10 - aashto design equation (flexible) (2015) - aashto design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 psi...

62
Pavement Performance

Upload: others

Post on 12-Apr-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Pavement Performance

Page 2: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

AASHO Road Test

Source: Highway Research Board Special Report 732

Page 3: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

AASHO Road Test

Source: WSDOT Pavement Guide Interactive CD-ROM 3

Page 4: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

AASHO Road Test

Source: http://www.fhwa.dot.gov 4

Page 5: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

AASHO Road Test

Source: WSDOT Pavement Guide Interactive CD-ROM 5

Page 6: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

AASHO Road Test

Source: WSDOT Pavement Guide Interactive CD-ROM 6

Page 7: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

AASHO Road Test

Source: WSDOT Pavement Guide Interactive CD-ROM 7

Page 8: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

AASHO Road Test

Source: WSDOT Pavement Guide Interactive CD-ROM 8

Page 9: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

AASHO Road Test

Source: WSDOT Pavement Guide Interactive CD-ROM 9

Page 10: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Present Serviceability Rating

“The judgment of an observer as to the current ability of a pavement to serve the traffic it is meant to serve”

10

Page 11: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Present Serviceability Rating

11

Page 12: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Acceptable Ride Quality

PSR Acceptable?

3.0 88%

2.5 45%

2.0 15%

12

Page 13: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Measuring Roughness

Straightedge

Slope Profilometer

CHLOE Profilometer

13

Page 14: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

CHLOE Profilometer

Source: State Library and Archives of Florida14

Page 15: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Slope Variance

22

6

1S SnSV 10

n 1

S = slope (radians)

15

Page 16: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Flexible Pavements

16

Page 17: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Rigid Pavements

17

Page 18: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Rut Depth

Source: www.halifax.ca/Works/AsphaltDefectGuide.html18

Page 19: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Flexible Pavements

19

Page 20: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Cracking

Source: www.asphaltrescue.com20

Page 21: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Patching

Source: www.asphaltrescue.com21

Page 22: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Flexible Pavements

22

Page 23: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Rigid Pavements

23

Page 24: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Present Serviceability Index

PC01.0RD38.1SV1log9.103.5PSI 2

PC09.0SV1log8.141.5PSI

Flexible Pavements

Rigid Pavements

24

Page 25: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Pavement Performance

Very good

Good

Fair

Poor

Very poor

5

4

3

2

1

0

PSI

ESALS (log scale)

Limit for Low-Volume Roads

Limit for High-Volume Roads

25

Page 26: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Pavement Performance

5

4

3

2

1

0

PSI

ESALS (log scale)

Acceptability Limit

75% Time

40%Drop

40%Drop

12% Time

Each $1 spent onmaintenance here

Ends up costing $4if delayed to here

26

Page 27: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Pavement Performance

5

4

3

2

1

0

PSI

ESALS (log scale)

Acceptability Limit

27

Page 28: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

AASHTO Design Equation

(Flexible Pavements)

Page 29: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Pavement Performance

Wp 4.2 4.2 1.5

InitialConstruction

failure

4.2

1.5

W 29

p

Page 30: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Pavement Performance

Wt

terminal serviceability

tt 4.2 4.2 1.5 Wp

pt

InitialConstruction

failure

4.2

1.5

30

Page 31: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Flexible Performance

9.365.93 4.33

9.364.7918

10 1 1 0.64 118 1

SN SN

3.23

5.19 518 .193.23

0.081 18 1 10940.4 0.41 1 1

SN SN

31

Page 32: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Pavement Performance

Wt

terminal serviceabilitypt

InitialConstruction

failure

4.2

1.5

5.1910940.4

SN 118

9.t 36Wp 4

0..2

64.2 1.5

4 SN 1

32

Page 33: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Pavement Performance

Wt

terminal serviceabilitypt

InitialConstruction

failure

4.2

1.5

5.19

10940.4SN 1

t 189.36

4.2 p W4.2 1.5 0.64 SN 1

33

Page 34: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Pavement Performance

Wt

terminal serviceabilitypt

InitialConstruction

failure

4.2

1.5

t 18

10 105.19 9.364.2 p 1094 Wlog 0.4 log4.2 1.5 SN 1 0.64 SN 1

34

Page 35: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Pavement Performance

Wt

terminal serviceabilitypt

InitialConstruction

failure

4.2

1.5

t10

1810 9.36

5.19

4.2 plogW 4.2 1.5log 10940.64 SN 1 0.4

SN 1

35

Page 36: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Pavement Performance

Wt

terminal serviceabilitypt

InitialConstruction

failure

4.2

1.5

t10

9.3610 18 10

5.19

4.2 plog4.2 1.5log W log 0.64 SN 1 10940.4SN 1

36

Page 37: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Pavement Performance

Wt

terminal serviceabilitypt

InitialConstruction

failure

4.2

1.5

t10

10 18 10

5.19

4.2 plog4.2 1.5log W 9.36log SN 1 0.20 10940.4SN 1

37

Page 38: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Flexible Performance

t10

10 18 10

5.19

4.2 plog4.2 1.5log W 9.36log SN 1 0.20 10940.4SN 1

1966

38

Page 39: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

AASHO Road Test

Average Mean Temperature (July) 24.5°C (76oF)

Average Mean Temperature (January) -2.8°C (27oF)

Annual Average Rainfall 837 mm (34 in)

Average Depth of Frost (for fine-grained soil) 711 mm (28 in)

Climate

39

Page 40: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

AASHO Road Test

Soil Classification A-6

Percent Passing a #200 Sieve 82%

Liquid Limit 31%

Plasticity Index 16%

Average Degree of Saturation 85%

Average CBR 2.9

Subgrade

40

Page 41: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Flexible Performance

1972

t

10

10 18 10

5

i

.19

4.2 plog4.2 1.5log W 9.36log SN 1 0.20 10940.

1log 0.372 S 3.

S 1

0R4

N

41

SubgradeSupportFactor

RegionalClimateFactor

Page 42: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Regional Factor

42

Condition R value

Roadbed materials frozen to a depth of 5 in. or more (winter)

Roadbed materials dry (summer and fall)

Roadbed materials wet (spring thaw)

0.2 – 1.0

0.5 – 1.5

4.0 – 5.0

Page 43: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Regional Factor

43

Page 44: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Soil Support Value

44

Page 45: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Flexible Performance

1986

10

t10

10 18 10

5.19

R

4.2 plog4.2 1.5log W 9.36log SN 1 0.20 10940.4S

2.32log M 8.07

N 1

45

SeasonallyAdjustedResilientModulus

Page 46: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Design Equation

18 TW w

PredictedTrafficLevels

PredictedPavement

Life

46

Page 47: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Design Equation

810 101log log TW w

PredictedTrafficLevels

PredictedPavement

Life

47

Page 48: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Predicted Pavement Life

t

10

10 10 10 R

5.19

T

4.2 plog4.2 1.5log 9.36log 1 0.20 2.32log M 8.071S 0940.4

1

N

SN

w

48

Page 49: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Reliability

Page 50: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Design Equation w/ FS

18 RTw FW

PredictedTrafficLevels

PredictedPavement

Life

Factorof

Safety

50

Page 51: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Design Equation w/ FS

10 10 10log log logTt RW w F

PredictedTrafficLevels

PredictedPavement

Life

Factorof

Safety

51

Page 52: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Reliability

wT Wt

PredictedTrafficLevels

PredictedPavement

Life

log10FR

52

Page 53: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Reliability

wT Wt

PredictedTrafficLevels

PredictedPavement

Life

log10FR

53

Page 54: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Reliability

wT Wt

PredictedTrafficLevels

PredictedPavement

Life

log10FR

54

Page 55: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Reliability

wT Wt

PredictedTrafficLevels

PredictedPavement

Life

55

Page 56: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Reliability

2 2 2o w nS S S

log10FR =

56

Page 57: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Reliability

2 2 2o w nS S S

P(fail)

log10FR =

57

Page 58: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Reliability

wT Wt

ZRSo

P(fail)

PredictedTrafficLevels

PredictedPavement

Life

log10Wt log10Wt 58

Page 59: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Design Equation

R 0

10

10 18 10 10 R

5.19

4.2 plog4.2 1.5log W 9.36log SN 1 0.20 2.32log M 8.0710940.SN 1

Z S4

1993

59

Reliability

Page 60: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Recommended Reliability

Functional Classification Urban Rural

Interstate and Other Freeways 85 – 99.9% 80 – 99.9%

Principal Arterials 80 – 99% 75 – 99%

Collectors 80 – 95% 75 – 95%

Local 50 – 80% 50 – 80%

60

Page 61: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

ReliabilityReliability

(%) ZRReliability

(%) ZR

50 -0.000 93 -1.476

60 -0.253 94 -1.555

70 -0.524 95 -1.645

75 -0.674 96 -1.751

80 -0.841 97 -1.881

85 -1.037 98 -2.054

90 -1.282 99 -2.327

91 -1.340 99.9 -3.090

92 -1.405 99.99 -3.75061

Page 62: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design... · 2019-02-26 · 3 2 1 0 PSI ESALS (log scale) Limit for Low-Volume Roads Limit for High-Volume Roads 25. Pavement

Standard Deviations

Source Flexible Rigid

AASHO Road Test Sn 0.35 0.25

AASHO Road Test So 0.45 0.35

Typical Range for So 0.40 – 0.50 0.35 – 0.40

62