201 11 - kentuckypsc.ky.gov/pscscf/2014 cases/2014-00084/20150311...mar 11, 2015 · kpsc case no....

BRUCE E. SMITH

BRUCE E. SMTH LAW OFFICES, PLLC201 SOUTH MAIN STREET

NICHOLASVILLE, KENTUCKY 40356

(859) 885-3393 + (859) 885-1152 FAX

RECK!'/EDMAR 11 ZDl5

PUBLfC SEHIr)CECOMMI$ $)c)N

HENRY E. SMITH

March 10, 2015

VIA UPS DELIVERYMr. Jeff R. DerouenExecutive DirectorKentucky Public Service Commission211 Sower BoulevardFrankfort, Kentucky 40601

Re: Case No. 2014-00084Jessamine-South Elkhorn Water District CPCN Application

Dear Mr. Derouen:

Delivered under cover of this letter is an original and ten (10) copies of the Applicant'sNotice of Filing and Jessamine-South Elkhorn Water District's Responses to Post Hearing DataRequests.

Bruce E. Smith

Enclosures

cc: Robert M. Watt, III, Esq.Monica H. Braun, Esq.Jennifer Black Hans, Esq.Gregory T. Dutton, Esq.Stefanie Kingsley, Esq.Ann Ramser, Esq.Anthony G. Martin, Esq.

g 1...UsEWD)Forest Hills)App 2)pleading and Motionsmeronen ltr 031015

COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY

BEFORE THE PUBLIC SERVICE COMMMISSION

RECEIVEDMAR 11 20l5

PUBLIC SERVICECQMMISSICN

In the Matter of:

APPLICATION OF JESSAMINE-SOUTH ELKHORN

WATER DISTRICT FOR A CERTIFICATE OFPUBLIC CONVENIENCE AND NECESSITY TOCONSTRUCT AND FINANCE A WATERWORKSIMPROVEMENTS PROJECT PURSUANT TO KRS278.020 AND 278.300

)))) CASE NO 2014-00084

))

JESSAMINE-SOUTH ELKHORN WATER DISTRICT'S RESPONSESTO POST HEARING DATA RE UESTS

Comes the Jessamine-South Elkhorn Water District ("Water District" ) and for its

Responses to the Post Hearing Data Requests made on February 10-11,2015, state as follows:

RESPONSES TO REQUESTS FOLLOW ON THE NEXT PAGE

TAB I:DALLAS B.HARPER, JR RESPONSETABS 2 —3:JOHN G. HORNE RESPONSES

TABS 4 —6r L. CHRISTOPHER HORiVE RESPONSES

TABS 7—Bt L. NICHOLAS VILLE STRONG RESPONSES

KPSC Case No. 2014 - 00084Post Hearing Data Requests

Filed March 11,2015Dallam B.Harper, Jr. Request

Page 2 of 15

Jessamine-South Elkhorn Water District

Dallam B. Ha er Jr. Re uestt Provide work papers, calculations and source

documents for the Maps on pages 3 and 4 of the Population Projections (electronic and formulas

intact):

Answer: See attached Excel spreadsheets. Calculations of the population were

derived from aggregate population totals of Census Blocks. Specifically, the data used for

the calculations came from the US Census Bureau and the TIGER Geodatabases, which

provide geospatial representations of Census-defined geographies. In the attached

spreadsheets denominated nBlockWhole.xls", you will see every Census Block that was

used (in whole or in part) to calculate the population numbers within the Study Area.

Of course, the Study Area used for this map is not defined by the US Census

Bureau. Therefore, while the majority of Census Blocks used for population calculation

are completely within the Study Area, some Blocks were bisected by the eastern and

southern boundary of the Study Area. Those blocks can be found in the attached

spreadsheets denominated "BlockSplit.xls". Inside of the table are all Census Blocks that

were split by the Study Area. To estimate. the portion of the population lying inside of the

'RCGIS 10.3for Desktop from ESRI, Inc. needed in order to read data at this site.2


Filed March 11,2015DaHam B.Harper, Jr. Request

Page 3 of 15

study area, a ratio calculation was used. Take the following as an example of how the

population within the Study Area was calculated:

In 1990, Block 101B (STFID: 21113060101101B)in total has 823.65 Acres.

Of that, 73.26 Acres are within the Study Area. Therefore, the percentage of

area inside the study area is 8.89% (73.26/823.65 x 100). The total

population of Block 101B in 1990 was 54. So, applying the same percentage,

the population of Block 101B inside the Study Area would be estimated at

4.8, or 5 (54 x 0.089).

The above calculation was used for all Census Blocks bisected by the Study Area boundary.

In the attached spreadsheets, every split is shown, giving total areas in acres of both sides of

the split. Parts inside of the Study Area are identified as "YES",while parts outside are

labeled "NO".

Finally, some clarification is needed with respect to the maps. In both maps

submitted, Census Block Groups are shown on the map and broken down by population in

tables. The reason for the inclusion of Census Block Group data was to show growth

within smaller areas. While Block Groups were shown on the maps, Census Block Grou s

were never used to calculate o ulation totals. Block Groups were only used as a

boundary to define areas of growth. AII population totals were calculated using Census

Blocks, not Block Groups.


Filed March 11,2015Dallam B.Harper, Jr. Request

Page 4 of 15

In response to questioning at the hearing, I mistakenly stated that the Block Group

population numbers reported in the lower left portion of each map were the populations

within each Block Group that were served by the District. The population numbers

p ttdf hBl kG p th ~tt l l tt f hBl kG p, d tth

population in each Block Group or part thereof served by the District. The attached

spreadsheets detail the calculations that derive the Study Area population and percent

change. As noted above, these Block Group totals were illustrative of total population

changes in those Block Groups only, and not used in the Study Area calculations. The

Study Area populations and Pct. Change reported on each map in the box on the lower left

of the maps correctly state the Study Area populations and Pct. Change, and were the only

numbers used to generate my future population projections.

[Dallam B.Harper, Jr.]

1990 Block Whole

FIPSSTCO

21113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113

TRACT

060101060101060101060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600

BLOCK

1018102201C

102201A

2018301302303C4018403404405407499103104105106107108109110111112113115116117118

'19

120121124128129130131132137138139140141142143

STFID

2111306010110182111306010110221113060101201C2111306040010221113060400201A211130604002018211130604003012111306040030221113060400303C211130604004018211130604004032111306040040421113060400405211130604004072111306040049921113060600103211130606001042111306060010521113060600106211130606001072111306060010821113060600109211130606001102111306060011121113060600112211130606001132111306060011521113060600116211130606001172111306060011821113060600119211130606001202111306060012121113060600124211130606001282111306060012921113060600130211130606001312111306060013221113060600137211130606001382111306060013921113060600140211130606001412111306060014221113060600143

POP100 STFID 154 21113060101101B0

268 21113060101201'C

64 21113060400102244 21113060400201A

20 21113060400201B188 21113060400301

17 2111306040030278 21113060400303C30 211130604004018

2 2111306040040312 2111306040040424 21113060400405

5 2111306040040702 211130606001030

500 21113060600105002 21113060600108

14 211130606001095 211130606001100

40 21113060600112195 21113060600113

4 21113060600115258 21113060600116

0303 21113060600118

4 211130606001190

29 21113060600121106 21113060600124

011 21113060600129

155 211130606001303 211130606001310

83 2111306060013782 2111306060013800

11 2111306060014100

ACRES

823.654.78

593.05957.62208.61113.58

1933.6680.34

773.75636.26240.00357.64278.72

7.89149.65316.9535.03

513.1816.580.40

165.57350.74

3.2913.82

1355.621789.45

23.83792.45

3.812249.41

4.571.21

955.862485.73

33.4674.28

1176.7841.6326.8327.1027.2818.2847.46

373.4818.512.50

1990 Block Whole

211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113

060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600

144145146147202205206207208209210211212213214215216217218219220221222

223224225226227228229230231

.2322332348235

2111306060014421113060600145211130606001462111306060014721113060600202211130606002052111306060020621113060600207211130606002082111306060020921113060600210211130606002112111306060021221113060600213211130606002142111306060021521113060600216211130606002172111306060021821113060600219211130606002202111306060022121113060600222211130606002232111306060022421113060600225211130606002262111306060022721113060600228211130606002292111306060023021113060600231211130606002322111306060023321113060600234821113060600235

11 211130606001446 211130606001451 211130606001465 21113060600147

44 211130606002022 21113060600205

24 2111306060020639 2111306060020711 2111306060020824 21113060600209

227 2111306060021007 2111306060021200

55 2111306060021574 211130606002163 211130606002178 211130606002184 211130606002199 21113060600220

52 2111306060022104 211130606002230

168 2111306060022515 2111306060022663 211130606002276 21113060600228

19 21113060600229162 21113060600230

32 2111306060023116 211130606002325 21113060600233

141 2111306060023484 21113060600235

2.562.69

15.5033.86

1268.7414.84

338.16513.31362.2069.21

2112.956.59

10.7732.1012.31

1548.17646.2614.61

627.1150.73

560.52100.72

2.6311.256.00

1115.80218.13692.1790.23

211.79708.44

5.364.343.91

1448.3021.91

1990 Block Split

FIPSSTCO

211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113

TRACT

060101060101060101060101060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600

BLOCK

10181018201C

201C102102201A

201A

20182018303C303C303C

303C

40184018403403499499103103121121130130132132202 .

20220520523482348235235

STFID

21113060101101821113060101101821113060101201C21113060101201C211130604001022111306040010221113060400201A21113060400201A21113060400201821113060400201821113060400303C21113060400303C21113060400303C21113060400303C211130604004018211130604004018211130604004032111306040040321113060400499211130604004992111306060010321113060600103211130606001212111306060012121113060600130211130606001302111306060013221113060600132211130606002022111306060020221113060600205211130606002052111306060023482111306060023482111306060023521113060600235

POP 10049

5

1431254519

2063817

3

532104

23

7110011

20

9132

23

00

3410

1

1123

182

2

STUDYAREA

NO

YES

NO

YES

YES

NO

NO

YES

YES

NO

YES

NO

NO

YES

NO

YES

NO

YES

NO

YES

YES

NO

NO

YES

YES

NO

YES

NO

NO

YES

YES

NO

YES

NO

NO

YES

BlockGroup

101110111012101240014001400240024002400240034003400340034004400440044004400440046001600160016001600160016001600160026002600260026002600260026002

ACRES

750.3973.26

317.17275.88677.54280.09176.2032.4096.7016.88

528.34202.90

0.2742.24

495.04141.22168.4371.57

140.858.80

185.89131.06657.32298.54

¹¹¹¹¹¹

173.7724.232.61

994.56274.18

7.777.07

¹¹¹¹¹¹

189.5812.219.70

2000 Block Whole

FIPSSTCO TRACT2000 BLOCK2000 STFID GEOJd GEO_displa POPlOO ACRES21113 060101 1008 211130601011008 1000000US211130601011008 Block 1008, Block Group 1, Census Tract 601.01, Jessamine County, Kentucky 52 990.8421113 060101 1009 211130601011009 1000000US21113060101100S Block 1009, Block Group 1, Census Tract 601.01, Jessamine County, Kentucky 0 4.7821113 060101 2000 211130601012000 1000000US21113060101200C Block 2000, Block Group 2, Census Tract 601.01, Jessamine County, Kentucky 209 610.3421113 060101 2001 211130601012001 1000000US211130601012001 Block 2001, Block Group 2, Census Tract 601.01, Jessamine County, Kentucky 42 29.4621113 060400 1003 211130604001003 1000000US211130604001003 Block 1003, Block Group 1, Census Tract 604, Jessamine County, Kentucky 87 957.6221113 060400 1008 211130604001008 1000000US211130604001008 Block 1008, Block Group 1, Census Tract 604, Jessamine County, Kentucky 521 208.6121113 060400 1009 211130604001009 1000000US21113060400100S Block 1009, Block Group 1, Census Tract 604, Jessamine County, Kentucky 8 14.5921113 060400 1010 211130604001010 1000000US21113060400101C Block 1010, Block Group 1, Census Tract 604, Jessamine County, Kentucky 15 98.9921113 060400 2000 211130604002000 1000000US21113060400200C Block 2000, Block Group 2, Census Tract 604, Jessamine County, Kentucky 177 595.0221113 060400 2001 211130604002001 1000000US211130604002001 Block 2001, Block Group 2, Census Tract 604, Jessamine County, Kentucky 0 41.6021113 060400 2019 211130604002019 1000000US21113060400201S Block 2019, Block Group 2, Census Tract 604, Jessamine County, Kentucky 70 267.7021113 060400 2020 211130604002020 1000000US21113060400202C Block 2020, Block Group 2, Census Tract 604, Jessamine County, Kentucky 214 1933.6621113 060400 2021 211130604002021 1000000US211130604002021 Block 2021, Block Group 2, Census Tract 604, Jessamine County, Kentucky 15 80.3421113 060400 3000 211130604003000 1000000US21113060400300C Block 3000, Block Group 3, Census Tract 604, Jessamine County, Kentucky 24 1055.5321113 060400 3001 211130604003001 1000000US211130604003001 Block 3001, Block Group 3, Census Tract 604, Jessamine County, Kentucky 33 636.3621113 060400 3002 211130604003002 1000000US211130604003002 Block 3002, Block Group 3, Census Tract 604, Jessamine County, Kentucky 7 7.8921113 060400 3998 211130604003998 1000000US21113060400399S Block 3998, Block Group 3, Census Tract 604, Jessamine County, Kentucky 0 9.3321113 060600 1001 211130606001001 1000000US211130606001001 Block 1001, Block Group 1, Census Tract 606, Jessamine County, Kentucky 65 635.4721113 060600 1002 211130606001002 1000000US211130606001002 Block 1002, Block Group 1, Census Tract 606, Jessamine County, Kentucky 0 35.0321113 060600 1003 211130606001003 1000000US211130606001003 Block 1003, Block Group 1, Census Tract 606, Jessamine County, Kentucky 266 360.7921113 060600 1004 211130606001004 1000000US211130606001004 Block 1004, Block Group 1, Census Tract 606, Jessamine County, Kentucky 522 891.6821113 060600 1005 211130606001005 1000000US211130606001005 Block 1005, Block Group 1, Census Tract 606, Jessamine County, Kentucky 288 2045.0821113 060600 1006 211130606001006 1000000US21113060600100e Block 1006, Block Group 1, Census Tract 606, Jessamine County, Kentucky 15 165.5721113 060600 1007 211130606001007 1000000US211130606001007 Block 1007, Block Group 1, Census Tract 606, Jessamine County, Kentucky 0 350.7421113 060600 1008 211130606001008 1000000US211130606001008 Block 1008, Block Group 1, Census Tract 606, Jessamine County, Kentucky 0 3.2921113 060600 1009 211130606001009 1000000US21113060600100S Block 1009, Block Group 1, Census Tract 606, Jessamine County, Kentucky 10 13.8221113 060600 1010 211130606001010 1000000US21113060600101C Block 1010, Block Group 1, Census Tract 606, Jessamine County, Kentucky 42 1355.6221113 060600 1011 211130606001011 1000000US211130606001011 Block 1011, Block Group 1, Census Tract 606, Jessamine County, Kentucky 306 1701.2021113 060600 1012 211130606001012 1000000US211130606001012 Block 1012, Block Group 1, Census Tract 606, Jessamine County, Kentucky 47 81.0921113 060600 1013 211130606001013 1000000US211130606001013 Block 1013, Block Group 1, Census Tract 606, Jessamine County, Kentucky 8 7.1621113 060600 1014 211130606001014 1000000US211130606001014 Block 1014, Block Group 1, Census Tract 606, Jessamine County, Kentucky 5 224.1121113 060600 1015 211130606001015 1000000US211130606001015 Block 1015, Block Group 1, Census Tract 606, Jessamine County, Kentucky 35 196.0921113 060600 1016 211130606001016 1000000US2111306060010ie Block 1016, Block Group 1, Census Tract 606, Jessamine County, Kentucky 10 8.25

2000 Block Whole

21113 060600 1017 211130606001017 1000000US211130606001017 Block 1017, Block Group 1, Census Tract 606, Jessamine County, Kentucky 0 4.5721113 060600 1018 211130606001018 1000000US211130606001018 Block1018, BlockGroup 1, Census Tract 606, Jessamine County, Kentucky 9 13.8221113 060600 1019 211130606001019 1000000US21113060600101S Block1019, Block Group 1, Census Tract 606, Jessamine County, Kentucky 4 5.8221113 060600 1020 211130606001020 1000000US21113060600102C Block1020, BlockGroup 1, Census Tract 606, Jessamine County, Kentucky 0 5.5721113 060600 1021 211130606001021 1000000US211130606001021 Block 1021, Block Group 1, Census Tract 606, Jessamine County, Kentucky 112 66.7021113 060600 1022 211130606001022 1000000US211130606001022 Block 1022, Block Group 1, Census Tract 606, Jessamine County, Kentucky 118 68.9921113 060600 1023 211130606001023 1000000US211130606001023 Block 1023, Block Group 1, Census Tract 606, Jessamine County, Kentucky 32 17.10

21113 060600 1024 211130606001024 1000000US211130606001024 Block 1024, Block Group 1, Census Tract 606, Jessamine County, Kentucky 73 27.10





21113 060600 1029 211130606001029 1000000US21113060600102S Block 1029, Block Group 1, Census Tract 606, Jessamine County, Kentucky 10 11.95

21113 060600 1040 211130606001040 1000000US21113060600104C Block 1040, Block Group 1, Census Tract 606, Jessamine County, Kentucky 0 47.46










21113 060600 2006 211130606002006 1000000115211130606002006 Block 2006, Block Group 2, Census Tract 606, Jessamine County, Kentucky 37 513.31











2000 Block Whole



















J

2000 Block Split

FIPSSTCO

211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113211132111321113

TRACT2000

060101060101060101060101060101060101060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060600060600060600060600060600060600060600

BLOCK2000

100810082000200020012001100310031008100810091009101010102000200020002000200120012019201920192019300030001001100110261026102910292003

STFID

211130601011008211130601011008211130601012000211130601012000211130601012001211130601012001211130604001003211130604001003211130604001008211130604001008211130604001009211130604001009211130604001010211130604001010211130604002000211130604002000211130604002000211130604002000211130604002001211130604002001211130604002019211130604002019211130604002019211130604002019211130604003000211130604003000211130606001001211130606001001211130606001026211130606001026211130606001029211130606001029211130606002003

GEO id GEO displa

1000000US21113060101100(Block 1008, Block G1000000U521113060101100(Block 1008, Block G1000000US21113060101200(Block 2000, Block G1000000U521113060101200(Block 2000, Block G1000000U521113060101200:Block 2001, Block G1000000US21113060101200:Block 2001, Block G1000000US21113060400100:.Block 1003, Block G1000000US21113060400100(Block 1003, Block G1000000U521113060400100(Block 1008, Block G1000000U521113060400100(Block 1008, Block G1000000US21113060400100(Block 1009, Block G1000000US21113060400100

2000 Block Split

21113211132111321113211132111321113

060600060600060600060600060600060600060600

2003201220122015201520162016

211130606002003211130606002012211130606002012211130606002015211130606002015211130606002016211130606002016

1000000U521113060600200:-Block 2003, Block 61000000U521113060600201;Block 2012, Block 61000000U521113060600201;Block 2012, Block 61000000U521113060600201!Block 2015, Block 61000000US21113060600201!Block 2015, Block 61000000U521113060600201(Block 2016, Block 61000000US21113060600201lBlock 2016, Block 6

40 YES141 YES

20 NO0 NO0 YES0 NO0 YES

6002600260026002600260026002

612.341249.49

175.0412.219.70

14.552.32

2010 Block Whole

TRACTCE10

060101060101060101060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600

BLOCKCE10

3000400040041007100810091010101120002001200220032031300030033006300730081002100510061007100810091010101310141015101610171018101910201021102210231024102510261027102810291030103110321033

GEOID10

211130601013000211130601014000211130601014004211130604001007211130604001008211130604001009211130604001010211130604001011211130604002000211130604002001211130604002002211130604002003211130604002031211130604003000211130604003003211130604003006211130604003007211130604003008211130606001002211130606001005211130606001006211130606001007211130606001008211130606001009211130606001010211130606001013211130606001014211130606001015211130606001016211130606001017211130606001018211130606001019211130606001020211130606001021211130606001022211130606001023211130606001024211130606001025211130606001026211130606001027211130606001028211130606001029211130606001030211130606001031211130606001032211130606001033

NAME10

Block 3000Block 4000Block 4004Block 1007Block 1008Block 1009Block 1010Block 1011Block 2000Block 2001Block 2002

Block 2003Block 2031Block 3000Block 3003Block 3006Block 3007Block 3008Block 1002Block 1005Block 1006Block 1007Block 1008Block 1009Block 1010Block 1013Block 1014Block 1015Block 1016Block 1017Block 1018Block 1019Block 1020Block 1021Block 1022Block 1023Block 1024Block 1025Block 1026Block 1027Block 1028Block 1029Block 1030Block 1031Block 1032Block 1033

COUNTY

113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113

POP100 ACRES

53208. 34

382374818

302244

00

4075

480

3110

61100

31156

150

42570200

64413127140

5630

280045

910243

105

936.56661.9530.19

208.3632.43

270.40409.01288.72

1910.692.920.07

925.8777.67

1176.45753.86670.37

14.075.73

639.8927.0137.6063.7289.0222.354.01

2946.1519.8543.13

0.2421.9631.9418.0820.568.316.16

413.200.09

12.261.410.090.250.285.08

62.3815.56

177.97

2010 Block Whole

060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600

10341035103620002002200320102011201220132014201520162017201820192020202120222023202420252026202720282029203020312032203320342035203620372038203920402041204220432044204520462047204820492050

Block 1034Block 1035Block

1036'lock

2000Block 2002Block 2003Block 2010Block 2011Block 2012Block 2013Block 2014Block 2015Block 2016Block 2017Block 2018Block 2019Block 2020Block 2021Block 2022Block 2023Block 2024Block 2025Block 2026Block 2027Block 2028Block 2029Block 2030Block 2031Block 2032Block 2033Block 2034Block 2035Block 2036Block 2037Block 2038Block 2039Block 2040Block 2041Block 2042Block 2043Block 2044Block 2045Block 2046Block 2047Block 2048Block 2049Block 2050

211130606001034211130606001035211130606001036211130606002000211130606002002211130606002003211130606002010211130606002011211130606002012211130606002013211130606002014211130606002015211130606002016211130606002017211130606002018211130606002019211130606002020211130606002021211130606002022211130606002023211130606002024211130606002025211130606002026211130606002027211130606002028211130606002029211130606002030211130606002031211130606002032211130606002033211130606002034211130606002035211130606002036211130606002037211130606002038211130606002039211130606002040211130606002041211130606002042211130606002043211130606002044211130606002045211130606002046211130606002047211130606002048211130606002049211130606002050

113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113

0

22

68

75

5151

3130

10136170

1112

10920

0

02

92

218

093

0

000

27

073

25910

10400

18188

0

3060

7

000

2

0.1619.4231.45

1464.19276.82829.62

2135.935.78

912.2090.3583.65

1.4938.515.51

348.599.141.560.18

28.073.934.16

276.95675.90

0.12504.47

1.274.620.310.44

51.420.38

102.521111.07216.73695.42

8.004.41

214.57703.62

0.351408.21

0.1810.120.820.15

37.821.63

2010 Block Whole

060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600

20512052300030013002300330043005300630073008300930103011301230133014301530163017301830193020302130223023302430253026302730283029303030313032303330343035303630373038

211130606002051 Block 2051211130606002052 Block 2052211130606003000 Block 3000211130606003001 Block 3001211130606003002 Block 3002211130606003003 Block 3003211130606003004 Block 3004211130606003005 Block 3005211130606003006 Block 3006211130606003007 Block 3007211130606003008 Block 3008211130606003009 Block3009211130606003010 Block 3010211130606003011Block 3011211130606003012 Block 3012211130606003013 Block 3013211130606003014 Block 3014211130606003015 Block 3015211130606003016 Block 3016211130606003017 Block 3017211130606003018 Block 3018211130606003019 Block 3019211130606003020 Block 3020211130606003021 Block 3021211130606003022 Block 3022211130606003023 Block 3023211130606003024 Block 3024211130606003025 Block 3025211130606003026 Block 3026211130606003027 Block 3027211130606003028 Block3028211130606003029 Block 3029211130606003030 Block 3030211130606003031 Block 3031211130606003032 Block 3032211130606003033 Block 3033211130606003034 Block 3034211130606003035 Block3035211130606003036 Block 3036211130606003037 Block 3037211130606003038 Block 3038

113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113

956

352

0

0

0000

1511

130414

370000

0

0

0

042

22

35600

115

0

2360

00002

1507

0

85.23470.98

2027.130.223.990.230.720.24

12.68166.45367.62

1359.541692.72108.85

0.260.192.010.480.220.950.140.25

103.6688.48

2504.401.170.51

55.953.080.51

412.730.180.690.420.701.97

21.319.252.06

23.400.13

2010 Block Split

TRACTCE10

060101060101060101060101060101060101060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060400060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600060600

BLOCKCE10

300030004000400040044004100710071007100810081009100910101010101110112003200320033000300030033003100210021005100510131013200020002000200220022044204420492049

GEOID10 NAME10

21113060101300(Block 300021113060101300(Block 300021113060101400(Block 400021113060101400(Block 400021113060101400iBlock 400421113060101400iBlock 400421113060400100;Block100721113060400100;Block100721113060400100:Block100721113060400100(Block 100821113060400100(Block 100821113060400100!Block 100921113060400100!Block 100921113060400101(Block 101021113060400101(Block 101021113060400101:Block101121113060400101:Block101121113060400200:Block 200321113060400200(Block 200321113060400200:Block 200321113060400300(Block 300021113060400300(Block 300021113060400300!Block 300321113060400300:Block 300321113060600100;Block 100221113060600100;Block 100221113060600100!Block 100521113060600100!Block 100521113060600101:Block101321113060600101!Block 101321113060600200(Block 200021113060600200(Block 200021113060600200(Block 200021113060600200;Block 200221113060600200:Block200221113060600204iBlock 204421113060600204iBlock 204421113060600204!Block 204921113060600204!Block.2049

COUNTY

113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113113

48 NO5 YES

124 NO84 YES21 NO13 YES18 NO

7 NO

13 YES233 NO

4 YES47 YES

1 NO15 YES3 NO

170 NO132 YES231 YES158 NO18 YES42 NO

6 YES

0 NO0 YES

43 NO18 YES9 YES1 NO

251 YES174 NO

52 NO

1 YES22 YES51 YES0 NO

268 YES38 NO0 NO0 YES

101310131014101410141014400140014001400140014001400140014001400140014002400240024003400340034003600160016001600160016001600260026002600260026002600260026002

POP100 STUDYAREA B(ockGroup ACRES

852.1784.39

393.43268.52

19.0211.1898.8239.5669.9831.920.52

266.354.05

335.2473.77

162.31126.42526.31358.5041.06

1034.88141.56684.30

69.56447.61192.2824.972.04

1739.451206.701010.62

28.07425.50276.81

0.011232.54175.66

24.9212.90


Filed March 11,2015John G. Horne Request

Page 5 of15

Jessamine-South Elkhorn Water District

John G. Horne Re uest: Provide surveyed distance &om constructed tank position tc

Douglas, Hutchens aud Pelpbrey homes.

Answer: See attached exhibit.

[John G. Horne]

GRAPMIC SCALEt 1 = 100'

100 200NOTE TOI Or TANK ELFVAmm CuTS.TT WASEXTRAPOLATED FROM CENERIC CADD DRAINNGOSTATIED fROM CALDWELL TANKS. HIGH WATERLEVEL Ol'ANK IS 14S.GS'ROII TOP OfFOUNDAlloN. foUNDATION ELEVATION IS 1023.0.THERESV GIVING A TANK HBGHT OF'52.11 HALfOF THE TANK DIAMETER 1300 ADDED To TltrOVERALL TANK ltEIGHT To DEflNE THE MAXIMUMEXTENSION CIS2.13 If TltE TANK WAS PLACED CNITS SIDE.

SURVEY OI=

NEAREST RESIDENCESRELATIVE TO TANK SITE

JESSAMINE —SOUTPt ELKS ORNWATER DISTRICT

JESSAMINE COUNTY, KENTUCKY

Jessamine-South Eikhorn Water District


Filed March 11,2015John G. Horne Request

Page 6 of 15

John G.HorneRe uest: Provide itemization of $500,000.00+ in expenditures to

utilize the Switzer Site.

Answer: The following expenditures are all related to the construction of a new

storage tank at or near the currently proposed site. The Switzer site was acquired in 2004,

and all of the listed expenditures since that date have been incurred in the expectation that

the Switzer site would be used for the new water storage tank.

2005 Forest Hill upsize 6"—12",WO¹36832008 US-68 Relocation WO¹3671

~ 8"-12"Upsize US-68, Keene Manor/Harrods Hill~ 4"-6"Upsize Catnip Hill Pike~ 12"Parallel US-68, Catnip / Forest Hills~ 10"Parallel US-68, Barkley Woods / "Y"

2009 8"Parallel US-68, Catnip / Mathews, WO¹38452010 12"Loop tie Chinkapin / Catnip, WO¹38452011 6"Loop tie KY-169 / Rhineheimer, WO¹38652014 Northwest Hydraulic, WO¹3868

~ 4"—6" Catnip Pike upsize~ 4"—6" Rhineheimer upsize

$ 41,650

$ 19)100$ 14)810$ 85,940

$210,420$ 89,830$ 337978

$101,845

$ 31,375$ 35,675

Expenditures disclosed in Response No. 23 (a) and (c)-(f) ofJSEWD Response to Forest Hills Residents'ssociation, Inc.First Set of Requests for Information —Case No. 2012-00470 $ 74,059

Payments for engineering services: 2004-2011 (see Tab 7 hereinexcluding Capital Improvement Plan and System Development Charges) ~$371 932

TOTAL $1)110,614

[John G. Horne]


Filed March 11,2015L. Christopher Horne Request

Page 7 of 15


L. Christo her Horne Information Re uest: Provide dates that new water mains were

constructed into the Switzer site.

Answer: The 12" main from Chinkapin Drive past the Switzer Site to Catnip Hill

Road was completed in May of 2010.

[L.Christopher Horne]

KPSC Case No. 2014 - 000S4Post Hearing Data Requests


Page 11of 15


L. Christo her Horne Re uest: Provide date of last calibration of JSEWD KY Pipe

model before 2014 EPS study was submitted.

Answer: October of 2011.

P..Christopher Horne]



Page S of 15


L. Christo her Horne Re uest: Provide differences between the 2012 EPS Study and

the 2014 EPS Study.

Answer:

1. As compared to the 2012 Study, there is one additional pipe and one

additional node in the 2014 analysis. The reason for this is because altitude valve AV-2 was

added at the base of Tank B. This altitude valve was added because the model includes

telemetry controls (control switches) at the proposed tank (Tank C) whereas telemetry was

modeled at Tank B in 2012. Adding the new altitude valve created one additional pipe and

one additional node with no additional demand. The new node is AV-2 and the new pipe is

338.

2. In the Data Summary, the section titled Output Option Data lists a group of

pipes and nodes in the 2014 analysis that differ from the list in the 2012 analysis. This list

of pipes and nodes identify all of those that were chosen for limited output. This means that

the pipes and nodes listed will have results printed for each case in a full output report

This group of pipes and nodes were changed from the 2012 analysis in order to give better

insight into how the system is performing. This change has absolutely no effect on any

calculation or result.



Page 9 of 15

3. In the 2014 model, one additional point on the pump curve data was added.

The additional point is taken from the identical pump curve that was used in 2012. The

additional data point was for 21 feet of head at 1300 gpm and 55% efficiency. This

provides more accurate simulation of the pumps performance when it is running at high

capacity.

4. The Global Demand Factor (GDF) in the 2012 model was set at 0.67. GDF is

a percentage that is applied to all demands across the district equally in order to adjust the

total system demand to a desired value. The total system demand of 516.43 gpm is the

average flow rate for the year 2010 based on the daily telemetry report for that year.

Applymg the GDF of 0.67 yielded a total system demand of 511.99gpm. If the GDF had

been set to 0.68 it would have resulted in a total system demand greater than 519 gpm.

Therefor in the 2014 model, the GDF was set at 0.675823 in order to arrive at a total system

demand of 516.43. This change in GDF is an adjustment of less than one percent, therefore

demands for all nodes in the system were adjusted by the same miniscule percentage. This

results in a more precise simulation of the average total system demand reported by

telemetry for the year 2010.

5. The telemetry control settings in the 2014 model have been moved from Tank

B to Tank C. The control switch elevations have been changed to more accurately reflect

the settings actually used by the water district.



Page 10 of 15

6. The initial elevation of the water level of the tanks was changed for 2014

because the control switch levels have been raised. This was done in order to have an

initial water level between the control switch settings.

7. The tank diameter was changed from a 1 million gallon tank to a 750,000

gallon tank.

P..Christopher Horne]

10


Filed March 11,2015L. Nicholas Strong Request

Page 12 of 15


L. Nicholas Stron Re uest: Provide engineering services and project administration

contracts related to proposed tank construction project and the compensation paid to Horne

Engineering, Inc. ("HEI"), thereunder and otherwise for the project.

Answer: The Agreement for Engineering Services, dated July 2, 2014, can be

found in the JSEWD Supplemental Responses to Forest Hills Residents'ssociation, Inc.'s

Information Requests filed on November 12, 2014. The initial project administrator

contracts for the $440,000.00 in grants, all dated August 10, 2010, can be found in JSEWD

Responses to Forest Hills Residents'ssociation, Inc.'s Requests for Information served

October 13, 2014 at response to Request No. 25. The initial project administrator contract

for the $1,000,000.00 grant, dated August 10, 2010, is attached. All of these contracts were

later amended by the contract attached and dated June 27, 2014.

No compensation has been paid to HEI as project administrator. See attached for

the amounts paid to HEI for its engineering work on this project.

[L.Nicholas Strong]

12

Horne Engineering, Inc.216 SOUTH MAIN STREET ~ NICHOLASVILLE,KEVMCKY 40356 ~ (859)885-9+f1 ~ FAX ((159)885-5160

ENGINEERS ~ LAND SURVEYORS ~ PLANNERSeroaili hoiueent.corn

August 10,2010

Nick Strong, Chairman

Jessamine South Elkhom Water District

3520 Keene Road

Nicholasville, KY i(0356

Re: Professional Service AgreementKentucky Infrasnucture Authority

WX21113016GearirIDi 29N- 008

Catnip Hill Pike 1.0MG

Elevated Storage Tank

Dear Mr. Suongi

This is a Professional Service Agreement between Jessamine-South Ekhorn Water District„

(hereinafter referred to as "JSEWD") and Home Engineering, Inc. (her~ referred to as HEI),whereas HEI shall act on behalf ofJSEWD as PROJECT ADMNISTRATOR for the above referenced

PROJECT,, under the requirement of rhe Kentucky Infrastructure Authonty, (hereinafter referred roas KIA).

Both parties mutually agree that the services provided by HEI are professional in nature and as

such, are not required for advertisement or bidding as exempted under KRS 424.260(1).JSEWD agreesto pay HEI the smn. of $50,000, based on periodic invoices to be billed at the following percentage ofcompletion of the hereinafter phases.

20% Bid Opening

50% Half Point of Construction90% Punch List Inspection

100% Project.Completion

All invoices are due, net 304ays. It is understocd that monies paid shall be reimbursed by KIA.

It is mutually understood that either party may terminate this agreement at any time jjpon thirty(30) day written notice to the other party. In the event of termination, JSEWD shall pay HEI for any .

unbilled services based on the percentage of completion a's of the date of notice. Either party to thisagreement, or KIA, may propose amendments to this agreement should the need arise, in which case,the mutually agreed amendment shall be reduced to writing and executed by all concerned parties.

This Agreement shall be in force beginning the last date of si'gnatory and shall remain h forceand effect until completion, unless it is otherwise terminated or amended.

JESSAMINE-SOUTH ELKHORN WATER DISTRICT HORNE'ENGINEERING, INC.

By:

L; Nicholas Strong, Chairman

D,tre ~'~ > Date:

y'w ~ ~WITNESS:

L ~s~Ma~~~

QAprcjccr Dir'jr ee4WO356prpre 6cricecjacrviccA ~rJSEWD-Kl A.lrr

Horne Engineering, Inc.Z16 SOUTH MAIN STREET ~ NICHOLASVILLE, KENTUCKY 40356PH. (859)8859441 ~ FAX (859)885-5160email@ loroeefg.cdeiie

ENGINEERS

LAND SURVEYORSPLANNERS

June 27, 2014

Nick StrongJessamine South Elkhorn Water District3520 Keene RoadNicholasville, KY 40356

Dear Mr. Strong:

Rei Amended Professional Service Agreement

Kentuclcy Infrastructure AuthorityWX21113016Grant IDI 229N.2008Catnip Hill Pike 0.75 MG ElevatedStorage Tank

On August 11, 2010, Home Engineering, Inc. (HEI) and JessamineSourh Elkhorn WaterDistrict (JSEWD) entered into an agreement whereas HEI is, to serve as Project Administrator for theCatnip, Hill Pike Elevated Tank This document serves to amend that agreement per the following:

A~del -A d ' d e f$3$O,ODD f d d G ID.33$30iewhich was transferred to this project and will be combined with Grant ID 229N-2008.

Amendment ij2 —The tank size has been redefined to 0.75 MG in lieu of the 1.0MG, originally.

These are the only two (2) amendments and although an increase in the grant amount,compensation shall remain unchanged.

DISTRICT HORNE ENGINEERING, INC.

ide

Date Date

JGH/jtenc.

0:KProjdorrflr'jeowdNWO$ 0$93deooevdddo mAgreemmcjrrdocx

Payment for Professional ServicesHorne Engineering, Inc. for Switzer Site

Z004 Property survey, platting and property acquisition $ 8,901.25

Z005.2006 Capital Improvement Plan R System DevelopmentCharges

$ 27,905.81

2011

2012-2014 PSC Hearing for CPCN

Z014 Design 0.75 MG Tank

20142015 PSC Hearing for CPCN

1.0MG Tank Topographic Survey and Design $ 166,600.70

$ 102,411.77

$ 67,995.00

$ 26,024.20


Filed March 11,2015L. Nicholas Strong Request

Page 13 of 15


L. Nicholas Stron Re uest: Provide a breakdown of all expenditures trom the

$1,000,000.00 grant from the Kentucky General Assembly for this project.

Answer: The total sum of $105,000.00 has been disbursed from the

$1,000,000.00 grant. $5,000.00 was disbursed to the Kentucky Infrastructure Authority for

administrative services and the sum of $100,000.00 has been taken by JSEWD as a

reimbursement for engineering services previously paid to HEI.s

[L.Nicholas Strong]

This same information was provided in the JSEWD Supplemental Responses to Forest HillsResidents'ssociation,

Inc.'s Information Requests Gled on November 12, 2014.

13

VERIFICATION

The undersigned being duly sworn, depose and say that they have personal knowledge ofthe matters set forth in the foregoing responses for which they are the identified witness and thatthe information contained therein is true and correct to the best of their information, knowledgeand belief.

COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY

COUNTY OF JESSAMINE, SCT...

Acknowledged, subscribed and sworn to me, a Notary Public in and before said County

and State by L. Nicholas Strong, John G. Horne, L. Christopher Horne and Dallam B. Harper,Jr. this the lOIO day of March, 2015.

14

Respectfully submitted,

Anthony G. Martin,'sq.P.O. Box 1812Lexington, KY 40588

Bruce E. Smith, Esq.Henry E. Smith, Esq.201 South Main SneetNicholasville, Kentucky 40356

OUNSEL FOR DISTRICT

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE:I hereby certify that the foregoing Jessamine-South Elkhom Water District's Responses to

Forest Hills Residents'ssociation, Inc.'s First Requests for Information with exhibits wasserved by first class mail, postage prepaid and by e-mail with exhibits, this the 10th day ofMarch, 2015, to:

Robert M. Watt, III, Esq.Monica H. Braun, Esq.Stoll Keenon Ogden, PLLC

300 West Vine Street, Ste. 2100Lexington, KY 40507-1801robert. wattskofirm.cornmonica.braun@skofirm. corn

Jennifer Black Hans, Esq.

Gregory T. Dutton, Esq.Stefanie Kingsley, Esq.Assistant Attorneys General

1024 Capital Center Drive, Suite 200

Frankfort, KY 40601-8204

[email protected]. gov

g:I...IISEWD'purest Hillsl App No. 2/Post Hearing Info Req/Response to Post Hearing Data Requests 030915

15

201 11 - kentuckypsc.ky.gov/pscscf/2014 cases/2014-00084/20150311...mar 11, 2015 · kpsc case no....

Documents