1

2

3

(), 2015

,

I

II

-

III

( )

.7

.31

.53

4

()

: 13, 1000 ,

: 00389 (02) 3298-139

: 00389 (02) 3116-447

-: contact@znm.org.mk

www.znm.org.mk

5

. - . - . , 1948 , - 1994 - 1997 .

, - . - . , , .

. , 16 - . , , . , , - . -, .1

- . - .

-, . 2, , .

, 2013 3. 3 , - , , - . . 1114 -

1 , http://bit.ly/1PGRsX7 2 , http://bit.ly/1KCyZK1 3 , http://bit.ly/1Vg6Pg5 4 Ibid, page 31

6

-, . , , .

24 - , , - .

, . , 83 - 5, , , -, -. 2009 34 , 117 , . 2015 6. 10 , - .

. - - . 2012 1, 13 , 2013 4 - . 2015 - , .

, , - , - , - . , .

5 Reporters without borders, 2015 World Press Freedom Index, http://index.rsf.org/#!/index-details6 Freedom House, Freedom of the Press 2015, http://bit.ly/1OZ0Ffa

7

,

I.

8

,

( ) __.9

__.13

__.16

__.21

__.26

__.28

1

3

5

2

4

6

9

, () 1 2 , . , .

, , , Freedom House, South East Europe Media Or-ganisation (SEEMO) Reporters Without Borders (RSF). 2014 .

- . , , .

1 -, , .2 - , , - , , .

( )

1

10

.

/ . , . , . , , , 2014, .

, . , 3.

, 2012 . , , 4. 2013 5, - 2013 . , 6, , : . 2012 6.615.609 , 7.244.950 2013, 6 2014 3.985.500 18 .

3 (2015), , 4 , ., , . (2014) , . 5 : http://www.avmu.mk/images/Analiza_na_pazarot_2013.pdf, 24 2015 .6 http://vlada.mk/node/9241.

,

11

, 2013 7 1.290,79 ( 21 ).

- 8, 2012 , 2008 , 2011, 2009 .

2014 , 9. , , () . , , , . 2012 ( ) .

, . . , , , .

7 2013 , http://avmu.mk/images/Analiza_na_pazarot_za_2013.pdf8 , ., , . (2014) , .9 AGB Nielsen , 30 5 .

12

, . ( 50% ), , 10.

, , . , , , 11. . , , .

1 , . , , . , , , . , . , , , , .

10 , , - , - . , - 25 . , . 11 : -, , 22 2014. : http://www.novini.mk/read/294628/selmani-drzhavata-vleguva-so-pari-vo-privatnite-televizii. 25 2015 .

,

13

, ( 92, 10). , - 12 2014 2013 . , , .

, 92 ( 11) , , ; , , , ; .

12 92 ( 8) , - , 10 7,00 23,00 , - 25 , a 30 , 7,00 23,00 , - 25 .

2

14

, , 23 ( 2), .

. . , , , , , . , . , , , , .

. , . .

: , 13.

, , ,

13 : -, 24 , 23 2014, http://24vesti.mk/znm-izmenite-za-mediumskite-zakoni-chekor-napred-vo-podobruvanje-na-sodrzhinata 28 2015 .

,

15

. 50%14. , 15 50 2.254 5.548 . 66.000 330.000 , , 5 , 10 50% , . , , , , .

. , ( 92) 30% , 2014 . 2015 , 30% 40%. 2016 , 40% 50%. , , .

14 , - , -, , - 2014 ( ), http://mdc.org.mk/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/CRM_Izvestaj_Monitoring-na-AVMU-MIOA-MRT-sobranie-i-mediumi_-Okt-2014.pdf, 29 2015.15 . .138/14 http://www.slvesnik.com.mk/Issues/50db360db2d34e499d1ee8b2aaaf788f.pdf

16

, . , , .

, , . , , , 16.

. , . . . T

16 Alonso, I.F., et al (2006) Press Subsidies in Europe, Generalitat de Catalunya

,

3

17

, 16 2014 , .

, , : l ,

, . , , , , . , , , . , , . , 12 , .

l , (KommAustria). . . : , . . , .

l , , . , ,

18

. , , . ( , , , ). , , . , e, , , , .17.

:

1 20% 10%

2 21% 0%

3 25% 0%

4 24% 10%

5 19.60% 2.10%

6 19% 7%

7 23% 9%

8 21% 4%

9 21% 6%

10 25% 0%

11 25% 6%

12 8% 2.50%

13 20% 0%

: (2013)

17 Schwelzer, C., et al (2014) Media Policy Brief 11: Public Funding of Private Media, The London School of Economics, http://www.lse.ac.uk/media@lse/documents/MPP/LSE-MPP-Policy-Brief-11-Public-Funding-Private-Media.pdf, 23 - 2015 .

,

19

, , . . . . ( , ). ( , ), (, ) . (, , , , ) .

. , 18. , Le Monde Le Figaro, La Croix LHumanit. , , .

, 1935 , . , , . , . . . .

18 ibid

20

1975 . :

l , , , , . l - . l . l . l 50 . l . l 19.

2004 , . , . , , . 10 . .

19 Murschetz, P. C. (2013) State Aid for Newspapers: Theories, Cases, Actions, Springer

,

21

. , , , .

, . , - . , . , 20. - 2013 33 , 3 . , (9.870.000,00 160.489,00 ), 5 (8.900.000,00 144.715,00 ) (4.700.000,00 76.423,00 21). , 2014 22.

20 , ., , . (2014) , .21 ibid 22 - , http://www.sec.mk/files/izbori2014/parlamentarni/cenovnici2/Sitel.PDF, 5 2015 .

4

22

, , 23. , , , - , .

, , . , , , . , , . , , . , 24, , .

, , . ( ) . 25.

23 , : , http://znm.org.mk/drupal-7.7/mk/node/47524 http://ec.europa.eu/enlargement/news_corner/news/news-files/20150619_recommendations_of_the_senior_experts_group.pdf, 25 2015 .25 : , , 28 2015, http://www.utrinski.mk/?ItemID=4143B4F42B125445B1E422348C33D62E, 25 2015.

,

23

.

. , , , , , , , , , . , , , .

, , , , , , . , (60 ) .

, . 2003 , ( ), .

2000 , . , , . RAI , ..... , 26.

, 10 , .

26 Plasser, F., Plasser, G. (2002) Global Political Campaigning: A Worldwide Analysis of Campaign Professionals and Their Practices, Greenwood Publishing Group.

24

, 2013 , 27. 2005 , Animal Defenders International (ADI) . Animal Defenders International, 20 . , . 10 , , 2008 . , , Ani-mal Defenders International 10 .

, :

l , . , , , . l , .

27 ANIMAL DEFENDERS INTERNATIONAL , - , 2013, http://hudoc.echr.coe.int/fre?i=001-119244#{itemid:[001-119244]}, 29 2015.

,

25

. , . . , , , .

, / .

, . , . , 28. , , .

, . . , . .

, , .

28 , Broadcasting Information Bulletin CRTC 2011-218, http://www.crtc.gc.ca/eng/archive/2011/2011-218.htm, 27 2015.

26

, . , , , , .

/, . , ; 29. , , . . 30.

29 Lange, Y. (2002), Mediji i izbori, Council of Europe, http://www.coe.int/t/dghl/standardsetting/media/Doc/Translations/Serbian/Media&Elections_sb.pdf, - 23 2015.30 ibid

,

5

27

-- , (IPI) , , . , . , 31.

. , . , .

. , , , , .

31 Hunt, N. (2012), Ka-Ching!: Avoiding Manipulation through Government Advertising, Public Money Should Serve Public Interest, International Press Institute, - http://www.freemedia.at/newssview/article/ka-ching-avoiding-manipulation-through-government-advertising.html, 30 2015 .

28

, , : , , .

.

50%.

. . ,

6

,

29

. , .

.

, , . , . . , , .

, , .

. . , , , , , . , , , . , . , , .

30

31

II.

( )

32

1

3

5

2

4

__.35

__.37

__.42

__.47

__.49

33

. , , , . , , , . 2005 , .. ( ) , . , , . , (2005 2013) , , .

34

2014 , 4.10 [ ] , . 1, 2015 , , , , , ... , . , 2000(23) 2, , , 19 , , - .

1 : http://ec.europa.eu/enlargement/news_corner/news/news-files/20150619_urgent_reform_priorities.pdf2 : http://ec.europa.eu/enlargement/news_corner/news/news-files/20150619_urgent_reform_priorities.pdf

35

: 2000(23)

: (1) - ; , , - ; (2) , , , , - .

: ( 1997 2005 ) (

) , . ( 1997) , - . . ( 2005) , , . 2005 , 2011 , 9 15, .

2013 ,

1

36

: ( 7 ) . , 2005 . , , , , () . - ... , 3.

( ), . 4 13 () - 11 , ( ) .

( ) . , , .

: 2000(23) , ;

3 : http://www.coe.int/t/dghl/standardsetting/media/doc/cm/rec(2000)023%26expmem_EN.asp 4 Media Regulators in Europe: A Cross-Country Analysis, : http://www.lasics.uminho.pt/ojs/index.php/cecs_ebooks/issue/view/118/showToc

37

: 2000(23)

- , . , :

- ; - , - ; - ; - - , - ;- .

: l . , ,

. , , , ( , .) () . , ( 16), ,

2

38

. , , , . , . : -/, , , , -, / /. , .

l . 1997 ,

, . 2005 , .. . , , . ( , , , .). 2011 . 2013 , , , , . - : (1)

39

(2) . - . .

l . 6

, . 7. , ( 15) , . , , 7 ( 9 , 2011). 2000(23) ... [ ] .

l . ,

, . , - . ( 16 4) . , . ( ) . - , - , - .

40

l , - . - . , , , .

: , , , , .

l ( ) . ( 16 1) , , . , 16 (2) 1 , , / . , ( 16 1) 5 10 . l 9,

: , , , 3 ( ), . .l

, . ,

41

14 4 / . l 6 . l

( ). , , 5 / , . l

. l 14 11 ,

. l 15 4,

5 , ( , ) . .

42

:

2000(23) : l

( ); l ( ) ; l ,

;l

( );l ,

; l

, ;l ,

; ( ) ; .

:

3

43

. . , .

l . ,

. , , , . , 4 ... , 6, , , : ... ,... ... , 28 () ... ... ... . 110 , 111 . 124 , , , . . , , 110, , , .

44

, , . , . , .

l .

23 ( ) . 24 , ( 147, 148 149) () . 150, . . , , . 48, . , 45 ( ) , .

l . 6

, . . .

45

( ) . , ( 6 29) , . .

: l 6 (, , , .), ( ) , . ( , ) . , , . l . . l .

46

47

: 2000(23),

: l , , ,

( ) ; ;l ,

() ( ); ;l

; ;

:

. , , . , , , , , . ,

4

48

. , , . , .

, . . - , .

: l 9 ( 1) , , , .l ( 2) , .l 9 .

49

: .

2000(23) : l ( )

; ; l

, ; , ; , ; ( ) .

: ,

, , . 6 :

5

50

( , ), , . 135 140 : (74,5%), (19,5%) (6%). , , , . 13 ( ) . 6 , , 3 ( )5.

, , , . ( ) , , . . , 2014 38.260.017,00 , 39.1% 97.857.693,00 ( ). , ( ) . , , .

5 Media Regulators in Europe: A Cross-Country Analysis, : http://www.lasics.uminho.pt/ojs/index.php/cecs_ebooks/issue/view/118/showToc

51

. , , , , , . , .

: l , . l , , , , , . l , ( 80) , ; ;

52

: www.radiomof.mk

53

III.

-

54

1

3

5

6

2

4

__.55

__.56

__.57

__.60

__.65

__.70

55

- . - . -

-. - . , , , , - .

(96) 10 - - , - , , .

(2012) 1 - . - , , . , .

- , , , - , .

1

56

- . , - . 2012 (Humphreys) . - , . , .

. -. , , RTE .

- , . . , , .

- , , - , -, . , , .

-

2

57

- 1991 , . 24 - , . , . 1997 , , . - , .

- . 2014 , . .1 , .

, - . / 2014 , . a -

1 2014 , http://bit.ly/1uAgzCC

3

58

, 7.8 1990 .2

- - . - , 3.

- . 104 . , , 4.

: .

-, , .

, , . , , -. , , , . , , 104 ,

2 / - 2014, http://bit.ly/1LqD1XR 3 , http://bit.ly/1FnQJJV 4 , http://bit.ly/1MkCmFR

-

59

, 110, . .

, - 110. -, , , , - , , . , - . -, - . .

: , . , , , , .

60

. , , -, , ., , .

, , -- . 190 , 100 , 15 .

. , , - , , - . - , .

, - , - .

-

4

61

- 50 . , 25 , - . 2010 63 . 5

2011 24 , - 2012 30 6. 15 , 11 4 .

2013 7 - 15 , , 7 , . - 2013 , 29 . -, - .

2014 8 25 , 18 7 .

- - 2015 9, 22 . , - 30 . , , , - - .

5 , http://bit.ly/1Ph2X7t 6 7 - 2013 , http://bit.ly/1KoQcqd8 -- 2014 , http://bit.ly/1U1TMhr9 -- 2014 , http://bit.ly/1U1TMhr

62

- (96) 10 , , .

, 105 - . , , .

2013 . - . 10.

2013 - , , . ? - , . , - , .

. - . , . - , , -. .

10 -

-

63

, .

, , 3 . , , , (96) 10 - , . , - .

- 139 . - . 2014 .

-, , . - . 12 5- .

- . , , -, , - .

, 2012 - 20 , 192 .11 15.8 , 157

11 EBU REPORT - FUNDING OF PUBLIC SERVICE MEDIA 2013, http://bit.ly/1V4qCtm

64

. -- (PPP Purchasing power parity) 18.314 , 9.300 . , , . , - , , .

: 2013 2,4 ,

24 - 2 . 5- . - .

.l .l .l - .l - .l . l 12 - .l , .

, .

-

65

- , , .

(96) 10 .

. 116, 4 - - , . 13 , , - . . - , , - . .

, -, , . , - , , -. .

5

66

, 2013 - . , .

:

, , . - .

, , . , . - , - .

, (2012) 1 - . , , - , - , , -, , .

. , .

-

67

: ,

. , , , . , - . , .

, .

117 , -, , , - , 12.

- . - . 118 .

118 - . , .

13. . - .

12

68

:

, , . . , , , -, , -, .

,

, , - , . , , , 1991 .

130 - . , , , , -, , . - , , . , .

: ,

, - . 4 . -, .

2012 , , - . , - . , .

-

69

, . .

, 122 ,

, , 2006 , - .

106 , -, , , - , -. - .

. , . , , . . 17 83 , .

: . , , - . , 17 .

70

-

. , ( ). : -

, , . , . . , -, . , - . .

6

71

-

119. . . , . - . .

: .

104, 6, -

, . - . -, .

: , , , , , . . , ,, , , , . .

72

. e