2011 nvt wheat and barley variety performance steven tilbrook– kalyx agriculture
TRANSCRIPT
Main Wheat Varieties in WA•Level of adoption•Correlation to NVT
Analysis of results•One year localised snapshot•Long term predicted yields
Local trial results
Barley
Area Sown to Wheat Varieties
Wyalkatch
em
Calingiri
Carnamah
Yitpi
Arrino
Bonnie Rock
Westo
nia
Stiletto
Magenta
Mace
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
2008200920102011
Are
a so
wn
to W
heat
Var
ietie
s (%
)
Area sown vs NVT ranking
Wyalkatchem Calingiri Carnamah Arrino Bonnie Rock Westonia Magenta Mace0
5
10
15
20
25 0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
Area Sown State Ranking
Are
a So
wn
(%)
Stat
e Ra
nkin
g
“This trial ranked varieties differently to all other Agzone 2 NVT trials in 2011. Interpret future variety performance with caution.”
•Rank vs. Yield
•What is this MET all about??
Disclaimer???
Badgingarra Top 10
VarietyBadgingarra Agzone2
t/ha Rank Rank METLongReach Cobra 3.28 1 1 19Arrino 3.10 2 14 12Westonia 3.06 3 6 8Magenta 3.03 4 4 3Mace 3.03 5 3 1Carnamah 3.02 6 9 15King Rock 3.01 7 6 16EGA Bonnie Rock 3.01 8 5 22Corack 2.91 9 2 4Wyalkatchem 2.82 10 8 6
LSD 0.18
AH & APW Varieties WA Agzone Ranking 2011
VarietiesAgzone 1 Agzone 2 Agzone 3 Agzone 4 Agzone 5 Agzone 6
2011 MET 2011 MET 2011 MET 2011 MET 2011 MET 2011 MET
Mace 3 1 3 1 7 1 3 1 3 1 3 1
Magenta 10 3 4 3 11 4 9 4 13 7 10 6
Wyalkatchem 8 4 8 6 20 16 5 8 5 4 11 4
total number of varieties 25 55 28 68 28 69 27 57 27 69 25 67
ASWN Varieties Ranking 2011
Varieties Badgingarra Eneabba Mingenew Buntine Miling Wongan Calingiri
Arrino 2 15 14 5 10 13 14
Calingiri 19 8 6 21 19 12 26
Fortune 17 13 11 11 23 21 8
Yandanooka 15 23 16 7 9 23 21
total number of varieties 28 28 25 28 28 28 28
2 Gene CL Plus Varieties WA Agzone Ranking 2011
VarietiesAgzone 1 Agzone 2 Agzone 3 Agzone 4 Agzone 5 Agzone 6
2011 MET 2011 MET 2011 MET 2011 MET 2011 MET 2011 MET
Impose CL Plus 15 42 26 50 27 66 14 41 17 56 25 63
Justica CL Plus 18 39 28 44 22 41 24 40 24 42 15 36
Kord CL Plus 19 37 24 40 26 49 22 38 23 41 21 44
total number of varieties
25 55 28 68 28 69 27 57 27 69 25 67
Badgingarra (21/5) Eneabba (31/5) Miling (22/5)
Variety t/ha Rank t/ha Rank t/ha Rank
Corack 2.91 9 4.82 2 3.52 4
Emu Rock 2.56 14 4.33 12 3.23 20
King Rock 3.01 7 4.53 6 3.50 6
LongReach Cobra 3.28 1 4.70 3 3.62 2
Mace 3.03 5 4.66 4 3.50 5
Magenta 3.03 4 4.45 9 3.93 1
Wyalkatchem 2.82 10 4.16 17 3.24 18
Higher Rainfall
“Lower” Rainfall
Variety
Buntine (25/5/11) Pithara (22/5/11)Yield(t/ha)
Yield (Rank)
Yield(t/ha)
Yield (Rank)
Corack 3.986 2 2.443 1Emu Rock 3.715 8 2.219 9LongReach Cobra 4.008 1 2.228 8Mace 3.760 6 2.367 2Magenta 3.933 3 1.995 21Wyalkatchem 3.699 9 2.159 11
Conclusion• 2009: Mace is a consistent performer across all Agzones –
suited to 2009 season• 2010: Same; adaptable to the 2010 season• 2011: Same; adaptable to the 2011 season, what yellow
spot?
• 2009: King Rock suitable replacement for Bonnie Rock• 2010: Same; Sound disease package inc yellow spot• 2011: Same
• 2009: Calingiri has to go – Fortune will do for the moment• 2010: Lucky Bonus for Calingiri, maybe not so lucky in 2011• 2011: Growers hanging with Calingiri, Fortune is ready to
replace.
• 2009: Magenta requires a longer season to reach yield and quality potential
• 2010: Same• 2011: Wish granted. Develop a sound Agronomic package.
• 2009: Absent• 2010: IGW 3176• 2011: Emu Rock: AH; sound disease package inc yellow
spot; large seed size, watch sowing rates.
• 2009: Absent• 2010: VW 2316• 2011: Corack: ASW (prov), Wyalkatchem derivative;
physiological yellowing not yellow spot.
Conclusion
• 2009: IGW 3114, 3118, 3119• 2010: IGW 3119• 2011: The whole family wiped out
• 2009: Westonia is on borrowed time, replacements are here
• 2010: Not yet• 2011: Welcome Cobra (AH), Carnamah maturity.
• 2009: 2 Gene CL plus lines on the way• 2010: 2 Gene CL plus lines on the way• 2011: IGW Impose; AGT Kord & Justica. Do not over use;
reduced yield potential compared to mainstream varieties
Conclusion
Barley NVT
•Sown 21/05/2011
•Good growing season
•Heavily infected with powdery mildew
•Late rains
•New varieties on the way, maybe??
VarietyYield
Hectolitre Weight Protein Screenings Plump Grain
(t/ha) (kg/hectolitre) (%) (%) (%)Vlamingh 3.5 66.6 13.4 1.4 94.9
Hindmarsh 3.45 66 12.4 2.8 90.5Henley 3.1 62.4 12.2 1.5 94.2Skipper 3.05 65.8 13.4 1.9 94.7Gairdner 2.92 65 13.4 4.1 82.4Roe 2.83 65 13.4 4.6 90.1Lockyer 2.73 63.2 13.3 4.2 79.7Commander 2.71 63.4 12.2 5.2 85.9Navigator 2.61 61 12.3 3.1 89.7Fleet 2.56 61.4 13.4 2.6 92.2Bass 2.52 64.2 13.3 4.1 88Buloke 2.51 62.8 13.3 4.8 83Scope 2.39 62.2 12.2 4.7 84.1Fathom 2.06 60 13.4 4.8 88.4Stirling 2.01 60.6 13.4 3.9 90.4Mundah 1.91 60.8 12.2 6.2 85.8Baudin 1.66 56.8 12.2 10 67.9
2011 Barley Results
New Varieties
Bass•Baudin replacement with greater disease resistance
• MS powdery and R to leaf rust•Similar malting quality and plumper grain•A few days earlier than Baudin•Limited release 2012 •Pending stage 2 accreditation 2012
Henley•Widely grown in Europe•Slight improvement on yields of Baudin across WA•Durable resistance to powdery mildew•Limited seed available
New Varieties
Scope•Very similar to Buloke with added “bonus”•Applied for registration for use with Clearfield•Available now•Malting accreditation 2013
Navigator•Niche variety for the domestic market•Limited release 2012
• 2012 will be a high risk year for powdery mildew
• 2 new varieties awaiting accreditation in 2012• Bass and Navigator
• Scope a future option to integrate
• Feed vs. Malting??
Conclusion