*. and c, courtenay · v 001 of 1990 between dalton seymour vacc iana plaintiff and oxford...

58
,fly! I , i IN THE SUPREME COURT OF JUDICATURE OF JAMAICA IN COMMON LAW LUIT NO. CL. V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF A N D OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the Defendant Heard on the 19th. 20th and 21st days of October 1993 and the 21st day of *. March 1997. COURTENAY ORR J. c, Throughout 1994. I struggled against exhaustion. A brief period of leave did not help much: and so my work suffered considerably. Then i n March 1995, shortly before I was due t o go on an extended period of leave I suddenly fell seriously ill. After two periods of hospitalization, I began the slow road t o recovery. :f I resumed duties on a limited basis i n mid September 1995, but even this -,-- proved t o be premature and so I again went on leave i n November 1995 u n t i l March 1996. I am not yet c recovered: hence the delay i n del i vering thi s judgment. \ I hope that the parties and all affected by these proceedings have not suffered too much i nconven i ence because of the del ay .

Upload: others

Post on 14-Sep-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the

,fly! I ,,,i

I N THE SUPREME COURT OF JUDICATURE OF JAMAICA

I N COMMON LAW

LUIT NO. CL. V 001 OF 1990

BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF

A N D OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT

!';~'tr'ick Ba i ley f o r the P l a i n t i f f

Norman Davis for the Defendant

Heard on t h e 19th. 20th and 21st days of October 1993 and the 21st day o f * .

March 1997.

COURTENAY ORR J . c, Throughout 1994. I struggled against exhaustion. A b r i e f per iod o f

leave d i d not he lp much: and so my work suffered considerably. Then i n March

1995, s h o r t l y before I was due t o go on an extended per iod of leave I suddenly

f e l l se r ious ly ill. After two periods o f h o s p i t a l i z a t i o n , I began the slow

road t o recovery.

:f I resumed dut ies on a l i m i t e d basis i n mid September 1995, bu t even t h i s -,--

proved t o be premature and so I again went on leave i n November 1995 u n t i l

March 1996. I am not y e t c recovered: hence the delay i n del i ver ing

t h i s judgment. \

I hope t h a t the p a r t i e s and a l l a f fec ted by these proceedings have not

su f fered too much i nconven i ence because o f the del ay .

Page 2: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 3: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 4: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 5: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 6: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 7: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 8: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 9: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 10: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 11: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 12: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 13: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 14: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 15: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 16: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 17: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 18: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 19: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 20: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 21: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 22: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 23: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 24: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 25: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 26: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 27: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 28: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 29: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 30: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 31: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 32: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 33: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 34: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 35: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 36: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 37: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 38: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 39: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 40: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 41: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 42: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 43: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 44: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 45: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 46: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 47: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 48: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 49: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 50: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 51: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 52: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 53: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 54: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 55: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 56: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 57: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the
Page 58: *. and c, COURTENAY · V 001 OF 1990 BETWEEN DALTON SEYMOUR VACC IANA PLAINTIFF AND OXFORD PRUDENTIAL HOLDINGS DEFENDANT !';~'tr'ick Bailey for the Plaintiff Norman Davis for the