13-53846-swr doc 5354 filed 06/17/14 entered 06/17/14 15 ... · edward j. gudeman...

13-53846-swr Doc 5354 Filed 06/17/14 Entered 06/17/14 15:13:39 of 8

UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF MICHIGAN

In re:

City of Detroit, Michigan

Case No.13-53846__________________________Debtors____/ Hon. Steven W. Rhodes

Chapter 9

NOTICE AND OPPORTUNITY FOR HEARING

PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that the attached Debtors Motion MOTION FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION OF PROOFS OF CLAIMS ## 2638, 2651, 2654, 2659, 2676, 2689 and 2692 has been filed in accordance with Local Bankruptcy Rule 9014-1 (E.D.M.). Pursuant to the rule, you have fourteen (14) days after service to file and serve a response or a request for a hearing.

YOUR RIGHTS MAY BE AFFECTED

PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE that unless a written objection is filed within fourteen (14) days from the date of this Notice, the Court may, upon presentation of an Order by the applicant, grant the relief requested consistent with the provisions of 11 U.S.C. 102, and L.B.R. 9014-1 (E.D.M.), without a hearing.

PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE that if a timely written objection in the form of a pleading is filed with the Clerk of the Court and served upon the Movant, the Court shall send a Notice of the date set for hearing on the objection1. The address of the Court is:

CLERK, U.S. Bankruptcy Court17th Floor

211 West FortDetroit MI 48226

PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE that any response or request for hearing must be served electronically or upon the following address:

KURT THORNBLADH, Esq.Attorney for Debtor7301 SchaeferDearborn MI 48126

U.S.Trustee7th Floor211 W. Fort StreetDetroit MI 48226

For the Movants:

Dated: June 17, 2014 ___/s/kthornbladh____________________KURT THORNBLADH P25858THORNBLADH LEGAL GROUP PLLC7301 SchaeferDearborn MI 48126(313) 943 [email protected]

Exhibit "2"1 Response or answer must comply with F.R.Civ.P. 8(b), (c), and (e).

13-53846-swr Doc 5354-1 Filed 06/17/14 Entered 06/17/14 15:13:39 Page 1 of 1

UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURTEASTERN DISTRICT OF MICHIGAN

SOUTHERN DIVISION - DETROITIN RE:

City of Detroit, Michigan CHAPTER 9 CASE NO. 13-53846

Debtor(s) JUDGE Steven W. Rhodes_________________________________________/

BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF MOTION

I. FACTS:

The Creditors, Hyde Park Cooperative, Plymouth Square Ltd Housing Association, Cambridge Tower Association, Ltd. H.A., Millender Center Associates L.P. and Village Center Assoc. Ltd. Div. H.A., for their memorandum of law rely upon the facts as stated in the Motion for Class Certification filed concurrently.

II. FACTS

SHOULD THE COURT GRANT CLASS CERTIFICATION OF THE ENUMERATED PROOFS OF CLAIM?

The Creditors say "yes".

In its Objection to Duplicate Claims the City says "yes it should".

III. AUTHORITY

The Creditors rely upon the application of law to fact as discussed in the Motion for Class Certification of Proofs of Claim.

IV. PRAYER FOR RELIEF

Wherefore the Creditors ask the Court to grant class certification of their Proofs of Claim.

FOR THE CREDITORS:/s/kurt thornbladh KURT THORNBLADH P25858Thornbladh Legal Group PLLC 7301 Schaefer Dearborn MI 48126 (313) 943 2678 [email protected] P25858

Dated: 5/30/2014 P25858Exhibit "3"



DETROIT DIVISION

IN RE:

City of Detroit, Michigan

Debtor(s).

) ) ) ) ) ) )

BANKRUPTCY NO. 13-53846

Chapter 11

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I hereby certify that on June 17, 2014 I electronically filed MOTION FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION OF PROOF OF CLAIMS ## 2638, 2651, 2654, 2659, 2676, 2683, 2689 and 2692 with the Clerk of the Court using the ECF system which will send notification of such filing to the following:

Elizabeth M. Abood-Carroll [email protected], [email protected] Daniel N. Adams [email protected], [email protected] Sam J. Alberts [email protected], [email protected] Carla Orman Andres [email protected] Mark A. Angelov [email protected] Charles N. Ash [email protected], [email protected] Karin F. Avery [email protected] Nabih H. Ayad [email protected] Allison Bach [email protected] Jason W. Bank [email protected] Paige E. Barr [email protected] Robert N. Bassel [email protected], [email protected] Kevin M. Baum [email protected] Dirk H. Beckwith [email protected] Michael R. Bell [email protected] Bruce Bennett [email protected] Ryan Blaine Bennett [email protected], [email protected];[email protected];[email protected];[email protected];[email protected] Ryan Blaine Bennett [email protected],[email protected], [email protected];[email protected];[email protected];[email protected];[email protected] Ryan Blaine Bennett [email protected],[email protected],[email protected],[email protected], [email protected];[email protected];[email protected];[email protected];[email protected] Douglas C. Bernstein [email protected], [email protected] Brendan G. Best [email protected], [email protected] Jeffrey H. Bigelman [email protected], [email protected] William C. Blasses [email protected] Brett A. Border [email protected], [email protected] Winnifred P. Boylan [email protected] Randall A. Brater [email protected] Mark E. Bredow [email protected], [email protected] Allan S. Brilliant [email protected] Lynn M. Brimer [email protected], [email protected] Charles D. Bullock [email protected], [email protected];[email protected] Judy B. Calton [email protected], [email protected]


Judy B. Calton [email protected],[email protected], [email protected] Peter L. Canzano [email protected] Eric D. Carlson [email protected] Julia A. Caroff [email protected], [email protected];[email protected];[email protected] Corey M. Carpenter [email protected], [email protected] Amy D. Caton [email protected], [email protected] Babette A. Ceccotti [email protected] Thomas P. Christy [email protected] Tracy M. Clark [email protected], [email protected] Mary Beth Cobbs [email protected], [email protected] Ryan Cochran [email protected] Carol Connor Cohen [email protected] Dawn R. Copley [email protected], [email protected] Sean M. Cowley (UST) [email protected] Elliot G. Crowder [email protected], [email protected] Robert Darnell [email protected] Hugh M. Davis [email protected] Peter D. Dechiara [email protected] Shannon L. Deeby [email protected] Melissa L. Demorest [email protected], [email protected] M. Ellen Dennis [email protected],[email protected] Robert J. Diehl [email protected] Karen B. Dine [email protected] Tamar Dolcourt [email protected] Mercedes Varasteh Dordeski [email protected],[email protected] David L. Dubrow [email protected] Ethan D. Dunn [email protected], [email protected] Jeffrey David Eaton [email protected] John E. Eaton [email protected], [email protected] David Eisenberg [email protected] Caroline Turner English [email protected] Earle I. Erman [email protected] Barry S. Fagan [email protected] Sherrie L. Farrell [email protected], [email protected];[email protected] Evan Justin Feldman [email protected] Lisa Hill Fenning [email protected] Robert Fetter [email protected], [email protected];[email protected];[email protected];[email protected] Mallory Field [email protected], [email protected] Jamie Scott Fields [email protected] Joseph M. Fischer [email protected], [email protected] Deborah L. Fish [email protected], [email protected] Joseph Mark Fisher [email protected] Robert M. Fishman [email protected] Steven B. Flancher [email protected] Vanessa G. Fluker [email protected], [email protected] Mark S. Frankel [email protected] Brendan H. Frey [email protected], [email protected] Timothy A. Fusco [email protected] Eric B. Gaabo [email protected] Joshua A. Gadharf [email protected] Niraj R. Ganatra [email protected] Andrew J. Gerdes [email protected],[email protected],[email protected], [email protected] Rozanne M. Giunta [email protected] Stuart A. Gold [email protected] Jerome D. Goldberg [email protected] William H. Goodman [email protected] Robert D. Gordon [email protected], [email protected] Jeffrey S. Grasl [email protected], [email protected] Timothy R. Graves [email protected], [email protected] Jonathan S. Green [email protected] John T. Gregg [email protected] Christopher A. Grosman [email protected], [email protected] Stephen M. Gross [email protected], [email protected] Stephen B. Grow [email protected], [email protected]


Edward J. Gudeman [email protected], [email protected] Raymond Guzall [email protected] Stephen C. Hackney [email protected] Paul R. Hage [email protected], [email protected] Paula A. Hall [email protected], [email protected];[email protected] Michael C. Hammer [email protected] Howard R. Hawkins [email protected], [email protected];[email protected];[email protected] David Gilbert Heiman [email protected] Robert S. Hertzberg [email protected], [email protected];[email protected] Steven G. Howell [email protected] Marshall S. Huebner [email protected] Charles Bruce Idelsohn [email protected], [email protected] Mark R. James [email protected] William W. Kannel [email protected] John P. Kapitan [email protected] Michael Anthony Karman [email protected] Michael Joseph Karwoski [email protected] Mami Kato [email protected], [email protected] Richardo I. Kilpatrick [email protected], [email protected] Susheel Kirpalani [email protected], [email protected] Scott B. Kitei [email protected] Anthony J. Kochis [email protected], [email protected];[email protected];[email protected];[email protected] Samuel S. Kohn [email protected], [email protected];[email protected];[email protected] Dan Korobkin [email protected] Deborah Kovsky-Apap [email protected], [email protected] Kay Standridge Kress [email protected], [email protected] Stephen S. LaPlante [email protected], [email protected] Patrick C. Lannen [email protected], [email protected] Lawrence A. Larose [email protected], [email protected];[email protected];[email protected];[email protected] Caralyce M. Lassner [email protected] Michael S. Leib [email protected], [email protected] David E. Lemke [email protected] Heather Lennox [email protected] David A. Lerner [email protected], [email protected] Richard Levin [email protected], [email protected] Sharon L. Levine [email protected] David T. Lin [email protected], [email protected] Ronald C. Liscombe [email protected] William Norman Listman [email protected] Sara Klettke MacWilliams [email protected], [email protected] Richard G. Mack [email protected], [email protected] Elias T. Majoros [email protected] Carolyn Beth Markowitz [email protected] Donald G. McGuigan [email protected] Patrick E. Mears [email protected] Leah Montesano [email protected] Claude D. Montgomery [email protected],[email protected], [email protected];[email protected] Claude D. Montgomery [email protected], [email protected];[email protected] Thomas R. Morris [email protected], [email protected] Wolfgang Mueller [email protected], [email protected] Harold E. Nelson [email protected] Fred Neufeld [email protected] Carole Neville [email protected],[email protected] Carole Neville [email protected] Karen Vivian Newbury [email protected] Max J. Newman [email protected] Kenneth E. Noble [email protected], [email protected] Eric David Novetsky [email protected] Sandra L. O'Connor [email protected] Brian D. O'Keefe [email protected], [email protected] Arthur O'Reilly [email protected], [email protected]


Lisa Okasinski [email protected] Noah J. Ornstein [email protected] Alidz Oshagan [email protected], [email protected] Yuliy Osipov [email protected], [email protected];[email protected] Michael R. Paslay [email protected], [email protected];[email protected];[email protected];[email protected];[email protected];[email protected] Barbara A. Patek [email protected] Andrew A. Paterson [email protected], [email protected] Geoffrey T. Pavlic [email protected], [email protected] Randall A. Pentiuk [email protected], [email protected] Alfredo R. Perez [email protected],[email protected],[email protected],[email protected],[email protected] Alfredo R. Perez [email protected],[email protected],[email protected],[email protected],[email protected],[email protected],[email protected] Heidi Peterson [email protected] Ryan Plecha [email protected], [email protected] Leland Prince [email protected] Thomas B. Radom [email protected] A. Stephen Ramadan [email protected] John Joseph Ramirez [email protected] H. Nathan Resnick [email protected], [email protected] Peter J. Roberts [email protected] Kimberly Joan Robinson [email protected] Richard A. Roble (UST) [email protected] Louis P. Rochkind [email protected], [email protected] Courtney M. Rogers [email protected] Ronald L. Rose [email protected] Eric Rosenberg [email protected], [email protected] Heath Douglas Rosenblat [email protected], [email protected];[email protected] Jeffrey Rossman [email protected] Jeffrey Rossman [email protected],[email protected],[email protected] Craig B. Rule [email protected], [email protected] Edward Todd Sable [email protected], [email protected] Kenneth M. Schneider [email protected] Matthew Schneider [email protected] Joseph R. Sgroi [email protected], [email protected] Mark H. Shapiro [email protected], [email protected] Howard S. Sher [email protected] John P. Sieger [email protected] Jeffery R. Sieving [email protected] John A. Simon [email protected] Jill Kristen Smith [email protected] William Pfeiffer Smith [email protected] James Sprayregen [email protected] Douglas Steele [email protected] Kevin N. Summers [email protected], [email protected];[email protected] Matthew Gernet Summers [email protected] Marc N. Swanson [email protected] Meredith Taunt [email protected], [email protected] Ralph A. Taylor [email protected] Julie Beth Teicher [email protected] Kurt Thornbladh [email protected], [email protected] My Chi To [email protected], [email protected] Sheryl L. Toby [email protected], [email protected] Sheldon S. Toll [email protected], [email protected] Matthew Troy [email protected] Brian R. Trumbauer [email protected] Suzanne L. Wahl [email protected], [email protected];[email protected];[email protected];[email protected] Scott M. Watson [email protected] Daniel J. Weiner [email protected] Robert A. Weisberg [email protected], [email protected] William A. Wertheimer [email protected]


Benjamin J. Wilensky [email protected] Matthew Wilkins [email protected], [email protected] Angela Williams [email protected], [email protected] Jeremiah Buffalo Wirgau [email protected] Scott A. Wolfson [email protected],[email protected],[email protected], [email protected];[email protected];[email protected] Stephen Wolpert [email protected] David M. Zack [email protected], [email protected];[email protected];[email protected];[email protected] Trevor J. Zamborsky [email protected], [email protected] Jennifer Zbytowski Belveal [email protected], [email protected] Craig E. Zucker [email protected]

And I hereby certified that I have mailed by United States Postal Service the Paper(s) to the following non-ECF participants:Due to the numerousity of the parties to the matrix, the Creditors have only filed this Motion electronically.

Date: June 17, 2014/s/ Kurt ThornbladhAttorney for Creditors in the MotionKurt Thornbladh P25858Thornbladh Legal Group PLLC7301 Schaefer 48532(313) [email protected]

Exhibit "4"



In the matter of:

City of Detroit, Michigan Case No. 13-53846Chapter 9

_______________________Debtor______/ Hon. Steven W. Rhodes

AFFIDAVIT

State of Michigan ))SS .

County of Wayne )

KURT THORNBLADH, first being duly sworn, deposes and says as follows:

1. I am Counsel for the Creditors named in the Motion for Class Certification of Proof of

Claims ## 2638, 2651, 2654, 2659, 2676, 2683, 2689 and 2692.

2. The statements made in the Motion for Class Certification are true and correct to the best of my

information and belief, based upon an investigation of the facts made by me and by co-counsel in

this Motion.

3. The documentary exhibits attached hereto are complete and accurate copies of the original

documents.

Further your affiant says not.

__/s/_KURT THORNBLADH____________KURT THORNBLADH

Subscribed and sworn to before meon May 30, 2014.___/s/_hawraa al-aridhiHAWRAA AL-ARIDHI, NOTARY PUBLICWayne County, MichiganMy Commission Expires: January 19, 2017Acting for Wayne County


13-53846-swr doc 5354 filed 06/17/14 entered 06/17/14 15 ... · edward j. gudeman...

Documents