101 - pete marks - dha it overview briefing - fedinsider · pdf...

21
Medically Ready Force…Ready Medical Force Medically Ready Force…Ready Medical Force 1 Desktop to Datacenter (D2D) Overview: A converged infrastructure for DoD health care integration Peter V. Marks, PhD COO, Defense Health Agency Infrastructure and Operations Defense Health Agency

Upload: dobao

Post on 13-Mar-2018

220 views

Category:

Documents


3 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing - FedInsider · PDF file“Medically)Ready)ForceReady)Medical)Force ... 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing

“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force” 1

Desktop  to  Datacenter  (D2D)  Overview:A  converged  infrastructure  for  DoD  health  care  integration

Peter  V.  Marks,  PhDCOO,  Defense  Health  Agency  Infrastructure  and  Operations

Defense  Health  Agency

Page 2: 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing - FedInsider · PDF file“Medically)Ready)ForceReady)Medical)Force ... 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing

“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”

∎ The  MHS  Genesis  deployment∎ The  value  proposition  for  infrastructure  consolidation∎ How  complex  is  the  environment?∎ What  IT  services  will  be  consolidated?∎ Focused  on  metrics  for  the  business

Agenda

2

Page 3: 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing - FedInsider · PDF file“Medically)Ready)ForceReady)Medical)Force ... 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing

“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”3

To  efficiently  improve  healthcare  for  the  active  duty  military,  veterans  and  beneficiaries  by:

• Establishing  seamless  medical  data  sharing  between  DoD,  the  VA  and  the  private  sector

• Modernizing  the  Electronic  Health  Record  (EHR)  for  the  Military  Health  System  (MHS  Genesis)  

Defense  Healthcare  Management  Systems  (DHMS)  Mission:  

Page 4: 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing - FedInsider · PDF file“Medically)Ready)ForceReady)Medical)Force ... 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing

“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”

Modernization History

2009EHR  Way  Ahead  

2010iEHR  

2013DHMSM  Kick-­‐Off  

2015Contract  Awardfor  MHS  Genesis

2006AHLTA  Fielding  Complete  

“I  walk  slowly,  but  I  never  walk  backward.”-­‐ President  Abraham  Lincoln

4

Page 5: 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing - FedInsider · PDF file“Medically)Ready)ForceReady)Medical)Force ... 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing

“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”

Why  Modernize?

5

Page 6: 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing - FedInsider · PDF file“Medically)Ready)ForceReady)Medical)Force ... 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing

“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”

EHR  Modernization  Guiding  Principles

6

Standardization  of  clinical  and  business  processes  across  the  Services  and  the  MHS

Design  a  patient-­‐centric  system  focusing  on  quality,  safety,  and  patient  outcomes  that  meet  readiness  objectives

Flexible   and  open,  single  enterprise  solution  that  addresses  both  garrison  and  operational  healthcare

Clinical   business  process  reengineering,  adoption,  and  implementation  over  technology

Configure  not  customize

Decisions  shall  be  based  on  doing  what  is  best  for  the  MHS  as  a  whole  – not  a  single  individual  area

Decision-­‐making  and  design  will   be  driven  by  frontline  care  delivery  professionals

Drive  toward  rapid  decision  making  to  keep  the  program  on  time  and  on  budget

Provide  timely  and  complete  communication,  training,  and  tools  to  ensure  a  successful  deployment

Build  collaborative  partnerships  outside  the  MHS  to  advance  national  interoperability

Enable  full  patient  engagement  in  their  health

Page 7: 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing - FedInsider · PDF file“Medically)Ready)ForceReady)Medical)Force ... 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing

“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”

EXAMPLE

#2 TEXT

HEREsupporting

text

MORE TEXT

Single  DoD  Electronic  Health  RecordGuiding   Principle:  A  flexible  and  open,   single  enterprise  solution   for  

both  garrison and  operational healthcare.

7

Page 8: 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing - FedInsider · PDF file“Medically)Ready)ForceReady)Medical)Force ... 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing

“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”

DHMSM  Initial  Operational  Capability  Sites

8

Washington

92ND Medical  Group  &  

Aeromedical  DEN  SQ/SGD

Naval  Hospital  Oak  Harbor

NHCL  Everett

Naval  Hospital  Bremerton

NBHC  Sub-­‐base  Bangor

Puyallup  Medical  Home

Madigan  AMC

Page 9: 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing - FedInsider · PDF file“Medically)Ready)ForceReady)Medical)Force ... 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing

“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”

Value  Proposition:  The  D2D  Solution

Standardization

D2D  is  vital  to  removing  sources  of  variance  that  undermine   efforts  to  implement standard  clinical  capabilities  and  workflows   .    Through  standardization  of  the  desktop,   end-­‐to-­‐end   control  of  the  network,  and  centralization  of  a  supporting   infrastructure,  D2D  will  achieve  the  operational  efficiency  required  to  support  DHMSM.

Operational  Efficiency

Through  selection  of  the  appropriate  architecture,  reduction  in  unused  or  duplicative  resources  and  the  leveraging  of  economies   of  scale  across  enterprise  procurement  D2D  will  achieve  improved  service  levels  and  reduced  costs  for  IT  infrastructure.

Achievement  of  Medical  Mission

D2D  will  provide   a  platform  that  allows  providers   and  beneficiaries   to  access  health  records,  move  seamlessly,   and  exchange  health  information  across  the  enterprise.  

D2D enables the medical mission to be achieved through a platform that allows providers to access systems, moveseamlessly, and exchangehealth information andmedical records across theenterprise.D2D provides the programmatic and architectural detail to support the key HIT objectives in support of the ITinfrastructure readiness: cost savings, operationalefficiency, and achievement of themedical mission.

9

Page 10: 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing - FedInsider · PDF file“Medically)Ready)ForceReady)Medical)Force ... 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing

“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”

Army          Navy          Air  Force          Marines

The  Complexity  (CONUS  only)

10

Page 11: 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing - FedInsider · PDF file“Medically)Ready)ForceReady)Medical)Force ... 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing

“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”

Large  Organizations  Standardize…

11

Standardization  Supports:

Effectiveness  

Agility

Cost  Efficiency

Quality

Page 12: 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing - FedInsider · PDF file“Medically)Ready)ForceReady)Medical)Force ... 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing

“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”

Health  IT  Standardization:  Proven  Successes

12

Size 177,445 employees,  38  hospitals,  serving  10.1  million  members

16,500  employees,  5  hospitals,  serving  2  million  patients

40,000 employees,  22  hospitals,  185  clinics  serving  750,000  SelectHealthmembers  and  over  1.5  million  patients

eHR Deployment

Completed  10-­‐year  roll-­‐out  of  largest  civilian  eHR in  US  history,  using  EPIC-­‐based  system  KP  HealthConnect.  Encompasses desktop  standardization,  datacenter  management  and  network  integration*

Completed  two-­‐year,  multi-­‐phase  go-­‐live  of  the  completed  EPIC  eHR suite  in  2012,  EpicCare,  across  hospitalnetwork  to  include  a  standard  desktop  and  centrally  managed  network

iCentra rollout  began in  January  2015  and  continued  in  October.  Tool  integrates  350  custom  products,  data  center  management,  eHRmanagement,  and  revenue  cycle  system*

Results

Credited  with:• Financial  savings  across  

infrastructurenetwork,  one  region  saved over  $1.4m  on  printexpenses   alone

• 54% reduction  in  archival  storage  space  translated  to  $200,000  savings  in  one  year**

• Awarded  HIMSS  Analytics  Stage  7  Award  in  2011+

2014  financial  statements  show:• .1%  decrease   in  operating  costs  in  

first  six  months  of  financial  year• A  decrease   in  Epic-­‐supported  eHR

IT  staff• Increase  in  end-­‐user  satisfaction**

By  the  end  of  2015,  rollout  using  Agile  methodology  tool  was  complete  at  4  hospitals  and  over  60  clinics.  Further  rollouts  by  region  are  planned  throughout  2016.

*Case  Study:  Inova Health  System  relies  CTG  Post-­‐implementation  helpdesk  solution**Modern  HealthCare.com

*Kaiser  Permanente:  It  takes  more  than  an  eHR to  be  most  wired**HIMSS  Analytics:  Case  Studies+PR  Newswire:  Kaiser  Permanente  Honored  for  eHRimplementation

*Sloan  Review:Case Study:  When  healthcare  gets  a  healthy  dose  of  data**Intermountain  Physician:  Med  Staff  News:  Dec  2015

Page 13: 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing - FedInsider · PDF file“Medically)Ready)ForceReady)Medical)Force ... 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing

“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”

Gartner:  The  Vital  Role  of  Standardized  Infrastructure  for  Healthcare  Organizations

13

“Gartner  IT  Key  Metrics  Data  (ITKMD)  demonstrate  that  IT  staff  productivity  clearly  increases  as  the  variability  of  infrastructure  in  an  organization  decreases.  As  such,  most  healthcare  organizations  are  standardizing  their  infrastructure  environment  to  support  not  only  cost  savings  but,  also,  IT  efficiency  for  organizations.”

“Gartner’s  analysis  strongly  suggests  that  through  2018,  at  least  70  percent  of  large-­‐scale  enterprises  can  reduce  I&O  “run”  total  cost-­‐of-­‐ownership  by  25  percent  or  more.”

Page 14: 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing - FedInsider · PDF file“Medically)Ready)ForceReady)Medical)Force ... 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing

“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”

D2D  Program  Overview

14

D2D  Core  Capabilities

Desktop  as  a  Service  (DaaS)

Improving  Desktop  Capabilities   and  Clinical  Workflows

Network  Security  Management  Service

(NSMS)Securely  Interconnecting  People and  Information

Compute  and  Storage  Management  Service  

(CSMS)Delivering  Mission  Agility   and  

Driving Efficiencies

Directory  Services  (DS)  /  EnterpriseManagement  (EM)

Information  Sharing  and  Access  to  Care  Across  Service  Lines

The  D2D  Program  consists  of  core  capabilities  that  collectively  enable  a  centralized,  standardized  infrastructure

Global  Service  Center  (GSC)

Providing   Global   Technical  and  Functional   IT  Support  

Infrastructure  and  

Application  Performance  Management

Computer  Network  

Defense  (CND)

A  Single  Place  for  all  Performance  Management  Data

A  Single  Approval   for  all  IT  in  the  MHS

Page 15: 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing - FedInsider · PDF file“Medically)Ready)ForceReady)Medical)Force ... 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing

“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”

DHA  Footprint  -­‐ Infrastructure  Management

15

Summary

• The  tables  above  represent  the  responsible  parties  managing  components  of  IT  Infrastructure

• Current  DHA  accounts  for  48%  of  the  enterprise

• Including  both  DHA  and  locally  managed  components,  DHA  accounts  for  65%  of  the  enterprise

• In  the  To-­‐Be  state,  DHA  will  account  for  87%  of  the  enterprise

Program Function ARMY NAVY AF TMA NCR

CSMSApplication  Mgmt.Hosting

NSMSWideAreaNetwork (WAN)Local Area  Network  (LAN)Wireless  LAN

DaaS

Tier  2  Touch  LaborTier  3  Desktop  Support

Infrastructure  Mgmt.

GSCTechnical  Service  DeskFunctional  Service  Desk

DSEMDirectory Services

Enterprise  Management

Program Function ARMY NAVY AF TMA NCR

CSMSApplication  Mgmt.

Hosting

NSMSWideAreaNetwork (WAN)

Local Area  Network  (LAN)

Wireless  LAN

DaaSTier  2  Touch  Labor

Tier  3  Desktop  Support

Infrastructure  Mgmt.

GSCTechnical  Service  Desk

Functional  Service  Desk

DSEMDirectory ServicesEnterprise  Management

48%

17%

23%

12%DHA  Enterprise  ManagementDHA  and  Local  ManagementLocal  ManagementLine  Management

DHA  Enterprise   Management DHA  &  Local  Management Local  Management Line  Management

As  Is To  Be

Page 16: 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing - FedInsider · PDF file“Medically)Ready)ForceReady)Medical)Force ... 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing

“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”

Measures  of  Success

16

Metric Description Industry  Benchmark

Baseline Threshold Objective

Operational  Availability

The  overall  availabilityof  IT  services  to  the  end  user  irrespective  of  the  source  of  downtime

99.99% 98.4% 99.0% 99.5%

Customer  Support

First  Contact  Resolution:  %  of  tickets  resolved  on   the  first call  to  the  help  desk

65% 78%  (1 Hour)

65% 78%

Average  Resolution Time  of  Incidents  and  Service  Requests  (Non-­‐GSC):  How  long  it  takes  to  get  a  ticket  resolved  when  Help  Desk  cannot   resolve  on  first  contact

NA90%  

10  Days  or  Less

90%  7  Days  or  Less

90%  3Days  or  Less

Cost  SavingsCost  Per  Agent  Handled  Contact $19.07 $16.89 $19.07 $16.64

Annual  End-­‐User  Computing Cost  per  EUD $1,015 $1,218 $1,015 $947

IT  Value  is  an  expression  of  Availability  and  Responsiveness  over  CostIT  Value

%  Service  Improvement

%  Baseline  Spending

Availability%  Decrease  in  Monthly  Downtime

%  of  Baseline  IT  Budget

Responsiveness%  Decrease  in  End  User  Resolution  Time

%  Baseline  End  User  Computing   Costs  

D2D  will   improve  IT  response  to  the  End  User  by  70%,  while  reducing  End  User  IT  costs  by  22%.

D2D  will   increase  operational  availability  while  reducing  downtime  per  month  across  the  enterprise  achieving  an  end-­‐state  IT  operating  cost  that  is  22%  lower  from  the  status  quo  baseline.

Page 17: 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing - FedInsider · PDF file“Medically)Ready)ForceReady)Medical)Force ... 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing

“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”

Conclusion

17

D2D  will   provide  infrastructure  standardization  to  effectively  and  rapidly  deploy  capabilities  to  improve  the  survivability  and  medical  readiness  of  the  warfighter  

Business

Financial

Schedule

Standards

DriversCurrent  Environment DHA  D2D  Environment

D2D  enables  the  medical  mission  to  be  achieved  through  a  platform  that  allows  providers  to  access  systems,  moveseamlessly,  and  exchange  health  information  and  medical  records  across  the  enterprise.  D2D  provides  the  programmatic  and  architectural  detail  to  support  the  key  HIT  objectives  in  support  of  the  IT  infrastructure  readiness:  cost  savings,  operational  efficiency,  and  achievement  of  the  medical  mission.

The  current  infrastructure  environment  is  fragmented  and  inconsistent  across  the  Medical  Treatment  Facilities  (MTFs).  

Inefficiencies  and  inconsistencies  within  site  service  levels  lead  to  unequal  distribution  of  staff  across  the  MTFs.   This  inequality  results  in  duplicative  cost  requirements  and  varying  service  levels  is  the  lead  cause  for  challenges  in  managing  information  across  our  health  care  environment.  

Page 18: 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing - FedInsider · PDF file“Medically)Ready)ForceReady)Medical)Force ... 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing

“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”

Backup  Charts

18

Page 19: 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing - FedInsider · PDF file“Medically)Ready)ForceReady)Medical)Force ... 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing

“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”

Pre-­‐Decisional Briefing

DHA  IT Infrastructure Plan  (1  OF  2)IT SERVICE CAPABILITY BUSINESS IMPACT

Network  Security  Management  Service  (NSMS)

Seamless  integrated  Wide,  Local,  and  Wireless  NetworkCapabilities  include  a  Single  Security  Architecture  and  centralized  Designated  Accrediting  Authority   (DAA),  standardized  monitoring/  management,  and  improved  provider  mobility

Systems  and  applications  will  be  accessible  across  the  entire  DoD  health  care  environment  allowing  complete  access  to  all  patient  information  regardless  of  health  care  location.

Directory  Services  (DS)/  Enterprise  Management  (EM)

Centralized  and  secure  access  and  authentication  capability  to  network   resourcesLeverages  ability  to  centrally  manage  DS  infrastructure  throughout   the  enterprise

Health  care  providers  and  staff  will  be  able  to  move  from  hospital  to  hospital  and  be  able  to  authenticate  to  all  IT  services  without  needing  new  accounts.

Desktop  as  a  Service  (DaaS)

Desktop  design  standardization  service  across  the  application,   desktop  and  server  environments  Includes  standardized  desktop  configuration  and  application  virtualization  capabilities  across  physical  and  virtual  desktops

All  desktops  will  be  standardized  so  providers  and  staff  will  be  able  to  move  within  the  medical  facility  and  have  access  to  their  information  resources.

Compute  and  Storage  Management  Service  (CSMS)

Centrally  managed,  integrated,  and  robust  computing:   infrastructureGeographically-­‐distributed infrastructure designed todeliver low-­‐latency services close to the point of careor point of need

Provides  a  standard  method   to  host  applications  and  the  ability  for  the  DoD  health  care  system  to  use  single  applications  to  support  all  care  encounters.

Global ServiceCenter (GSC)

Consolidated MHS enterprise IT service desk Provides  a  single  point  of  contact  for  all  customers  to  obtain  support   for  all  systems  regardless  of  physical  location.

Page 20: 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing - FedInsider · PDF file“Medically)Ready)ForceReady)Medical)Force ... 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing

“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”

IT SERVICE CAPABILITY BUSINESS IMPACT

Infrastructure  and  Application  Performance  Management

Integrate  capacity  planning  and  performance  monitoring   seamlessly  through  use  of  integrated  tools  and  processes  to  monitor   the  end   to  end  performance  of  all  technology  solutionsCapabilities  include  one  set  of  tools  and  processes  to  monitor  all  technology  solutions  for  all  customers.  

Will  support  the  business  by  having  a  single  organization  support  all  elements  of  systems,  network  and  performance.Will  save  money  by  consolidating  all  tools  and  processes  for  monitoring  all  aspects  of  technology  solutions

Computer  Network  Defense  (CND)

A  computer  network  defense  program  provides  protection,   detection,   response  and  sustainment  activities  for  network   incidents   through   a  tiered  support   process.    Provide  various  enclave  protection  countermeasures  which  include  host  intrusion  protection  and  prevention,  network  configuration  management,  anti-­‐virus/anti-­‐spyware,  mitigate  Information  Assurance  Vulnerability  Management  (IAVM)  issuances.  

Will  support  the  business  by  having  a  single  CND  provider   to  ensure  an  enterprise-­‐wide  computer  network  defense  program  that  provides  protection  measures  to  mitigate  the  risk  to  DoD  beneficiary  information,  safety  and  life  issues  in  the  delivery  of  medical  care.  Will  save  money  by  consolidating  all  tools  and  processes  for  monitoring  all  aspects  of  technology  defensive  protection  suites.

Draft  slides  for  January  D2D  Update

DHA  IT Infrastructure Plan  (2  OF  2)

Page 21: 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing - FedInsider · PDF file“Medically)Ready)ForceReady)Medical)Force ... 101 - Pete Marks - DHA IT Overview Briefing

“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”“Medically  Ready  Force…Ready  Medical  Force”

Notes  on  Metrics

21

Operational  AvailabilityHealthcare  Industry  has  99.99%  availability.    Baseline  data  represents  AHLTA  operational  availability  for  FY15.    Threshold  and  Objectives  are  based  on  maintaining  and  expanding  redundant  circuits,  adding  redundancy   to  the  architecture  under  MEDCOI,  and  improving  resiliency  in  power  outages  through  LAN  UPS  upgrades.

Customer  Support  First  Contact  Resolution

Industry  benchmark  comes  from  Gartner  IT  Key  Metrics  Data  2016:  Key  Infrastructure  Measures:  IT  Service  Desk  Analysis:  Current   Year;  Baseline  comes  from  GSC  data  for  Technical  Service  Desk  support   to  Army  for  FY15;  Threshold  is  based  on  industry  benchmark,  Objective  based  on  standard  currently  achieved  for  Army  users.

Customer  Support  Average  Resolution  Time

Baseline  comes  from  GSC  data  for  Technical  Service  Desk  support   to  Army  for  FY15;  Threshold  and  Objectives  are  based  on  projected   improvements  from  standard  processes  and  support  model  put  in  place  under  centralized  management  of  help  desk/customer  support  functions.

Cost  Savings  Cost  Per  Agent  Handled  Contact

Benchmark  comes  from  Gartner  IT  Key  Metrics  Data  2016:  Key  Infrastructure  Measures:  IT  Service  Desk  Analysis:  Current  Year;  Baseline  comes  from  GSC  data  for  Technical  Service  Desk  support   to  Army  for  FY15;  Threshold  is  based  on  industry  benchmark,  Objective  based  on  Industry  average  for  large  help  desks.

Cost  Savings  Annual  End-­‐User  Computing  Cost  per  EUD

Benchmark  comes  from  Gartner  IT  Key  Metrics  Data  2016:  Key  Infrastructure  Measures:  End-­‐User  Computing  Analysis:  Current   Year;  Baseline  comes  from  analysis  of  ZBR  data  for  EUD  spend  and  local  help  desk  staffing  plus  industry  averages  for  software,  occupancy  and  overhead;  Threshold  is  based  on   industry  benchmark,  Objective  based  on   Industry  average  for  large  enterprises  based  on  hardware  volume  discounts.