• At:.;c:.. ney fox• · I. . • ~"lt.:.. ;! .. ' •

rwY· 1:1, ·-,rucE 53D ·,;!) ,....,~ S:'.; .. ·~·· Lo.:: i\nri,.:l.i,;;., --u TRi1S ty 562 '.>

'In .. l '.:\ °:.'' :.l(i.

1 tt-rney f:·)'/ D0f~ndw.Yt

..

fi'rui tv• le :r ·i.usl ·;JD.r;ol:' Gor:r; f..'.ny

• )~

..-- , . ~ ' ... { }

Bl: '· ::..,Jl)S GO:JH'J.~

q 9c:'· . . 1 -ttr J. ~ .. ,I l.. {· - ~ :> .. :;.,

G" A• ?aq:,.;..r:3g:. .• O.o "-~ Dy D 11"•1.s Da .. say

Dopu·i; ·

p,: .l\liD ron '.t'F .: COUNTY OX ' IIVEHSID.~

THE CPJ.:Y 0F' SAN ;j'AC!:rTO ~ HO\r,1\RD l:OSE: COMPJl.,NY HEMET m.,RSE.,.~Y COI-lP/. iY, PAUC1 W o EO\'J!L.· / , ~a oxecutor of t,h,11 Eato:!i,il of Co W. ;iO:\l'ARJ.; Deceusoc, LJ\RVEY D, .ALLENc : T ~LT,A E .. ALLEN;, ~ALE W .. H.Mi \'8R 11

E., ~o : {U;'.I1::.s.., GJlAiU.,ES /'y. !!OWARDp lft}TRY BEIIl~fu ~·, GE]'l111UD.t5 BEEJ.Ti<:nr, FBAWK r-lILl ,D'.R, r-'iILTCi1! , 31.:i:Lr;-:Y" ALIC:2 iio Bi" JLLY r HA,r:or ~ r # ~..:iiJllJ · ~ c , 1r1.HI0l1 E., S !.IJDALL. E.JWIN 1 .11:,'YER b ; Li· IL, ~IBYEH.i G. go 00UYLiiill 0

SUSIS E .. ;:JCITKI.Il'JE;, 1I!~f!Vf{t c; ~ JOEUSTO J;, !1'1YDELL "·0m;s1.COU ., WILLJ:~ 1-'.i H .. COfJ·JIU:, AL. -.. WIL .. BJH J , GOW·JIN~ ,;,:3 Co,.,Pru.•1;:-.ox•s, doing h:1s:L10s ~"· ur a.er. tbe :1£":110 o.nd rii.;yJ.c; 01 .. Corwin Rr nch., HOBEff·l' D1' GRABhI{ and DONAT ~1

G., c·J~HIE, a.~ Co""Pr-z-'im' 1•s, d inc buslnasf' unde... the namo ru1d styJ.o of' G. Co Gx•abor Cor.1:nL'"lY,. GEI.ARD HAL11AN ~ RUTH IlAL!-lA.N, HAHR''I s .. HI nacK, JOSS.?II E TIAHLJM;p KA':i:'AlUNA RJ .tTLJi'i.K:.

Plaint.if..:.'"" n

'V'3 .. ,

FRUI'.:.'VJI..LE T.filT:JAL T,JATER GOI·l? JUJY' JOHN ONL ,, JOH11 TWO TOIIlT Tl.REE, JOHIT FJUH., JOBN FI\'15:- J'OHN SIX,. JOHN SEVEN, JOim EIGI-i'"T , JO:I:rn !HJJE, JOinI TEN JI JOlIH ELEVE!I .P as i;' p0rsonal. r . .Jrese:ntut1 vo of John Twol " 1:, ~ decenso·"'... "i/iHE ON.Sil JANE T\·IJO JAHE ·.Z:1IH11?. ,TA.NB F'O U! ~ dt. HJ.G FP.G., J f HE SIX, J .Al-IE d

SEVEN': JANE EiGIIT.~ .. TAHE nnm! J.ANE TEN.,. JOI.m· TWEL'i'I~ co:UAHY fl S. Cc.1-partne1~ship,. JOHN. 1r:iIIR'I'.E~':J COH? ANY"' a cor':.)or11tion~ JOHN' FOURTEill'i COH2Al'JY,, e COI'J?O!'S.tion. JOHN FIF'I'EE~'\J CO}!PlllTYs a corporation~ and JOHN SIXT ·.c.i.i G0l1PJ\!'iY, a corporation"

Dofondan-~su

) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ' J ) )

' ) ) )

) )

) ) I

)

I 'I I

I

) )

. ) ) } ) }

AND

DECREE

In the above onti tlcd ac t:;lon~ 1 t aJ.)earinc to the Coi.lrt that

so.id action has bean dianissed as to plainti.ffa, II. Wo .i>Iyers,

Arba C ... .i1yers, Harvey A. Dulm~ Joseph Dul<lra, Hary ~uldra and

Lethe&. Hinnick and as to d.ofondant.s, Lake Hemet Wa.tor Company and

Fairview Land ancl Water Cor.ipn..."'1y6 pursuant to a request there.for

si;:;ned by Courtnay Lacey~ ~sq., as attornoy of record .for all of

the plaintif1'ae and by Ray W., Bruce, Esqo, aa attorney of' record

for the defendant Fruitvale Hutual Water Com:,any., and that all of

tho now ;,:>1aint1ffs of record and tllo defendant, Fruitvale Mutual

Water Compan:,4) individually and by and throuc;h their respective

attorneys or record~ have ~igned and riled herein a stipulation and

consent that the !'ollowine; judsment and decree may be signed, filed

and enterod in said s.ctionp

NOW THEREPORE~ th.a Court being i'ully advised in the premises9

and pursu9..nt to said stipulntionc

IT IS HEREBY ORDERED~ ADJUDGED AND DECREED e.s follows:

I

The Department of Puhl1c Works of the State of Ce.liforn1a9

actln[.:; throur;h t;he State Encinear as Re:fsra&g, is hereby ordered to

cease completely .fl"om this time t"orthg the carrying on of.' 1 ts 1n ...

Vf.Hr~iGnt:I.on of' the phyaicnl facts involved 111 the above action as

haretof'ora roquj.rsd by the Order of: the Court dated September 17 Ji

1951~ and filed heraino

It :!.s f'u.1:ther ordered that said Refer•ee shall prepare a

report aur1r:1ar1z1ng tho data alrr.:lady coll•:}Ctod ru1d tul'."n over copies

of sald report to:

( u) The Cour•t;

(b) PlaintiI'.f the Ci;J of San Jacinto;

tc' \ J All other plaintii.:'ts th.'3.n said plaintiff the City of

San Ja.cinto 0 by daliverinc; a copy to plaintiff Charles s. Ho\-lardJr

who ls now the secretary of the association comrn•ising ea.ch of

said ;)lru.ntiffs~ or any otho~ person duly acting as sacretary or

\

l • I

j

said associutlon;

(d) Dofondant;, 1:i'ruitvalo Mutual Water Gom.J&"1Yo

II

'rhe "Entire Basin" refer•red. to herein shall be that area

within the oran~e line on tha map attached hereto entitled

11 Dlvis1on of: Water Resources; south Coaate.l Baain :Cnvestir;ation,

San Jacinto Areo..,, Riverside County, Gsneral :ta;;>s*" TJ)?er San

Jacinto Ba.sin Ref,,,~ *To Accom~nmy nemoo Rep•t ... Re .. Meeting with

Parties., • ., o Hay 20 .$ '52, s..nd made a ?art of this JudQ11ent and

Deoreo as though sot fot>th in f 1..l.ll herein end f Ol" reference

purposes markod Exhibit A ..

The F2:-ui tvala Mutuel \~ater Company, one of the defendants

herein., until its rlr;ht to ·r.s..ke more, o~ loas., ls dater"!llined by a

court o:r comt:>etant jurisdiction!'< roay divert .from th6 su.rface

stream flow of th.a San Jacinto Hiver at any place within the

Entire Bo.sins, for. di.rect uss or s'l;or•age~ wit,hout limit., and may

extract :f"rom the subsu~fs.ce wa.te1•s in that oortion of the Entire > - -

Basln east of the east section line of Section 6 0 Townshlp S

South~ Ransa l Enstp San Be1mardlno Base a:nd ~1eri.d1s.n . in Rivorl!lide

County si State oi' Ctlifornia., ond tho nortlv.>1?1y and southerly e;::c

tens.tons of said east sactton line. which -e.ld r>or ion of ss.1.d

restriction or 1:tml t so long s.<1 the ata.t:Lc levol 01" the nubsurfacs

numb · r sevan i.2 :not oval" 2S f ee-t, bt..JlOJf the ~-;~vat ion of - =

1665, 42 f et abovf.-1 se1S. :.evaJ.:. •-;he eJ evatto:'.1 or t,he pr.~asent

lishedii to be biwad on t;he. ur_it0d State~ Geoloeical Survay Ban1}h

Marlc at tlw sou'Gh':.·rnst corner of the school sx~ounds a.t Valle Vista.))

California, a.t e'.~ovat.ion l 76::·,, 967 feet, or based on some other

alternative United States Geological Survey Bench ,:e.rk; n.nd said

... .3.

water may ba used either ovor or outside of said Entire I3asin~ 8.nd 0

subjee·t to tti.e lin1itat:ion of 12.,000 acre feet hereinafter specif'ied

until its richt to take moroa or less 0 is detorm1ned by a court of

competent jur1sdiction0 snld defendant shall limit its extraction

of subsurfuco water from the said Canyon Ba.sin~ at all times when

said static level of the subsurface waters at the present location

of said well number seven iD 25 feet~ or more., below the said

elevation of 1665 042 feet o.bo·tJe sea leval 0 to 4~500 acre .faat

of water durinc any poriod f'rom Ilovember 1st of one year to

Octobor 31st of the follow .. n0 ye~. starting November 1st., 1953P

said periods to be hereino:-'.'tor referred to as the fiscal yee.ro

Said static level of the subsurfe..ce waters at the present

location of' said well num1:ei .. soven shall be ascertained and es ...

tablishad by a committee ~onsistinc of one representative ot

plaintiffs., one represeni;ative of defendant, Fruitvale Hutual

Water CompanyD &nd one J tconsed civil engineer of Eastern I1unic1..,

pal Water Distri.ct, by .1easurements with a continuous automatic

water recorder of a te:; ·n well, or any replacement thereof• located

on property owned or i:;ontrolled by Fruitvale Hutual Wate1~ Companyg

and within said Cau:,ron Basin, at a polnt agreed upon by a majority

of said oomraitteo! and a correlation approved by a majority of

said committeev rJf the measure::nents 1n so.id test woll and measure..,,

ments made at J;·aa proaent location of said well number seveno

Sai.d committee chn.11 have access at any and all. t:lmoa to f-.ho

proper"GY in t:.e Canyon Basin owned or controlled by F'ruitvals

Hutunl Wate,· Company which nay be required to make correlations

of ·t;he wat;;r le·vels in sru.d tost well e.nd said wall number sevenJ

and as.id .Jor:1.mi ttoe ahall ho.ve access to se.id test well at e.n7

and all ·,;irnosa Said co~m:ni ttee shall have access to said well

number ·.:1evon fo1• further tests a.t any time when the pumps of the

Fru.it·Hllo :iui;ual Water Company in said Canyon Bo.sin are not

-4=

operating, and at such other times o.s may ba mutually agreeable

on the part ot the committee and the Fruitvale Hutual Water

Company/) Said cormnitteo shall deterr.iine the depth of said teat

well 0 which shall not exceed 200 .rooto Tho cost of said test

well, equipment and operation shall be pa.id: One-ninth by

the City of San JacintoQ three-ninths by the plaintiffs other

than ~.;he city 01.' San Jacinto.() and fivet;;ninths by Fruitvale

Hut'..lal Wa.tar- Comi:>&nyo The findlngs of the committee and readings

from the test well shall be kapt on file at the of:f:tces of tho

Fruitvale Hut1ial Water Comp.g.ny and may be inspected and copied

at said office by plaintiffs at 11ny time during office hourso

Said def'enda.nteJ Fruitvale Mutual We.te:..• Company, may until

its right to take more, er loss, la determined by a court of

competent jurisdiction~ oxtvset r~om said Entire Basin~ by

pumpingD tor US6 outside of ne.i.d l':·1tire Bas:'!.n0 a toto.l of not

mor"e than 123000 acz-a i"aGt of wa-tei· during a..~y flscru. year,, and

shall ;Limit such o:a:tractio ':;y pump:,ng from any part or said

Entire Basin 11 whether from !'. ,'oovo or belm said static level 1n

said Canyon Basin, above s::,:-:1ci.±'led,, to not moi~e than 129 000

acre feet or water clurL"'l.g an~ onf, 1"l;leal year X-or usa outside

of said Entire nasin3 EL"l<I f.'urthe7.' prc.·-1ided1t however 0 that not

more than 4:,500 aore f"oa l, ot· 1atc:.n" aha:: he axtrat}tod by

dofendan·t 9 F1""llit·\fo.la Hm;1n1l Water Compr.: rv., :Crom said Canyon

:"3asin in any ono fisce} y-,a:r2 wh.U.c th(,. sal<l at tic la1rol o:r the

.subsu1•raco t,rater in sa!.d ·.::nn:yon Bo.s:ln Ls 25 i'ee·c or more 9

below the aald el~va:tlm·. oi~ 1~165. J.~2 fo:i t above sou levGl()

said deft1nuant 9 F.~·ui i:,valo if1rcus.l ir/;; i;e1• Gcm).s.ny ~ until its

riGht is res.t;r:i.cted b,; doto~m:tnution of' :.1. court ,')f competent

jurisdiction_ may t.a~~e wJ..thoat ).J.r.1it. nny ,.~ '.\ters which it may

recover from the :sll.bsu.r.face ·.rcts1•s of said .mtire Basin, for

use on lands m.rer• ~ aid Entire Ba.nln:.i ;;ubjoci.: orly to the

limitation that .r.ot mcra thfl'':l ,'-1-~SOO acre foot of wc.t,ar may bs

axtractod from tho subsU!.*.fn.co w11te1"s oi' Csnyon Basin during

e.ny fiscal yon.r,, wi:1ilo the sn.id otatic lovol of tho s1.,;.bsurl'ace

1 .. m.te:."'o therein ars 2S feet; 11 or moro, below tho said elevatlon

o::e 1665 ,4.2 feet c.bovs sea le.veto

On !>l" boforf· n::L"'tty de.yn after tho lc:i.st day o:t Oct;obe1 .. of

C:tty of San Jacinto, two (2) cc-:,:Lc.3"" a:;.."l.d. c;..:-1 t . .1.e otha1• ;:Jlainti.ff's

by mailinc to Chur. os s~ H-::>w:•.1 • .,d_l -t11.e pr•eson;; st:r.,x•sta.ry of' the

~~~O"J0 a.~1cln •o~;)l100•n• g.-,"' I., • 1..o- • .• {_, l.,l~ J. ,.... l>

31ati

sr ..... d ,11aint1.ffs 19 o:i:• any futuro sec1•etary

&t!.l~. ., C ., . ..,. , . -' <~·n r. J·"" f,bc:'. "2 .J . \I 1.;l.'J .A V ,. ...,,,.\.... / l)c. a

bent infOl'•mution and belief of the then .?resident or Vice ..

ProsidGnt of saicl dofondant, who sh.all cause said statements

to be ::>repared and ma.ilede .Dach deli vary of' so.id statement

required to be ci ven,. shall be sufficient and coml)leto when

deposited in en envelope in tho United Staten mail with post­

age prepai.d and addressed to plaintiff, the Cit;y of San Jacinto,,

at; San Jaclato,. Go.lif'o1"?1ia., a.nd to all other plitlnt1f'f's when.

addressed to ple.Jntif'f ,. Churloa S,: Howard 9 c/o Howard ;{ose

Company, IIonot~ CaJ.lforni.a., or tc sueh othor addl~easas or

persons as oithor or them may froi1l timo to time haraafter

specif'y in ·wr1 tinGo

V

None of the pr,.,vislons 0.r this jude,ment and deeroe shall

bo conside:r.•cKl as construingt> decl u-1ng or settinc; torth in

any we.yD t?.ny of the rlGhts to 01:> :.imitations upon any of

the 1·•ic;hte i;o watar of my porson 1hethel"' p::oesently parties

heroto 9 a.a r;;uch r·'ights existed on .ue,!omber 29s 1950~ and the

rights o.f' any and. all partJ.0:1 h.er•etoi to ·t;he use of water

i"l""Om said So:n Jacinto River or said ::ntir~ Be.sin, as they

exi3ted on Decemb,air 29 9 1J50~ are not !.~ an;r manne1~ or to any

&Jr.tent enJ.ru:,c;ed 0 diminl};1hed:, amended» a.lL.,1J:~f3G or• chai,ged by

t:1is stipulated. Ju.dcnont ru1c R'to1.,,eo" p:r-ov:\dod:, howevez•t, the.t

no party to t;his action shall acquire tmy :.:ichto as o.eainst

any other pnrty t.o thls notlcm" to tho use r.1 r watex .. f'r-om said

Sru.1 ~Jee into R:t vor or said ?.u t,ir.ei Daatn or a-s:1-:;· p !il"t. tb.e1 .. ¢.;01" 8

by any ad't"f)J•sa uro of ws.t,o :.:· r,ll;;ft""~:from 13"1.1.bs,,:;q_ucr.t to D@(:ember

29, 1950 ~ ,rh"3tl.~or' for v.S(j ox· used outside of nf:~d ETftire

Er.trJi.11 or ovor ar1y part of' s0.ld Entil"e Bus1nc

VI

The ri,:;hts of t.he pa:riti1s ·1; 0 this action:l rxn.d &,:>.ch ot

them.:i to tho une of the wutor from sald Entlra Ba.sin., ;tcquired

by reason of' ripcrian ownershiPt· a,_opro?riat~1 on or adveJ'.'~;e use.,

prior to December 29~ 1950i by extraction ~rom tho undercrcnmd

wa.toro of salcl :.nt:lre Basin or by direct di version .from the

stream flow for diroct use or atora3e:;1 and a.o thoy ex:lsted on

December 29 9 19.50,, shall not be lost or gained or au~nted

by r•eason of' any uss of wo.t0r f.ron said Eni;ire Bo.sin or any

part theroof,, after December 29u 1.')50:; by any of tho parties

to ·this e.c ,ion, and in any futu ·e trial 01., reopening of this

action the :elcJto of' tLo pe.1•tio3u and each of them~ shall be

datorolnod in accordance with the fac'Gs existing on Docer.1be~

29$ 1950,,

VII

Tho Cou:<'"t rese1 .. ves jur:lodlction or this a.ct:ton end of

the parties to i t/)1 and cny of said pm,..tion:, or any other per=

son.'3 who may he 01.~ bccorna pc1rt,iea to 'chis s.ction 0 a.t any

.future t:Irr.c i, mo.'J 1:'eopon ... lw J.J.tigs.t1.on f'or f'urti.1er proceedings

~he::::>e:tr,. to b.a.vo a.djudicatecl ru,.y snd all their r<H.!pective

r·:tis:1ts P oub j (-let to the px-01.;i.slons oi' Para.graph VI hereo.f o

VIII

The· .Dopart.ri en-b ot: Public Wo;:-I.::s of t.ho State of Callfor=

n!.tt.~ aot,:7 ng t.ll?'cv.gh thf; Rt.1to E:nr.;:lnoe:r~B ref-!:>reo~ is hereby

01•J.erad to subr:.15 t to tho ~ou.rt e . .,tatement o.f t.b e total ex ....

?<:m;:1es lncurrsd by i·t; ln l,,;:c invostlr_;atlon hez•ein prior to

th:li; ,Jud.g::-.1nnt ar d Dota•oo » n..0d the maJdn.g of tho roport re­

qu.i:r.:oc1. 'i:if +-.h.:.s ~ · •dr.,;m0nt t'.nd Dec:-.,oo~ wh:i.ch should be paid by

t.ho porson I p1· , 0;1tly pe.rt.i.oa t;o 1c:hls a.ction~ '.lnd that a copy

the ::>oo:f a toc.:;,1~nc 1:• with c. n -~ic, of the date of i'ili..11g such

sta\;(v:1~n t~ 1J~. rr1t:c led to O!J.(:!;1 o:L· l.lL, o.ttorn~ys of record for

a.'Yly of snid pr...x-01 ::.0~1' m1c'i. t;0 C;1i:Jrlea Sa I:.o 1ar•d, .for• all otho1•

Jlainti:t'fs o::ce1•t ·the City of ;:,an J·ac.lnto 9 1>.1ithin two days

ai't0r such f'ilil'C.:. Ob}3c:cions to t.he Ei.lllOlmt of expenseo

clair,10-' [) o:.-. the a.llocation theroof ~ may bo Iaado to the Court

at rm.y t:i.mo t·.ritl·in thirty U.flJ'.S ester tho filing of" said state ...

e mont and Lho rn:1o~mt of tho o:s: 1e11sen clnL1cd D.nd t~10 ulloca ...

tion thor0of' shu'..l bo subject to ?:"Jodificc:.tion by t.ho Court

_)ursunnt to tho ;n-•ovision::i of Article J., Chapter 1, ?art 3

of: Div:Leicn 2 of the •h:ttor Coe"'.~ of California.a

p:!.'5 .. oP to t!1e ent:i•y of 1.~his ,Tu. 'grnont a.,'"ld. D ::ioree nnd t:he c::>st

llscortf',inotl v.nd f:Lxec.1 aa provided in Pru: s..sraph VIII horeo1'.,

Or:,.o, .. n:J.nt-h ti e:·oof by t.he Cit, of San Ja.cln·;o;

::.co!'dinc aa tllel .. x·especti 10

P ... lL : !) r:, n ..:·<." 'l c. _, O ... \;.'tt ~.;. ~.. 1J010GB:.i~ ·ld ...

; ! 1"} • 1" f :,,t-_; ') i V ,..- ;_

.. ~ . ~ " ...... ~ .. 440 a.cros

0'

,. ..... t;. "1?, .. 220

0 ••••• .,160

" •c.•o••••o•o

30

10

15

2

10

"

n

" n

ts

" ,, If

Go r:., Conkl1'.1e and Susie Eo Conklina o,,,," " .. (J ... ~ .. ., o 'J 10 acres

IIarvoy C" .Johnston and IIaybell Johnstono,·•o•o .. .,, ........ 14

\· illi01J1 n., Corwin and 1fllbur Jo Cox>win~ as Co-Partners» doinc busino:.rn under tho ~1ane and style of' CoPw:tn He.ncho., ..... ,. ...... .,. ........ ,,., .... ,, ., 2.50

i1ol>ert ,)., Or.1ber and Donald Goei Cur>rle, as co ... Partners, doing businoss under the nane and style of' CM Co Grabo~ Com)anYooft03050~•·o~oo•oolOO

Gora.rd Halnu1:n and Ruch Jlalmun_.,, .... o ...... ., ... ~ . ............ olOO

Harry 3.() I·tlnaioko o.,. o .. ~ .. ,, ...... ., ............. ,, .. ., ..... o ~ ......... 10

Jos&ph E.., Ramljak and Katt\I'ins .i1runljak, •• ., o ...... ~ ••• 35

"

"

" ff

n

ti

Tota.i. 1916 Acres

X

Each of the parties to this actJ.on :1r.tall bo~ his. h.er

or its resp&ctiv0 costs of suit not herein cthor1ise oxpressly

provided foro

Ju110,, 195li.l)

(SAAL)

/.::u JOHN Go GABBERT

Judge or. the Superior Court

EHTERED

JUN 4. 1954

Judcmont nook 72 pg 164