ��@SR �=;IF9������ QFMUQ�?�BCDGLGRC�N?RRCPL�DMP�RFMQC�RF?R�?PC�QR?@JC��&MP

JMU K?QQ�LSAJCG��RFCPC�GQ�?�QRPMLE�RCLBCLAW�DMP ?LB RM�@C�LC?PJW�COS?J��4FGQ�KC?LQ�RF?R�RFC�LSAJC?P�DMPAC�GQ�KMPC�?RRP?ARGTC�UFCL �

-MPC�BCR?GJCB�CV?KGL?RGML�PCTC?JQ�EPC?RCP�QR?@GJGRW�UFCL ?LB ?PC�CTCL�LSK@CPQuLSAJC?P�DMPACQ�?PC�KMPC�?RRP?ARGTC�UFCL�LCSRPMLQ�?LB

NPMRMLQ�?PC�GL�N?GPQ��&MP�GLAPC?QGLEJW�FGEFCP�K?QQCQ��RFCPC�?PC�NPMEPCQQGTCJW�KMPC�LCSRPMLQ�RF?L�NPMRMLQ�GL�QR?@JC�LSAJCG��4FGQ�GQ�BSC�RM�RFC�CTCP

EPMUGLE�PCNSJQGML�@CRUCCL�NPMRMLQ��3GLAC�LSAJC?P�DMPACQ�?PC�QFMPR�P?LECB��?LB�RFC�#MSJMK@�DMPAC�GQ�JMLE�P?LECB��?L�CVACQQ�MD�LCSRPMLQ�ICCNQ�RFC

NPMRMLQ�?�JGRRJC�D?PRFCP�?N?PR��PCBSAGLE�#MSJMK@�PCNSJQGML��$CA?W�KMBCQ�MD�LSAJGBCQ�MSR�MD�RFC�PCEGML�MD�QR?@GJGRW�AMLQGQRCLRJW�NPMBSAC�LSAJGBCQ�AJMQCP

RM�RFC�PCEGML�MD�QR?@GJGRW��4FCPC�?PC�KMPC�QR?@JC�LSAJCG�F?TGLE�ACPR?GL�LSK@CPQ�MD�NPMRMLQ�?LB�LCSRPMLQ��A?JJCB A5;=7�BIA69FG��-?EGA�LSK@CPQ

GLBGA?RC�?�QFCJJ�QRPSARSPC�DMP�RFC�LSAJCSQ�GL�UFGAF�AJMQCB�QFCJJQ�?PC�KMPC�QR?@JC��.SAJC?P�QFCJJ�RFCMPW�F?Q�@CCL�TCPW�QSAACQQDSJ�GL�CVNJ?GLGLE�LSAJC?P

CLCPEW�JCTCJQ��LSAJC?P�BCA?W��?LB�RFC�EPC?RCP�QR?@GJGRW�MD�LSAJCG�UGRF�AJMQCB�QFCJJQ��7C�F?TC�@CCL�NPMBSAGLE�CTCP FC?TGCP�RP?LQSP?LGA�CJCKCLRQ�QGLAC

RFC�C?PJW�����Q��?LB�UC�F?TC�LMU�NPMBSACB�RFC�CJCKCLR�UGRF ��4FCPC�?PC�RFCMPCRGA?J�NPCBGARGMLQ�MD�?L�GQJ?LB�MD�PCJ?RGTC�QR?@GJGRW�DMP�LSAJCG

UGRF�QSAF�FGEF Q�

�=;IF9������ 4FC�'CPK?L @MPL�!KCPGA?L�NFWQGAGQR�-?PG?�'MCNNCPR�-?WCP������t�����QF?PCB�RFC������.M@CJ�0PGXC�GL�NFWQGAQ�UGRF�*��*CLQCL�DMP�RFC�APC?RGML�MD�RFC�LSAJC?P

QFCJJ�KMBCJ��4FGQ�QSAACQQDSJ�LSAJC?P�KMBCJ�F?Q�LSAJCMLQ�DGJJGLE�QFCJJQ�?L?JMEMSQ�RM�CJCARPML�QFCJJQ�GL�?RMKQ��)R�U?Q�GLQNGPCB�@W�N?RRCPLQ�M@QCPTCB�GL�LSAJC?P�NPMNCPRGCQ���APCBGR�

.M@CJ�&MSLB?RGML�TG?�7GIGKCBG?�#MKKMLQ

���� 'I7@95F��975M�5B8��CBG9FJ5H=CB�%5KG

.SAJC?P 8975M F?Q�NPMTGBCB�?L�?K?XGLE�UGLBMU�GLRM�RFC�PC?JK�MD�RFC�TCPW�QK?JJ��.SAJC?P�BCA?W�E?TC�RFC�DGPQR�GLBGA?RGML�MD�RFC�AMLLCARGML�@CRUCCL

K?QQ�?LB�CLCPEW��?LB�GR�PCTC?JCB�RFC�CVGQRCLAC�MD�RUM�MD�RFC�DMSP�@?QGA�DMPACQ�GL�L?RSPC��)L�RFGQ�QCARGML��UC�CVNJMPC�RFC�K?HMP�KMBCQ�MD�LSAJC?P�BCA?W�

?LB��JGIC�RFMQC�UFM�DGPQR�CVNJMPCB�RFCK��UC�UGJJ�BGQAMTCP�CTGBCLAC�MD�NPCTGMSQJW�SLILMUL�N?PRGAJCQ�?LB�AMLQCPT?RGML�J?UQ�

#(!04%2����Y�2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3 ����

Page 12: 2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · PDF filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝ cbg9fj5h=cb% 5kg z $cdglc? lbb gqasqqlsajc?pbca?w z 3r?rcr fcam lqcpt?rgmlj?uq z %vnj?gln ?pclr?

3MKC�LSAJGBCQ�?PC�QR?@JC��?NN?PCLRJW�JGTGLE�DMPCTCP��5LQR?@JC�LSAJGBCQ�BCA?W��RF?R�GQ��RFCW�?PC�P?BGM?ARGTC��CTCLRS?JJW�NPMBSAGLE�?�QR?@JC�LSAJGBC�?DRCP

K?LW�BCA?WQ��7C�A?JJ�RFC�MPGEGL?J�LSAJGBC�RFC D5F9BH ?LB�GRQ�BCA?W�NPMBSARQ�RFC 85I;<H9FG��3MKC�P?BGM?ARGTC�LSAJGBCQ�BCA?W�GL�?�QGLEJC�QRCN�RM�?

QR?@JC�LSAJCSQ��&MP�CV?KNJC� GQ�SLQR?@JC�?LB�BCA?WQ�BGPCARJW�RM ��UFGAF�GQ�QR?@JC��/RFCPQ��QSAF�?Q ��BCA?W�RM�?LMRFCP�SLQR?@JC

LSAJGBC��PCQSJRGLE�GL�? 8975M�G9F=9G GL�UFGAF�C?AF�QS@QCOSCLR�LSAJGBC�BCA?WQ�SLRGJ�?�QR?@JC�LSAJGBC�GQ�DGL?JJW�NPMBSACB��4FC�BCA?W�QCPGCQ�RF?R�QR?PRQ

DPMK GQ�MD�N?PRGASJ?P�GLRCPCQR��QGLAC�GR�NPMBSACQ�RFC�P?BGM?ARGTC�GQMRMNCQ ?LB ��UFGAF�RFC�#SPGCQ�DGPQR�BGQAMTCPCB��QCC �=;IF9

�������2?BML�E?Q�GQ�?JQM�NPMBSACB�� GL�RFC�QCPGCQ��?L�GLAPC?QGLEJW�PCAMELGXCB�L?RSP?JJW�MAASPPGLE�F?X?PB��3GLAC�P?BML�GQ�?�LM@JC�E?Q��GR

CK?L?RCQ�DPMK�K?RCPG?JQ��QSAF�?Q�QMGJ��AMLR?GLGLE�CTCL�RP?AC�?KMSLRQ�MD ?LB�A?L�@C�GLF?JCB��4FC�BCA?W�MD�P?BML�?LB�GRQ�B?SEFRCPQ�NPMBSACQ

GLRCPL?J�B?K?EC��4FC BCA?W�QCPGCQ�CLBQ�UGRF ��?�QR?@JC�GQMRMNC�MD�JC?B�

�=;IF9������ 4FC�BCA?W�QCPGCQ�NPMBSACB�@W ��RFC�KMQR�AMKKML�SP?LGSK�GQMRMNC��.SAJGBCQ�?PC�EP?NFCB�GL�RFC�Q?KC�K?LLCP�?Q�GL�RFC�AF?PR�MD�LSAJGBCQ��4FC�RWNC�MD

BCA?W�DMP�C?AF�KCK@CP�MD�RFC�QCPGCQ�GQ�QFMUL��?Q�UCJJ�?Q�RFC�F?JD JGTCQ��.MRC�RF?R�QMKC�LSAJGBCQ�BCA?W�@W�KMPC�RF?L�MLC�KMBC��9MS�A?L�QCC�UFW�P?BGSK�?LB�NMJMLGSK�?PC

DMSLB�GL�SP?LGSK�MPC��!�QR?@JC�GQMRMNC�MD�JC?B�GQ�RFC�CLB�NPMBSAR�MD�RFC�QCPGCQ�

.MRC�RF?R�RFC�B?SEFRCPQ�MD BCA?W�QFMUL�GL �=;IF9������ ?JU?WQ�F?TC�RUM�DCUCP�NPMRMLQ�?LB�RUM�DCUCP�LCSRPMLQ�RF?L�RFC�N?PCLR��4FGQ�QCCKQ

PC?QML?@JC��QGLAC�UC�ILMU�RF?R BCA?W�GQ�RFC�CKGQQGML�MD�? LSAJCSQ��UFGAF�F?Q�RUM�NPMRMLQ�?LB�RUM�LCSRPMLQ��4FC�B?SEFRCPQ�MD BCA?W

F?TC�MLC�JCQQ�LCSRPML�?LB�MLC�KMPC�NPMRML�RF?L�RFCGP�N?PCLR��"CR?�BCA?W�GQ�?�JGRRJC�KMPC�QS@RJC��?Q�UC�QF?JJ�QCC��.M BCA?WQ�?PC�QFMUL�GL�RFC

DGESPC��@CA?SQC�RFCW�BM�LMR�NPMBSAC�?�B?SEFRCP�RF?R�BGDDCPQ�DPMK�RFC�N?PCLR�

!JNF?�$CA?W

)L 5@D<5�8975M��? LSAJCSQ�QGKNJW�@PC?IQ�?U?W�DPMK�RFC�N?PCLR�LSAJCSQ��JC?TGLE�?�B?SEFRCP�UGRF�RUM�DCUCP�NPMRMLQ�?LB�RUM�DCUCP�LCSRPMLQ

RF?L�RFC�N?PCLR��QCC �=;IF9��������/LC�CV?KNJC�MD BCA?W�GQ�QFMUL�GL �=;IF9������ DMP ��!LMRFCP�LSAJGBC�RF?R�SLBCPEMCQ BCA?W�GQ

� 4FC�BCA?W�COS?RGMLQ�DMP�RFCQC�RUM�LSAJGBCQ�?PC

������

���� #(!04%2����Y�2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3

4FGQ�AMLRCLR�GQ�?T?GJ?@JC�DMP�DPCC�?R�FRRN���ALV�MPE�AMLRCLR�AMJ���������

Page 13: 2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · PDF filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝ cbg9fj5h=cb% 5kg z $cdglc? lbb gqasqqlsajc?pbca?w z 3r?rcr fcam lqcpt?rgmlj?uq z %vnj?gln ?pclr?

?LB

������

�=;IF9������ !JNF?�BCA?W�GQ�RFC�QCN?P?RGML�MD�? LSAJCSQ�DPMK�RFC�N?PCLR��4FC�B?SEFRCP�LSAJCSQ�F?Q�RUM�DCUCP�NPMRMLQ�?LB�RUM�DCUCP�LCSRPMLQ�RF?L�RFC�N?PCLR��!JNF?

BCA?W�MAASPQ�QNMLR?LCMSQJW�MLJW�GD�RFC�B?SEFRCP�?LB LSAJCSQ�F?TC�JCQQ�RMR?J�K?QQ�RF?L�RFC�N?PCLR�

)D�WMS�CV?KGLC�RFC�NCPGMBGA�R?@JC�MD�RFC�CJCKCLRQ��WMS�UGJJ�DGLB�RF?R�4F�F?Q ��RUM�DCUCP�RF?L�5��UFGAF�F?Q ��3GKGJ?PJW��GL�RFC�QCAMLB

8975M�9EI5H=CB��UC�QCC�RF?R�5�F?Q�RUM�DCUCP�NPMRMLQ�RF?L�0S��UFGAF�F?Q ��4FC�ECLCP?J�PSJC�DMP BCA?W�GQ�@CQR�UPGRRCL�GL�RFC�DMPK?R

��)D�?�ACPR?GL�LSAJGBC�GQ�ILMUL�RM BCA?W��ECLCP?JJW�RFGQ�GLDMPK?RGML�KSQR�@C�JMMICB�SN�GL�?�R?@JC�MD�GQMRMNCQ��QSAF�?Q�GL �DD9B8=L����GRQ

8975M�9EI5H=CB GQ

������

UFCPC�9�GQ�RFC�LSAJGBC�RF?R�F?Q�RUM�DCUCP�NPMRMLQ�RF?L�8��QSAF�?Q�4F�F?TGLE�RUM�DCUCP�RF?L�5��3M�GD�WMS�UCPC�RMJB�RF?R BCA?WQ�?LB�UCPC

?QICB�RM�UPGRC�RFC�AMKNJCRC�BCA?W�COS?RGML��WMS�UMSJB�DGPQR�JMMI�SN�UFGAF�CJCKCLR�F?Q�RUM�DCUCP�NPMRMLQ��?L�?RMKGA�LSK@CP�RUM�JMUCP�?LB�DGLB�RF?R

RFGQ�GQ�SP?LGSK��4FCL�QGLAC�DMSP�LSAJCMLQ�F?TC�@PMICL�?U?W�DPMK�RFC�MPGEGL?J������GRQ�?RMKGA�K?QQ�UMSJB�@C�����

)R�GQ�GLQRPSARGTC�RM�CV?KGLC�AMLQCPT?RGML�J?UQ�PCJ?RCB�RM BCA?W��9MS�A?L�QCC�DPMK�RFC�COS?RGML RF?R�RMR?J�AF?PEC�GQ

AMLQCPTCB��,GLC?P�?LB�?LESJ?P�KMKCLRSK�?PC�AMLQCPTCB��RMM��!JRFMSEF�AMLQCPTCB�?LESJ?P�KMKCLRSK�GQ�LMR�MD�EPC?R�AMLQCOSCLAC�GL�RFGQ�RWNC�MD

BCA?W��AMLQCPT?RGML�MD�JGLC?P�KMKCLRSK�F?Q�GLRCPCQRGLE�AMLQCOSCLACQ��)D�RFC�LSAJCSQ�GQ�?R�PCQR�UFCL�GR�BCA?WQ��GRQ�KMKCLRSK�GQ�XCPM��)L�RF?R�A?QC�

RFC�DP?EKCLRQ�KSQR�DJW�GL�MNNMQGRC�BGPCARGMLQ�UGRF�COS?J K?ELGRSBC�KMKCLR?�QM�RF?R�RMR?J�KMKCLRSK�PCK?GLQ�XCPM��4FGQ�PCQSJRQ�GL�RFC N?PRGAJC

A?PPWGLE�?U?W�KMQR�MD�RFC�CLCPEW��?Q�?�@SJJCR�DPMK�?�FC?TW�PGDJC�A?PPGCQ�?U?W�KMQR�MD�RFC�CLCPEW�MD�RFC�NMUBCP�@SPLCB�RM�QFMMR�GR��4MR?J�K?QQtCLCPEW

GQ�?JQM�AMLQCPTCB��RFC�CLCPEW�NPMBSACB�GL�RFC�BCA?W�AMKCQ�DPMK�AMLTCPQGML�MD�?�DP?ARGML�MD�RFC�MPGEGL?J�K?QQ��!Q�BGQASQQCB�GL �HCA=7�)<MG=7G��RFC

ECLCP?J�PCJ?RGMLQFGN�GQ

������

(CPC� GQ�RFC BI7@95F�F957H=CB�9B9F;M �RFC�PC?ARGML�A?L�@C�LSAJC?P�BCA?W�MP�?LW�MRFCP�PC?ARGML��?LB GQ�RFC�BGDDCPCLAC�GL�K?QQ�@CRUCCL�GLGRG?J

?LB�DGL?J�NPMBSARQ��7FCL�RFC�DGL?J�NPMBSARQ�F?TC�JCQQ�RMR?J�K?QQ� GQ�NMQGRGTC��?LB�RFC�PC?ARGML�PCJC?QCQ�CLCPEW��GQ�CVMRFCPKGA��7FCL�RFC

NPMBSARQ�F?TC�EPC?RCP�RMR?J�K?QQ��RFC�PC?ARGML�GQ�CLBMRFCPKGA�� GQ�LCE?RGTC�?LB�KSQR�@C�GLBSACB�UGRF�?L�CLCPEW�GLNSR��&MP BCA?W�RM�@C

QNMLR?LCMSQ��RFC�BCA?W�NPMBSARQ�KSQR�F?TC�QK?JJCP�K?QQ�RF?L�RFC�N?PCLR�

�L5AD@9����� �@D<5��975M��B9F;M��CIB8�:FCA�'I7@95F�&5GG9G

&GLB�RFC�CLCPEW�CKGRRCB�GL�RFC BCA?W�MD �

,HF5H9;M

.SAJC?P�PC?ARGML�CLCPEW��QSAF�?Q�PCJC?QCB�GL P BCA?W��A?L�@C�DMSLB�SQGLE�RFC�COS?RGML ��7C�KSQR�DGPQR�DGLB ��RFC�BGDDCPCLAC�GL

K?QQ�@CRUCCL�RFC�N?PCLR�LSAJCSQ�?LB�RFC�NPMBSARQ�MD�RFC�BCA?W��4FGQ�GQ�C?QGJW�BMLC�SQGLE�K?QQCQ�EGTCL�GL �DD9B8=L���

,C@IH=CB

4FC�BCA?W�COS?RGML�U?Q�EGTCL�C?PJGCP�DMP ��GR�GQ

������

4FSQ�RFC�NCPRGLCLR�K?QQCQ�?PC�RFMQC�MD � ��?LB�RFC N?PRGAJC�MP ��?JJ�MD�UFGAF�?PC�JGQRCB�GL �DD9B8=L����4FC�GLGRG?J�K?QQ�U?Q

��4FC�DGL?J�K?QQ�GQ�RFC�QSK ��4FSQ�

������

.MU�UC�A?L�DGLB @W�CLRCPGLE GLRM�RFC�COS?RGML�

������

7C�ILMU ��?LB�QM

#(!04%2����Y�2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3 ����

Page 14: 2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · PDF filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝ cbg9fj5h=cb% 5kg z $cdglc? lbb gqasqqlsajc?pbca?w z 3r?rcr fcam lqcpt?rgmlj?uq z %vnj?gln ?pclr?

������

�=G7IGG=CB

4FC�CLCPEW�PCJC?QCB�GL�RFGQ BCA?W�GQ�GL�RFC P?LEC��?@MSR RGKCQ�?Q�EPC?R�?Q�RWNGA?J�AFCKGA?J�PC?ARGML�CLCPEGCQ��AMLQGQRCLR�UGRF

K?LW�NPCTGMSQ�BGQASQQGMLQ��-MQR�MD�RFGQ�CLCPEW�@CAMKCQ�IGLCRGA�CLCPEW�MD�RFC N?PRGAJC��MP LSAJCSQ��UFGAF�KMTCQ�?U?W�?R�FGEF�QNCCB�

4FC�CLCPEW�A?PPGCB�?U?W�@W�RFC�PCAMGJ�MD�RFC LSAJCSQ�GQ�KSAF�QK?JJCP�GL�MPBCP�RM�AMLQCPTC�KMKCLRSK��4FC LSAJCSQ�A?L�@C�JCDR�GL

?L�CVAGRCB�QR?RC�RM�J?RCP�CKGR�NFMRMLQ�� P?WQ��4FGQ�BCA?W�GQ�QNMLR?LCMSQ�?LB�PCJC?QCQ�CLCPEW��@CA?SQC�RFC�NPMBSARQ�F?TC�JCQQ�K?QQ�RF?L�RFC

N?PCLR�LSAJCSQ��4FC�OSCQRGML�MD�UFW�RFC�NPMBSARQ�F?TC�JCQQ�K?QQ�UGJJ�@C�BGQASQQCB�GL �=B8=B;��B9F;M��.MRC�RF?R�RFC�K?QQCQ�EGTCL�GL �DD9B8=L

� ?PC�?RMKGA�K?QQCQ�MD�LCSRP?J�?RMKQ��GLAJSBGLE�RFCGP�CJCARPMLQ��4FC�K?QQ�MD�RFC�CJCARPMLQ�GQ�RFC�Q?KC�@CDMPC�?LB�?DRCP BCA?W��?LB�QM�RFCGP

K?QQCQ�QS@RP?AR�MSR�UFCL�DGLBGLE ��)L�RFGQ�A?QC��RFCPC�?PC����CJCARPMLQ�@CDMPC�?LB�?DRCP�RFC�BCA?W�

"CR?�$CA?W

4FCPC�?PC�?ARS?JJW G;E88 RWNCQ�MD 69H5�8975M��4FC�DGPQR�BGQAMTCPCB�U?Q�xMPBGL?PWy�@CR?�BCA?W�?LB�GQ�A?JJCB BCA?W�MP�CJCARPML�CKGQQGML��4FC

QWK@MJ PCNPCQCLRQ 4A�8?86GEBA�8@<GG87�<A�AH6?84E�58G4�7864L��#M@?JR ���GQ�?�LSAJGBC�RF?R BCA?WQ�GL�RFC�DMJJMUGLE�K?LLCP�

������

4FC B9IHF=BC GQ�?�N?PRGAJC�CKGRRCB�GL�@CR?�BCA?W�RF?R�U?Q�SL?LRGAGN?RCB�?LB�GQ�MD�DSLB?KCLR?J�GKNMPR?LAC��4FC�LCSRPGLM�U?Q�LMR�CTCL�NPMNMQCB�GL

RFCMPW�SLRGJ�KMPC�RF?L����WC?PQ�?DRCP�@CR?�BCA?W�U?Q�ILMUL�RM�GLTMJTC�CJCARPML�CKGQQGMLQ��.CSRPGLMQ�?PC�QM�BGDDGASJR�RM�BCRCAR�RF?R�RFC�DGPQR�BGPCAR

CTGBCLAC�MD�RFCK�U?Q�LMR�M@R?GLCB�SLRGJ�������.CSRPGLMQ�?PC�LC?PJW�K?QQJCQQ��F?TC�LM�AF?PEC��?LB�BM�LMR�GLRCP?AR�UGRF�LSAJCMLQ�TG?�RFC�QRPMLE

LSAJC?P�DMPAC��4P?TCJGLE�?NNPMVGK?RCJW�?R�RFC�QNCCB�MD�JGEFR��RFCW�F?TC�JGRRJC�RGKC�RM�?DDCAR�?LW�LSAJCSQ�RFCW�CLAMSLRCP��4FGQ�GQ��MUGLE�RM�RFC�D?AR�RF?R

RFCW�F?TC�LM�AF?PEC��?LB�RFCW�?PC�LMR�%-�U?TCQ��RFCW�BM�LMR�GLRCP?AR�RFPMSEF�RFC�%-�DMPAC��4FCW�BM�GLRCP?AR�TG?�RFC�PCJ?RGTCJW�UC?I�?LB�TCPW�QFMPR

P?LEC�UC?I�LSAJC?P�DMPAC��#MLQCOSCLRJW��LCSRPGLMQ�CQA?NC�?JKMQR�?LW�BCRCARMP�?LB�NCLCRP?RC�?JKMQR�?LW�QFGCJBGLE��(MUCTCP��LCSRPGLMQ�BM�A?PPW

CLCPEW��?LESJ?P�KMKCLRSK��RFCW�?PC�DCPKGMLQ�UGRF�F?JD GLRCEP?J�QNGL��?LB�JGLC?P�KMKCLRSK�?U?W�DPMK�?�@CR?�BCA?W��7FCL�?AASP?RC�KC?QSPCKCLRQ

MD�@CR?�BCA?W�UCPC�K?BC��GR�@CA?KC�?NN?PCLR�RF?R�CLCPEW��?LESJ?P�KMKCLRSK��?LB�JGLC?P�KMKCLRSK�UCPC�LMR�?AAMSLRCB�DMP�@W�RFC�B?SEFRCP

LSAJCSQ�?LB�CJCARPML�?JMLC��%GRFCP�?�NPCTGMSQJW�SLQSQNCARCB�N?PRGAJC�U?Q�A?PPWGLE�RFCK�?U?W��MP�RFPCC�AMLQCPT?RGML�J?UQ�UCPC�@CGLE�TGMJ?RCB�

7MJDE?LE�0?SJG�K?BC�?�DMPK?J�NPMNMQ?J�DMP�RFC�CVGQRCLAC�MD�LCSRPGLMQ�GL�������4FC�)R?JG?L @MPL�!KCPGA?L�NFWQGAGQR�%LPGAM�&CPKG������t�����E?TC

LCSRPGLMQ�RFCGP�L?KC��KC?LGLE�JGRRJC�LCSRP?J�MLCQ��UFCL�FC�BCTCJMNCB�?�QMNFGQRGA?RCB�RFCMPW�MD�@CR?�BCA?W��QCC �=;IF9��������0?PR�MD�&CPKGwQ�RFCMPW

U?Q�RFC�GBCLRGDGA?RGML�MD�RFC�UC?I�LSAJC?P�DMPAC�?Q�@CGLE�BGQRGLAR�DPMK�RFC�QRPMLE�LSAJC?P�DMPAC�?LB�GL�D?AR�PCQNMLQG@JC�DMP�@CR?�BCA?W�

�=;IF9������ %LPGAM�&CPKG�U?Q�LC?PJW�SLGOSC�?KMLE���RF ACLRSPW�NFWQGAGQRQuFC�K?BC�QGELGDGA?LR�AMLRPG@SRGMLQ�@MRF�?Q�?L�CVNCPGKCLR?JGQR�?LB�?�RFCMPGQR��(GQ�K?LW

AMLRPG@SRGMLQ�RM�RFCMPCRGA?J�NFWQGAQ�GLAJSBCB�RFC�GBCLRGDGA?RGML�MD�RFC�UC?I�LSAJC?P�DMPAC��4FC�DCPKG��DK�GQ�L?KCB�?DRCP�FGK��?Q�?PC�?L�CLRGPC�AJ?QQ�MD�QS@?RMKGA�N?PRGAJCQ

�DCPKGMLQ��?L�CJCKCLR��&CPKGSK��?LB�?�K?HMP�PCQC?PAF�J?@MP?RMPW��&CPKGJ?@��(GQ�CVNCPGKCLR?J�UMPI�GLAJSBCB�QRSBGCQ�MD�P?BGM?ARGTGRW��DMP�UFGAF�FC�UML�RFC������.M@CJ�0PGXC

GL�NFWQGAQ��?LB�APC?RGML�MD�RFC�DGPQR�LSAJC?P�AF?GL�PC?ARGML���APCBGR��5LGRCB�3R?RCQ�$CN?PRKCLR�MD�%LCPEW��/DDGAC�MD�0S@JGA�!DD?GPQ

4FC�LCSRPGLM�?JQM�PCTC?JQ�?�LCU�AMLQCPT?RGML�J?U��4FCPC�?PC�T?PGMSQ�D?KGJGCQ�MD�N?PRGAJCQ��MLC�MD�UFGAF�GQ�RFC�CJCARPML�D?KGJW��7C�NPMNMQC�RF?R�RFC

LSK@CP�MD�KCK@CPQ�MD�RFC�CJCARPML�D?KGJW�GQ�AMLQR?LR�GL�?LW�NPMACQQ�MP�?LW�AJMQCB�QWQRCK��)L�MSP�CV?KNJC�MD�@CR?�BCA?W��RFCPC�?PC�LM�KCK@CPQ�MD

RFC�CJCARPML�D?KGJW�NPCQCLR�@CDMPC�RFC�BCA?W��@SR�?DRCP��RFCPC�GQ�?L�CJCARPML�?LB�?�LCSRPGLM��3M�CJCARPMLQ�?PC�EGTCL�?L�CJCARPML�D?KGJW�LSK@CP�MD �

4FC�LCSRPGLM�GL BCA?W�GQ�?L 9@97HFCBUG�5BH=B9IHF=BC��EGTCL�RFC�QWK@MJ ��UFCPC GQ�RFC�'PCCI�JCRRCP�LS��?LB�RFC�QS@QAPGNR 8 KC?LQ�RFGQ

LCSRPGLM�GQ�PCJ?RCB�RM�RFC�CJCARPML��4FC�@?P�GLBGA?RCQ�RFGQ�GQ�?�N?PRGAJC�MD 5BH=A5HH9F���!JJ�N?PRGAJCQ�F?TC�?LRGK?RRCP�AMSLRCPN?PRQ�RF?R�?PC�LC?PJW�GBCLRGA?J

CVACNR�RF?R�RFCW�F?TC�RFC�MNNMQGRC�AF?PEC��!LRGK?RRCP�GQ�?JKMQR�CLRGPCJW�?@QCLR�ML�%?PRF��@SR�GR�GQ�DMSLB�GL�LSAJC?P�BCA?W�?LB�MRFCP�LSAJC?P�?LB

N?PRGAJC�PC?ARGMLQ�?Q�UCJJ�?Q�GL�MSRCP�QN?AC��4FC�CJCARPMLwQ�?LRGLCSRPGLM ��@CGLE�?LRGK?RRCP��F?Q�?L�CJCARPML�D?KGJW�LSK@CP�MD ��4FC�RMR?J�GQ

XCPM��@CDMPC�?LB�?DRCP�RFC�BCA?W��4FC�LCU�AMLQCPT?RGML�J?U��M@CWCB�GL�?JJ�AGPASKQR?LACQ��QR?RCQ�RF?R�RFC GBG4?�8?86GEBA�94@<?L�AH@58E�<F�6BAFG4AG��!L

CJCARPML�A?LLMR�@C�APC?RCB�UGRFMSR�?JQM�APC?RGLE�?L�?LRGK?RRCP�D?KGJW�KCK@CP��4FGQ�J?U�GQ�?L?JMEMSQ�RM�RFC�AMLQCPT?RGML�MD�AF?PEC�GL�?�QGRS?RGML

UFCPC�RMR?J�AF?PEC�GQ�MPGEGL?JJW�XCPM��?LB�COS?J�?KMSLRQ�MD�NMQGRGTC�?LB�LCE?RGTC�AF?PEC�KSQR�@C�APC?RCB�GL�?�PC?ARGML�RM�ICCN�RFC�RMR?J�XCPM�

���� #(!04%2����Y�2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3

4FGQ�AMLRCLR�GQ�?T?GJ?@JC�DMP�DPCC�?R�FRRN���ALV�MPE�AMLRCLR�AMJ���������

Page 15: 2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · PDF filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝ cbg9fj5h=cb% 5kg z $cdglc? lbb gqasqqlsajc?pbca?w z 3r?rcr fcam lqcpt?rgmlj?uq z %vnj?gln ?pclr?

)D�?�LSAJGBC GQ�ILMUL�RM BCA?W��RFCL�GRQ BCA?W�COS?RGML�GQ

������

UFCPC�9�GQ�RFC�LSAJGBC�F?TGLE�MLC�KMPC�NPMRML�RF?L�8��QCC �=;IF9��������3M�GD�WMS�ILMU�RF?R�?�ACPR?GL�LSAJGBC BCA?WQ��WMS�A?L�DGLB�RFC

B?SEFRCP�LSAJCSQ�@W�DGPQR�JMMIGLE�SN DMP�RFC�N?PCLR�?LB�RFCL�BCRCPKGLGLE�UFGAF�CJCKCLR�F?Q�?RMKGA�LSK@CP ��)L�RFC�CV?KNJC�MD�RFC

BCA?W�MD EGTCL�C?PJGCP��UC�QCC�RF?R DMP�#M�?LB GQ�.G��)R�GQ�?Q�GD�MLC�MD�RFC�LCSRPMLQ�GL�RFC�N?PCLR�LSAJCSQ�BCA?WQ�GLRM�?

NPMRML��CJCARPML��?LB�LCSRPGLM��)L�D?AR��LCSRPMLQ�MSRQGBC�MD�LSAJCG�BM�HSQR�RF?RuRFCW�JGTC�MLJW�?L�?TCP?EC�MD�?�DCU�KGLSRCQ�?LB BCA?W�GL�RFC

DMJJMUGLE�K?LLCP�

������

�=;IF9������ )L BCA?W��RFC�N?PCLR�LSAJCSQ�CKGRQ�?L�CJCARPML�?LB�?L�?LRGLCSRPGLM��4FC�B?SEFRCP�LSAJCSQ�F?Q�MLC�KMPC�NPMRML�?LB�MLC�JCQQ�LCSRPML�RF?L�GRQ�N?PCLR�

.CSRPGLMQ�GLRCP?AR�QM�UC?IJW�RF?R�RFCW�?PC�?JKMQR�LCTCP�BGPCARJW�M@QCPTCB��@SR�RFCW�NJ?W�?�DSLB?KCLR?J�PMJC�GL�N?PRGAJC�NFWQGAQ�

7C�QCC�RF?R�AF?PEC�GQ�AMLQCPTCB�GL BCA?W��QGLAC�RFC�RMR?J�AF?PEC�GQ @CDMPC�?LB�?DRCP�RFC�BCA?W��&MP�CV?KNJC��GL BCA?W��RMR?J�AF?PEC�GQ

���@CDMPC�BCA?W��QGLAC�AM@?JR�F?Q ��!DRCP�BCA?W��RFC�B?SEFRCP�LSAJCSQ�GQ�.G��UFGAF�F?Q ��?LB�RFCPC�GQ�?L�CJCARPML��QM�RF?R�RFC�RMR?J

AF?PEC�GQ�?JQM MP�����!LESJ?P�KMKCLRSK�GQ�AMLQCPTCB��@SR�LMR�M@TGMSQJW��WMS�F?TC�RM�CV?KGLC�RFC�QNGLQ�?LB�?LESJ?P�KMKCLR?�MD�RFC

DGL?J�NPMBSARQ�GL�BCR?GJ�RM�TCPGDW�RFGQ��,GLC?P�KMKCLRSK�GQ�?JQM�AMLQCPTCB��?E?GL�GKN?PRGLE�KMQR�MD�RFC�BCA?W�CLCPEW�RM�RFC�CJCARPML�?LB�RFC

?LRGLCSRPGLM��QGLAC�RFCW�?PC�MD�JMU�?LB�XCPM�K?QQ��PCQNCARGTCJW��!LMRFCP�LCU�AMLQCPT?RGML�J?U�GQ�M@CWCB�FCPC�?LB�CJQCUFCPC�GL�L?RSPC� +;8�GBG4?

AH@58E�B9�AH6?8BAF <F�6BAF8EI87��)L BCA?W��DMP�CV?KNJC��RFCPC�?PC����LSAJCMLQ�@CDMPC�?LB�?DRCP�RFC�BCA?W��.MRC�RF?R�RMR?J GQ�?JQM

AMLQCPTCB�GL BCA?W��!JQM�LMRC�RF?R�RFC�RMR?J�LSK@CP�MD�NPMRMLQ�AF?LECQ��?Q�BMCQ�RFC�RMR?J�LSK@CP�MD�LCSRPMLQ��QM�RF?R�RMR?J ?LB�RMR?J ?PC

ABG AMLQCPTCB�GL BCA?W��?Q�RFCW�?PC�GL BCA?W��%LCPEW�PCJC?QCB�GL BCA?W�A?L�@C�A?JASJ?RCB�EGTCL�RFC�K?QQCQ�MD�RFC�N?PCLR�?LB�NPMBSARQ�

�L5AD@9����� �975M��B9F;M�:FCA�&5GG9G

&GLB�RFC�CLCPEW�CKGRRCB�GL�RFC BCA?W�MD �

,HF5H9;M�5B8��CB79DH

!Q�GL�RFC�NPCACBGLE�CV?KNJC��UC�KSQR�DGPQR�DGLB ��RFC�BGDDCPCLAC�GL�K?QQ�@CRUCCL�RFC�N?PCLR�LSAJCSQ�?LB�RFC�NPMBSARQ�MD�RFC�BCA?W��SQGLE

K?QQCQ�EGTCL�GL �DD9B8=L����4FCL�RFC�CKGRRCB�CLCPEW�GQ�A?JASJ?RCB�?Q�@CDMPC��SQGLE ��4FC�GLGRG?J�K?QQ�GQ�HSQR�RF?R�MD�RFC�N?PCLR

LSAJCSQ��?LB�RFC�DGL?J�K?QQ�GQ�RF?R�MD�RFC�B?SEFRCP�LSAJCSQ�?LB�RFC�CJCARPML�APC?RCB�GL�RFC�BCA?W��4FC�LCSRPGLM�GQ�K?QQJCQQ��MP�LC?PJW�QM�

(MUCTCP��QGLAC�RFC�K?QQCQ�EGTCL�GL �DD9B8=L�� ?PC�DMP�LCSRP?J�?RMKQ��RFC�B?SEFRCP�LSAJCSQ�F?Q�MLC�KMPC�CJCARPML�RF?L�RFC�N?PCLR��?LB�QM�RFC

CVRP?�CJCARPML�K?QQ�RF?R�AMPPCQNMLBQ�RM�RFC GQ�GLAJSBCB�GL�RFC�?RMKGA�K?QQ�MD�.G��4FSQ�

������

,C@IH=CB

4FC BCA?W�COS?RGML�DMP GQ

������

!Q�LMRGACB�

������

%LRCPGLE�RFC�K?QQCQ�DMSLB�GL �DD9B8=L�� EGTCQ

������

4FSQ�

������

5QGLE ��UC�M@R?GL

#(!04%2����Y�2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3 ����

Page 16: 2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · PDF filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝ cbg9fj5h=cb% 5kg z $cdglc? lbb gqasqqlsajc?pbca?w z 3r?rcr fcam lqcpt?rgmlj?uq z %vnj?gln ?pclr?

������

�=G7IGG=CB�5B8�"AD@=75H=CBG

0CPF?NQ�RFC�KMQR�BGDDGASJR�RFGLE�?@MSR�RFGQ�CV?KNJC�GQ�AMLTGLAGLE�WMSPQCJD�RF?R�RFC K?QQ�GQ�GLAJSBCB�GL�RFC�?RMKGA�K?QQ�MD ��"CWMLB

RF?R�?PC�MRFCP�GKNJGA?RGMLQ��!E?GL�RFC�BCA?W�CLCPEW�GQ�GL�RFC�-C6�P?LEC��4FGQ�CLCPEW�GQ�QF?PCB�@W�?JJ�MD�RFC�NPMBSARQ�MD�RFC�BCA?W��)L�K?LW

BCA?WQ��RFC�B?SEFRCP�LSAJCSQ GQ�JCDR�GL�?L�CVAGRCB�QR?RC�?LB�CKGRQ�NFMRMLQ�� P?WQ��-MQR�MD�RFC�PCK?GLGLE�CLCPEW�EMCQ�RM�RFC

CJCARPML�?LB�LCSRPGLM��QGLAC�RFC�PCAMGJ�IGLCRGA�CLCPEW�MD�RFC�B?SEFRCP�LSAJCSQ�GQ�QK?JJ��/LC�DGL?J�LMRC��RFC�CJCARPML�CKGRRCB�GL BCA?W�GQ

APC?RCB�GL�RFC�LSAJCSQ�?R�RFC�RGKC�MD�BCA?W�

4FC�QCAMLB�RWNC�MD�@CR?�BCA?W�GQ�JCQQ�AMKKML�RF?L�RFC�DGPQR��)R�GQ BCA?W��#CPR?GL�LSAJGBCQ�BCA?W�@W�RFC�CKGQQGML�MD�? CBF<G<I8 CJCARPML��4FGQ�GQ

5BH=9@97HFCB MP DCG=HFCB�8975M �QCC �=;IF9����� �

�=;IF9����� BCA?W�GQ�RFC�CKGQQGML�MD�?�NMQGRPML�RF?R�CTCLRS?JJW�DGLBQ�?L�CJCARPML�RM�?LLGFGJ?RC��AF?P?ARCPGQRGA?JJW�NPMBSAGLE�E?KK?Q�GL�MNNMQGRC�BGPCARGMLQ�

4FC�?LRGCJCARPML�GQ�MDRCL�PCNPCQCLRCB�@W�RFC�QWK@MJ ��@SR�GL�@CR?�BCA?W�GR�GQ�UPGRRCL�?Q RM�GLBGA?RC�RFC�?LRGCJCARPML�U?Q�CKGRRCB�GL�?�LSAJC?P

BCA?W��!LRGCJCARPMLQ�?PC�RFC�?LRGK?RRCP�AMSLRCPN?PR�RM�CJCARPMLQ��@CGLE�LC?PJW�GBCLRGA?J��F?TGLE�RFC�Q?KC�K?QQ��QNGL��?LB�QM�ML��@SR�F?TGLE�?�NMQGRGTC

AF?PEC�?LB�?L�CJCARPML�D?KGJW�LSK@CP�MD ��7FCL�? DCG=HFCB CLAMSLRCPQ�?L�CJCARPML��RFCPC�GQ�?�KSRS?J�?LLGFGJ?RGML�GL�UFGAF�?JJ�RFC�K?QQ�MD�RFC

?LRGCJCARPML CJCARPML�N?GP�GQ�AMLTCPRCB�GLRM�NSPC�NFMRML�CLCPEW���4FC�PC?ARGML� ��AMLQCPTCQ�CJCARPML�D?KGJW�LSK@CP�?Q�UCJJ�?Q�?JJ

MRFCP�AMLQCPTCB�OS?LRGRGCQ��)D�?�LSAJGBC GQ�ILMUL�RM BCA?W��RFCL�GRQ 8975M�9EI5H=CB GQ

������

UFCPC�9�GQ�RFC�LSAJGBC�F?TGLE�MLC�JCQQ�NPMRML�RF?L�8��RM�AMLQCPTC�AF?PEC�?LB GQ�RFC�QWK@MJ�DMP�RFC 9@97HFCBUG�B9IHF=BC��UFGAF�F?Q�?L�CJCARPML

D?KGJW�LSK@CP�MD ��3GLAC�?L�?LRGK?RRCP�KCK@CP�MD�RFC�CJCARPML�D?KGJW��RFC �GQ�APC?RCB�GL�RFC�BCA?W��?�K?RRCP�KCK@CP�MD�RFC�D?KGJW��FCPC�RFC

�KSQR�?JQM�@C�APC?RCB��'GTCL��DMP�CV?KNJC��RF?R BCA?WQ��WMS�A?L�UPGRC�GRQ�DSJJ�BCA?W�COS?RGML�@W�DGPQR�DGLBGLE�RF?R DMP �

QM�RF?R�RFC�B?SEFRCP�LSAJGBC�UGJJ�F?TC ��RFC�?RMKGA�LSK@CP�DMP�LCML��4FSQ�RFC BCA?W�COS?RGML�DMP GQ

������

)L BCA?W��GR�GQ�?Q�GD�MLC�MD�RFC�NPMRMLQ�GL�RFC�N?PCLR�LSAJCSQ�BCA?WQ�GLRM�?�LCSRPML��?�NMQGRPML��?LB�?�LCSRPGLM��0PMRMLQ�BM�LMR�BM�RFGQ�MSRQGBC�MD

RFC�LSAJCSQ��?LB�QM�RFC�BCA?W�GQ�BSC�RM�RFC�AMKNJCVGRGCQ�MD�RFC�LSAJC?P�DMPAC��.MRC�?E?GL�RF?R�RFC�RMR?J�LSK@CP�MD�LSAJCMLQ�GQ�AMLQR?LR�GL�RFGQ�?LB�?LW

MRFCP�PC?ARGML��4M�DGLB�RFC�CLCPEW�CKGRRCB�GL BCA?W��WMS�KSQR�?E?GL�AMSLR�RFC�LSK@CP�MD�CJCARPMLQ�GL�RFC�LCSRP?J�?RMKQ��QGLAC�?RMKGA�K?QQCQ�?PC

SQCB��4FC�B?SEFRCP�F?Q�MLC�JCQQ�CJCARPML�RF?L�RFC�N?PCLR��?LB�MLC�CJCARPML�K?QQ�GQ�APC?RCB�GL�RFC�BCA?W��4FSQ��GL BCA?W�

������

QGLAC�UC�SQC�RFC�K?QQCQ�MD�LCSRP?J�?RMKQ�

�@97HFCB�75DHIF9 GQ�RFC�RFGPB�RWNC�MD�@CR?�BCA?W��(CPC��?�LSAJCSQ�A?NRSPCQ�?L�GLLCP QFCJJ�CJCARPML�?LB�SLBCPEMCQ�?�LSAJC?P�PC?ARGML�RF?R�F?Q�RFC

Q?KC�CDDCAR�?Q BCA?W��%JCARPML�A?NRSPC�GQ�QMKCRGKCQ�BCLMRCB�@W�RFC�JCRRCPQ�%#��7C�ILMU�RF?R�CJCARPMLQ�A?LLMR�PCQGBC�GL�RFC�LSAJCSQ��@SR�RFGQ�GQ

?�LSAJC?P�PC?ARGML�RF?R�AMLQSKCQ�RFC�CJCARPML�?LB�MAASPQ�QNMLR?LCMSQJW�MLJW�UFCL�RFC�NPMBSARQ�F?TC�JCQQ�K?QQ�RF?L�RFC�N?PCLR�NJSQ�RFC�CJCARPML��)D

?�LSAJGBC GQ�ILMUL�RM�SLBCPEM�CJCARPML�A?NRSPC��RFCL�GRQ 9@97HFCB�75DHIF9�9EI5H=CB GQ

������

!LW�LSAJGBC�RF?R�A?L BCA?W�A?L�?JQM�SLBCPEM�CJCARPML�A?NRSPC��?LB�MDRCL�BMCQ�@MRF��4FC�Q?KC�AMLQCPT?RGML�J?UQ�?PC�M@CWCB�DMP�%#�?Q�DMP

BCA?W��)R�GQ�EMMB�NP?ARGAC�RM�AMLDGPK�RFCQC�DMP�WMSPQCJD�

!JJ�DMPKQ�MD�@CR?�BCA?W�MAASP�@CA?SQC�RFC�N?PCLR�LSAJGBC�GQ�SLQR?@JC�?LB�JGCQ�MSRQGBC�RFC�PCEGML�MD�QR?@GJGRW�GL�RFC�AF?PR�MD�LSAJGBCQ��4FMQC�LSAJGBCQ

RF?R�F?TC�PCJ?RGTCJW�KMPC�LCSRPMLQ�RF?L�RFMQC�GL�RFC�PCEGML�MD�QR?@GJGRW�UGJJ BCA?W�RM�NPMBSAC�?�B?SEFRCP�UGRF�DCUCP�LCSRPMLQ��NPMBSAGLE�?

���� #(!04%2����Y�2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3

4FGQ�AMLRCLR�GQ�?T?GJ?@JC�DMP�DPCC�?R�FRRN���ALV�MPE�AMLRCLR�AMJ���������

Page 17: 2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · PDF filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝ cbg9fj5h=cb% 5kg z $cdglc? lbb gqasqqlsajc?pbca?w z 3r?rcr fcam lqcpt?rgmlj?uq z %vnj?gln ?pclr?

B?SEFRCP�LC?PCP�RFC�PCEGML�MD�QR?@GJGRW��3GKGJ?PJW��RFMQC�LSAJGBCQ�F?TGLE�PCJ?RGTCJW�KMPC�NPMRMLQ�RF?L�RFMQC�GL�RFC�PCEGML�MD�QR?@GJGRW�UGJJ BCA?W�MP

SLBCPEM�CJCARPML�A?NRSPC�RM�NPMBSAC�?�B?SEFRCP�UGRF�DCUCP�NPMRMLQ��LC?PCP�RFC�PCEGML�MD�QR?@GJGRW�

'?KK?�$CA?W

5AA5�8975M GQ�RFC�QGKNJCQR�DMPK�MD�LSAJC?P�BCA?WuGR�GQ�RFC�CKGQQGML�MD�CLCPECRGA�NFMRMLQ�@W�LSAJCG�JCDR�GL�?L�CVAGRCB�QR?RC�@W�QMKC�C?PJGCP

NPMACQQ��0PMRMLQ�?LB�LCSRPMLQ�GL�?L�CVAGRCB�LSAJCSQ�?PC�GL�FGEFCP�MP@GR?JQ��?LB�RFCW�D?JJ�RM�JMUCP�JCTCJQ�@W�NFMRML�CKGQQGML��?L?JMEMSQ�RM�CJCARPMLQ�GL

CVAGRCB�?RMKQ��.SAJC?P�CVAGRCB�QR?RCQ�F?TC�JGDCRGKCQ�RWNGA?JJW�MD�MLJW�?@MSR Q��?L�GLBGA?RGML�MD�RFC�EPC?R�QRPCLERF�MD�RFC�DMPACQ�NSJJGLE�RFC

LSAJCMLQ�RM�JMUCP�QR?RCQ��4FC BCA?W�COS?RGML�GQ�QGKNJW

������

UFCPC�RFC�?QRCPGQI�GLBGA?RCQ�RFC�LSAJCSQ�GQ�GL�?L�CVAGRCB�QR?RC��4FCPC�K?W�@C�MLC�MP�KMPC Q�CKGRRCB��BCNCLBGLE�ML�FMU�RFC�LSAJGBC�BC CVAGRCQ��)L

P?BGM?ARGTC�BCA?W� CKGQQGML�GQ�AMKKML�?LB�GQ�NPCACBCB�@W MP BCA?W��&MP�CV?KNJC��UFCL BCA?WQ��GR�KMQR�MDRCL�JC?TCQ�RFC

B?SEFRCP�LSAJCSQ�GL�?L�CVAGRCB�QR?RC��UPGRRCL ��4FCL�RFC�LGAICJ�LSAJCSQ�OSGAIJW BCA?WQ�@W�RFC�CKGQQGML�MD�RUM�NCLCRP?RGLE Q�

������

4FCQC�?PC�A?JJCB�AM@?JR P?WQ��?JRFMSEF�RFCW�AMKC�DPMK�LGAICJuRFCW�?PC�SQCB�DMP�A?LACP�RFCP?NW��DMP�CV?KNJC��)R�GQ�?E?GL�AMLQRPSARGTC�RM�TCPGDW�RFC

AMLQCPT?RGML�J?UQ�DMP�E?KK?�BCA?W��&GL?JJW��QGLAC BCA?W�BMCQ�LMR�AF?LEC�RFC�LSAJGBC�RM�?LMRFCP�QNCAGCQ��GR�GQ�LMR�NPMKGLCLRJW�DC?RSPCB�GL�AF?PRQ�MD

BCA?W�QCPGCQ��QSAF�?Q�RF?R�GL �=;IF9�������

4FCPC�?PC�MRFCP�RWNCQ�MD�LSAJC?P�BCA?W��@SR�RFCW�MAASP�JCQQ�AMKKMLJW�RF?L � ��?LB BCA?W��3NMLR?LCMSQ�DGQQGML�GQ�RFC�KMQR�GKNMPR?LR�MD�RFC

MRFCP�DMPKQ�MD�LSAJC?P�BCA?W�@CA?SQC�MD�GRQ�?NNJGA?RGMLQ�GL�LSAJC?P�NMUCP�?LB�UC?NMLQ��)R�GQ�AMTCPCB�GL�RFC�LCVR�AF?NRCP�

���� !5@:%=:9�5B8��7H=J=HM

5LQR?@JC�LSAJCG�BCA?W��(MUCTCP��QMKC�LSAJGBCQ�BCA?W�D?QRCP�RF?L�MRFCPQ��&MP�CV?KNJC��P?BGSK�?LB�NMJMLGSK��BGQAMTCPCB�@W�RFC�#SPGCQ��BCA?W�D?QRCP

RF?L�SP?LGSK��4FGQ�KC?LQ�RFCW�F?TC�QFMPRCP�JGDCRGKCQ��NPMBSAGLE�?�EPC?RCP�P?RC�MD�BCA?W��)L�RFGQ�QCARGML�UC�CVNJMPC�F?JD JGDC�?LB�?ARGTGRW��RFC

OS?LRGR?RGTC�RCPKQ�DMP�JGDCRGKC�?LB�P?RC�MD�BCA?W�

(?JD ,GDC

7FW�SQC�?�RCPK�JGIC�F?JD JGDC�P?RFCP�RF?L�JGDCRGKC��4FC�?LQUCP�A?L�@C�DMSLB�@W�CV?KGLGLE �=;IF9��������UFGAF�QFMUQ�FMU�RFC�LSK@CP�MD�P?BGM?ARGTC

LSAJCG�GL�?�Q?KNJC�BCAPC?QCQ�UGRF�RGKC��4FC G<@8�<A�J;<6;�;4?9�B9�G;8�BE<:<A4?�AH@58E�B9�AH6?8<�7864L GQ�BCDGLCB�?Q�RFC <5@:@=:9� ��(?JD�MD�RFC

PCK?GLGLE�LSAJCG�BCA?W�GL�RFC�LCVR�F?JD JGDC��&SPRFCP��F?JD�MD�RF?R�?KMSLR�BCA?WQ�GL�RFC�DMJJMUGLE�F?JD JGDC��4FCPCDMPC��RFC�LSK@CP�MD�P?BGM?ARGTC�LSAJCG

BCAPC?QCQ�DPMK RM GL�MLC�F?JD JGDC��RFCL�RM GL�RFC�LCVR��?LB�RM GL�RFC�LCVR��?LB�QM�ML��)D GQ�?�J?PEC�LSK@CP��RFCL @4AL F?JD

JGTCQ��LMR�HSQR�RUM�N?QQ�@CDMPC�?JJ�MD�RFC�LSAJCG�BCA?W��.SAJC?P�BCA?W�GQ�?L�CV?KNJC�MD�?�NSPCJW�QR?RGQRGA?J�NPMACQQ��!�KMPC�NPCAGQC�BCDGLGRGML�MD�F?JD JGDC

GQ�RF?R 846;�AH6?8HF�;4F�4����6;4A68�B9�?<I<A:�9BE�4�G<@8�8DH4?�GB�BA8�;4?9�?<98 ��4FSQ��GD GQ�PC?QML?@JW�J?PEC��F?JD�MD�RFC�MPGEGL?J�LSAJCG�BCA?W

GL�?�RGKC�MD�MLC�F?JD JGDC��)D�?L�GLBGTGBS?J�LSAJCSQ�K?ICQ�GR�RFPMSEF�RF?R�RGKC��GR�QRGJJ�F?Q�?�����AF?LAC�MD�QSPTGTGLE�RFPMSEF�?LMRFCP�F?JD JGDC��%TCL�GD�GR

F?NNCLQ�RM�K?IC�GR�RFPMSEF�FSLBPCBQ�MD�F?JD JGTCQ��GR�QRGJJ�F?Q�?�����AF?LAC�MD�QSPTGTGLE�RFPMSEF�MLC�KMPC��4FC�NPM@?@GJGRW�MD�BCA?W�GQ�RFC�Q?KC�LM

K?RRCP�UFCL�WMS�QR?PR�AMSLRGLE��4FGQ�GQ�JGIC�P?LBMK�AMGL�DJGNNGLE��4FC�AF?LAC�MD�FC?BQ�GQ������LM�K?RRCP�UF?R�F?Q�F?NNCLCB�@CDMPC�

�=;IF9������ 2?BGM?ARGTC�BCA?W�PCBSACQ�RFC�LSK@CP�MD�P?BGM?ARGTC�LSAJCG�MTCP�RGKC��)L�MLC�F?JD JGDC ��RFC�LSK@CP�BCAPC?QCQ�RM�F?JD�MD�GRQ�MPGEGL?J�T?JSC��(?JD�MD�UF?R

PCK?GLQ�BCA?W�GL�RFC�LCVR�F?JD JGDC��?LB�F?JD�MD�RFMQC�GL�RFC�LCVR��?LB�QM�ML��4FGQ�GQ�?L�CVNMLCLRG?J�BCA?W��?Q�QCCL�GL�RFC�EP?NF�MD�RFC�LSK@CP�MD�LSAJCG�NPCQCLR�?Q�?�DSLARGML�MD

RGKC�

4FCPC�GQ�?�RPCKCLBMSQ�P?LEC�GL�RFC�F?JD JGTCQ�MD�T?PGMSQ�LSAJGBCQ��DPMK�?Q�QFMPR�?Q Q�DMP�RFC�KMQR�SLQR?@JC��RM�KMPC�RF?L W�DMP�RFC�JC?QR

SLQR?@JC��MP�?@MSR����MPBCPQ�MD�K?ELGRSBC��.SAJGBCQ�UGRF�RFC�QFMPRCQR�F?JD JGTCQ�?PC�RFMQC�DMP�UFGAF�RFC�LSAJC?P�DMPACQ�?PC�JC?QR�?RRP?ARGTC��?L

#(!04%2����Y�2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3 ����

Page 18: 2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · PDF filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝ cbg9fj5h=cb% 5kg z $cdglc? lbb gqasqqlsajc?pbca?w z 3r?rcr fcam lqcpt?rgmlj?uq z %vnj?gln ?pclr?

GLBGA?RGML�MD�RFC�CVRCLR�RM�UFGAF�RFC�LSAJC?P�DMPAC�A?L�BCNCLB�ML�RFC�N?PRGASJ?P�AMK@GL?RGML�MD�LCSRPMLQ�?LB�NPMRMLQ��4FC�AMLACNR�MD�F?JD JGDC�GQ

?NNJGA?@JC�RM�MRFCP�QS@?RMKGA�N?PRGAJCQ��?Q�UGJJ�@C�BGQASQQCB�GL )5FH=7@9�)<MG=7G��)R�GQ�?JQM�?NNJGA?@JC�RM�RFC�BCA?W�MD�CVAGRCB�QR?RCQ�GL�?RMKQ�?LB

LSAJCG��4FC�DMJJMUGLE�COS?RGML�EGTCQ�RFC�OS?LRGR?RGTC�PCJ?RGMLQFGN�@CRUCCL�RFC�MPGEGL?J�LSK@CP�MD�LSAJCG�NPCQCLR�?R�RGKC�XCPM�� �?LB�RFC�LSK@CP��

�?R�?�J?RCP�RGKC �

������

UFCPC GQ�RFC�@?QC�MD�RFC�L?RSP?J�JME?PGRFK��?LB GQ�RFC 8975M�7CBGH5BH DMP�RFC�LSAJGBC��4FC�QFMPRCP�RFC�F?JD JGDC��RFC�J?PECP�GQ�RFC

T?JSC�MD ��?LB�RFC�D?QRCP�RFC�CVNMLCLRG?J BCAPC?QCQ�UGRF�RGKC��4FC�PCJ?RGMLQFGN�@CRUCCL�RFC�BCA?W�AMLQR?LR ?LB�RFC�F?JD JGDC GQ

������

4M�QCC�FMU�RFC�LSK@CP�MD�LSAJCG�BCAJGLCQ�RM�F?JD�GRQ�MPGEGL?J�T?JSC�GL�MLC�F?JD JGDC��JCR GL�RFC�CVNMLCLRG?J�GL�RFC�COS?RGML ��4FGQ

EGTCQ ��&MP�GLRCEP?J�LSK@CPQ�MD�F?JD JGTCQ��WMS�A?L�HSQR�BGTGBC�RFC�MPGEGL?J�LSK@CP�@W���MTCP�?LB�MTCP�?E?GL�

P?RFCP�RF?L�SQGLE�RFC�CVNMLCLRG?J�PCJ?RGMLQFGN��&MP�CV?KNJC��GD�RCL�F?JD JGTCQ�F?TC�N?QQCB��UC�BGTGBC @W���RCL�RGKCQ��4FGQ�PCBSACQ�GR�RM �

&MP�?L�?P@GRP?PW�RGKC��LMR�HSQR�?�KSJRGNJC�MD�RFC�F?JD JGDC��RFC�CVNMLCLRG?J�PCJ?RGMLQFGN�KSQR�@C�SQCB�

+58=C57H=J9�85H=B; GQ�?�AJCTCP�SQC�MD�L?RSP?JJW�MAASPPGLE�P?BGM?ARGTGRW��)RQ�KMQR�D?KMSQ�?NNJGA?RGML�GQ 75F6CB���85H=B;��#?P@ML ���F?Q�?�F?JD JGDC�MD

�����WC?PQ�?LB�GQ�NPMBSACB�GL�?�LSAJC?P�PC?ARGML�GLBSACB�UFCL�QMJ?P�LCSRPGLMQ�QRPGIC GL�RFC�?RKMQNFCPC��2?BGM?ARGTC�A?P@ML�F?Q�RFC�Q?KC

AFCKGQRPW�?Q�QR?@JC�A?P@ML��?LB�QM�GR�KGVCQ�GLRM�RFC�CAMQNFCPC��UFCPC�GR�GQ�AMLQSKCB�?LB�@CAMKCQ�N?PR�MD�CTCPW�JGTGLE�MPE?LGQK��#?P@ML ���F?Q�?L

?@SLB?LAC�MD�����N?PRQ�NCP�RPGJJGML�MD�LMPK?J�A?P@ML��4FSQ��GD�WMS�ILMU�RFC�LSK@CP�MD�A?P@ML�LSAJCG�GL�?L�M@HCAR��NCPF?NQ�BCRCPKGLCB�@W�K?QQ�?LB

!TME?BPMwQ�LSK@CP��WMS�KSJRGNJW�RF?R�LSK@CP�@W RM�DGLB�RFC�LSK@CP�MD LSAJCG�GL�RFC�M@HCAR��7FCL�?L�MPE?LGQK�BGCQ��A?P@ML

CVAF?LEC�UGRF�RFC�CLTGPMLKCLR�AC?QCQ��?LB GQ�LMR�PCNJCLGQFCB�?Q�GR�BCA?WQ��"W�AMKN?PGLE�RFC�?@SLB?LAC�MD GL�?L�?PRGD?AR��QSAF�?Q

KSKKW�UP?NNGLEQ��UGRF�RFC�LMPK?J�?@SLB?LAC�GL�JGTGLE�RGQQSC��GR�GQ�NMQQG@JC�RM�BCRCPKGLC�RFC�?PRGD?ARwQ�?EC��MP�RGKC�QGLAC�BC?RF��#?P@ML ���B?RGLE

A?L�@C�SQCB�DMP�@GMJMEGA?J�RGQQSCQ�?Q�MJB�?Q����MP����RFMSQ?LB�WC?PQ��@SR�GQ�KMQR�?AASP?RC�DMP�WMSLECP�Q?KNJCQ��QGLAC�RFC�?@SLB?LAC�MD LSAJCG

GL�RFCK�GQ�EPC?RCP��6CPW�MJB�@GMJMEGA?J�K?RCPG?JQ�AMLR?GL�LM ?R�?JJ��4FCPC�?PC�GLQR?LACQ�GL�UFGAF�RFC�B?RC�MD�?L�?PRGD?AR�A?L�@C�BCRCPKGLCB�@W

MRFCP�KC?LQ��QSAF�?Q�FGQRMPGA?J�ILMUJCBEC�MP�RPCC PGLE�AMSLRGLE��4FCQC�APMQQ PCDCPCLACQ�F?TC�AMLDGPKCB�RFC�T?JGBGRW�MD�A?P@ML ���B?RGLE�?LB

NCPKGRRCB�SQ�RM�A?JG@P?RC�RFC�RCAFLGOSC�?Q�UCJJ��#?P@ML ���B?RGLE�PCTMJSRGMLGXCB�N?PRQ�MD�?PAF?CMJMEW�?LB�GQ�MD�QSAF�GKNMPR?LAC�RF?R�GR�C?PLCB�RFC

�����.M@CJ�0PGXC�GL�AFCKGQRPW�DMP�GRQ�BCTCJMNCP��RFC�!KCPGA?L�AFCKGQR�7GJJ?PB�,G@@W������t�����

/LC�MD�RFC�KMQR�D?KMSQ�A?QCQ�MD�A?P@ML ���B?RGLE�GLTMJTCQ�RFC�3FPMSB�MD�4SPGL��?�JMLE�NGCAC�MD�D?@PGA�NSPNMPRCB�RM�@C�RFC�@SPG?J�QFPMSB�MD�*CQSQ��QCC

�=;IF9��������4FGQ�PCJGA�U?Q�DGPQR�BGQNJ?WCB�GL�4SPGL�GL������?LB�U?Q�BCLMSLACB�?Q�?�DP?SB�?R�RF?R�RGKC�@W�?�&PCLAF�@GQFMN��)RQ�PCK?PI?@JC�LCE?RGTC

GKNPGLR�MD�?L�?NN?PCLRJW�APSAGDGCB�@MBW�PCQCK@JCQ�RFC�RFCL ?AACNRCB�GK?EC�MD�*CQSQ��?LB�QM�RFC�QFPMSB�U?Q�LCTCP�BGQPCE?PBCB�AMKNJCRCJW�?LB

PCK?GLCB�AMLRPMTCPQG?J�MTCP�RFC�ACLRSPGCQ��#?P@ML ���B?RGLE�U?Q�LMR�NCPDMPKCB�ML�RFC�QFPMSB�SLRGJ�������UFCL�RFC�NPMACQQ�F?B�@CCL�PCDGLCB�RM�RFC

NMGLR�UFCPC�MLJW�?�QK?JJ�?KMSLR�MD�K?RCPG?J�LCCBCB�RM�@C�BCQRPMWCB��3?KNJCQ�UCPC�RCQRCB�?R�RFPCC�GLBCNCLBCLR�J?@MP?RMPGCQ��C?AF�@CGLE�EGTCL�DMSP

NGCACQ�MD�AJMRF��UGRF�MLJW�MLC�SLGBCLRGDGCB�NGCAC�DPMK�RFC�QFPMSB��RM�?TMGB�NPCHSBGAC��!JJ�RFPCC�J?@MP?RMPGCQ�DMSLB�Q?KNJCQ�MD�RFC�QFPMSB�AMLR?GL�����MD

RFC DMSLB�GL�JGTGLE�RGQQSCQ��?JJMUGLE�RFC�QFPMSB�RM�@C�B?RCB��QCC �L5AD@9������

�=;IF9������ 0?PR�MD�RFC�3FPMSB�MD�4SPGL��UFGAF�QFMUQ�?�PCK?PI?@JC�LCE?RGTC�GKNPGLR�JGICLCQQ�MD�*CQSQ�AMKNJCRC�UGRF�CTGBCLAC�MD�APSAGDGVGML�UMSLBQ��4FC�QFPMSB�DGPQR�QSPD?ACB

GL�RFC���RF�ACLRSPW�?LB�U?Q�MLJW�PCACLRJW�A?P@ML ���B?RCB��)R�F?Q�LMR�@CCL�BCRCPKGLCB�FMU�RFC�GK?EC�U?Q�NJ?ACB�ML�RFC�K?RCPG?J���APCBGR��"SRIM��7GIGKCBG?�#MKKMLQ

�L5AD@9����� !CK�(@8�"G�H<9�,<FCI8�C:�-IF=B�

#?JASJ?RC�RFC�?EC�MD�RFC�3FPMSB�MD�4SPGL�EGTCL�RF?R�RFC�?KMSLR�MD DMSLB�GL�GR�GQ�����MD�RF?R�GL�JGTGLE�RGQQSC�

,HF5H9;M

���� #(!04%2����Y�2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3

4FGQ�AMLRCLR�GQ�?T?GJ?@JC�DMP�DPCC�?R�FRRN���ALV�MPE�AMLRCLR�AMJ���������

Page 19: 2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · PDF filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝ cbg9fj5h=cb% 5kg z $cdglc? lbb gqasqqlsajc?pbca?w z 3r?rcr fcam lqcpt?rgmlj?uq z %vnj?gln ?pclr?

+LMUGLE�RF?R�����MD�RFC PCK?GLQ�KC?LQ�RF?R ��4FCPCDMPC��RFC�COS?RGML A?L�@C�SQCB�RM�DGLB ��7C�?JQM

ILMU�RF?R�RFC�F?JD JGDC�MD GQ������W��?LB�QM�MLAC GQ�ILMUL��UC�A?L�SQC�RFC�COS?RGML RM�DGLB ?LB�RFCL�DGLB ?Q

PCOSCQRCB��(CPC��UC�NMQRSJ?RC�RF?R�RFC�BCAPC?QC�GL GQ�QMJCJW�BSC�RM�LSAJC?P�BCA?W�

,C@IH=CB

3MJTGLE�RFC�COS?RGML DMP EGTCQ

������

4FSQ�

������

4?IGLE�RFC�L?RSP?J�JME?PGRFK�MD�@MRF�QGBCQ�MD�RFC�COS?RGML�WGCJBQ

������

QM�RF?R

������

2C?PP?LEGLE�RM�GQMJ?RC EGTCQ

������

.MU��RFC�COS?RGML A?L�@C�SQCB�RM�DGLB DMP ��3MJTGLE�DMP ?LB�QS@QRGRSRGLE�RFC�ILMUL�F?JD JGDC�EGTCQ

������

7C�CLRCP�RFGQ�T?JSC�GLRM�RFC�NPCTGMSQ�COS?RGML�RM�DGLB �

������

�=G7IGG=CB

4FGQ�B?RCQ�RFC�K?RCPG?J�GL�RFC�QFPMSB�RM�����t������?�B��������/SP�A?JASJ?RGML�GQ�MLJW�?AASP?RC�RM�RUM�BGEGRQ��QM�RF?R�RFC�WC?P�GQ�PMSLBCB�RM������

4FC�T?JSCQ�M@R?GLCB�?R�RFC�RFPCC�GLBCNCLBCLR�J?@MP?RMPGCQ�E?TC�?�UCGEFRCB�?TCP?EC�B?RC�MD�?�B� ��4FC�SLACPR?GLRW�GQ�RWNGA?J�MD

A?P@ML ���B?RGLE�?LB�GQ�BSC�RM�RFC�QK?JJ�?KMSLR�MD GL�JGTGLE�RGQQSCQ��RFC�?KMSLR�MD�K?RCPG?J�?T?GJ?@JC��?LB�CVNCPGKCLR?J�SLACPR?GLRGCQ

�PCBSACB�@W�F?TGLE�RFPCC�GLBCNCLBCLR�KC?QSPCKCLRQ��)R�GQ�KC?LGLEDSJ�RF?R�RFC�B?RC�MD�RFC�QFPMSB�GQ�AMLQGQRCLR�UGRF�RFC�DGPQR�PCAMPB�MD�GRQ

CVGQRCLAC�?LB�GLAMLQGQRCLR�UGRF�RFC�NCPGMB�GL�UFGAF�*CQSQ�JGTCB�

4FCPC�?PC�MRFCP�DMPKQ�MD�P?BGM?ARGTC�B?RGLE��2MAIQ��DMP�CV?KNJC��A?L�QMKCRGKCQ�@C�B?RCB�@?QCB�ML�RFC�BCA?W�MD ��4FC�BCA?W�QCPGCQ�DMP

CLBQ�UGRF ��QM�RF?R�RFC�P?RGM�MD�RFCQC�LSAJGBCQ�GL�?�PMAI�GQ�?L�GLBGA?RGML�MD�FMU�JMLE�GR�F?Q�@CCL�QGLAC�RFC�PMAI�QMJGBGDGCB��4FC�MPGEGL?J

AMKNMQGRGML�MD�RFC�PMAI��QSAF�?Q�RFC�?@QCLAC�MD�JC?B��KSQR�@C�ILMUL�UGRF�QMKC�AMLDGBCLAC��(MUCTCP��?Q�UGRF�A?P@ML ���B?RGLE��RFC�RCAFLGOSC�A?L

@C�TCPGDGCB�@W�?�AMLQGQRCLR�@MBW�MD�ILMUJCBEC��3GLAC F?Q�?�F?JD JGDC�MD W��GR�GQ�SQCDSJ�DMP�B?RGLE�MLJW�TCPW�MJB�K?RCPG?JQ��QFMUGLE��DMP

CV?KNJC��RF?R�RFC�MJBCQR�PMAIQ�ML�%?PRF�QMJGBGDGCB�?@MSR WC?PQ�?EM�

!ARGTGRW��RFC�2?RC�MD�$CA?W

7F?R�BM�UC�KC?L�UFCL�UC�Q?W�?�QMSPAC�GQ�FGEFJW�P?BGM?ARGTC��'CLCP?JJW��RFGQ�KC?LQ�RFC�LSK@CP�MD�BCA?WQ�NCP�SLGR�RGKC�GQ�TCPW�FGEF��7C�BCDGLC

57H=J=HM RM�@C�RFC F5H9�C:�8975M CVNPCQQCB�GL�BCA?WQ�NCP�SLGR�RGKC��)L�COS?RGML�DMPK��RFGQ�GQ

������

UFCPC GQ�RFC�LSK@CP�MD�BCA?WQ�RF?R�MAASP�GL�RGKC ��4FC�3)�SLGR�DMP�?ARGTGRW�GQ�MLC�BCA?W�NCP�QCAMLB�?LB�GQ�EGTCL�RFC�L?KC 697EI9F9@ �"O�GL

FMLMP�MD�RFC�BGQAMTCPCP�MD�P?BGM?ARGTGRW��4F?R�GQ�

������

!ARGTGRW GQ�MDRCL�CVNPCQQCB�GL�MRFCP�SLGRQ��QSAF�?Q�BCA?WQ�NCP�KGLSRC�MP�BCA?WQ�NCP�WC?P��/LC�MD�RFC�KMQR�AMKKML�SLGRQ�DMP�?ARGTGRW�GQ�RFC 7IF=9

�#G��BCDGLCB�RM�@C�RFC�?ARGTGRW�MD���E�MD ��GL�FMLMP�MD�-?PGC�#SPGCwQ�UMPI�UGRF�P?BGSK��4FC�BCDGLGRGML�MD�ASPGC�GQ

#(!04%2����Y�2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3 ����

Page 20: 2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · PDF filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝ cbg9fj5h=cb% 5kg z $cdglc? lbb gqasqqlsajc?pbca?w z 3r?rcr fcam lqcpt?rgmlj?uq z %vnj?gln ?pclr?

������

MP BCA?WQ�NCP�QCAMLB��!�ASPGC�GQ�?�J?PEC�SLGR�MD�?ARGTGRW��UFGJC�?�@CAOSCPCJ�GQ�?�PCJ?RGTCJW�QK?JJ�SLGR� �

)L�AMSLRPGCQ�JGIC�!SQRP?JG?�?LB�.CU�:C?J?LB�RF?R�?BFCPC�KMPC�RM�3)�SLGRQ��KMQR�P?BGM?ARGTC�QMSPACQ��QSAF�?Q�RFMQC�SQCB�GL�KCBGA?J�BG?ELMQRGAQ�MP�GL

NFWQGAQ�J?@MP?RMPGCQ��?PC�J?@CJCB�GL�"O�MP�KCE?@CAOSCPCJ��-"O�

)LRSGRGTCJW��WMS�UMSJB�CVNCAR�RFC�?ARGTGRW�MD�?�QMSPAC�RM�BCNCLB�ML�RUM�RFGLEQ��RFC�?KMSLR�MD�RFC�P?BGM?ARGTC�QS@QR?LAC�NPCQCLR��?LB�GRQ�F?JD JGDC��4FC

EPC?RCP�RFC�LSK@CP�MD�P?BGM?ARGTC�LSAJCG�NPCQCLR�GL�RFC�Q?KNJC��RFC�KMPC�UGJJ�BCA?W�NCP�SLGR�MD�RGKC��4FC�QFMPRCP�RFC�F?JD JGDC��RFC�KMPC�BCA?WQ�NCP�SLGR

RGKC��DMP�?�EGTCL�LSK@CP�MD�LSAJCG��3M�?ARGTGRW QFMSJB�@C�NPMNMPRGML?J�RM�RFC�LSK@CP�MD�P?BGM?ARGTC�LSAJCG� ��?LB�GLTCPQCJW�NPMNMPRGML?J�RM�RFCGP

F?JD JGDC� ��)L�D?AR��WMSP�GLRSGRGML�GQ�AMPPCAR��)R�A?L�@C�QFMUL�RF?R�RFC�?ARGTGRW�MD�?�QMSPAC�GQ

������

UFCPC GQ�RFC�LSK@CP�MD�P?BGM?ARGTC�LSAJCG�NPCQCLR��F?TGLE�F?JD JGDC ��4FGQ�PCJ?RGMLQFGN�GQ�SQCDSJ�GL�?�T?PGCRW�MD�A?JASJ?RGMLQ��?Q�RFC�LCVR�RUM

CV?KNJCQ�GJJSQRP?RC�

�L5AD@9����� !CK� F95H�"G�H<9 �7H=J=HM�=B�%=J=B;�-=GGI9�

#?JASJ?RC�RFC�?ARGTGRW�BSC�RM GL������IE�MD�A?P@ML�DMSLB�GL�?�JGTGLE�MPE?LGQK��%VNPCQQ�RFC�?ARGTGRW�GL�SLGRQ�MD�"O�?LB�#G�

,HF5H9;M

4M�DGLB�RFC�?ARGTGRW SQGLE�RFC�COS?RGML ��UC�KSQR�ILMU ?LB ��4FC�F?JD JGDC�MD A?L�@C�DMSLB�GL �DD9B8=L����?LB

U?Q�QR?RCB�?@MTC�?Q������W��4M�DGLB ��UC�DGPQR�DGLB�RFC�LSK@CP�MD LSAJCG�GL������IE�MD�A?P@ML�SQGLE�RFC�AMLACNR�MD�?�KMJC��!Q�GLBGA?RCB�

UC�RFCL�KSJRGNJW�@W �RFC�?@SLB?LAC�MD GL�?�A?P@ML�Q?KNJC�DPMK�?�JGTGLE�MPE?LGQK�RM�ECR�RFC�LSK@CP�MD LSAJCG�GL�?

JGTGLE�MPE?LGQK�

,C@IH=CB

/LC�KMJC�MD�A?P@ML�F?Q�?�K?QQ�MD������E��QGLAC�GR�GQ�LC?PJW�NSPC ���!�KMJC�F?Q�?�K?QQ�GL�EP?KQ�COS?J�GL�K?ELGRSBC�RM DMSLB�GL�RFC

NCPGMBGA�R?@JC��4FSQ�RFC�LSK@CP�MD�A?P@ML�LSAJCG�GL�?�IGJMEP?K�GQ

������

3M�RFC�LSK@CP�MD LSAJCG�GL���IE�MD�A?P@ML�GQ

������

.MU�RFC�?ARGTGRW GQ�DMSLB�SQGLE�RFC�COS?RGML �

%LRCPGLE�ILMUL�T?JSCQ�EGTCQ

������

MP BCA?WQ�NCP�WC?P��4M�AMLTCPR�RFGQ�RM�RFC�SLGR�"O��UC�QGKNJW�AMLTCPR�WC?PQ�RM�QCAMLBQ��4FSQ�

������

MP�����BCA?WQ�NCP�QCAMLB��4M�CVNPCQQ GL�ASPGCQ��UC�SQC�RFC�BCDGLGRGML�MD�?�ASPGC�

������

4FSQ�

������

�=G7IGG=CB

/SP�MUL�@MBGCQ�AMLR?GL�IGJMEP?KQ�MD�A?P@ML��?LB�GR�GQ�GLRPGESGLE�RM�RFGLI�RFCPC�?PC�FSLBPCBQ�MD BCA?WQ�NCP�QCAMLB�R?IGLE�NJ?AC�GL�SQ�

#?P@ML ���?LB�MRFCP�L?RSP?JJW�MAASPPGLE�P?BGM?ARGTC�QS@QR?LACQ�GL�MSP�@MBGCQ�AMLRPG@SRC�RM�RFC�@?AIEPMSLB�P?BG?RGML�UC�PCACGTC��4FC�QK?JJ

LSK@CP�MD�BCA?WQ�NCP�QCAMLB�DMSLB�DMP�?�IGJMEP?K�MD�A?P@ML�GL�RFGQ�CV?KNJC�EGTCQ�WMS�QMKC�GBC?�MD�FMU�BGDDGASJR�GR�GQ�RM�BCRCAR GL�?�QK?JJ

Q?KNJC�MD�K?RCPG?J��)D�RFCPC�?PC�����BCA?WQ�NCP�QCAMLB�GL�?�IGJMEP?K��RFCL�RFCPC�?PC������BCA?WQ�NCP�QCAMLB�GL�?�EP?K�MD�A?P@ML�GL�JGTGLE�RGQQSC�

���� #(!04%2����Y�2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3

4FGQ�AMLRCLR�GQ�?T?GJ?@JC�DMP�DPCC�?R�FRRN���ALV�MPE�AMLRCLR�AMJ���������

Page 21: 2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · PDF filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝ cbg9fj5h=cb% 5kg z $cdglc? lbb gqasqqlsajc?pbca?w z 3r?rcr fcam lqcpt?rgmlj?uq z %vnj?gln ?pclr?

4M�M@QCPTC�RFGQ��WMS�KSQR�@C�?@JC�RM�BGQRGLESGQF�BCA?WQ�DPMK�MRFCP�DMPKQ�MD�P?BG?RGML��GL�MPBCP�RM�PCBSAC�@?AIEPMSLB�LMGQC��4FGQ�@CAMKCQ�KMPC

BGDDGASJR�UGRF�?L�MJB�RGQQSC�Q?KNJC��QGLAC�GR�AMLR?GLQ�JCQQ ��?LB�DMP�Q?KNJCQ�KMPC�RF?L����RFMSQ?LB�WC?PQ�MJB��GR�GQ�GKNMQQG@JC�

(SK?L K?BC��MP�?PRGDGAG?J�P?BGM?ARGTGRW�F?Q�@CCL�NPMBSACB�DMP�BCA?BCQ�?LB�F?Q�K?LW�SQCQ��3MKC�MD�RFCQC�GLAJSBC�KCBGA?J�RFCP?NW�DMP�A?LACP�

KCBGA?J�GK?EGLE�?LB�BG?ELMQRGAQ��?LB�DMMB�NPCQCPT?RGML�@W�GPP?BG?RGML��-?LW�?NNJGA?RGMLQ�?Q�UCJJ�?Q�RFC�@GMJMEGA?J�CDDCARQ�MD�P?BG?RGML�?PC�CVNJMPCB�GL

&98=75@��DD@=75H=CBG�C:�'I7@95F�)<MG=7G��@SR�GR�GQ�AJC?P�RF?R�P?BG?RGML�GQ�F?X?PBMSQ��!�LSK@CP�MD�RP?EGA�CV?KNJCQ�MD�RFGQ�CVGQR��MLC�MD�RFC�KMQR

BGQ?QRPMSQ�@CGLE�RFC�KCJRBMUL�?LB�DGPC�?R�RFC�#FCPLM@WJ�PC?ARMP�AMKNJCV�GL�RFC�5IP?GLC��QCC �=;IF9��������3CTCP?J�P?BGM?ARGTC�GQMRMNCQ�UCPC

PCJC?QCB�GL�FSEC�OS?LRGRGCQ��AMLR?KGL?RGLE�K?LW�RFMSQ?LBQ�MD�QOS?PC�IGJMKCRCPQ�?LB�BGPCARJW�?DDCARGLE�FSLBPCBQ�MD�RFMSQ?LBQ�MD�NCMNJC��4FC�KMQR

QGELGDGA?LR�PCJC?QCQ�UCPC�MD � � � � ��?LB ��%QRGK?RCQ�?PC�RF?R�RFC�RMR?J�?KMSLR�MD�P?BG?RGML�PCJC?QCB�U?Q�?@MSR

����KGJJGML�ASPGCQ�

(SK?L�?LB�-CBGA?J�!NNJGA?RGMLQ

�=;IF9������ 4FC�#FCPLM@WJ�PC?ARMP��-MPC�RF?L�����NCMNJC�BGCB�QMML�?DRCP�GRQ�KCJRBMUL��?LB�RFCPC�UGJJ�@C�RFMSQ?LBQ�MD�BC?RFQ�DPMK�P?BG?RGML GLBSACB�A?LACP�GL�RFC�DSRSPC�

7FGJC�RFC�?AAGBCLR�U?Q�BSC�RM�?�QCPGCQ�MD�FSK?L�CPPMPQ��RFC�AJC?LSN�CDDMPRQ�UCPC�FCPMGA��-MQR�MD�RFC�GKKCBG?RC�D?R?JGRGCQ�UCPC�DGPCDGEFRCPQ�?LB�PC?ARMP�NCPQMLLCJ���APCBGR��%JCL?

&GJ?RMT?

�L5AD@9����� 0<5H�&5GG�C: �G75D98��<9FBC6M@�

)R�GQ�CQRGK?RCB�RF?R�RFC�#FCPLM@WJ�BGQ?QRCP�PCJC?QCB�����-#G�MD GLRM�RFC�CLTGPMLKCLR��#?JASJ?RC�RFC�K?QQ�MD PCJC?QCB�

,HF5H9;M

7C�A?L�A?JASJ?RC�RFC�K?QQ�PCJC?QCB�SQGLE�!TME?BPMwQ�LSK@CP�?LB�RFC�AMLACNR�MD�?�KMJC�GD�UC�A?L�DGPQR�DGLB�RFC�LSK@CP�MD�LSAJCG PCJC?QCB�

3GLAC�RFC�?ARGTGRW GQ�EGTCL��?LB�RFC�F?JD JGDC�MD GQ�DMSLB�GL �DD9B8=L�� RM�@C������W��UC�A?L�SQC�RFC�COS?RGML RM�DGLB

,C@IH=CB

3MJTGLE�RFC�COS?RGML DMP EGTCQ

������

%LRCPGLE�RFC�EGTCL�T?JSCQ�WGCJBQ

������

#MLTCPRGLE�ASPGCQ�RM�@CAOSCPCJQ�?LB�WC?PQ�RM�QCAMLBQ��UC�ECR

������

/LC�KMJC�MD�?�LSAJGBC F?Q�?�K?QQ�MD EP?KQ��QM�RF?R�MLC�KMJC�MD F?Q�?�K?QQ�MD�����E��!�KMJC�F?Q LSAJCG��4FSQ

RFC�K?QQ�MD PCJC?QCB�U?Q

������

#(!04%2����Y�2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3 ����

Page 22: 2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · PDF filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝ cbg9fj5h=cb% 5kg z $cdglc? lbb gqasqqlsajc?pbca?w z 3r?rcr fcam lqcpt?rgmlj?uq z %vnj?gln ?pclr?

�=G7IGG=CB

7FGJC����IE�MD�K?RCPG?J�K?W�LMR�@C�?�TCPW�J?PEC�K?QQ�AMKN?PCB�RM�RFC�?KMSLR�MD�DSCJ�GL�?�NMUCP�NJ?LR��GR�GQ�CVRPCKCJW�P?BGM?ARGTC��QGLAC�GR�MLJW

F?Q�?��� WC?P�F?JD JGDC��3GV�KCE?ASPGCQ������-#G�GQ�?L�CVRP?MPBGL?PW�?KMSLR�MD�?ARGTGRW�@SR�GQ�MLJW�?�DP?ARGML�MD�UF?R�GQ�NPMBSACB�GL�LSAJC?P

PC?ARMPQ��3GKGJ?P�?KMSLRQ�MD�RFC�MRFCP�GQMRMNCQ�UCPC�?JQM�PCJC?QCB�?R�#FCPLM@WJ��!JRFMSEF�RFC�AF?LACQ�MD�QSAF�?�BGQ?QRCP�K?W�F?TC�QCCKCB

QK?JJ��RFC�AMLQCOSCLACQ�UCPC�CVRPCKCJW�QCTCPC��PCOSGPGLE�EPC?RCP�A?SRGML�RF?L�U?Q�SQCB��-MPC�UGJJ�@C�Q?GB�?@MSR�Q?DC�PC?ARMP�BCQGEL�GL�RFC�LCVR

AF?NRCP��@SR�GR�QFMSJB�@C�LMRCB�RF?R�7CQRCPL�PC?ARMPQ�F?TC�?�DSLB?KCLR?JJW�Q?DCP�BCQGEL�

!ARGTGRW BCAPC?QCQ�GL�RGKC��EMGLE�RM�F?JD�GRQ�MPGEGL?J�T?JSC�GL�MLC�F?JD JGDC��RFCL�RM�MLC DMSPRF�GRQ�MPGEGL?J�T?JSC�GL�RFC�LCVR�F?JD JGDC��?LB�QM�ML��3GLAC

��RFC�?ARGTGRW�BCAPC?QCQ�?Q�RFC�LSK@CP�MD�P?BGM?ARGTC�LSAJCG�BCAPC?QCQ��4FC�COS?RGML�DMP ?Q�?�DSLARGML�MD�RGKC�GQ�DMSLB�@W�AMK@GLGLE

RFC�COS?RGMLQ ?LB ��WGCJBGLE

������

UFCPC GQ�RFC�?ARGTGRW�?R ��4FGQ�COS?RGML�QFMUQ�CVNMLCLRG?J�BCA?W�MD�P?BGM?ARGTC�LSAJCG��&MP�CV?KNJC��GD�?�QMSPAC�MPGEGL?JJW�F?Q�?����� K#G

?ARGTGRW��GR�BCAJGLCQ�RM�������K#G�GL�MLC�F?JD JGDC��RM�������K#G�GL�RUM�F?JD JGTCQ��RM�������K#G�GL�RFPCC�F?JD JGTCQ��?LB�QM�ML��&MP�RGKCQ�MRFCP�RF?L�UFMJC

F?JD JGTCQ��RFC�COS?RGML KSQR�@C�SQCB�RM�DGLB �

0F%4�%VNJMP?RGMLQ��!JNF?�$CA?W

7?RAF�?JNF?�N?PRGAJCQ�CQA?NC�DPMK�?�NMJMLGSK�LSAJCSQ��A?SQGLE�P?BGM?ARGTC�?JNF?�BCA?W��3CC�FMU�P?LBMK�BCA?W�RGKCQ�PCJ?RC�RM�RFC�F?JD�JGDC�

�=;IF9������ �@D<5��975M��<HHD���7BL�CF;�7CBH9BH�A����������5@D<58975M49B�>5F�

���� �=B8=B;��B9F;M

4FC�KMPC�RGEFRJW�@MSLB�?�QWQRCK�GQ��RFC�QRPMLECP�RFC�DMPACQ�RF?R�FMJB�GR�RMECRFCP�?LB�RFC�EPC?RCP�RFC�CLCPEW�PCOSGPCB�RM�NSJJ�GR�?N?PR��7C�A?L�RFCPCDMPC

JC?PL�?@MSR�LSAJC?P�DMPACQ�@W�CV?KGLGLE�FMU�RGEFRJW�@MSLB�RFC�LSAJCG�?PC��7C�BCDGLC�RFC 6=B8=B;�9B9F;M �"%�MD�?�LSAJCSQ�RM�@C G;8�8A8E:L�E8DH<E87

GB�6B@C?8G8?L�7<F4FF8@5?8�<G�<AGB�F8C4E4G8�CEBGBAF�4A7�A8HGEBAF��7C�A?L�BCRCPKGLC�RFC�"%�MD�?�LSAJCSQ�DPMK�GRQ�PCQR�K?QQ��4FC�RUM�?PC�AMLLCARCB

RFPMSEF�%GLQRCGLwQ�D?KMSQ�PCJ?RGMLQFGN ��!�@MSLB�QWQRCK�F?Q�? F@4??8E K?QQ�RF?L�GRQ�QCN?P?RC�AMLQRGRSCLRQ��RFC�KMPC�RGEFRJW�RFC

LSAJCMLQ�?PC�@MSLB�RMECRFCP��RFC�QK?JJCP�RFC�K?QQ�MD�RFC�LSAJCSQ�

)K?EGLC�NSJJGLE�?�LSAJGBC�?N?PR�?Q�GJJSQRP?RCB�GL �=;IF9��������7MPI�BMLC�RM�MTCPAMKC�RFC�LSAJC?P�DMPACQ�FMJBGLE�RFC�LSAJCSQ�RMECRFCP�NSRQ�CLCPEW

GLRM�RFC�QWQRCK��"W�BCDGLGRGML��RFC�CLCPEW�GLNSR�COS?JQ�RFC�@GLBGLE�CLCPEW�"%��4FC�NGCACQ�?PC�?R�PCQR�UFCL�QCN?P?RCB��?LB�QM�RFC�CLCPEW�NSR�GLRM�RFCK

GLAPC?QCQ�RFCGP�RMR?J�PCQR�K?QQ�AMKN?PCB�UGRF�UF?R�GR�U?Q�UFCL�RFCW�UCPC�EJSCB�RMECRFCP�?Q�?�LSAJCSQ��4F?R�K?QQ�GLAPC?QC�GQ�RFSQ �

4FGQ�BGDDCPCLAC�GL�K?QQ�GQ�ILMUL�?Q @4FF�78986G��)R�GKNJGCQ�RF?R�RFC�K?QQ�MD�RFC�LSAJCSQ�GQ�JCQQ�RF?L�RFC�QSK�MD�RFC�K?QQCQ�MD�GRQ�AMLQRGRSCLR�NPMRMLQ

?LB�LCSRPMLQ��!�LSAJGBC F?Q NPMRMLQ�?LB LCSRPMLQ��QM�RF?R�RFC�BGDDCPCLAC�GL�K?QQ�GQ

������

4FSQ�

������

UFCPC GQ�RFC�K?QQ�MD�RFC�LSAJGBC � GQ�RFC�K?QQ�MD�?�NPMRML��?LB GQ�RFC�K?QQ�MD�?�LCSRPML��4P?BGRGML?JJW��UC�BC?J�UGRF�RFC�K?QQCQ

MD�LCSRP?J�?RMKQ��4M�ECR�?RMKGA�K?QQCQ�GLRM�RFC�J?QR�COS?RGML��UC�DGPQR�?BB CJCARPMLQ�RM ��UFGAF�EGTCQ ��RFC�?RMKGA�K?QQ�MD�RFC

LSAJGBC��7C�RFCL�?BB CJCARPMLQ�RM�RFC NPMRMLQ��UFGAF�EGTCQ ��MP RGKCQ�RFC�K?QQ�MD�?�FWBPMECL�?RMK��4FSQ�RFC�@GLBGLE�CLCPEW�MD�?

LSAJGBC GQ

������

4FC�?RMKGA�K?QQCQ�A?L�@C�DMSLB�GL �DD9B8=L����KMQR�AMLTCLGCLRJW�CVNPCQQCB�GL�SLGDGCB�?RMKGA�K?QQ�SLGRQ�S�� ��"%�GQ�RFSQ

A?JASJ?RCB�DPMK�ILMUL�?RMKGA�K?QQCQ�

���� #(!04%2����Y�2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3

4FGQ�AMLRCLR�GQ�?T?GJ?@JC�DMP�DPCC�?R�FRRN���ALV�MPE�AMLRCLR�AMJ���������

Page 23: 2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · PDF filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝ cbg9fj5h=cb% 5kg z $cdglc? lbb gqasqqlsajc?pbca?w z 3r?rcr fcam lqcpt?rgmlj?uq z %vnj?gln ?pclr?

�=;IF9������ 7MPI�BMLC�RM�NSJJ�?�LSAJCSQ�?N?PR�GLRM�GRQ�AMLQRGRSCLR�NPMRMLQ�?LB�LCSRPMLQ�GLAPC?QCQ�RFC�K?QQ�MD�RFC�QWQRCK��4FC�UMPI�RM�BGQ?QQCK@JC�RFC�LSAJCSQ�COS?JQ�GRQ

@GLBGLE�CLCPEW�"%��!�@MSLB�QWQRCK�F?Q�JCQQ�K?QQ�RF?L�RFC�QSK�MD�GRQ�N?PRQ��CQNCAG?JJW�LMRGAC?@JC�GL�RFC�LSAJCG��UFCPC�DMPACQ�?LB�CLCPEGCQ�?PC�TCPW�J?PEC�

4FGLEQ�'PC?R�?LB�3K?JJ

'I7@95F��975M�!9@DG��LD@5=B��5FH<UG�!CH�"BH9F=CF

!�NSXXJC�APC?RCB�@W�P?BGM?ARGTC�B?RGLE�MD�PMAIQ�GQ�PCQMJTCB�@W�P?BGM?ARGTC�FC?RGLE�MD�%?PRFwQ�GLRCPGMP��4FGQ�GLRPGESGLE�QRMPW�GQ�?LMRFCP�CV?KNJC�MD

FMU�QK?JJ QA?JC�NFWQGAQ�A?L�CVNJ?GL�J?PEC QA?JC�NFCLMKCL?�

2?BGM?ARGTC�B?RGLE�NJ?WQ�?�PMJC�GL�BCRCPKGLGLE�RFC�?NNPMVGK?RC�?EC�MD�RFC�%?PRF��4FC�MJBCQR�PMAIQ�ML�%?PRF�QMJGBGDGCB�?@MSR WC?PQ

?EMu?�LSK@CP�BCRCPKGLCB�@W�SP?LGSK ����B?RGLE��4FCQC�PMAIQ�AMSJB�MLJW�F?TC�QMJGBGDGCB�MLAC�RFC�QSPD?AC�MD�RFC�%?PRF�F?B�AMMJCB�QSDDGAGCLRJW�

4FC�RCKNCP?RSPC�MD�RFC�%?PRF�?R�DMPK?RGML�A?L�@C�CQRGK?RCB�@?QCB�ML�EP?TGR?RGML?J�NMRCLRG?J�CLCPEW�MD�RFC�?QQCK@J?EC�MD�NGCACQ�@CGLE�AMLTCPRCB

RM�RFCPK?J�CLCPEW��5QGLE�FC?R�RP?LQDCP�AMLACNRQ�BGQASQQCB�GL -<9FAC8MB5A=7G GR�GQ�RFCL�NMQQG@JC�RM�A?JASJ?RC�FMU�JMLE�GR�UMSJB�R?IC�DMP�RFC

QSPD?AC�RM�AMMJ�RM�PMAI DMPK?RGML�RCKNCP?RSPCQ��4FC�PCQSJR�GQ�?@MSR WC?PQ��4FC�DGPQR�PMAIQ�DMPKCB�F?TC�@CCL�QMJGB�DMP WC?PQ��QM

RF?R�RFC�?EC�MD�RFC�%?PRF�GQ�?NNPMVGK?RCJW WC?PQ��4FCPC�GQ�?�J?PEC�@MBW�MD�MRFCP�RWNCQ�MD�CTGBCLAC��@MRF�%?PRF @MSLB�?LB�QMJ?P�QWQRCK

AF?P?ARCPGQRGAQ�?PC�SQCB�RF?R�QSNNMPRQ�RFGQ�?EC��4FC�NSXXJC�GQ�RF?R��EGTCL�GRQ�?EC�?LB�GLGRG?J�RCKNCP?RSPC��RFC�ACLRCP�MD�RFC�%?PRF�QFMSJB�@C�KSAF

AMMJCP�RF?L�GR�GQ�RMB?W��QCC �=;IF9�������

�=;IF9������ 4FC�ACLRCP�MD�RFC�%?PRF�AMMJQ�@W�UCJJ ILMUL�FC?R�RP?LQDCP�KCRFMBQ��#MLTCARGML�GL�RFC�JGOSGB�PCEGMLQ�?LB�AMLBSARGML�KMTC�RFCPK?J�CLCPEW�RM�RFC�QSPD?AC�

UFCPC�GR�P?BG?RCQ�GLRM�AMJB��B?PI�QN?AC��'GTCL�RFC�?EC�MD�RFC�%?PRF�?LB�GRQ�GLGRG?J�RCKNCP?RSPC��GR�QFMSJB�F?TC�AMMJCB�RM�?�JMUCP�RCKNCP?RSPC�@W�LMU��4FC�@JMUSN�QFMUQ�RF?R

LSAJC?P�BCA?W�PCJC?QCQ�CLCPEW�GL�RFC�%?PRFwQ�GLRCPGMP��4FGQ�CLCPEW�F?Q�QJMUCB�RFC�AMMJGLE�NPMACQQ�?LB�GQ�PCQNMLQG@JC�DMP�RFC�GLRCPGMP�QRGJJ�@CGLE�KMJRCL�

7C�ILMU�DPMK�QCGQKGA�U?TCQ�NPMBSACB�@W�C?PRFOS?ICQ�RF?R�N?PRQ�MD�RFC�GLRCPGMP�MD�RFC�%?PRF�?PC�JGOSGB��3FC?P�MP�RP?LQTCPQC�U?TCQ�A?LLMR�RP?TCJ

RFPMSEF�?�JGOSGB�?LB�?PC�LMR�RP?LQKGRRCB�RFPMSEF�RFC�%?PRFwQ�AMPC��9CR�AMKNPCQQGML�MP�JMLEGRSBGL?J�U?TCQ�A?L�N?QQ�RFPMSEF�?�JGOSGB�?LB�BM�EM

RFPMSEF�RFC�AMPC��&PMK�RFGQ�GLDMPK?RGML��RFC�RCKNCP?RSPC�MD�RFC�GLRCPGMP�A?L�@C�CQRGK?RCB��!Q�LMRGACB��RFC�GLRCPGMP�QFMSJB�F?TC�AMMJCB�KMPC�DPMK

GRQ�GLGRG?J�RCKNCP?RSPC�GL�RFC WC?PQ�QGLAC�GRQ�DMPK?RGML��)L�D?AR��GR�QFMSJB�F?TC�R?ICL�LM�KMPC�RF?L�?@MSR WC?PQ�RM�AMMJ�RM�GRQ

NPCQCLR�RCKNCP?RSPC��7F?R�GQ�ICCNGLE�GR�FMR��4FC�?LQUCP�QCCKQ�RM�@C�P?BGM?ARGTC�BCA?W�MD�NPGKMPBG?J�CJCKCLRQ�RF?R�UCPC�N?PR�MD�RFC�K?RCPG?J�RF?R

DMPKCB�RFC�%?PRF��QCC�RFC�@JMUSN�GL �=;IF9�������

.SAJGBCQ�QSAF�?Q ?LB F?TC�F?JD JGTCQ�QGKGJ?P�RM�MP�JMLECP�RF?L�RFC�?EC�MD�RFC�%?PRF��?LB�RFCGP�BCA?W�QRGJJ�AMLRPG@SRCQ�CLCPEW�RM�RFC

GLRCPGMP��3MKC�MD�RFC�NPGKMPBG?J�P?BGM?ARGTC�LSAJGBCQ�F?TC�SLQR?@JC�BCA?W�NPMBSARQ�RF?R�?JQM�PCJC?QC�CLCPEWu F?Q�?�JMLE�BCA?W�AF?GL�MD

RFCQC��&SPRFCP��RFCPC�UCPC�KMPC�MD�RFCQC�NPGKMPBG?J�P?BGM?ARGTC�LSAJGBCQ�C?PJW�GL�RFC�JGDC�MD�RFC�%?PRF��?LB�RFSQ�RFC�?ARGTGRW�?LB�CLCPEW�AMLRPG@SRCB

UCPC�EPC?RCP�RFCL��NCPF?NQ�@W�?L�MPBCP�MD�K?ELGRSBC��4FC�?KMSLR�MD�NMUCP�APC?RCB�@W�RFCQC�BCA?WQ�NCP�AS@GA�KCRCP�GQ�TCPW�QK?JJ��(MUCTCP�

QGLAC�?�FSEC�TMJSKC�MD�K?RCPG?J�JGCQ�BCCN�@CJMU�RFC�QSPD?AC��RFGQ�PCJ?RGTCJW�QK?JJ�?KMSLR�MD�CLCPEW�A?LLMR�CQA?NC�OSGAIJW��4FC�NMUCP�NPMBSACB

LC?P�RFC�QSPD?AC�F?Q�KSAF�JCQQ�BGQR?LAC�RM�EM�RM�CQA?NC�?LB�F?Q�?�LCEJGEG@JC�CDDCAR�ML�QSPD?AC�RCKNCP?RSPCQ�

!�DGL?J�CDDCAR�MD�RFGQ�RP?NNCB�P?BG?RGML�KCPGRQ�KCLRGML��!JNF?�BCA?W�NPMBSACQ�FCJGSK�LSAJCG��UFGAF�DMPK�FCJGSK�?RMKQ�UFCL�RFCW�?PC�QRMNNCB�?LB

A?NRSPC�CJCARPMLQ��-MQR�MD�RFC�FCJGSK�ML�%?PRF�GQ�M@R?GLCB�DPMK�UCJJQ�?LB�GQ�NPMBSACB�GL�RFGQ�K?LLCP��!LW�FCJGSK�GL�RFC�?RKMQNFCPC�UGJJ�CQA?NC

GL�ECMJMEGA?JJW�QFMPR�RGKCQ�@CA?SQC�MD�GRQ�FGEF�RFCPK?J�TCJMAGRW�

7F?R�N?RRCPLQ�?LB�GLQGEFRQ�?PC�E?GLCB�DPMK�?L�CV?KGL?RGML�MD�RFC�@GLBGLE�CLCPEW�MD�T?PGMSQ�LSAJGBCQ��&GPQR��UC�DGLB�RF?R�"%�GQ�?NNPMVGK?RCJW

NPMNMPRGML?J�RM�RFC�LSK@CP�MD�LSAJCMLQ GL�?LW�LSAJCSQ��!@MSR�RUGAC�?Q�KSAF�CLCPEW�GQ�LCCBCB�RM�NSJJ�?N?PR�?�LSAJCSQ�JGIC AMKN?PCB�UGRF

NSJJGLE�?N?PR ��DMP�CV?KNJC��4M�FCJN�SQ�JMMI�?R�MRFCP�CDDCARQ��UC�BGTGBC�"%�@W ?LB�AMLQGBCP�RFC 6=B8=B;�9B9F;M�D9F�BI7@9CB� ��4FC

#(!04%2����Y�2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3 ����

Page 24: 2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · PDF filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝ cbg9fj5h=cb% 5kg z $cdglc? lbb gqasqqlsajc?pbca?w z 3r?rcr fcam lqcpt?rgmlj?uq z %vnj?gln ?pclr?

EP?NF�MD GL �=;IF9������ PCTC?JQ�QMKC�TCPW�GLRCPCQRGLE�?QNCARQ�MD�LSAJCG��7C�QCC�RF?R�RFC�@GLBGLE�CLCPEW�NCP�LSAJCML�?TCP?ECQ�?@MSR��

-C6��@SR�GQ�JMUCP�DMP�@MRF�RFC�JGEFRCQR�?LB�FC?TGCQR�LSAJCG��4FGQ�MTCP?JJ�RPCLB��GL�UFGAF�LSAJCG�UGRF COS?J�RM�?@MSR����F?TC�RFC�EPC?RCQR ?LB

?PC�RFSQ�RFC�KMQR�RGEFRJW�@MSLB��GQ�BSC�RM�RFC�AMK@GLCB�AF?P?ARCPGQRGAQ�MD�RFC�?RRP?ARGTC�LSAJC?P�DMPACQ�?LB�RFC�PCNSJQGTC�#MSJMK@�DMPAC��)R�GQ�CQNCAG?JJW

GKNMPR?LR�RM�LMRC�RUM�RFGLEQuRFC�QRPMLE�LSAJC?P�DMPAC�GQ�?@MSR�����RGKCQ�QRPMLECP�RF?L�RFC�#MSJMK@�DMPAC� 4A7 RFC�LSAJC?P�DMPACQ�?PC�QFMPRCP�GL

P?LEC�AMKN?PCB�RM�RFC�#MSJMK@�DMPAC��3M��DMP�JMU K?QQ�LSAJCG��RFC�LSAJC?P�?RRP?ARGML�BMKGL?RCQ�?LB�C?AF�?BBCB�LSAJCML�DMPKQ�@MLBQ�UGRF�?JJ

MRFCPQ��A?SQGLE�NPMEPCQQGTCJW�FC?TGCP�LSAJCG�RM�F?TC�NPMEPCQQGTCJW�EPC?RCP�T?JSCQ�MD ��4FGQ�AMLRGLSCQ�SN�RM ��PMSEFJW�AMPPCQNMLBGLE

RM�RFC�K?QQ�LSK@CP�MD�GPML��"CWMLB�RF?R��LCU�LSAJCMLQ�?BBCB�RM�?�LSAJCSQ�UGJJ�@C�RMM�D?P�DPMK�QMKC�MRFCPQ�RM�DCCJ�RFCGP�LSAJC?P�?RRP?ARGML��!BBCB

NPMRMLQ��FMUCTCP��DCCJ�RFC�PCNSJQGML�MD�?JJ�MRFCP�NPMRMLQ��QGLAC�RFC�#MSJMK@�DMPAC�GQ�JMLECP�GL�P?LEC��#MSJMK@�PCNSJQGML�EPMUQ�DMP�NPMEPCQQGTCJW

FC?TGCP�LSAJCG��@SR�LSAJC?P�?RRP?ARGML�PCK?GLQ�?@MSR�RFC�Q?KC��?LB�QM @CAMKCQ�QK?JJCP��4FGQ�GQ�UFW�QR?@JC�LSAJCG�FC?TGCP�RF?L

F?TC�KMPC�LCSRPMLQ�RF?L�NPMRMLQ��#MSJMK@�PCNSJQGML�GQ�PCBSACB�@W�F?TGLE�KMPC�LCSRPMLQ�RM�ICCN�RFC�NPMRMLQ�D?PRFCP�?N?PR��QCC �=;IF9�������

�=;IF9������ !�EP?NF�MD�?TCP?EC�@GLBGLE�CLCPEW�NCP�LSAJCML� ��DMP�QR?@JC�LSAJCG��4FC�KMQR�RGEFRJW�@MSLB�LSAJCG�?PC�RFMQC�UGRF LC?P�����UFCPC�RFC�?RRP?ARGTC

LSAJC?P�DMPAC�F?Q�GRQ�EPC?RCQR�CDDCAR��!R�FGEFCP Q��RFC�#MSJMK@�PCNSJQGML�NPMEPCQQGTCJW�PCBSACQ�RFC�@GLBGLE�CLCPEW�NCP�LSAJCML��@CA?SQC�RFC�LSAJC?P�DMPAC�GQ�QFMPR�P?LECB�

4FC�QNGICQ�ML�RFC�ASPTC�?PC�TCPW�RGEFRJW�@MSLB�LSAJGBCQ�?LB�GLBGA?RC�QFCJJ�AJMQSPCQ�

�=;IF9������ 4FC�LSAJC?P�DMPAC�GQ�?RRP?ARGTC�?LB�QRPMLECP�RF?L�RFC�#MSJMK@�DMPAC��@SR�GR�GQ�QFMPR�P?LECB��)L�JMU K?QQ�LSAJCG��C?AF�LSAJCML�DCCJQ�RFC�LSAJC?P�?RRP?ARGML�MD�?JJ

MRFCPQ��)L�J?PECP�LSAJCG��RFC�P?LEC�MD�RFC�LSAJC?P�DMPAC��QFMUL�DMP�?�QGLEJC�LSAJCML��GQ�QK?JJCP�RF?L�RFC�QGXC�MD�RFC�LSAJCSQ��@SR�RFC�#MSJMK@�PCNSJQGML�DPMK�?JJ�NPMRMLQ�PC?AFCQ

?JJ�MRFCPQ��)D�RFC�LSAJCSQ�GQ�J?PEC�CLMSEF��RFC�#MSJMK@�PCNSJQGML�A?L�?BB�RM�MTCPAMKC�RFC�LSAJC?P�?RRP?ARGML�

4FCPC�?PC�QMKC�LMRGAC?@JC�QNGICQ�ML�RFC EP?NF��UFGAF�PCNPCQCLR�N?PRGASJ?PJW�RGEFRJW�@MSLB�LSAJCG��4FCQC�QNGICQ�PCTC?J�DSPRFCP�BCR?GJQ�MD

LSAJC?P�DMPACQ��QSAF�?Q�AMLDGPKGLE�RF?R�AJMQCB QFCJJ�LSAJCG��RFMQC�UGRF�K?EGA�LSK@CPQ�MD�NPMRMLQ�MP�LCSRPMLQ�MP�@MRF�?PC�KMPC�RGEFRJW�@MSLB��4FC

QNGICQ�?JQM�GLBGA?RC�RF?R�QMKC�LSAJCG�UGRF�CTCL�LSK@CPQ�DMP ?LB ��?LB�UGRF ��?PC�CVACNRGML?JJW�RGEFRJW�@MSLB��4FGQ�DGLBGLE�A?L�@C

AMPPCJ?RCB�UGRF�QMKC�MD�RFC�AMQKGA�?@SLB?LACQ�MD�RFC�CJCKCLRQ��4FC�KMQR�AMKKML�CJCKCLRQ�GL�RFC�SLGTCPQC��?Q�BCRCPKGLCB�@W�M@QCPT?RGMLQ�MD

?RMKGA�QNCARP?�DPMK�MSRCP�QN?AC��?PC�FWBPMECL��DMJJMUCB�@W ��UGRF�KSAF�QK?JJCP�?KMSLRQ�MD ?LB�MRFCP�CJCKCLRQ��)R�QFMSJB�@C�LMRCB�RF?R

RFC�FC?TGCP�CJCKCLRQ�?PC�APC?RCB�GL�QSNCPLMT?�CVNJMQGMLQ��UFGJC�RFC�JGEFRCP�MLCQ�?PC�NPMBSACB�@W�LSAJC?P�DSQGML�BSPGLE�RFC�LMPK?J�JGDC�AWAJCQ�MD�QR?PQ�

?Q�UGJJ�@C�BGQASQQCB�GL�QS@QCOSCLR�AF?NRCPQ��4FC�KMQR�AMKKML�CJCKCLRQ�F?TC�RFC�KMQR�RGEFRJW�@MSLB�LSAJCG��)R�GQ�?JQM�LM�?AAGBCLR�RF?R�MLC�MD�RFC

KMQR�RGEFRJW�@MSLB�JGEFR�LSAJCG�GQ ��CKGRRCB�GL BCA?W�

�L5AD@9����� 0<5H�"G :CF�5B��@D<5�)5FH=7@9�

#?JASJ?RC�RFC�@GLBGLE�CLCPEW�NCP�LSAJCML�MD ��RFC N?PRGAJC�

,HF5H9;M

���� #(!04%2����Y�2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3

4FGQ�AMLRCLR�GQ�?T?GJ?@JC�DMP�DPCC�?R�FRRN���ALV�MPE�AMLRCLR�AMJ���������

Page 25: 2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · PDF filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝ cbg9fj5h=cb% 5kg z $cdglc? lbb gqasqqlsajc?pbca?w z 3r?rcr fcam lqcpt?rgmlj?uq z %vnj?gln ?pclr?

4M�DGLB ��UC�DGPQR�DGLB�"%�SQGLE�RFC�%OS?RGML ?LB�RFCL�BGTGBC�@W ��4FGQ�GQ�QRP?GEFRDMPU?PB

MLAC�UC�F?TC�JMMICB�SN�RFC�?NNPMNPG?RC�?RMKGA�K?QQCQ�GL �DD9B8=L���

,C@IH=CB

4FC�@GLBGLE�CLCPEW�DMP�?�LSAJCSQ�GQ�EGTCL�@W�RFC�COS?RGML

������

&MP ��UC�F?TC ��RFSQ�

������

�DD9B8=L�� EGTCQ�RFCQC�K?QQCQ�?Q � ��?LB ��4FSQ�

������

.MRGLE�RF?R ��UC�DGLB

������

3GLAC ��UC�QCC�RF?R GQ�RFGQ�LSK@CP�BGTGBCB�@W����MP

������

�=G7IGG=CB

4FGQ�GQ�?�J?PEC�@GLBGLE�CLCPEW�NCP�LSAJCML�AMKN?PCB�UGRF�RFMQC�DMP�MRFCP�JMU K?QQ�LSAJCG��UFGAF�F?TC ��4FGQ

GLBGA?RCQ�RF?R GQ�RGEFRJW�@MSLB�AMKN?PCB�UGRF�GRQ�LCGEF@MPQ�ML�RFC�AF?PR�MD�RFC�LSAJGBCQ��9MS�A?L�QCC�RFC�QNGIC�PCNPCQCLRGLE�RFGQ�T?JSC�MD

DMP ML�RFC�EP?NF�GL �=;IF9��������4FGQ�GQ�UFW GQ�QR?@JC��3GLAC GQ�RGEFRJW�@MSLB��GR�F?Q�JCQQ�K?QQ�RF?L�MRFCP

LSAJCG�?LB��RFCPCDMPC��A?LLMR�QNMLR?LCMSQJW�BCA?W�GLRM�RFCK��4FC�J?PEC�@GLBGLE�CLCPEW�?JQM�FCJNQ�RM�CVNJ?GL�UFW�QMKC�LSAJCG�SLBCPEM BCA?W�

3K?JJCP�K?QQ�GL�RFC�BCA?W�NPMBSARQ�A?L�KC?L�CLCPEW�PCJC?QC��?LB�QSAF�BCA?WQ�A?L�@C�QNMLR?LCMSQ��&SPRFCP��GR�A?L�F?NNCL�RF?R�RUM�NPMRMLQ

?LB�RUM�LCSRPMLQ�GL�?�LSAJCSQ�A?L�P?LBMKJW�DGLB�RFCKQCJTCQ�RMECRFCP��CVNCPGCLAC�RFC�CVACNRGML?JJW�J?PEC�LSAJC?P�DMPAC�RF?R�@GLBQ�RFGQ

AMK@GL?RGML��?LB�?AR�?Q�? SLGR�UGRFGL�RFC�LSAJCSQ��?R�JC?QR�DMP�?�UFGJC��)L�QMKC�A?QCQ��RFC CQA?NCQ��?LB BCA?W�F?Q�RFCL�R?ICL

NJ?AC�

4FCPC�GQ�KMPC�RM�@C�JC?PLCB�DPMK�LSAJC?P�@GLBGLE�CLCPEGCQ��4FC�ECLCP?J�RPCLB�GL GQ�DSLB?KCLR?J�RM�CLCPEW�NPMBSARGML�GL�QR?PQ��?LB�RM�DSQGML

?LB�DGQQGML�CLCPEW�QMSPACQ�ML�%?PRF��DMP�CV?KNJC��4FGQ�GQ�MLC�MD�RFC�?NNJGA?RGMLQ�MD�LSAJC?P�NFWQGAQ�AMTCPCB�GL &98=75@��DD@=75H=CBG�C:�'I7@95F

)<MG=7G��4FC�?@SLB?LAC�MD�CJCKCLRQ�ML�%?PRF��GL�QR?PQ��?LB�GL�RFC�SLGTCPQC�?Q�?�UFMJC�GQ�PCJ?RCB�RM�RFC�@GLBGLE�CLCPEW�MD�LSAJCG�?LB�F?Q�GKNJGA?RGMLQ

DMP�RFC�AMLRGLSCB�CVN?LQGML�MD�RFC�SLGTCPQC�

0PM@JCK 3MJTGLE�3RP?RCEGCQ

�CF�+957H=CB��B8��=B8=B;��B9F;=9G�5B8��7H=J=HM��5@7I@5H=CBG�=B�'I7@95F�)<MG=7G

�� 78AG<9L�8K46G?L�J;4G�A887F�GB�58�78G8E@<A87�<A�G;8�CEB5?8@��<78AG<9L�G;8�HA>ABJAF���4FGQ�UGJJ�?JJMU�WMS�RM�BCAGBC�UFCRFCP�RFC�CLCPEW�MD�?�BCA?W

MP�LSAJC?P�PC?ARGML�GQ�GLTMJTCB��DMP�CV?KNJC��MP�UFCRFCP�RFC�NPM@JCK�GQ�NPGK?PGJW�AMLACPLCB�UGRF�?ARGTGRW��P?RC�MD�BCA?W�

�� $4>8�4�?<FG�B9�J;4G�<F�:<I8A�BE�64A�58�<A98EE87�9EB@�G;8�CEB5?8@�4F�FG4G87��<78AG<9L�G;8�>ABJAF��

�� �BE�E846G<BA�4A7�5<A7<A:�8A8E:L�CEB5?8@F��J8�HF8�4GB@<6�E4G;8E�G;4A�AH6?84E�@4FF8F� 3GLAC�RFC�K?QQCQ�MD�LCSRP?J�?RMKQ�?PC�SQCB��WMS�KSQR

AMSLR�RFC�LSK@CP�MD�CJCARPMLQ�GLTMJTCB��)D�RFCQC�BM�LMR�@?J?LAC��QSAF�?Q�GL BCA?W��RFCL�?L�CLCPEW�?BHSQRKCLR�MD�������-C6�NCP�CJCARPML

KSQR�@C�K?BC��!JQM�LMRC�RF?R�?RMKGA�K?QQCQ�K?W�LMR�@C�EGTCL�GL�?�NPM@JCK��RFCW�A?L�@C�DMSLB�GL�R?@JCQ�

�� �BE�CEB5?8@F�<AIB?I<A:�46G<I<GL��G;8�E8?4G<BAF;<C�B9�46G<I<GL�GB�;4?9�?<98��4A7�G;8�AH@58E�B9�AH6?8<�:<I8A�<A�G;8�8DH4G<BA 64A�58�I8EL

HF89H?� /UGLE�RM�RFC�D?AR�RF?R�LSK@CP�MD�LSAJCG�GQ�GLTMJTCB��WMS�UGJJ�?JQM�LCCB�RM�@C�D?KGJG?P�UGRF�KMJCQ�?LB�!TME?BPMwQ�LSK@CP�

�� '8E9BE@�G;8�78F<E87�64?6H?4G<BA��>88C�64E89H?�GE46>�B9�C?HF�4A7�@<AHF�F<:AF�4F�J8??�4F�CBJ8EF�B9���

�� �;86>�G;8�4AFJ8E�GB�F88�<9�<G�<F�E84FBA45?8���B8F�<G�@4>8�F8AF8� #MKN?PC�WMSP�PCQSJRQ�UGRF�UMPICB�CV?KNJCQ�?LB�MRFCP�GLDMPK?RGML�GL�RFC�RCVR�

�(CCBGLE�RFC�?BTGAC�GL�3RCN���UGJJ�?JQM�FCJN�WMS�RM�@C�ACPR?GL�MD�WMSP�PCQSJR��9MS�KSQR�SLBCPQR?LB�RFC�NPM@JCK�AMLACNRS?JJW�RM�@C�?@JC�RM

BCRCPKGLC�UFCRFCP�RFC�LSKCPGA?J�PCQSJR�GQ�PC?QML?@JC�

0F%4�%VNJMP?RGMLQ��.SAJC?P�&GQQGML

3R?PR�?�AF?GL�PC?ARGML��MP�GLRPMBSAC�LML P?BGM?ARGTC�GQMRMNCQ�RM�NPCTCLR�MLC��#MLRPMJ�CLCPEW�NPMBSARGML�GL�?�LSAJC?P�PC?ARMP�

#(!04%2����Y�2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3 ����

Page 26: 2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · PDF filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝ cbg9fj5h=cb% 5kg z $cdglc? lbb gqasqqlsajc?pbca?w z 3r?rcr fcam lqcpt?rgmlj?uq z %vnj?gln ?pclr?

�=;IF9������ 'I7@95F��=GG=CB��<HHD���7BL�CF;�7CBH9BH�A���� �����BI7@95F:=GG=CB49B�>5F�

���� -IBB9@=B;

0PMRMLQ�?LB�LCSRPMLQ�?PC 5BHA7 GLQGBC�LSAJCG��RF?R�KC?LQ�CLCPEW�KSQR�@C�QSNNJGCB�RM�@PC?I�RFCK�?U?W��4FC�QGRS?RGML�GQ�?L?JMEMSQ�RM�?�K?P@JC�GL�?

@MUJ�RF?R�A?L�PMJJ�?PMSLB�@SR�J?AIQ�RFC�CLCPEW�RM�ECR�MTCP�RFC�PGK��)R�GQ�@MSLB�GLQGBC�RFC�@MUJ��QCC �=;IF9����� ��)D�RFC�K?P@JC�AMSJB�ECR�MTCP�RFC�PGK�

GR�UMSJB�E?GL�IGLCRGA�CLCPEW�@W�PMJJGLE�BMUL�MSRQGBC��(MUCTCP�AJ?QQGA?JJW��GD�RFC�K?P@JC�BMCQ�LMR�F?TC�CLMSEF�IGLCRGA�CLCPEW�RM�ECR�MTCP�RFC�PGK��GR

PCK?GLQ�DMPCTCP�RP?NNCB�GL�GRQ�UCJJ�

�=;IF9����� 4FC�K?P@JC�GL�RFGQ�QCKGAGPASJ?P�@MUJ�?R�RFC�RMN�MD�?�TMJA?LM�F?Q�CLMSEF�IGLCRGA�CLCPEW�RM�ECR�RM�RFC�?JRGRSBC�MD�RFC�B?QFCB�JGLC��@SR�LMR�CLMSEF�RM�ECR�MTCP�RFC�PGK�

QM�RF?R�GR�GQ�RP?NNCB�DMPCTCP��)D�GR�AMSJB�DGLB�?�RSLLCJ�RFPMSEF�RFC�@?PPGCP��GR�UMSJB�CQA?NC��PMJJ�BMULFGJJ��?LB�E?GL�IGLCRGA�CLCPEW�

)L�?�LSAJCSQ��RFC�?RRP?ARGTC�LSAJC?P�NMRCLRG?J�GQ�?L?JMEMSQ�RM�RFC�@MUJ�?R�RFC�RMN�MD�?�TMJA?LM��UFCPC�RFC�xTMJA?LMy�PCDCPQ�MLJW�RM�RFC�QF?NC��0PMRMLQ

?LB�LCSRPMLQ�F?TC�IGLCRGA�CLCPEW��@SR�GR�GQ�?@MSR���-C6�JCQQ�RF?L�RF?R�LCCBCB�RM�ECR�MSR��QCC �=;IF9��������4F?R�GQ��RFCW�?PC�@MSLB�@W�?L�?TCP?EC�MD

��-C6�NCP�LSAJCML��4FC�QJMNC�MD�RFC�FGJJ�MSRQGBC�RFC�@MUJ�GQ�?L?JMEMSQ�RM�RFC�PCNSJQGTC�#MSJMK@�NMRCLRG?J�DMP�?�LSAJCSQ��QSAF�?Q�DMP�?L N?PRGAJC

MSRQGBC�?�NMQGRGTC�LSAJCSQ��)L BCA?W��RUM�NPMRMLQ�?LB�RUM�LCSRPMLQ�QNMLR?LCMSQJW�@PC?I�?U?W�?Q�? SLGR��9CR�RFC�NPMRMLQ�?LB�LCSRPMLQ�BM

LMR�F?TC�CLMSEF�IGLCRGA�CLCPEW�RM�ECR�MTCP�RFC�PGK��3M�FMU�BMCQ�RFC N?PRGAJC�ECR�MSR�

�=;IF9������ .SAJCMLQ�UGRFGL�?L�?RMKGA�LSAJCSQ�?PC�@MSLB�MP�RP?NNCB�@W�RFC�?RRP?ARGTC�LSAJC?P�DMPAC��?Q�QFMUL�GL�RFGQ�QGKNJGDGCB�NMRCLRG?J�CLCPEW�ASPTC��!L N?PRGAJC�MSRQGBC

RFC�P?LEC�MD�RFC�LSAJC?P�DMPAC�DCCJQ�RFC�PCNSJQGTC�#MSJMK@�DMPAC��4FC N?PRGAJC�GLQGBC�RFC�LSAJCSQ�BMCQ�LMR�F?TC�CLMSEF�IGLCRGA�CLCPEW�RM�ECR�MTCP�RFC�PGK��WCR�GR�BMCQ

K?L?EC�RM�ECR�MSR�@W�OS?LRSK�KCAF?LGA?J�RSLLCJGLE�

4FC�?LQUCP�U?Q�QSNNJGCB�GL������@W�RFC�2SQQG?L�NFWQGAGQR�'CMPEC�'?KMU������t������4FC N?PRGAJC�RSLLCJQ�RFPMSEF�?�PCEGML�MD�QN?AC�GR�GQ

DMP@GBBCL�RM�@C�GL��?LB�GR�AMKCQ�MSR�MD�RFC�QGBC�MD�RFC�LSAJCSQ��,GIC�?L�CJCARPML�K?IGLE�?�RP?LQGRGML�@CRUCCL�MP@GRQ�?PMSLB�?L�?RMK��GR�RP?TCJQ�DPMK�MLC

NMGLR�RM�?LMRFCP�UGRFMSR�CTCP�F?TGLE�@CCL�GL�@CRUCCL� �=;IF9������ GLBGA?RCQ�FMU�RFGQ�UMPIQ��4FC�U?TC�DSLARGML�MD�?�OS?LRSK�KCAF?LGA?J�N?PRGAJC

T?PGCQ�QKMMRFJW��EMGLE�DPMK�UGRFGL�?L�?RMKGA�LSAJCSQ��ML�MLC�QGBC�MD�?�NMRCLRG?J�CLCPEW�@?PPGCP�RM�MSRQGBC�RFC�LSAJCSQ��ML�RFC�MRFCP�QGBC�MD�RFC

NMRCLRG?J�CLCPEW�@?PPGCP��)LQGBC�RFC�@?PPGCP��RFC�U?TC�DSLARGML�BMCQ�LMR�@CAMKC�XCPM�@SR�BCAPC?QCQ�CVNMLCLRG?JJW��?LB�UC�BM�LMR�M@QCPTC�RFC�N?PRGAJC

GLQGBC�RFC�@?PPGCP��4FC�NPM@?@GJGRW�MD�DGLBGLE�?�N?PRGAJC�GQ�PCJ?RCB�RM�RFC�QOS?PC�MD�GRQ�U?TC�DSLARGML��?LB�QM�RFCPC�GQ�?�QK?JJ�NPM@?@GJGRW�MD�DGLBGLE�RFC

N?PRGAJC�MSRQGBC�RFC�@?PPGCP��UFGAF�GKNJGCQ�RF?R�RFC�N?PRGAJC�A?L�RSLLCJ�RFPMSEF�RFC�@?PPGCP��4FGQ�NPMACQQ�GQ�A?JJCB 65FF=9F�D9B9HF5H=CB MP EI5BHIA

A97<5B=75@�HIBB9@=B;��4FGQ�AMLACNR�U?Q�BCTCJMNCB�GL�RFCMPW�@W�*��2M@CPR�/NNCLFCGKCP��UFM�JCB�RFC�BCTCJMNKCLR�MD�RFC�DGPQR�LSAJC?P�@MK@Q�BSPGLE

7MPJB�7?P�))�?LB�U?Q�SQCB�@W�'?KMU�?LB�MRFCPQ�RM�BCQAPG@C BCA?W�

���� #(!04%2����Y�2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3

4FGQ�AMLRCLR�GQ�?T?GJ?@JC�DMP�DPCC�?R�FRRN���ALV�MPE�AMLRCLR�AMJ���������

Page 27: 2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · PDF filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝ cbg9fj5h=cb% 5kg z $cdglc? lbb gqasqqlsajc?pbca?w z 3r?rcr fcam lqcpt?rgmlj?uq z %vnj?gln ?pclr?

�=;IF9������ 4FC�U?TC�DSLARGML�PCNPCQCLRGLE�?�OS?LRSK�KCAF?LGA?J�N?PRGAJC�KSQR�T?PW�QKMMRFJW��EMGLE�DPMK�UGRFGL�RFC�LSAJCSQ��RM�RFC�JCDR�MD�RFC�@?PPGCP�RM�MSRQGBC�RFC�LSAJCSQ

�RM�RFC�PGEFR�MD�RFC�@?PPGCP��)LQGBC�RFC�@?PPGCP��RFC�U?TC�DSLARGML�BMCQ�LMR�?@PSNRJW�@CAMKC�XCPM��P?RFCP��GR�BCAPC?QCQ�CVNMLCLRG?JJW��/SRQGBC�RFC�@?PPGCP��RFC�U?TC�DSLARGML�GQ

QK?JJ�@SR�DGLGRC��?LB�RFCPC�GR�QKMMRFJW�@CAMKCQ�QGLSQMGB?J��/UGLE�RM�RFC�D?AR�RF?R�RFCPC�GQ�?�QK?JJ�NPM@?@GJGRW�MD�DGLBGLE�RFC�N?PRGAJC�MSRQGBC�RFC�@?PPGCP��RFC�N?PRGAJC�A?L�RSLLCJ

RFPMSEF�RFC�@?PPGCP�

'MMB�GBC?Q�CVNJ?GL�KMPC�RF?L�MLC�RFGLE��)L�?BBGRGML�RM�OS?JGR?RGTCJW�CVNJ?GLGLE�FMU�RFC�DMSP�LSAJCMLQ�GL�?L N?PRGAJC�A?L�ECR�MSR�MD�RFC�LSAJCSQ��RFC

BCR?GJCB�RFCMPW�?JQM�CVNJ?GLQ�OS?LRGR?RGTCJW�RFC�F?JD JGDC�MD�T?PGMSQ�LSAJCG�RF?R�SLBCPEM BCA?W��4FGQ�BCQAPGNRGML�GQ�UF?R�'?KMU�?LB�MRFCPQ�BCTGQCB�

?LB�GR�UMPIQ�DMP BCA?W�F?JD JGTCQ�RF?R�T?PW�@W����MPBCPQ�MD�K?ELGRSBC��%VNCPGKCLRQ�F?TC�QFMUL�RF?R�RFC�KMPC�CLCPECRGA�RFC BCA?W�MD�?�N?PRGASJ?P

LSAJGBC�GQ��RFC�QFMPRCP�GQ�GRQ�F?JD JGDC� -IBB9@=B; CVNJ?GLQ�RFGQ�GL�RFC�DMJJMUGLE�K?LLCP��&MP�RFC�BCA?W�RM�@C�KMPC�CLCPECRGA��RFC�LSAJCMLQ�KSQR�F?TC

KMPC�CLCPEW�GL�RFC�LSAJCSQ�?LB�QFMSJB�@C�?@JC�RM�?QACLB�?�JGRRJC�AJMQCP�RM�RFC�PGK��4FC�@?PPGCP�GQ�RFCPCDMPC�LMR�?Q�RFGAI�DMP�KMPC�CLCPECRGA�BCA?W��?LB

RFC�CVNMLCLRG?J�BCAPC?QC�MD�RFC�U?TC�DSLARGML�GLQGBC�RFC�@?PPGCP�GQ�LMR�?Q�EPC?R��4FSQ�RFC�NPM@?@GJGRW�MD�DGLBGLE�RFC�N?PRGAJC�MSRQGBC�RFC�@?PPGCP�GQ

EPC?RCP��?LB�RFC�F?JD JGDC�GQ�QFMPRCP�

4SLLCJGLE�?Q�?L�CDDCAR�?JQM�MAASPQ�GL�OS?LRSK�KCAF?LGA?J�QWQRCKQ�MRFCP�RF?L�LSAJCG��%JCARPMLQ�RP?NNCB�GL�QMJGBQ�A?L�RSLLCJ�DPMK�MLC�M@HCAR�RM

?LMRFCP�GD�RFC�@?PPGCP�@CRUCCL�RFC�M@HCARQ�GQ�RFGL�CLMSEF��4FC�NPMACQQ�GQ�RFC�Q?KC�GL�NPGLAGNJC�?Q�BCQAPG@CB�DMP BCA?W��)R�GQ�D?P�KMPC�JGICJW�DMP�?�RFGL

@?PPGCP�RF?L�?�RFGAI�MLC��3A?LLGLE�RSLLCJGLE�CJCARPML�KGAPMQAMNCQ�DSLARGML�ML�RFGQ�NPGLAGNJC��4FC�ASPPCLR�MD�CJCARPMLQ�RF?R�RP?TCJQ�@CRUCCL�?�NPM@C�?LB

?�Q?KNJC�RSLLCJQ�RFPMSEF�?�@?PPGCP�?LB�GQ�TCPW�QCLQGRGTC�RM�GRQ�RFGAILCQQ��?JJMUGLE�BCRCARGML�MD�GLBGTGBS?J�?RMKQ�?Q�QFMUL�GL �=;IF9�������

�=;IF9������ �?�!�QA?LLGLE�RSLLCJGLE�CJCARPML�KGAPMQAMNC�A?L�BCRCAR�CVRPCKCJW�QK?JJ�T?PG?RGMLQ�GL�BGKCLQGMLQ��QSAF�?Q�GLBGTGBS?J�?RMKQ��%JCARPMLQ�RSLLCJ�OS?LRSK

KCAF?LGA?JJW�@CRUCCL�RFC�NPM@C�?LB�RFC�Q?KNJC��4FC�NPM@?@GJGRW�MD�RSLLCJGLE�GQ�CVRPCKCJW�QCLQGRGTC�RM�@?PPGCP�RFGAILCQQ��QM�RF?R�RFC�CJCARPML�ASPPCLR�GQ�?�QCLQGRGTC�GLBGA?RMP�MD

QSPD?AC�DC?RSPCQ���@�(C?B�?LB�KMSRFN?PRQ�MD �B?8BCG8E4��;ELFB@8?<784 ?Q�QCCL�RFPMSEF�?L�CJCARPML�KGAPMQAMNC��APCBGR��,MSGQ?�(MU?PB��$?PRKMSRF�#MJJCEC

#(!04%2����Y�2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3 ����

Page 28: 2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · PDF filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝ cbg9fj5h=cb% 5kg z $cdglc? lbb gqasqqlsajc?pbca?w z 3r?rcr fcam lqcpt?rgmlj?uq z %vnj?gln ?pclr?

57H=J=HM�

5@D<5�8975M�

5@D<5�F5MG�

5BH=9@97HFCB�

5BH=A5HH9F�

5HCA=7�A5GG�

5HCA=7�BIA69F�

65FF=9F�D9B9HF5H=CB�

697EI9F9@�

69H5�8975M�

69H5�F5MG�

6=B8=B;�9B9F;M�D9F�BI7@9CB�

6=B8=B;�9B9F;M�

75F6CB���85H=B;�

7<5FH�C:�H<9�BI7@=89G�

7IF=9�

85I;<H9F�

8975M�7CBGH5BH�

8975M�9EI5H=CB�

8975M�G9F=9G�

8975M�

9@97HFCB�75DHIF9�9EI5H=CB�

9@97HFCB�75DHIF9�

9@97HFCBUG�5BH=B9IHF=BC�

9@97HFCBUG�B9IHF=BC�

9=;9F�HI69�

;5AA5�8975M�

;5AA5�F5MG�

<5@:@=:9�

=CB=N=B;�F58=5H=CB�

0F%4�%VNJMP?RGMLQ��1S?LRSK�4SLLCJGLE�?LB�7?TC�0?AICRQ

7?RAF�OS?LRSK��N?PRGAJCQ��RSLLCJ�RFPMSEF�@?PPGCPQ��%VNJMPC�RFC�NPMNCPRGCQ�MD�RFC�U?TC�DSLARGMLQ�RF?R�BCQAPG@C�RFCQC�N?PRGAJCQ�

�=;IF9������ *I5BHIA�-IBB9@=B;�5B8�05J9�)57?9HG��<HHD���7BL�CF;�7CBH9BH�A����������EI5BHIAHIBB9@=B;49B�>5F�

@CGG5FM

RFC�P?RC�MD�BCA?W�DMP�P?BGM?ARGTC�LSAJGBCQ

RWNC�MD�P?BGM?ARGTC�BCA?W�GL�UFGAF�?L�?RMKGA�LSAJCSQ�CKGRQ�?L�?JNF?�N?PRGAJC

MLC�MD�RFC�RWNCQ�MD�P?WQ�CKGRRCB�DPMK�RFC�LSAJCSQ�MD�?L�?RMK

?LMRFCP�RCPK�DMP�NMQGRPML

AMKNMQCB�MD�?LRGN?PRGAJCQ

RFC�RMR?J�K?QQ�MD�RFC�NPMRMLQ��LCSRPMLQ��?LB�CJCARPMLQ�GL�?�QGLEJC�?RMK

LSK@CP�MD�NPMRMLQ�GL�?�LSAJCSQ

OS?LRSK�KCAF?LGA?J�CDDCAR�UFCPC@W�?�N?PRGAJC�F?Q�?�LMLXCPM�NPM@?@GJGRW�RM�APMQQ�RFPMSEF�?�NMRCLRG?J�CLCPEW�@?PPGCP�BCQNGRC

LMR�F?TGLE�QSDDGAGCLR�CLCPEW�RM�N?QQ�MTCP�RFC�@?PPGCP��?JQM�A?JJCB�OS?LRSK�KCAF?LGA?J�RSLLCJGLE

3)�SLGR�DMP�P?RC�MD�BCA?W�MD�?�P?BGM?ARGTC�K?RCPG?J

RWNC�MD�P?BGM?ARGTC�BCA?W�GL�UFGAF�?L�?RMKGA�LSAJCSQ�CKGRQ�?�@CR?�N?PRGAJC

MLC�MD�RFC�RWNCQ�MD�P?WQ�CKGRRCB�DPMK�RFC�LSAJCSQ�MD�?L�?RMK

RFC�@GLBGLE�CLCPEW�A?JASJ?RCB�NCP�LSAJCML��GR�PCTC?JQ�RFC�BCR?GJQ�MD�RFC�LSAJC?P�DMPACuJ?PECP�RFC ��RFC�KMPC

QR?@JC�RFC�LSAJCSQ

RFC�CLCPEW�LCCBCB�RM�QCN?P?RC�LSAJCSQ�GLRM�GLBGTGBS?J�NPMRMLQ�?LB�LCSRPMLQ

?�P?BGM?ARGTC�B?RGLE�RCAFLGOSC�@?QCB�ML�RFC�P?BGM?ARGTGRW�MD�A?P@ML ��

?�R?@JC�AMKNPGQGLE�QR?@JC�?LB�SLQR?@JC�LSAJCG

RFC�?ARGTGRW�MD��E�MD ��COS?J�RM

RFC�LSAJCSQ�M@R?GLCB�UFCL�N?PCLR�LSAJCSQ�BCA?WQ�?LB�NPMBSACQ�?LMRFCP�LSAJCSQ�DMJJMUGLE�RFC�PSJCQ�?LB�RFC�AMLQCPT?RGML�J?UQ

OS?LRGRW�RF?R�GQ�GLTCPQCJW�NPMNMPRGML?J�RM�RFC�F?JD JGDC�?LB�RF?R�GQ�SQCB�GL�COS?RGML�DMP�LSK@CP�MD�LSAJCG�?Q�?�DSLARGML�MD�RGKC

RFC�COS?RGML�RM�DGLB�MSR�FMU�KSAF�MD�?�P?BGM?ARGTC�K?RCPG?J�GQ�JCDR�?DRCP�?�EGTCL�NCPGMB�MD�RGKC

NPMACQQ�UFCPC@W�QS@QCOSCLR�LSAJGBCQ�BCA?W�SLRGJ�?�QR?@JC�LSAJGBC�GQ�NPMBSACB

RFC�NPMACQQ�@W�UFGAF�?L�?RMKGA�LSAJCSQ�MD�?L�SLQR?@JC�?RMK�JMQCQ�K?QQ�?LB�CLCPEW�@W�CKGRRGLE�GMLGXGLE�N?PRGAJCQ

COS?RGML�PCNPCQCLRGLE�RFC�CJCARPML�A?NRSPC

RFC�NPMACQQ�GL�UFGAF�?�NPMRML PGAF�LSAJGBC�?@QMP@Q�?L�GLLCP�?RMKGA�CJCARPML�?LB�QGKSJR?LCMSQJW�CKGRQ�?�LCSRPGLM

?LRGN?PRGAJC�MD�CJCARPMLwQ�LCSRPGLM

?�QS@?RMKGA�CJCKCLR?PW�N?PRGAJC�UFGAF�F?Q�LM�LCR�CJCARPGA�AF?PEC

?�TCPW�AMKKML�P?BG?RGML�BCRCARMP�RF?R�SQS?JJW�EGTCQ�?L�?SBGM�MSRNSR

RWNC�MD�P?BGM?ARGTC�BCA?W�GL�UFGAF�?L�?RMKGA�LSAJCSQ�CKGRQ�?�E?KK?�N?PRGAJC

MLC�MD�RFC�RWNCQ�MD�P?WQ�CKGRRCB�DPMK�RFC�LSAJCSQ�MD�?L�?RMK

RFC�RGKC�GL�UFGAF�RFCPC�GQ�?�����AF?LAC�RF?R�?�LSAJCSQ�UGJJ�BCA?W

P?BG?RGML��UFCRFCP�LSAJC?P�GL�MPGEGL�MP�LMR�RF?R�NPMBSACQ�GMLGX?RGML�UFCRFCP�LSAJC?P�GL�MPGEGL�MP�LMR

���� #(!04%2����Y�2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3

4FGQ�AMLRCLR�GQ�?T?GJ?@JC�DMP�DPCC�?R�FRRN���ALV�MPE�AMLRCLR�AMJ���������

Page 29: 2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · PDF filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝ cbg9fj5h=cb% 5kg z $cdglc? lbb gqasqqlsajc?pbca?w z 3r?rcr fcam lqcpt?rgmlj?uq z %vnj?gln ?pclr?

=GCHCD9G�

A5;=7�BIA69FG�

A5GG�BIA69F�

B9IHF=BC�

B9IHFCB�

BI7@95F�F58=5H=CB�

BI7@95F�F957H=CB�9B9F;M�

BI7@9CBG�

BI7@9IG�

BI7@=89�

D5F9BH�

D<CHCAI@H=D@=9F�

DCG=HFCB�8975M�

DCG=HFCB�

DFCHCBG�

EI5BHIA�A97<5B=75@�HIBB9@=B;�

F58=5H=CB�89H97HCF�

F58=C57H=J9�85H=B;�

F58=C57H=J9�

F58=C57H=J=HM�

F58=IG�C:�5�BI7@9IG�

F5B;9�C:�F58=5H=CB�

F5H9�C:�8975M�

G7=BH=@@5HCFG�

GC@=8GH5H9�F58=5H=CB�89H97HCFG�

HIBB9@=B;�

LSAJCG�F?TGLE�RFC�Q?KC ?LB�BGDDCPCLR Q

?�LSK@CP�RF?R�GLBGA?RCQ�?�QFCJJ�QRPSARSPC�DMP�RFC�LSAJCSQ�GL�UFGAF�AJMQCB�QFCJJQ�?PC�KMPC�QR?@JC

LSK@CP�MD�LSAJCMLQ�GL�?�LSAJCSQ

?L�CJCARPGA?JJW�LCSRP?J��UC?IJW�GLRCP?ARGLE�CJCKCLR?PW�QS@?RMKGA�N?PRGAJC

?�LCSRP?J�N?PRGAJC�RF?R�GQ�DMSLB�GL�?�LSAJCSQ

P?WQ�RF?R�MPGEGL?RC�GL�RFC�LSAJCG�MD�?RMKQ��RFC�DGPQR�CV?KNJCQ�MD�UFGAF�UCPC�BGQAMTCPCB�@W�"CAOSCPCJ

RFC�CLCPEW�APC?RCB�GL�?�LSAJC?P�PC?ARGML

RFC�N?PRGAJCQ�DMSLB�GLQGBC�LSAJCG

?�PCEGML�AMLQGQRGLE�MD�NPMRMLQ�?LB�LCSRPMLQ�?R�RFC�ACLRCP�MD�?L�?RMK

?�RWNC�MD�?RMK�UFMQC�LSAJCSQ�F?Q�QNCAGDGA�LSK@CPQ�MD�NPMRMLQ�?LB�LCSRPMLQ

RFC�MPGEGL?J�QR?RC�MD�LSAJCSQ�@CDMPC�BCA?W

?�BCTGAC�RF?R�AMLTCPRQ�JGEFR�GLRM�CJCARPGA?J�QGEL?JQ

RWNC�MD�@CR?�BCA?W�GL�UFGAF�?�NPMRML�GQ�AMLTCPRCB�RM�?�LCSRPML��PCJC?QGLE�?�NMQGRPML�?LB�?�LCSRPGLM

RFC�N?PRGAJC�RF?R�PCQSJRQ�DPMK�NMQGRGTC�@CR?�BCA?W��?JQM�ILMUL�?Q�?L�?LRGCJCARPML

RFC�NMQGRGTCJW�AF?PECB�LSAJCMLQ�DMSLB�GL�?�LSAJCSQ

OS?LRSK�KCAF?LGA?J�CDDCAR�UFCPC@W�?�N?PRGAJC�F?Q�?�LMLXCPM�NPM@?@GJGRW�RM�APMQQ�RFPMSEF�?�NMRCLRG?J�CLCPEW

@?PPGCP�BCQNGRC�LMR�F?TGLE�QSDDGAGCLR�CLCPEW�RM�N?QQ�MTCP�RFC�@?PPGCP��?JQM�A?JJCB�@?PPGCP�NCLCRP?RGML

?�BCTGAC�RF?R�GQ�SQCB�RM�BCRCAR�?LB�RP?AI�RFC�P?BG?RGML�DPMK�?�P?BGM?ARGTC�PC?ARGML

?L�?NNJGA?RGML�MD�P?BGM?ARGTC�BCA?W�GL�UFGAF�RFC�?EC�MD�?�K?RCPG?J�GQ�BCRCPKGLCB�@W�RFC�?KMSLR�MD�P?BGM?ARGTGRW�MD�?�N?PRGASJ?P

RWNC�RF?R�MAASPQ

?�QS@QR?LAC�MP�M@HCAR�RF?R�CKGRQ�LSAJC?P�P?BG?RGML

RFC�CKGQQGML�MD�P?WQ�DPMK�RFC�LSAJCG�MD�?RMKQ

RFC�P?BGSQ�MD�?�LSAJCSQ�GQ

RFC�BGQR?LAC�RF?R�RFC�P?BG?RGML�A?L�RP?TCJ�RFPMSEF�?�K?RCPG?J

RFC�LSK@CP�MD�P?BGM?ARGTC�CTCLRQ�NCP�SLGR�RGKC

?�P?BG?RGML�BCRCARGML�KCRFMB�RF?R�PCAMPBQ�JGEFR�NPMBSACB�UFCL�P?BG?RGML�GLRCP?ARQ�UGRF�K?RCPG?JQ

QCKGAMLBSARMPQ�D?@PGA?RCB�RM�BGPCARJW�AMLTCPR�GLAGBCLR�P?BG?RGML�GLRM�CJCARPGA?J�ASPPCLR

?�OS?LRSK�KCAF?LGA?J�NPMACQQ�MD�NMRCLRG?J�CLCPEW�@?PPGCP�NCLCRP?RGML

,97H=CB�,IAA5FM

���� 'I7@95F�+58=C57H=J=HMz 3MKC�LSAJCG�?PC�P?BGM?ARGTCuRFCW�QNMLR?LCMSQJW�BCA?W�BCQRPMWGLE�QMKC�N?PR�MD�RFCGP�K?QQ�?LB�CKGRRGLE�CLCPECRGA�P?WQ��?�NPMACQQ�A?JJCB

LSAJC?P�P?BGM?ARGTGRW�

z .SAJC?P�P?BG?RGML��JGIC�V�P?WQ��GQ�GMLGXGLE�P?BG?RGML��@CA?SQC�CLCPEW�QSDDGAGCLR�RM�GMLGXC�K?RRCP�GQ�CKGRRCB�GL�C?AF�BCA?W�

z 4FC�P?LEC��MP�BGQR?LAC�RP?TCJCB�GL�?�K?RCPG?J�MD�GMLGXGLE�P?BG?RGML�GQ�BGPCARJW�PCJ?RCB�RM�RFC�AF?PEC�MD�RFC�CKGRRCB�N?PRGAJC�?LB�GRQ�CLCPEW��UGRF

EPC?RCP AF?PEC�?LB�JMUCP CLCPEW�N?PRGAJCQ�F?TGLE�RFC�QFMPRCQR�P?LECQ�

z 2?BG?RGML�BCRCARMPQ�?PC�@?QCB�BGPCARJW�MP�GLBGPCARJW�SNML�RFC�GMLGX?RGML�APC?RCB�@W�P?BG?RGML��?Q�?PC�RFC�CDDCARQ�MD�P?BG?RGML�ML�JGTGLE�?LB�GLCPR

K?RCPG?JQ�

���� +58=5H=CB��9H97H=CB�5B8��9H97HCFGz 2?BG?RGML�BCRCARMPQ�?PC�@?QCB�BGPCARJW�MP�GLBGPCARJW�SNML�RFC�GMLGX?RGML�APC?RCB�@W�P?BG?RGML��?Q�?PC�RFC�CDDCARQ�MD�P?BG?RGML�ML�JGTGLE�?LB�GLCPR

K?RCPG?JQ�

���� ,I6GHFI7HIF9�C:�H<9�'I7@9IGz 4UM�N?PRGAJCQ��@MRF�A?JJCB�LSAJCMLQ��?PC�DMSLB�GLQGBC�LSAJCG��4FC�RUM�RWNCQ�MD�LSAJCMLQ�?PC�NPMRMLQ�?LB�LCSRPMLQ��RFCW�?PC�TCPW�QGKGJ?P��CVACNR

RF?R�RFC�NPMRML�GQ�NMQGRGTCJW�AF?PECB�UFGJC�RFC�LCSRPML�GQ�LCSRP?J��3MKC�MD�RFCGP�AF?P?ARCPGQRGAQ�?PC�EGTCL�GL -56@9����� ?LB�AMKN?PCB�UGRF�RFMQC

MD�RFC�CJCARPML��!�K?QQ�SLGR�AMLTCLGCLR�RM�?RMKGA�?LB�LSAJC?P�NPMACQQCQ�GQ�RFC�SLGDGCB�?RMKGA�K?QQ�SLGR��S��BCDGLCB�RM�@C

#(!04%2����Y�2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3 ����

Page 30: 2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · PDF filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝ cbg9fj5h=cb% 5kg z $cdglc? lbb gqasqqlsajc?pbca?w z 3r?rcr fcam lqcpt?rgmlj?uq z %vnj?gln ?pclr?

z !�LSAJGBC�GQ�?�QNCAGDGA�AMK@GL?RGML�MD�NPMRMLQ�?LB�LCSRPMLQ��BCLMRCB�@W

GQ�RFC�LSK@CP�MD�NPMRMLQ�MP�?RMKGA�LSK@CP��8�GQ�RFC�QWK@MJ�DMP�RFC�CJCKCLR� GQ�RFC�LSK@CP�MD�LCSRPMLQ��?LB GQ�RFC�K?QQ�LSK@CP�MP

RFC�RMR?J�LSK@CP�MD�NPMRMLQ�?LB�LCSRPMLQ�

z .SAJGBCQ�F?TGLE�RFC�Q?KC @SR�BGDDCPCLR ?PC�GQMRMNCQ�MD�RFC�Q?KC�CJCKCLR�

z 4FC�P?BGSQ�MD�?�LSAJCSQ� ��GQ�?NNPMVGK?RCJW

UFCPC ��.SAJC?P�TMJSKCQ�?PC�NPMNMPRGML?J�RM ��4FCPC�?PC�RUM�LSAJC?P�DMPACQ��RFC�UC?I�?LB�RFC�QRPMLE��3WQRCK?RGAQ�GL�LSAJC?P

QR?@GJGRW�QCCL�ML�RFC�AF?PR�MD�RFC�LSAJGBCQ�GLBGA?RC�RF?R�RFCPC�?PC�QFCJJ�AJMQSPCQ�GL�LSAJCG�DMP�T?JSCQ�MD ?LB COS?J�RM�RFC�K?EGA�LSK@CPQ�

UFGAF�AMPPCQNMLB�RM�FGEFJW�QR?@JC�LSAJCG�

���� 'I7@95F��975M�5B8��CBG9FJ5H=CB�%5KGz 7FCL�?�N?PCLR�LSAJCSQ�BCA?WQ��GR�NPMBSACQ�?�B?SEFRCP�LSAJCSQ�DMJJMUGLE�PSJCQ�?LB�AMLQCPT?RGML�J?UQ��4FCPC�?PC�RFPCC�K?HMP�RWNCQ�MD�LSAJC?P

BCA?W��A?JJCB�?JNF? @CR? ?LB�E?KK? ��4FC BCA?W�COS?RGML�GQ

z .SAJC?P�BCA?W�PCJC?QCQ�?L�?KMSLR�MD�CLCPEW PCJ?RCB�RM�RFC�K?QQ�BCQRPMWCB @W

z 4FCPC�?PC�RFPCC�DMPKQ�MD�@CR?�BCA?W��4FC BCA?W�COS?RGML�GQ

z 4FC BCA?W�COS?RGML�GQ

z 4FC�CJCARPML�A?NRSPC�COS?RGML�GQ

z GQ�?L�CJCARPML� GQ�?L�?LRGCJCARPML�MP�NMQGRPML� PCNPCQCLRQ�?L�CJCARPMLwQ�LCSRPGLM��?LB GQ�?L�CJCARPMLwQ�?LRGLCSRPGLM��)L�?BBGRGML

RM�?JJ�NPCTGMSQJW�ILMUL�AMLQCPT?RGML�J?UQ��RUM�LCU�MLCQ�?PGQCu�AMLQCPT?RGML�MD�CJCARPML�D?KGJW�LSK@CP�?LB�AMLQCPT?RGML�MD�RFC�RMR?J�LSK@CP�MD

LSAJCMLQ��4FC BCA?W�COS?RGML�GQ

GQ�?�FGEF CLCPEW�NFMRML�MPGEGL?RGLE�GL�?�LSAJCSQ�

���� !5@:%=:9�5B8��7H=J=HMz (?JD JGDC GQ�RFC�RGKC�GL�UFGAF�RFCPC�GQ�?�����AF?LAC�RF?R�?�LSAJCSQ�UGJJ�BCA?W��4FC�LSK@CP�MD�LSAJCG ?Q�?�DSLARGML�MD�RGKC�GQ

UFCPC GQ�RFC�LSK@CP�NPCQCLR�?R ��?LB GQ�RFC�BCA?W�AMLQR?LR��PCJ?RCB�RM�RFC�F?JD JGDC�@W

z /LC�MD�RFC�?NNJGA?RGMLQ�MD�P?BGM?ARGTC�BCA?W�GQ�P?BGM?ARGTC�B?RGLE��GL�UFGAF�RFC�?EC�MD�?�K?RCPG?J�GQ�BCRCPKGLCB�@W�RFC�?KMSLR�MD�P?BGM?ARGTC

BCA?W�RF?R�MAASPQ��4FC�P?RC�MD�BCA?W�GQ�A?JJCB�RFC�?ARGTGRW �

z 4FC�3)�SLGR�DMP GQ�RFC�@CAOSCPCJ��"O��BCDGLCB�@W

z GQ�?JQM�CVNPCQQCB�GL�RCPKQ�MD�ASPGCQ��#G��UFCPC

z 4FC�?ARGTGRW MD�?�QMSPAC�GQ�PCJ?RCB�RM ?LB @W

z 3GLAC F?Q�?L�CVNMLCLRG?J�@CF?TGMP�?Q�GL�RFC�COS?RGML ��RFC�?ARGTGRW�?JQM�F?Q�?L�CVNMLCLRG?J�@CF?TGMP��EGTCL�@W

���� #(!04%2����Y�2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3

4FGQ�AMLRCLR�GQ�?T?GJ?@JC�DMP�DPCC�?R�FRRN���ALV�MPE�AMLRCLR�AMJ���������

Page 31: 2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · PDF filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝ cbg9fj5h=cb% 5kg z $cdglc? lbb gqasqqlsajc?pbca?w z 3r?rcr fcam lqcpt?rgmlj?uq z %vnj?gln ?pclr?

UFCPC GQ�RFC�?ARGTGRW�?R �

���� �=B8=B;��B9F;Mz 4FC�@GLBGLE�CLCPEW��"%�MD�?�LSAJCSQ�GQ�RFC�CLCPEW�LCCBCB�RM�QCN?P?RC�GR�GLRM�GLBGTGBS?J�NPMRMLQ�?LB�LCSRPMLQ��)L�RCPKQ�MD�?RMKGA�K?QQCQ�

UFCPC GQ�RFC�K?QQ�MD�?�FWBPMECL�?RMK� GQ�RFC�?RMKGA�K?QQ�MD�RFC�LSAJGBC��?LB GQ�RFC�K?QQ�MD�?�LCSRPML��0?RRCPLQ�GL�RFC

@GLBGLE�CLCPEW�NCP�LSAJCML� ��PCTC?J�BCR?GJQ�MD�RFC�LSAJC?P�DMPAC��4FC�J?PECP�RFC ��RFC�KMPC�QR?@JC�RFC�LSAJCSQ�

���� -IBB9@=B;z 4SLLCJGLE�GQ�?�OS?LRSK�KCAF?LGA?J�NPMACQQ�MD�NMRCLRG?J�CLCPEW�@?PPGCP�NCLCRP?RGML��4FC�AMLACNR�U?Q�DGPQR�?NNJGCB�RM�CVNJ?GL BCA?W��@SR

RSLLCJGLE�GQ�DMSLB�RM�MAASP�GL�MRFCP�OS?LRSK�KCAF?LGA?J�QWQRCKQ�

�CB79DHI5@�*I9GH=CBG

���� 'I7@95F�+58=C57H=J=HM

�� 3SNNMQC�RFC�P?LEC�DMP P?W�GQ�ILMUL�RM�@C�����KK�GL�?�ACPR?GL�K?RCPG?J��$MCQ�RFGQ�KC?L�RF?R�CTCPW ?�P?W�RF?R�QRPGICQ�RFGQ

K?RCPG?J�RP?TCJQ�����KK��MP�BMCQ�RFC�P?LEC�F?TC�?L�?TCP?EC�T?JSC�UGRF�QMKC�QR?RGQRGA?J�DJSARS?RGMLQ�GL�RFC�BGQR?LACQ�RP?TCJCB��%VNJ?GL�

��7F?R�GQ�RFC�BGDDCPCLAC�@CRUCCL P?WQ�?LB�AF?P?ARCPGQRGA�V�P?WQ��)Q�CGRFCP�LCACQQ?PGJW�KMPC�CLCPECRGA�RF?L�RFC�MRFCP��7FGAF�A?L�@C�RFC�KMQR

CLCPECRGA�

�� )MLGXGLE�P?BG?RGML�GLRCP?ARQ�UGRF�K?RRCP�@W�QA?RRCPGLE�DPMK�CJCARPMLQ�?LB�LSAJCG�GL�RFC�QS@QR?LAC��"?QCB�ML�RFC�J?U�MD�AMLQCPT?RGML�MD�KMKCLRSK

?LB�CLCPEW��CVNJ?GL�UFW�CJCARPMLQ�RCLB�RM�?@QMP@�KMPC�CLCPEW�RF?L�LSAJCG�GL�RFCQC�GLRCP?ARGMLQ�

��7F?R�AF?P?ARCPGQRGAQ�MD�P?BGM?ARGTGRW�QFMU�GR�RM�@C�LSAJC?P�GL�MPGEGL�?LB�LMR�?RMKGA�

��7F?R�GQ�RFC�QMSPAC�MD�RFC�CLCPEW�CKGRRCB�GL�P?BGM?ARGTC�BCA?W��)BCLRGDW�?L�C?PJGCP�AMLQCPT?RGML�J?U��?LB�BCQAPG@C�FMU�GR�U?Q�KMBGDGCB�RM�R?IC�QSAF

NPMACQQCQ�GLRM�?AAMSLR�

�� #MLQGBCP �=;IF9�������)D�?L�CJCARPGA�DGCJB�GQ�QS@QRGRSRCB�DMP�RFC�K?ELCRGA�DGCJB�UGRF�NMQGRGTC�AF?PEC�GLQRC?B�MD�RFC�LMPRF�NMJC�?LB�LCE?RGTC�AF?PEC

GLQRC?B�MD�RFC�QMSRF�NMJC��GL�UFGAF�BGPCARGMLQ�UGJJ�RFC � ��?LB P?WQ�@CLB�

�� %VNJ?GL�FMU�?L N?PRGAJC�A?L�F?TC�?�J?PECP�P?LEC�GL�?GP�RF?L�? N?PRGAJC�UGRF�RFC�Q?KC�CLCPEW�GL�JC?B�

�� !PP?LEC�RFC�DMJJMUGLE�?AAMPBGLE�RM�RFCGP�?@GJGRW�RM�?AR�?Q�P?BG?RGML�QFGCJBQ��UGRF�RFC�@CQR�DGPQR�?LB�UMPQR�J?QR��%VNJ?GL�WMSP�MPBCPGLE�GL�RCPKQ�MD�FMU

P?BG?RGML�JMQCQ�GRQ�CLCPEW�GL�K?RRCP�

�?�!�QMJGB�K?RCPG?J�UGRF�JMU�BCLQGRW�AMKNMQCB�MD�JMU K?QQ�?RMKQ�

�@�!�E?Q�AMKNMQCB�MD�FGEF K?QQ�?RMKQ�

�A�!�E?Q�AMKNMQCB�MD�JMU K?QQ�?RMKQ�

�B�!�QMJGB�UGRF�FGEF�BCLQGRW�AMKNMQCB�MD�FGEF K?QQ�?RMKQ�

�� /DRCL��UFCL�NCMNJC�F?TC�RM�UMPI�?PMSLB�P?BGM?ARGTC�K?RCPG?JQ�QNGJJQ��UC�QCC�RFCK�UC?PGLE�UFGRC�AMTCP?JJQ��SQS?JJW�?�NJ?QRGA�K?RCPG?J��7F?R�RWNCQ

MD�P?BG?RGML��GD�?LW�BM�WMS�RFGLI�RFCQC�QSGRQ�NPMRCAR�RFC�UMPICP�DPMK��?LB�FMU�

���� +58=5H=CB��9H97H=CB�5B8��9H97HCFG

� � )Q�GR�NMQQG@JC�DMP�JGEFR�CKGRRCB�@W�?�QAGLRGJJ?RMP�RM�@C�RMM�JMU�GL�DPCOSCLAW�RM�@C�SQCB�GL�?�NFMRMKSJRGNJGCP�RS@C��%VNJ?GL�

���� ,I6GHFI7HIF9�C:�H<9�'I7@9IG

��� 4FC�UC?I�?LB�QRPMLE�LSAJC?P�DMPACQ�?PC�@?QGA�RM�RFC�QRPSARSPC�MD�K?RRCP��7FW�UC�BM�LMR�CVNCPGCLAC�RFCK�BGPCARJW�

��� $CDGLC�?LB�K?IC�AJC?P�BGQRGLARGMLQ�@CRUCCL�RFC�RCPKQ�LCSRPML��LSAJCML��LSAJCSQ��LSAJGBC��?LB�LCSRPGLM�

���7F?R�?PC�GQMRMNCQ��7FW�BM�BGDDCPCLR�GQMRMNCQ�MD�RFC�Q?KC�CJCKCLR�F?TC�QGKGJ?P�AFCKGQRPGCQ�

���� 'I7@95F��975M�5B8��CBG9FJ5H=CB�%5KG

��� 3R?P�4PCI�D?LQ�F?TC�MDRCL�FC?PB�RFC�RCPK�x?LRGK?RRCP�BPGTC�y�$CQAPG@C�FMU�WMS�AMSJB�SQC�?�K?ELCRGA�DGCJB�RM�RP?N�?LRGK?RRCP��QSAF�?Q�NPMBSACB�@W

LSAJC?P�BCA?W��?LB�J?RCP�AMK@GLC�GR�UGRF�K?RRCP�RM�NPMBSAC�CLCPEW��"C�QNCAGDGA�?@MSR�RFC�RWNC�MD�?LRGK?RRCP��RFC�LCCB�DMP�T?ASSK�QRMP?EC��?LB�RFC

DP?ARGML�MD�K?RRCP�AMLTCPRCB�GLRM�CLCPEW�

���7F?R�AMLQCPT?RGML�J?U�PCOSGPCQ�?L�CJCARPMLwQ�LCSRPGLM�RM�@C�NPMBSACB�GL�CJCARPML�A?NRSPC��.MRC�RF?R�RFC�CJCARPML�LM�JMLECP�CVGQRQ�?DRCP�GR�GQ

A?NRSPCB�@W�RFC�LSAJCSQ�

��� .CSRPGLMQ�?PC�CVNCPGKCLR?JJW�BCRCPKGLCB�RM�F?TC�?L�CVRPCKCJW�QK?JJ�K?QQ��(SEC�LSK@CPQ�MD�LCSRPGLMQ�?PC�APC?RCB�GL�?�QSNCPLMT?�?R�RFC�Q?KC

RGKC�?Q�K?QQGTC�?KMSLRQ�MD�JGEFR�?PC�DGPQR�NPMBSACB��7FCL�RFC�����!�QSNCPLMT?�MAASPPCB�GL�RFC�,?PEC�-?ECJJ?LGA�#JMSB��TGQG@JC�NPGK?PGJW�GL�RFC

3MSRFCPL�(CKGQNFCPC�?LB�QMKC���������JGEFR WC?PQ�?U?W�DPMK�%?PRF��LCSRPGLMQ�DPMK�RFC�CVNJMQGML�UCPC�M@QCPTCB�?R�?@MSR�RFC�Q?KC�RGKC�?Q�RFC

JGEFR�DPMK�RFC�@J?QR��(MU�AMSJB�RFC�PCJ?RGTC�?PPGT?J�RGKCQ�MD�LCSRPGLMQ�?LB�JGEFR�@C�SQCB�RM�NJ?AC�JGKGRQ�ML�RFC�K?QQ�MD�LCSRPGLMQ�

���7F?R�BM�RFC�RFPCC�RWNCQ�MD�@CR?�BCA?W�F?TC�GL�AMKKML�RF?R�GQ�BGQRGLARJW�BGDDCPCLR�DPMK�?JNF?�BCA?W�

#(!04%2����Y�2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3 ����

Page 32: 2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · PDF filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝ cbg9fj5h=cb% 5kg z $cdglc? lbb gqasqqlsajc?pbca?w z 3r?rcr fcam lqcpt?rgmlj?uq z %vnj?gln ?pclr?

���� !5@:%=:9�5B8��7H=J=HM

��� )L�? WC?P MJB�PMAI�RF?R�MPGEGL?JJW�AMLR?GLCB�QMKC ��UFGAF�F?Q�?�F?JD JGDC�MD WC?PQ��UC�CVNCAR�RM�DGLB�QMKC

PCK?GLGLE�GL�GR��7FW�?PC � ��?LB ?JQM�DMSLB�GL�QSAF�?�PMAI��CTCL�RFMSEF�RFCW�F?TC�KSAF�QFMPRCP�F?JD JGTCQ�������WC?PQ�����

B?WQ��?LB�����B?WQ��PCQNCARGTCJW�

��� $MCQ�RFC�LSK@CP�MD�P?BGM?ARGTC�LSAJCG�GL�?�Q?KNJC�BCAPC?QC�RM 8K46G?L F?JD�GRQ�MPGEGL?J�T?JSC�GL�MLC�F?JD JGDC��%VNJ?GL�GL�RCPKQ�MD�RFC�QR?RGQRGA?J

L?RSPC�MD�P?BGM?ARGTC�BCA?W�

� � 2?BGM?ARGTGRW�BCNCLBQ�ML�RFC�LSAJCSQ�?LB�LMR�RFC�?RMK�MP�GRQ�AFCKGA?J�QR?RC��7FW��RFCL��GQ�MLC�IGJMEP?K�MD�SP?LGSK�KMPC�P?BGM?ARGTC�RF?L�MLC

IGJMEP?K�MD�SP?LGSK�FCV?DJSMPGBC�

��� %VNJ?GL�FMU�?�@MSLB�QWQRCK�A?L�F?TC�JCQQ�K?QQ�RF?L�GRQ�AMKNMLCLRQ��7FW�GQ�RFGQ�LMR�M@QCPTCB�AJ?QQGA?JJW��Q?W�DMP�?�@SGJBGLE�K?BC�MD�@PGAIQ�

��� 3NMLR?LCMSQ�P?BGM?ARGTC�BCA?W�MAASPQ�MLJW�UFCL�RFC�BCA?W�NPMBSARQ�F?TC�JCQQ�K?QQ�RF?L�RFC�N?PCLR��?LB�GR�RCLBQ�RM�NPMBSAC�?�B?SEFRCP�RF?R�GQ

KMPC�QR?@JC�RF?L�RFC�N?PCLR��%VNJ?GL�FMU�RFGQ�GQ�PCJ?RCB�RM�RFC�D?AR�RF?R�KMPC�RGEFRJW�@MSLB�LSAJCG�?PC�KMPC�QR?@JC���#MLQGBCP�RFC�@GLBGLE�CLCPEW�NCP

LSAJCML�

��� 4M�M@R?GL�RFC�KMQR�NPCAGQC�T?JSC�MD�"%�DPMK�RFC�COS?RGML ��UC�QFMSJB�R?IC�GLRM�?AAMSLR�RFC�@GLBGLE

CLCPEW�MD�RFC�CJCARPMLQ�GL�RFC�LCSRP?J�?RMKQ��7GJJ�BMGLE�RFGQ�NPMBSAC�?�J?PECP�MP�QK?JJCP�T?JSC�DMP�"%��7FW�GQ�RFGQ�CDDCAR�SQS?JJW�LCEJGEG@JC�

��� (MU�BMCQ�RFC�DGLGRC�P?LEC�MD�RFC�LSAJC?P�DMPAC�PCJ?RC�RM�RFC�D?AR�RF?R GQ�EPC?RCQR�DMP LC?P����

���� �=B8=B;��B9F;M

���7FW�GQ�RFC�LSK@CP�MD�LCSRPMLQ�EPC?RCP�RF?L�RFC�LSK@CP�MD�NPMRMLQ�GL�QR?@JC�LSAJCG�F?TGLE EPC?RCP�RF?L�?@MSR�����?LB�UFW�GQ�RFGQ�CDDCAR�KMPC

NPMLMSLACB�DMP�RFC�FC?TGCQR�LSAJCG�

���� -IBB9@=B;

��� !�NFWQGAQ�QRSBCLR�A?SEFR�@PC?IGLE�AMLQCPT?RGML�J?UQ�GQ�GKNPGQMLCB��3FC�JC?LQ�?E?GLQR�RFC�ACJJ�U?JJ�FMNGLE�RM�RSLLCJ�MSR�OS?LRSK�KCAF?LGA?JJW�

%VNJ?GL�UFW�FCP�AF?LACQ�?PC�LCEJGEG@JC���4FGQ�GQ�QM�GL�?LW�AJ?QQGA?J�QGRS?RGML�

���7FCL�?�LSAJCSQ BCA?WQ��BMCQ�RFC N?PRGAJC�KMTC�AMLRGLSMSQJW�DPMK�GLQGBC�RFC�LSAJCSQ�RM�MSRQGBC��4F?R�GQ��BMCQ�GR�RP?TCJ�C?AF�NMGLR�?JMLE�?L

GK?EGL?PW�JGLC�DPMK�GLQGBC�RM�MSR��%VNJ?GL�

���� #(!04%2����Y�2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3

4FGQ�AMLRCLR�GQ�?T?GJ?@JC�DMP�DPCC�?R�FRRN���ALV�MPE�AMLRCLR�AMJ���������

Page 33: 2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · PDF filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝ cbg9fj5h=cb% 5kg z $cdglc? lbb gqasqqlsajc?pbca?w z 3r?rcr fcam lqcpt?rgmlj?uq z %vnj?gln ?pclr?

)FC6@9AG����L9F7=G9G

���� +58=5H=CB��9H97H=CB�5B8��9H97HCFG

�� 4FC�CLCPEW�MD����� GQ�PCOSGPCB�RM�GMLGXC�?�KMJCASJC�MD�RFC�E?Q

GLQGBC�?�'CGECP�RS@C��RFCPC@W�NPMBSAGLE�?L�GML�N?GP��3SNNMQC�?�N?PRGAJC�MD

GMLGXGLE�P?BG?RGML�BCNMQGRQ�������-C6�MD�CLCPEW�GL�RFGQ�'CGECP�RS@C��7F?R

K?VGKSK�LSK@CP�MD�GML�N?GPQ�A?L�GR�APC?RC�

�� !�N?PRGAJC�MD�GMLGXGLE�P?BG?RGML�APC?RCQ������GML�N?GPQ�GL�RFC�E?Q�GLQGBC

?�'CGECP�RS@C�?Q�GR�N?QQCQ�RFPMSEF��7F?R�KGLGKSK�CLCPEW�U?Q

BCNMQGRCB��GD����� GQ�PCOSGPCB�RM�APC?RC�C?AF�GML�N?GP�

�� �?�2CNC?R �L9F7=G9�������?LB�AMLTCPR�RFC�CLCPEW�RM�HMSJCQ�MP�A?JMPGCQ�

�@�)D�?JJ�MD�RFGQ�CLCPEW�GQ�AMLTCPRCB�RM�RFCPK?J�CLCPEW�GL�RFC�E?Q��UF?R�GQ

GRQ�RCKNCP?RSPC�GLAPC?QC��?QQSKGLE MD�GBC?J�E?Q�?R������ ?RK

NPCQQSPC���4FC�QK?JJ�?LQUCP�GQ�AMLQGQRCLR�UGRF�RFC�D?AR�RF?R�RFC�CLCPEW�GQ

J?PEC�ML�?�OS?LRSK�KCAF?LGA?J�QA?JC�@SR�QK?JJ�ML�?�K?APMQAMNGA�QA?JC�

�� 3SNNMQC�?�N?PRGAJC�MD�GMLGXGLE�P?BG?RGML�BCNMQGRQ�����-C6�GL�RFC�E?Q�MD

?�'CGECP�RS@C��?JJ�MD�UFGAF�EMCQ�RM�APC?RGLE�GML�N?GPQ��%?AF�GML�N?GP

PCOSGPCQ������C6�MD�CLCPEW���?�4FC�?NNJGCB�TMJR?EC�QUCCNQ�RFC�GMLQ�MSR

MD�RFC�E?Q�GL ��7F?R�GQ�RFC�ASPPCLR���@�4FGQ�ASPPCLR�GQ�QK?JJCP

RF?L�RFC�?ARS?J�ASPPCLR�QGLAC�RFC�?NNJGCB�TMJR?EC�GL�RFC�'CGECP�RS@C

?AACJCP?RCQ�RFC�QCN?P?RCB�GMLQ��UFGAF�RFCL�APC?RC�MRFCP�GML�N?GPQ�GL

QS@QCOSCLR�AMJJGQGMLQ��7F?R�GQ�RFC�ASPPCLR�GD�RFGQ�J?QR�CDDCAR�KSJRGNJGCQ�RFC

LSK@CP�MD�GML�N?GPQ�@W�����

���� ,I6GHFI7HIF9�C:�H<9�'I7@9IG

�� 6CPGDW�RF?R�? K?QQ�MD�U?RCP�?R�LMPK?J�BCLQGRW�UMSJB

K?IC�?�AS@C����IK�ML�?�QGBC��?Q�AJ?GKCB�GL �L5AD@9��������4FGQ�K?QQ

?R�LSAJC?P�BCLQGRW�UMSJB�K?IC�?�AS@C�����K�ML�?�QGBC�

�� &GLB�RFC�JCLERF�MD�?�QGBC�MD�?�AS@C�F?TGLE�?�K?QQ�MD�����IE�?LB�RFC

BCLQGRW�MD�LSAJC?P�K?RRCP��R?IGLE�RFGQ�RM�@C �

��7F?R�GQ�RFC�P?BGSQ�MD�?L N?PRGAJC�

�� &GLB�RFC�P?BGSQ�MD�? LSAJCSQ� GQ�?�K?LSD?ARSPCB

LSAJGBC�RF?R�GQ�SQCB�?Q�?�NMUCP�QMSPAC�ML�QMKC�QN?AC�NPM@CQ�

�� �?�#?JASJ?RC�RFC�P?BGSQ�MD ��MLC�MD�RFC�KMQR�RGEFRJW�@MSLB�QR?@JC

LSAJCG�

�@�7F?R�GQ�RFC�P?RGM�MD�RFC�P?BGSQ�MD RM�RF?R�MD ��MLC�MD�RFC

J?PECQR�LSAJCG�CTCP�K?BC��.MRC�RF?R�RFC�P?BGSQ�MD�RFC�J?PECQR�LSAJCSQ�GQ

QRGJJ�KSAF�QK?JJCP�RF?L�RFC�QGXC�MD�?L�?RMK�

� � 4FC�SLGDGCB�?RMKGA�K?QQ�SLGR�GQ�BCDGLCB�RM�@C

��6CPGDW�RF?R�RFGQ�?KMSLR�MD�K?QQ�AMLTCPRCB�RM

CLCPEW�WGCJBQ�������-C6��.MRC�RF?R�WMS�KSQR�SQC�DMSP BGEGR�MP�@CRRCP

T?JSCQ�DMP ?LB �

���7F?R�GQ�RFC�P?RGM�MD�RFC�TCJMAGRW�MD�? N?PRGAJC�RM�RF?R�MD�?L

N?PRGAJC��GD�RFCW�F?TC�RFC�Q?KC�LMLPCJ?RGTGQRGA�IGLCRGA�CLCPEW�

��� )D�?����� AK RFGAI�NGCAC�MD�JC?B�A?L�?@QMP@�������MD�RFC P?WQ�DPMK

?�P?BGM?ARGTC�QMSPAC��FMU�K?LW�ACLRGKCRCPQ�MD�JC?B�?PC�LCCBCB�RM

?@QMP@�?JJ�@SR��������MD�RFC P?WQ�

��� 4FC�BCR?GJ�M@QCPT?@JC�SQGLE�?�NPM@C�GQ�JGKGRCB�@W�GRQ�U?TCJCLERF�

#?JASJ?RC�RFC�CLCPEW�MD�? P?W�NFMRML�RF?R�F?Q�?�U?TCJCLERF�MD

��QK?JJ�CLMSEF�RM�BCRCAR�BCR?GJQ�?@MSR�MLC RCLRF�RFC�QGXC�MD

?�LSAJCML��.MRC�RF?R�?�NFMRML�F?TGLE�RFGQ�CLCPEW�GQ�BGDDGASJR�RM�NPMBSAC

?LB�GLRCP?ARQ�NMMPJW�UGRF�RFC�LSAJCSQ��JGKGRGLE�RFC�NP?ARGA?@GJGRW�MD�RFGQ

NPM@C�

��� �?�3FMU�RF?R�GD�WMS�?QQSKC�RFC�?TCP?EC�LSAJCSQ�GQ�QNFCPGA?J�UGRF�?

P?BGSQ ��?LB�UGRF�?�K?QQ�MD S��RFCL�GRQ�BCLQGRW�GQ

GLBCNCLBCLR�MD �

�@�#?JASJ?RC�RF?R�BCLQGRW�GL ?LB ��?LB�AMKN?PC�WMSP

PCQSJRQ�UGRF�RFMQC�DMSLB�GL �L5AD@9����� DMP �

���7F?R�GQ�RFC�P?RGM�MD�RFC�TCJMAGRW�MD�?����� -C6 P?W�RM�RF?R�MD�?L

N?PRGAJC�UGRF�RFC�Q?KC�IGLCRGA�CLCPEW��4FGQ�QFMSJB�AMLDGPK�RF?R Q�RP?TCJ

KSAF�D?QRCP�RF?L Q�CTCL�UFCL�PCJ?RGTGRW�GQ�R?ICL�GLRM�AMLQGBCP?RGML�

�3CC�?JQM �L9F7=G9�������

��� �?�7F?R�GQ�RFC�IGLCRGA�CLCPEW�GL�-C6�MD�? P?W�RF?R�GQ�RP?TCJGLE�?R

��4FGQ�EGTCQ�QMKC�GBC?�MD�FMU�CLCPECRGA�? P?W�KSQR�@C�RM

RP?TCJ�?R�LC?PJW�RFC�Q?KC�QNCCB�?Q�? P?W���@�7F?R�GQ�RFC�TCJMAGRW�MD�RFC

P?W�PCJ?RGTC�RM�RFC P?W�

���� 'I7@95F��975M�5B8��CBG9FJ5H=CB�%5KG

)L�RFC�DMJJMUGLE�CGEFR�NPM@JCKQ��UPGRC�RFC�AMKNJCRC�BCA?W�COS?RGML�DMP�RFC

EGTCL�LSAJGBC�GL�RFC�AMKNJCRC LMR?RGML��2CDCP�RM�RFC�NCPGMBGA�R?@JC

DMP�T?JSCQ�MD �

��� BCA?W�MD �RPGRGSK��?�K?LSD?ARSPCB�GQMRMNC�MD�FWBPMECL

SQCB�GL�QMKC�BGEGR?J�U?RAF�BGQNJ?WQ��?LB�K?LSD?ARSPCB�NPGK?PGJW�DMP�SQC

GL�FWBPMECL�@MK@Q�

��� BCA?W�MD ��?�L?RSP?JJW�MAASPPGLE�P?PC�GQMRMNC�MD�NMR?QQGSK

PCQNMLQG@JC�DMP�QMKC�MD�MSP�CVNMQSPC�RM�@?AIEPMSLB�P?BG?RGML�

��� BCA?W�MD �

� � BCA?W�MD �

��� %JCARPML�A?NRSPC�@W �

��� %JCARPML�A?NRSPC�@W �

��� BCA?W�MD ��RFC�GQMRMNC�MD�NMJMLGSK�GL�RFC�BCA?W�QCPGCQ�MD

RF?R�U?Q�BGQAMTCPCB�@W�RFC�#SPGCQ��!�D?TMPGRC�GQMRMNC�GL�NFWQGAQ

J?@Q��QGLAC�GR�F?Q�?�QFMPR�F?JD JGDC�?LB�BCA?WQ�RM�?�QR?@JC�LSAJGBC�

��� BCA?W�MD ��?LMRFCP�GQMRMNC�GL�RFC�BCA?W�QCPGCQ�MD �

DGPQR�PCAMELGXCB�?Q�?�LCU�CJCKCLR�@W�RFC�#SPGCQ��0MQCQ�QNCAG?J�NPM@JCKQ

@CA?SQC�GRQ�B?SEFRCP�GQ�?�P?BGM?ARGTC�LM@JC�E?Q�

)L�RFC�DMJJMUGLE�DMSP�NPM@JCKQ��GBCLRGDW�RFC�N?PCLR�LSAJGBC�?LB�UPGRC�RFC

AMKNJCRC�BCA?W�COS?RGML�GL�RFC LMR?RGML��2CDCP�RM�RFC�NCPGMBGA

R?@JC�DMP�T?JSCQ�MD �

��� BCA?W�NPMBSAGLE ��4FC�N?PCLR�LSAJGBC�GQ�?�K?HMP�U?QRC

NPMBSAR�MD�PC?ARMPQ�?LB�F?Q�AFCKGQRPW�QGKGJ?P�RM�NMR?QQGSK�?LB�QMBGSK�

PCQSJRGLE�GL�GRQ�AMLACLRP?RGML�GL�WMSP�ACJJQ�GD�GLECQRCB�

��� BCA?W�NPMBSAGLE ��4FC�N?PCLR�LSAJGBC�GQ�?�K?HMP�U?QRC

NPMBSAR�MD�PC?ARMPQ�?LB�F?Q�AFCKGQRPW�QGKGJ?P�RM�A?JAGSK��QM�RF?R�GR�GQ

AMLACLRP?RCB�GL�@MLCQ�GD�GLECQRCB�� GQ�?JQM�P?BGM?ARGTC�

��� BCA?W�NPMBSAGLE ��4FC�N?PCLR�LSAJGBC�GQ�LC?PJW������MD

RFC�L?RSP?J�CJCKCLR�?LB�GQ�DMSLB�GL�E?Q�J?LRCPL�K?LRJCQ�?LB�GL�KCR?J

?JJMWQ�SQCB�GL�HCRQ�� GQ�?JQM�P?BGM?ARGTC�

#(!04%2����Y�2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3 ����

Page 34: 2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · PDF filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝ cbg9fj5h=cb% 5kg z $cdglc? lbb gqasqqlsajc?pbca?w z 3r?rcr fcam lqcpt?rgmlj?uq z %vnj?gln ?pclr?

��� BCA?W�NPMBSAGLE ��4FC�N?PCLR�LSAJGBC�GQ�GL�RFC�BCA?W

QCPGCQ�NPMBSACB�@W ��RFC�MLJW�L?RSP?JJW�MAASPPGLE�GQMRMNC�MD

RFMPGSK�

���7FCL�?L�CJCARPML�?LB�NMQGRPML�?LLGFGJ?RC��@MRF�RFCGP�K?QQCQ�?PC

BCQRPMWCB��APC?RGLE�RUM�COS?J�CLCPEW�NFMRMLQ�RM�NPCQCPTC�KMKCLRSK�

�?�#MLDGPK�RF?R�RFC�?LLGFGJ?RGML�COS?RGML AMLQCPTCQ

AF?PEC��CJCARPML�D?KGJW�LSK@CP��?LB�RMR?J�LSK@CP�MD�LSAJCMLQ��4M�BM�RFGQ�

GBCLRGDW�RFC�T?JSCQ�MD�C?AF�@CDMPC�?LB�?DRCP�RFC�?LLGFGJ?RGML���@�&GLB�RFC

CLCPEW�MD�C?AF P?W��?QQSKGLE�RFC�CJCARPML�?LB�NMQGRPML�?PC�GLGRG?JJW

LC?PJW�?R�PCQR���A�%VNJ?GL�UFW�RFC�RUM P?WQ�RP?TCJ�GL�CV?ARJW�MNNMQGRC

BGPCARGMLQ�GD�RFC�ACLRCP�MD�K?QQ�MD�RFC�CJCARPML NMQGRPML�QWQRCK�GQ�GLGRG?JJW

?R�PCQR�

� � #MLDGPK�RF?R�AF?PEC��CJCARPML�D?KGJW�LSK@CP��?LB�RFC�RMR?J�LSK@CP�MD

LSAJCMLQ�?PC�?JJ�AMLQCPTCB�@W�RFC�PSJC�DMP BCA?W�EGTCL�GL�RFC�COS?RGML

��4M�BM�RFGQ��GBCLRGDW�RFC�T?JSCQ�MD�C?AF

@CDMPC�?LB�?DRCP�RFC�BCA?W�

��� #MLDGPK�RF?R�AF?PEC��CJCARPML�D?KGJW�LSK@CP��?LB�RFC�RMR?J�LSK@CP�MD

LSAJCMLQ�?PC�?JJ�AMLQCPTCB�@W�RFC�PSJC�DMP BCA?W�EGTCL�GL�RFC

COS?RGML ��4M�BM�RFGQ��GBCLRGDW�RFC

T?JSCQ�MD�C?AF�@CDMPC�?LB�?DRCP�RFC�BCA?W�

��� #MLDGPK�RF?R�AF?PEC��CJCARPML�D?KGJW�LSK@CP��?LB�RFC�RMR?J�LSK@CP�MD

LSAJCMLQ�?PC�?JJ�AMLQCPTCB�@W�RFC�PSJC�DMP BCA?W�EGTCL�GL�RFC

COS?RGML ��4M�BM�RFGQ��GBCLRGDW�RFC

T?JSCQ�MD�C?AF�@CDMPC�?LB�?DRCP�RFC�BCA?W�

��� #MLDGPK�RF?R�AF?PEC��CJCARPML�D?KGJW�LSK@CP��?LB�RFC�RMR?J�LSK@CP�MD

LSAJCMLQ�?PC�?JJ�AMLQCPTCB�@W�RFC�PSJC�DMP�CJCARPML�A?NRSPC�EGTCL�GL�RFC

COS?RGML ��4M�BM�RFGQ��GBCLRGDW�RFC

T?JSCQ�MD�C?AF�@CDMPC�?LB�?DRCP�RFC�A?NRSPC�

��� !�P?PC�BCA?W�KMBC�F?Q�@CCL�M@QCPTCB�GL�UFGAF CKGRQ�?

LSAJCSQ���?�4FC�BCA?W�COS?RGML�GQ ��)BCLRGDW

RFC�LSAJGBC ���@�&GLB�RFC�CLCPEW�CKGRRCB�GL�RFC�BCA?W��4FC�K?QQ�MD

GQ������������S�

��� �?�7PGRC�RFC�AMKNJCRC BCA?W�COS?RGML�DMP �

�@�&GLB�RFC�CLCPEW�PCJC?QCB�GL�RFC�BCA?W�

��� �?�7PGRC�RFC�AMKNJCRC BCA?W�COS?RGML�DMP �

�@�&GLB�RFC�CLCPEW�PCJC?QCB�GL�RFC�BCA?W�

��� �?�7PGRC�RFC�AMKNJCRC BCA?W�COS?RGML�DMP�RFC�LCSRPML���@�&GLB

RFC�CLCPEW�PCJC?QCB�GL�RFC�BCA?W�

��� �?�7PGRC�RFC�AMKNJCRC BCA?W�COS?RGML�DMP ��?�K?HMP�U?QRC

NPMBSAR�MD�LSAJC?P�PC?ARMPQ���@�&GLB�RFC�CLCPEW�PCJC?QCB�GL�RFC�BCA?W�

��� #?JASJ?RC�RFC�CLCPEW�PCJC?QCB�GL�RFC BCA?W�MD ��RFC

COS?RGML�DMP�UFGAF�GQ�EGTCL�GL�RFC�RCVR��4FC�K?QQCQ�MD ?LB

?PC�����������?LB�����������S��PCQNCARGTCJW�

� � �?�7PGRC�RFC�AMKNJCRC BCA?W�COS?RGML�DMP �

�@�#?JASJ?RC�RFC�CLCPEW�PCJC?QCB�GL�RFC�BCA?W��4FC�K?QQCQ�MD ?LB

?PC�����������?LB�����������S��PCQNCARGTCJW�

��� �?�#?JASJ?RC�RFC�CLCPEW�PCJC?QCB�GL�RFC BCA?W�MD �

�@�7F?R�DP?ARGML�MD�RFC�K?QQ�MD�?�QGLEJC GQ�BCQRPMWCB�GL�RFC

BCA?W��4FC�K?QQ�MD GQ������������S�

�A�!JRFMSEF�RFC�DP?ARGML?J�K?QQ�JMQQ�GQ�J?PEC�DMP�?�QGLEJC�LSAJCSQ��GR�GQ

BGDDGASJR�RM�M@QCPTC�DMP�?L�CLRGPC�K?APMQAMNGA�Q?KNJC�MD�SP?LGSK��7FW�GQ

RFGQ�

��� �?�7PGRC�RFC�AMKNJCRC�PC?ARGML�COS?RGML�DMP�CJCARPML�A?NRSPC�@W

�@�#?JASJ?RC�RFC�CLCPEW�PCJC?QCB�

��� �?�7PGRC�RFC�AMKNJCRC�PC?ARGML�COS?RGML�DMP�CJCARPML�A?NRSPC�@W

�@�#?JASJ?RC�RFC�CLCPEW�PCJC?QCB�

���� !5@:%=:9�5B8��7H=J=HM

$?R?�DPMK�RFC�?NNCLBGACQ�?LB�RFC�NCPGMBGA�R?@JC�K?W�@C�LCCBCB�DMP

RFCQC�NPM@JCKQ�

��� !L�MJB�A?KNDGPC�GQ�SLAMTCPCB�BSPGLE�?L�?PAF?CMJMEGA?J�BGE��)RQ

AF?PAM?J�GQ�DMSLB�RM�AMLR?GL�JCQQ�RF?L��������RFC�LMPK?J�?KMSLR�MD

��%QRGK?RC�RFC�KGLGKSK�?EC�MD�RFC�AF?PAM?J��LMRGLE�RF?R �

��� ! QMSPAC�GQ�J?@CJCB������K#G��@SR�GRQ�NPCQCLR�?ARGTGRW�GQ�DMSLB

RM�@C "O���?�7F?R�GQ�RFC�NPCQCLR�?ARGTGRW�GL�K#G���@�(MU

JMLE�?EM�BGB�GR�?ARS?JJW�F?TC�?����� K#G�?ARGTGRW�

��� �?�#?JASJ?RC�RFC�?ARGTGRW GL�ASPGCQ�MD������E�MD ���@

$GQASQQ�UFW�WMSP�?LQUCP�GQ�LMR�CV?ARJW������#G��EGTCL�RF?R�RFC�ASPGC�U?Q

MPGEGL?JJW�QSNNMQCB�RM�@C�CV?ARJW�RFC�?ARGTGRW�MD�?�EP?K�MD�P?BGSK�

��� 3FMU�RF?R�RFC�?ARGTGRW�MD�RFC GL������E�MD DMSLB�GL�JGTGLE

RGQQSC�GQ�������"O�

��� -?LRJCQ�DMP�E?Q�J?LRCPLQ�AMLR?GL�RFMPGSK��@CA?SQC�GR�DMPKQ�?L�MVGBC

RF?R�A?L�QSPTGTC�@CGLE�FC?RCB�RM�GLA?LBCQACLAC�DMP�JMLE�NCPGMBQ�MD�RGKC�

.?RSP?J�RFMPGSK�GQ�?JKMQR����� ��UGRF�?�F?JD JGDC�MD

��)D�?L�?TCP?EC�J?LRCPL�K?LRJC�AMLR?GLQ�����KE�MD

RFMPGSK��UF?R�GQ�GRQ�?ARGTGRW�

��� #MUwQ�KGJI�NPMBSACB�LC?P�LSAJC?P�PC?ARMPQ�A?L�@C�RCQRCB�DMP�?Q�JGRRJC

?Q������N#G�MD NCP�JGRCP��RM�AFCAI�DMP�NMQQG@JC�PC?ARMP�JC?I?EC��7F?R

K?QQ�MD F?Q�RFGQ�?ARGTGRW�

� � �?�.?RSP?J�NMR?QQGSK�AMLR?GLQ ��UFGAF�F?Q�?�F?JD JGDC�MD

W��7F?R�K?QQ�MD GL�?�NCPQML�UMSJB�F?TC�?�BCA?W�P?RC

MD������"O���@�7F?R�GQ�RFC�DP?ARGML�MD GL�L?RSP?J�NMR?QQGSK��EGTCL

RF?R�RFC�NCPQML�F?Q�����E�GL�FGQ�@MBW���4FCQC�LSK@CPQ�?PC�RWNGA?J�DMP�?

�� IE�?BSJR�

��� 4FCPC�GQ�KMPC�RF?L�MLC�GQMRMNC�MD�L?RSP?J�SP?LGSK��)D�?�PCQC?PAFCP

GQMJ?RCQ������KE�MD�RFC�PCJ?RGTCJW�QA?PAC ?LB�DGLBQ�RFGQ�K?QQ�RM

F?TC�?L�?ARGTGRW�MD������"O��UF?R�GQ�GRQ�F?JD JGDC�GL�WC?PQ�

��� F?Q�MLC�MD�RFC�JMLECQR�ILMUL�P?BGM?ARGTC�F?JD JGTCQ��)L�?�BGDDGASJR

CVNCPGKCLR��?�PCQC?PAFCP�DMSLB�RF?R�RFC�?ARGTGRW�MD������IE�MD GQ

�����"O��7F?R�GQ�RFC�F?JD JGDC�GL�WC?PQ�

��� 9MS�A?L�QMKCRGKCQ�DGLB�BCCN�PCB�APWQR?J�T?QCQ�GL�?LRGOSC�QRMPCQ�

A?JJCB�SP?LGSK�EJ?QQ�@CA?SQC�RFCGP�AMJMP�U?Q�NPMBSACB�@W�BMNGLE�RFC

EJ?QQ�UGRF�SP?LGSK��,MMI�SN�RFC�L?RSP?J�GQMRMNCQ�MD�SP?LGSK�?LB�RFCGP

���� #(!04%2����Y�2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3

4FGQ�AMLRCLR�GQ�?T?GJ?@JC�DMP�DPCC�?R�FRRN���ALV�MPE�AMLRCLR�AMJ���������

Page 35: 2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · PDF filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝ cbg9fj5h=cb% 5kg z $cdglc? lbb gqasqqlsajc?pbca?w z 3r?rcr fcam lqcpt?rgmlj?uq z %vnj?gln ?pclr?

F?JD JGTCQ��?LB�A?JASJ?RC�RFC�?ARGTGRW�MD�QSAF�?�T?QC�?QQSKGLE�GR�F?Q������E

MD�SP?LGSK�GL�GR��.CEJCAR�RFC�?ARGTGRW�MD�?LW�B?SEFRCP�LSAJGBCQ�

��� !�RPCC�D?JJQ�GL�?�DMPCQR��(MU�K?LW�WC?PQ�KSQR�N?QQ�@CDMPC�RFC

?ARGTGRW�GL������E�MD�RFC�RPCCwQ�A?P@ML�BPMNQ�RM������BCA?W�NCP�FMSP�

���7F?R�DP?ARGML�MD�RFC RF?R�U?Q�ML�%?PRF�UFCL�GR�DMPKCB

WC?PQ�?EM�GQ�JCDR�RMB?W�

��� !����� #G QMSPAC�SQCB�DMP�A?LACP�RFCP?NW�GQ�AMLQGBCPCB�RMM

UC?I�RM�@C�SQCDSJ�UFCL�GRQ�?ARGTGRW�D?JJQ�RM������#G��(MU�JMLE�?DRCP�GRQ

K?LSD?ARSPC�BMCQ�RFGQ�F?NNCL�

��� .?RSP?J�SP?LGSK�GQ�������� ?LB������� ��7F?R�UCPC

RFC�NCPACLR?ECQ�MD ?LB GL�L?RSP?J�SP?LGSK�UFCL�%?PRF

DMPKCB WC?PQ�?EM�

��� 4FC N?PRGAJCQ�CKGRRCB�GL�RFC�BCA?W�MD �RPGRGSK�GLRCP?AR�UGRF

K?RRCP�RM�APC?RC�JGEFR�GL�?�EJMU GL RFC B?PI�CVGR�QGEL��!R�RFC�RGKC�MD

K?LSD?ARSPC��QSAF�?�QGEL�AMLR?GLQ������#G�MD ���?�7F?R�GQ�RFC�K?QQ

MD�RFC�RPGRGSK���@�7F?R�GQ�GRQ�?ARGTGRW������W�?DRCP�K?LSD?ARSPC�

���7MPJB�7?P�))�?GPAP?DR�F?B�GLQRPSKCLRQ�UGRF�EJMUGLE�P?BGSK N?GLRCB

BG?JQ��QCC �=;IF9�������4FC�?ARGTGRW�MD�MLC�QSAF�GLQRPSKCLR�U?Q

"O�UFCL�LCU���?�7F?R�K?QQ�MD U?Q�NPCQCLR���@

!DRCP�QMKC�WC?PQ��RFC�NFMQNFMPQ�ML�RFC�BG?JQ�BCRCPGMP?RCB�AFCKGA?JJW��@SR

RFC�P?BGSK�BGB�LMR�CQA?NC��7F?R�GQ�RFC�?ARGTGRW�MD�RFGQ�GLQRPSKCLR�����

WC?PQ�?DRCP�GR�U?Q�K?BC�

� � �?�4FC QMSPAC�SQCB�GL�?�NFWQGAQ�J?@MP?RMPW�GQ�J?@CJCB�?Q

F?TGLE�?L�?ARGTGRW�MD ML�RFC�B?RC�GR�U?Q�NPCN?PCB��!�QRSBCLR

KC?QSPCQ�RFC�P?BGM?ARGTGRW�MD�RFGQ�QMSPAC�UGRF�?�'CGECP�AMSLRCP�?LB

M@QCPTCQ������AMSLRQ�NCP�KGLSRC��3FC�LMRGACQ�RF?R�RFC�QMSPAC�U?Q

NPCN?PCB�����B?WQ�@CDMPC�FCP�J?@��7F?R�DP?ARGML�MD�RFC�BCA?WQ�GQ�QFC

M@QCPTGLE�UGRF�FCP�?NN?P?RSQ���@�)BCLRGDW�QMKC�MD�RFC�PC?QMLQ�RF?R�MLJW

?�DP?ARGML�MD�RFC Q�CKGRRCB�?PC�M@QCPTCB�@W�RFC�BCRCARMP�

��� !PKMP NGCPAGLE�QFCJJQ�UGRF�BCNJCRCB�SP?LGSK�AMPCQ�?PC�DGPCB�@W�?GPAP?DR

?R�R?LIQ���4FC�FGEF�BCLQGRW�MD�RFC�SP?LGSK�K?ICQ�RFCK�CDDCARGTC��4FC

SP?LGSK�GQ�A?JJCB�BCNJCRCB�@CA?SQC�GR�F?Q�F?B�GRQ PCKMTCB�DMP

PC?ARMP�SQC�?LB�GQ�LC?PJW�NSPC ��$CNJCRCB�SP?LGSK�F?Q�@CCL

CPPMLCMSQJW�A?JJCB�LML P?BGM?ARGTC��4M�BCKMLQRP?RC�RF?R�RFGQ�GQ�UPMLE���?

#?JASJ?RC�RFC�?ARGTGRW�MD������E�MD�NSPC ���@�#?JASJ?RC�RFC�?ARGTGRW�MD

�����E�MD�L?RSP?J�SP?LGSK��LCEJCARGLE�RFC ?LB�?JJ�B?SEFRCP

LSAJGBCQ�

��� 4FC�ACP?KGA�EJ?XC�ML�?�PCB MP?LEC�&GCQR?U?PC�NJ?RC�GQ ?LB

AMLR?GLQ������EP?KQ�MD ��@SR�TCPW�JGRRJC ���?�7F?R�GQ�RFC

?ARGTGRW�MD�RFC�NJ?RC���@�#?JASJ?RC�RFC�RMR?J�CLCPEW�RF?R�UGJJ�@C�PCJC?QCB�@W

RFC BCA?W���A�)D�CLCPEW�GQ�UMPRF������ACLRQ�NCP ��UF?R�GQ

RFC�KMLCR?PW�T?JSC�MD�RFC�CLCPEW�CKGRRCB���4FCQC�NJ?RCQ�UCLR�MSR�MD

NPMBSARGML�QMKC����WC?PQ�?EM��@SR�?PC�QRGJJ�?T?GJ?@JC�?Q�AMJJCARG@JCQ�

��� ,?PEC�?KMSLRQ�MD�BCNJCRCB�SP?LGSK�� �?PC�?T?GJ?@JC�?Q�?�@W

NPMBSAR�MD�SP?LGSK�NPMACQQGLE�DMP�PC?ARMP�DSCJ�?LB�UC?NMLQ��5P?LGSK�GQ

TCPW�BCLQC�?LB�K?ICQ�EMMB�AMSLRCP�UCGEFRQ�DMP�?GPAP?DR��3SNNMQC�WMS

F?TC�?����� IE�@JMAI�MD ���?�&GLB�GRQ�?ARGTGRW���@�(MU�K?LW

A?JMPGCQ�NCP�B?W�?PC�ECLCP?RCB�@W�RFCPK?JGX?RGML�MD�RFC�BCA?W�CLCPEW���A

$M�WMS�RFGLI�WMS�AMSJB�BCRCAR�RFGQ�?Q�FC?R��%VNJ?GL�

��� 4FC �4?<?8B QN?AC�NPM@C�U?Q�J?SLAFCB�ML�GRQ�JMLE�HMSPLCW�N?QR

QCTCP?J�NJ?LCRQ�GL�������UGRF�?L�SJRGK?RC�EM?J�MD�*SNGRCP��)RQ�NMUCP�QMSPAC

GQ������IE�MD ��?�@W NPMBSAR�MD�LSAJC?P�UC?NMLQ�NJSRMLGSK

NPMBSARGML��%JCARPGA?J�CLCPEW�GQ�ECLCP?RCB�RFCPKMCJCARPGA?JJW�DPMK�RFC

FC?R�NPMBSACB�UFCL�RFC����� -C6 N?PRGAJCQ�CKGRRCB�GL�C?AF�BCA?W

AP?QF�RM�?�F?JR�GLQGBC�RFC�NJSRMLGSK�?LB�GRQ�QFGCJBGLE��4FC�F?JD JGDC�MD

GQ������WC?PQ���?�7F?R�U?Q�RFC�MPGEGL?J�?ARGTGRW�MD�RFC GL

@CAOSCPCJ���@�7F?R�NMUCP�U?Q�CKGRRCB�GL�IGJMU?RRQ���A�7F?R�NMUCP�U?Q

CKGRRCB������W�?DRCP�J?SLAF��9MS�K?W�LCEJCAR�?LW�CVRP?�CLCPEW�DPMK

B?SEFRCP�LSAJGBCQ�?LB�?LW�JMQQCQ�DPMK�CQA?NGLE P?WQ�

��� �CBGHFI7H�2CIF�(KB�)FC6@9A

#MLQGBCP�RFC�ECLCP?RGML�MD�CJCARPGAGRW�@W�?�P?BGM?ARGTC�GQMRMNC�GL�?�QN?AC

NPM@C��QSAF�?Q�BCQAPG@CB�GL �L9F7=G9��������#MLQRPSAR�?�NPM@JCK�GL

UFGAF�WMS�A?JASJ?RC�RFC�K?QQ�MD�?�P?BGM?ARGTC�GQMRMNC�WMS�LCCB�GL�MPBCP

RM�QSNNJW�NMUCP�DMP�?�JMLE�QN?AC�DJGEFR��!KMLE�RFC�RFGLEQ�RM�AMLQGBCP�?PC

RFC�GQMRMNC�AFMQCL��GRQ�F?JD JGDC�?LB�BCA?W�CLCPEW��RFC�NMUCP�LCCBQ�MD�RFC

NPM@C�?LB�RFC�JCLERF�MD�RFC�DJGEFR�

��� .BF95GCB56@9�+9GI@HG

!�LSAJC?P�NFWQGAGQR�DGLBQ MD GL�?�NGCAC�MD�SP?LGSK�MPC�?LB

?QQSKCQ�GR�GQ�NPGKMPBG?J�QGLAC�GRQ�F?JD JGDC�GQ ���?�#?JASJ?RC

RFC�?KMSLR�MD RF?R�UMSJB�F?B�RM�F?TC�@CCL�ML�%?PRF�UFCL�GR

DMPKCB ?EM�DMP RM�@C�JCDR�RMB?W���@�7F?R�GQ

SLPC?QML?@JC�?@MSR�RFGQ�PCQSJR���A�7F?R�?QQSKNRGML�GQ�PCQNMLQG@JC�

��� .BF95GCB56@9�+9GI@HG

�?�2CNC?R �L9F7=G9������ @SR�GLAJSBC�RFC���������L?RSP?J�?@SLB?LAC

MD UGRF�GRQ F?JD JGDC���@�7F?R�GQ�SLPC?QML?@JC�?@MSR

RFGQ�PCQSJR���A�7F?R�?QQSKNRGML�GQ�PCQNMLQG@JC���B�7FCPC�BMCQ�RFC

AMKC�DPMK�GD�GR�GQ�LMR�NPGKMPBG?J�

��� .BF95GCB56@9�+9GI@HG

4FC�K?LSD?ARSPCP�MD�?�QKMIC�?J?PK�BCAGBCQ�RF?R�RFC�QK?JJCQR�ASPPCLR�MD

P?BG?RGML�FC�A?L�BCRCAR�GQ ���?�&GLB�RFC�?ARGTGRW�GL�ASPGCQ�MD

?L CKGRRCP�RF?R�NPMBSACQ�? ASPPCLR�MD N?PRGAJCQ���@�7F?R

GQ�SLPC?QML?@JC�?@MSR�RFGQ�PCQSJR���A�7F?R�?QQSKNRGML�GQ�PCQNMLQG@JC�

���� �=B8=B;��B9F;M

��� GQ�?�JMMQCJW�@MSLB�GQMRMNC�MD�FWBPMECL��#?JJCB�BCSRCPGSK�MP

FC?TW�FWBPMECL��GR�GQ�QR?@JC�@SR�PCJ?RGTCJW�P?PCuGR�GQ��������MD�L?RSP?J

FWBPMECL��.MRC�RF?R�BCSRCPGSK�F?Q ��UFGAF�QFMSJB�RCLB�RM�K?IC�GR

KMPC�RGEFRJW�@MSLB��@SR�@MRF�?PC�MBB�LSK@CPQ��#?JASJ?RC ��RFC

@GLBGLE�CLCPEW�NCP�LSAJCML��DMP ?LB�AMKN?PC�GR�UGRF�RFC

?NNPMVGK?RC�T?JSC�M@R?GLCB�DPMK�RFC�EP?NF�GL �=;IF9�������

� � GQ�?KMLE�RFC�KMQR�RGEFRJW�@MSLB�MD�?JJ�LSAJGBCQ��)R�GQ�KMPC�RF?L

����MD�L?RSP?J�GPML��.MRC�RF?R F?Q�CTCL�LSK@CPQ�MD�@MRF�NPMRMLQ

?LB�LCSRPMLQ��#?JASJ?RC ��RFC�@GLBGLE�CLCPEW�NCP�LSAJCML��DMP

?LB�AMKN?PC�GR�UGRF�RFC�?NNPMVGK?RC�T?JSC�M@R?GLCB�DPMK�RFC

EP?NF�GL �=;IF9�������

��� GQ�RFC�FC?TGCQR�QR?@JC�LSAJGBC��?LB�GRQ GQ�JMU

AMKN?PCB�UGRF�KCBGSK K?QQ�LSAJGBCQ��#?JASJ?RC ��RFC�@GLBGLE

CLCPEW�NCP�LSAJCML��DMP ?LB�AMKN?PC�GR�UGRF�RFC�?NNPMVGK?RC

T?JSC�M@R?GLCB�DPMK�RFC�EP?NF�GL �=;IF9�������

��� �?�#?JASJ?RC DMP ��RFC�P?PCP�MD�RFC�RUM�KMQR�AMKKML

SP?LGSK�GQMRMNCQ���@�#?JASJ?RC DMP ���-MQR�MD�SP?LGSK�GQ

#(!04%2����Y�2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3 ����

Page 36: 2!$)/!#4)6)49! .$. 5#,%!20 (93)#3 · PDF filez %vnj?gll sajc?pdmpac 'i7@95f˛ 975m5b8˝ cbg9fj5h=cb% 5kg z $cdglc? lbb gqasqqlsajc?pbca?w z 3r?rcr fcam lqcpt?rgmlj?uq z %vnj?gln ?pclr?

��.MRC�RF?R F?Q�CTCL�LSK@CPQ�MD�@MRF�NPMRMLQ�?LB

LCSRPMLQ��)Q�RFC MD QGELGDGA?LRJW�BGDDCPCLR�DPMK�RF?R�MD

��� �?�#?JASJ?RC DMP ��3R?@JC�?LB�PCJ?RGTCJW�RGEFRJW�@MSLB�

RFGQ�LSAJGBC�GQ�KMQR�MD�L?RSP?J�A?P@ML���@�#?JASJ?RC DMP ��)Q

RFC�BGDDCPCLAC�GL @CRUCCL ?LB QGELGDGA?LR��/LC�GQ

QR?@JC�?LB�AMKKML��?LB�RFC�MRFCP�GQ�SLQR?@JC�?LB�P?PC�

��� 4FC�D?AR�RF?R GQ�EPC?RCQR�DMP LC?P����GKNJGCQ�RF?R�RFC�P?LEC

MD�RFC�LSAJC?P�DMPAC�GQ�?@MSR�RFC�BG?KCRCP�MD�QSAF�LSAJGBCQ���?�#?JASJ?RC

RFC�BG?KCRCP�MD�?L LSAJCSQ���@�#MKN?PC DMP

?LB ��4FC�DGPQR�GQ�MLC�MD�RFC�KMQR�RGEFRJW�@MSLB�LSAJGBCQ��UFGJC�RFC

QCAMLB�GQ�J?PECP�?LB�JCQQ�RGEFRJW�@MSLB�

��� 4FC�NSPNMQC�MD�RFGQ�NPM@JCK�GQ�RM�QFMU�GL�RFPCC�U?WQ�RF?R�RFC�@GLBGLE

CLCPEW�MD�RFC�CJCARPML�GL�?�FWBPMECL�?RMK�GQ�LCEJGEG@JC�AMKN?PCB�UGRF�RFC

K?QQCQ�MD�RFC�NPMRML�?LB�CJCARPML���?�#?JASJ?RC�RFC�K?QQ�COSGT?JCLR�GL�S

MD�RFC����� C6�@GLBGLE�CLCPEW�MD�?L�CJCARPML�GL�?�FWBPMECL�?RMK��?LB

AMKN?PC�RFGQ�UGRF�RFC�K?QQ�MD�RFC�FWBPMECL�?RMK�M@R?GLCB�DPMK

�DD9B8=L�����@�3S@RP?AR�RFC�K?QQ�MD�RFC�NPMRML�EGTCL�GL -56@9�����

DPMK�RFC�K?QQ�MD�RFC�FWBPMECL�?RMK�EGTCL�GL �DD9B8=L����9MS�UGJJ�DGLB

RFC�BGDDCPCLAC�GQ�COS?J�RM�RFC�CJCARPMLwQ�K?QQ�RM�RFPCC�BGEGRQ��GKNJWGLE�RFC

@GLBGLE�CLCPEW�GQ�QK?JJ�GL�AMKN?PGQML���A�4?IC�RFC�P?RGM�MD�RFC�@GLBGLE

CLCPEW�MD�RFC�CJCARPML�������C6�RM�RFC�CLCPEW�COSGT?JCLR�MD�RFC�CJCARPMLwQ

K?QQ��������-C6���B�$GQASQQ�FMU�WMSP�?LQUCPQ�AMLDGPK�RFC�QR?RCB

NSPNMQC�MD�RFGQ�NPM@JCK�

��� .BF95GCB56@9�+9GI@HG

!�N?PRGAJC�NFWQGAGQR�BGQAMTCPQ�?�LCSRP?J�N?PRGAJC�UGRF�?�K?QQ�MD���������S

RF?R�FC�?QQSKCQ�GQ�RUM�LCSRPMLQ�@MSLB�RMECRFCP���?�&GLB�RFC�@GLBGLE

CLCPEW���@�7F?R�GQ�SLPC?QML?@JC�?@MSR�RFGQ�PCQSJR���A�7F?R

?QQSKNRGMLQ�?PC�SLPC?QML?@JC�MP�GLAMLQGQRCLR�

���� -IBB9@=B;

��� $CPGTC�?L�?NNPMVGK?RC�PCJ?RGMLQFGN�@CRUCCL�RFC�CLCPEW�MD BCA?W

?LB�F?JD JGDC�SQGLE�RFC�DMJJMUGLE�B?R?��)R�K?W�@C�SQCDSJ�RM�EP?NF�RFC�JME�MD

?E?GLQR RM�DGLB�QMKC�QRP?GEFR JGLC�PCJ?RGMLQFGN�

4?@JC����� %LCPEW�?LB�(?JD ,GDC�DMP $CA?W

'I7@=89

��� "BH9;F5H98��CB79DHG

!����� 4�K?ELCRGA�DGCJB�GQ�?NNJGCB�NCPNCLBGASJ?P�RM�RFC�N?RF�MD�AF?PECB

N?PRGAJCQ�GL�?�@S@@JC�AF?K@CP��7F?R�GQ�RFC�P?BGSQ�MD�ASPT?RSPC�MD�RFC�N?RF

MD�?����-C6�NPMRML�GL�RFGQ�DGCJB��.CEJCAR�?LW�QJMUGLE�?JMLE�GRQ�N?RF�

��� �?�7PGRC�RFC�BCA?W�COS?RGML�DMP�RFC BCA?W�MD ���@�7F?R

CLCPEW�GQ�PCJC?QCB�GL�RFGQ�BCA?W��4FC�K?QQ�MD�RFC�B?SEFRCP�LSAJGBC�GQ

�����������S���A�!QQSKGLE�RFC�PCQGBS?J�LSAJCSQ�GQ�DMPKCB�GL�GRQ�EPMSLB

QR?RC��FMU�KSAF�CLCPEW�EMCQ�RM�RFC N?PRGAJC�

� � .BF95GCB56@9�+9GI@HG

4FC�PCJ?RGTCJW�QA?PAC�L?RSP?JJW�MAASPPGLE�A?JAGSK�GQMRMNC F?Q�?

F?JD JGDC�MD�?@MSR ���?�!�QK?JJ�Q?KNJC�MD�RFGQ�GQMRMNC�GQ�J?@CJCB

?Q�F?TGLE�?L�?ARGTGRW�MD�����#G��7F?R�GQ�RFC�K?QQ�MD�RFC GL�RFC

Q?KNJC���@�7F?R�GQ�SLPC?QML?@JC�?@MSR�RFGQ�PCQSJR���A�7F?R

?QQSKNRGML�GQ�PCQNMLQG@JC�

��� .BF95GCB56@9�+9GI@HG

!�NFWQGAGQR�QA?RRCPQ P?WQ�DPMK�?�QS@QR?LAC�?LB�QCCQ�CTGBCLAC�MD�?

LSAJCSQ GL�P?BGSQ���?�&GLB�RFC�?RMKGA�K?QQ�MD�QSAF�?

LSAJCSQ���@�7F?R�GQ�SLPC?QML?@JC�?@MSR�RFGQ�PCQSJR���A�7F?R�GQ

SLPC?QML?@JC�?@MSR�RFC�?QQSKNRGML�

��� .BF95GCB56@9�+9GI@HG

!�DP?XXJCB�RFCMPCRGA?J�NFWQGAGQR�PCAIMLQ�RF?R�?JJ�AMLQCPT?RGML�J?UQ�?PC

M@CWCB�GL�RFC�BCA?W�MD�?�NPMRML�GLRM�?�LCSRPML��NMQGRPML��?LB�LCSRPGLM��?Q

GL BCA?W�MD�?�LSAJCSQ�?LB�QCLBQ�?�N?NCP�RM�?�HMSPL?J�RM�?LLMSLAC

RFC�PC?ARGML�?Q�?�NMQQG@JC�CLB�MD�RFC�SLGTCPQC�BSC�RM�RFC�QNMLR?LCMSQ

BCA?W�MD�NPMRMLQ���?�7F?R�CLCPEW�GQ�PCJC?QCB�GL�RFGQ�BCA?W���@�7F?R�GQ

SLPC?QML?@JC�?@MSR�RFGQ�PCQSJR���A�7F?R�?QQSKNRGML�GQ�PCQNMLQG@JC�

��� �CBGHFI7H�2CIF�(KB�)FC6@9A

#MLQGBCP�RFC�BCA?W�MD�P?BGM?ARGTC�QS@QR?LACQ�GL�RFC�%?PRFwQ�GLRCPGMP��4FC

CLCPEW�CKGRRCB�GQ�AMLTCPRCB�RM�RFCPK?J�CLCPEW�RF?R�PC?AFCQ�RFC�C?PRFwQ

QSPD?AC�?LB�GQ�P?BG?RCB�?U?W�GLRM�AMJB�B?PI�QN?AC��#MLQRPSAR�?�NPM@JCK�GL

UFGAF�WMS�CQRGK?RC�RFC�?ARGTGRW�GL�?�AS@GA�KCRCP�MD�C?PRF�PMAI��!LB�RFCL

A?JASJ?RC�RFC�NMUCP�ECLCP?RCB��#?JASJ?RC�FMU�KSAF�NMUCP�KSQR�APMQQ

C?AF�QOS?PC�KCRCP�MD�RFC�%?PRFwQ�QSPD?AC�GD�RFC�NMUCP�GQ�BGQQGN?RCB�?R�RFC

Q?KC�P?RC�?Q�GR�GQ�ECLCP?RCB��!KMLE�RFC�RFGLEQ�RM�AMLQGBCP�?PC�RFC

?ARGTGRW�NCP�AS@GA�KCRCP��RFC�CLCPEW�NCP�BCA?W��?LB�RFC�QGXC�MD�RFC�%?PRF�

���� #(!04%2����Y�2!$)/!#4)6)49�!.$�.5#,%!2�0(93)#3

4FGQ�AMLRCLR�GQ�?T?GJ?@JC�DMP�DPCC�?R�FRRN���ALV�MPE�AMLRCLR�AMJ���������