ΣΧΟΛΙΑΣΜΟΣ ΚΕΙΜΕΝΟΥ Ε΄ ΠΠΔ-περι Οικουμενισμού.pdf
TRANSCRIPT
-
. . . . . 6945-377621, [email protected]
(11-17.10.2015)
2016
-
2
2
3
1. 6
2. 8
3. 10) 10)(6); 10
),,.! 13
)=; 15);:(22) 16)(23)19);(1621) 20
4.20 25) 25) 26 1. 26
2. 30 3. 33
)20; 37 45
1. 462.(..,35.12.2015) 533..(..,35.12.2015) 58
-
3
(,2015)
1976,ProrienteGraz
JosephRatzinger XVI ,. Ratzinger , , 1 ! , , , ., .
,, ,,., , , , , . , , .,, . , . ,, .
,, ( 2)
1 . -
( 20.5.2009).
2 . . . . , (25.10.2015) . . , . . , .
-
4 ( ) .
, . , , . , , .,..
, ! . , , .
( 16.1.2016) ,KurtKoch RadioVaticana: 2016 ... , ... ., 3.
, , : , , ,,
: , , ! , , , . , , , . ( ) , , , , , , ! , . , (. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zp15aaXPCWM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bVghw-sjp5Y)!
3 http://de.radiovaticana.va/news/2016/01/16/ein_spannendes_jahr_der_%C3%B6kumene_konzil_und_reformation/1201463
-
5. . .
( ...) ( 1017.10.2015) (:),(2016).
16.2.2016 4 , ,14 ,(, 2-3.2.2016)5 !
, . , ,,, , .
4
: ... ... , . . . . video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x7kwe5FQjgU
5 http://sobor.patriarchia.ru/db/text/4367700.html
-
61.
(,692014), (1986), 6. (29.94.10.2014)()(1117.10.2015) , (,2016).
(2015), 8) 9) , ..8 , . 9 .
,,(2015) (1986).(2015)(1986).
, . , . ,. (1986)7, (adreferendum) . (1986) . 8.
!
6 . 8) , 9)
, , 369(15.12.1986), 9-13 14-17, , , . , - 2014, . 305-310 311-314.
7 . . (1986), , . 104.
8 . . (1986), , . 104.
-
7;,: , , 35 50 ; ( ) . , ,;
,, , ( ) ; . , expressis verbis : , ! , , , , ( , ,intercommunion,,)! (, 13.9.2015) , . ; , , ,, ! , , ; :; , ;
-
8
2. (2015)
:
1. :,,(1).
2. , ( 2). , :, . ( ),. . : ,, !
3. , ( 3). , , . (intercommunion) ,.,, , . , ,(lexorandilexcredenti)9.
4. ( 5). , (12).
5. ( 9 . :
. . , . , , , , , . , , . , , (. , , . , 2006, . 285-286). . , !
-
96). ( 29.94.10.2014), . . , , , , , , 10 , .
6.,, 190211()192012( )., ., 175513, ,,().1755, ()14.
10 . .,
, 3.2.2016, www.impantokratoros.gr/4442D55555D1B1.el.aspx
11 , . , , /.- . 2003, . 71-77. 12 . , , 1953, . 958. 13 . , , 1953, . 989-991. 14 . . , ,
/ , . , 1996, . 93-94, . -, (1453-1756), ( ), 2009, . 102.
-
103.
(2015) , ,:
1.: ...
. . ,.,,, , (). , !
2.(6);)
(6), , . ( 6), 15 . ; , ,:) , , ,), . ) ,!
),, .,
15 . . 37 .
-
11 . 16, , vestigia ecclesiae( ) 17 ! , 18.1.2016. : ; , , ; , , . : , , , , 18 . 11.2.16 . : , . ,1, , : ;;19.
) ,,,.,
16 , -
- , . , 10.2.2016 . , http://impantokratoros.gr/53D3566C.el.aspx, , , , 3.2.2016, http://impantokratoros.gr/42D5D1B1.el.aspx
17 . , , . Uncut Mountain Press, 2014, . 177 .. 18 1 (. . 11/18.1.2016)
, http://www.impantokratoros.gr/dat/storage/dat/D2D27B0E/naupaktou_1.pdf 19 www.imlemesou.org/images/20016/keimeno-g-sinodo.pdf
-
1220 , ,
) , ( 6) . . , , , , . , . . , (1971):,,,, 21.22,: 23 . : 1971, 1986( 2), 2015 : (6)!
, , , ., , , , ,
20 , ( ), (
1986), , . 107. 21 , , . 107, ,
16-28 1971, . Chambesy 1973, . 143, - , , 1, , , . Chambesy 1971, . 63.
22 , . 104-108, 238-240. ( ) , ( ) , ( ) , , . , . , . .
23 , , . 305.
-
13 . !
) , , 24 , ( 4) ( 8) ( 6).. ; ; 25 ., (. 26 ,27, 28, 29, 30, 31) ( 345, , , , , freeChurches ); .
,,,,,, .! (UnitatisRedintegratio): , 32
3.,,.!) ,
, 33 . ,
24
(Unitatis Redintergratto 3, 4) - (ansi 31, 1028) . , ( )
25 , 11.2.2016 . , www.imlemesou.org/images/20016/keimeno-g-sinodo.pdf
26 , 369(15.12.1986), 12. 27 , 369(15.12.1986), 12-13. 28 , 369(15.12.1986), 11. 29 , 369(15.12.1986), 13. 30 , 369(15.12.1986), 10-11. 31 , 369(15.12.1986), 13. 32 ,
33 ( 1986) !
: : ,
-
14, : (,20,29),(.20,30),(2.2,1),(2.2,1).,, (. 345 ) ,,! , , , , . ( 11), ( 11)! 34 ! ,, 35,,. , ! , , ( .2,18) (.1,20) (.3,16). .
), . . . ,, ,, , .
. : - ! ( , . 251).
34 Unitatis Redintergratto 3, 4, . , , . Uncut Mountain Press, 2014, . 287-292.
35 . . , , / , . 1996, . 60.
-
15consensuspatrum.
)(4),, , ( 24) (.4,14),, . :,,,, ,,36.
4.=!) ( 4) ,
, ,37.
, , (.) ;
, , . ! , . , , , ...
) , , , ,,,
36 . , , , PG 36, 233. 37 (21-28.1.2016)
) , ) , ) , ) , ) , ) , ) , ) - , ) , ) , ) , ) , ) .
-
16 . . ( ), , , , , .
., : . 38, , 39 , 40 . ,.41.
) , , , : 1. (. ) 2. !
5. ; ( 22): )22
, , . :., , . , :, 42 , : 38 Mansi 13, 482D, 208E. . 22, 26,31. 39 Mansi 13, 260D. 40 Mansi 13, 333D. 41 Mansi 13, 232A. 42 6, 11 ( 1), PG 35, 737, , 2, 82
: , (PG 35, 489), , 6, 12 1: , , (PG 35, 740).
-
17,... ( ) 43,. :,, , ,44!
) 22 : ,, . , .45.,., , : , , , . . 46.
) , , ..: . ,,;;.;.; ; ; . , ,.,,;47
, . :,.,. , 48. , !:),
43 , , 35,1, PG 57, 405. 44 , 4, 36, , PG 78,1088CD. 45 , 11.2.2016 . ,
www.imlemesou.org/images/20016/keimeno-g-sinodo.pdf 46 (), , ,
1965, . 128 . 47 . , P.G. 99, 1321B, 31, , PG 99, 1009. 48 . , 24, , PG 99, 985.
-
18 49 . .50 . 51 . ,, ) . , , .,,,, ( )!)., , 52;
)15, , , , , !
) , , , 53. , , ,,.,,.
, , , ,
49 , Mansi 4, 1101-1108. 50 . , , Mansi 4, 1004-1008, ,
, , Mansi 4, 1093-1096D, , , Mansi 4, 1097.
51 . , , : . ( ) . Mansi 4, 1036C-1045D.
52 . : , , ... , , ,... . , , , . .... ; ;.... - ... , . (. ), , , ... (Patrologi Orientalis, XV, 318-320).
53 (1848), . , , . , 1953, . 920.
-
19 ;54
22 .
6.(23). 23
() . , , ; ( . , ,, inercommunion, , ); ;
. . : , , , ,55.:,,,, , , .56 , , ; , , . ;
. , , . (;) ! , : , (. ).,! 54 2 (. . 20/20.1.2016)
, http://www.impantokratoros.gr/dat/storage/dat/3925A205/naupaktou_2.pdf 55 PG 54, 623 56 , () ,
, PG 91, 464 465
-
20 . , . 57 , ! . .
7.;(1621)
i.(1621) , (17).
ii. (1950) Toronto(1950), , (19). 19 ( Toronto, 2). ; ( ) ;
iii. ( 17). 58 , .,,;
iv., , : .
57 . , , 699(2009)
11-33 , ., ., , ., , . , 2011, . 107-146. .: . , . , . , , . , 20092, . 197-245.
58 . , , . , 20092, . 105-108.
-
21, , . . ; , 59; ;
,1982,(Baptism,EucharistandMinistry), 60 . () 345:
,6:,, ... () (.2021)
,13:,. , , , . , (.26).
,15: ., (.28).
59 (. ) : (1986),
, (--) . , , , ( , . 145). ( ) : , , ( , . 150).
60 , , , , , 1983.
-
22 19:,,
, , (.43)
21:(.44).
53:, ..: () , (.86)
54:,., . (.8687)
; ; ( ) 61;
v. , 62 .,:(21)!13, , , 63;
; , : 64, intercommunion,
61 . . 59. 62 (1998) , Porto Alegre
(2006), : Bousan (2013), .
63 . ( ) : , . , ( , . 147). . (. ) ( , . 250).
64 . , , . , 20092, . 105, . 176.
-
23 65 , , , , .
vi. 66. (2006), :[.] .,[ ]. , ...,[] 67 . , , ,(=), ! , , intercommunio: ,,, , 68.
, , . ( 17), , ,, 65 ( 1970),
E. C. Blake (1966-1972), 44 . , , . : , , , , , - (, 15(1970) . 83 . 376-378)!
66 . : , , , 2007, http://www.orthodoxnet.gr/pse%20IK/IK-PSE_Ypomnima.php, http://oodegr.co/oode/oikoymen/ypomnima_ag_orous1.htm.
679th Assembly of WCC, Assembly Documents, Text on ecclesiology: Called to be the One Church, 6-7, http://www.impantokratoros.gr/B46B3299.el.aspx.
68 19, , , , , , 1983, . 43.
-
24 ,,69.
, , : : . . ; ; 300 , , , , ..., . , 10291, ...;70.
,,
vii. (16).;;
69 ,
, , 2007, http://www.orthodoxnet.gr/pse%20IK/IK-PSE_Ypomnima.php, http://oodegr.co/oode/oikoymen/ypomnima_ag_orous1.htm. . . (Towards a Common Understanding and Vision of the WCC), 1. 4. 6, . . . , , , , , . . (. 9th Assembly of WCC, Assembly Documents, Towards a Common Understanding and Vision of the World Council of Churches, 1. 12.)
70 . , ;, . . . , 1991. - - -, . 1992, . 178-179.
-
25
4.20. 20, :
(795).
)1.20,
. . (),.
2.20., 34571. ( , ,,,freeChurches)!
3.20 . , .(419)18 . . , 95 ( 7). 7 95 ,( ) , . 95 ( 7) : , , , , .
,, (8, 19,46, 47, 50, 68,7, 8,.,. 1, 5, 20, 47), 95(7).
71 , , , , , .
-
264.
, . , !,, , ! , ! , , , . . , , !, ,!
5.7 95, , , . , , ,,,.
6., , : ) ,) , ) , ). , !
)795., ,
20,795.:
1.
,,, .,
-
2772. , 73. 74 , , . , , ,.
3. ,(). . , , 75, 46,47,5068,220 76, , 77, . . . (25531,25671,25685),.
(255 ) , . (1), ( ,
72 , (),
, . , 1995, . 94-95. 73 , , , , -
, , , , , (), , . , 1995, . 95.
74 -46: , , , , . ; ;. -47: , , , , , . -50: , , , , , . , , , . -68: , , , , , , . , , .
75 . , . , . , 19902, . 125-130, . , De Catholicae Ecclesiae Unitate, 4-9, . , , . 1, , , 1) De Catholicae Ecclesiae Unitate, 2) 73, 66, 46, 74, 10, 70. 1968, . 31-37.
76 . , , 1990, . 618. 77 . , ( 200 )
. , , , , , , 7, 7. PG 20, 649.
-
28 , ), : , .
1( ), . ( ), ( ) , ,. : ; ; , , , , .,,,,,,, , , , . , ,.,.
,1878, . 79 , ( , , ,
78 . , , . 1, , ,
1) De Catholicae Ecclesiae Unitate, 2) 73, 66, 46, 74, 10, 70. 1968, . 113. 79 . , To . , . .
, . , 1972, . 131-132. . . . , . , , 81 (2010) . , 137-158. . . , , , . , 2010, . 96-114. . Heers : , , , (LG 8b, 15 UR 3a, 3d). , , ; , ; , . (.1,10) (. 9, 5), (. 5, 15-16). , . , , . Uncut Mountain Press, 2014, . 182-183.
-
29, ), 8081.
.,.82 . , 83 ! . , , , , []84.
1 (2, 1) ,., . . 85 , , . .(1,47),.
80 . , , . Uncut Mountain Press, 2014, . 168, 192-
193: , 3 , , . , . , . (1 . 2, 4). , . , , , , , , . . , .. . , . , , , , . , , Congar , , . . , , , , .
81 . , . , . , 19902, . 131-132.
82 Mansi 1, 931A, B. , , . --, 19703, . 89. 83 , , , .
172-173, . , , . 1, , , 1) De Catholicae Ecclesiae Unitate, 2) 73, 66, 46, 74, 10, 70. 1968, . 18-19.
84 74 1, 4, 7, . , , . 1, , , 1) De Catholicae Ecclesiae Unitate, 2) 73, 66, 46, 74, 10, 70. 1968, . 95, 98, 101.
85 . , , . -, 19703, . 89, . , . , . , 19902, . 130-131. . , . , , 81 (2010) . , 147-148.
-
30 (2 1)
. (1): , , . , ., . ,, , , , , , , , , 86 . . :,..
2..
, , , , . . , 7 95 : , ..
, : ) 46,47,5068,1. (1 47), , , , () ,)7,951,47, .
,,; ;
. , . .,
86 -, , . , . 89-92.
-
3187,.,, . . .(..)! . , 1 , .: .
. , . , .,..,.(1), (47), . , , , , . , ,.
, , ( ), ( ). ,,, . , . (.),. , , ,,.
79588.,,.
87 . , . , , 81 (2010) . , 146,
. 11. 88 -95
[(-)] (, ): 1. : , , , , , ,
2. : ( ), , , , , , , ,
3. : , , . -7, (381) (5 .).
-
32 .89,. . . . : ., , (1). , , . . : , , ,90
,. ( ., , , ). ! , , !,, . ,!
(1971), :) ., , (.PG103,953)91. 89 -1 -1, -47, -46
; ;, -47 , , -50 , , , -68: , , .
90 . , 57, , PG 77, 320-321. 91 ,
16-28 1971, . Chambesy 1973, . 144.
-
33 , , , !
. () ( ) : , ,92. (,10.5.2014) , 93.
, , , !
,, : ! , ,.
3..
,20(7 95), : . , . , . . ,,.
20 (7 95) , 92 , (),
, . , 1995, . 184. 93 . (), ,
, , 8-11.5.2014 ( 18:11 19:58 ).
-
34 , :
1. , . , , , () , [ (4), , , ( 24)] ,,94! 95! , 7:, , .7(), ()! , , ,!
, .,,.
2.. (,).,. ( ) ( 96 ) . , , (.
94 . , :
, : ( , 3-5 2015), , 86(2015) . 4, . ;;;.
95 . . . , , / , . 1996, . 99-110.
96 Mansi 13, 225C.
-
35 14 , )., (, ), () ! , , , , , , 97, , ,.
. ( 47, ) () ., , .,,,., , (47).
3..., , , , : , , (1).
4. .. : [ ],[].[]...,, , , , 98. , ., , . , 68 99 (258 , . ) 100 ,
97 , -8, -, , . ,
2002, . . 134 98 PG 35, 1089. 99 -68: , , , ,
, , . , , .
100 (251, . ) , ' , , , ' , ;
-
36 ,,.8 , 101 , , ., , .1: , . , . , , , , ,, , , , .:,,, ! , , ,,..,.,!
5..20 (7 95), . (7 95), , , . : , , (,),,795, 102. 103. : , (15451563), , 7 95
, ; ;.
101 -8: , , , .
102 . . , 1453-1756), ( ), 2009, . 350-358.
103 . . , , / , . 1996, . 26-28, 49, 72-75.
-
37;, , , ; (. , . . , ., , . , . ,, , , , ) ! 104, , . ,,, 1755 : , ,,, , , 105.
6. : , , . , ,., , . . , . , , . ,!
)20;,
, , .20, .
104
. . , , / , . 1996.
105 , , . . , , / , . 1996, . 128, . , 1453-1756), ( ), 2009, . 88.
-
38,
, !, (.. , 35.12.2015) . . , . (, , ), , .: . 106( ) . 107 ( , , , , , ! (2016)!!).
expressisverbis20.
. 20 :)(.795) ( 20). , , , ., 108.
[, , (,10.5.2014),, , ,. 109]. 106 :
. 107 : :
. 108 , . ,
, , 86(2015) . 4, . ;;;. 109 .
(18:11)
-
39 .
..:, , ,20.: 7 95 ,20 ,110.
20, , , ., , . ( ; , ,;!)
, 20 . 20 ,.,20 , .
, , 20:
, 7 . .(18:46) , .
(19:01) , , . , , , , .(19:45) (19:58), (), . , , , , 8-11.5.2014 ( 18:11 19:58 ).
110 . , : , , 86(2015) . 4, . ;;;.
-
401. ,
,,,; , ; , (;) . , . 111 , 112. Balamand (1993) . , , ,,113!
111 , -
16-28 1971, . - Chambesy 1973, . 129-132.
112 . : . (30.10.86) : . ( , . 103). . ( ) : , . , , . - - , Unam Sanctam; , , , ( , . 106-107). . . (. ) ( , . 107) . (. ) . , - . , . . . .. - . ; ; ( , . 108).
113 : ) - ( 6). ) ( , Morges 6-8.12.1999) ( 2002), . , (desiderata) , , . 14, , (), , . , 1995, . 192 . 127. ) , ( 1986) . ( ) : - - ; . . ; ; , . , ; . . ( , . 105). . :
-
41,
, , , ,,. , ( 22). ,,,, .
2. , , .
, , .
3. , 20 () 7 95: , ,:.)()795 , , , ) , , , ) , , .,) .
, , . ( , . 105). ) . (31.10.86): , , ( , . 141-142).
-
42 , ) , , !
4. 20,20,.,20, , 345 , , . (,,)(!).
,,20,,20. 20 , :
1. . , 20.795,, , status . , , .. ! , !
2. (. 14, 15), , ,. ,, , , , , . , , (), .
-
433. ,
114. , . ,115.,, , . , ,, , ..
, , (1971), :) . , , (.PG103,953)116, 117 . , ,,.
4. 20, ,.,:
)()118. 114 (1971):
, , , 16-28 1971, . Chambesy 1973, . 145.
115 , , , , . , . , , , . ( ), . , , 1953, . . 808-809.
116 , - 16-28 1971, . Chambesy 1973, . 144.
117 , - 16-28 1971, . Chambesy 1973, . 144.
118 (Codex Juris Canonici), 861, , 1256 1284, . , (, , ), .
-
44 ,,;
) ;
);
),;
) , ;
, 1989, . 98-103, . , , . Uncut Mountain Press, 2014, . 56-59.
-
45
,:),) ) .
, ,,,. , .
, . , , , .
,.
25 . 2 . 2015
.
. . . . 6945-377621, [email protected]