1. 2 the valuation of warehouses presented at: appraisal institute dallas, texas july 28, 2015 the...
TRANSCRIPT
1
Appraisal InstituteDallas, Texas
“AI Connect” 2015
2
“That’s Logistics”
or
“The Valuation of Warehouses”
3
The Valuation of WarehousesPresented At:
Appraisal Institute
Dallas, Texas
July 28, 2015
The Valuation of Warehouses
4
The Valuation of WarehousesDeveloper & Presenter:
C. Kevin Bokoske, MAI
Broward County Real Property
Fort Lauderdale, Florida
The Valuation of Warehouses
5
THAT’S LOGISTICS
The Valuation of Warehouses
6
The Valuation of Warehouses
“You Don’t Know What You Don’t Know”
- BUT -
“You Don’t Have to Know it, if You Know About it”
The Valuation of Warehouses
7
Importance of Logistics:
For want of a nail the shoe was lostFor want of a shoe the horse was lostFor want of a horse the rider was lostFor want of a rider the battle was lostFor want of a battle the kingdom was
lost
The Valuation of Warehouses
8
SEMINAR OBJECTIVES
1. Introduce Broad Overview of “Logistics”
2. Explore Warehouses as a Property Type
3. Increase Ability to Value Warehouses
The Valuation of Warehouses
9
Logistics - Defined“The management of the flow of goods and services between the point of origin and the point of consumption.”
From: Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
The Valuation of Warehouses
10
Logistics – Involves:InformationTransportationInventoryWarehousingMaterial HandlingPackagingSecurity
The Valuation of Warehouses
11
Logistics
A channel of the supply chainAdds value of time and place utilityGlobal economy means global supply
chainBegan as business concept in 1950s
The Valuation of Warehouses
12
Logistics Business Logistics can be defined as:The right itemIn the right quantityAt the right timeAt the right placeFor the right priceIn the right conditionTo the right customer
The Valuation of Warehouses
13
Logistics
Where do “WAREHOUSES” fit into this picture?
The Valuation of Warehouses
The Valuation of Warehouses 14
Introduction
The Valuation of Warehouses 15
Introduction
The Valuation of Warehouses 16
What is the Missing Piece?
The Valuation of Warehouses 17
What is Missing?
The missing piece is………
The Valuation of Warehouses 18
Warehousing!!
19
Four P’s of Marketing
PriceProductPlace (=Distribution)Promotion
The Valuation of Warehouses
20
Move Goods To Consumers
Channels of Distribution
- Or -Supply Chain
- Or -Logistics
The Valuation of Warehouses
21
Terms To Know
What is “JIT”?
The Valuation of Warehouses
22
Terms To Know: “JIT”
“JIT” = Just in Time Delivery
The Valuation of Warehouses
23
JITDeveloped by Toyota 1980s:Reduced inventorySaved moneySaved timeIncreased efficiency
The Valuation of Warehouses
24
Events Affecting JITEarthquake (Japan)West Coast Labor Strife
The Valuation of Warehouses
25
Dock After LA Port Strike
The Valuation of Warehouses
26
Events Affecting JITEarthquake (Japan)West Coast Labor StrifePolitical Unrest (Syria)Civil Wars (Egypt, Libya)Mid-East Oil SupplyWar (Ukraine)
The Valuation of Warehouses
27
Ex.: “JIT” Challenge
The Valuation of Warehouses
28
Ex.: “JIT” Challenge-BoeingItaly
Japan
USA
Australia
Canada
France
U.K.
Sweden
The Valuation of Warehouses
29
Ex.: “JIT” - i Phone 6
The Valuation of Warehouses
30
Ex.: “JIT” - i Phone 6i Phone 6i Phone 6 PlusWent on sale 9/19/2014Apple to ship 80,000,000 by Y/E Shipped from: ChinaDesigned in: CaliforniaScreen: Texas Instruments
The Valuation of Warehouses
31
Ex.: “JIT” - i Phone 6Flash Memory: MicronSemiconductors: DialogGyroscope: ST MicroelectronicsMemory: SamsungApplications Processor: SamsungAudio Controller: Cirus LogicBlue Tooth: Murata
The Valuation of Warehouses
32
Ex.: “JIT” - i Phone 6Network Components-by InfineonPower Management-by Dialog
SemiWiFi Components-by MurataFrom: USA, Germany, South Korea,
Tiawan, Japan, and ItalyAssembled: Shenzhen, ChinaShipped to USA and World! (JIT)
The Valuation of Warehouses
33
Terms To Know
What is “Belly Cargo”?
The Valuation of Warehouses
34
Logistics Belly Cargo
The Valuation of Warehouses
35
Logistics Belly Cargo
The Valuation of Warehouses
36
Logistics Air Cargo
The Valuation of Warehouses
37
Air Cargo Planes
The Valuation of Warehouses
38
Air CargoAir Freight Only
FedExUPSDHL
The Valuation of Warehouses
39
Air CargoTOP U.S. AIRPORTS: CARGO
1. Memphis 4,138,644 Tons
2. Anchorage 2,438,534 Tons
3. Louisville 2,216,079 Tons
4. Los Angeles 1,926,050 Tons
5. Miami 1,864,269 Tons
6. Chicago ORD 1,434,377 Tons
The Valuation of Warehouses
40
Air CargoTOP U.S. AIRPORTS: CARGO
7. New York JFK 1,288,582 Tons
8. Indianapolis 1,092,652 Tons
9. Dallas 652,303 Tons
10. Newark 650,541 Tons
11. Atlanta 616,365 Tons
12. Oakland 504,019 Tons
The Valuation of Warehouses
41
Airport “Premium”??
JLL Research reports that the average rent for “airport-near” space enjoys a 11.2% premium compared
to the overall market.
JLL Airport Outlook, Spring 2014.
The Valuation of Warehouses
42
Global Air Cargo ValueGlobal air freight comprises only 2.0% of total cargo shipped.
Global air freight represents 35.0% of the value of all commodities shipped.
JLL Airport Outlook, Spring 2014.
The Valuation of Warehouses
43
LTL
What is “LTL”?
LTL=Less Truckload Delivery
The Valuation of Warehouses
44
Consider….
HOW DOES “STUFF” GET HERE???
The Valuation of Warehouses
45
CARGO CONTAINER SHIPS
PANAMA CANAL LOCKS
46
47
CARGO SHIP SIZE1. “Panamax” ships are ships with
the maximum dimensions to fit the Panama Canal.
2. Maximum now for canal is: 1,000 feet long; 110 foot beam; 41 feet draft.
3. TEU (twenty foot equivalent units): 5,000
48
#1 CONTAINER SHIP
49
#1 CONTAINER SHIP
“CSCL Globe”Holds 19,100 Containers1,312 Feet LongContainers stretch 72 milesMSC building 19,224-container
50
CONTAINERSHIP FACTOIDS
1. The fastest growing segment in world shipping.
2. Average containership today is 2,230 TEU.
3. Largest was 9,200 TEU.
51
POST-PANAMAX
1. Need 50-ft. Channel
2. Need larger cranes
3. Four East Coast Ports=Ready
4. NY, Baltimore, Miami, Norfolk
5. US is behind Global competition
52
CONTAINERSHIP FACTOIDS
1. “Post-Panamax”
2. Average containership today is 2,230 TEU. Post-Panamax will be up to 12,500 TEU.
3. Enlarge Panama Canal
53
PORT GANTRY CRANE
54
PORT GANTRY CRANE
55
“Ro-Ro”
The Valuation of Warehouses
56
“Ro-Ro”“Ro-Ro”: Roll-On/Roll-OffWheeled cargoCars. TrucksNo cranes. Uses rampsSmall cargo component %
The Valuation of Warehouses
57
2014 Largest U.S. Ports (TEU)1. Los Angeles, CA 3,969,845
2. Long Beach, CA 3,457,689
3. New York/Newark 2,789,542
4. Savannah, GA 1,157,680
5. Norfolk, VA 902,619
6. Oakland, CA 781,420
7. Tacoma, WA 724,691
8. Houston, TX 682,847The Valuation of Warehouses
58
2014 Largest U.S. Ports (TEU)9. Charleston, SC 658,324
10. Seattle, WA 572,534
11. Miami, FL 363,719
12. Port Everglades, FL 336,462
13. Baltimore, MD 328,285
14. Philadelphia, PA 175,950
15. Wilmington, DE 162,672
16. San Juan, PR 163,114The Valuation of Warehouses
59
HOW DOES STUFF GET HERE?
WHERE DOES IT GO NEXT?
60
HOW DOES STUFF GET TO US?
OFTEN FROM A WAREHOUSE!
61
HOW DOES STUFF GET TO US?
OFTEN TO A WAREHOUSE!
62
The Valuation of Warehouses
Let’s Look at the Property
63
Warehouse: Definition“A structure designed and used for the
storage of wares, goods, and merchandise.”
Warehouses are a Subclass of Industrial buildings.
Many types of Warehouses.
The Valuation of Warehouses
64
Is a Warehouse Just a Box?
The Valuation of Warehouses
65
All Boxes May Look Equal
The Valuation of Warehouses
66
All Boxes Are Not Equal
The Valuation of Warehouses
67
Different BoxesExcess LandClear Height or Clear SpanOffice Space Build-outLoading FacilitiesFloor ThicknessPower ServiceLand-to-Building RatioSize Relative to Typical Building
The Valuation of Warehouses
68
Different BoxesBuilding SizeSingle-TenantMulti-TenantGross LeaseNet LeaseBuilding TypeBuilding ConstructionTurning Radius
The Valuation of Warehouses
69
Q & A
How many differences can you remember that can exist in
warehouses?
Can you name 5?
The Valuation of Warehouses
70
Different BoxesExcess LandClear HeightOffice Space Build-outLoading FacilitiesFloor ThicknessPower ServiceLand-to-Building RatioSize Relative to Typical Building
The Valuation of Warehouses
71
Different BoxesBuilding SizeSingle-TenantMulti-TenantGross LeaseNet LeaseBuilding TypeBuilding ConstructionTurning Radius
The Valuation of Warehouses
72
Different Boxes
Warehouse Types
The Valuation of Warehouses
73
Warehouse TypesMega-warehouseBulk warehouseDistribution warehouseFlex-warehouseSelf-storage warehouseSteel BuildingsCold storage warehouseTruck Terminals
The Valuation of Warehouses
74
Mega-WarehouseEx.: Office Space if 2% of GBA
The Valuation of Warehouses
75
Mega-WarehouseLargest of the new generation of
warehouses.Typically concrete tilt-up construction.Minimum office space. (2-5%)300,000 to 1,000,000 + square feet.Usually near major transportation and
urban centers.
The Valuation of Warehouses
76
Q & A
How many different types of warehouses can you think of?
Can you name 5?
The Valuation of Warehouses
77
Warehouse TypesMega-warehouseBulk warehouseDistribution warehouseFlex-warehouseSelf-storage warehouseSteel BuildingsCold storage warehouseTruck Terminals
The Valuation of Warehouses
78
Warehouse
The Valuation of Warehouses
79
Warehouse Interior
The Valuation of Warehouses
80
Cold Storage Warehouse
The Valuation of Warehouses
81
Cold Storage Warehouse
The Valuation of Warehouses
82
Cold Storage Air Door
The Valuation of Warehouses
83
Personal Property?
The Valuation of Warehouses
84
Cold Storage WarehouseEntire building or just partRefrigeration. Insulation. Energy-
saving exterior doorsCostlier to buildCostlier to operateReal property?Personal property?Staff Considerations
The Valuation of Warehouses
85
“CROSS-DOCKING”
Different Procedure
Different Warehouse?
Same Warehouse?
The Valuation of Warehouses
86
“Cross-Docking”Definition: Process of receiving
product and shipping it out the same day or overnight; without putting it in storage
Reduce the number of “touches”Truck or Dock doors on two or more
sides; very little storage space
The Valuation of Warehouses
87
% Who Cross-DockCurrently Cross-Dock: 68.5%Plan to Cross-Dock: 15.1%No plans to Cross-Dock: 15.5%Don’t know: 00.9%
(Only 50% Cross-Docked in 2008)
From 2010 Saddle Creek Corporation SurveyThe Valuation of Warehouses
88
“Cross-Docking “
The Valuation of Warehouses
89
Cross-Docking BenefitsImproved serviceReduced transportation costsConsolidates shipments Get products to market quickerRequires less warehouse spaceImprove inventory managementLess inventory requiredMore JIT service
The Valuation of Warehouses
90
Pioneer Metal Warehouse
The Valuation of Warehouses
91
“Butler” Metal Warehouse
The Valuation of Warehouses
92
Large Metal Warehouse
The Valuation of Warehouses
93
Truck Terminal
The Valuation of Warehouses
94
Trucking Terminal May resemble bulk warehouseOften steel constructionTemporary storage onlyMore truck doors than warehouseLess than 150 feet deepFunction is to unload, sort, and re-load
trucks; not for storage and racks
The Valuation of Warehouses
95
Self-Storage Warehouse
The Valuation of Warehouses
96
Self-Storage Warehouse
The Valuation of Warehouses
97
Self-Storage Warehouse
The Valuation of Warehouses
98
Self-Storage Warehouse Also called “Mini-Warehouse”.Subdivided into cubicles.Customers are residential and small
businessesPurchased for income potentialClimate controlled or Open AirOn-site manager office-OptionShort-term tenants. Credit risks
The Valuation of Warehouses
99
Self-Storage Warehouse Question: Is there a business
component in the valuation of self-storage warehouses?
(Purchased for income potential.)Example: If a 10 ft X 10 ft storage unit
rents for $250 a month, would you use $30.00 as the building S/F rental rate? ($250 X 12 divided by 100 S/F=$30.00)
The Valuation of Warehouses
100
Flex-Warehouse
The Valuation of Warehouses
101
Flex-Warehouse
The Valuation of Warehouses
102
Flex-Warehouse Low-rise structuresUsually combination of office,
showroom, and warehouse spaceResembles storefront from frontOffice or showroom in front; storage or
service in rear. Visit or see plansDock height floors not universalMost are multi-tenant
The Valuation of Warehouses
103
Flex-Warehouse Try to inspect each “bay”; interior
build-out or finish can vary widely.Multi-tenants can increase time and
cost of management.Hard to determine occupancy levels by
exterior inspection onlyRents per S/F tend to be higher than
plain warehouse space
The Valuation of Warehouses
104
The Grass is Green……
The Valuation of Warehouses
105
But, Is The Warehouse?
The Valuation of Warehouses
106
GREEN IS GOLD1. LEED (Leadership in Energy &
Environmental Design)
2. US Green Building Council
3. Points for: Water Efficiency Energy and Atmosphere Indoor Air Quality, etc.
The Valuation of Warehouses
107
LEED SCORE CARD (POINTS) Platinum Gold Silver Certified
The Valuation of Warehouses
108
LEED CONSIDERATIONS Orient building on site to
control sunlight to interior Vent roof for heat escape Minimize landscaping to save
mowing and water Save and Re-use graywater
for landscaping
The Valuation of Warehouses
109
“GRAYWATER”1. Water from bathroom sinks,
showers, tubs or washing machines
2. Water that has not come in contact with feces
3. May look dirty
4. Safe and clean
The Valuation of Warehouses
110
LEED CONSIDERATIONS (Cont.) Insulate roof (R-12) Photovoltaic roof Grass on roof Insulate walls (R-30) Use pervious pavers
The Valuation of Warehouses
111
LIGHTING CONSIDERATIONS Increase energy use by
building skylights. Computer controlled timers Motion sensors
The Valuation of Warehouses
112
SUSTAINABILITY1. Green is about Sustainability
2. Green is about Cash
The Valuation of Warehouses
113
SUSTAINABILITY1. LED fixtures use less energy
2. Software to control use of LED fixtures
3. Light only parts of warehouse that are in use
4. Doing right by the environment
The Valuation of Warehouses
114
3PL “3PL” is Third Party LogisticsMany large, (“Fortune 500”-type)
of customers do not operate their own supply chain or logistical operations
Ordering, delivery, transportation, returns, etc., can be assigned to third party
The Valuation of Warehouses
115
Third-Party Logistics Also referred to as “3PL”Arrangement in which a firm with a
long and varied supply chains outsources its logistical operations to one or more specialist firms, the third party providers.
3PL provides outsourced or “third party” logistical services to other companies
The Valuation of Warehouses
116
Third-Party Logistics (Cont.)3PL services may include packaging,
transportation, warehousing, cross-docking, inventory management, freight forwarding, and custom brokerage
Third-party logistic providers give one-stop service for part or all of supply chain management
Different levels, from freight forwarder to non-asset based logistic providers
The Valuation of Warehouses
117
Top US 3PL Warehouse (S/F) 2014 1. Exel (DHL Supply) 109,000,000 S/F
2. GENCO ATC 36,000,000 S/F
3. Ryder Supply 35,000,000 S/F
4. Americold 34,500,000 S/F
5. CEVA Logistics 33,000,000 S/F
6. Jacobson 32,000,000 S/F
7. OHL 32,000,000 S/F
8. Kenco Logistics 31,000,000 S/F
The Valuation of Warehouses
118
Top US 3PL by Revenue-2014 1. C. H. Robinson $13,470,000,000
2. Expeditors $ 6,565,000,000
3. J. B. Hunt $ 5,799,000,000
4. UPS Supply Chain $ 5,758,000,000
5. Kuehne + Nagel $ 5,157,000,000
6. Uti Worldwide $ 4,180,000,000
7. Hub Group $ 3,571,000,000
8. Burris Logistics $ 3,506,000,000
The Valuation of Warehouses
119
Top 3PL Global Warehouses-2014 Refrigerated by Cu. Ft.
1. AmeriCold Logistics 950,051,004 cu ft
2. Lineage Logistics 544,413,930 cu ft
3. Swire Cold Chain 304,577,596 cu ft
4. Preferred Freezer 235,100,269 cu ft
5. Nichirei Logistics 152,406,799 cu ft
6. Kloos terboer 124,403,435 cu ft
7. WersaCold Log 115,092,447 cu ft
8. Partner Logistics 101,021,075 cu ft
The Valuation of Warehouses
120
Foreign Trade Zones (FTZ)Supervised by U.S. Customs and
Border ProtectionAdministered by Commerce Dept.FTZ physically within U.S.Treated as if outside U.S.DFW: $1.4 Billion in FTZ in 2012DFW: 2,400 Acres-on AirportDFW: 10,000,000 S/F warehouses
The Valuation of Warehouses
121
Foreign Trade Zones (FTZ)To provide competitive advantageCan eliminate custom dutiesCan locate “General” FTZ within 60
miles of Port of EntryCan be seaport or airport# 25 Broward County# 32 Miami Port Authority
The Valuation of Warehouses
122
Foreign Trade Zones (FTZ)# 39 Dallas/Fort Worth# 79 City of Tampa#136 Canaveral Port Authority#198 Volusia & Flagler Counties#218 St Lucie County-Ft Pierce#104 Savannah Airport Authority
The Valuation of Warehouses
123
Port Everglades FTZ #25Largest and Oldest in FLSecured. Fenced. Lighted.388,600 S/F WarehousingOther FTZ sites available in Davie
and MiramarInternational Warehouse ServicesLargest exporter FTZ to Latin
America
The Valuation of Warehouses
124
In FTZ, Merchandise May Be:AssembledExhibitedCleanedManufacturedRepackagedRepairedStored and Diagnostic Tested
The Valuation of Warehouses
125
FTZ Reduces Costs:Duty DeferralDuty Elimination (on Scrap)Duty ReductionState and Local Ad Valorem on
Inventory TaxExpedited Flow & Entry Reporting
The Valuation of Warehouses
126
Why Do We Look at FTZ?Part of Supply ChainClients may work with FTZFTZ involves WarehousingFTZ warehouses often require
appraisals:To Buy/Sell warehousesTo set Market Rental Rates
The Valuation of Warehouses
127
FTZ Anecdotal Info:To set Rental Rate for PEV in FL:
1. Googled for list of US Ports
2. Googled for list of US Airports
3. Googled “FTZ” & Researched
4. Personalized Mass e-mail to each
5. Asked if premium for FTZ vs Non
6. Good response rate
The Valuation of Warehouses
128
FTZ Anecdotal Info:Conclusion: No Premium for FTZ vs Non-FTZ
The Valuation of Warehouses
129
Term: “INTERMODAL”Definition: Relating to transportation by more than one means of conveyance, as by truck and rail. (American Heritage Dictionary of the English Language, Fourth Edition copyright 2000 by Houghton Mifflin Company.)
The Valuation of Warehouses
130
INTERMODALSea/RiverHighwayRailAir
The Valuation of Warehouses
131
INTERMODAL VARIABLESSingle journey?Containerized?Store containers: Full? Empty?
The Valuation of Warehouses
132
TEU
The Valuation of Warehouses
133
INTERMODAL ADVANTAGESStandardized containers
20-ft TEUs40-ft Boxes
Easier to moveBegan in maritime shippingUnloading time went from days to minutes
The Valuation of Warehouses
134
INTERMODAL ADVANTAGESCan includes reefersEach container has own IDFaster & cheaperLess damage to goodsWeather no problemSecurity is betterGOH Containers (Garments)
The Valuation of Warehouses
135
Terms: “REVERSE LOGISTICS”
“REVERSE LOGISTICS”
The Valuation of Warehouses
136
Reverse Logistics-Defined“Process of planning, implementing and
controlling the efficient flow of goods from the point of consumption to the point of origin for purposes of recapturing value or proper disposal.”
Source: Ryder Supply Chain Solutions
The Valuation of Warehouses
137
Send it Both Ways?1. “Reverse Logistics”
2. $43,000,000,000 Cost of Returns
3. Electronic Sector Leads the Way
4. Supply Chain Complexity
5. Return-Repair-Repackage-Recycle
The Valuation of Warehouses
138
Reverse Logistics1. Was “Black Hole”; no visibility
2. Now “Untapped Revenue Stream”
3. Returns no longer an after-thought
4. Can increase customer satisfaction
5. Reduce transport and admin costs
6. Reduce aftermarket support costs
7. Enhance bottom line
The Valuation of Warehouses
139
Reverse Logistics-Options Scrap (5% of companies do) Liquidate (10%-25% of companies do) Refurbish (25%-50% do) On-line auction (60% do) Repackage & re-stock (70% - 90% do) Donations PCs? Milk? Bread? Cell phones?
The Valuation of Warehouses
140
Reverse Logistics-Go Green Maximize tons-per-mile Reduces emissions Lower carbon impact Co.’s want sustainable initiatives Saves landfills if recycle returns
The Valuation of Warehouses
141
Reverse Logistics-By Whom?1. Companies can do their own
2. They can outsource to 3 PLs
3. 35% surveyed say they outsource reverse logistics to 3rd party logistics
4. Whether done in-house or outsourced to 3 PLs, it requires warehouse space
5. Ironically, Reverse Logistics can also reduce warehouse requirements
The Valuation of Warehouses
142
Terms to Know: “RFID”
“RFID”
The Valuation of Warehouses
143
RFID Is:
Radio Frequency IDentification
The Valuation of Warehouses
144
RFID TagsUses radio waves to exchange data
between a reader and a tagUsed in electronic toll collection, such
as Sun Pass and EZ-PassCasino chips. $1.5 million theft at Wynn
Casino in LV: $0 value at deactivationSecurity in retail and in DCsLibrary books. Airline baggage
The Valuation of Warehouses
145
RFID TagsID badge security.May replace magnetic swipe cards.Tracks rail cars. Tag on each side of
car.Used in hospital ORs to track each item
used in surgery and stop misplaced sponges
In warehouse (DC) RFID helps control inventory, reduce labor costs
The Valuation of Warehouses
146
RFID in WarehousesOriginally to track pallets and cases
through distribution centers. (“DCs”).Inventory immediately updates as
merchandise is moved.Improvement over bar coding.More information than bar codes.Integrate stores and DCs.Walmart and DoD were leaders.
The Valuation of Warehouses
147
RFID in WarehousesWalmart asked vendors to place RFID
tags on all shipments in 2005.Improved supply chain management.RFID reduced retail out-of-stocks by
21% versus non-RFID stores.Can read tag while moving; unlike bar
codes.Used in hotels for laundry
The Valuation of Warehouses
148
More Technology….WMS = Warehouse Management
SystemsTo control movement and storage in a
warehouseReduce inventoryReduce labor costsBetter customer serviceMore accurate inventory
The Valuation of Warehouses
149
Items Affecting Warehouse Utility
COLUMN SPACING
The Valuation of Warehouses
150
Column Spacing
The Valuation of Warehouses
151
Column Spacing
The Valuation of Warehouses
152
Columns
The Valuation of Warehouses
153
Items Affecting Warehouse Costs What is it?
The Valuation of Warehouses
154
Items Affecting Warehouse Costs: Sprinkler Protection
1. Building codes, insurance companies, and good business sense support the use of sprinklered buildings
2. Save Lives
3. Save Property
4. Put fires out
5. Reduce damages to products
The Valuation of Warehouses
155
Items Affecting Warehouse Costs: Sprinkler Protection
1. Special consideration for sprinklers in High Bay and Automated Storage in warehouse storage facilities
2. Rack storage heights of 40 feet and over limits sprinkler choices
3. In-Rack sprinklers
The Valuation of Warehouses
156
ESFR Sprinkler Protection1. ESFR: Early Suppression Fast
Response
2. Most newer Distribution and Bulk warehouses have ESFR, per IDI
The Valuation of Warehouses
157
Items Affecting Warehouse Costs: ESFR Sprinkler Protection
1. ESFR sprinklers are designed to release 2-3 times the amount of water of conventional sprinkler heads and to emit larger droplets of water. As a result more water and a greater share of the water reaches the fire, allowing the flames to be extinguished.
The Valuation of Warehouses
158
Two Different Views of the Same Building Feature:
1. Wall Height (=Height of Building as seen by the Assessor)
2. Clear Span Height (=Height of Building as seen by Tenants or Owner)
The Valuation of Warehouses
159
Same Building FeatureSeen By Assessor:
1. Wall Height (=Height of Building as seen by the Assessor)
2. Wall Height is a major Cost Approach determinant
3. Used by Assessor to differentiate or segment. Used in CAMA models.
4. Value Indicator
The Valuation of Warehouses
160
Same Building FeatureSeen By Tenant/Owner:
1. Clear Span Height (=Height of Building as seen by Tenants or Owner)
2. Clear Span Height is the warehouse open area with no physical obstructions
3. Used by Tenants and Owners to figure “cube” capacity; how high pallets or racks can be stacked
4. Value IndicatorThe Valuation of Warehouses
161
Two Different Views of the Same Building Feature Example
1. Wall Height could be 33 feet
2. Clear Span Height could be 30 feet
3. Could be the same building!
4. Do not use terms interchangeably
5. A warehouse with a 30 foot clear span height will probably not have a 30 foot wall height
The Valuation of Warehouses
162
Items Affecting Warehouse Value: Obsolescence
Under 300,000 S/F? (Local Markets)Less than 25 feet Clear Height?Minimal Parking?Not Sprinklered?Too Customized for Later Users?Thinner Floor Slabs?
The Valuation of Warehouses
163
Items Affecting Warehouse Value: Mezzanines
The Valuation of Warehouses
164
Items Affecting Warehouse Value: Mezzanines
Typically a custom “add-on” that was constructed for owner/user
First generation user will likely have amortized cost of this added to the rent
Mezzanine S/F typically not included in rentable area
New owner/tenant may not need or wantMay or may not add to value
The Valuation of Warehouses
165
Warehouse Sale Ad-FLL
The Valuation of Warehouses
166
Warehouse Sale Ad-FLLAddress: Fort Lauderdale (Prospect Park)Price: $5,825,000Building Size: 64,678 S/F Price/SF: $90.06Land Area: 4.41 AcresProperty Type: Industrial/WarehouseClear Span: 14 Ft. Year Built: 1990Other: Two Buildings. 5.7% Cap on Actual NOIOther: Near Fort Lauderdale Exec
The Valuation of Warehouses
167
DFW Area Warehouse Sale Ad-1
The Valuation of Warehouses
168
DFW Warehouse Sale Ad-1Price: $5,445,000Size: 18,806 S/F Type: Ind/WarehouseNo. Stories: 1Bldg. Class: CYear Built: 1948Clear Height: 20 Ft.Drive-In Doors: 2Lot Size: 2.51 Acres
The Valuation of Warehouses
169
Local Warehouse Sale Ad-FL
The Valuation of Warehouses
170
Local Warehouse Sale Ad-FLAddress: Plantation Price: $2,995,000Building Size: 52,207 S/F Price/SF: $57.37Land Area: 5.99 AcresProperty Type: Industrial. R&D.Clear Span: 12 Ft. Sprinklered Year Built: 1957Other: 3-Phase Electric. VacantOther: Opposite Plantation H.S.
The Valuation of Warehouses
171
Local Warehouse Sale Ad-3
The Valuation of Warehouses
172
Local Warehouse Sale Ad-3Address: Pompano Beach Price: $7,800,000Building Size: 61,527 S/F Price/SF: $126.77Land Area: 5.88 AcresProperty Type: Industrial. Cold Storage.Clear Span: 24 Ft. and 26 Ft. (18% Office)Year Built: 2005Other: 3-Phase Electric. SprinkleredOther: Andrews Avenue
The Valuation of Warehouses
173
IDI Warehouse Lease Ad
The Valuation of Warehouses
174
IDI Typical Warehouse Lease AdSpace Available: 52,782 SFRental Rate: $7.25 /SF/YearNo. Parking Spaces: 52Office SF: 3430 SFNo. Dock-High Doors: 13Clear Ceiling Height: 24 ft.Description: The Property is ±52,782 SF
with ±3,430 SF of 1 story office space
The Valuation of Warehouses
175
Local Warehouse Lease Ad
The Valuation of Warehouses
176
Local Warehouse Lease Ad2030 W. McNab, Fort Lauderdale Space Available: 103,316 SF on 4.66 AcresRental Rate: $6.95 S/FLease Type: NNNDate Built: 1976. Distribution or Mfg. Dock-High Doors, Recessed: 3 # Grade-Level Doors: 3Clear Ceiling Height: 20 Ft. - 100% A/C
The Valuation of Warehouses
177
Self-Storage Sale Ad
The Valuation of Warehouses
178
Self-Storage Sale AdPrice: $10,550,000Building Size: 83,200 SFPrice/SF: $126.80Property Type: IndustrialProperty Sub-type: Self/Mini-Storage
FacilityProperty Use Type: InvestmentTenancy: MultipleYear Built: 2005Lot Size: 4.35 AC
The Valuation of Warehouses
179
Warehouse Racking
The Valuation of Warehouses
180
Items Affecting Warehouse Utility
LOAD FACTOR
The Valuation of Warehouses
181
LOAD-CARRYING CAPACITYSlab-on-Grade designInteraction of concrete slab and soil
support systemSoil prep as vital as concrete!Soil support involves:
Kind of soilDegree of compactionMoisture content
The Valuation of Warehouses
182
Terms: “The ‘F’ Factor”
Super-flat Floors
The Valuation of Warehouses
183
Terms: Super-flat Floors
The Valuation of Warehouses
184
Super-flat Floors
The Valuation of Warehouses
185
Items Affecting Warehouse Costs: Thin Floor Slabs/Super-Flat FloorsWithout Super-flat Floors, a building is
functionally obsolete, regardless of its size
Allows lift trucks to move through a 6-foot aisle at maximum speed
Variations in floor surfaces or gradients impairs ability to move and pick loads
The Valuation of Warehouses
186
Super-Flat FloorsMeasure “F” factor for floor flatness
and floor levelness. (Created by Allen Face.)
Lift trucks can pick product from increasingly higher racks
90% of warehouses use wire-guidance systems that requires flat floors
The Valuation of Warehouses
187
Retro Uneven Floors?1. Pour super-flat floor over existing
floor. Raises whole floor. Affects docks and entrances. Cost $4.00 per S/F.
2. Tear out old floor. Install new super-flat floor. Cost $8.00 per S/F or more.
3. Grind away 3/8 inch to make super-flat. Only do traveled portion or 15%. Best.
The Valuation of Warehouses
Not Super Flat? Retro Uneven Floors?
Super-flat floor alone cannot redeem an old building.
Often other inefficient factors present. Investors and owners want super-flat
floors. Floor tolerances should be measured
daily. Grinding imperfections can cure.
The Valuation of Warehouses 188
Super Flat FloorsRaising the roof (and walls) of an older
warehouse does not cure all functional obsolescence.
To be efficient, lift trucks must move at top speed, picking from pallets and delivering to conveyors.
Floors must be flat!Lift trucks are made for F-factors.
The Valuation of Warehouses 189
Super Flat FloorsFlatter floors permit 38 + feet ceiling
spans.90% of warehouses use wire-guidance
systems.Without flat floors, lift trucks could
cave in the racks.Lasers used to lay floor
The Valuation of Warehouses 190
191
Tilt-Up Construction
Many large warehouses are “tilt-up” construction.
The Valuation of Warehouses
192
Tilt-Up Construction
The Valuation of Warehouses
193
Tilt-Up Construction1. Footings are installed
2. Floor slab is poured
3. Wood panel forms assembled on slab
4. Doorway and window openings made
5. Reinforcing rods are tied in
6. Inserts for lifting panels are added
7. Concrete poured into forms
8. Panels are created when solidifies
The Valuation of Warehouses
194
Tilt-Up Construction9. Wood forms are removed
10. Crane hooks panel at inserts
11. Crane lifts (“tilts”) panel into place
12. Panel connected to slab and footing
The Valuation of Warehouses
195
Tilt-Up Construction
The Valuation of Warehouses
196
Construction
We just saw the building “go up”
What can bring it down?
The Valuation of Warehouses
197
The Ring of Fire
The Valuation of Warehouses
198
Earthquake Diagram
The Valuation of Warehouses
199
Is Texas at Risk?
The Valuation of Warehouses
200
Warehouse Quake Damage
The Valuation of Warehouses
Seismic Building Codesand Warehouses
Earth’s crust is divided into plates Can make earthquake-resistant Cannot make earthquake-proof To protect people inside To prevent collapse of structure Newer safer than older Very costly to retrofit for seismic
The Valuation of Warehouses 201
Seismic Building Codesand Warehouses
Most danger: California. Also: Southern Illinois. Also: New Madrid seismic Zone. Cost: 1% to 2% of total cost of New
building; much more to Retrofit. Faults can move vertically, laterally, or
in combination.
The Valuation of Warehouses 202
203
We All Get Old!!
What Happens to “Old” Warehouses?
- Or -What Happens to Obsolete, but “Young”, Warehouses?
The Valuation of Warehouses
204
Things To Ponder:Does original building code still
apply?Warehouses had low standardsGrandfathered?Non-industrial uses allowed?Use change require more parking?Use change require more exits?
The Valuation of Warehouses
205
More Things To Ponder:Would new use change seismic
requirements?Permitting requirements?Cost to retro?Health-safety issues?Delay in permits?Delay in construction?
The Valuation of Warehouses
206
Local Thing To Ponder:Hurricane-Hardening?Some tenants demandCostlyBig issue in Florida! Texas?
The Valuation of Warehouses
207
The Valuation of Warehouses
The Appraisal
208
What Approaches to Use?Cost Approach?
Yes, if Applicable
The Valuation of Warehouses
209
What Approaches to Use?Income Capitalization Approach?
Yes, if Applicable
The Valuation of Warehouses
210
What Approaches to Use?Sales Comparison Approach?
Yes, if Applicable
The Valuation of Warehouses
211
Approaches to Use
Cost Approach
The Valuation of Warehouses
212
Cost ApproachReproduction or Replacement Cost
Property Type: Storage Warehouse
Square Feet (GBA): 200,000
Marshall & Swift Section 14
Property Class: C
Property Quality: Low Cost
Property Type: Warehouse
Effective Age (Years): 5
The Valuation of Warehouses
213
Cost Approach (Cont)Base S/F Cost (Sect. 14; P.26): $28.96
Cost Multipliers
Current Cost Multiplier (Sect. 99; P.3): 1.05
Local Cost Multiplier (Sect. 99; P.7): 0.97
Perimeter Multiplier (Sect. 14; P.37): 1.00
Average Story Height (In Feet): 30
Story-Height Multiplier (Sect. 14; P.38): 1.38
Combined Multiplier: 1.41
Modified Per S/F Cost: $40.70
The Valuation of Warehouses
Cost Approach (Cont)Combined Multiplier: $40.70
Other S/F Adjustments
Heating & Cooling (Sect. 14; P.36): $8.50
Sprinklers (Sect. 14; P.36): $2.00
Dock-Height Floors (Sect. 14; P.37): $1.40
Other Adjustments: $0.00
Total Per S/F Adjustments: $11.90
Building Per S/F Cost: $52.60
Building S/F (GBA): 200,000
Preliminary Cost New of Structure: $10,520,830
The Valuation of Warehouses 214
Cost Approach (Cont)Fencing – Linear Feet: 2,100
Cost Per Linear Foot (Sect. 66; P.4): $15.75
Fencing Cost: $33,075
Office – Square Feet: 7,500
Cost Per S/F (Sect. 14; P.35): $30.00
Office Cost: $225,000
Site Preparation and Grading: $200,000
Indirect Costs (Finance, CPA, Brokers): $225,000
The Valuation of Warehouses 215
Cost Approach (Cont)Paving Area – Square Feet: 250,000
Cost Per S/F (Sect. 66; P.4): $2.00
Paving Cost: $500,000
Preliminary RCN of Improvements: $11,703,905
Entrepreneurial Incentive - % of RCN: 7.50%
Entrepreneurial Incentive: $877,793
Replacement Cost New of Improvements: $12,581,698
Improvements RCN Cost Per S/F $62.91The Valuation of Warehouses 216
Cost Approach (Cont)Life Expectancy in Years (Sect. 97; P.7): 40
RCN of Improvements: $12,581,698
Less: Physical Depreciation %: 5.00%
Less: Physical Depreciation: $629,085
Less: Functional Depreciation: $0.00
Less: External Depreciation: $0.00
Total Depreciation – All Sources: $629,085
Depreciated Cost of Improvements: $11,952,613
The Valuation of Warehouses 217
Cost Approach (Cont.)Site – Square Feet: 700,000
Value Per S/F: $6.50
Site Value: $4,550,000
Depreciated Cost (RCNLD): $11,952,613
The Valuation of Warehouses 218
Cost Approach SummaryDepreciated Cost of Improvements: $11,952,613
Plus: Value of Site $4,550,000
Value Indicated: $16,502,613
Value Indicated (Rounded): $16,500,000
Value Per S/F, Including Land: $82.51
The Valuation of Warehouses 219
220
Approaches to Use
Income Capitalization Approach
The Valuation of Warehouses
221
Income Capitalization ApproachInvestment Grade A
GLA (Square Feet) 200,000
Base (Market) Rental Rate Per S/F-NNN $7.00
Potential Rental Income $1,400,000
Plus: Other Income 0
Potential Gross Income (PGI) $1,400,000
Less: Vacancy and Credit Loss - % 10.00%
Less: Vacancy and Credit Loss - $ $140,000
Effective Gross Income (EGI) $1,260,000
The Valuation of Warehouses
222
Income Approach (Cont.)Effective Gross Income (EGI) $1,260,000
Common Area Maintenance (CAM) 0
Insurance @ $0.10 Per S/F $20,000
Reserves @ $0.25 Per S/F: $50,000
Miscellaneous Expenses: $110,000
Total Expenses: $180,000
Net Operating Income (NOI): $1,080,000
Capitalization Rate: 6.50%
Indicated Value: $16,615,385
Indicated Value (Rounded): $16,615,000
The Valuation of Warehouses
223
Income Approach (Cont.)
Indicated Value (Rounded): $16,615,000
GLA (Square Feet) 200,000
Value Per S/F, Including Land: $83.07
The Valuation of Warehouses
224
Approaches to Use
Sales Comparison Approach
(Excel Spreadsheets)
The Valuation of Warehouses
225
Reconcile Sales-Property
(From Excel Spreadsheets)
Sale Adjusted Sales Price
1. $20,614,000
2. $14,512,000
3. $16,474,000
4. $ 8,225,000
5. $41,040,000
The Valuation of Warehouses
226
Reconcile Sales-Per S/FSale Adjusted SP Per S/F
1. $82.46
2. $82.92
3. $82.37
4. $86.58
5. $82.08
Reconcile to: $82.00 per S/FThe Valuation of Warehouses
227
Reconcile Sales-Per S/F
Value per S/F: $82.00
Building Area: 200,000 S/F
Indicated Value: $16,400,000
The Valuation of Warehouses
228
Reconciliation – Final Value
Cost: $16,500,000
Income Cap: $16,615,000
Sales: $16,400,000
Final Value: $16,500,000
The Valuation of Warehouses
229
FUTURE???
The Valuation of Warehouses
230
The Valuation of Warehouses
Crystal Ball?
231
The Valuation of Warehouses
WHAT’S IN THE FUTURE?
232
TERM: “AMAZON EFFECT”
Effect on 3PLsEffect on Distribution/LogisticsBusiness shifts from brick-and-mortar to internet
Amazon is the 800-lb. gorillaAll will watch Amazon
The Valuation of Warehouses
233
TERM: “FINAL MILE”
Deliver product the “last mile” in what may have been a long haul from Asia or across US
J.B. Hunt has opened 90-plus warehouses for this
Two on a truck. May wear Best Buy, Home Depot, etc. garb.
The Valuation of Warehouses
234
TERM: “FINAL MILE”
Product from Mfr to WhseWarehouse to RetailerAbove use Rail-Truck-ShipHow get to treadmills, furniture, etc to Customer?
Less-than-Truckload carriers
The Valuation of Warehouses
235
TERM: “FINAL MILE” (Cont.)
Can be 100’s of milesCan be down the block (mall)All eyes on AmazonUber-type delivery?Reduce # of deliveriesStarts upstream
The Valuation of Warehouses
236
“FINAL MILE” (???)
Drones?USPS on Sundays at XMAS?
More independents?Hurt UPS and FedEx?Effect on DCs?
The Valuation of Warehouses
237
TERM: “DIMENSIONAL PRICING”
FedEx and UPS began 1/1/15Between 5 and 20 lbs.Cubic volume or weightCharge for higher of twoGround or Air deliveryEffect on Warehouses
The Valuation of Warehouses
238
TERM: “RESHORING”Oversees wages have jumpedBrings Mfg jobs back to U.S.Reduce U.S. deficitStrengthens U.S. securityProtect intellectual propertyReduce logistical costsNeed more warehouses?
The Valuation of Warehouses
239
National Distribution Centers(Per IDI)
AtlantaCincinnatiChicagoDallasLAMemphisNY-NJ
The Valuation of Warehouses
240
What’s Ahead?
“Aerotropolis”
The Valuation of Warehouses
241
TERM: “AEROTROPOLIS”
City or economic hubExtends from large airportSurrounded mostly by distribution centers
Links to airport
The Valuation of Warehouses
242
TERM: “AEROTROPOLIS”
Coined by Dr. Kasarda-UNCEx.:Hong Kong. Amsterdam Singapore. Dubai. Memphis
Why Memphis? Memphis: “America’s Distribution Center”
The Valuation of Warehouses
243
Aerotropolis: Memphis, TN
RailRiverRoadRunway
The Valuation of Warehouses
244
245
Memphis RAIL
BNSFCSXUnion PacificNorfolk SouthernCanadian National
The Valuation of Warehouses
246
247
248
249
Memphis: RIVER
Mississippi RiverMinnesota to GulfLow cost shippingBulk items via bargeFourth largest inland port
The Valuation of Warehouses
250
251
Memphis: ROADS
Interstate 40NC to CA3rd busiest truck corridor
Interstate 65Great Lakes to Gulf
The Valuation of Warehouses
252
253
254
255
Memphis: RUNWAY
WHO IS THIS MAN???
The Valuation of Warehouses
256
257
Memphis RUNWAY
YaleMarinesPilotTwo PlanesFederal Reserve contractLittle Rock to Memphis
The Valuation of Warehouses
258
259
260
261
Memphis DCNew Nike Warehouse facility
Largest Nike facility outside of Beaverton, OR
2,400,000 S/FWall Height: 38 Ft.
The Valuation of Warehouses
262
Wrap it Up……….Logistics are vitalLogistics involves storageStorage often means
“warehouses”Warehouses can be seen as
“boxes”The boxes are everywhere
The Valuation of Warehouses
263
Wrap It Up…….We need the boxesThere are various boxesThere are appraisal concernsYou don’t have to know it; if you
know about it.
The Valuation of Warehouses
264
Wrapping Up (But, Not Boxed)Thank youQ & AC. Kevin Bokoske, MAI, AI-GRS,
AI-RRS
954-357-6808
The Valuation of Warehouses
265
ReferencesApplied Technology Council and
Structural Engineers Association of California. (ATC/SEAOC Joint Venture).
Supply Chain Management Review and Logistics Management.
Ryder Supply Chain Solutions
The Valuation of Warehouses
266
References (Cont.)www.ezinearticles.comModern Materials Handlingwww.nreionline.com (National Real
Estate Investor.)Saddle Creek Corporation.
Whitepaper Series. 2011.”Cross Docking Trends Report”
www.airportbusiness.comThe Valuation of Warehouses
267
References (Cont.)Council of Supply Chain
Management – 2009 Annual Global Conference. “Innovative Warehouse Design” PowerPoint by Doug Pope.
“Design Considerations for Warehouse Floors” by Andrew K. Bowser, P.E.
The Valuation of Warehouses
268
References (Cont.)www.supplychainnetwork.comwww.logisticsmgmt.comMarcus&Millchap. “Self-Storage
Research”.www.wbdg.org “Warehouse Whole
Building Design Guide”.The Valuation of Warehouses.
IAAO. C. Kevin Bokoske. 2003The Valuation of Warehouses
269
References (Cont.)www.thefreelibrary.com
“Challenges in Appraising Simple Warehouse Properties”.
L. Scott Helms, IDI Corp. SVP and Regional Managing Director. Fort Lauderdale. (Reviewed presentation.)
The Valuation of Warehouses
270
References (Cont.)Blow, Charles and C. Kevin Bokoske.
(Nov-Dec) 1998. Mass Appraisal of Flex Warehouses. The Assessment Journal.
Marshall Valuation Service.McKnight, Douglas. (January) 1999.
A Practical Guide to Evaluating the Functional Utility of Warehouses. The Appraisal Journal.
The Valuation of Warehouses
271
References (Cont.) “REVERSE LOGISTICS” By Greve
& Davis. Commissioned by UPS.www.georgiaftz.comThe Geography of Transport
Systems. Rodrigue et al. 2009. New York.
Youtube. “That’s Logistics UPS”.
The Valuation of Warehouses
272
References (Cont.) “North American Port Analysis, by
K. C. Conway, MAI. Colliers International. White Paper. August 2012.
Jacksonville Port AuthorityLoopnet.comSupplyChain24/7 News. Photo by
Mike Kelly of Post-Strike LA.The Valuation of Warehouses
273
References (Cont.) “The City Wire” Fort Smith, ARwww.aircargonews.netVandana Vraghubar; CIC-FLIntermec by Honeywell;
www.supplychainservices.comwww.Motorola
Solutions.com/warehouse
The Valuation of Warehouses
274
References (Cont.)CAPA (Center for Aviation) Air
Cargo Analysis White Paper, 2013JLL “Port, Airport & Global
Infrastructure Report”. Spring 2014.Shelby County (TN) AssessorModern Materials Handling. “Top
20 3PL and Public Refrigerated Warehouses”, 2014.
The Valuation of Warehouses
275
References (Cont.)Supply Chain24/7. “Last Mile E-
Commerce Delivery Starts Early”Endicia. “The Impact of Rate and
Billing Charges for 2015”
The Valuation of Warehouses