الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim,...

42
, 29 , 1 , 2017 1438 37 , 29 , 1 , 37 77 , 2017 1438 : , , , * 10 12 1436 ; 22 01 1437 : , , , , : , , , , : , , , , , ; , , , , : , , : , , , , _________________________________________________________________________ Concept of Tibaaq in the Hadith Discipline: Definition, Evolution, Importance and Benefits Saleh Abduallah Al-Sayyah * Majma'ah University (Received 23/09/2015; accepted for publication 04/11/2015.) Abstract: This research is concerned with the concept of tibaaq. The concept is commonly used by Hadith specialists, especially later ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims to: define the tibaaq concept form the linguistic and the technical points of view; show the relationship between the two definitions; establish the historical evolution of the term; describe tibaaq in terms of format, content and mode; and highlight the importance and benefits of tibaaq. The research follows an analytical inductive methodology. Among the research's important findings are: tibaaq highlights the Muslims' great care for their academic achievements, for tibaaq is not just a term, but is a reflection of the critical methodology applied by Hadith specilaists in dealing with Sunnah books and narrations for the purposes of safe and sound reporting; tibaaq and related new methodology have given rise to great changes in aspects of Hadith sciences, rules and requirements; it has been used widely in recent studies on jarh and ta'deel (processes of establishing incredibility or credibility of a narrator); in fact, Hadith specialists now require that a narrator's name has to be mentioned in the related tibaaq document, otherwise the narrator's calim to have listened to the book in question is not considered a vaild claim; and the most significant evolution of tibaaq is the writing of the tibaaq certificate or testimony. The research recoomends that the styles and methodologies applied by Hadith specialits should be studied, and so should their impact on the narrators and the narrated contents. Keywords: tibaaq listening – articulation – equivalence – matching listening content with written content - documentation _ _______________________________________________________________________ * , , , , , 391276 11365 (*)Assistant professor, Department of Islamic Studies, College of Sciences and Humanities, Majma'ah University. Rmaah, KSA, p.o box: (391276), Postal Code: (11365) : [email protected] e-mail:

Upload: others

Post on 29-Jun-2020

11 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

�������� ��� �� ���� ,29 ���� ,�1� ����� ,�2017� 1438$%�

– 37 –

�������� ��� �� ���� ,29 ���� ,�1�& & , 37 − 77 ����� ,�2017� 1438$%�

������ �� �� �� :������� ,������ ,������ ,��� !� "��#�� �$�% &' (� �� &' )��**

��(�� ����) � * +,�� ��-10 12 1436 * +,�� /0-1 ;$%22 01 1437$%�

,-.�/��:3��45$6� 7��$8 9:$�; �$,; <��=6$� �>? ,7��8 /%@ �,; A��B�C A:D� A�E�FG� 7E0� H �� /��$�6�1 I�$J1 K)L$� M$6? * , N% O�FG� P%1 ,�%QR1 ��SNF=� * P?1 ,O�FG�1TU�0F�V W7E0� X�%@ 3�1 : ,:D,$�Z [Z�$� \�$�Z ]$� ,A�^�F$_1 �$`� U�$0F� �N$Da� \��Z

��b@ c�Zd1 ,<6�a�?1 eN6f1 U�0F� �a_ \��Z1 ,gh �6� e NFi1 U�0F� j5kl m; XN-N�1j��$�6� e�BNn1 U�0F� W oD,$� N$% ��=6p$� 7$E0� oD,$�1q��E6� gB�r6�sW 7E0� oB�6l K%@ 3�1 : �$D)�6,Z �$rB�a� ��t ���,; m; ]S�� \�%�Z1 ]S�- /���1 ,����� ��t �4�a� 3� �(�u; j�=a� U�0F� \@

g(���, ,O�FG� ��� v�� N%1 ,�Dh �i w; <ua^1 <6l��_1 �$�N0,� �,p$� M$6? /-�,i * 7��8 /%@ �,; �(6�� Q4t x�r,� oD,� 3; Q0�i N% :ld1<6E_ 3� yrE6�1 ,/r,� P% ���� \:z� ;�D6�1 1 W e�$;N-1 7��$8 �N$�; 3$� jQ$0? M$lN) * �Q$`i �$��J oD,�1 O�FG� P% 3; o6l �-1

I�J M6? * <��=6� �>?1 ,<S1{1 * A�$ZN6|� x1�$� K$� �N)1 }�6|�� x1�� ~:� �EG� \NSLk� 7��8 9:�; �E�@ �6^ ,j�456� /���6�1 <=�C 3; \�? N�1 ,}�6|�� <;:� OG� � sd1 ,U�0F� WU�0F��Z jc�) �Z�6? N% U�0F�� ��^ NFi c�Z@1 W���_N6� K%@ 3�1 : ,���$E� M����@ �� �

\��Z1 ,KD�%�,�1x1��1 x1�� * �%��@ W

0�1��!�� 23-4��:~:p� ,]� �( �p�6� ,~:p� �r0S ,�r0F� ,U�0F� W _________________________________________________________________________

Concept of Tibaaq in the Hadith Discipline: Definition, Evolution, Importance and Benefits

Saleh Abduallah Al-Sayyah*

Majma'ah University (Received 23/09/2015; accepted for publication 04/11/2015.)

Abstract: This research is concerned with the concept of tibaaq. The concept is commonly used by Hadith specialists, especially later ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims to: define the tibaaq concept form the linguistic and the technical points of view; show the relationship between the two definitions; establish the historical evolution of the term; describe tibaaq in terms of format, content and mode; and highlight the importance and benefits of tibaaq. The research follows an analytical inductive methodology. Among the research's important findings are: tibaaq highlights the Muslims' great care for their academic achievements, for tibaaq is not just a term, but is a reflection of the critical methodology applied by Hadith specilaists in dealing with Sunnah books and narrations for the purposes of safe and sound reporting; tibaaq and related new methodology have given rise to great changes in aspects of Hadith sciences, rules and requirements; it has been used widely in recent studies on jarh and ta'deel (processes of establishing incredibility or credibility of a narrator); in fact, Hadith specialists now require that a narrator's name has to be mentioned in the related tibaaq document, otherwise the narrator's calim to have listened to the book in question is not considered a vaild claim; and the most significant evolution of tibaaq is the writing of the tibaaq certificate or testimony. The research recoomends that the styles and methodologies applied by Hadith specialits should be studied, and so should their impact on the narrators and the narrated contents.

Keywords: tibaaq – listening – articulation – equivalence – matching listening content with written content - documentation

________________________________________________________________________

�*� ��6�@�;�p� Kp- ,����� ��� �� , ���?��l�pl ��� ��1 �N��� ����) ,��(��

I�� ���N�p� ��Z��� �|�(� ,& ,W }�391276 � �����11365�

(*)Assistant professor, Department of Islamic Studies,

College of Sciences and Humanities, Majma'ah University.

Rmaah, KSA, p.o box: (391276), Postal Code: (11365)

�1L|� ��w�: [email protected] e-mail:

Page 2: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

I��G� � �0; 3Z O��_: �,; U�0F����E� :e�BNn1 ,<6�b@1 ,<i5kl1 ,<�NDa�

– 38 –

0��5��: e�a`6pl1 <,��6pl1 e�(El � �(8 \d, �N�l1

�,�:;@ ����� 3�1 �,pal@ 1{ 3� ��Z, � e�� 3� �n<� /z� ,<� x��% �n /�z� 3�1 , <�d s \@ �DC@1

<� ��{ s e�^1 � sd, A�(f \@ �DC@1 e�0; <�N� 1 $pκ š‰r'‾≈ tƒ tÏ%©! $# (#θ ãΨ tΒ#u (#θ à) ®? $# ©! $# ¨,ym ϵÏ?$s) è? Ÿω uρ ¨è∫θ èÿ sC

āω Î) Ν çFΡ r& uρ tβθßϑÎ= ó¡•Β ⟨ � ��\�(;:102�W $pκš‰r'‾≈tƒ â¨$Ζ9$# (#θà)®?$# ãΝä3−/u‘ “Ï%©!$# /ä3s)n=s{ ÏiΒ <§ø�‾Ρ ;οy‰Ïn≡uρ

t,n=yzuρ $pκ÷]ÏΒ $yγy_÷ρy— £]t/uρ $uΚåκ÷]ÏΒ Zω%y Í‘ #Z��ÏWx. [!$|¡ÎΣuρ 4 (#θà)?$#uρ ©!$# “Ï%©!$#

tβθä9u!$|¡s? ϵÎ/ tΠ%tnö‘F{$#uρ 4 ¨βÎ) ©!$# tβ%x. öΝä3ø‹n=tæ $Y6ŠÏ%u‘ ⟨ �9�p,�:1�W $pκ š‰r'‾≈ tƒ tÏ%©! $# (#θ ãΖtΒ#u (#θ à) ®? $# ©! $# (#θ ä9θ è% uρ Zω öθ s% #Y‰ƒ ω y™ ⟨

�}�^t:70� W��Z ��@: KD0���$$�@1 7��$$8 9:$$�; o%�$$,� �$$n��� \�$$n 7$$���^t �$$n��� * �$$`��Z �$$�b@ �$$� ,K��E�FG$$�1 3$� �$��`� g$%1 ,A���$�i1 A�^�) ,A� 1 AsN0- ��1 1

D��d ��p� g6� j�(>�1 ,7��8 �N�;3a� P% 9:�; � W ��@ \@ �00^@ ,~N�N� P� jQ0|� ��bt K|�6�1 M���$�@ 3$� }N�$�@ �$� � ��$4 3� <6��4 * xN��Z

���E� 1 �$� g$6� KD|��p$� 3$� ��p�1 ,j NF6� N%1 s@ ,�D��;TU�0F�V <i5k$l1 <$�NDa� 3; �k|�� e�BNn1 <6�b@1W 6���� 0-4�� :

]B�$$C K$$� U�$$0F� �$$>|� ,7��$$8 /$$%@ �$$,;

I�$J M$6? * 3��456� 7��8 9:�; �,; <��=6� ��$SNF=�1 O�FG$� M6? *1 ,K)L�1 /���6�1 oD,$� 3; Q0�i N% :ld1 ,K� ��� v�� N%1 ,�%QR1 /$-�,i * 7��$8 /$%@ �$(B@ e�-@ xP� Q4t x�r,�

�� \:z� ;�D,�11� ��1 1 ��N0,� �,p� /$r,� P% ��<6E_1 W �d �$��J oD,$�1 O�FG$� P% �n@ �-1

e�$;N-1 7��$8 �N$�; 3$� MlN) * jQ0? �Q`i /��$�6�1 I�$J M$6? * <��=6$� �>?1 ,<S1{1

j�456� W eP$% �9�$) 3�@ 3�1 ?<�NDa� ��1 ?U�0F� :n �$�1 ?<$,; M$6? 3$� �1@ 3$�1 ?5k$l �6�1 ?��(p6�

6� � NF6� * e�$�@ �$�1 ?<$6�b@ �$�1 ?<$��; ��� g?<6(�-1 e�BNn ��1 ?x1��1 x1��W

�$� �� �Nr6$� �$� P%−��$�i � 9�$C \d − <6r�r^ ����1 ,<E��N6ZW

05'�/�� 2�7�8���: ��n@ �3 �� �)@ � ,x�E6�1 7E0� ��ZTU�$0F�V

��r6p� ��(�; �� �ZW 6���� 0��� :

,�`��Z ��b@ 7E0������6� N�t * m�6i: 1 − x1�� * ��� <��; MiLi A�|�p� �1�,6� <l@x1��1 W

2 − * �(D� ���E� M����@ 3� }N��@ \��Z

Page 3: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

�������� ��� �� ���� ,29 ���� ,�1� ����� ,�2017� 1438$%�

– 39 –

��N0,� �,p� /rlW 3 − �k$|�1 ,�,p��Z 7��8 9:�; ���,; c�Zd

M$$6? /$$rl [0$$� * KD6$$-�1 ,KD�%�$$,� N$$Fi 3$$;�D,�1�i1 ,7���^t W

9��:�6����: 1 − \��Z ]� ,A�^�F_1 �`� U�0F� �NDa� \��Z

:D,�Z [Z��W 2 − U�0F� j5kl m; XN-N�,gh �6� e NFi1 W 3 − c�$Zd1 ,<$6�a�?1 eN$6f1 U�0F� �a_ \��Z

j���6� e�BNn1 <6�b@W ;������� 07�8��� < �� :

gB�r6�s oD,� N% 7E0� P% * ]06� oD,�6� �DG$En1 �$�(��� j��� ]� * �1t />(6�1 ,q��E

,g(��� /��E6� M����@ �:�6� * ��>�1 ,�D6� �1 ,�$�Nr,� &NG$,� y$��Ni * ��(��� U�F� �:6; ]� ,\�$�0�1 /$�>(6�� c�$��Z K)L�  �Z �?PZ 9�a6?s1 /$f1 ,7$E0� ~N$�N(Z �$-�; <� �� m; �G6-s1

,� �%�k��� ,< j 1¡ ¢�,% 3|� �W 6���� 0 =:

�\N|67$E0� �$£�41 ,�$>E0� 3$� , /$? *1 M��F� ���� 7E0�,q� :? :

− ?�@� 6AA���� :����AA�� �AA� �� B�AA !� C 0AA�D� �AA���E�� �:

− �1t M�F� :�`�� * U�0F�W − ��>� M�F� :I�F_s * U�0F�W − 7��>� M�F� : U�0F� j5kle NFi1W

− F�G�� 6���� :��A����� �A����� �A� �� 0!A* C �A���E�� � 0�D�:

− �1t M�F� :<6�a�?1 eN6f1 U�0F� �a_W − ��>� M�F� :U�0F� ��b@ W − 7��>� M�F� :U�0F� �BNnW

− 0H�I� :2��*����� <������ J:� K LM����C * * *

?�@� 6���� :,�� �� B� !������� ?�@� E- �� :0N-�� O �� ��C

�$$,Z �$$�− 3$$� A�E�FG$$� �1�$$,6l 3$$El1 ���E� ��E�FG�−�$n ;�$`� e�$,�� m$; �$rl \@

3$� �$r>0l �$�>��8 ��E�FG$� 3$� AQ>? \@ �ah A�$�B�) 1@ A���i A�rZ�Fi <�� yZ�F6i 7�EZ xN`�� �%�,��,

$? P$�1 ;:D,$�Z �$� �$-�; ¢�,% \N|� 1@ 3$� �$Zs \� �$n��� �$�1�f1 ,U�0F� 3; �`�� /%@ ��? ���6�

O�FG$� 3� \N��E� e�G- �� ���� }�-@TU�$0F�V :,�^eNr�S@ g$6� �EG$� g$%1 ,~:p$� �$r0S m;

3$$� ~:p$$� 1¤$$^ 3�P$$� �$$��1@ 9:$$�@ �$$¥ \1�$$i}�6|� x1 3� 1@ ,KD=�CW

U�0F��n : �� �1 ,�$ �r0�S 1�@ y$�0�S ]$� � �N �( �p$� <$�,

Page 4: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

I��G� � �0; 3Z O��_: �,; U�0F����E� :e�BNn1 ,<6�b@1 ,<i5kl1 ,<�NDa�

– 40 –

U�0F� :� �r0S UN�n � �r0S�1�W x�ct �� � 3Z ��- :T�r0F� :\N¥�k6� � �N �r �� W

�� �r�0 �S H��,� �1 : �Z 3� /zn@ KDz��ZV�2�W <$$�Nrn :T\N¥�k$$6� � �N$$ �r ��V �$$,�� \N$$|� �$$- ,

,U�$0F� O�FG$� * \N��$E6� <$u^s xP� xN`��0S * 1�?� 3� \@ �06;�Z Nz$EZ N¥�k$i ~:p$� �r

3p��Z 1@ ,¦�k� 3; gr�6��Z 1@ ,~:p� P%W H �n 3Z ��-1:T �y�0�S : §9��F�, §9��0 �� �1 , §X�$ �r �� �1 :

©N §p$�0 �� 9 � �ª �] �� �1 �m �; «� §� �� �N §% �1 , ¬� � �1 ¬O� �E �_ ¬/ �_�@ §<�� ­F � §� ��6 � �<���> �� �m �; W §y$�0�F� ���� �� �3 �� W$ §r�i §�N : §�$ �r�0 �S�@

���$�>��� ¬y$�0�S §� �1� �t�$�n , �9 � �®� �m �; �9 � �®�$�؛ �r�Z� �F�i ��$ �- �1 W �r�Z� �S �1 � ������ �k$� � ���Z §�: �$ � �1 1 �P$ � �m$ �; �: §D�6$ �� �� �) ���d W

� ���i ��$ �� �� ��$ �|�� �3$ �� �� �;� �z$�i �$ �� §3$ �E�l ��,�� �($ �� ���� �P�� �1�$$ Ar�Z��F §� W �� �1 �] �G$$ �� �_ �1 , �/ �G$$�� �_ �1 , ��$$ �) �� �) §/$$�> �� ��$$�� W §y�0�F� �1 : �� ��� �J �3 �� §� �; �:� �Jg$­F ؛ � §� y�0 �F�Z ���� �� �<­0 §C �:�l�d �1 �� � � �t W §��$ �r §� �1 : ��$ �� �1 A�$ �r�0 �S �1 �$ Ar�0�S §K�,$ � �� ��: ��$$ �� �1 ���d

 ���Z �� ���Z � �D §z ���Z W ���� �� �* §H��� �r �� �1 ¬� � �1 �<­� §? V�3�W <�Nrn: T$ �; ©N §p�0 �� 9 � �ª �] �� �1 �m �; «� §� �� �<$���> �� �m

§<�� ­F � §� ��6 �V �d �u,��$Z U�0F� m; �,�� P% y0F,� �- ��=6p$� �$rn ,9:$�t <�n /�pi xP� \N��� ���i

�1� �ul:� \1�4�1 �aFG� K�%�Z ,[��N� K���2 550 W� �2� �� � 3Zs ,�`�� j�D��1 358 W� �3� H �n 3Zs ,�`�� v���r��3 439−440W�

9:�t j�>|� ;y0S 3� �>?@W <�N- P?1:T ���d� �D §z ���Z �� �� �1  ���Z �� ���Z V y0F,� �-

�Dz$�Z �N)1 �d �u,��Z U�0F� �E_ m; �,�� P% �d �u,��$Z 1@ ,}�$6|�� ~:p� v��� ���6� ; �Z ��Z ��;��1 ��r0S 3� }�6|� ~:� �|6� ;�r0F� �|i

�i1�a6� ��,�c ��� * j���6�W N$$u,� 3$$Z ��$$-1:T §y$$�0�F� : ,9 � �ª ­/$$ §? §9�$$�F �R

� �J �1 �y�0�F�i1 �y�0�F�l�n < �r�0 �S1 < �r�0 �S�@ �� �- �1 ,U�0�S�@ §] �( : e�$�F �R A�$r�0�F §� §<�� �� �) �1W WW §y$�0�F�: �9 � �®$� �m$ �; � �c �s 9�$�F �R «/$? W

9 � �ª ­/? §y�0�S1 : §<$ �r�Z�S ��$ �- �1 ; ¬U�$0�S�@ §] �(� �J �1 , §e �1� �� � �� A�$-�0�S1 A�r�Z�F� W\����k$� �y�Z�$F�i1 :�� �1�p$i W §�$r�Z�F�1 :

�r�nN� Wy§Z�F�6�1 : §U� �a­i �s W � ������ �k$� � ��$�Z §� �r�Z�S1: ��d :D6-�$$��@1 �$$ � �1 1 �P$$ � �m$$ �; �: §D�6$$ �� �� �) W7$$��� ��$$- :

�3$ �� �$ � �1 «/$ §? �1 , $ ���Z �m$ �; � �D §z ���Z ¬U�0�S §�N(p�� �?P�1 ,�r�0�S �U��0­F�, §�� �r§� �n : ¬y�0�S W¯�;�t §3�Z : §y�0�F� :

� °�§t �� ���Z � °�§t Wg�(_�t : � �± �|����Z , §y�0­F� : �3 �� §�;:J �H��,� W �e ��� �� §3�Z :y�0�F�1 : \N� ��$ �� �� �H�$�,� �3 �� §� �; �:� �J

�/��- �1 , �K §D���> �� A� �;�� �� : �H�$�,� �1 �� ��$� �J �3$ �� §�$ �; �:� �J �N$ §% Wx�@ , ¬y�0�S1 �H��,� �3 �� ¬y�0�S � �l �9� �) �1 : ¬Q�> �?V�4�W

<�Nrn:T �9 � �®� �m �; � �c �s 9��F �R «/?V<$�N- P?1 ,: T �$ � �1 1 �P$ � �m$ �; �: §D�6$ �� �� �) ��d � ������ �k$� � ��$�Z §� �r�Z�S1

:D6-���@1V �� �d �u,��Z U�0F� m; �,�� P% y0F,� �- ,

�4� Nu,� 3Zs ,}��� \�p��10 209 −210 W�

Page 5: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

�������� ��� �� ���� ,29 ���� ,�1� ����� ,�2017� 1438$%�

– 41 –

$��d �1²$� �l��G$$�1 ³$a8 3$� v$��� �$$�Z �$��^ <X�f 1�� �� �D��d /Gis �6^ �� ��F`6�1W

<�N- P?1:T \����k$� �y�Z�$F�i1 :�� �1�p$iV P$?1 ,<�N-:T §U� �a­i �s ,�r�nN�V m$; �$,�� P$% y$0F,� �$- ,

,~:p$� P¥ �D�n K�1�pi �d �u,��Z U�0F��Z 3� N?P� :�$n Na�64 \d1 K´�,$�@1 K��$r0S X�64�$Z ,e�$;�%QR1 KD6l�|�1 W

���0S �d �u,��Z U�0F� m; �,�� P% y0F,� :? j���6� �E_ �´t ;9:�t �D�n /�pi g6� �EG�

�r� ��1�p6�W <�N- P?1:T §y$�0�F� :�$ °�§t ��$ ���Z �$ °�§tV, P$?1

<$$�N-:T y$$�0�F�1 :$$�,� �3$$ �� §�$$ �; �:� �J A�$$ �;�� �� \N� ��$$ �� �� �H� �K §D���> ��V 3$� }�$6|� ~:� �|6� ;�r0F� �|i �06;�Z ,

�i1�a6� ��-1@ * j���6� ��;��1 ��r0SWW <�N- P?1:T x�@ , �H�$�,� �3 �� ¬y�0�S ��l �9� �) �1 : ¬Q$�> �?V,

U�$0F� * ���p$� 9:$�t j�$>? �d �u,��$Z N% W ��$-1x��Z�c1Qa� :T §y�0�F�1 : 3� A�z�@ §y�0�F�1 ,9ª ­/? §9�F �R

9ª ­/? : §<$ �) �11 ,A�$-�0�S1 A�$ �r�Z�F §� <$ �r�Z�S �-1 , §e1�� �� 1@ , �\�$$��� 3$$� §\ ��$$ �r�1 ,<$$��; §/$$ �? �²§� xP$$�1 , �� t

����J1 �H�,� 3�1 , A��, �� �\1+�; : §�;:J 1@ , §Q>|�V�5�W <�Nrn:T �;:JV,$� \N$|� �u,��Z N% * ���p�;�� U�0F�W

�5� & x��Z�c1Qa�� ,[�E� HN��r� �902 W�

[��N� K��� * 9�)1:T y�0�F� : eQ$`� yZ�F� ��$� �8 �1 , �<��n / �? �² §� 9�l1 9�k`�1 9�F`�1 , §< �� x �1� �p�

U�$0S1 U�$0S@ <$��1 ,���,�1 W�$ �r�0 �F�1 : �$�Z /$�J ��$$� �8 �1 ,�$$D; 1�@ °3$$� �* \N¥�k$$6� � �N$$ �r �� 1�@ ,/$$�J

���,�1y0S1 �� �r�0 �S <��1 ,�) ��1 �0i��1V�6�W <�Nrn:T /�J ��Z /�JV �$,�� P% y0F,� �- ,

~:$� �$|6� ;�$r0F� �$Z�6? �$|i �$06;�Z U�0F� m;�a�6µ \��c@ * j���6� ��;��1 ��r0S 3� }�6|�W

<�N- P?1:T §< �� x �1� �p�� eQ`� yZ�F�W WW � �N �r �� 1@ �* \N¥�k$$6�$$� �8 �1 ,�$$D; 1�@ °3$$� �$$0i��1 �$$��,�1 ��

�) ��1V U�$0F� * 3� N?P$� m; �,�� P% y0F,� , 11�p$i1 ,N¥�k$i ~:p� �r0S * 1�?� 3� \@ �06;�Z * �$0i��1 �) �1 ���,�1 ��EZ 1@ ,~:p� P% NzEZ KDB:$�@ 3�1�$6Z 1@ ,¦�k� 3; gr�6��Z 1@ ,~:p� P%

* A����j�^1 �a�E_W ���0S �d �u,��Z U�0F� m; �,�� P% y0F,� :? j���6� �aE_ �´N|� ;9:�t <�n /�pi g6� �EG�

�r�1 H�r� ��1�p6�W 3� �p�� U�0F� ³a� \@ �d �e ��� �� 3Z M%�1 }�Z 3� N% :ld1 ,U��0�S@ y0S ]� �\t ;y0S ]� }�Z

��FR N% y0F� \@1 , �G���- �rn ,9 � �ª ­/ §? §9 :T §9��FR

�6� 3��$$4�1 �aFG$$� K�%�$$Z ,[�$$�N� K$$����2 551 �X¶6Z W

Page 6: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

I��G� � �0; 3Z O��_: �,; U�0F����E� :e�BNn1 ,<6�b@1 ,<i5kl1 ,<�NDa�

– 42 –

�� � �t �9��F� �� �/��- <�, �� �1 , §< �� ¬y�0�S 9 � �ª ­/ §? : <�, �� �1 , ¬y�0�S <� �N �- − ��� ���i − : yìö7 y™ ;N≡uθ≈ yϑy™ $]%$t7 ÏÛ ( ⟨ �����:3�x�@ , :

x�@ , A� �r�Z��F §�1 A�-��0S � �D�6�0 � � �_ � �D�, �� j�^1 «/ §? �rZ�S : �R e �P �%e �P �% �1 , �e �P�� ¬9��F /�- �P �% 3� �1 ,� �D�, �; / �G�a§i � �D�6·

��� �t m; � �� �r �a�6 §(�� : �P �? �1 �P �? m; \�r�Z��F�6 §� W � �( �p�n − §<�l� �E�0 §� − �]� �� �\t ;y�0�S �³a� m; ] �(� §� K��n , � �� �G��Z

U��0�S@ �y0�SWWW �S1 §< �� ¬y�0�S �9®�� g­F � �1 ¬U�0V�7�W ���� 3� �;N(� ¸�=6pl \@ 3|(� y0� �¹1 U�$Sd �%�^@ 3� 1@ �D,� P �4§@ �- \N|� \@ 3|(� g6�

K� ���E�TU�0F�V W �d �D(�pri 3|(� ���� eP%1��p-@ ����:

�1t Kpr� : �l1� 3�P� j1���Z �r��6� ������6� ���� g%1 ,~:p� �r0FZ K%º:�@��:

1− ,��$� �8 �1 ,�$D; 1�@ °3$� �* \N¥�k6� � �N �r �� �) ��1 ,�0i��1 ,���,�1W

2− �3 �� §� �; �:� �J ,� °�§t �� ���Z � °�§t ,/�J ��Z /�J K §D���> �� A� �;�� �� \N� �� �� �� �H��,�W

3−H��,� �3 �� �;:J 1@ �;:J W 4−x@ , �H��,� 3� y0S :Q�>?W 5− U� �a­i �s1 ,�r�nN�W

��$$>� Kp$$r� : �a�E$$_1 j�5$$Z �$$r��6� ��$$�� g$%1 ,~:p� 1¤^ 3� 9:�@ �¥ �l1� g6� 3�1�6�

�7� e��� 3Zs ,¸G=��2 435W�

����6� ����: 1− � ������ �k� � ���Z §� �r�Z�S : 1 �P$ � �m$ �; �: §D�6 �� �� �) ��d

:D6-���@1 ,� � �1W 2−9ª ­/? §9�F �R W 3− �c �s §9��F �R 9 �®� �m �; �W 4−<��­F � §� ��6 � �<���> �� �m �; ©N §p�0 �� 9 � �ª §] �� �1 W

7��>� Kpr� : �rZ�p� �(pr��Z �r��6� ��������6� ���� g%1 ,:D��?:

1−<�� x �1� �p�� ,eQ`� yZ�F� W 2−\����k� �y�Z�F�i :�� �1�piW 3− ���Z �� ���Z � �D §z ���Z �� �� �1 W

O�FG$$� ���$$E� ��=6$$� \@ �$$�l P$$|%1 1�1 y$nN6� N$% /$Z ,�$`�� ��$�� 3; »�h � U�0F�

�D�l��� �^@ ]� 1@ ,�D�� �r��1 �-�;W F�G�� E- �� :"D *P� O �� ��C

����6� ���i 3� �)@ � ,x�E6�1 7E0� ��ZU�0F� − O�FG$� P% <��; �r6� :? − ���$E� �$,;

A�$$a���i \@ P$$% * M0p$$� /$$��1 ,A�$$r�-�1 A�E$$�1 s �D���=6p$� �$,; ���Z �n1���1 �r0F� ��E�FG� �$$)�8 5k$$,i 3$$|�1 ,X °�$$�§� s X1�$$�� ��d ;X °�$$�§i �$�� ]$-1 :$? ,��5kl 3� /�NS \��c ��Z �¥ ����6�� 7��$$8 9:$$�; 7$$|� �$$rn ,7��$$8 O�FG$$� K$$���

�i \1� �Dn�k� <i�E�FG� \N�1�6� ;j�$��; \1�r� 3�1

Page 7: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

�������� ��� �� ���� ,29 ���� ,�1� ����� ,�2017� 1438$%�

– 43 –

��)1 ���,;1 ,��P� �)�8 ����1 ,�¥ ���6� KD6n�������6�1 ��G,6� @�Z ,��8 �z6-1 ,�)�8W

A�$n1��� \�$? �$rn ,U�0F� * ,�,% ��8 P|%1 \�$r� /$0- �>^�$0�1 9:$��� �,; A�E�11 A NDk�1

s :Z +; x��8 <Z ����6� ���6p�W :$$��� \@ :$$? I+$$�1 ����6��$$Z eN�1�$$,i 9

N%1 ,¼�4t <B:�@ �^5Z y�rE6�1 /�Ga6�1T �$Z�6?]� �( �p�6�V I�F$_s �r6p$� \@ /$0- <(� P% \�?1 ,

K��Z <��;TU�0F�VW O�FG$$� P$$% �$$���i �1�$$^ 3$$� �1@ /$$��1 ��$� N$% <$� ���$E� ��=6$� ]$� M��,6� A�a���i

<$Z�6? * ,x1�=p�T ,�$��`�* ,�$��� I{ * K$�;��1��V \N,; �· T ](p$� �:$�Z / �( �� �� �1 , �]� �( �p�6� � �Z��6�?

MG�6� ¢�i �1V <i��G$- * x �$J 3$Z �Nr� A�^{ ,T���� * ��1�� K�;V : T �~ �: �p$$$$$���Z U�$$$$$0F� M$$$$$6 �|� �1* g$$$$;1 [0$$$$� �1 UN$$$$�N� [$$$$ �=�ZV

�� A�^ �C x1�=p� ��-:T �$D6�l �� �$��a�� �? 3$� ����p$� �$�Z��6�? 3$� j�� �� �� �<�Z ��) � �� m; <0l ~:p� W

�$$r0F�1 : ~:p$$? ,&�$$4 9ª * \N?Lk$$� �$$;:JeNEl1 ,&NGµ }�6? W �r0F� Mi�? \N|� \@ �`0,�1

��@ <l�n ;<Z �-N�N� * ���V�8�W

�8� I{ ���`�& x1�=p�� ,��1�� K�; * ���� �95−96 W�

X�$; :$ld1 ,U�$0F� X�$�� � �$,% x1�=p�1 �%�^1− �r0F� g%1 − �$- g6� ��N`�� �D�l��� �^5Z

]$� y$a6� :$Z �$� /$°>� <,|� ,�D,� A�N45� U�0F� \N|�<$�NrZ ,KD^�F$_1 ���E� X�;:T }�$6? ~:p$?

&NGµVW ����i ¸�=6pl \@ x1�=p� e�?� �¹ 3|(�1

�$´5Z e�,; U�0F�:T ~:$� * �?Lk$� �$;:J �$Z�6?&NGµ }�6?VW

X��§� U�0F� \N|�1$Z A�rZ�� T]� �( �p$�6� �Z�6?V , /$$%@ �$$,; �]� �( �p$$�6� �$$Z�6? �$$���i 3$$; §�$$>EZ �$$rn A�a���i ���r6� I�F_s M6? * �)@ �1 ,I�F_s 3$� �1@1 ,K��$� e�$,�� IN$�1 ��� M0� /��1 ,<� �$(; 3$Z K�%�$Zd 3��$� \�$%�Z N$% <n�; <l@ ��)1

g;�r0���:885$% � <$Z�6? *T�$�nN� �$|,�, * :$Z ��a�t I{V<�n ��- :T §<�N-:T §]�(p�6�V §<� �($ �� 3� �N §%

A���( �p�i :/$>� , �~: �p$� �d §<0p$�l ���d : �d <0p$l ���d §<r °p$n�,��1 , �ypa� : A�60>� �����p� �9:�@ M6|� �[Z�z� �\@

KD��d §< �� A�0��l1 , �~:p� K�V�9�W x1�=p� <n�;1��:902$% �5Z ��rn ,�r0F� <l

g-��� �N- A�^{:T ]�(p$6� �Z�6?V :T�(p$� N$%1 :�r0F��ZV�10�W

�9� g;�r0�� ,��a�t I{ * :Z ��nN� �|,��2 186 W� �10� x1�=p�� ,7��8 ��a�@ I+Z 7�`� O6n�3 114W�

Page 8: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

I��G� � �0; 3Z O��_: �,; U�0F����E� :e�BNn1 ,<6�b@1 ,<i5kl1 ,<�NDa�

– 44 –

P$$$?1− A�z$$$�@ − x �G$$$lt �$$$��?c <$$$n�; ��:926$%���- �rn ,:T ]�(p6� �Z�6? : ,~:p� �,�(Z

�r0F��Z �(p�V�11�W ��N��� j NDk� �´N? M0p�1 ,�r0F� �n��� �1

:D6-1 * ��(�6p�1 j�%�½W Z1 U�$$0F� �$$���i 3$$|(� ��$$�� P$$% �$$�

<l5Z A�^�F_ :T ,����p$�1 ] ­(p$� ¦�k� K� �Z�6? ~N(p$� }�6|� 3� ]�N(Z ~:p� v��1 ,~N(p�1

¦�k� �-�ZV W �$$�F4 j��D$$C1 ��$$0�d �$$r��1 g$$% U�$$0F��n

�SN0z�1 �r�N�1 �ZN6|� W A�$l�%�Z1 A�$�S�- A��$�� ��i1 A�$$�h �i A�%�$$C1 A��S�$$� P$$% �E$$_ m$$; A�$$�-�Z A���$$Z@

��|k$6� 1@ 3$�F�� A�$r�F� ��� �n ,<6���1 gr�6��D�nW

�s:�6�s O��Ni 3p¾ M�F� P% ��64 *1 ³a�� ¼�4t ��^�F_sTU�$0F�V ,���$E� �$,;

K%QR1 : ��a,G$� 9�r6$� ��4 3(n \N��E� ��5np$� �$- K$´@ ��)1 ,7��8 O�FG� K�; * \N�(�6

³a�TU�0F�V �4� �,�� <Z \1����1 −�$� QR y0$�− N%1T��r0F�Vx@ : ��,�c ,�D;Nl \�? A��@ ,j1�� Mi��

�%QR 1@ ,��(�; 1@ ,�l�?W P% 3�1 :��a�t * g-��� ³n�8 �N-:

�11� ���?�� ,g-��� ��a�@ I+Z g-�0� O6n x �Glt �2 63 W�

T §�$$$$� �� ���i �� ��$$$$ §� �\�d ¬U�$$$$�0�S �K$$$$ §% �1* �/$$$$$��- : §�$$$$$� ���i �1�@ �j � �+$$$$$ �; �$$$$$�6�, ��V

<�NrZ <^{1:T �$06;�Z ��$r0S m$; �Z�EG� ,����a� �%�k� �NDC 1@ j��� 1@ ��� �d KDr0�

�%�; * K��r0S �?PZ �,6; 3� ��? ��64 �-1V�12�W P% 3�1− A�z�@ −<�N- :

T §]�Z�$$$$�6� �U�$$$$�0­F� * «�$$$$ �� §� ��$$$$ �- �1*

§]�B� �k$$$$$$� §\N$$$$$$ §|�� ��d �K �D� ���Z�$$$$$i *

���$$$$�l ­�� � �5$$$$? �K §D�,$$$$ �; �/$$$$ �(�8*

��� �p$$$$�n 1 §� �N$$$$ �% �1 �9�$$$$ �) §v$$$$ �| ���1V

<$�NrZ <^{ K� :Tx@ : * �,$_ 3$� �$�� �$- M$��`� \N|� ;��Z�6� ~�0i@ * ��Z�6�  �Z ��r0F� ,KD,$; <$�¿1 ,��Z�$6� 3$; <$6�1 <,; ]B�k�1 <��;

\N?� 3Z � �0; ��l�� ¯5?V�13� W P% 3�1− A�z$�@ − * gSN�p$� ³n�$8 �N$-

��a�t : T ��$$«� �(�6� �1 �� �N$$ �r �� �I��F$$ �_ x � ��$$ ��*

��$$$$$�� �� ���$$$$$ �) ­�� �M$$$$$�i �� �� � ��$$$$$�Z

�12� g-���� ,j�?P6�1 j¶06� I{�2 136 W��z�@ �ul1 : O6n x1�=p�� ,7��8 ��a�@ I+Z 7�`��4 148�eQR1 ,W

�13 � ,j�?P6�1 j¶06� I{ g-���� �2 167W� �z�@ �ul1 : O6n7��$8 �$�a�@ I+Z 7�`�,x1�=p$�� �4 162−163� ,

eQR1W

Page 9: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

�������� ��� �� ���� ,29 ���� ,�1� ����� ,�2017� 1438$%�

– 45 –

�U�$$$$$�0­F� �1 ���� �z$$$$$� �1 �$$$$$ �r�� �** �U�$$$�S�À�� ��$$$ � §M$$$��F� �Á �P$$$ �?V�14�

<�N-1− A�z�@ −: T$$$$�0­F� §�$$$$ �4� �1 �v$$$$�l�@ g$$$$�-s �U�* �v$$$$�- �1 , Âx ��$$$$ §_ �P$$$$ �? M�B�$$$$ �� �1

§/ �z$$$�n�t �$$$ ���@ ¬v$$$ �� �1§@ �K §% § �Q$$$ �4 �1:* §3�Z�$$$�n §/$$$ �( �� �� �\�$$$ �? �1 , �M­� �p$$$§��V�15�

���E� QR ��@1 − �R�0� 9:�; K%1 − \�n TU�0F�V 3� N%1 ,]��0� K�; ~Nl@ 3� K%�,;

��N,�� ��, °pE� A�z�@ � °(p�1 , : y�0F6�1 �rZ�F��ZN%1 ,²n�|6�1 ��z°6�1 :3���z6� �Z ](J ,x@:

* ��Z�r6� ��,�� <�Nr? ,��(J − ���i − : öΝ åκ â:|¡øt rB uρ

$Wß$s) ÷ƒ r& öΝ èδ uρ ׊θ è% â‘ 4 ⟨ ��D|�:18��16�W �$�R�0� �|,� �d KD06? * \N��E� ���i �d1

/%@ ��E�FG(Z N��· x1�$,� �N$- ��� 3�1 ,�R�0� �0=,� ���r� * ��^ 3Z �N- A�^ �CT H�,� �d <�� @

A Pl1 AQkZV :T ]��$0� ~Nl@ 3� <�n1TU�$0F�VN$%1 :�b1 ,3���z6� ���d :j P,�1 ,j �k0�V�17�W

�14� � ��a�@7��8 K�; * gSN�p& gSN�p�� , �91W� �15� yZ�p� �G� & �116W� �16� �$$ul: xNl�$$D6�� ,�N$$���1 \N$$,a� ��^�F$$_ X�k$$?

�2 1125��$$$R�0� �N$$$�; * I�z$$$�1 , g$$$,�1�r�� , & �317W�

�17� I{ ��1 ��-N�� x1�,(�� ,�|a� �0=l �1 207W�

6��G�� E- �� :�8� �� ,�� �� Q���C U�0F� �:�6��Z \N��E� @�Z;�d1 y$��N6� ��$0

\�$? <$l@ m$; ��$� <$i�)1 ¸$l ��-@1 ,A�|0� ~:p� ��$$>� \�$$r� 3$$� Q$$4t ]$$Z�� * A�$$n1���1 A NDk$$� 3$; x�$��D��� <$)�4@ �$� N% ¸,� P%1 ,x���

��- ,xc�� �; c ¯@ :T �$nN|��Z /) m; /) �;� m; \�?1 ,���R 3Z ¸a^ �d :?�E6n ,e��d <�,� A�;:�

,�nN|� 9�z-}�$6|� M^�G$� ¸$a^ ��rn : »�$4@ ¢�$� [$=Z /$)�� P$% ~:$� 3� \�? :n ,�06? �,��d

<,� ¢�,�a;@ <F=Z \�? ��1 ,¢�,���@ W �; c ¯t /�rn :��- ?<6�(� 3¹ : U�E$�d 3�

x �Glt ��N� 3ZV�18� W �r� ��-�19�:T 3$; xQZ�$� � �0; �Z@ ��5�

��rn ,P% : K|^ }�0� P% * 9g� s ;P% 3� 3p^@ ~:6$$��Z e�$$� m$$; �� }�$$6|� M^�$$_ [$$4 \t

eQR ��-1 ,<,� <0^�_ :9®Z v��V�20�W

�18� /$$_�a� ��$$E�1 x1�$$� �$$Z x�$$��D���� ,g;N$$� & �589 W�<)�4@ <r��S 3�1 : ]��J * x��`0� M�FÁ

]��p� }��1 x1�� U�4t�1 241�, ��$�; �r�1 �N_@ �n��� �d ~�� *& ~:p� ���ri1 ��1�� �223W�

�19� x���D��� <pal �,G� N%W �20� /$$_�a� ��$$E�$$��D���� ,g;N$$�1 x1�$$� �$$Z x�

& �589 W�<)�4@ <r��S 3�1 : ]��J * x��`0� M�FÁ ]��p� }��1 x1�� U�4t�1 241�, ��$�; Ã�r�1

� ���ri1 ��1�� �N_@ �n��� �d ~�� *& ~:p �223W�

Page 10: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

I��G� � �0; 3Z O��_: �,; U�0F����E� :e�BNn1 ,<6�b@1 ,<i5kl1 ,<�NDa�

– 46 –

���R 3Z ¸a^ �Nrn:T :$n ,�$06? �,��d »�4@ \�$? �$�1 ,¢�,���@ ¢�� [=Z /)�� P% ~:� 3� \�?

<$,� ¢�,�a;@ <F=ZV 9:$�@ �$Z�6? \@ m$; 9�$�Z ��$� � �l�? ~N(p� }�6|� * ����p� j NDk$�1 �$n1��

¼�� A�r6p�1 A��6�� A�ZN��@ O0_@ <l@1 ,�-N� ��� * M^�$$_ /$$)�� �5p$$� � ¸$$a^ \N$$|� ;���$$E�

�=p,� : �06?@9:�@ »�4�Z e��@ :ld1 ?s �@ ��(p� j{�0� <06?; ?]��p� x1�� K� M6? �3 �� [=Z �u,��

?]��p� x1�� [=Z �@ ,�=p,� M^�_ [=Z@W ¸a^1��1 ���R 3Z :,�$B��1 j+$; ]0� �,�

*Ni1 :/$�-1 ,�$B��1 ��p$i1 ]$Z @ �,� : v$Ä �,$�/�-1 ,��pi1 :��pi1 �� �,�� 21�W

/$-@ <$,|� ,¸,� P% �,�� * �4� ¸l ¢�,%1 �]� �( �p$�6� �$Z�6?1 ,U�$0F� �N)1 m; ��� ,<,� �^Å x�$��D��� e�?� ,7��>� \�r� 3� �1t �G,� /0-

−z�@ A�− ��$�R 3$Z ¸a^ �d K?�E6� �G- e�?� ��Z �� N%1 ,�al� j N?P� ��- ,}�^ 3Z K�%�Zd e1 :T \�?

3; v0^ A�l�n \@ e�,; x��6� �d Æ���F� ���N� NZ@]Z °�� M^�_ �d ��ri ,<;:� \�n�22� \�$?1 ,<p$0En ,

�21� * <6��i �ul : g0%P�� ,9�0,� ��;@ Q��9 22−34W� �22 � ��- 3|� ,7EZ ��Z e�,�� �)@ � M�FÁ »��; �(f N6?��

,g;N$�1 x1�$� �$Z /_�a� ��E� }�6? m; <r���i * & x���D�����590 � K- ��C�^�1 :�TM$r�� P% m; �>�l �=

<,�Z1 <,�Z ����� N%1 ,<��d <£�=Z 7�0�V�23�W ���N� NZ@1��1 Æ���F� : �$���1 ��$� �,$�

�B��1�6B��1 3�+;1 ]0� �,� ���1 ,�24�W }�$$Z * x�$$��D��� �$$b�?� \�G$$,� \P$$%1

N%1 ,�^1T ~:p� ],�V�25�, ��; <�n e�G- \@ g,�� �¹ <$��; /�� xP� ~N(p� }�6|� P4@ 3� P�(�6� ],�

<�n ���p� ����p� 9:�@ ]� <(� W$�FÁ <rn11 M �1t ¸,� * x��`0�− 3Z ¸a^ �d K?�E6� �G-

���R−��$>� ¸,$� \1� ,* �1t ¸,$� �$?� �$rn T * ��$� 3� ��1 ,~:p� M6? j �;d * M�RL� }�Z

~�,6�s1 /=0� y��S ���V�26� W �$rn ��$>� ¸,� ��@1

=e�,�� m;1WWW g(�1 ,��p-@ ��Z @ �(pr� �l�? j¶0� /��1 P$% xNr�1 ,]Z�� M^�GZ �D,� ]Z /? * 3�t 3; �1²p�

\@ x�,; \N$r�F� M��- �D; �d Nl�? ¶� * H�,�T3(>$�V �S+� Kp- m; WwÁ <��; /(¾ �,�� }�-@ P%1VW

�23� /$$_�a� ��$$E� x�$$��D���� ,g;N$$�1 x1�$$� �$$Z & �589 W�<)�4@ <r��S 3�1 : ]��J * x��`0� M�FÁ

]��p� }��1 x1�� U�4t� 1 243W� �24� * <6��i �ul :� 9�0,� ��;@ Q�10 341−345W� �25� �(�|�T~:p�V K%�G$r� X���1 ,j���; \��� ���E� �,;

�� K%�,; �D�l��� 3�1 ,U��p� 3� �¥ x��`0� M�FÁ e1 |� *& �$�1�� K�; * ���a �323 � 3$Z �$��� 3$; e�,p$Z

vl@,��- :T}¡@ ���� m; �l�,; ~:p� :��1@ : m; �i9�-����,��>�1 :���; ���� j9�-,7��>�1 : ���� ���d ]n�� \@

�� �Nr�n ,<n�; �- A�Z�6? :g,; e1 VW �26� �ul:M$�F=�� ,]��p$� }��1 x1�$� U�$4t ]��$J =

Page 11: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

�������� ��� �� ���� ,29 ���� ,�1� ����� ,�2017� 1438$%�

– 47 –

<0^�$_1 <$|��� �d }�$6|� j��$;d m; 78 <,� KDnrn ,e �;@ xP�<$�NrZ <$lN,; ,�$4� }�$Z * <�$�1 � :

T * 9�) ��1 ,�¥�E_@ 3; j ��6p� M6|� v0^ �%�?�¥�Z @ �d �%� /���6Z ��tV�27�W

/$rl �$rn ,~N$�N� P$% * 7$��� ¸l ¢�,%1 \�$? <$l@ /$0,^ 3$Z �$¿@ ��� 3; x��`0� M�FÁ e�r; xP� ]�(p6��Z &�Á }�0� gan ,]�(p6� M6|�

$$�FÁ <$$Z�6? * MT }��1 x1�$$� U�$$4t ]��$$J]��p�Ve:�1 , :T ,<$,; �N$r,� * x1�� ��(pi K�

<,� <;:� ¤^ 3� ��(pi1V��- ,:T xP$� * M$6|�1 m$�n ,}�$6|� �1@ * M6|� :?,¦� �6�1 ]�(p6� <��� ��@ 1 ,��N��� �,4N�C 3� �;�� �N_@ ��%�C P%

@ � �0; ¯@ [=Z A�Z�6? <�($� �¹ /0,^ 3Z �(f 3Z �¿<,� �- 1 ��C�^ *1 ,� �0; <,Z <,� :� �0; È�ZV�28�W

]$Z ¸l ¢�,%1− A�z$�@ − ,~N$�N� P$% * <0ki ,~:p� ],� M0pZ ��- �d K?�· �G- N%1 �G-

��$i A�z�@ g%1 ,j N?P� ���R 3Z ¸a^ �d K?�E6�� �( �p$�6� �$Z�6?1 ,U�0F� �N)1 m; \�$r� �$��´ /$0- �]

3$Z �0�$C 3$Z }N$r�� 3Z �¿@ 3Z �(f �%1 ,7��>�

= x��`0��1 240W� �27� yZ�p� �G��1 242W� �28� ��$`0� M$�F=�� ,]��p$� }��1 x1�� U�4t ]��J x

�1 268−269 W�

��- ,��G� :T 3$Z /�;:$�d �d A�) ��- A�) ��@ * 7��$8 * A�;:� <� \@ <��; �;��n ,�r� U�E�d ,<��; �;�� /�;:�d �5pn ,eQ�� \@ �Z@ �- <l@1 ,<Z�6?

��rn ,<-�Gn :$;@ �p$�1 ,~:$� ¯�6? * U�S5$n ,eQ<$� ��$rn ,<$��; �;�� �d <�@ ]n K� ,A���� /�;:�d :

\@ �����n ,�F=Z �Z�6? * <;:� \�? \d ,� ¢�n�; ,K�;@ �l5n ¢QR [=Z �Z�6? * <;:� \�? \d1 ,eQ�i

��- : , °q$; e��$Z É$F0� <$,|�1 ,g$F=Z ¯�6? * <;:���$$rn : m$$; /$$0-@1 ,eQ$$�i \@ M$$^@ 3��$$� * ¢N$$4@

��rn ,/)�� :<Z ÉF0i �n A���C ¢ �;@ �dV�29�W �$(f N$Z@ Q�t �%1 �rn ,�4� y��S �Gr��1

��- ,gar>� \:>; 3Z � �0; :x�) ��(� K��r� �Z@��- 3¿���0; 3Z �(f:T U�E�d 3Z /�;:�d �d ��ri

�b�$^@ �;��$n ,7��8 }�E_@ 3� \�) Ã�r��6? * A�;:� �4Ê m; �Z5$n <=p$,�� <p$(6�� <$l@1 ,<Z

Ã�r� ��rn ,�-5n <��; �;�� Ã�r� �5pn ,<��; : \d \�$? \d1 ,K|8�$Z �$��� �F=Z �Z�6? * <;:� \�? ,<$�,�1 <$�n� * �$�Á�Z �$l5n <$F=Z �Z�6? * <;:�

�4Ë� ��-1 : ;<$ZP�i �n �D=p,6� <06? ¢N4@ ¢ �;@ �dE6p$i �$¹ �$�,� �p$al m$; U�Fi �l�n ,��$��n ,y

���-1V�30�W

�29� yZ�p� �G��1 241� �30 � ��$�; �r�� ,~:p� ���ri1 ��1�� �N_@ �n��� �d ~��=

Page 12: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

I��G� � �0; 3Z O��_: �,; U�0F����E� :e�BNn1 ,<6�b@1 ,<i5kl1 ,<�NDa�

– 48 –

�$r� U�E$�d 3Z /�;:�d1�31� e�$�N� : �,$�*N$i1 ,�B��1 ��pi1 ]pi : �,$� ,�$�8 x� �D$C *

�6B��1 �l:�1 �6,�W ��$��r� K$|^ m$; ��$�; �r� y�; �-1

− �i�$% * U�E$�d 3$Z /�;:$�d1 ,��$�R 3Z ¸a^ �6Gr�−<�NrZ :TZ�6? * <;:� \N? �Z U�n s P$% <

<$�n }�$6|� \�$? �d ,<$F=Z 1@ }�6|� M^�_ [=Z <$6^�Zd m$; A���� ��PZ e�� /�) �d ,<l�d1 <6n��(Z

P$% K%�$,; X�$�� \�$? \�n ,Ì�p6l��− Í1@ :D�$n �b�^@− K$|� §¾ s ��d ;�bQR ��- �� �Nr��n sd1 ,K�,n

,<;:� �EGZ <i��DC 3� �>?5Z }�6|� * ~:p� M�6 �|�X ��$ §; �$�� �d X�z� \@ sd ,�n ��� m; �Bc ��@1,

K�;@ �1 ,��ri �� m; <Z K|E�nV�32�W 9:$$�@ �$$Z�6? \@ m$$; ��$$i &NG$$,� eP$$Dn @�$Z �$- U�$0F� K$��Z A�$r^s �$n�; g$6� ,����p� �$��ri1 ��0� ;A�|0� 7��8 /%@ /0- 3� �D��=6�

 �Z 3� KDz�Z j1�� ~:�W

=& �222−223W� �31� 3$Z /�;:$�d U�E$�d N$Z@ ,��� ¦�C ,³n�8 ,��� N%

K%sN$$� ,x�ct �$$�c 3$$Z ��$$¿ 3$$Z /�;:$$�d 3$$Z U�E$$�d1 ,��`Z Ã�- ,g|��� ,x¶0���l�G$6� M^�$_ W �$ul

g0%P�� ,9�0,� ��;@ Q� * <6��i�13 339−341W� �32� 1�� �N_@ �n��� �d ~�� ���; Ã�r�� ,~:p� ���ri1 ��

& �223−224W�

�� �)@ �1 <$)1 m$; <��=6� 3� �1@ m; ��� A�n1���1 A NDk� \�? <l@ �,� �Du� y0� �¹ 3|� ,���E6� �$¹ ,x�$�� ��$>� \�$r� 3$� Q4t ]Z�� * A�r6p�1

K�;@ �1 ,�|0� �-NZ ��� /0- 5kl <l@ g,��W <r�0Fi1 <��=6�1 <i5kl ���0Z y��6� �� P% W

�(pi1 <,�1�6Z y��6� �� ��@1 �$C@ 3$� �15n ,<6��@ 3¹ e�?�1 ,<��d O�FG� K�; *:

1 − &A' &STA�� �A� &' &/U� �MV �'� B��W� XY�T ��T�� ZD=[\���� :360A: :`

<Z�6? * ���1T x1�$� �$Z /$_�a� ��$E�g;N$�1V��$rn ,A�r6p$� A�$$lN,; <$� /$�) ��d ; :T ]$$,�

~:p�V$|· �G$- Q$R <$�n �?P$� � 3$|� , Ã�$r� K� * Æ$���F� �$��N� ¯@ 3; x1 ��1 ,���R 3Z ¸a^ �?P$� �1 ,�$b�?� yZ�p$� ,~:p$� K��pi ],�1  n

A�r�F� �4� A���C�33�W e:$�@ �$,% x���D��� \@ :?T~:p$�V��$rn ,:

T~:p� ],�V�34�x@ , : <$�n �$0�@ xP$� ~N(p� }�6|��(� �- A�l�n \@ �Z�6? <0^�_ 1@ ¦�k�< W \�$? P$|%1

<i5kl * ���r6� ���E� �,; U�0F� �(p��35� ���1 ;

�33 � �ul: x�$��D���� ,g;N$�1 x1�$� �$Z /_�a� ��E� &�589W�

�34� yZ�p� �G�& �589W� �35� �,�� �� :?3Z /�;:�d1 ,���R 3Z ¸a^ ����r� K|^ * =

Page 13: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

�������� ��� �� ���� ,29 ���� ,�1� ����� ,�2017� 1438$%�

– 49 –

�$�FÁ j��Dk$�1 ,~N(p� }�6|� �Z y��N� �c�6�� \d �$6^ ,¦�k$� 3$� <�($� 3$� 9:�@ �?PZ <�n �60>� y$�F� 7��$8 O�FG$� * 3��45$6� �a,G�  �Z

U�0F� Mi�? m; A�l��^@ :~:p� Mi�?�36�W 2 −U� b��AU� (� �� &' �MV (� ���'� ,Jc�

de�f��� &'�' 9�Tg�� X8�'�/����[\����:405A: :` ,x NZ�p$�,� §K?�$8 ­x�$��D��� �$�Z 9�) K�

<06? 3� �Z�6? * ]�(p6� �Z�6? �d �C5n: �b�^@ :T7��$8 �N�; �n���V 7��$8 �$,�n

7��8 K�; ~Nl@ 3� 7��>� ~N,� m;N$%1 , : �$n�����- ,<�N_@ �E_1 <60�1 <l�rid1 ��E� U�_:T È$0l

,�$¥ \N��$E�n M$6|� \1Lk$� �$;�� P% �l¶; * * �$r�6; M$6? * KDSNF=Z K��;:� \N06|� �;��1 /$%@ Q$R 3$� KD,$� ](p� 3(n ,�¥ \N��E�n ,�-N� 3� N�(� �d ��,G� /%@ ��5n ,<�D�Z 1P�(n ��,G�

s²% ��>�@ \@ �d KDS�r�d1 KD^�) <�an ,jwÁ ��Z 9 <$l�n ; P$�� s ��,G$��Z /$%�J \@ m$; ,KD6ZNi �Dui

; �²p� <������p� \�? ��� m;1 ,<n��� s : {

=,U�E�dÆ���F� ���N� ¯@ 3; x1 ��1 W �36� ��>� /�0� m; �ul : ¶$6µ * x1�� /D,� 7��$8 �N$�;

& �$$;�� 3$$Zs ,xN$$0,�� 97� �$$��r� m$$; �$$|,�1 , ®? ��� ,I�G� 3Z�3 498�j�?P$6�1 j¶$06� I{1 ,,

g$$-�����1 410�,1 ,7��$$8 �$$�a�@ I+$$Z 7$$�`� O6$$n x1�=p���3 116W�

���@V�37�W K$´@ �;:J 9s²% m; }�; K?�8�nT \N$06|�

\N��$E�n �-N� * �r�6; M6? * KDSNF=Z K��;:��$$¥V�$$Z�6? \t ; ~:p$$� �$$,; �=p$$,� m$$; ]�(p$$6�

<($� \1�$� � 3(n ,K´��c * A�(6�� A��D,� �E0_@ ,<;:$� ~�$� ¦�k� m; �;N(p� �r�6�� �=p,� m;

s1 ]$� <($� �n�$�d 1@ �=p$l 9+Z <? �6� 3|(��r�6�� �=p,� m; ����p� 9:�@W

�4Ê1 : }�6?T/��? }�6? �d /4��V �$rn ��- − �^1��� ��r0S ���� N%1 −:T �$,��>� �r0F�

�^1��� 3� : ÌN�$C 3$� �a,G$� A�$06? N�($� �N$- Nl1�$�1 ,~:p$� �$,; KD;:�@ N=p,� �1 ,K%N? �@ ,7��$$8 3$$; N��$$�1 ,3p$$� * N$$,�S \@ �d ,�$$¥ 3$� M6|� ��6Z N��^ \@ m; e+�1 /DJ KD�(En

�D�n K� v�� jLk� M6? \NbN6� K%1 ,Î�Z s1 ~:�\N-��_ K���1 * K´@ W�>? �¹ ~N,� P%1 * ,H�,�

/?1 ,I�G��Z �n1���1 9:��� �Z�?@ 3� �N- e�F�i1<,��; �,l��c * <0�S 3�V�38�W

g$% �,% ��1�� \@ m; ¸l x NZ�p�,� K?�8�n KD^�$) \@1 ,¦�k$� 3$� �;N(p� �a,G� M6? ��1

�? :ld K� �;N(p� M6|� eP% 3� jLk� ¦p,� \t \

�37� K?�E�� ,7��8 �N�; �n��� & �15− 16W� �38� K?�E�� ,/��? }�6? �d /4�� & �65−66W�

Page 14: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

I��G� � �0; 3Z O��_: �,; U�0F����E� :e�BNn1 ,<6�b@1 ,<i5kl1 ,<�NDa�

– 50 –

3$� ]$� �$l1�� K%º:�@ \N|i \5Z KD;:� �D��; v���=p,� eP% ](�W

[0z$$�1 �$$���� ©1{ * �N$$· A�z$$�@ N$$%1 [0zZ y��6� �� sd �?P� K�n ,\���� ��� /%t ��Gis1

��N0r� �E�E_ <6�1 1 <;:� \N|� g|� ;}�6|� W 3 − �'� EA� I� jA'�� &A' kA &A' �AS� T4'

XZ��N���[\����:463A:C` <$� �r�n ,x��`0� §M�FÁ , �K?�8 ��Z 9�) K�

<$Z�6? * A�$_�4 A�Z�ZT }��1 x1�$� U�$4t ]��$J]��p�V��rn ,:T ,<$,; �N$r,� * x1�$� ��(pi K�

<,� <;:� ¤^ 3� ��(pi1V�39�W $El m; <6�a�?1 <6a_ �?� K� A�,6p$� /G$a� N

�N$_@ * <=B�k$� ���p$� 3$� e�%�C �� �d �?� :�n g$% �$��(�� ��$r�0F6�1 �$� :� \@ g$,�� �¹ ,KD06? ,U�0F� ��a�? 3; M�FÁ �%�?� g6� ���N��� �G�

��^Lr�1 �|n@1 Qu,i ��� �p��1W }�0� \N,; * <(p� � x��`0� M�FÁ \@ :?

,A�al� N?P�e:$� <$� <a$_11 <$��; <$��? 9�,�@ 3|�: T]� �( �p$$�6�V��$$rn , :T ]� �( �p$$�6� <$$��� xP$$� * M$$6|�1

}�6|� �1@ * M6|� :? ,¦� �6�1V�40�W

�39� x��$`0� M$�F=�� ,]��p$� }��1 x1�� U�4t ]��J�1 268 W�

�40� yZ�p� �G��1 268 W�

x��$`0� M$�FÁ �$�Z 9�$) �3 �� @�Z �,D% 3�1�(�? �:�6��Z :T M$i�?1 ,]� �( �p$�6� �$Z�6?1 ,]� �( �p$�6�

]� �( �p�6�VP$% m$; ��$|� �,; , 9s²$% �1@1 ,}�$0� <$Z�6? * I�G� 3ZT7��$8 �N$�; ~N$l@ �$n���V ,

��$? /$rl \@ �$�Z1 ,~N$�N� P$% 3$; K�|i :,�En��$- ,}�0� P% * x��`0� M�FÁ:T ]� �( �p$�6� §�$�0�6�?

<� ©N^@ e�?� 7�^WWW [$=Z ]� �( �p�6� \N|� \@ g`0,�1[Á �ND� QR <Z UN�N� ¸=CWWW$; \d K� M$i�? m

©��6^s1 x�E6� ]� �( �p�6�WWWV�41�W ��$� ��� �,% ]� �( �p�6� I�G� 3Z �?� �rn:

T]� �( �p�6� §��0�6�?,]� �( �p�6� ,]� �( �p�6� Mi�? V W O�FG$$� O0$$_@ P$$|%1T]� �( �p$$�6�V ]B�$$C

K��Z ��Z :�n X�; :; Q0�6�� �:�6�sTU�0F�V �$�Z �`0� M�FÁ e�?� \@:D�Z�6? * I�G� 3Z1 x�W

4 −l�AA� m�AA5�� nAA7�� &AA' o�#AA���� [\����:544A:C`

��$�; Ã�$r� �,_ x��`0� M�FÁ ��Z1N$%1 ,\5k$� /��) A�Z�6? g0GE��T �d ~�$� }�$6?

~:p$$� �$$��ri1 �$$�1�� �N$$_@ �$$n���V ��$$a� � <$$,|� ,�$�6� �1 ,/r6p$� }�0Z ]�(p6� �Z�6? 1@ U�0F� <$� �

,<$Z�6? 3$� ��Ga,� ���N� * e�?� :ld1 ,/�Ga6��Z �(pnTU�$0F�V�1t ]$�N� * :T M$�6 �?1 ,~:p$��Z

�41� s ,7��8 �N�;I�G� 3Z & �205W�

Page 15: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

�������� ��� �� ���� ,29 ���� ,�1� ����� ,�2017� 1438$%�

– 51 –

~:p�Ve:� ��>� ]�N� *1 , :T~:� ���riVW �1t ]�N��n :e:$� ,A�$;N,� A�$Z�Z �$r; :,$�^ :

Tj��¿ }��1 j��a� ��Ê ]��) }�ZV�42� K|^ <�n �?� ,a^ ����r� * U�E$�d 3$Z /�;:$�d1 ,��$�R 3$Z ¸

�6rZ�p� �6Gr��43�<$�NrZ <$��; y�;1 ,:T �$Z U�$n s ,<F=Z 1@ }�6|� M^�_ [=Z P% <Z�6? * <;:� \N? ��P$Z e�� /�) �d ,<l�d1 <6n��(Z <�n }�6|� \�? �d P$% K%�$,; X��� \�? \�n ,�p6l�� <6^�Zd m; A����

− �b�^@ Í1@ :D�n − ;�$bQR ��- �� �Nr��n sd1 ,K�,n <i��D$C 3$� �>?5$Z }�$6|� * ~:p$� M�6 �|� K|� §¾ s ��d �d X�z$� \@ sd ,�n ��� m; �Bc ��@1 ,<;:� �EGZ

K�;@ �1 ,��ri �� m; <Z K|E�n X �� §; ���V�44�W ��>� ]�N�1 : �$?� <,|� ,jc�) 3; <>��^ 9�,�@n ,�(D� ���N��� �,���r:T �Z@ ��(� 3¿�$� �$0; �$(f

�Nr� ,<�ra� 3pf 3Z }�6; 3Z �(f 3Z : ,¯@ ��($��Nr� : [$�`� �$- <$lt ;jc�$) 3$� ~:p� * �,R s

Ï �r� N$% \�$? \d ¦�k$� [$�`� 1@ ,¦�k$� /$a`�1 ,jc�)�Z <i�n �� <� w�,�n ,]��p� /a`�1 ,Ï �r�W

�42� ���; �r�� ,~:p� ���ri1 ��1�� �N_@ �n��� �d ~�� &�213 W�

�43� U�0F� j5kl m; ��|� �,; :��?� W �44� ���; �r�� ,~:p� ���ri1 ��1�� �N_@ �n��� �d ~��

&�223−224W�

9�$$D0l  �0$$� ~:$$� �$$��ri m$$; �$$a-1 �$$-1 3$Z <$��d �$C@ �$� N$E,Z U+$� /%@ 3� ��l���Á

��rn ,}�6; : ¦�k$� m$; ¬\�$n1 ¬\�n �9�J P% ](� �$� c�)@1 ,x �=0� /�;:�d 3Z ����� �0; /za� ¯@ m$$; <$$,; ¼1�$$� \@ ,<$$��d ÈG$$� �1 ,�E$$_1 /$$aR@

�EG� W A�) }�0� * /�0l ~�,� P%1V�45� W �,% �l��n@ ���; �r�1�(D� �BNn ��>Z:

1− jc�$$) �$$Z ]$$(J �d �$$;� 3$$� �1@ \@ s1 ,}�6; 3Z N% ~:p�1 <��d �;� �� y0S <l@ M� W

2− 3$� N$F6� P$� q(; y�0Fi 3� e�%�C �� ��l���Á 9�D0l  �Z /0-W

3−K� ���; Ã�r� U�Sd :T ~:$� �$��riV m;TU�0F�VW

�1@ U�$$0F� * jc�$$) �$$Z�6|n * �$$%�?� 3$$� ��$$�; �$$r� N$$% 7��$$8 O�FG$$� ��a,G$$�

g0GE�� W m$; �$�4� g6� �(D� � NF6� 3� g%1 ]$�� 3$� �¥ jQ0? j��Cd1 A�l�pE6� ��)11 ,U�0F�

O�FG� K�; * �a,G� ���E� W A�$���; Ã�$r� \@ �,% M��`�1− <$6n��� ]$�

�%�$C g$�-1 ��$>� e�$?�1 ,~:p� ���r6Z <p$a,Z e− � �$�� * M0p� /��1 ,A�al� <i�?� �� ¼N� ��|Z <Gh <Z AsN(��1 A�r6p�1 A NDk� <lN? N%1 ,A �� <i�?� ��

�45� yZ�p� �G� & �92− 93W�

Page 16: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

I��G� � �0; 3Z O��_: �,; U�0F����E� :e�BNn1 ,<6�b@1 ,<i5kl1 ,<�NDa�

– 52 –

<� �)�^ s <a���i /�� �¹ ,K%�,;W M$$�FÁ �$$�Z 3$$� �a,G$$� 3$$� AQ$$>? \d K$$�

³$a� ��$4��Z N��$- I�G� 3Z1 x��`0�T�$r0F�V m; ��s���T?�Z�6]� �( �p�6� V j �$0; /(�6� 3� KD,(n ,

T~:p� �r0SV²% 3�1 ,9s : K�%�Zd 3Z �(; 3Z K�%�Zd °xw�J /��4 3Z�ÍN6� :732$$% � <$Z�6? *T �N$�

7��8 �N�; * 7��E6�V��- 7�^ ,:T �$r0S M6|�1[Á NDk� <�>� ew4@ 1@ ,¤^ �r� 1@ N% ~:p�V�46�W

KD,$$�1 :%�$$Zd 3$$Z �$$(f ��$$,|� �$$;�� 3$$Z K��ÍN6� :733$% � <Z�6? *T �N�; ¶6µ * x1�� /D,�

xN0,� 7��8V��$- 7�^ ,:T �$r0S M$6|Z H5$Z s1 3|6$�1 ,<$,� �$ah s 7$�^ 1@ }�6|� �4� * ~:p�

[Á X1��� �r� [=Z �r0F�V�47�W KD,$�1 : Q$$>? 3$$Z �$(; 3$$Z /�;:$$�d�ÍN$$6� :

774$% � <Z�6? *T647��8 �N�; �GV��$- 7$�^ :T 3$� [$4 1@ <$F=Z ��d ,}�6? * <;:� �r0S �)1 N�

��P� <;:� �?P6� �1 ,<Z y>�WWWV�48�W j �0; ��=6� 3� KD,�1T U�$0S1 ,~:p$� �r0S

�46� �$$E6� �N$$� °xw$$�J /$$��4 3$$Zs ,7��$$8 �N$$�; * 7� &�125 W�

�47� �$;�� 3$Zs ,xN$0,� 7��$8 �N$�; ¶6µ * x1�� /D,���,|� & �97W�

�48� Q$$>? 3$$Zs ,7��$$8 �N$$�; �G$$64 �d 7$$�>8 7$$;�0� &�140W�

~:p�V9s²% 3�1 ,A��� : g$-����ÍN$6�:806$$% � * <^{Tj�?P6�1 j¶06�V :��$- 7�^ :T��$r�1 : �1@ \d

? 3�~:p� U�0S * jc�) M6 : 3Z /�;:�d �%�F� NZ@ /%t ��� <,� * Q4 � e��n ,gS:lt 3pE� �0; ¢�i M0pZ ]Frl �r�1 ,Q>? ]al <Z /G^ �r�n ,7��8 M0pZ ,��0�  �Z * M6|�  �Z ��Gi <��bd1 ��� jc�)d ~:p� �r0S * �?P� �1 ,�Nn <� \�? KDz�Z \N?

�k�K� ¦V�49�W KD,$$�1 : Ð�$$,Zt U�E$$�d N$$Z@ 3��$$� \�$$%�Z

��N� 3Z K�%�Zd�ÍN$6�:802$$% � <$Z�6? *T Pk$�I�G$� 3$Z �N$�; 3� I��a�V��$- 7$�^ , :T g$`0,�

�$$Z�6? M$$r; ¦�k$$� jc�$$)d M$$6|� \@ ~:p$$� M$$i�|���r�1 ,~:p� : M6? 3� �1@ \d~:p� U�0S * jc�) :

3Z /�;:�d �%�S NZ@ � e�$�n ,g$S:lt 3p$E� �$0; Q4 W <��bd1 ��� ¢�i M0pZ ]Frl �r�1  $�Z ��G$i

<$� \�$? KDz$�Z \N$? M0p$Z ,��0�  �Z * M6|�K� ¦�k� jc�)d ~:p� �r0S * �?P� �1 ,�NnV�50�W

j �$$0; ��=6$$� 3$$� KD,$$�1T~:p$$� U�$$0SV, KD,�1 :$Z X1�$�� ,q; 3Z �(f 3Z �(f 3Z �(f 3Z�

,x �$$J�ÍN$$6� :833$$$%� <i��G$$- * ��$$- 7$$�^ ,T���� * ��1�� K�;V:

�49� g-���� ,j�?P6�1 j¶06� I{�1 410W� �50� �N�; 3� I��a� Pk� Ð�,ZÑ� ,I�G� 3Z�1 293W�

Page 17: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

�������� ��� �� ���� ,29 ���� ,�1� ����� ,�2017� 1438$%�

– 53 –

T �~ �: �p$$$$$���Z U�$$$$$0F� M$$$$$6 �|� �1* g$$$;1 [0$$$� �1 UN$$$�N� [$$$ �=�ZV�51�

³a� �:�6� ~�C P|%1TU�0F�1 ,�r0F�V �,; m; ��s��� O�FG� K�; * �a,G�T ]� �( �p$�6� �Z�6?V

,3��>� \�r� * ���Z1 3��>� \�r� ���´ ]� <l@ ��l /Z�E0_@ ]��6� \�r�T ]� �( �p�6� �Z�6?V�§i ,�$r0F��Z X�

x1�=p$� ����i P% 3�1��:902$$% � * �N$r� ��d <Z�6?T7��$8 �$�a�@ I+Z 7�`� O6nV �N$- A�^ �$C

g-���:T ]� �( �p�6� �Z�6?V :T�(p� N%1 :�r0F��ZV�52�W <$$$n�; P$$$?1−$$$�@ A�z− x �G$$$lt �$$$��?c

��:926$$$% � <$$Z�6? *T �$$�a�@ I+$$Z g-�$$0� O6$$ng-���V<�n ��- �d , :T]� �( �p$�6� �Z�6? :~:p$� �$,�(Z,

�r0F��Z �(p�V�53�W 3�Q$$4t �a��$$�6� * ³$$E�l1− ���$$�d 3$$�

3�QDC− O�FG� 3� Q0|� �NE6� ��� T]� �( �p$�6�V O�FG� �dTU�$0F�1 ,�r0F�V �:�6$� \@ g$,�� �$¹ ,

O�FG�T�r0F�1 ,U�0F�V �r6p$�1 ]B�k� N% O0_@ <$Z X °�$�§� <$ld �$6^ ,\�$��� ��� /%@ �,; X1���1

/0- 3� eN� X��§� s \�? xP� §]� �( �p�6�W * * *

�51 � ���� I{ ���`� * x1�=p�� ,��1�� K�; & �95−96 W� �52� 7��8 ��a�@ I+Z 7�`� O6nx1�=p�� ,� 3 114W� �53� x �Glt ���?�� ,g-��� ��a�@ I+Z g-�0� O6n�2 63 W�

F�G�� 6���� ������� ,������ ,�� �� 0!*

?�@� E- �� :���!�c� ,����V� ,�� �� 0!*C @ g% /Z ,j���) M����@ �p�� ���E� M����

/$? ��$0�F6� M��6p$i ,j��$�6�1 j N$F6� M���$�@1 ,���-NZ ��,�c ��^��TU�0F�V P$% 3$; ���(Z v��

�E�N� e N_ 3� j N_ N% /Z , NF6�W 3$; 7��$8 O�FG$� * \Na,G$� K$�|i �rn N$,�Z1 ,y$�-�1 /G$a� /|kZ ]�(p6� �Z�6?1 ,U�0F�

<ZN��@ <$��|^@1 <�B�p$� 1�$?�1 ,<i N$_1 <6r��S1 j��6p� <6Z�6? � NFi Nn��@1 ,�a�6=� W

�� -� 0�7�7@� 2�$�����C g$% U�0F�� �����t ��lN|� : ,¦�k$� K$�

,U�$0F� M$i�? K$�1 ,¦�k$� m; ~N(p� }�6|�1 ]$� ](p$� ¦�k$� 3$� �=p$,� eP� ����p� 9:�@1

�r�1 ��^ O��Ni �~:p, ,KD,� �^1 /? ��n �� 1@ ����i \d <p��� ��;1 ,<l�|�1 ,~:p� �-1 ¦� �i1W

�� �� E��4� 0N����� 0��@�C N$f <$ld ��d ;�$��n �$�(�; ���,� U�0F� Mi�|� <6E$_1 ~:p$� jN$rn ,U�$0F�1 ~:p$� �E_ �%N)1 3$Z ��$- ,<$, °|£1 <$l�rid1 U�$0F� Mi�? �r� m; \�6�,0�

I�G� :T UN$�N� ¸=C [=Z ]�(p6� \N|� \@ g`0,� M$6|� s \@ * P$�,�^ Q$� s1 ,[$Á �N$D� Q$R <Z

Page 18: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

I��G� � �0; 3Z O��_: �,; U�0F����E� :e�BNn1 ,<6�b@1 ,<i5kl1 ,<�NDa�

– 54 –

m$; H5$Z s P$|%1 ,O�EG$6��Z <$F4 ](p$� ¦�k� }�6|� M^�_ − <$Z A�$-N�N� \�? �d − m$; ¶$6r� \@

��� ��r>� /�n ���Fn ,<pal [=Z <;:� ��0�dV�54�W M$i�|� \N? ND½ ��^ *1 A:D6$� 1@ A�$^1��

�$�� 3$�1 ,<$�Nr,Z ~:p� 3� \N���p� ],6(� <6���Z 3$$Z �$$¿@ 3$$Z �$$¿@ 3$$Z K�$$£ �$$��i * g0%P$$� �N$$-

g��l�,0� :T�456� ��fW eN$-1 ,¤$4t 3$Z <$ZP?eQR W ��,� 3Z ��-1 : ,��1�� 9�)t1 M6|� X���

3��456� �N^@1,$��- <$,|� ,j�$n1 �$(¥ KD��i1 / 3$� ��;:p$� /$r,� �$�1�� * A�%�p6� \�?1 ,K��� 3$� �$;�� ],6��$n ,/$_5Z ��Z�r� QR ~1�n m; <ua^ ,Ð�$r� �$,`� �$0; 3$Z �(f ³n�8�? ,<�Nr,Z ~:p�

3��� 9��� ³n�81 W 3$Z K$��r� ¯@ ~:$� /$rl �$-1M$�RL� 3� 9�J Ò��? 3Z 3� [0p�, �%�$C 3$Zs

,����? �=pl m; ,�$0=6,� �=p$l * ]($� <l@ �D½ K� �$B��� �,;:$� /$F0n ,7$���^@ j�$; �G-�l �´@ \�Z1 W

:Da�z$n ,�$¿@ <$�4@1 K�$£ 3$; ,¤4t 3Z ��5�}P|��Z �b�� 1 ,A�)V�55�W

3$� 3���(6� �(D� eP� \1 �6h 9:��� \�? P�1 �$_N� 3� * A�S{ U�0F� �Z�6? �E0_@ �6^ ,�0�F�

Mr�ZTf��Vg|0p$� 3��$� »�$i ��- ,3��456� �,; :

�54� I�G� 3Zs ,7��8 �N�; & �205 W� �55� s \��� g0%P�� ,��6;�1 359−360W�

T��l��t X�; 3� ��E� :ld1 ��$)�� 9:�@1 ,/��� 3$� j�>|6p$� �$�� �$�� ]$� ³$a^1 ,�c�,�1 ����1 ,/$0,^ 3$Z �$¿@ �,p$�1 ,�6p$� M6|� ](�1 ,\N6� �$r� P$% �d K$�1 ,�w$F� K���1 ,grD�0� 3,�1

�8 9�)t 3� 9�) ��@ ��$n ,<$i�) � /$-@ P$% ,��>� K�|i1 ,ÌN�k� m; �1 ,U�0F� M6?1 ,e�l�?� �� ](� ��$$) � �1@ * \�$$? ,��l�p$$�1 ��$$�nN�1 /$$��� *

9�k� �� 9�k� 3� � ���� K� ,���E�V�56�W ,<$Z eN$,� O0$_@ �l�|�1 ,U�0F� Mi�? ��bt1

�45$$6� 9:$$���1 j1�$$�� �$$�L� �$$,; <$$��d �k$$�1 ,3� <l5Z �_N�nTU�$0F� M6?V �$En�S K)L$� M$6?1 ,

�$Z�6? * <$F41 <$6r��S �6^ �_Ni A�l��^@1 /Z ,P¥ /��$�6� 3$� <$S��6^1 <$6ur�1 ecL^ \��0� ;U�0F�

<06? �� Q�`6�1 W � �$0; 3Z ��,� ���i * g0%P� ��-g?L� :T M$6?1 ,3a��$Z �p$l@ <$� �_1 ,��1���Z g,;

U�0F�xN- [=ZV�57�W ���!�c� �� �� 0!*C

* U�$0F� �a$_ 3$; /�G$a6Z x1�=p� K�|i <Z�6?T7��$8 �$�a�@ I+$Z 7�`� O6nV :$Z g$a6?@1 ,

�$$� �$$?� <$$lN|� ;e�$$?� I�G$$� 3$$Z1 M$$�FÁ e�$$?� �$$� °�$$Z1 ,A�$$l��Z1 A�E�$$�Ni e�c1 ,K%Q$$R1 g$$-���1

�56� g|0p�� ,Kr,� ��0�1 K�,� ���� & �82−82W� �57� ���E��Z ¸6=� K��� g0%P�� ,�1 106W�

Page 19: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

�������� ��� �� ���� ,29 ���� ,�1� ����� ,�2017� 1438$%�

– 55 –

}�$Z * �$��1 ,U�$0F� m; ��6�T]�(p$6� �$Z�6?V g-��� �N- A�^ �C :

T<�(p$$0� �$$�Z ¦�k$$� K$$� M$$6|�1*

<$$$$$$�(|� �$$$$$$D�0- ����p$$$$$$�1

�F��$$$$$$Z �$$$$$$D0,) 1@ �$$$$$$4 ²� e*

e�$$$$$$D½ sd1 9�$$$$$$J �$$$$$$4� 1@

�$$$$n�; [$$$$=Z UN$$$$�N� [$$$$=Z*

�$$$$$a? <p$$$$$a,� <$$$$$F=Z N$$$$$�1

m(6$$$$� sd1 /$$$$|� ¤$$$$^ \d*

s �@ ¦�$$$$C OE$$$$_ �$$$$r� 3$$$$�V

��- �rn :T(p6� �Z�6?<6�a�?1 ]� W �(p$� N$%1�r0F��ZW WW1TM6|�V M��F� T¦�k� K�V 1@ ,@�- xP�

](�<��; , y$E6�� �$�1 ,eN$El 1@ A9�) 1@ A�Z�6? <,� 1@ N$El1 ,M%P$�1 Mr�1 ��,?1 �0pl1 Mpl 3� K�s�Z * <a,G$� ~N(p$��Z e�,� U��� ]� ,<Z X��� �¹ ���

g6� �=p,� * 1@ ,��PZ <Gh xP� <60� �D��G· �1�� ~N(p� 3� W A�>� ��(p0� ��Z �Nr�n : \�n \�n NZ@ �l@

\�n �,� ,��a� \�n 3Z W m$; e�$4� �d �,p� UNp�1]-1 xP� <)N� WT1 V 9:$�@ M6|��n eQR <�� ](� \d

T����p�V ��d T�D�0-V �%�F� UNn 1@ T��(|�V QR 3� ��p� 3� /? ����i K6� s �� �G64 A�zn ,<l1�Z ��

KD,� �^t XP^ 3;W P81− I�G� 3Z ��- :? − K� ©�r�d 3�

e�$$|^ �$$� M$$��`� 3$$�1 ,�$$��n ��$$`� KD,$$� �$$^@ �$l�? :$´@ ,ga�p� <=�C1 /za� 3Z 3; ,x�p� 3Z �$?�i K%�?� m; ��i@ ��n ,3p� x1PZ U�0F� \ �G�

�ua� gS * K%�) �@1 ,}�0k�T3��$4�1V W1 �%�$u�:D�l�� 3; <6E_ ��;W

}N$6|� \N$? ��^ ��� /?T A�$4 ²�V �$-NZ <p��� ��; P?1 ,<B �-1 ��0� 3� <�f A N?P� ,~:p�

− ���$$�i \d − �p$$;�,�1 �$$�(|� �$$��£1 ,�$$,��� �iNa� 3� 3�¡�81 �0i�|�1 �>^�0�1 ���E6�1

����p�1 �6G,�1 �ur��1W T1@V6|� ��� MT�D0,)Vx@ : �- N� * ��(p0�

�1tTj�F��ZVg,�� : :0p$^ ,��P$� ��p$6� ��$C�8 <$��n P$?1 ,<4N�C /�n 3; M�FÁ <6��|^ �d �C@ � N$�1 ,��C�8�Z ~:p� ga�p� M6|� :Z /Z ,ga�p�

eQ$R <$�� 3|� WT1@V ]�(p$6� M$��F� M$6|� T �$4�9�JV ,}�6|� 1@ Tsd1V�n <06|� Te�$D½V /$�n :$Z 1 ,

eNEl eQR1 ga�p�, \N$|� :�$n ]�(p6� \N06|� 7�^ <$,� <��N� �ah s 7�^ <06|� 1@ ,���-N��? ~N(p(��

��� NEl1 9�,�t * ��C�^ 3�W P% /|n− I�G� 3Z ��- :? −<Z H5Z s W ]�

�ah s5Z ¼�^@1 <� ©N^@ M�FÁ <��- �� \5Z <¾¶i6¾ 3� m;\@ m; ,<��d »� 3$; �$|^ �$- x �$J 3Z

<4N�C  �Z �$Z�6|� ��$; }�t �$D) 3$� �1t \@

Page 20: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

I��G� � �0; 3Z O��_: �,; U�0F����E� :e�BNn1 ,<6�b@1 ,<i5kl1 ,<�NDa�

– 56 –

<��; <rn11 ,�Dn+� ��(p0� UNnW ]�(p$6� M$6? \d ,~N(p$� ��(pi 3p¾ P?1 QG$�n ,�$- N� ��al 3� A�nN4 ;<�n �(p� QR /E(Z �$Z�6|� �$l�? 7$�^ <$0,� \@1 ,jQ^ * �D��; �-N�

t�Z ,<��a� �,=�C ��@ �rn ,~N(p� �1@ �D�f m; 9�,� A�>� �Nr�n :��a� \�|��Z �r0F�1 ,\�n A�;:� <R�n W

�N$r� \5Z v�� /? 9�D6l �,; �N��Z K���1 A�>� : <$iNa� 3$� /$)t ;\�n m; �1t * ~:p� �Z

�Dz�Z ](p� 1@ ,�Dz�ZW g$$`0,�1− I�G$$� 3$$Z ��$$- :$$?−� \@ \N$$|

}N6|�T[=ZV ¸=C TUN�N�V ,[$Á �ND� QR <Z /ZT�$n�; [=ZV ,7��$8 }�E$_@ �$Z TN$�1V \�$?

]�(p6�T<pa,� <F=ZV ��PZ <n�Gi ]� T�a?V ��$Fn ,s �@ eQR <�� \�? 9N� ,��� ��r>� /�n ��W

,�Nnt /�Gai * x�E6� ~:p� Mi�? m;1Z ~N(p$�1 ](p$�1 ]��p� \��Z1 �$Z�6?1 ,�$,�Z j �$0�

<6��,� /? ��ld1 ,�E�1W [0$� K�Nn ���£1 ,����p� * e�:6; \N|�1

,<palTm(6� sd1 ,/|� ¤^ \dV <,; }�R �� T 3$��r�V��Pn ,¤^ 3¹ [Z�� − I�G$� 3Z ��- :? −

<Z H5Z s− ��$�i ,� 9�C \d − �$r>� �:6$; * 9N$� �$$r� 1@ ,<p$$al [0z$$� ,<$$F4 * ��P$$Z OG$$n@ ,eQ$$R

TOE$$_V ]�(p$$6� m$$; T¦�$$CVx@ : ,](p$$� ¦�k$$�

,yai :0p^ ,�>?5n A�^1Ts �@VW I�G$� 3$Z ��- : ¦�k$� 1�$(Z g,��$^ �$-1

3$(; ,<$�Z@ 3; ,xc1�� ��� ¯@ ³n�8 3Z �au� NZ@ 3$Z � �$0; ¯@ 3Z 3¿�� �0; \@ ��l�D0_t 3� <��^

�$`0Z @�- e�,� <�5$�1 ,Ã�$a� �$¿@ ¯@ m$; A9�$) ��¿@ NZ@ <� ��rn ,<� ��^ \N|�� ;<F4 : �$��; ,g$,Z ��

U�G$i1 ,�$^@ �ZP|� s <Z �n�; �d �l�n ;U�G��Z ��� QR �,? �d1 ,/r,i1 �Nri :�n؛�� /�- N�n : �$�

?K� �Nri ��� ,�¿@ ¯@ [4 P%W x �J 3Z �N- eNEl1 : ³n�$8 �,=�k� ���-

@ ,](p$� <lN|� ;�D��; OEG�� �r0S ME� 3Z �|Z ¯��$-1 ,g$,� �$�� e�|n : �d »�$6¾ :l�$n ;<$��d �$�i s

<�n �k� 3� O�EG6� W�D6l W :$ld ��(p$� ÌN�k$� O�EG$i 3� �)N� ��1 x�$E6� OGn@ :Z 1 ,�FZ�z� m; A�0��R <�n K%�:6;

\d sd ,<$�n j�B�n �n P�,�^1 ,��PZ KD,� ¦�k$� \�$? ��r� ;A�0��R <��a� �G,� 3Z \�? :? ,[Z�z� N% <pal

��� * 3���(6� W �$� 3���k6�  �Z �Du6� :Z ,K�l eQ$R <$�� \�$? 7$�^ <�(� <l@ <pa,� ��E� M6|� A��$a,� \�? 7�^1 ,���E� �Z ����p� �^@ j�DkZ

R N$�h s }�$6|� �d ;<D0C1 O�EG6�1 U�8�Z A�$0��x1�� ���E6Z1 /Z ,��P� »��6^s 3;V�58�W

�58 � x1�=p�� ,7��8 ��a�@ I+Z 7�`� O6n�3 114 −117�=

Page 21: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

�������� ��� �� ���� ,29 ���� ,�1� ����� ,�2017� 1438$%�

– 57 –

�� �� O J7P� 2��� &� ,-.���: A:D6$� 1@ A�$^1�� ¦�k$� \N$? N$D½ ��^ *1 <$,� KD;:$� 3$� ¸�=6� �d \N���p� 5��� ,<6���Z * �$Frl 3$Z ��$- ,U�$0F� * KDB:�@ m; ~�- ]�NZ

X1��� q; 3Z ��¾ ���?c ¯@ ���i :T-� �� �(f NZ@¶$(Z ³n�$8 x P,� xNr� �0; 3Z K�u�� �0; : N$%

¶$� ÌN�C 3� �? �@ 3� ]�� ¢�i ,<a�� m; ](�<>��^ W �?�1− A�z�@ − 3$Z q$; 3p$8 ¯@ ³n�8 3;

}P$|��Z <$���� \�? <l@ Ð�r� /za� W �$0; � ��$-1K�u�� :�$%N-��5n ,A�;�- 1P4@ ¶� /%@ 3� �;�� \d

<��; KD;:� U�0S m;V�59�W �� ��' Qp�qW� 0'��c C

I�G� 3Z e�?� �¹1− A�z$�@ − �$-�; <$� �$¹ U�0F��Z−<$Z�6? 3$� �$4� ]$�N� * 3|� �60� –: �$Z�6?

��- 7�^ ,U�0F��Z jc�) :T ��� \@ ¦�k�� ME6p�1 xP$� }�$6|� 1@ ,9�$J ]$�� �$�1 ����p� ]�(J

m; ¼�) \d1 ,eN�(�~:p� K� <�? W �^t �PZ �d1<$� M$6? ��PZ <F4 KD,� : ,}�$6|� P$% g$,� ]($�

 $�Z \�$? :$? ,P$% N$El 1@ ,g,; <6�1 <� ��)@1

=X¶6ZW �59� �Frl 3Zs ,�:? �:?d�4 123W� �60� �G$� 3$Zs ,7��8 �N�;I & �137� 3$� H��p$� * ,

/(E6�1 ,P4t ��p-@ 3� ��>� Kpr� �����ai : m; j9�r�¦�k�W

/$�a� ÌN�k� W 3$Z �$(f ¯@ <$�ra� 3$; <$�1�l :�$n1 <$$�Z@ 3$$; ,Æ$$��lt <$$�ra� }�$$6; 3$$Z � �$$0; ¯@�61�

− � :D¿ −��- <l@ ::p� * �,R sjc�$) ؛~ ;3$ \d ¦�k� [�`� 1@ ,¦�k� /a`�1 ,Ï �r� [�`� �- <lt

jc�)�Z <i�n �� <� w�,�n ,]��p� /a`�1 ,Ï �r� \�? W3p^ y�r· e�l�?� xP� P%V�62�W

�l�?� \@ y0� �-1�63� U�0F� * jc�) �Z�6? \@ ��)11 ,U�0F� m; ��4� g6� �(D� � NF6� 3�

d1 A�l�pE6� * �a,G$� ���$E� 3� �¥ 3�Q0? j��CO�FG$$� K$$�;�64� ��a,G$$� * �$$%�?� 3$$� �1@ \@1 ,

�61� 9�0,� ��;@ Q� * g0%P� <� K)�i�18 328−330� �¹1 ,��- :T ,�$���� ,��$� Æ$��lt 3p$f 3$Z }�6; 3Z �(f

}�$$6; ¯@ 3$$Z �N$$� � �$$0; N$$Z@ ,�$$0S�- g$$6a� ,��$$E�tÆ��l W��1 :�$B:���1 �l:�1 ��� �,� W 3$Z �$�4 ��$-

�N|kZ: s ,<$-�S1 7��$8�Z AQGZ ,A���; A�; 1 A�D�rn \�? ,A�$)@ �^@ 3� �D��; P4@ ��1 ,e�(; �D06? ,yB��N� * ¼ ��

��r� : A�a�²� ��Z @ 3� ��c@ �D�n @�- W ,K$��� * �$,,a6� \�$?1>�t1 ��Ct1 �04Ñ� �un�^�� W��� : �$6,� �,� �a_ *

�B:�Z @1 �6�1VW �62� I�G� 3Zs ,7��8 �N�; & �146−147W� �63� U�0F� NFi1 j5kl 3; �,��? 9�,�@W �64� �$�a�@ I+$Z 7$�`� O6$n * ��$rn ,x1�=p� �¥ ��C@ 3¹1

7��8�2 208 :�T <$�0i1−x@ : g$S:lt 3$Z − eP$% * �,p8 �,p�−g,;@ : U�$0F� * ,jc�) �Z�6?− ,e�$�Z 3$�

�$�� ��$bd M0p$Z �$�Frl �$r�n ,Q>? ]al ��PZ /G^1�- \�? ��1 \N|� ;M6|�  �Z ��1 ��0�  �0Z <?�i1 =

Page 22: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

I��G� � �0; 3Z O��_: �,; U�0F����E� :e�BNn1 ,<6�b@1 ,<i5kl1 ,<�NDa�

– 58 –

g0G$$E�� ��$$�; Ã�$$r� N$$% 7��$$8 O�FG$$�[ÍN6�:544$$%` <$Z�6? * T� �d ~�$� �N$_@ �$n��

~:p� ���ri1 ��1��V&NGÁ P¥ �i�B�aZ �l��n@1 : 1 − �$$Z ]$$(J �d �$$;� 3$$� �1@ \@ jc�$$)

}�6; 3Z N% U�0F� * ~:p�1W 2 − 3$� N$F6� P$� q(; y�0Fi 3� e�%�C ��

~:p�� e���r6Z ,��l���Á 9�D0l  �Z /0-W <$�NrZ NF6� P% m; ���; Ã�r� y�; �-1:

T A�) }�0� * /�0l ~�,� P%1V�65�W QR �4� y��S }�6; 3Z 3; �Nr� P% ��1��1

xP� <,Z y��SI�G� 3Z e�?�, A�z$�@ <$,; e1 �rn m$; �$|,� * ®$? �� ��$- ,��p`� q; NZ@ ³n�8

I�G� 3Z ���r� :T<$�rl ���66� e�$?� }�$6; 3$Z 3$; <Z�6? * ��; 3Z �(;NZ@ ³n�8T ÌN�C * va,� �l�¾

v��lt /%@V��- ,��p`� q; ¯@ ³n�8 3; : �,� ��-

= :$n ,����p$�� ](p� jc�)d �r0F� * �)N� �1 ,��� <i�n yai :? ,�Drr· ���� ;jc�)�Z <��; �Na� ��� j9�- 3|�@

* 3,p$� * g0S�k$� XNG� 3Z � ¶l 3Z q; 3p8 ¯@ m$; <$,� <;N(p$� ¼N$� <$,; 1P$45� � gB�p$,�� ¼�`G� �$-N� 3$� <;:� }�- ]� P% ,[rn �-�Z 3Z �|Z ¯@ gaG� 3$|� � <$��� 3$|�1 ,�$D6Z�6? g$S:lt 3$Z <$�n �$|6Z xP�

�D6CVW �65� i1 ��1�� �N_@ �n��� �d ~�����; �r�� ,~:p� ���r

&�92− 93W� �66� I�G� 3Z �Gr�W

}�6; 3Z �(f : xP��N-@ : K$��� M$��F� �$,R s <ld 3$� j9�$- \N��$� 1@ 7��$8 ](� N�1 ,jc�) 3; <�0k6� 1@ ��a`� 1@ NDp� cNJ ,<��; j9�- 1@ ��E�

�b�^@ m; 1@ :D��;V�67�W 3$; ��p$`� q$; ¯@ 3$; ®$? �� e�$?� ��1

3Z A����; Ã�r� \t ;}�6; 3Z �d \�� y��S N% }�6; 3Z1 }�$6; 3Z \@ m; ��� �¹ ,<,; <,Z 3; e�rl I�G�

<Z /(�� m; <iP��i & °� §¾1 ,�Nr� P% +,� \�? W Ã�$r� ��$? m; �a,G�  �Z ~�S ����1  $�Z /$0- 3$� P$� q(; y�0Fi 3� e�%�C :Z ���;

��l���Á 9�D0l, 3½ jc�$) �$Z�6|Z ��$- 3� �1@ \@t 3Z N% ~:p��ZgS:l�68�W

3$Z �$��r� m$; �$|,� * ®$? �� ��$- �rnI�G� :T��r�1 : U�$0S * jc�$) M$6? 3� �1@ \d

gS:lt 3pE��0; 3Z /�;:�d �%�F� NZ@ ~:p�V�69�W �r� e�?� :Z �Nr� P% x1�=p� Mr�i �-1

�67� ®? ��� ,I�G� 3Z ���r� m; �|,��3 498−499W� �68 � 9�0$,� ��$;@ Q$� * g0%P$� <$� K)�i�22 173−174 �

��- �¹1 :T ,��k$� �$�a� ,~ �0� �N�� ,³n�8 ,���� ,¦�k�;:�d �%�F� NZ@ ,3��� gri 3Z 3pE� �0; 3Z � �0; 3Z /�

,g�n�k$$$� ,x¶$$$� ,x �G$$$lt � �$$$0% 3$$$Z �$$$|Z ¯@ gS:lt 3Z W�B:p$Ä1 ��0� �,� ,j��r� x� * ��1 W ��$�

�B:6�1 j+; ]pi �,� ,M) *VW �69� ®? ��� ,I�G� 3Z ���r� m; �|,��3 498−499W�

Page 23: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

�������� ��� �� ���� ,29 ���� ,�1� ����� ,�2017� 1438$%�

– 59 –

��rn ,���; :T ��P$Z gS:lt y0� 3� m; �a-1 �-���; �r� ��? *��- 7�^ , : �$��ri m$; �$a-1

U+$� /$%@ 3� ��l���Á 9�D0l  �0� ~:�WWWV�70� W�al� N?P� ���; Ã�r� ��? U��1W

e�$?� �$� U�$0F� * jc�$) �R��$_ N_ 3�1<�NrZ x1�=p� :T �$)1 :�n I�G� 3Z �N- 3p^@ ��1

x �=0� O�E_ <,� ](� 3� <F=Z : <$6�1 <� ��)@1GGµ g,; 1@ �$�a`� ](p$� 3$; �c �$� jc�$)�Z <,� A�

}�0�t 3� M0pZ ~:p� �,; [r� W ]n 3Z \�? P?1 A�B�- ~:p� ��Z jc�)�Z ³a�6� : g,; <6�1 K|� ��)@

���4 \d ~:p� /_@ ���4 �� jc�)d1 A�;:�V�71� W �$,; jc�) 3� ~:p� O�N� \@ ���� /% 3|�

?9�t ; x1�=p� }�)@<�NrZ <, :T �r��Z ���DJ �a6`i

<$6�1 �^ ��PZ I�Gn <���� s1 ,<00pZ ��)@ xP��>?@ \d sd؛}��$? ]($� <$l@ P$�,�^ w=� \t ؛ ��$��

P% />� jc�) w� s1 ,]-N�� <6rZ�F� W y�S@ \d ,K�l ��p$-@ 7$��� �$41@ * Ô5�$� :$? ,�-��_ \�? �04

/(E6� WSd e�? :ld1�z$E� jc�$) �=��6a$> ؛�-> * �$��1 ,�_@ ](p� � <l@ K�; �d �(� <;�r� 1@ ,j����

<F4 Q`Z �60>� ~:p� \�? �d :�� s ,�,% �19 ؛����a6ls

�70� ,7��8 ��a�@ I+Z 7�`� O6n x1�=p���2 208W� �71 � x1�=p�� ,7��8 ��a�@ I+Z 7�`� O6n�2 206 − 207W�

<)1 /|Z <,; �0���V�72�W F�G�� E- �� :�� �� 0���C

¦� �$i w$; �$�N0,� �,p$� /rl \5Z �Nr� 3|(��>Z �� ����p�B /^�� �:

�1t : �$Z j1�$� �$�1 m$; �:6$;s ��^���N�- s1 ©1{ W

�Z�EG$��Z �_�4 ��^�� eP%1{ * g$a|�n K� �0EG� �N0� KD6�1 �N0-W

��l�>� : ©1+$Z j1�� ��1 m; �:6;s ��^���N�-1W

�Z�EG� ��Z 3� ��^�� eP%1{ [$�1@ �d � \�r� ���´ 1@ �$���� ©1{ y$r· 3$� �$Z�n ,]Z�

x1�� * [0z�1W �>��>� : 1@ M$6|� �$�1 m$; �:6$;s �$�^��

�ZN6|� ��1��W �l¶$; �d ]$Z�� \�$r� 3$� @�$0i ��^�� eP%1 /$rl \@ ]Z�� \�r� * 7��8 9:�; ¢ �@ �rn ,¡�8 /$%@ \�$? \@ �$�0n ,j�$��) �$�^�� /4�� @�Z 7��8

8 * j@�$� 1@ �Dn�k$� ���1�� \N�-�,6� \NrZ�p� 7�� �$�^�� g$% j�$��J �$�^�� �E0_@ ,�rZ�p� ��^�� ��$6� �$r�� �$�Z ���1 ,�ZN6|� ��1�� 1@ M6|� ��1 ,�6$$C ��a,G$$�1 M$$6? * ��$$�1�� ]$$�� 3�1�$$6Z

�72� yZ�p� �G��2 208− 209W�

Page 24: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

I��G� � �0; 3Z O��_: �,; U�0F����E� :e�BNn1 ,<6�b@1 ,<i5kl1 ,<�NDa�

– 60 –

���E6$�1 /$Z ,<$,�1�i K6$� � x1�$� �N$)1 ���E6�1�N0r� 7��^ �N)1�^1 1 <6�1�Z ��a,� W

A���kn A���C 9:��� 9s²% <0l �,% 3�1− Mp$^1 ��^�� ��i NFi » �i− ��SL$C1 ��$0�F6� m;

�$�i � g6� jQ`6� ©1+� ��i1 ,j���J ��^�� eP% 3$� Na6? /Z ,x1�� ���1�� �N0- * �����@ A�S1{

,M$6|� ��i /rl �E_ 3(z� :Z ©1+� �D6��$�1 1@ ���E6Z Q�`6� 3� �Dua^1 ,\�Gr,� 1@ j����� 3�

��� QR 1@ ,��1�i 1@ ��EGi 1@ 5F4W j���J ��^�� eP% ©1{ K%@ 3�1 : K� ���ri

~:p��Z 1@ ,�r0F��Z A�rZ�� X��� �� 1@ ,U�0F� * x1�� y$rE6Z \Na6|� 7��8 9:�; \�? \@ ��0n ,]�(p6� 1@

>Z ��Gis 1@ <$B�r� 1@ ,<,; ¼1 3¹ x1�� ~:� �N0 �N$0� \NSLk$� �$�^�� eP$% * NE0$_@ ,<iÅ��� A�$ZN6|� <($� �N)NZ <=�C 3; <�1�� }�6? /? <;:�

}�6|�� <;:� OG� � sd1 ,U�0F� *W j�$$��J �$$�^�� eP$$% ��($$� N$$�1T �$$�^�(Z

U�0F�V * ]�(p$6� �$Z�6? \t ;�$�N0r� ��(p$i �l�|� �%�:6;1 ��1�� �E_ ©{ �E0_@ U�0F�W

���0�F6�1 j���J ��^�� eP% 3; K�|i 3¹1: 1− ,J��1 �'� ,�S� &' r��1 &' �MV ,r��1 &'�

o�/s���[\����:354A:C` <$Z�6? ���r� * ��rnT~N$lt1 K�$��r6�V :T �$�

O�EG$��Z H�$,� �$n���1 ,��>? �D-�S �04t ��@ �°�- �D,� 5$FÁ ³$a^1 ,��;N$�N� �06|Z K��`6Cs ;

,M6|� s A N�D� O�EG� wÁ �_ �6^ ,��ZN�r�1 3$� 3,p$� ]� 3� \@1 ,}�`6p� A���; }N�r� �|,�1 ,3��$�1 <$ra� /$%@ 3$� �D��; K�|i1 ,����� �(Bt ��$�� �$|i 3$� 1�>?@1 , �04Ñ� U�F� �?� * N,��@

A�G- , ��Ë� �$Dua^ � 3� m; Õ�a�t /�GE6� KD,� * �$� m$; K��6$� �:6$; M0$� ��� \�|n ,Õ�a8 3� ��Z�$6n ,}�$F=�� /�G$E6� v0$6r� ¢�i1 ,}�6|�

�(��6� m; �Dua^ /D�t I�EG�V�73�W <�Nrn:T }�$6|� * �$� m$; K��6$� �:6$;WWWV

,�Dp$al ��ai �@�Z g6� j���J ��^�� eP� O��Ni�D6�1 1 M6|� /rl m; �D�n ��1�� �(6�i \5ZW

2 − b��AU� (� �A� &' �MV (����'� ,Jc�U� de�f��� &'�' 9�Tg�� X8�'�/����[\����:405A:C`

* �$��0�F6�1 j���J ��^�� eP% �d �C@ �-1,<06? 3� �Z�6?<��? �?� y0� �-1 �74�W

3 − TA4' �A'� ,kA &' �/U� &' �S� ,o5 ���� o5 ����[\���� :458A: C`

<,; I�G� 3Z ��- �rn :<$ld T �$,�1 :�$n �$?�

�73� �ul: }�6? \�$0�Z 3Zs ,\�0^ 3Z O�E_ M��ri * \�p^�1 102W�

�74� �1t 7E0� * :7��>� M�F� :e NFi1 U�0F� j5klW

Page 25: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

�������� ��� �� ���� ,29 ���� ,�1� ����� ,�2017� 1438$%�

– 61 –

<,; : <$l��c g��$f  �Z 3� ~:p� * ]�Ni 3� ]�Ni 3$$� <$$i9�- \N,p$$¾ s1 ,KD>��$$^ \N$$ua¾ s 3�P$$�

@�r� �� \Nn��� s1 ,KD06? j9�$r� \N|i \@ ��Z KD��;KD;:� /_@ 3� KD��;W

1@ ,�E$_ �$- g6� 7���^t \5Z ��� <)11 * �$$06?1 ,�$$l1� �$$- ,Krp$$�1 �EG$$� �$$Z �$$a-1 M%P$� \@ cN$� s1 ,7��$8 �(B@ �D�� g6� ]�NJ ;KDz�Z m; M%P� \@ c�) \d1 ,KD��� m; �D,� 9ª

�Dua^ ���+� M^�_ \:z�W ��- :Tn �$,; �$)N� s 7��$EZ �N$�� 9�$) 3(

K%�$,; X1��� 7��EZ 9�) 3�1 ,<,� /0r� � KD���, <$>��EZ �$(B�- �$�81 ,<$6�1�Z ��a,� s <�1�� xP��n QG$� \@ <$,� ~:p$�1 <6�1 3� �Gr�1 ,eQR ��1�Z �$��|� eP% �r0i1 ,�lw4@1 ,�,��EZ A�p�p� 7��8

�¥ �G4 g6� A�n{ ��t eP% �aFG$� �,�0,� − m$_ K��1 <�� m;1 <��; �−K�;@ �1 V�75�W

g$rD�0� �N$- �$?� ��Z x �Glt ���?c ��-1 :T3$; eNEl1 ,K?�8 < §=�C <�N- NEl �d �grD�0� y0�1

ga�p�V�76�W 4 − EA� I� jA'�� &A' kA &A' �AS� T4' �'� XZ��N���[\����:463A:C`

�75� 3Zs ,7��8 �N�;I�G� & �121�W �76� ,g-��� ��a�@ I+Z g-�0� O6nx �Glt ���?�� � 1 342W�

* ��$$- �$rnT * �$$��a|��$$�1�� K$�;V :T }�$$Z �1 7$$���^@ ÌN�k$$�  $$�Z 3$$� ]($$� 3(�$$n �N$$r�

�Dua¾,�$¥ ��$E� /$_@ �$)1 K� , �$D�n M$6|� �1 �d <pal 3|pi ¦�k� 3; �06? �=pl �)1 1@ ,<;:�

�D6E_, }�E$_@ �$��; ?�$D,� �$�1�� <$� cN$� /% ��� 3� \N�,(� 7��8WWW �6� <l@ �u,� <0)N� xP�1

��^t \@ X�; g$6� g$% �=p$,� �D6,(z$i g$6� 7� �d <pal �,|� �d ,��1�� \@ <� c�) ¦�k� 3� �D�(�

�$D�n K%N$� �N4� 3� ���p�1 ,�� /r,� �E_, �1 K�;@V�77�W

<$�NrZ <$l��c * j1�� m; M6; ��� /0- \�?1KD,; :TS��i \d� �E$_ 3$(n 7��$^ ��1 K%�^@

QR 3� �D�� �l1²� ga? ,�D;�6Z �$n��� s1 ,�$� ~:� �D�-�l ��EZV�78�W

9:$$�; /$$�) xP$$� Q$$`6� P$$¥ j��k$$� g$$%1 P$% �k$6l /$0- �$�^�� ��0�F6� \NE�N� 7��8

��8W 5 − T:�Au �A'� ,0!f-A v7 &A' �MV &' �S� b��U� o!f- e/��[\���� :576A: :`

g-��� ³n�8 ��-− g$rD�0� �N$- �?� \@ ��Z yZ�p�− :T * <$�� <$� 9�$) * ga�p$� ��$- ��P?1

�77� x��`0� M�F=�� ,��1�� K�; * ���a|� & �257W� �78� yZ�p� �G� & �4W�

Page 26: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

I��G� � �0; 3Z O��_: �,; U�0F����E� :e�BNn1 ,<6�b@1 ,<i5kl1 ,<�NDa�

– 62 –

Tj9�r� ©{V : ,KD>��$^ \Nn��� s 3�P� ÌN�k� \dKD��; s KD,; ��r� �r>� m; KD6�1 * §�:6;s W \d1

Np$�� �d ;��l��t ³a^ �d Õ�a8 3� /�Ni <�? P% �G$4 sN�1 ,��Z�6� <)1 m; sd ,O�EG� ©{ 3�

�c�) �� 9:��� �N$- 3$; sd ��1�� s1 ,KD,; �Z�6|�3��4� \1� KD,� W�D6l W <$��; �r6$� xP$� N% P%1

/(��V�79�W 6 − ,&STAA�� �AA� &AA' r3GAA ,"D#AA�� &AA'�

&$��� o5� ,�TM�'�[\���� :643A:C` A��$�Ni �$�^�� eP$% m$; ��|� * ]�Ni �-1

Q0? A Z <��? ��4 3� �Du�1 ,<06? 3� ��; * IN$�N m$; �$�^�� eP$% �D6$��n g6� �sNE6�1 �Q`6�

�FG� 3� �(D� MlN) ��� 3(n ,e�;N-1 7��8 O <�N- <Z�6? * T7��$8 �N$�;V ]$�N� �$^@ * 3$;

7��8 j1 ©1{ :T �G$;t eP% * H�,� ��;@ j1 * ©1+$� 3$� �$,�Z �$� ~N(� �06; 3; j�456�

n ,<h�k�1 7��8 P$�6� ;K��$�1 * �$¥ 1��r6� K���$ri 3$� <$��; \�$?1 ,��ri �� NEl m; ��PZ 9�nN� W

�NGr� \N? 3� P% �,Z�6? �1@ * �,��- �� ��� <)11 * �$$�t eP$$% �G$$�G4 m$$; �$$un�E� �d A�$$4� �� 3$� w$6���n ,�D6�p$�� ~�Frl 3� j ��E�1 ,��l��t

P$¥ y$��� �$� j N?P� ©1+� ,e��$� m$; ��$`�

�79� g-���� ,j�?P6�1 j¶06� I{�1 368W�

QR ,A�-�; ,A�`��Z , A:�p� <lN|Z ¦�k� ���%@ * �6|��1 <;:$� �N$)NZ <F0$� *1 ,�=p$�1 ypa��Z �%�u6� /$_t y$nN� /_@ 3� <6�1�Z1 ,KD6� QR [=Z A�60>�

<=�C W �|ZNZ@ <�ra� ³n�8 e�l�?� �� NEl �d y0� �-1 grD�0��]�Ni <,; �,�1 :�n �?� <l�n * ]�Ni 3�

~:p�WWWV�80� W��r6� grD�0� ��? U�� K�W ~:p$� ��$0�d /$rl * �4� ]�N� * ��-1 :T �d

�$�Z�r� �$�Z sd <6=p$l �d <;:� /r,� �n }�6|� ¦pl����� W 9ª �d A�;:$� /$r,� \@ �$^t g`0,� s P|%1

��Z sd ,9�6Z ~:p� �,; �D�n <60>� 1@ ,¦p,� 3� �$�Z�r� Q$R �=p$,� �$�6Z �$^@ L$`� ��$? ;~N(p��Z ����� Q$R �=p$,� \N$? e�$,;1 ,/r,� ]� �0� \@ sd ,��Z�r�

K�;@ �1 ,��Z�r�V�81�W 7$��� ]$�N� * ��-1 :T �$�1�� * �N$- ��$C

N$S�an \1�$4� �D�n /%�pi1 ,NS�n5nWWW /$%@ 3$�1/%�p6� :Nl1�$�1 �a,G$� A�$06? N�(� �N- �d �$6^ ,

m; e+�1 /DJ KD�¿ KD��d o�6^1 ,3p� * N,�S ,�$�Z�r� Q$R j ��6p$� 1@ ,jLk$� ¦p$l 3� �%11 \@ ��$$$r0S * ³n�$$$8 � �$$$0; N$$$Z@ K?�$$$8 K%�$$$�n

�^1�$$�� W��$$- : �$$D6�1 * K$$´@ \N$$bN6� K$$%1\N-��_ W��-1 : 3$� �N- e�S��i1 ,H�,� * �>? �¹ P%

�80� I�G� 3Zs ,7��8 �N�; & �120−121W� �81� �G�yZ�p� & �208W�

Page 27: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

�������� ��� �� ���� ,29 ���� ,�1� ����� ,�2017� 1438$%�

– 63 –

:��� �Z�?@I�G��Z �n1���1 ,9V�82�W ]Z ]�N� * ��-1 :T � @ K$� ,A�$Z�6? ]($� �d

�=p,Z ��Z�r� g% s1 ,<;:� �D�n v�� �=pl 3� <6�1 ��� <� �� � ,<=�C m; �D,� ](� <l@ QR <;:� W ]F-

<$,; �$,`�Z :�$n <$�ra� Î�0G$� 3$Z ¶$l NZ@ ��� <Z W@ ,<=�C ~:� �D�n \�? N� ��P?1 3$; �$r� �D,� ¼1 1

�d ;��� ��� m; A�:6; �D,� ��1�� <� cN� �n ,<=�C<;:� �=pl * �p�� �B1c �D�n \N|i \@ 3�²� sW

3$; �$�� U�G� �|^ �- M�FÁ ��)1 K���$E� /_@ �)1 �d :�n �?Pn ,7��8 /%@ �>?@, �1

<;:� <�n M6|�WWWV W� yZ�p� M�FÁ ��? U�� K� xP<��; A�r��� ��-1 ,<i�?�:T �$�- : <$� \N$|i \@ sd K$D��

<$� cN$��n ,�$�� NEl 1@ ,<i��1�� ���; <=�C 3� jc�)d �$�i �$�1 3$� �$>?@ <$�n v�$� �d ;�$D,� ��1�� P�,�^

³a�Z jc�)�Z ������T�lw4@V 1@ ,T�,��$^V Q$R 3$� $f * <�>� ]r� M��- ��� * ��t1 ,�D�n jc�)À� \��Z /

O��p6� W 3; ~:� /? * �,R s <l@ ��ri :�n �,�|^ �-1 eQ$R1 NDp� <)1 m; ~:p� * [rp� �� ]r�� ;jc�)

�Dua� �?P� � \d1 ,jc�)�Z ��1�� ,�>?@ 1@ �:�? 3�W 1@ ,<=�$C ¦�$C ~:� �=p,� * xP� \�? \�n ¦�$C 3$; �$�1�� 1@ ,<=�$C ¦�$C m$; �;N(p� g%

g`0,�n ,<=�CP�,�^ <�−�$D,� <6�1 * − <$� \N$|i \@

�82� yZ�p� �G� & �208− 209W�

3$� ����$C jc�$)d <=�k$�1 ,<=�$C 3$� ����C jc�)d <$� � �l�% 3p^ Qp�i P%1 ,<=�C− �$(8 <$�1 −

�) �,l��c * ���� <��d �)�81 WK�;@ �1V�83�W <Z�6? * ��-1TK�p$� O�E_ �l��_V :T�$�1��

* �¥ �NGr� v�� ��G6� ��l��t�Z �l¶$; − 3$� Q$>?1 <�0- �G;t − 3; �D,� ��,�d N�h s ��d ;�¥ ¼1�� �� ��0�d

O�G$� A�F0� <Z�6? * �� [0z� s1 ,<�1�� �� x �� s ¦�C��p�� 9�rZd �D,� �NGr� :ld1 ,<iN0� * <��; �(6�� \t

���? � �%�c ,��t eP% �¥ �G4 g6�1 ,��,�W �P? ��� \�? �d1 »��6^s � @ 3� /�0pn ,�

/$_@ 3$� e�r�6� \@ <%�0C@1 K�p� O�E_ 3� 7��EZ �E�E$_ �N$_5Z ,�$6r� ��Z�$r� x�$� m$; /Z�r� <Z

��PZ <� /GE�� ;�;N,6� ���1�Z ��1�� j���6�− ]$� /��$06��Z �G$ri \@ 3$; �%�$�Z1 ,M$6|� eP% �D6C

���E6�1−�N_t ��i <��; �rai �� �EGZ �r>� W��$�1�� }�Z * A�(6�� M6|��Z [0z� \�? �� K, �$rn

1@ �iN$6� �$��,� ��$,6i j�$>? �$¥ /Z�r� �N_t �>|i �$�� È�0� � �� K� ,��� È�0i s �-1 ,���a6�s ���,�

���|��Z /F0� s−e�?� �,��- �� j�B�n <�n : �$� \N$? 3� 3$� <6EGZ A�;NFr� �b�^@ 1@ \�E�EG� <��; /(6C

^ �N0r��$Z �$�� ��t gr�i 7�− * �$�@ <$� �$r0� /$Z 3� K|^ m; �r�,� ~���? ���1 ,O�)L�1 ��Nr6�

�83� yZ�p� �G� & �211−212W�

Page 28: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

I��G� � �0; 3Z O��_: �,; U�0F����E� :e�BNn1 ,<6�b@1 ,<i5kl1 ,<�NDa�

– 64 –

��PZ /F0� s <l�n ,��^Ê y��FZ �,��d /rl �d ��|^t �r0� /Z ,���|��Z eQ�5i− O_t m; − /$_@ * eQ�5i

K�;@ �1 ,��� K�;�n ,/(�� }N)1V�84�W ��Z 9�) 3� /?1 <$��? m$; �$� I�G� 3Z

KDz�Z �?PZ ga6?@1 ,��t P% * <)�D,�1W 7 − &A' �AMV (� �� �'� &$��� xM% ,o�:y��

r3G &' �S�[\���� :748A: :` <Z�6? ���r� * ��- �rnT��$6;s \�$��V A�$,�0�

<�n <S{ :T KD,$� � 1@ s 3��45$6� 3� <�n K�|i �- 3��0i �- 3� sd j�$(�� �d ;j1�� 3� e��@ Ozi1 ,<a��

,3��$�r�1 ���$E� m$; /$Z ;j1�� m; v�� �,l��c * 9:$$�@ [0$$� * KD-�$$_1 KD6��$$; �$$n�; 3�P$$�1

����p� W x1�$� \N$_ 3$� �$Z s <$l@ �N$��� 3� K�eL�1 W �,$� H@ N$% �456�1 ��r6� �Z /_�a� �8�n

�B:��� W m; �E6n N�1 K�$� �$� }�$0� P% ���i Æal �$$� \1 �$$� s �$$>?t �d ;/$$��r� sd g$$�� s1 ,\11�$$�

�d o�$6^1 ,�`G$� * N�(� :ld ,\5k� P% \Nn��� 3� m;1 ,K� @�- 3� m; j�(���n ,w|� * K%�,� N�; ,7��8 �N�; * ©Np0� N% :? ,K� ~:p� U�0S �0�@

��6�s <Z1 ,ynN� �1<Z sd jN- s1 ,�lV�85� W P$% 3$; g0%P$� K$�|i 9�0$,� ��;@ Q� *1

�84� I�G� 3Zs ,K�p� O�E_ �l��_ & �115−116W� �85� g0%P�� ,��6;s \����1 4W�

,7��$$8 �N$$�; * e �$$��1 <$$h �i A�E$$�N� �N$$E6� �$$��i * ��$$rn ,/��$$�6�1 I�$$J �$$;N- �$$_�41

g0�G$,� �$�N� 3$Z �$¿@ �|Z ¯@ ��4 3Z�ÍN$6� :359$% :�T ,U�$�� �,p$� ,��E� ,U1�G� ,¦�k�

M�FÁ ��-: <;:� \@ QR ,K��� 3� A���C X��� s \�?g,F- �� 3p8 �Z@ �5� �-1 ,O�E_,��rn : w?@ :�@

�0�F�� ��rn ?�� 1@ ~�G� :K|=�$C �d 1�ul W ��$-1K��l NZ@ :�r� \�? W ,H N$a� ¯@ 3$Z O6$a� N$Z@ <$r�1

��-1 : A���C 7��8 3� X��� 3|� � W �$-N� P% 3(n− <�0-1 /Z − m$; �$ua�� eP$% \N$r�F� Õ�$a8 �_

,��$; ��$0�d1 3r6� j9�rZ O�E_ <;:� xP� ¦�k� �$(B@ X�$; * �$r>� :$ld1 ,�r>��Z <6�(pi * NG4�i1 ,<$�¿ �$� 3r6$� ,<p$al * ��$�� m; ]ri �l�? �r,� ]$$�N6n ,3a��$$Z �$$n���1 K$$Dn <$$�1 ,/$$rl �$$� [Z�z$$�

\1�456�V�86�W 8 −�AAMV �TAAM �AA'� AA�� &AA'� r3GAA &AA' z'�T

ou��TN��[O���� :752A:`{[87` C ��- �rn :T �04t �l °1 §� �-, O��$�6�� grZ ��1

�B:�Z t H@ 3� ��Frl /Z ,j�B�nV�88�W

�86� g0%P�� ,9�0,� ��;d Q��16 69−70W� �87� * <6��i �ul:1 3,p� j1 * ���r6� /�� Ð�$a�� ,��l�$�t

�1 173W� �88� �ul}�$6? x1�=p$�� ,7��$8 �$�a�@ I+$Z 7$�`� O6$n

�4 358W�

Page 29: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

�������� ��� �� ���� ,29 ���� ,�1� ����� ,�2017� 1438$%�

– 65 –

9 − }Gc &' TM &' L�37~ ,}Gc &'�[\���� :774A: :`

<$Z�6? * ��-T7��$8 �N$�; �G$64V :T ��$- I�G$� 3Z :$4� /%�p$i � ¦p$l 3$� �$�1�� * \1�

M��F� �N- ���(Z ,/Z�ri: T�6�1 3� P%V QR 3� ,<;:$� �r0S �rai s1 ,�=p,� * �ul s1 �0>i W��$- :

�^1��� ��r0S * K?�8 K%�; �-1V�89�W 10 − &A' �AMV &A' �MV &' �MV ,X8Y�� &'�

k[\���� :833A: C` j:p� <i��G- * ��-T���� * ��1�� K�;V:

©Lk$$$� v�$$$� �G$$$;t eP$$$%1* [0z$$$$$$$l ~:p$$$$$$$� �N$$$$$$$0� sd

���p$$$�p� �E$$$_ ³$$$a^ /$$$)t* ��$$$$$$$�t eP$$$$$$$� � �G$$$$$$$�G4

�$$$$l1�1 �$$$$D6l 7$$$$���^t �d* �$$$$$,�Z1 �DaE$$$$$_ * �$$$$$;�1@1

�$� A�^ �$C x1�=p� ��-1 :Tx@ : �G$;t \@ ©1+$� ~N$(� �$D�n w6�� s j�456�s ,j N?P$� *

s1 ¦�k� * A���$C ¸r,$� ��$�1 ,�%±$�� ;M$��F� [$=Z A�SN0z$� x1�$� ~:$� �N)NZ Na6? /Z ,A���kn ��p�� 9�rZd m; 7��8 /%@ &�^ /)t ;<Z UN�N�

�89� Q$$>? 3$$Zs ,7��$$8 �N$$�; �G$$64 �d 7$$�>8 7$$;�0� &�139W�

��t eP¥ &NG=� ��,� W ��$�6� � K½�,� \d K� 3$�1 ,A N6p$� <$lN|Z x1�� ���; 3� Na6? K´N|� ¢�i <l5?1 ,<=�C /_t ynN� /_@ 3� <6�1�Z <F0� s 7�EZ ,\��ct eP% * ���L�s * KD��N6� ���

A�60>� <;:� �N)1 QR m; \N_�¾V�90�W 11 − &$�AA�� ?DAAq ,TAA4' �� &AA' &STAA�� �AA� ou��/��[\���� :911A:C`

<6��� * ��-Tx1�=p$� ¦� �$i * x1�$|�V − K|^ O�N� N%1 j�45$6� �,�ct * j1�� I�)− :T 3� P4²� 7��8 \�? 7�^ �G� * cN) :ld I�J

<$��d o�6^�$n , �a$�t \N$FZ 3$� s , �0^t 1�_ 3$� �1��$�1 �N0r� �n���1 , ��Ê 3; }P�� j 1¡ M$6|� m$; j�$(���n \Ê �$�@1 , �04t1 7���^t

{ K´@ }�0� * �� ���R ,�l1�� * \Ê �?P$� 3$� NS O�G$� 3� [=Z <;:� �N0�1 ,<lNGi ��,� ��p�� ga6? ��� * ��|� � \Ê o�6^ ��n ,�:6;s <��;

��r� \5Z : A�;Nl <;:� * \@ \��Z1 , N6p� 1@ \NG� QR 1��1 ND6� 3�V�91�W

6��G�� E- �� :�� �� �����C t �4�$$a� 3$$� �$$(�u; j�$$=a� U�$$0F� �$$�

�90� ���`� * x1�=p$�� ,��1�� K�; * ���� I{ & �132−133W�

�91� �ul: }�6?xN,|�� ,/�(|6�1 ]n�� & �13− 14W�

Page 30: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

I��G� � �0; 3Z O��_: �,; U�0F����E� :e�BNn1 ,<6�b@1 ,<i5kl1 ,<�NDa�

– 66 –

3$� �$�Z�l ,�DGB�G4 3� ����) �G�G41 ,����� 3Z ³n�8 /rl :? g%1 ,��,��Z ��t eP% &�G64

�Nr� 7�^ ,9�za�  �Z 3; ��^:T  $�Z ��(��Nr� 9�za� :M6|� }�pl@ ��l��tV�92�W

,�$BNa�� yn�$6� �$´1 ,K$B� �,? yEZ U�0F��n3|� � N�1 ,�B�a�1 yB�rE�� ]0,�1 A���� <lN? sd �D,�

�$D)�6,Z �$rB�a� �$�t �$��,; m; A��S�� �l�%�Z1 A��S�- �$6(� �$Dh �i w$; <6���1 <ua^1 <6l��_1 ,g(��� �$�|n ,3(>$Z �$ri s �$(�u; �$���) j�B�n �¥ �a|� �%¶$$$^ M�G$$$� jQ$$>? ¼�$$$4@ �$$$BNn U�$$0F��1

?�%���i1! ¦�k� e�?� :�n /��1 , ������� ��� 3� 3; g(��r� �$� ,��$0�t * �;N(�� ��l��t �BNn

��$- 7�^ ,��� 3� A���C O�N� :T\@ K$�; M$�Fi * XNk$6� g$%1 s@ ,����� 9:|E�� ���R M6|� ��l��@ &�^ ¼@ �d /-��� \�n ;�D6���F�1 �D��d ~N)�� �d �$� \@ K$�; �D�a,G$� �d �,p$��Z �D6�1 m; ���-t

|� ���r� H�06-1 ,��9�- * P45�n ,\�n��� 9:� * A�,� K�$� * A�$�-�i1 A N$,i ���$�n ,�$D,� X �$��1 �BNa� �,|� N%1 ,\�(�� �:;1 ,���� �N- K��� \�n ;�N���

�,a� s xP� �4P�1 ,�(>�W M6|� ��l��@ �BNn 3�1 : \��p$,� 3$� �$Dua^

�%�BNn 3�1 ,~��z�1 :��� +l �D�1�i1 X ���1 �N

�92� ��^ 3Zs ,x �0� O6n�1 5� W

,}�$F� �$D��; �$r6� ;�$����1 �_�Á �Z �D6;�d1�D,�1 : * �0R�� \�n ;M6|� ����F� y�Nk6�1 M�RL�

3�1 ,\�pl ~Nl �¥ ¸4 g6� K�,� w?@ 3� ����F��%�$$BNn : K$$��� M$$6|� �$$�1t �$$06; m$$; �$$�s��

�;d1 �% �- K�u�i1 ,�´5kZ <�N,6�1�DBWWW �$� U @ ��1 <$Z�6? �$��r� * M$�FÁ 3$Z 3��$� \�p$� ��cN� <��-

T�S�l�R �04@ * �S�^V : ¼�%− <l�E0� − ,K$�@1 K��� �,�a�@ �6^ ,K��� 3|� � �� K�r��Z \�pl K�;1 ��l�$�t1 ,�$�Nr,� �$04t1 ,�$���% �$C��1 ,j�B�-

�$r� ¦� N$6�1 ,j �f �N_t1 ,��N_N� Qp$�1 ,j ,��-�Z �D�%@ ��Z 3� /B�za�1 ,j N�5� ��Ê1 ,j N?P�

��$� /$��1 H�$S�r� �´ \5? ,j�%�C ��S�- ��×�1, :$D(n ,��p$a�1 \N$|� ��$; * �$D,�1 /��� \�pn�,�

e+l �d N;� A�?� �,n� 1@ ,e+,Z ���1 ���C ��NSV�93�W �d �$)�EZ U�0F� �BNn }���6� \t1 �$� �

��r6p$� ��Ga�, �d Qk$l \@ 7$E0� P$% * �,0p$En �Dz�Z �G64�Z ,�NG$r� O�Ni »�:l �?� ]� c��d1

U�0F� �BNn 3(n: 1− A���� A��S�- A����1 ,A���Z@ A��h �i A�%�C �´N?

��$r6l �E$_ m$; �$���66� ����� ��t ���)@ ���@D6��$$�1 �D6l��$$_1 �$$Dua^1 M$$6|� ¦� �$$i �N$$S �

�93� g($$��r�� ,7��$$8 O�FG$$� \N$$,n 3$$� 7��$$E6� �$$;N- &�215−216W�

Page 31: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

�������� ��� �� ���� ,29 ���� ,�1� ����� ,�2017� 1438$%�

– 67 –

1@ �$-�^ 1@ e �$? 1@ 1�$�� A�$r�F� ��$� �n ,�(�p� ����$$� �$$�t K$$��Z ��|k$$6� 1@ 3$$�F�� �$$��^

�D��i1 W 2−��t * ��,� �G�G4 9�rZ m; �un�E� W

I�G$� 3Z ��- :T ��l�$�t�Z �$�1�� \@ K$�; 3$$� Q$$>?1 ,�l¶$$; * �$$D,� �NG$$r� v�$$� ��G$$6�

�G;t<�0-, 3; �D,� ��,�d N�h s �d ;¼1�� �� ��0�d A�F0$� <$Z�6? * �$� [0z$� s1 ,<�1�� �� x �� s ¦�C 9�$rZ �$¥ �NG$r� :ld1 ,<iN0� * <��; �(6�� \t O�G� � �$%�c ,�$�t eP$% �$¥ �G4 g6� ��,� ��p��

���?V�94�W ��-1− A�z�@ − :T :$Z �NG$r� K$u�� �$_ 3� �1�6���l��tWWW �G4 g6� ��,� ��p�� 9�rZd

��t eP% �¥V�95�W 3−}�6|��1 ¦�k�� x1�� ~:� ��0�d W

]-1 �� U�0F��Z x1��� ~:p� ��0�d * �?� �¹1 K�,$� �$Z@ 3$Z M$��S �$Z@ 3Z �¿@ H�0�� ¯@ ¦�k��

, ��8 g8�G�� �,� ��1624 �,$� *Ni1 ,A�0��ri $%730$% �8 <� K)�i��$rn ,��^ 3Z ³n�:T �,$� �$�1624 ,x�$�Z�� 3$Z 3� ](�1 ,��� /0- /Z ,A�0��ri $%

,<$Zc1 3Z1 ,g��Fr� ��`Z 3� <� c�)@1 ,g6�� 3Z1q$; 3$Z �$a�) yk$�� 3$�1 ,\1�4�1 ,x�`C�|�1 W

�94� I�G� 3Zs ,K�p� O�E_ �l��_ & �115W� �95� I�G� 3Zs ,7��8 �N�; & �17 �X¶6ZW

�$)t�Z ��$a^t y$8@ �$6^ � °( §;1 �$D½ �$� �1@1 ,� �,� ���E(��706q$; 9�$)@ * <(� �)1 ,$% 3$Z

/>� ,g6�� : �D½ K� , ��,�� �(; �,p�1 ,��µ 3Z 9�) ��$$En ,x�$�Z�� 3$Z q$; ����p$� 9:$�@ * <($� ,��8�G$�1 ,yk$��Z j�$� ��0$� 3$� �>?@ O�EG��Z

�a?1 ,¸¿1 ,�0��Z1 ,j�¿1 ,¶�1 ,j�%�r��Z1 �$,FZ ,<$��; �$��� s �$� ��$?1 �$�� 3$� ¼@ 1 ,�%QR1

Õ�a8 <��; �E6l1 3� <��d /^ 1 , N$¿�i1 ,��0$� �,� 3� <��;717 H�$,� ��l ��� ��1 ,��� \@ �d $%

�) � <iN(ZV�96�W �$$�¾ 3$$Z 3¿���$$0; �$$���� ¦�k$$� ��$$-1

g(��� :T ,�,� ]zZ1 �,� �B�� Ò�; �(�� /)�� P% ¢ �$0� 3Z �p8 3� x �=0� O�E_ e�`_ * ](�

1 ,x��`0� q0,8 x��Z�� ¤$^ 3(�$n <($� M$6? :$�n ,��l�$� N�5$Z /`6C K� ,��� QR ](�1 ,~:p� * <(� m; \N��E� �>; j���c1 �,� �pÄ e�(; È�Z

�$a8 <$��; ]($� ,��$� \@ �d eN$���n ,��;:p� :K%QR1 ,g0%P�1 ,�cw�1 ,x��V�97�W

]��p$$�� �Dk$$i �$$6Z�� �$$�F4 �$$r��1 U�$$0F� \t1

�96� * <6��i �ul:Zs ,�,��>� �B�� \��;@ * �,��|� �� ��^ 3�1 142W�

�97� * g$$(��� ��$$? �$$ul: ���(p$$�� ,}�p$$lt m$$; <$$r���i �4 60W�

Page 32: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

I��G� � �0; 3Z O��_: �,; U�0F����E� :e�BNn1 ,<6�b@1 ,<i5kl1 ,<�NDa�

– 68 –

G� ~:p��Z M$iLi <$�n <i�0�d ��Z K�s Q�`i O0_@ O�E 3$�1 ,<$,; ]$,6(� ��P$Z �|a� 3� /�� jQF4 ��� <��;

��� m; ��>�t: * 3��$� Å�$l 3$Z ��$- �$�T O�$�Ni<06k�V:T g6�,§� §?: KzZ ,�,?�� \Nl K� ,��� ���1 X�|�

�,?�$� X1�8 �4� 9��� �D��i j Np|� UNn j�,>� K� : �@? �(f �,=�$C 3$Z �$¿@ H�$0�� ¯@ Ã�$r� �,Z g6,�

g�n�k$� ��Dk$� 3$Z �$(f O6$a� ¯@ ����� Ã�r� W QR ��(�1 ,M��r� O6a� <Z�6? 3� �%�) m; ��(�

��� W /$�a� K$�n �D($� Q$�`i � @ �%��1 \@ �w4@1~:p� U�0S * ��P? �D(� ��0�V�98�W

4−� <;:� ���� ;x1�� I�) �N0� 1@ <i��1��D,� 9ªW

�(6�� ��N0,� �,p� /rl * ��t �� O0_@ \@ ��Z /��$�i * �$`��Z �$�b@ U�$0F�� O0$_@ ,M6|� /-�,i m;

��- �d È��Z@ s q�� /Z ,j1�� I�)1 : �E0$_@ �$´d ��E�FG$� �5kl �6^ ,jQ4t \1�r� * ��� ��

/���6�1 I�J K��� j���) �;N-1 Õ�a�@1W ����1 �D��) �½Naf ��F4 �r��1 U�0F� \N?1 �k$� ��$^ �$D��d ~N$)�� 3$|(� �%�$½ �$,�Z ����1 /Bs� 3� e�nNi �� ���1 ;��t �r�r^ �k|� ;M���1 x1�$� I�$) 1@ }P$? m$; �s�6$�s�? ,�6Z�� ��N-

− ~:p� U�0S * <(� �n���Z }�6|�� <;:� ¼N;�Z −

�98� 3��� �l 3Zs ,<06k� O��Ni�7 338W�

X�64�$Z 1@ ,[$Á j1�FZ <$|^ 1@ <$lN� 1@ ,<$(�^ <Fk?1WW 9:$�; ]�F6p$� g$6� M���$�t 3� �%QR �d

�E_ �k|� ,�^ ��Z N�1 ,�DEzn1 �Dak? 7��8<��; 1@ ~:p�W

j1�$$� 3$$� ��$$; 3$$� �$$��  $$�Z ]$$-1 �$$-1 M$6? * K%��$�d1 ,KD^�) * A�00� \�? �¹ ,3��456�

�1 9�a�z���^1�W g0%P� �N- ��� ��>�@ 3�1 ¯@ 3Z 9�rZ ���i *

�(��8 �?�C :T�r0S ��@ 1c ,��)� }P? WWW e�$?��akn ��,� 3Z W�¿@ 3Z 9�rZ ��-1 : �r��F� É�� \�?

e�0_ *W WW ¯@ 3$� ~:p$� �$;�1 ,jQ$>? 9�$)@ ]� ,[k$|n ,�c�$)�Z ]$-11 ,<6r0S1 \1Q4 3Z NG,�

$a=n ,�$��� * �$%�r�@1 ,[k|� \�|� <(� �0�@1 gKDa� �1 ,<� <�r,n xcNJ 3Z �d ��� /¿ K� ,[k|� W

m$; H�$,� �$(6;�n ,q�$J Uc�$� �$0; <� /rl P?1 \:�$� 3$Z �$¿@ <$��; @�$rn ,�N$_t �a4@1 ,:D�rl ��$D½ K� ,eQR1 \�6� �� Ø�- jc�)�Z AQ>? �Z�8 <($� y8@ �-1 ,<ZP? \�Z1 ,Oz6n�n �c�) �N_@

� �>?@ *9�) ��@ 3 W<,; ��1�� /· sV�99�W � �$0% 3$Z 3p$8 3$Z �$(f �$��i * <�N-1 :

T}P? WOz6n�n ,j�; A�-�0S 1cV�100� W

�99� g0%P�� ,��6;s \����1 339−340W� �100� yZ�p� �G��3 521W�

Page 33: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

�������� ��� �� ���� ,29 ���� ,�1� ����� ,�2017� 1438$%�

– 69 –

�$(; 3$Z q; 3Z �p8 3Z �¿@ ���i * <�N-1x�|p� ¯�8 :TWWq%P$� ~��$C1 ,M$�FÁ <$,;1 W

s�-1 : A���(p$i e�$) M$6?  �Z * <pa,� ~:p� y8@ A���SV�101�W

¯@ NG$,� 3$Z q$; 3$Z ¶$l �$��i * <�N-1xNE,� q8 \c�Á 3Z IN6a�:T 9��z$� ³n�$8 ��- :

M6|� ,KD6� <l@1 ,�0�F�  �Z <�n K�|i1 ,<pa,Z M�S<�(p� � �� m; U�0F� W ,�B:6$� �,$� �Z�$C ��$� �-1

�D;:� 3; ��)�n ,9�)@ ���� <i9�rZ ��(�V�102�W @ ���i * <�N-1x�|p�� ���� 3Z �¿ :T 1�$�

U�0F�V�103�W K$� ,xw$|�� ¢ �$0� 3$Z ��0-d ���i * <�N-1

gF�N� :Tg>�Z�� 3Z ��- :U�0S * <(� y8@V�104�W 3$Z K�%�$Zd 3$Z �$¿@ 3$Z �(f ���i * <�N-1

g06|� Q�� :T ,�$Zc1 3$Z1 ,�$��Fr� 3$Z 3� ](�,U�0F� <Z�6? * KD6� <,|�1 ,��^13��� /��- V�105�W

��N$� 3$Z ���$� 3$Z /�;:$�d �$��i * <�N-1x��`0� :TH Na� ¯@ 3Z ��- : 3��$� * /%�p$i <�n

�101� yZ�p� �G��1 93W� �102� yZ�p� �G��4 252W� �103� yZ�p� �G��1 101 W� �104� yZ�p� �G��1 275W� �105� yZ�p� �G��3 457W�

~:p�1 WM�FÁ ��-1 : y$8@ A�Np$a� �;:$� <� ��@ <�nV�106�W

cc�� �(; 3Z ��� �0; ���i * <�N-1 :T x1��~:p$� �$�1�6Z KD6� ,eQR1 g,F- �� 3; W; ¼1 <$,

M�FÁV�107�W �¶$� /�;:�d 3Z �(f ���i * <�N-1 :T ��$-

®|� �; cNZ@ :~:p� 1��1 ,}P|� \�?V�108�W �$0; 3$Z �$(f 3Z �¿@ 3Z �(f ���i * <�N-1

x¶� 3¿�� :T �0�S 3� \�?1 ,]�(p6� <Z�6? * KD6�7��8 W��rn ,<h �i * M�FÁ e�?� : q; �Z@ ��(�

3Z �p8 \1�?P$� �,Z�E$_@ 3� eQR1 �l�-�0� �¿@ 3$|� � g6� M6|� �- N� 3� xLk� \�? x¶� \@

<pa,� �D�n ](p�1 ,�D�(�V�109�W 5− A�;:$$� �;N(p$$� x1�$$� ��$$�1�� �$$��£

�%QR 3� A�E�E_W 3$Z �$�¾ 3Z ��c <=�C ���i * ��,� 3Z ��-

]�0� � �0% 3Z �¿@ :T 3� <,; �06? ;O�EG$� <;:� ,~:p$� U�0S 3� K�,� �0; <�4@ K� [k|� \�? <lt

��� j1�1 ³��R K�rZ <��N� <(� M6|�1 W ��� /�n

�106� yZ�p� �G��1 232 W� �107� yZ�p� �G��2 660W� �108� yZ�p� �G��3 483 W� �109� yZ�p� �G��3 463W�

Page 34: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

I��G� � �0; 3Z O��_: �,; U�0F����E� :e�BNn1 ,<6�b@1 ,<i5kl1 ,<�NDa�

– 70 –

�¿@ <�4@ �N_@ 3� 9�)@ j�; m;V�110�W 3$Z K��$|� �$0; 3$Z K�^�� �0; ���i * ��-1

�au� ¯@ ,���(p� �(f:T �1t g6�^ * 1�(Z <6�r�,\���4 �d AQ>? <,� ��(�1 WWW g$6� <i�;:� �l�?1

,�E�E$_ ���$E� 3� �n1��� ©NF41 e��1 [=Z <($� yE�� \�? <l�n ,<��; �(6�� �n <F=Z \�? �� ��5n ~:$� g;�$�1 ,A�%�$½ A�-�8d �D�n <(� 3|� � U�0S *

�D,� <;:� �)N� � 9��C@ W A�f�p6� \�?1V�111�W 6 − N6� ��0�d 1@ gal ¦�W

q$; Q$�t 3Z ���i * g0%P� �N- ��� 3�1�(f 3Z �(f 3Z :Tg� �$8 3��$� ��$� �r� ��- :

�,$� ,\�0�$C 3$� 3�+��1 v��Á * 3��� �; *Ni�B:6�1 ���� Wx�%N$J 3$Z �$¿@ H�$0�� NZ@ ��-1 :

�,p� 3� \�z� * ��� W ,\�|�4 3Z1 ,x P,� ��-1 [0� �au� NZ@1x�%�$u� 3$Z1 ,g;�p� 3Z1 ,xcNJ:

�110� 9�r6l , ��,� 3Zs ,��`Z ¦� �i /��� 3� ��a6p� : ,gS����$��ul : <�N��1 ��`Z ¦� �i�21 88W�

�111� yZ�p� �G��21 118W� \��� \�p� * ��^ 3Z ³n�8 <,; ]n� �-1�4 7�,��rn :

T<$6��; �N$0� �$�Z I�$r� s <$�n �$�,� 3Z <��- xP� P% \�$? <$l@ cN��n ,U�0F� * <(� yE�� \�? <lN? ��@ ,<-�_1

��@1 ,<;:� yr¾ K6� :ld PDn ,�)Ni � 9��C@ ~:� �;� <lN? �1 ,<$�n ]($� <$l@ �$;� xP$� /_t �)1 N� <�n I�r� <Z

<�n ÌN�k�� Ml� �n �N_t \�rn ��@ ,<�n <(� �)N�VW

g� �8 <,�; �-1 ,�N�� N,��� � ,\�0�C * ��� W �$-1 �Gl * �Dh �i ~:� �r0S m; A�E�EGi <F4 �l@ ��@

�,p� 3� \�0�CV�112�W 3$Z �p$�; 3$Z �¿@ ���i * g|0p� �N- P?1

¯N��r� 3Z \N� :Tg0%P� �,=�C ��- : �,$� *Ni <ld�1 ]pi�B:6�1 �l: W��- : �45$i �- /Z ,��P? v��1

K$��� * <$��; ~:p� U�0S ��@ �rn ,�-N� P% 3; * �Dz$�Z ,�B:6�1 ��pi1 ¼�^d �,pZ �4 ²� �%�u� <$$F4 �$$D��;1 ,M$$) * �Dz$$�Z1 ,�1t ¼��$$�

O�EG6��ZV�113�W 7 − ,}�6|��1 ¦�k�� �(�p� QR ~:� ��0�d

��d ��Z 9�t �E_1<�W x1�$� ~:p� U�0F� ��0�d * �?� �� c�Z@ 3�1 3$; <$>��^ �$,; g$-��� ³n�$8 e�$?� �� K�p� QR

��rn ,�n�|�� jc�):T �$)@ K$�n �n�|�� jc�) ��@1 �^@ 3; �)@ �1 ,O�E_ <;:� \@ ��ri �-1 ,�rl �D�n �G=C \@ sd ,�n�|�� jc�) 3��456�1 ���r6� 3�

St 3� ,<$��; ]($�@ �1 ,yk��Z <6�@ 3¹ yk��Z 9�0<� ��r� : * 7��8 ](� ,\���� 3Z ��p� �0; 3Z �(f

3�²$� �$0; 3$Z �$(f � �$0; ¯@ m$; <$6��N� ��^ ,����p$� ]$� ~:p$� �r0S * <(� M6?1 ,x NG�

�112� g0%P�� ,9�0,� ��;@ Q��22 356W� �113� g|0p�� ,¼w|� ���n�k� ��r0S�8 23−24W�

Page 35: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

�������� ��� �� ���� ,29 ���� ,�1� ����� ,�2017� 1438$%�

– 71 –

KD6�� 3� N%1 ,](� 3� 3�²� �0; 3Z c�)@1 W \�?1EZ jc�)1 ~:p� 3Z ��N� »��8 ¯@ ³n�8 Nz

QR * ���1 ,<i9�rZ ~:p�  �Z1 ,x�� 3¿�� �0;�D,� ,9�) �� :TjL; 3Z 9�)V cN) ¼�� x�� \@ sN�n

<��; �-@ �� ��� W N?P$� ��p$� �$0; 3Z � ¼�% K��,Z�E_@ <,� ](�1 ,��^1 ,���À�WWW ]l�� �c ��n

9�t O_ 9�t 3�V�114�W 8−s 3�P� j1��� ��n1 ���i 3�N|i K� �)Ni

K��a$_1 KDB:$�@ [0�1 ,j1�� ��^ �n���1 ,���iKD6l�|�1W

�a,G$�1 �4 ²(�� A�0G4 A �G� U�0F� ��i ,�$(D� ��$�N��� m$; /(6ki �´N|� ;j1�� K)�i * s :,$�^ �$_�=Z1 ,j1�$� 3$; �$;N,6�1 �(�- �BNn1

i ¢�,% \N|i��� ��>�@ 3�1 ,x1��� ��� : ����� �N-��$6|� g8 �0; [0$� �%�$C 3$Z �$�N� �$��i * ��^ 3Z ³n�8− ��NF�1 ��n1 ���N��� �?� \@ ��Z

<,;− ��- :Tj�n1 K)L(�� ³aEl s �l@ ,��@ /|Z�115� ,�$$$��i s1�116� ��a,G$$$� 3$$$� 9ª * A�$$$?� s1 ,

�114� j¶06� I{ g-���� ,j�?P6�1�1 429W� �115� *Ni899$% We�l�@ ��C�8 * <6��i ��G�  �Z �ul1W �116� * ��n1 ���i ��^ 3Z [0p� x1�=p� K)�iT ]��$F� �0�

]Z�p� \�r� ��Z 3� 3��E(ZV� 2 354� <$� K)�$i P$?1 , * gSN�p�T\�$�;t \�$�;@ * \�$�r�� K$ulV & �179� , ��?Nk$$�1 *T]$$��6� \�$$r� /$$%t ]$$��� 9Nz$$�V=

3��456��117���L$� xP� <(� QR ��;:p$� * AQ$>? �$�� /$%@ e�$S��i g>��$^ }�6? °/rn ,j�>|Z U�0F�1 �$�1 ,~:p$� ��r0S * <��; <(� �� sd <�0-1 ¶�� eP=n ,�N,� j�; * <6�� �¹ �,% <6��i �1@ * <i�?�

A�?�CV�118�W 9:$���1 �a,G$�1 �4 ²(�� U�0F� ��ri :?

3; �(�-1 �r�-�1 �r�N� ���N��� x�²$� �$-1 ,j1�$�s ��|k� /^ �d �D��d ~N)�� 3$� sd �$D�^ 3|(�

�$$�n�? �$$��i ¢�$$,% \N$$|i s :,$$�^ �$$_�41 ,�$$��4��� 3�1 ,x1��� : q$; 3Z �(f ���i * g0%P� �N-

$J 3$Z � �$0; ¯@ Ã�r� �(f 3Z ,gF$�N� ,¯�� �,� ÍN6�542$% :�T¯�J :E6n1 <(� * ��6µ ,<

gS:lt 3Z �%�S NZ@ ��rn : O6$a� N$Z@ �,=�$C �,� ��-gB�,� : ,<$6�)�n ,�$C �$Z K�$J O6aZ ,¯�J N%

��-1 ,Mz`n : �$l@1 9�z$r� * x�$�1 3; }N,� \�?<Z w4@ WgS:lt 3Z ��- : 3$Z ��+$� <$,; ��5�1

��rn ,]�(p� �0; : 3$� M$��i1 ,Kz$��Z sd <n�;@ sa� ¯@ �N-O6W

�$$�- : A�SN0z$$� <$$6�@ �t ;Kz$$� O�EG$$�1 3� <�� :�n ]�N� QR * ,q; e��1 [=ZT ¦� �i /��

=�10 313W� �117� e�;@ ��C�8 * y���6� �ulW �118� ��6|�� ,H �Da� H�Dn�2 1139−1140W�

Page 36: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

I��G� � �0; 3Z O��_: �,; U�0F����E� :e�BNn1 ,<6�b@1 ,<i5kl1 ,<�NDa�

– 72 –

[�1V m$; ¦� �$6� P� ~:p� U�0S * �;�� [=Z1 1�?P$� �1 ,eQ$R1 ,�Frl 3Z e��- P?1 ,Kz��Z <a�²�

A�n�4 <�nV�119�W ,� �$0; 3$Z �$(f 3$Z K�%�Zd �N- ��� 3�1

d ¯@ 3��� \�%�Z ,U�E�� �,� ÍN6�884$% � ���i * ��$E� Ï�$r� q�$|� ¢ �$0� 3$Z NG$,� 3Z �Z��

� �,� ÍN6�529$%:�T ,���$E� 3$� �;�� e�?� �-1eNa_11 * ³n�8 ����Z ~:p� U�0SV�120�W

3$$Z ¶$$l �$$��i * M$$) 3$$Z �N$$- P$$?1 ¯Nr��� �FZ 3Z �N�p� ¯@�� ÍN6� �,643$% :�T 3$�

�$ZNr�� /$%@ W~:p$� U�$0S 3$$� Q$>? *1 : �d Mp$$,�w|; WU�0F�  �Z *1 :�$FZ 3$Z � �$0; ¯@ [0$� W

<i�,Z  �Z ��1 3� <l@ m; ��� P%1V�121� W ��$�� �$�L�1 ��L� �Z \@ ³^�l �^1 ��$�N��� m$; �NG$8 N;�F6$� P$% ]�1 ,�,p�

,�(�-1 �r�-�1 �r�N� /z$n �$�Z U�0F� /zaZ P% /? ,��W

9− 3$; �$-�a6� �BNn1 ���N��� m; �NG8 }�6|�W

�119� g0%P�� ,��� ¦� �i�11 812W� �120� ,�$¿@ ��$� }�E_@ �?� * �C t �Gr� 3��$� \�$%w�

O�a� 3Z�1 293W� �121� ��r0S /�� M) 3Zs ,��Z�,8�3 512−513W�

m$; �NG$8 U�$0F� y$��S 3$; 3|(� 3(n �E$_ ��$0��? ,}�$6|� 3$; �-�a6� �BNn1 ���N��� ,<$a��5i ¦� �$i �$n���1 ,<0^�G� <60pl1 ,}�6|� K�

9:��� �:6% ¼��1 ,¦��,�1 Mi�|� �n���1 ,<;:p$Z ��l���� ��(��� �?�81 ,K��� /%@ �0? 3� <�(� �3 ��1 1@ �$�²� [4 j�%�k�1 ,}�6|� �D|�� g6� ��l�|�1 1@ �$�²� �=pl 3; �=p,� x1�� xP� ](p� ¦�k�

�D;�n 3;W �$^@ y$r^ y$rf x@ �$��r� �$��Ù ����F(Z1,��$�N��� eP% 3� 9ª m; ��(6C �´@ ��l M6|�

3$� g$a6?@ ,<^N$�11 e�nN$6� P% * /�Fl s �6^1U�0F� �BNn 3� �i�B�a� /�>(6��Z ��� W

�1t j�B�a� : g6� ��l�|� ��(��� �?�8 �n��� 9:$�@ �Z�6? �,; M6|� \�|� \@ ���1 ,}�6|� �D|��

<6�>�@ 3�1 ,U�0F� * ����p� : M��$C ¦�k$� �N$-,p� <r�r· * ©1²l t�1� ¯@ 3:T * �60>� ��;:p�

�$- �=p$,� eP$% \@ �d §�$ �C�§i 9�$)t 3$� 9�$) /?�$|�1 j�%�$r�1 M$�^1 yk$�� �Z ��r6l W �$D6l1

3$Z �$(f ¦�k$� �,; �l�|n ,9�p^t �,��� �d AQ4@ �d �%�$%@ N$%1 ,9�p$^t 3� c ­w� Ã�- ��r� �0;

K�%�Zd 3Z ����� �0; ¦�k� �� §¦�k$� �%�%@1 ,¦�k� � �1 �$¥ ]$a6,�� ;��$����Z �$���� �06|� �d ����� �0;

�D,; N_ �P �4§@1 ,<06?1 7��8�Z \N,6�� �06|� W �-1

Page 37: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

�������� ��� �� ���� ,29 ���� ,�1� ����� ,�2017� 1438$%�

– 73 –

�c � �wS 3Z q; §3 �pE� §\�F�p� �D §|���� �=p,� eP% ](�yk�� �d ��`Z 3� <��r6� xP�V�122�W

3,p$� <$r�r· �$��r� * <$�N- P?1<$)�� 3$Z :T ,xN$�t ]��J * yk��Z �£ �D��� ��;:p� eP%1

�$� �� *1 ,��B��z$� �� �� *1 ,x��au� ]��J *1 7��$$8 � *1 ,xc �N$$�J 3$$Z 3��$$� g$$�f M^�G$$� \��$$r� � *1 ,gS�p$$�� �( «p� ©�$$Z�� *1 ,�$$�n{t

*1 ,��r �k$$� �r §k� 7��$$$8 � *1 ,�$$� ���J �$$$� �� ��Å�,� ©�Z *1 ,�� �G�V�123�W

��l�>� j�B�a�1 :}�6|� �n��� : �N$- �$�� 3�1 }�$6? yrf g;NZ�J ��; 3Z �N�� N6?��T �$BNa�

M$B�`�1 I�EG� �0=6,�V��$- , :T �$^N� * <$0, §� s 3$� �D>���^@ \@ m; �°�>��8 �BNa� M6?  �Z \N,;

§�0�@1 ,ÌN� °k� �BNn ¼�$^�Z �$BNa� 3� �D>���^@ \@ �6r��S− A��� :¥ 1@ − :�1t : §�$^@ P% m; ° §, �� \@

U�$0S 3$� ��$; 1@ ,�$r0S * <����$� 1@ ,}�6|� j1 <i�;:�WWW ¯@ �$BNn1 , °g°�1Q °k$� �$ °a`� �$0; �$BNa?

» ° °±� U�E�d 3Z � �(f H�°0��,�bQR1 W��l�°>�1 : \@^ <��; ° §, ��KD,� �;�� 1@ Õ� °a8 3� ³n�V�124�W

�122� �1� ¯@ 3,� }�6? y�r· ���r�����r� & :89W� �123� <)�� 3Z 3,� }�6? y�r· ���r�����r� & :37W� �124� }�$6? y$�r· �$��r� ,M$B�`�1 I�EG$� �$0=6,� �$BNa�

�P(D�� �1 151W�

0H�I� ,��8�G$� K6i <6(�,Z xP� � �¿@ ��6Á *1

e�|C@1− ���i − P$% ��$£d 3$� °q$; <$Z K�l@ �� m; <�B�6l �D½@ 3� \�? xP� ,7E0�:

− �$�t �4�$a� 3$� �$(�u; j�$=a� U�0F� \@ 3$� �$�Z�l ,�DGB�G4 3� ����) �G�G41 ,�����

�´1 ,KB� �,? yEZ gDn ,��,��Z ��t eP% &�G64 � N$�1 ,�$B�a�1 yB�r8 3� ]0,�1 ,�BNa� 3� yn�6� A�%�C1 ,A��S�� �l�%�Z1 ,A��S�- A���� <lN? sd �D,� 3|� �$D)�6,Z �$rB�a� �$�t �$��,; m; s� A��-�Z A���Z@ A��h �i

h �i w$; <6���1 <ua^1 <6l��_1 ,g(��� �$6(� �$D �$�|n ,3(>$Z �$ri s �$(�u; �$���) j�B�n �¥ �a|� �%¶$$$^ M�G$$$� jQ$$>? ¼�$$$4@ �$$$BNn U�$$0F��1

?�%���i1W! − �N4�$Z 7��$8 9:��� �|0�1 yB�a� g;N�

�Z��6$�s1 ,7$���^t /$rl1 �$�1�� j���) ��^�� j���) o%�,� �|6Z1 ,M����@ ��NF6Z ���0�F6� �� Na�

�1 ���,�Z����1 �-W − y$��N6� U�$0F� �:�6$��Z 1º�$Z ���E� \@

A�|0� ~:p� ��0�d1, <$l@ m$; ��� <i�)1 ¸l ��-@1 Q$4t ]$Z�� �d ])�� A�r6p�1 A�n1���1 A NDk� \�?

x��� ��>� \�r� 3�W − �$� �E0$_@ U�$0F� * ]�(p$6� �Z�6? \@

Page 38: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

I��G� � �0; 3Z O��_: �,; U�0F����E� :e�BNn1 ,<6�b@1 ,<i5kl1 ,<�NDa�

– 74 –

�� ]Z�� \�r� P,� ��1�� /rl �E_ ��(� N�1 ,x� ��^�� eP%TU�0F� ��^�(ZV<�)1 <)1 ��P� \�|� W

− O�FG� \@ TU�0F�V$��@ <$r�0Fi oD,$�1 � �d e�$;N-1 7��$8 �N$�; 3$� MlN) * jQ0? �Q`i M$$6? * 3��45$$6� �$$,; <��=6$$� �$$>?1 ,<$$S1{1

O�FG�1 /���6�1 I�J1 K)L� W −Z <$,; ­w §; U�0F� �NDa� \@ j��$�6� ���(p$6

K$�s P$% m; e �r6� /0- W ��$; P$% * M0p$�1 7��$$$$8 �N$$$$�; * /$$$$B1t �a,G$$$$� j ��$$$$0�

− M�FÁ1 K?�81 x���D����? − c�Z@1 ,<6�(pi �d g$% <$��; �$r�S@ g6� ���(p6� : �$Z�6? K$� ,~:p$�

]� �( �p�6�1 ,]� �( �p�6�, K$� ,�$r0F� K$� ,~:p$� �$r0S K� F�U�0 W

− jc�$) �Z�6? N% U�0F�� ��^ NFi c�Z@ \@ �´�p$E6� m$; 7��$8 9:$�; y$0S@ 7�^ ,U�0F��Z

�$¥ j��C1 W N$% �$���J �,p$� eP$% 3$� 3$� �1@1 Æ��lt }�6; 3Z �(f ,��E����; ÍN6�462%$ W�

− <$ld ��d ;�$��n �$�(�; ���,� U�0F� Mi�|� \@ :p� �E_ �%N)1 NfU�0F�1 ~W

−<$l5Z A�^�F$_ U�0F� ����i :T K$� �$Z�6? ~:p$� v$��1 ,~N(p$�1 ����p$�1 ] ­(p� ¦�k�

¦�k� �-�Z ~N(p� }�6|� 3� ]�N(ZV W − ��>$Z �$� ¦� �$6� w$; ��N0,� �,p� /rl \@

g% ,��:6� �E�1 ��p�B /^��: 1−s1 ©1{ �$Z j1�$� m$; �:6;s ��^��

�Z�EG��Z �_�4 ��^�� eP%1 ,�N�- {W 2− ©1+$Z j1�$� �$�1 m$; �:6;s ��^��

�N�-1 W �Z�EG� ��Z 3� ��^�� eP%1{W 3− �$�1�� 1@ M6|� ��1 m; �:6;s ��^��

�ZN6|� W �l¶$; �d ]$Z�� \�$r� 3$� �$�^�� eP$%1¡�8W

y$$rE6Z \N$$a6|� 7��$$8 9:$$�; \�$$? \@ �$$�Z 1@ <$B�r� 1@ ,<,; ¼1 3¹ x1�� ~:� �N0>Z ��Gis �N$0� \NSLk$� �$�^�� eP$% * NE0$_@ ,<iÅ��� A�$ZN6|� <(� �N)NZ <=�C 3; <�1�� }�6? /|� <;:�

}�6|�� <;:� OG� � sd1 ,U�0F� *W −���_N6� K%@ 3(n A���641 : M���$�@ �$� �

* �%��@ \��Z1 ,KD�%�,�1 ���E�x1��1 x1��W � �5�@1 ,P%- ���i − �8�_ �,�:;@ /�� \@

K��|� <D)N� �G��4W * * *

0M���dq�T��� 8Z�#�� r��1 &'� )��* E$T5� O r�/1W�C ,\�0^ 3Z \�$0^ 3$Z �(f

3Z�¿@ WM�i�i : 9�; Q�t\�0�Z 3Z q; 3���, <rr^ : ,©1²$$l t M��$$C©1�1Q$$Z ,: �p$$�²��$$����� ,

1408 $%− 1988�W 6$�U� B�- 8�#�=�C ,Q>? 3ZZ@N�$(; 3$Z /�;:$�d 9�$a� W

Page 39: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

�������� ��� �� ���� ,29 ���� ,�1� ����� ,�2017� 1438$%�

– 75 –

y$$�r· : ,�?�$$C �$$(f �$$¿@©2�1Q$$Z ,: M$$6|� � ,��(����W�W

?3cW� ?3c~[P�c�A� &A'P ?3cW� ���4� 0-M4�`C ,�$Frl 3$Z~��$C 3$Z �$|Z ¯@ 3$Z g$,`� �$0; 3$Z �(f Wy$�r· :

� W�0;�N�r� ,g0,� } �0; ©1�$��|� �|� , : �$���) ¼�r� �@, 1410$%W

6$�AAU� JAA- O ou��/AA�� 0AA�!��C ,gSN�p$$� 3$$Z 3¿�$$� �$$0; �|Z ¯@W<^{1 <EE_ : ,�?�C �(f �¿@�W� : �$06|���(���� ,W�W

�3/A�� �A��5�� 0$��T�� ?�*� 0�Tg� �~ ���W�C ��$�; �$r�, /za� NZ@��$�; 3$Z �$�N�g0G$E�� \1�$(; 3$Z W

y�r· : ,�r$_ �$¿@ ��p$�©1j�%�$r� ,: �L$� � ,vlNi : ,�r�6�� �06|�1379 $%− 1970�W

��/�@�C ,xc1�� NG$,� 3$Z �$(f 3$Z K��$|� �0;Wy$�r· :�0;�:�$� g$(��� �$�¾ 3Z 3¿��, ©1��$Z� �$�^ ,:

,��l:>�� X ��� j�B� v��1382 $%− 1962�W 0AA�D��� B�AA- O "��AA$W�C ,g$$,�1�r� 3��$$� ��$$) 3$$Z �$$(f

�0;�(; 3Z 3¿��W y�r· :g)�$a4 K�,$� �$0; �$(f, ©3�1QZ , :/�J Wت.، د�

d'�/�� rT5�� �g' &� &7��M' d�� �� 8����C ,��?Nk� 3$Z �$(f�(f 3Z q; W�W,© �1QZ: �n��� �� ,W�W

37� z�� O ������ )����J:�A�c� J��A5��� J��/��� Q��T�� �C ,3��� Å�l 3Z� �$0; 3$Z �(fWy$�r· : K�$�l �$(f

,ÐNp-���©1�1QZ ,: ������ �p�²� ,1993�W d��/�� ��Z�� X��T�� D=@ d����C ,x��`0� M�FÁZ@N �|Z

�Z�� 3Z q; 3Z �¿@Wy�r· :� W ,\�$EF� �N$(f�W ,©�����: � �06|�X ��� ,W�W

0N-�� QT �C ,x�ctZ@N�$� � 3$Z 3p8 3Z �(f �|Z Wy$�r· : ,g|0��Z Q,� x�� ©1�1QZ ,: �$��(�� K$��� � ,

1987�W 0���G�� 0���� r��� O 0���4�� 88���C ,��^ 3ZZ@N 3$Z �¿@ /za�

�¿@ 3Z �(f 3Z q;W �W�1Q$Z ,© : �L$� 9�$�^d �¯���, NG� �$�^ ,��l:>�� X ��� j�B� ��0F� 3; j

��Z@ ��; �,�1350$%W ����7@�� &�/�� Q��8 O ���5��� L$�C ,�a� 3��� gri 3$Z �(f

q; 3Z �¿@Wy�r· : ,�N8 ��N� �:?©1�1Q$Z , : ,��(��� M6|� �1410$% − 1990�W

0-'��U� 2�5�u L$�C ,M) 3Z�� �0; 3��� 3�c�$¿@ 3Z 3¿W y�r· :�W ,�(�>�� \:��� 3Z 3¿�� �0; ©1����� , :

�|�0�� �06|� ,\1425 $%− 2005�W 6$�AAU� B�AA- O 6$�AA���� B�AA78C ,xw$$�J 3��$$� \�$$%�Z

Z@N�(; 3Z K�%�Zd U�E�d Wy�r· : �$�{ 3$Z K�%�Zd ,q��©1�1QZ , : ,��^ 3Z �1421 $%− 2000�W

���� d�T��L$�g���� "T�� O L�M4C ,��,p8 NZ@ g8 �0; �(fx �G$lt K�$�8 �$0; �(f 3ZWy$�r· : I�$6a� �$0;

,j�$$RNZ@�WM$$�^ ,©: $$Z �$$06|� ��$$;N0F� �$$�(�i 3 ,������W�W

Z��Z �� &�7C $Z@N�1� ,7�$Ct 3$Z \:��$� Wy$�r· : M� ��$C©1²l t, 1 ,q�Z e�- / ���? � �(�f©1� ,W�: ���$��� �

,������1430 $%− 2009� �D���� BD� }7C ,g0%P� 3$Z �$(f � �$0; ¯@ 3��$� v($C

�¿@W y�r· : M��C ¦�k� X{�Z �rrE� 3� �;N(� ,©1º�l t©3�1QZ ,: ,������ �p�²� 1405$$% −

1985�W

Page 40: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

I��G� � �0; 3Z O��_: �,; U�0F����E� :e�BNn1 ,<6�b@1 ,<i5kl1 ,<�NDa�

– 76 –

&'� B�- &� "��!�� �y���"D#�� �C Ð�$,Zt 3��$� \�%�Z ,}N�@ 3Z ��N� 3Z K�%�ZdWy�r· : ,/$�% gE6n I�_

©1����� , :�C�� �06|�, 1418$% − 1998�W QTcyAA���� Q�AA���� "�C ,g$$-���$$Z@N 3��$$� 3$$�c /z$$a�

�0;�p$8 3$Z K�^��Wy$�r· :K�$(� �$�F�� �$0;, 1 ,/En ���� �%��©1�1Q$Z ,: ,�$�(��� M$6|� �

1423 $%− 2002�W 0���* ��5A7W� &A� �A�$�S� zA-N��� ?D=W� &� J-/� )��*

z5/���C ,I�G� 3Z3¿�$� �$0; 3$Z \:>;Wy$�r· : , ��r��$$0; ��$$0; y$$nN�©2�1Q$$Z ,: }�$$`� �

g��� ,1408$%W dA7���� rTA5�� LA:@ dA�D�� �����C ,x1�=p$� 3��$� v($C

3¿�� �0; 3Z �(f QÁ ¯@W �W�1QZ ,©: k$,� � Nj��8 �06|� Wت.، د�

6$�U� B�-C ,I�G� 3Z3¿�$� �0; 3Z \:>;Wy$�r· : N$l ,L$$; 3��$$��W�� N$$� ,©: �$$|a� � ,1406 $$$%−

1986�W 0AA$��T�� JAA- O 0AA$���� "� O 0AA$�N��C ,x1�=p$$� 3$$Z �$$(f

�$$0;�$$(f 3$$Z 3¿��Wy$$�r· : K�,$$� �$$0; ÓB�$$; N$$Z@ ,K�%�Zd©1� ,W�: |� ,�L�� ¦�k� �s1@ �062001�W

X8�.��� )��* "� X8���� )��C ,��^ 3Zq; 3Z �¿@W K$- <$$>���^@1 <$$ZNZ@1 <$$06? : ��$$- ,g-�$$0� �$$0; �²$$n �$$(f

<$$�0S m$$; X{@1 <EE$$_1 <$$)�4�Z : 3��$$� M$$f����� ��r���i ,M�FÁ :c�Z 3Z � �0; 3Z ����� �0; ,

�W� ,©W�: ��a�p� �06|�,� W�W o��Tg�� 0�!�� "�' o����� )��C ,x �Glt �$�¾ ¯@ 3��$� 3$�c

���?cWy�r· :K�$b ��F�� �0;, 1 ,/$Ea� �%�$�©1 ,

�W�: ��(��� M6|� � ,1422$% − 2002�W 6$�U� 0�!�� "�' 6�N�� )��C Q$Á ¯@ 3��$� v(C ,g-���

3Z �(f3¿�� �0; Wy�r· : ,q; �p^ q;©1¶� ,: ,�,p� �06|�1424$% − 2003�W

2D/-/��� 2�.����� Jq�g�� J�g�� 2���@�� �8� !�� �T �C ,��6|� g8 �0; �$(f 3Z Q0|��0; 3Z °g�8 ��0 �; �(fÆ� � g,p8Wy�r· : ,H�0; \�p^d©2�1Q$Z ,:

g��� }�`� �, 1982�W TN��� "��#�� 0�.���� ����!��E��C ,�P(�Z@N �$�N� K$��r�

�¿@ 3Z �(f 3ZWy�r·1 �� � :� W 3$Z �$�; 3$Z �N�� ,g;N$Z�J ���; 3Z Q(;©1j N$,� �$,��� ,: �$���J

����� ,g(��� 7E0� j�:; , �$_ K$- �41� ,1422 $%− 2002�W

z���� ����5��C ,x��Z�c1Qa�3��$� ��, 3$Z �$(f �%�$S ¯@}Nr��Wy�r· : ,������ �p�²� * �L� y�r· M6|�

X{�Z : ,ÐN §p-��� K��l �(f©8�1QZ ,: �p$�²� ,]�cN6�1 +,�1 �;�0F�� ������1426 $%− 2005�W 6$�U� )- #� r��� &� 6$����� ����C ,g(��r� ��� �(f

���� �(f 3Z 3���W �W�1QZ ,©: ��(��� M6|� �, �W�W

0$��T�� J- O 0$�!4��C ,x��`0� M�FÁZ@N 3Z q; 3Z �¿@ �|Z �¿@ 3Z �Z��Wy�r· :g- Np$� ��$0; N$Z@, K�%�$Zd1 ,��� x�¿�Wj N,� �,��� ,©: ��(��� �06|�� ,W�W

�Tg�� r�/�C, Nu,� 3Z q$; 3Z ��|� 3Z �(fW ©3�1Q$Z ,: ��_ �, 1414$%W

!�� �����o��A��� X��TA�� �' L*�C ,x�$��D���$Z@N �$(f ��4 3Z 3¿�� �0; 3Z 3p8Wy�r· :� W »�$�; �$(f

Page 41: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

�������� ��� �� ���� ,29 ���� ,�1� ����� ,�2017� 1438$%�

– 77 –

,M�FÁ©3�1QZ ,: �|a� � ,1404$%W ,#.��C ,Ð��Z@Ne��$� 3Z /�;:�d 3Z q; 3p8 Wy$�r· :

,��$a) K%�$Zd /��4©1�1Q$Z ,: �L$� 9�$�^d � ,¯���1417 $%1996�W

L�-cW� ���c �~ L=���C ,]�0� 3ZZ@N 3$Z �$(f K?�8 � �0; <�1�¿ 3Z �(f 3Z � �0;Wy�r· :� W K�,$� �$0; �²$n

,�¿@�W�� �,|� ,© :jN;�� �� ,W�W Z��AN' �$8�A� L�$� &� Z�!�/��C9�$r6l , �$�,� 3$Z :gS����$�,

��`Z ¦� �i ]� ~N0F�,¢�$,% e�ul�$n � ,W� ,©W� :�W ,\�W�W

���A���' ,�.�� J�g��C ,g0%P$� � �$0; ¯@ 3��$� v($C�$$(fWy$$�r· : � W ,�$$��� M$$�08 �$$(f©1�B�$$F� , :

��G� �06|�y ,1408 $%− 1988�W z�7��� J�g��C���5$i ,j�%�$r��Z ��Z��� �`�� ](� : ,�aFG$�

K�%�Zd; ,������¿@ , ��r� �0; ;���^ ; ,� , �� �(f ��,�W �W� ,©W�: jN;�� �� ,W�W

0N-�� x�$�5� J�g�C ,xc��9�$��?c 3Z H �n 3Z �¿@Wy$�r· : ,\1 �% �(f ��p��0;�W� ,©W�: ,�|a� �1399 $%

− 1979�W 6$�U� B�- 0�Tg�C ,]$�0� 3$Z$Z@N 3$Z �$(f K?�$8 � �$0;

�0;<�1�¿ 3Z �(f 3Z �Wy�r· :� ,�p$^ Ku�� ��p©2�1QZ ,: ,��(��� M6|� �1397 $%− 1977�W

J5��� ����� Jg��� ��g�C ,g|0p�}�%N��0; 3��� »�iWy$�r· : ,3��4�1 ��,� q; �(f©2j�%�r� ,: g�l�Á �06|�,

1413$%W �AS� B��W� ���*� Tc� O �%8@� �#5��C \�$%�Z ,O$�a� 3$Z

3���f 3Z K�%�Zd� �0; 3Z �(Wy�r· :�W 3¿�� �0;

,�$$(�>�� \:��$$� 3$$Z©1��$$��� ,: �$$C�� �$$06|� ,1410 $%− 1990�W

X����� 6$�U� B�- ��� O X�T�� L ���C ,xN$(8 3��� �ZZ@N��$� 3Z K�%�Zd 3Z �(f ,� �0; Wy$�r· :� W g$�f

,\�z$� 3¿�$$� �$0; 3��$�©2yk$�� ,: �$$|a� �, 1406$%W

B�-g��� r��!�� 2�1D *� 9��c 0�7��C ,xNl�D6� 3Z �(f�$(f Ã�$r� 3Z q;Wy$�r· :� W ,»1�$^� q$;©1 ,

�1QZ : ,\1{�l \�,0� �06|�1996�W ?�qT�� �5� O ?���P� r�Y��C ,g0%P� � �$0; ¯@ 3��� v(C

�¿@ 3Z �(fWy�r· : ,x1��0� �(f q;©1�1Q$Z , :� ,+,�1 �;�0F�� �n��� 1382$% − 1963�W

0�!�@� "� O 3' 0����� j4���C ,g;�r0� 3Z K�%�Zd 3��� \�%�Z�(;Wy�r· : ,/Ea� ���� �%��©1��$��� ,: �$06|�

�� ,\1{�l �C1428$% − 2007�W "D#�� &'� 0��5� K j4���C ,®? ��Z@N 3��$� �$Z � �0;

0; 3Z �(f� �Wy�r· :� W �$Z �$(f 3$Z 3��Z��� 3�c ,o��$$n©1��$$��� ,: ,��p$$� 9N$$�@1419 $$$%−

1998�W TA�1 &A'� 0�.� "� O 88���� j�������C ,x1�$,� 3$�c 3��$�

�0;�n �$�� »�$i 3Z X1º��Wy$�r· : 3��$� Ú$i�� ,�¿@©1����� ,: �C�� �06|�, 1999�W

* * *

Page 42: الرئيسية | مجلة الدراسات الإسلامية · ones, in books of taraajim, jarh, ta'deel and mustalah as well as in handwritten manuscripts. The research aims

I��G� � �0; 3Z O��_: �,; U�0F����E� :e�BNn1 ,<6�b@1 ,<i5kl1 ,<�NDa�

– 78 –